The Millions

On Semicolons and the Rules of Writing

1.
Kurt Vonnegut’s caution against the use of semicolons is one of the most famous and canonical pieces of writing advice, an admonition that has become, so to speak, one of The Rules. More on these rules later, but first the infamous quote in question: “Here is a lesson in creative writing. First rule: Do not use semicolons. They are transvestite hermaphrodites representing absolutely nothing. All they do is show you’ve been to college.”

To begin with the lowest-hanging fruit here—fruit that is actually scattered rotting on the ground—the “transvestite hermaphrodite” bit has not aged well. The quote also, it seems, may have been taken out of context, as it is followed by several more sentences of puzzlingly offensive facetiousness, discussed here.

That said, I also have no idea what it means. My best guess is that he means semicolons perform no function that could not be performed by other punctuation, namely commas and periods. This obviously isn’t true—semicolons, like most punctuation, increase the range of tone and inflection at a writer’s disposal. Inasmuch that you would like everyone to write like him.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Millions

The Millions8 min read
When We Were Young: Christine Sneed in Conversation with Anthony Varallo
I don’t know why I have to keep learning the same lesson again, but here’s one I can't seem to remember: Your writing doesn’t care about your plans for it. The post When We Were Young: Christine Sneed in Conversation with Anthony Varallo appeared fir
The Millions13 min readPsychology
We Can Be Anyone: A Pride Month Conversation with Nicole Dennis-Benn
I think of that little girl in me, that 17-year-old, 14-year-old, who wanted to see books like mine. I wanted to see love between two women on the page. The post We Can Be Anyone: A Pride Month Conversation with Nicole Dennis-Benn appeared first on T
The Millions4 min read
Tuesday New Release Day: Bhattacharya, Mechling, Rilke, Ginzburg, and More
This week's fresh reads include stories of adult friendship, ”new“ Rilke, and a secret history of Charles Manson and the CIA. The post Tuesday New Release Day: Bhattacharya, Mechling, Rilke, Ginzburg, and More appeared first on The Millions.