Post Magazine

US negotiators 'don't know' if North Korea intends to remove nuclear weapons, contradicting Donald Trump

US officials negotiating with North Korea to rid the country of nuclear weapons do not know if Pyongyang intends to accept that goal, a senior administration official said on Thursday, contradicting earlier comments made by US President Donald Trump and his administration.

"I don't know if North Korea has made the choice yet to denuclearise but the reason why we're engaged in this is because we think there's a possibility that North Korea can make the choice to fully denuclearise and that's why the president has assigned such a priority to engaging with them," one senior administration official said on a briefing with reporters.

The comments come amid preparations for a second summit between Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, scheduled to take place in Hanoi next week. The first meeting, held in June in Singapore, ended with commitments to work toward normalisation of US-North Korea relations as well as a denuclearisation plan, which has been criticised for a lack of details.

Since then, Trump's North Korea diplomacy has been called into question as military analysts have flagged the existence of hidden military bases capable of deploying nuclear-tipped missiles.

US, North Korea negotiating statement to follow Trump-Kim summit

"Of course we've had no denuclearisation since Singapore," Bruce Klingner, a former deputy division chief for Korea at the CIA, said in a Heritage Foundation roundtable with journalists on Thursday, around the same time as the White House briefing.

"In fact North Korea continues to nuclearise," Klingner, now a senior research fellow at the Heritage Foundation, said. He cited intelligence leaks and satellite imagery showing the hermit country has expanded and refined its facilities for making mobile missile launchers and materials that can sustain a nuclear chain reaction, among other nuclear armament infrastructures.

North Korea has more than a dozen operating missile bases that its government has not declared, according to reports published in November by the Beyond Parallel programme of the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a Washington-based think tank.

The network is designed to maintain Pyongyang's ability to launch missiles capable of reaching the continental US, even after joint air strikes by South Korean and American forces, according to the reports.

Immediately after the Singapore summit, Trump told reporters that he expected Kim to begin dismantling his nuclear arsenal "very quickly".

'Even if it is paid trillions of dollars, North Korea won't give up nukes'

"During President Trump and Chairman Kim's historic Singapore summit, Chairman Kim committed to work towards the complete denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula," US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said in September in an address to the UN Security Council.

Pompeo also testified at a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing in July that North Korea had "agreed to denuclearise fully".

Trump and Kim aim to reach an agreement on the meaning of denuclearisation when their delegations meet in Hanoi, the senior administration official said.

"Eventually we are going to need a full declaration [of nuclear weapons facilities in North Korea] in order to complete the process of denuclearisation," the official said.

A consensus between Pyongyang and Washington on what denuclearisation means must be part of a detailed and comprehensive roadmap that "clearly delineates everyone's responsibilities", said Klingner, criticising the administration's acceptance during last year's talks of "another vague, poorly crafted agreement".

"The denuclearisation section was weaker than the September 2005 six-party talks statement," the former CIA official said, referring to multilateral discussions that took place between the US, China, North Korea, Japan, South Korea and Russia more than a decade ago.

Kim Jong-un unlikely to travel exclusively by rail to Hanoi: sources

Whatever outcomes are secured next week, he urged Trump and his administration to "stop the hype " don't do your endzone dance too early".

In the unlikely event of a breakthrough agreement, he said, "we also have to remember that implementation has always been the failing point for agreements with North Korea".

Besides faulting the president for overplaying progress, Klingner criticised Trump for glorifying Kim " whom the US president has praised as "smart" and "talented" " and for his administration's cancelling joint military exercises with South Korea.

Halting the military games "is the gift that keeps on giving for North Korea", said Klingner, adding that it "risks degrading the allied deterrence and defence capability the longer it goes on".

There is concern in Seoul and Tokyo that the US could include a commitment to pull the US military out of South Korea as an inducement in its negotiating strategy, Klingner said.

If Korean war ends, will Seoul still require national service?

Asked during the White House briefing whether the US was prepared to withdraw its troops from South Korea in exchange for a formal treaty ending the Korean War, another senior administration official said that such a quid pro quo "isn't really an operative discussion so far".

An armistice agreement ended the Korean War's active battles in 1953. A formal agreement to end the war was never signed.

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2019. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from Post Magazine

Post Magazine1 min read
Hong Kong Cab Driver Dies After Crashing Into Barrier On West Kowloon Corridor
A Hong Kong cab driver died on Wednesday night after crashing into a traffic barrier on the West Kowloon Corridor near Cheung Sha Wan. Two female passengers in the taxi escaped uninjured, according to local media. Police said the force received a rep
Post Magazine4 min readPolitics
China Watchers In US Debate 'Strategic Competitor' Label Donald Trump Has Pinned On Beijing
Prominent China policy analysts clashed on Tuesday in New York over Washington's portrayal of the country as a strategic competitor, a designation that has defined US President Donald Trump's hard-line approach to Beijing since he started a bilateral
Post Magazine2 min readPolitics
Submarine Arms Race Seen Heating Up In Indo-Pacific Amid 'Great Threat' From China
The submarine arms race in the Indo-Pacific is heating up, military analysts said after the US Indo-Pacific commander told a Senate panel that America needed to strengthen its underwater advantage in the region. Admiral Phil Davidson told a Senate Ar