The Atlantic

The Christmas Dilemma: How Much of a Kid’s Wish List Should Parents Oblige?

A conversation with the sociologist Allison Pugh, who studies why children want what they want and how moms and dads navigate those desires
Source: Paul Hackett / Reuters

A little more than a decade ago, the sociologist Allison Pugh spent three years studying parents and children at three elementary schools—one low-income public, one affluent public, and one private—in Oakland, California. Pugh wanted to understand what it is that kids want, why they want those things, and how parents decide whether to fulfill their kids’ wishes.

I sat with kids in classrooms and after-school programs, while they did homework and biked and knitted and played games,” Pugh says. “I tied shoes and turned jump ropes and caught footballs. I was with them while they sold lemonade and bought birthday presents, when they went to the library and to parades.” In addition, Pugh interviewed 54 of the children’s parents. Her research was published as a book, Longing and Belonging: Parents, Children, and Consumer Culture, in 2009.

I spoke with Pugh about her work recently, and an edited

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

Related Interests

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic3 min readPolitics
Republicans Don't Understand Democrats—And Democrats Don't Understand Republicans
A new study shows Americans have little understanding of their political adversaries—and education doesn’t help.
The Atlantic3 min readPolitics
Not All Drones Are Created Equal
Autonomous-weapons systems won’t be the spark that leads to war with Iran or any other country. Human decisions might be.
The Atlantic6 min readPolitics
Is There Still a Deal to Be Done With Iran?
The United States stepped right up to the brink of striking Iran over a downed American drone—and then abruptly stepped back. Yet the conditions that have stoked weeks of tensions remain fully in place, as does the question of what exactly President