Professional Documents
Culture Documents
$ %&
!" #
?"! ?
LK#
K
'& ( K
+ K/
C{
W012
8K9: 7;7 K8
L{<&1
/2&?> LW
W012
'
() *
+ ,
-.
/
01 2
+
: 56
-4
KK
)*+,-./0+'1E#$ %
&'F !
2'%3+3%4!+3+456%4
75%4+,3%8 9:;<=+?4
8%8 C@+A;2BCDE+FG%4'
H+4+I
'5R? %44POQ*+ A12'J+;%K4LM+AN+B?O=
%ED'V
W%4P
C+U' J ET)
M%P!S+K=
K%K4LM+AN%
M+4+E
%41=%+X C%4+YHZR?2CR
+PAM:J+;
%4^ _[\'+ !]+4+I@+PY6%4'
H%8 9+
TE#$ %
&'FcdR?Vb !F$%4
QC+1'`a
R1'#$ %
&MeKQ?1Mf agP%4d+F
RCA
$+?!+=+' g4/hV4U/,%8P
JF`'
Ha@dGT'HZ+i0jd=A/J+A
+4 FmJF0n%
$e5+?l+ !cA8k#$ %
&'
+9UT,
=JFT4PO2'J+;+?'aH:YFoE
H
K@dG%
'+%4'
H+
&M
o6/nGpV?JFq^Q*+A!2'J+;
#$ %
&MeKQ?1M2%
b
%*+$%
&M+?4:=
B=tu @s%
&MV+F$r+ P8,=)'+:P$q^
!g
+12'JF+18F$%$f a %/%4+K +
K@ IRC2'+KOA,'
KKz4 A+w`KA18+'x+,w4yJF)
'v
/3/
8&6
:
-
++nJF+;%+HGA%? %
b
5%4PlTLA,=
TjPAJ 8JF2}06{2'%L8%4K
|+?%
b
5
K%4K
~ZR?B
J+;^n0nx+,
r+a++H
++HJ =JF:F2'2'F+'Ae+K=:F2'
,%1LA'%
8 O%',MZRCVPA;x+,
r+/ a3;F
wA$
%8{:3%7~~,KZRC%7|
%
b
5++n+?1K=o%8{'`%E1'++,32'Zjd
K%/O
HI@J&:<K ;'FGED&"?!F?
9?B@A9L
O PQ'ARS>THLO PLU2KO!K2KLMN
NXYJZL/;![7K/A\']XVWAHK/SK
W`!JF`GaA0bcJd8eK&T^?P"N_K2YJZK
hIi&'YKEIslam at the CrossroadsFf'YfgGRS#
K`Aj'kl72L&mEThe Road to MeccaFF
:3'
HT,AW%4=%U/:E
5w+A;G
+?L:4Vd47$w*DF:;\+1PBXT
1C28 =
4%+2*p\TY+?44r+L+?LB4-P
<
KEF%'nz8OEF
Hx+P'2'w?nV
7 =+'B4C+K'2'w=+'JF0n
+r C 'r+' ?K'0nV4@d6%*+ \ZRCJF1$Fw4$
H2r+i+!28k)
M#
JFTL=KK
H2
HJ+;,KK
HBC'F+; 4JFGB?$+K|H2
KEF@%4'+
%4+,%86^n:*5
):m+' C
KEF%'nz8OEF
Kz+`MEF
Kz+`MEF
Kz+`MEF
>
V,,,KK
r 47Fr+4+Ar$+=V!+;,:+n
4r+4+=+$:EM4/ T+A0,q^JF
6'
w!F75
Fj$'p6'
z,,%8U!
+2'%1
%*+'2':$F`
+O!
,z,j$'p
@
8
:475T,1: B
w4
7
,KK%4K
~nfD8B8 ,Q?1F%4+AJ,G+Kw4
\+2'JF0n4,\+,! UKJFJ
MJKM+/
jKA2 K$ =+?A02 +,=$:$F! +;BC
%4+;
%5 ,V!+;KK~+?A0SPM
`+'RCeKe+LT$2'%4'+
%$Gwa
,JF0n
CR+%
/Mq
=#7n)|&M
%4'
H+L;T/\Rd,1V=+'$%
K%PM%$~ ,+,A0r
Q?1'z4,G287+M
)M+K|n2'3;F
dY+'Jn
uFJF4K8J+;w=^Q?1MG%1LAM+4!+'H
H
RCz4POA%+!%+X+1CV!+;KKj$'p6'|w!F
J+;+'r+,/0w,4,2}+'V$Gw,4,2'F+'Q?1M
+4
A2Y)
MJF T
|G+; ?8
B?
o+4+3M2JAP8B?
/eR+'KK28
%4
75
D=0+4
Aq
=V'+'VL'r+!$ %:P$B?4P!+C+8n
T%4'+
%+
2'w
+'nS+A
0FJnB9%/+A'
%+
q
=B4+=n+AT++!G2+1!F+
;
,B
w4
7XG Y+28R\0&C2'3;F
V!+;qRJ4!+rj3;FuW+b4G Y+
w4+4/FV1;eRk++1= '2'j3:$FB?= '
,KKKY C+'j| C+M%'+%8{eF@+4dPA8J+;w
;
%8*+,%8+
F+A7+M+1AJF+=),4V/F
w
yJ+}nn+Aw!FZF)$+A+YF2'rY =
TO8wK!V$ Gw=^,A:F2'e+M,A| \8
)Jp Az4,%4K4;n+!Yj
q^JF+?P4!+4
wEA!%,,X%+;2'+!R,14
q^JF%4!P%4/+1=++4A/
%'eV
dYT=+4/2'hKq
=G%
$+?4n
%
/'p+i$:P$2'|v\TYC^:d 8k+;
H
,)P8%+,28T
,+AC0eKdA
0
KEF%,4,2 XnT'+AC
89`dFI2q/ &89MXRJjnBX
?9?oi7Ap
O 2W A` ;Sr &'s K#
I O !t u
K/e
K
Kz+`MEF
3
TK4L'JF0n@+/eF rV+!FVJnX+
:
;
%1
o*+'qR;:U=JF2}J+;+?4
rO|: 8F%
[G+?
F%
+AK%4Od=`1JFF+?!F0 6|F
K:`$' F
w42
FeRELLFGjY4*@+O|G
+PZRC:3'`1R?8J !+$7n%Z48=
%8%4'+/jLK%8J+a%4!K%4!+
JnF
w!+}n2jPAZ*+Y%
+%4!+'n:2'&=>,A
cK=J8?AlVwK!yJFJ%8/%14!l:
V=+FeRR?@+O~+YFE6|F,A'F%+1$w4
KEk+GrA'JE8gA+?'%4'Uw4
6 A+P%OP='+PZRCJ+!HF,8JFg
+12'
c%
MF
@+EJnA ,84/S a MGCp54Y
%
FM2q^
+?P
+/w*FG$^nT9n
j ZRC%
+2'+?1}%4'
nj%J !+,VL|^n
<
MXNJ1?7J
HK@ JWV?JSHKY
7XYL!HL
2 |L #
@J8 e? N` 7[& 7JK' k}
KO!'~Ok2PKL&'FGPRS:n\K
'+A%O|2'B
A+L%$GV! 8 ,8
z1A%O~ZRCgPFJ 5J
M+?E?A18J+;o8
B?1'r4
$0n)41 )4AYD`42444BU'
H
K@ ?42'j3;
hp+%=@+L/w+A;GJ u+A
,8
0@:3')X+A')+u=kB'5JFzAWEF
B?X+=)+K@B
/2'J |&Mw
?+'B?18:3'r+18
B?U!B?18B'52'j3;+1A% ?
G@+P
52'J+;
=JFA/%*+$V4,+d`4V'+$V
oB?Ad
K@k+f'2@J+O
5
HFG@|FV!+;AWEFG+$
B9AB9J+;KK% Pl+$c5B'F|F2'rj3;$F
+B?*+Pl:P!BC ?BC{+%
dMB'5 B?X+=
K@6|5B'5
-$+!U1#$ A8
++ A;0%'\'+!+83;F2'
HAWEFG
J+/H
rm[ K1
r+P8R?=+?UF2'B
K@'+A
=
%
+4
1/F+;+4!+P
F%
+4
@2/FAWEFG
z/B?14! $B?*+1;B9' FB9=; ,'+8
:CF
K@B?1'+L$n+a+,M
r+8+'+4!+P
F JF@S+OA
AWEFG+$
F:%45q+M[F
+C
yJFJ$%LGr+4+,
JF +/F%4!1
@28RB?[+1|FG
K@J+!H+K72F CeR8'+A+C
8
Gr+ ,
O'J+;8'+AJF ,2}AWG
K@:4jRC
+!F$@+L/+Cp
Gibb and Kromer, F
AM%
MW@+A;G
+4!+P
FG%4'
H+' B/VAWE251969
>
-8'+A%8+`AA=)44MJ+2'jC+IV!+;
T'
HJ !+,LA,':T
+4+4A|0%E4A!28keR
%7+~B?;+X%7+~B?14! ,J J 44MJ+
B?*+
{J UKA! +;B?K!FB?14%4L,J =+14/
K@B?*+1;)418
M. N. Roy, the Historical F
T+AW@+A;G
o%4+A0uU
%4+A%4K
~AWERole of Islam
0%;Mj)
?U8$eR'+A`+OwAPl+?4 !
2
H++?O!Jr+84
,=+!AogAf`'zKA8
K@'+Az
+C/0nwn0
%4$|FAW7372EIslam at the Crossroads F@+A;G
TC`ANK
%P1+T,
~
+C =Gethics
H
H%4d+LG+?A
43'2'r0+;3;F`F/
P)+M| z8OA%4!+!H%4CdF
z52'FU1=JF2D+D=0%4d+L2
@/F%4,PO$u8k
HT' ,T$+,
z4L
\
J+'z8H?R1'T58+A2+,PO
K@%4+A0%4CT,PO+
2'
H2 PA;2'+?4
zKA8+8o%U/MZRC
T
+
FJ ''+AJFnj =o288+)4d28KM
2'+bMJv,2'+8 2'V?
A
H%4Pl2'
%
+,'6^5
B
KdM K+'=o8+/5
G'+ARCF?U8JFT4PO2'J+;J+/H+\+
H
`'T+yH8+A
,%
dM'` @T!+!H:'+A
wP 8+`AA=28G)
%K+M+4
$5V4,^n#+M
+?*+L,+?14! $`a :,A=+4
$5ZRCV!+T=RB
28G%'XA=0o' 5G+T*+1IJ !+,2'V413A
K%4
$5
%4P
5%' %4
$5)+'!0q^%E4A!V!+;
)1l M)+'!T
:4PJFr+ 4
VPF+%;+
4'+A C+E!+r+'4
B?=$%+,3TK
AM
K+?Oa0dLgA
L8eU2K9@ JL/|72?NmJdL8eL
#
xI/|S9LJS<mK'XO!tJGJd!`X
9
N! 2zM_iX &:U2^2W!8 P`NXTK
&}8Pv Sv NXYA8eM!
7XTsv'9mLF&:K
v !7]/e;7KR_d9K'ebL/e;NkdI;&9&}u'F
VKEE
F{/eNA9;?S/F'e98I"27JMXK
R S
!'7M "H}>1 cj/ |78 S ;
RS1
HK1
9RS!HK
!'SRS
c7HK
cS
KEF{'AL#1lK#1lL;NJ!HI!9
2'@d4KA8JFn)4d28K= $
GEA.ToynlieeFW $q^2'+NRCG
H[
e1D44A!JFE205Civilization on TrialF@+A;
7+Mk+G
%*p+H/F C)
)
Ecrying needF%
'%+/ =8LAk+GF
KE%4'
H%
4LKZRC 1 n
%KGEA Study of HistoryF8+A
%
w+A;G
TC:%8U!6 V45)%4'
H| 5JnF238
KET
`$
HFW379%K7EWhether IslamFw+A;GEGibbF ,8
80KKKT!+!Hu?
%
4
%'|1}JF
r+$D80
RC4/ =Gf+E12'w
E
:3'wJ+;
H+;|v`A
G++G%8 P52'S 1AMjP
KEf+E1:GKT+A0D;
JnFW391%K7@+L/w+A;GEJ u+A
F ,8
B?U1r+,%,
O+fJ KA8E)
F@
KT!+P5w7mFZEF
3
G
r0r0 $+FG2
FeR+FP'JF%4
+4
q
A)
?0w!Fr+ '+=r+|
ET'
HF S+Pl
K@dG 3#1Fn+C 6Fo%4+A0+,PO
:'+JnEEncyclopediaBritannica v,12 p669FG\+
+?1'o%4+A0|5+G%44'+183;5eC I
\+LF:;EQUALISATIONISM+ C%4!+!
H
T+A0D;MFJ
2U1-dB
M`AN
K`ANG+M$
J ;+ A'\+LF
0bK#
L'~?{GJ &89LFu'kl'9;L
B
92 JdrX !&'X1? &<m 'Y KN/
;Pm89bIK?7#
;KM2?
?Sp ' zK/ iY V? 7V? 7R SX ;&
#7KGAt^N
K7"l?J7&K?qK
K
K?8dN?SdIGAH2K1
%4+$G7+M+LQ?1Q?1MRCJ+,8
w AE4A!2'J+;eRKK ,%4' ,%
&
@2'%
%1
28 |GJ+A4+J+/
r O=%
53;FV'A
@ZRC:;G6|5jd
Krj'=+?d
F
,K%
4
\TY:; %4' ,%
M`aJnFWEof Religion
Juh0+0nZ =2}0k+Jn\TY:;
jPA4+ C+jPA C@` $ C+jPA C
KE%14'%8 % N)'V$G`+! C+
Hopes for Changing the Fw+A;G:
! =,8
:
: @
?
2% 8{ J 8JF2}%,+,K\$2'
WT=G
A=
H
KFDEA80:;+4
:'+;Q?1'
H) " (
[ K)r+8 Lr+ m=J+!H6 8
H(C)
)r+ ,= f++/I++%+EA
0Gr+ !p=
Kw4k+J+!H
% $1}JFJw!+'nGD80Ta+MGF
H
(D)
KT!+!He+LGM,A
r+8 $rD+/T+yH OA
Z+AuOA
wA'+,'A0%4O
w=
H( E)
e1D44A
w*+dnJ+!H):'+A
+$'+A
G!F/z
OMwaT 4
$HTK*+OgA
z4,A%4+yn:' ,8RC:
HZjdB
M%$
K2'5%8
H+_n
H%UF2'BCTa+MGJ
M4(
)
#
A%+/J 48J
M)
M%UF2' C
gP+_nw4$
Hx+PMB?,4PO=gP4+O0
KB4,x+PZRCz4PO=2B?4
2BCDEw*+,!
H\+KBC,)
M#
gP
(0)
KB?4+=%+2'J 5J
Mw,Pl+;w,4PO=
N 6I
LM K!&
;
: Y01 Y
q#
`SiY&K
G "!;K'7/FJ
K`I/FAS1i&'TK
q#
/e'|dK
O s{/e'|dK
: C
W
T+YFTK1/FT4YF
V!F:CWB
'eFV
X+/O70ZRCT!+'J5B!Fr qP4E4
K+?4!+'
%0G%a
B!FqP4yJF`4OA82
TK
V!F:CwA
2
TK
=^+'WZq8A/
2'j3;GX ?K'w4fO70RCJFgP
+GfO70RC:A8JF2}r
L'J 8J+4/5
FZ+i0GJ K
A[+!FT8JFK+?=0+F\+0
[+!F#7 8JF+;J 4K
B?!jKAGJ L$+1A'
KJ 4K
B?!FKGJ L$+1A'FZ+i0GJ K
A
+Y5BC#
@ 1M8TK
e d
1 Jn
2'BC +=
%+7T'
H
OMGJ ,+
KB?A,8lB?E?1'
+
Q?1M
TK
<
B?!F+PA+\A$rCFBC8%+h48
B
'eFJFg+d+4w
H ,Pl28RBC
\+13A
+q^r+4K
wK!B8kJn1R?r+4K
A8B
A'
8Jv,GT?!F'FeFJ L8)OA2'X
K%4d+4%K
`'r+,KA'28k^n4
w4n%+aH+51+B
82'TK
+ ,J+;^n
)+
%48D4+A4'$ +,A0 P,8,=-8
nu+L=%8+P[ ,leF-8' 5F\+4/52'\
+KA/0:3'FK%+
V$G +P
T4
)
M%'+2':$FrJ]KE%4 $)+
KE%819+,GJ 81 8r3'FTK
w!
`'w!Fw4n#4L82T!+31M+B
82' ,MJ+;^n
+?A02}E
r 3'T
P1F%4?,KgCR/Fn@+A!0
--68+;6|5gCR/F2'T?,eF+4A|
B*+Az4
=:3'F+r '+CF+|+CA8o+48D4+A4M
+<A
+8F+?L+8F+85-JF+,A
)
AM2'BCF)
%'+%P1+r4
$rJ]E)+
ZPX@+C P2XW
r 3'FTK
w!T4
E+r P+
KET4CHj P8+24P
=
3>
+N-a%14'\n^+0%48'5
*+%+,34;A%48'5HVO !
+P;2'% +| K@+CH+%8 G
[ J+I+'F+?
H+|2'\~2'+?4KW '
G*+%418%+,3JF+eFS+1$ncd8+
G
JFBDq^w'#l+A=Fw=F@+CHz
%8
+|Z+i+?E%4K
F%4+C F%8 G*+%+,3
T'
Hk+G6|5%418+C+i02'+Cj2+CD4}
V|:4PRCGB
jdB
%$z
A8+4
%8j~+
&M:;J[ S+1$HS+A
%
2'3;F
2'2A=k+? ZRC:;V!+;Jn@+CH %8
:3'
+Pn%F8n2rL+?'+?=1=ZX`*+$;^
K`*+$ ZRC
:4P
+?=0@R;VAP%l+$%F+4?Ww!n:
%
&'gA'8'J 48'5#OA| 8+'GW+3M
+F2E
n'5w?A!+4!D1=G%8 %8j~')
2
F+?A$g8RAS! F$5c=J+A!+dFGE%\T
OJ+;Z8'J5z
FgAMJFT8'5%!D~8p
K%4+Cn+4
3
w/
z
lFB?A8RC2E
2'r?Y %
KO|/w'+?=w4
-P,J%48'5HVh
,MAP
2' e+%1I8,=7+'1
)'%
&'2r+ 7+|2L=T8'5[d!
S+1A$0:'A+CF,82'
cK=%7r+7 !2L=%8j~
%
&M+?'+?=
:4q
0%48'5HJ,4
@RS+1A$0n:@+CHB=+?!+?K41=%8j~')
%8 +
&M3;FTC ;RM%
&MJF./8+?=0
K%48'5H:P$2'6^Va=o
%8 GT8'54I %a+88A
JFBDTM+
O|+?!%8 %418%+,3+?=
+46|5%4'
H+C+i02'+Cj2#
A%+,3ZRC
KB
MjdB
M%$z
A8
WT=8+4q^LA8#8Da)A+G288A;
WhKz
)18A3;FJ+; A/F/5%4a+hKGzP8k
)
j
chJFE+CjF%8 Gr=
KE+|T*+13A
`a+9%18M%'FK8%8 cF
%8+$ =V!+;1J,2'+14~G
V!+;+?*+,P%8 $%a+'%8 cF
%48'F
3
33
3
3:
)4'H)4
+4Jnw,8=g+'+P|52'8+
ZRC=0o%R+4 1=
J 1C8+'rj3;
2'2=k2ET/+K;F@+A;Go+4 1A
KET
+4'F?2'+?!
+}[+1J+;:E
ACFSh|
J]wR;+4?WJn~JFJ 4'H%
+u8
K%
OM%? nT,
Awwa~z,/JFJ 8q^
G+??U=o +%4K
V!+;Jn ,!zP
+'\ aG
K+1V44;A+T?+8'5FJ020T'H@+O~
: E&-S Q 24 #(
ZV&[ J & "
3;
3<
3
W%4 75
3=
%4!gA+J+4/52'j3;G%4 75V!$
ZRC:;TO8fO70RCP7#1+A
0A
0
T 75
H+
H%4=-!+1!]qR\+ H
J C+;J A'FJ OA')
M )8w!F1!0
H%-$+1'
du OA2+!+8`4G
K%',Gq^njYF+;EA0%4O
F%4
+
5
-$+18T
# ;J A/ 8kw!]q^n%+aH+
KJv,Gr+!
)$ AM:P$2'Jv,%4$ ' / YjFTa+G
J $ AM+7 ZRCV\+L=2'D,=+
;2
KJv,%4$ B4
An@$F
B?8JT'
Hk+G++I-V?=Ta+G
w!]a+G2Jv,%4$ r0 $FFr+F
F+8pFr+,!Jv,GJ $
{y)
2'/F0
J%4 A/
' 1w4
J+;+r8=
KqRB?'+?=J18
V$ GB
'w!Fw 8FT 8Y 806|F+P
V/[+
5RC
Jv,%4$ 'Gw f8wK!
%P1+#
A'5+8p F!
'G+4
%
T4'w!FY T8JFEBibleF%P1+2}w!FEBibleF
>
5 G`,A
\P1g/@ZRCJF@
A/\+':4
+?4`K=8+K2'J 4
'+A*+'+?4:A,84/
KEIbidp.21F:4'n[,2'A%+:4~%1F
P8
:4IG@J =JFJ+yT8'54*`$ =$
w38/FKwA
+*hGJ =Jw =2w448eR
n+w38/EFG;+B4n+G
%48'5%4
4*
H%'+J& %1I\+LF/FTom Dine
KEIbidp.17F
KE*+
F
$-dB
0W%81'JK+$
W6|5%81MR9? 8BC
U=JFB18gPB!
=+,8
EA=JFEM2B;7JF $J+b1YB1'y0F
B;
=+$28R ,\0&CB
0eFE*+M
F
BC
U=JFEM2B;7B;+82'B; |F
2'@
O'Wj3;2KM+$B?A
'+'G' DA:
K+/:;G/F:/F:;
G+4RCJ]:3+%
'++8J+;^n
4,+%
4P1|5wP =+DA0+4,'X
H
+!U!%?
j
K)
3
+!A,+!{F:3'^nl,jPK ,8+%4
2?!B
w4
71J5BCA,:43A+1p y
:A,!JF+1p y+1')
=+,Mj+1+KlF+!\+!
A$^n%
3
KB?1')
=+,MjB9+KlFBC\+!
B?=0' B
p y0)+ \0& ?%P1+w!F
2B;+?18+_nFW+=+$)
BC!%1LA
C+WB;+82'B; |F28GB;
=+$28R
KE%1AM
FEJ M+UBCqbB9 A82'BC =JFB|n
JnFJ +/H'` B
w,k+
%P1++'F
28R2B;+?180FE:1
FEJ+/H+'8
O,=BC=JFB;+82'B; k28GB;
=+,8k
w
r+1l' J+;J]KE%1AM
FE)O,gJnB?4n
%4+A0%+Kz/wA8/w+'wK!%8+mz/%
B
Mj13A8\+L,+'FB
'`+B
+':3'
,A80o +%P1+T'
HT*DIJ !+,z4PO=2'
+4
$J ;h8J, lJ
:W$w18G+?}
+'FTa+,A+?,4PO=%7+~B?14! $7n%
Mj
KBC+?! b 18o%7+~B?;+X
K)4!+3A/4
,ARCA
nw=ECPB?4P!j
J PA8RCGJ
J+;
%ZRC28 =GJ+;wA
+*%18%V! =%18
K ?42':*+P$)41 -)
g!+n 8
+)
MJ^&8w!^&8! +;\0&CJF2'B+
qR|+;+,A/0+!+CH28nB?4nw4nJ ? 8
+CRnBA8+!^nF+=w $:3'`a' GJv,
kq^`'w!F0nE*+MFEJ
,80 $B?!q^r+ PDC
@+A= F28R2'2AFK'5%+lB?+,E
828
q^J] ,A==Jnrj3;6^F; YF28R2'B
P$2'
EB?1'%1*+|
`
O=D=0FEJv
FE '5D2'
KE*+
FE)1gJnK7B?1#+F ?4eF
6^5n ,2'6^5BC /JFn#1+B?
'+ 8k
KjG%%4+,\HBCaR+:K+
%8/Z+i'+A=%a+V$ GA/JF+12'
2'%ZRCn%+,328G+?%K+%4
$56 ,
K'+A
wJ]r+Fr+ P8$F%pFr+ 'FFr+ FB
jJ+;^n
T
nq8 T YJFFW+=+$)
+
3'r+ $ ,/
+?O=B
wq4+'T =JF
C+JnGjM
+1FEJ+,
FE+r '+4!G+?P/+7
:
: @
f
8+/FwP =%Jv,! wP =eRQ?1
K28Y\+K
~j
w4ne?=+;%4
`$ uA|
)
JFww8 1Agy+JF
Q? 1)
,KA'
WB?1:*+2'j3;GB?A|
B?*+?,2'r/FJFu!0)
j`'B?
'+=Gw4n+
1+!;^+;,'Q?1'w!F^nQ?1RC2RYB?*+
K8+/52'4Jv,
jdB
M%$GT'
HT!+!HQ? 1R?%E4A!w!n
%4'
H:WGz8OP=RY+'0n :;GB
M
K+'!02'%=+KA'%n+AN)+E!0nTa+MG
%4P
5)+'!0+B?=+YnJ 4dJ |&$
B/V$+4!+P
FG+?14+4%K
A+4
$5)+4
$5
8+AG%$ '%O,!8K%EAq
=A
)
KT!+!H
;
%;+%4P
5BCO
J,GJ
J+;^n
2'Z+1K7eR6 AM+%' %
j%4
$5'`J
'+A8
JF%4!,8 1AGJ+!H2U8JF8eR+'+A
'+A%4P
5nU12DE=u
%' %
%4
$5
K%4+yn+ '
`AGT+yH+'!0JFVP3=%4'
H%4+A%EA
%8+Cp0Y5++,3A'
o%+1%K7 +0nz,A80T+yH+'!0JFT+A0
E +A:*+P$r+ YB;+1
FW?u+A?FJv,+?f7
K+'!0+CgA:?I+EE
F
+'!0JFnw4P1A
T+yH#7 ++'!0+!4$
:8 lV$2'FJnG+,3w 1=`ANw4,K8eR
JFr:A2'J5r+4+|w!]%/+%4!+!n+!+'
@R=JF8
+'!0B,g A I`AE
g
y
K/%+,G% 1AM++,3
G)
B/ ,
%i+4!+P
F+1V'$,
'%44 +%+,3G%4'
H%+,3V!^5
V,A
4AKAB;+X:WV%4!+!H+!+2'J$
K%K$ %++@5[+'+?K8JFq^+4!+P
F
<
%4P
5%+,G+?A+,J+^J]%7+|%4'
H%4
$5%+/G
A}:+C/%4'
H%4
$5`Aj'=
A,80%45
Kw
;jP`AEnL+
wa 8JF`4OA82+45w!]w18,K8)/B
Jn
+r YB4,!JF+1w8T,
~[+
5+4?!8q^|v28
Kw;
P1A!T,
|[+
FJ
!+FG#$ %
&' JFg
+12':
% j%P1%
&
)
&M-./0+'n
:4I2'BC2%45J EG)
2')+
T,
~[+
5#aq^GgPJF,+3T!+3
B?18 A%8+1B?A4=2B?*+v+d !2)bY+1\0&C6
K%4+,3B?A8 C#aw1 !eR'5T,
~
g|'G+,3S 1AJF68%8A:P,8`AG
w4T+yH+'!0z4,%4&'J =%4!+!\n
K)P!+I
%4&MJ =+8'F+FG%4'
H+4
$5%+/G
W%4=@+P
;F%K4LP
+4
$5V!+;%,+
%1
%*+'|o4 +H+4?!:P$
U1J+'52'jP;,%8+`AA=k+G%4'
H
ZRC =%K4LM+AE2=k:P,An%1bO'
=
:>
:
: QV&b
Y
pJp8&7JAe/Fda &?;SO 8NAb
(27&8dMe?7XJ Aw'&L/FGK
!'~
OdN
: CW
%4K4;
`'8+A
`AN
KTd
:
2'+1K$ '
o%8{
:;PA=
c+8J !+$
2'+?1'%4!+'n[G+?
F%
%4Od=`1T!K
eFG%
'%4+eFJF A8/FJ+;+':2;+'FGq^
)! ,
K%4'
H
KT!+P5w7mFZEF
:3
:
::
:;
%418B?A8/J%+ZRCGJ
M 4
4;A+
KV?A!$
F%4!KPRECEDENT%,+ZRCJ Fuh!JFgy
J 80$B?1'FB?A8/Jr Y+FG%
+4
$56
6FTa+G+?J+;eRJ+L:P,AG+?
K%'pFJ ? 8B?!
)-
2'7+?=R%14'%4L,;%4!K%,+nU18k
T$+n%4!K6^
+'J \+A8! +;/%
2'6|F+8+L$n@+E%4L$'5p+i ^+':+F
+r 'Xw!,A8+B?'DnnFr+418r+'DAw!,A8+'B8
K+r 418
%\H%P1+T,!0Z+i0u+MZRCpD,
+P=0+%}IFE%8%5F]\AM+80 G
BJ A14
;T8'54*?GEGuilty by Association
6S+PO!0Jn20 4*?GEl FJ !+$7
ZRCJFAM+80 G)
Mj2')44
)M
F)
'F
+1+'G+Fg+dGV,Pl)! ,
K%4'
n+
&'
:<
:
: CW @?
:=
:g
&
b
Y
L&1?Jv1"'98AMK'YJK1?J/FG
/787JAeK/FJ
: CW
? K'
6 A
%
&'
#$
wLwA
H%4O
2%',G+'Jn ,!
%4 752%+HGZ+!;^JFzP
+'qR;uOA
d
f+L8H+8DKuOA A2+1' ?K'f+L8H+18FGTK8
2'%4+%TC6 ,Az4,AB
MT
JF6!0+1!n ,!
w!Fw' J+!H Y+?14'+L'2'JF%4,
~%4
+
rYJnjrj|Jnw
wP
+u
w!FwA4!Z
B
8
DA
8JFr= 6!0+;r+O=Fr= RC6!0
@+0+;D +;w18+P B
[F%4Od=FM:
%K+;w18+?Z'Fo%4+A0
KF
'F)
w!| nB4
AB
8JFr= 6!0
+'28%,4,/2' C+')B?D4}w,*+,/B?a 8B?18
K4+,A+2'w4
x+l C
q
}w!FJ+!HT8JFGuOA A6!+
Z8+'c+JFq^2'F
F%4*+?1%,4,Z/
KZj
;>
#4;
J ?=
rF
K28 A'
;
w4
\1%4=[+1)wA+Ynw%8+1Q?1MRCJF6!
0+w!F6! A0+/2'j3%8+$ +:4K;
ZRCJnK+LMuOA A:3'r+b4YuOA Az
+?/+K;)
M
gyo%34P~%,
J =%+M
K+?A'+,'
)J 80JF2L!`4E
%/ AK'+1=+4,A
'+!+'Jn
F AM%4Pl2'JFu!+11uOA'F A'JL2'
g4EA=%b4G0n%4Kl+%4
,wA/y0w!FuOAM
KKZ+5
%b4TC+1
`$' G+C+yn+o%b4PV!+;+
%b4J A
+?!F2U!0+1!]Jp An %4O
A0
2
r+aL/ %OA'r+F:2M L
%E '
KZ+Fj4dAA
w8J+;^n0n L`
=E A8
+4,
%7Kw4A!2'#A8JF
J+'H,+1!n
GA0+)M2'J 8JF+1$' GB4
A%4h%?
KfOGJp AK
ZRC:3'r+,+
+!;^+;w!F+!2g4d80w!F
KBU1%4Y%4P12'%4
;F=JF2}0+8+L,
;
S+,8nTC%4
+
5J+O4 %K4WJF2'),8
+1!n
B14`$ 8JFJ+O4 88+_nF+=+$\+LdP
KE*+M
FE\+LdP
W%}%8w'F+J+O4 +!JF+1PJFu!
J+O4 JnB?14D18J+O4 Jn2/FTCo ,8e+P:$F
E+r 1/[+1
$FE\
H
FE+r 14P'rJ+!J+;
KE,P
F
rr0 $2/5%,8O+%
'+M2 ,+%8=
z
'+AqRuOAz
uOAJF+;w!F,A!
w14q14eR]^2/FTCo+`FWJv,TK'+A
KEV
FEB4mTw!;
R'w=+~+, B4,IJF6!
2'+1P;$
+ 1T+yH+ 12:d !0JF
Gg!kQAkw
;+1
k%
+4ZRC
+?'Fw'+1A|J+;+?'%
&'F`'+|G |
KZ+i0FKG
k:$5
F28|%$7,A!+;+1P;R9
K/FcA!
;3
h
(
%K
S a
. 5
6
-4
.
;
;
KTK Q?1
3<
3
K%4 75
:
:
: QT
j JV&
- 0 *
W * i6&
2
:
KTd`AN'`8+A
:
PA'%4'
H24! ,c+8J !+$:;:C
:
K@ I%7|
:=
: E
$
:=
;>
;3
. h
(
;
+ Q
KC+V
=%8 %44
=%
&'
:
k" F
KB?18 'F[+1B4
A)? %*5
)Q8n K
KB?AdB?18)
B4
= K
K)+A
k+\+FG:4CA%+K%8+B8,= K
K24 1
+?! F`4s%*%*+O%+HB8,= K
K
5F+%8+1 K