The Breadwinner

I really loved this book.
it was a real and heart touching story.

Don’t use the accent. That is what made me use YouTube most of the time.

Loved this audiobook. You’re immersed into the world of Afghanistan during the Taliban rule, and are taken on an adventure like no other. I laughed and cried listening to this. The restrictions on women and girls are so shocking and I had no idea of some of them. Amazing story and our heroin is incredible. Can’t wait to listen to the next two in the trio.

The Breadwinner is a richly-written story of Parvana, a young girl growing up in Taliban-occupied Afghanistan. After her father is imprisoned (apparently just for being an educated man), Parvana must dress up as a boy in order to be able to go out into the market and earn money for her family to survive--girls or women were prohibited by the Taliban from going out alone. This book is very important, not only because of the social themes of injustice and oppression, but also because of the personal struggles of the heroine, who grows in courage and love through the hardships she endures. I would recommend it for ages 8 and up.

Parvana is a young girl living with her family in a bombed apartment building in Afghanistan. Her father is taken away by the Taliban and Parvana is forced to disguise herself as a boy in order to obtain food for her family. It’s a compelling story which allows children who have never experienced war or hunger to see what life in other places can be like.

Afghanistan in the early 90s. The Taliban have taken over, and women are not allowed to go outside without permission from the males in their family. In fact, they are not allowed to show their faces in public anymore, but must wear the cumbrous burqa. People who resist their authority are summarily shot. Anyone can be imprisoned. This is the world of 11-year old Parvana. Her older sister and mother have not left the house since the Taliban took control a few months ago. Her brother is just a toddler and her father has only one leg, having lost the other when the high school where he taught was bombed. In order to make money, the Father , with the help of Parvana, make their way to the market, where he sells his services as a letter writer and reader, as well as selling some of their goods from the old life. Parvana knows to keep her head down and as silent as possible in order to not grab the attention of the numerous soldiers patrolling the market. But when their father is arrested for being educated in England, the family has no way of supporting themselves. Parvana must dress as a boy and go out into the market by herself to support her family.Though I consider myself pretty educated and knew that the status of women is deplorable under fundamentalist groups such as the Taliban, this read as a sort of absurdist dystopia. Did the Taliban not make provisions for all the women they left husbandless, fatherless? A short, but intense read, this is a very, very good introduction to the plight of women in Afghanistan for middle schoolers.In fact, I hope this will be the crux of our third discussion group with our kids. As the need for feminism has been called into question lately, this book is a good reminder that there is still a lot of work to be done.

This book had no real plot that I could see. Who is the lady who keeps throwing tokens down from the window? We never really find out. What happens to her family at the end? We don't really know. What happens to Mrs. Weeza and the secret school? Nooriya? The Taliban? Anyway, the list goes on and on.

I felt as if this children's book was attempting to provide an overview of the harsh Taliban regime and a family's suffering. But that's just it- it's an overview. I wanted a story and a plot I could truly care about and feel for. I got neither. I felt like I was reading the book in a truly superficial way.

My favorite part was the Author's note at the end which mentions how, "In the fall of 2001, the Taliban were driven from most of Afghanistan" but failed to mentioned who did the driving out. Way to conceal a whole messy can of worms from the innocent youth.

 I appreciate one of the purposes of literature is to teach, particularly in children's fiction. In pursuit of that goal, Deborah Ellis makes the common mistake of writing down to children rather than filtered through their lens. Admittedly, I knew very little about Taliban-run Kabul previously, and as introductions to world affairs go, I think The Breadwinner isn't bad for kids: neither overly confusing nor whitewashed, and featuring dilemmas framed relatably (if at very high stakes). However being rather worthy in subject matter does not make compelling writing in itself. In terms of actual plot, The Breadwinner is exceedingly predictable and its characters underdeveloped. It all lends to an overall flatness to the prose that doesn't distract from the message of the piece, but nor does it animate it past mere lesson.

A gripping story of a young girl who must disguise herself as a boy in order to work and bring home money to ensure her family's survival when the Taliban tears her family apart.

Parvana is a young girl living in Afghanistan under Taliban rule. Her father is taken to prison on random day, leaving the family with no income and no way to eat. Parvana changes her appearance to that of a boy so she can work and get food for her mother, sisters and brother. She finds a former classmate in the same situation. Her friend, Shauzia expresses her desire to leave Afghanistan in pursuit of a better life, even if it means leaving her family behind. Parvana's sister, Nooria, goes to Mazar with the family minus Parvana to be married. Mazar is attacked, Parvana's father returns home and Parvana and her father decide they must travel to see if their family is in one of the refugee camps. Shauzia decides to travel with a group of nomads. The book ends with the girls exchanging goodbyes en route to their respective destinations. There are plenty of teaching opportunites from this book. I think that the gender identity issue that Parvana has to confront is a unique teaching opportunity because that is something that American students never have to conceive of doing. Even just the fact that the book is written about Afghanistan is important and opens the door for explaining Middle Eastern culture, which is important now because so much racism exists from 9/11. Having students maybe write a letter to Shauzia expressing approval or disapproval of her decision to leave her family would be a good writing activity. I would encourage the students to make it a persuasive letter, to try and persuade her to stay or to leave her family. Having students do a Venn diagram to compare and contrast their lives to Parvana's would also help give students some perspective to sympathize with Parvana and Shauzia. I really enjoyed this book! It's not a complex or complicated read but the plot is definitely intriguing. I love that I could use this book in the classroom to help students let go of prejudices against Middle Eastern people. I like that it doesn't even involve religion explicitly because I think that is where the issues become to blurred and difficult to explain to adolescents. But helping them learn that the Taliban is just an extremist religious organization, not the voice of an entire nation and not an example of the sentiments of the people from Afghanistan is so important. I just think this book will be so useful in helping students learn empathy.

It’s Battle of the Books Friday. This week’s book is on the 2010 – 2011 Pikes Peak Region Battle of the Books list. The Breadwinner tells the story of Parvana and her family after the Taliban took over Afghanistan. Since that time she has only been outside in the company of her father. Her mother and two sisters have not left the apartment in over a year. Women are prohibited from attending school, shopping or even being outside alone. Eleven-year-old Parvana is allowed to accompany her crippled father to the market where he reads and writes letters in an effort to support the family. She is only allowed to do this because he needs assistance walking. Before the Taliban, Parvanna’s family was successful. Both her parents are well educated. They had a nice home. She and her sister attended school. After the Taliban they had to move frequently as their homes were bombed. Things couldn’t get much worse until the Taliban arrests her father. To save the family from starvation Parvana must to become the "breadwinner." She disguises herself as a boy so she can get a job to support her family. Set in the early years of the Taliban regime, The Breadwinner highlights the harsh life for girls and women in Afghanistan under the Taliban rule. Ellis is an excellent storyteller, able to convey the seriousness of the situation but also keeping the reader entertained with Parvanna’s resourcefulness and courage. This is an excellent novel to use for teaching about perseverance as well as differences in other cultures. One of my former students read this book and was so moved by the plight of girls and women under the Taliban regime that she was inspired to start fundraising to help build schools for women and girls in Afghanistan and Pakistan.Recommended for Grades 3 and up.Mrs. Archer’s rating: 5 or 5

I love this book. A young girl has to go through so much in Ahfganistan. The title, "The Breadwinner" meaning the person who makes the money and brings it home, is totally appropriate for this book because this young girl has to do many things to provide for her and her family.

Why is the book called ''The breadwinner'', because breadwinner is the person who provides money or is the source of someone elses survival. It takes place in Afganistan which is a land locked area.This book is about a girl's life under the Taliban's rule. The story started off by showing how life was like in Kabul, Afghanistan under the taliban rule. Where woman and girls are not aloud to go to school or do work. And windows are needed to be painted black because they don't want to see woman inside the house. The men are the ones who was aloud to go to work. If the taliban comes by and see a woman walking alone on the street they can just shoot her or do whatever they like, which is not correct. Woman had no rights at that time. Unluckily the Taliban soldiers took away Parvana's father and he never came back to their house again. She became the leader of the family. Ever since that happened her family had problems, and she(11 year old Parvana) had to disguise herself as a boy and go to the market to get what the family needs, she also works like her dad, translate letters and sell some stationaries as well. Parvana did that for a long time and she even dig up bones from the graveyard to sell them. She found a friend who is in the same situation as her. With luck, somebody bring her dad home, he was very ill though. Then her sister Shauzia decides to marry at age of 14 in Mazar-e Sharif, because she thought that life would be better there and so she can get more education because over there the talibans are not there. But unlucky when they where there (her siblings and mom) (not Paravana and her father), the taliban were there before...Paravana and her friend agreed to meet each other again at the eiffel tower, Paris, France in another 20 years from today...and the story ends...I would like to recommend this book to everybody who wants to know more about people lives...

This is a book about this girl's life under the Taliban's rule. The story started off with how life was in Afghanistan and there were rules about how girls could not go out of their home but only do house work. The males were the only ones who were able to go out of the house to work, and they had rules about executing people who had education before. Unlucky the Taliban soldiers took away her father and he never came back to their house again. Ever since that happened her family had problems, and she had to disguise herself as a boy and go out the market to buy and get what ever the house needs and the story goes on talking about what happened to her dad and how she overcame the problems.

The story of Parvana, a young Afghan girl who must support her family in Kabul. Provides a glimpse of what life is like in Afghanistan for women and girls. Twenty years of war have left this a difficult place to live.

Because the Taliban rulers of Kabul, Afghanistan, impose strict limitations on women's freedom and behavior, eleven-year-old Parvana must disguise herself as a boy so that her family can survive after her father's arrest.

This is a well written, eye-opening book about life in Afghanistan under Taliban rule.Pavana's mother is well educated but is forbidden to work because women have to stay at home. Her father has a degree from an overseas university but is reduced to reading and writing letters in a corner of the market.When her father is taken by the Taliban there is no male figure to provide for the family and to shop for everyday needs. The only solution is for Pavana to dress as a boy and work in the market.An excellent insight into life under very difficult circumstances. Books such as this should be compulsory reading for young readers.

A great kids book with realistic descriptions about life under Taliban rule. My 11 year old read it for school and loved it.

Deborah Ellis does a magnificent job portraying the lives of women being ruled by the Taliban in this book. I am ashamed to admit that I don’t know a lot about the culture of Afghan or the severe struggles these people endured to survive under Taliban rule. The restrictions on females described in this book prompted me to further research. It is amazing women, and children, could survive this heinous treatment. This book served a reminder of the cocoons we can weave ourselves into as we go about our daily lives, giving no thought to the outside world. The interaction of the female characters in this story made a huge impact on me. When Father is with them, the girls are rude to each other, bantering back and forth about everything. Rarely do they have a pleasant exchange. Because of the laws concerning women, even Mother, who in the past was a very active member of society, is stuck in her own little world within her apartment. As the story progresses, the women begin to rely on each other, and also on other females outside the apartment. Finally, the females in the story even begin helping others, seeing needs beyond their own and realizing their own strength and significance. Library Implications: This book is an excellent addition to any library collection. It gives the reader, young and old alike, a perspective of Afghanistan few can even imagine. The reader is able to experience the plight of women being terrorized by the Taliban but also feel a sense of hope as the events of the story unfold. The student reading this book could further their study of Afghan women by focusing on present-day conditions of life for women. Although graphic in nature, the more mature student could focus their research on Taliban control tactics and battle strategies that have made it difficult for Afghans to survive in that war-ravaged land.

This book is interesting in that you get to see what daily life is like in Afghanistan under the Taliban. However, the story itself was rather plain. I guess this may be very intriguing to children since the topic will shock them and the writing is simple. It is not recommended to squeamish kids.

The Bread Winner is about a war in the in the East in Kabul where women aren't allowed to have an education, work nor go outside. So Parvana (the main character) cuts him hair and disguises herself as a boy to go to school, work, and shopping to support the family. But she has to be careful for the Taliban or else she may get killed.

The Breadwinner is a fictional account of a girl living in Kabul in the late 1990s during the rule of the Taliban. Parvana, the narrator - main character, is lively and brave. The title of the book reflects what she does every day; goes to the market in disguise to try and earn enough money to support her family. Her knew identity as a boy gives her freedom to move around the bombed out city, albeit in constant fear of being discovered. Ellis does a fantastic job in moving the plot along, suspense is on every page. There is also a brief glossary in the back to assist with some of the language used in the novel. This book would be a great fit for a class read, or for any young adult who wants to experience a war torn city through the eyes of Parvana.

This book Bread Winner A.K.A Parvana is a great book about a 11 year old girl who lives in Afghanistan and has to dress up like a boy to get money for her family after her father is put in prison for something and meets another girl just like her called Shauzia and they work together to get more money, and they take on more than one job to help feed their family but Shauzia wnts to leave Afgaistan.this book is full of the things Parvana and what her family have done, the members of Pavanas family are Nooria,Parvana,Maryam,Ali,Mother whos real name is only mentioned once and Farther whos real name isnt mentioned. thats my reveiw and I hope you enjoy this book! By AwsomeGuy!!

this book is so cool it is about a girl called Parvana who has to turn into a boy to help her family survive because her father has been take. The taliban can not find out will they manage to keep it a secret????

This book was published only a year or two before the September 11 attacks. The fact that Ellis had to define terms like "Taliban" seems kind of amusing now. This is a good illustration, I think, of what it would be like to be a child in Afghanistan under the Taliban.

11-year-old Parvana's father has been taken to prison. Under the Taliban in Afghanistan, women and girls are not allowed to leave the house without a man - with her father gone, Parvana's family will be trapped inside and starve to death. The only solution is for Parvana to dress as a boy, and make money as a scribe at the market place.This story was wonderfully touching. While it firmly aims to show how difficult Taliban rule was, especially for woman, this message does not overwhelm the characters. Parvana is a game and fiesty little girl, and her frustrations and fears are easy to identify with. I found the sotry personal and sympathetic rather than didactic. In one incident Parvana and a friend follow a crowd to stadium hoping to sell sweets to football fans and instead encounter a mass execution - while the gore is not vividly described, the children's shock is bright, sharp, and memorable.I'd give this to readers interested in life in other stories, and especially about the conflict in the Middle East.

Parvana is a girl living in Kabul, Afghanistan under the rule of the Taliban. In a society where grown women are held prisoner to repressive rules of behavior, Parvana is just the right age. She is old enough to run errands for the family and help her crippled father get around town. But then her father gets hauled off by the Taliban soldiers and the burden of supporting the family falls on her young shoulders. She's the only one in her family who can masquerade as a boy, don't you know. (Well, except for baby Ali, I suppose, who really is a boy.) As far as a girl-masquerading-as-a-boy tale goes, The Breadwinner is pretty typical. What makes the book interesting is the picture of Taliban run Afghanistan it offers. 'Tis a culture of oppression, yet one that had failed to totally eliminate hope. I can only pray that hope and justice win out wherever such regimes hold sway.--J.

Wow! This book is a wonderful way to introduce students to what life was like in the late 1990s Afghanistan under Taliban rule.

Couldn't put this down on a flight to London. Very much a page turner, and whilst it is 2 years since I read it I can still remember vividly the sense of place depicted in this moving story.