Promise unrealized: A birth checklist fails to reduce deaths in rural India

Dr. Atul Gawande's closely watched study, the BetterBirth Trial, was supposed to be a breakthrough moment in global health. But it has produced a disappointing result.
Vinita, 23, holds her baby girl a few hours after her birth at a Community Health Center in Mall, near the capital of Uttar Pradesh. Source: ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images

It was supposed to be a breakthrough moment in global health.

Atul Gawande, the physician and writer, was applying a simple tool he championed — the checklist — to improve birth outcomes in a rural part of India with some of the world’s highest infant mortality rates.

But his closely watched study, the BetterBirth Trial, has produced a disappointing result: Despite increased adherence to best practices, outcomes for babies and mothers did not improve with the use of a checklist and coaching on its implementation, according to data published Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine.

“The improvement in quality was part of the answer, but it was not enough,” Gawande said. “We need to understand what more needs to be added to get to the endpoint everyone wants.”

The idea of the checklist

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from STAT

STAT5 min readSociety
Opinion: Diagnostics Are Essential For Universal Health Coverage To Succeed
It's difficult to cure illness without first diagnosing it, making diagnostics as important as medicines and vaccines in delivering universal health care.
STAT4 min read
Pharma Is Making Progress Addressing Global Health, But It’s Still A Mixed Bag
Drug makers are taking steps to reach people on very low incomes, but access programs are for just a few diseases.
STAT5 min read
After Forced Sale, PatientsLikeMe Founder Frets That U.S. Policy Could Chill Collaboration In Biotech
PatientsLikeMe founder speaks publicly for the first time about the U.S. order that the company must find a new buyer.