This Week in Asia

On gay sex, India has assumed an ancient position. Read the Kama Sutra

The Indian ethos towards sexual difference has historically been liberal and eclectic, with neither mythology nor history revealing the persecution or prosecution of sexual heterodoxy. In fact, the Hindu epics are dotted with characters like Shikhandi in the Mahabharata, who was born female and became male; many Hindus venerate the half-man, half-woman Ardhanarishvara; and temple sculptures across India depict homosexual acts. Yet India's political class " including its ruling Hindu nationalist party, which portrays itself as the custodian of traditional Indian values " has been favouring the British law (which the British themselves had outgrown), finally leaving it to the judiciary to set it right.

Indian LGBTI activists celebrate the Supreme Court's decision to decriminalise gay sex. Photo: Reuters

It has become quite clear that homosexuality was acceptable in pre-colonial India, that colonialism changed it, and that it's time to change it back. While each Asian culture has its own traditions, Hinduism, the dominant cultural tradition in India, with its myths and gods, is astonishingly open-minded in accepting the sexual realities and ambiguities of the human species. This is clear from images on temple walls, sacred narratives and ancient scriptural texts.

Temples openly depicted erotica, since sensual pleasure (kama) was seen by Hindus as one of the purusharthas, the four vital expressions of human life, along with dharma (righteous conduct), artha (the pursuit of material success and wealth) and moksha (ultimate salvation). The purpose of human life is to pursue all four goals with the same commitment and to lead an existence that harmoniously integrates all four.

The sculptures and carvings on the walls of the 12th-century Khajuraho temple in central India explicitly depict couplings that employ every conceivable sexual position, whether heterosexual, homosexual or bisexual. Lesbians are shown in flagrante, but then they were recognised as swarinis in the 2nd-century text on love and eroticism, the Kama Sutra, which even recognises homosexual marriage as "a union of love and cohabitation, without the need for parental approval".

Indian revellers at the 'Kitty Su' nightclub in New Delhi celebrate the Supreme Court's ruling on gay sex. Photo: AFP

Indian legends cheerfully portray sexually ambiguous individuals and relationships. The mythological Bhagirathi was born of two queens who made love to each other when his father, the king, died. Varuna and Mitra were two gods depicted as a "same-sex couple" in ancient Indian scripture, always shown side-by-side. The religious text Shatapatha Brahmana mentions them as personifications of two half-moons implanting their seed in each other as the moon waxes and wanes.

Indeed, homosexual sex is mentioned without embarrassment: homosexuals and the "third gender" were widely accepted identities. In the Valmiki Ramayana, female Rakshasis are mentioned who kiss women lying on the demon-king Ravana's bed, on whose lips still linger the taste of their master.

The popular scholar of Indian classical literature, Devdutt Pattanaik, has written of how Indian lore is full of tales where men turn into women and women into men. Several Puranas (sacred Sanskrit writings) tell tales of Lord Vishnu who, for various reasons, becomes a woman, Mohini, and seduces sages and demons whom the gods wish to defeat.

Even personifications of the planets embrace alternative notions of sexuality: thus, in his Navagraha Kriti set of songs, the great 19th-century Carnatic music composer Muthuswami Dikshitar describes Budh (the planet Mercury) as Napumsakam, or one who is not quite male or female, since, as the love child of his adulterous mother, Tara, goddess of the stars, he was cursed by her husband, Jupiter, to be neuter.

Prince Manvendra Singh Gohil, India's only openly gay prince. Photo: Thomson Reuters Foundation

All this (and more) offer ample evidence that homosexual activities existed and were acknowledged in ancient India. They were accepted in the Dharmashastras, the ancient texts, as an inescapable feature of society, but that does not necessarily imply approval of homosexual conduct.

The Kama Sutra mentions homosexuals but with disdain. The ancient lawbook Manusmriti prescribes stringent punishments for male and female homosexuals. But there are very few stories of such punishments actually being carried out; their existence was intended to discourage overt homosexual practice but not to persecute it, let alone to stamp it out, since it was part of human reality.

The same was true of transsexuals. India has long recognised as a feature of its society the transgender people known as hijra s, who consider themselves neither male nor female.

Hijras have been organised for centuries into formal communities of males who see themselves as " and express themselves socially as " female, dress in women's clothes, and are attracted to men.

Incongruously enough, they are often seen dancing at weddings, in exchange for generous rewards.

But all this elicited imperial disapproval. The heyday of colonialism coincided with the peak of the repressive Victorian era, when hypocrisy about sex was at its peak " even piano legs had to be covered because they were, well, legs! Colonial powers, breathtakingly self-assured about the superiority of their ways, disrespected (indeed often condemned) the cultural values of the people they conquered, particularly when it related to sexual activity, and had no hesitation about imposing their "superior morality" on the "inferiors" they ruled.

Victorian Britain found "morbid sexual passion between members of the same sex" to be "unnatural" and imposed severe colonial laws punishing it. Inevitably such laws came to be seen as "right" and previous indulgent attitudes "wrong" in the very societies upon which they were imposed.

Colonial laws not only exercised a powerful influence on subjugated people, but set the standard to which colonial subjects were expected to adhere to receive the approval of the imperial authorities. As a result, these colonial attitudes were internalised by the victims. Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalised "unnatural" sex, was drafted by Lord Macaulay in 1839 and enacted by the British Government in 1861. Though the British left in 1947, it took India another seven decades to get rid of the prohibition. As columnist Gurcharan Das put it: "Tragically, the colonial brainwashing was so deep that this un-Indian imposition remained on our statute books for 71 years after the colonisers had left."

Members of the LGBT community celebrate the striking down of a colonial-era law that made homosexual acts punishable by up to 10 years in prison. Photo: AP

Das points out that "India's is the only civilisation to have elevated kama, or desire and pleasure, to a goal of life .... Dharma [reflects] our duty to others but ... kama is a duty to ourselves. The extreme pleasure of sex is recompense for the loneliness of the human condition." Ancient texts grapple with the nature and power of desire, some acknowledging it as the essence of life " the source of action, creation and procreation " while others like the Bhagavad Gita commend the pursuit of right action without desire for reward or personal pleasure.

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2018. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia6 min readTech
North Korean Cyberwarfare: As Big A Threat As Its Nuclear Weapons?
North Korea's nuclear weapons programme has for several years posed a growing threat to international security " to its neighbours in the South and to the rest of the world. However, the hermit kingdom has also been fashioning another weapon with whi
This Week in Asia2 min readPolitics
Trump-Kim Summit 2019: US And North Korea Negotiating Terms Of Joint Statement From Hanoi Meeting
US and North Korean senior diplomats on Thursday began last-minute talks in Hanoi as official sources claimed both sides had not yet reached a consensus on the joint communique to be issued at next week's summit of the two countries' leaders. The mee
This Week in Asia3 min read
Thai Elections: Thai Raksa Chart Party That Put Princess Ubolratana Forward As Candidate For PM Defiant Ahead Of Court Ruling On Controversial Move
The political party that stunned Thailand with its now-vetoed nomination of King Maha Vajiralongkorn's sister as its prime ministerial candidate has resumed campaigning following a temporary suspension, with its leaders putting up a defiant front ahe