Professional Documents
Culture Documents
: /
. : .2008
..
978 - 977 - 452 - 112-6
.1 732-808 .2 . -- .3 .
-- . . . . . . - 1944
907.202
2008359423
2008 .
. :
.
.
.
. .138 .
21526 . secretariat@bibalex.org :
1000
5
9
47
71
91
123
157
185
186
188
194
Unesco World Social Science Report
1999
-
.
- -
.
- - - -
-
.
7-5 -2006 -
.
-
-
.
.
.
- -
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. R. Altamira
- :
()1
:
.
- -
.
.
()1
.
.
.
:
( )2
.
92 (711) .
(
( ) 2
an un .
... :
( ) 7-5
.2006
12
) .
.
( .)3
. .
732 ( 1332)
749
( .)4
748 .
.
( )3 .
()4 :
2006 .9
" "
13
752
.
756
( )
.
759 .
760 . 764
759 761
.
-
- .
- -
.
14
( )5
( .)6
-
- .
( )
.
.
.
() 5 :
7-5 .2006
( ) 6
8280
.
" "
15
.
.
772
.
772 . 12 774
. 774
.
.
776 .
.
776.
16
.
779
780
.
.
784 1382/ .
. - -
....
.
(.)7
( )7
.
" "
17
.
...
.
787()8
. .
7891387/
791
801 803
8031400/ .
.
( ) .249
( )8 :
18
.
( .)9
804
808 1406/ . (
)(.)10
784 801
.
808
24 26
24 .
( )9 .
( )10 27/11
" "
19
.
.
. ( )11
-
-
.
.
.
2006/13-11
( )11
20
.
.
:
.
.
-
- .
... .
( .)12
.
.
- . ( .)13
( )12
. :
.
( )13
.161/1
" "
21
( .)14
.
( )15 .
- -
( )16 .
-
( )17 .
.
-
-
.
.
.
.
( ) 14 . 164/1
( )15 . 164/1
()16 ()
. 160/1
( )17
. 135
22
( )
( .)18 .
.
(.)19
( .)20
( .)21
.
( )22
.
.
( .)23
( )18 ( 4.6) 60 120 .
: 126-125
( )19 . 196-95
( )20 .230-1
( )21 .153-1
( )22 .
.
( )23
.
" "
23
( .)24
7501349/ :
. :
()25
7001300/( )26
( )27
. ( )
( .)28
7561355/ :
()24 (
.)141-137
( )25 .195-4
( )26 .164-1
( )27 .169-1
( )28 .202 -4
24
( .)29
. ( .)30
.
.
( .)31 .
( .)32
( .)33
:
()34
( )29 .202-4
( )30 .204-4
( )31 .230-4
( )32 .372-371
( )33 .55
( )34 .57
" "
25
.
( .)35 (.)36
( .)37
( .)38
.)39( ...
.)40(...
: ...
.)41(...
( )42
()35 ()
47 .
( )36 .70
( )37 .49
( )38 .52-51 20
( )39 22 .
( )40 .40
( )41 .43
( )42 . 72
26
( .)43
.
(.)44
.
.
( .)45
.
()
( .)46
( .)47
.
( )43 .256 242 218
( )44 .218-217
( )45 .194-1
( )46 .195-1
( )47 .197-196
" "
27
( )48 ( .)49
( .)50
(.)51
.
(.)52
.
.
.
( .)53
( .)54
( ) ( .)55
.
( )48 .
( )49 .190-4
( )50 .184-4
( )51 .93-2
( )52 184-4 .
( )53 .160-2
( )54 .256 242 218
( )55 .
28
-
-
.
( .)56
Frescobaldi 1384
.. ( .)57
.
Frescobaldi (.)58
.
( )56 1.232
( )57 .1
( )58 .
" "
29
.
.
... .
.
( / ) .
.
.
.
.
.
. - -
30
(.)59
- -
.
.
.
.
.
( )60
(.)61
( .)62
.
()59
7-5 .2006
( )60 1421 .
( )61 1970 .182
()62 :
2004 .200-189
" "
31
( )63
....
( )64 ( -.)65
.
.
.
( )66
7001300/ .
( .)67
(7341333/) .
.
(.)68
( )63 .541
()64
.1965
( )65 )138( 1989 .90
( )66 .16-1
( )67 .168
( )68 .168-1
32
( 7501349/)
( 7501349 /)
( 7501349/ )(.)69
. (7421342 /)
( .)70
( .)71
( )72 .
(.)73
7391338 / .
( .)74
(.)75
( )69 . 197-4
( )70 .168-1
( )71 . 187-169/1
( )72 . 184-1
( )73 . 169-1
( )74 . 93-2
( )75 .85
" "
33
.
()
( )76
( .)77
( )Sale ( .)78 ()Chella
( .)79
6771278/
.
( .)80
(.)81
.
( )76 .202- 4
( )77 47 .
( )78 .42
( )79 .40
( )80 .4198
( )81 / 1973
.697-684-3 399-2
34
( .)82
( )83
( .)84
( )85
.
.
( )86
6671268/ . (:)87
( )82 () ()
( 372-371 : )1 (.378-374 : )2
( )83 .72
( )84 .67-66 63-62
( )85 . 199
( )86 1.32-30
()87
7-5 .2006
" "
35
(941-6251534-1228/) ( )
7251324 /) (747-718-1318/
1346)
(750-7311348-1331/)
. (.)88
. (924-6331518-1236/) .
(.)89
(957-591 1550-1195) ( )90
- -
( .)91
.
( )88 .187 - 186
()89
1986 .20
()90 2
1991 .17
( )91 1980 . 22
36
.
(731-7101331-1310/)
( .)92
...
.)93(...
.
.
:
.)94(...
( .)95
:
.)96(...
( )92 .157-1
( )93 .184-1
( )94 .192
( )95 .218
( )96 .186-1
" "
37
-
- .
( )97
()
.
.
(.)98
.
-
.
.
( )99
( )97 72 64-60 58 .184 52
( )98 . 158-157/1
( )99 .164
38
( .)100 ( )101
( .)102
/
( )103 :
. .
(.)104
()105
( )106
.
" "
39
( )107
(.)108
. : ( .)109
.
( .)110
.
.
.
( )107 .
( )108 . 591
( )109 . 161/1
( )110 2.24
40
( )
.
.
.
(.)111
.
7731371/ .
.
/803 1400
!
Will Durant
...
( .)112
( )111 .234
( )112 26 .74-47
" "
41
.
.
.
.
42
.
606
( )113 .
.
672
( .)114
...
.
.
( )113 .
()114 1323
.3-2
" "
43
.
.
.
(.)115
(.)116
- -
.
( )115 .6-3
( )116 .25-12
44
...
.
.
.
.
.
. .
( .)117
(.)118
( )117 .33-29
( )118 ( ) .
" "
45
.
( .)119
803 .
(.)120
.
.
.
( )
( )119 2006 .11-9
( )120 .240-239
46
672 1272/
( )121
( )Crecy 1346
.
.
( )121 7.188
....
... ...
.
.
285
.
50
.
.
.
.
.
.
( )1
.
( )2
:
( )1
7-5 .2006
( )2 .69
51
: .
:
(.)3
.
)4(.
.
.
.
.
.
. : ....
...
.17
( )3
( )4 .32
52
.
.
.
:
....
....
....
.... .
( .)5
.
-
:
-1 - -
.
.
.19
( )5
53
-2
- -
.
.
-3
.
:
.
(.)5
:
-1
.
:
-
.
( )6 72/70
54
-
.
(.)7
-2
.
- . .
:
... .
.
( )7 .5
55
.
...
(.)8
( .)9
( .)10 -
(.)11
.
( .)12 :
()
( )8 ...
7-5 .2006
( )9 .44
( )10 .515
( ) 11 .. .
( ) 12 .515
56
( .)13
( .)14
.
.
.
( .)15
.
.
(.)16
( )17
.
()13
()14
()15
()16
()17
.114/258
.116
.39
.40
.79/45/331/303/52/49/44/43/39
57
( .)18
( .)19
( .)20
.
( .)21
.
( )22
( .)23
.
( )18 .87
( )19 .114/111
( )20 .414
( )21 .52-51
( )22 2006 .33
( )23 . 40
58
....
.
- -
.
.
( )
.
- -
:
.
.
.
.
59
... .
. .
!
.
( .)24
.
( .)25
.
.
( )24 : 522-487
.1988
( )25 .5
60
(.)26
( .)27
}
{ ( )706 : 89
. (.)28
.
.
.
.
( )26 326-265
.1976
( )27 .14-13
( )28 .15-14
61
( )29
.
- .
.
.
.
.
.
.
( )29 46-44
62
.
.
( .)30
. .
.
(.)31
.
.
.
.
( ) ( )
( ) . .
(.)32
. .
( )30 .23
( )31 .32
( )32 .28
63
... .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
( .)33 (
)
. :
-1 ( )
.
-2
.
( )33 .35
64
-3
.
.
)34(.
.
.
.
.
. .
- - .
.
.
( )34 .52-46
65
.
.
.
(.)35
.
.
.
.
.
.
66
. :
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
:
67
-1
.
.
.
-2
... .
.
.
.
-3
( )1908 .
( - -
)
.
.
.
(
68
)
.
.
.
() ( )
.
.
. .
.
.
69
( .)37
(.)38
( )37 .
( )38 .
...
... . .
...
.
.
31/29.
. Toynbee
(.)1
()1
74
.
.
(.)2
.
( )2 .60-59
:
-
-
. .
-
-
.
:
.
.
75
76
.
- -
()
.
(.)3
.
.
.
( )3 .665
77
(
) .polis
.
()4
.
. .
(.)5
Race
-
.
-
-
( )4 : .278-223
()5
7- 5 .2006
78
.
....
( .)6
(.)7
( .)8
:
.
.
.
.
( )6 .353
( )7 .33-29
( ) 8 .7-5
( )
.
(.)9
.
.
)(.)10
:
.
( )9 .76-59
( .J.H. Abraham Thee Origins and Growth of Sociology London, 1973, p. 30 )10
79
80
.
(.)11
:
:
.
(.)12
.
( )11 : / 1970 .306/304
( )12 .253
81
...
(.)13
( )
(
) ( ) ( )
(.)14
(.)15
( )16
( )13 :
1965 .61
( )14
7-5 .2006
( )15 .84-79
( )16 .88-86
82
( .)17
( .)18 .
.
.
( .)19
....
(.)20
- :
( )17 .266
( )18 .129/128
( )19 / 1988 .10
( )20 .117
.
.
(.)21
.
.
.
( )22
( .)23
(.)24
( )21 4 .286-285
( )22 .
( )23 .4
( )24 .27
83
84
.
.
( .)25 - -
.
(.)26
( )25 .161
( )26
1947 .92
.
.
.
( .)27
:
.
.
.
.
.
( )27 : .
85
86
.
( ).
-
-
.
.
:
(.)28
( )28 .
.
( .)29
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
(.)30
.
.
( )29 .44-41
( )30 .
87
88
(.)31
.
.
( )
() -
- .
.
( )31 .45
89
. ( .)32
.
.
( .)33
.
. .
- -
.
:
( )32 : 1975 .182/181
()33
1965 .209
90
.
.
.
. -
-
.
.
94
.
.
.
- -
.
(.)1
....
(.)2
.
( )1 66/63
( )2 .39
.
.
:
:
( ).
: (
).
: /.
: : .
.
-
95
96
( .)3
-
.
- -
.
.
- -
.
.
( )3 - .143
97
:
.
.
.
/
(.)4
- -
:
.
.
-
-
.
( )4 ( :
( 1997 )27 51 .
98
(
) (
) .
.
- .
.
.
.
99
.
( )
()
(
) (
)
.
(.)5
()5
.
.
. -1883 Humanit Civilise
Humanit Barbare Humanit Sauvage Franz Von Liszt
Volkerrecht 1898 Civilises : Civilises -Simi Non- Civilizes
. :
7-5 .2006
100
- -
-
-
( ).
:
-
( -)6 .
:
( )6
.
101
:
( )
() (//)
.
.
.
.
.
102
.
(.)7
:
( )8
.
:
( )7 :
.112
()8
.
.
.
103
( .)9
:
.
:
:
.
:
:
.
:
-1 : .
-2 :
.
-3 :
.
(:)10
( )9 :
7 .2006
( )10 .231
104
()1
()1
/
/
()2
105
:
.
.
.
.
.
:
( )1
106
( )2
( - )
-
- .
( )3
:
.
: .
(
) (
) (
)( .)11
.
()11 :
. .
.
. .
107
.
( )4 -
-
-
.
.
.
:
.
.
.
- - (.)12
()12 162
.
. =
108
( .)13
(.)14
= .
.
.
.
( )13
.
()14
-
- .
.
:
. .
.
.
:
.
. = .
109
: ()15
(.)16
.
(.)17
.
.:
( : 1319
45 . 47 ( : 1977
.192
( )15 .
( )16 .120
()17
. :
: .1982
( : . )1981
8 29 / 1987 .178-160
110
( /
/) ( / //
/ / / )
.
111
.
( - - - - -
) . -
-
- - .
-
.
( ) ( )
.
(.)18
( )18 120
112
113
(.)19
-
-
.
( /)
/ .
.
()19
.
.
.
114
(-- -)
- -
.
( ) ( )
.
() .
.
: ()
( )
115
(.)20
....
.
}:
{ .
. .
(:)21
()20 : .
.
()21 :
.
116
-1 (
) ( )
( ).
( /)
(/)
()22
()23
()24
()25
(/)
(//)
()26
()22 : :
/// / / / //
.
( )23 .
( )24 .
()25
.
( )26 .
117
-2
.
-3 :/
/.
.
( ) (
)(.)27
( ) (
)
.
()27
.
.
- .
}
{.
118
.
....
....
.
( .)
...
. ....
.
.
:
: (= )
.
.
()
.
.... ()
.
:
.
.... .
119
:
.... ....
.....
.....
.....
.
( .)28
(.)29
( )28 : :
1 1 / 1981.30
( )29 . 30
120
.
( .)30
(.)31
(.)32
( )30 ( )
() :
(( )31 : ) 2004 .80-79
( )31 .8
()32 :
4 13 1987 .67-66
121
(.)33
.
:
( )34
(.)35
( )33 .67
()34
.
( )35 .43
.
" " .
.
.
.
126
" "
-
- (.)1
. -
.
Bouthoul
( )2
" " ""
. ""
""
.
7891387/ .
( )1
7- 5 .2006
( )2 .
127
"
( ) ()
".
.
"
" .
:
.
.
.
(.)3
-
-
()3
7-5 .2006
128
.
"
"
. ()
" " ( )
" " ( )( )4
" " (.)5
()4 : ( )
.1995 .
()5 :
6 1996 . .109 -69
129
. :
:
-
. --
" " - -
"" "" .
(
)
" ( )6
( ) (
) .
.
""
" "
()6 : () () :
.2004
130
.
.
" "
.
.
:
" :
".
" :
".
" :
".
" :
".
131
" :
".
( )7
:
.
" " .
: " "
" ".
(.)8
( ) 7
7- 5 .2006
( )8 2004.14
132
" "
.
-
- " "
( ) .
.
" "
(.)9
( )9 : - ( )1992
.215-212
133
(.)10
.
(.)11
.
( )10 .267 -265
( )11 .271-268
134
.
:
(.)12
:
. .
.
120 :100
.
.
" ".
. - -
.
. .
. - (.)13
( )12 .145
( )13 .
135
.
.
.
.
" "
"" " "
.
"
".. (
) "( )14
"
( )14 : .215-212
136
"
" "
"
"
:
(.)15
" " "
-
" . " " "
" .
. " "
(.)16
:
: .
: .
: .
:
.
( )15 .
( )16
137
.
.
.
" "
.
-
-
.
" " : :
: .
:
.
138
(.)17
.
""
. ""
. " "
""
.
""
.
:
( Joseph S. Nye, Jr. ,the Americas soft power: why Washington should worry, Foreign Affairs, Vol. )17
.39-83, May, June 2004, p. 35
139
.
.
.
De mas latrie
"" "" ""( )18
.
() .
.
""
(Le compte de mas latrie: relation et commerce de l'Afrique septentrionale avec les nation cetiennes )18
age, 1886, p. 274- 275.
140
. "" ""
.
" "
!!
""
!..
.
.
!
- -
... ...
.
.
( )
.
141
"" (.)19
:
:
.
:
( .)...
.
(
) .
( ).
.
( )19 .
142
( )
(
).
.
-
.
(:)20
.
(
) .
.
()20 1416 50
.100-69
143
.
- (
)
( )
.
.
.
( -)21
"" .
.
.
()22
:
( )21 .94
()22 :
.2006
144
:
.
: .
: .
.
:
:
.
.
" " :
-1
:
: ( )
:
:
.
145
.
: " "
.
: :
( )
.
-2
.
(
)
.
.
-3 .
(()23 ) -
()23 . .
1996 .164 -163
146
.
.
( .)24
.
.
" ."..
.
( : )
.
.
( )25
.
( )
.
( )24
1998 .84
()25 :
: .. .
147
" "
.
-4
.
-
- .
(
) .
" " .
" "
.
"
" ( )
.
""
.
148
:
" "
-
" " " " ""
/
.
""
- "" .
/ / . -
. " "
( /
/)( .)26 "-
"( )27 " "
( Alexander Wendt: : Social theory of International Politics, Cambridge University Press, 1999. PP. )26
.44-22
(.Robert Adams: A new age of International Relations, International Affairs, Vo. 67, No. 3, 1991 ) 27
149
.
.
- -
" "
" " .
( )28
:
( )
" "
.
" " Global Society
.
( )29 -
(Akbar Ahmed: Ibn Khaldun's Understanding of civilizations and the dilemmas of Islam and the)28
.4-West today, Middle East Journal, Vo. 56, No. 1, Winter 2002, PP. 20
()29
Seifudein Adem Hussein and Ali A. Mazrui: A postmodern Ibn Khaldun, Journal of Muslim
.Minority Affairs, Vo. 23, No. 1, April 2003, PP. 127- 145
150
.
.
" "
- -
.
.
.
" " - -
.
( )
- -
"
"
.
151
-
() :
.
.
.
.
(
).
( ) (
).
.
(:)30
-1
.
( )30 196-47
152
-2 .
-3 ()
.
-4 .
-5
.
-6 : / :
(
).
-7
( ) :
"" .
-8 ( )
( ) ( ).
-9 " "
. : /
.
-10 :
.
-11 ( ) .
153
-12 :
:
. :
.
-13
.
" " .
:
"" (
)
. :
(
) 600
( ) (
)
154
.
( )
. ()
.
.
.
.
.
(
) -
. (
)
.
155
- -
:
.
-
.
. ""
)..
.
)
(
/ /
.
norms Values
156
.
"
"
" " .
- -
() (
+ + )... .
() -
() -
.
( )
.
.
Arnold Toynbee
1930 N.SHMIDT
1806 De Sacy.
!.
.
1636 ( )1
()1 1987 32
.1
160
1825 Schulz
:
.
.
Quatremer .1858
161
- - De Slane
1862 .1868
.
.2005:1910
.
.17
.
800
(.)2
.
(Maria J. Viguera Molins Ibn Khaldun his Universality, an International Perspective, Bibliotheca)2
Alexandrina 5- 7 December 2006
162
.
.
(.)3
.
( )
.
.
.
..
(.)4
( )3 1961253
()4
.2006/2005
163
- . :
-1
Rosenthal Von Kremer Lewine
G.Bouthoul Gabrieli R.Maunier
.
-2
Carra de Vaux De Boer
G.Richter
Cl, Huart Nicholson
G.Faure-Bigue .
-3
R.Flint
F.L. Vard
Ch.Rappaport .
164
.
.
Gumplovitz
Gumplovitz
....
....
1914
..
.
Colosio
(.)5
( )5 .202 200
165
F.L. Vard
De
Boer
(.)6
- -
.
.
:
(.)7
( )6 .204
()7 18-13 2006
14-12 2006 16
2006
11-9 2006
166
.
.
( ) . - -
- -
.
= 16-15 2006
4-3 2006 28 2006
22-20 2006
5-3
7-5 2006.
167
.
.
.
.
( )8
...
( )8
7-5 .2006
168
(.)9
( )10 ( )11
( )12 ()13
( )9 24 11/
1988 .50
()10 ( :
)1992 :
: 37-11
34
( )
.
.
.
.
()11
.
()12
15 58 1998 .56-37 :
15 3 1987 .187-171
()13 : :
169
.
:
( )14
(.)15
.1984 ( /
: )1983
( )25 1994
.
()14
.
( )15 .43
170
...
( )16
.
.
... ...
.
()16
.1979 .1984 .
.1990
.1961
. 1992 .1992
. 1974
.1988 .1997
.1996
.1952 17 6
/ 1981 .47-19
10 37 1990 .126-92
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
174
.
.
.
( )1 .
.
( .)2
(.)3
.
( )1 : 1994 .110/109
( )2 : .320
( )3 .
175
.
.
.
.
: ....
... .
.
.
.
.
:
....
....
....
.... .
176
:
.
.
.
.
.
- -
.
177
.
()
.
De Boer
.
.
.
.
178
.
.
.
.
.
.
...
(.)4
.
( )4 1988 .70/39
179
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
....
.
180
( )
- -
(.)5
.
.
.
.
( )
()5 ( ) 1
.119
181
.
14
.
-
.
19
.
.
182
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
183
:
(
)
( ) .
.
.
.
.
185
.
.
.
.
.
.
186 -
1332 .1406
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
187
.
.
.
.
188 -
.
.
.
. .
- -
.
.
.
.
189
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
190 -
.
.
.
-
.
.
: :
.
191
.
.
.
.
192 -
.
.
- -
.
.
.
.
193
.
-
. .
194 -
.1 .
.1987
.2 /
.3 .
.
.4 . .
.1996
.5 .2
.6
.1979
.7 24
11 .1988
.8 :
( )31 .2004
.9
.10
/.1983
195
.11
/.1983
.12 :
7 .2006
.13 :
.
.14 :
15 3 .1987
.15 ( 14)
7-5
.2006
.16 () ( )
.
.17 .
.18
.
.19
7-5 .20
.20
.1992
196 -
.21 :
2 .
.22 .2006
.23
7-5 .2006
.24
.1988
.25 )138( .
.26 .
.27 .1980
.28 :
.
.29 .2006
.30 .
.31
.
.32 .1
.33
.1992
.34 (. )
197
.35 :
.2006
.36 15
58 .
.37 50
1416 .
.38 1320 /
.11960
.39 .2006
.40 / .
.41
.1998
.42 .
.43 /
.1973
.44
7-5 .2006
.45 :
.
198 -
.46 1
.1995
.47
.1986
.48 :
1 1 1981.
.49
.1988
.50 :
4 13 .1987
.51
.2006
.52
7-5 .2006
.53 .
.54 :
2.1973
.55 .
.56
.2004
199
.57
.2006/2005
.58 .1970
.59
.
.60 :
.
.61 .
.62 : ..
.1992
.63 -.
.64 - .2
.65 :
.1984
.66 ( )1
/.
.67
1421 .
.68 :
7-5 .2006
200 -
.69 :
7-5 .2006
.70
( )27.1997
.71
7-5 .2006
.72 :
6 .1996
.73
7-5
.2006
.74 :
.2004
.75 .1984
.76 :
.1970
.77 26 .
.78 - /
.2007
201
1. Alexander Wendt, Social theory of International Politics, Cambridge
University press 1999.
2. Akbar Ahmed, Ibn Khaldun's Understanding of civilizations and the dilemmas
of Islam and the West today Middle East Journal, Vo. 56 No. 1 winter 2002.
3. Anna Akasoy, Reading Ibn Khaldun in the Age of Post-Orientalism, an
International Perspective, Bibliotheca Alexandrina, 57- December 2006.
4. Anne Wolff, The View of European Travelers on Arab/Islamic Civilization
during Ibn Khaldun's Age, Ibn Khaldun, An International Perspective,
Bibliotheca Alexandrina, 57- December 2006.
5. Charles E. Butterworth, Ibn Khaldun and the Political Regime of the
Philosophers, Ibn Khaldun, an International Perspective, Bibliotheca
Alexandrina, 57- December 2006.
6. Dimitry Ghutas, The Development of the Concept of civilization and
Meaning of Umran in Ibn Khaldun, An International Perspective, Bibliotheca
Alexandrina, 57- December 2006.
7. Gaston Bouthoul, IBN KHALDUN SAPHLASOPHIE SOCIAL.
8. Joseph S. Nye, Jr., The of Americas soft power: why Washington should
worry, foreign Affairs, Vol. 83, May, June 2004.
9. Maria J. Viguera Molins, Ibn Khaldun his Universality, an International
Perspective, Bibliotheca Alexandrina, 57- December 2006.
10. Robert Adams, Affairs, Vo. 67, No. 3, 1991.
11. Seifudein Adem Hussein: Ali A. Mazrui, A postmodern Ibn Khaldun, Journal
of Muslim Minority Affairs, Vo. 23, No. 1, April 2003.
12. Le compte de mas latrie: relation et commerce de l'Afrique septentrionale avec
les nation cetiennes age, 1886.