لماذا يسمح الله بالألم ؟

?

-& +, ( '& $"#
.
2 +3 1 + "
+ 6 753 .
2 (B6 C +@? > ( 6;
?,D. ?,6
2 +6 + B ;6 5
>1# GH (+( $1 7 +&1.F
2 6JB J L
; 5 1 BF
+, $1 N1 F
6 (+3 .
PQO? '& J SBJ #

B 6 V W $B? V6 O? .
>YJ & +,+' +- +( X7H #
.(> NB
5 +7 Z+&1
. (W1

?
J 'W +# ?+- +- DH?
?,6O? ?,6_H # \P
17 ' @7O? J
& ? +7 -
?+3, \6 6(HB
; "+ +%, )%& '(%
( a @7 F
6%%%17 %%% & 3 %%% %%%+0%%% &0%%% %%%1
9%%% %%% .. %%% <%%%, . % %<+= %%%
? <1" : .
ZJ b'O :B $( F $
B( F $J, G17 SH7O6 F? ZJ,6
5 1 C
( 6# 7 - ,(B gL
+L " (2 ( +7 h (2
((1 ZJL5 (' 3 17
& S $' ( b (i ,
_6# ,#L PN B SL J +
(2 . 7
:
N S5L ?,L( (GQ
> P@3# B1 3 _H B1
(6 7 $DiY D L
6# +, HD Q (' b1iD1$
L NB ' $6 ( N 7 (
' $5 BDO? 17
( N 7 ( '( B1
O _ B 1 Z \ 6
+ (1 \- ( 5L
+O W 1(6+O +L Hi m
_6# n+H H L n bH+6
(1 .
31 $36 6 H(3
"B , +5L 6O
31 J p '@, P L H
31 L 6 S r(
31 +# 5 ++ Q76 @ .
B 6O # (7 ?, 3 J

( H_ 6 S P@7D J &
, SH76 t1 '@ B' P + - $+
1
rDJ L 6 B
+ PL
u5J " (' (' +
5 Q76 +
$6 iHu + ( +_6#
B++7 1 G17O6 F? H 'O
+ +3 J p Vi i S
$ v C+- +, !"# ?+3
3 C i GY6 S 6#- F
" %%F %%6%% F%% G%%H< . $ D%% E
& "I . :
B F w6 i 6#O B1 3
\ ' ( b@L .6 ?n( B1
1 & 7 (
>i7 "# SH7 1 +#

O
6 ?n( B1 ?,1 BD #
( ( 7 >3 16 iY
p SH76 BD1 ( B1 $ h
> h-1& > +&1 3i6 BD1F
. Z7
1 pD +# +6 p(B
"&' (") *+ ,- . /012 3

"45
6 789 :;5<9
""0= 6
( 2 v ( 6 ?,1 'SH
O? J O? D H
1D h ,,5
, #L 16 ii CLY
3 B SH' #?
B1 56 $1 #L$6 >-
#L N & + rD ?,1J p(\L
pi u5 >i7 rD & C

L $6 > ?@ 3 +" p+7

p65 a ,#. ,
L & N ;3 a
,6&1 L 2 ( ,L
_7 + 1 $J J
J p +36 1 (i F
L5 w6 >Y(1 O #
+7# 2 Q 2; HN
+H F6 p1 p? (,
. p
1 G17O6 F?
? O? J + W7 : NB
? &#
F L( 1 +H L 'V
S nO $, +3 i' F
i7H (B : i7 J
L 1> 2

w6( 1u J NB6 XL

O (B # ?,O F? i7
5 J,6 G17 WH p3D . - 1
W wH # F + ?,(B $
(a ?,O C ,!! L
wH' 3_1 6 ( SL
( > (B +3 h'Oi7 J
B S11 .
( wHB71 J 36 1_6
1BL +3 HL1 $u7
D .
zLHB +31 hDB '?
FJ >i7 $1 $ Z+ v N
6 $ 1 (> "&1 H
6 ?n $1
b h-'V1 1 D
( > hQ (B +H 1
>175( S i+71 .
B +31 W +( i7$
+O u H (B
( u 7 B +

m ( ( b
' i B . Hi
( D V N & # $BZJ
O W1 1 Sn $NB
D1 $. H5
+- F B i +73N
p 1 6 $ 1 Sn
,;. ,
ZJ+' 51 ' _6#
''OB +31 '( G17 F
O6? 3D1 (1 (,H( B BD i
3 B & 1{6 # ( BD B
B B N6 ,H G7166 (i6
(\6 +7 HL1. wH
* ?
: BCB 409
5 +6 1 ? 5

B hB p?
+H '+H B H3 $6 1# p
B + ? ,a ? +1
B ( W( W? 7# 'h-
2 &(L J ( B ( 7
7B 1a6 J p+ ( H
Q7J & >1"u B +7#
+ L6J6 D ( p,H + 1
X & S 3 B ( J V6 "@+ +
'(& +6. ,
-( Vi? .
-( - Vi . F
.
-( Vi
$ ZJD1( $ & B1 1 B
' SHO? ( ( a 3 31$
+ (: ,
+36 wuHO? $6 ZB +6; ( >17(

N W ( +
JL , B ( Vi p+L
( (,H ' SHO? NO? 7
BD1O 33L? & } #
J + "# & +7 i
. i
( ' h O? B1 B PQ
(,H( F :
: F9 4 ' GHI J BK -1

(H "L1W1 C 1D -
( i +# +L Y1
& C ++5 $H-\3
+3 O ? J ZHV J 6 CL
Li 'OJ L1 B
$J D O? 6 "1(#O 6
1" "# 1# n ;6 $6
Hn Z ' +6 i' $ ?B
+ ' +L b O L ;56 7
3 ? +L HQ O 17
L6 DL ? 6O 5L
D G& 1(6 ?,O & 6 -
+3 ZJ BD1 m '2 67

L $6 W ! F6 1{6 3
H p $#" &' 1 ):(
" .. %%%%%% %%% K%%% %%%F D%%% K %%%1F L%%%
E 9 . Q ' '.= L# ' %?+
9 . - D( R 6I ='+% 6I+(%
( . < G%% %?S% L 0% 3U% .
1 ? ( . X %& D7Y= . 6I+1W6I
'%%%%%%= . 6Y0%%% S%%% KI(%%% . G%%%1
%%%+1 '%%% %%+1W 0%%%<[%%% %%%+1 %%%1<= .
%% %% 6I+(%% 6I(%% %% 0%%+9 ..
%%% 6%%%9%%% 'Y (%%% %%%%%% %%%X
" ). (
7 CW7 -
" H3
0%% < 6%% %%?H %%F . 6%%F 6I1(%%6I%%
< 6I % 6I%&% .. 6I% '% %c 6I%
S%%%& 6I%%%1& %%% . d%%% f%%% 1 6. e%%%E L
%%%% 6I h%%%% L%%%%1+Y .. g (%%%% %%%% <%%%%
E S K+ ".. .
? a $J W V - ( $ 2?

3+ S- H- 1 6 pQ7
+ 1 @ (a
' h\ $#@ B
" w1 ' V
J 6 >Y( .. H3? wu6Q7 !
; 2 @-+
& C 7 V
631 @
1 7(B S5 S7 $Bi 1@3
$a n 1@3 +H W ( nH
V1 } SH' u ?,#
O? Z(# SH' u Vi. Z-
O? + V OB 5 J, 6
+3 p ,((# ( a
6 H5J 16 S " +
1 + Z+ u5 +3
SH76 Hi + ,- +
-+ .. Z t $J +H } ? } 1
B S5_7 H_6! .
?MK /> /N O0 P@3 > hL

H ( B 33L (H uV
H_6 (H5 $D ? +- B F
P ZB 1? Vi ? B
' i $# F' 1 P z 1
>i7 ' b +3 z (
J ?,\6 ? B' i F+-
P 1 DL \ Q7
O 1
? ' .. i (B? . $1
L i ( +3
(H ,Q $1Li ! v7
J 6 F +&1 - 1

J SL F N
"P 19 Q"IR SC<< T;

! <09
"6 )89 ' 09 V P UF F9
G1(
B p- p 6 B 2 7
? ;6? B 7_
( z 1 (@B

B1 2 P 1 6 W $

B B1 p $N P H
3 ". ,(\L "pH
B F Xi +- P@(
>i7 B1 $1 +Y B
. ,3
( V7 :J + 76 + +
& 6? v7 (& +3
H (B7 ' ) B
+3 ( ( 6 $5 h iD ?,HL L
.. F ;D 1,(BL 6 u 6BJ
" 17 $D "iW 1 )_+(
& ?7,# ?iL (1 GH51 + JB
D( iB1 $# $3( $- &$
J ++# $# $ V i
Hn $1 B ) i :
: . (

" )@ W 4 0< X B2M' 4 Y

^0' 4K B'Z_ B'Z[ 4 \] UB09
"` F9 ab" :M9 "]9
. .
? B+ i ? V +
Hi S7L DH B i\ HH7
( 17 F' B_L
) BL (( h 1 &+7 1
"# LH &" # DH )+O
( 1 p J GYH
_ 7 >i7 + 6JB $-O
( ZB W 1 LY+) 1 (
O ( 6D p7LJ & $_7
H H +) u (Q
7H & $1J B11,
$B6 >1 J 7 # 6 ,1D
> 11L+) F . (

: b"d 4 ' GHI J BK -2

_7 B1 B + 5 '3
3 D iD( i-7
B@;1i-7 ?,++3 -
W ,6 ?,7 .
. T B9 UCC 6# &07
( # V +# L
?, i( +-
' bL ZJ
b7 1W , , ?,JW p .
; +(6
B +31 NV6 $ W N1
- $3 Z$6
) : B ( : B
7' ,'Z 1 (6 7- (7
h' ' #
) ( : B6 3 +
-' 33L ( >17

;
+,&+3 ++ ' 6 C 5
$B 3 F3 b , > i( a p-
J P( \
V : i
"L %%%%7 %%%%F %%%% 1[<%%%% L . d
D<j%%%L .. %%%E?1 %%% 1 %%% 1 I(%%%k j%%%
?& '%% l<%% %%(%%k %%H %% ) %%L . d
p < 61 1 'o% %< n+% %m"
. :
1 B 7 a BD1P1
1 +3 &( CDH $B P?
" J LY Q ,
(7(#DH 33O? $NH
5 @- ? CL 3, F
.
JV p # '' BD1# O?
(& H1 + i ? O? ((,H
Y ", (H( DD (
B1 B & 2 H#? X-7
+6 'H SH ( .

1 3 ; h5 ? B

$" b +<+1 F D%+
. %%%%r %%+ %% %%Q=%% 0%%& %%"
) ( : ' %% B1 $( ( 7
( ' 6 h+H Z6 h +6 B
( : B) - +6 p 1,
Q # ,6 ? 1 6
H7 1 3 6J h' $ &7
1# ( B) ,HBL t
$&7" B +31 #h
$ _'@ 7- $B6 5 (h
) ( 1 H# tip 1
J $-QO 6O J
6L ?L ( 7 $3 H
) . ( :
O J 6 (H5 P ># B1
) ) ?,H#B 16 H +
;,iY
&'f2 ,) Z SH7
L 1'V6 b t J O
Y ,1,iY $3+ J

1 F . H
$H &+ ''i > $637 PQ) PD1 ( + (
$1 $' $& B
6 (W1 7 ' 3 6 $
O 3? 1 )1 ( : :
+- ''i B1 1
+L ( ? . T B9 gC
+6 B; & S"&1 6 1
7 . $1L Z $ ,iY (
&6 & '6 _& $) 5 1 :
$6 ( : +3'i 3 2
+' , 1L 6 HD: H ) G71
( 1 p( >i7 +3
O? J ' Z++& +6
3 _L ) ( : ' N
N .
hR"B 6 H19 UCC 6# &07
( 1 p 1 F NBH'O F

? '- B ' n ' G1L
"1 J,6 ) $BD .(
""? /C) Z 19 ;B+ &' /C) ij #
:
' 6 C + O? # +++3
- +7# BD H ( " [% . (H
E0%%%% ) "%%%%+1E%%%%X ( : 3
6 C F; L B ZZJ
D p ' SH? w1 B
@ ' Z+
F? V' i +6 (B
B h ZJ 65 6 'HH
u 6 # +3 G6 $B C >Y
# 1" B ( 1_,
( 3 17 J "?%%% %%% %%%
Y <k F 1& Y 4) .. f(+
":"b )# MkB5 OFW )# B3%X
. :
; 7 5 GJ B1

N
& +5 2 & S5,
SH76& iD G1' +3 F iD O
& >1#; V (6 ( J(6
$B Z+ +1 1 +7# $#J
[
( +,6 F3 " U = % %
( + d '& Y "0 :
.
V +3 1 '& $H 367 3i6
H'O G1' 6 F iD +
; ,
? B ,' O
& 6? B F $J
6 176 ( $ +&1# B -
+ 1B F HL. Z
L ( - 1? B
\-L H ,
O F L 6 3N _7
B1 F6 PN "(6 gL ' 3
?iLL (O D ' SH O F
PL7 3N ( , + ?n 1,
C $ 1 # $1iD

'& $B +31 NV6 $m? ',HH
L+ , $N 1O ?O&$
: $N H551 65
&. : $
)# 4
m ' GHI J BK -3
+L ( Vi (H5?
n "3 H (& V6 SH76 "+ &" F
+- i Z(HBN \ " ?
C SH7 ?,HB 3L7
V SJ C6 6\ 1
a;1 367 NBO?
J HH' (H5( ? (B7 ?iL
1iL 1 .
i ? 376 'HH
SH7 NBO? J . DH
-+ GHI "Bn V? SH76

i' >1 1 3
" '%% %% 3%%1%% %% '%% %%+ (%%+"
: + 6 B D C1 B6 (1
3 " v%E R% %% d <6%I
< .. 6IS D D ( + R d
? 3 R ( '( 61" :
C (1 3 " & %+7
c L 3%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%I %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% I"
. :
; J "- ?,7 C(& Q u1
p 1O7 : Z1 7
O $ SB i O 6 1 bi1
J ( &7& " Rv(%['1%F xU%
< GHI# &' 61U ) x & %+ )%
: H? 7 1-; $#
i6 ,HB 6" Z=%% (%% LU%%
vE L I7 ' x&+ . : "R d

G() 11F(Y . 6I U% }= %% %<k+

0 F?& "R' :
.
;
# 7 ;B ( 7 @-
" ' )? R R "R . :
LH ++
HL H h F (D +6 ' X3
i(&' > >HD6 $- Z ,#B
1 1 ? S $?
,# (. H
"1 )5 ( ( H6 3QH
h > & J 6 C
$&7 1 $#u " 2
$V V L iu i& ,
" S a 6 B' 1 O
; L . 6Q 'H
+ , 3
" "g3 : .
" . ,q r Z !9 gRG2 < Z 4B#
"URf !9 UCs :M9 6

ZJ,65 3( L ,#33L

H5 w6 V(& H
i 1 V H FGL5
7 ?,HL J3 1 B 63 2
11 ? .
g"]2 5]2
( +- (Y7 (3 G71
(5 1 L( 5D 1_6 F (66
(6 "# L @ ' ,O
SL1J + ( GL5 C(, 6
' \ W? +& OJ ' 2 Z
!
/p 12 o)^+
" L Yv G L 9 3
U R?Y { R 1H ' ? .. R1 F 6
%%c %% =(%% {%%' %% . 6I%%I [%%j%%
9 = 99 9 . Y 3o

&?' :
' O $N JL '

6 C (W1O _ 6 ,
( D JY1 ,'6
& SV S ' J V S
n 3 "9 U% v % 0%
' &0 Y v 0 %
'%% .. R(%%k= %%U%% 6%%%%X k<%% %%
%%X %%F +%% 9%%1& %%+) %% %%
. 1& 6) + (k' 1& 6) F{% '%
L < "6X :
.
>i7 ?, ( +H1 : HL W6
>- LO SL1 GL5i
+ & (Q ++ .
: )"BR
$ F\ > n (W1 +1J
5 $1 D_7 J ? i $H3
; +6 F H- >- S\n F

2 (+ i( ++

' 1 JL h- 731 S
"9 & 6v %? '% % 6j 0 v .. j6%1 %& 3Yj%
. eH & D+) "6F X ( :
.
( (+ m +3 . +1
S # i &6 B pb-n J
_? ). ( B
'+ 1 6( SH76 7 J
B) 1, . (
' $\6 7- SH76 51?,
) . (
SD ?+3 L1D ( J
'(B ( : (N) +1Y
p 1&1 6+ +,
&) ++1 . ( :
(+ ' $6 F+
> B $ J\ ' 3 HL
)- i6 . ( :
( ( 6 - +6 #O

H'O 1BL6 $5 $#W B+ J( F
1 2 '2 " S J
Z ? aJ L SB DGL5
+H (D G# 1(66O
Y & (1 ? (B"1
1 B6 , H 3 "S%F %+1 < %U%
%%%< %%%) . %%%& %%% G%%%%%% D%%%1 <%%%1
?K %%% %%% ) . 2I# P D%%%I6I%%%1<= l%%%
6IE %%% %%%?%%% .%%%, %%% %%%1 %%%r
1Y+ ' '& 61Y% % &%
K "6I) Y L :
'2 $V ' i ? 'i (a
O . a ,#
L 33 # 1&6 D
n -; ;- ( J
" 1& 4)G< .. % L 3%1I% %
? +H " E . :
&" O _ BD 6#O? F
?# + ( D,D1 u +
BCB<9 +7 D $i O?

_J J D ( Vi?
> DH1&1 p B' 1
&" N J( F 6 X3D1 $(B
L71- "o- t9 ) R" , B33L

W1 1 ? ZJ,6 B5 Q +3 Z1
SLB +31 +' ?
+' L7 H( 1 1 7
? : +3( >H' 5 1
( Jb 6H W? na n 1
L Y +3 F u5 $#
@ , +6 B (' C1 O? ..
u B FJ $N16 G17 ZJO
+L - +6 . 3 +3 . 1 +3 1
_1 N V6 7\! !! $
,+7\ (&D& L . U ..
:
);- 409
L +6 r FV? , O?
' HH BO? B
?B 71 SH76 GL5
# ? +' +3 ? O? L V6N
Y F6 ?,-; $#- P N
B1 hB $N1 ZJa V SH7
31 ( 6 $5 O(
+O6 C + +- S"1 -
""/02 OF9 4 42"b 6 4<F) ,t02

X
:
" %%?F %% 6v%% . LW %% %%m <%%

K "3F D7kY 69 . :
B( 6 HJ D B71 6

' #) ,1'( z ,2 F
5- S BL( 3 +& h-
)(' +6 (# 6 ,63 $ D :
+# ) (# $L71 6 P,

66 ,1 SL B ,
+& 61 ,6 7L
3 # + +7L 6B
( , + F SL1J 6 3 (2
+H b'O@L ,7 + _1
'; . 3
J (L ) (# ' HH 1 3+
- ,( H (#) : , 7 +J,6 651 1 7 6 D
PH' O # CH 1' +3
S 5 71L .
3 S : 53 -1 B (#) S -
aL QJ B +6 ? ,2
H6 i ,+6 F C(6 C'OH-N
+7# ", ,J, L u
17+ SH' zLH J
+H .
, +1 (#) LH N N. ,6
( a L (a . 1 h
3 : SB ) (# > F,(B

? .. ( + (#) 17,6
;u /I;93 J \+ $ ,
+3'+ ,Y F. U9 K*) Lt B
H
J +H1 V6 $@3 O? B1 ( B
1 F' 6 C' N $
N +33 S :
"v [ 1IH IL ' = I
c , = 1 X ) FE
( ' Y ' . j 6) (k
+ L 1& '1 1& (kd
U ' 69" X : .
$NJ 7 B3 Z ' 6C
6& +7 - +- H" C3%%k
<9 + F <j "+%X :
(- Jb 6% %?" C Y% % %
k<%%% %%%%%%F %%%1& %%%Y 3U%%% . f(%%%+%%%
k<j%%%%% 60%%%%%j%%%%% LIE%%%%%
j =99 f(+ %+) % U%oY <%

F" X . :
" S7L Lc %%%K Y L %%% %%% %%%H+

< %% "'1<(%%B 7 ( @" 1'%%Y
< 61 9 <%?Y ' U%1 %1 < + "d
) : . ( :
O? ( 33\ h (7 +L?

H (a J - ?, & ,6O?
+? # 1 F . B h-B
J ( Z+ + GL5 #O? a
- " 3k<L + F <j. "+
O? & H + BO ?3
O+ ;O 71 +5 3
+; F6 (-6( .
O? # 3Q( P@3L
JL &+6 Z O F N
& O? Z ?,
( a "%+H %
+& $# +6
+K "R1& '1 . :
O? & ?3 H& >i7 L( ( Z
V PQ" D ( L
B1 1( # 6 $O 7
i F (LJ6 H p "=%% K%% L"

_L ) (' H "#O

W1+ (3 L ' 7 7
L 1 Y65 $B
a $J 6_1 1B

- F' i $ v 1,
a O + SH73 F6
_1 6 1 # 7 Y1 .
; +3 ( _L ) (H
N1
v"B9 $#J a( (' () \- +F
6i J ' G7B $v
). ( : B
K $ F(' a 33
$H + +J 6 Z+. F
+H O=" >6 ? $ 1# ;6 &7,-

(B } 1+ SH76 Q
(B( , h'+ F+6 $
6 5 ?B H +-
H36 Z O "S%%F 6%% %% 6%% . %%d
R S" ' . :
4="' a $H- (' () Z1
+7 F3 , 5 - J
SD + , () 7-
( .
_L ) (H +# ? B
D1 $@1 J 5
1a D u g; ((B
( h5+ )V& ( & + (7 #> #
1L 2++ +5
1 ' G1 F ?, Y ZJ
W, '1 ( 6J ( + #
1# D 6D(1 (Q 'b
?, i (3 '&
+31 W :
"U& .. 1? 6 %H ..%H %K% =%1

[
%%F %% 6%% j%%) . ?%%=%%+ 0%% %% %%F
%% (%% %%1= %% 6%%Q=%%1 <K%% <%% '
%%' .. 'U%%%% %% 'I%% =?%% % r
9" &. : G
+5- F bB ZJO B
+6O hDB' , ?,; ?,
6 L5 ) : S . (
""'G 6 w 4 $ x9 " 6 7w '#
":2 Z
&?' :
O? \ i ( a} +6(

(+ V7 'V H :1 (
u >H ZJ b'O ,,6D
& _6# B +31 ' N
HN J #L $1L BB1 7-

L ' (O 6 (H5 L

YL 7 $(. p
63 C - 6 , +&1+6O J
( S Fi 7 7 $

tL DH J ( ,&7 ,
( 1# i- ,@ ' Jb( . Z+&1
( a O \. $
>-( (1L h a O? J
(H5& ( PQ
( a S F7 $ v(2
+36 HL16 u>Y
6( H7 ++ D1. C'O
' 6 C )p%%" SB ( :
)( G Lc K Y ;u T 2 Z<%
"%% '1<(%%' ( (6 h7
, ( (B S i (W1
(a ?,2 ?,HL Y &
. +6O
16 D ( $6 3 1iL( 16
(2++ ( S51 ,B

( a' 6"Cs J pO

7-a 31 .
33 ZJH NB F
O( J5 2 ?,6n&
?,? J (a (a?
?,O +6O " %%%%7 %%%% +%%%%I %%%%
9 %, %< I %I%?& "d' :
.
( V J2 - N $V 2
N1 J ?a ( J P
7 S 5J ( a ;1
\ $ t + 1_7
"( H h J
1 a 6B J 7
+ J +6 p 1+6
J V 5( D 1iL
7 +6 B $J ;3 y-
7 6O ;&6 3 , Y
Y S 5 h i++# ( 3

+ 1 +H S 5 S 5
" 1 GH 5 . H n
L\ B1 $1L ( S 5
>i7 ( a ,V 5 +H (O
(5 .
"{"!9 4+ hz UBF' !"F U9 &
4
} ' /> 5C9 | "9 S) ]9 U
"
K :
JB \ S1 +D ,

+ +6 +L $J J J : F
+7 $N ZJa 3 B +
a ' L y 9 x9 P +
. *<)Z
:
: B01 409
i6 HL Y '+ J : ?, H
Z # Z +16 3 + 1?,6
: + S( +6 h W1 ZH1
7(1? PJ GL G6
C $O B $1D + (
@ +. LY
; ? S NB YN
# V6 D $BJ ,&1 $BJ _,#
\ +6 ZJ,1 .. B1,(1
1 3 $B6 ZJ
? O PL7 G6O? v, 1;S
O B 5 ;@ .. 3 . G6
B1 1 B @ + @ LYB
O? J (H5
1 J ( ( L
5( PH7 J
hQ G6 ( $J 3 $

PL7 G6O?
(2 H ,3Q $6 (1 C (&D

6 $L(@ ( @, 6&6 CO? ,
( ( 6 7 1
Q7 O 1 +5- "1
+O 'V1 $B ZJ aW 1
J ? ( ? +- 67
' 6 D ( SH76 6i
.
( $V 1 +V1 1 3H' J

' ?aJ V? '-? 6 i
NB 3 HJ +5
3 2 62 :
" 9< % . Xj% % . %H(%
% . X%+ % %X ..[% % D%
<%%% . S%%% =v .. D%%%+%%%E %%% v .%%%E
S v ..E ' %= % .. U &%E
.. &" X . :
( 17 P : H5
" '+%%& 9 4 ~<t) / .. lj%%
?, e0 ?SK K %=% =% L
K ".. : .
6 C( Z +3 H Z@ +O? 36
" hB " 9 4 ~<t) /'i 3
( & S +7 & (O 2 3Y
W1 + 3 ( (H16 $LH (B
>i7 16 F ( 6 Z+&1'i
6 C\ 3 ( ( a + (2

H V b? +L O J D S5
+ H 1 NB ' ?,7 73?,Q
6( ?,7O H76( H7 2
. 6 (1 C 1 bJ
+ H (1 & O6? J W
& + F &1 J O W1
>-# . H5 $
' 3 \ S S& h
6(& ( ( @,( 3 '& 6
+3 J +5 :
")(? x ) %+ <% %%H

& '+%%& %% %%Y %%+?%%, e0%% 6 %%
%+& R% '%1 ?S%% %% '%'1%%
Q 'SF < "e . :
- 6 X6 L 6 C 3 H
>i7 367 (@ Him?
H5" ,i H #
>i7 F +7 3D L ( BD BB
(6 $5 ( 1# _1 3 B
( PQ+3' 6 HD G71 PN
_7 G71 5 6 W 5
; ;6 i Vi B
& 7
> ( 3 i\ Pi
J 3 17 ( GH5 JbL -(1
5D 1 ? _7 & ++ NN
F Y h bD S7 7O?
$ 3 i > $ L
P1OJ,6 ( 1- $5 H .
"")"02 409 2 /+ U9 &0 ^]9 '#

"- 4 o]b ) i o' > o' 2
< :
3 +B HB ( 1J : ( $BD
" ?aa ' ,1 7
$6 6(1 1 .
?a P1 P@3L 1 F n H
PQ pb J a (6
' Z ; PQ B(
J B6O? 1 6H Q
F 31; &. H
' +( > ?, 6- J'(N $ -?
J ?, $ 3 C1D NBO?
. ?,
N( D 6 1& $1?, 6- J
? B ? ' J PQ 6
?, $ B pb?, J
a W1V 1" ?,6 ?,n H"?,
1 B +1 F 1

W $ $1J1 a 1?

$-( L .
<%%?Y ' U%%1 %%1 %< %%+ d ' U%%&%% 6%%

)(. "xSF G
ZJ N ' v'+ , $ 3'v
,1, B1 ,33 B & S NB" .
(3 )W ( + $1( : F
D pb ?, +# J

BD HH76 +# $ 3 - 7+-F
"O " J H -1 1 a
( 6 .. ?,Y # (7
O N 1 OO NB
6& $1_ ,+ J 6 ?,
'+1 +# B".
hB # S5L
6 D $1 p7 m1+# p
1( $ p1 ,} i p3
$ N6 ,H G71; p-
$ i p BD B& p,H
56 (6
>? i~9 F' y - /' /F2 O
N"# B +31 " ( O?
& 6 : 3 6 CJ
HO? $B6B " '%%Y< 6%%1 %%9%%

7 ( (i ) (W +(

( () F +7( -
) (Y . (
) >\ (\ (25 O H1
1 F( : $1 $1B F+ )(
+O W +( HL F( +#
$# +# v_;Q >i7 >(1 F1 + 1
+# >i7 v . HL ( 5
( a ) (a(1 +& GL5
+ ) - (3 m1 ( $#O $1 F>
$ JY ?,3 ?,1 (6r 1
. +
) ( (( ' ?, $+ L
( +6' (2 - H H6 H
ZJL W ,(B +( J( F i5L

( PQ ( BD} $BD 1(

$B. Z+&1
+O , L ?16 ,( '1

n Y(. "@,
+W1 ') >1 "( 3 6

) GH5 h LL 7? : (?iL
" OH 7 7 } $&' F( 7
Pi L + B >i7 F
( (2 7}( 1 7 iO
DJ B1 (H5 L 5 G F
: \1 _ ,( SLF
( B1 +7 P3Ln Y7
. " B
Fi 7 O + $? +7 L

,- 1( B ( H H
G71 C ?1 B - iO
?1 B ZJnO , +
(+7(2 +7 & C
& ' PH( # C + 1
- 2 +7 + 16 L
J '( $V&" .
? 7 J W7 J + : NB
B1 h B F +H i71 L
,V i7
B1 h $O $1 Z+&1((
) SB ' (S) 61 L( 3 :
" W F +H ' i6 C+$
171(> ZJ+O 6 Bi7
?
);3" 409
O? & 6H & (
+- ,+ (+
( + ( J +6 Y (V6
33L hY B1 +7
- . 5D
ZJV 33L + W p $ &> , >1

w6 (W11# ; ZJ
O- ?'3 $ $1 ?, + (, $i
w1( J L } BD
1 1 b7 ; ,-";
' ( V? O
@ +6 G71 + LH
J 2 L - J W BD - ZB S2 >
.. 5( ,(6 i. t
N BD(W1 1&1 $#O F
>&D+71 ,i +
$# X6O PJ X6 3 1&1J
m1 3 63 . 5
(a(6 $V 31 33L

+7 1, FO? u (W > +
2 .
ZJH Y 5D B1 J

33L6 :
- +7 # (W1
.
- +7 +3 +71 +36
G17 G71 6 L'. (i

-1
3 z 4+ );+ 2 Z

: &I oB'f
h+ 66 (W1 G71'+
' 6 C & +7_ 7' O
$N _L ) (- (
# (\6 wH3 B 1V6( 56
@ 3 h7 \ 6 \
1 B6 W 3 SB :
"p & j) +H 6vj&9 R%< 6v
. & j) +Hj&9 k . R
(H 6 f(+&j x" X
: .
' H ' Y C
+ & +7 i6W \ $ \
3 ' $" C7U R %(%H

? < + %1& +& G() Sk

F =K S%Y? (%H %+ % R%"%?Y+
( . :
+H B1 +3( (W1
(+(' Jb ? @+ ' &(
+1 (+ ?, > O? D
S1 Jb( >i7 (36 h5 ,V +(7
(W1 (+71 (+7&
++# +- . W1? C h'W1 - h3
(W1 2 & h- wH;H .
' 1 +31 6 (u 1& 1
D1 +# " > B6 >
H" .
-2
3 "' 4+ );+ 2 Z
B s 6# 9 ) ' ; &I
' N N_L O SB

6%?" C d %(% % f(%+ %%
R < % % K< K % %) % E(%
<K ' U 6 < K <K '%Y
' I "dX : .
( H1 L& ' 1\L( P
(" (3Y FO 6 +3 "1
7 ( +, ZJ" " L
\ $ 3Y 6. (W1
+-( &" P67( L (\6w
( +3 1 b ( + ( (a
P1 1BL (1 1,6#
& $ ( 1-# rD
SL1a 1 C H"
_ ,( } W? (B Jb ( +3
- # pb& J } 1 .
- +3 NBH O V1 2
H+L w6 J O? $6
; D O NL6 J
O? ?,
'+? '+? N- ?,(L

& B1 : J h- #?

'? ?,2 5 J# C
H $NJ (B1 rD W6 +H
B V ;B & 6 w6 ?, 3N JO?
W ?,1&a( 6 6 pD V?,
; :( ?, O6 p? w11
@ J ! p(Li B J +- rDH
;.
O? # } 1
' 1# 3 ")%%% % %

')%%k%% %%?%%' n<?%% 6j%%< '%%+I .
+) ".. : .
S+ )6 6 (+ r5
H 3 :
" S5H 5 5 $ J
6J # +56 D(- 5u
B ( (3J S 3N D71i6
", " ? w61 B 316
nL ,1 ,6 +H" $6 w1
3 16 uH( b 3 $NJ
a .
>i7 L J LY-+

# J " B 65 Z (BiY
+ +6 (D- 3 '?< ' K<" ?,. "61
6 ?n \ $ "1? pb J#
} 1 1 6' ?,2 i
H J ( b7 ( B
b7 O $1 $' +7 B"
+D & J a W1 16C
' ' 3 Q;n $ ")%%1+
< 6j < nU ++ : "f(%+
.

" (B' +' Y1? '+?

?,2 '# >1 Hn 6 uJ "?
C S;B (? 5D L1
B p_7 ?,1J >17 ? B 1 N
( G5 h7 p_7 J &Z+
L w1 J Z+6 p71
(\L -J 6 CL w1
D D " .

" ~19 :5= yR J BK Y ]<I

'<C 6Z X C P <s G<
6Z X G
" V Y 6# @ 2 "] SH<2
G1(
GY F (3 +1 ( +
J J 36 . ?+-
1#
(6

Si
- 2
6V
1#
7B
-
7B

) :F ' U%% %% 6%% %%4<9 F<9 %%

)< :F ' I 'Y "dX : .
>- +3 +71 B 16 "#
1@ p(. 7
B p - +- J SBB B +-
+7 H V P+? HL r
- ,# p31 O .
+7 Q H +& 16 .
(+71 $6 ,+36 -; 16 wG5
3 16 J ( uH 3 ?n
$J +6L +71 $N7
5 GJ - 7 J : -
b716( +71 V1 15 J ?, pL
?,6 w6 p- :
.
( a2 5 3 6 $1
Y > p7(6V1? +36 i71
; C\( .
" pH ?,#5D
+& p#_6# . H'(1

'(& + ( + +3 1 NB J O?
2 (+? +3 1 NB( &
3D ( 1 ZJ+ 7 " HH
+ +7 F O? (,H( BD1$
i+7 5 3 B
+7 3D1 ( & B N6 ,HG71.
;+ 2 6# SH<2 L)#
ZJ aL 3 ,J ;B B 16
O? ++ pB +7
ZJ +H \11 L7i3 +( B
( Pi $H3" _' ,
&+( + '+ " B 2 3 1 6C
"? d ( f(+ R%%
< % BF :M9 K % %) %6# E(%

' G1 ?, H D? ?BL

+. ?,Q
. ?, BD NB
++6 p? PH7 p5 > O?
V6 $BB .
$# 5 p1 .
&( S3 " ( uH p DJB
(. " 1 p uH
+ ?,. ?, #O 5 p
'V F +7 +7? .
+36 ?,( H- >i7 $1,
. ?,
'+? + O? 6 C\
& . i
?,( S Q V7 u G71
V1 SH76. i
& ?, J ? F. 367
" N G71. +7
? V6 F (H (6 ?, S
i 77 .
& ?, D }6 ?, .
& ?, H i +71 -+O

@ . 7(B
'+? + > $O?
L . -
? HL16 F )" . (
? 76 F? ' i
+O H u .
"o> C9 S' y 0 o3t9 S' 3
:
&. ?, BD $
(i5 B L > ( ?,
. -
H ?, HL1 (
( } C. ?,
+7 +# .
D 33L6 6? .
?,i D $&7. O
w &' /
L L $B6& +, $5L6#

( ,J B
B+3 F +6 7
( L L( 6 PN 7 (B
(2 (H+6 7 ( (B
F ' B 1 i( J
+ bD S7 $( +&1
V6 33 Z .
+ $ ?aO1 (6 F GY r
7 F . G71 S (1V1? '$
(6 +V? 1 ( #OL ?B
(+O? +6O (3 ZJ1 B ;
(6 HL1_: ,
";3"9 UB Q; 4<3 F9 g3 M0K
V U9 6"02 / U &'f &' /> , Z 409
; 6; Z
U &'f :M9 ..
& = &'f U) &R ;b &'f Z :M9
";3"9

) :

6' i7 G71 B1( &( S'
O? . ? 5 F +6O6'i
V ZL
_1 6 G71 33 1
>i7 $1L' '1 L J >#
3 \ ( ,# J \ (
.
" &09 X ' > oC9 { \]) &N
; "U2 B9
i O 1 BD ,#O? 1 3i6
+ J# +11 >1&11
SH76. i
$ ? V? 7 S 5 p #B
L 3 i+6O
>Y p3 i ( $H-u &1
& + $L+@? BD1O? .. p
? .

لماذا يسمح الله بالألم ؟

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

لماذا يسمح الله بالألم ؟

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

 

 PQO? '&  J SBJ #

 B  6O  # (7 ?, 3 J

>i7  "#   SH7 1 +#

 1  pD +# +6 p(B

"&' (") *+ ,- . /012 3

L $6 > ?@ 3 +" p+7

w6(   1u J NB6 XL

  ( u   7 B +

5 +6 1 ?  5   

+36  wuHO? $6 ZB +6; ( >17(

: F9 4 ' GHI J BK -1

+3 ZJ BD1  m '2 67

 ? a $J W V  - ( $ 2?

?MK /> /N O0 P@3 >  hL

 J   6 F +&1  - 1 

"P 19 Q"IR SC<< T;

  B1  2 P 1  6 W  $

"  )@ W 4 0< X B2M' 4 Y

:  b"d 4 ' GHI J BK -2

1 3  ; h5    ? B

Y ,1,iY   $3+ J

( 1 p 1  F  NBH'O F

;  7 5 GJ  B1

 C $ 1 #  $1iD 

-+  GHI "Bn   V? SH76

G() 11F(Y . 6I U% }= %% %<k+

ZJ,65  3( L   ,# 33L

 ' O   $N JL '

2 (+  i( ++ 

( ( 6 -  +6  #O

&" O  _ BD   6#O?  F

 ?# + ( D,D1  u +

 BCB<9 +7 D $i O? 

L71- "o- t9 ) R" , B 33L

""/02 OF9 4 42"b 6 4<F) ,t02

" %%?F  %% 6v%% . LW %% %%m <%%

B(  6 HJ D B71 6

+# ) (#  $L71  6 P,

3 : SB ) (# > F,(B

 j =99 f(+ %+) % U%oY <%

" S7L Lc %%%K Y L %%% %%% %%%H+

O? (  33\ h  (7 +L?

_L )  (' H  "#O

+H O=" >6 ? $ 1# ;6 &7,-

"U& .. 1? 6 %H ..%H  %K% =%1

O? \ i ( a}  +6( 

L ' (O 6 (H5  L

63 C  - 6 , +&1+6O J

( S Fi 7 7   $

( a' 6"Cs J     pO

Y  S 5  h i++# ( 3

JB \  S1 +D ,

 hQ  G6  (   $J 3 $

(2 H ,3Q $6 (1  C (&D

(   $V 1  +V1 1 3H' J

6 C\  3 ( ( a +  (2

")(? x   ) %+ <%  %%H

"")"02 409  2 /+ U9 &0 ^]9 '#

 W  $  $1J1 a 1?

<%%?Y ' U%%1 %%1 %< %%+ d ' U%%&%% 6%%

D  pb ?,  +#  J

 7 (  (i  ) (W +(

 ( PQ  ( BD} $BD 1( 

PQO? '& J SBJ #

B 6O # (7 ?, 3 J

>i7 "# SH7 1 +#

1 pD +# +6 p(B

"&' (") *+ ,- . /012 3

L $6 > ?@ 3 +" p+7

w6( 1u J NB6 XL

( u 7 B +

5 +6 1 ? 5

+36 wuHO? $6 ZB +6; ( >17(

+3 ZJ BD1 m '2 67

? a $J W V - ( $ 2?

?MK /> /N O0 P@3 > hL

J 6 F +&1 - 1

"P 19 Q"IR SC<< T;

B1 2 P 1 6 W $

" )@ W 4 0< X B2M' 4 Y

: b"d 4 ' GHI J BK -2

1 3 ; h5 ? B

Y ,1,iY $3+ J

( 1 p 1 F NBH'O F

; 7 5 GJ B1

C $ 1 # $1iD

-+ GHI "Bn V? SH76

G() 11F(Y . 6I U% }= %% %<k+

ZJ,65 3( L ,#33L

' O $N JL '

2 (+ i( ++

( ( 6 - +6 #O

&" O _ BD 6#O? F

?# + ( D,D1 u +

BCB<9 +7 D $i O?

L71- "o- t9 ) R" , B33L

""/02 OF9 4 42"b 6 4<F) ,t02

" %%?F %% 6v%% . LW %% %%m <%%

B( 6 HJ D B71 6

+# ) (# $L71 6 P,

3 : SB ) (# > F,(B

j =99 f(+ %+) % U%oY <%

" S7L Lc %%%K Y L %%% %%% %%%H+

O? ( 33\ h (7 +L?

_L ) (' H "#O

+H O=" >6 ? $ 1# ;6 &7,-

"U& .. 1? 6 %H ..%H %K% =%1

O? \ i ( a} +6(

L ' (O 6 (H5 L

63 C - 6 , +&1+6O J

( S Fi 7 7 $

( a' 6"Cs J pO

Y S 5 h i++# ( 3

JB \ S1 +D ,

hQ G6 ( $J 3 $

(2 H ,3Q $6 (1 C (&D

( $V 1 +V1 1 3H' J

6 C\ 3 ( ( a + (2

")(? x ) %+ <% %%H

"")"02 409 2 /+ U9 &0 ^]9 '#

W $ $1J1 a 1?

<%%?Y ' U%%1 %%1 %< %%+ d ' U%%&%% 6%%

D pb ?, +# J

7 ( (i ) (W +(

( PQ ( BD} $BD 1(

+O , L ?16 ,( '1

+W1 ') >1 "( 3 6

Fi 7 O + $? +7 L

ZJV 33L + W p $ &> , >1

(a(6 $V 31 33L

ZJH Y 5D B1 J

3 z 4+ );+ 2 Z

? < + %1& +& G() Sk

3 "' 4+ );+ 2 Z

B s 6# 9 ) ' ; &I

' N N_L O SB

& B1 : J h- #?

' 1# 3 ")%%% % %

>i7 L J LY-+

" (B' +' Y1? '+?

" ~19 :5= yR J BK Y ]<I

) :F ' U%% %% 6%% %%4<9 F<9 %%

' G1 ?, H D? ?BL