A, :

, , .

, ,

. (
,
350

" ").
, ,
.
,
" " , ,
- . 19 ,
, ( ) ,
. ,
,
.
, ,
.
" "
,
, ,
. ,
,
, . ,
,
, . , .
,

. ,
,

( ),
. ,

,

.

"".
1

B. Chantal Jacquet, Sub specie aeternitatis. tude des concepts de temps, dure et

ternit chez Spinoza, d. Kim, Paris 1997, . 110.

2

"Nec aeternitas tempus definiri, nec ullam ad tempus relationem habere potest" ( . 23 .)

 , ""
-

. ,
" .
,
, " .
: ,
,
,
,
, expressis verbis
" ", ' 1
. , , '
,
" " -/

.
3

1.
, ,
, -
.
"
" .
,
,
.
:
To ,

,
.
/ ,
6

Pierre-Franois Moreau, Spinoza et l' Exprience, in : Spinoza et la politique, Actes du Colloque de

Santiago du Chili, L' Harmattan, Paris/Montral 1997, . 33.
, ,
Spinoza. L' Exprience et l' Eternit, PUF, coll. Epimthe, Paris 1994.
4 Pieter van Hove Antonio Perez.
5 14 . 9,
,
, ,
. .
6 . , , 1997, . 48 .,
"" ,
, ", "
" ". ,
" "
- .
7 . : ", " ( , 22-10-1999).

 " "
.

, :
8

" ,

" (. 10 8).
, , ,

" " ,

.
,

.
,
.
9

,
, .
, .
o
, ,
,
,
(ibid).

,

. , , , ,
- " " .

"
"
10

11

. . Ko, " ", , 14-12-1999.

. ". M" E (1/3/2000): "
. '
, , ' .
, ,
2000".
10 ,
. ..: ,
N .
11 . . 13 : "
,
, , ,
,
, ,
".
9

 ,
.
,
[multitudo],
: " ,
, " (. . 2 17).
,
,
.
, .
. ,
, : , ,
. o
.
12

13

14

"


, ,
, " (. . 5 6).

(
) (
)
.
.
"
". , "", ,
:
""; ,
.
" " . .,

.

multitudo,
15

12

. . 2 21: " ,
, ".
13 . . 6 1.
14 , passim.
15 . .. : "
" (. . 9 13
).
.. , , ...
""
. .. , 14 9 .
., , "

,
".

 ()
: ;
( )
, , " ".
:
, [superbia] , [ambitio] ,
[aemulatio] , , [invidia] ,
.
16

18

17

19

2.

. 11 . 8 :

,
.

( ),
:
, [ /
, ..], .

, , :
, , ,
.
,
,
, ,
.

,
,
, , ,
,
,

, ,
, .

,
-
- . , ,

-,
16

, 28.
.., 44.
18 33. "" "
". . .
19 23.
17


, .

,

.

:
20

,

.

,
,

(6 32).

. , " "
,
.
' , ,

.
, ,
.
21

22

20

. : "
. , " ( , 3012-1999).
, ( )
, ""
2000 . . ..
.
21 ,
, ,
.-. . ,
("Urbs Amstelodamum exemplo sit"), " ,
[sectae], " "
, [...]
" (. 20, . van Vloten Land, 1895, . , . 171).
22 ,
(03-08-1998), " ",
:
" . [] , ,
, 1996-97
5%
20%. []
:
1
. . []
2 . .
, .

 . ,

,

.

, ,
, .
, ' -
,
. . 2 . 5 . .:
23

24

,
, . []

' , ,

, o
.

,

- , .
, ,

.
17 - , ,

. (" ...")
. "
", . "
' , ; ; ,
".

3. /
,
-,
,
.
. 9.4-30.4.98, 22
, 11
7 ".
23 "The mutual Preservation of their Lives, Liberties and Estates, which I call with a general Name,
Property ..." (Locke, Two treatises of Government, Cambridge University Press, 1967, . , .
123, . 368 ).
24
2000.
,
.


,
: ( "",
, )
, , .
, gentis ingenium, ,
,
, .
: " ,
[ ], , ,
,
" .
, /
(, , )
, , , ,
.
,

.

-
,
, ,
" ( , ...) ".
,
, , ,
, .
" " .
, , " "
,
- .
25

26

27

28

29

25

.-. . . 3, . . 390.
. 17 : "
, , ,
. ,
, (...), ,
".
27 .-. .,
""
, , ,
(.-. . . 3, in fine).
, "", . ,
,
.
28 . (28/03/2000) ... "" :
[ . ]
. "

, ,
. , -
. []
, ; ;.
26

 , ,
,
:
( " " ).
,

,

,
() .
" "
, '
(" "), "
". , ,
,
:
.
/ , gentis
ingenium , ,
,
universalia.

( ) . :
, ,
.
natio,
" " , classis. ,
N,
30

31

32

33

29

. " 1 3 " ( , 10-06-1999): " 1

, 40.000 ,
. ,
1
. ,
.
.
,
, 10%
, ".
30 , , .-. .
(17) .
31 . . 40 : "
, ".
32 " [. -..]
, .
" (.-. ., ..).
, ,
, ,
, (.
, . . . 1 . 1). , ,

"" ,
"" -
.

 ,


: 46 . ,
, ingenium,
,
, " "
" " . , , , ,

(
).
, ,
(nomina universalia).
34

35

36

37

4.
,
-
.

- ,
.
.
, "
"
. :
, - -

. ,

38

39

33

-, ,
, . , , 1993.
34 " " (. Negri,
L'Anomalia Selvaggia. Saggio su potere e potenza in Baruch Spinoza, Feltrinelli, Milano 1981). .
.. . 2. . Gilles Deleuze , PUF,
Paris 1982, . 9.
35 " , ' ,
, (sub nomine universalis)
, ,
".
36 . 16 ,
"
, ,
[ ]
" ( ).
37 . 40, . 2.
38 .: ": " ( , 01-02-1999):
" . ,
, .

, ' , ".

10

 ,
17 (
20).
, '

' ,
. , -
, -
- ,
" " ( .. "") ,
, ,

. , ,
-,
, .

'
. 6 . 6 . .:
40

41.

. 14
. 9, .
,
:
" , ,
,
,
".

39

..
.
" "
, ..
. , 10 . 6
"
[architecturam militarem]".
40 G ran
Therborn : " [...]
. 1540 1690,
17 1792 1840.
,
, , ,
, , " (European
Modernity and beyond. The trajectory of European societies 1945-2000, Sage Publications, LondonThousand Oaks-New Delhi 1995, . 22 ).
41 ..
, (. ,
)
.

11

 ,
.
. .,
Jan de Witt, ,
, .
"", .
,
'
.

,
. ,
, , "
" ( . . 40)

14 .
,
, , . .,

, , "
", . .
, ,
, ,
" " ,
, .
, , ,
, ,
- - :
: "
;",
, , ,

"", ,
,
, .
, ,
, (deliberatio)

( ), ,
,
,
42

43

44

42

. . . (,
1996), . 10 ..
43 " , ,
,
,
" (9 14). ,
,
, .
44 dum Romani deliberant perit Sagunthus xxi, vii, I.

12

 -
.
,
!

. , ,
.


, ,
: (militia ex
solis civibus) , ,
.

(= ) " ,
: , " . , '
,
" " .
..
,
" "
[Principum libidinem coercendam] .
, (
' ), ,
-
, -,
, ,
.
45

46

47

48

49

50

45

. . 7 12.
. . . 6 . 10.
. 8 9 8 .,
, ""
. , ,
.
"-"
, - : (. -. . . 17, . . 142).
, , .
47 . Machiavelli, Il Principe, Feltrinelli, Milano 1991, . 82.
48 . (Spinoza, l' anti-Orwell - la crainte des
masses, in : Les Temps Modernes . 470, 1985).
49 .-. . . 17 (..). K "
' . , ' ,
, ,
" (ibid).
50 . " " ( , 27-01-2000):
" ,
. . . , ,
20%
.
.. . . ,
.
.
46

13


.
- , ,
.

12 . 7:

,

,
.

(, ) ,
, .
" ",
" ' ,
,
, ' ,
" (. . 7 28).
. 7 ,
, '
, "
,
. ,
[. - ..]
, , ,
,
,
,
".
, /
/ .
,
, (,
) -
.
" "
/, /,
, . .

,
,
.
. , ".

14


:
51

" , , ,

, ,
,
. ,
, ,
,
.
:
" 52.

,
:

- - (, ,
) - (, . ,
) - .
, , -
- (, , ) - (=
, , . )
- .

5.
,
,
.
, ,
, , ,
/ .
' . , , 17

( ).
1648,
,
. "
. ,
, .

51 De

Cive X, 17 (in : Hobbes, Opera, ed. Molesworth, Londini apud Joannem Bohn, MDCCCXXXIX,
v. II, . 277). , , ,
,
" ", "monarchia absolutissima civitatis sit
optimus omnium status".
52 7 5.

15

 " .
, ,
,

.
,
, ,
1611, ' ,
.
"
, : , , ,
, , , , , , , , ,
:
,
" .
: ,
" ",

, ,
. , ,
multitudo,
: "
, ,
, - de Witt , , ,
: , , , .
1672
" .

,
,
- :
53

54

55

56

57

" ,

. ,

'
53

Pierre-Franois Moreau, Spinoza, d. du Seuil-crivains de toujours, Paris 1975,

( ) .
54 . Lodewijk Wagenaar, "Les mcanismes de la prosprit", in: Henry Mechoulan (dir.),
Amsterdam XVII sicle, d. Autrement-Srie Mmoires No 23, Paris 1993, . 72.
55 Wagenaar, .. . 74.
56 . . 14 . 9, : "
,
, . ' ,

. ,

.
".
57 , .. (. 41), . 14-15.

16

. , ,
'
(integrae
societati incumbit) "58.

,
/ . ,
,
, ...
.
.
, , ,
, :
, ,
.
, ' , . ,
,
, ,
.

, - -
. ,
,
-
.
,
,
, ,
-
.
,
, . ,

, -
- jus .
.
,
,

59

60

61

58

, . 17.
. , 19 .
60 .., 23.
61 . . . 2 . 10: " ,

, , ,

. ,
, ,
".
59

17

"" ( )
. , ,
.
()
,
: (, )
, ,
, , ,
.
.
. - - . , 6
( ),
.
(7 . 8),
.
,

.
("ut olim ab Atheniensibus ..."),

, ,
- - 17 ,
.
,
.
A
"" . . imperium Hollandorum.
. 31 . 8,
62

63

64

65

66

62

. " " ( , 01-03-2000):

" .
, , ,

.
' , ,

, ' .
O .
".
63 " , ,
, ,
" (. 12).
( ). . .-.
. . 17 (. . 145).
64 lbert . irschman,
The passions and the interests : political arguments for capitalism before its triumph,
Princeton University Press, 1977 (. 74-75).
65 .: " [ ]
..." (Isaak Ilych Rubin, , ,
1994, . 59 ).
66 , , "
, . '
, "
(. 7 . 8).

18


, ,
( ) "
". , ,
:
,
, " ,

, ,
" (=, ,
).
, ,
,
-
. ,
.
67

68

6.
,
,

.
,
- - ,
, ( ) .
:
, , .

/
, ' .

multitudo " "
-
,
.
:
1. (

)

69

67

" [. ]
, [= ] ". ,
: " ,
".
68 " ;
, ..." .. (ibid.).
69 . . , .
, , 2000, .

19

2. , ..
" ",
" ",
:
)
( ,

),

/ ,
)
- ,

3.
-, ,
.
,
- ,
: ,
, . ..
, (
1)
( 2), .
( 3)
(. 1)
" " (. 2),
(2) " "
. (2)
,
(1). .
,
, -
- ,
- , . "

, ,
" .
70

71

72

73

74

70

. 28.
. 50.
72 , .. ,
" :
" ( , 17-08-1998),
:
" , . .
, . ,
.
.
, ".
73 . 8.
74 " : ", -, , , .
, , 1993, . 142. (. 155)
" ,
71

20

, " []
20 ".
, ,
,
:
/, ,
"" -


.
- -
().
, ,
- - ,
,
. ,
,
,
:
. ,
/ ,

- . , ,
. '
, ,

, , ,
".

21