The Marshall Project

Was This Man Sentenced to Death Because He’s Gay?

His defenders say yes. South Dakota says no. The Supreme Court may soon weigh in.

Before South Dakota jurors decided the fate of Charles Rhines in 1993, they sent a handwritten note to the judge. They had just found Rhines guilty of fatally stabbing 22-year-old Donnivan Schaeffer, an employee of Dig ‘Em Donuts in Rapid City, during a robbery a year earlier. But now they had some questions.

Case in Point In “Case in Point,” Andrew Cohen examines a single case or character that sheds light on the criminal justice system. An audio version of Case in Point is broadcast with The Takeaway, a public radio show from WNYC, Public Radio International, The New York Times, and WGBH-Boston Public Radio. Related Stories

If they didn’t vote for the death penalty, what would his life in prison look like? Would he be “allowed to mix with the general inmate population”? Would he be able “to create a group of followers or admirers”? Would he

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Marshall Project

The Marshall Project6 min readRelationships & Parenting
After Prison, I Became a Better Dad
“Even when a parent has been part of a child’s pain, that parent’s love can still be the antidote.”
The Marshall Project8 min read
I Thought I Knew My Father, Then I Met Him in Prison
Editor’s note: This week, we’re running a special Life Inside series about fathers and incarceration. Read the previous essays about next-cell neighbors and dancing in the prison gym. I always called my father Mr. Moore. It didn’t seem strange to me
The Marshall Project5 min readSociety
My Cellie Was the Father I Never Had
Editor’s note: This week, we’re running a special Life Inside series about fathers and incarceration. Read the previous essays about next-cell neighbors, dancing in the prison gym and a surprise meeting. I was born in 1964 on the South Side of Chicag