Post Magazine

Trade war talks: China and US said to be far apart on framework for monitoring Chinese action on structural reform; US could possibly drop 10 per cent tariffs

Chinese and American negotiators remain far apart on a key US demand meant to ensure Beijing honours any commitment to equal market access and intellectual property protection " an issue the US team sees as crucial in reaching a deal to end the months-old trade war, sources familiar with the situation said.

In the latest round of talks underway in Beijing, both sides also are discussing the possibility of the US' removing the 10 per cent punitive tariffs it has imposed on US$200 billion of Chinese products, while leaving the 25 per cent tariffs on US$50 billion of Chinese products unchanged, two sources said.

In return, China could pledge to make structural changes that would better protect the intellectual property of foreign companies doing business in China, would expand access to Chinese markets and reduce hefty state subsidies, one of the sources said.

One of the sources said that during the last round of talks between the countries in Washington, China raised the idea of setting up a parallel dialogue aimed at resolving Huawei Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou's extradition case. Huawei, a Chinese telecommunications giant, faces criminal charges in the US and is increasingly being excluded from the 5G market in Western countries.

European and Asean orders boost China's exports despite US trade war

It is not clear whether the company's status is a prominent issue in the Beijing talks.

With the March 1 expiration of the 90-day trade war ceasefire now just two weeks away, the latest negotiations pick up where the talks that concluded at the end of January left off. Jointly chairing the talks are Chinese Vice Premier Liu He, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and US Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin.

Creating a framework to monitor China's implementation of structural industry reform is a top priority for the US team, especially United States Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer.

The US has repeatedly said China does not have a good track record when it comes to implementing its commitments, and its reluctance to trust Beijing has left the countries far apart in their negotiations, a source close to the US government told the South China Morning Post.

The US delegation has repeatedly insisted that any deal on structural reform must be verifiable and monitored. Under a verifiable mechanism, if China failed to deliver on its promises by an agreed period, the US would immediately impose or raise the tariffs on Chinese products.

Beijing, however, has used the softer phrase "implementation mechanism" to describe the framework for monitoring China's actions, and resists the idea of giving the US power in this regard, the sources said. The source added that China refused to accept an overhaul of its economic model as a condition for proving its commitment to reform.

Another source familiar with China's position said it worries that the US would use the verification mechanism to make additional demands on the technology front, which is at the centre of a growing rivalry between the two countries.

If a deal to end the trade talks cannot be reached by the March 1 deadline, the US has said it will increase its punitive tariffs on US$200 billion of products to 25 per cent from the current 10 per cent.

Hopes for a breakthrough in the trade war are increasingly riding on the potential for US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping to meet in face-to-face talks in the coming months.

US-China trade war sees China buy dramatically fewer US goods

Bloomberg, citing unnamed sources, said on Wednesday that Trump was weighing whether to extend the trade war truce's expiration date by 60 days.

However, Larry Kudlow, the director of the White House's National Economic Council, said on Thursday that "no decision" had been made on extending the tariff truce beyond March 1.

"I've talked to the group [in China]," Kudlow told reporters. "They're covering all the ground. They're hard at it. They are going to meet with President Xi, so that's a very good sign. They're just soldiering on. The vibe is good. I can't give you details."

Additional reporting by Owen Churchill

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2019. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from Post Magazine

Post Magazine7 min readPolitics
Free From Chinese Repression, Desperate Dissidents In US Cling To Tradition Of Petitioning To Air Grievances
Chinese Vice-Premier Liu He came to Washington at the end of January for two days of negotiations and a meeting with US President Donald Trump in search of a trade war breakthrough. But Bai Jiemin, a former businessman from China now living under pol
Post Magazine4 min readPolitics
Donald Trump's March Tariffs Could Hit China's GDP By Under 1 Per Cent - But Do Lasting Wider Damage, Experts Warn
Chinese and US negotiators are facing a critical moment in the next two weeks as the two sides try to keep a lid on tensions and reach a deal to end the trade war. Officials from both sides said progress was made in the latest round of talks that wra
Post Magazine3 min readPolitics
New Round Of US-China Trade Talks Begin In Washington With Eye Toward Reaching Framework For Final Deal
China and the United States began a fresh round of high-level talks in Washington on Thursday, amid reports of progress in their bid to nail down a meaningful deal ahead of the deadline for an agreement to end their trade war. Time is running short t