,

Federaction, 6/08

 2008
.
.
.
.

 federaction

" ". ,

: . '
. .
- federaction
,
,
'
.
,

,
. ,

( ), ,
' .
federaction.
federaction , . .
, .
T ; T, .

:
,
. " ".
federaction.
,
,
, , .
, .
,
, , ,
federaction,
.
federaction,
federaction .
, . M' , , "" .
M'
'
. ,
, .
' , .
.


:
()..................................................................................................................................................................8

1. ................................12
2. Tout va bien. 60s..........................13
3. (1965 - 1975)........................................................................................................................................................................14

1945 - 2001
. : 1945 - 1975
1. : Buzz bombs.........................................................................................................17
2. : ................................................................19
3. : 1945-1975.............................................................................................................22
. :
STAR WARS 1980-1989.
1. ; ............................................................................................................. 26
2. : .......................................................................29
3. ...................................................................................32
. : 1990 - 2001.
1. (1990-1997)...................................................................................................................................................33
2. : 1997 - 2000......................................................................................... 36
3. : ....................................................................................................................................40
. 2000 - 2007:
1. 2000 - 2006: .....................................................................................................................................................42
2. 2007-: ..............................................................................................................................................43
3. , ...................................................................44

; .
... ................................................46

. ! ..............................................................50
. ! .........................................................................................52
. : .......................................................................................54
. Ronald Reagan, ( SDI)...............................................56
. : 80s...............................................................................60

, .

.
. ,
, .

- - , . , .
- , ,
.
,
, ,
. ,
( - ) , . ,
, ,

.

,
2000, , 1945 , .
:
1945
, ;
, ,
;

. , , . ,

. ,
, ,
. ,
1945 , ,

,
.
,

 :
, .
, .
, , .
.
, , . , ,

, , , .
, : , .

.
, ; ,
,
.
, live ,
: . ,
. , ,
. : , ,
, , ... .
,
. - - . .
,
:
, , ,
, , .
. ...
.
1899.

5/08


( )

,
, . , . Laser ...

1. ,
. .

3.
.

2. ()
. .

4.
.

5. ,

.
.
9




' - - . ( "").
/ ( " ") ' . ,
, / . " ", , 1945.
, , , , .

Vannevar Bush. ( '
) ( - )
, .
Bush ( ) Eisenhower
" ". : 1940 - Bush- National Defence
Research Comitee ( ) .
- ' ' - '45. ,
"" . ,
/ :
'
( ) . , , ' .

Vannevar Bush:

"(1890- 1974).
manager,
,

memex ,
. A, ,

/
ever. T .
Thanks Vannevar!!! ( van-NEEver)

11

1.

Vannevar Bush, Science: The Endless

Frontier, 1945.
(
, ...)
. .

"" . .

Bush, ..

Vannevar Bush:
...

1940 Vannevar (- ) "" meeting .

(, ;).

12

,
/ : .
MIT, , , 4 10 , 85% '
EC (Atomic Energy Commission:
). ,
.
,
. , ,
. :
. , , New Deal

( )
. /.
Vannevar Bush
. 1945, Truman "- ".
Roosevelt " ", New
Deal. , Bush
( ' ) . , Bush / . . '90 , " Vannevar Bush" . "". ,
, Bush :
(1) - / radar, , , ,
(2) ' .
(3) ' , " ", --
' , .
, , Bush '
' ( '
) , . ' . , o Bush
(4) ' , -- '
.
(5) . ,
, :

 , ,
'
' ...1
, Bush :
,
.
' ,
.
Bush
. " Laissez- Faire" (1924)
: "" "" - -
: .
( ). " " "
"
, .
, 2.
, Bush () ' ( ).
.
"", "" ""
: - / . ( ) , , "" "/".
,
, Bush
, ""
. ,
.
2. Tout va bien.
60.
M , , Bush , .
1946 Office of Naval Research ( ) " ". , , 40% 1950 1200 200 ,
.
1950 National Science Foundation 1958 Advanced
Research Projects Agency (ARPA) . Bush: " , , ,

1938: Vannevar Bush

Lungley, Virginia.
CIA , NASA...

Vannevar Bush:
Science...
( ) '
V.Bush:

-
,



1939, - ,
, ,

. , , : . , , , , , , , , ,
-
( ..) .
.
, ,
- , ()
.
( ...)
13

Vannevar Bush:
Science...
( .)

, ' ,


.
. '
.
.

, '

. , . . ,

, '
'




,

'

...

14

, ' "3.
: 1/5 ' NSF 1/3 ' , NASA . (
). ( 1965-1975)
' 30% projects "
" . , ' .
,
, , " ", , , , . ... ' ,
. , ,

'60 - ( ) .
( ' ) ,
.
.
3. (1965 - 1975)
1961 Eisenhower .

.
:
'
... ... 3.500.000 ...

...
... ,
...
...
... , .4
Eisenhower , . , , ; Bush ( , ,
" " ) Eisenhower;

. .
( )
60's. To

 "". ( )
, -
'65- .
' . (!) , .
"", "",
.
1961- 1975, ,
.
Eisenhower ,
' Willian Fullbright.
Fullbright :
.
, . o , 45 , 5.000 , 8.000.000
( ),
10% , ' . 75 , (!)
' ...5
, , , . , ,
, ,
1965 , .
.
( ) ,
" ". (
'64) Barry Goldwater. Lindon Johnson
1969, Goldwater ' :

... '
, o
...
. .
"".
, ' . :
; ...
... ...

Bush, ..
Dwight, D. Eisenhower, "Farewell
Radio and Television Address to the
American People", January 17, 1961.
5
William Fulbright, , 13/12/1967.
3

1958
1978. : Thats Why,

15

Senator Barry Goldwater of Arizona,

Civilian Complex, 15/4/1969.

ARPA.
'
' NASA o Kennedy




"" 1965-1975.

Dwight Eisenhower 1945.

.
Barry
Goldwater,
.
(1964),

Ronald Reagan .

" ". , : ;
. , "
";
,
" ";
: '
' ; : " ;6
Goldwater ( Ronald Reagan)
The Civilian Complex. ( )
. ,
, . .
. 1965-75.
7.
, ,
, .
. ' '70s, ' '
"" . ' .
, ,
/ ' ( ). , ' , .
.

William Fulbright
1965 - 1975. 1971.
,
Fulbright, John Kerry,
2004, .
...
16


1945 - 2001

. :
1945 - 1975
1. :
Buzz bombs8
Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down?
That's not my department, says Wernher von Braun.
Tom Lehrer, Wernher von Braun (1965)
. -
-
.
""

Wernher von Brown, . ,
,
, Katyusha.
,
, -
.

, V-1, Vergeltungswaffen. ,

: 600
,
,
. "" : . , V-1 , "" . ,
: . ,

.



V-1 "buzz
bomb".
, "Vergeltungswaffen" "",
" ". ,
. V-1 .
V-2,
. V-2

: Cliff
Lethbridge, A History of Rocketry, Spaceline.org, 2000. Lawrence M. Kaplan, Missile Defence: The First Sixty
Years, www.mda.mil, 9/2006. William H. McNeill, The Pursuit of Power, University of Chicago Press, 1982.
James J. Flink, The Automobile Age, MIT Press, 1990. Harry Braverman,
: , , 2005. Sarajevo #6,
, 7/1999.

17

V-2 :
, V-2
...
V-2 , , , , , V-2
, .
... 200 300
. , .

,
135
35.000 . 70

3
. .


.
V-2
.

18

V-1,
. ( ) . , V-2
, ,
- - .

. ' ' .
, , , ...
,
, V-2. , 8 1944 ( V-2 ), ,
V-2 V-2.
. , ,

.
"", "" , ,
. , ' ,
,
"" .
" " ,

: . , ,

.
, 20 1914, . , ,

150%.
. , "
".
,
.
.


. ,

, : - ,
.
. " ".
, V-2
. , V-2, , " ",
.
, .

.

1945, .


1940 - 1945.
" ", .
, ,
, , .
, " "
. . .
2. :
.
8 1944 , 6.000 V-2.
, 5.000 .
,
, V-2 -
.
, Sir Frederick Pile,
. , ( 55 3
5 )

. -

V-2
.

.

.

Sir Frederick Pyle, 1945.

. ...
Werner Von Braun

Von Braun
.
( ) Von Braun

.

20

, V2. Pile 12.000

V-2, 3 10%, "
".
, Pile , V-2

.

,
.
,
,
.
, .
,
: , , (12.000
V-2 ),
, .
, 1945,
, ,
,
.
,
:

,
. 1945
,
, . ' ,
.
,

Sir Frederick Pile ,

.
, .
Missile Defence
Agency ( )
Pile 50 :
Pile
.... '
...
, - - Pile
, .9
,

' "",

. " " ,
. ,
,
Pile .
'
, " "
/ .
John Maynard Keynes 1936:

, ,
,
laissez faire
(
, ) , ,
,
, ... , ,
,
' ,
' ...10

 Kaynes, , .
, (
) " " ( , ).
Keynes ,
, ,
( ) . , , "" "", , .
Keynes ,
laissez faire .
. ;
; , , / ; ; ,
, ;
" " . Frank Lichtenberg , "" "" :
-
.
- .
- .
-
.
- 11.

,

,
.
. , " ",
. ( )
. .
. - ,
- .
1975 - . .

Lawrence M. Kaplan, Missile Defence: The

First Sixty Years, www.mda.mil, 9/2006.
.

John Maynard Keynes,

,
, 1936.
, :
,

, 2005.
10

Frank R. Lichtenberg, "The Impact of the

Strategic Defense Initiative on US Civilian
R&D Investment and Industrial
Competitiveness", Social Studies of Science,
Vol. 19, No.2 (May, 1989). ""
Lichtenberg
38,4%.
11

21

3. :
1945-1975.
1945-1963

' . . , , . ,
, " "

.

.
, ,
.

, -
- .
' , , 1945 . ,
. - - Vannevar Bush

Henry Arnold.
1945 "
". , .
Sir Frederick Pile:

V-2 . ' ,
,
...

22

, .
, , -

,
. , Pile , ,
" , ",
. 1946
1947 "
".

'50. ,

Vannevar Bush , , , , . Nike
Zeus .
Nike Zeus,
1957
. ,

,

, . , ,
,
: "
,

" . , , Zeus
. , Zeus

.
.
4 1957 Sputnik,
. Sputnik ""
.

 . , .
James Killian, ,
Sputnik . :
,
, ...12

Nike Zeus, 1957

, "
". 1961,

Gagarin. :
50 100 .
100 . Gagarin Titov
, , ...13
, . , .
Sputnik, " " . "" , ,
MAD [Mutually Assured
Destruction, ].
, ,
14. , . (MAD ) Keynes
.
,
, "
" ,
"
".
,
. 1958 Advanced Research Projects Agency
(ARPA). Vannevar Bush:
. ARPA Project
Defender. , " ". ,

Nike Zeus 1957 .

,
...

J. Killian, Sputnik, Scientists and

Eisenhower, Cambridge, Mass., 1977.
E.P Thompson (ed.), Star
Wars, Penguin, 1985.
12

13

.
. , 1959 .
-

.
14

23

BAMBI ( )

BAMBI
Walt Disney, .

Nike - X, 1963

NIke Zeus Nike - X

...

Silvia Federici George Caffentzis,

, Monitor
'07, 21 ,
2007. , "" ,
" - - " [Jeff
Bingaman & Bobby Inman, "Broadening
Horizons for Defense R&D," Issues in
Science and Technology (Fall 1992)].

15

16

24

BAMBI. H Ballistic Missile Boost Intercept

.
, .

' . - - , "" ,
, " " .
Nike Zeus.

, , Nike Zeus , 1963 Nike-X
.
.
. '
. .
: 1963 - 1975.
, 1961,
. ,
' , .
, ,
Vannevar Bush
, .
, , "
-
"15.
,
, ,
.
, .
, 1967, William Fulbright
" "
:

Fulbright, ..

,
"" 5
McNamara, -

 "" ""
,
. , ...16

. ,
, , . " " 1967
Fulbright,
Nike -X. 1963, Nike-X
, (
) "
",
Sentinel.
To 1969 ,
Sentinel
: Safeguard
,
, .
,

. , ,
,
.
,

, -

' , .
, " " " ", .
,
,
, .
1963 1972. , .
. , 1972 ABM
(Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty). , . ,
. , .
, , - ...- .
, 1975
, . ,
. ,
'50. , :
. '80 ,
.

Safeguard, 1969

Safeguard, 1975

, 1969. Nixon .

.

, 1975:
2000
. .
25

. :
STAR WARS 1980-1989.
Rockwell

. .
[
Rockwell, 1981].
, '60 '70,
. , . ,

, ,
.
, " ",
" ",
.
, - " "
"Laissez-faire", '80,
.
,
-
, ' , .
,
- - . .

26

1. ; .
1979 1965 - 1975
.
1979 :
. , ,

MAD. ,
" "
-

. ,
START II
17.
, .
, ,
. ' ,
Ronald Reagan. 1980,
,
.
Brown, " 1965 - 1975",
.
16,5 . ,
MX (
) 1,5 ,
, , , ,
18.
1980 , .
. , . , Ronald Reagan .
Ronald Reagan O
Hollywood. California,
Reagan . Lawrence Livermore,
, .
Vandenberg ' ,
Cal Tech,
19. , California

 Rockwell,
, " , "20. Reagan,
21. "
;
;" 1980. , (NORAD)
Colorado :
NORAD ... ,
, .
: '
, ,
, . ,
... ... '
.22
, , ,
, .
Ronald Reagan . 23 1983,
. " " : , " "
. , :
1981, :
,
. :
,

.23
1965 - 1975 ,
, .
. , " " . :

17

,
1986.

Emma Rothschild, "The

American Arms Boom", E. P Thompson
& Dan Smith (eds), Protest and Survive,
Penguin, 1980.

18

19
Cal Tech
Mike Davis, City of Quartz, Verso,
1991, .
20

E. P. Thompson (ed.), Star Wars, Penguin,

1985

,
, Reagan
1964 (
) Barry
Goldwater .
21

22

E. P. Thompson (ed.), Star Wars, ..

Ronald Reagan,

, 23/3/1983.
.
.
23

27

 , , ,
, , (...)
, :

Ronald , 1983.

:
;

;

.
,
. , (...)
:
, ,
.
,
, (...)

Reagan SDI,
23/3/1983. Mig

24

David Holloway, "War, Militarism and the

Soviet State" E. P. Thompson (ed.),
Protest and Survive, ..

25

28

,
. " welfare"24, . , . "
" - ,
Reaganomics, , . . ,

, , , .
.
,

' , :
, ABM, , .
-

 . ...
'80 .
. .
2. :
.
Reagan 23 1983
. .
.
" , " .
:
, ()
, , - - .

. ,
, :
,
. ,
,
"" .
: , . ,
:

.
. , '80. ,
,
25, . Edward Teller , , Lawrence
Livermore, Star Wars, :

Edward Teller,

,
Edward Teller McCarthy .

Three Mile Island. ,
Jane Fonda, , ...

. [
], , ...26
, ""
, :

29


, :
,
, 1987.

27

Mary Kaldor,
'70.

28

Brown , 1980.

29

30

Thompson, Star Wars, ..

"The Role of Space and

Defense in Nato Alliance"
NATO 16 ations
1985. E.P. Thompson, Star
Wars, ..

31

Emma Rothschild, "The American Arms

Boom", E. P Thompson & Dan Smith
(eds), Protest and Survive, Penguin, 1980.

32

Frank R.
Lichtenberg, "The Impact of the Strategic
Defense Initiative on US Civilian R&D
Investment and Industrial Competitiveness",
Social Studies of Science, Vol. 19, No.2 (May,
1989)

33

1992, ,
, .

34

.

.
, , . ,
. .27
. 1989
. .
, . , , ,
. " "28
. ,
- -
. ,

, "" "" . ""
, ,
; " "29: , , , laser, ,

, , " " . , " " Reagan
, . , , , , ,
.
:
H [SDI] , . , .
, . ,
, , , .30

30

Reagan
1985. SDI: '60, , , " "
( ""). - - . ,
Edward

Teller , , 1985
, 1984 " ", "
, , ". " ", .31
" ", - -
,
.
,
, . , " " ,
'60 '70. ;
" " , " " "
, , "32. . , '80 , .
,
.
,
'80. , . '80 ,
,
33:
, 1984 - 1989
( )
1984
1,1

1985
1,6

1986
3,0

1987
3,7

1988
4,0

1989
6,7

20
1989, 199234. , ,
,
10 ( 1986), 20 ,
'80 [ M ] .
. .
Star Wars
80%
'80, '60. Rockwell, TRW AVCO
MX, Lockheed Trident, LTV B-1 , Litton

SDI 80.
Welles .
a ,
Space Invaders, .
.

31

32

Cruise.
McDonnell
Douglas, Hughes Aerospace, Teledyne (
Pershing II), Ford Aerospace
Corporation . , . , 77
" "

. 45%

California, ' Reagan.

! 1982
1985, ,
2.300

35.

, : .
, ( 36) , , . Star Wars "
" 37,
.
,
. ,
. , Georgia,

, , " ,
".
: Alabama, Arizona Florida .
,
,
"" :

.
,
, . -

, ,

, .
. The Scientist
29/6/1987
Star Wars ( !) 1989, ", 35 ,
" ,
1958 250.000.38
.
3.
.



'80.
,
, .
, Star Wars,
- .
- .
- , .
, . , '80, , 39.
,
" "

. - - '80 .
, ,
. '80,
. ,
, , , .
.
.

. :
1990 - 2001.

1. (1990-1997).

1990 . " " 1991
.
,
. Scud , Patriot. . . ,
Patriot
Scud . ,
.
, " ", . , , . ,
, , 1991, , . .
"" .
:
. ,
--- ,
. , ,
,
, , : " ". , , ,
'90,
, - - .
,
, , 15 , " Patriot , "40.
"" ' ,
. , : ,
. -

35

E.P. Thompson, Star

Wars, .

36

1981 1987,
64%,
26%.
1981
[Frank R.
Lichtenberg, . .]

"Security Clearance",
.
37

"
" E
: That's Why!
38

39

-
, - Eric Hobsbawm
.

Steven Hildreth, CRS Report for

Congress: Ballistic Missile Defense:
Historical Overview, 9/7/2007.
Scud .
40

33


Project for the New American Century, : ,
9/2000.
:
. "
" 2007. .
.

41

"Reagan's Missile Shield in Space, "Star

Wars", is Pronounced Dead", New York
Times 14/5/1993.

42

Lawrence M. Kaplan, Missile Defence: The

First Sixty Years, www.mda.mil, 9/2006.

43

44

"Aspin Says Inquiry is Set on 1984 "Star

Wars" Test", New York Times 19/8/1993.

, :
"Aspin Disputes Report of "Star Wars"
Rigging", New York Times 10/9/1993.
MDA Historian's Office, National Missile
Defence: An Overview (1993-2000),
www.mda.mil, ,
2005.

45

34

, . , , ,
, ,
. ,

. ,
,

. . .
: 1990-1995.
1990 , , SDI
. , 1959. , 25 ,
"Brilliant Pebbles", " ". " " ,
, laser, , . ,
, ' .
,
. 1990 - 1997. ' , () . , " "
, , .
, , , "" . ,
. , 1993,
Les Aspin, .. Clinton,
" " Bottom Up Review (BUR). 1/9/1993 , ,
- . , ' , . ,
:
Clinton 160 . Bush [. ] 1992 1996.
Clinton "" 426 . , ...41

 , . ,
13/5/1993, BottomUp Review, " SDI", Ballistic Missile Defence Organization, "
". :
" Star
Wars" Aspin . "
Star Wars ", . : John
Conyers , Mitchigan , Aspin
. " ,
", Convyers.

, Laser .
, ,
, . 1992 , 8
...42
: ,
. ,
'80 . " "
( 1999)
, 1984 ( 43)
.
1993 , " " , 44.
,
Clinton " ABM
". , Bottom
Up Review 1/9 1993. ,
" ", , 45.
1995.
, " 15
" .
, " 15 48 ". " -

SDI,
$ 9.000.000.000

SDI
1987. , :
.

Brilliant Pebbles (1990)

,
.

1940 - 2001,
41.

35


DCI National Intelligence Estimate (NIE)
95-19, "Emerging Missile Threats to North
America During the Next 15 Years, 11/1995.
, Google .

46

Rumsfeld Report, 7/1998. MDA Historian's Office,

National Missile Defence: An Overview
(1993-2000), . .

47

Project for the New American Century,

..

48

49

MDA Historian's Office, National Missile

Defence: An Overview (1993-2000), ..

"46.
, ,
.
.

. , , , , ,
, ! ' ,
Reagan
" " '80.
", " . ' .
2. : 1997 - 2000.

1995, Malcolm
O'Neill, : " ". , ,
, . , , O' Neill, ' .

, .
, - . 1995 " ", O'Neill, " ",
Lockheed Martin, .

, , " " Donald
Rumsfeld
. , 1998, :

. .

. ,
, ...47

36

" ", , ,
" "
. ! -

 1993, . , , 1997 Clinton

William Cohen.

, .
1995 .
, , .
Project for the New American Century 2000,

1990: Brilliant
Pebbles. .

.
, , , ... "Pax Americana". ,
, ...48

19/8/1993:
, .

,
,
,
, . , 1999. 20 ,
William Cohen, , "
" . :
[ Taepo Dong 2
31/8/1998] , [
] (Rogue States), . (...)
. , . , , (...)49
, : , 10,5 . , Rumsfeld
1995 . , ABM,
" " " ",
, " , ". , 2005 .

, 1990 - 2000.

3/1993: "
" (Bottom Up Review)
13/5/1993: Les Aspin
" SDI".
.

1/9/1993: Bottom Up Review

.
.
10/9/1993:
1984.
11/1994:
.
25/9/1995: Newsweek " "
11/1995:
(NIE 9519)
. 15 . Malcolm
O'Neil, " ".
6/1996: Malcolm O'Neill

Lockheed Martin.
8/1996: NIE 95-19.
Donald Rumsfeld.
5/12/1996: William Cohen .
1/4/1997: "

" ( LSI).
5/1997:
"
"
.

( ...)
37


50

MDA Historian's Office, National Missile

Defence: An Overview (1993-2000), ..

51

"The Misconceptions of National Missile

Defence", Kandish

Orange County, California, 20/4/2000.

52

" ",
, 10/7/2000,
New York Times.

, 1990 - 2000
(
).
30/4/1998: LSI
Boeing 1,6 .
12/1998: Raytheon .
7/1998: Donald
Rumsfeld. .
31/8/1998:
.
20/1/1999: William
Cohen

. 10,5
2000.
2/10/1999: Raytheon "
".
18/1/2000: " ". .
7/7/2000: .
31/8/2000: Clinton

.
2000: think tank Project for a
New American Century " "
.
Pearl Harbor.
9/12/2000: George Bush Jr.
.
22/12/2000: Boeing 13
2007.

38

, '90.
, " " ( " "), "
" ( ). ,
ABM 1972, Reagan . , .
,
. .
, .
7 2000, . ,
. Clinton " ' " ( ) , ABM.
,
. 2 ,
Raytheon Boeing 5 , " ", " " 100 . , " " .50
Ronald Kadish, ,
,
.
,
.
, : ,

, . , ( "") . ,

24 . ( ), , ...
' , .
, , . , . -

 . ,
, "" " " . .
, 43 , 51.
, , . , Dan Rather, CBS
. , ,
.
, . , , " " "". ' ,
ABM. "" , ,
16 ,
, - . . . : " ". . , .
:
: " "
:
,
.


60 ...

, , ...52
Kadish, 31 2000,
Clinton, , . ,
9/12 George Bush Jr. , 22/12 2000, Boeing
13 2007.
,
" " 2000 500 .
.

,
.

8 2000. ,
Kadish

M
MDA Historian's
Office, National Missile Defence: An
Overview (1993-2000). '90
internet, , . ,
google

( )
.
,
. :

John Deutch
John Deutch



1994
1995, 1995
1996.
.
, MIT,
John Deutch
Raytheon, .

39


53

Project for the New American Century, 2000,

..
.
Samuel Huntington,
" ": , , .

54

. .

()
Malcolm ONeill
O Malcolm O'Neill
SDI
Ronald Reagan.
Ballistic
Missile Defense Organization, O'Neill
. O'Neill : 1996 Lockheed Martin Corporation,
.

William Perry
William Perry
1994 1997.

Hambrecht & Quist,

.
Rwanda,
1994.

40

3. :
2000 , . , ,
2000 , " " . , " " .

- - , ,
. ,
"" "", "" "",
"" , ,

.
,
2000 "
Bush". , 1995 1999
. ,
i) " ". , , .
ii) " ",
. , ,
. 1995 1999
"" ( ) .
iii) . .
,
Clinton . ,
,
, : " "
'90, 10 1997. 1993, " Rumsfeld" 1998. ABM " " 1993, Clinton , 2000.
2001 " Bush",
.

 1995, 1999. "" .

,
, 1995. -
- ,
, . Project for a New American Century 2000
H Pax Americana
,
.

. .
, . ,
, .
(...)53
2000: 1990, , . - "" "", "" "", "", , " " 1995. , , ,

, .
2000, .
; Project for a New American Century,
George Bush Jr.,
" ". " ", "" , ' , "
" .
" , ,
- Pearl Harbor"54.
" Pearl Harbor"
11 2001.
( ) :
11 2001,
11 "
" . , .

(...)
William Cohen
, O
William Cohen

Clinton

1997.

, , .

Larry Welch

Larry Welch "

"


'90. To
1998, Donald
Rumsfeld. ,
CACI
International,
" "
Abu Ghraib.
Defence Science Board,
, "
".

Kadish
O Kadish .


.

41

. 2000 - 2007:

1. 2000 - 2006:
2000 , , . 2001 .


1972.
, . , :

6/2002:
ABM,

.

, 3/2/2007. 250

Jince, 70 .
, 18/10/2006, ,

.63
42

1972
.55
, , , . . , . . .
. .
. . 11/09/2001: .

.
.
- - - " ". .

. .
2001,
56. . . . 2002 "
"57.
. ' , ,
" "(!) . , , , . ... . '50, , 1975
. . -
- ,
. ...
. , 2004,
...

' , . "".
,
... . -
- , .58

. , ( ...).
,
. -
' . .
'96 02/03/06 . .
,
. . '96
. . .
: "
, ."60 .
.
, .
. , 2006,
.
.
... 1996
.

55

, 3/05/01.
,
,
,
.
56
57

, 21/04/02.

58

63

, 13/12/01.
, 18/11/04.

59

, 03/03/06.

60

, 19/12/06.

61

, 23/01/07.

62

, 27/01/07.

Sarajevo, #15, 9/2007.

2. 2007-:
2007
"" ,

. 2007 .
. .
" ", . "
..."61
, , , 4 . .
, . ,


62.

43


64

, 08/01/08.

65

, 29/02/08.

66

Missile Defense Agency,
Proposed U.S. Missile Defense Assets in
Europe.

.
. . , , (;) : ( ) , - - 2007 .
- . ,
"
". . ,
. . " , ", . ; ; . , ,
64.
, , .
, , "
: ."65 ,

.
, .
.
.
. ...

.
3. , : !66
, , -
, . 2007 , - ,
. ,
- .
,
"" . .
; ;

44

-,

 , ,
.
,
, ,
- ,
! !
... ...

;
, ! :
...
. 1700-2200 .
, (
). , ,

, .
! ! , : , .
; ;
:
. ,
...

, "" ,
: , , ,
. - .
- - .
... !
;

. - .

.
,
( )
- .
...

45


; .

" " '
. .
, .

'
. : , ,

.
() .

,


.
' ; , - -

46

, -

; '
(
)
;
:
'
'
" ". - ('
).
'
-
...
...
i. '
. ' . .

, .

 '
. / . "" ""
;
ii.
. ,
, , .
(
) .
. .

: " , ". ; ...
iii.
. , ,
,
. " "; ,
60 ...
iv. ,
. ;
, ' . , ...
...

, : ,

. , , , .
, , -

- ; .
, .
'
- .

, ' , . ' .
. ,
, .
( ...). .
.
, .
i. " ".
/
.
(
)
, Bill Clinton, ' .

, .
;
.
. ,
, '
' ( ).
'
.
.

, .

47

ii. - .. - ,
. , , ,
. ( ) ;

48

iii. , , :

. ' . '
'
.
. .
' .
. ,
. - (;)
.
iv. ' : " , ...". ,
,
. ' ' .
1940,
. ,
.
, ;
""
. .
. 80 . . ' , . .
v. , ,

.
( , , , , , , ,
, , ).
, ,
' ,
. :
- -
"" "" . , , , ...

. !

!
, , ,
2005.

16/7/2006

9/1/2006, 13/1/2008

16/7/2006

13/1/2008

16/7/2006

World Nuclear Association (www.world-nuclear.org)

16/7/2006

29/9/2006: 2006. .
.

50

( ) : '
.
,
. .
: . , ,
.
, 1, :
Gazprom,
' , . '
2-3 .
, 2003 ,
2. ,
2021, 3. "" ,
' ' , 2009 1600 4. ,
.
-

7.2
2.4
0
0
44.3
13.0
18.1
92.4
51.8
24.5
0
22.0
428.7
158.7
12.5
15.6
0
0
0
291.5
0
0
141.2
8.0
10.4
3.3
2.6
5.2
144.3
16.6
5.3
10.1
57.4
65.1
26.4
0
0
84.8
69.2
787.2
0
2658

6.9
42
0
0
54
3.3
44
16
1.9
31
0
28
78
32
38
2.6
0
0
0
30
0
0
39
69
4.9
3.5
2.7
9.0
16
57
40
4.4
20
48
37
0
0
48
18
19
0
16

(, 2008)

,
.


, .

30 :

. , .
( ""

The Guardian8).
,
: 9.

1
1
2
0
0
4
0
2
86
2
1
1
1
0
2
9
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
2
2
0
2
1
20
0
1
24
0
0
1
4
3
20
0
25
2
222

123
51
0
0
1011
303
261
1665
1396
619
0
1051
10527
3332
271
978
0
143
0
7569
0
0
3109
225
246
98
65
174
3365
313
141
303
1398
1418
537
0
0
1974
2199
18918
0
64,615

2
1
0
0
7
2
2
18
11
6
0
4
59
17
4
17
0
0
0
55
0
0
20
1
2
1
2
2
31
5
1
8
10
5
0
0
15
19
104
0
439

1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
5
0
0
1
1
0
0
6
0
1
0
2
0
0
2
0
0
0
1
0
7
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
34

(2006)
%*
KWh . .

: , , , , , , ,
, , , .
: , , , , , .
: , , , .
: , ,
, , , ,
.
: , , , , , , , .
: , .

. ,
, 5 (
;)
,
, : , 80%
,
72%, 55%, 55%,
52%,
6.
7, 30
( ) , :

1
0
0
2
0
1
2
4
30
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
2
2
0
11
0
1
6
0
0
0
2
2
8
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
7
0
93

: World Nuclear Association, 14/01/08.

: IAEA - *
.

. !

24/2/2000

8/1/2006

12/9/2005

18/11/2004

1/4/2006

30/5/2007

25/4/2000

13/3/2006

20/1/2006

10

10/11/2006

11

23/2/2000

1995 ( )
70 . ( ): "
. ". [New York Times,
23/12/1995].

12

13

4/1/1998

14

13/10/2003

15

13/12/2006

16

19/12/2006

17

12/4/1998

18

10/10/2006

19

12/2/2006

52

" " .
.
, (,
, , ),
( ). , , . . , (, , , ) ( ). ,
( ) . , ; . -
,
(.. , ) (..
-). ' :
: 200 1. ' ( 2001
,
). 2020, 2030 2040 2.
. ,
3.
: . . 2004
" , " "

 "4. ,
2006,
5.
. 2007 " "6.

About Mordechai

. : 12 . 2000 ( Greenpeace) , " "7. 8 (

!).
: '90 - (
).
. 2006 9
10.
:
. 2000 (
) "Der Spiegel" 11.
: .
( 1956 ), 12. 1998

" "13. 2003 Harpoon, 14. , 2006 15,
( )
: 1974.
1998, , . 2006 ( ).
14 ,
8 16.
: . 1998
, , ( )17.
: 2006 18.
( , 1 2)19.
. . " " ,
, "
".

21/4/2004. Mordechai Vanuu,

18
About Abdul
,
Abdul Qadeer Khan .
.

2004,

,
'80.
.
, ,
. ..
, . , Khan ,

. Khan , ..
2004 Khan,
, . '
(, by the
way, , ).
: Wikipedia,
TIME magazine 14/2/2005

. :

ABM, 1972.

Nixon
2 .
1963: Limited Test Ban Treaty
,
, .
.
116
, , ,
1992
.
1967: Outer Space Treaty
,
. ,
.
.
1968: Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty
,
. 133

. - .
1972: Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty I
ABM Treaty

54

"".
. ,
. ,

-
"" .

. ; . -
, ;
.
"" (1963-1996)
, - 1963
1996- .
( ),
" " . , ,
" " . "" - . (
'60 - ).
1963 , 1992
. 1968
, - , - . 1996 - - ,
, - - 2006 ,
.
H ABM treaty, , 1972. . , Clinton
" . . '
. 2001
: .
.

.


100 . .

. . ,
, ; : . .
'60 '70
. , , /
, , .
, . , - - .
: . , , .
. . , , , , , .
-
.
. .
:
- , . . ( )
, " ".
. .
.
. ,
, . ; ; ; - ; . '80
. .
'90.
,
.
" " '90 . . '90 .
.
, , .
, .
...

1972: Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty I

Interim Agreement
.
5 .
(ICBM).
1979: Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty II

.

2400. MIRVed
1320.
1986.
1987: Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces
Treaty (INF)

(IRMs), .
.
1991: Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty
.
1600.
6000.
. 15% 25% .
1993: Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty II
.

5000.

4/12/2001.
1996: Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty
(CTBT)
,
. 170 .
. .

55

. RONALD REAGAN,
, 23/3/1983
( SDI)

Reagan . , : .
, SDI, - ,
.

Ronald Reagan (1911-2004).

56

, .
, , . .
. , .
, .
, , .
,

,

. ,

.
,
. ,
.

. ,
, .
, , , -


. : .
, - .
(...)

: .
.
, - .

. "" : , ,
, . , .
.
. . . , ,
, , ,
.

. - .
.
,
, ,
, . ,
.
.
, . , , . .
,
.
.

. . , -
.
, , Minute Man III,
1969, Titan.
; , 1969,
. ,
' , ,
. (...)

,
, .
, .

,
, .
: ,

; :
; . ,
,

.

.
' .
,
,
.
,
- . , ,
,
.
,
.
-
, , - , :
. , -

57

58

, , .
1981, : ,
. : ,
.

. ,
.

, (
). ,

.

. . ,

. , . , ,
. , ,

;
,

, , , ,
.

, - .
-

. '30
.

.
. , , .
, , .
, ,
, :

.
. ,
'
, ,
.
,
. ,


. , .
,
, . , . ' ,
, , ,
.
,
, ,

,
.

.

 , , , .
,

. , .


,
.
,
, .
.
: ;
, ,
; , , . , .
,
, .
.
.
, ,
.
:
; ;

,
. ,
. , .
,
. ,
,
. , ,
;
: .
, ,

. ,


, .
, -, -
, . ,

.
, ,
.
. . .
.

, . , , ,
,
. , ,
, ,
.
,
ABM,

, .

-
. . ,
.
- -

.
, , . , . . ,
.
, , , .

59

. :
80s

Blame Canada!

Toronto, 1962.
: .

60

. .
, .
.
,
John Maynard Keynes
.
: .
! ! , . .
- .
- ! .
.
, , .
"
".
-----
. , .
"" - .
" " . .
" " .

. '

. , ' .

1. : Best of
i. : !
Brockdorf ''
''. Gottingen . Brocksdorf : ( ), , (
). '
. 13 1976 30.000 10.000 .
Grohnde ' . ,
. . ,
. Grohnde .
.
1976, 1

, '70 80. .

,
. . " "
.
. . ! , ,
, , .
. ,

Super Fenix

Super Phenix

A.G. Grauwacke, Autonome in Bewegung,

Assoziation A, 2003
2

George Katsiaficas, , , 2007,

134

" . , , ".2

.
Whyl 1975,
1973/4
Schmidt Matthofer
. . -

61

 ,
. ; ..
! ! !
! ! ;
Whyl 1975.
.
,
.
40.000 ' : Brokdorf, 19/2/1977. .
!
Whyl . , ,
... ' - ,
, .

' . 30.000
.
. .

.
. Whyl . ! 11
" "
Malville, 1977.
.
Brokdorf, 1977.

Malville

62

Malville 1977,

.
.
.

. , , , . !
1977. 50 . SuperPhenix:

.
"
" SuperPhenix ,
, Malville.
-

 . 30
1977 100.000
. .
ii) ...:
'
'
- .
.

.
. ' .


. -
, , :
.
'
. ' "
" ,
. ,
, ...
Seabrook 1977, New Hampshire
' . '70
: , , ' .
. -

...

. ,

.
-

1976 Clamshell
Alliance. Clamshell Alliance
New Hampshire ,
1150MW , Seabrook. 1976 Clamshell Alliance
' . 200 . .
, Clamshell Alliance 30
1977 1800 .
1400 ! Clamshell
Alliance 24 1978
20.000 .
Clamshell Alliance

.
.

-
. ... " " . ( ) .
' "
".

New Hampshire, 1977.

.

2. :

, New Hampshire, 1977.

: .
.

.
,
- , -
. ' ' 70 !3 '
.
, , , , , ,
, . . " "
.

( ) .
i) :
' ' , . ' "
" ,
.
Midnight Notes Collective, Strange Victories
(The Antinuclear Movement in the USA and Europe), 1979
' 1979, .
, , .
" ". " , , ". . ;
;

. ,
. .

.
" "
: -

64


4
.
: (affinity groups), ,

.
.
ii) Back to the land! ( ...)
. '70 '80. ( ...) , , , . , .
.

.
.
.
' (
) :
"" .

, '
.
'
. ' . " ".
' - , ' . "
' " . '
" "5 - , , , , , , ' - . -
: , , . :
. , , , , , , .6

Midnight Notes Collective, Strange Victories,

The Antinuclear Movement in the USA and
Europe), 1979

. , ' ( ).
5

Midnight Notes
Collective, ..

...

.
6

New Hampshire, 1977.

65

iii) , ...

1) H

2) H
[...]
Clamshell Alliance
[ Clamshell Alliance, 1976]

, 1980.

...

. . ;
. - -
.
, , .
.
-
,
, - : , .7 : ( "" )

"" " ".
" " - "" - .
: . .
' , ; ! . '
.
mainstream :

'
...8
;
"".
iv) ; ( ...)

66

B : ...
' '
10 . , Kleve, ,
. , ' , . " ".
300 ' , ' . . , , '
' ' . ...
[ 9]


1. .
2. [...]
7. .
[
Seabrook, 197710]


.
- - ' . .
.


.
, / , ( ), .
:
,
,
. '
-
' "" . "" . "" .
- ' - , .
"". "" ' . ""

.11
. ' , , . ' "" , .
, .

midnight notes collective

A Clamshell
Alliance, 1976
9

A.G. Grauwacke, Autonome in Bewegung,

Assoziation A, 2003, ..
10

11

Midnight notes collective, ..

George Katsiaficas, ,
, 2007, 142 A.G.
Grauwacke, Autonome in Bewegung, 2003,
24

Brockdorf .
1970 1980
Brokdorf
.

" ".
New
Hampshire, 1977.

67

 (affinity groups), (Burgerinitiativen): ...

' , ' , .

' " " (affinity group)

. Seabrook
1977 .

1975 '
.
2007
Greenpeace.
. " "
'70 '80. .
(affinity groups)
Clamshell Alliance . . , , .
, . , -
20 - .
, , .12 .

. .
. Wally Nelson,
,
. ".13

Seabrook 1977,
.
:
" ",
, non violent . .

68

. , (Burgerinitiativen) . ' .
:
. . .

(.. )
' "" : ! ""
.
,
, .

3. :



'60 '70. . : ( ) " ". " "
- ' .
:

.

(' ). , .
, ...
[]
.
. .
, . .
'
.
...
[E. P. Thompson, Star Wars ]

. , ,
. . , . (
) .
; '
, .
,
just in time . .
" " ;
" ";


. , -

Midnight Notes
Collective, Strange Victories, The Antinuclear
Movement in the USA and Europe, ..
12

13

Wally Nelson, Valley Advocate,

Sept.1, 1976.

Ralph Nader ( 1980),

'

1970.
Nader . 1971 ...
"Public Citizen",
, global fair trade, , ,
.
140.000 "Public
Citizen" ' . Nader

(
) . '
"Public Citizen" 40 .

69

 .



.
" "; " ";
.

, , .

. .
, .
, . ,

. ,

,
. ,
.
[R.Reagan,
, 23/3/1983].
1983. - , " ", "
". ,
. ' ,
.
. :
.
/
. .
R.Reagan
' . ; "
, ,
, . .
. . ...,
".
, R.Reagan , ,
.
70