The New York Times

Are Christians Supposed to Be Communists?


It was in 1983 that I heard the distinguished Greek Orthodox historian Aristeides Papadakis casually remark in a lecture at the University of Maryland that the earliest Christians were “communists.” In those days, the Cold War was still casting its great glacial shadow across the cultural landscape, and so enough of a murmur of consternation rippled through the room that Professor Papadakis — who always spoke with severe precision — felt obliged to explain that he meant this in the barest technical sense: They lived a common life and voluntarily enjoyed a community of possessions. The murmur subsided, though not necessarily the disquiet.

Not that anyone should have been surprised. If the communism of the apostolic church is a secret, it is a startlingly open one. Vaguer terms like “communalist” or “communitarian” might make the facts sound more palatable but cannot change them. The

This article originally appeared in .

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The New York Times

The New York Times6 min readPsychology
What 'Good' Dads Get Away With
Division of labor in the home is one of the most important equity issues of our time. Yet at this rate it will be another 75 years before men do half the work.
The New York Times7 min read
36 Hours in Mendocino County
(36 Hours) Ninety miles north of San Francisco, Mendocino County is just faraway enough to have narrowly escaped the Bay Area’s radical transformation during the tech boom years. In contrast to other formerly quiet Northern California backwaters, Men
The New York Times5 min readPolitics
What's Really Going On in the Democratic Primary?
Bundlers and endorsers are out. Ears and eyeballs are in. candidate wins his or her party’s presidential nomination. Recent Democratic primary battles were all about the