www.minbaralhurriyya.

org
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by
any means without the prior permission of Minbaralhurriyya Team.

www.arab-csr.org
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by
any means without the prior permission of Arab Center for Scientific Research
and Humane Studies Team.

* " " .

1

3 ............................................................................. .......................................
:
:

14 ................................................................................... ...........................
: : 40 .................................
. : : 50 ............................

: : !
: 78 ...............................
:

102 .................................................................................................. ..........

. :
129 ......





(1825-1756) " "
] [

.

: ! :
:
! : ! :
!!

802
" "!!

.
.



3




.
" "
:
(1


.
" "


.
(2
.


" .. " .

(3

. "
"

.

 (4

.
(5

.

.
.



!


" "
" : " .

- -

.


.
5

...

.
:

.

: 1967

:

... . .1975
1979


. :

.



6

 .

"
"" :
.
!" .

1909

:


... !


!!

" "
!!
!!

! !!


... .

" "
" " !! www.imhalal.com
7


.

" " .
!

] [

.
:
..

!!

:
.


"
"

.
: "
* "
" : " .
*

.
8

 " :
" . .

" : " .
" :
: !" : :
" " .
" :
" . .

" : " .
:
:
-

.
" "



.

.
.
:

9



.
" "
. :

" :

] " : .[10

""

.
:
" .
"
:

.

10

 :

" :

" .
:
:

.
.
:

: . "
"
:
.
11

 .



.

.
.

12

13

.

.

.


" "] [ " "
.

.
- .

*

.
14

 .
.

.
:

:
/ .
) lacit

) ( " :
(


" (1).
] [

" "
. " : ""

") "Secularism (
.

" . " : ) (Secularism

1
" " .2005/4/27
) ( :
15

" (2).

.

(3).

.

3 1924
.

(1) :
(2) .

.

) (2 .
)(3 : .. .2007/6/19
16


" " " " "

" .

" " .

:
(1 :


.

.
(2 :
.
)
(

.
17

 (3 :

)(4
.
.

.


.


(5).

) (4 :
.2007/4/21
) (5 .
18

 .



.
" "




(6).

:

... .

(7).

) (6 .
) (7 : .2007/06/21
19

 " : "
" "

) (

.
(8).

) (
- -
)
(
(9).

.

) (8 : .
) (9 .
20


(10).

.

(11).

:
(1

(2 :
)( .
)(

)(
) .(

) (10 : : .180
) (11 :
.2003/5/14
21

 (3

(4

:
)( .
)( .
)(

.
(5

(12).

) (12 : :
.
22

" " "
" .
- -
. " "

) ( .
" "
.
"
"

.
"
" .

23


(13).





(14).
:

.

:

)(15

) (13 .
) (14 :
.2007/4/17

) (15 .
24

 : :



.
" "

.

.

.


25

.

:

(16).





.

)( . " :


" . "
) (16 : : 180
.2007
26


"
" :
" .
" :

" " :

" (17).

" "
.


.


(18).

) (17 .
) (18 : .2007/6/26
27





(19).

!!




(20).
"
" " "
:
.

) (19 .
) (20 .
28



(21).

(22).

.
.

(23).


.

.

) (21 : ..

) (22 .
) (23 : .2003/8/14
29

 .
24
.
: :


.


.


- -

(25).



) (

) (24 :
.2007
) (25 : .2007/06/21
30


(26).

(27).


.

)
) (26 .
) (27 .
31

!
.

(28).

" "

) (28 :
32

.2007/1/28


) (

) ( (29).
: :


.


.

.

) (29 17 18- 2007 .

33



.


:
(1











.
(2




34



.






.
(3


.
(4



.


.

35


.


.

.


(30).

:
:

) (30 :
.
36


.
: :
.
: /

.
:


(31).




:

.
) (31 : .2006/7/27
37



.

.






.



.


.




38

 .
.


.

39

:
*

.

... .
" "

!
)( !

. 1951

"
") (32 ) (
" .
2003 2000 "

* .
) (32 :
) . .(
40

) -(33 -

.

) (1 :

1966 " "

. :

"



" .

) (33
.
" " !!
" "!!
) . (
41



" "

" .

"

:
.

) .(34

"

" "

" "

."

" :

" " .
" .
) (34 -


.. ) . (
42

 " "

" .
" :

)(35

.
:

.

) ( .1497

-

.


.

.
) (35 " :
" . : .46
43




.

.
*
) (2

.
-
-

( .

(1915)

.


. . -

" " .

)*(

.(1564-1509)
44

.
" "
.

" "

"
.
"

.


.

. :

" " .
45

 " "

/ .
- -
" "
*

.
.

.
.

* ) (1976-1889 .
46

" :

" .

) (
.

- .

" "

" "
.

2005 " "

"

" " "

.

" ."

" "
.

.
47

"" .

-

- .
- -

" "

- .

48

"

(36)." -

""

.

) (36 : .10
49

 :
. *
/



" "
" " " "
: !




.

* . : Fullbright
.
) .(1990-1983
1990 .1996 :
" Membendung Militansi Agama " Erlangga) Sejarah Fikih Islam: (2003
" Sebuah Pengantar " Risalah Gusti) (1995
:
" Mutiara Terpendam: Perempuan dalam Literatur Islam Klasik :
"" Melawan Hegemoni Barat (2002 Gramedia) "Lentera)
(1999 ) Islam Liberalisme Demokrasi : (
) (2002 Paramadina " Fikih Lintas Agama " (2003 Paramadina)
" Islam Ditelanjangi " .(2003 Paramadina)
50

 " " .

" "

" " (37).

.

" " "" .

.
.
: " "

.
.
.

(37) John L. Esposito, The Islamic Threat: Myth or Reality? (New York: Oxford University Press, Vol. 3,
1999).
51

-
(38). "" " "
.

)
( .
.
.
" "
:

)(39

1993" : "

.
) .(1996 " "
"" .

) (38 " : " " Defisit

" Demokrasi di Dunia Islam .
) (39 Glenn E. Perry, Huntington and his :
Critics: Islam and the West" Arab Studies Quarterly 24, no 1 (Winter2002).
52




. ) (

" "
" (40).
"
"
.
.

(41).

(40 ) Samuel P. Huntington, "The Clash of Civilization", Foreign Affairs 72. no 4 (SeptemberOktober 1993).
M.A. Muqtedar Khan, "Living on Borderlines," dalam Zahid H. Bukhari, Sulayman Nyang,
Mumtaz Ahmad, john Esposito (eds.), Muslim's Place in the American Public Square (New
York: Altamira Press, 2004).
53

)(41

 ) :
(
.

" "
(42).
" : "
. .

:
"

] [

. .

.

.
.

Bernard Lewis, "The Roots of Muslim Rage", Atlantic Monthly, September 1990.
54

)(42

" (43).

.



.

... . ""

.

" : "

" "
(44). "

"

) (43 : .2
Bernard Lewis, What Went Wrong? Western Impact and the Middle East Response (New York:
Oxford University Press, 2002).
55

)(44

 " .

" (45).


.




" "... .

" "
) (
.

.

. " :
Bernard Lewis, "The Roots of Muslim Rage,".
56

)(45

" (46).

" " (47).

" " .

. .
"

"

" " " " .

)(48

" .

.
""

Gema "Esposito, "Clash of Civilizations? Contemporary Images of Islam in the West,

Martin Munoz (ed.), Islam, Modernism, and the West (New York: I.B. Tauris Publishers, 1999),
p 106.

)(46

(47) Tarig Ali, Clash of Fundamentalisms: Crusades, Jihads, Modernity (New York; Verso, 2002).
Ali S. Asani, "So That You May Know One Another": A Muslim American Reflects on Pluralism
and Islam," American Scholar 71, no. 1 (Winter 2002).
57

)(48

(49).

. "
" (50).

" "
) 24 (51)(1986
" :" (52).

" " .

)
( " " .
)(49

(1) Edward W. Said, Orientalism (New York: Vintage Book, 1979).
(2) Edward Said, Covering Islam (New York: Pantheon Books, 1981).
Said, Orientalism, p. 316.

)(50

Bernad Lewis, "The Question of Orientalism," The New York Review of Books, 24 Juni 1982,
Islam and the West (Oxford University Press, 1993). :

)(51

Edward W. Said, "Orientalism: an Exchange," The New York Review of Books, 12 Agustus
1982.

)(52

58

) ( .

.

.
:

... (53).

" "

.
:

)(53

Mehrzad Boroujerdi, Iranian

Intellectuals and the West (Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 1996); Mir Zohair
Hussain, Global Islamic Politics (New York: HarperCollins, 1995).
59

 : :

" " (54). " : "
.

.
.

" "
" (55).

" "
.

. ) (
" " .1989
" " (56).

(54) Esposito, The Islamic Threat: Myth or Reality?.

)Kai Hafez, "Islam and the West: The Clash of Politicized Perceptions." dalam Kai Hafez (ed.
The Islamic World and the West (Leiden: Brill, 2000), h. 3-18.

)(55

(56) Fukuyama, The End of History and The Last Man (London: Penguin Books, 1992).
60

" "

(57).

" " .

.
:
" " " .


.


" (58).

" "

" " .
:
) (57 .46
) (58 .237
61

.
!!

(59).


.

.
.

.
. "
" " : "


(60).
) (59 .46
(60)"Islam Resumes its March," The Economist, 4 April 1992, h. 63.
62

. 1973

.
.

) ( .

.
63

.
.
:

.

.

.
. ) (
.

.


.
64

 "
"
) (61 (62).
) (

.
.

: :
:

.
) (
) (

(61) Oliver Roy, The Failure of Political Islam (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1994).
(62) Gilles Kepel, Jihad: the Trail of Political Islam (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2002).
65


(63).

(64). " "

" : " " .


" "
" " .

. " "

" (65).

.

.

) Greg Fealy: "Divided Majority: limits of Indonesia Political Islam," (63
Islam and Political Legitimacy (New York: Routledge, 2003).:
) (64
) ( Kai Hafez, Islam and the West in Mass
Media (New Jersey: Hampton Press, Inc, 2000).
(65) Said, Covering Islam,, p. xi.
66

 .

.

)(66

.

"
) ( ) ( .

" (67).

(66) Gema Mantin Munoz (ed.), Islam, Modernism, and the west, h. 5.
J. Hippler dan Lueg (ed.), The Next Threat; Western Perception of islam (London; Pluto Press,
1995), p. 156-57.
67

)(67

 (68).

) : (

( .
" " .

.



.

(69). :
:

.
Munoz, op.cit, p. 5.

)(68

Ghassan Salam, "Islam and the West." Foreign Policy, no. 90 (Spring, 1993).

)(69

68

 .
.
:
.

.
.

.

) ( .

) " :
"(

:

. "
"
(70).
.
) (70 .
69

.


" "

.
""
. "
" " "
.
... .
" "
.
"" . " :
)

" (71).
(
Fred Halliday, Islam and the Myth of Confrontation (New York: I.B. Tauris Publishers, 1996), p.
114.
70

)(71



.
.
.

.
: :
. :

" "

" "

.
:
:

71

 .

" " "
. "

.
.



.
. " "
.

)(72

.
" .
.

" (73).
: " "

.
Mohammed 'Abed al-jabiri, "Clash of Civilization': The relations of the Future?" dalam Gema
Martin Munoz, Islam, Modernism, and the West, p. 65-80

)(72

Salam, op.cit.

)(73

72


. ) (

.
"
.

" (74).
.
" "

.

. " "

" " .

(74) Shireen T. hunter, The Future of Islam and the West: Clash of Civilizations or Peaceful
Coexistence? (Washington, D.C.: Center for strategic and International Studies, 1998), p. 166.
73



.

" "

" "
" "
) ( .

:

.



.
"
" .
.


74

 " "
.

.

:

(75).

.
" "
.
.

.
.
.
.

.

Graham Fuller, "The Next Ideology," Foreign Policy 98 (Spring, 1995).

75

)(75

76

:
!

77

(1991) " "


" "
.
" " .
" "

* .1976
) (1994
) .(1998
. New Age: Sisata Spiritual Lintas Agama :
: ) (2002 Teologi Inklusif Cak Nur
) .(2001 .
Kompas, Media Indonesia, Republika, Suara Karya, :
Majalah Panjimas, GAMMA, Forum .
)-2004 ( )-2002
(2004 .
78

(76).

2002 47
] [%23

.
110 145 ] [%75
(77). )
( .
16
.
.

18
21 . 85 39
21 .

.
) (76 :
2002 103
) (77 : -2001
2002 .2002
79



.
" :

" (1991)

30 1974 1990
%75 .
(78).

.1973

.
115

) (78 :
1991 .76
80


.



(79).
:

.
)(
.


.

(80).
:

) (79 . : : : 15
2004 2 .77
) (80 : : .
81

.
.

) (1 :

.
:
... .





.


.
82

.
. "
" (81).

.
:

" "

" (82).

(83).


.


.

.
) (81 :
1996 .70
) (82 .217 70
) (83 .
83

 :
(84). :
. 53

(85).
.




: .
" " " "

" :

" .

(86).

"" . ""
) (84 : 1993 .89
) (85 : 1996 2
.63-52
) (86 .
84

" "

.

.

(87).

.
.


.

" " .

.

) (87 . : :
1984 .31
85

" " " "

(88).

)1111-1058(

. )1263(

. "

"

" :
" (89).

) (

. "

" .

(90).

.
) (88 : :
1993 .42
) (89 .
) (90 .
86

.
) (2


. :

)(91

.

.
) (

.
:
) (91 : " " :
. 2003
.xi
87

 (1 .
(2

(3
(92).

.


.
.
1999
) .(1






) (92 : .37
88

)
(

30

1967

28

1982

20

1966

17

1977

12

1990

1979

5.2

1980

1995

1971

10

0.45

89

1952

) (3 :

.

)(93

(94).
.

!!

) (93 .

) . (
) (94 ) (2001 .29-28
90

) (1 .
) (2
(95).

" "

" " 2004 :

(96).

.

) (95 : 1996 2 .89-86
) (96 : :
http://www.nawalsaadawi.net/ 13 .2004
91


1981

(97).


.

.

(98).

(99).
" "


.
" :

) (97 .
) (98 : 15 4
2004 .129
: : :
) (99
: . 2001
.28
92

 " (100).
.
(1406-1332)

(101).

(102).
) (4 :



.

) (100 : :
.4
) (101 : .127
) (102 .
93


.

:

.
" "
2003 :

(103).

.



) (103 .129 .
94


.

.

.
" "

.


.
: ]

11 [

(104).

.
) (5 :
) (104 : 15 2004 2 .5
95

. 1999 2004

)

( .

.
.

.
.

" "

.

.
96


.
) ( .

.

.


.
.


(105).
.

:
... . "
) (105 11 (2000) 4
.48 .
97

 " "
"!!

(106). : 435
600
. 435
110 120
65 120
.
415 20

435 (107).

.

. 1999 2004
) (106 .
) (107 : .49
98



" " :
) (1 .
) (2 .
) (3 .
) (4

) (5 .
) (6 .
) (7 .
) (8

(108).
2004

.

) (108 . : : 1971 .3-1

99



.



.

.
(109).


(110).

. "

" (111).

:
) (109 : :
2004 .17-1
) (110 : .50
) (111 : 15
2004 1 110
100

 .
.

.

.
" : "

)(112

.


.

.
) (112 : 1955 .286
101

.

) ( "

" .

* .2000
) (1998-1996 ) .(2000-1999
) (
) ( .
.
. 2001 .
.Tempo, Kompas, Media Indonesia, Koran Tempo and Jawa Pos
: ) (2001
) .(2002 " Isu-isu Kontemporer Dalam Fikih Islam
" (1998) " Wajah Liberal Islam di Indonesia " .(2002)
102

) (

(113).

. " "
) ( .

.


.
(113) Hamid Enayat, Modern Islamic Pol;itical Thought, 1 st ed, Modern Middle East Series. Austin:
University of Texas Press, 1982
103

.

.
.
:

(114)
(115).
.
) (

) ( .

.
) (114
.

) (115

.

104

.
(116)

)( (117).
.

(118).


.

.

" "
) (116 : : .1996
) (117
. "
: " :
1 .1414
(118) Bernard Lewis. The Political Language of Islam. Karachi: Oxford University Press, 2002.
105

(119).

) (

.

(1) :

(120).
) (2

) (119 : "Al-Farabi and :

his School, Arabic Thought and Cultur, London; New York: routledge, 1992,
Lenn Evan Goodman. Avicenna, Arabic Thought and Culture", London; New
York: Routledge, 1992
) (120 :
Robert Nozick " . New York: Basic Books, 1974 "Anarchy, State, and Utopia
106

) (3

.
" "

)(121

) ( .
) (


.

.
" " (122).
.
" "
(123).

) (121 :
: 1977 :
1976 1 : 1976 Dergah Yaynlai
: : .1966
(122) Al-Farabi and Richard Wazler, Al-Farabi n the perfect Starte, Abu Nashr al-Farabi's Mabdi Ar
ahl al-Madinah Al-Fadlila: Revised Text with introduction, Translation, and Comentary. New
York: Clarendon Press; Oxford University Press. 1985.
) (123 .
107

.
.

(124).

.
" "

.

.

.

.
) (124 : : : 1
.1987 : .
108

 .

:


. ) (125

(126).

(127).

.
" " .
" " " "

) (125 " : ") (

" :
" .
) (126 ) (
.

.
) (127 ) (
. : Political Philosophy in Classical
Islam, Edward Craig, Routledge Encyclopedia of Philisophy. 10 Vols. London; New York:
Routledge, 1998.
109

. )

(
.

.

.
:

(128).

) (128

.
110


.

.

(129).
1999 (130).

.

.
"
"!

.

)(

)( .

) (129 ) Presiden dan Agama : ( 21 Kompas .1998

) (130 :
Nelly van Doorn-Harder. "The Indonesian Islamic Debate on a Woman President. "Sojourn,
vol. 17, No. 2 (2002), pp. 164-190.
111


.

.
.
.

) (

)(

" "
.
.

. )
(
.

.

. " "

112


.
) (
.

.
" " (131).

.

) (
.

" " .
.

) (
) ( .

(131) Michel Foucault. Archaeology of Knowledge Classics. New York Routledge, 2002.
113

 .
)
( .
/ (132).
.

.
.


.
.
.

.
) (132
.
" " "
".
114

:



. : (1873-1801)
(1898-1817) (1935-1882)
.


.

" (133)"
. " ") (134
.
.
(135).

) ( 133 : : .1982
) (134 : .1957
) (135 :
.
115

 .
:
. .

) (

.

.

.


.
.

.

.

(1905-1849)
) (1966-1888 (1973-1898) (1938-1877)
.

116

.
.

.
"" .
") ""(
"
.
(136). )

) (136 :
) Datuk Batuah ( ) (
" " . Datuk Batuah : :
.
Ajahku: Riwajat Hidup Dr. H. Abd Karim Amrullah dan Perdjuangan kaum Agama di
Sumatera. Tjet, 2. ed. Djakarta: Widjaya, 1958.
:
Takashi Shiraishi. An Age in Motion: Popular Radicalism In Java, 1912- 1926, Asia East by
South. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1990.
117

 ( " " (137).

.
. "
" ) (

:
" ) (
.
.
" "

" "
) (137
" " " " (SI Merah)
1923 " " Sarekat Rakyat
" .PKI
"
:
Ruth T. McVey. The Rise of Indonesian Communism. Ithaca, N.Y; Cornell University Press,
1965; The Social Roots of Indonesian Communism, Courrier De L'extrme Orient; No 35
Brussels: Centre d'tude duSud-Est asiatique et de I'Extrm-Orient, 1970
118

" (138).

. ""

.
. ""

(139).

" " " " .

(140).
"" (141).

)Umar Said Tjokroaminoto, (138 Islam dan Socialisme. 4.

ed (Djakarta: Bulan Bintang, 1954), h. 14.
(139) Dalier Noor. The Modernist Muslim Movement in Indonesia, 1900-1942. Singapore, New
York: Oxford University Press, 1973, h. 254
) (140 .259 .
) (141 . :
) (1950-1900 (1903)
119

) ( " "
.
.
" "
.
" "
.

.

.

.
"
" .
: "
" (142).

" "

" "
Persatuan Muslimin Indonesia .
) (142

:
Piagam Jakarta 22 Juni 1945 Dan Sejarah Konsensus Nasional Antara Nasionalis Islami dan
Nasionalis Sekular Tentang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia, 1945-1959. Cet. 1, ed.
Bandung; Pustaka Perpustakaan Salman ITB, 1981.
120

) (
: .


.
) (143
.

.

.

. " ") (144

) (143
) (BPUPKI )(PPKI
22 22-1945 .1945 1 .1995
, Padang Pandjang: Poestaka . Islam dan Negara (144) Mukhtar Yahya
Saadijah, 1946, (Microform).
121

" ") (145 " ") (146 "

") (147" ") (148 "

" (149) " ") (150 "
") (151 "

") (152 "

") (153

, Medan, 1951. . Politik dan Islam. . (145) H. S. Fachruddin.

, . Soal Agama dalam Negara Modern (146) Abu Hanifah
Djakarta, 1949.
, . Persoalan Negara Islam (147) Muhammad Saleh Suaidy
Djakarta, Perbaikan, 1953.
, . Membentuk Negara Islam (148) Zainal Abidin Ahmad
Djakarta, Widjaya, 1956.

. Dasar-dasar Pemerintahan Islam (149) M. Hasbi Ash Shiddieqy

, Medan, 1950.

, Bandung, . Islam dan Parlementarisme (150) Zainal Abidin Ahmad

Indonesia, Aliran Islam, 1950.
. Dapatkah Dipisahkan Politik dari (151) Mohamad Iqbal dan M. Natsir
, Djakarta: Mutiara, 1954. ?Agama
. Konsepsi Asasi (152) Khalifa Abdul Hakim dan Syarif Usman.
Tatanegara Islam: Ditambah dengan Pendapat Alim Ulama Seluruh Pakistan dan Pendapat
: Alim Ulama Seluruh Indonesia
, Djakarta, Fa. Sudjas, 1953.
. Mungkinkah Negara Indonesia Bersendikan Islam: Analyse. (153) Ibnu Amatillah, M. Sj.
, Tjet. 1. ed. Semarang; Usaha :.
Taruna, 1950.
122

 .
.

" "

" "
. " "
"" .

.
) (

. .


.

123

" .
" "
" (154).

.
: :

. " "
.

.

" " " "
.

, 64. . Membentuk Negara Islam (154) Ahmad

124

" "

. :

" " .
(155).

. ) (
.
" " " :
" " .

.
) (155
.
.
" " .
125

 " "
.
(156).

.

.

(157).

"
" (158).

) (156 :
Ibnu Amatillah itu Munawir Sjadzali 22 Kompas .2004
(157) Ikatan Persaudaraan Haji Indonesia dan Yayasan Wakaf Paramadina
. Kontekstualisasi Ajaran Islam: 70 Tahun Prof. Dr. H.
: Munawir Sjadzali, MA.
, Cet.1. ed. Jakarta; Ikatan Persaudaraan Haji Indonesia: Paramadina, 1995, P. 50.
. Islam dan Tatanegara: Ajaran, Sejarah, dan Pemikiran. (158) Munawir Sjadzali.
, Cet. 1. ed. Jakarta: Penerbit Universitas Indonesia, 1990. :
126

 ) (
.

... .

" " "

" " " " "
.

.
" " " " .

.
127

: .

. .

.
.

.
.

128



)(159

"

) (159
12
.2003
* 29 .1945
.1983 1989 AIDAB
Curtin .
Investigations into subpixel feature detections and measurements :
.
.Islamic Network (Isnet)
. 1998
. computer vision, visual
recognition, multimedia information retrieval and information theory
.
2002 31 2003
.
129

".

)
Okinawa
("




.

.

"
" (160).

)
(1999Gates .
160
" "Telematics
) (
1979 . :
. "
".
130



)
.(1997 Huff
2000

!!



.
: :
: (1997) Kahin and Nesson

.

.

. ) (


.
131

 " (1995) " Penziass theory

:

. "
"

) .(1996 Marien



.

) Hagel
.(1997and Armstrong

.
132


.


) .(2000 Currie

: .

.(2000 Castells

.
:


.
.


133

) (1997Kedzies



.
(1996) Barber

" :

".

.
134


. :(1995) Azzman
"

" .
: :


) .(%75
) (2001 35

) ( .

35
) ( ) (

) ( ) ( )
( .
: ) .(2001 Spiegalman
) .(%75

%84 %15 %1
%99 %1
135

%93.4 %2.5 %2.3

%1.8

%100 ) %75 %25 (

%88.3 %10.5 %1.2

%98 %2

%94 %6

%94 ) ( %6

%90 %9 %1

%85 %8 %7

%88 %8 %2 %1 %1

%99 ) %89 %10 ( %1

%97 ) %65-60 %37-%32 ( %3

%96 ) ( %4
%85 ) %45 %40 ( %15

%75 %20 %5
136

%97 ) (

%100

%90 %9 %1
%100
%98.7 %1.1 %0.2

%75 )

%97 ) %77 %20 ( %3

%95

%100

%92 %6 %2

%100 ) (

%74 ) ( %16 %10

%80 %5

%98 %1 %1

%99.8 ) ( 0.2 ) (

137

%89 %9 %2
%96 ) %80 %16 ( %4

%88 %9 %3

%99.9 ) %53 %46.9 ( %0.1

:


. "
") .(2000 Norris
/ )
( )
( .100

)(161

" " . 35
23 .
) (161 0 .120
0 .100
138

 23

%8.8
) %31
() (162 %1.51!!

.%19
:

) (2001 165
) (0.25-
.

.165 -
) 0.3 (%95
.


:

) (162 ISP

.

139

 ) (
.

"

"

N/A

0.90

0.14

0.01

0.53

5.32

5.42

9.34

24.55

0.01

0.30

0.15

1.27

7.7
8.91

0.42

6.5

12.41

7.6
3.4

1.42

4.5

0.62

0.91

6.02

11.08

1.25

6.5

0.04

0.82

2.70

7.80

0.75

3.4

0.15

11.18

11.50

0.17

6.6

140

3.19

3.10

7.33

7.7

0.82

1.29

8.55

10.08

1.75

4.4

3.69

10.49

23.59

38.42

12.00

4.5

8.36

9.33

7.7

2.86

5.86

19.76

21.17

7.25

5.5

0.45

0.72

5.44

9.83

1.00

5.4

1.74

2.10

9.23

27.58

3.25

6.5

0.04

0.39

1.94

5.25

0.33

6.5

4.58

12.09

25.99

13.92

6.6

0.58

4.96

14.26

4.67

7.7

16.50

6.7

0.14

0.07

1.30

9.54

9.42

1.17

7.7

0.52

1.47

8.06

10.92

1.67

6.5

0.95

2.32

25.41

18.00

2.92

4.5

8.88

10.62

38.90

28.33

17.00

6.5

0.04

0.12

1.34

2.50

0.17

5.6

141

39.11

45.86

66.13

83.83

83.41

1.1

1.51

3.53

10.56

15.56

4.40

) (0.42
) 15.56 .(100 - 0
.83.83

.
:

.

1996 " "

142

 .2020
.
1998
2001 )
www.nue.ie (Microsoft Bookshelf 2001

1998 1999

2000

2001

90

14

20000

50000

180000

0.57

32500

40000

105000

10.07

7000

20000

100

300

900

1000

61000

260000

450000

560000

0.81

80000

400000

1450000

4400000

1.93

100000

200000

0.38

125000

0.05

750

143

0.02

20000

50000

127000

210000

4.07

42.350

62800

100000

165000

8.08

7500

20000

0.24

137000

600000

1500000

3700000

16.98

6000

32000

120000

220000

0.72

20000

40000

50000

90000

3.55

1200000

0.85

27500

45000

75000

9.75

112500

300000

570000

2.5

17295

200

15000

20000

30000

32000

0.19

48000

110000

280000

2.89

600000

2000000

3.05

204300

400000

735000

31.02

6300

12000

14000

0.08

88552

2000

59.75 16614000 14690000 10600000 7300000

0
144



) (2000

.
.
" ") (163
23 3 7 5.5
) (
(164).


) . ( .
""
.
) (

) (163 1 7
. 1 7
.
) (164 2-1 5-3
5 .
145

. ) (2001

.
1998

.

.
:
: :


) .(2001

146


.
Henry

(1998) Clement

"
"

" "
" "
"

" .
- -
.
- -2001
200/1
1000/12 .

147

 (1998)
% 33
. %24

%19

%8.5

) . (1997

(1985) Katz and Liebers " :

-
.

.
.

. " .
148

.
(1958) Aldous Huxley "


.

.
."


.
.



.
149

150

1) Azzman M. (1995). Moving tosard a more intelligent use of human

intelligence. INFOTECH 95. Kuala Lumpur Malaysia.
2) Barber B. R. (1996). Jihad vs. Mc World: How globalism and tribalism
are reshaping the world. Ballantine.
3) Castells M. (2000) The Rise of the Network Society Blackwell.
4) Currie W. (2000) The Global Information Society. John Wiley & Sons.
5) Gates B. (1999) Business @ the speed of thought. Penguin.
6) Hagel. J. and Amstrong A. (1997) Net gain: Expdaning markets through
virtual communities. Harvard Business School Press.
7) Henry C. (1998) Challenge of global capital markets to informationshy regimes: The case of Tunisia. UAE: The Emirates Center for Strategic
Studies and Research Occasional Papers #19.
8) Hill K dan Hubhes J (1998). Cyberpolitics. Citizen Activism in the Age
of the Internet. Roman and Littlefield.
9) Huff. T (1997). Science and the public sphere: Comparative institutional
development in Islam and the West Social Epistemology vol. 11 no.
1 pp. 25-37.
10)
Huff. T (2001). Globalization and the Internet: Comparing the
Middle Eastern and Malaysian experiences. The Middle East Journal.
Vol. 55 no. 3. pp. 1-20.
151

11)

Huxley. A (1958). Brave New World. Perennial pp. 39.

12)
Kahin B. and Nesson C. (ed). (1997). Borders in Cyberspace:
Information Policy and he Global Information Infrastructure Harvard
Univ. Press.
13)
Katz E. and Lieber T. (1985). Mutual aid in the decoding of
Dallas: Preliminary notes from a cross-cultural study. In Drummond
and Peterson (Ed) Television in transition: Papers from the First
International Television Studies Conference. London British Film
Institute.
14)
Kedzie C. (1997). The third wave in B. Kahin and C. Nesson
(ed). 1997 Borders in Cyberspace: Information Policy and the Global
Information Infrastructure. Harvard Univ. Press.
15)
Marien M. (1996). New communication technology. A survey
of impacts and issues Futuresco 7. Paris UNESCO.
16)
Norris P. (Digital Divide? Civic Engagement Information Poverty
& the Internet in Democratic Societies. J. F. Kennedy School of
Government Harvard University.
17)
Norris P. (2000). Information Society Database. J. F. Kennedy
School of Government Harvard University.
18)
Penzias A. (1995). Harmony Business Technology & Life After
Paperwork. Harper Business.
19)
Spiegelman S. (2001). Islam and Internet: The correlation
between Islamic Religion and Internet Diffusion. Information and
152

Autonomy: The Relationship Between Individual and Government in

the Digital Age. Deborah Hurley ed. J. F. Kennedy School of
Government Harvard University.
20)
Talero E. (1997). National information infrastructure in
developing economies in B. Kahin and E.J. Wilson III (ed). 1997.
National Information Infrastructure Initiatives: Vision and Policy Design.
MIT Press.
21)
World Bandk (2001). World Development Report 2000/2001
Table 19 pp. 310-311

153