The Atlantic

'The Court System Shouldn't Interrupt the Treatment Process'

A Massachusetts case illustrates the glaring difference between the medical community’s approach to addiction and the laws on the books in the United States.
Source: John Moore / Getty Images

The notion that drug addiction is a health condition is not, in the main, controversial in 2017—not politically and not medically. For decades, doctors and researchers have categorized it as a disease, and in recent years the majority of the American public has caught up with them, with widespread support for increased access to treatment and reduced reliance on incarceration. But this consensus hasn’t entirely translated to the courts.

There’s perhaps no case that illustrates this disconnect more clearly than one that’s playing out in Massachusetts. There, the state Supreme Court is considering the appeal of 29-year-old Julie Eldred, who’s contesting a trial court’s decision that she violated probation by failing a mandatory drug test. She’d been under court supervision for theft for 12 days in 2016 when she tested positive for fentanyl, a powerful opiate; she subsequently spent 10 days in jail before being sent to an inpatient treatment facility.**

Eldred says that she shouldn’t be the Associated Press last year that “for far too long” addiction hasn’t been treated like a medical condition: “I think about addiction as a disease in the same way we think about diabetes as a disease or heart disease as a disease.” But in Eldred’s case, that thinking hasn’t influenced the state’s argument: Healey’s office has refined its stance to say that, in a legal setting, it’s not the same thing.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
The Contraceptive Mandate Discriminates on the Basis of Sex
Its exclusion of men perpetuates harmful stereotypes. The most obvious one is that birth control is a woman’s responsibility.
The Atlantic3 min readPolitics
Republicans Don't Understand Democrats—And Democrats Don't Understand Republicans
A new study shows Americans have little understanding of their political adversaries—and education doesn’t help.
The Atlantic7 min readSociety
The Boomers Ruined Everything
The Baby Boomers ruined America. That sounds like a hyperbolic claim, but it’s one way to state what I found as I tried to solve a riddle. American society is going through a strange set of shifts: Even as cultural values are in rapid flux, political