You are on page 1of 57

3

gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv








4
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv



15Zg el : 9g msLv























-1|-+|<


<||<
AvaywbK RvnwjqvZ Zvi meMvmx cZviYvi Rvj dj
gvbeZvK Avc Rwoq djQ| `ki ivRbxwZ,
A_bxwZ, wkv I wePvieev meB Avj vn weivax|
GgbwK agbxwZZI RgvU euaQ agbZv`i evbvqvU
ixwZbxwZ I AMwYZ wkiK I we`AvZi Rvj| AvR
mZi nvZ-cv euvav| wg_vi iqQ evnxb ^ vaxbZv|
GgZvevq gvbyli euvPvi c_ wK? Avgiv gb Kwi,
mvgb gv wZbwU c_ Lvjv iqQ| 1. cwiwwZi
`vnvB w`q evwZjK AuvKo aiv| 2. nK-Gi Dci `p
_K evwZjcx`i nvgjvq Qei Kiv| 3. evwZjK
mvnmi mv_ gyKvwejv Ki nK-Gi weRq jvfi c_
myMg Kiv|
Dciv wZbwU c_i ga c_gwU Kvb euvPvi c_ bq,
eis IUv giYi c_| wZxqwU mvgwqKfve M nY Kiv
MjI vqxfve MnY Kij Zvi cwiYwZ GUvB ne h,
wZj wZj giZ ne| hvi Kvb fwelZ bB| GLb
Kejgv ZZxq c_UvB Lvjv iqQ| Avi Zv nj
evwZji mv_ Avcvl Ki bq, eis evwZji gy Kvwejv
Ki nK-Gi weRqi c_ myMg Kiv| GLvb welq nj
`ywU| 1. evwZji gyKvwejv Kiv Ges 2. weRqi c_
myMg Kiv| gyKvwejvi nK I evwZj `ywUiB wbR^
c_ I cwZ iqQ| evwZji cwZwU Mwjc_ cvnviv
emvbv wbqg njI nK KLbvB evwZji c_ hvq bv|
Kbbv IUvI evwZji cvZvbv du v` gv| hgb
evwZjcxiv nKcx`i wei wg_v iUbv I bvbvwea
bvsivwgi Avkq wbjI nKc xiv Zv cvi bv|
nKcxK nK c_ _K evwZji gyKvwejv KiZ ne
I Avjvn&i mvnvh Kvgbv KiZ ne| Avjvn PvBj
mvnvh Kieb I `ywbqvex weRq `vb Kieb| Avi
civwRZ nj mUv AvMvgx w`bi weRqi mvcvb ne|
Ze Dfq Aevq nKcxi Rb AvLivZi weRq
mywbwZ| gvi bZv`i `vex Abyhvqx Kej Kvjgv
ZvM KijB gynvv` (Qvt) mviv Aviei bZZ cq
hZb| Aekl Kej Zv`i g~wZjvK gb wbq
hvi hvi ag ^vaxbfve cvjb Kivi Avcvl c veI
m~Pxc
-1|-+|<
<+
cwe KziAvb ewYZ 25 Rb bexi Kvwnbx
(~/~ ll) -!|! !!! !-^!l<
cweZv ARb mwK Z wewea gvmvqj
-!|! < !
Avjvn&i mZKevYx
-< !!
keeivZ
-!-!<
gvbevwaKvi I Bmjvg (~ ll)
-! !
`wY Zvjcw xc f w`Q fviZ
-! !!~
f~wgKi UvBg evgvi Ici XvKv \
GLbB mPZb nZ ne
-!< !!
|-|<|
cZviYv nZ mveavb _vKzb!
|-|v<
RvbvZ cekKvix ev`vi mv_ Avjvn& i K_vcK_b
< x|<ix |-
Kvjv UvKvi Dcnvi
||+|
nuvUzi q iva wPwb Kg Lvb
-|x|<
Kvqj cvjb ^vej^x ^ k g AwaK jvf
+|<|
cw_K wRnv`i cqvRb ZIev
mvi Aw Z cfyi YMvb
x||-< ||
wbR euvPzb Ges Avnvj-cwieviK euvPvb!
-!><! l< <<!
|-|x|-< ||
^--|<-
x|x ||-
|<|- |<^|<
t- t<|-
|<


02

03

12

16

19

22


25

27


29

36

37

38

39

40

41


44
45
47
47
48
50






5
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
wZwb ivhx nbwb| dj wZwb evnZ: civwRZ njb I
gv Qo g`xbvq wnRiZ KiZ eva njb| wK gvi
bZv`i weRqi nvwm ekx w`b vqx nqwb| gv AvU
eQii gv_vq gynvv` (Qvt) gvq wdi Avmb weRqxi
ek| cyiv gv I Zvi cvkeZx GjvKv mw`b webvhy
Zuvi KiZjMZ nq Ges mevB Zuvi xb Keyj Ki bq|
G weRq wQj Av`ki weRq| mZi weRq| hv md
Avjvn&i Mvqex g``B me nqwQj| AZGe nK-Gi
Dci `p _KB evwZji gyKvwejv KiZ ne| evwZji
mv_ Avcvl Ki evwZji `Lvbv c_ wMq KLbvB
evwZj nUvbv hvq bv| Avi GUvB ev e h, nK I evwZj
Avcvl Kij evwZj jvfevb nq Ges nK wZM nq|
evwZji hywmg~n eoB gbvni I jvfbxq| ZvB
nKcxiv AbK mgq c`wjZ nq| ew I mvsMVwbK
Rxeb hvi AmsL cgvY Avgv`i mvgb iqQ Ges
ninvgkv NUQ| GgbwK wewfb `ki Bmjvgx bZviv
hviv mviv Rxeb Bmjvgi ivRbwZK weRqi Rb KvR
KiQb, Aekl evwZji c_ ai GMvZ wMq
evwZji nvgjvq civf~Z nqQb| wbqZ njI iv v
cwieZb Kivq kl gyn~Z wZwb c_ njb| Avevi
GgbI wKQz gvbyl GB Dcgnv`kB wQjb, hviv md
Avjvn&i ^v_ jovB KiQb wbR^ Cgvbx ZR
mevaywbK Aavix`i wei| GgbwK euvki Kjv w`q
Kvgvbi Mvjvi gvKvwejv KiQb| Zviv knx` nqQb
wK evwZji m Avcvl Kibwb| dj ZvivB njb
RvwZi ciYv| Zv`i mB iwcwQj c_ eqB RvwZ
ci ^vaxbZvi ^v` cqQ|
gywgbK mvnvh Kiv Avjvn&i `vwqZ (< :/)| ZvB
evwnKfve civwRZ nIqvi A_ GUv bq h, Avjvn Zuvi
`vwqZ cvjb Kibwb (!l<!)| eis Gi A_ GB
h, evwnK GB civRq Zvi fwelZ weRqi mvcvb| hv
Avjvn&i Bjg iqQ| wK ev`vi Bjg bB| gvq
hLb ejvjK gi-wcwUq nvZ-cv eua bM`n
AwMSiv iv` ywjsM m`k gievjyKvi Dci cv_i Pvcv
w`q wbhvZb Kiv nZ, ZLb bZviv fveZ, ejvjiv
kl nq Mj| wK gv weRqi ci hLb ejvj Kvev
Mni Qv` `uvwoq `ivh K Avhvb w`jb, ZLb gvi
bZv`i `q Rj Mj| Zviv ej DVj wK mfvMevb
Avgv`i wcZviv! h GB `k `Lvi AvMB Zviv gviv
MQb| Bqvwmi I Zvi x mygvBqv gvq hLb knx`
njb, mvBwq`yk kvnv`v nvghv hLb Inv` cv i knx`
njb, ZLb Zviv RvbZb bv h, wKQz w`b ciB Zviv
weRqx neb I gv Zv`i KiZjMZ ne| Avj vn wK
Zv`i GB ZvM I Kzievbxi mvgwqK civRqi gvag
cieZxZ vqx weRqi cy ivi `vb KiQb| `ywbqvZ
weRqi Lei bv cjI Rvb vZ wMq mKj weRqx`i
wgjbgjvq mgeZ neb| ZvB gywgb hw` jPzZ bv
nq Ges Zvi Kgm~Px I KgcwZZ ` p _vK, Zvnj
Rxekvq nK ev gZzi ci nK, Zvi Rb weRq
AeavwiZ|
nK-Gi weRq whwb hZUz Kz Ae`vb ivLeb, wZwb ZZUzKz
cwZ`vb cveb| wZwb Avj vnK Lykx Kivi Rb KvR
Kieb, Abi Rb bq| kqZvb bvbv ARy nvZ `wLq
ZvK cwZ c` c` evav w`e Ges Zvi AMMwZK
evnZ Kie| GgZvevq Avjvn& i c_i `vC kqZvbK
wPwZ Kie Ges ZvK c``wjZ Ki wbR KZ e mvab
GwMq hve| 4_ wnRixZ bvR`i bZviv Gm Zv`i
GjvKvq `vIqvZi Rb jvK PvBj| Zviv Zv`i
wbivcvi Iqv`v Kij| Avjvn&i ivm~ j (Qvt) mij wekvm
Zv`i wbKU 70 Rb miv `vCK cvVvjb| wK Zviv
Iqv`v f Ki mevBK nZv Kij| wK wei gvEbvi
GB gg` NUbv wbq KD K_v Zzjj bv| bZvi fy j
aij bv| xb cwiZvM Ki Pj Mj bv| KviY mevB
KvR KiQb Avjvn&i Rb| Avjvn&i BQvq Zviv cixvi
myLxb nqQb I Zvi BQvq knx` nqQb| dj Zviv
nvwmgyL Rxeb w`qQb| bexi wei Zv`i ev Zv`i
cwievii Kvi Kvb AwfhvM wQj bv| eis Avjvn& i c_
mevP ZvM ^xKvi KiZ ci Zviv I Zv`i
cwieviwj wQj gnv Lykx|
A_ I Aavix KcU kwejqi wei GLb c wZivai
GKUvB c_ Lvjv AvQ| Avi Zv nj, Avjvn&i Dci ` p
Cgvb iL evwZji wei _nxb cZq NvlYv Kiv
Ges Cgvb`viMYi ga mxmvXvjv mvsMVwbK HK
cwZv Kiv| Avjvn BQv Kij GKwU Kzb-Gi gvag
evwZjK wbw Ki w`eb| hgb BwZc~e g~ mv I Zuvi
wbi mv_x`i wei evwZji wkLx divEb mmb
Wye BwZnvmi Av vKuyo wbw nqQ| Avjvn Zzwg
nKcx`i kwkvjx Ki- Avgxb! (..)|






6
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv


!|! !!! !-^!l<
(25/24 wKw)
>c. << x|-||-
(v||| ||# <| ||x)
-<| |-< x<|-|
1. cwe KziAvb Zuv`iK . , . . ` . ` n bexi
cZxMY ej m^vab Ki mevP ghv`v c`vb Kiv
nqQ (!!< ::/:, :~)| Ab :. - ,` _ ' Zvgvi
xMY (!!< ::/~, > !< ::/:-~) ejv nqQ|
hvIR A_ Rvov, mgZzj, mgchvqfy e, hgb ejv
nq, ..` - -` , _ gvRvi `ywU Ask| ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi
xMYK Zuvi _ ,` _ ' ejvi gvag Zuv`iK mevP
ghv`vq DbxZ Kiv nqQ| A_P ',. (x) k ejv
nqwb, hv Abvb bex Ges bex bb Ggb mKji
ejv nqQ (!< ::/:)| hgb- nhiZ b~n I j~Z
(Avt)-Gi x`i . ' ,` ` ` , _ . ' ,` , ` , b~ni
x, j~Zi x ejv nqQ| Abw`K divEbi xi
, . ' ,` .` ,. ` , (!< ::/:) Ges Avey jvnvei
xi ` .` ' ,` (!!< :::/) Kiv nqQ| Beivnxgi
xi ` ` ' ,` (!l<! :/~>) Ges .` ' ..` , ev
cwievi ( ::/:) `yaibi k GmQ| Ze
hvKvwiqvi xi ` ' ,` (!l<! :>/) Ges ` . -` , _
(!l! ~:/>) `ywU k GmQ| wK klbexi xMYi
_ ,` _ ' k LvQ Kivi gvag Zuv`i ghv`vK
weklfve mgybZ Kiv nqQ|
2. bexcZxMYi ghv`v cw_exi mKj gwnjvi Dci|
hgb Avjvn ejb, ` ` ` - ' . ` Zvgiv Ab
Kvb gwnjvi gZ bI (!!< ::/:~)| GLvb - ' k
eenvi Kivq bex I bex bb, mKji x I mKj
gwnjvK eySvbv nqQ| bexcZxMYi DP ghv`vq ^qs
Avjvn c` GB Abb mb` wbtm`n Miei Ges
GKB mv_ gymwjg Dvn&i Rb wbtm`n ClYxq welq|
3. Avjvn bexcZxMYK wbjsK NvlYv KiQb Ges
Zv`i MnK mKj cKvii AvwejZv I cswKjZv nZ
gy ejQb (!!< ::/::)|
4. Avjvn bexcZxMYi MnwjK Anxi AeZiY j
, , -, , wnmve NvlYv KiQb (!!< ::/:)|
hv Zuv`i ghv`vK mevi kxl cuQ w`qQ|
5. bexi gZzi ci Zuviv mKji Rb nvivg Ges Zuviv
DZi gv , ` ` - ,` _ ' , ` ,` ,` . ,` ' , wnmve wPiw`bi Rb
eiYxq I c~Rbxq (!!< ::/: ::/:)| mivmwi Avj vn
KZK NvwlZ GB ghv`v cw_exi Kvb gwnjvi fvM
nqwb| AZGe mwZKvii gywgb mB ew whwb ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt)-K wbRi Rxebi PvBZ fvjevmb Ges Zuvi
xMYK gvqi ghv`vq mvb c`kb Kib|
-<| |< | -<|< <x |<
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb, ` , ` ,` , - ` , ` ,` , - ` . ' , ` , ` ,` , -
_. ` . Zvgv`i ga mB-B Dg, h Zvi cwievii
wbKU Dg| Avi Avwg Avgvi cwievii wbKU Dg|
1

GLvb cwievi ejZ x ey Svbv nqQ|
mZxbi msmvi Rvnvbvgi kvwgj ej GKUv K_v
mvaviY Pvjy AvQ| K_vwU Kgekx mZ Ges ev e|
Ze Avjvn&i mw jvf wbew`Zc vY cwievi Zv
wKfve kvw i evnb cwiYZ nq, ivm~j-cwievi wQj Zvi
Abb `v| Ab mKj i bvq cvwievwiK RxebI
Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt) wQjb DZi Rb Dg Av`k|
wKQz `v i gvag msw cwimi Avgiv wbg Zv Zzj
aivi Pv cve|
:. ^|< | x|- <i<|<
Lv`-e-evmvb mn hveZxq AvPvi-AvPiY Avjvn&i
ivm~j (Qvt) Zuvi mKj xi m mgvb eenvi KiZb|
mvaviYZt AvQi QvjvZi ci wZwb cZK xi Ni Ni
wMq Zv`i `bw`b cqvRbxq welq AewnZ nZb|
2

2. wZwb x`i ga Zv`i mwZg mgfve cvjv
wbaviY KiZb|
3

3. Kvb Awfhvb ev mdi hvIqvi mgq jUvwii gvag
x evQvB Ki GKRbK mv_ wbZb|
4


1. l<l, !<, l! !/:~~|
2. <!< !/~:: l !/~:>|
3. l<l, !<! l, l! !/:~:|
< +






7
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
4. xMYi evex I AvZxq-^Rb`i mv_ menvi
KiZb I Zv`i nvw`qv-Zvndv w`Zb|
5

5. xMYi cZKi K c_K wQj| hwjK Avjvn
cvK RyivZ eyq~Z BZvw` bvg AwfwnZ KiQb
(:><! >/ !!< ::/::)|
6. xMYi AwaKvsk eo eo Nii gwnjv njI ivm~j
(Qvt)-Gi wkvY Zuviv mevB nq DVwQjb A Zz
I mnR-mij Rxeb hvcb Af|
7. Abi ^v_K wbRi ^v_i Dci vb `Iqvi Abb
Y Yvw^Zv GB mKj gwnqmx bvixMY| Zuviv m`
cvq jyUvjI mw`K c KiZb bv| `vbkxjZvq
Zviv wQjb D`vin| Dyj gywgbxb nhiZ hqbe webZ
Lyhvqgv (ivt) Zv Dyj gvmvKxb (wgmKxb`i gv)
wnmve AwfwnZ wQjb| Lvqei weRqi ci wecyj
MYxgZ nMZ nq| ZLb ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi cvc Ask
nZ cZK xi Rb eQi 80 AmvK LRyi Ges 20
AmvK he eiv Kiv nq| mB mv_ GKwU Ki `yeZx
Dx c`vb Kiv nq| wK `Lv Mj h, cwev xMY
hZUzKz bv nj bq, ZZUzKz iL evKx me `vb Ki
w`qQb|
6

8. mcZxMYi ga ciii fvjvevmv wQj Mfxi I
wbt^v_| cZKB cZKi cwZ wQjb mnvbyf~wZkxj
I `qv`wP| GiciI hw` KLbv Kvi cwZ Kvi Kvb
ip AvPiY cKvk cZ, Zvnj `Z Zv wgwUq djv
nZ| hgb (K) GKevi ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi GKgv
B`xRvZ x QvwdqvK nhiZ hqbe webZ Rvn&k (ivt)
B`x ej m^vab Kib, hvi ga ZvwQji fve
wQj| GZ Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt) GZB z nb h, hqbe
(ivt) ZIev Ki AbyZ bv nIqv ch Zvi Mn cv
gvovbwb|
7
(L) AviKw`b ivm~j (Qvt) Ni Gm `Lb
h, Qvwdqv Kuv`Qb| KviY wRm Kij wZwb ejb h,
nvdQv (ivt) AvgvK B`xi gq ejQb| GK_v b
ivm~j (Qvt) QvwdqvK mv bv w`q ejjb, eis Zzwg
wbqB bex (BmnvKi) Kbv| wbqB Zvgvi PvPv
(BmgvCj) GKRb bex Ges wbqB Zzwg GKRb bexi
x| Zvnj wKm Zvgvi Dci m Me KiQ? AZtci
wZwb nvdQvK Dk Ki ejjb, AvjvnK fq Ki n
nvdQv!
8


4. !! !!, l! !/:~:~|
5. !! !!, l! !/::|
6. = ! ! : l>|
7. !!, !<!, l! !/> !-!<^< !
!<< !/~:, !!|
8. l<l, !!^, l! !/:::, |
(M) Avqkv (ivt) ejb, jvKiv Avqkvi cvjvi w`b
wVK ivLZ| Hw`b Zviv ivm~j (Qvt)-K Lykx Kivi Rb
nvw`qv cvVvZv| xMY `y`j wef wQjb| Avqkv,
nvdQv. Qvwdqv I mI`v GK `j Ges D mvjvgvn I
evKxMY AviK `j| klv `ji xMYi Aby iva
D mvjvgvn (ivt) ivm~j (Qvt)-K GKw`b ejjb,
Avcwb jvK`i ej w`b, Zviv hb Avcwb hw`b h
xi KvQ _vKb, mw`b mLvb nvw`qv cvVvq|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejjb, n D mvjvgvn! Zzwg AvgvK
Avqkvi evcvi K w`qv bv| D mvjvgv ZIev
Kijb| ci Zviv D welq dvZgvK ivm~j (Qvt)-
Gi KvQ cvVvjb| mLvbI ivm~ j (Qvt) GKB Reve
w`jb Ges ejjb, dvZgv! Avwg hv cm` Kwi, Zzwg
wK Zv cm` Ki bv? Zvnj Zzwg AvqkvK fvjevm|
9

GBme QvULvU welq hLb nv`xQi cvq wjwce nq
AvQ, ZLb Gmei PvBZ eo wKQz NUj wbqB Zv
iKW nq _vKZ| wK m aibi wKQz cvIqv hvq bv
weavq wbwZfve ai bIqv hvq h, bexcZxMYi ga
mve I m`qZv LyeB Mvp wQj Ges Zuv`i cviwiK
mK mevg ghv`vevai Dci cwZwZ wQj|
9. ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi cvwievwiK Rxeb wQj AZ
mvavwmav| wZwb ^Qvq `wi`Zv Aej^ b KiwQjb|
wZwb ejZb, ` ,` , ` _ ,` - ' ` , ` . ` _. ` ' , ` , ` .
` _ ` ,` ` - , ` _ ,` ` _ ` , . n Avjvn! Zzwg AvgvK
wgmKxbx nvj euvwPq ivLv I wgmKxbx nvj g Zz `vb
Ki Ges AvgvK wgmKxb`i mv_ cybiwZ Ki|
10

Ze m `vwi`i KlvNvZ wQj GZ KVvi h, mvaviY
Kvb gwnjvi c Zv mn Kiv wQj ixwZgZ KKi|
ZeyI bexcZxMY Zv nvwmgyL eiY Ki wbqwQjb|
ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Lv`g nhiZ Avbvm (ivt) ejb, .
` , ` ' ` _ ` _. = , , , ' _ ` , _ ,` _` - -
= , . . , ' _ ` , . = . ` , , . Avwg Rvwb bv,
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Avjvn&i mv_ wgwjZ nIqvi AvM ch
KLbv Kvb cvZjv big iwU `LQb wKsev Kvb Av
fybv eKix `LQb|
11
gv Avqkv wQxKv (ivt) ejb,
g`xbvq Avmvi ci wZbw`b GKUvbv iwU KLbv LZ

9. !! !!, l! !/:: !! ' <!-:,
<^< !!' -::|
10. l<l, <!!, !< ^!, l! !/~ !
!/:|
11. <!< !/~: l! !/:|






8
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
cvBwb|
12
Ab eYbvq GmQ, cici `ygvm AwZevwnZ
nq ZZxq gvmi Puv` Dw`Z nZ, A_P bexMn Kvb
(Pzjvq) Avb RjZv bv| (A_vr gvmfi Pzjv RjZv
bv)| fMxcy DiIqv web hyevqi wRm Kijb,
Lvjvv! . ` , ` , ` , Zvnj wK Lq Avcbviv Rxeb
aviY KiZb? wZwb ejb, . ,` . ` ,` ` .. , `ywU
Kvjv e w`q- LRyi Ges cvwb|
13
bexRxebi mekl
ivZI x AvqkvK PivM RvjvZ cwZekxi wbKU
_K Zj wbZ nqwQj|
14
g~jZt GmeB wQj Zuvi hyn&`
ev `ywbqvZvMx Pwii wb`kb gv|
GB KwVb KQZv mvabi gaI cwev xMY KLbvB
gyL Amw fve cKvk KiZb bv| eis me`v gnvb
^vgxi mvnPh nvwmgyL `vZ Rxeb hvcb KiZb|
Ze `yGKwU NUbv Ggb wQj hv ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi BQvi
weivax wQj Ges ZvZ wZwb `ytwLZ nqwQjb| nZ
cvi kixAvZx weavb Pvjy Kivi j Avjvn&i wekl
BQvq Gic NUbv NU _vKZ cvi| hvi ga iqQ
DZi Rb iZc~Y wkYxq welq| hgb 5g
wnRixZ Avnhve hyi ci eby Kzivqhvi weRq Ges
MYxgZi wecyj gvjvgvj cvwi dj gymjgvb`i ga
^vQ` wdi Avm| G cwZ cwev xMY ivm~j
(Qvt)-Gi wbKU Zv`i Lv`-e I Abvb LiPvw`i
cwigvY ewi Ave`b Rvbvb| GZ Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt)
ggvnZ nb Ges Zv`iK ZvjvK MnYi AwaKvi c`vb
Kib| D gg AvqvZ ZvLqxi bvwhj nq (!!<
::/~-~>)|
G AvqvZ bvwhji ci ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) AvqkvK Zvi
wcZvgvZvi m civgk KiZ ejj nhiZ Avqkv
(ivt) ej IVb, GRb wcZv-gvZvi mv_ civgki wK
AvQ? Avwg Zv Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~j I AvLivZK Keyj
Ki wbqwQ|
15
Zuvi GB Reve Avjvn&i ivm~j
(Qvt) LyeB Lykx njb Ges Abvb xMY mKjB
Avqkvi c_ AbymiY Kijb|
Dciv NUbvq cyYeZx xMYi GB ewk Zzj aiv
nqQ h, Zviv myL-`yL mevevq cyYevb ^vgxi
GKwb Abymvix nq _vKb| Gi viv AviKwU welq
cgvwYZ nq h, Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt) gvbyl wnmve

12. <!< !/:: !' <! < (!:) !< !!<^
l!< !!-!! <' -~:|
13. <!< !/:> l<!' <! <! !!<< >< !
l' -:|
14. !!, !<!<!, ! !/~::|
15. l, l! !/:~>|
gvbexq ivM-Awfgvb I `ytL-e`bvi AwaKvix wQjb|
^vgx-xi cgi mK Gmei gvag gvS-ga
SvjvB nq AviI `pZi nq| ivm~j I Zu vi cwev
xMYi gaKvi G aibi NUbv Zvi c K cgvY|
fwelZ Kvb gywgb ^vgx- xi ga Gic NUbv NUj
Zviv hb ivm~j-cZx`i `v Aby miY Kib Ges
msmvi f bv w`q AviI gheyZ Kib, mw`K
c_c`kbi RbB Avjvn& i BQvq D NUbv msNwUZ
nq|
eZt ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) I Zuvi cyYeZx xMYi gaKvi
mK wQj DbZ Av`k PZbvi Dci cwZwZ| `ywbqv
I AvLivZ mevevq Zu viv bexcZx wnmve ewiZ (<
:/ !!< !)| ZvB `y wbqvex z ` ^v_i Rb Zuviv
KLbvB AvLivZi eng ^v_ wewKq w`Z cvib bv|
`ywbqvZ Zuviv wQjb ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi cvwievwiK Rxebi
wek Zg mvx Ges Zv`i gvagB DZ gynvv`x
Bmjvgi cvwievwiK I Abvb weavb mg~n RvbZ ci
ab nqQ| Gw`K w`q weePbv Kij Zuviv Kej
bexcZx wQjb bv, eis Zviv wQjb DZi wkwKv I
bZzj `v| wbtm`n bexi m bexcZxMYi
mK I AvPvi-AvPiY wQj AZxe gayi Ges ^Mxq
PZbvq DxweZ|
<| (v|:)-=< - <
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi `nveqe wQj AZxe my`i, my Vvg I
gagvKwZi| (1) Zuvi Mvqi is wQj D j I Mi-
Mvjvcx (2) c~Y Mq mn gyLgj wQj j^ vU MvjvKvi
(2) myksLj ` ivwRi myL fvMi Dci `ywU `uvZi
gvS wKQzUv duvK wQj (4) ck jjvU, Db Z bvwmKv,
wKwZ ivf I wevwiZ myigv Pz| c_K A_P
cii weRwoZ wPKb hyMj (5) `xN Mxevwewk eo
AvKwZi gv_v, hv wQj NbK KkewZ| hv bv AwaK
KuvKovbv wQj, bv AwaK Lvov wQj| hv eveix wQj| gZz
ch gv_vi gaeZx vbi wKQz Pzj Ges VvUi wbg
`ki I `vwoi wKQz Pzj kZeY aviY KiwQj| `vwoZ
gn`x is eenvi KiZb| wZwb ejZb h, Pzj-`vwoZ
Kvjv is eenviKvix ew RvbvZi myMwI cve bv|
wZwb wbqwgZ wPibx eenvi KiZb Ges gv_vi Pz j
`yw`K fvM Ki w`Zb (ZvZ gvSLvb wmu w_ nq hZ)
(6) Mvd QvU I `vwo wQj `xN I Nb mwbewkZ (7)
`ni Rvo mg~n Ges i Awmg~ n wQj eo AvKvii
(8) Pwei AvwaKnxb mykvfb D`i`k (9) c mvwiZ
ecyU nZ bvwf `k ch wQj ^ jvgi c jw^ Z
iLv (10) n I c`q wQj gvsmj Ges Mvovwj wQj






9
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
cvZjv| c_ Pjvi mgq mvgbi w`K mvgvb SuyK
PjZb| hb Kvb Xvjy vb AeZiY KiQb (11)
nvZi Kwq I Avyjjv wQj wKQzUv eo AvKvii,
Zvjyq wQj ck I gvjvqg (12) `yB wQj
cjw^Z| hvi gvS evg Kuvai AwgyL wQj KeyZii
wWgi AvKwZi QvU gvsmwc- gvni beyAZ|
MveYi mv_ mv`kc~Y D gvnii Dci wQj PgwZj
mgwi bvq meyR iLv (13) k, mg_ I kwkvjx `n
mei AwaKvix GB my`i gvbylwUi `n e eqm
wKQzUv fvwi nq wMqwQj| ZvB wmR`vq ekxY _vKZ
cviZb bv| kl eVK em mvjvg wdivbvi AvM ch
`xNY ai `vAv KiZb| (14) `n wbtmZ ^`we`y
mg~n gyvi bvq cwi` nZ Ges hv wQj wgkK Av^ii
PvBZ myMwgq| GKevi Mxi `ycyi Nyg ivm~j
(Qvt)-Gi `nwbtmZ Ngmg~n evwUZ Rgv KiwQjb
Lvjv D myjvqg (ivt)| ivm~j (Qvt) ZvK wRm
Kijb, Gme wK Kie? Reve wZwb ejb, GMywj
Avgv`i myMwi mv_ wgkvev| Kbbv Gwj AwaK
myMwgq| Ab eYbvq GmQ, wZwb ejb, n Avjvni
ivm~j! Gi eenvii viv Avgiv Avgv`i evPv`i Rb
eiKZ Avkv Kwi| ivm~j (Qvt) ejjb, Zzwg wVKB
KiQ|
16
(15) cdzj Aevq Zuvi gyLgj P`i bvq
PgwKZ nZ| ivMvw^Z nj Zv Wvwjgi bvq iwg eY
aviY KiZ| Ngv Aevq Zv DjZvq Sjgwjq
DVZ|
(K) ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi my`i Pnvivi cksmvq PvPv Avey
Zvje ejwQjb,
,,', _` , ,-,, ' _, ` .
_
MieYi gynvv`| hvi Pnvivi Amxjvq ew cv_bv
Kiv nq _vK| whwb BqvZxgi Avkqj I weaev`i
iK|
17

(L) AveyeKi wQxK (ivt) ejZb,
' _=. _-, ,, ' .,. _ ,_ =
wek, gbvbxZ, KjvYi w`K Avnvb Kib| c~wYgvi
Puv`i Avjvi bvq hv AKvi `~ixf~Z Ki|
18


16. !! !!, l! !/ !! !!'
<!, ~ |
17. <!< !/:-> l!' <!-: <!< !<
l <l*< > !!< !< <!' -:|
18. <!!, !! < !/~: : :/~|
(M) Igi dviK (ivt) ivm~ j (Qvt)-Gi Pnviv `L
hynvqi web Avex myjgvi wbgv KweZv cvV KiZb, hv
wZwb Zvi bZv nvivg web mbvbi cksmvq ejwQjb,
, . . , , ' . ..' , _
hw` Avcwb gvbyl eZxZ Ab wKQz nZb, Zvnj
AvcwbB c~wYgvi ivwK Avjv `vbKvix nZb|
19

Kve web gvjK (ivt) ejb, ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) hLb
Avbw`Z nZb, ZLb Zu vi Pnviv D j nq DVZ| Zuvi
Pnviv hb P`i UzKiv , = ,. , nq hZ| Avgiv
GUv eySZ cviZvg|
20
gvUK_v cksmvKvixi fvlvq
ivm~j (Qvt) wQjb, ` , _ ' ` ` , ` ` , ` . _ = ` ,
, , Zuvi c~e I ci Zuvi bvq my `i KvDK `wLwb|
dvimx Kwei fvlvq,
'-,- -, _-,= --,, -= * -' -,=
'+-- ,- --
BDmydi ic, Cmvi duyK I g~mvi Zvjy
meB AvQ Zvgvi gvS n wcq ivm~j| -(! <!)
<| (v|:)-=< |< <|fi
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) wQjb mKj cKvi gvbweK Y Yvw^ Z
GK AmvaviY ewZ| ez I k mKji gy L mgfve
Zuvi Abycg Pwi gvayh i cksmv ewY Z nqQ| KVvi
cwZc Avey mywdqvb mgvU nivwK qvmi my L AKz
wP Zuvi mZZv, AvgvbZ`vix I mPwiZvi DP cksmv
KiQb| Avjvn cvK wbRB ^xq ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi
cksmvq ejb, :` , _ ` - ` ,. = , wbqB Avcwb
gnvb Pwii AwaKvix ( :/)| ivm~j (Qvt) ejb,
` . ` , ,` . _ ` - . Avwg c wiZ nqwQ me vg
Pwii c~YZv mvabi Rb|
21
ZvB `Lv hvq, beyAZ-
c~e Rxeb mKji wbKU ckswmZ wnmve wZwb wQjb
Avj-Avgxb (wek, AvgvbZ`vi) Ges beyAZ cieZx
Rxeb Pig kZvc~Y cwiekI wZwb wQjb ah I
mnbkxjZv, mvnm I `pwPZv, `qv I mse`bkxjZv,
civcKvi I cigZ mwnzZv, jvkxjZv, KiYv I

19. ! |! !/: ! !!<, ! ! l<
!! /~> :|
20. !! !!, l! !/> !! !!'
<! ~ |
21. !! !, l! !/>:|






10
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
gvkxjZv cfwZ Yvejxi Rxe cZxK| Avjvn ejb,
` . ` , ` ` ,` _ = ,` ' - ` . ,.` -` , ,
= ` , , , , - , , = ` , , wbqB ivm~jyjvn&i ga
Dg Av`k wbwnZ iqQ H ewi Rb h Avjvn I
AvLivZK Kvgbv Ki I ekx ekx AvjvnK iY
Ki (!!< ::/~:)| Zuvi Abycg Pwi gvayh I Abb
ewk mg~n c~Yfve eYbv Kiv Hic Ame, hic
c~YP`i m`h eYbv Kiv Ges Lvwj PvL AvKvki
ZviKvivwR MYbv Kiv Ame| ZeyI `v ^ic wKQz
PvwiwK bgybv I ewk wbg Zzj aiv nj-
(:) <|+<|| wZwb mvaviYZt Pzc _vKZb| webv
cqvRb K_v ejZb bv| hZUzKz ejZb we gvwRZ
I my`ifve ejZb| hv `Z kvZvK AvK KiZ|
Avi GKB jvKiv Rv`y ejZ| Zuvi fvwlZvq gy
nqB Bqvgbi hgv` Avh`x gymjgvb nq hvb|
22
wZwb
wbii nIqv mI wZwb wQjb Avie I Abviei ga
mek fvlvwe`|
23
GgbwK nv`xQ Rvj nevi AbZg
wb`kb nj Zvi kmg~ni DPgvb wewk bv nIqv
(!: ^)| GKviYB Aviex mvwnZ KziAvb I
nv`xQi cfve mevi Dci| eis ev e K_v GB h,
KziAvb I nv`xQi mevP evKixwZ I AvjsKwiK
ewki KviYB Aviex fvlv I mvwnZ mevP ghv`vq
Avmxb nZ ciQ Ges gvbwZi c_ GwMq
PjQ| A_P jvwUb, wne, msZ cfwZ cw_exi cvPxb
fvlv mg~n wejy nq MQ A_ev wejywi c_|
(>) |< -x- | va `gbi GK Ac~e gZv
Zuvi ga wQj| wZwb ejZb, cKZ exi mB, h wbRi
vaK `gb KiZ cvi|
24
Avqkv (ivt) ejb, wZwb
KLbv KvDK wbRi ^v_ wbR nvZ gvibwb| Kvb
gwnjv ev Lv`gK KLbv cnvi Kibwb|
25

() ||-+|-| wZwb g`y nvm KiZb| KLbvB
Anvm KiZb bv| m`v cdzj _vKZb| KLbvB
Mvgov gyLv _vKZb bv| QvULvU iwmKZv KiZb|
(K) GKw`b GK bIgymwjg B`x evK x Avqkvi
wbKU emv `L ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejjb, Avqkv Zvgvi
mv_xK ej h, eiv KLbv RvbvZ hve bv| GK_v
b D gwnjv Kuv`Z i Kijb| ci ivm~jyjvn

22. l, l! !/:|
23. !~!! !: l !<: l : ::|
24. !! !!, l! !/: l*!!<' <! ~
|
25. l, l! !/:|
(Qvt) Gm ejjb, fq bB! Rvb vZevmx bvix-cyil
mevB hyeK eqmx ne|
26
(L) GK mdi wZwb `Lb h,
gwnjv`i wbq RbK D PvjK `Z DU nvwKq hvQ|
ZLb ivm~j (Qvt) ejjb, ` _ , ` , _ . . , , _ ` , , axi
PvjvI| KuvPi cvwji c wZ m`q nI|
27

QvjvZi ga wekl Ki Zvnvy`i QvjvZ wZwb
Avjvn&i fq Kuv`Zb| AfveM ewK `Lj Zvi
A i Ku` DVZv Ges Zvi Afve `~ixKiY e nq
coZb| PvPv nvghv, Kbv hqbe I cy Beivnxgi
gZzZ wZwb wki gZ Ki Ku`wQjb| GKevi
Beby gvmE`i gyL KziAvb ZjvIqvZ b Zu vi PvL
eq Aweij avi Ak c evwnZ nq| GgbwK wbmv 41
AvqvZ cuQj wZwb ZvK _vgZ ejb|
28

() <|< <<|| KwVb wec`i gaI wZwb ` p
wngvw`i bvq ahkxj _vKZb| gvx Rxebi Amnvq
Aevq Ges gv`vbx Rxebi cwZ gy n~Z Rxebi gwKi
gaI ZuvK KLbv fxZ-wenj I Aah nZ `Lv
hvqwb| nhiZ Avjx (ivt) ejb, NbNvi hyi
wefxwlKvgq Aevq Avgiv ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi wcQb wMq
Avkq wbZvg| wZwbB me`v ki wbKUeZx _vKZb|
ki fq hyi gq`vb _K cvwjq hvevi Kvb NUbv
Zuvi Rxeb bB| Afve-AbUb, `ytL-e`bvq,
mevevq wZwb KwVb ah Aej^ b KiZb| GgbwK
wZbw`b bv Lq cU cv_i eua mb`i mv_
AeYbxq K L`K Luvovi KvR Ask wbjI Pnvivq
Zvi cKvk NUZv bv| eis mb`i mv_ AvLivZi
KweZv cvVi ga w`qB Lykx gb wbR nvZ L`K
LuyoQb| k`i kZv hZB ew cZ Zu vi ahkxjZv
ZZB eo hZ| Inv` I nvbvqb hy Zuvi exiZ I
Amg mvnwmKZv wQj AZz jbxq|
nhiZ Avbvm (ivt) ejb, Avwg GKw`b ivm~ j (Qvt)-Gi
mv_ PjwQjvg| Gmgq Zuvi Dci gvUv AuvPji GKwU
bvRivbx Pv`i kvfv cvwQj| nVvr GKRb e`yCb Gm
Zuvi Pv`i ai Ggb nPKv Uvb `q h, ivm~j (Qvt)
e`yCbi eyK wMq cob| GZ Avwg `Ljvg h,
ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Nvoi Dci Pv`ii AuvPji `vM co
Mj| jvKwU ejj, n gynvv`! Avjvni gvj hv Zvgvi
KvQ AvQ, mLvb _K AvgvK `evi wb`k `vI , ,

26. <!, l! !/, l*!!<' <! :~
|
27. <!< !/::> l !/~->|
28. !! !!, l! !/~:>|






11
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
` ` = ` _ ` ,` ` ` -` , | ZLb ivm~j (Qvt)
Zvi w`K ZvKvjb I nvmjb| AZtci ZvK wKQz `vb
Kivi Av`k w`jb|
29

D NUbvq ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi AZzjbxq ah I `vbkxjZvi
cgvY cvIqv hvq| Gic AmsL NUbv Zuvi Rxeb
iqQ|
(c) <| <|<| KD Amy nq coj wZwb Zvi
evoxZ wMq ivMxK cwiPhv KiZb I mv bv w`Zb|
Zvi Rb `vAv KiZb| wK LZ gb Pvq wRm
KiZb| wZKi bv nj Zv `evi eev KiZb|
wbRi B`x KvRi QjwU Amy nq coj wZwb Zvi
evoxZ wMq ZvK mv bv `b I cwiPhv Kib|
30

(e) | <-- nhiZ Avqkv (ivt) ejb,
ivm~jyjvnK hLbB `yBwU KvRi GLwZqvi `Iqv nZ,
ZLb wZwb mnRwU eQ wbZb| hw` ZvZ bvni wKQz
bv _vKZ| wZwb wbRi Rb Kvb Abvqi cwZkva
wbZb bv| wK Avjvn&i Rb nj cwZkva bv wbq
QvoZb bv|
31
Iqvh-bQxnZ Ggbfve KiZb, hvZ
gvbyl weeZeva bv Ki|
32
bdj QvjvZ Pzc Pzc Av`vq
KiZb, hvZ Abi K bv nq| wZwb ejZb, ` ,
` , =` ` ,. . Zvgiv Ggbfve Bev`Z Ki, hv
Zvgiv mnR KiZ cvi|
33

() -|-|| Zuvi `vbkxjZv wQj b`xi mvZi gZ|
hZY Zu vi KvQ wKQz _vKZ, ZZY wZwb `vb KiZb|
ivgvhvb gvm Zv nq hZ ` , ` , _ ` ,` evqy cevni
bvq| wZwb Qv`vKv MnY KiZb bv| wK nvw`qv
wbZb| A_P Zv wbRi cqvRb hrmvgvb jvwMq meB
`vb Ki w`Zb| wZwb ejZb, . ` ` ,` , ` , ` - ' _.` -
` . -` , ` , - . ' . -` , . KD AZY cKZ gywgb
nZ cvie bv, hZY bv m Acii Rb mB e
fvjevme, hv wbRi Rb fvjevme|
34
wZwb ejZb,

29. !! !!, l! !/: !! !!'
<! : |
30. <!<, l! !/: >!!' <! : |
31. !! !!, l! !/: !! !!'
<! : |
32. !! !!, l! !/~|
33. <!< !/:>:: !' <!-: ! <! <!$!<!l$<
!l' ->|
34. !! !!, l! !/>:: l*!!<' <! :
|
. , ` _ ` - , ' _' ` , , . . , ' .` . ` GKRb
ev`vi `q Cgvb I KcYZv KLbv GKwZ nZ cvi
bv|
35

() ||| ivm~jyj vn (Qvt) me`v `w AebZ
ivLZb| KLbvB Abi Dci wbR ` w wbc KiZb
bv| AvKvki PvBZ gvwUi w`K `w AebZ ivLvKB
wZwb kq gb KiZb| wZwb Kvi gyLi Dci Kvb
Acm`bxq K_v ejZ jv cZb| Avey mvC` Ly`ix
ejb, . ,` _ = _. = , ,, ` ' . , -
. _ ` _ _` - . , , ` , ` , ` _ ,` - , .
wZwb c`vbkxb Kzgvix gq`i PvBZ jvkxj wQjb|
hLb wZwb wKQz Acm` KiZb, ZLb Zuvi Pnviv `L
Avgiv eyS wbZvg|
36
Kvi Kvb g` KvR `Lj
mivmwi ZvK g` bv ej mvaviYfve wbla KiZb,
hvZ jvKwU jv bv cvq| A_P welqwU eySZ ci
mskvab nq hvq|
(o) |<-< -x| wZwb wQjb webqx I wbinsKvi
Pwii gvbyl| wZwb mevBK gvbyl wnmve mgvb vb
KiZb| DuPz-bxPz f`vf` KiZb bv| ZuvK `L
QvnvexMYK mvbv_ `uvovZ wbla KiZb|
37
wZwb
mKji mv_ GKBfve gvwUZ em coZb| `vm-
`vmx`i wbKU KLbvB AnsKvi cKvk KiZb bv|
Zv`i Kvb KvR Am nq Dn& k KiZb bv| eis
Zv`i KvR mvnvh KiZb| Avbvm (ivt) ejb, Avwg
10 eQi ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi wL`gZ KiwQ| wK wZwb
KLbv AvgvK Kvb KvRi Rb KwdqZ Zje
Kibwb|
38
wZwb me`v AvM mvjvg w`Zb I gyQvdvnvi
Rb AvM nvZ evwoq w`Zb| QvnvexMYK mvb Ki
A_ev Av`i Ki Zv`i Dcbvg WvKZb| hgb
Avyjvn web IQgvbK AveyeKi (ivt), Avy i ingvbK
Avey ivqiv (ivt), AvjxK Avey Zvive BZvw`| DjL
h, Lykx Aevq Dcbvg WvKv Aviexq ixwZ wQj|
(K) bdj QvjvZ Ae vq Kvb gngvb Gj wZwb
msc QvjvZ kl Ki K_v ej wbZb| Zvici
cybivq QvjvZ iZ nZb| `y`vwqbx gvZv, ivMx, e,

35. l<l, !!^, l! !/:~ l>!' <!|
36. !! !!, l! !/:: !! !!'
<! : |
37. l<l, l! !/:>|
38. !! !!, l! !/:|






12
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
gymvwdi BZvw` weePbvq wZwb RvgvAvZ QvjvZ
msc KiZb|
39

(L) ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Avhev , ... , bvgx GKUv Dx
wQj| m GZB `ZMvgx wQj h, Kvb evnb ZvK
AwZg KiZ cviZ bv| wK GKw`b GK e`yCbi
mIqvix Avhev-K AwZg Ki Mj| welqwU
gymjgvb`i KvQ K`vqK gb nj| ZLb ivm~j (Qvt)
Zv`i mv bv w`q ejb, . - _ = . ' . _ ` , , ` ,
,` ' . . ` . . , `ywbqvZ Avjvn&i bxwZ GUvB h,
KvDK DuPz Kij ZvK bxPzI Ki _vKb|
40

(M) GKevi RbK ew ivm~jK ,_ _- (mwi miv)
ej m^vab Kij ivm~j (Qvt) ZvK ejb, ` , ,` , ` ,
` , ` ` IB ghv`v nj Beivnxg (Avt)-Gi|
41

(N) GKevi RbK ew ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi mvgb Gm
fq wenj nq co| ZLb ivm~j (Qvt) ZvK ejb,
.` , :` , ` _` , ` .` : , ` ' ` ` , ' ,` ` , ,. `
' .` , wi nI! Kbbv Avwg Kvb ev`kvn bB|
Avwg GKRb Kzivqk gwnjvi m vb gv| whwb Kbv
MvkZ fY KiZb|
42
DjL h, Aviei Mixe
jvKiv Kbv MvkZ LZb| G mKj NUbvq ev e
Rxeb ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi webq I bgZv Aej^bi I
wbinsKvi Pwii ewk dzU IV|
(:) t|< |<- nhiZ Avqkv (ivt) ejb,
Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt) wbRB RyZv mjvB KiZb I cw
jvMvZb| wbRi Kvco wbRB mjvB KiZb, msmvii
KvR wbR nvZ KiZb, wbR eKix `vnb KiZb,
Kvco Qvd KiZb I wbRi KvR wbR KiZb|
43

x`i ga Avqkv (ivt) wQjb Kzgvix I mePq Kg
eqv| ZvB ivm~j (Qvt) KLbv KLbv Zvi mv_ `o
cvjv w`Zb|
44
ZvK wbq weq evoxZ e`yCb gq`i
bvPMvb bQb|
45
ivm~j (Qvt) h KZ ev eev`x I

39. !! !!, l! !/::::, :, ~>|
40. <!< !/:: l<!' <!-: !' -:|
41. l, l! !/>: l*!!<' <! :: |
42. < !>! !/:::~, |
43. l<l, l! !/~~
44. < !>! !/:>> |
45. !! !!, l! !/:~ <!<, l!
!/::|
mswZgbv wQjb, GZ Zvi cgvY gj| GKevi GK
mdi x QvwdqvK DU mIqvi Kivi Rb wZwb wbRi
nvUz cZ `b| Qvwdqv bexi nvUz i Dci cv iL DU
mIqvi nb|
46

(::) x| |<- ez`i m mymK eRvq
ivLZb| wbRi I x mwK Z AvZxq-^ Rbi mv_ ` p
mK iv KiZb| Kvi wZ nZ cvi Ggb KvR
_K `~i _vKZb| ciwb`v I ciPP v nZ euP
_vKZb| mx-mv_x`i LuvR-Lei wbZb| wZwb
k`i `Iqv K I g~L`i evovevwoZ ah aviY
KiZb| wZwb g`K g` ejZb, fvjK fvj ejZb|
wK me`v gacv Aej^b KiZb| me`v wZwb mKji
cwZ mnvbyf~wZkxj _vKZb| Zuvi wbKU jvK`i
ghv`vi wfw wQj ZvKIqv ev Avj vnfxiZv| mgvRi
`yej kYxi cwZ Zuvi KiYv wQj mevwaK| wZwb ejZb,
` _ ,` ` , . ' . ` , ` , _` ,` . ` ,` , .` ` , . ` , ` . , Zvgiv
AvgvK `yej kYxi ga Zvjvk Kiv| Kbbv Zvgiv
iwhcv nq _vK Ges mvnvhcv nq _vK `yej kYxi
gvag|
47

Kvi gvbnvwbKi K_v wZwb ejZb bv|
mgvR msvi wZwb RbgZi g~jvqb KiZb| hgb-
(1) Kzivqk`i wbwgZ KvevM n Beivnxg (Avt) wbwg Z
KvevMn _K wKQz Ask Qo ivLv nqwQj| Qvov
AskwUK iKb nvZxg ejv nq| Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt)
PqwQjb IUvK Beivnxgx Kvevi bvq KvevM ni
ga kvwgj KiZ Ges Kvev Mni `iRv `yUv KiZ|
wK RbgZ weMo hvevi AvksKvq Zv Kibwb| wZwb
GKw`b Avqkv (ivt)-K ejb, .` , :.` ` , ` , . - .
` ,` ` ` , , , ` .` . ` ` . - , ` , , , ` . , ` -` ,
.` ` ` . , , ` ,` -` ,` - , . hw` Zvgvi KIg bZz b gymwjg bv
nZ, Zvnj Avwg Kvev f w`Zvg Ges Gi `ywU
`iRv KiZvg| GKwU w`q gyQjxiv cek KiZ Ges
AbwU w`q ewiq hZ|
48
A_vr wZwb PqwQjb
nvZxgK A fy Ki g~j Beivnxgx wfZi Dci
KvevMn wbgvY KiZ| hv gvwU mgvb ne Ges hvi c~e
`iRv w`q gyQjx cek Kie I QvjvZ kl cwg
`iRv w`q ewiq hve| wK Kzivqkiv Zv bv Ki
AbK DuPzZ `iRv wbgvY Ki| hvZ Zv`i BQvi

46. <!<, !/~~: <' <!|
47. !<! !/~> l! !/~: ll! ! !/>|
48. <!< !/:~:|






13
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
evBi KD mLvb cek KiZ bv cvi| Lvjv Avqkv
(ivt)-Gi wbKU G nv`xQ kvbvi ci Avyjvn Beby
hyevqi (ivt) ^xq LjvdZKvj 64 wnRix mb KvevMn
f ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi BQv Abyhvqx Zv cybwbgvY Kib|
wK 9 eQi ci 73 wnRixZ DgvBqv MeYi nvvR web
BDmyd Zv f AvMi gZ wbgvY Kib| hvi AvKwZ
AvRI iqQ| ejv evj Gi viv ivRbxwZ ev evqb
nqQ| wK ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi AvKvsLvi ev evqb AvRI
NUwb Ges g~j Beivnxgx wfZ Kvev AvRI wdi
Avmwb|
(2) g`xbvq gybvwdK`i AcZrciZv mxgv Qvwoq Mj
Igi dviK (ivt) ivm~j (Qvt)-K ejb, AvgvK AbygwZ
w`b GB gybvwdKUvK (Beby DevBK) kl Ki w`B|
Reve ivm~j (Qvt) ejb, bv| ZvZ jvKiv eje h,
gynvv` Zvi mv_x`i nZv KiQb|
49

|-| -|| <-- wZwb wbRi Rb wZbwU bxwZK
AvewkK Ki wbqwQjb- (1) ..,, wiqv A_vr jvK
`Lvbv Kvb KvR bv Kiv (2) _.. AvwaK cwinvi
Kiv (3) ,, . , Ab_K K_v I KvR Gwoq Pjv|
Abi evcviI wZwb wZbwU welq _K wbRK `~i
ivLZb- (1) KvDK wb`v Kiv (2) jv `Iqv (3)
wQ`v^lY Kiv|
<+< -||
eVK Kvbic AnZzK I AcqvRbxq K_v ejZb bv|
wZwb hLb K_v ejZb, ZLb mKj bxie Zv bZb|
KDB Zuvi mvgb DPt^i K_v ejZb bv| Zuvi K_v
kl bv nj KD K_v ejZ bv| wZwb me`v Ggb K_vB
ejZb, hvZ QIqve Avkv Kiv nZ| KD Zuvi cwZ
mvgvb mnvbyf~wZ `Lvj wZwb Zvi Rb mevg
KZZv ^xKvi KiZb| e`yCb`i ip AvPiY wZwb
ah Aej^b KiZb| ejv Pj h, Zuvi GB webg
eenvi I AZzjbxq ew gvayhi cfveB i ^fvei
giPvix AvieMY `j `j Bmjvg cek KiwQj|
Avjvn ejb, ` - _ = .` ` ,` , ` , , .` =
` , . ` ,' . ` ` : ` , - Avjvn&i AbyMni dj
Avcwb Zv`i cwZ Kvgj `q nqQb| hw` Avcwb
KKkfvlx I ip `q nZb, Zvnj Zviv Avcbvi KvQ
_K wewQb nq hZ (! <! :/:>)| ivm~j (Qvt)-

49. l<l !/::: |
Gi G Abb Pwi gvayh wQj wbtm`n Avjvn& i wekl
`vb|
<t|<
cwikl eje, AwZ eo `y kgbI ivm~j (Qvt)-K KLbv
Amr ejwb| wK Zviv KziAvbx weavbK gvbZ ivhx
nqwb| ^QvPvwiZvq Af cuywRev`x MvbZviv
Bmjvgi cuywRev` weivax I bvqwePviwfwK A_bxwZ,
Mvxq mgvRbxwZ Ges AvLivZwfwK wbqw Z
RxebvPviK gb wbZ cviwb| Avi m KviYB Zv
Avey Rvnj ivm~j (Qvt)-K ejwQj, . :, ,
. .- ., Avgiv ZvgvK wg_v ewj bv| eis
Zzwg h Bmjvg wbq GmQ, ZvK wg_v ewj| G c m
wbgv AvqvZ bvwhj nq,
` ,` ,` , . ` ,` , ` , : ` , ` , = . , , = ` ,` -` - , .
eZt Iiv AvcbvK wg_v ej bv| eis GBme hvjgiv
Avjvn&i AvqvZ mg~nK A^xKvi Ki (!! :/::)|
50

GgbwK GBme jvKiv KziAvb cwieZbi `vexI
KiwQj| hgb Avjvn ejb,
, _ ` ` ` , ,` , ` , . ` , , ` , . ` ,` -` , , . . .
.` , , ,` , ` , ' ` ` , ` , , . ` . ' ` ` , ' ` .
` . ` _ ` ' ` ,` , _ - ` ` ` ` - ' . ` .` , . ` ` , _
. ` , , ` , = , , ,, ~ ,
Avi hLb Zv`i KvQ Avgv`i AvqvZ mg~ n cvV
Kiv nq, ZLb hviv Avgvi `x`vi Kvgbv Ki bv Zviv
ej h, GwU eZxZ Ab KziAvb wbq Gmv A_ev
GUvK cwieZb Ki| Avcwb ej w`b h, GK wbRi
c nZ cwieZb Kiv Avgvi KvR bq| Avwg Zv Kej
AbymiY Kwi hv Avgvi wbKU Anx Kiv nq| ^ xq
cvjbKZvi AevaZvq Avwg KwVb w`emi Avhvei fq
Kwi ( :/:)| Avj vn Zu vi ivm~ jK ejb, :.`
_ .` ,, ` .` wbqB Avcwb mij-mwVK c_i
Dci AvQb ( ~~/:)|
ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi cyiv Rxeb wQj Kz iAvbi ev e wP|
mKviY GK`v gv AvqkvK ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Pwi
mK wRm Kiv nj wZwb ejwQjb, . ` . ` -

50. l<l, l! !/:, <!|






14
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
.` ,. Zuvi Pwi wQj KziAvb|
51
A_vr wZwb wQjb
KziAvbi ev e icKvi| nv`xQi cvZvq cvZvq hvi
`v mg~n ^Yvi wjwce nq AvQ| KziAvb I
nv`xQ ZvB gymwjg Rxebi Pjvi c_i GKgv
AvjvKewZKv| Avjvn Avgv`iK ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Rxeb
PwiZ AbymiYi ZvIdxK `vb Kib| Avgxb!
|< x'<|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi Rxeb Avgiv e gyRhvi K_v
RbwQ| hvi meB wQj Zuvi Rxekvq Ges Zuvi gZzi
mv_ mv_ hwji Aejyw NUQ| hgb Abvb
bexMYi ejvq NUQ| A_ev Zv`i wKZve mg~n
cwiewZZ I weKZ nq MQ| hgb ZvIivZ I BbRxj|
wK ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi B Kvji ciI h gyRhv Rxe
nq AvQ Ges wKqvgZ ch hv wPi RvMiK _vKe, Zv
nj Zuvi AvbxZ Kvjvgyjvn Avj-KziAvbyj nvKxg| wek
gvbeZvi wPi b c_c`kK wnmve mwKZv Avjvn hv
`ywbqvevmxi Rb Zuvi klbexi gvag ciY KiQb
Ges hv gvbe RvwZi AvgvbZ wnmve iwZ AvQ Ges
wPiKvj _vKe| hZw`b cw_ex _vKe, gvbeRvwZ _vKe,
ZZw`b KziAvb _vKe AweKZ I AzYfve| ivm~j
(Qvt)-Gi 23 eQii beyAZx Rxebi euvK euvK
Avmgvbx ZvievZv wnmve KziAvb bvwhj nqQ
ciivMZfve| byh~j KziAvbi i _K beyAZi
i Ges byh~j KziAvbi mgvwZ bex Rxebi mgvw|
ZvB bexPwiZ AvjvPbvq KziAvbi AvjvPbv
Aekvexic Gm co| bex Kixg (Qvt) Pj MQb|
iL MQb KziAvb| wK wK AvQ mLvb? GY
Avgiv KziAvbi cwiPq I ewkvejx msc Zzj
aivi cqvm cve|
+<|-< |<<
KziAvbi cavbZg cwiPq nj GB h, GwU Kvjvgyjvn
ev Avjvn&i Kvjvg| hv mivmwi Avjvn&i wbKU _K
GmQ|
52
mwRMZ `ywbqvex PvL KLbvB Zvi mwKZv
AvjvnK `LZ cve bv (!! :/::)| Ze Zuvi
Kvjvg `L, co, b I eyS n`vqvZ jvf KiZ
cvie| KziAvbi fve I fvlv, Gi cwZwU eY, k I
evK Avjvn&i| wRexj wQjb evnK
53
Ges ivm~j (Qvt)

51. ! !!, : >! !/::|
52. l! /~, !! :/::, !<! /:, ! !>!
:/~ !l! :/-~ !+! :>/: !<
:/~:|
53. <!!<! ~/> !<! ~:/:> !< :/:>
wQjb cPviK I evLvZv|
54
G KziAvb myiwZ djK
wjwce wQj|
55
mLvb _K Avjvn& i Kzg g g
bvwhj nqQ|
56

klbex gynvv` (Qvt)-Gi AvMgbi ci weMZ mKj
bexi beyAZ kl nq wMqQ Ges KziAvb AeZiYi
ci weMZ mKj Bjvnx wKZvei Kzg I KvhKwiZv iwnZ
nq MQ| Cmv (Avt) mn weMZ mKj bexB klbex
gynvv` (Qvt)-Gi AvMgbi mymsev` w`q MQb (
::/:) Ges Zuviv klbexi Avgj cj ZuvK mev KiY
mvnvh Kieb ej Avjvn&i wbKU AxKvive
nqwQjb (! <! :/:)| m wnmve gy nvv` (Qvt)
Kej AvLix hvgvbvi bex bb, eis wZwb wQjb weMZ
mKj bexi bex| Abyicfve Zuvi AvbxZ wKZve I
kixAvZ weMZ mKj wKZve I kixAvZi
mZvqbKvix
57
Ges c~Y Zv `vbKvix (!! /:)|
AZGe KziAvb eZgvb cw_exi GKgv Gjvnx wKZve
Ges mKj gvbyli Rb GKgv c_c `k K Bjvnx M|
mevwaK cwm bvg nj KziAvb| hvi A_ cwic~Y
hgb ` ` ,. - .' , nvDm Kvbvq Kvbvq c~Y nqQ|
mg vbi fvvi c~Y fve mwZ nIqvi KviY
KvjvgyjvnK KziAvb ejv nqQ| Bebyj KvBwqg GK_v
ejb| Avjvn ejb, ` .` , ` . :` , _ ` . ` , .` .
Avcbvi cfyi Kvjvg mZ I bvq viv cwic~Y (!!
:/::)| A_vr KziAvbi cwZwU K_vB mZ Ges c wZwU
weavbB bvq I BbQvd cwic~Y|
(:)













54. !! /: ! ::/, :|
55. <<> /~:-~~|
56. ! !>! :/~ !l! :/|
57. <!!<! ~/:, >:, > ! <! :/:, l! /
!! / !< :/:: !! :/:






15
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
|<| - -1|+ |<|<< x||<
!|! < !
|x+|
Avjvn ZvAvjv gvbe RvwZK GKgv Zuvi Bev`Z Kivi Rb
mw KiQb Ges Bev`Zi hveZxq wbqg-cwZ Anx
gvidZ Rvwbq w`qQb, hv KziAvb I nv`xQ M mg~n
we`gvb| Avi mKj Bev`Zi ga k Bev`Z nj QvjvZ,
hv cweZv ARb eZxZ ea bq| G KviY mKj gynvwQ
Ges dKxnMY Zvnvivn ev cweZv Aavq w`q wKZve wjLv
i KiQb| AZGe cweZv ARbi iZ Acwimxg|
wbg G mK avivevwnKfve AvjvPbv Kiv nj|-
_.,=| (|<|)-=< ||<||-+ .= .
.., . ,.., A_vr cweZv, cwiQbZv I
weZv|
58

_,=| (|<|)-=< ||<||<+ cvwifvwlK A_
_,= (Znvivn&) `ywU A_ c`vb Ki| h_v :
:- -.,,-- _,| | |-+ + |<| Zv
nj . _,~ A_vr Avjvn ZvAvjvi Bev`Zi ga
Kvb ew ev eK kixK Kiv _K wbRi A iK
cwe ivLv Ges Avjvn ZvAvjvi gywgb ev`vi Dci
wnsmv-wel I Mvcb kZv _K wbRK weiZ ivLv|
Avi GUv Kvb Acwe e _K kixi cwe Kivi Pq
AwaKZi iZc~Y| Kbbv wkiK viv Acwe kixiK
cvwb viv aZ Ki cwe Kiv me bq| hw`I evwnK
w`K _K Zvi kixi Acwe bq| A_vr Zvi kixi k
Kij KD Acwe ne bv Ges Zvi DwQ Acwe bq|
Avjvn ZvAvjv ejQb, , . ,' , ' ` , . ` ,.` . `
` , ,` ` . ` - n Cgvb`viMY, wbqB gy kwiKiv bvcvK
ev Acwe (<! ~)|
>- -,.- _,=| | -<<|i <||i+ |<| Zv
nj, .- ,_ , .- __ A_vr kixii AcweZv
Ges kixi jM _vKv Acwe e `~i Kiv|
<i|i| :- ..- __ Z_v kixii bvcvKx `~i Kiv|
A_vr h mKj KviY QvjvZ Av`vq evav c`vb Ki Zv
nZ cweZv ARb Kiv| GUv `yB cKvi| h_v :

l!, ! ! l<l<!, !<<
. !->! !, (<< !< =! <! !-
!<!<), : :
(K) ,.' .- Z_v QvU bvcvKx| hv _K Kej Ih~ i
gvagB cweZv ARb Kiv m e| hgb ckve-cvqLvbv
Ges evqy wbtmiY nj Ih~i gvagB cweZv ARb Ki
QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv hvq|
(L) _' .- Z_v eo bvcvKx| hv _K Mvmj eZxZ
cweZv ARb me bq| hgb- x mnevm Kij A_ev
^c`vli gvag exhcvZ NUj Mvmj IqvwRe nq
hvq| G Aevq cvwb bv cj Zvqvygi gvag
cweZv ARb KiZ nq|
2- .- ,_ Z_v kixi jM _vKv bvcvKx `~i Kiv|
A_vr ckve, cvqLvbv BZvw` kixi ev Kvco jM
Mj cvwb viv aZ Kivi gvag cweZv AR b
Kiv|
59

|<| -< +x bvcvKx _K cweZv ARb Kiv
mg ewi Dci IqvwRe| Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb,
, :.. , , ` ,..` , = Zvgvi cvlvK-cwiQ` cwe ivL
(~!l< )|
wZwb Ab ejQb, ` , , _ ` , ,` , , ` , .` , . '
,` , ~ ` , , ` , = ` , , _. ' , , ` ,` -' . Avi
Beivnxg I BmgvCjK ZvIqvdKvix, BwZKvdKvix, iK~
I wmR`vKvix`i Rb Avgvi MnK cwe ivLZ Av`k
w`qwQjvg (<!!<! :~)|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` , ` , ` ` _` ` .` ` ,` _ = _. = .,
,, ` , , . ` . ,` , , ` ,` , ~ _ . , . ` ` ,
Beby Igi (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, Avwg ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt)-K ejZ bwQ, cweZv eZxZ QvjvZ Ges
nvivg gvji `vb Keyj nq bv|
60

|<| -< < <|-|<|
(K) ev`vi QvjvZ Qnxn& nIqvi c~ ekZ nj cweZv
ARb Kiv| nv`xQ GmQ,
` , ' ,` , ,` ,` _ = _. = , ,,
. ` . ` . ` - ' _` - '` . , ,
Avey ivqivn (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~ jy jvn
(Qvt) ejQb, h ewi Ih~ f nqQ Zvi QvjvZ ne
bv hZY ch m Ih~ bv Ki|
61


>. !|! l< ! !-!, !<: !! !l
!l :/~-:~ l: !!<, : :
:. l, !/~~, l!, !/~:






16
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
(L) Avjvn ZvAvjv cweZv ARbKvixi cksmv KiQb
Ges wZwb Zv`iK fvjevmb| Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb,
. = ' . -` , ` , ,` ,` ' . -` , , ` , ,.` , = ` - wbqB Avjvn
ZIevKvix`iK fvjevmb Ges fvjevmb AwaK cweZv
ARbKvix`iK (<!!<! ~~~)|
Avjvn gmwR` Kzevi Awaevmx`i cksmv Ki ejb, ` ,
- _ ` ,' -` , . . ' ` ,` ,` , = , = , ' . -` , ` , ,` , =` - mLvb
Ggb jvK AvQ, hviv Dgic cweZv ARb KiZ
fvjevm| Avi Avjvn cweZv ARbKvix`i fvjevmb
(<! :)|
(M) Keii KwVb Avhve _K cwivYi AbZg Dcvq
nj Acwe e _K `~i _vKv| hgb nv`xQ GmQ,
` , ` ` , ` ,` _ = _. = , ,, _
` , ,` ` ,` . , ` , , . , ` , ` _ ` , , ` ' .
. ` ,` ` , ` , ` ' , . _ ` , ` , ` ,
Beb Avevm (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, GK`v
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) `ywU Keii cvk w`q AwZg KiwQjb|
AZtci wZwb ejjb, wbqB GB `yB ew kvw fvM
KiQ| wK Zviv eo Kvb Acivai KviY kvw fvM
KiQ bv| Zvi ga GB ew cmve _K mZK _vKZ
bv| Avi GB ew PvMjLvix Ki eovZ|
62

||- t| x|||
< ||- |<| |<| - +<| <<
cweZv ARbi Rb H cvwbi cqvRb h cvwb wbR
cwe Ges AbK cwe KiZ mg| DjL h, cvwb
wZb cKvi| h_v-
(K) ` _` ,.` , ~ (Zvn~i): A_vr h cvwb wbR cwe Ges
AbK cwe KiZ mg| A_vr h cvwbi is, ^v`, M
wKQzB cwieZb nqwb| hgb- ewi cvwb, b`xi cvwb,
mvMii cvwb, eidi cvwb, K~ ci cvwb, SiYvi cvwb,
bjK~ci cvwb BZvw`| Kejgv GB cKvi cvwb vivB
cweZv ARb Kiv me| Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb, ` , ` , ,
` , ` , . ` . ` , ,.` , =` , . , Avi AvKvk nZ
Zvgv`i Dci ew elY Kib, Avi Gi gvag wZwb
Zvgv`iK cwe Kib (!! ::)|
wZwb Ab ejQb, ,` ' , . ` . ` ,.` , ~ _ Avi
Avwg AvKvk _K cwe cvwb elY KiwQ (<! )|

::. eyLvix, cweZv eZxZ QvjvZ Keyj ne bv AbyQ`, nv/135, evsjv Abyev`, ZvInx`
cvewjKk, 1/85; gymwjg, nv/225| wgkKvZ, nv/280, evsjv Abyev`, Gg`vw`qv 2/48|
:~. Avey `vD`, nv/20, bvmvC, nv/31, 69, Beby gvRvn, nv/347, nv`xQ Qnxn|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` , ' ,` , ,` ' ` - _ ` _ ` _. = , ,,
, ` ,` _ = ` ` . ` , ,` - ` - , ` ,
. . , , '` . , ` = '` . , ' . , ,` - ` ,` _
= _. = , ,, ,` ` ,` , = ` _ ` ` , - ` ` ` ,
Avey ivqivn (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, GK ew
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) K wRm Kijb, n Avjvni ivm~ j!
Avgiv mgy` (bKvq) AvivnY KiwQ Ges Avgiv m
A wKQz cvwb wbqwQ| hw` Avgiv mB cvwb viv Ih~ Kwi
Zvnj Avgiv wccvwmZ ne| AZGe Avgiv wK mgy` i
cvwb viv Ih~ KiZ cvwi? ivm~ jy jvn (Qvt) ejjb, Zvi
(mgy`i) cvwb cwe Ges Zvi gaKvi gZ nvjvj|
63

(L) ` , . ~ (Zvni): A_vr h cvwb wbR cwe| wK
AbK cwe KiZ cvi bv| hgb- ccwm, dji Ry m,
`ya wgkvbv cvwb BZvw`| Gjv wbR cwe wK Kvb
AcweK cwe KiZ cvi bv| A_ vr Gjv viv Ih~
ea bq Ges kixi Kvb bvcvKx jM Mj Gjv viv
aZ KivI ea bq|
Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb,
. , ` ,` ` _ .` , ` , ' _ , ` , ' . - ` - ' ` , `
` , ' . ` ,` ` . ` ` , ` ,` - . ` ,` ` , ` , . ` , ~
` ,` - ` ` ,` -` , , ` , ` , ` , ' , ` , ` ` -
Avi hw` Amy nI wKsev mdi _vK A_ev hw` Zvgv`i
KD cvqLvbv _K Avm A_ev Zvgiv hw` x`i mv_
mnevm Ki AZtci cvwb bv cvI, Ze cwe gvwU viv
Zvqvyg Ki| myZivs Zvgv`i gyL I nvZ Zv viv gvmn
Ki (!! :)| AZGe hw` cvwb eZxZ Rym, ccwm
BZvw` viv Ih~ Rvqh nZ Zvnj cvwb bv cj Avjvn
ZvAvjv mivmwi gvwU viv Zvqvyg Kivi wb`k w`Zb
bv| eis cvwb RvZxq wRwbm viv Ih~ Kivi wb` k w`Zb|
(N) .- (bvRvm): A_ vr h cvwb wbR cwe bq Ges
AbKI cwe KiZ cvi bv| Ggb cvwb viv cweZv
ARb Kiv Rvqh bq|
||-< | |< <^< |x ' |< + x
cvwb Kg nvK wKsev ekx nvK Zvi mv_ Acwe ei
wgkYi dj hw` is, ^v` I M GB wZbwU Yi Kvb
GKwUi cwieZb nq, Zvnj mB cvwb Acwe nq
hve| GB cvwb eenvi Kiv Rvqh bq Ges Zv AbK
cwe KiZI mg bq| cv i hw` is, ^v` I M

::. Avey `vD` nv/83; wZiwghx nv/69; bvmvC nv/59; Beby gvRvn nv/3246|






17
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
GB wZbwU Yi mewj wVK _vK Zvnj Zv cwe ej
MY ne Ges Zv viv cweZv ARb Kiv ea|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` , ' ` , ` _` ` - ` , , ` ,` _ = ` '` . , `
, , .` , , _ ` , ` , , ` , - ` ` ,` - , ` . ` ` ` ,
. . ` ,` , ~ ` _ . ` ` ` - ` , .`
Avey mvC` Ly`ix (ivt) nZ ewYZ, GK`v ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-
K wRm Kiv nj n Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt)! Avgiv wK
eyhvAv Kci cvwb viv Ih~ KiZ cvwi? A_P Zv Ggb
GKwU Kc, hvZ nvqhi bKov, giv KzKzi I c~wZMgq
AveRbv wbw nq _vK| Di ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejjb,
cvwb cwe, Kvb wRwbmB ZvK Acwe KiZ cvi bv|
64

||-< | |< <^< |x ' |< +x
cvwbi mv_ hw` Kvb cwe ei wgkY nq| hgb-
ei cvZv, mvevb, Kzj ev eiB BZvw` Ges is, ^v`,
M GB wZbwU Yi mejvB wVK _vK Zvnj Zv
cwe ej MY ne Ges Zv viv cweZv ARb Kiv
ea| wK hw` DwjwL wZbwU Yi Kvb GKwU b nq
hvq Zvnj mB cvwb ~ ` , Z_v cwe eU wK Zv viv
cweZv ARb Kiv ea bq|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` ' ` , = ` , _ .` . . _ ` ,` ` . - ` ,
` ,` _ = _. = , ,, ` , - ` ,` . , ` ` ` ,
, ` , ' ` - ` , ' , ' ` : . ` ` ` , ' _ :
. , _` , ` - , , -. _, ` , ' ` , ` ` , _
Dy AvwZqvn AvbQvix (ivt) nZ ewYZ, ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt)-Gi Kbv hvqbve (ivt) gZzeiY Kij wZwb
Avgv`i wbKU Gm ejjb, Zvgiv ZuvK wZbevi ev
cuvPevi ev cqvRb gb Kij Zvi Pq AwaKevi eiB
cvZvmn cvwb w`q Mvmj `vI| klevi Kcyi ev wKQz
Kcyi eenvi Kie...|
65
A nv`xQ cgvY Ki h,
cwe ei wgkY cvwb Acwe nq bv|
<x ||- |<| |<| -< +x
(K) hw` Kvb Acwe eK Rvjvbx wnmve eenvi Ki
cvwb Mig Kiv nq| A_vr hw` KD Mvav ev Nvovi
cvqLvbv Rgv Ki Ges ZvK Rvjvbx wnmve eenvi Ki
cvwb Mig Ki Ges cvi gyL Lvjv _vK, Zvnj Zv

:. ! !! :/: !< ! !/:: !!^ !/~
l! !/ <>!<!, =!l! ~/::
:. <!< << !!< !l l ^! <!!'
, !/:~:, <!! <!, ! !<l ~/
gvKin ev Acm`bxq| Kbbv Acwe e wbmZ auvqv
H cvwbZ cwZZ nIqvi dj Zvi M cwieZb nIqvi
mvebv _vK cv i hw` cvi gyL e Kiv _vK,
Zvnj ZvZ Kvb mgmv bB|
66

(L) hw` Kvb cwe eK Rvjvbx wnmve eenvi Ki
cvwb Mig Ki A_ev m~ h i Zvc cvwb Mig Ki,
Zvnj ZvZ Kvb mgmv bB|
67

<i<||<+ ||- |<| |<| -< +x
eenvwiK cvwb A_vr Ih~ A_ev Mvmj Kivi mgq Ih~i
Amg~n _K Mwoq cov cvwb viv cweZv ARb Kiv
ea| Ze kZ nj is, ^v` I M wVK _vKZ ne|
nv`xQ GmQ,
,` ,` _ ,` ,` , , ` ` .` , - , ` ,`
` - . , '` . , ' ` _. = , ,, ` ,` ` , , .
_ ` ,` . , .
DiIqv (int) wgmIqvi (int) c gyLi wbKU nZ nv`xQ
eYbv Kib| G Dfq eY bv GKwU AbwUi mZvqb
^ic| bex (Qvt) hLb Ih~ KiZb ZLb Zuvi eeZ
cvwbi Dci Zuviv (Qvnvevq Kivg) hb gwo Lq
coZb|
68

Ab nv`xQ GmQ,
, ,` , ' ` ,` _ ' ` _. = , ,, _ , ` ,
. ` , , ` ,` - , , , ` _ , ` , ` , ` , , ,` ` `
, ' , _ ` ,` -` , ` ,` -` , _
Avey g~mv (ivt) ejb, bex (Qvt) GKwU cv Avbvjb
hvZ cvwb wQj| AZtci wZwb Zvi ga Dfq nvZ I
gyLgj aZ Kijb Ges Zvi viv Kzwj Kijb|
AZtci Zv`i `yRb [Avey g~mv I ejvj (ivt)]-K
ejjb, Zvgiv G _K cvb Ki Ges Zvgv`i
gyLgj I eyK Xvj|
69

AZGe hw` eenvwiK cvwb cwe bv nZ Zvnj
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Ggb wb`k w`Zb bv Ges Qvnvevq
Kivg Ggb KvR KiZb bv| GQvovI ivm~ jyjvn (Qvt)
Ges Zuvi QvnvexMY Zuv`i x`i mv_ GK GKB cv
nZ Ih~ KiZb| hgb nv`xQ GmQ,

::. !<: !! !l !l :/::-:
:. !<: !! !l !l :/:
:. <!<, < <l* !l <<!<' , !/:>, <!!
<!, ! !<l :/:>
:>. <!<, < <l* !l <<!<' <!, !/:, <!!
<!, ! !<l :/:>






18
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
` ` = ` , , ` ` ` ' . -` , . ` , ` , ` . , , .
` . _ ` ,` _ = _ . = ` , , , ` , -
Avyjvn Beby Dgvi (ivt) nZ ewYZ wZwb ejb,
Avjvn& i ivm~j-Gi mgq cyil Ges gwnjv GK (GK
cv nZ) Ih~ KiZb|
70

x|-< =<t || < <|vf |< |+z
x : x|-<< <|vf, A_vr LvIqv I cvb Kivi ci
hv Aewk _vK Zv cwe| nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` . ` .` ` . ,` ' ' , ` - ` , ` , ' ` _ `
_. = , ,, ` _ . , ` _ _ .` , ` _ ` . ,` ,
` ` , ' , ` , ' , ` - ` , ` , ' ` _ ` _. = ,
,, ` _ . , ` _ _ .` , ` _
Avqkv (ivt) ejb, Avwg nvqh Aevq cvb KiZvg,
AZtci Zv bex (Qvt)-K w`Zvg, Avi wZwb Avgvi gyLi
RvqMvq gyL iLB cvb KiZb| Avi KLbI Avwg nvqh
Aevq nvoi MvkZ LZvg, AZtci Zv Avwg bex (Qvt)-
K w`Zvg, Avi wZwb Avgvi gyLi RvqMvq gyL iL
LZb|
71
AZGe gvbyli DwQ mevevqB cwe|
||< : < <|vf MncvwjZ c hvi Mvk&Z LvIqv
nvjvj Zvi DwQ cwe| hv Ijvgvq Kivgi HKgZ
viv cgvwYZ|
cv i h mKj ci MvkZ LvIqv nvivg m mKj
ci DwQ cwe A_ev Acwe nIqvi evcvi gZf`
iqQ| Ze Qnxn gZ nj, KzKzi Ges Kzi eZxZ Ab
mKj ci DwQ cwe|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` .` , .` ` , : ` . , .` - ` , ` _ , '
. ' , ' - ` . ` ` ,` . , . ` . . - ` , ` . , ,
` ` _ ` . ' , . _` - ` . , , ` . ` _ , ` , =` '
` , ` , -` ' , ` , ` _ - ' ` . ` , . . ,` _
= _. = , ,, ,` ` . ` , - , ,`
` , ` , = ` , ` , . ` , = ,
Kvekv webZ Kve Beb gvjK whwb Avey KvZv`vi
cyea~ wQjb| Zvi _K ewYZ AvQ h, GK`v (Zvi
ki) Avey KvZv`v Zuvi wbKU Mjb| wZwb Zuvi Rb

. <!<, < <l* !l <<!<' , !/:>:, <!!
<!, ! !<l :/:::
:. l, !/:, l!, !' <!, !/~, <!!
<!, =!l! ~/:~
Ih~i cvwb Xvjjb| ZLb GKwU weovj Avmj Ges Zv
nZ cvb KiZ jvMj, Avi wZwb cvwU weovjwUi Rb
KvZ Ki aijb, h ch bv m cvb Kij| Kvekv
ejb, ZLb wZwb AvgvK `Ljb, Avwg Zuvi w`K Pq
iqwQ| GUv `L wZwb ejjb, n fvwZRx! Zzwg wK
Avheva KiQ? wZwb ejb, Avwg ejjvg, nuv| ZLb
wZwb ejjb, ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejQb, weovj bvcvK
bq| Zv Zvgv`i cvk Nb Nb wePiYKvix A_ev
wePiYKvwiYx| (myZivs Gi DwQ bvcvK bq)|
72

Ze cvwbi cwigvY hw` `y y B Kzjv-Gi Kg nq Ges H
mKj ci LvIqv I cvb Kivi dj is, ^v` I M
cwiewZZ nq hvq Zvnj Zv Acwe ne|
nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` = ` , , ` ` . ` , , . ,
` _ . , ` ,` , ` ` , ,` ` . _ ` , ` ,` _ = _ .
= ` , , , _ , . ` , ` , ` ` ` - ` , .`
Beby Igi (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, GK`v ivm~jy jvn
(Qvt)-K wRm Kiv nj mB cvwb mK, hv gvV-
weqvevb Rg _vK| Avi ci ci Zv nZ bvbv aibi
eb Rxe-R I wnsm c cvwb cvb KiZ _vK| Di
wZwb ejjb, cvwb hLb `yB Kz j v cwigvY nq, ZLb Zv
bvcvK nq bv|
73

Avi KzKzi Ges k~Kii DwQ Acwe| KviY ivm~j
(Qvt) ejQb,
` ` _ , ' ,` , ,` ` ,` _ = _. = ` , ,,
` ,` , ~ ` _ . ` , - ' _ , ` , ` . . ' ` ` , _` .` ,
` , ' ` ` . . ,' ,
Avey ivqivn (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) ejQb, Zvgv`i Kviv cv KzKzi gyL w`j
ZvK mvZevi aZ Ki Ges c_gevi gvwU viv|
74

AZGe KzKzii DwQ Acwe bv nj ivm~ j (Qvt)
mvZevi aZ Kivi wb`k w`Zb bv| Avi k~Kii
evcvi Avjvn ZvAvjv ejQb, ` ` , ` ` - _ wbqB Zv
Acwe ( !! :)|
/<}

~. !< !, l<$!< l*' , !/, l<l, !/>~,
l!, !/:, <!! <!, =!l ~/::
:. ! !!, ~/~, !< !, !/::, l!, !/,
<!! <!, =!l! ~/::
. <!<, !/:~, l, !/~>, l!, !/, <!!
<!, =!l! ~/:~:






19
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
||< +<||
< !!
Avjvn GK, AwZxq I Amxg mvi AwaKvix| Avi gvbyl
nj Zuvi mevwaK wcq mw| wZwb gvbylK kqZvb nZ
mveavb _vKvi cybt cybt wb`k c`vb KiQb| KziAvb
Gjvnx M| G M Avjvn BnKvj I ciKvj mK
gvbylK mZK-mveavb KiQb|
cwe KziAvbi evYx mg~ni cwZ Avvkxj I AKwg
wekvmx _vKvi Avnvb Rvbvb nqQ| GZ`mI KD
Kbvcm~Zfve wbZbZzb KgKv ce nj Zvi
cwiYvg ne fqven| GLvb GB fqven cwiYwZ mK
mZKevYxi AeZviYv Kiv nj| gnvb Avjvn ivm~j
(Qvt)-K mZKKvixic cw_exZ ciY KiQb| Zuvi
gvagB gvbylK uwkqvi KiQb| Avjvn ejb, ` ' . .
` ,, . ` , , ` - , ` _ ' ` ` , , , . ` ' ` ` . , ,
- ` , ` , . , ` , Avcwb Zv Kej GKRb mZKKvix|
Avwg AvcbvK mZ agmn cvwVqwQ msev``vZv I
mZKKvixic| Ggb Kvb mc`vq bB hvZ mZKKvix
Avmwb (!l< ~:-~)|
GKB ggv_ Ab AvqvZ gnvb Avjvn ejb,
` ` . ` ` , ` _` ' , ` ' , ` , ` , ` , , ,
` ,` , ` _ ` ' . ` , ' , ` _ - ` , ' ` , `
ejyb, Avwg Zv Kvb bZzb ivm~j bB| Avwg Rvwb bv
Avgvi I Zvgv`i mv_ wK eenvi Kiv ne| Avwg
Kej ZviB AbymiY Kwi, hv Avgvi cwZ Awn Kiv nq|
Avwg mZKKvix e bB (!! >)|
Ab wZwb ejb,
, ` _ ' ` ' ` ,' , ' , ` ` , , ,` , . _ , ,
= ` , ' - , , , , , . ` , ` ,` ,` , , = .` ,` , . ' ,
` , ` . , . ` , , _ =` , ` , . ` , ` ,.` ' ` _ ,
= , _ , = _ , , , ` ,
n bex! Avwg AvcbvK mvx, mymsev``vZv I mZKKvix
ic ciY KiwQ Ges Avjvn&i Av`kg Zuvi w`K
AvnvqK ic Ges Dj c`xcic| Avcwb
gymjgvb`i mymsev` w`b h, Zv`i Rb Avjvn&i c
_K weivU AbyMn iqQ| Avcwb Kvdi I gybvwdK`i
AvbyMZ Kieb bv Ges Zv`i Drcxob Dcv Kib I
l (<:), l<<!<, l!><
Avjvn&i Dci fimv Kib| Avjvn Kvh wbe vnx ic h_
(!!< -)|
GKB welq Ab ewYZ nqQ,
` ` ' ` ` _ . ` , = ` _.` , ` - , . _ ' .
` , , ` , ` , , , ` _ ' , . , ` ` _ ` ,
ejyb, Avwg Zv GKRb mZKKvix gv Ges civgkvjx
Avjvn eZxZ Kvb Dcvm bB| wZwb Avmgvb-hgxb I
GZ`yfqi gaeZx mewKQzi cvjbKZ v, civgkvjx,
gvRbvKvix| ejyb, GwU GK gnvmsev` (!! :-:)|
gvbylK kqZvbi evcK cfve I AvwacZi eovRvj
nZ ivi Rb Zv`iK mZK Ki cig KiYvgq
Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb, ` ` - ' , , , ,
` , . =` ,` . ` ,` . . ` . . =` ,` . `,` , ` , , _ ,
` , ' . Avgvi ev`v`iK ej w`b, Zviv hb hv Dg
Ggb K_vB ej| kqZvb Zv`i ga msNl euvavq|
wbqB kqZvb gvbyli cKvk k (<! <!^ :)|
gnvb Avjvn AviI ejb, ` , ` , ` ,` :` , _` , . =
= , ` ,` ` ` ` , ` . ` ,. ` _ ` , hw` kqZvbi c
_K Avcwb wKQz KzgYv Abyfe Kib, Ze Avj vn&i
kiYvcb nvb| wbqB wZwb mekvZv me (!-
!>! ::)|
gvbyl I wRb RvwZK Avjvn ZvAvjvi Bev`Z Kivi
RbB mw Kiv nqQ| AZtci bex-ivm~jMYi gvag
Rvwbq `qv nqQ Zv`i Rxeb-hvcb cwZ I agxq
weavbvejx| ^qs Avjvn c` GB weavbvejxi wecixZ
KvR Kivi Kvb AeKvk bB gvbe mc `vqi| Zb
Avjvn ZvAvjv e mZK evYx viv gvbe RvwZK evisevi
mveavb KiQb Ges Zv`i c_c`k K gnvbex (Qvt)-
KI mZK Kiv nqQ Zu vi DZi ^c| Dcii
AvqvZjv Zvi my c gvY| gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi c wZ
AwcZ Acwimxg i`vwqZi c vcU Zu vK cy bt cybt
cZv`k viv cZ mZKKvix wnmve NvlYv `Iqv
nqQ| KziAvb GK I AwZxq Avjvn& i Aw Zi weK
h Kvb cKvii aviYv nZ weiZ _vKZ ejv nqQ|
GB mZKevYxi mwVK g~jvqbKvix gy mjgvb`i Rb
Avjvn&i c nZ mymsev` Ges Aeg~jvqbKvix Kvwdi
I gybvwdK`i eRb Kivi msev`I `Iqv nqQ|
AZtci mKj AcKgi nvZv kqZvb nZ mveavb
_vKvi mwekl cZv`k GmQ| kqZvb h Kvb
cwiwwZZ `yej ev`vK c_ KiZ cvi Ges
kwkvjx ev`vKI AvgYi Pv KiZ cvi|






20
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
GgZvevq Avjvn&i kiYvcb nIqv ev Avjvn&i mgxc
AvZmgcY KiZ ne|
Aciw`K gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi evYx I Rxebv`k mgM
wekevmxi Rb GKBfve AbymiYhvM| A_vr Avjvn&i
Av`k, wb`k I mZKevYxi cvkvcvwk gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi
Av`k, wb`k I mZKevYxiI h_vh_ g~jvqb KiZ
ne| bBj Avgv`i Rxebi mKj mrKg mg~n wbj
nq hve| Avjvn ejb, ,` . ` , . ` _ ' `
` , , , . ` ,` ` ,` = , ` ,` _ , ` ,` _` , ` , ` ,` , ,` , ` ` ` ,` -` .` , `
` ,. . ' , ,. ` , Avwg AvcbvK (ivm~j) ciY KiwQ
Aev eKvix ic, mymsev``vZv I fq c`kbKvix
ic| hvZ Zvgiv Avjvn I ivm~ji cwZ wekvm vcb
Ki Ges ZuvK mvb I mvnvh Ki Ges mKvj-mvq
Avjvn&i cweZv NvlYv Ki (!! ->)|
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~ji cwZ Cgvb bv Avbvi cwiYwZ
fqven| hviv Kvdi Zv`iK Rvnvbvg wbc Kiv
ne| Avjvn ejb, = , ` ,` , ` , , ` ,` _ , ` ` ' ` ,
` , , ` , , . ` , ` , ` _ ' , . , ` ` : ` , ` .
., -` _ _,. ` . , . , ` . ` , , . , hviv
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~j wekvm Ki bv, Avwg mme
Kvdii Rb Rj AwM cZ Ki iLwQ| bfvgj
I f~gji ivRZ Avjvn&iB| wZwb hvK BQv gv Kib
Ges hvK BQv kvw `b| wZwb gvkxj, cig
gnievb (!! ::-:)|
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~ji AevaZvi cwiYvg fvj bq;
Zv`iK Avjvn c_Zvq wbcwZZ ejQb| Avjvn
ZvAvjv ejb, , ` ,` . , . = _ .. ` ,`
` , , . ' ,` ' ` ,` _ , , , - ` ,` , . ` = ` , , ` , ,` '
` , ' . . . ` ` ,` _ , Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~j Kvb
KvRi Av`k Kij Kvb Cgvb`vi cyil I Cgvb`vi
bvixi m welq wfb wmv i gZv bB| h ew
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~ji Av`k Agvb Ki, m cKvk
c_Zvq cwZZ nq (!!< ::)|
cwe KziAvb Kixgi evLv I ggvbyhvqx GK_v
myfve cgvwYZ h, bvix-cyil wbwekl DZi
cZKi Dci ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi nK me PvBZ ekx|
^qs gnvb Avjvn ZvAvjv wbR Kvjvg Zuvi Av`k gvb
Kivi mv_ mv_ ivm~ji Av`kI gvb Kivi Kzg
w`qQb| AZtci hviv Zuvi I ivm~ji Av`k Agvb
Kie ev Zuv`iK Awekvm Kie, Zv`i fqven
cwiYwZi welqwUI Dcii AvqvZ DjL Kiv nqQ|
Ze Kvb Cgvb`vi cyil ev Cgvb`vi bvix Avjvn I Zuvi
ivm~ji Av`k cvjb wfbgZ cvlY Ki bv| GKgv
AwekvmxivB Zvq cwZZ nq| G welq nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` _ , ' ,` , ,` . ' ` ,` _ = _. = , ,,
` _ ` ' ` , ` -` , . . ` - . ` _ , ' ` , , ` ,` _ = ` ,
_ , ' , ` ` _ ~ ' - . ` - ` , ` _ . ` _ , '
Avey ivqiv (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) ejQb, Avgvi DZi mKjB Rvb vZ cek
Kie, Ze hviv A^xKvi KiQ Zviv eZxZ| QvnvexMY
wRm Kijb, n Avj vn&i ivm~j (Qvt)! K A^ xKvi
Ki? wZwb ejjb, h ew Avgvi xbi AvbyMZ
Kie, m RvbvZ cek Kie, Avi h ew AvgvK
Agvb Kie mB A^xKvi Ki (<!< !/~)|
Ab nv`xQ GmQ, Avyj vn Beby gvmE` (ivt) nZ
ewYZ wZwb ejb, ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejQb, evK GKwU,
Avi Avwg ejwQ wZxqwU| wZwb ejQb, h ew
Avjvn&i mgK AvQ wekvm iL gZzeiY Ki m
Avb (Rvnvbvg) cek Kie| Avi Avwg ejwQ, h
ew Avjvn&i mgK A^xKvi Ki gZzeiY Ki m
RvbvZ cek Kie (<!<)|
cwe KziAvb nQ mekl Avmgvbx wKZve, hv gnvb
Avjvn&i Zid _K gnvbex gynvv` (Qvt)-Gi Dci
AeZxY nqwQj| Avi nv`xQ nj gy nvv` (Qvt)-Gi
Kvhvejxi weeiY I Zuvi eei A_ev Avj-KziAvbi
ev e ic| Qnxn eyLvixi DcivwjwLZ nv`xQ `ywU
gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi cZ I civ mZKevYxi cgvY|
cmZ DjL h, gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi hveZxq nv`xQ
msiwZ nqQ| myZivs cwe KziAvb I nv`xQ Dfq
mZKevYxi j I Dk GK I Awfb| Gme nv`xQi
mg_bcy AviI e AvqvZ iqQ|
AvwLivZK wg_v cwZcb Kij mKj Kg evwZj nq
hvq| G evcvi Avjvn gvbylK mZK Ki ejb, ` , ,
` ,` , ` ,` , ` ' ` . = - , -. . , , , . .` , ,` -` ,
` ,` . ` ,. ` , . eZt hviv wg_v RbQ Avgvi
AvqvZ mg~K Ges AvLivZi mvvrK, Zv`i hveZxq
KvRKg asm nq MQ| Zgb e`jvB m cve hgb
Avgj m KiZ (!<! :)|
Ab gnvb Avjvn ejb, ~ ' ` = _ , ` ` ,
` ,` ,` -` ` _ ` , . ` ` , , . ` , ' , . AZtci Zvi
Pq eo hvjg K AvQ, h Avjvn&i cwZ Acev`
Avivc KiQ wKsev Zuvi AvqvZ mg~ nK wg_v cwZcb
KiQ? KwbKvjI cvcx`i Kvb KjvY nq bv
( :)|






21
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Avjvn Zuvi wcq nvexe (Qvt)-K j Ki ejb, _.`
` ` ` ' ` , ' ` , -` , ` _ ` , . ` , . ' , ` . . ,.`
` , . , Avcwb Avgvi ev`v`iK Rvwbq w`b h, Avwg
AZ gvkxj I `qvjy Ges GUvI Rvwbq w`b h,
Avgvi kvw B hYv`vqK kvw (l>< >-)| G mKj
AvqvZ Avjvn&i mZKevYx we`gvb|
Avjvn&i iY _K D`vmxb _vKj kqZvb ZvK c_
KiZ Pv Ki| G cm gnvb Avjvn ejb, ` , ` ` ,
` ` , , ` , , ` ,` , =` , ` ` ` , ` ` - ` h ew
`qvgq Avjvn&i iY _K PvL wdwiq bq (fyj
_vK), Avwg Zvi Rb GK kqZvb wbqvwRZ Ki `B,
AZtci mB nq Zvi mx (< ::)|
cwe KziAvbi GB Afvebxq evYx GKw`K gvbeZvK
Avjvn&i iY Wye _vKvi Avnvb RvwbqQ, Aciw`K
mZKZv Aej^bi HKvw K `xvI c`vb KiQ| myZivs
k ag Bmjvg myivq Avjvn&i iY hgb Acwinvh,
Abyicfve Avjvn&i mZKevYxi AbymiYI GKBfve
cqvRb| BnKvjxb Rxebi cwimgvwi ci ciKvjxb
Rxeb cek gyn~ZB Avjvn&i mZKevYxi cfve cwZdwjZ
ne| Avi wek ev`v`i cB GZ`msv welq
wKQzUv aviYv ARb Kiv me| AZtci G`iK
KjvYi c_ wdivbvi jB cwe KziAvb GB
mZKevYx m^wjZ AvqvZjv mshvRb Kiv nqQ|
eZ mKj mZKevYxi g~j DkB nQ gvbylK
mskvabi gvag Zv`i gywi c_ cwiPvwjZ Kiv|
gnvb Avjvn ejb,
` , ` , . . _ , ' , , - . , . ` ' _. ` , ` ` _
_ = . _ ` ' ` . , . ` _ , , . . ,` ` -` , ,
_ ` ' . _ , , ` ` ,` , . . ` ` ` - ' ,
,` -` . _ ` ' ` , _ ` - , . ` , . _ .` , , ` , ,
Avgvi `vwqZ c_c`kb Kiv| Avi Avwg gvwjK
BnKvji I ciKvji| AZGe Avwg Zvgv`iK
cwjZ AwM mK mZK Ki w`qwQ| GZ wbZv
nZfvM ewB cek Kie, h wg_vivc Ki I gyL
wdwiq bq| G _K `~i ivLv ne Avjvnfxi
ewK| h AvZwi Rb Zvi ab-m` eq Ki
Ges Zvi Dci KviI Kvb cwZ`vbhvM AbyMn _vK bv,
Zvi gnvb cvjbKZvi mw A^lY ewZZ, m mZiB
mw jvf Kie (!-! :~-~:)|
Dcii AvqvZjvZ Acivax`i j Ki cwjZ
AwMKzi A_vr Rvnvbvgi fxwZ c`kb Kiv nqQ|
Aciw`K Avjvnfxi I Avjvn& i mw A^lYKvix`i
cyivcywi Afq `Iqv nqQ|
gnvbex gynvv` (Qvt)-Gi Ag~ jevYx Z_v nv`xQ
c_Kfve msiwZ nqQ nv`xQ M| cwe KziAvbi
mZK evYxi bvq, nv`xQ MI e mZKevYx iqQ|
D`vniY ^ic GKwU nv`xQ ck Kiv nj,
` ` , ` - ` , . , ` , , . ` ` ` , '` , . ` ,` _ =
_. = , ,, ,` , - ` .` , '` ' ` .` ,`
- . ' ` _ _` ` , ` . , ` ,` _ = ` ` ` _ ` , -
, , . - = , , . ,` , - , ` , ,` , - ` ,
` , . ` . , ` , : ` ,` ` ,` , - .` , ` , ,
` - . ` . , ` ` - ` ` , ` ,` ` , , . ,` , , . ` ` ,`
` ,` ,` ` , ` ` , . ` . , ` , : ,` , - ` , .` ,
` _ . ,` , ' . ,` , - ` ` ,` , , - ' ,` , ` , ,, . ` .
, ` ,` _ = ` ,` , . . ` ,` ` . - .,` , ,
' , . ` . ` _ ` ,` ' . ` _ _` ' : ` , -
` , ` ` ` ,` , , . ` . . , ` , ` , ` ,` , - . , `
, ` : , . , ` , , . ' ` ` ` . ' , . , -
_` - : _` ` , .` .` , .` ' , _ : -
hvqdv Bebyj Bqvgvb (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb,
jvKiv ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi wbKU KjvYKi welq
mK ck KiZ| Avi Avwg AKjvYKi welq mK
wRm KiZvg, GZ Avgvi cwZZ nIqvi fq| ZvB
Avwg wRm Kijvg, Bqv ivm~ jvjvn! Avgiv g~L Zv I
AKjvYi ga wQjvg| AZtci Avj vn ZvAvjv
Avgv`i G KjvY (Cgvb) `vb KiQb, Ze wK G
KjvYi ci cybivq AKjvY (msNwUZ) ne? wZwb
ejjb, nuv ne| Avwg ejjvg, mB AKjvYi ciI
wK cybivq KjvY Avme? wZwb ejjb, nuv Avme| Ze
Zv a~qvhy (wbfRvj) ne| wRm Kijvg, `yLvb
(a~qv) A_ wK? wZwb ejjb, jvKiv Avgvi c_ eZxZ
Ab c_ Aej^b Kie| Zv`i c nZ fvj I g`
DfqB Zzwg cZ Kie| Avwg ejjvg, AZtci G
KjvYi ci wK cybivq AKjvY Avme? wZwb ejjb,
nuv Avme| Zv GB h, Rvnvbvgi w`K KZK
AvnvbKvix ne, hviv Zv`i Avnvb mvov w`e,
Zv`iK Zviv Rvnvbvg wbc Kie| Avwg ejjvg, n
Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt)! Avgv`iK Zv`i cwiPq Rvwbq
w`b| wZwb ejjb, Zviv Avgv`i gZB ne Ges






22
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Avgv`i K_vi bvqB K_v eje| Avwg ejjvg, Avwg m
Aevq DcbxZ nj AvgvK wK wb`k `b? (Avgvi
KiYxq wK ne)? wZwb ejjb, ZLb AekB
gymjgvb`i RvgvAvZ (msMVb) I gymjgvb`i BgvgK
AuvKo ai _vKe| Avwg ejjvg, m mgq hw` Kvb
gymwjg msMVb I gymwjg Bgvg bv _vK (ZLb Avgv`i
KiYxq wK)? wZwb ejjb, eg~jK aviY Ki njI
mme (Kzdix) `jK cwiZvM Ki Pje| GgbwK G
Aevq Zvgv`i gZz DcwZ nq hve, A_P Zzwg H
AevqB _vKe (A_vr evwZj wdiKv _K weiZ _K
`pfve nK aviY Ki _vKe) (!! !!, l!
!/:~)|
ev`vi cwZ Avjvn&i mZKevYxi bvq gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi
mZKevYxiI h cqvRbxqZv iqQ, Dcii AvjvPbvq
Zv my nq DVQ| Avjvn&i mZKevYxK cZ
NvlYv Ges gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi mZKevYxK civ
NvlYv ejv hZ cvi| Ze Dfq mZKevYxi j-
Dk GK I Awfb| AZGe Avgiv mev KiY GK
Avjvn&i Av`k I Zvi ev evqbKvix gnvbex (Qvt)-Gi
evYxi mg^q Avgv`i fwelZ Kgcv mywi Kie|
Avjvn Avgv`i ZvIdxK `vb Kib-Avgxb!





















keeivZ
!-!<
Aviex kvevb gvmi 14 ZvwiL w`evMZ ivZK
mvaviYfve keeivZ ev jvqjvZzj evivAvZ , .,
._. , ejv nq| keeivZ kwU dvimx| Gi A_
wnm&mv ev wb`k cvIqvi ivw| wZxq kwU Aviex| hvi
A_ weQ` ev gywi ivw| G`k keeivZ mfvM
iRbx wnmveB cvwjZ nq| GRb miKvix QywU NvwlZ
nq| jvKiv aviYv Ki h, G ivZ ev`vn&i bvn gvd
nq| Avqy I ihx ew Kiv nq| mviv eQii nvqvZ-
gDZi I fvMi iwRvi wjwLZ nq| GB ivZ
injv me AvZxq-^ Rbi mv_ gy jvKvZi Rb
cw_exZ bg Avm| wekl Ki weaeviv gb Kib h,
Zv`i ^vgx`i in H ivZ Ni di| GRb Nii
ga Avjv Rj weaevMY mviv ivZ gZ ^vgxi ini
AvMgbi Avkvq eyK eua em _vKb| evmMn ayc-aybv,
AvMievwZ, gvgevwZ BZvw` w`q AvjvwKZ Kiv nq|
AMwYZ evj Rvwjq AvjvKmv Kiv nq| GRb
miKvix cyiviI NvlYv Kiv nq| AvZxqiv me `j
`j Mvivb QyU hvq| nvjyqv-iwUi wnwoK co hvq|
Qjiv cUKv dvwUq AvZkevwR Ki n-jvo ivZ
KvwUq `q| hviv KLbv QvjvZ Af bq, ZvivI H
ivZ gmwR` wMq QvjvZ Avj& wdqvn , ,. . ,
ev 100 ivKAvZ QvjvZ Av`vq iZ nq, hLvb cwZ
ivKAvZ 10 evi Ki m~ivq BLjvQ cov nq| msc
GB nj G`k keeivZi bvg c PwjZ Bmjvgx ce i
ev e wP|
<x|< ||
gvUvgywU `ywU agxq AvK x`vB Gi wfw wnmve KvR Ki
_vK| 1. H ivZ ev`vn&i bvn gvd nq| AvMvgx GK
eQii Rb fvj-g` ZvK`xi wbavwiZ nq Ges GB ivZ
KziAvb bvwhj nq| 2. H ivZ inwj Qvov cq gZ
bg Avm| nvjyqv-iwU mK ejv nq _vK h, Hw`b
Avjvn&i bex (Qvt)-Gi `v`vb gyeviK Inv`i hy
knx` nqwQj| e_vi Rb wZwb big Lv` wnmve
nvjyqv-iwU LqwQjb weavq Avgv`iI mB e_vq
mge`bv cKvk Kivi Rb nvjyqv-iwU LZ nq| A_P
Inv`i hy nqwQj 3q wnRixi kvIqvj gvmi 11
ZvwiL kwbevi mKvj ejvq| Avi Avgiv e_v Aby fe
KiwQ Zvi cvq `ygvm c~e kvevbi 14 ZvwiL w`evMZ
iv...! GY Avgiv Dciv welqwji agxq wfw
KZUzKz Zv LuyR `Le| c_gwUi mc h me AvqvZ I
nv`xQ ck Kiv nq, Zv wbic: 1. m~ ivq `yLvb-Gi 3 I
4 bs AvqvZ-






23
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
` , _ ` ` ` ` _ ` ` , ` _ ` ,` ` . ` , ` , ,` ,
,` , - ,` '
A_: (3) Avgiv Zv GwU AeZxY KiwQ GK gyeviK
iRbxZ; Avgiv Zv mZKKvix (4) G iRbxZ cZK
iZc~Y welq wixKZ nq| nvdh Beb KvQxi (701-
774 wnt) ^xq Zvdmxi ejb, GLvb gyeviK iRbx A_
jvqjvZzj K`i| hgb m~ivq K`i 1g AvqvZ Avjvn
ejb, _` . . ` , ` _ ` ,` ` wbqB Avgiv GUv
bvwhj KiwQ K`ii ivwZ| Avi mwU nj ivgvhvb
gvm| hgb m~ivq evKvivn&i 185 bs AvqvZ Avjvn
ejb, . .` ,. .` , ,` ' ` . . _ `,` , GB mB
ivgvhvb gvm hvi ga KziAvb AeZxY nqQ| GB ivZ
GK kvevb nZ AviK kvevb ch ev`vi ihx, weq-
kv`x, Rb-gZz BZvw` wjwce nq ej h nv`xQ
cPvwiZ AvQ, Zv gyimvj I hCd Ges KziAvb I Qnxn
nv`xQ mg~ni weivax nIqvi KviY AMnYhvM| wZwb
ejb, K`i iRbxZB jIn gvndh msiwZ fvMwjwc
nZ c_K Ki AvMvgx GK eQii wb`kvejx Z_v gZz,
wiwhK I Abvb NUbvejx hv msNwUZ ne, mwj jLK
dikZvMYi wbKU c`vb Kiv nq| GicfveB ewYZ
nqQ Avyjvn web Igi, gyRvwn`, Avey gvwjK, hvn&nvK
cgyL mvjvd Qvjnxbi wbKU nZ|
AZtci ZvK`xi mK cwe KziAvbi _nxb ee
nj-
,` ,' , _ ` ` , .` , ` , = ` ` ,` , ` , ,` , . ,
A_: Zv`i mg KvhKjvc AvQ Avgjbvgvq, AvQ
z` I enr mg wKQyB wjwce (!!< ~-:)|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Gikv` Kib, ` - ,` , = .
` -` , .' . .. ' ` , .` - , ` _' , . , ` ..
Avmgvb mg~n I hgxb mwi cvk nvhvi ermi c~eB
Avjvn ZvAvjv ^xq gvLj~KvZi ZvK`xi wjL iLQb
(l !/::>)| Avey ivqivn (ivt)-K ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) ejb, Zvgvi fvM hv AvQ Zv NUe; G welq
Kjg wKq MQ (cybivq ZvK`xi wjwLZ ne bv)|
GY keeivZ cwZeQi fvM wjwce nq ej h
aviYv cPwjZ AvQ, Zvi Kvb Qnxn wfw bB| eis
jvqjvZzj evivAvZ ev fvMiRbx bvgwUB m~Y evbvqvU
I DkcYvw`Z| Bmjvgx kixAvZ GB bvgi Kvb
Aw Z LuyR cvIqv hvq bv|
evKx iBj GB ivZ bvn gvd nIqvi welq| mRb
w`b wQqvg cvjb I ivZ Bev`Z KiZ nq| A Zt
100 kZ ivKAvZ QvjvZ Av`vq KiZ nq| cwZ
ivKAvZ m~ivq dvwZnv I 10 evi Ki m~ivq Kyj
Iqvjv- Avnv` coZ nq| GB QvjvZwU Mvmj Ki
Av`vq Kij Mvmji c wZ du vUv cvwbZ 700 kZ
ivKAvZ bdj QvjvZi QIqve cvIqv hvq BZvw`|
G mK cavb h wZbwU `jxj ck Kiv nq _vK, Zv
wbic:
1. Avjx (ivt) nZ ewYZ ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Gikv` Kib,
` , ` ,` ` , . ` ` .` .` ` , ` . ` ,` ` ,.` . , . ,
_ _ , ga kvevb Gj Zvgiv ivwZ Bev`Z Ki
I w`b wQqvg cvjb Ki| Kbbv Avjvn cvK Hw`b
m~hv i ci `ywbqvi Avmgvb bg Avmb I ejb,
AvQ wK KD gv cv_bvKvix, Avwg ZvK gv Ki `e;
AvQ wK KD ihx cv_x Avwg ZvK ihx `e| AvQ wK
Kvb ivMx, Avwg ZvK AvivM `vb Kie|
GB nv`xQwUi mb` Beby Avex mve&ivn bvg GKRb
ivex AvQb, whwb nv`xQ RvjKvix| m KviY nv`xQwU
gynvQxbi wbKU hCd|
wZxqZt nv`xQwU Qnxn nv`xQi weivax nIqvq
AMnYhvM| Kbbv GKB gg cwm nv`xQ byh~j Beby
gvRvn&i 98 cvq gv Avqkv (ivt) nZ (nv/1366)
Ges eyLvix kixdi (gxivU Qvcv 1328 wnt) 153, 936
I 1116 cvq Ges Kz Zze wmvn mn Abvb nv`xQ
M megvU 30 Rb Qvnvex KZK ewY Z nqQ| mLvb
ga kvevb bv ej c wZ ivwi kl ZZxqvsk ejv
nqQ| AZGe Qnxn nv`xQ mg~ni eY bvby hvqx
AvjvncvK cwZ ivwi ZZxq cni wb AvKvk AeZiY
Ki ev`vK dRii mgq ch Dciv Avnvb Ki
_vKb; aygv wbw`fve ga kvevbi GKwU ivwZ
bq|
2. gv Avqkv (ivt) nZ ewY Z ivm~ jyjvn (Qvt) GK`v
ivwZ GKvKx g`xbvi evKx Mvivb wMqwQjb|
mLvb wZwb GK chvq AvqkvK j Ki ejb, ga
kvevbi w`evMZ ivZ Avjvn `ywbqvi Avmgvb bg
Avmb Ges Kj&e Mvi QvMj mg~ ni jvg msLvi
PvBZ AwaK msLK jvKK gvd Ki _vKb| GB
nv`xQwUZ nvvR web AviZvZ bvgK GKRb ivex
AvQb, hvi mb` gybK vZv nIqvi KviY Bgvg eyLvix
c gyL gynvwQMY nv`xQwUK hCd ejQb|
cKvk _vK h, wbQd kvevb-Gi dhxjZ mK
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) nZ Kvb Qnxn gid nv`xQ bB|
3. Bgivb web QvBb (ivt) ejb h, GK`v ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) RbK ewK ejb h, Zzwg wK wmivi
kvevbi wQqvg iLQ? jvKwU ejjb, bv| Avj vn&i
bex (Qvt) ZvK ivgvhvbi ci wQqvg `ywUi K vhv Av`vq
KiZ ejjb|






24
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Rgn~i wevbMYi gZ wmivi A_ gvmi kl| D
ew kvevbi klvewa wbavwiZ wQqvg cvjb Af
wQjb A_ev HUv Zvi gvbZi wQqvg wQj| ivgvhvbi
m wgwkq djvi wblavv jsNbi fq wZwb
kvevbi kli wQqvg `ywU ev` `b| mKviY ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) ZvK H wQqvgi Kvhv Av`vq KiZ ejb| eySv
Mj h, GB nv`xQwUi m cPwjZ keeivZi Kvb
mK bB|
<<<|< v||
GB ivwi 100 kZ ivKAvZ QvjvZ mK h nv`xQ
ejv nq _vK Zv gIh~ ev Rvj| GB QvjvZ 448
wnRixZ mec_g evqZzj gyKvvm gmwR` AvweKZ
nq| hgb wgkKvZzj gvQvexn-Gi LvZbvgv Aviex
fvlKvi gvjv Avjx Kvix nvbvdx (gt 1014 wnt) Avj-
jvAvjx KZvei eivZ ejb, RygAv I C`vqbi
QvjvZi Pq iZ w`q QvjvZ Avj&wdqvn bvg GB
ivZ h QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv nq Ges Gi mc hme
nv`xQ I AvQvi ejv nq, Zvi meB evbvqvU I gIh~
A_ev hCd| GB we`AvZ 448 wnRixZ mec_g
Rihvjgi evqZzj gyKvvm gmwR` cewZZ nq|
gmwR`i g~L BgvgMY Abvb QvjvZi m hy Ki
GB QvjvZ Pvjy Kib| Gi gvag Zviv RbmvaviYK
GKwZ Kivi Ges gvZeix Kiv I cU cywZ Kivi
GKUv dw` GuUwQj gv| GB we`AvZx QvjvZi evcK
RbwcqZv `L bK&Kvi-cinhMvi ewMY Avjvn&i
Mhe hgxb am hvIqvi fq kni Qo Rj cvwjq
wMqwQjb|
GB ivZ gmwR` wMq GKvKx ev RvgvAvZ efve
QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv, whKi-AvhKvi wj nIqv mK
Rvbv hvq h, kvgi wKQy wevb GUv c_g i Kib|
Zviv GB ivZ my`i cvlvK ci, AvZi-myigv jvwMq
gmwR` wMq ivw RvMiY KiZ _vKb| ci welqwU
jvK`i ga Qwoq co| gv-g`xbvi AvjgMY Gi
Zxe weivwaZv Kib| wK kvgi wevb`i `Lv`wL
wKQy jvK Gjv KiZ i Ki| GBfve GwU
RbmvaviY ew jvf Ki|
<< |x-
GB ivwZ evKxG MviKv` bvgK Keivb ivZi
ejvq ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi wbtm Aevq hqviZ KiZ
hvIqvi nv`xQwU (< !>! !/::>) h hCd I gybKvZv
Zv Avgiv BwZc~e `L GmwQ| GLb ck njt GB
ivZ mwZ mwZB injv Bjxb ev wmxb nZ
mvgwqKfve Qvov cq cw_exZ bg Avm wK-bv|
hv`i gvMdivZ Kvgbvi Rb Avgiv `j `j
Keivbi w`K QyU hvB| GgbwK gq`i Rb Kei
hqviZ Awm njI Zv`iKI G ivZ Keivb `Lv
hvq| G mK mvaviYZt m~ ivq K`i-Gi 4 I 5bs
AvqvZ `ywU ck Kiv nq _vK| hLvb ejv nqQ,
.` ,` ' ` ` , ,` , _ . ,, ,` , ` _` ,` , , : ` ,
,` - _ = _` - _
m ivwZ wdwikZvMY I in AeZxY nq Zv`i
cwZcvjKi AbygwZg| mKj welq Kej kvw;
Elvi D`qKvj ch| GLvb m ivw ejZ jvqjvZzj
K`i ev keK`iK eySvbv nqQ- hv GB m~ ivi 1g, 2q
I 3q AvqvZ ejv nqQ|
A m~ivq in AeZxY nq K_vwU iqQ weavq nqZev
AbK aviYv Ki wbqQb h, gZ ew`i inwj me
`ywbqvq bg Avm| A_P GB A_ Kvb wevb Kibwb|
in kwU GKePb| G mK nvdh Beb KvQxi
(int) ^xq Zvdmxi ejb, GLvb in ejZ
wdwikZvMYi mi`vi wReivCjK eySvbv nqQ|
|'<|- x|< +<|<
ivgvhvbi AvMi gvm wnmve kvevb gvmi cavb KiYxq
nj AwaKnvi wQqvg cvjb Kiv| gv Avqkv (ivt)
ejb, Avwg ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-K ivgvhvb eZxZ Ab
Kvb gvm kvevbi bvq GZ AwaK wQqvg cvjb KiZ
`wLwb| kli w`K wZwb gv KqKwU w`b wQqvg ZvM
KiZb| hviv kvevbi c_g _K wbqwgZ wQqvg cvjb
Kib, Zv`i Rb kli cbi w`b wQqvg cvjb Kiv
DwPZ bq| Aek hw` KD Af nb ev gvbZ Ki
_vKb, Zviv kli w`KI wQqvg cvjb Kieb|
gvUK_v kvevb gvm AwaK nvi bdj wQqvg cvjb Kiv
mybvZ| Qnxn `jxj eZxZ Kvb w`b ev ivZK wQqvg I
Bev`Zi Rb wbw` Kiv mybvZi eiLjvd| Aek hviv
AvBqvg exh-Gi wZb w`b bdj wQqvg Af, Zviv
13, 14 I 15B kvevb D wbqZB wQqvg cvjb
Kieb, keeivZi wbqZ bq| wbqZi Mvjgvj nj
Kej K KivB mvi ne| Kbbv we`AvZx Kvb Avgj
Avjvn cvK Keyj Kib bv Ges mKj cKvi we`AvZB
Zv I cZvLvZ| Avjvn Avgv`i mevBK cwe
KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi AvjvK wbR wbR Avgj mg~n
cwi Ki bIqvi ZvIdxK `vb Kib- Avgxb!!










25
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
x|-<||<+|< #|x
! !
(2q wKw)
#|x< -|f+| x|-<||<+|<< <| x|<+|
gvbevwaKvi (Human Rights) kwU AvaywbK RMZ
AwZ cwiwPZ I eenviMZ GKwU k wnmve vb Ki
wbjI Gi gwjK aviYv I eenvi wK e cvPxb|
evBej, KziAvb I wevbi AvjvK Rvbv hvq cw_ex
mwi inm wK? KD KD ejQb, gnvwek mw nqwQj
1,600 KvwU eQi AvM| A_vr GUv cw_ex mwi 460
KvwU eQi AvM| GZ cvYi De NU meZ 350
KvwU eQi AvM| Avi gvbyl GmQ 1 j eQi
AvM|
75
KviI gZ, cw_exZ gvbyli AvMgb KqK
j eQi c~e| KD ejb, Av`g (Avt) _K Beivnxg
(Avt)-Gi mgqKvji eeavb gvUvgywU fve Ewbk kZ
eQi| Aaybv wnmve Ki `Lv MQ h, nhiZ Beivnxg
(Avt) Lc~e 1850 mvji w`K RxweZ wQjb| cv GB
wnmvei mv_ evBeji wnmve hvM Ki wbj `Lv
hvq, `ywbqvZ c_g gvbyl (Av`g Avt)-Gi Avwefve
NUwQj Lc~e gv 38 kZ eQi AvM|
76
Bmjvgx
cwZMY GB mgqKvjK AwaK hywmZ Kvj wnmve
ai wbqQb| hw` ZvB-B nq Zvnj G wekRMZi
mfvMevb I weivU `nveqei AwaKvix huvi DPZv
wQj 60 nvZ
77
Av`g (Avt)-Gi mgqKvj A_ev
ZrcieZxZ gvbevwaKvii Kvb NUbv Avgv`i
`wMvPi nq wK-bv| cKZc gnvb Avjvn ZvAvjv
Av`g (Avt) I wewe nvIqv (Avt)-K cw_exZ
cvwVqwQjb `ywbqvZ gvbevwaKvi cwZvi Rb| Zuvi
ci b~n (Avt), Beivnxg (Avt) cgyL _K kl bex
gynvv` (Qvt)-Gi AvMgb NUwQj| GiKg 315 Rb
ivm~j mn 1 j 24 nvhvi
78
cqM^i aivavg cwiZ nb
gvbeZv cwZvi j| hvi cwic~Y BwZnvm I NUbv
KziAvb I nv`xQ weklY Kij Rvbv hvq| hgb-
Kzievbx Keyj nIqvi NUbvK K` Ki kqZvbi
civPbvq Kvwej Zvi mnv`i fvB nvwejK wbggfve
nZv KiwQj| ci Kvwej Zvi KZKgi Rb AbyZ
nqwQj| wK Abvqfve nZvKv NUvbvi Rb

75. Agj `vk , gvbyli wVKvbv, 13 I 14 ct|
76. Wt gwim eyKvBwj, evBej, KziAvb I wevb, icv i AvLZvi
Dj Avjg, (XvKv : vb cKvkbx, 1986), 120-121 ct|
77. wgkKvZ, nv/5336|
78. gynvv` Avmv`yjvn Avj-Mvwje, bex`i Kvwnbx, 1g L
(ivRkvnx : nv`xQ dvDkb evsjv`k, 2010), ct 9|
cw_exZ msNwUZ Abvq nZvKvi cvci GKUv Ask
Zvi Dci eZve| G mK ivm~j (Qvt) ejb,
Abvqfve Kvb gvbyl wbnZ nj ZvK Lyb Kivi
cvci GKUv Ask Av`g (Avt)-Gi c_g cy Kvweji
Avgjbvgvq hy nq| Kbbv mB c_g nZvi m~Pbv
Ki|
79
wZwb AviI ejb, h ew Zvi fvBqi mvb
nvwb ev Ab Kvb cKvii hyjyg KiQ, m hb Zvi
_K AvRB Zv wgwUq bq| mB w`b Avmvi AvM
hw`b Zvi wbKU `xbvi I w`invg (^Y I ic gy`v)
wKQzB _vKe bv| hw` Zvi wbKU Kvb mrKg _vK, Zvi
hyjyg cwigvY bKx mLvb _K wbq bIqv ne| Avi
hw` Kvb bKx bv _vK, Zvnj ghj~gi cvc mg~n wbq
hvwjgi Dci Pvwcq `Iqv ne|
80

D gg KziAvb ewYZ nqQ ` - , , _` . ' , ` ,` , ' `
` ,` ` , ` , , ` '` ` , , ` , , ' ` ,` ,. , . Avi Zviv
AekB wbRi cvc fvi enb Kie I Zvi mv_ Ab`i
cvc fvi Ges Zviv hme wg_vivc Ki, m mK
wKqvgZi w`b AekB wRvwmZ ne (!!< ~>/::)|
AZGe Abvqfve gvbyl nZv Kiv RNb Aciva ev cvc,
hv gvbe mwi c_g w`Ki Kvwnbx _KB eySv hvq|
meZ Acivai wePvi I kvw i ee vi Rb AvBb
Av`vjZ GiB avivevwnKZv Qvov wKQzB bq| AvaywbK
gvbevwaKvii Drcw I aviYv GfveB GmQ m`n
bB| Kbbv gvbyl wkLQ h KD KvDK Abvqfve
nZv Kij, KD KviI Dci hyjyg Kij ev AZvPvi
Kij Zvi Rb wbRK hgb ciKvj P~ ov Revew`wn
KiZ nq, Abyic BnKvjI Zvi KZKgi `iY kvw I
Revew`wnZvi Pig ee v iqQ Ges Zv Kej GKwU
cwZ gvZveK cqvM Kiv nq|
Gw`K `ywbqvex eevcbvi mKj vb Av`gK `Iqv
nqwQj Ges Zvi gvagB cw_exZ c_g f~ wg Avev` I
PvKv PvwjZ cwienYi m~ Pbv nq| Avi me wKQz B m w
nqQ gvbyli mevi Rb| Avi gvbyl mw nqQ
Avjvn& i `vmZi Rb|
81
Ab GK NUbvq weaZ nqQ
KIgi Awekvmx bZviv RbMYK wev Kivi Rb b~ n
(Avt)-Gi wei cuvPwU Avcw Dvcb KiwQj, Gi
ga AbZg GKwU nj Avcbvi Abymvix nj Avgv`i
ga wbZv B nxb I Mixe, ZvI Avevi Kg eyw mb,
Avi Avgv`i Ici Zvgv`i Kvb k ZI Avgiv `LwQ

79. eyLvix nv/3335; gymwjg, wZiwghx, Beby gvRvn, wgkKvZ nv/221 Bjg Aavq|
80. eyLvix, nv/2449; wgkKvZ wkvPvi Aavq, hy jy g Aby Q`, ct 21|
81. bex`i Kvwnbx, 1g L, ct 50|






26
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
bv, Zv`i GB Avcwi Reve b~ n (Avt) ejb, ` , , ,
. _. = , ' , = _ . ,` - ' . . ` , ` , '` '
. .` , ,` - ` , ` , _ ' ` . , ` , ,` , _ , ' ,` ,` ,` ` ,
` ` , , , ` ` ,` .` , = . .` ,` , ' ` ,` ,' , ~
Avwg Kvb (Mixe) Cgvb`vi ewK Zvwoq w`Z cvwi
bv| Zviv AekB Zv`i cvjbKZvi `x`vi jvf ab ne|
eis Avwg Zvgv`i g~L `LwQ| n Avgvi KIg! Avwg hw`
Hme jvK`i Zvwoq `B, Zvnj K AvgvK Avjvn&i
cvKovI _K iv Kie? Zvgiv wK Dc`k MnY Kie
bv? ( ::/~>-: !!<! ~:/:::-::)|
Dciv AvqvZ _K nq h, gnvb Avjvn Mixe-
abx ew`i ga Kvb cv_K Kibwb; eis Zv`i
(xbx Mixe-wgmKxb)-K AbK ghv`v w`qQb, hv cvq
mvo cuvP nvhvi eQi c~e b~n (Avt) gvidZ NvwlZ
nqQ| eZgvb RMZi ivRv-ev`kvn abx-Mixe, DPz-wbPz
ej gvbyl gvbyl Kvb f`vf` bB(?) ej h
AvIqvR Zvjv nq, Zv GiB AwZ cvPxbZg HwZnvwmK
`jxj ej ^xKZ| Lc~e qv`k kZvxZ wgkii
ZrKvjxb mgvU divDb hLb Av`k w`jb, Kvb B`x
cwievi cy m vb RbMnY KijB hb nZv Kiv nq|
cwiKbv Abyhvqx divDb I Zvi gxiv mviv `k
GK`j avx gwnjv I Qzwiavix Rjv` wbqvM Ki|
gwnjviv evox evox wMq eby BmivCji MfeZx
gwnjv`i ZvwjKv KiZ Ges cmei w`b nvwRi nq
`LZ, Qj bv gq| Qj nj cyil Rjv`K Lei
w`Z| m Gm Qzwi w`q gvqi mvgb m vbK hen
Ki dj iL Pj hZ|
82
Gfve eby BmivCji Ni
Ni Kvbvi ivj co hZ| G NUbvwU g~mvi c~e wk
Aevq| AZtci g~mv (Avt) eo nj ^ivPvix kvmK
divEbi Gme jvgnlK nZv, wbhvZb-wbcxobi
cwZev` `xK ejjb, . ` , , - ` ` ,` ,` , `
` , _ ` _ ` ` , :` ,` _ . ' . ` , -, ' ` `
_ ,. , . _ . eby BmivCj`i Dci
wbcxob Kiv bv| Avgiv Avjvn&i wbKU _K Anx jvf
KiwQ h, h ew wg_vivc Ki I gyL wdwiq bq
Zvi Dci Avjvn&i Avhve bg Avm (-! ~/-)|
GLvb _K eySv hvq h, m mgqi gvbeZv weivax
Abvq AZvPvii cwZev` Kiv nqwQj|

82. Zvdmxi Beb KvQxi, KvQvQ 89; bex`i Kvwnbx, 2q L, ct 16|
Gi ciB `Lv hvq Beivnxg (Avt) Avj vn& i GKZev`K
ai ivLvi Rb wcZv Avhii Av`k Agvb Kij wcZv
ejjb, n Beivnxg! Zzwg wK Avgvi Dcvm`i _K gyL
wdwiq wbQ? hw` Zzwg weiZ bv nI, Ze Avwg AekB
cv_i gi Zvgvi gv_v P~Y Ki `e| Zzwg Avgvi myL
nZ wPiw`bi Rb `~i nq hvI (!l<! :>/:)|
wcZvi GB KVvi agwK b Beivnxg (Avt) ejjb,
' , - ` , . ` ` ` ` , _ : ` , ` ` ' :` , ` ` , , ` ' , .
' ' _ ` ` , _ ,` ` ' , = .` ,` ` .` ,` ` , . ` , .` ,
' , ` ` , _ Zvgvi Dci kvw ewl Z nK! Avwg Avgvi
cvjbKZvi wbKU Zvgvi Rb gv c v_ bv Kie|
wbwqB wZwb Avgvi cwZ gnievb (!l<! :>/-)|
GLvb wcZv-gvZvK h mvb I gvbeZv `Lvbv nqQ
Zv my| GQvov wcZvi mnhvwMZvq gykwiKiv
ZvInx`cx Beivnxgi Dci AgvbweK AZvPvi-
wbcxob, wbzi AvPiY, Avb wbc Kivi gZ
jvgnlK NUbv NUvjI wZwb wcZvi cwZ Awfkvc `bwb
eis Avjvn&i `ievi LvjQ A i Zvi Rb `vAv
KiQb| wcZv-gvZvi c wZ Ggb gvbeZv c`kbi bex
Avi LuyR cvIqv hvq bv| Gfve chvjvPbv Kij `Lv
hve hyM hyM bexMY iL MQb gvbevwaKvi cwZvi
`v| Ze mekl kl I wek bex gynvv` (Qvt) ay
H mgqi eei wbzi gvbyli Rb bq mehyM me kYxi
gvbyli Rb gvbevwaKvi cwZvi GK Abycg `v
vcb Ki MQb, hv 631 L v gvZveK Avivdvn
gq`vb `kg wnRixZ c` we`vq ni HwZnvwmK
fvlY DjL iqQ| 8g wnRixZ 1 j 40 A_ev 44
nvhvi jvKi
83
myL ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi fvlY wek
gvbeZv Z_v gvbevwaKvi cwZvi Rb mKj gvbyli
KvQ GUv gnvKvji gnvmb` wnmve ^xK Z|
we`vq ni fvlY wekbex (Qvt) gvbevwaKvi mwK Z
h mb`c NvlYv Kib, `ywbqvi BwZnvm Zv AvRI
AZzjbxq| mw`b wZwb x K NvlYv KiwQjb| (1) n
ezMY! iY iL, AvRKi Gw`b, G gvm Ges G cwe
bMix Zvgv`i wbKU hgb cwe, Zgwb cwe Zvgv`i
mKji Rxeb, Zvgv`i ab-m`, i Ges Zvgv`i
gvb-ghv`v Zvgv`i ciii wbKU cwe| KLbI Kviv
Dci Abvq n c Kie bv (2) gb iL, x`i Dci
Zvgv`i hgb AwaKvi AvQ, Zvgv`i IciI x`i
Zgb AwaKvi AvQ (3) mveavb! kwgKi Nvg Kvevi

83. QwdDi ingvb gveviKcyix (it), Avi-ivnxKzj gvL&Zg, ct 522|






27
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
c~eB Zvi Dchy cvwikwgK cwikva Ki w`e (4) gb
iL h cU fi Lvq A_P Zvi cwZekx yavZ _vK, m
cKZ gymjgvb nZ cvi bv (5) `vm-`vmx`i cwZ wbzi
nBI bv| Zvgiv hv Lve, Zv`iK ZvB LZ w`e;
Zvgiv hv cwiavb Kie, Zv`iK ZvB (mgg~ji)
cwiavb KiZ w`e (6) Kvb AevZ BqvZxgi m`
AvZmvr Kie bv|
84

Ggwbfve mw`b wZwb gvbevwaKvi mwKZ AmsL evYx
wekevmxi Dk ck Kib| wekbex gynvv` (Qvt)
Zuvi beyAZi 23 eQii Rxeb Aviei GKwU Amf I
eei RvwZK mf I myksLj RvwZZ cwiYZ
KiwQjb| ivRbwZK, A_bwZK, mvgvwRK, mvswZK
cfwZ Avg~j msvi mvwaZ nqwQj| ivRbwZK
wPivPwiZ Mvxq cv_K Zzj w`q wZwb NvlYv
Kib, Abviei Dci Aviei Ges Aviei Dci
Abviei, Kvi Dci kZvi Ges kZvi Dci
Kvi Kvb cv_K bB| eis Zvgv`i ga mB
mevwaK mvwbZ h AwaK gyvKx|
85
A_bwZK
wZwb m~`K m~Yfve wbwl Kib Ges hvKvZ wfwK
A_bxwZi gvag Ggb GKwU A_eev cwZv
KiwQjb hLvb ivi cwZwU bvMwiK Zv`i Avw_K
wbivcv jvf KiwQj| mvgvwRK bvixi Kvb
ghv`v I AwaKvi wQj bv| wekbex (Qvt) bvix RvwZK
mevP ghv`vi Avmb cwZwZ Kijb Ges NvlYv
Kijb gvqi cvqi wbKU m vbi RvbvZ|
86
bvix
RvwZK ay gvZZi ghv`vB `bwb DivwaKvii
I Zv`i AwaKviK KiQb mgy^Z I mycwZwZ,
hv Ab Kvb ag `Lv hvq bv| KZ`vm Avhv` KivK
wZwb Dg Bev`Z ej NvlYv Kib|
87
agxq
hLvb g~wZc~Rv, AwMc~Rv Ges wewfb ei c~Rv
Avieevmx`i RxebK KjywlZ KiwQj mLvb wZwb
Avjvn&i GKZ cwZv KiwQjb| gvvK_v wZwb Ggb
GKwU Acivagy mgvR I iv eev cwZv KiwQjb,
hLvb Kvb nvbvnvwb, ivnvRvwb, weksLjv kvlY, hyjyg,
AwePvi- ewfPvi, m~`-Nyl BZvw` wQj bv|
wek bex (Qvt)-Gi Rxebx wjLZ wMq Lvb jLK
HwZnvwmK DBwjqvg g~i ejQb, 'He was the matter
mind not only his own age but oI all ages' A_vr
gynvv` (Qvt) h hyM cw_exZ Avwef~Z nqwQjb ZvK
ay m hyMiB GKRb gbxlx ejv ne bv eis wZwb wQjb

84. Z`e, ct 20|
85. Qnxn AvZ-ZviMxe IqvZ Zvinxe, nv/2963; wmjwmjv Qnxnvn nv/2700|
86. wgkKvZ nv/4939|
87. gymwjg, wgkKvZ nv/2555|
mehyMi mek gbxlx|
88
aygv HwZnvwmK DBwjqvg
g~iB bb, cw_exi eyK hZ gbxlxi Avwef ve NUQ c vq
cZKB gynvv` (Qvt) mK Zu v`i Ag~ j evYx
cw_exi eyK iL MQb| cwe KziAvb ejv nqQ,
` - ,` ' = ` ,` _ ` ` , . ` ,.` -` , , .
,.` , = , , , - ` , , , = . Zvgv`i Rb Avj vi
ivm~ji ga iqQ Dg Av`k (!!< ~:)|
wek mc`vqi `w AvKlY Ki Dcvcb Kiv hvq h,
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Kej GKRb agxq bZvB wQjb bv;
eis wZwb wQjb mekYxi gvby li Rb GKRb mdj
ivbvqK I gvbevwaKvii cwZvZv| hgbwU gy nvv`
(Qvt) gv _K g`xbvq Gm mgvR msvi KiZt iv
MVbi cqvRbxqZv Dcjw KiwQjb| ZLb wZwb
cwjK, B`x, bvQviv mn mKj agi jvKi mg_b
wbq GKwU HwZnvwmK mb` iPbv Kib| hv g`xbv
mb` ej LvZ| cw_exi BwZnvm GUvB wQj c_g
wjwLZ msweavb ev kvmbZ|
15
D msweavb ivi
cwZwU bvMwiKi AwaKvi, Rvb, gvj I Bh&hZi wbivcv
Ges agxq ^vaxbZvi K_v NvlYv Kiv nq| GB msweavb
weagx I msLvjNy`i mv_ wKic AvPvi-eenvi Kie
Zvi my I Dg wb`kbv `qv AvQ| mKj agi
Abymvix`i agxq ^vaxbZvI c`vb Kiv nqQ| KD
KviI Dci Rei`w Kivi Kvb my hvM bB| myZivs G
K_v wekevmxi wbKU Pvj w`q ejv hvq h, mKj
gvbevwaKvii Drm, Dg cqvM ee v I msiYKvix
mek wKZve nj KziAvb I Qnxn myb vn|
/<}
15. Z`e, ct 20|


88. weki k 100 gbxlxi Rxebx, ct 20|






28
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
-| ||# | |-v |<
! !!~
evsjv`ki cwg my`ieb msjM Zvjcw xcwU
myKkj fviZ f w`Q| evsjv`ki mxgvbvq enr
G xcwU hvZ Avi Mo DVZ bv cvi mRb fviZ
DRvb nvwoqvfvv b`xi mvZ I cwj wbqY KiQ|
dj bZzb Ki cwj RgZ bv ci Zvjcw xc Avi DuPz
bv nq eis mcwZ mLvb fvOb i nqQ| Iw`K
Pvi-cuvP eQi AvM _K fviZ wekevcx cPvi i
KiQ h, Zvjcw xcwU wejxb nq MQ| Gi Kvb
Aw Z eZgvb Avi bB| wK ev eZv nQ, Zvjcw
xci Aw Z GLbv AvQ Ges fvUvi mgq Gi P~ov
mvgvb fm IV| wK Rvqvi cyivcywi Wye hvq|
AvM hZ `Z xcwU Mo DVwQj, eZgvb mfve Avi
MoQ bv| Ze wejxb nqwb| MZ mvnI Mji
mvUjvBU gvbwP Zvjcw xcwUi Aw Z `Lv MQ|
evsjv`ki cLvZ mgy` wevb I f~Mvj wekl, XvKv
wekwe`vjqi f~Mvj I cwiek wevb wefvMi mveK
Pqvigvb cdmi W. Avyi ie Gme Z_ Rvwbq ejb,
xcwU iKWc evsjv`ki| GKvii ^vaxbZvi ci
_K fviZ Rvic~eK Zvjcw `Lj Ki iLQ|
wK cwmWU wRqvDi ingvb GKevi xcwUi `Lj
wbqwQjb| Gici fviZ mgy`mxgv wbaviY msv
weivai gxgvsmv bv nIqvi ARynvZ `wLq weivac~Y
GjvKvq evsjv`ki bevwnbxK vqxfve NuvwU MvoZ
`qwb| Gi ga fviZ GKvwaKevi Rwic Ki `LQ,
Zvjcw cyivcywi RM DVj Ges Av RvwZKfve
mgy`mxgvi dvqQvjv nj Zviv KLbvB Gi gvwjKvbv cve
bv| eis evsjv`k Gi gvwjKvbv jvf Kij mgy`mxgvq
AbK`~i GwMq hve| ZvB fviZ Zvjcw xcwU f
`qvi Kkj MnY KiQ| wekl Ki evcmvMi
mgy`mxgv wbq gvqvbgvii mv_ evsjv`ki weivai
evcvi mgy` AvBb welqK Av RvwZK UvBeybvji
(BUjm) ivqi ci fviZ G evcvi Aviv wnsm nq
DVQ| hvZ Zvjcwi gvwjKvbv KvbfveB evsjv`k
bv cZ cvi GRb GKw`K nvwoqvfvv b`xi gvnbvq
fviZxq Ask Mvqb wbgvY Ki mvZi MwZ
evsjv`ki w`K Vj `qv nQ, Aciw`K b`xi
DRvb euva wbgvY Ki cwj wfb LvZ mwiq w`Q|
G Aevq wgqvbgvii ci Gevi fviZi mv_ mgy`mxgv
wbaviYi gvag `wY Zvjcw xc diZ cvIqvi
evcvi hw`I evsjv`k cP Avkvev`x nq DVQ, wK
kl ch m Avkvq oevwj coZ cvi ejB AvksKv
Kiv nQ| Gw`K miKvii gwiUvBg wekl I mgy`
Aj mxgvbv iv KwgwUmn mswk gnj Ges DcKjeZx
mKj kYx-ckvi gvbyli ^c, Avv I wekvm `p nqQ
h, mUgvwUbi gZv Zvjcw xcI evsjv`ki
mgy`mxgv ewZ nqZv wekl f~wgKv ivLe| Zv`i
`vwe Av RvwZK UvBeybvj AvBbx jovBq Rvivjvfve
Z_-Dcv I hyw Dcvcb Ki `wY Zvjcwmn
wekvj mgy`mxgvq evsjv`ki KZ Z cwZv P~ov Kiv
nvK| `wY Zvjcw `Lj Ki bqvi c Kvb
hwK ev AvBbMZ `vwe bB fviZi| Zviv h GwU
Rei `Lj Ki iLQ `xN w`b, Zvi wecixZ Rvivjv
Kvb c`cI bqv nqwb evsjv`ki c _K|
`wY Zvjcw wewfbfve evsjv`ki ej cgvwYZ
njI fviZ Mvqi Rvi eiveiB Zv A^ xKvi Ki
AvmwQj| GLb Av RvwZK U vBeybvji ivq GUv
diZi c_ myMg nIqvi AvMB fviZ PvjvwK Ki
xcwU asmi c_ eQ wbqQ|
bevwnbx m~ Rvbv hvq, evcmvMii AMfxi mvgyw` K
GjvKvq RM IVv DcKjxq xc `wY Zvjcw|
evsjv`ki mvZxiv hjvi kvgbMi Ges cwgei
24 ciMbv hjv ewminvUi gaj nvwoqvfvv b`x viv
wPwZ mxgv iLv eivei nvwoqvfvvi gvnbvi
evsjv`k Ask AMfxi mgy` xcwUi Ae vb| xcwU
Mv ev cv b`xi wewfb kvLv b`xi cjj AecYi
dj Mo DVQ| nvwoqvfvv gvnbv _K xcwUi `~ iZ
gv 2 wKjvwgUvi| `wY Zvjcw xci mivmwi Di
evsjv`ki g~j f~L Ges me-`wY evcmvMi|
xcwUi eZgvb AvqZb cvq 10 eMwKjvwgUvi| 1970
mvji bf^i cjqsKix N~ wYSo Mvq e-xcvji
`wYfvM AvNvZ nvbvi ci ciB xcwU Z`vbx b c~e
cvwK vb miKvii c_g `wMvPi Avm| ZrKvjxb
Lyjbv hjv ckvmb bevwnbxi mnhvwMZvq cv_wgK
Rwic kl ckvmwbK `wjjc bw_fy Ki xcwUi
bvgKiY Ki `wY Zvjcw| fviZ ZLb G evcvi
Kvb DPevP Kiwb| A_P 1971 mvji ^vaxbZv hyi
gvSvgvwS mgq fviZi cwge miKvi xcwU wbDgyi
xc bvg AewnZ Ki ivZvivwZ `Lj Ki bq|
^vaxbZv hyi Awi mgq xcwUi `Lj`vwiZ ZLb Avi
evsjv`k ev cvwK vb KZci c cwZv Kiv me
nqwb| ci 1974 mvj hyiv i BAviwUGm f~-
DcMni gvag ^ I Mfxi mvgy w`K cvwbZ RM IVv
GB Wye f~Li Rwic Kiv nq Ges xcwU evsjv`k
Ask ej cgvwYZ nIqvq iKW fy Kiv nq| Gici
_KB welqwU wbq n P nZ _vK| wK cwZev`
Rvivjv bv nIqvq `xNmgq ai xcwU fviZi Aea
`Lj iq MQ| `wY Zvjcw xci Pvicvk `k
wKjvwgUvi we Z| GLvb DcK jxq mgy`i Mo MfxiZv
gv 3 _K mvo 5 wgUvi| xcwU _K mvRv c vq 43
wKjvwgUvi `wY Mfxi mvgyw` K LvZ ev AZjvw K
N~YveZi (mvqvP Ae bv M vD) Aevb| mswk
wekl`i ee Abyhvqx xcwU I Gi Pvi cvki
f~icZvwZK Aev Ges msjM nvwoqvfvv I ivqgj






29
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
b`x `ywUi RjZvwZK cwqv _K aviYv Kiv nq, A`~i
fwelZ GwU Di AewZ evsjv`ki g~j f~L
Zvjcwi mv_ hy nq hve| `ki wZxq mgy`e`i
gsjv I mswk gwiUvBg wekl Ges mgy` m`
cheK`i AwfgZ, AvqZbi w`K _K `wY
Zvjcw AZ z` xc njI f~-ivRbwZK wbwiL
xcwUi iZ Acwimxg| DcKjxq xcwUi gvwjKvbvi
mv_ RwoZ iqQ evsjv`ki evcmvMii wekvj
mgy`vji mvefgZi ^v_| ZvB mvwjwk wbwi
gvag ay `wY Zvjcw bq, mgy`mxgvi GKzwmf
BKvbwgK RvbK wbK Kiv GKv hiix|
evsjv`ki DcKj _K `wY cvq 5k wKjvwgUvi
ch gnxmvcvbi we wZ| GB AMfxi mgy`vji gvU
AvqZb Kgc mvo 3 jvL eMgvBj| Av RvwZK mgy`
AvBbi mekl bxwZ Abyhvqx wbR `ki DcKjxq
msjM gnxmvcvbi hveZxq mgy` m`ivwRi eenvi I
gvwjKvbv ^Z fvM Kivi GKQ AwaKvi m `ki
iqQ| `wY Zvjcw gvwjKvbvi mv_ evcmvMi
evsjv`ki ^vfvweK mxgvi AwZwi Kgc 25 nvhvi
eMvgBj mgy`vji ^v_ RwoZ| xcwUi `wY, `wY-
c~e I `wY-cwg nvhvi nvhvi eMwKjvwgUvi msiwZ
A_bwZK Aj grm I Zj-Mvm mn wecyj
cwigvY mvgyw`K m` ihQ| H GjvKvi mgy`Zj
jn, gvvwbR, Gvjywgwbqvg, ZRxq fvix LwbR
c`v_ BZvw`i wecyj mq iqQ| Gi cgvY cvIqv
MQ evcmvMii AMfxi gnxmvcvb Zj`k LwbR
Zj Ges cvKwZK Mvmi eo aibi mq AvweKZ
nIqvq| GQvov evcmvMii H mvgyw`K GjvKvq
A_bwZK grm Aj MwVZ| GwU 3wU fvM wef|
c_gwU KevRvi I mUgvwUb xci KvQ mvD_
cvmR, wZxqwU eibv-cUzqvLvjxi KvQ wgWj cvmR
Ges Lyjbv-mvZxiv I my`iebi KvQ B cvmR|
evsjv`ki `wY-cwg evcmvMii Kvj AewZ
g~j my`ieb| fviZi 24 ciMbvi `wY fvMI
my`iebi Askwekl| cwg fvMxiw_ b`xi gvnbv
_K c~e gNbvi gvnbv ch my`ieb we Z| mswk
m~gZ, 6 nvhvi 17 eMwKjvwgUvi we Z my`iebi 4
nvhvi 143 eMwKjvwgUvi f~-fvM Avi 1 nvhvi 874
eMwgjvwgUvi RjfvM| eZgvb my`ieb wNi
evcmvMi evsjv`ki Ask wewfbfve fviZxq`i
KZZ cwZvi AcPv PjQ| mgy` Aj mxgvbv iv
RvZxq KwgwUi AvnvqK gvnv` byi gvnv` GK
mvvrKvi Rvbvb, `xNw`bi `vwei cwZ gvqvbgvii
mv_ evsjv`ki mgy`mxgv Av RvwZK UvBeybvj
wbaviY nqQ| ZvZ cvw-Acvw hvB _vK, GKwU `xN
weZKi Aemvb nqQ| Ze GLvb Kvb fyj ev Acvw
_vKj Zv _K wkv wbq AvMvgxZ fviZxq`i mv_
Aviv KvhKifve Av RvwZK Av`vjZ joZ ne| G
Aevq evcmvMi ay gvwjKvbv cwZv KijB ne
bv, Gi cyivcywi wbqYI wbZ ne evsjv`kK| wZwb
ejb, KwgwUi m`m mwPe Aemicv wiqvj GvWwgivj
Lvik` Avjgmn bZe` 1982 mvj Av RvwZK mgy`
AvBb cvm nIqvi ci _K e `b `ievi KiQ wewfb
cvq| GLb fviZi mv_ mgy`mxgv wbaviY I weiva
wbw nIqv hiix| G `wY Zvjcw xcmn H
GjvKvi weivU mgy`vj AwaKvi cwZv KiZ ne|
Zvi gZ, Av RvwZK U vBeybvj fviZi wei AvBwb
jovB Rvi`vi KiZ ne| GRb `wY Zvjcw xc
cqvRb h_fve ev Av RvwZKfve Rwici eev
KiZ ne Ges fviZxqiv Kvb Kkj xcwU f
`Iqvi AcPv Kij mUvI Av RvwZK Av`vjZi
bhi AvbZ ne| G evcvi Kvbic XvKXvK oo
Kivi myhvM bB| GLbB KVvi bv nj Avgv`i Aw Z
gwKi gyL coe|
wewRwe m~ Rvbvq, `wY-cwgmn `ki wewfb mxgv
GjvKvq nvhvi nvhvi weNv Rwg fviZ Rvic~ eK `Lj
Ki iLQ| hv wbq `xNKvj ai Rwic I eVK PjQ,
wK Kvb myivnv nqwb| fviZ wcvwKfve Avjvc-
AvjvPbvi gvag mgvavbi K_v ej KvjcY Ki
PjQ| KvMRc I iKW Rwg evsjv`ki _vKjI
fviZxqiv hywi cwieZ Mvqi Rvi me fvM`Lj
KiQ| GKBfve mgy`vj Zvjcwmn weivU GjvKvq
KZZ cwZv Ki AvQ fviZ| fviZi `wfw, AvPiY
I KvhKjvc mK cheK`i AwfgZ, cwZekx`i
^vaxbZv-mvefgZi c wZ Zv`i we`ygvI kvevai
bgybv cvIqv hvq bv| cwZekxK eiveiB KVvi wbqY
I Kvi ga ivLZ Zviv AvMnx| evsjv`ki f~L
`wY Zvjcw xcwU Mvqi Rvi `Lj Ki bqv Zvi
eo cgvY| Av RvwZK UvBey bvj welqwUi wbwi
evcvi ivRbwZK, mvgvwRK msMVb, mPZb I
cheK gnj Rvi `vex ZzjQb| mgy ` Aj mxgvbv
iv RvZxq KwgwUi AvnvqK gvnv` b~ i gvnv`
Aviv Rvbvb, AbwZwej^ miKviK GKwU mgy ` welqK
gYvjq cwZv KiZ ne| Zvi AvIZvq _vKe GKwU
mgy` Awa`i| GKBmv_ Av RvwZK mgy` MelYv
K` cwZv Kiv GLb mgqi `vweZ cwiYZ nqQ|
hfveB nvK wekvj mgy` m`K myiv KiZ ne|
KviY evsjv`ki jfvMi Pq AbK ekx m`
iqQ mgy`| GB evcmvMi hme b`xi cvK wZK
MwZc_ I cevn HwZnvwmKfve hfve Gm wgkQ
mUvI AwaKfve ivi eev KiZ ne| fviZ hb
euva w`q GB MwZc_ I cevn cwieZb KiZ wKsev
Nywiq w`Z bv cvi, m evcviI Av RvwZK
Av`vjZi `w AvKlY KiZ ne|
/l}






30
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
|x+-1< |#x <|x|< < |+| :
=-# - ' <
!< !!
GKevi Kbv Kib Zv, Avcbvi `ni wbgvsk am
cov `qvji wbP| _uZj MQ| wKQzZB ei nZ
cviQb bv| Kvb iKg euP AvQb| H AevqB
Avcwb m vbi ei nq _vKv nvZwU `LQb| G wP
wbqB Avcbvi KbvqI VuvB cve bv| wP vaviv
Abw`K Nywiq `eb| AvgivI G wP Kbvq AvbZ
PvB bv| A_P G aibi ev Gi Pq AviI fqven wP
h Kvb mgqB cwKvRyo `Lv hZ cvi| Ggb
AvksKv jvKRb KiQb| BwZga wekliv NvlYv
w`qQb, XvKv kni f~wgKi UvBg evgvi Dci em
AvQ| h Kvb gyn~Z dvUZ cvi| dvUj Kx ne,
ZviB GKwU KvwbK `k jLvi iZ Dcvcb Kiv
nqQ| GB `k cwKvRyo cKvwkZ nvhviv KiY
wPi GKwU nZ cvi, hv `qK `wjZ-gw_Z Ki
Zzje| fvlvnxb, wei nq em _vKv Qvov wKQzB Kivi
_vKe bv| cvKwZK GB gnv`yhvM _K AvMvg invB
cvIqvi Rb Ggb Kvb h AvR ch gvbyl Avwevi
KiZ cviwb, hvZ cjqsKix So ev gnvcvebi Avkv
AvM _KB Ui cvIqv hvq| gvbyli Rvb-gvji
wbivcv weavb AvMvg eev bqv hvq| wK f~wgK
cKwZi GgbB GK Awfkvc, KLb AvNvZ nvbe KviI
c aviYv Kiv me bq| AvNvZ nvbvi ci Gi
asmjxjv `Lv hvq| Kej ZLbB gvbyl AvnZ-
wbnZ`i Dvii cwZ wbZ cvi|
f~wgK gvKvejvq evsjv`ki cwZ KZUzKz? c-
cwKv I wewfb Z_-Dcv _K hv Rvbv hvq, Zvi
wPwU nZvkvRbK| Avgiv ay Rvwb, miKvi Dvi Kg
cwiPvjbvi Rb 70 KvwU UvKvi hcvwZ Kbvi D`vM
wbqQ| wK D`vM ev evqb ne Ke Gi wbqZv
bB| A_P f~wgKi UvBg evgvi Dci em _vKv
XvKv kni h Kvb mgq f~wgK fqven AvNvZ nvbZ
cvi|
RvwZmsN cYxZ Av_KvqK wWRvvi wi BbWi
GK eyjwUb `Lvbv nqQ, weki 20wU SuywKc~Y
knii ga Bivbi ivRavbx Znivb c_g I Avgv`i
wcq bMix XvKv wZxq| cKwZMZfve Avgv`i XvKv
kniK `yfvMvB ejZ ne| Gi AvM `Lv MQ, weki
mePq emevm AbychvMx knii ZvwjKvqI XvKv
wZxq| c_g wR^veyqi ivRavbx nvivi| A_vr
AcwiKwZfve XvKvK Avgiv emevmi AbychvMx Ki
Mo ZzjwQ| GB `vq Avgv`i| Avi c vKwZK
f~wgKi Kej covi Avgiv wbRivI `vqx|
GK AmZK, APZb I AvbZvi ga w`q Avgiv
PjwQ| wekliv Avkv KiQb 7 gvvi f~ wgK
AvNvZ nvbjB XvKv kni asmZc cwiYZ ne| gviv
hZ cvi 2 jvL gvbyl| GB 2 jvLi ga Avwg,
Avcwb, Avgv`i gv-evev, fvB-evb, x-m vbI _vKZ
cvi| GB h Avwg, Avcwb h febwUZ emevm KiwQ,
cixv Kij `Lv hve Zv AZ cyibv ev `ye j wfwi
Dci `uvwoq AvQ| RvwZmsNi `yhvM SuywK m~PKi
Z_vbyhvqx, XvKv knii gv 35 fvM vcbv k gvwUi
Dci `uvwoq| Avi evwK 65 fvM evjy w`q wewfb
Rjvkq fivU Ki big gvwUi Dci wbg vY Kiv nqQ|
Kx fqven K_v! Zvi gvb Gme vcbv hviv Zix
KiQb, ZvivB Avgv`i Rb GKKwU gZzKc Zix
Ki iLQb| miKvwi Z_gZB 72 nvhvi feb
SuywKc~Y| emiKvwi Z_gZ G msLv KqK jvL|
Zvrchi welq, f~wgK nj AvnZ`i wPwKmvi Rb
h gwWKj nvmcvZvjK mePq eo f~wgKv cvjb
KiZ ne, mB XvKv gwWKvj KjR nvmcvZvjB
fqven SuywKi ga iqQ| KvRB f~wgK nj
mvaviY gvbyl h wPwKrmv _KI ewZ neb, Zv
wbwZ| wekliv ejQb, gvSvwi gvvi f~ wgK nj
XvKvi 60 fvM feb P~Y-weP~Y nq gvwUZ wgk hve|
cyibv XvKvmn Abvb GjvKvq feb am jvL jvL
gvbyli gZz ne|
BDbvBUW bkbm WfjcgU cvMvg (BDGbwWwc)
GK MelYvq ejQ, h Kvb mgq evsjv`k eo
gvvi f~wgK nZ cvi| A_vr f~ wgK jvL jvL
gvbyli gZz h Kvb mgq nZ cvi| Avi XvKv
wekwe`vjq I evsjv`k c Kkj wek we`vjqi
wkKiv `yB eQievcx (2008-2009) GK MelYvq
Avkv cKvk Ki ejQb, eo aibi f~ wgK nj
mB GjvKvi gvwUi i Avjv`v nq hvq| Avjv`v GB
gvwUi i k nZ 100 eQi jM hvq| gvwUi i k
nq Mj cKwZi ^vfvweK wbqg H GjvKvq cybivq
f~wgK nIqvi Avkv _vK| 1762 mvj mxZvKz I
1885 mvj gaycyii fqven f~wgKi AvjvK Zviv
wnmve Ki `LQb, G eQiB eo aibi f~ wgK
cybivq AvNvZ nvbZ cvi| G wnmve XvKvq h Kvb
gyn~Z f~wgK nZ cvi| Zvi AvjvgZ BwZga `Lv
hvQ| cvqB QvU gvvi f~ wgK XvKv kni Kuvwcq
`q| mekl MZ 11 Gwc j XvKvq 3.8 gvvq cici






31
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
`yevi f~wgK XvKv bo DV| G iKg QvU gvvi
f~wgK cwZ eQiB GKvwaKevi nQ| wekliv gb
KiQb QvU QvU f~wgK eo wKQz NUbviB BwZ
w`Q| hw` 1885 mvji gZv 7 gvvi f~wgK nq,
Ze XvKv knii GK ZZxqvsk feb asm ne| cvY
nvive jvL jvL gvbyl|
XvKvq h G eQi eo aibi f~wgK AvNvZ nvbZ
cvi, Zv MelKiv wnmve-wbKvk Ki `wLqQb| wK
kvRbK GB cwiwwZ _K Avgiv A Z wbR`i
wKfve wbivc` ivLZ cvwi, Avgiv wK Zv wbq fvewQ?
fvewQ bv| wews KvW bv gb AcwiKwZfve GKi
ci GK feb wbgvY Ki PjwQ| f~Zwe` W. e`ij
Bgvg ejQb, Avgv`i Rb mePq wec`i KviY
fivU GjvKvq feb wbgvY Kiv| XvKv knii Pvicvki
Lvj, wej, b`x I Rjvkq fivU Ki cwZwbqZ feb
wbgvY Kiv nQ| GB fivU KvR Kiv nQ evjy I
Kv`vgvwU w`q| hv f~wgKi Rb LyeB SuywKc~Y| wZwb
Rvbvb, ivRavbxi c~evj Rjvf~wg I wbPz GjvKv fivU
Ki eZj feb wbgvYi dj XvKvq f~wgK
qwZi SuywK AbK eo MQ| weki Abvb `ki
Zzjbvq XvKvq f~wgK wZi cwigvY ne AbK ekx|
wZi cwigvY ekx nIqvi Rb RvwZmsNi mgxvq
XvKvq RbmsLvi NbZ, AwaK feb, AcwiKwZ
AeKvVvgv, bMi Lvjv RvqMvi Afve, mi Mwjc_ I
jvBd jvBbi `~ievK `vqx Kiv nqQ| f~wgK
cieZx Dvi ZrciZv wbq evsjv`ki cwZ LyeB
mvgvb| dvqvi mvwfm Av wmwfj wWd, evsjv`k
iW wmU mvmvBwU, XvKvi nvmcvZvjjvi
AwaKvskiB wekl cwZ bB| RvwZmsNi G m~PK
Avgv`i Rb fqven BwZ w`Q| f~wgKi ci Dvi
I vY ZrciZv wbq miKvi, wewfb DviKvix msv I
nvmcvZvjjvi wekl Kvb cwZB bB| Zvi gvb
f~wgK jvL jvL gvbyl Zv gviv hveB, hviv AvnZ
nq euP _vKeb Zv`iI euvPvi Dcvq bB| Zvrchi
welq, f~wgK hLb Avgv`i GKUz bvwoq w`q hvq,
Kej ZLbB miKvi I mswk wefvMjv boPo em|
wK ^vqx f~wgKi gZvB Zv`i GB bovPov vqx
nq| Zvici egvjyg fyj hvq| A_P ^ mgq
f~wgKi h fqven asmh I wefxwlKv fveUv Ggb
AvM f~wgK nvK, Zvici `Lv hve| G aibi wP v
AvZNvZx ejv hvq| f~wgK mK mevi AvM
miKviK Zrci nZ ne| mKj Awbqg `~i KiZ
ne| f~wgK cieZx Dvi Kg hvZ `Z Kiv hvq,
GRb chv mivgv`x msMn KiZ ne| msMni ci
Gme hcvwZ w`q wbqwgZ gnovi AvqvRb KiZ ne|
wews KvW gb hvZ feb wbwgZ nq, GRb ivRDKK
KVvi bhi`vwii eev wbZ ne| hviv wews KvW
gvbwb, Zv`i wei kvw g~jK ee v wbZ ne|
miKvii cvkvcvwk wewfb mvgvwRK msMVbjvK
f~wgKi fqvenZv mK RbmPZbZvg~jK Kvhg
wbZ ne| mfv, mwgbvi, gvbeebi gZv Kgm~wPi
cvkvcvwk cvov-gnjvq mPZbZvg~ jK Kvhg PvjvZ
ne| hviv evwoi gvwjK Zv`i ejZ ne, wbRi evwowU
hvZ f~wgKi SuywKi ga bv co Zvi ee v wbZ
ne| KviY evwoi Pq Rxebi g~j AbK ekx|
wbRi evwoZ wbRB Pvcv coZ cvib| hviv bZz b
evwo KiQb, Zviv hb iv vi Rb wKQz RvqMv Qo
feb Zix Kib| hvZ f~wgK nj DviKvix Mvwo I
hcvwZ mnR PjvPj KiZ cvi| cvov-gnj vq hme
KjvYg~jK mvmvBwU Mo DVQ, mjv f~ wgK
mK wbR wbR GjvKvq mPZbZv ewi Rb wbqwgZ
mfv-mwgbvii AvqvRb KiZ cvi| f~wgK h Kvb
mgq nZ cvi| KviY cyiv XvKv kniB f~wgKi
UvBg evgvi Dci em AvQ| `Lv hve, evwoi KD
evBi Aevb KiQb, f~wgKi ci wMq `Ljb
evwoi asmZc ZviB cwievii jvKRb Pvcv co
MQ| wZwb ay GKv euP iqQb| ZLb nqZv
wejvci myi ejeb, Avwg Kb euP iBjvg| KvRB G
aibi UvwRK NUbvi wkKvi nIqvi AvM Avgv`i
cZKKB mPZb nZ ne| f~wgK cieZx mgq
AvnZ`i wPwKrmv `qvi Rb miKvwi-emiKvwi
cZKwU nvmcvZvjK AvMvg c wZ wbZ ne|
miKvii c _K G c wZ bqv evaZvg~ jK KiZ
ne| Avi f~wgK _K wbRi Rxeb euvPvZ
ewMZfve wKQz eev bqv hvq| wekliv ejb,
f~wgKi mgq evwoi ev dvUi `yB `qvji
mshvMj, k Uweji wbP Avkq wbZ ne| hvZ
A Z gv_v I eyK AvNvZ bv jvM| cvkvcvwk 24 Nv
euP _vKvi Rb Kbv Lvevi iwW ivLv| f~ wgK
Abyf~Z nj Mvmi jvBb I we`y Zi jvBb m m
e Ki w`Z ne|
:l:
/l!< !< !^ <! <!^
!!< !! ><-! < < l< *!
!!< l !! <! ! !! < <
! ! !! =<! <, > l< l$
$ !< < <' (< :) =< !<
l, l !!!< l<< ! -!!}







32
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv

|<| ' |<<|- |+-
(:) mcwZ `ki wewfb vb bvgavix wKQz ivRbwZK
agbZv Zv`i ^v_wmwi Rb Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjbi
wei AweiZfve wg_vPvi Ki PjQb| Zviv
nvbvdx`iK Avnjnv`xQi wei wcq `evi
AcKkj wbq `ki wewfb vb wewfb wgwWqvi
gvag AccPvi PvjvQb Ges wjdjU Qo I eB
wjL AccPvi KiQb| Zv`i mKji fvlv cvq
GKBic| hgb,
fviZel gymjgvb`i viv ewUk ZvovI Av`vjbi
AMbvqK mq` Avng` (int) evjvKvUi hy knx`
nIqvi ci 1840 mvji w`K Avyj nK ebvimx bvgK
GK ewi gvag GB `jwUi De NU| Zvi kixqZ
weivax K_vevZvi KviY gv-g`xbvi AvjgMY ZvK
nZvi dZvqv `b| GivB BsiR weivax Av`vjb I
wRnv`K nvivg ej NvlYv `q| c_g Zviv wbR`i
Invex A_ev gvnv`x ej cwiPq w`Z| G`ki gvbyl
Zv`iK ivdv`vbx ev jv-gvhnvex ejB Rvb| ewUk
miKvii c`jnx GB idv`vbx ev jv-gvhnvex `jwUi
bZv cvve c`ki gynvv` nvmvqb evUvjfx bvgK
ew cvve c`ki BsiR MfYii wbKU 1886 mvj
GB ej `iLv Ki h, Avgiv me`v BsiR miKvii
wnZvKvLx I fvKvLx| Avgv`i bvg Invex ev jv-
gvhnvexi Dci wblavv Avivc Ki Zvi cwieZ
Avnjnv`xQ ivLv nK|
cvve c`ki BsiR miKvii 3.12.1886Bs
ZvwiLi 1758 bs viK evUvjfxK Zvi `iLv
gyixi Lei `Iqv nq| GB Avnjnv`xQivB fviZ
GfveB BsiR`i `vjvjx KiwQj|
Gici _K Zviv AvnjmybvZ Iqvj RvgvqvZ wekl
Ki nvbvdx`i wei DV co jvM| Lvb`i A_
eo IVv GB givn `jwU nvbvdx`i gykwiK ejZI
wav Ki bv| Zviv ej nvbvdx`i bvgvRB nq bv|
Dcii wewwU mcwZ PzqvWvv _K cKvwkZ `ywU
AvwjK `wbK cwKv _K DZ| ay ZvB bq, Gwj
wbq gnicyi hjv ckvmbi KvQ wMq Avnjnv`xQi
mfv-mwgwZ e Kivi Rb Mvsbxi vbxq e`qvZx `gb
KwgwU-i c nZ wjwLZfve `vex Rvbvbv nqQ Ges
K`xq Avnjnv`xQ bZe`K Mvsbx kni Zviv
AevwZ NvlYv KiQ| G welq cwKvi 1g cvi kxl
wkivbvg wQj, nvbvdx`i ga DRbv, Wt MvwjeK
AevwZ NvlYv| Zviv Avnjnv`xQi wei RygAvi
QvjvZi ci Mvsbx Dchjv kni wgwQj ei Kivi Rb
nvbvdx RbMYi cwZ Avnvb Rvwbq wjdjU weZiY
Ki| hw`I Zviv ZvZ mdj nqwb| eis mLvb wbavwiZ
w`b I wbavwiZ mgq Avgxi RvgvAvZi DcwwZZ
Avnjnv`xQi iYKvji eng Bmjvgx mjb
AbywZ nqQ Kvbic evav-weN QvovB Ges GB
mjbi gv `ymvni ga mLvbKvi kZvwaK ew
Avnjnv`xQ nq MQb Ges GLbv nQb| !l!l
! GY = |<<< |x|-< <<i |-x<
||-|v-=< |<< cwe Kz iAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi
wbtkZ Abymvix ewK Avnjnv`xQ ejv nq| whwb
Rxebi me cwe KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi wmv K
kZnxbfve gb wbeb Ges ivm~jy jvn (Qvt) I Qvnvevq
Kivgi ZixKv Abyhvqx wbRi mvweK Rxeb Mo ZzjZ
mP neb, Kejgv wZwbB G bvg AwfwnZ neb| GwU
Bmjvgi Avw`ic cwZvi Av`vjb, hv Qvnvevq
Kivgi hyM _K G hver cw_exi wewfb `k cwiPvwjZ
nq AvmQ| DjL h, Avnjnv`xQ nIqvi Rb i,
eY, fvlv I Aj kZ bq|
Qvnvevq Kivg njb RvgvAvZ Avnjnv`xQi c_g
mvwii mvwbZ `j| huviv G bvg AwfwnZ nZb| hgb
cLvZ Qvnvex Avey mvC` Ly`ix (ivt) Kvb gymwjg
hyeKK `Lj Lykx nq ejZb, ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi
AwQqZ Abyhvqx Avwg ZvgvK gvinvev RvbvwQ|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Avgv`iK Zvgv`i Rb gRwjm c k
Kivi I Zvgv`iK nv`xQ eySvevi wb` k w`q MQb|
Kbbv ZvgivB Avgv`i cieZx eskai I cieZx
Avnjyj nv`xQ|
89

eo cxi ej LvZ kvqL Avy j Kv`i Rxjvbx (gt 561
wnt) bvRx dKv wnmve AvnjmybvZ Iqvj RvgvAvZi
eYbv `Iqvi ci Zv`i wei we`AvZx`i va eYbv
KiZ wMq ejb, we`AvZx`i wb`kb nj
Avnjnv`xQ`i Mvwj `Iqv I wewfb bvg Zv`i m^ vab
Kiv| Gwj mybvZcx`i wei Zv`i `jxq wel I
A Rvjvi ewntcKvk wfb wKQzB bq| Kbbv Avnj my bvZ
Iqvj RvgvAvZi Ab Kvb bvg bB GKwU bvg eZxZ|
mwU nj AvQnveyj nv`xQ ev Avnjnv`xQ|
90
bi
weLvZ gbxlx wnRix cg kZKi Bgvg Beby nhg
Av`vjymx (384-456 wnt) ejb, AvnjmybvZ Iqvj
RvgvAvZ hv`iK Avgiv nKcx I Zv`i weivax`i
evwZjcx ejwQ, Zviv njb, (K) Qvnvevq Kivg (L)
Zv`i Abymvix k ZveCMY (M) Avnjnv`xQMY (N)
dKxn`i ga huviv Zuv`i Abymvix nqQb hy M hyM
AvRKi w`b ch (O) Ges cvP I cZxPi mKj Avg
RbmvaviY, hviv Zuv`i Abymvix nqQ|
91
Bgvg Beby
Zvqwgqvn (661-728 wnt) ejb, gymjgvb`i ga

89. < <!^!, !< !!l< ! : :~ !<!,
ll! ! !/~|
90. !+ !< >!, l!< l! < l! !<
(l< !!, ::: l:), :/> :|
91. < , l!< l!, << :/::|
|-|<|






33
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Avnjnv`xQ`i Aevb Ggb ghv`vc~Y, hgb mKj
RvwZi ga gymjgvb`i Aevb|
92

fviZi kvn AwjDjvn `njfx (1114-76/1703-
62Lt) ejb, PZz_ kZvx wnRixi c~e Kvb gymjgvb
wbw`fve Kvb GKRb wevbi gvhnvei ZvKjx`i
Dci msNe wQj bv|
93
nvdh Bebyj KvBwqg (691-
751wnt) ejb, gvhnvex ZvKjx`i GB we`AvZ
AvweKZ nqQ ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi fvlvq wbw`Z 4_
kZvx wnRixZ
94
kvn AwjDjvn `njfx (int) ejb,
Avevmxq Ljxdv nvibyi ikx`i LjvdZKvj (170-
93/786-809 Lt) Avey nvbxdv (int)-Gi cavb wkl
Avey BDmyd (int) cavb wePvicwZ _vKvi KviY BivK,
Lvivmvb, ga ZzwK vb cfwZ Aj nvbvdx gvhnvei
we wZ NU|
95
ci nvbvdxiv kvdC`i wei
gvjexi nvjvKz LuvK WK Avbj 656/1258 Lv
evM`v`i Avevmxq LjvdZ asm nq hvq|
G mgqi wKQz c~e Mhbxi myjZvb gvnvv` Nvixi ZzKx
Mvjvg KzZzeyxb AvBeK I BLwZqvixb gynvv`
eLwZqvi wLjRxi gvag 602 wnt/1203 Lv w`jx
nZ evsjv ch mvgwiK weRq mvwaZ nq| Guiv wQjb
bIgymwjg ZzKx nvbvdx| hvZ wgkY NUwQj ZzKx, Civbx,
AvdMvb, gvMj, cvVvb Ges vbxq wn`y I e AvKx`v
I ixwZ-bxwZ mn AmsL fviZxq Kzmsvi| Qvnvev,
ZveCb Ges Avie ewYK I gynvwQMYi gvag BwZc~e
cPvwiZ we Bmjvgi mv_ hvi Lye mvgvbB wgj wQj|
G mgqKvi Aev eYbv Ki LvZbvgv fviZxq nvbvdx
wevb Avyj nvB jvex (1848-86 Lt) ejb, wdKn
eZxZ jvKiv KziAvb I nv`xQ _K gyL wdwiq
wbqwQj| ...Avnjnv`xQMYK Zviv RvbZ bv| KD KD
wgkKvZ cojI Zv coZ eiKZ nvwQji Rb, Avgj
Kivi Rb bq| ZvnKxKx ZixKvq bq| eis ZvKjx`x
ZixKvq wdKni vb nvwQj KivB wQj Zv`i j|
96

myjvqgvb bv`fx (1884-1953) ejb, ZzKx weRqx hviv
fviZ GmwQjb, `yPviRb mbv Awdmvi I KgKZv
ev` Zv`i KDB bv Bmjvgi cwZwbwa wQjb, bv Zv`i
kvmb Bmjvgx bxwZi Dci cwiPvwjZ wQj| Giv wQjb
Avie weRqx`i _K AbK `~i|
97

ZvB ejv Pj h, ga Gwkqv _K Di fviZ nq ZzKx-
Civbx mvaK-`iek`i gvag I ivRkwi QQvqvq
cieZxZ evsjv`k h Bmjvg cPvwiZ nq, Zv BwZc~e

92. < !l!, l!> !, << ~/:>|
93. ! l!, :!!l <!l^!, :/:~-:
!+< << << !< <!' |
94. < !l, ! !^ ~/~|
95. :!!l <!l^! :/:: < !!< <
!< ' |
96. !! !!, 5< ll (<!l< :>>~ !,
!.!.<!. :>>:), : ~:|
97. !|
Avie ewYK I gynvwQ Ijvgvq xbi gvag evsjv`k
AvMZ cv_wgK hyMi g~j Aviexq Bmjvg nZ ejvsk
c_K wQj| dj nvbvdx kvmK I bevMZ gigx Q~ dx`i
cfve evsjv`ki gymjgvbiv g nvbvdx I cxicx
nq co| Zviv ewea Kz msvi Ges wkiK I we`AvZ
Af nq co| Gfve G`ki g~j kixqZx Bmjvg
cieZxZ jwKK Bmjvg cwiYZ nq| hvi djkwZZ
Nvovcxi, Zbvcxi, Xjvcxi cf wZ AmsL fyqv cxi
evsjvi gymjgvbi c~Rv cvq|
98

kvn AwjDjvn `njfx (int) ejb, nvbvdx gvhnvei
wKqvmx drIqv mg~n Ges wdKn I DQ~j wdK ni bvg
hme gvmAvjv-gvmvqj I AvBbm~ mg~n wjwLZ nqQ,
mwjK Bgvg Avey nvbxdv I Zu vi `yB wkli w`K
m^wZ Kivi evcvi GKwU eYbvI we bq|
99
wZwb
Avnjyj nv`xQ I Avnjyi ivq-Gi cv_ K wkivbvg Zu vi
RMwLvZ M vZzjvwnj evwjMvn& i ga (:/:-~)
Avnjnv`xQ wevbMYi `jxj MnYi bxwZgvjv
we vwiZfve AvjvPbv KiQb| wZwb ghnvecx
gyKvwj`MYi cwZ vf c Kvk Ki ejb, Zviv gb
Ki h, GKwU gvmAvjvZI hw` Zv`i AbymiYxq
wevbi ZvKjx` nZ m ewiq Avm, Zvnj nqZev
m gymwjg wgjvZ _KB LvwiR nq hve| H wevb hb
GKRb bex, hvK Zvi KvQ ciY Kiv nqQ|
100
wZwb
ejb, h ew QvjvZ ivdDj Bqv`vqb Ki, H ew
Avgvi wbKU AwaK wcq H ewi PvBZ, h ew
ivdDj Bqv`vqb Ki bv| Kbbv ivdDj Bqv`vqbi
nv`xQ msLvq AwaK Ges AwaKZi ghey Z|
101
nvbvdx I
kvdC gvhnvei wek wdKn M n`vqv, Avj-IqvRxh
cfwZi AgvRbxq nv`xQweivwaZv mK Avyj nvB
jvex ejb, Gwj gIh~ ev Rvj nv`xQ viv
cwic~Y|
102
Bgvg Beby `vKxKz j C` (g: 702 wnt) Pvi
gvhnve cPwjZ Qnxn nv`xQ weivax drIqvmg~ni GKwU
weivU msKjb Zix KiwQjb| hvi f~wgKvZ wZwb
NvlYv KiQb h, GB gvmAvjvwjK Pvi Bgvgi
w`K m^ Kiv nvivg|
103
KviY Pvi Bgvgi cZK
Avnjnv`xQ wQjb Ges Zviv cZK ej MQb,
hLb Zvgiv Qnxn nv`xQ cve, Rb iL mUvB
Avgv`i gvhnve|
104
Avnjnv`xQMY Zuv`i mK_vB
gb Pjb Ges Zv`i mvwe K Rxeb cwe KziAvb I
Qnxn nv`xQ Abyhvqx Mo Zvjvi Pv Kib|
= |-=< <|< x

98. !, : :-|
99. ! l!, :!!l <!l^!, :/::|
100. =, !! !l! :/::|
101. =, :!!l <!l^!, ~/:|
102. !+ ! !<, ! !<< (>! ^<-=< l!,
! :~>: l:), : ::|
103. ! !, ^! l! : >>|
104. !<!, l!< ! (l !!, :~: l:), :/: :|






34
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
:. '<||+| <+< < : |< |-+ | +
<-|<| -|x+ <i|< x|<ix -|< << '
GwU Wvnv wg_v I wfwnxb K_v| Gi eo cgvY evjvKvU
hyi wmcvnmvjvi Avjvgv kvn BmgvCj knx` (int)
wbRB wQjb Avnjnv`xQ| whwb 1246 wnt gvZveK
1831 mvji 6B g evi c~e v evjvKvU knx`
nb| Zuvi mv_x kZ kZ gyRvwn` wQjb Avnjnv`xQ|
evsjv I wenvii Avnjnv`xQ RbMvxi AwaKvsk Zuvi
bZZ cwiPvwjZ wRnv` Av`vjbi dmj| Avyj nK
ebvimx (1206-86wnt) wQjb Avjvgv knx`i mncvwV
Ges wZwb Zv`i mv_ GK n Kib| w`jxZ
jLvcov kl Ki wZwb Bqvgb wMq Bgvg kIKvbxi
(1172-1250 wnt) wbKU nv`xQ wkv Kib I mb`
jvf Kib|
105
Gi ekx Zuvi m^ Rvbv hvq bv|
weivaxiv AbK wb`vl gvbylK `vlx evwbqQ| ZuvK
wbq hw` KD wg_v iUbv Ki _vK, mUv Zv`i
evcvi| Ze Zuvi gvag Avnjnv`xQ `ji De NUQ
ej h `vex Kiv nqQ, GUv AvKvU g~LivB Kej
KiZ cvi| evsjv`k Ggbvgb esk iqQ, hviv
KqK kZ eQi hver Avnjnv`xQ| hgb eni Lyjbv-
hkvi, 24 ciMbv, Mjx, eagvb Aji Avnjnv`xQ
Av`vjbi bZv gvIjvbv Avngv` Avjxi (1883-
1976Bs) esk| Zuvi 7g EaZb cyil gvIjvbv mq`
kvn bhxi Avjx Avj-gvMiex c_g Avie `k _K
G`k wnRiZ Kib Ges Zuvi eski i _K Ghver
cvq mvZkv eQii AwaKKvj ai mevB Avnjnv`xQ|
ZvQvov GB esk wPiKvj cwZ i A Zt GKRb Ki
hvM Avjg wQjb|
106

>. '=<|# #t< |<<|<| |-|- ||-+ |<|x
< |<| -<'
A_P BsiR-weivax wRnv` Av`vjbi bZZ wQjb
Avnjnv`xQMY| Lv` Avjvgv kvn BmgvCj (1193-
1246/1779-1831Lt) wQjb hvi cavb mbvcwZ|
evjvKvU-c~eeZx cuvP eQi wkLweivax wRnv`
Avnjnv`xQ nvbvdx mKj hy wQjb| wK weivax
Avjg`i Pv wekl Ki gvIjvbv gvne~e Avjx
cgyLi civPbvq nvbvdx`i AbK wRnv` _K mUK
cob| gjvbv KvivgZ Avjx Rbcyix (1215-
90/1800-73Lt) Zv`i AbZg| wZwb evsjv`k Gm
wRnv` weivax gZ cKvk Kib Ges BsiRi c
drIqv `b| 1870 mvji 23k bf^i KwjKvZv
gvnvgWvb j mvmvBwUZ c` eZvq ewUk fviZK
`vij Bmjvg NvlYv w`q wZwb ejb, GY gymjgvb
cRviv Zv`i (BsiR) kvmKK mvnvh KiZ Ges

105. !<!l> !! ! l, l ! , : ~-:|
106. !ll !!! !! !, ~ < ~:::, :
|
kvmKi mnhvwMZvq we`vnx`i (A_vr wRnv`x
Avnjnv`xQ`i) wei hy KiZ eva _vKe| GB
mgq kxAv bZvivI nvbvdx bZv`i bvq wRnv` weivax
drIqv cKvk Kib|
107

Dciv AvjvPbvq cgvwYZ nq h, nvbvdx I kxAv
bZvivB BsiR weivax wRnv` Av`vjbK nvivg
NvlYv KiwQjb| beve, bvBU, Lvbevnv`y i I cxi-
gvkvqL bvgavixiv hLb Avivg-Avqk c vmv` I
LvbKvq em nvjyqv-iwU Avi Iim-gxjv` wbq e
wQjb, ZLb gynvv`x-Avnjnv`xQiv BsiR kvmK`i
Rj-hyjyg, duvwm I xcv i AKvZi Rxeb wejvwQjb
`ki ^vaxbZv I Bmjvgi mevP AMvwaKvi cwZvi
Rb| hgb evsjv`ki LvZbvgv HwZnvwmK I MelK
Avyj gI`y` ejb,
Kvjg evOvjx Rnv`xiv Avnjnvw`m, jv-gvhnvex,
gIqvn`, gyn`x, Mvqi gyKvwj` cf wZ bvg wPwZ
nqwQj ... wkL I BsiR`i wei wRnv` joZ
evOvjx gymjgvbiv mwqfve AskMnY KiQ Ges
AMwYZ A_ I mb cvwVq wbR`i KZe cvjb
Zrci nqQ| mKvjxb evsjv`ki cZK kni
Zv`i A_ I mb msMni NuvwU wQj| ... gvj`ni
(eZgvb PuvcvB beveMi cvKv-bvivqYcyi) iwdK wgquv
I Zuvi cy Avgxixbi bvg BwZnvmi AMZ
nqQ|
108
m mgq wenvi I evsjv wQj gyRvwn` I im`
ciYi K`j| Avi mKviY wenvi, cwg e I
evsjv`k Avnjnv`xQi msLv mevwaK| Avnjnv`xQ`i
mw`bi ZvMi djB ewUk Zvovbv me nq I hvi
djkwZZ ci ^vaxb fviZ I cvwK vb I eZgvb
^vaxb evsjv`k jvf Kiv me nqQ|
Gw`K BwZ KiB KwjKvZv wekwee`vjqi Bmjvgi
BwZnvm I mswZ wefvMi cdmi Wt Imgvb MYx
ejb, GB gnr Av`vjb ^ vaxbZvi c~e Zb exRic bv
iq Mj AvRKi w`bi ^ vaxbZvi mvbvi dmj meyR
kvjeb GZ mZi Av` Avgv`i nvZ AvmZ wK? my Zivs
GB Av`vjbi Ave`b I Ae`vb `yB-B AeY bxq I
AweiYxq|
109
AZGe Acc PviKvix`i ee Abyhvqx
Avnjnv`xQiv KLbvB BsiRi `vjvjx Kiwb Ges
Lvb`i A_ eo IVwb| GwU md g~LZv m~ jf I
welcm~Z cvcvMvv gv|
evsjv`k cPwjZ wkiKx wekvm I we`AvZx img-
iIqvR mg~ni wei evivmvZi mq` wbQvi Avjx
ZxZzgxi (1782-1831 Lt)-Gi cwiPvwjZ gynvv`x
Av`vjb I dwi`cyii (eZgvb gv`vixcy ii) nvRx

107. !!<, l l! !, <! !l!! (!!:
:>~) l<l*-: : >>-: :>|
108. !+ , !< !! (!! :>), : :|
109. !! !!, 5< ll : :-:|






35
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
kixAvZzjvn (1781-1840Lt)-Gi cwiPvwjZ dvivqhx
Av`vjb wQj g~jZt Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjbiB
cwZic| ZxZzgxi 1822 mvj n wMq mq` Avngv`
ejfxi nvZ evqAvZ Kib| wZwb `k wdi Gm
msvi Av`vjb i Kib| gymjgvb`i wei wn`y
Rwg`vii emvbv `vwoi Uv I Abvb wbhvZbi
wei wZwb mvPvi nb Ges AZvPvwiZ wn`y-gymwjg
KlK kYxi c Rvivjv Av`vjb Mo Zvjb|
dj wRnv` I kvnv`vZ bQxe nq| nvRx kixAvZzjvn
1799 _K 1818 Lt ch 19 eQi mE`x Avie
Aevb Kib I mLvb Iqvn&nvex Av`vjbi viv
cfvweZ nb| AZtci `k wdi mvgvwRK Kzmsvi
mg~ni wei Av`vjb i Kib| wZwb G`kK
`vij nie (weagxi ivR) ej drIqv `b| ZvZ
wZwb gvIjvbv KvivgZ Avjx Rbcyix (1800-1873) I
Zvi Abymvix Ges AZvPvix wn`y Rwg`vi I BsiR
KzwVqvj`i Pzk~j nb|
110
dj ZuvKI bvbvwea hyjyg I
wbhvZbi wkKvi nZ nq| DjL h, evsjv`ki e
Avnjnv`xQ AvRI gynvv`x dvivhx bvg cwiwPZ|
111

wewZ gv-g`xbvi Avjg`i h drIqvi K_v ejv
nqQ mUv wQj BsiR`i mg_b nvbvdx Avjg`i
c| m drIqv ZvivB GbwQjb Ges ZvivB GUv
Avnjnv`xQi wei evcKnvi cPvi KiwQjb|
hgb Avyj gI`y` ejb, mgy`Z A I AvBb ksLjv
chv bv nIqvq `kcwm Avjg`i, GgbwK gv
kixdi Pvi ghnvei cavb gydZx`i dZvqv cPvii
`iKvi nqwQj fviZxq weklZt evOvjx gymjgvb`i
ageywK cfvweZ Kievi Rb| we`kx I weagx`i
kvmbvwaKvi Pj MjI G`kUvK `vij Bmjvg
wnmve gb wbq GLvb kvw Z I wbic`e emevm
KiZ agxq Abygv`bI Gme dZvqvi viv jvf Kiv
nqwQj|
112
AZGe Kviv m mgq BsiRi `vjvjx
KiwQj I ewUk miKvii c`jnx wQj, D jLbx
_KB Zv cwivi nq hvq|
AbK Ijvgvq `De`K 1857 mvji wmcvnx
we`vni wniv evbvevi Pv Kib| hvK Av`
wRnv` ejv hve bv| Kbbv Bmjvgx LjvdZ cwZvi
j GB we`vn msNwUZ nqwb| AZtci h NUbvi
wfwZ D `vex Kiv nq Zv GB h, 1857 mvji g
gvm wmcvnx we`vni m~Pbvce mvnvivbcyi hjvi
_vbvfyb ciMYvi AbZg m`vi Kvhx Avyi inxg nvwZ
qi Dk mvnvivbcyi kni hvb| mKvj nvwZ wQj

110. .=. <! l~ !, <!! l! l<! (!!
~:), : :-
111. !! !!, 5< ll, ct 63|
112. !+ , !< !! : :: !l
!l!! l l l! !, !! :>~,
l<l* :, ~, :- < : :>:->|
Avgxi I iCm`i kvfv ea bi gvag| wK Kvhx
Qvnei kiv Mvcb BsiR gvwR UK Z_ `q h,
wZwb BsiR`i wei hy Kivi Rb nvwZ wKbZ
GmQb| gvwRU GB Lei cqB ZuvK MdZvi
Kib I Kvbic hvPvB-evQvB bv KiB KqKRb
mxmn ZvK nZv Kib| GZ GjvKvi jvK w nq
Ges Zviv we`vnx nq DV|
DjL h, _vbvfyb ciMYvi 35 nvhvi RbmsLvi mvZ
nvhviB wQj BsiR mbvevwnbxZ KgiZ| Zvi ga 32
Rb wQjb DPc` KgKZ v|
113
AZGe Zv`i BsiR
weivax nIqvi Kvb KviY wQj bv| eis GwU wQj
cwZkvag~jK GKwU vbxq NUbv gv|
114
Avi m eZt
mKviYB DBwjqg DBjmb nvUvi c` wicvU, hv
AvIqvi Bwqvb gymjgvb&m bvg 1872 mvj c_g
cKvwkZ nq, Zvi me Iqvnnvex I Qvw`Kcy ix
gyRvwn``i BsiRweivax ZrciZvi AvjvPbvq ficyi
_vKjI Kv_vI mvnvivbcyi ev `De`i gvkvqL`i
bvg LuyR cvIqv hvq bv| GgbwK Ijvgvq wn` Kv
kvb`vi gvhx (l! !< ! ' : !
:>:>, << ! :>) eBqi jLK gvIjvbv gynvv`
wgquv Lye evwoq-Pvwoq wjLI Aekl ^xKvi KiZ
eva nqQb h, BwZnvmi GKRb Qv weqi mv_
j Ki h, ^vaxbZv hyi BwZnvm gvjvMo I
diLbMii gZ ALvZ vb mg~ni bvg cvIqv MjI
gyhvddi bMi I mvnvivbcy i hjvi bvg cvIqv hvq bv
(hLvb `De` AewZ)|
115
eis 1875 mvj D
gv`ivmv KZci AvgY BsiR miKvii cwZwbwa
wgt cvgvi `De` gv`ivmv cwi`k b Ki GB ej
wicvU `b h, GB gv`ivmv me `v e wUk miKvii
AbyMZ I mnhvMx|
116

cieZxZ 1913 mvj AmnhvM Av`vjbi mgq gvIjvbv
Ievq`yjvn wmxi civPbvq ZrKvjxb gynZvwgg kvqLy j
wn` gvIjvbv gvng~`yj nvmvb 1914 mvji ci ikgx
igvj loh gvgjvq MdZvi nq wZwb I gvIjvbv
nvmvqb Avngv` gv`vbxmn AvURb gvvq 4 eQi wbevwmZ
_vKb| ejv nq _vK h, GBme njy ` igvj gvIjvbv
gvng~`yj nvmvb Zzii Ljxdv I wnRvhi kvmK`i KvQ
ewUk miKvii wei mvnvh Pq wKQz jvKK Hme
`k cvwVqwQjb| GB Mvcb Z_ duvm nj Zviv
MdZvi nb| GZ `De` gv`ivmvi cwiPvjbv KwgwU ev
Ab Kvb bZe`i mwZ wQj bv Ges G KviY
Ievq`yjvn wmxK 1913 mvj gv`ivmvi wkKZvi PvKzix

113. !! l ! !!< !, <>!<! !!, . !. <!.
~::, /~, |
114. !!:~ , !< l>! (><!!!, !l!
::/:>:), : :-:>|
115. !|! l=!, !! l ! !!< !, !!< !!,
/~> : =, <>!<! !!, /~:|
116. !< l>!, : :|






36
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
nZ ewnvi Kiv nq| DjL h, Bwb bI gymwjg wkL
wQjb Ges 1909 mvj Bwb `De`i wkK nIqvi AvM
ch GB gv`ivmvi Kvb ew BsiRi AvbyMZ weivax
Kvb KvR Ask bbwb|
117
eis 1911 mvj RgCqvZzj
AvbQvi (mvnvhKvix`i `j) bvg kvqLyj wn` h
ivRbwZK `j cwZv Kib, Zvi j I Dk MnxZ
c vebv mg~ni ga AbZg c vebv wQj, miKvii
AvbyMZi cwZ RbMYK wb`kbv c`vb|
118

eZt 1913 mvj `kevcx AmnhvM Av`vjbi mgq
`De` gv`ivmv KZc me`v BsiR kvmK`i mv_
cyivcywi mK iL Pjb Ges Ievq`yjvn wmxK ei
Ki `evi ci Zviv BD,wc-i BsiR MfYiK gv`ivmvq
AvgY Rvbvb| MfYi Rg&m wgmUb Lykxgb GLvb
Avmb I eZv Kib| AZtci gynZvwgg nvdh
gynvv` Avngv`K kvgmyj Ijvgv (Avjg`i m~h)
DcvwaZ f~wlZ Kib| GB gynZvwgg wQjb gv`ivmvi
cwZvZv gvIjvbv gynvv` Kvmg bvbyZzexi cy|
119

1917 mvji 6B bf^i gvIjvbv gvng~ `yj nvmvb I
Ab`i gywi Rb Ijvgvq `De`-Gi c nZ
BsiR miKvii wbKU h Ave`b ck Kiv nq, ZvZ
Zviv ejb h, md m`nek ZuvK MdZvi Kiv
nqQ| bBj weMZ 30/40 eQii AwfZvi AvjvK
Avgiv ejwQ h, wZwb mn mg `De`x RvgvAvZ me`v
wbzc I ivRbxwZgy GKwU RvgvAvZ|
120
GZ eySv hvq
h, 1857-Gi wmcvnx we`vn ev 1914 mvji ikgx
igvj loh KvbUvZB Zviv hy wQjb bv| eis me`v
BsiR ZvlY evcZ _KQb|
. <- |x|- <| (<:) |< |+|-|
Avgxij gyRvn`xb mq` Avngv` ejfx (1201-
46/1786-1831Lt) fviZi Di c`ki
ivqeijxZ RbMnY Kib| wZwb evjKvj w`jxi
gv`ivmv inxwgqvZ `yeQi covbv Kib| ci wZwb
UvsKi beve Avgxi Lvb wcvixi mbvevwnbxZ mvZ
eQi PvKzix Kib| wK Avgxi Lvb BsiRi m
Avcvl Kivq wZwb z nb Ges fviZi mxgv Aj
_K BsiR`i wei wRnv`i cwiKbv Kib| wZwb
ZrKvjxb fviZi Bjgx ivRavbx w`jxi AwjDjvn
cwievii mg_b jvfi Dk mLvb Mgb Kib|
AZtci D v` gvIjvbv Avyj Avhxh `njfxi BwZ
gvIjvbv Avyj nvB I gvIjvbv kvn BmgvCj Zuvi nvZ
wRnv`i evqAvZ Kib|
mvBwq` Avngv` ejfxi agxq I ivRbwZK wP vavivi
meUzKzB wQj kvn AwjDjvn I kvn Avyj Avhxhi jLbx
I wkv viv cfvweZ| wZwb evnZ nvbvdx wQjb| GRb

117. !, : |
118. H, ct 73, UxKv-1|
119. !< l>! : -:|
120. =, : >, >|
mhyMi KwVb mvgvwRK KzcgyKZvB meZt `vqx wQj|
wK Zuvi eei mgw wQivZ gy vKxg-Gi ga wZwb
cwivifve ejQb h, mvaviYfve h Pvi gvhnvei
AbymiY Kiv nq _vK, Zv mwVK| wK bex Kixg (Qvt)-
Gi Bj&gK Kvb wbw` GKRb gyRZvwn`-Gi ga
mxgve aviYv Kiv wVK bq| hw` Kvb gvmAvjvq we,
I Mvqi gvbm~L nv`xQ cvIqv hvq, m Kvb
gyRZvwn`i AbymiY Kiv Pje bv| gynvwQMYK G
evcvi AbymiYxq MY KiZ ne|
121
GLvb wZwb
ZrKvjxb wbqgvbyhvqx Kvb nvbvdx wevbi ZvKjx` bv
Ki gynvwQ Z_v Avnjnv`xQ wevbi wbKU _K
gvmAvjv Rb bevi wb`k w`Qb| ejv evj, mq`
Avng`i Dciv ee Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjbiB
h_v_ cwZawb|
122
AZGe mq` Avng` (int)-K
wkiK I we`AvZcx mvaviY nvbvdx fvev wVK bq|
AbK Zuv`i Av`vjbK ZixKvq gy nvv`xqv
Av`vjb ejZ PqQb
123
Ges Avnjnv`xQ`iK
mB Av`vjbi GKwU wewQb Dc`j wnmve MY
KiZ PqQb| A_P ev e K_v GB h, Zviv c PwjZ
wPkwZqv, Kv`wiqv BZvw` ZixKvi bvq wbqge Kvb
ZixKvi ceZK wQjb bv| eis ZvKjx`-wbfi h Bmjvg
ZrKvjxb fviZxq gymwjg mgvR Pvjy wQj, kvn
AwjDjvn I kvn BmgvCji wkv wQj Zvi wecixZ|
gymwjg mgvRK Avgj wej nv`xQi cwZ Dy Kiv I
wevb`i DvweZ ZixKvi e`j mivmwi ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi
nv`xQi AbymiYi cwZ AvnvbB wQj kvn AwjDjvn,
kvn BmgvCj, mvBwq` Avngv` ejfx I ejvqZ Avjx-
GbvqZ Avjxi Av`vjbi g~j myi| Zv`i GB `vIqvZ
wQj g~jZt Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjbiB `vIqvZ|
124
Avi
mKviYB Zuv`i Av`vjbi dj nvhvi nvhvi gvbyl
ZvKjx` Qo Avnjnv`xQ nqQb|
. 3/12/1886 Bs ZvwiLi 1758 bs viK cvve
miKvi Ave`bKvix jv-gvhnvex `jwUi bZv gynvv`
nvmvqb evUvjfxi `iLv gbhy i Kib Ges ZLb _K
G`i bvg Invex ev jv-gvhnvexi cwieZ Avnjnv`xQ
ivLv nq| < |<< <|< |-x <
evjvKvU cieZx wRnv` Av`vjbi bZZ cvUbvi
Qvw`Kcyix Avnjnv`xQ cwievii Dci Avm| dj Gi
cieZx kZelevcx wRnv` Av`vjb g~ jZt

121. l<! !, <! !!, : :::|
122. ll : ~:-, ~:|
123. !< = <!<!< ll ' !l (<:)-=< l! l
!!< <! ' !-, ! !!< < !! !l
<! (!:) =l!< <l =l ! <l <
l !!< l<! !! l< =l ! !l
< <!< l<' (ll : ~:>, : !-~>) =! l<
ll =! <!< >/ ! !!$! <l !l
^ (!!, l<l, l! !/:> l<!' <!|
124. ll, : ~:-|






37
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Avnjnv`xQ`i bZZ cwiPvwjZ nq| BsiRi AbyMZ
nvbvdx Avjgiv ZLb Avnjnv`xQ`iK Iqvnnvex,
ivdv`vbx, jv-gvhnvex, Mvqi gyKvwj`, exb BZvw`
bvg me Acev` iUvZv| Avi Zv`iB wbi i
AccPvi I loh BsiR kvmKiv Avnjnv`xQ cjB
ZvK wRnv`x, Iqvnnvex ej MdZvi KiZ| Avi Zv`i
fvM bg AvmZ Rj-hyjyg, duvwm, xcv i BZvw`
bvbvwea wbhvZbi xg ivjvi|
gvIjvbv gynvv` nvmvqb evUvjex (gZ: 1920 Lt)
Zuvi `iLv i gvag Iqvnnvex I Avnjnv`xQ GK bq
mUv eySvZ Pv KiwQjb Ges Gi viv wZwb mvaviY
wbixn Avnjnv`xQ`iK BsiRi Rj-hyjyg nZ
euvPvZ PqwQjb| wK Gi Rb mg Avnjnv`xQK
BsiRi AbyMZ cgvY Kivi h e_ Pv Kvb Kvb
gnj _K j Kiv MQ, Zv KvbgB wVK bq|
125

gb ivLv AvekK h, GB w_wmmi cixK gjx wQjb
ivRkvnx, XvKv, PMvg I KwjKvZv wekwe`vjqi
^bvgab nvbvdx cdmiMY Ges Zuv`i AbK wQjb
cxicx| GiciI Zuviv memwZg D w_wmm cvm
Ki w`qQb| 1996 mvj GwU MvKvi (538 ct)
cKvwkZ nqQ Ges evRvi cvIqv hvQ|
c. '=<| |-||-< x|<+ < |<| +< -|'
<|< hme jvK Keic~Rv Ki Ges Keievmx gZewi
Amxjvq Avjvn&i bKU nvwQj wekvm Ki, mme ew
wbtm`n gykwiK| Aviei gykwiKivI g~wZc~Rvi gvag
Avjvn&i bKU nvwQj wekvm KiZ (!< :)|
evsjv`ki cvq mKj Keic~Rv Kw_Z nvbvdx bvgavix
wKQz wev jvKivB Ki _vK| AZGe Zv`iK
gykwiK ejvq Kvbic wav-msKvPi AeKvk bB|
hw`I Zv`iK mivmwi KD gykwiK ejb bv| Ze
K_vq ej, VvKzi Ni K? Kjv LvBwb|
e. '|<| < |-||-< -|x|# < -|'
<|< Gi A_ nvbvdx`i QvjvZ ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi
ZixKv Abyhvqx nq bv| D`vniY ^ic: (1) nvbvdxiv
QvjvZi c~eB Rvqbvgvhi `vAv cob (2) Zvnixgv
euvavi ci wbqZi bvg bvIqvBZz Avb cob, hv
GKeviB evbvqvU (3) hCd nv`xQ Rvbv mI md
ghnvei `vnvB co nvbvdx cyiliv bvwfi bxP nvZ
euvab I gwnjviv eyKi Dci nvZ euvab (4) GKB
`vnvB co nvbvdx gyv`xMY m~iv dvwZnv eRb Kib
(5) GKB `vnvB co Rnix QvjvZ m~iv dvwZnv kl
Avgxb bxie cob (6) GKB `vnvB co iKzZ
hvIqv I iKz _K IVv Ges ZZxq ivKAvZ `uvovevi
mgq ivdDj Bqv`vqb- Gi Qnxn gyZvIqvwZi mybvZ
cwiZvM Kib (7) GKB `vnvB co wmR`v _K DV

125. ll : ~|
`uvovevi mgq gvwUZ nvZ fi bv w`q Zxii gZ mvRv
DV `uvovb (8) GKB `vnvB co KvZvi `u vwoq `yB
gyQjxi cvqi gvS duvK ivLb Ges Gfve ivm~ j (Qvt)-
Gi ee Abyhvqx KvZvii gvS Kvjv eKixi bvq
kqZvbK me`v jvjb Kib (9) GKB `vnvB co
Zv`xj AviKvb Z_v axi-my QvjvZ Av`vq bv Ki
`Z QvjvZ cob (10) GKB `vnvB co nvbvdx
gwnjvMY wmR`vq wMq gvwUZ wbZ^ ivLb| dj mviv
Rxeb Zviv mwVKfve wmR`v QvovB QvjvZ Av`vq Kib
(11) GKB `vnvB co nvbvdx gyQj xMY `yB wmR`vi
gvS eVK em mybvZx `vAv cvV Kiv nZ weiZ
_vKb (12) GKB `vnvB co nvbvdx LZ xeMY
RygAvi w`b gyQjx`i gvZfvlvq g~ j Lyrev bv w`q
AvMB wg^i em evsjvq ZZxq AviKwU Lyrev Pvjy
KiQb| A_P Avjvn&i ivm~ j (Qvt) me `v ^ xq gvZfvlvq
`uvwoq `yB Lyrev w`qQb (13) GKB `vnvB co
nvbvdx gyQjxMY C`vqbi QvjvZ AwZwi 12
ZvKexii j 6 ZvKexi `b| ZvI Avevi `y B
ivKAvZ `yB ZixKvq (14) GKB `vnvB co ivm~ j
(Qvt)-Gi wbqwgZ mybvZ 8 ivKAvZ Zvivexn-Zvnvy`
ev` w`q Zviv 20 ivKAvZ cob| m m Igi
(ivt) I Abvb QvnvexMYi Dci BRgv-Gi bvg
wg_vivc Kib (15) GKB `vnvB co Zviv Rvbvhvi
QvjvZ ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi R jRv mybvZ m~iv dvZnv cvV
Kib bv| A_P hUv ivm~j (Qvt) Kibwb, mB wbqZ
cvV Kib I Qvbv cob (16) GKB `vnvB co Zviv
mdi QvjvZ Rgv I KQi Kib bv| GgbwK ni mgq
AvivdvZi gq`vbI hvni I AvQi Rgv I KQi bv
Ki c_Kfve mybvZ mn cy iv QvjvZ Av`vq Kib|
GmeB Zviv mviv Rxeb Ki hvQb nvbvdx gvhnvei
`vnvB co| A_P gvhnve gvbv dih bq, eis Qnxn
nv`xQ gvbv dih| ZvQvov meB Kiv nQ Bgvg Avey
nvbxdv (int)-Gi bvg| A_P wZwb cwivifve ej
MQb Qnxn nv`xQB Avgvi ghnve|
126
AZGe cKZ
nvbvdx Kej wZwbB nZ cvib, whwb me Qnxn
nv`xQ gb Pjb| Avnjnv`xQMY hUv Ki _vKb|
Avgiv ejZ PvB whwb Rb-b mviv Rxeb evc-`v`v
wKsev gvhnvei `vnvB w`q Qnxn nv`xQK AMvn
Kib, wZwb wK ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi Aeva bb? Zuvi QvjvZ
wKfve Keyj ne? wZwb wKfve ivm~ j (Qvt)-Gi
kvdvAvZ Avkv KiZ cvib? ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi AevaZv
Avjvn&i AevaZvi kvwgj| AZGe n Aeva gy Qj x!
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi AevaZv Ki Kvb&
AvKvk ZvgvK Qvqv w`e? Kvb hgxb ZvgvK Avk q
w`e? AZGe mveavb nI! g Zzi AvMB ZIev Ki Qnxn
nv`xQi AvjvK Rxeb Mo| bBj wK qvgZi w`b

126. <!~ !< < !!! !, (<< !< l<,
::>>/:>>), :/:|






38
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
Avdmvm eZxZ Zvgvi fvM Avi wKQzB RyUe bv
(<!!<! ::)| Kvb Bgvg, cxi ev gyiex Zvgvi Rb
mw`b mydvwik Kie bv|
. =# x<| -|...
<|< Bgvg Avngv` web nv^j, Bgvg eyLvix I Abvb
BgvgMYi ee gZ cKZ Avnjnv`xQ hviv, Kej
ZvivB bvRx dKv| Bgvg Avey`vE` (202-275 wnt)
ejb, GB `jwU bv _vKj Bmjvg `ywbqv _K wgU
hZ| evKx gyZvwhjv, gywRqv, nvbvdx mn mevB givn
`j 72 dKvi A fy| GB fvMwU KiQb nvbvdx`i
kq eo cxi kvqL Avyj Kv`i Rxjvbx (int)|
127

huvi gZzw`em wnmve Zviv dvZnv Bqvh`ng ev GMviv
kixd cvjb Ki _vKb| AZGe G welq Avgv`i wKQz
ejvi bB| Avjvn mevBK cwe KziAvb I Qnxn
nv`xQi Dci h_vh_fve Avgj Kivi ZvIdxK `vb
Kib- Avgxb!
. |< '<-<|| -x- +|x|' ...
<|< K_vq ej A Qji bvg cjvPb| Gfve
wPiKvj we`AvZxivB Avnjnv`xQK wewfb evR bvg
AwfwnZ KiQ| eZ: KziAvb-nv`xQ Qo Kvb ewi
w`K m^ Ki Kvb gymjgvbi bvgKiY KivUvB Zv
Avmj we`AvZ| Gici wbR`i ivq-wKqvm I Rvj-
hCd nv`xQ fiv Ges wbR`i AvweKZ AmsL
we`AvZ, hgb- gxjv`-wKqvg, keeivZ, KzjLvwb-
Pnjvg, cxic~Rv, Mvic~Rv, Iim, wPjv, AvLix gybvRvZ
Ges ZvhwKqvq bdmi bvg AvweKZ kZ iKgi
gvidZx Kmir I miKvix wnmve gZ `ki Ab~b 2
j 98 nvhvi cxii bZzb bZzb drIqv I wkiK-
we`AvZi RMvwLPzoxK XvjvIfve nvbvdx gvhnve
ej Pvjvbv wK wb`vl Bgvgi Dci Pvjvbv wbKZg
Acev` bq? Bgvg Avey nvbxdv (int) wK Gme KiZb?
wZwb wK Gme KvRi AbygwZ w`qQb? Zuvi gvhnve wK
wQj, m evcvi Zuvi wjwLZ Kvb wKZve `ywbqvZ AvQ
wK? hw` bv _vK, Zvnj Zuvi bvg fvwOq wbR`i
nvbvdx ej gvbylK cZviYv Kivi A_ wK? AZGe
e`qvZx `gb KwgwU bv ej gyLvk Lyj dj
wbR`iK mivmwi we`AvZx bvg AwfwnZ Ki
mrmvnmi cwiPq `IqvB fvj ne| Kbbv mw`b ekx
`~i bq, hw`b nK-Gi wbR^ kwZ we`AvZ AcmZ
ne BbkvAvjvn| evbvqvU gvhnve I ZixKvi gvnRvj
wQb Ki nKcx gvbyl mZi mvb QzU Avme Pz^Ki
gZ cwe KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi w`K|
gb ivLv AvekK h, Avnjnv`xQ cPwjZ A_ Kvb
dKv ev gZev`i bvg bq, GwU GKwU c_i bvg| hv
cwe KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi c_| gvbyli agxq I

127. l!< l!, l< !!, :/:: <!, !-l!,
<< !!, :/::
elwqK Rxebi hveZxq n`vqvZ G c_B gIRy`
iqQ| G c_i kl wVKvbv nj RvbvZ| Avnjnv`xQ
Av`vjb mB RvbvZx c_B gvbylK Avnvb Rvbvq|
(>) Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjb evsjv`k I Zvi mnhvMx
msMVb I cwZvb mg~ni gvag Ges mggbv ewMYi
gvag `k I we`k hLb evcKnvi Qnxn nv`xQ
wfwK Rxeb Movi `vIqvZ evw jvf KiQ Ges `j
`j gvbyl evc-`v`vi gvhnve Qo Avnjnv`xQ nQb,
ZLb mgvRi GK`j Kvqgx ^ v_ ev`x ivRbwZK
agbZvi Mv`vn i nqQ| Giv Avnjnv`xQ-Gi
wei bvbvwea MxeZ-ZvngZ I Acev` iUvQb|
weMZ Pvi`jxq RvU miKvii cvUbvi wnmve G`i
GKwU `j Avnjnv`xQ bZe`i Dci wg_v Acev`
w`q Rj-hyjygi wkKvi evwbqwQj| GLb Zv`i Ab
`jwj gvV Mig KiQ| GBme cu y wRev`x ivRbwZK cxi
Qvne`i ew`bi Lv`g I gyix`iv hLb ZIev Ki
Avnjnv`xQ nq hvQb, ZLb Gu iv PvL mldz j
`LQb, Avi cjvc eKZ i KiQb| Zviv mcwZ
nvbvdx HK cwil` AvnjmybvZ Iqvj RvgvqvZ
cwil` Ijvgv cwil` BZvw` bvgKvIqv msMVb
Kvqg Ki Avnjnv`xQ bZe`i KvQ bvsiv Zv`i
eB-c Ges Pvji wPwV I KvMR-c cvVvQb| Giv
KD `k Bmjvgx KzgZ KD Bmjvgx LjvdZ KD
Bmjvgx kvmbZ BZvw` Kvqgi k vMvb w`q
ivRbxwZi gvV Mig Kib| Giv wbRiv gI`~`x-
ZvejxMx, PigvbvB-`IqvbevMx, AvUikx-gvBRfvvix,
wihfx-Invex BZvw` bvg cviwiK `jv`wj I
nvbvnvwbZ Z-weZ| A_P Avnjnv`xQK ejQb
gybwKi nv`xQ|
128
jv-kigi evjvB _vKj Gic
K_v Zviv wjL cPvi KiZb bv| Avgiv ewj, AwZfw
I AwZ wel cwinvi Kib| cwe KziAvb I Qnxn
nv`xQ Abyhvqx Rxeb Movi kc_ wbb| wbR`i wKQz fyj
_vKj Zv mskvab Kib| gy mjgvb`i ciii fvB
nIqvi myhvM w`b| Zv`i ga cviwiK gneZ
ewi cwiek Zix Kib| Zvnj `k Avj vni wekl
ingZ bg Avme BbkvAvj vn|
Avjvn Zzwg Zvgvi wcq ev`v`iK Zvgvi wbfRvj
xbi cwZ Ges Zvgvi c wiZ wQivZ gy vKxgi c wZ
n`vqvZ `vb Ki- Avgxb! (..)|





128. !| !+< <!, < !! <! l
!!< !!l <!! (! ! !
!= !!, !! !^<-<, !! ~:~) : ~~






39
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv

|- <|- =<t ||-|<<|<+ <||-
!><! l< <<!
m vbi cwZ wcZv-gvZvi mePq eo `vwqZ I KZe
nQ- Zv`iK Av`k m vb wnmve Mo Zvjv| Avi
Qj-gqK wkwZ I Av`kevb Ki Mo Zvjvi g~j
Dk ne Zv`iK Rvnvbvg nZ iv Kiv| gnvb
Avjvn ejb,
` , ,' , ' , ` ,` ` , ` ' ` , ` ' , ` , ` , , _ ` , ` ` `
,` , _ - - , . ` ` ,` ..` , = . .
` , , , ` ,` , ' ` ,` , ` ,` , . .
n Cgvb`viMY! Zvgiv wbR`iK I ^xq cwievieMK
Avb (Rvnvbvg) nZ iv Ki, hvi Bb ne gvbyl I
cv_i| mLvb AZ KKk, ip I wbgg ^fvei
dikZv wbqvwRZ _vKe, hviv KLbB Avjvn&i K_v
Agvb Ki bv Ges wb`k Abyhvqx KvR Ki (!< :)|
AvRKvj wcZv-gvZv Zv`i m vb`iK wkv `vbi
Rb AbK Pv Ki _vKb| GgbwK Zviv m vbK ay
zj cvwVqB v nb bv; eis Kvmi ci cvBfU,
KvwPs BZvw`i gvag m vb`iK AvaywbK wkvq
wkwZ Kivi Pv Kib| ck nQ AwffveKiv wK
KLbv wP v Ki `LQb h, Zv`i m vbi Dci
Avjvn Kvb we`v wkv Kiv dih KiQb?
Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb, ` :` , _ ,` , ' , . - co
Zvgvi cfyi bvg, whwb ZvgvK mw KiQb (!! :)|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejQb, ` . ~ , ` , , . _ , ` `
we`v wkv Kiv cZK gymjgvbi Dci dih|
129
Avi
mUv nj KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi wkv Z_v xbx wkv|
G wkvq hw` m vb`i wkwZ Ki bv Zvjv nq, Zvnj
Zviv c_ nq hve| Kbbv `ywbqvex wkv nQ eev`x
wkv| Avi xbx wkv nQ AvLivZgyLx wkv| h wkv
gvbylK Zvi mvi mvb `q Ges ciKvj P~ov
mdjZvi w`K gvbylK avweZ Ki| xbx wkv wVK iL
Acivci vbvRb Kiv hZ cvi| Ze KLbv xbx
wkvK Dcv Ki Ab Kvb we`v ARb Kiv mgxPxb
bq| GZ eis c`PzZ I c_ nIqvi mvebvB _K
hvq|

* ll!, <l! !l !<!!, >!!<
129. < !>!, !< ^!, l! !/~:|
m vbK mywkvq wkwZ I Av`kevb Ki Mo Zvjvi
Rb wcZv-gvZvB cavbZ `vwqZkxj| Kbbv cvwievwiK
zjB Zvi wkvi nvZ Lwo| mKviY wcZv-gvZvK
`vwqZ mPZb nZ ne| Ab_v wK qvgZi w`b jv
RIqve nq hZ ne| Avyjvn Beby Igi (ivt) ejb,
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejQb,
. ' ` , _ _ ` , , ` , ` ` _ ` , ` , . ` , ` _
` _ _ ,` , ` , ` ` ` , _ . ` -` , , _ _ _ ` '
` , , ,` , ` , ` ` ,` ,` . '` , , , _ _ .` , , , ` ,
, , _ , ` , ` ` ,` ,` . ` ` , _ _ _ ` , ,` ,
` , ` ` ` . ' ` , _ _ ` , , ` , ` ` ` , _
mveavb Zvgiv cZKB `vwqZkxj| wK qvgZi w`b
Zvgv`i cZKi `vwqZ mK wRm Kiv ne|
myZivs kvmK RbMYi `vwqZkxj| wKqvgZi w`b Zvi
`vwqZ mK wRm Kiv ne| cy il Zvi cwievii
`vwqZkxj, ZvK cwievii `vwqZ mK wRm Kiv
ne| x Zvi ^vgxi msmvi Ges m vbi Dci `vwqZ kxj|
wKqvgZi w`b ZvK G `vwqZ mK wRm Kiv ne|
GgbwK `vm-`vmxI Zvi gvwjKi m`i evcvi
`vwqZkxj| mBw`b ZvKI Zvi `vwqZ mK wRm
Kiv ne| AZGe gb iLv, Zvgiv cZKB
`vwqZkxj, Avi Zvgv`i cZKKB wK qvgZi w`b GB
`vwqZ mK wRm Kiv ne|
130

AZxe `ytLi welq nQ h, AvRKvj AwffveKMY
Zv`i m vb`i xbx wkvq wkwZ bv Ki `ywbqvex
welq wkv w`Z e nq coQb| Avgv`i DwPr
`ywbqvex wkvi cvkvcvwk xbx wkvq m vb`iK
wkwZ Kiv| KziAvbi Dciv AvqvZ I nv`xQ Avjvn
Rvnvbvgi fqvenZv ck KiQb Ges cwievii
cavbK KVvifve mveavb KiQb Ges cwieviK
Rvnvbvg _K iv Kivi wb` k w`qQb| my Zivs wcZv-
gvZvi c _K m vb-m wZi cwZ mePq eo AbyM n
nQ, Zv`iK mywkv I m`yc`k w`q, Avj vn&i fq
`wLq fvj KvR-Kg Af Kiv Ges Gi gvag
ciKvj Rvnvbvg _K iv Kivi Pv Kiv| G c m
KziAvb DwjwLZ jvK gvb KZK ^xq cy K c`
Dc`kevYx weklfve jYxq| Dc`kjv
avivevwnKfve Dcvcb Kiv nj-
(:) jvKgvb ^xq cyK wkiK _K weiZ _vKvi
Dc`k `b| hv KziAvb Gfve DwjwLZ nqQ-

130. <!<, l, l! !/:|
x||-< ||






40
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
` , . , . ` ` , , ` = , ,` , =. , ` ,` .` .
` ` , = ` , = ` , ` , .
iY Ki, hLb jvKgvb ^xq cyK Dc`k w`q
ejjb, n wcq erm! Avjvn&i mv_ KvDK kixK Kiv
bv| wbqB wkiK mePq eo hyjyg (!! ::)|
DjL h, wkiKi fqvenZv mK Ab Avjvn
ZvAvjv ejb, ` ` ` ' , = , ` ,` = ` , - ` ` , ` -
` , = , ` _` ` , ' , .` ' ` _ . . wbqB h ew
Avjvn&i mv_ wkiK Kie, Avjvn Zvi Rb RvbvZ nvivg
Ki `b| Avi hvwjg`i Kvb mvnvhKvix _vKe bv
(!! ~)| wZwb Aviv ejb, . = ` , ` , . ' ' , ,`
, ` , ` , , ` ,` . : ` ` , . wbqB Avjvn Zuvi mv_
kixK Kivi Mvbvn gv Kib bv| Zv eZxZ Abvb
Aciva hvK BQv gv Kib (l! )| Ab wZwb
ejb, ` , ` , ' - :` , _ , ` , ` : ` ` . ,` '
` = ` - , : ` , , ` ` , , - Zvgvi cwZ I
Zvgvi c~eeZx`i cwZ AekB Anx nqQ, Zzwg
Avjvn&i mv_ kixK wi Kij Zvgvi Kg wbj ne
Ges AekB Zzwg wZM `i A fy ne (!< :)|
(>) jvKgvb Zuvi QjK me aibi wkiK cwinvi
Kivi Dc`k c`vbi ci Avjvn&i gZv AewnZ Kib|
Avjvn&i vb Amxg| wZwb mewKQz AeMZ| ZvgvK
mecKvi Mvcb I cKvk Abvq _K weiZ _vKZ ne
Ges ciKvj wePvii w`b AYy cwigvY fvj wKsev g`
KvRi dj fvM Kivi RbI cZ _vKZ ne|
jvKgvb ejb, . ,` ` ` , , ` , - ` ` ` - ` :
` ` ` , ' . , ` ` , ' ,` - . , , . ' , ` _ '
= . = ` , = ` , - ` . ` , . n erm! z` ewU hw` mwilvi
`vbv cwigvYI nq Ges Zv hw` _vK wkjvMf A_ev
AvKvk wKsev gwKvi bxP, Avjvn ZvI DcwZ
Kieb| Avjvn m~`kx, mgK AeMZ (!! :)|
() `ywbqvZ h KvR GKv hiix Zv nQ QvjvZ Av`vq
Kiv| jvKgvb ^xq cyK QvjvZi Dc`k w`q ejb,
` .. ,. ' ` . ` , , n wcq erm! QvjvZ Kvqg Ki
(!! :)| DjL h, G cm Avjvn ZvAvjv ivm~j
(Qvt)-K wb`k w`q ejb, ` ,` ' , : ` ' ` . , ` , =` . ,
. ,` , Avcwb Avcbvi cwieviK QvjvZi Av`k w`b
Ges wbRI Gi Dci AwePj _vKzb (-! ::~)|
Dciv AvqvZ `ywUZ Avjvn ZvAvjv wcZv-gvZvK
m vb`i Dg wkvPvi wkv `vbi Dk QvjvZ
wkv `Iqvi evcvi ZvKx` KiQb| Kbbv QvjvZ
Akxj KvR nZ gvbylK weiZ ivL| hgb Avjvn
ZvAvjv ejb, . ` . _ ,` . .` - ,. ` ` ,
wbqB QvjvZ Akxj Ges g` KvR nZ weiZ ivL
(!!< )| hw` KD mwVKfve QvjvZ Av`vq Ki,
Zvnj m mnR g` KvR KiZ cvie bv|
() fvjKvRi Av`k I g`KvRi wbla Kivi
Dc`k w`q jvKgvb Zuvi wc q cy K ejb, ` ,.` ' ,
` ,` ,` , ` ` ` , , fvj KvRi Av`k `vI Ges
Abvq KvR _K wbla Ki (!! :)|
Cgvb`vi ew Kej wbRK wbqB ewZe _vKZ
cvi bv| eis cwievi, mgvR I RvwZi fvj-g` mK
j ivLv Zvi KZe| Zvi AbZg `vwqZ nj mr
KvRi Av`k Kiv Ges Amr KvRi wbla Kiv| Avi
mr KvRi Av`k I Abvq KvRi wbla Kivi KviY
ZvK bvbv iKg `ytL-K I jvbv fvM KiZ ne|
m Zviv hvZ nKi Dci my`p _vK Ges
mvnwmKZvi mv_ Abvqi cwZev` KiZ cvi Ggb
wkv w`Z ne| kwai hvwjg`i gy LvgywL `uvovZI
hb Zviv fq bv cvq| AbvqK bxie mn Kivi gZv
KvcilZv hb Zv`i wfZi KLbv cek KiZ bv
cvi, G wkvI m vb`iK w`Z ne|
(5) Qei ev ah-mwnz Zvi wb`k w`q jvKgvb Zu vi
cyK ejb, ` ,. ` : . : , . ' _ ` , ` . ,
` ,` ' _ Avc`-wec` ah aviY Ki| GUvZv `p msKi
KvR (!! :)| wec`-Avc` gy lo bv co m vbiv
hb ah aviY Ki G `xv Zv`iK w`Z ne|
(e) jvKgvb Zuvi cyK gvbyl _K wegyL bv nIqvi
Dc`k w`q ejb, . , ` ` - ` ,` .` Zzwg gvby lK
Aev Kiv bv (!! :)|
g~jZt m vbK G wkv w`Z ne h, Zviv hb
wbR`iK mvaviY gvbyl gb Ki| wbRK eo fe
KLbv hb Abi w`K nZ gyL wdwiq bv bq| Kbbv
AbK Aev Ki Zv`i _K gyL wdwiq bqv
AnsKvii bvgv i| Avi AnsKvi gvby lK mZ nZ
wegyL ivL| hgb AnsKvii KviY mZ nZ wegyL
nqwQj Bejxm| Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb, ,
` ,` ` -` ` ,` - . ` , ` , _ , ' , ` , . , .






41
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
` , , .. Avi Avwg hLb wdwikZvMYK ejjvg,
Zvgiv Av`gK wmR`v Ki, ZLb Bejxm eZxZ mKj
wmR`v Kij, m AMvn Ges AnsKvi Kij| Avi
Kvwdi`i A fy nq Mj (<!!<! :)|
() jvKgvb ^xq cyK AnsKvi bv Kivi Dc`k w`q
ejb, . , ` ` _ ' - , . = . ' . -` , .
` -` ` ,.` - _ hgxbi Dci AnsKvi ek Pjvdiv Ki
bv| Avjvn Kvb AvZMex I `vwKK cm` Kib bv
(!! :)| G AvqvZ viv evSv hvq h, `vwK I
AnsKvixiv Avjvn&i fvjevmv jvf KiZ cvi bv|
AnsKvix`i mK Avjvn Aviv ejb, . , `
` _ ' - , :` ` ,` - ` _ ' ` , _ ` - ` , ~ .
Zzwg hgxb ` fi Pjvdiv Kiv bv| Zzwg c`fvi
KLbvB hgxbK we`xY KiZ cvie bv Ges DPZvq
KLbB ceZ cgvY nZ cvie bv (<! <!^ :)|
() jvKgvb Zuvi cyK gacv Aej^bi Dc`k
w`q ejb, ` . , ` . : ,` . Avi Zzwg Zvgvi Pvj
Pjb gag cv Aej^b Ki (!! :>)| gag cvq
PjvPji KviY gvbyl mvwbZ nq| ZvB m vb`iK
gag cv Aej^bi Dc`k w`Z ne|
(o) jvKgvb Zuvi cyK wbg^i K_v ejvi Dc`k
w`q ejb, ` ` ` . , ` ' . : ` , . . ,.` . ' ,.
.` , - ` .` , .. , Avi Zvgvi K^i wbPz Ki| wbqB
^ii ga mePq KKk AvIqvR nj Mvavi AvIqvR
(!! :>)|
DPt^i K_v ejv kvjxbZv weivax| mf mgvR
DPt^i K_v ejv cm` Ki bv| ZvB m vb`iK
big I my`i fvlvq K_v ejv wkv w`Z ne|
wcZv-gvZvi `vwqZ nj, m vbK jvKgvbi bvq Dc`k
`qv, hv wZwb Zvi wcq cyK w`qwQjb| G `vwqZ cvjb
Kiv wcZv-gvZvi GKv KZe| nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` _ , ' ,` , ,` _ . = ` ` ` ,` _ = _. =
, ,, ` , ` ` , ` . ` , ` - ` , ` ' ` .
, ` , ' ` , , ` , ,
Avey ivqivn (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~j (Qvt)
ejQb, Av`g m vb cZKB KZv| myZivs cyil Zvi
cwievii KZv Ges bvix Zvi Nii KZx|
131


131. : >! !/: ll! ! !/~:|
G nv`xQ viv eySv hvq h, m vbK Av`k m vb ic
Mo Zvjvi `vwqZ wcZv-gvZvi| wcZv-gvZvi KviY
m vb Av`kevb nq Ges Zv`i KviYB m vb `y wii
AwaKvix nq| Zgwb wcZv-gvZvi KviY m vb wewfb ag
MnY Ki _vK| hgb nv`xQ GmQ,
` ` _ , ' ,` , ,` ` ` ' . ` , , ` ,` _ = _. = ,
,, ` ` , ` , . ` ,` , ` _ , = ` , , ' ` , ,` ,
,` . ` , , ` - ` , ,
Avey ivqivn (ivt) _K ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~jyjvn
(Qvt) ejQb, cZK m vb Bmjvgx ^ fvei Dci
RbMnY Ki| AZtci Zvi gvZv-wcZv ZvK B`x,
Lvb I AwM DcvmK ic Mo Zvj|
132

Aciw`K m vbK Av`k evb ic Mo ZzjZ wcZv-
gvZvi AbZg `vwqZ nj Zv`i Rb mr mx Ly u R ei
Kiv| hgb ejv nq _vK, mr m ^Mevm, Amr m
mebvk| G cm ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb,
` ` _ , ' ` ,` _ _._ = ` _ ` _. = , ,,
` , - _ ` . .` ,` , - :` _ ,
` , . , - :` ` . ' . : , ` -` , ` , . ' _ ` .` `
` , . ' - ` ` ` , _ - . ` , ~ ` _ , ` , , ` . ' ,` -` ,
. : , , ` , . ' - ` , _ - ` , -
Avey g~mv (ivt) nZ ewYZ, wZwb ejb, ivm~ jyjvn (Qvt)
ejQb, Dg mx I g` mxi ` v nQ, wgkK Av^i
I nvci Iqvjvi bvq| wgkK Av^i Iqvjv nqZv ZvgvK
wKQz `vb Kie A_ev Zvi KvQ _K wKQz q KiZ
cvie A_ev Zvi KvQ _K Zzwg myMw jvf Kie| Avi
nvci Iqvjv Zvgvi Kvco Rvwjq w`e A_ev Zvi KvQ
_K Zzwg `yM cve|
133
GB nv`xQ viv cZxqgvb nq
h, mxi KviY m vb wewfb ^fvei nZ cvi| ZvB
GB w`K wcZv-gvZvi weklfve Lqvj ivLv DwPr|
cwikl eje, wcZv-gvZv m vb wbq cwievi| wcZv-
gvZv cwievii g~j| m vbK Av`kevb Ki Mo
Zvjvi `vwqZ Zv`iB| ZvB Zv`iK G welq hZevb
nZ ne| Avi m vb Av`kevb I Bmjvgx gb-
gvbwmKZvq Mo DV h_vh_ Bev`Z KiZ cvij
RvbvZ hZ cvie| ZvB cZK wcZv-gvZvK KziAvb
I Qnxn nv`xQi Abymvix nq wbRK I Zvi cwieviK
Rvnvbvgi Avb _K iv Kivi Pv KiZ ne|
Avjvn Avgv`i ZvIdxK `vb Kib-Avgxb!!

132. !! !!, l! !/>|
133. <!< !/:|






42
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv

|-| <+|<| <|-|< | ||<
+|+-
gywgb Zvi cvci KviY Rvnvbvgi Avb ` ne| wK
Zvi Cgvbi KviY GK mgq m RvbvZ hve| Rvb vZ
hvIqvi c~e Avjvn ZvAvjv I ev`vi ga h
K_vcK_b ne, m mK wbgv nv`xQ-
Ave~ ivqiv (ivt) nZ ewYZ, jvKiv wRm Kij, n
Avjvn& i ivm~j (Qvt)! Avgiv wK wKqvgZi w`b Avgv`i
cwZcvjKK `LZ cve? AZtci Ave~ ivqiv (ivt)
nv`xQi evKx Ask Ave~ mvC` Ly`ix (ivt) ewYZ nv`xQi
Abyic eYbv KiQb| Ze Ave~ ivqiv (ivt) Avjvn&i
cvqi bjv cKvk Kieb G K_vwU DjL Kibwb| Avi
ivm~j (Qvt) ejQb, Rvnvbvgi Dci cyjwQivZ vcb
Kiv ne| m mgq ivm~jMYi ga Avwg Ges Avgvi
DZB mec_g cyjwQivZ cvi ne| mw`b cyjwQivZ cvi
nIqvi mgq ivm~jMY Qvov Avi KD K_v ejeb bv| Avi
ivm~jMY ay ejeb, mvwjg mvwjg, n Avjvn! wbivc`
ivL, n Avj vn! wbivc` ivL| Avi Rvnvbvgi ga
mv`vbi KuvUvi bvq AvsUv _vKe, mwj mv`vbi KuvUvi
gZ Ze mwj KZ eo Zv AvjvnB fvj Rvbb| H
AvsUvwj gvbylK Zvi Avgj AbycvZ AuvKo aie|
myZivs wKQz jvK wbR Avgji KviY asm ne Ges wKQz
jvK UzKiv UzKiv nq hve, ci Avevi bvRvZ cve|
Aekl hLb Avjvn wePvi kl Kieb, wbRi wekl
`qv viv wKQz gvbylK Rvnvb vg _K gyw `Iqvi BQv
Kieb| Avi hviv mv w`qQ h, GK Avjvn Qvov Kvb
gve~` bB| ZLb Avjvn dikZv`i Av`k Kieb h,
hviv GKgv Avjvn& i Bev`Z KiQ Zv`iK Rvnvbvg
nZ ei Ki Avb| ZLb Zviv H mg jvK`i Kcvj
wmR`vi wP `L wPbZ cvieb Ges Rvnvbvg _K ei
Ki Avbeb| Avi Avjvn wmR`v wPwZ vbmg~ n Avbi
Rb R vjvbv nvivg Ki w`qQb| dj Rvnvbvg wbw
cwZwU gvbyli wmR`vi vb eZxZ Rvnvbvgi Avb MvUv
`nwU R vwjq wbw Ki w`e| myZivs Zv`iK Ggb
AwM` Ae vq Rvnvbvg nZ ei Kiv ne h, Zviv
GKevi Kqjv nq hve| ZLb Zv`i Dci nvqvZ `vb
Kiv cvwb Xj `Iqv ne| GZ Zviv Ggbfve mRxe
nq DVe, hgb Kvb exR cvwbi mvZi avi mRxe nq
DV| m mgq Rvnvb vg nZ mekl Rvb vZ cekKvix
GK ew RvbvZ I Rvnvbvgi gvS _K hve, hvi gyL
ne Rvnvbvgi w`K| m eje, n Avgvi cwZcvjK!
Rvnvb vgi w`K nZ Avgvi gy LLvbv wdwiq w`b| KviY
Rvnvb vgi D nvIqv AvgvK AZwaK K w`Q Ges
Zvi AwMwkLv AvgvK ` Ki djQ| ZLb Avjvn
ejeb, Zzwg hv PvQ Zv w`j Avi Ab wKQz PvBe wK?
ZLb m eje, Avcbvi mvbi Kmg Ki ejwQ, Avwg
Avi wKQzB PvBe bv| Avi m Avjvn& i BQvZB G
cwZkwZ c`vb Kie| ZLb Avj vn Zvi gyLK Rvnvb vgi
w`K nZ Nywiq w`eb| hLb m RvbvZi w`K gyL
Kie Ges Zvi PvKwPK I kvgj `k `LZ cve, ZLb
Avjvn hZY Pzc ivLZ PvBeb ZZY Pzc _vKe|
Zvici eje, n Avgvi c wZcvjK! AvgvK RvbvZi
`iRv ch wbq hvb| G K_v b Avjvn ejeb, Zzwg wK
cwZkwZ `vIwb h, Zzwg GKevi hv PqQ ZvQvov KLbI
Avi Ab wKQz PvBe bv| ZLb m eje, n Avgvi
cwZcvjK! Avcwb AvgvK Avcbvi m wK~ji ga
mevcv nZfvM Kieb bv| ZLb Avjvn ejeb, AvQv,
ZvgvK hw` G mg wKQz `Iqv nq Zvnj wK Ab Avi
wKQy PvBe? m eje, bv| Avcbvi mvbi Kmg! GQvov
Avwg Avi wKQzB PvBe bv| m Avjvn& i BQvZB G
cwZkwZ c`vb Kie| ZLb ZvK RvbvZi `iRvi KvQ
wbq Avmv ne| Gmgq m Zvi gaKvi Avivg-Avqk I
Avb`i cvPzh `LZ cve Ges Avjvn hZY Pzc ivLZ
PvBeb ZZY m Pzc _vKe| AZtci m eje, n
Avgvi cwZcvjK! AvgvK Rvb vZ cek Kwiq w`b|
ZLb Avjvn ejeb, Avdmvm n Av`g m vb! Zz wg
mvsNvwZK Iqv`v fKvix| Zzwg wK G gg cwZk wZ `vIwb
h, Avwg hv wKQz w`e, ZvQvov Ab Avi wKQz PvBe bv?
ZLb m eje, n Avgvi cwZcvjK! AvgvK Avcbvi
mwi ga mKji Pq `y fvMv Kieb bv| GB ej m
Avjvn& i KvQ cv_bv KiZ _vKe| GgbwK Zvi G wgbwZ
`L Avjvn nm DVeb| hLb wZwb nm djeb ZLb
ZvK Rvb vZ ceki AbygwZ w`q ejeb, Gevi PvI
Zvgvi hv PvIqvi AvQ| ZLb m Avj vn&i KvQ gb Lyj
PvBe| GgbwK hLb Zvi AvKvsLv kl nq hve, ZLb
Avjvn iY Kwiq w`q ejeb, GUv PvI, IUv PvI|
GgbwK m AvKvsLvI hLb kl nq hve| ZLb Avjvn
ejeb, G mg wKQzB ZvgvK `Iqv nj| Ave~ mvC`
Ly`ix (ivt)-Gi eYbvq AvQ- Avj vn ejeb, hvI
ZvgvK G mg wKQz Zv w`jvg, Gi m AviI `kY
cwigvY w`jvg (<!<, l, l! !/::)|
Avjvn& i cwZ h_v_ Cgvb AvbqbKvix ew Zvi cvci
KviY Rvnvbvg MjI Kvb GK mgq Avj vn ^xq
ingZ gywgb ewK Rvb vZ cek Kiveb| ZvB
Avgv`i DwPZ Avjvn&i cwZ GKwbfve Cgvb Avbqb
Kiv Ges h_vmva Avgj Qvjn Kiv| Avjvn Avgv`i
ZvIdxK `vb Kib- Avgxb!
!|! !< !!<
l&<, !!!$!, ^!!^&
|-|v<






43
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv

+|| |+|< <|<
Avgxb Abvm-gvvm cvk GKRb UMeM hyeK| Abvb
Qj`i gZv ZvK PvKwii Rb vi vi nu vUZ nqwb ekx
w`b| wekwe`vjq _K ewiq Qq gvmi ga PvKwi Ry U
Mj| Lye fvj PvKwi| eo Awdmvi c`| eZbI ek fvj|
wK cwikgUv GKUz ekx| mB mKvj 8-Uv _K ivZ 8-Uv
ch|
^ZtZZv, KgPvj I mRbkxj wP vaviv w`q m A
mgqi ga Awdmi QvU-eo mevi gb Rq Ki dj| m
Awdmi KvR LyeB hZkxj I Av wiK| Zvi nvwhiv LvZvq
Kvbw`b jvjKvwji `vM cowb|
cvwbi mvZi gZv w`b eq Pjj| BwZga PvKwi Rxeb Zvi
cg eQi c`vcY| mdjZvi mv_ G eQiUv PvLi cjK
KU Mj| l eQi PjQ| mw`bwUi K_v AvRv Zvi fvj
iY AvQ| fyj hve wK Ki? w`bwU wQj mvgevi| mKvj 7-
Uvq Nyg fvjv| Rvbvjv w`q evBi mvbvSiv ivyi Pvwiw`K
Sjgj KiQ| `Z weQvbv Qo DV Kvb GK ARvbv Avb`
wbR wbR nvmj Avgxb| Zvici Mvmji Rb ev_ig XyK
mvevb-kvy gL Lye fvj Ki Mvmj Kij| wgwbU `kK
eq nj ZvZ| Gevi wPiYx wbq Avqbvi mvgb `uvovj|
Avqbvq PvL coZB fxlYfve PgK DVj m| `wcUvq
hb nvZzwoi evwo coj| nvZzox cUvbvi k hb m wbRi
KvbI bZ cvQ| wbRi ARv B AvZwPrKvi ewiq Gjv
Zvi gyL _K| Avqbvi KvQ _K 7-8 cv wcwQq Avmj m|
Zvi mg kixi Aek nq AvmZ jvMj| gb nj kixii
wkiv-Dcwkivq i PjvPj e nq hvQ| wbRi PvLK
wekvm KiZ cvij bv| f~Z `Lvi gZ gb nj| mwK! Zve
evcvi|
wbevK cv_ii gZ KZ mgq `uvwoq wQj m Zv ejZ cvie bv|
wbRi ga kw-mvnm mq Ki GK cv `y cv Ki Avqbvi Lye
KvQ Pj Mj m| nvZ w`q fvj Ki `LZ jvMj| ZvBZv
bvK Mj Kv_vq? nvIqv nq Mj bvwK? m gb Kij hb MZ
ivZ KD Pzwi Ki wbq MQ| wK mLvb Zv ii `vM
_vKe| ZvI Zv bB| ZvK KZ exfrm `LvQ| wK Ggb
Zv nevi K_v wQj bv|
GZY wbRK m Avwevi Kij| mg kixi kxZi eid
Rgv wekvj cvnvo| kixi GZ fvix gb nj h cv Zvjvi
gZv bB| A^wZ QUdU KiZ jvMj| mvRv Pj Mj
Rvbvjvi cvk| iv vq vggvb meviB Zv bvK wVK RvqMvq
AvQ| Zvnj ZviUv Mj Kv_vq?
gNvQb gyL-PvL Ki jvbv Rj wbq Avgxb GKevi LvUi
Dci emQ Avevi DV Avqbvi mvgb `uvovQ| wbRK Zvi
Lye Amnvq gb nj| Ggb fqsKi NUbv `Lv Zv `~ii K_v
c-cwKvqI Zv Kvbw`b cowb m| Aw i QUdUvwbZ
KU hvQ mgq| Nwoi w`K ZvKvj m| mKvj mvo `kUv|
LvUi Dci big weQvbvq Mv Gwjq w`j m| ZvI A^ w jvMQ
Zvi| nVvr Zvi evoxi K_v gb coj| gv-evev, fvB-evb
AvZxq-^ Rb, KZ ey-eve I`i mvgb m G Ae vq wKfve
`u vove? Nvg mg kixi wfR hvQ| `q gvPo w`q
DVjv| wKQzB fveZ cviQ bv| gv_v Ny icvK LvQ| wP vq
KvZi nq coj Avgxb|
MZ `yw`b AvM Avgxbi KvQ Avmv` Qvne GmwQjb GKUv
hiix KvR| Zvi mg wKQz bj| Nvo bo Avmv` QvneK
ejj, evcviUv eo iZi| wZwb cvk Gm nvZ ai ejjb,
fvB AvgvK Dvi Kib bBj...? M xi K ejj, cbi
nvhvi UvKv w`Z ne| UvKvi AsKUv b Zvi PvL Qvbveov|
wZwb GKUz Kg w`Z PvBjb| Avgxb GKevi bv Kij|
Aekl wK Avi Kiv? cyiv UvKvUvB w`q Mjb Avmv`
Qvne| UvKvjv ZvovZvwo wbq Avjgvwii ga Zvjve Kij
Avgxb| gbi wfZi Abvwej Avb` eq hZ jvMj Zvi|
mw`bi K_v AvR q wP v KiQ, GUv wbqB Zvi cvci
c wZdj| Ggb bvRy K Aevq gby l mgvR evm Kiv me bq|
jvq gylo coj m| Rxeb _K m cvwjq euvPvi wmv
wbj| AvR ivZB ne Zvi Rxebi kl ivZ| Nwoi w`K
ZvKvj| mv 6-Uv| AveviI Avqbvi KvQ Mj| wmv wbj
AvM GB cvci UvKvjv wdwiq `e, Zvici `y wbqvi
gvqvRvj ZvM Kie|
Zwor MwZZ DV nvZ gyL ayq cvU-kvU ci wbj| cvci
UvKvjv Avjgvwi _K ei Ki _j fwZ Kij| eo GKLvbv
igvj gyL eivei Pc ai ei nj| GKwU wiv WK mivmwi
Avmv` Qvnei evmvi w`K Qz Uj| wMq UvKvi evMUv Zvi nvZ
awiq w`q we`yr eM Pj Avmj Avgxb| Avmv` Qvne g~ wZi
gZ ZvwKq iBj| wKQz ejZ Mj wK...? wivq Avevi Pc
emj Avgxb| wiv Avcb MwZZ PjQ| gbi ga ck D`q
nj mevB Zv ek myLB PjQ| wK Avgvi GwK nj? c w_ex
Qo hvevi c~e gyn~ZwU Pvwiw`K fvj Ki `L wbQ m|
Avj vn&i mw cw_ex KZB bv my`i| wbRi ARv B `xNkvm
ei nq Gjv| wbRi Rxebi Rb GKUz `ytwLZ nj|
mvgb cuvP wgwbUi `~ iZ Zvi evmv| igvji wfZi k
Abyf~wZ Ui cj| QjK DVjv ey Ki i| PgK DVj m
Avevi wK nj? fq cj wKQzUv| fq PzcPvc em AvQ| eyKi
wfZi wK hb Abyf~ wZ Rvi Rvi jvdvQ| wiv Zvi evmvi
mvgb ivLj| wiv IqvjvK fvov wY w`j| W vBfvi Zvi
w`K KiY bqb ZvwKq _vKj|
mvRv ig XyK `iRvi wQUwKbx AvUK w`j Avgxb| Avqbvi
mvgb wMq fq fq igvj mivj| `LB Avb` bP DVj
Zvi gb, wPrKvi w`q DVj m| Gevi bvKZv wVK RvqMvqB
AvQ| m wbLuyZfve `LZ jvMj| wVK RvqMvqB Zv bvK
AvQ| cig myL PvLi KvY Ak Gm Mj| gb cojv
Zvi AvR mvgevi| enwZ I mvgevi ZIev Key ji w`b|
ZvB m ZIev Kij| Avi bq cvci c_ DcvwR Z UvKvi
jvf| GLb _K nvjvj c_ DcvRb Kie; mr I my`ifve
euvPev| GUv Avgxbi ` p msK|
=. !! l<!
!!>! ll<< !l !<!!, !<!
< x|<ix |-






44
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv


|< < <|
q hvIqv nuvUz wbq mgmvq cob AbK| eZgvb Kwg
Rvby chyw I mvwRKvj Kkji DbwZZ c wZvcb GLb
AbK ewk KvhKi nQ| G chyw i nqQ 20 eQi ev
GiI ekx c~e| Zey Wvviiv GLbv cwZvcbi
ivMx`iK Amy bv nIqv ch Acv KiZ ejQb| dj
AbK ivMx Zv`i Rvbymwi Kvgjvw cy ivcy wi q hvIqv
ch Acv Ki _vKb| Gfve Zviv Mne`x nq cob,
RvbyZ cPzi e_v wbq nq cob khvkvqx| mgmv nj, h
ivMxiv AbK w`b Acv Kib, Zviv GZ iM nq cob
h, mi DVv KwVb nq co| nuvUz i Kvh gZv wdi cvIqvI
me nq bv| hyivi `jvIqvi wekwe`vjqi
wdwRI_ivwc wefvMi AavcK wjb mvBWvi ejb, Lye
`xNmgq Acv Kij Ggb GK Aevq DcbxZ nq hvq,
hLvb _K diZ Avmvi mvebv gB Kg hZ _vK|
DbZ `ki cwimsLvb gZ, c~Yeq cuvP Rbi ga
GKRbi _vK Av_vBwUm ev nvoi wMuUi wbK e_v|
gvbyli eqm hZ evo, ZZB Kvgjvw q hZ _vK|
dj c`vn nIqvZ dvjv nq, e_v nq Ges wbj nq mw|
wekl PvKzix ev Ggb Kvb xov hvi Rb wekl nvoi wMU
cybtcybt mvjY NU, GZ mB nvoi wMuU nq Av_vBwUm|
cvwievwiK BwZnvm I Ihb ewiI f~wgKv iqQ GLvb| Ze
Av_vBwUm m~wPZ njB nvoi wMUi cwZvcb Aek vex nq
bv| e_v I c`vni wPwKrmv Avkvby ic nj Kg gZv
`xNw`b _vK| e_vi Ilya Ges Mz KvmvgvBb I KbWvqvwUb
Gi gZ mvwcgU w`j Dckg nq| ^vKi Ihb eRvq
ivLj RvbyZ Av_vBwUmi SuywK Kg hvq| gvSvwi aibi
evqvg wKQz KvR nq| mvRvwii evcvi cyili Pq bvixiv
ewk w`b Acv Kib| nqZ `yej nq hvIqv nvoi
mxgviLv GKv MnY KiZ cvib ewkY| Rvbvj Ae evb
Av RqU mvRvwiZ 2009 mvji kl w`K cKvwkZ GK
MelYvc Wvt mvBWvi gvKjivi I mnKgxiv 95 Rb cyil
I 126 Rb bvixi Dci MelYv Kib| G`i Rvby
cwZvcbi K_v Rvbvb| `Lv hvq, cy il`i Zzjbvq bvix`i
mvRvwi eQ bqvi cwZi mgq kvixwiK Aev I nvoi
wMUi Aev AbK ewk Lvivc| MZ eQii Mvovi w`K
KvbvwWqvb gwWKvj Avmvwmqkb Rvb vj wicvU `Lv
hvq, Wvviiv bvix`i Pq cy il`i AbK ewk evi
mvRvwii civgk w`qwQjb| UiUv wekwe`vjqi MelKiv
GKRb cyil I GKRb bvix eQ wbjb, `yRbiB eqm 67
eQi| hv`i RvbyZ IwIAv_vBwUm wQj GKB gvci|
G`i cZK 29 Rb A_vcwWK mvR b I 38 Rb
cvwievwiK wPwKrmKi KvQ wfbfve Mjb| hw`I Zviv
DfqB GKB iKg DcmMi K_v ejjb| ZeyI `yB-ZZxqvsk
wPwKrmK cyilK w`jb Rvby cwZvcbi civgk, A_P
Kej GKZZxqvsk gb Kib h bvix`i RbI GwU
cqvR| wfb`kx lvUva GKRb gwnjvi ee, eQii ci
eQi hYv fvMi ci Zvi wPwKrmK ZvK Rvby cwZvcbi
civgk w`jb| wZwb Rvbvb, m~Y Ag nq covi ciI
wPwKrmKiv G evcvi gZ w`Z wavw^ Z wQjb|
||- +x |-
||- + |<- ekx wgw Lj Ihb evo| wPwbZ evcK
cwigvY Kjwi _vK| wgw wRwbm PweI ekx _vK| wPwbZ
KvbI wfUvwgb, wgbvij ev cwK Z _vK bv| ZvB i
_KB Kg Ki wgw LZ nq| eqm eo hvIqvi mv_ mv_
wgw wRwbmi cwZ `yejZvI eo hvq| ZLb ekx Ki wPwb
LjI Zv`i wRf jvM bv|
++ ||- |<| -<+|< Kvb ^vevb hy eK 1600
Kjwihy Avnvi MnY Kij m 6 PvgP A_ vr 24 M vg wPwb
LZ cvi| Abw`K 2,200 Kjwihy Avnvi M nY Kiv
ewi 12 PvgP A_vr 48 M vg wPwb LvIqv cqvRb|
|x|f |<|| |-< <| - dji im, AvBmwg BZvw`i
gvag Avgv`i kixi h cwigvY wPwb cek Ki, mUv
myMvii gvv ewZ mvnvh Ki| Gi dj kixi Aek fve
bg Avm|
* jey i cvwb, Pv, Kwd BZvw`Z wPwbi cwieZ gay LvIqv
cqvRb|
* wgw LZ gb PvBj wgwi cwieZ dj LZ ne|
* cwZw`b cuvP _K Qq PvgPi ekx wPwb LvIqv wVK bq|
: l :
||+|






45
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv


+|< |- ^|<-|
w`bvRcyii cveZxcyi knii GK wkwZ hyeK Kvgij
`v 1995 mvj cveZxcyi wWMx KjR _K weG cvm
Ki Rwoq cob wewfb eemvi mv_| Gi gvS Zvi
gb RvM Kvqj cvLx cvjbi mL| GK mgq mL Ki
Kvqj cvjb KijI cieZxZ wZwb eySZ cvib h,
GUv GKwU jvfRbK eemv| A RvqMvq Kg LiP ekx
jvf Kivi myhvM iqQ G eemvq| ZLb _KB
evwYwRKfve wZwb Kvqj cvjb i Kib| 2008
mvji m^i gvm wbR evoxZ gv 350wU Kvqj
wbq hvv i nq| 2009 mvj Rvbyqvix gvm cveZxcyi
knii cyivZb evRvi GjvKvi cwiZv mvMi wmbgv
nj feb Kvqj cvLxi dvg I nvPvwi Mo Zvjb|
GB dvg I nvPvwi Ki mLvbKvi Avq w`q Zvi msmvi
PvwjqI A_ MwQZ KiZ cviQb|
GK mgq 350wU Kvqj cvLx w`q G dvgi hvv i
njI eZgvb G dvg 6 nvhvi Kvqj cvLx iqQ|
cwZgvm Kvqj cvLx I wWg wew Ki h Avq nq Zv
w`q Zvi 4 m`mi msmvi fvjfve Pjv QvovI GKUv
gvUv AsKi UvKv MwQZ ivLv me nQ| GLb G dvg
GKw`b eqmi Kvqj cvLx _K i Ki wWg cvov I
MvkZ LvIqv cvLx ch wew nq _vK| GKw`bi
evPvi g~j 10 UvKv Ges eocvLxi g~j 30 UvKv|
GKkwU Kvqj cvLxi wWg 180 UvKv _K 190 UvKv
`i wew nq _vK| Ab me c cvLxi Pq Kvqj
cvLx cvjb LiP Kg njI Avq ekx| Avi G cvLx
cvjb ekx RvqMviI cqvRb nq bv| GKwU eo
Kvqj cvLx gvm 2 KwR Lvevi Lvq| A_P wWg `q
gvm 25 _K 28wU| GB cvLxi Kvb ivM evjvB bB
ej evoZx Ilya ciI cqvRb nq bv| ZvQvovI GB
cvLxi wWg I MvkZi cPzi Pvwn`v iqQ| Zvi GB
dvg wZwb wbR cvLx cwiPhv Kivi cvkvcvwk AviI
`yRb eZbfy KgPvix iLQb Gjv `Lvkvbvi
Rb| wZwb ejb, cqvRbxq myhvM myweav I miKvix
mvnvh-mnhvwMZv cj we`k Kvqj cvLxi MvkZ
ivwb Kiv hve| Avgv`i `ki wkwZ eKvi hyeKiv
jLvcov wkL PvKzix cvIqvi Avkvq QzUvQzwU Ki
eovb| A_P A RvqMvq mvgvb cuywRZ Kvqj cvLx
cvjb Ki Zviv mnRB ^vej^x nZ cvib|
^ x |<+ |
Avw_Kfve jvfRbK I Awekvm gvvq cywi Avavi
nQ Mvg-evsjvq Qwoq-wQwUq _vKv mRb MvQ| mRb
wew Ki Avw_Kfve jvfevb nIqv hvq Ges Gi dz j,
exR, cvZv, Qvj, AvVv, wkKo BZvw` hveZxq cywi
Avavi I mvaviY ivM wbivgq LyeB Kvh Kix| GLb
mRbi cyiv gmyg| evowZ LiP QvovB Lye Kg hZ Avi
A kg eo IVv GKwU eo AvKvii mRb MvQ _K
12 _K 15 gY WuvUv msMn Kiv hvq| evRvi hLb
mRb WuvUvi c_g Avg`vwb NU ZLb cwZKwR 50
_K 60 UvKvq wew nq| Avg`vwb ewi mv_
cwZKwRi g~j 15 _K 20 UvKvq `u vovq| G wnmve
cwZwU MvQ _K 9 nvhvi 6k _K 12 nvhvi UvKvi
mRb WuvUv wew Kiv hvq| mivmwi exR _K Avevi
MvQi Wvj cyuZ mnRB G MvQ ivcY Kiv hvq| Zgb
LiP QvovB mvgvb hZ Avi cwik gi D`vM wbjB cwZ
cwieviB AvmZ cvi gvUv AsKi evowZ Avq|
Gw`K G MvQwUi YvY mK c v Z_ Rvbv hvq,
ZvRv mRb cvZvq iqQ MvRii Pq 2 Y ekx
wfUvwgb-G, Kgjv jeyi Pq 7 Y ekx wfUvwgb-wm,
Kjvi Pq 3 Y ekx cUvwkqvg, `Bqi Pq 2 Y
ekx cvwUb, `yai Pq 4 Y ekx Kvjwmqvg I
cvjskvKi Pq 3-4 fvM ekx AvqiY| Kbv mRb
cvZvq iqQ MvRii Pq 10 Y ekx wfUvwgb-G,
Kgjvi AaK wfUvwgb-wm, Kjvi Pq 15 Y ekx
cUvwkqvg, `Bqi Pq 9 Y ekx cvwUb, `yai Pq
17 Y ekx Kvjwmqvg I cvjskvKi Pq 25 Y
ekx AvqiY| mRb cvZvq Avi hme wfUvwgb, LwbR
ev Lv`cvY iqQ mjv nj wfUvwgb-G, wfUvwgb we-
1, we-2, we-3, wfUvwgb-wm, Kvjwmqvg, vwgqvg,
Kcvi, AvqiY, gvMbwmqvg, gvvwbR, dmdivm,
cUvwmqvg, cvwUb I wRsK| GQvov mRb MvQi c wZwU
AskB DcKvix| G MvQi cvZv-WuvUv cyw I Ilya wnmve
Ges dzj, Qvj, AvVv I kKo Ilya wnmve eenvi Kiv
hvq| mRbi exR cvwb cwikvabKvix, ivbvi Zj I
cmvabx KvR eenvi Kiv hvq| c wZw`b 8 _K 24
Mvg mRb cvZv Lj ^v i evcK Db wZ NU|
ZiKvixi mv_ ivbv Ki, ZvRv A_ev Kbv mRb cvZv
h Kvb Lvevii mv_ LvIqv hvq| Gi cvZv wKq
`xNw`b msiY iLI mviveQi ZiKvixi mv_ LvIqv
hvq| mRb cvZv wKq A_ev KuvPv Aevq Ges Wu vUv
ZiKvixi mv_ wbqwgZ Lj kixii ivM cwZiva
gZv ew cvq Ges kixi my`i I gheyZ nq|
Mevw`ci RbI mRb cvZv GK Av`k Lvevi| mRb
cvZv Mevw`cK wbqwgZ LvIqvj `ya I MvkZ `yUvB
AwaK cwigvY cvIqv hvq| mRb cvZv Kbv A_ev
KuvPv DfqfveB Mevw`cK LvIqvbv hvq mviv eQi|
mRbi evMvb Kiv LyeB mnR| Zz jbvg~jK Aby ei RwgZ
^ vbB G MvQ ivcY Kiv hvq|
: l :
-|x|<






46
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv



|+
!|! !l< <!
l =!, !<!, <!>!
cw_K Zzwg v Kb Pj cybevi,
bBj nvwie fe `wLe Auvavi|
Mvjvc wQwoZ Mj nvZ wea KuvUv
^ci vi bqZ Lvjv m h Zvjv Au vUv|
ezi c_ Kb cve gb fq,
`LQ K webv Avm Kvi Rq?
wcwcwjKv Abi Zi w`b ivZ Ny i,
wPj `L myLi Rb DV KZ `~ i?
cvbKwo Rj Wye wgUvq gbi Avkv,
`Lwb Kgb euva eveyB Zvi evmv?
ZzwgZv gvbe RvwZ mevB Zvgvq gvb,
Kb Zzwg fxZ nq ie Nii KvY?
n-c` k Ki gb Ki ej,
`wLe meB mnR meB mgZj|
||-< <|-
!<!
!<, <!>!
cw_exZ bg GmQ Auvavi Wye MQ AvdZve
AvKvk wmZviv wgqgvb IV bv Avjvi Pu v`|
hyMi w`kvix NygZ wefvi RvwMevi bB fve
wKmi KviY AvR G nZvkv wK KviY Aemv`?
Sv wez Dvj mvMi uwkqvi Kvvix!
cvnvo mgvb Dwggvjv, nvi-Kzwgi KZ,
gjQ _vev MvwmZ Zvgvq `y hvM nqQ fvwi
G Zzdvb Kvj w`Z ne cvwo wm`vev`i gZv|
w`bi AvjvK Avevi dzwUe KU hve gN-So
Nyg f me RM IVv AvR, RvMv RvMv fvB-evb,
myL iqQ wecyj Avkvi ^c-Rxebfi
Rxeb Ges xbi Rb wRnv`i c qvRb|
KD wK AvQv GB msKU awiZ bvqi nvj,
RvZxq Rxeb hyMi w`kvix nq iBZ wPiKvj?
<|
l !
!!^$ !<!!, ^!
Rvwb n cfy! Zvgvi bvg inxg I ingvb,
gv Ki wKqvgZ iL Avgvi gvb|
AmsL jvKi gvS Kiv bv Avgvq Acgvb,
Wvb nvZ Avgjbvgv w`q gvi w`I cgvY|
hLvb _vKe c_g nZ kl bexi Abymvix,
cvc cyY gvcvi mgq cyYi cvjvUv KwiI fvix|
Rvbvi ciI hyjyg I Abvq KiwQ wbRi Dci,
gvi Avkvq AvR fimv Kwi ay ZvgviB Dci|
Zvgvi gv bv cq Avwg Kvb `ievi Nywi,
Zzwg Qvov bB Kvb cfy ZvB Zvgvq m`v wi|
Zvgvi gv cj ne bv KD Rvnvbvgx Kfy,
ZvB Zzwg AvgvK gv Ki `vI n `qvgq c fy!
Rvwb Avgvi cvc nqQ ce Z cwigvY,
Zey GI Rvwb Zvgvi `qv Amxg Adzivb|
kqZvbi auvKvq co cvc KvR wj nqwQjvg,
Zvgvi kvw i K_v gb nq cy bivq wdi Gjvg|
hve bv Avi KLbI mB KvR Zvgvq K_v w`jvg
Zvgvi KvQ ZIev Ki A i c kvw cjvg|
f|< |^
!!<!!
!<!^!, <<
gvkwiKi H w`M IV beviY,
A hvq mvejv Kvi Kz `iZi `iY|
Pviw`K Avmgvb mv`v gNi fjv,
Kvb m Kwei AZzj Qwe wbLu y Zfve AuvKv|
Acic m Rb Zvgvi KiQ Zvmexn YMvb,
Ak Si Zvgvi fq ZzwgB mv gnvb|
Awebki GK, Zz wg h wiwhK`vZv,
Zzwg h Aw Zkxj Rvb bv AbK gvbe vZv
wb`kb Zvgvi Qwoq AvQ GB aiYxi ey K,
weeK _vKvi ciI h bv ey S,
e_ Zvi G Rbg Gm aiv gvS|
< |-
=.=. !<! !!<
!l^!, !!!$!, ^!!^&
Kvi Bkvivq P` Zviv
w`Q ivZ wKiY
Kvj gnvKvj GB aivZ
KD Kiwb eviY|
Qyen Qvw`K kl nj
gyIqvhwhbi Avnvb,
gy MMb fvii Avjvq
niK cvwLi KjZvb|
wkwki KYv Nvmi WMvq
m` vb Ki,
j eQi euP AvQ
esk we vi Ki|
wRb-`vbei fq KvwUq
ivw nj kl,
mvbvi iwei cik cq
AvjvwKZ `k|
`k `kv i wPi mey R
dmj Niv gvV,
Avjvn Zvgvi m w mwe
wek fei nvU|
zav gy `vwi` gy
Mo mdj `k,
Zvgvi YMvb Kwiqv cfy
ne bvKv kl|
dzj dzUj myevm w`Z
dj nj ZvZ
Avjvn Zvgvi m w mwe
hv AvQ RMZ|
+|<|






47
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv




ti|< |<|< |- (#|x|)-=< |+ <i
1| gvbeRvwZ| 2| m~iv eviAvZ I m~ iv bvgj|
3| gvwiqvg| 4| hvq` (ivt)-Gi|
5| Avqkv (ivt); m~iv b~i|
ti|< x<| <|| (--|-- |<|-)-=< |+ <<
1| Zvj 2| KvZvi| 3| KvV|
4| evev, Qj I c| 5| gq`vb|
| ti|< |<|< |- (#|x|)
(1) Dcgnv`k eveyj Bmjvg KvK ejv nq?
(2) mgM gvbeRvwZi wcZf~wg KvK ej?
(3) eveyj gv KvK ej?
(4) fviZi RivUK Kb eveyj gv ejv nq?
(5) evsjv`k eveyj Bmjvg KvK ej?
t << <!
-l<!, !!l
<|- -< |<|-
|<| -+ f| <| < +<|< +
1. c_g wnRix mbK 33 w`q fvM Ki ay fvMdjwU
MnY Kie (fvMkli wP v Kie bv)|
2. Gici wnRix mb _K fvMdjwU weqvM Kie|
3. mekl weqvMdji mv_ 622 (gnvbexi g`xbv
wnRiZi el) hvM Kie| mekl GB hvMdjwUB ne
KvwLZ Lv ev BsiRx mvj|
hgb 1435 wnRixZ Lxxq mb KZ ne? DwjwLZ
wbqgvbyhvqx-
(K) 1435 33 = 43 (GLvb fvMkl 16 aZe bq)|
(L) 1435-43 =1392
(M) 1392+622= 2014
GB hvMdj Z_v 2014B nj KvwLZ Lv| Gfve c~ei
mvjI ei Kiv hve| mvbvgwYiv Pv Ki `L|
^ !+< <
-l<!, !!l
|-|x| t<|-
+|+<|t|, <-<, ||# -<|<a-<< > =| <|<
A` mKvj 10-Uvq WvKevsjv Avnjnv`xQ Rvg gmwR`
mvbvgwY hjv Kvhvjq GK wekl cwkY AbywZ nq| hjv
Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ I hjv mvbvgwYi cavb Dc`v
gvIjvbv Avyjvn& i mfvcwZZ AbywZ D cwkY cavb
AwZw_ wnmve DcwZ wQjb mvbvgwY K`xq mn-cwiPvjK
ehjyi ingvb| wekl AwZw_ wnmve DcwZ wQjb hjv
hyemsN-Gi mfvcwZ I mvbvgwY hjv Dc`v gynvv`
gyLZvij Bmjvg, mvbvgwY gviKvh GjvKvi cwiPvjK
Avyjvn Avj-gvg~b cgyL| Abvbi ga DcwZ wQjb
hjv Av`vjb I hyemsN-Gi wewfb ii `vwqZ kxj, Kgx
I myaxe`| Abyvb nvdh Avbvqvi nvmbK cwiPvjK
Ki cu vP m`m wewk mvbvgwY Pu vcvB beveM-Di
mvsMVwbK hjv cybMVb Kiv nq| Aby vb cwiPvjbv Kib
mvbvgwY hjv cwiPvjK nvdh Avbvqvi nvmb|
|+|
!!! !!
!!$! !<!!, <!>!
UvKv _vKj _vK gvb,
UvKv bv _vKj Amvb|
UvKvB Rxeb UvKvB giY,
UvKvi Rb g Zz eiY|
mevi g~ j _vK UvKv,
UvKv bv _vKj Rxeb duvKv|
cw_ex Nyi m~ h i wcQ,
gvby l Nyi UvKvi wcQ|
UvKvB me wKQzi g~ j,
UvKvi Rb gvbyl Ly b|
UvKv _vKj myL wgj,
RxebUv hvq nm Lj|
A_ Ab_i g~j
G K_v Rvbv PvB,
nvivg c_ Kij KvgvB
Rvnvb vg ne VvB|
***
v| <|| <||
!< !
!<!, <l$, l!
Qv GKwU wefvM Zey
evcK Zvi Kg,
h co mB Rvb
G wefvMwUi gg|
mvbvgwY bvgwU m`v
AvZ-ZvnixK iq
G cwKv co AbK
fvj gvbyl nq|
vb-wevb fiv _vK
AvZ-ZvnixKi cvZv
Aviv _vK AbK AbK
wn`vqvZi K_v|
ZvnixK cwieviK ZvB
fQv ivwk ivwk,
Avjvn& i KvQ `vAv Kwi
cPvi nvK ekx|
***
|-|x|-< ||






48
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv



^-
|<<-|-| |-< <x |<< <|-
weq-kv`x _K agK weZvob Kiv nqQ wekl weevn AvBb|
Gi dj weqZ m vbi Kvb ag cwiPq _vKe bv| G wekl
weevn AvBb 1972 weMZ ZveavqK miKvii Avgj mskvab
Kiv nq| bZzb mskvabx wekl weevn AvBb 2007 bvg
eZgvb msm` cvm nq AvBb icv wiZ nIqvq GLb weq-kv`x
_K ag ev` coQ| Bmjvgx kixAvZ Gfve weq I
Rvqh bv njI AvBbZ G aibi weq msNwUZ nQ| wn`y
aggZI Gfve weq ea bq| GB AvBb Aby hvqx GKRb
gymjgvb, wn`y, e, wLvb, B`x wKsev Ab hKvb ag i h
KD h KvDK weq KiZ cvie| cv-cvx GKRbKI agv
wiZ nZ ne bv| ag cwieZb QvovB Zviv `vZ Rxeb c ek
KiZ cvie| BQ Kij ^vgx-x Dfq A_ev hKvb GKRb
wbR agxq wekvm ev`I w`Z cvi| G aibi weqi gvag Rb
bqv m vb`i Kvb agxq cwiPq _vKe bv| eo nq (18 eQi)
Zviv hKvb ag eQ wbZ cvie A_ev ag wekvm QvovB Rxeb-
hvcb Kie| evev-gvqi gZzi ci Gme m vb hvi mwi
DivwaKvix ne Zvi ag Abyhvqx gxivQ cve|
/!< l<< =l !!< !l !<! <!< =
< !!< !! >!!l (..)}
GmGmwm I `vwLj cixvi dj c Kvk; wRwcG-5 cqQ 82 nvhvi 212 Rb
gvawgK zj mvwUwdKU (GmGmwm) I mggvbi cixvq
cvmi nvi iKW mw nqQ| `ki 10wU wkv evW i
Aaxb AbywZ 2012 mvji GmGmwm I mggvbi cixvq
Gevi Mo cvmi nvi 86 `kwgK 37 kZvsk| MZ eQii Pq
cvmi GB nvi 4 `kwgK 06 fvM ewk| MZ eQi cvmi nvi
wQj 82 `kwgK 31 kZvsk| Gevi wRwcG-5 cqQ 82 nvhvi
212 Rb| GB msLv MZ evii Pq 5 nvhvi 463 Rb ewk|
MwWs cwZZ dj cKvki 12Zg eQi cvmi nvi AZxZi
mKj iKW fQ| Gevi `vwLj cixvq Mo cvmi nvi
88.47 kZvsk| hv MZ evii Pq 5 `kwgK 24 kZvsk
ewk| Avi KvwiMwi wkv evWi Aaxb GmGmwm (fvKkbvj)
cixvq Gevi cvmi nvi 80 `kwgK 69 kZvsk| gv`ivmv
evW wRwcG-5 cqQ 13 nvhvi 436 Rb Ges KvwiMwi
evW wRwcG-5 cqQ wZb nvhvi 524 Rb|
/< !< !< <l ! l l!< ! <l ! ! l*
l < <!< !! >!! (..)}
Mvevj cvi c wZe`b
weki wbK nIqvi cwZhvwMZvq GwMq AvQ evsjv`ki Mvg Um LvZ
hyivwfwK wfb avivi msev`gvag Mvevj cvi GK
cwZe`b ejv nqQ, cw_exi ga wbK nIqvi cwZhvwMZvq
AbKUvB GwMq iqQ evsjv`ki MvgUm LvZ| GLvb
kwgK`i eZb hgb cw_exi ga mePq Kg, Zgwb Kg
cwiekI mePq wbK| mcwZ cKvwkZ H c wZe`b ejv
nq, evsjv`k MvgUm kwgKiv K^vwWqvi MvgU k wgK`i
AaKiI Kg Ges Pxbi kwgK`i GK PZz_vski Kg eZb
cvb|
/<!! <l < < <<!l< <!< ! <!
< >! < ! =l ' <<! ^<< <!l
< !< < ! <! =< ! ! l ! <!
< =< ! l< (..)}
msm` c wZ Nvi 58 wgwbU eq nq bZvi YKxZ b I cwZci mgvjvPbvq
-
msm`i Kvhgi Nvi 58 wgwbU eq nq `jxq bZvi
YKxZb I cwZci mgvjvPbvq ej AwfgZ e KiQb
IqvK vm cvwUi mfvcwZ ivk` Lvb gbb| wZwb ejb, RvZxq
msm` Mo `yB wgwbU mgq mvaviY gvbyli AwaKvii K_v ejv
nq| evKx mgq GK `j Ab `ji mgvjvPbv Ki Ges
bZv`i gnvb Kgi YKxZb Ki AvjvPbvi gvag| MZ
5g XvKv wicvUvm BDwbwUZ GK mwgbvi cavb AwZw_i
ee wZwb GK_v ejb|
/<<! =!< <! ! = !! l><! !<
l !<< !!$<' ll l> => =<
l> !!! ! < (..)}
: +|| |+| +< ||+ |-<v +||-
WmwUwb Mci `ywU cwZvbi wei G ch 100 KvwU UvKvi
ewk Ki duvwKi cgvY cqQ RvZxq ivR^ evW (GbweAvi)|
cwZvb `ywU nj WmwUwb wU c vUkb wjwgUW I WmwUwb
2000 wjwgUW| GbweAvi m~ Rvbv MQ, Gi ga WmwUwb wU
cvUkb 73 KvwU UvKvi Ki du vwK w`qQ| G KviY MZ 8 g
cwZvbwUi me evsK wnmve R Kiv nqQ| Avi WmwUwb
2000 wjwgUWi wei 32 KvwU UvKvi g~ j mshvRb Ki
(g~mK) duvwKi Z_ wgjQ| GB Z_ cq MZ 9 g eyaevi
cwZvbwUi Pqvigvb gy nvv` mvBbmn cu vP kxl kqviavixi
evsK wnmve R KiQ GbweAvi| GbweAvi Rgv `qv GB
`ywU cwZvbi evwlK Avq-eqi weeiYxi m evsK wnmve
jb`bi GB Miwgj LuyR cvq GbweAvi| GbweAvi GLb
WmwUwbi Ab cwZvbjvi Avq-eqi weeiYx cixv-wbixv
KiQ| BwZga WmwUwb M ci wewfb cwZvb I kxlvbxq
KgKZ v`i ivR^ msv Awbqg cixv-wbixv Kivi Rb
GbweAvii m`m (wbixv, cwi`k b I Z` ) gynvv`
AvjvDxbi bZ Z Uvdvm MVb Kiv nqQ|
/< <!< <!!<! =< ll<!< !<! <<
!^ !< l<< <l <!< = !< l<< < <
< !! !< < !< <!< = <!!< ! !l<
, ! <! ^ (..)}
`k civfve 4 KvwU 20 jvL jvK a~ gcvbi wkKvi nQ
M vevj GWv UvevKv mvf Abymvi `k 4 KvwU 20 jvL
jvK civfve a~gcvbi wkKvi nQ| Gi ga 1 KvwU bvix|
Kg kZKiv 63 Ges cvewjK c m 45 fvM a~ gcvbi
wkKvi| ay i viuvq 2 KvwU 58 jvL gvby l civfve
a~gcvbi wkKvi nQ| ZvgvK ev a~ gcvbRwbZ KviY c wZeQi
57 nvhvi gvby l gviv hvQ| cy Z eiY KiQ cvq 3 jvL 82
nvhvi gvby l| a~gcvbi au vqvq c vq 7 nvhvi aibi welv
KwgKvj _vK, hvi ga 69wU Kvvi mwi Rb `vqx|
/= !<< < =!< ! <!< =< l<< !
l <! ll <!< ! l ^ <!<<
!< !^ <! !$ < !! !< < !-
^--|<-






49
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
! < < =< ! !> < < (..)}
|<-
||+|< - |<< << <| <
||- |+ <<v
fqven LivcxwoZ gnv`k AvwdKvi f~-Mf RjvavijvZ
weki mePq ewk mycq cvwb mwZ AvQ ej `vwe
KiQb wevbxiv| Zv`i `vwe f~-Mf Hme Rjvavi f~-
c cv mycq cvwbi cwigvY _K kZY ewk cvwb AvQ|
GbfvqiYgUvj wimvP jUvi mvgwqKxZ cKvwkZ GK wbe
BDwbfvwmwU KjR Ae jb (BDwmGj) I hyivRi
wRIjwRKvj mvf (wewRGm)i MelKiv G `vwe KiQb|
aviYv Kiv nq, eZgvb AvwdKv gnv`ki 30 KvwUiI ewk
gvbyl mycq cvwb cvQb bv| G gnv`k RbmsLv ewi dj
Ges dmji mPi Rb cvwbi Pvwn`v AvMvgx KqK `kK
evcKnvi eo hve| Di AvwdKvi wjweqv, AvjRwiqv I
Pv`i f~-Mf cvjwjK wkjvi wekvj ii ga mePq eo
Rjvavijvi Aevb ej Rvbvb cKvwkZ wbei AbZg
jLK wewRGmi njb ebmi| wZwb ejb, f~-Mf H
cvwbi Drm GLbv Avgv`i `wi evBi, ZvB Avgv`i
gbiI evBi| wK gvbwP Zwi kl nj Drmjvi
mvebvi welq Avgv`i `w Lyj hve| GB MelYvq c v
djvdj KvR jvwMq mycwiKwZfve H f~-Mf cvwb
eenvi Kiv Mj AvwdKvi Liv I my cq cvwbi Afve wPiZi
`~i nq hve ej `vwe Kib wZwb|
/=! !!< <<!! ll <!!< > , ^
! < = <l< <<! < < <!! < >
<< < < =< <-< < < l l<
-!l <<! < < (..)}
|t+|< x|- <+-< |x|
kxjsKvi gavj GKwU gmwR`i Dci nvgjvi ci vbxq
gymjgvbiv evii QvjvZ hvM`vb _K weiZ _vKZ
eva nqQb| Wv^yjv kni gea gvb DRbvi ga
kxjsKvi msLvMwi e mc `vqi cvq `ynvhvi gvbyl
gmwR` f djvi `vweZ gmwR`i evBi wevf KiQ|
G mgq gmwR` _K me gyQjxK mwiq bqv nq| D~Z
cwiwwZZ mLvb RygAvi QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv evwZj Ki
`qv nqQ| gmwR` j Ki MZ 19 Gwc j ivZ cUvj
evgv Qvov nq| GZ KD nZvnZ nqwb, Ze gmwR`i
wKQzUv wZ nqQ ej Rvbv MQ| kxjsKvi e e gb
Ki Wv^yjv Zv`i Rb cwe kni| `ki H Aj weMZ
KqK gvm ai agxq DRbv PjQ|
/<! !!-l<! < <! ' ! !!< ~
!< <! l<!<! ! < !< ! ==
!< <!<< l>< l<< l< !! ! !!
l>< l<< << !!< < !!^ ! !
!< = < => l =! <!<! <<
!< =l ll l> > < ! l<!l$
<<, =! ! ! ! ! =< <!< !
l! l<, =! !<! !! l< (..)}
|x +|< < x||+- -||<+-< |^ | <|-x
gvwKb hyivi my wcg KvUi Ici `kwUi bvMwiK`i Avv
GLb mewbg Gm VKQ| wcD wimvP mUvi cwiPvwjZ
GK bZzb RbgZ Rwic G Z_ Rvbv MQ| RbgZ Rwici
djvdj `Lv hvq, `kwUi kZKiv gv 52 fvM gvby l GLb
mevP Av`vjZi Ici Av v ivL| gvwK b mywc g KvU wbq
RbgZ Rwic ii ci MZ 25 eQii ga GUvB mePq
Kg Rbmg_bi wP| wZb eQi AvM me vP Av`vjZi Dci
Avv wQj kZKiv 64 fvM gvby li| Avi 1994 mvj kZKiv
80 fvM gvbyl Avv e KiwQj|
/! ! !< l-! ! <!*
^!l !!l !< !!
! !< ! = <! ^ !><< <!>l
ll <! !< (..)}
x-|< x<i |<-< <-|<| |<| <-|
A_ bwZK g`v Aviv Nbxf~Z njI MZ eQi weUbi abxiv
Aviv abx nqQb| AbK wewjqwbqvi Ges gag gvbi
D`vv`i m` Kgwb eis eoQ| c KvwkZ Z_ Rvbv
MQ, weUb ZvwjKvfy kxl GK nvhvi abxi gvU m` 41
nvhvi 426 KvwU cvD| A_ vr hv MZevii ZvwjKvfy gvU
GK nvhvi abxi m`i Zz jbvq 4 `kwgK 7 kZvsk ewk|
MZevi gvU m`i A_ g~j wQj 41 nvhvi 285 KvwU
cvD| Gevii ZvwjKvq wewjqwbqvi iqQ 77 Rb| 2005-
2011 mvj ch Uvbv AvU eQi weUb kxl abxi Ae vb ai
iLQb fviZxq BvZ eemvqx jx wgvj| Zvi m`i
g~ jgvb GK nvhvi 270 KvwU cvD|
/^!! !!< l<l< ! ! l><! l !
!! ! !! =< !-l!< < ! l< < !
! l< l: < =< ^! < !$ !^ =<
! > !< ! ^<<< < !<, = =<! !
l ! ! ! !> l =< !!l < !!
!, < =l = !!! !< << !
=<, <' !<<! (..)}
Advgi wicvU
|< v <|< ^ +-|<|
A wblavv mI MZ GK `kK wewfb `k 220 KvwU
Wjvii ewk A Avg`vbx KiQ| Advgi GK wicvU G
Z_ cvIqv MQ| gvbevwaKvi McwU Rvbvq, A evRvi
wbwl _vKv mI ekwKQz `k evcK AvKvi A evwYR
KiQ| G`i ga wgqvbgvi 2000 _K 2010 mvji
ga 60 KvwU Wjvii A q Ki| Bivb 57 KvwU 40
jvL Wjvii A wew KiQ 2007 _K 2010 Gi ga|
Aciw`K A LvZ MYc RvZ x Kv 12 KvwU 40 jvL
Wjvi eq KiQ|
|<< e |t <|< ||- - |<
fviZi GK miKvix cwZe`b ejv nqQ, `ki 60
kZvsk hjvi cvwb `~wlZ nq MQ| mePq DMRbK Z_
nj fviZi gvU 639wU hjvi ga 385wUi cvwbZB
bvBU U cvIqv MQ, hv gvbe`ni Rb wZKviK| ZvQvov
158wUZ jeYi cv`y fve, 267wUZ dzivBW, 53wUZ
AvmwbK I 270wUZ iqQ gvvwZwi jvnv|






50
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv



|-| <x|--| x|x|< ||+^ |-< <|-x|
||-|< +< |+| ||
cvwK vbi c avbgx BDmyd ivRv Mxjvbx Av`vjZ Aegvbbvi
gvgjvq `vlx mve nqQb| Av`vjZ wMjvbxK Kvb Kviv` bv
w`jI ZvK 30 mKi c ZxKx ` `b| wePvicwZ bvwQij
gy jKi bZ Zvaxb my wc g KvUi mvZ m`mi e MZ 26 Gwc j
G ivq NvlYv Ki| ivq wePvicwZ bvwQij gy jK ejQb, wewai
evcvi my wc g KvUi wb`kbv BQvKZfve jNb Kivq cvwK
vbi msweavbi 63 (1) (wR) avivq cavbgx Av`vjZ Aegvbbvq
`vlx mve nqQb| AZGe Av`vjZ PjvKvjxb mgq ch
cavbgxK GRjvm `uvwoq _vKvi ` c`vb Kiv nj| Gfve
kvw NvlYvi ciciB wZwb GRjvm ZvM Kib| Avi GZB
cavbgxi mvRvi gqv` gv 30 mKB kl nq hvq|
DjL, cwmWU Avwmd Avjx Rvi`vixi wei `ybxwZi gvgjv
cybivq Pvjy Kivi Abyiva Rvwbq myBRvijv KZ cK wPwV
wjLZ A^xKwZ Rvbvb wMjvbx| Gici Zu vi wei Av`vjZ
Aegvbbvi AwfhvM Zvjb mywcg KvU|
|||-^ |- x | |-< x||+ - -|-< <|
AvdMvwb vb GK AvZNvZx nvgjvKvixi jvk wbq gvwKb mbv`i
Djvm I weKZ Qwe Zvjvi wP cKvk KiQ gvwK b `wbK jm
Avjm UvBgm| NUbvwU 2010 mvj NUQ ej cwKvwU
RvwbqQ| H cwKvq cKvwkZ QweZ `Lv hvQ- GK Zvjevb
hvvi wQbwfb `yB cv `wo w`q eua GK gvwK b mbv Mjvq
SzwjqQ Avevi KD wewQb nvZ wbq KZz K KiQ| KD Avevi
jvki cvk `uvwoq fswP KU nvmQ| BwZc~e MZ RvbyqvixZ
duvm nIqv GK wfwWIZ `Lv MQ, KqKRb gvwKb gwib mbv
wZb Zvjevb hvvi jvki Ici cmve KiQ| Gici deqvix
gvm gvwKb mbviv AvdMvwb vb KziAvb cvovbvi gZv RNb I
aZvc~Y KvR KiQ| GQvov gvP gvm KqKRb gvwK b mbv Vvv
gv_vq `ywU Mvg nvgjv Pvwjq A Z 17 wbixn AvdMvbK nZv
Ki| wbnZ`i ga ewki fvMB wQj bvix I wk|
/< , !l ' < :-!!<!-<!^<! '
!! l = !< l < (..)}
=<|< x-< - | <| +<< -<|#
AvKvkQuvqv ey R Avj-Ljxdv Zix Ki gNi Dci evwo Kivi
^c c~iY KiQ `yevB| mgy`i Dci Kwg xc Zix Ki mgy`i
DcwifvMI Rq KiQ Zviv| Gevi mgy `i Zj`k GKUv kni
Zixi cwiKbv KiQ `yevB| jvwnZ mvMii Zj`k ek
KqKwU Wye nvUj Zixi cwiKbv wbqQ kni KZc| Rvbv
MQ, cvwbi Zjvq nvUji wKQz dvi _vKe, Avi evKx Ask ne
cvwbi Dci| cvwbi Dci _vKe GKwU fvmgvb kni| 2017
mvj bvMv` nvUjjv Zix nq hve| `yevBqi A_ bxwZi GKUv
eo Ask Avm chUb _K| ZvB wekevcx ch UK`i AvKlYi
Rb cvwbi wbP GB nvUj Zix Kiv nQ|
/l<!l!< l<! <' =< l<!<!' ! !,
=! !<! ! l != !!< < !> !<!
< !!< !l l><! !< <!< < !<! l<
!!< l !<!< l !!< = < l$ !
! = < =< !<!
!< ! !!<!! l < !! < (..)}


|- -+|- |<|< <|#<
cw_exi Pvicvk Nyi eovQ cvq 9 nvhvi M nvYy ev
AviqW| Gi ga cvq GK nvhvi cuvPkwUZ PvBj hZ
cvie gvbyl| g~jevb me LwbR Dcv`vb fiv Gme M nvYy|
mjvi LuvRB Gevi KvR i KiQb gvwK b wevbxiv|
30 wgUvi `Ni Qv GKwU M nvYy Z h cwigvY c vwUbvg
_vKZ cvi Zvi `vg A_i wnmve cvq 25 _K 50 wewjqb
Wjvi| A_vr cvq `yB jvL Pvi nvhvi _K Pvi jvL AvU
nvhvi KvwU UvKv|
GB GKwUgv cwimsLvb _K evSv hvQ, MnvYyjv wVK
KZUv g~jevb nZ cvi| Avi mRb gvwK b Kvvbx
cvbUwi wimvmm G welq wZb eQi ai KvR KiQ|
mc wZ Zviv RvwbqQ, AvMvgx `o _K `y B eQii ga
gnvKvk GKwU Uwjvc cvVve, hUv LwbR m` ficy i
MnvYy Lu y R ei Kie|
/!! <, !<! ! , !! !!< > !< !
! ^ !< ! <: (!! ~)
=< ! ' !!< < T! < !< l<! !!
< (..)}
-|f| |<< + |x |
`wnxb`i `wkw divZ AZvay wbK evqvwbK AvB ev
hvwK PvL ZwiZ mg nqQb ej `vex KiQb
vbdvW wek we`vjqi MelKiv| Zv`i `vex, GB
evqvwbK AvB ev Kwg PvL evUvwii `iKvi bB| mvjvi
cvbj hfve kw hvMvq mfveB Avjvi mvnvh KvR
Kie GwU| Kvb cwievnx Zvii cqvRb bv _vKvq Gi dj
AbK mnR PvL AvcPvi Kiv hve| iwUbvi Amy L hviv
`wkw nvwiqQb Zv`i Avjvq divZ evqvwbK AvB
eenvi BwZgaB mvdji gyL `LQb we Ub I
AvgwiKvi MelKiv|
-<|-i <|< |<| |<|-|<|
hyivi BDwbfvwmwU Ae Uvmi wevbxiv bZz b GK
aibi wPci wWRvBb KiQb| Avi mB AmvaviY wPci
gZv iqQ Nb hKvb eK f` Ki hvIqvi| Avcbvi
nvZ _vKv gvevBj dvb GwU eenvi Kiv nj mB
gvevBj dvb nq DVe `qvjf`| GRb wevbxiv
eenvi Kib KgwcgUvwi gUvj AvBW mwgKvi ev
wmgvm chyw| GwU Pvi Bw cy i hKvb wRwbmK f`
KiZ cvie| wevbxiv ejQb, GwU Nii `qvj wVK AvQ
wK-bv mwU hgb `LZ cvie, Zgwb Rvj UvKv aiZI
mnvqK ne| GgbwK Kvvi wUDgviI kbv KiZ cvie|
x|x ||-
|<|- |<^|<






51
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv



<| -|-
<i| |x||+ |<- <|'| x- -
-!<! !< >!!!
+<<, <|< :o =| <^1|<|< A` ev` AvQi
Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjb evsjv`k I evsjv`k
Avnjnv`xQ hyemsN hkvi hjvi D`vM Kkecyi
cvewjK gq`vb AbywZ hjv mjb cavb AwZw_i
fvlY gynZvivg Avgxi RvgvAvZ < +: x|-||-
||-| |-||< Dciv K_v ejb| wZwb ejb,
Qvnvevq Kivg I ZveCb Ghvg Zuv`i agxq I elwqK
Rxebi mKj Bmjvgx kixAvZ gb PjZb| A_P
Avgiv Kej agxq Rxeb kixAvZ gvwb| mLvbI
AwaKvsk Qnxn nv`xQ ev` w`q Kw_Z agbZv`i
ivq-wKqvm gb Pwj| Ab w`K Avgv`i ivRbwZK,
A_bwZK, mvswZK I wePvi eevq B`x-bvQviv I
Abvb weagx`i Mvjvgx Kwi| GY hw` Avgiv `ywbqv I
AvLivZ gj PvB, Zvnj Avgv`iK AekB mvweK
Rxeb cwe KziAvb I Qnxn mybvn&i Abymvix nZ ne|
hjv Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ AavcK wmivRyj Bmjvgi
mfvcwZZ AbywZ D mjb Abvbi ga ee
ivLb Av`vjb-Gi K`xq mUvix Rbvij
AavcK gvIjvbv b~ ij Bmjvg, cPvi I cwkY
mv`K Ges gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK-Gi mv`K Wt
gynv` mvLvIqvZ mvBb, Avj-gviKvhyj Bmjvgx Avm-
mvjvdx Kgc, bI`vcov, ivRkvnx-Gi fvicv Aa
gvIjvbv Avyi ivhhvK web BDmyd, evsjv`k
Avnjnv`xQ hyemsN-Gi K`xq mfvcwZ gyhvddi web
gynwmb, mvZxiv hjv Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ gvIjvbv
Avyj gvbvb, hjv Av`vjb-Gi cPvi mv`K
gyvwje web Cgvb, gvIjvbv AveyeKi wQxK (ivRkvnx)
cgyL| mjb Bmjvgx RvMiYx cwiekb Kib Avj-
niv wkxMvxi cavb gynvv` kdxKyj Bmjvg|
+ |-|| ||-, |<|- + ||-|v
-!<! !< >!!!
|t-|, x<< > =| <|< A` ev` AvQi
Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjb evsjv`k I evsjv`k
Avnjnv`xQ hyemsN gnicyi hjvi D`vM Mvsbx
evwjKv we`vjq gq`vb AbywZ hjv mjb cavb
AwZw_i fvlY gynZvivg Avgxi RvgvAvZ < +:
x|-||- ||-| |-||< Dciv K_v ejb|
wZwb ejb, Pvi Bgvgi cZK ej MQb, Qnxn
Avgv`i gvhnve| Avnjnv`xQMY Qnxn nv`xQi
Abymvix| AZGe cKZ Avnjnv`xQB Kej cK Z
nvbvdx nZ cvi, Abiv bq| wZwb kvn AwjDjvn
`njfx, Avjvgv ZvdZvhvbx, Avy j nvB jv ex cgyL
wevbMYi DwZ ck Ki ejb, cPwjZ wkiK I
we`AvZc~Y Ges Rvj-hCd nv`xQ I ivq-wK qvm fiv
nvbvdx gvhnvei mv_ Bgvg Avey nvbxdv (int)-Gi
KvbB mK bB| meB cieZx`i Zix| hv Bgvg
Avey nvbxdv (int)-Gi bvg Pvjvbv nQ|
DjL h, ivRbwZK ^v_v wKQz bvgavix gvIjvbv
e`qvZx `gb KwgwU bvg w`q Avgxi RvgvAvZK
GLvb AevwZ NvlYv Ki Ges vbxq c-cwKvq
cPvi Ki I wjdjU Qwoq nvbvdx RbMYK DwRZ
Kivi Pv Ki Ges RygAvi QvjvZi ci Zv`i me
gmwR` _K wgwQj ei Kivi wmv bq| Zviv hjv I
vbxq ckvmbi KvQ mfv ei Rb `b-`ievi Ki|
wK Avjvn&i ingZ I vbxq nvbvdx gqii ` p
Aevbi KviY Zv`i mKj AcPv fy j nq hvq|
mjb GZ ekx jvK mgvMg nq h gq`vb Qvwoq
Dchjv knii Kv_vI Mvox ivLvi gZ Lvwj RvqMv
cvIqv gykwKj nq| eei kl w`K gy nZvivg Avgxi
RvgvAvZ mgeZ wekvj RbZvi Dk ejb, Rb
ivLyb G`k hw` KvDK nvbvdx ejZ nq, Ze
Avmv`yjvn Avj-Mvwjei PvBZ eo nvbvdx Avi KD
bB| ci Rvbv hvq h, Zu vi GB _nxb NvlYv gi
gZ KvR Ki Ges vbxq RbMYi ga Avnjnv`xQ
nIqvi wnwoK co hvq| wjdjU weZiYKvix Z_vKw_Z
e`qvZx `gb KwgwUi bZviv AKvi gyL jyKvq|
Zviv GLb RbMYi ckevY RRwiZ|
hjv Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ AavcK gvIjvbv b~ ij
Bmjvgi mfvcwZZ AbywZ D mjb Abvbi
ga ee ivLb Av`vjb-Gi K`xq cPvi I
cwkY mv`K Ges gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK-Gi mv`K
Wt gynv` mvLvIqvZ mvBb, k~iv m`m W. gynvv`
Kvexij Bmjvg, Avj-gviKvhyj Bmjvgx Avm-mvjvdx
Kgc, bI`vcov, ivRkvnx-Gi fvicv Aa
gvIjvbv Avyi ivhhvK web BDmyd, evsjv`k
Avnjnv`xQ hyemsN-Gi K` xq mfvcwZ gyhvddi web
gynwmb, mvsMVwbK mv`K gynvv` Avyi ikx`
AvLZvi, hjv Av`vjb-Gi mn-mfvcwZ gvIjvbv
gvbQ~ii ingvb, Kzwqv-cwg hjv Av`vjb-Gi
mfvcwZ gynvv` Mvjvg whj wKewiqv, Kz wqv-c~e hjv
Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ Kvhx Avyj Iqvn&nve, hjv
hyemsN-Gi mvaviY mv`K Avey j evkvi Avyjvn, A_
mv`K Avyj nvjxg cgyL| mjb Bmjvgx RvMiYx
cwiekb Kib Avj-niv wkxMvxi cavb kdxKzj
Bmjvg I Av`vjb-Gi Kgx gy nvv` iKby h&hvgvb|
t- t<|-
|-|-






52
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
x|-<< x<i |<^1|<+ x<|-|< =+x|
x|+|| ' | ||<|
-!<! !< >!!!
||<| >c <|, x x<|< A` ev` AvQi
Avnjnv`xQ Av`vjb evsjv`k I evsjv`k Avnjnv`xQ
hyemsN mvZxiv hjvi D`vM knii HwZnevnx wPjWb& m
cvK AbywZ hjv mjb cavb AwZw_i fvlY gy nZvivg
Avgxi RvgvAvZ < +: x|-||- ||-| |-||<
Dciv K_v ejb| wZwb ejb, mKj gvbyl GK Av`gi
m vb| Zv`i ga cv_K Kej AvjvnfxiZvi| wZwb
ejb, Avjvn PvBj mKj gvby lK n`vqvZ `vb KiZ
cviZb| wK wZwb gvbylK cixv KiZ Pvb| ZvB g Zzi
AvM gyn~Z ch Avgv`iK cixv w`Z ne|
wZwb ejb, `k `ybxwZZ fi MQ| gvbyli Rvb-gvj I
BhhZi MvivwU bB| Avgv`i Qjiv KLbvB Lybx-alK-
g`Lvi wQj bv| wK `jZx `ytkvmbi KviYB Zviv AvR
gZvi wmuwo wnmve eeZ nQ Ges ^ QvPvix nq DVQ
(G mgq e Qj Zuvi Avnvb mvov w`q `ynvZ Zz j
Avjvn&i bvg ZIev Ki)|
wZwb mcwZ RvZxq msm` cvm nIqv Avtag weevn AvBbi
Zxe mgvjvPbv Ki miKvii Dk ejb, AbwZwej^
GB Rsjx AvBb evwZj Kib Ges cwZekx `ki I
we`kx`i Mvjvgx Qo wbR `ki RbMYi Cgvb-AvKx`vi
cwZ mvb `wLq ^vaxbfve `k cwiPvjbv Kib| wZwb
ejb, miKvii fyj hvIqv DwPr bq h, 1947 mvj G`k
^vaxb nqwQj Kej Bmjvgi Rb| Avi mB gvbwPi
DciB ^vaxb evsjv`k cwZv jvf KiQ| A_P AvR
gymjgvb`i wbevwPZ miKviwj Bmjvgi wei Aevb
wbQ| wZwb ejb, hviv cvwK vb cwZvq bZZ w`qwQjb
mB ki evsjv dhjyj nK, mvnivIqv`x, kL gy wRe cgyL
bZe` Ges m mgq wbnZ, AvnZ I `kv wiZ nvhvi nvhvi
gymjgvbi AvZZvM I Ae`vbK fy j hvIqv DwPZ bq|
wZwb ejb, iex`bv_i mxZK evsjv`ki RvZxq mxZ Kiv
DwPZ bq| GwU g~jZ: Avgv`i civaxbZvi mxZ| Kbbv G Mvb
wZwb iPbv KiwQjb GKk eQi AvM wef `yB evsjvK GK
Kivi Rb| AvRK hvi GKgv cwiYwZ nj fviZi Ki`
ivR cwiYZ nIqv| hv Avgiv KbvI KiZ cvwi bv| wZwb
ejb, agwbic cwige gymjgvb`i gvBK Avhvb `evi
^vaxbZv bB| wK evsjv`k wn`y`i Mvb-evRbvi ^vaxbZv
iqQ| GmeB Bmjvgi gnvb wkvi dj| AZGe Avgv`iK
bZzbfve agwbicZvi meK bevi `iKvi bB|
wZwb ejb, hw` Cgvb`vi RbMY cybivq Avjvn&i bvg RM
IV, Ze mw`b ekx `~i bq, hw`b ivm~jyjvn (Qvt)-Gi
fwelvYx BbkvAvjvn evsjv`kB ev evwqZ ne| hLvb
wZwb ejQb, hw` Zvgvi nvqvZ `xN nq, Ze Zzwg `LZ
cve h, Avjvn GB Bmjvgx kvmbK Ggb c~YZv `vb Kieb
h, GKRb Dvivnx (Bqvgbi ivRavbx) QvbAv nZ
nvhvivgvDZ ch GKvKx wbivc` gY Kie| A_P Avjvn
Qvov m KvDK fq Kie bv (<!<)| Ab eYbvq GmQ,
GKRb Mneay BivKi nxiv bMix nZ GKvwKbx mdi Ki
gvq hve| AZtci KvevMn Z vIqvd Ki nxivq wdi
Avme| A_P Avjvn eZxZ Zvi A i Ab Kvi fq _vKe
bv| wK Zvgiv eoB Zvovov KiQ (<!<)| wZwb mKjK
Avjvn&i c_ wdi Avmvi Ges mew`K _K gyL wdwiq cwe
Kz iAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi AvjvK Rxeb Movi Avnvb Rvbvb|
DjL h, mvZxivi BwZnvm GwU wQj AbZg e ng
Rbmgvek| bvix I cyili c_K `ywU e nr cvj wQj| Ri
evBi Lvjv gq`vbi Kv_vI wZj aviYi Vu vB wQj bv| ivw mvo
12-Uvq mjb kl nIqv Aewa gvbyl Mfxi gbvhvM ee
kvb| gq`vbi evBi evcKfve gvBKi ee v _vKvq gvK U,
evoxZ I Qv` me kZkZ gvby l Mfxi AvM n mjbi
eemg~n keY Ki| mjb ZiLv`v, Ly jbv, hkvi, gnicy i
_K Ges mvZxiv hjvi c Z Aj _K nvhvi nvhvi bvix-
cyil wiRvf evm I Abvb hvbevnb hvM`vb Ki|
hjv Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ gvIjvbv Avy j gvb vb-Gi
mfvcwZZ AbywZ D mjb Abvbi ga ee ivLb
Av`vjb-Gi cavb Dc`v cdmi bhij Bmjvg, K` xq
mUvix Rbvij AavcK gvIjvbv b~ij Bmjvg, c Pvi I
cwkY mv`K Ges gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK-Gi mv`K Wt
gynv` mvLvIqvZ mvBb, Avj-gviKvhy j Bmjvgx Avm-mvjvdx
Kgc, bI`vcov, ivRkvnx-Gi fvicv Aa gvIjvbv Avy i
ivhhvK web BDmyd, evsjv`k Avnjnv`xQ hy emsN-Gi K`xq
mfvcwZ gy hvddi web gynwmb, Lyjbv hjv Av`vjb-Gi mfvcwZ
gvIjvbv Rvnvxi Avjg, mvbvgwYi K` xq mn-cwiPvjK ehjy i
ingvb cgyL| mjb Bmjvgx RvMiYx cwiekb Kib Avj-niv
wkxMvxi cavb gy nvv` kdxKyj Bmjvg|
DjL h, mjbK mvb `wLq iex` Rq xi miKvix Aby vb
D gq`vb _K Ab mwiq bIqv nq| GRb mjb KZc
I gvbbxq cavb AwZw_ hjv ckvmbK abev` Rvbvb|
|#-x |+ <i|| |--
-<! < l !< >!!!
weq-kv`x _K ag ev`| GLb _K m vbi Kvb ag cwiPq _vKe bv|
gymjgvb-Kvdi cii weevn Kie I ciii mwi IqvwiQ ne|
18 eQi eqm ch m vbi Kvb ag cwiPq _vKe bv| RvZxq msm`
ck Kiv AvBbgxi GB DU c ve cvm nq eZgvb Zv AvBb cwiYZ
nqQ| AvBbgx ejb, ^vaxb `k gvby l mevB ^vaxb| iv mevBK
^vaxbfve Pjvi wbqZv w`q hve| AvBbgxi bvg `L gb nq wZwb
GKRb gymjgvb| gymjgvbiv Avjvn&i weavbi Aaxb Rxeb hvcb Ki|
GB Rxeb hvcb evav `Iqvi AwaKvi ivi bB| Avi RbMYK wbqB
iv| KqKRb bvwK-mKzjvi g x I msm` m`m wbq iv bq|
Bmjvg agi weavb Abyhvqx Kvb Kvdi I Agymwjg bvixi mv_ Kvb
gymwjg cyili weevn wm bq| gymwjg I Kvwdi ciii mwi
DivwaKvix bq| A_P ivi bvg Ki AvBbg x ekse` `jxq msm`K
w`q AvBb cvm Kwiq G`ki msLvMwi gymwjg RbmvaviYi Dci
Pvwcq w`Z Pvb| Zvnj wK Zviv `kUvK ag nxb Rsjx `k cwiYZ
KiZ Pvb? Ab agi AbymvixivI G AvBb gvbe bv| Zvnj Kvi Rb
G AvBb Kiv nqQ? Avgiv GB Kvjv AvBb AbwZwej^ evwZji `vex
RvbvwQ Ges Bmjvg mK A AvBbgxK ` Z AevnwZ `Iqvi Rb
gvbbxqv cavbgxi cwZ Avnvb RvbvwQ|
/l<<ll ^ :: <l<<!< l l!< l=!< !< : ! :
<!l<!< l !l^ <$ l<!! !l :< :
!l<< l=! !< << ! , < l !! !^ =
! !<! << !' ! <<! -!!}






53
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv




(:/>:) <| < ||-|v -||| -
|+ |<| =- < - |< -||| +|| |+ -
- |< <z | -||| - +|-|z
-<< !, !
<< cKZ Avnjnv`xQ hviv, Zv`i ga Kvb `jv`wj
bB| KviY AvKx`vMZfve mKj Avnjnv`xQB GK|
kixAvZi evLvMZ eySi cv_Ki KviY wKQz ckvLvMZ
welq gZf` _vKv ^vfvweK| gZf` _vKjI
RvgvAvZMZfve HKe _vKvi wb`k GmQ nv`xQ|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb, .,, ,.,, .-, ,,
Zvgv`i Dci RvgvAvZx wh`Mx dih Kiv nj Ges
wewQbZvK wbwl Kiv nj (l<l !/~:)| Ze `ywbqvex
^v_ nvwQji Dk wh` I nVKvwiZvek hw` KD `jv`wj
mw Ki, Ze Zvi Rb Avjvn&i wbKU hKvb ewKB
Revew`wn KiZ ne Ges kvw fvM KiZ ne (<!!<! ::
! <! : !! :>)| ivm~jyjvn (Qvt), Qvnvevq
Kivg, ZveCb Ghvg Ges gynvwQ Ijvgvq Kivgi fvl
Abyhvqx KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQi wbtkZ Abymvix
Avnjnv`xQMYB gv bvRvZcv `j (l<l, l! !/:~:,
=, <>!<! !/::~ <!^!, !< !!l< ! l<!l<
!!! !! !! l ' <)|
(>/>>) ^|x|< <i^ |< +|< +|- x||
-| |-- <| +i|< < <||< #|x< -|f
|<< < |+z
-!
!!<l$, !!, ^!
<< gvnivg eZxZ gwnjv`i GKvKx ei nIqv kixAvZ
wbwl (<!< !/:: l! !/~::)| Ze wbivcvi wbqZv
_vKj GKv evaMZ cqvRb gyLgjmn mg kixi AveZ
Ki mveavbZvi mv_ evRvi hZ cvi (!: !< /:,
!!< > !!< <!! !!! !>! !! :/~~)|
(/>) <+|<| |-<x|-<|<| x|-<||< x<| ,
+| :| + |<+| | < -+ x< x|-<|| <
+< -< >/ |< <|$| < < |<|< +-| x|-<||<
< |$ -| < <|< =| |+ <|< <z =< -i
|+<|x< |-- <|<|-| +< < |+z
-!|! << <!
!, !<!, <!>!
<< cwZvbi wbqg bv gvbj AekB `vwqZ mK
Revew`wn KiZ ne| ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb, mveavb!





Zvgiv cZKB `vwqZkxj| Avi (wKqvgZi w`b)
Zvgiv cZK ^ ^ `vwqZ mK wRvwmZ ne (!!
!!, l! !/::)| Ze evaMZ Ae vq KZci
wbKU gv PvBZ ne| Avjvn ejb, Zvgiv mvagZ
AvjvnK fq Ki (!^!< ::)|
(/>) x|-v< | |< |+ |-| -1+ ||-<
<||< +<<-
-!
l=!, l
<< mvBb web gvbQ~i web gvngv Avj-nvj vR (244-309
wnt/848-922 Lt) Bivbi evqhv bMixZ RbMnY Kib|
IqvwmZ eo nb| ci evM`v` Pj Avmb| wZwb fviZ
hvb I mLvb Rv`y we`v wkLb| evM`v` wdi wZwb c_g
bex `vex Kib| AZtci mwi ga m vi Aevb msv
AZev`x `kbi cPvi i Kib Ges GK chvq wbRK
Avbvj nK , - ' , ej Avjvn `vex Kib| ZvK
Kviv` `Iqv nq| wK mLvbI Kq`x`i ga GB
Kzdix AvKx`v Qwoq coZ _vK| dj Ljxdv gyK Zvw`i
wejvn&i mgq (295-320wnt/907-932Lt) `ki mevP
wevbgjxi gZvgZ I wePviK`i ivq ZvK gZz ` `Iqv
nq| Gfve 9 eQi wewfb KvivMvi e`x _vKvi ci 309
wnRixi 9B hyjKv`vn gjevi c Kvk Zvi nvZ-cv I gv_v
KU exRi Dci Szwjq ivLv nq Ges `nK Avb cy woq
fxf~Z Kiv nq (!-l<!! ::/::-: : !l !,
! < l : :~~-:~:)|
(c/>c) ^|< +|< #x|x < v|| |-|<
+< x|-|<| -||$< v|| |-|< +< |<< |+z
|-|v|< #<|< ||-< <||< +<<-
-!!!
<!>! !, <!>!
<< cvie (<!<, l! !/:::>)| gvq`x ejb,
_ . - ` , . ` , ` - . ,` _ . , ` , , ` , _ .
` , : ' _ ` . _ = ` , , , - ` ` , ` - ,
` , ` ,` ` ,` ' , ` ,` , ` , -` ,` , , -. , , -.
|<
!< !
! ! <!!






54
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
hLb Bgvg em QvjvZ Av`vq Kie ZLb Zvgiv em
QvjvZ Av`vq Ki| GB Aev wQj ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi c~ei
ivMi KviY| Gici ivm~j (Qvt) em QvjvZ Av`vq
KiQb Ges QvnvexMY Zuvi wcQb `uvwoq QvjvZ Av`vq
KiQb| wZwb Zv`iK emvi Av`k `bwb (<!< !/:>-
=< ! l<! />)|
(e/>e) -+ |-<|x v|| |v<|x |-
+< |+ <-| |-< -| +|$ < |-|v
|v, |-< -| +|$ |<<|-+|<| <i| ||-|x| <
<i|< |<|x +| <z
-<
!<, !<, <!>!
<< QvjvZ, wQqvg Av`vq Kiv mI hw` KD UvLbyi
bxP cvkvK cwiavb Ki, Zvnj AekB Zvi Cgvb
`yejZv AvQ| Giv ZIev bv Kij Avjvn ZvAvjv gv
Kieb bv| ivm~j (Qvt) Gikv` Kib, hviv UvLbyi bxP
Kvco cwiavb Ki, wKqvgZi w`b Avjvn Zvi m K_v
ejeb bv, Zvi w`K ZvKveb bv, ZvK gv Kieb bv
Ges Zvi Rb iqQ K`vqK kvw (l !/:: l!
!/~>)| GZ cZxqgvb nq h, QvjvZ-wQqvg D Kexiv
Mvbvn gvd ne bv| Kbbv cvci KviY gyQjxivI
Rvnvbvg hve (! -:)| hw`I Zv`i wmR`vi vb
Rvnvbvg cvovZ cvie bv (<!< !/:)|
(/>) +|- |+ <|- x <i|< |<|<
+<|< |+|< +<, |< < |+|< +<, |
|< |<| |+ <z
-!, <l
<< AxKvi f Kiv gybvwdKi AvjvgZ mg~ni AbZg
(<!< !/:: l! !/)| Avi wKqvgZi w`b mdjKvg
gywgb ZvivB, hviv AxKvi c~Y Ki (l )| AZGe hw`
KD Kvb ewi `bvi `vq MnY Ki Zvnj G `vwqZ
nZ m gy nZ cvie bv (<!< !/~~>-=< :)|
(/>) <||< + i |+- -i< +|v <|
-|x |<< +< | << < |+z
-!!
$$, <!>!
<< cZviYv I wg_v Kkj _K gy nj G aibi
eemv ea ne (l !/~> l! !/:~)|
: (o/>o) +|- x|| ^|x|< | |,|<-< x|
-|- +< |+ |,|<<| ^|x|< +|v v| =<t |
< < ^|x|+ |-|-| < -| =< -|- |+ <|'|
-| <z
-!!
!!<l$, !!, ^!
<< ^vgxi msmvii wZ bv nj Ges Gic `vb ^vgx
m _vKe ej gb Kij D `vb kixAvZ mZ ne|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb, x Zvi ^vgxi Lv` mvgM x nZ
Qv`vKv Kij Ges ZvZ wechqi Dk bv _vKj m
QIqve cve| DcvRb Kivi KviY ^vgxI QIqve cve
Ges gvji cvnviv`viI Abyic QIqve cve (<!<
!/:: !! !!, l! !/:>)|
: (:/) <|< |< -# |< |< <|- =<<-<
|+|-| |< +<| <|< |+z
-!-!
l<<
<< GUv Kzdix AvKx`v| Bmjvg cxii Kvb Aw Z
bB| KviY Avjvn I ivm~j (Qvt) Kvb cxii Aby miY
Kivi wb`k `bwb| Avj vn ejb, n Cgvb`viMY! Zvgiv
Avjvn, Zuvi ivm~j I Zvgv`i Avgxii AvbyMZ Ki (l!
>)| whwb Avjvn&i wKZve Abyhvqx Zvgv`i cwiPvjbv
Kib (l, l! !/:::~ l<!<' <!)| cxi
G`k Q~dx`i GKwU Dcvwa| cvPxb I Avay wbKKvj
gymjgvb`i ZvInx` wek vm wdrbv m wi mePq eo
gvag nj Q~dxev`| AZGe GBme gZev` _K mveavb!
(::/:) -+ |x <-, x||-< -i |<
|<, | |t|, -|+ -|+ -<| |<< -< +|<
-|+ -|+ |- -|+ ||- < +< -| |# |-<
< < -| =<t v|| < -| < -|<| |+ |+z
-
!< <!>!<, !!, ^!
<< D `vex mwVK bq| gwnjviv Mnbv I AjsKvi
cwiavb KiZ cvi| ivm~ jy j vn (Qvt) C`i QvjvZ I Lyrev
c`vbi ci gwnjv`i wbKU wMq bQxnZ Kijb I Zv`i
Qv`vKv Kivi Dc`k w`jb| dj Zviv Kvb I Mjvi Mnbv
Lyj ejvji wbKU w`Z jvMjb (!! !!, l!
!/:~>)| myZivs Mnbv civ hve Ges Zv cwiwnZ Aevq
Ih~ KivI hve| Mnbv Ih~i Kvb wZ Kie bv| KviY
kixAvZ G mK Kvb wb`kbv bB| DjL h, nvZ
AvswU _vKj Ih~i mgq bovPov KiZ ne gg h nv`xQ
ewYZ nqQ Zv hCd (!<!, < !>!, l! !/~>)|
(:>/>) -+ <i| |-|-f +|- x|-<||< -|x
< -| +< <v-, x|-<||< -|x =# |x -|- +<|x
<x|- = <i| < -# =- |< <||<v < |x
N-| <|-| |< =| <|'| -| < |+z
-!|! < !
>^!<, !! <!<^&
<< gv`ivmvq `vb Kivi K_v ejvi KviY D Rwg h
Kvb gv`ivmvq w`Z ne (l: ! <!' )|






55
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
gv`ivmv ejZ Kej HwjK ejv nq, hLvb cwe
KziAvb I Qnxn nv`xQ Abyhvqx AvKx`v I Avgj wkv `Iqv
nq| cv i xbx Bjgi bvg hLvb wkiK, we`AvZ I
Q~dxev` wkLvbv nq, mwj Av` Kvb gv`ivmv bq| eis
Gwj Bmjvg asmi AvLov gv| Avjvn ejb, Zvgiv
bKx I ZvKIqvi KvR ciiK mvnvh Ki Ges Mvbvn
I mxgvjsNbi KvR mvnvh Kiv bv (!! ~)| AZtci
gv`ivmv KZci AbygwZ mvc gv`ivmvi gvV C`i
QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv hve|
(:/) x| -+ |<|| |+ <<v- <|<|
| <v< |- +<- =<t x< # x<| +<
<|- |+ <|< |,|<-^- =<t <|< |<|< |
<| <|- -| #|x< -|f < x<|<
<^| +| <z
-!< !
l<<, !^&
<< evi evi n I Igivn bv Ki `wi` I Amnvq cvov-
cwZekx, AvZxq-^Rb I BqvZxg`i cwZ j ivLv Ges
Zv`i gvS A_ `vb Kiv Dg (!!! !, ~:/~ :)|
ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) ejb, H ew gywgb bq h cU fi Lvq|
A_P Zvi Zvi cwZekx bv Lq _vK (<!!, !< ^!
!/::: ll! ! !/:> l! !/>>:)
(:/) x'|< v||< < < |< <|+'|
-| $| < | |+ -| x<|e|-|z
-!+ !
>!, 1^!
<< RygAvi QvjvZi c~e Pvi ivKAvZ QvjvZ Av`vq
Kiv mK Beby gvRvnZ ewYZ nv`xQwU hCd (^ <
!>! !/::~>)| Ze LZxe wg^i emvi AvM ch hZ
ivKAvZ Lykx bdj QvjvZ Av`vq Kiv hve (l, l!
!/::, ::, )|
(:c/c) <x +|- v||<|< |-|<| < =<t
# |-|<|< v|| + #x|x| +<-z
-! :!
!!<!$!, !<!!, !<!
<< gv`vbx Rxeb c_g Rvbvhvi weavb Rvwi nq| 1jv
wnRixi kvIqvj gvm e`i hyi c~e LvZbvgv AvbQvi
Qvnvex AvmAv` web hyivivn (ivt) A eqm gZzeiY Kib
Ges 1g Qvnvex wnmve evKx Mvivb Kei nb| wZwbB
wQjb 1g gvBqZ, Avjvn&i ivm~j (Qvt) hvi Rvbvhv cob
(!-!<! l ::: !!< <! (!:), : :>, !-)|
(:e/e) +|- +|- |< +<| <<z
-!|! < !
!!$, !!$!, <!>!
<< (1) AZvPvixi AZvPvi c Kvk Kivi Rb (2) mgvR
_K Abvq `~i Kiv Ges cvcxK mwVK c_ wdwiq Avbvi
evcvi mvnvh Kivi Rb (3) nv`xQi mb` hvPvB I drIqv
Rvbvi Rb (4) gymwjg`iK g` _K mZK Kiv I Zv`i
gj Kvgbvi (5) cvcvPvi I we`AvZ wj nj Zv
cKvk Kivi (6) cwm bvg ai cwiPq `Iqvi
(<<, l<! !, ~: , : )|
(:/) <|| v< -i x x|<< |-|<|
-|- +|< ||+ +< t< +<| <|< |+z
-!+!
!!, !! <!<^&
<< hve bv| KviY ivm~j (Qvt) ejb, Kvb Qwe cj
ZvK aywjmvr Ki `vI (l !/>:>)| ZvQvov GZ Kvb
KjvY bB| eis gvqi A`k wZ eyK aviY Ki Zvi
Rb cvYfi `vAv I Qv`vK v Kivi gaB c K Z KjvY
wbwnZ iqQ (l, l! !/~: ' <!)|
(:/) ||x =<t |x|< =+ |,|< =+| |x
< +|< |+ | +< |x| |< -|x -| +<
-< = |x< xi -||< +< | |- ^ |+|< +<
= -1+ -f < = -i -|<| < +z
-l! !<!!<
!< <!>!<, !!, ^!
<< cZviYvKvix ewB `vqx ne| KviY m `ywU Abvq
KiQ| GKwU nQ Abi m` wbR bvg Ki bIqv|
wZxqwU nQ Rwg diZ bv `Iqv| D `ywU AbvqB
ev`vi nKi mv_ RwoZ, hv ev`v gv bv Kiv ch
Avjvn gv Kib bv (<!< !/~> l! !/:~:)|
GY H ewK Rwg diZ w`Z ne ev eZ gvb evRvi
g~j c`vb KiZ ne| AZtci Zvi wbKU gv PvBZ
ne| Ze Dfqi ga mvjvg-gyQvdvnv AevnZ ivLZ
ne (!! !!, l!, !/~)|
(:o/o) |x x|-< -i |<|- -|| +<+
<v< < |x -|- +<- < x|- x|-< t^|< +|
v t+< +|< |x| |<<< |+|
<v |+ |x|< +| |+ -| <|< <|#<< |+
| < +< |v -| =x|<^|< <|<| -|- +<v-,
|-< +|v |<< +<| <|< |+z <| = -i +<|< +|z
-l> ll
!!<, !, ^!
<< gmwR`i Rwg hw` KD q KiZ bv Pvq, Ze
gmwR` msvii ^v_ Rwg `vZv wbR Zv q Ki wbZ
cvib (!!! < !l!, ::/~::)|
(>/) << < |<|x| -| < < < |+z






56
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
-!< <!
!!, ^!
<< Ih~i iZ h wemwgjvn eje bv Zvi Ih~ ne bv
(!<! !/:: < !>! !/:>, !! )|
(>:/:) |<< <| +|- <x|< -|- ||+ +<|
<|< |+z ||- -| |+ <|'| -| <z
-!!!
!! l<l<!
<< weq Abyvb wfwWI Kiv hve bv| KviY GwU md
mL gv| agxq Abyvb wfwWI Kiv hvq mLvb _K agxq
Dc`k jvfi Rb|
eZgvb wUwf PvbjwjZ cvci AskB ekx| ivm~j (Qvt)
ejb, Av`g m vbi Dci ewfPvii GKwU Ask wbavwiZ
AvQ| PvLi hbv `Lv, Kvb hbv keY Kiv, gyLi hbv
K_v ejv, nvZi hbv k Kiv, cvqi hbv Pjv Ges A
ii hbv Kbv Kiv (l !/:>~ l! !/:)| Akxj
Qwe `Lv, Mvb evRbv keY Kiv Ges gyL ejv BZvw`i
gvag hbvi gZ bvsivwg QovQ| AZGe Gme _K
euP _vKv KZe|
(>>/>) -| -|< <x x|-<||< x|
||<| |-<v- <, 'xe|< <|<| x+|x |<| +<
x-|-|-|<||-x<-|||< x< x v|| $< =<t
+v< +< |<< -| (||<| |x|<| :x :o
:. -|<| :x :ee :. x|x|-<| :x eo :)
< ||<| |+ |+ <vz
-=.=. >, !
<< D drIqv mwVK bq| KviY ivm~j (Qvt), AveyeKi
(ivt) Ges Igi (ivt) wgbvZ QvjvZ KQi Ki KiZb|
gvi vbxq ewivI Zuv`i mv_ KQi KiZb| Ze
IQgvb (ivt) Zuvi LjvdZi c_gw`K KQi KiZb Ges
cieZxZ cyiv coZb (<!< !/:~ l !/::~ l!
!/:: << !!' )| GwU wQj IQgvb (ivt)-Gi
ewMZ Avgj| Avjvn ZvAvjv Gikv` Kib, Zvgv`i
gvS hw` Kvb welq gZvbK nq, Zvnj Zvgiv wdi hvI
Avjvn I Zuvi ivm~ji w`K (l! >)| Ave`yi ingvb web
Bqvhx` ejb, Avwg hLb Ave`yjvn web gvmD` (ivt)-K
IQgvb (ivt)-Gi cyiv QvjvZ covi welq wRm Kijvg,
ZLb wZwb ejjb, Avgvi Rb `yB ivKAvZ Avjvn&i `ievi
Keyj nIqv Pvi ivKAvZi PvBZ ewk cm`bxq (!
!!, ! !l < l :/:~)|
DjL, ivm~j (Qvt) gv weRqi mdi gvq `yB ivKAvZ
QvjvZ covi ci ejjb, , ' , ., .,_ ,. .
` , . , n bMievmxMY! Zvgiv Pvi ivKAvZ co| KviY
Avgiv gymvwdi (!<! !/:~~> l! !/::~) eYbvwU
hCd| Gi mb` Avjx web hvq` web Ry `Avb bvg
GKRb hCd ivex AvQb (!: <!< / l!< <!!, l
~, /~:)| we`vq ni mgq ivm~jyjvn (Qvt) Avivdv
gq`vb AevbKvj GK Avhvb I `y B BKvgZ hvni I
AvQi Rgv ZvK`xg Kib| gy K xg-gymvwdi mKj Zu vi mv_
GKBfve QvjvZ Av`vq Kib (<!<, l! !/~:: '
<! !<! !/:>::)| gy h`vjdvZI gvMwie I Gkv
Rgv ZvLxi KiwQjb| AvM-wcQ Kvb myb vZ cobwb
(<!<, l! !/~: l !/:~)| Bgvg Beby
Zvqwgqvn (int) ejb, GwU dK xn wevbMYi ga BRgv-
Gi bvq (!<!, !!l ! <! : ~> !-:)|
(>/) +|- || ||- <|< <|< =+# |+
|<| +|x| - +<| < <|- ||+ -||-|< <i<^|
<<v = -i |+ f |+- =|< <|-|<
+ |<-f< +|< ||- <|-+ || < +|v
<|<|-| +< < |+--| ||-< <||< +<<-
-!|! !+ >
l>! <! l! >
l<!> <
<< hw` cwZvbi MVbZ wewfb gqv` c_K c_K
wkK _vKvi welqwU AvewkK _vK, Ze cwZvb cavb
`vqx neb| Avi Zv bv _vKj KwgwUi civgk cavb wkK
hvK hvM gb Kieb Zvi bvg c ve KiZ cvib| GZ
GKB wkK GKvwaKevi AvmZ cvib| Avi hw` c wZvb
cavbi GZ Kvb cZviYv ev KvimvwR _vK Ges wZwb
hvMZvi g~jvqb bv Kib, Zvnj AekB Zu vK Revew`wn
KiZ ne (<!< !/~> l! !/:~:)| Kbbv ivm~j
(Qvt) nK`viK Zvi nK w`Z ejQb (<!< !/:>:)|
(>/) |-|<|+ |+- < >:: ti|<
'|< +<|- <| >c - -<|< +||-|' <+ <<<|
x| +<| <| <v |, <<<| =+|
x|< -|x <|< | -#, || |< | -# |'
|- < - x||+ <|<< | -- =<t ||
+< - | | |+ |vz
-!|! !+ !
!!^, l<!><
<< IUv bvix wRb wQj| Dhhv g~wZi ic ai gwnjv wRb
g~wZc~Rv Kivi Rb Drmvn w`Z| GRb ivm~j (Qvt) D
bM bvix wRbK cKZ Dhhv ejQb (!!^ <<! !/::)|
DevB Beby Kve (ivt) ejb, c ZK g~wZ i mv_ GKRb
Ki bvix wRb _vK (!! !/~:~:>)| h gvby lK Zvi
w`K cjy Ki|
(>c/c) |x<| ||- :> |-- | x| <
x| = < + -<| < =< < <+|-
x|<ix = = |- |-| < |+z






57
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
-!: l
!^!>!!$!, <!^!<!, <!>!
<< Awf Wvvii civgki AvjvK hw` gvqi
Rxebi gwK _vK Zvnj MfwZ Y dj `qv Rvqh|
Ab_vq kixAvZi `wZ MfcvZ Kiv nvivg (<!!<!
~)| Avi `vwi`i fq m vb nZv Kiv nj Zv ne
Aviv eo cvc (< <!^ ::)|
(>e/e) -+| x|| + |< <|<
|# ^|x|< | <| +< =x|<^|< +<|< |+z
-!^
l<, ^!><
<< GRb Zv`iK ZIev KiZ ne Ges GK `xbvi ev
Aa `xbvi Qv`vKv KiZ ne (Avey`vE` nv/264; wgkKvZ nv/553)| GwU wQj
bex hyMi ^Ygy`vi bvg| GLb mLvb Zv bB| AZGe ^ ^
`ki gy`vq wKQz Qv`vKv Kiv Dg| Bgvg Avngv` (int)
ejb, wb`kwU gvb`~e chvqi| IqvwRe chvqi bq (wgiAvZ
3/251)| AZGe KwVbfve ZIev KivB KZe|
(>/) |+|< <|+| |-<||< < |+|<z |<^
||< ||-< <||< +<<-
-!+!
!< <!>!<, <!>!
<< mvbv-Puv`xi wbQve Abyhvqx UvKvi hvKvZ wbavwiZ
ne| A_vr eZgvb Ihb Abyhvqx 85 Mvg mvbv Ges 595
Mvg Puv`x| cqvRbxq LiP ev` hv Aewk _vKe Ges GK
eQi Zvi Dci AwZevwnZ nj mwZ UvKvi Dci hvKvZ
IqvwRe ne| kZKiv AvovB fvM wnmve (< !>!
!/:)| ^Yi g~jgvb icv Acv wwZkxj Ges
wekevcx MnYhvM weavq AwaKvsk wevb ^Yi wnmve
Abyhvqx hvKvZ `Iqvi c gZ cKvk Kib|
(>/) -| |<<|| |<- ^|x|< xi|< +|<
|- v -| =x|<^|< ^|x|< |-+ + ||+ |-<
-i |<<| +<| <|< |+z
-< >!!
!!<, !!
<< ^vgx-xi wgjbi gvag m vb Avm| wK wgjb
njB m vb ne GgbwU bq| KviY GUv m~Y Avjvn&i
nvZ (<! >-)| ZvQvov Ab weevn nj m vb neB
gg Kvb wbqZv bB| KvRB ahaviY Ki ^vgxi mv_
Rxeb-hvcb KivB fvj ne| KviY bex Kixg (Qvt)
ejQb, h gwnjv Zvi ^vgxi wbKU _K AKviY ZvjvK
Pvq Zvi Dci RvbvZi myMwI nvivg nq hve (!<!
!/~~:, l! !/:~>)|
DjL h, wPwKrmvi gvag hw` ^ vgxi `ye jZv bv mvi,
Zvnj x ^vgxi wbKU _K Lvjv-i gvag wbRK
wewQb Ki wbZ cvi (<!<, l! !/:~)|
(>o/o) |x<| (e) v< <|- |< () |#
<|<|-x| <<# < |v |<|< -|x > x|<<
-|x > |<| x| >e |<| |x |v |#<<| |x
<|--<+ |- |v -| x|<< |x + |- |v
< -1|< x<i + + + |<z || < |<<|- -<|<|
<9- -| +< |< |<|x +| ||-< <||< +<<-
-!! !
!><!<, <!>!
<< IqvwiQMY K KZUzKz cve Zv ^qs Avj vn wbavib
Ki w`qQb (l! , ::)| wK mUv cve gZyi ci,
AvM bq| Ze KD hw` RxweZ Aevq eUb KiZ Pvq,
Zvnj AekB me IqvwiQK Ask gZ w`Z ne| Ze
GUv nZ ne mvgwqK wfwZ Kej gwLKfve| KviY
P~ov fvMeUb ne gZzi ci Bmjvgx kixAvZ gZ|
ck DjwLZ welq Qj`iK gq`i wY bxwZi
wfwZ gv I evc Dfqi 26 weNv Rwg 14 fvM fvM Ki
Qjiv cve `yB fvM, Avi gqiv cve GK fvM Ki|
evb`iK Zv`i cvc nK _K gvnig Kiv wbtm`n
Kvexiv bvn Ges Zv Abi nK AvZmvZi kvwgj| Zviv
gv bv Kij Avjvn ZvAvjv D cvc gv Kieb bv
(<!< !/~> !!< !/!' <! :, : )|
(/c) +|- xv | x||<<< v|| |< <|-
- #x|x >< <|+'| <| || < +< -i <|
| +<v- < <^|< = x v | |+ < <| ||
$<z -| v|-| | +< <| || $<z <| <
<|+'| <v #x|x< ||x< < =+ <|+'|
+< $<, -||+ -'<|+'| =+ | $<z
-!!!<, <<
<< D Aevq kyay m~ iv dvZnv coe (<!< !/
l !/)| Avi Bgvg mvjvg wdivbvi ci `uvwoq GK
ivKAvZ co eVK Kie| AZtci AviK ivKAvZ co
eVK kl mvjvg wdive| wcQb Avmv ew Bgvgi mv_
h ivKAvZ cve mUvB Zvi c_g ivKAvZ ej MY ne
(<!< !/:: l !/::>)|
(:/c:) |-|| x|- v|| |-|< +<
#x|x< - $|< +|< v|| =+|| | -|
|v|$| <, <|<, |v< v|| |<| -+ -<|
$ = =+|+| |<<| <| v|| |-|< +<|
<|< |+z
-!: !, ^!
<< G aibi gmwR` QvjvZ Av`vq Kivi KviY
QvjvZ GKvMZv b nj Bgvg cvcx ne| Ze gyv`xi






58
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
QvjvZ nq hve (<!< !/:> l! !/:::: !< <'
)| Avi QvjvZi mgq nq Mj GKvKx AvDqvj
Iqv QvjvZ Av`vq Ki wbZ ne| ci Zv`i mv_
coZ mg nj kvwgj nIqv hve| Ze cieZx QvjvZwU
bdj ej MY ne (l !/:>)|
(>/c>) <-|<< <i<| +<| |+ <|'|
-|z x||-< x||< |$|-| < |<-| <
< | |<< +<| <|< |+z
-!! !!<
!^<, !<!
<< Pzj q-weq Kiv kixAvZ mZ bq| KviY hv
mshy _vKv Aevq wew Kiv bvRvqq, Zv c_K nIqvi
ciI bvRvqh| gvbyli Pzj Zvi AbZg| Gi viv gvbyli
ghv`vi nvwb nq (<<, !-!> >/~ :)|
(/c) |<+ =<t |<-'|+|<|+ ||
|'|| |+<|x< |-- +x- ||^ |-<-z |<+
|<-'| <||< <|< |+z
-!|! !<<< <!
<!!!l, =!<, l<!>^&
<< wkiK I we`AvZ `yBwUB RNb Aciva| hw` D
cvc nZ ZIev bv Ki KD gviv hvq, Zvnj Avjvn ZvK
Rvnvbvgi Avb cywoq kvw w`eb| hgb wkiK mK
Avjvn ejb, wbq h Avjvni m wkiK Kie Avjvn
Zvi Rb RvbvZK nvivg Ki w`eb| Avi Zvi vb ne
Rvnvbvg| Avi mxgvjsNbKvix`i Rb AvLivZ Kvb
mvnvhKvix _vKe bv (!! ~)| AZtci hviv we`AvZx
Zviv ivm~j (Qvt)-Gi mybvZK cwiZvM Ki gvbyli Zwi
weavbi AvbyMZ Ki| hviv Avjvn&i ivm~ji weavb gvbe
bv, Zviv gywgb nZ cvie bv (l! :)| we`AvZxiv nvDh
KvIQvii cvwb cvb Kivi myhvM cve bv Ges ivm~j (Qvt)-
Gi kvdvAvZI cve bv (l !/~:)| Aekl Zviv
Rvnvbvg wbw ne (!!^ !/:)|
AZGe hveZxq Kg Ges Bev`Z aygv Avjvn&i mwi
Dk Kij wkiK _K euvPv me| Abyic `jxjwenxb
I Rvj-hCd nv`xQwfwK Avgj ZvM Ki ay Qnxn `jxj
wfwK Avgj Kij we`AvZ _K euvPv me|
(/c) <|| (v|:) +|- =|+|< #x|x-<
<- |-<v- |+z #x|x <- |- ||< <-
|+z || <-, +<|-+ ^ xi <-|<< +< -|
=< |<| +| <|-| <vz
-!|! <!
<!>!, !!!, <!^<!
<< KziAvb wkv w`q, BgvgwZ Ki, Avhvb w`q, xbx
Zvjxg w`q wewbgq MnY Kiv Rvqh AvQ| Ze A_ MnY
hb Dk bv nq| Dk nZ ne Avjvni mw| KviY
ivm~j (Qvt) ejQb, h ei Dci Zvgiv cvwik wgK M nY
Kie mjvi ga mevcv ekx nK`vi nQ Avjvn& i
wKZve (<!<, l! !/~>)| D nv`xQ m~ iv dvwZnv
cvV Ki SvoduyK Ki QvnvexMY Lv` wnmve wewbgq M nY
KiQb m K_vI DjL iqQ|
ivm~j (Qvt) Ave~ gvn&h~ivK Avhvb kl GKwU icvi _wj
c`vb Ki Zvi Rb eiKZ Kvgbv Ki `vAv Kib (!!^
!/::~ < !>! !/)| Ab nv`xQ ivm~ j (Qvt)
Avhvbi wewbgq h cvwikwgK M nY Kie bv ZvK
gyqvhwhb wnmve MnY KiZ ejQb (!!^ !/:~ l<l
!/~>)| Gi A_ nQ, h wbw` cwigvY A_ MnY Kivi
kZ w`e| hgb ejj, G cwigvY UvKv bv w`j Avwg
BgvgvwZ Kie bv, Avhvb w`e bv, KziAvb covev bv| wK
KZc wbR`i BQvq c `vb Kij ZvZ Kvb `vl bB
(! , !<: ! !l >/:>)|
GwjZ wewbgq MnY Kiv Kz iAvbK ^ g~ j weqi A
fy welq bq| B`x-bvQviv agbZviv Zv`i ^v_ wmwi
Rb Zv`i wKZvei k ev A_ cwieZb Ki djZ Ges
Zvi wewbgq jvK`i wbKU _K A_ DcvRb KiZ|
Avjvn GK ZvwQjfi ^g~j weq ej AwfwnZ
KiQb (Zvdmxi KziZzex, D AvqvZi evLv `t)| AZGe Bmjvgx kvixAvZi
Kvb weavbK cwieZb Kivi j hw` KD Ny li gvag
A_ MnY Ki Zvnj Zv G AvqvZi A fy ne|
(c/cc) =x- +|- |x |v |+ <|< |<|
+<<< | + x| |<| <|<z ||-< <||< +<<-
-!
!<, <!>!
<< Keii gvwUi Pvc _K mr Amr, gymwjg Agy mwjg
KD iv cve bv (!! !/~:~ ll! !
!/::>)| Ze mevi Pvc GKB aibi ne bv| gy wgb ew
GB Pvc kvw Abyfe Kie|
(e/ce) |x<| =|-- <|< '- # |-|<' x|<
-|'| -|<< $ ||v |+ '| ||- -' x
<<, >/-c#t |+- <-|-<|<| ti| :-: |<
||-< ||+ | <v - # |-|< x|< -|'|
<< $ < =<t | |-|||<| <|<|x-|...'
-|'|| <N < |<<< x|<|- ||-< <||< +<<-
-!!!
<!!!l, =!<, l<!>^&
<< h `vAvi mv_ Abiv Avgxb ej hgb Kyb~ Z
bvhjv, G vi `vAv BZvw` eZxZ evKx mKj `vAv
bxie cov DwPZ| Kbbv Avjvn ZvAvjv Gikv` Kib,
Zvgiv cwZcvjKK gb gb webq I fxwZ mnKvi
AbyP^i WvK (!<! ~)| c k DjwLZ `vAvwU Qnxn
nv`xQ viv cgvwYZ (!<! !/>: l<l !/~)|






59
gvwmK AvZ-ZvnixK Ryb 2012 15Zg el 9g msLv
(/c) v|, <, x|<, $| | <
|x$| |<| <|< |+z
-: !|! !
!< <!, >!^< l^ >
!!<
<< henKZ nvjvj ci cevwnZ i eZxZ meB nvjvj
(!! :)| nvbvdx wKZve mg~n Aviv QqwU e nvivg
ej DjL AvQ| wK mwj me wKqvmx ev Abygvb
wbfi| myZivs nvjvj ci Pvgov hw` KD LZ Pvq, LZ
cvi| Ze ^vi Rb wZKi mewKQz _K weiZ
_vKZ ne| Kbbv ivm~j (Qvt) ejb, wZM nqv bv
Ges wZ Kiv bv (< !>! !/~: ! !/~)|
Kbbv GZ Lv` MnYi j evnZ nq (: !<
<!!<! :: !! !! :> ! ::)|
(/c) || |'|| x|x- <|-|< +<<
|< <^|- +<- |< x|x- <|-|< +< ||<
|<' =< -| ||-< <||< +<<- ||
|x|< <x x< ||< |x|+ |<|i -|-
+< =|< -|'| +<| <|< |+z
-!+ !
=.=. l<!<l, 1^!
<< D gg mgvR h eYbv cPwjZ AvQ Zv wfwnxb
(ll! ^! /::)| Gwelq mwVK AvKx`v nj, Avjvn
ZvAvjv Aviki Dci mgybxZ| G mK KziAvb mvZwU
AvqvZ eqQ (<! : !<! !!! <! >
!>! ! )| GKvwaK Qnxn nv`xQ vivI Zv cgvwYZ
(l !/:~~ <!< !/~:)| Ze Avjvn Zuvi Bjg I
Kz`iZi gvag mKji mv_ _vKb| hgb wZwb g~mv I
nviYK ejQb, . ` ` - _ ' , ` _ ` ' fq Kiv
bv| Avwg Zvgv`i mv_ AvwQ| Avwg me bwQ I `LwQ
(!!! :)|
Avjvn&i bvg I Yvejxi Amxjvq `vAv Kiv hve| hgb,
,.. , . , .__ __ , .~_ ,,-_ ,
,. n `qvjy! AvgvK `qv Ki| n ihx`vZv! AvgvK
ihx `vI| n c_ c`kK! AvgvK myc_ `LvI| n
mvnvhKvix! AvgvK mvnvh Ki BZvw`| Gfve A_ eyS
`vAv Kij `q ckvw Avm| Avjvn&i cwZ wbfiZv
ew cvq I `ngb kw Avm| eZt wQdvZx bvgwj
Avjvn&i GKZev`, Zuvi `qv, `vbkxjZv I mevP kw
nIqvi cgvY enb Ki| Avjvn ZvAvjv ejb, Avjvn&i
my`i bvg mg~n iqQ Zvgiv mwji gvag AvjvnK
WvK (!<! :)|
(/e) |x <<< +|z <<< =<t |<|<
|<- |+ =+#z
-!|! !<<< <!
<!!!l, =!<, l<!>^&
<< eihL ki A_ A ivq I c_KKvix| kixAvZi
cwifvlvq gZi ci nZ wK qvgZ ch mgqKvjK eihL
ejv nq| GUv `ywbqv I AvLivZi Rxebi gaKvi
cvPxi| Avjvn ejb, Zv`i mvgb c`v _vKe cy bivb
w`em ch ('l :)| wK qvgZi ci _K AvLivZi
Rxeb i| hnZz AvLivZB kl Rxeb, ZvB ZvK
AvLivZ ev klw`em ejv nq (!< !<!<, <!!<!
!!< <!!)| Zvici hvi bKx ewk ne m hve
RvbvZ, Avi hvi bvn ewk ne, m hve Rvnvb vg (<!
!-!l<! :-::)| myZivs eihL I AvLivZ c_K welq|

You might also like