STAT

Opinion: Ignoring evidence begot Medicare’s dangerous hospital readmissions penalty

If health policies should be shown to be safe and effective before implementation, then risky programs like the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program should be terminated.

Federal programs designed to cut costs and improve health by penalizing doctors and hospitals are failing at an alarming rate. Some of them actually harm patients, and many don’t cut costs. One in particular, the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP), may have caused thousands of deaths instead of preventing them, and probably hasn’t saved money during its seven years in operation.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services began reviewing the safety of this program on Jan. 19. It shouldn’t take CMS nearly four months to err on the side of caution and pull the plug on it.

The HRRP was imposed upon Medicare by the Affordable Care Act. Its goal makes sense: reduce the number of patients readmitted to hospitals soon after being discharged. But its approach — penalizing hospitals millions of dollars if their rate of readmissions within 30

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from STAT

STAT9 min read
While Addiction Crisis Raged, Many Surgeons Overprescribed Opioids, Analysis Shows
Amid the addiction crisis, thousands of surgeons continued to hand out far more pills than needed for postoperative pain relief.
STAT2 min read
A New ‘DNA Microscope’ Peers Deep Inside Living Cells
A “DNA microscope” shows locations of DNA (and its cousin, RNA) in a cell and their precise nucleotide sequences.
STAT9 min read
Employers Are Steering Workers Toward A Controversial Stem Cell Therapy
A stem cell clinic has persuaded over 100 employers to include its controversial therapy in their health insurance plans.