This Week in Asia

Singapore's Trump-Kim summit: North Korea wins first round 3-2

The actual meeting of US President Donald Trump and North Korean paramount leader Kim Jong-un marks the end of what could be called the pre-summit period. In a sense this was the first round of negotiation.

Because much of this negotiation was public, whether the United States or North Korea won the pre-summit negotiations can be assessed by comparing each side's agenda against the concessions made by the other side. Both governments had their respective victories, but Kim was the bigger winner.

Kim's agenda includes two immediate goals: to alleviate the threat of a US preventive military strike against nuclear and missile facilities on North Korean territory, and to get the international community to lift economic sanctions against North Korea. Kim also hopes to earn international prestige for his government; to gain recognition, particularly from Washington, of North Korea as a nuclear weapon state; to move US troops off the Korean Peninsula; and to generally weaken the US-South Korea alliance.

Trump's agenda starts with the overriding US interest in persuading North Korea to halt and dismantle its missile and nuclear bomb programmes. Trump also wants to emerge from the negotiations looking like the master deal maker he claims to be, solving a tough problem his predecessors could not. He clearly likes the idea of winning the Nobel Peace Prize, telling reporters "everyone thinks" he deserves it.

Kim's biggest success this year was getting the meeting with Trump. And he may have achieved this under false pretences.

US policy since the Obama Administration was that Washington would not negotiate with North Korea unless the Pyongyang government agreed beforehand the topic would be denuclearisation. The negotiation would be over the price America would pay North Korea to give up its missiles and nuclear bombs. No negotiations occurred because Pyongyang repeatedly said it would never yield its nuclear weapons, or would do so only if America denuclearised first.

It wasn't a departure from this policy for Trump to agree to meet Kim. Trump made that announcement after hearing from South Korean intermediaries that Kim was "committed to denuclearisation", which met the US pre-condition. What was unconventional about Trump's snap agreement to a summit was the reversal of the usual process, in which the top leaders meet only after their subordinates have hammered out a detailed and mutually acceptable deal.

Since then, however, Pyongyang has appeared less willing to denuclearise than the South Korean intermediaries indicated. Subsequent North Korean statements used the phrase "denuclearisation of the Korean peninsula", which has long been shorthand for North Korea's demand that the US-South Korea alliance must end before the North gives up its nuclear weapons.

US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. Photo: The Washington Post

Trump reportedly hoped to bring about the total dismantling of North Korea's nuclear missile project by the end of his first term, but more recently he has tried to lower expectations, saying "I never said it goes in one meeting. I think it's going to be a process", and "I told them today, 'Take your time ... We can go slowly'." After his National Security Adviser John Bolton said the US would insist on complete North Korean denuclearisation before making any concessions, Trump disavowed Bolton's statement.

North Korean leader Kim Jong-un meets South Korean President Moon Jae-in. Photo: AP

Furthermore, Kim has succeeded in lightening some of the pressure arising from economic sanctions on his country. While the US has not lifted any of its sanctions, Trump has said he will not add any new sanctions before the summit. More importantly, China, which accounts for 90 per cent of North Korea's trade, has signalled it will no longer vigorously enforce sanctions against Pyongyang as a reward for Kim's outreach. Kim is also enjoying a bonanza of both domestic and international prestige by meeting foreign leaders like the South's President Moon Jae-in and Chinese President Xi Jinping, helping to obscure his government's immense crimes against humanity and seemingly proving his claim that nuclear weapons command respect for his country.

Kim Dong-chul, one of the three US citizens released by North Korea. Photo: AP

America, too, has benefited from the pre-summit thaw, but not as much as Pyongyang. First, the three US citizens detained by North Korea are now home. Second, the self-imposed moratorium on missile and nuclear explosion tests has interrupted North Korea's march toward deploying a credible nuclear missile capability. Without further testing, North Korea remains a "virtual" rather than a demonstrated nuclear weapons state. So that is two successes for the US - one large and one small.

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2018. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia4 min readPolitics
Who's Making China Look Ugly Now? Anger Over Zara's Ad Showing Freckle-faced Model Li Jingwen Only Puts Chinese People's Lack Of Confidence On Show
In the latest case, a new cosmetics advertisement for the Spanish fashion house Zara featuring a Chinese model has stirred up debate on the topic of "uglifying China". Since the ad "Beauty is Here" was released on Sina Weibo last week, a number of an
This Week in Asia5 min readPolitics
Huang Xiangmo And Meng Wanzhou Today, Any Other Chinese Tomorrow?
According to Chinese tradition, the first day of the Lunar New Year is one of the most sacred occasions. It is when Chinese around the world gather with their loved ones to celebrate and pray for an auspicious year ahead. But the first day of the Yea
This Week in Asia6 min readPsychology
Mikhy Farrera Brochez, American Man At Heart Of Singapore's HIV Data Scandal, Ran Hong Kong Centre For Special Needs Children
The American at the centre of Singapore's HIV data leak scandal ran education-related businesses in Hong Kong, charging as much as HK$8,000 for each assessment of a child with special needs, the South China Morning Post has found. Mikhy Farrera Broch