Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    Unavailable
    On the Precipice: Stalin, the Red Army Leadership and the Road to Stalingrad, 1931-1942
    Unavailable
    On the Precipice: Stalin, the Red Army Leadership and the Road to Stalingrad, 1931-1942
    Unavailable
    On the Precipice: Stalin, the Red Army Leadership and the Road to Stalingrad, 1931-1942
    Ebook898 pages15 hours

    On the Precipice: Stalin, the Red Army Leadership and the Road to Stalingrad, 1931-1942

    By Peter Mezhiritsky

    5/5

    ()

    Currently unavailable

    Currently unavailable

    About this ebook

    Nominated for the 2013 PushkinHouse/Waterstone's Russian Book Prize.

    Like some astronomers, who discover cosmic objects not by direct observation, but by watching the deviations of known heavenly bodies from their calculated trajectories, Peter Mezhiritsky makes his findings in history through thoughtful reading and the comparison of historical sources. This book, a unique blend of prosaic literature and shrewd historic analysis, is dedicated to events in Soviet history in light of Marshal Zhukov's memoirs. Exhaustive knowledge of Soviet life, politics and censorship, including the phraseology in which Communist statesmen were allowed to narrate their biographical events, gave Peter Mezhiritsky sharp tools for the analysis of the Marshal's memoirs.

    The reader will learn about the abundance of awkward events that strangely and fortuitously occurred in good time for Stalin's rise to power, about the hidden connection between the purges, the Munich appeasement and the German occupation of Czechoslovakia, and about the real reason why it took so long to liquidate Paulus' Sixth Army at Stalingrad. The author presents a clear picture of the purges which promoted incompetent and poorly educated commanders (whose most prominent feature was their personal dedication to Stalin) to higher levels of command, leaving the Soviet Union poorly prepared for a war against the Wehrmacht military machine. The author offers alternative explanations for many prewar and wartime events. He was the first in Russia to acknowledge a German component to Zhukov's military education.

    The second part of the book is dedicated to the course of the Great Patriotic War, much of which is still little known to the vast majority of Western readers. While not fully justifying Zhukov's actions, the author also reveals the main reason for the bloody strategy chosen by Zhukov and the General Staff in the defensive period of the War. In general, the author shares and argues Marshal Vasilevsky's conviction - if there had been no purges, the war would not have occurred.

    The book became widely known to the Russian-reading public on both sides of the Atlantic, and in the last ten years its quotations have been used as an essential argument in almost all the debates about the WWII. The book is equally intended for scholars and regular readers, who are interested in Twentieth Century history.
    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherHelion and Company
    Release dateSep 13, 2012
    ISBN9781908916754
    Unavailable
    On the Precipice: Stalin, the Red Army Leadership and the Road to Stalingrad, 1931-1942

    Related to On the Precipice

    Related ebooks

    Modern History For You

    View More
    View More

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • Article

      The Nazi Invasion Of Poland

      Aug 8, 2019

      The Nazi Invasion Of Poland
      1 min read

    • Article

      Warsaw Rises

      May 17, 2018

      Home Army soldiers, using a pistol and a Błyskawica sub-machine gun, fight the German forces on the streets of Warsaw Four and a half hours of film recorded during the Warsaw Uprising has survived, giving a unique insight into the lives of soldiers

      13 min read

    • Article

      The Propeller Age

      Jun 9, 2022

      The Propeller Age
      3 min read

    • Article

      Full Medal Jacket

      Sep 3, 2019

      Full Medal Jacket
      8 min read

    • Article

      A Nation’s Alibi

      Feb 25, 2020

      A Nation’s Alibi
      8 min read

    • Article

      Indonesian Insurgency

      Dec 22, 2020

      Indonesian Insurgency
      1 min read

    • Article

      The Volkssturm

      Dec 4, 2020

      The Volkssturm
      5 min read

    • Article

      Confederation Of The Rhine

      Feb 16, 2023

      Confederation Of The Rhine
      3 min read

    • Article

      Death In The Mountains

      Feb 24, 2020

      Death In The Mountains
      4 min read

    • Article

      Golan Heights

      Apr 18, 2019

      At 14:05 on 6 October 1973, the Syrian Army unleashed a massive assault on the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights. The attack was part of a two pronged assault on Israel, with the Egyptian Army having attacked across the Suez Canal only 15 minutes before

      10 min read

    • Article

      '1983' Chronicles A Cold War-era Narrow Escape From Nuclear War

      May 2, 2018

      The incident was sparked by a routine NATO military exercise and occurred when mistrust and suspicion between superpowers America and the USSR was sky-high.

      3 min read

    • Article

      Battle Of Warsaw

      May 13, 2021

      Battle Of Warsaw
      3 min read

    • Article

      Fascism On The Rise

      Feb 20, 2020

      Popular history writing has not kept pace with the continuing public interest in Nazi Germany. Readers willing to face the long haul have a couple of options. They can still pick up William Shirer’s Rise and Fall of the Third Reich (1960). Its heroic

      2 min read

    • Article

      Justice Denied?

      Feb 4, 2020

      Justice Denied?
      15 min read

    • Article

      Rise Of The Cossacks

      May 14, 2020

      Rise Of The Cossacks
      9 min read

    • Article

      Get Hooked

      Jul 7, 2021

      Richard J Evans’s three-volume history – The Coming of the Third Reich(2004),The Third Reich in Power (2005) and The Third Reich at War (2008) – offers a definitive account of the rise and fall of Nazi Germany. The much-acclaimed series explores Hitl

      1 min read

    • Article

      Strike At Africa

      Jul 6, 2023

      Strike At Africa
      3 min read

    Reviews for On the Precipice

    5/5

    1 rating1 review

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

    • 5/5
      As Stuart Britton, the translator, explains, Peter Mezhiritsky doesn’t so much tell a story as engage in a dialog with the reader. In general this is something that’s rather more common in Russian historical literature (mainly when written by hobbyists and journalists) but it comes with strengths and weaknesses. Many assertions are offered, poetic licenses taken, and guesstimates proposed with the end result being the author is showing the numerous blank spots that are evident even in today’s literature that deals with both the history of the Soviet Union and the Eastern Front. In the end, this style works well enough with both the pre-war Soviet period and the Second World War because some revelations will remain a mystery to us while others are gathering dust in still inaccessible archives. Thus when Mezhiritsky, for instance, questions the level of Zhukov’s education and where his genius originated – was it in short Soviet courses during the 1920s or when he studied in Germany thanks to the Treaty of Rapallo? – it gives the reader something to think about and chew over. Unfortunately, Zhukov either never left an account of his time in Germany or it is buried among his papers in Russian archives, but to this day we don’t know what impact that time had on him and how much of an influence it had over future studies and his time in the field throughout the Second World War. An additional strength of this text is encompassed in some of the more interesting asides and accounts dealing with the author’s personal recollections about the war. He witnessed June 22 as a seven year old in Kiev and experienced the fear and chaos of evacuations firsthand, as well as the condition the country found itself in as Germany’s armed forces enjoyed continued success in the first months of the invasion. The majority of the text follows Zhukov’s career with quite a few detours into Soviet history. Stalin features regularly but one needs to keep in mind that the book is not wholly about Stalin and his actions, but rather his impact on Zhukov and the Soviet Union as a whole. In many ways this text resembles dissident polemics of the Cold War period, which also means that dissident ideas come to the forefront. For instance, Mezhiritsky holds Stalin’s genius for planning and cunning in high regard, but there are today many questions that have been raised and answered about Stalin’s role in the purges and the direction Soviet foreign policy assumed in the 1930s. While I don’t fully agree with all Mezhiritsky’s ideas, I will say they still provoke questions that need to be asked and for which we are still missing concrete answers. And in the end Mezhiritsky himself understands that much of what he writes is in the form of ‘suppositions’ that are in desperate need of ‘supplementary research’. This also applies to the author’s thoughts on Operation Barbarossa, including its planning and execution. These days I am in agreement with David Stahel’s work, ‘Operation Barbarossa and Germany’s defeat in the East’ (which Mezhiritsky is aware of and addresses), that shows through meticulous research Germany’s plans for subduing the Soviet Union were flawed from the beginning and doomed to failure. Mezhiritsky, however, has highlighted some interesting ideas but I would argue that he is missing the forest for a few select trees. Anecdotal evidence is interesting to come by, and he has plenty to offer having lived through the war, but the overall situation is much harder to grasp within the framework that he’s created.An added contribution of Mezhiritsky’s is the introduction of a plethora of characters, personalities, and ideologues that few in the west are familiar with. His concentration remains on the Red Army so many of those introduced participated in the creation of the Red Army or became famous/infamous among Red Army circles. The culmination point, in many instances, is the purge of the Red Army in 1937, but there were numerous deaths that occurred before that year. For some there are accepted explanations (Frunze, Triandafillov, etc.) but for many others, strange circumstances surround their demise and to this day a conclusive answer still eludes historians (what happened to General Kotovsky is one example). Additionally, there are references to events and battles that continue to be missing from the mainstream narrative of the war. Although I have studied the Eastern Front for over a decade, Mezhiritsky’s mention of an attack by a reinforced 20th army around the summer of 1942, and an ensuing tank engagement that featured some 3,000 tanks is an event I can’t recall coming across previously. And it is certainly an operation that is in need of greater study and analysis. Finally, some of the most interesting commentary is offered around the battle for Stalingrad. Once more, a meticulous reading of both Zhukov’s and Vasilevsky’s memoirs raises more questions than we have answers for, but also shows how shrewd one has to be to ‘read between the lines’ of Soviet era publications. There are, unfortunately, minor grammatical problems throughout the text, but many can be overlooked as the translator tried to retain the original ‘richness’ that Mezhiritsky wrote into his text. Another problem is encountered when chapter sixteen ends in the middle of a sentence. Perhaps a word is missing, as the sentence is clear enough in where it’s going, but there is no period at the end. Additionally, somewhere along the line a corrupted image/picture of General G. I. Kotovsky somehow made it into the book. Aside from the grammatical problems, there are some incorrect facts presented, as when the author claims the Luftwaffe lost only 17 aircraft on 22 June (pg. 200), when in fact total losses for the day were 78 with another 89 damaged. This doesn’t change that the Soviet Air Force lost a great deal more aircraft, but 17 is not 78. Another mistake is the mention of a Polish cavalry charge against German tanks as a well-known fact. While it might be well-known it certainly isn't a fact (315). In the end Mezhiritsky accomplishes what he’s set out to do. He provokes, prods, aggravates, upsets, angers, and incites the reader to want to know more about the Soviet Union, the Eastern Front, leading men like Yakir, Gamarnik, Bliukher, and Tukhachevsky, and the multitude of men and women who gave their lives either as a sacrifice to the system that Stalin attempted to create and perfect, or the German war machine that almost achieved its destruction.