هدم نظرية التطور في عشرين سؤالا - هارون يحيى

153

150

#( .%
$ #

/
.
9 $ 6$ %
4 . #
/
;
.%

$(
? #
%
#
DC B.

H
F 6 (

4 . ?
4 $ J ;
$ 9

K
.

"
" % # .1956
) *).
#
* % . 7
: . 7
* % * .
C A 7@
% % F :
A ) C 7
@ .
154

3

$ #! " "
.1956

2 ( )( . $#
! ) . # $ #

# (? #> <
) ! A!
. ! C$ # "" ""
! ) . #! C ?
( ) . J ) 2( . < J
$ # O
" "
. $ # !

! ).
$ #? # :
J ) 2 )
( 2 < .
> )
) ) ) )
) ? ) . O ? (

)( S
T
> !).< A! C <
>

T 2 )

T ).
? $
U$
) ! C
T (
. ! C T

) ) .
! C
( !
S

.A ! S
( ) (
! C S 2
) .
?

. S
! C
) ) J .?
$ #
( T ) . #T
! C.< ) ! C T 2 > ! C
""
) ( . ! 2

A Y 2 $ )

A

2 )? S 2 $ .

#
)! 2
! 2 S . !
S

# ? .J Z !C
[ >.
! (
: [
< ) 2 ( . )> ! ) ?
T J (
2 !) .< )
$) 2 # [
! C

[
) .
) )! ) ( ! . ! C
# # T
J.
" : "" "" ""

"" )! ("" "" "" ! "
". : 0" "!. ."" ""
"" 64 . "" ""
"" . ! ! "" .!"
" 6> "" = "" " "(1) 9" "(2) 9"(3) 9
" : C " "!. >! ? B" "!.B 9 > @! ?
"" 9">" @! " "E" "(1) 6" "(2) 6 B
"" " " . .!"" . . !"" 9
!"B" =? = " "I>! 4 !"" I "" !"
" "" "" "" !"" 4"" ! !
"" !"" " "6 ? "" 0 ! !""
"" " "9@! : "" ? B 9 "" ""
"" !"" . ! "" ? .""
."" @ 6) (1) . ("" @ 6) (2) . ("" B
"" >! "" = ?"" = "" @" "96
!"" @ 9>"" ."" = J ""
"" ! "B" ! J"" @? = : "" @ "" @
!" @ " "9@ " "E@ "" @ "B" @
6" "9@ " "?4@ "" @ " "?4@ !"
"@ " "E@ !"" @? 6!"" @ !"" @
" "6 4@ 9"" @? 6 @"( ! ) =L
." : 6"" !"" " "9 6="
" "" @ 9 ? "" :"" =?
"" :0 ".
O 9>" : >!"" 6>"
" ! :@= " "3 2 1 9 "" 6. "" P"
" "" "" >!"" 9>!"" ? "" 6 6 >!"
" !"" = "" S ? >!"" ! >!"" 9
"" "" :!.! !"" :J " "O! ="" "!.
"= >!"" " " . >!"" "B" ! "" >
"" 6! "" >!"" 9 ! >!""
"! "" "" 9"" !"" ! "
" "" L4 >! ?"" ! L4
:@= " "4 3 2 1 "" !""
6 >!"" C ! !"" "" 6
"" = 9 ! . "" !"
" 4 IJ"" ! "" 0 ? >!""
="" = >!"" E >!"
" !"" >!"" ?
>!"" >!"" ! ! >!"" =
>!"" ! :"" P >!"" ! !"6."
4 >!"" ? !".
!

& $
$4 .& -
. ? $ 56 7
6 K .IJ F
& J J $
5
56 5 & 6
Z . J
J & .
F \
6 . &
6J 6 .
&
-
J &
.
6 IJ d c \ 5
F J
.
\ & & \ \iJ
\ $ J 56 6 J
6 F F &K&
IJ 6 -.l

1
2
3
4
5

6 34 2 0 , + %

"; "9
+> 4; >

> 9> B
+ B> K 99 + ,
> 9

> 9 , P6 P

6 34 " ,4
"
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
+ V "> "
W
,4 , K 4 9

,4 \ 4

;+ >
\ K> K 4B
P
+

+B
> , ,4,
P
> , ,4

d >
(4 , >) 93
>
+ > P

W +

9
150
- K .? & Z
6 - 6 " d ."$
K & 6 -
d 6 . 4 J&
K v 6 -
l J
6 $ $
- 6 $...
v J 6\
) J "
10
J"" "" J"

" J " . 6& 6
"" 6 56 - 6 J J
& 6
.$
6 5J & 6
J J "" $
d v$
.
v F J 6 J .\
6 F 6 $ J J v $ 6 v
? 6 . 6 $
F6 J 6\
" " "J J".
11
1
'

6 J cJ 6 $
. &
K & K
v J . 6 &
d $ Z
d F J.
J
5 & 56
6 .
6 6 : .
12
K - 6
K 6 K . K 6
J c
- Z &
6 6 6 J J
J J .J 6 J56 J
6 \ $ $ J Z
6 K 6 vJ.
6 Z d $J
6 $ 6
6 $ . 7
l 6 6
. 6
K 56 \ .
6 K $ 6
6
\ J J . 6 6 J
\ .J
v 6
) F J
" "(.
K 6 v
6 F K . 6 J J $
13
6 5&
6 Z .
56 J 6 6 6 Z 6 c -
6
. v - c J
6
J .$
6 c J
6 J J 6 F
.
FJ 6 v 6
6 5 $ $
. K v FJ $ 6
v $ .6 J\ J J
6 : v 6 .
6 6 $
5 Z cJ
6 J 6 J c
K 6 & 6
. c $ $
$ organelles
$ 6 mitochondriaribos- $
6 6 omes 6 cell membranes

14
7 4 3 .
endoplasmic reticulum .
J 6 v 6
.v
5 J
\ 6 $ .J
7 4 6 J (6 ) 5
J Z 3.5
. 6 J $ $
(6 ) 5 v J $J
15
B @ : ;
. " " nucleosome H H (B 3) C C
) .(C H @
B U ! B H BB O . B N3! B
3 B U @
B \4 [ B.
J 5 J v
. $4 Francis Crick
J

5 6
J:
6
"
6 6 6F
".
K J Ali 5
16
Demirsoy v
:d

" v
(6 J 6 ) 56 v 6
. K

2
J ".
6 Homer Jacobson K
:

" $ $
6 4 Z
effector mechanism
6 4 ) ( . 6
& ".
$ 6\ K .J 6
$ J 6 56 5
6 v $ $J J
4 6 d 6 $ .J
& $ $ 7
. K 6 & $
.$ & v $
6 6 6 6 d $ Z
. 6 J J &
17
B 3
C 3 .
' BB C h B @
i B'! .
B C C C@
@ BB O .
18
v 6 $
. K 6 56 & v

v .
J
6 6 $ d $
J
6 v 6 v
.J
6 v JJ
6 6
6
56
J .

B U
:v $

r .

U
.
H
.
19
2

v cJ
:
6 $ $ v .J
J $6 v 6
K 6 "
" . 6\ &
$J K 6 cJ
d .
6 "" . $ $
6 .d v
20
v 6 $
F 5 .Z
7 K 6 6 6 v
& 6 6 $
.
Z 6
. K \
v 6 \
. & \
vdisjunctive inference modus 5
.tollendo ponens
6 J\ K 6 6 d cJ J

J K 6
5 . J Z
. J 6 -
Douglas Futuyma :
" 6 $ $ cJ J
6 K . $ J 6 $J
v\ $ 6 d K .
$ J 6
".J
$ K J $
6 $ $ cJ 6
21
.
6 $ J $$
$ 6 J Z
6 $ J 6 J $ $
"".
v .F6 J\ & $
$ $$
\ J $ 7 $
J $ $ 6 .
56 $ 6 " v" .5
$ \ K d \:
J $ . 6 JJ
$ .
J $ Robert Carroll v J $
J6 $ 6 J J J
v $:
" Z
$ J 6 $ Z
J J
".
H
6 $ $
$ $ . & $ J ""

22

@
65
H
144

208

245

286

408

408+
H
438
3
505
H
550
H
630
) H
(
2500
H "@ @"
! B U'
@ The Book of Life
2001 H U HB
BB 4 . HB
C CC
.
2500
. @
) . B @
! (.

@
'! .H O @
) H the Cnidaria
( . '
C H@ 13
.
U@
23
B C
B @.
B h
B U@
" " . B O B
3 )@
B O
( . U
B 3
3 .

U
C C.
B
B
U 4 3 B
O.
.H
B :Marella C @

Burgess Shale
H.H
phyla . & 6 J
6 &
& . v ) Arthropoda $
$ 6 $\ J6 $K (
$J
. Chordata $ $ 6 5
.5 6 $
7 J $
J $ J.$
35 $ $
Mollusca J $ 6 $
Nematoda $ 6 .
& K 4
K . $J
.
K & $
6 v J . J 6 c
$ 7 $ 6
24
B N@:
B :Hallucigenia
C C@
.H U
C H ON
@3 .
H B U
B U C
h
N C .
B 3 C
U N
B .
v $ . & 6

6 $ 6 v .
6 $ $ $
5 J.
J 6 J7
d . & J
J J Z" 6 " . 6
6 6 6\
$ J $ .
.J & $J

. $
. $ $
25
C C@
@ 500 B 3
H .@ B O .
.
Z
.5 5 J 6 J $
65 56 570 505 . J
$ $
5 & " J ."5 K
. Stephen C. Meyer . . P. A. Nelson
v Paul Chien J $
vJ K 2001 " 6 J 5 v
Z 5 ".
K 6 56 7 $ 5
$ $ $.
$ 6 v
J) .5
26
C @ B U B C@ C
@ H 550 . N B O C
! B B '! . B C
3 .C 3
C@ ! . @ U
500 ' ; B C @ !
3 .C
27
!(.
$ J $
d $ $ Z
J . $
6 J Z
K . & $K
J v Z.
J Z J Richard Monastersky
Science News journal
v J 5 5 :J
" ... $ 6 v $
.Z 5cJ
56 550 J 5J 5 J
$ ".
6 Phillip Johnson K J
6 6 5 J &
J:
" J " l d" v 6

dJ J
v 6 6 d
$ . $
6 F l6J F
K".
d J
28
6 $ c
$ . $
6 6
.J 6J $
$ J .
29
3
! HB O
' U

6 v $ v:
cJ K 6 6 J
. & $
6 - . 6 64 ZJ
"4 J "Z $ $ 5J
Mary Leakey 1977 Laetoli .
6 $J& .Z 6 $J
6 J 3.6 . J
Russle Tuttle 5 4 J Z :
" 6 & J
... J $ 6Z
30
J 6 Z ".

J $ 6 4 JZ
6 . 4 J Z&
6 20 5 & 27
6 & 6 . &
6 v Don Johnson
Tim White J
5J . 6 &J:
" 6 ... 6& J 46 J Z
. 5 K6 7 & J Z J6 v
J &
6 J .7
6 $ J\
10
J v." .
64 $J J Z& 66 lJ
K .J 6 K 6& J 46 J4 Z
K 6 J 5& K6
.
K 6 5J
. 6\
J
B
6 6 4 6 JZ
3.6

.
. J 6
9
31
6 J J :
" 4 6 J Z 3.5
G 4 J Z 5
. 56 6) $ ($
$ 6 J . 4 6 JZ
G 6 J 6
...&J 56 v 6
c 46 J Z d 56
6 -J"Australopithecusafarensis"11 .
6 Z $ 5
Louis Leakey 6 Olduvai Gorge 5 .$
u 1.7 . 6
d 5 7 K Z
6 ) (
Homo Sapiens6 J\ .5 6 &
6 6 5 6&
J 6 J J 6 6.
5 2.3
5 Hadar J6
6 5 cJ
12
6 v 6 J.J
\ 66 Z $
KNM-WT 1500 6
" J" .Turkana Child
H
1.7 U .
J Donald Johanson
32
1.6 $J:
" 6
J 5 .
6
13
J 6 ".
6 &
1.83 . v
4 Alan Walker
" 6 J $ 6 5
5J

."5
6 4J "
14
J".
$
J Z
6 .1995
Gran
Dolina 6 Atapuerca
6 J
3 3 /h
3 1997 3
.
B B B C
&
@ ! U
5
800.000! '
800.000J . $&
B
6 J6
3" : "
33
B
@ )(1975
B
Neanderthals
4 H @ C
.@3 3@
B @ B U
3 . ' CB
U .C
B C
B
B U .@3B U
@ 26.000 B

@ .
CB C
h
! B B
@
3B.U
34
@ ) (2000 h /4
2000

3 !
B !
.
Juan Luis Arsuaga Ferreras - 5 $

. v:-
" 6 ...
. 6 Z& 800.000 J.
...
... J
. Z J 6 $ J
.- d J6 6 6
6 . 6 J ...
. K
J 6 6
. $K 5& 800.000.
15
6J ".
6J $ " J".
Z Z 6
35
\ $ .
J& " J"
.
" "$
6 J J $ 6 v . C. A. Villie
.5 . E. P. Solomon . . P. W. Davis
16
6 J\ .5J
7J Mark Collard JBernard J
Wood J
2000 " $J J $ v J
".
6 5 6 J J
6 6
" " . 4 v K
6 2001 -
.Kenyanthropus platyops 6 $ Jv
.5 Daniel E. Lieberman
J J v -
:Nature
" J 5J .Z 6 6F
v d 4
J 3.5 ... -
i $ v J 7 d .K
v d 5 6
36
B C @ B

9
9

1

1.8

)(
)(
)(

4

1.8

) 6(

5
5
150
B B B h
B
C
i@ " ."3
C @3 U
C B
) H @'! .(2001
B B B O N
B ! hB H
.i ' 3
" "3 B ! U
" " ! .;
HB B;
.@3 O B
! B '
\! .

9

?
2
1.8

1

)(

6
)(

5
37
5 -
1
Z 6 d
) (hominin species\
Z
6 6 . 6 6 J -
v $ 6
Z $
h 3
18
$J 6 d".
@
:
6 6

J 6 6
!
-
B 32 National) .
Sahelanthropus tchadensis
Geographic
.2002
(2000
6 $J& J.
$K
6 5 " 6 6
19
6J J".
v v J" :J )(
20
6 ".
K 6 6
7 " " )
6 J J ( 6 -
Australopithecus 5 6 "6Z
" . K 6 J 6d
38
J
" " J .
6 56 John Whitefield
" 6 Z " Oldest Member of Human
Family Found J J 11 / 2002
J J
J :
" v" : J
1963 J6 5 " . J J$
v J v
.6
J6 5 . 6 c $
... v v v v
21
6 ".
6 $ 5 Henry Gee 5J
v
. J
J Guardian v v :
" 6
" " ... 6 6
5
22
".
6J $
J . & J
39
6 c 4 J 6 c Z
. J F
6 6 Origin of Species d J &
.$ 6J 6 $
$ . 6
$ . K6 $
6 6 J Z 6 56.-
B
6 $ 6J 6
6 6 6\ 6 6J
J .v
6 6 d & .
v 6 $
5 6 J
56 d 6 d K .5J 6 JJ
6 6 &
6 J .$
6 J

.
40
4
'
" "
6 $ 6 J J
J - ...? 6
6 6 J 6
.-
.J
6 K J6 6 Arda Denkel 6
Z d:
" v ? 6? J" 6
J J Z $
"K . 6 v ) v v5
( 6 $ v $
.J K
41
! 3 B "3
" ! . B B
.
6 6 $ .
23
".
6 J 7J\ Z
" J - " .

K 6 Z J
6 J & Z . K
d Z $$
$J .J 6\ J $
& Z v J .
6 Z J6 J
. $
6 " " dialectical materialism
- 6 .Z
42
.&
J 5 6 Z
6 & Z J4J
.
K J Z J $
5 .$
J J 6 $
v6 l $ .
J .J
Z J
6\ c .
K $ .
56 J & .
. .J G. W. Harper 6J v
d:
" 6 J J .
K $ J
24
56 "...
K Z 6d
6 J ?
.
43
5
' B 3
3
v 6 J 6 J 6 -
.J J 6 JJ
J .
Z 6 v
K" : $6 v J
6 $ -" 6 J\ K"
v Z4 \ $
6 $ $K - $ "
J & 6$
J 6 . J$
- Z 6 d
"" variation 5 & .
44
Z
J J
J $
6$
6 d
4 . J
$J
K .d 6
d $J
B @3
v .$
h C C
K v J
B
chromosomes $Z
U @3
.F $
C
.
K d
$.

$
- $ .5
- - cJ $J
6 6
K & $J.
K
5 K J . 6 l
J 6 v
45
J .6 J\ $
6 v 6 v .
l $ 6\ 6
K.
6 : 7
genes . 6 6
$ J . v7
6 Z 6 .F
.
Z .& K
\ $ &
J
. K 6
v .6 J\ 6

6
.
$ \ $
K . $ 4 $ K
v Z
J $
. 6
J v 6
. v 6 Z4 d 6 $
v 6 &
$ . $6
46
JJ 5 $
$ . J K \6
J $ d
v K \6 . &J J
6 -.
K 7 & & :
v -
d.5
47
6
' 3 3
@3
99
3
J J 4
99 J 6
.J $ 6
6 F .
K FK 6 J J $
5 v& .$
48
3
%99 3
6 J J
J .$ 6
6 $ J 6 6 " $
99 " " 6 (6 ) 5
" . Z J Z
$ J c
.
6 /v 6 2002 \ J 6 $
6 J J v d K
$\ - K . 6 " $
"%99 6 JK .J
6 J 6 .%95 J
CNN.com " 6 $ "Human,
J chimps more different than thought :

" J J 6 $ 5
6 .
6 $ $
98.5 . 5 J Roy Britten
J K J $ d
6 7 J 6 $ 6 $ J
5 \ 95 .
49
J J
780.000 base pairs
(6 ) 5 5 .5
6
3.9 6
6 (6 ) 5
.
& K
J 5 5
".
25
New Scientist
\ $
$ v d "
) (6 5 6
chimps DNA difference trebled
" 6 K
6 (6 ) 5
7 7 98.5
666 F . 6 .
95 J 5
$ 6".
26
v 5 J &
J
50
$ 56J $
6 6 v
6 56 J 6
."dJ
(B 3H
U i
K $ J
$
6 $
. 6 $
.5
v J
J 3
%75 (B 3) H
27. K
6 &
50
51
%25!
6\K 4 6
6 ZJ $ 6 ' C !
J C B C 3
.%60
28
J $ 6\ Z 56
6 J 29.J & 6 6
.J
" :"N B
6 5 6
52
$ \ $
Z & 6
.$ J 6 . '
' 3 B C .N
K 6& " " J " "7
56 .
6 & :v Z $
) ( . K K
6 " "$J . 6
Z . $K $ 6.
K J $
.J
J
$ 5 J .
53
7
' 3 C
! C
J 6 .
J & . J 6 K
? .
6 J 6
4 v .
$ 4 $ J
. v
J $ 6 -J J J
$ . K 6 & J
$ . 6 $ J v
6 $ .

J $

. $ J
6 J J . K
54
$ 6 J6 J 6 K .J
6 6 J J 6 $J .
. v v" :
6 $J" 6 " : K 6 56 J
$"
v $J J 6 JJ
.
" " .cursorial theory & 6$J
J v cJ .
c
6 $J J& .
4 & K . 6 $J
6 J
4 .
"" arboreal theo-
.ry 6 v
$J
66" :
."F
6 6? v
6
:J
5
&J \
J . v
6
55
6 6 $J .J
6
$ 6i . 6
.v
6 6 J J J 6$J
J 6 K .$ K
$J J 6 $
J J J
.$ 6 J J $ 6
.v K &
"J6" Archaeopteryx
$ .
! @ " C
B B "
B
B .
h ' ! HBO
B B .
56

J Z J J
J 150 .\ 6 $J
6 Velociraptor J JDromaeosaur J
$J v F $6 . c
6 J d 6 $J 6
v.
K 6 J $ v $J 6
6 56 - . 6
d c J J
56 .
6 J J 6
J " " .
F 6) sternum (J 6
6 &J ) .
J $ .
J J J J
$ (.
K & J
.1992 K 6 &
J J 5
6 J6 J .
:
" J
J v& .
57
K $ J
30
$ ."v
6 6
J &J .
K6 J 6 6
6J J K . 6
J & & J
K 6 &J 6 .
v $ J . 6 vJ " :Carl O. Dunbar J
6 )J( J J " 31.
J $ $ v J ? :d
" J J J
J J J
. 6 ? J
J ...
? J J
$ $ J Z
cJ J J ... J
32
7 150 "...
7 6\ v J J 6
6 $ K Z .J 6& $J
J 6 J J 6
$ J Z J J 6
. \ 6 J J
J J J . 6J J 6
58
C B B O
. 3 ! HB
B .
J Z J $ J
.$J
B
7 6 J J
J 6
6.
6J 6
59
& $ 6 56 . K
7 6 d J
touraco J
4 hoatzin .
& $ J 56 $ .
6 56 - Z J
.
JJ 6
. 6 J J & $
K .
6 . K
J d $ K J . 6
6 $ K J -J
$ 6 v J & J
7 J
" $ K J".
6 6 6 J & $ K J
6 6 56 .$J
J .5 .v JJ L. D. Martin.
.5 J. D.Stewart $J . . K. N. Whetstone
6J & J 6
.J 6 6 $ K $Jtheropod Z
33
dinosaurs J .J
J 6 Z J 6
34
$J 56 .
J6 $ 6 .- vJ S.
60
.Z Tarsitano . M. K. Hecht

.5 . 6 A. D. Walker
6 6 John Ostrom Z 6 $
d 5 6J J
$J& 6
& 6J 6 6 vJ
35.$J .5 .
K\ J 6
36
J.
6 $ Icons of Evolution J
6 Jonathan WellsJ
"6" J 6 ? 6
.J 6 $ K 6
$ K $J Z J
6 J " : $ KZ
cJ $6 $\ 6
37
6 $ J".
& 6J
J 6 " $ K J".
J $ K $J .Z
" v J The Demise of the $J
Birds Are Dinosaurs Theory JJ
.v Richard L. Deem J J J
$J :
" J $ 6 6 5 $ K $J Z
61
J Z 6 6 J
J Z
J6 ... 76 $\ " J."$J
$ K 6 Z )
( J . " 6? "
$ K Z
J& $J . 6 6
$ K Z Z
\ 56
ZJ . K
$ K Z -
)( 66 F\
J
. 6\ 6 6
38
$ K Z $ JJ".
& 6\ 6 J
d\ J 6 .
$ 6 6 d J $J .
6 $ J Z J
J .
6 6 d& J J J
Confuciusornis c 6 d

K .J
62
B 3:
3 -

6 $ "J
$J "$J J 6
Z6 J Alan

B
Julie Nowicki
J J J Z
6\ 6 6 J J
.$J J 6 7J Eurek Alert $
Z Z :
" Z4 J J J
Z
& 6 J 6 $J
...$J
v 6" : J 6&
6 v $ K $J..."Z
6 6 J K J
J " : 6" 6 "5 $J
v ... K J
Z 6 J \
6
J K" " .
6 $J 6 J .
63
6 J
J \ v
K "".
J $ 6
" J $J :"$J
" v J " : & $ ".
" J 6& 7 K 6$J
J $ ! 25 80
B 7 H 150 U ".
h '!" :
h
3 \ @"" .
B C' C @
B B @ .
40
B ;4 ".
6\ 6 "- "J
"6" J 56
.
39
B C
-
6 J6 $ J J $
J 6 6 v .J
6 J J 56 .
$ J J $" $ J
64
J " . $ Z
J J J $
6 "-J "$J6
. K
6 6 $
.
v 6 J
J Sinosauropteryx
.1996

& "K J
J" 6 $JJ
. K J 6
J 6 J J J 6 "J "
.
" J
5K" Plucking the Feathered Dinosaur
:Science
" Z 6 J $ v J 6
"J K J" J6 d5
$J . $J 7J
J K Yixian
Formation \6J 6 vJ
.J d $J Z5
6 :
v F $ $
65
J ... $ 5JJ
-J 6 J 6
41
56 ."J
1999 6\ "- K ."J
6\ " ."J
v 6 National Geographic
J "J 5K J" $J
& J J 6 . v
J6J J Archaeoraptor liaoningensis d
5 125 .
K
J J $
. Z6 6
$ &
. - J 6
6 J J K . - J 88
. 6JJ J
6 K
J6 $ . $
:
" JJ J " "
6 J 6 J 6J
$J 6 d 4 $J .Z
6JJ J Z
J J 5J J ...
JJ J 5
66
5 J
J $ .... K
6JJ J 6 6 6
42
J $"...
v 6 Z &
" J"
v 6 Z J . 6 v
J 6 6 56 Z \
6
" " .Piltdown man scandal
6 J J Z J v
6 . J 6 .v -J J Storrs L. Olson
6 J
J
6 J . J
J Peter Raven v 6:
" " $J 6" /
1998 v J
4 National Geographic
Society J $
. K 6 6
6 7 $
5 v 6
v 5 6
43
J J ."$J
.- . USA Today 5 6 v:
67
0 ...-
/ 1999
h
h
/ 1999
...
/' 29 2001
h
"- "C U
1999
U 3 .
' B
UHB
.
68
" 6 v 6 $
& $ " 44.6 J\
v v
J 6 .J
6 6 v
v 6 & .J
? vJ K . J Ernst
Haeckel J J . J 6 JJ
F 40
" 6 ."JZ
6 J J " " Nebraska man
. 6 J J " "
reconstructions $ cJ6 "$
" ".
" 6
J6 Z J J 6\ v
K . 5
J . JJ \ d
5J J J
6 6 6 J J 6 d F 6
.
69
8
! HB
" B "
6 $ 6
J66 Z J
$J K .J 6
"" recapitulation 66 $ J J
6 .

"" 56& " 6 J
J" J 5J
. c & 6
70
! B .
J 6 . Z &
6 6 J66 Z & $
7 $ $ . &
6 "" 6 &.
K & K . 6 $J - $
? v - J$
v\ & . & J 6 $ 6
6 -\ 6 $ J J $ .
" 6" 6 c
K
5
71
J parathyroid .thymus
6 K 6 5 " F " J
6 6
F Z6 . K 5
"K" 5 5
J.
& 6
J6 J . J J George
6 Gaylord Simpson J :
6 K 5J . d
"
6 J J J
45
".
J $ J 16
6 /v 6 :1999
"6 )( K
- . 6 ZJ
. v \ 5
7 6
46
".
$ 6 American Scientist
:6
" 6 J
.-6 6 J .$
47
c d 5 "...$
6J $J ? d v
72
J 6 5 - . K &
K $J 6 ""
.

J v 6 ? Z
. B N
! 6& 6 6J
J J :
" "" 5 $c
6 6 6 J6
Z $
6 6 . c
Z 6
J " " J
"48.
6 /v 1997
J 6 Z
J . "B ! @3
:Haeckels Embryos: Fraud Rediscovered "h
" v JJ
J " : d 5 )J Z(
d" ... 6\ JJ
J &i J 6 J 6
73
d J .
" $ "
6 JJ 6 /F4
49
".
$:
" 6 JJ 6 &i
6
$ 6 6 d
$ 6 10 .
6\ 6 K $ d
$ $.
JJ 6 &i
6 7 J
. JJ J)" :6 Z( 6
50
6 6 6 Z ".
5 / 1997
74
3 3 8B / 2001 N
B
3 .William Dembski !
@ B .
@ B B C .
6 J 6 Z $
J 6 $J JJ
1901 d
F . 6
$J 6 J v 6
: J 6 &
.
75
9
'
"3 "
;
? v v K Z u
" 6 "J &J
.& 6 J J
- . 6 d u 56
J 6 Z 5 6 JJ
. K v 6 J 6
56 F 4 6 6 l
$ 6 u
J .J
76
@ ) (B 3 B h@
! . HB
. h ; B H B.
'
Z u ) (6
Z . ) (6 56
egg cell 4

c
.d K
.Z J
.Z K & .
'
u J K . Z J
) .
6 6 ( . 6\
u J Z J
K .
J .76 J\ v

& "" J
77
! C
@3 ! @3
. U HB
B @.
" ".
u J . K
56 c - J .
6 " 6 6 "
? 6 Louis Pasteur J F
. u J
.Z
Z 5 6 d \
6 & .
l J 6 J J
6 d J .Z
& 6 J J 6 $\ .
6 6 v Z "6" 6 "u v"
.J
\ 6 J J
$ -
K 6 J
78
B
C
B !
B h B
@ B
h
7 . C

3 B
C@
. 3
B HB
h
C B
.
' B
.
h
U3
.

' .
. 6 v Z \ u Z
6 6
6 .
79
B C O
7 4 - 6 u 6
u " 6 " . K u
K . 6 u J $
4 6 . v
4 56 6 J K . $J
J 6 .
K
6 $ $J.
6 "6 " 5
6 - u
J K6 6 J v .u
v 6 - 6 J & 30
J 4 & 30 .Z d
u v K .
6 u6 Z " Z6"
) 6 J\ J .(Z J
" ".
K 6 56 6 4 6 J\
Z & .
Z $K v 6 6
Z 4 :
'! i B

h
C

) J ( 117 /
80
10
B @ B

? J
6 6 J\ v 6
. 6 6 J
K . 6
J . 6 $ FJ
$ 6 6 " "
.J
J 6
6 7J " " 6 6
81
J . 6
Fred Hoyle J .Chandra Wickramasinghe
J 6 7 ""$J
. J & J
v 6 $ 6 $ 6
cJ $6 .
Francis Crick
James Watson
6 (6 ) 5 6 6
J 7J6 . 6 v 6 6
$6 K 6 cJ 6
\ J " J."cJ
6J 6 $ J
J . $
$6 v . J 6
J J 6.

? " J" J
J meteorites cJ
. 6 56
6 Z 5 $ J6 $J
.cJ 56
6 56 $ macromolecules
6 v.
82
B N4 C ! i @ @ @
3 7 H . :
@ @ N B . !' 3 C
h4 B H B O .
K J d
.
Z $
c $ K $
6 6 6 )"$
" (optical isomers . K
$\ c
$ ) $ K $
$( J .
51
6 6.
& 5 v v $
6 Z J
83
6 $ .cJ 6 6 J
J Z K cJ
J . K J & J 56
" "J 5 .v
74 v :
6 v J J
cJ $ d cJ
6 $6 .
& $ 6 56 J
6 6 v 6 6 .cJ
$ $
56 J & .J
' " [ "i

6J 6 - 6
cJ 6 $ J . 56 $ K 6
. K 6 ?
& K J .
& 6 cJ
. 7J6 6
6 v cJ 6

.dJ $ 6
J J .J
K 6 J
J \ :
84
B \4 " C3 [ "i

@ 0 @
" 0- E "D
" E "D
-
I .
0 0-
I@
. I -
K
" E"D
0- 0 @ V
PI . I
" : VI
D O
ED" . -Q
D Q
Q
PI
Q II . O
0 @ .
Q @.
"I O ."N
0 D 85
B ! B:
@3 += ; @
! 3 B U B
'! . B
C ' CC

3 @ !
; @ .
B 7
U .
B B
" "
"") .
( .
! "" B
B [
[ . B
" HB "
B
C @ B h
U :
"B
B O
" . i 3
B C H
HB HB
.C
J $ 6 .
7 6\ 6 6 6
J 6 56
. 6 6 v
J6 6 6
. 6 6 cJ $6
6 J dJ
J.
K v6 d
86
dJ \ . Z 6
J 15-12 "J
" .the Big Bang $
.J 56 6
cJ 4 6 v 6
J K J . K 6
? 6\ .J
) J " "" :
.("J
6J " Z J"
J 56J J Z 4
.dJ 6
i 6
J.
6 " $ J "cJ
6 6 . K 6
" $ J "cJ v 6
6 6 K
K) .dJ 6
( . K 6
5 J
.
87
11
' B i
B
6 J J J $ $
. \ J J 6
" " .considerable time v
J J 6
6 . 7J\
K 6 J J
" ".
& 66 J Z
J v
. v J 6
d
88
cytoplasm
- mitochondria
Z microtubules
nucleus 0
vacuole 0
lysosome
endoplasmic reticulum
Golgi apparatus
N N@ @ B
B C B C B
C 7 @.
.Z v J K Yaman -J 6
6 $J6 K" :rs J &

52
".
.
K . 6
J . K c 6 - J
$ " " .spontaneous generation
6 - 6 $
6 ) dJ( $ $&
89
cJ .
6 - 6 6

6 F
l F .
K6
6 Francesco Redi 5J

F
F
.& $

.

K
F .J
6\ $ .
6 6 J 6
. " 6 "6 6
.
7 J 6 $
6& $ \
K .
Z 6 6
FJ $ 6 6
6 6 J J 6 v -J 6
.
90
6 $ 6
cJ6 . 6 FJJ controlled experi-
ments 6 $ 6
J v K K \.
$JK J ZZ
J
K . K ? 6 J6 J
$J J J
J .
6 6 & $J 6 &
$ J J
J J
7J d
Z $J .
K 6
6 J J $
& .
K 6 v J J & $
" " . 6
v d . ?
J d $ . F
J . J
J Z FJ
.
FJ FJK
91
.
6 FJ J .J &
v FJ
.Z
J 6 J v
K dJ .v 6 J
K J K .
4 J . K . J
entropy 5J " J"
6 K7
Z .
& 6 v cJ Z
6 J J .
Z 6 .dJ
5 J v6 v
d 4 d 6 v
" \ " .& 6
& 56 6 FJ
.$ K
J . cJ
K 6 l 6 J . K K
$ $ . 6 K .
J 6
6 $J
56 $ F . $
92
@ 7 B! h B 4
. 7 B @ 7 7
! h .@3 ' C
B; C C.
56 . K &J
6 $ Z J J
. 6 K .$
J J 6 J 5 J
. K $ $
. 7 6 6 -\ 6
. d .
6 " " d J FJ
.$ 4 J 6 40 6 400
Z 6 $
J cJ6.
93
12
'
3
\ 6 d J "
" K .vestigial organs 6 J 6 J 6
$ J 6 &
K . 6 6 J J
6 " :
$ 6 ".
6 6 $J J J 6
\ 5 c
KJ
- . K $
$ 6 .
6 .
6 J K .J 6
6
94
$ . 6 6 Z
6 c KJ J J.$
J 6 - J 5
" ".
6 Z $ Z .
6 J J .
6 6 6 6 J6 J 6
5 $J
6.
6 J - . 6 JJ
J 6& c &.
J K
6 - .
6 6 6 J J
6 - 56 c 6 -
6 J 5
\ 53. K 6 $ 6
- Z Z \ .
J6 $\ 6 - 6 6\
6 - 54.
$ - 6\
K 55.- d 6 -
5 \6
56 J 5.c
K K - $ -
6 d $ -
$ $ 6 $ .
95
C .
Z 6& J $ J
. 6 v $ 6 $
v $ $ 6
. 6 $ -
$ $.
6 6 $ 4 J
6 \ . \6 v 7 $
v - \.
K & 6 " "$
. $K 6 - K . $
$ " 56 J."5J
96
13
i @
@3
B C
$ .$
$ Z 6 $ $
$ J6 7 $ J.$
J 6
K .J 6 $ $J
6 v 6 v6 v d
6 d . ? 6 J 6 J Z J 56
$ J $ $ 300
97
K . v J 6 K$
:Aykut Kence
" 6 J K K $
56 !5 Z
56
J ".
! @
-J 5J $ K .
$ $J 6 v 6 v
6 J J 5 v .v
6 K .v Frank L. Marsh J-J 5
6 J J 5 $
Variation and Fixity in Nature
6 C
57
! .
6

5 6 $J
J . K
$ $

6 c J J.

$ trilobites
$ $ 6 $K
98
H 3
4 3 H
@ C C@ ' .h
334 3 \4 h U .
: H 34 .Zdenek Burian
6 Z6 . 6? $ J$
v $ .
$ $ 5
.$ \
. v 6 David Raup F J K $
J J " : $ 450

J
58
."Z
99
7 4
6 6 F

K .6 J\
v

.
\

5
J J
6 .d
6 $ $
3
6 5 $
J $\ $
J . J v d .
c " v J $d
6 " 5J
) K :(5
" v 5 6 $ J
$J 6 $ 5 6
5J 5 J 56
... K v 6
6 J $
100
J \ 5J
6 v $
K $6 .
v J ZJ
$ $
59
6 6 Z ".
J v K" :
v 6 $
6 ."5J v
B ;
J Z $ $
J v 6 Z v
$ K J " $ " .
$ ? 6
$ 5 6 . K 6 6
J J 6 K" : " .
J $ .
74 v 6 J 6 v 6v
6 .
v 6 $ $
400 . $
$ & &
$ 6 . 74 v
$ $
cJ $ .
101
@ 3 C @ C .U
3 C .
6 6 d 6
.
$& 6 J $6 vv
$ . v 6 -J
$ $ \ $
6 $ ) .(J
$ \ K
102
. J Z K "J
" K . \ $ K
\ $ 6 K
K.
6 $J $J . 6 6
) $ ($ .$
\ 46 \ $J copepodes $
\ $ 800 $ .
C
"B"
J $ 6
$ $ 6 $ . 6 d
J $ J Zi
$ $ .cJ
K6 v cJ
6 Z 3.5 K .
J K $ 6
. $K 5 5 v J
J $ .J J
6 530
) . 7 $ K (.
v $ . J
6 $ v
103
. $K $
\ . $ v
6 J\" ". 6 J J
K $
6" J " \ v
K . 6 $ d6 J\
J.
$ J
. $

$ \ .
6\ 6 6 7J&
6 J
"" . Z K .$ 6
K & ) .
F J " : .("J
6 J6 K J J 6 6 d v d
4 K 6 $ $J
.cJ J J 6 5 6&
$ v d K .
6J $ 6 6 77
6 J $
6 $ K . J
104
J J 6 $
Z J 56 . v
K J 6 56 v .
$ J
4 Derek W. Ager
$ " JJ J
60
F\".
Z J 6 $
J $ . K
$ $J 4
6 $ "
6:"Z
C

O

i B
H
.
B
3
) J ( 4 /
" "Z J 6 .J
6\ 4 6 $
. K v J
$ .
105
14
'

" " $ .

6 v 6 Z
J . " Z "J .
6 K Z&
. 4 .
K J
v cJ 5 v .
6 J J $
Z 4 . v " $

106
) ."J K 6 6
J .Z $
Z $ ( . K
6" 6 d $ J J
."Z 6 6
$ v
Z 6 d
$J
.
B
B
6 J J
6 v J 6 J 6
Z 6 J 6 J Z
.
\ 6 Z
. 73 3 Leonardo da Vinci
Copernicus
Kepler Galileo
Cuvier $
Linnaeus Z $$ !\
Isaac Newton K !3 Edwin
Hubble 5 $ 4
107
4 .
v
BC
Albert
6 Einstein 6 :
" 6 6 6 J K
. vJ
: 6".
61
v Max Planck
:
" 56 7J l 56
d 6 d 6 $
F $ : 6
.
".
62
J 6 Z
6 J . 6\
6 $J v
5 6 v
3 3
6 . 6?
6 6
Z6 J\ 6 "" .
Z 6 J
J .&
108
K 5 5 5
6 &
$ . 7J6 6
J 4 6
6 J . 4
& :

i
C
B
B

B

.

) J ( 30 /
!
.

) JJ( 47 / $
6? Z 5 v
6
.
6 .
6 (6 ) 5
. Z 5
F
\ 5
& 5 4 \ .
K
109
150 $ .J
6 6 J
J Z J . -
6 K . 6J Z 6
J J
6 - .
6
110
15
3
B
C
6 6 $
6 \
- J K 6 7
v J.
6 . J
v K 6 J 6 . 6
K v $
) 6 J\ $4(
111
.
J
6 "
."J
6 v 4 $4
v
@
. 56 5 56
! B .
$ .J
6 J\ 4 56 6 $ $
.J 6 $
"".
6 $ $ 6 " 6 "J
K . 6 $ d v
J $
.6 J\ d.
7 " "J J Z
6 . Z
J F . v 6
5 . K
K 6 . 6 J
J . -J K
.
v 7
112
6 v ZJ K . K
6\ . 7
6 6 v 4 d6 . v
6 $
$ $ d 6
. K $ $
\ .
J $ 6 c $ $
$ . K 6 $ 6
J v .d 6\

$ v
7 $ $ v
. J 6 c 6 & .
C
C N
3 : C
.
4.
113
110
C

! 100 150 .

B.U
!
135 .
! B B C
3B U
C B
400
C B
HB .

B B 7 .
U B
B .
114
v 4 d.
K 6 6 d
6J $ 6 $ $
6 6 . Z &
J 6 $ 6
6 $J .
K 6 $ J
"" . & 6 $
$ .cJ
6 " 6 6
$ "J "" J.
K K . 6
J d . J Z v
d 6 d
.6 J\ v J 6
6 $ v&J
.d 6 "J6 "
.
& J 6 ? v J
5 6 . 150
J J 5
& 56 J6 .
115
16
3
B
- J
" K $
J Z $J ".
6 J J
.Z J 6 " :
C .
O ! ; ! ".
. - 6
6 J Z
K .Z 6 -J .$
116
6 "" 6 6 J\ 6
$.
K
6 J J J - 6
. 6c
:
6 J v 6 6:
.1 v 6 $
.2 d 6 v 4 d
.3 56 $ 6$

6 5 v v&
6 ? . K
6 J .
K v .
.1 v " v"
5 .J 6 v 6 d
v 6 " Z" .
K :
" 6 v & ?
J 747
".
63
117
Z 5 6 J.J
v 5 Z Willian Paley
6 Z
. J 5\
100 6
56 ? v .cJ K F
6 .
F 6 6 &J K .
$ .

\
6 J K . 5
6 .
Z .
$J v \
.$ v J
iJ 6 J ? . 6J
J 6 6J \
K 5
100 . K 6 Z
6 K J .
5 " "5J\ J
K . 6 $J $ $
118
J v
J ) F J "
"( . $
. $ J
J i

6.
.2 6 J 6 J d 6 4 d
. 6 vd
6 5 56 5J 56 .d Z
\ 3 @
B h3 3
B
B B
@ B
B B;
B C B .
119
Colin Patterson $ J
& $:
" 6 4 $ .
6 F K J v
J v& ".
64
6 v 6 5
J . v J .J . B. G.
:Ranganathan
" 6 $ 6 J .
$ J $ 6
$ 56 Z J
6 . K F v
J Z 6
J ".
65
d
6J $ J
J . 6 Z $

\ Z 6 J 6 56
$ 6J.
.3 6 $ 6 56 J
$ "" . K $
120
. Niles Eldredge J $
J J J 6
56 v J 56 $ :
" 7 $ $ 6
K 6 $ 6 J
5J $".
66
6 4 J $ Robert Wesson
J 1991 J Beyond Natural
" 6 Selection $ $

" . :
" K $ . 5
Z 5 566 $K $.
d 6 J$
J d J d
J d v
" .
67
$ 150 ? J v
$J . J
6 6 v
.
$ ? .
121
J 6 J

J.
J Z .J
$J 6 6 .
6 v $ J 6&
& . Z
J 6 $
6 & 56 .$
5
6 6 $ Z $
J \ J .
6 .
" 6 J
" " Z 6cJ
".
122
17
' h
3
$ $
. &
v .metamorphosis v
6 v 6 J J 6
J& .J& J J
v " "J 6 J
6 - 6 6
$ 6 6 d J J 6 J
J . 6
J 6 $ $
123
J
. \
...
$ F
6 $ v
. d 6
4 .
J J v
6 $ $
$ .
K v
v
6 J.
v
$J
. d
J $
v .
v J
J $
J . $K
$ v.
C h:
; .
124
h 3
6 $ v v 6
$ . v d
v $ & 6 12.
K 6& $ .
& " " irreducible
complexity 6 v .
" " Z $
K Michael Behe
.J
6 Z
5 v 6 $
6 K
6 6 6
6 . 6
& $
'
$ J
.J v.
& v $ $ $
J .$ .
& 6
. 6 6
"4 " 6 6J
K .J 56 6 J
J .
6 & 6 6 d Z
56 J c - J
125
! B h "3 "

' . B h "
"
3 C H "
3" ! . h h " " B 3
.
v . 6 K J
6 $ v
.
126
18
'
(B 3) H "3"
\ 5 6 Z
$ 6
. v " d Z "56
7J \ $
$.
J d $
10 $ 6
(6 ) 5 \ .
127
128
$ $
.
6 J 6 J
Francis Collins 5 -6 d Z 5 &
\ $ 5
) .(6
J 10 $ $
& $ 6
$
$ .(6 ) 5
(B 3) H
3
$ (6 ) 5

. K d ) (6
v Z Z K 100.

K 6 K .
$ (6 ) 5 J J
. 5 1000
6 Z .
K 6 $
6 100 100 7
129
.
J6 K 6 J $& \ 5
6 56 Z v K .
6 J Z 100 : 1000
!F $ . K
K cJ
56
J J $ .
& $ .
6 6 $ .$
K J (6 ) 5 &
\ 6 6
J .
J J 6 Gene Myers 6
Celera Genomics dZ
.5 $ 6 d
" :(6 ) 5 'B B
'! ...
@ ...
68
".
130
!' C @3 3) H
(B 7 !
.
7 4 6 6
6 v
6 & K .
6 6 $ (6 ) 5 .
6 6 v $ 6 Z
J.
K . $
$ .
131

J \K . 6 6-
""
6 .$ K
Z J J c

. J K 6 " :\ $
"K . 6
6 6\ J $
.
6 J J $ (6 ) 5
v
J 6 K . 6 (6 ) 5 5
6 d $ $
132

.

$

.
$

6 F 6 d
. 6 (6 ) 5
$ 5 6
6 . 6 6J
J d J v
6 $\ v " ".
133
19
'
C3

6 - 5 6 v J J
- $ K .
6 J J J & $
v J $ $ .
$ $
5 5 .DDT
K J J 6 v .d
$ J " $" $
$ 6\ . v 6 5
134
5 6 J Alexander Fleming .1928

J 55
7J6 6
Staphylococcus
v .
K $ K $
.
K . 6
$ J . :$
c $

5
. $.
6 v J 6 J K " J
".
K .
6 6 v d
Lee Spetner 6
" " Not by Chance 5 .1997
6 4
.J :
.1 $ .
.2 J $ .
? K $ :2001
" $ $ Z& $
. 6 & 5 5
135
E. coli H
! C3
3
.
6& ... $ & 6 $

6\ 6 . 4 6$
5
c $ $
6 $".
69
" :"J
" F $ ...
d 5 K 6 $
K ...J 6 $J 6
6 $ Z
6 $ .biocosm 5 6
$ v $
."d
70
136
K 6 56 J Z $
J $J
.
d 5 J
6 . :
" 6 5 6
5 v v
nucleotide
... Streptomycin 5
6 Selman Waksman $ Albert Schatz
v 1944 5
6 . 6
6 5
K 6 d $
J K . 6 d
Z Z
5 ."5
71
" " v
? . ?
Z Z . Z 6\
Z .Z
" 6 "
K 6
& \ J .
v& :
137
" J Z 5 5
Z .5
6 J.$
6 ...J 6
$ d K . 6 J 6
$ \ ".
72
J Z
. K J "" Z
. K 6 J $ .
56 Z "" ) .
6 J 6 Z 6 J
J Z .(5 6 "" 5
Z K 5 " ."5
6 v " J $" .6 ZJ
J 6 5 J
v d .
$K $ 5
5 $ . $Z
$ . 5J
6 Francisco Ayala& " : 6 $J
6 6 d $
$ $ & $ ".
73
6 \
138
v Z6 J& J
" )( $J" .$
& 4 $
$ K .J 6&
6 $ J v .$ K ?
6 $ 56 6\
v :
" $ JK . 6$
J \ - 6
$ J - 56
.$ v6 5 : $
d 5 6
!"
74
139
20
;
6 J
$K . 6&
\ $
.
6 J J 6 6
6 56 - . 6
K $
Z J v " d
&J " .\ 6 F
6 J . K J
" J " J K . 6 6
140
J ,
6 6 6
J4 . K J .
B @3
B 3
-J 6 J

.
6 .
v v
6
. K
. 6 \ .
K &
6 . 6 v
-J Z 6& 56
.
K
K .$ " : dJ
J 6 "6 . -J
"J " " J "K . 6
-J 6 7J 5 J
6 6 . 67J
141

3
3 ;
Democritus B @3 @3
B h4 N .@3
6 dJ
K iJ
.
v
K 6 .
142
K
\ J
\ J
6 6
7
. KK
JJ
J
c
6 . iJ
6 & 6.
3
-J K .v

6
6 . K Z 67
& 6 5
6& .
FJ 6 $ 6
6 $ 6 .
6 FJ J J & K . 6
. J
6 J Andrew Scott $ v d
143
& . 6 K
$ 5 -J
v :d
" 76 6
$& . v
6 c v &
5 $K . 6
$ 56 d d J .d
Z\ ) $
( 6 .c
. J
J 66 c $ 6\
".
76
6 6 K .
6
6
144
:
" .&
i . 6 c
\ "" K
\
... &

4 $
'
6\
v d
6 vJ 7".Z
75
6 - v
6 . K 6
@3 @3 @
' 3
; @
7 . '
![ H H
![ .
145
7 3
4 3
27 /4
1998
" ".
6 . K $
5 J 5 .
K 6 $

.
K 6 . ""
v $ .
6 J J " J
6 " . 6
7 6
$ . K $J
5 6 6 $
146
6 . 6
" " Science Finds God 5
Newsweek J J 27 / 1998
d 5 .
147

Francis Crick, Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature, New .1
.York, Simon & Schuster, 1981, p.88
Ali Demirsoy, Kaltm ve Evrim (Inheritance and .2
Evolution), Meteksan Publishing Co., Ankara, 1984,
.p. 39
Homer Jacobson, Information, Reproduction and the .3
.Origin of Life, American Scientist, January 1955, p. 121
Douglas J. Futuyma, Science on Trial, Pantheon .4
.Books, New York, 1983, p. 197
Robert L. Carroll, Patterns and Processes of .5
Vertebrate Evolution, Cambridge University Press, 1997, p. 25,
((emphasis added
Stephen C. Meyer, P. A. Nelson, and Paul Chien, The .6
.Cambrian Explosion: Biologys Big Bang, 2001, p. 2
Richard Monastersky, Mysteries of the Orient, .7
(Discover, April 1993, p. 40, (emphasis added
Phillip E. Johnson, Darwinisms Rules of .8
Reasoning, in Darwinism: Science or Philosophy by Buell
Hearn, Foundation for Thought and Ethics, 1994, p. 12,
((emphasis added
Ian Anderson, Who made the Laetoli footprints? .9
.New Sceientist, vol. 98, 12 May 1983, p. 373
D. Johanson & M. A. Edey, Lucy: The Beginnings of .10
.Humankind, New York: Simon & Schuster, 1981, p. 250
.R. H. Tuttle, Natural History, March 1990, pp. 61-64 .11
.D. Johanson, Blake Edgar, From Lucy to Language, p. 169 .12
.D. Johanson, Blake Edgar, From Lucy to Language, p. 173 .13
.Boyce Rensberger, Washington Post, 19 October 1984, p. A11 .14
Is This the Face of Our Past? Discover, December 1997, pp. .15
.
97-100
Villee, Solomon and Davis, Biology, Saunders College .16
.Publishing, 1985, p. 1053
Hominoid Evolution and Climatic Change in Europe, .17
Volume 2, Edited by Louis de Bonis, George D. Koufos,
Peter Andrews, Cambridge University Press 2001, chapter 6,
((emphasis added
148
Daniel E. Lieberman, Another face in our family

(tree, Nature, March 22, 2001, (emphasis added
John Whitefield, Oldest member of human family
.found, Nature, 11 July 2002
D. L. Parsell, Skull Fossil From Chad Forces
Rethinking of Human Origins, National Geographic News,
.July 10 2002
John Whitefield, Oldest member of human family
.found, Nature, 11 July 2002
.The Guardian, 11 July 2002
Arda Denkel, Cumhuriyet Bilim Teknik Eki (Science
and Technology Supplement of the Turkish daily Cumhuriyet),
.27 February, 1999
G. W. Harper, Alternatives to Evolution, School
.Science Review, vol. 61, September 1979, p. 26
http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/science/09/24/
humans.chimps.ap/index.html
http://www.newscientist.com/news/
news.jsp?id=ns99992833
Karen Hopkin, The Greatest Apes, New Scientist,
(vol. 62, issue 2186, 15 May 1999, p. 27, (emphasis added
(Hrriyet, February 24, 2000, (emphasis added
Harun Yahya, Darwinism Refuted, pp.207-222
.Nature, vol. 382, August 1, 1996, p. 401
Carl O. Dunbar, Historical Geology, John Wiley and
.Sons, New York, 1961, p. 310
Robert L. Carroll, Patterns and Processes of
Vertebrate Evolution, Cambridge University Press, 1997, p.
.280-281
L. D. Martin, J. D. Stewart, K. N. Whetstone, The
.Auk, vol. 97, 1980, p. 86
L. D. Martin, J. D. Stewart, K. N. Whetstone, The
Auk, vol. 97, 1980, p. 86; L. D. Martin, Origins of the
Higher Groups of Tetrapods, Ithaca, Comstock Publishing
.Association, New York, 1991, pp. 485-540
S. Tarsitano, M. K. Hecht, Zoological Journal of
the Linnaean Society, vol. 69, 1980, p. 149; A. D. Walker,
149
.18
.19
.20
.21
.22
.23
.24
.25
.26
.27
.28
.29
.30
.31
.32
.33
.34
.35
.Geological Magazine, vol. 117, 1980, p. 595

A. D. Walker, as described in Peter Dodson, .36
International Archaeopteryx Conference, Journal of
.Vertebrate Paleontology, 5(2): 177, June 1985
Jonathan Wells, Icons of Evolution, Regnery .37
.Publishing, 2000, p. 117
.http://www.yfiles.com/dinobird2.html
Richard L. Deem, Demise of the Birds are .38
.Dinosaurs Theory. http://www.yfiles.com/dinobird2.html
Scientists say ostrich study confirms bird hands .39
unlike these of dinosaurs, http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_
releases/2002-08/uonc-sso081402.php
Scientists say ostrich study confirms bird hands .40
unlike these of dinosaurs, http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_
releases/2002-08/uonc-sso081402.php
Ann Gibbons, Plucking the Feathered Dinosaur, .41
Science, vol. 278, no. 5341, 14 November 1997, pp. 1229
. 1230
Forensic Palaeontology: The Archaeoraptor Forgery, .42
.Nature, March 29, 2001
Storrs L. Olson OPEN LETTER TO: Dr. Peter .43
Raven, Secretary, Committee for Research and Exploration,
National Geographic Society, Washington DC 20036,
.Smithsonian Institution. November 1, 1999
Tim Friend, Dinosaur-bird link smashed in fossil .44
(flap, USA Today, 25 January 2000, (emphasis added
G. G. Simpson, W. Beck, An Introduction to Biology, .45
.Harcourt Brace and World, New York, 1965, p. 241
Ken McNamara, Embryos and Evolution, New .46
(Scientist, vol. 12416, 16 October 1999, (emphasis added
Keith S. Thompson, Ontogeny and Phylogeny .47
Recapitulated, American Scientist, vol. 76, May/June 1988,
.p.273
Francis Hitching, The Neck of the Giraffe: Where .48
Darwin Went Wrong, Ticknor and Fields, New York, 1982, p.
.204
Elizabeth Pennisi, Haeckels Embroys: Fraud .49
150
,Rediscovered, Science, 5 September

Elizabeth Pennisi, Haeckels Embroys: Fraud .50
(Rediscovered, Science, 5 September, (emphasis added
Massimo Pigliucci, Rationalists of East Tennessee .51
.Book Club Discussion, October 1997
Evrim Kuram Konferans (Conference on the Theory .52
of Evolution), Istanbul Universitesi fen Fakultesi (University
.of Istanbul, Faculty of Economics), June 3, 1998
Leonard M.S., 1992. Removing third molars: a review .53
for the general practitioner. Journal of the American Dental
.Association, 123(2):77-82
M. Leff, 1993. Hold on to your wisdom teeth. .54
.Consumer reports on Health, 5(8):4-85
Daily.T 1996. Third molar prophylactic extraction: a .55
review and analysis of the literature. General Dentistry, 44(4):
.310-320
Evrim Kuram Knoferans (Conference on the Theory .56
of Evolution), Istanbul Universitesi Fen Fakultesi (University
.of Istanbul, Faculty of Science), June 3, 1998
http://www.icr.org/creationproducts/ .57
creationscienceproducts/Variation_and_Fixity_in_Nature.html
David Raup, Conflicts Between Darwin and .58
Paleontology, Bulletin, Field Museum of Natural History,
.vol. 50, January 1979, p. 24
Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species, 1859, p. 313- .59
(314, (emphasis added
Derek A. Ager, The Nature of the Fossil Record, .60
Proceedings of the British Geological Association, vol. 87,
(1976, p. 133, (emphasis added
Science, Philosophy and Religion, A Symposium, .61
published by the Conference on Science, Philosophy and
Religion in Their Relation to the Democratic Way of Life, Inc.,
(New York, 1941, (emphasis added
Max Plank, Where Is Science Going?, Allen & .62
(Unwin, 1933, p. 214, (emphasis added
Hoyle on Evolution, Nature, vol. 294, November .63
.12, 1981, p. 105
151
Colin Patterson, Cladistics, Interview by Brian

Leek, interviewer Peter Franz, March 4, 1982, BBC, (emphasis
(added
B. G. Ranganathan, Origins?, Pennsylvania: the
.Banner Of Truth Trust, 1988
N. Eldredge and I. Tattersall, The Myths of Human
.Evolution, Columbia University Press, 1982, p. 59
R. Wesson, Beyond Natural Selection, MIT Press,
.Cambridge, MA, 1991, p. 45
Human Genome Map Has Scientists Talking
About The Divine by Tom Abate, San Francisco Chronicle,
(February 19, 2001, (emphasis added
Dr. Lee Spetner, Lee Spetner/Edward Max
Dialogue: Continuing an exchange with Dr. Edward E. Max,
2001, www.trueorigin.org/spetner2.asp
Francisco J. Ayala, The Mechanisms of Evolution,
Scientific American, vol. 239, September 1978, p. 64,
((emphasis added
Andrew Scott, Update on Genesis, New Scientist,
.vol. 106, May 2nd, 1985, p. 30
Fred Hoyle, The Intelligent Universe,
.Michael Joseph, London, 1983, p. 20-21
152
.64
.65
.66
.67
.68
.69
.70
.71
.72
.73
.74
.75
76

هدم نظرية التطور في عشرين سؤالا - هارون يحيى

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

هدم نظرية التطور في عشرين سؤالا - هارون يحيى

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

153

) ? ) . O ?    (   

  .  ! C      T 

 " :  ""   "" ""

 J"" ""   J"

6 6 omes  6 cell membranes  

6 J\ K 6 6 d  cJ J

 $ $ . &  $ J  ""

v  $ . &  6 

    J 6 Z ".

 Juan Luis Arsuaga Ferreras - 5  $

   "  J  - " .

J chimps more different than thought :

.Z Tarsitano . M. K. Hecht

'  " [ "i

B \4   " C3 [ "i

" 0-   E "D

 " :   VI   

   endoplasmic reticulum

6 $J6 K" :rs  J &

 " "   $ .

" 6 Selection $  $

!    B  h "3 "

 5 6 J Alexander Fleming .1928

6&  ...  $ &  6 $

Daniel E. Lieberman, Another face in our family

.Geological Magazine, vol. 117, 1980, p. 595

,Rediscovered, Science, 5 September

Colin Patterson, Cladistics, Interview by Brian

You might also like

) ? ) . O ? (

. ! C T

" : "" "" ""

J"" "" J"

6 6 omes 6 cell membranes

6 J\ K 6 6 d cJ J

$ $ . & $ J ""

v $ . & 6

J 6 Z ".

Juan Luis Arsuaga Ferreras - 5 $

" J - " .

J chimps more different than thought :

.Z Tarsitano . M. K. Hecht

' " [ "i

B \4 " C3 [ "i

" 0- E "D

" : VI

endoplasmic reticulum

6 $J6 K" :rs J &

" " $ .

" 6 Selection $ $

! B h "3 "

5 6 J Alexander Fleming .1928

6& ... $ & 6 $