This Week in Asia

For China and Japan, is this Trump's 'Nixon shock'?

Annoyed with a US president who simply seems to change policy at whim, the Japanese prime minister plans to see China's leader for a one-on-one discussion. This isn't a description of the sudden warming of relations between Shinzo Abe and Xi Jinping over the past few days. It happened in July 1971, when president Richard Nixon announced that he would visit China without having first warned his closest Asian ally, Japan, an event that became known as the Nixon "shock".

Wasting little time, prime minister Eisaku Sato began his own overtures to China. His eventual successor, Kakuei Tanaka, visited Beijing in the autumn of 1972, just a few months after Nixon. From that point, Japan felt put on notice that it would have to chart more of its own course in foreign policy.

This week, there has been wide coverage of a new warmth in the relationship between China and Japan. The chilly looks and words between Abe and Xi of just a year or two ago seem to have been replaced by a flurry of visits and plans for visits. The Chinese president and Japanese premier recently spoke on the phone for the first time and Chinese Premier Li Keqiang has just finished a three-day tour of Japan, the first by a major Chinese leader since 2010, during which he met the Emperor. With the relationship between the two sides still sensitive because of unreconciled issues over Japanese crimes during the second world war, this is a startling development indeed.

Kim Jong-un and Donald Trump. Beijing and Tokyo are both uneasy about being cut out of the loop. Photo: AFP

Yet it needs to be seen from both a short- and long-term perspective. In the short term, there is one reason why China and Japan might need to be on the same page: Korea. Nobody quite knows where the current negotiations may go, but there seems to be an unease both in Beijing and Tokyo about their two capitals being cut out of the loop while a maverick DC establishment cuts a deal with both Koreas.

There are supplementary reasons too. With much of the rest of the world, Tokyo and Beijing sit in the same place when it comes to wanting to preserve the Iran nuclear deal. But compared to Europe, China and Japan stand to suffer more if that deal falls through. The North Korean talks could stall if, having seen Trump reverse Washington's position on the Tehran deal, Pyongyang decides it cannot trust the US to keep to its word.

Yet warming and cooling is nothing new in the Japan-China relationship over the past half-century. That 1972 "Nixon shock" seemed like a very big deal to the Japanese at the time, leading Sato and Tanaka to reach out to China to show they were capable of independent diplomacy. Within a short time, tempers cooled. The US-Japan relationship remained a strong one; a decade later, Ronald Reagan and Yasuhiro Nakasone would develop one of the strongest relationships of the cold war era.

The underlying reason was the same then as now: the US and Japan needed each other in terms of preserving a liberal political and strategic order in East Asia. They had a commonality of basic interests against the USSR. China was a partner, a balance against the Soviets, in those days, but an ally of convenience for the US and Japan rather than a friend because of shared mutual values.

Over the post-cold war decades, there have been periods of warmth between Beijing and Tokyo. Abe's first brief premiership, in 2006-7, was also marked by a rapprochement with China (ironically, as Abe then became the butt of Chinese ire in the first part of his current premiership, which began in 2012).

Ronald Reagan and wife Nancy with Emperor Hirohito at the Akasaka Palace in Tokyo. Photo: AP

That perspective is needed to understand the new, more positive language of the last few days. It is very good news that China and Japan are speaking respectfully to each other once again. The behaviour of the two biggest economies and military powers of the region shapes the tenor of everything from Siberia to Tasmania.

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2018. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia3 min read
China Must Choose: Growth Or Lasting Economic Health. It Can't Have Both
It is an irony of the so-called free economies that their governments are more constrained than China's when it comes to pursuing growth. China's central bank can print as much money as the economy needs; its government can order state-owned banks to
This Week in Asia4 min readPolitics
Former New Zealand PM Jenny Shipley Distances Herself From Controversial Op-ed In Chinese State Media
Former New Zealand prime minister Jenny Shipley has distanced herself from a controversial op-ed published in China's People's Daily, saying the state-run newspaper constructed it from an interview she did during a visit to China last December. Publi
This Week in Asia5 min read
Spurned By West, Saudi Crown Prince MBS Heads To China, Becomes Unlikely Peacemaker For India And Pakistan
Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman created quite the buzz this week with his whirlwind weeklong Asian tour, starting in Pakistan on Sunday before moving to India and wrapping it up with a two-day stop in China that ended on Friday. Many