2

10

14

19

32

35

38

: :

41

53

57

63

69

81

84

88

92

 ""

:
:

)(

. :

-1
.

-2
.

-3 .
:

:
-1
-2

.

-1

-2

-3
5

 :
) (Good Governance

"" ) (Conditionality

) Structural Adjustment

.(Programs

-1 :

.
8

-2 :

" "

 Nanda, 2006: ) Good Governance

.(271

) .(Weiss, 2000: 796

) Boyer, 1990:

.(51 -

) World Bank,
.(2003: xviii

10

 "" -

) Guhan, 1998:

.(185

)(1
11

 "

" De-Centralization of the Political

System

) .(Jayal, 1997: 408

) (Axtmann, 2004: 269-70

).(1

12

(Weiss, 2000:

) .799

) (Weiss, 2000: 800

).(Nanda, 2006: 272, 277

13

: )

( )

(
.(Weiss, 2000: 798) .

).(Weiss, 2000: 801

"

" "

). (Johnson, 1997: 1

14

).(OCED, 1995: 14

(Weiss,

) .2000: 798
.

15

).(Weiss, 2000: 804
16

.
) Human

.(Development Index - HDI

) .(Weiss, 2000: 802

1997

)(Minimalist State

).(Weiss, 2000: 803

17

).(UNDP, 2002: 51-52

18

).(UNDP, 2006: 34-5

"

" :

: )
( :

) (.

)
19

(
.

1996

" "

".

:
)

( )
(
http://www.unescap.org/pdd/prs/ProjectActivities/Ongoing/gg/governance.asp 1

20

( ) IMF,

.(1997: 3

:
.

.
21

- :

) UNDP,

.(1993: 3-12

http://ww.moibrahimfaundation.org.

22

-1 :
.

-2 :

-3 :

-4 :
.
-5 :
.

Democratic
Governance Human Governance

).(UNDP, 2006: 22

:
23

 -1 :

.

-2 :

-3 :
.

-4 :
.

-5 :
.

-6 :
.

-7 :
.

24

) UNDP,
.(2006: 32

. " "

).(UNDP, 2006: 36

25

 ) UNDP, 2006:

.(38-40

)(UNDP/UN-OHRLLS, 2006: 36

).(Weiss, 2000: 805

26

) Chandhoke, 2003:

.(2957 :

-1 ):(Deconcentration

-2 ) :(Delegation

-3 ) :(Devolution

).(UNDP, 1993: 66-7

:

27

) :
(

:

.

:
.

:
.

28

 :

).(UNDP, 1997: 104-5

.
.

29

).(UNHCR, 2007: 2

) (Gender Equity

30

).(Danida, 2008: 3-4

( 1.

).(UN, 2007: 17, 31
1 :
http://www.un.org/arabic/millenniumgoals/news.shtml

31

 :
:
:
:

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

: -

: -

32

).(Guhan, 1998: 185

:
.

:

.

:
.

:
) Kaufmann, et. Al,

.(2007: 3-4

33

.
) (kleptocracy " "

).(Amundsen, 2006: 3-4

34

:
- ) +

( -
.
:

35

 .
).(Nanda, 2006: 273, 278

(Weiss, 2000:

) .801 1989" :
"

36

 )(Top-down approach
.

) .(Jayal, 1997: 410

).(Brinkerhoff and Brinkerhoff, 2002: 515

37

(..... )

(......
.

/ / /.

Franck, ) .
(1992: 91

38

 : -

.. .

-1

39

 -2 :

.

-3 :
.

40

 : -
:
1

.
:

:

2

"

"

:

1

41

.

.

42

.1

.2

:
"

".

: .

.
- 1 2003
2
.2002

43

 :
-1 : :

.
-2 :

-3 :

: 1

- :

- :

- 1 .
.2009

44

- :

-4 :

.1

1 : :
.2004

45

. 1
2

.2 .

.2002

1 ,
.2004 ,

2 , - )( ,
2001

46

) - ( .

) (

1 , ,
1996

2 , , ,

.2004

- 4 . : .2003

- 5

.2007

47

-5 :

- 1 . :

. ) ( :

- 2 :
.2003

- 3 . .2007

.
.2000

48

.3

: .

) (

.

1 ,

2 )
( .

- 3
) ( .

49

, 1

1 , , ,

- 2 ""
.2006

50

 -6 :

)(

. "
".

)(

51

 Operational
.

1 :

- .

-

.

- .

) (
)(.

- 1 . :
15 .2003

52

. -
-

" ".
2
) (.

1 ,
.

- 2

53

 .
:

-1 1

-2 2

.

:

-
.

-
.

1
2005

2 ,
) (3 2007 ,

54

-
.

. :

-1
-2
-3
-4
2

1 : )(

- 2 .

.2006

55

 1

.
-3 2

1 : )(
.

- 2 . .

56

 :
1 - :

. "

".

:
1990

1 .

. 2003

2 .2000

57

2000 :

2004

-1

. - .2006 http://www.icrs-:
iraq.org/ar/r+s/1-1-3.htm

58

-
.

-

.

- 1
.2007-10-3

59

-
.

) ( :

1 "

"
.

2 .

1 .

2
. 2005

60

/
.

. 2006

- : .2003

61

 -1 )
(

-2
.

-3

.

62

-1 :

1 :

: -1 -2
-3.

: :
-

-
.

: :

1 ) (POGAR .

63

.
2 :

1 .

64


.1

-3

.1

1 , , ,
.

, , .3

2 , , , , .1999
- , .

65

 4 :

" "

.
:

-1 :

" "

66

..

-2 :

-3 :

(.

. :
,

67

68

2004-1996

.
69

 Millennium Challenges Account

)(
.

) (100-

70

 - %75

- %50

- %25

- %10

- %10

2005

2009 21 ) (2004-2002
195 19 ).(2002-2000

:
-1

-2

-3

-4

-5

-6

.
71

"

" " "

OCED

-1 : -2 -3

-4 -5 -6 -7 -8

-9 .

)( .

72

73

74

2004-1996

75

:
200

.

.

2009:
-

76

: :

21.8

78.2

86.1

79.3

78.7

86.7

Source: World Bank Institute, Data Base of Good Governance

Indicators 2009, www.worldbank.org

.
.

77

(2009 -2002
.

.
:

-1 .

-2

-3

-4

78

 : :

2009

22.8

7.3

7.9

14.8

12.1

22.7

Source: World Bank Institute, Data Base of Good Governance

Indicators 2009, www.worldbank.org

:
79

 .1

.2

.3

.4 .

.5 .

80

" " "

-1

)
( Participation

81

-2

. )

(.

-3
.

-4
.

-5
:

.
.

-6

-7 ) (

.

-8

82

 ) (

-9
: .

83

 :
-1

: :

.
)( :

:
.

:
.

:
: .
:
.

:
.

84

 -2

.
-3

85

-4

-5

-6
- -
.
-7

:
-1 .

-2 .
86

87


-1 :
-1
1997.

-2 .2002
-3 2003.
-4

2002.

-5 :
, . 1999

-6
. 2000

-7
15 13

. 2002

-8

.2004 ,

-9 :
)(
. 2006

-10

2009

88

- 11 :
: .2004

-12

.2002

-13 , , :
)( ,

2001

-14 , ,,

)(
.1999

-15 , ,

, .2004

-16 . :

.2003

-17

2007.

- 18 :
. ) (

: .2001

-19 :
.2003

- 20
2007.
-21

.2000

-22
"" .2006

89

 -23 :
15 .2003

-24
2005

-25
, ) (3 2007

-26

2006.

-27

. 2003

- 28
.2000

-29

. 2005

-30

. 2006

-31 :
.2003

-32

. - .2006
http://www.icrs-iraq.org/ar/r+s/1-1-3.htm:

-33
.2007-10-3
-34 ) (POGAR
.

90

-35 , ,
, , .1999

-36

9-8

2007.

-37
- )(2005/6/23-21

-38

.2009

-39

28 . 2007

-40 , , 2005.
-41

: :29 )( 2006

-42 , ,
, 2008.

-43

8-4 2008.

-44
.

-45 )( "
.2007

-46 :

2002.

91

 : -47
, : ) :

.(2004

48http://www.unescap.org/pdd/prs/ProjectActivities/Ongoing/g
g/governance.as
49http://www.un.org/arabic/millenniumgoals/news.shtml
50http://www.usaid.gov/ourwork/democrac_and_governance/te
chnical-areas/governance/-

-2
1. Amundsen, Inge. Political Corruption. Norway: AntiCorruption Resource Centre, 2006.
2. Axtmann, Roland. The State of the State: The Model of
the

Modern

State

and

Its

Contemporary

Transformation. International Political Science Review

2004; 25-3; 259-279.
3. Better Governance for Development in the Middle East
and

North

Africa:

Enhancing

Inclusiveness

and

Accountability. Washington DC: World Bank Group,

2003.
4. Boyer, William W. Political Science and the 21st
Century: From Government to Governance. Political
92

Science and Politics, Vol. 23, No. 1 (Mar., 1990), pp. 50-54.
5. Brinkerhoff, Derick W. and Jennifer M. Brinkerhoff.
Governance Reforms and Failed States: Challenges and
Implications. International Review of Administrative
Sciences 2002; 68; 511-531.
6. Chandhoke, Neera Governance and the Pluralisation of
the State: Implications for Democratic Citizenship.
Economic and Political Weekly July 2003; 38-28; 29572968.
7. Franck, Thomas M. The Emerging Right to Democratic
Governance. The American Journal of International Law,
Vol. 86, No. 1 (Jan., 1992), pp. 46-91.
8. Gender Equality in Good Governance. Denmark: Danida,
2008
9. Good Governance: The IMF Role. 1997.
10. Governance for the Future: Democracy and Development
in the Least Developed Countries. New York: UNDP/UNOHRLLS, 2006.
11. Good Governance Practices For Rights. Office Of The
United Nations High Commissioner For Human Rights
(UNHCR). Geneva, 2007.
12. Governance For The Millennium Development GOALS:
Core Issues and Good Practices. Vienna: UN, 2007.
93

13. Guhan, S. World Bank on Governance: A Critique.

Economic and Political Weekly Jan. 1998; 33-4; 185187+189-190.
14. Human Development Report 1993. UNDP
15. Human Development Report 1997. UNDP
16. Human Development Report 2002. UNDP
17. Governance for the Future: Democracy and Development
in the Least Developed Countries. UNDP 2006.
18. Johnson Isbelle, Redefining the Concept of Governance
Canada Canadian International Development Agency
1997
19. Jayal, Niraja Gopal. The Governance Agenda: Making
Democratic Development Dispensable. Economic and
Political Weekly Feb. 1997; 32-8; 407-412.
20. Kaufmann, Daniel, Aart Kraay, and Massimo Mastruzzi.
Governance Matters VI: Aggregate and Individual
Governance Indicators 19962006. World Bank Policy
Research Working Paper 4280, July 2007.
21. Leftwich,

Adrian.

Governance,

Democracy

and

Development in the Third World. Third World

Quarterly, 1993, Vol. 14, No. 3, 605-624.
22. Nanda, Ved P. The "Good Governance" Concept
Revisited. The ANNALS of the American Academy of
94

Political and Social Science 2006; 603; 269-283.

23. Participatory Development and Good Governance Development

Co-operation

Organization

for

Guidelines

Economic

Series

Cooperation

and

Development Paris 1995

24.

Weiss, Thomas G. Governance, Good Governance and

Global Governance: Conceptual and Actual Challenges.

Third World Quarterly, Vol. 21, No. 5 (Oct., 2000), pp. 795814.

95