MINUTES OF TECHNICAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 19/08/2013 FOR TENDER MEDICINE IN BULK.

A technical evaluation committee meeting was held on 19/08/2013 at 10:00 A M in the committee room of this institution. Following attended the meeting: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Prof. Dr. Bilal Zakariyah Khan Prof. Dr. Nadeem Hayyat Mallick Dr. Zafar Tufail Dr. Irfan Azmat Ullah Dr. Ahmad Nauman Mr. Shaheen Iqbal

Following firms were rejected / disqualified because their bids were not responsive. M/s. Well & Well. M/s. Valor Pharmaceuticals M/s. Medera Pharmaceuticals M/s. Allied Distributors M/s. SurgE Laboratories M/s. PharmaWise Labs Pvt. Ltd, M/s. Medi Mark Pharmacuticals M/s. Intra Health M/s. Rasco Pharma M/s. Tread Pharmaceuticals Pakistan M/s. Mega Pharmaceuticals M/s. Maple Pharmacuticals M/s. Harmann Pharmaceuticals Technical evaluation committee discussed the agenda items in detail and after due deliberation agreed with the opinion of end user. Keeping in view, the previous crisis of contaminated drugs causing death of patients who took the medicine from this hospital, the end user accepted the quality brands and not recommend the other brands on following grounds: 1. Not Good Brand with unreliable efficacy 2. No Past Experience The detail of the recommendations / decisions are depicted as under: S.# 1 MEDICINE NAME. Cap. Amoxicillin Blister Pack of 100 STRENG TH 500 mg NAME OF BRANDS & COMPANIES Ospamox, Novartis, Pakistan RECOMMENDATIO NS Accepted

Cap. Omeprazole Blister Pack of 14

20 mg

Glucoprotein 2B3A Inhibitors (Abiximab / Tirofiban HCl / Eptifibitide) Individually Pack Inhail. Isoflourane Individually Packed

Amoxil, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Omrel 20 mg Well & Well, Pakistan Zemnol, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Sante, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Lozal, Novartis, Pakistan Xerosec, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Zampra, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Omepraval, Valor Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Amazole, Medera, Pakistan Omesec, Brookes Pharma, Pakistan Valuprazol, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Risek, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Aggrastat

Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

100ml

10

Inj. (Piperacillin + Tazobactum) Individually Packed with Diluent Inj. (Piperacillin + Tazobactum) Individually Packed with Diluent Inj. Amikacin, Individual Pack, Liquid Form Inj. Ampicillin 250 + Cloxacillin 250 mg, Individually Pack Inj. Atracurium Besylate Pack of 5

4.5 gm

Restane, Piramal Critical Care Inc., USA Forane, Aseica Queen Borough Ltd., UK Tanzo, BOSCH, Pakistan

Rejected Accepted Accepted

2.25 gm

Tanzo, BOSCH, Pakistan

Accepted

500mg

13

500mg

Amikacin, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Amikin, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Zampilox, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Accepted Accepted Accepted

14

5 ml

Relaxtron, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Atrelax, Abbott, Pakistan Acuron, Brookes, Pakistan Tracrium, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan

Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted

20

Inj. Cefoperazone & Sulbactam Individual Packed with Diluent Inj. Ceftriaxone individualy Packed with Diluent

2 Gm

Sulzone, Suzhou Dawnrays Pharmacuticals, China Cebac, BOSCH, Pakistan Xtracef, Surge Lab, Pakistan Titan, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Sergifex, Surge Lab, Pakistan(with WFI without tray) Aventriax, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Zeftrox IV, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Traxef, Korea Pharma Co, Korea Ryxon, Brookes, Pakistan Stericipro with set FDL Bacip, Surge Lab, Pakistan(without drip set and cartoon) Gen-Sipro, Brookes, Pakistan Cipesta, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Calamox, BOSCH, Pakistan Amoxiclave, Novartis, Pakistan Zamoclav, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan(with WFI) Iopamiro, 370/50 ml, Bracco, Italy Ultravist 370, Medipharm, Pakistan Iopamiro, 370/50 ml, Bracco, Italy Ultravist 370, Medipharm, Pakistan Dextrose 25 %, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Rejected

21

1Gm

Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected

22

Inj. Ciprofloxacin with I.V Set (Registered) & Hanger

200mg

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

23

Inj. Clavulanic Acid 200mg + Amoxycillin 1000 mg

1.2 gm

24

Inj. Contrast Medium Non Ionic Individual Pack Inj. Contrast Medium Non Ionic Individual Pack Inj. Dextrose Water 25%

50 ml

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

25

100 ml

26

20 / 25 ml

27

Inj. Dextrose Water 5% With Set (Registered) Inj. Dobutamine

1000 ml

Sterifluid 5% with set FDL

Accepted

32

250mg / 5 ml

Myungmoon, Myunmoon Pharm Co.Seoul Korea Dobamine, Korea Pharma Co, Korea Dobuject, Primex Pharmaceuticals Oy, Finland

Rejected Accepted

33

Inj. Dopamine

200mg / 5 ml

Inopan, Myunmoon Pharm Co.Seoul Korea

34

Inj. Frusimide Pack of 50

20 mg

35

36

Inj. Modified Fluid Gelatin / Polygeline with IV Set (Registered) Inj. Gentamycin Pack of 25

500 ml

Laxide, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Lasix, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Haemaccel, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

Rejected Accepted Accepted

80 mg / 2 ml

Genxat, Surge Lab, Pakistan

Re-Tender

37

Inj. Hartman Solution with IV set (Registered) Inj. Heparine

1000 ml

Sterifluid RL with set FDL

Accepted

38

40

Inj. Human Insuline NPh Individually Packed Inj. Human Insuline Regular Individually Packed Inj. Hydrocortisone Sod. Succinate Individually Packed Inj. Isosorbide Dinitrate Pack of 10

Heparine Sodium, B. Braun, Germany Multiparin, Bio Pharma, UK Heparotex, Rotexmedica, Germany 100 iu / ml Insuman Basal, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

5000 iu / ml

Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted

41

100 iu / ml Insuman Rapid, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

Accepted

42

250 mg

Hydro Sod. Suc., Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Accepted

43

10 mg / ml

Isoket, Schwarz, Germany Sorbid, Myunmoon Pharm Co.Seoul Korea Sterilevo with set FDL Tavanic, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Gen-Levo, Brookes, Pakistan Leflox, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Lidoject, Surge Lab, Pakistan

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Re-Tender

45

Inj. Levofloxacin with IV Set (Registered) & Hanger

500 mg

47

Inj. Lignocaine 2% HCl Pack of 50

10 ml

49

Inj. Mannitol 20 % with IV Set (Registrered) Inj. Dextrose 5% with IV Set (registered) Inj. Meropenem Pack of 10

500 ml

Steriflutol 20% with set FDL

Accepted

50

1000 ml

Sterifluid 5% with set FDL

Accepted

51

500 mg

Penro, BOSCH, Pakistan Meronem, ICI, Italy

Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected

52

Inj. Metclopramide Pack of 10

5 mg / ml

Clotide, Surge Lab, Pakistan Maxolon, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Merol, ATCO, Pakistan Lopresor, Novartis, Pakistan

53

Inj. Metoprolol Pack of 5

5 mg / m5 ml

54

Inj. Metronidazole with IV Set (Registered) & Hanger

100 ml

55

Inj. Midazolam Pack of 10

5 mg / 5 ml

Sterimet with set FDL Flazol, BOSCH, Pakistan Intobix, Surge Lab, Pakistan(without drip set and cartoon) Flagyl, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan(with out set) Idazol, BOSCH, Pakistan Hypozam, Brookes, Pakistan

Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected

56

Inj. Nor Adrenaline Pack of 10

4 mg / ml

57

Inj. Normal Saline 0.9% with IV Set (Registered) Inj. Normal Saline 0.9% with IV Set (Registered) Inj. Omeperazol Individually Packed

1000 ml

Norepine,(sterop lab belgium). Ontech Corporation, Pakistan Nor-Adrine, ATCO, Pakistan Sterifluid NS with set FDL

Accepted Accepted

58

100 ml

Sterifluid NS with set FDL

Accepted

59

40 mg

Loprot, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Omezol, BOSCH, Pakistan Risek, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Propofol Lipuro, B. Braun, Germany Pofol, Dongkook, Pharma Co. Korea

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected

62

Inj. Propofol 1% Pack of 5

10 mg / ml

64

Inj. Ranitidine Pack of 5

50mg / 2ml

66

Inj. Streptokinase Individually Packed

1.5 miu

Recofol, Primex Pharmaceuticals, Finland Rantin, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Peptiject, Surge Lab, Pakistan Zantac, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Dilcair - ST, BBt-Biotech GmbH, Germany

Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted

67

Inj. Teicoplamine Individually Packed

200 mg

Targocid, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

Accepted

68

Inj. Teicoplamine Individually Packed

400 mg

Targocid, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

Accepted

69

Inj. Tygacyline Pack of 10

50 mg

Tygacil, Patheon Italia, Italy

Accepted

70

Inj. Vancomycin Individually Packed

500mg

72

Nebule Ipratropium (Nebulizing Sloution)

0.00025%.

73

Soln. Hydrogen Peroxide 6%

450 ml

Hisun, Zhejiang Hisun Pharmaceuticals Co. China Vanbact, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Vinjec, BOSCH, Pakistan Vancomycin, Abbott, Pakistan Ipneb Soln, ATCO, Pakistan Tropum, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Optra, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Atem Hudrogen Peroxide, Pharmawise, Pakistan

Rejected Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Re-tender

74

Soln. Instrument Disinfactant

2 Lit / G

75

Soln. Povidone Solution 10%

450 / 500 ml

76

Soln. Propanol Hand Rub Disinfection

1000 ml

Korsolex Basic, BodeChemie, Germany Combi, Antiseptica, Germany Povine, Pharmawise, Pakistan Pyodine Soln, Brookes, Pakistan Sterillium, Bode-Chemie, Germany Manorapid, Antiseptica, Germany

Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected

77

Soln. Surface Disinfactant

4 / 5 Lit / G

78

Syp. Lactulose Individually Packed

120 ml

Kohrsolin FF, BodeChemie, Germany Descocid N, Antiseptica, Germany Sanlac, Novartis, Pakistan Duphalac, Abbott, Pakistan Lilac, Getz Pharma, Pakistan

Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

80

Tab. Amiodarone HCL Blister Pack, Pack of 30 Tab. Amlodipine, Blister Pack, Pack of 20

200 mg

Cordarone, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

81

5mg

82

Tab. Aspirin Enteric Coated, Pack of 30 Tab. Aspirn Soluble, Aluminium Strip Pack, Pack of 600 Tab. Atenolol Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 20

75 mg

Rasdipine, Rasco Pharma, Pakistan Amdipine, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Adoptin, Fynk, Pakistan Quvasc, Novartis, Pakistan Zamlo, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Megadip, Mega Pharmaceuticals, Pakistan Ascard, ATCO, Pakistan Disprin CV, Reckitt & Benckiser, Pakistan Solprin, Pharmawise, Pakistan Disprin, Reckitt & Benckiser, Pakistan Nomin, Maple, Pakistan Normitab, Nabiqasim, Pakistan konduct, Fynk, Pakistan Qunoten, Novartis, Pakistan Atenolol, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Tavist, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Colstat, Rasco Pharma, Pakistan Descol, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Stator, Fynk, Pakistan Winstor, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Colezaf, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Megavastin, Mega Pharmaceuticals, Pakistan Eravas, Medera, Pakistan Lipiget, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Eptril, Fynk, Pakistan Acetopril, Zafa

Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Rejected Rejected Rejected Rejected Accepted

83

300 mg

84

100 mg

85

Tab. Atorvastatin Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 10

20 mg

88

Tab. Captopril Bisected Blister

25 Mg

Pack, Pack of 30

Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Capoten, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Hart, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Normidilol, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Cipnolone Well & Well, Pakistan CP Zaf, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Zecip, Valor Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Gen-Sipro, Brookes, Pakistan Cip val, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Cipesta, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Platagrel, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Loclog, Maple, Pakistan Locril, Macter Intl:, Pakistan Nilcot, Rasco Pharma, Pakistan Deplat, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Plavix, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Platagg-I , Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Noclot, CCL Pharmaceuticals, Pakistan Vomilux, ATCO, Pakistan MOvedone, Medera, Pakistan Myozem, Fynk, Pakistan Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Re-Tender

89

Tab. Carvedalol Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 30 Tab. Ciprofloxacin, Blister Pack, Pack of 10

6.25 mg

90

500 mg

91

Tab. Clopidogrel Blister Pack, Pack of 20

75 mg

92

Tab. Demperidone, Blister Pack, Pack of 50 Tab. Diltiazem Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 30 Tab. Enalapril Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 30 Tab. Frusemide Blister Pack, Pack of 100

10 mg

94

60 mg

95

10 mg

Cardace, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Accepted

96

40 mg

Laxide, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Lasix, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Frusa, Medera, Pakistan Truride, Fynk, Pakistan Lasoride, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan

Rejected Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted

97

Tab. Frusemide + Amiloride Blister Pack, Pack of 30

40 mg / 5 mg

Tab. Frusemide + Spironolactone Blister Pack, Pack of 30 99 Tab. Glyceryl Trinitrate S/L, Aluminium Strip pack, Pack of 30 100 Tab. Isosorbide Mononitrate Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 20 101 Tab. Levofloxacin Blister Pack, Pack of 10

98

40 mg

Re-tender

0.5 mg

Angilingual, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Re-Tender

20 mg

Unitrate, Benson, Pakistan Monocard, Valor Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Lefnil Well & Well, Pakistan Tavanic, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Vofloza, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Lecin, Valor Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Leflox, Getz Pharma, Pakistan Lame, ATCO, Pakistan Renopril, Harmann, Pakistan Lisopril, Valor Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Goronil, Rasco Pharma, Pakistan Bepsar, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Tansar, Fynk, Pakistan Noktan, Novartis, Pakistan Zosartan-K, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Megasar, Mega Pharmaceuticals, Pakistan Merol, ATCO, Pakistan Mepresor, Novartis, Pakistan Megatop, Mega Pharmaceuticals, Pakistan Flagyl, Sanofi Aventis, Pakistan Elazyl, Pharmawise, Pakistan Anorol, Medera, Pakistan

Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected Rejected Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted Rejected Re-Tender

500 mg

102 Tab. Lisinopril Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 20 103 Tab. Losartan - K Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 20

10 mg

50 mg

104 Tab. Metoprolol Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 30

100 mg

105 Tab. Metronidazole, Blister Pack, Pack of 200 106 Tab. Orphenadrine + Paracetamol Blister Pack, Pack of 100 107 Tab. Paracetamol Blister Pack, Pack of 200

400 mg

500 mg

Febrinol, Pharmawise, Pakistan Paracetamol, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan

Rejected Accepted

108 Tab. Propranolol Blister Pack

10 mg

Calpol, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan Disprol, Reckitt & Benckiser, Pakistan Hyprol, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Inderal, ICI, India Zantac, Glaxosmith Kline, Pakistan

Accepted Accepted Accepted Rejected Accepted

109 Tab. Ranitidine Aluminium Strip Pack, Pack of 10 110 Tab. Simvastatin Bisected Blister Pack, Pack of 10

150 mg

20 mg

Simtanil, Munawar Pharma, Pakistan Simva, Nabiqasim, Pakistan Simvazaf, Zafa Pharmaceutical, Pakistan Dinemic, Maple, Pakistan Vastarel, Servier, Pakistan

Accepted Accepted Rejected Rejected Accepted Rejected Accepted

112 Tab. Trimetazidine Blister Pack, Pack of 20 113 Tab. Trimetazidine MR Blister Pack, Pack of 20

20 mg

35 mg

Dinemic SR, Maple, Pakistan Vastarel MR, Servier, Pakistan

Mr. Shaheen Iqbal Deputy Drug Controller

Dr. Ahmas Nauman Assistant Prof. of Cardiology.

Dr. Irfan Azmat Ullah Assistant Prof. of Cardiac Surgery

Dr. Zafar Tufail Associate Prof. of Cardiac Surgery

Prof. Dr. Nadeem Hayyat Mallick, Chairman Technical Evaluation Committee for Medicine in Bulk, Punjab Institute of Cardiology, Lahore

diology, Lahore