ANLISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RUGOSIDAD

SOBRE EL COEFICIENTE DE ARRASTRE DE UNA PLACA PLANA

RUGOSA.
La simulacin que se presenta en este trabajo se hace para comprobar los valores que se
da en la tabla de la figura #1 dada en el libro Mecnica de Fluidos de Frank M. White (Ver
bibliografa).

Fig. #1

Coeficientes de resistencia de la capa lmite laminar y turbulenta de placas planas lisas y

rugosas, en este caso es apropiado el parmetro

en analoga al parmetro

para tubos.

Este grfico es el equivalente para placas planas al diagrama de Moody y las ecuaciones a
las que hace referencia son las ecuaciones tericas y empricas desarrolladas para la capa
lmite en una placa plana lisa y rugosa paralelas al flujo. De esta manera la Ec. (27) hace
referencia
a
la
ecuacin
para
el
coeficiente
de
arrastre

para una placa lisa en rgimen laminar obtenida a partir de la solucin presentada por
Blasius en 1908 para el perfil de velocidades en la capa lmite a partir de la ecuacin:
donde

( )

Antes de continuar se resalta que la transicin se establece que empieza desde

aunque se puede retrasar puliendo la superficie y con una corriente libre sin
perturbaciones.
Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 1 of 18

31.12.2013

La ecuacin 7.45 es la ecuacin:

La cual es obtenida para un flujo turbulento tambin para un placa plana a partir de un
anlisis integral similar al que se hace para el perfil laminar pero esta vez se da un perfil de
velocidad de raz sptima , puede que se d logartmico, pero dado que no hay solucin
exacta para este caso y hay muchas soluciones empricas se acepta ampliamente la solucin
de la raz sptima .
En el caso de la ecuacin 7.48 para la placa rugosa en la que el coeficiente de arrastre se
vuelve independiente del nmero de Reynolds de modo que la resistencia varia con y es
independiente de y se da con la siguiente expresin:
(

Esta ecuacin se representa a la derecha de la lnea discontnua.

Y en cuanto a la ecuacin 7.49 el Dr. HERMANN SCHLICHTING (Ver ref. bibliogrfica)

sugiere las siguientes ecuaciones para correlacionar las curvas de resistencia en la zona de
transicin dependiente del valor del nmero de Reynolds
para el que se inicia la
transicin:

Planteamiento y conceptualizacin del problema.

En este caso el problema consiste simplemente en idear un modelo apropiado para la
simulacin en el que se pueda calcular la fuerza de arrastre sobre una superficie plana con
rugosidad variable y a varias velocidades de manera que vare el nmero de Reynolds y as
se obtengan los valores del coeficiente de arrastre dado por:

El Reynolds se calcul con la velocidad, viscosidad del flujo libre y la longitud de la

pared de 10 metros:

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 2 of 18

31.12.2013

Modelo fsico computacional.

Para agregar a la figura anterior del deflector se presenta la geometra y vistas del camin
en
Para la simulacin se uso un slido con la siguiente geometra

Fig. #2 Vista isomtrica del modelo utilizado en la simulacin.

Fig. #3 Vista del croquis con las medidas en milmetros.

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 3 of 18

31.12.2013

METODOLOGA DE ESTUDIO, PARMETRO,

CONSIDERACIONES Y RESPUESTAS DEL PROGRAMA.
Para el anlisis se puso como condiciones de forntera una velocidad de entrada (con la
cota de 2000 mm en la figura anterior) y en la salida una presin de 1 Atm as como que la
pared inferior era rugosa pero la superior(Con la cota de 10000 mm en la figura anterior)
era ideal.La velocidad y la reugosidad se variaron segn el Reynolds par las siguientes
condiciones de flujo:

Resultando entonces que la velocidad y el coeficiente de arrastre sean:

Y
Donde es la fuerza de arrastre sobre la superficie rugosa del modelo la cual se calcula
con el software. Las ecuaciones anteriores se utilizaron para poner los Goals y as poder
lograr el objetivo (Ver archivo del modelo).Recordar que la simulacin se realiz con un
anlisis en 2-D.
El ancho del dominio que se tomo fue de 0.1m de manera que el rea de la placa es de 1m 2.

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 4 of 18

31.12.2013

RESULTADOS
La equation goal dada en cada caso es la ecuacin del coeficiente de arrastre.

L/e=200

MODELO.SLDPRT [200-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG
X - Component
of Force 1[ ]
Equation
Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000577246
0.000576075
0.00057072
0.000579831
0.011447945
0.011424726
0.011318514
0.011499205

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [200 -1.5-10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG X - Component of Force 1[ ]
Equation Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.001423988
0.001413045
0.001401469
0.001423988
0.012551529
0.012455077
0.012353038
0.012551529

Iterations: 57
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [200 -1.5-10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG X - Component of Force 1[ ]
Equation Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.004246222
0.004249579
0.004244392
0.004252782
0.013473824
0.013484475
0.013468015
0.01349464

Iterations: 79
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [200 -10- 6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG X - Component of Force 1[ ]
Equation Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.071098871
0.071058432
0.070957176
0.071118807
0.014100328
0.014092308
0.014072227
0.014104282

Iterations: 107
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [200 -10- 8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG X - Component of Force 1[ ]
Equation Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
747.3032538
747.1422797
746.9360711
747.6355233
0.014820518
0.014817326
0.014813236
0.014827108

Iterations: 80
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [200 -10- 9 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Unit
Goal Name
[N]
SG X - Component of Force 1[ ]
Equation Goal 1

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
75405.88157
75395.61547
75367.31325
75471.21478
0.014954494
0.014952458
0.014946846
0.014967451

Iterations: 81
Analysis interval: 21

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 5 of 18

L/e=500

31.12.2013

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Iterations: 81
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=500

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Equation Goal 1
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000201008
0.000200847
0.00020021
0.00020114
0.003986382
0.003983201
0.003970557
0.003989002

Iterations: 80
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -2-10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Equation Goal 1
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.001926235
0.001924886
0.001923776
0.001926235
0.009550291
0.009543605
0.0095381
0.009550291

Iterations: 88
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -7-10- 5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Equation Goal 1
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.026376097
0.026368679
0.026354961
0.026379206
0.010675343
0.010672341
0.010666788
0.010676602

Iterations: 72

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -10- 6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Equation Goal 1
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.05383464
0.053825992
0.053799801
0.053843192
0.010676486
0.010674771
0.010669576
0.010678182

Iterations: 74
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -10- 8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
552.8977802
552.7839429
552.6338832
553.1226343
0.109650688
0.010962811
0.109598352
0.109695281

Iterations: 81
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [500 -10-9 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
55893.50607
55891.80669
55877.22707
55942.75653
0.0110848
0.011084463
0.011081572
0.011094567

Iterations: 77
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=5000

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 78
Vsquez
Arribasplata
Analysis
interval:
21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 6 of 18

31.12.2013

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Iterations: 77
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=5000

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
0.002791002
0.002790443
0.0027851
0.002792337

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -7-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.003672183
0.003672806
0.003669912
0.003675565
0.001486263
0.001486515
0.001485344
0.001487632

Iterations: 75
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.021590895
0.021651344
0.021582825
0.021873989
0.004281906
0.004293895
0.004280306
0.00433805

Iterations: 77
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -5-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.746508466
0.746592891
0.746508466
0.747034728
0.005921902
0.005922572
0.005921902
0.005926077

Iterations: 71
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
3.045167221
3.045475471
3.045155928
3.047269438
0.006039176
0.006039787
0.006039153
0.006043345

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
303.48711
303.518382
303.4868924
303.6869557
0.006018756
0.006019377
0.006018752
0.00602272

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 7 of 18

Iterations: 72
Analysis interval: 21

31.12.2013

SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

CD
[ ]

3.045167221
0.006039176

3.045475471
0.006039787

3.045155928
0.006039153

3.047269438
0.006043345

Iterations: 77
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=5000

MODELO.SLDPRT
MODELO.SLDPRT [5000
[5000 -10-8
-10-5 ANALISIS
ANALISIS Y
Y SIMULACIN
SIMULACIN
Goal
Unit
Goal Name
Name
Unit
SG
[N]
SG X
X -- Component
Component of
of Force
Force 1
1
[N]
CD
[[ ]]
CD

Value
Averaged
Minimum
Maximum
Value
Averaged Value
Value
Minimum Value
Value
Maximum Value
Value
303.48711
303.518382
303.4868924
303.6869557
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.006018756
0.006019377
0.006018752
0.00602272
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

Iterations:
Iterations: 72
78
Analysis
Analysis interval:
interval: 21
21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-9 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI
Goal Name
Unit
SG
X Name
- Component of Force 1
[N]
Goal
Unit
CD
[[N]
]
SG X - Component of Force 1
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
30103.23667 Averaged
30107.73562
30103.23667
30116.27331
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.005970074
0.005970966
0.005970074
0.005972659
0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
0.002791002
0.002790443
0.0027851
0.002792337

Iterations: 66
Iterations:
76
Analysis
interval:
21
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=10 000

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -7-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT
[10 000 Averaged
-10-5 Value
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
Goal Name
Unit
Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD Name
[ ]
Goal
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.003672183
0.003672806
0.003669912
0.003675565
0.001486263 Averaged
0.001486515
0.001485344
0.001487632
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

Iterations: 75
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT
[10 000 Averaged
-2-10-5
ANALISIS
Y
SIMULAC
Goal Name
Unit
Value
Value
Minimum Value
Maximum
Value

SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

CD Name
[ ]
Goal
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.021590895
0.021651344
0.021582825
0.021873989
0.004281906 Averaged
0.004293895
0.004280306
0.00433805
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
0.002791004
0.002790444
0.002785101
0.002792338

Iterations: 77
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -5-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.746508466
0.746592891
0.746508466
0.747034728
0.005921902
0.005922572
0.005921902
0.005926077

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]
Iterations: 71

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.002216059
0.002220184
0.002214189
0.002295933
0.001757959
0.001761231
0.001756476
0.001821321

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULAC

Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21
Goal Name

Unit

Value

Averaged Value

Minimum Value

Maximum Value

SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

3.045167221
3.045475471
3.045155928
3.047269438
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10
000 -10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
CD
[ ]
0.006039176
0.006039787
0.006039153
0.006043345
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]
Iterations: 73

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.008235521
0.008325335
0.007011796
0.009244526
0.001633269
0.001651081
0.001390579
0.001833374

Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [5000 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
303.48711
303.518382
303.4868924
303.6869557
0.006018756
0.006019377
0.006018752
0.00602272

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 8 of 18

Iterations: 72
Analysis interval: 21

31.12.2013

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.002216059
0.002220184
0.002214189
0.002295933
0.001757959
0.001761231
0.001756476
0.001821321

L/e=10 000

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA R

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Iterations:
90
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.008235521
0.008325335
0.007011796
0.009244526
0.001633269
0.001651081
0.001390579
0.001833374

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
100 Yes
9.7863E-07 2.8397E-0
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216
100 Yes
1.94082E-05 5.63168E-0

Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -2-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.090118169
0.090091821
0.090022421
0.090118169
0.004468068
0.004466761
0.004463321
0.004468068

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged000
Value Minimum
Value MaximumANALISIS
Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence
Delta
Criteria
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10
-3-10-6
Y SIMULACI
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
100 Yes
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
0.002791004 0.214777835
0.002790444
0.002785101
0.002792338
100 Yes
0.214762566
0.214707486
0.00473263

0.004732293

1.45973E-06
7.23734E-06

1.46865E-0
7.2816E-0

Maximum Value
Progres
0.214777835
0.004731079
0.00473263

Iterations: 68
Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10 000 -5-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.613080119
0.61304946
0.61274982
0.613097959
0.004863442
0.004863199
0.004860822
0.004863583

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name

Unit

Value

Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta

Criteria

MODELO.SLDPRT
[100.002220184
000 -7-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.002216059
0.002214189
0.002295933
100 Yes
8.17433E-05 0.00010460
CD

[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

0.001757959
0.001761231
Value

0.001756476

0.001821321

100 Yes

6.48455E-05

8.29782E-0

Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
1.227664936
1.227632385
1.227342322
1.227751303
0.004968796
0.004968664
0.00496749
0.004969145

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21
MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA R

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Goal Name
Unit
SG
X
Component
of
Force
1[N]
Iterations: 66
CD interval: 21[ ]
Analysis

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
2.559333462
2.559274564
2.558164244
2.559677817
0.00507567
0.005075553
0.005073351
0.005076353

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.008235521
0.008325335
0.007011796
0.009244526
100 Yes
0.000299136 0.00034698
0.001633269
0.001651081
0.001390579
0.001833374
100 Yes
5.93247E-05 6.88144E-0

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 90
Analysis interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
260.6661583
260.6744563
260.5873187
260.7292194
0.005169531
0.005169696
0.005167968
0.005170782

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -2-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT
[10
000
-10-9
ANALISIS
SIMULACIN
Vsquez
Arribasplata
Gilmer-Ing.
Mecnica
Page
18 Value Progress [%] UseY
Goal
Name
Unit
Value
Averaged
Value Minimum
Value9 of
Maximum
In Convergence31.12.2013
Delta
Criteria
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value 0.090091821
Averaged
Minimum100
Value
0.090118169
0.090022421 Value
0.090118169
Yes
25821.4574
25820.51447
25810.80373
0.004468068 0.005120911
0.004466761
0.004463321
0.004468068 0.005118799
100 Yes
0.005120724

9.57486E-05
4.74723E-06

0.0001378
6.83511E-0

Maximum Value
Progres
25823.85614
0.005121387

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progress
2.559333462
2.559274564
2.558164244
2.559677817
0.00507567
0.005075553
0.005073351
0.005076353

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=10 000

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA R

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name

Unit

Iterations: 66
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Analysis interval: 21

CD

[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progress
260.6661583
260.6744563
260.5873187
260.7292194
0.005169531
0.005169696
0.005167968
0.005170782

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.000200962
0.00020076 0.000200071
0.00020105
100 Yes
9.7863E-07 2.8397E-0
0.00398547 0.003981468 0.003967808 0.003987216
100 Yes
1.94082E-05 5.63168E-0

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-9 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progress
25821.4574
25820.51447
25810.80373
25823.85614
0.005120911
0.005120724
0.005118799
0.005121387

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval:
21
Iterations:
66
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=50 000

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000562928 0.000200962
0.000562815 0.000561737
0.000563197 0.000200071
100 Yes
1.45973E-06 Progress
1.46865E-0
0.00020076
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216
0.002791004 0.002790444 0.002785101 0.002792338
100 Yes
7.23734E-06 7.2816E-0

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progress
0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
0.002791002
0.002790443
0.0027851
0.002792337

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.002216059 0.002216059
0.002220184 0.002214189
0.002295933 0.002214189
100 Yes
8.17433E-05 Progress
0.00010460
0.00222018
0.002295849
0.001757959
0.001761228
0.001756475
0.001821255
0.001757959 0.001761231 0.001756476 0.001821321
100 Yes
6.48455E-05 8.29782E-0

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 73
MODELO.SLDPRT
[50 000 -7-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progress
0.003671311
0.003679226
0.00366967
0.003824395
0.00148591
0.001489114
0.001485246
0.001547869

MODELO.SLDPRT [10 000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA R

Iterations: 73
Vsquez Arribasplata
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name

Unit

Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 10 of 18

Value

31.12.2013

Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta

Criteria

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress
46.17609604
46.17499158
46.16356473
46.17700039
0.003663057
0.00366297
0.003662063
0.003663129

L/e=50 000

Iterations: 68
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -7-10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RUG

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Iterations:
68 [ ]
CD

Analysis interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress
91.8220781
91.81940101
91.79734671
91.82284979
0.003716365
0.003716257
0.003715365
0.003716397

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.000200962
0.00020076 0.000200071
0.00020105
100 Yes
9.7863E-07 2.8397E-06
0.00398547 0.003981468 0.003967808 0.003987216
100 Yes
1.94082E-05 5.63168E-05

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress
189.1705389
189.1665923
189.1216873
189.1742691
0.00375163
0.003751552
0.003750661
0.003751704

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RU

Iterations: 68
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name

Unit

Value

Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta

Criteria

MODELO.SLDPRT
-10-90.000563197
ANALISIS
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.000562928 [50
0.000562815000
0.000561737
100 Yes Y SIMULACIN
1.45973E-06 1.46865E-05
CD Name
[]
0.002791002
Goal
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

0.002790443
0.0027851
100 Yes
7.23733E-06
7.2816E-05
Value
Averaged0.002792337
Value Minimum
Value Maximum
Value Progress
18754.64284
18754.09841
18749.79941
18754.881
0.003719421
0.003719313
0.00371846
0.003719468

Iterations: 76 68
Iterations:
Analysis interval: 21
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RU

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.002216059
0.00222018 0.002214189 0.002295849
100 Yes
8.16602E-05 0.000104583
0.001757959 0.001761228 0.001756475 0.001821255
100 Yes
6.47795E-05 8.29634E-05

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -7-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RU

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 11 of 18

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

31.12.2013

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
0.003671311 0.003679226
0.00366967 0.003824395
100 Yes
0.000154725 0.000205199

CD

[]

0.005120911

0.005120724

0.005118799

0.005121387

100 Yes

2.58855E-06

2.90321E-06

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT
[50 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI
Iterations:
66
Goal Name
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
Analysis
21 of Force Unit
SG X - interval:
Component
1
[N]
0.002216059
0.00222018
0.002214189
0.002295849
CD

[ ]

0.001757959

0.001761228

0.001756475

0.001821255

L/e=50 000

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -7-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RUGOS

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.003671311
0.003679226
0.00366967
0.003824395
0.00148591
0.001489114
0.001485246
0.001547869

Goal
Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
Iterations: 73
SG
X - Component interval:
of Force 1[N] 21 0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
100 Yes
9.7863E-07 2.8397E-06
Analysis
CD
[]
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216
100 Yes
1.94082E-05 5.63168E-05

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
0.001608941
0.001565199
0.00137476
0.001615164

Iterations: 78
Analysis
interval: 2191
Iterations:
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -2-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RUG

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
0.439828164
0.439776019
0.43944735
0.439829323
0.003489069
0.003488655
0.003486048
0.003489078

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
SG
X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.000562928
0.000562815
0.000561737
0.000563197
100 Yes
1.45973E-06 1.46865E-05
Iterations: 65
CD
[]
0.002790443
0.0027851
0.002792337
100 Yes
7.23733E-06 7.2816E-05
Analysis interval:
21 0.002791002

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 76
Analysis interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
1.740831481
1.740791165
1.740433371
1.740870805
0.003452417
0.003452337
0.003451627
0.003452495

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -3-10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN DE LA INFLUENCIA DE LA RUG

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
16.17909406
16.17908309
16.17542907
16.17978021
0.003293416
0.003293414
0.00329267
0.003293556

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
SG
X
Component
of
Force
1
[N]
0.002216059
0.00222018
0.002214189
0.002295849
100
Yes
8.16602E-05
0.000104583
Iterations: 68
Analysis interval:
21 0.001757959
CD
[]
0.001761228
0.001756475
0.001821255
100 Yes
6.47795E-05 8.29634E-05

MODELO.SLDPRT [50 000 -5-10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
46.17609604
46.17499158
46.16356473
46.17700039
0.003663057
0.00366297
0.003662063
0.003663129

Iterations: 68
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT
[50
000 -7-10-7
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
MODELO.SLDPRT
[50 000 -7-10-5
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACIN
DE LA INFLUENCIA
DE LA RUG
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1
[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Progres
91.8220781
91.81940101
91.79734671
91.82284979
0.003716365
0.003716257
0.003715365
0.003716397

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value Progress [%] Use In Convergence Delta
Criteria
SG X - Component
of Force 1[N]
0.003671311
0.003679226
0.00366967Page0.003824395
100 Yes
0.000154725
0.000205199
Vsquez
Arribasplata
Gilmer-Ing.
Mecnica
12 of 18
31.12.2013
CD
0.00148591
0.001489114
0.001485246
0.001547869
100 Yes
6.26229E-05 8.30515E-05
Iterations: 68 [ ]
Analysis interval: 21

L/e=1 000 000

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
0.001608941
0.001565199
0.00137476
0.001615164

Iterations: 91
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
1.574392017
1.574373651
1.574085819
1.574417895
0.003122334
0.003122298
0.003121727
0.003122386

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
113.7286859
113.7322309
113.7152433
113.7371443
0.002255467
0.002255538
0.002255201
0.002255635

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -5-10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
2723.400671
2723.479551
2723.132796
2723.585445
0.002160422
0.002160485
0.00216021
0.002160569

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -8-10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
7077.458662
7077.656662
7076.747905
7077.929002
0.002193128
0.002193189
0.002192907
0.002193273

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -9-10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing.
Mecnica
Page 13
of 18
Value
Averaged
Value

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

8996.632495
0.002202736

8996.881956
0.002202797

31.12.2013

Minimum Value
Maximum Value
8995.721296
8997.233816
0.002202512
0.002202883

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -8-10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULAC

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
7077.458662
7077.656662
7076.747905
7077.929002
0.002193128
0.002193189
0.002192907
0.002193273

L/e=1 000 000

Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -9-10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULAC

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Iterations: 66
Analysis
interval: 21
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
8996.632495
8996.881956
8995.721296
8997.233816
0.002202736
0.002202797
0.002202512
0.002202883

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.00398547
0.003981468
0.003967808
0.003987216

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-9 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21
L/e=100 000 000

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
11150.92158
11151.22714
11149.78256
11151.65434
0.002211455
0.002211516
0.002211229
0.002211601

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Iterations: 78
CD
[]
Analysis
interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
0.003985479
0.003981476
0.003967816
0.003987225

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value
0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
0.001608941
0.001565199
0.00137476
0.001615164

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -2.5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULAC

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Iterations: 91
Analysis interval: 21

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000785247
0.000785172
0.000783811
0.000785697
0.002491689
0.002491449
0.002487132
0.002493116

Iterations: 75
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-7 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -3-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.001031109
0.001032534
0.001029834
0.001061187
0.00227211
0.002275251
0.002269301
0.002338389

Value
Averaged Value Minimum Value Maximum Value
1.574392017
1.574373651
1.574085819
1.574417895
0.003122334
0.003122298
0.003121727
0.003122386

Iterations: 74
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.002216059
0.00222018
0.002214189
0.002295849
0.001757959
0.001761228
0.001756475
0.001821255

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 14 of 18

31.12.2013

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^6 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.002216059
0.00222018
0.002214189
0.002295849
0.001757959
0.001761228
0.001756475
0.001821255

L/e=100 000 000

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACIN
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.000200962
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
CD
[ ]
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.003985479
0.003981476
0.003967816
0.003987225
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
0.001608941
0.001565199
0.00137476
0.001615164

Iterations: 78
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 91
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -2.5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULA

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-2-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.000785247
0.000785172
0.000783811
0.000785697
CD
[ ]
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.002491689
0.002491449
0.002487132
0.002493116
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.072280199
0.072203214
0.07203609
0.072280754
0.003583659
0.003579843
0.003571557
0.003583687

Iterations: 75
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 60
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -3-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-3-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD Name
[ ]
Goal
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.001031109
0.001032534
0.001029834
0.001061187
0.002275251
0.002269301
0.002338389
Value0.00227211
Averaged
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.164251714
0.164195758
0.164006072
0.164251714
0.003619287
0.003618054
0.003613874
0.003619287

Iterations: 74
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 64
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-4-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value

SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

Goal
Unit
CD Name
[ ]
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.002216059
0.00222018
0.002214189
0.002295849
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.001757959Averaged
0.001761228
0.001756475
0.001821255
0.285034737
0.284996896
0.284849311
0.285034881
0.003533006
0.003532537
0.003530707
0.003533007

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval:
21
Iterations:
66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-5-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
CD
[ ]
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.001608941
0.001565199
0.00137476
0.001615164
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.430373464
0.430322024
0.430107109
0.430375475
0.003414067
0.003413659
0.003411954
0.003414083

Iterations: 91
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -2-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9
-6-10-6
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACI

SG X - Component of Force 1[N]

CD Name
[ ]
Goal
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.072280199
0.072203214
0.07203609
0.072280754
0.003583659Averaged
0.003579843
0.003571557
0.003583687
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.608545109
0.608524556
0.608327125
0.608549194
0.003352414
0.003352301
0.003351213
0.003352437

Iterations: 60
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -3-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -7-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI
Goal Name
Unit
Goal
Name
Unit
SG X
- Component of Force
1[N]
SG
X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]
CD
[ ]

Value

Averaged Value

Minimum Value

Maximum Value

Value
Averaged
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.164251714
0.164006072
0.164251714
Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing.
Mecnica Page
150.164195758
ofValue
18
31.12.2013
0.808596772
0.808560735
0.808225526
0.808603537

0.003619287
0.003272678

0.003618054
0.003272532

0.003613874
0.003271176

0.003619287
0.003272706

L/e=100
Iterations: 67 000 000
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -7-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN
Goal Name
Unit
SG
X -Name
Component of Force 1[N]
Goal
Unit
CD
]
SG X - Component of Force [1[N]

CD

[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.000200962 Averaged
0.00020076
0.000200071
0.00020105
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
0.003985479
0.003981476
0.003967816
0.003987225
0.808596772
0.808560735
0.808225526
0.808603537

0.003272678

0.003272532

0.003271176

0.003272706

Iterations: 78
Analysis
interval:
21
Iterations:
66
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -2.5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACI

Goal
Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum ValueY Maximum
Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9 -8-10-6
ANALISIS
SIMULACIN
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[Unit
]
Goal Name
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.000785247
0.000785172
0.000783811
0.000785697
0.002491689 Averaged
0.002491449
0.002487132
0.002493116
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
1.034163865
1.034142432
1.033813361
1.034181214
0.003199444
0.003199378
0.00319836
0.003199498

Iterations: 75
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -3-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal
Name
Unit
Value
Averaged Value
Minimum ValueY Maximum
Value
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9 -9-10-6
ANALISIS
SIMULACIN
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[Unit
]
Goal Name
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.001031109
0.001032534
0.001029834
0.001061187
0.00227211 Averaged
0.002275251
0.002269301
0.002338389
Value
Value
Minimum
Value
Maximum
Value
1.294713972
1.294689128
1.294292403
1.294735131
0.003169978
0.003169917
0.003168946
0.003170029

Iterations: 74
Analysis interval: 21
Iterations: 67
Analysis interval: 21

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -5-10-5 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value

Averaged Value

Minimum Value

Maximum Value

0.002216059
0.002214189
0.002295849
MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9
-10-70.00222018
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 73
Analysis interval: 21

0.001757959

0.001761228

0.001756475

0.001821255

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
1.574392017
1.574373651
1.574085819
1.574417895
0.003122334
0.003122298
0.003121727
0.003122386

Iterations: 67
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9 -10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN D
Analysis interval: 21
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value

Averaged Value

Minimum Value

Maximum Value

0.008112855
0.007892289
0.006932028
0.008144233
MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9
-5-10-7
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Iterations: 91
Analysis interval: 21

0.001608941

0.001565199

0.00137476

0.001615164

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
31.08548288
31.08673757
31.08355431
31.08805027
0.002465949
0.002466049
0.002465796
0.002466153

Iterations: 67
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9 -2-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN
Analysis interval: 21
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
0.072280199
0.072203214
0.07203609
0.072280754
0.003583659
0.003579843
0.003571557
0.003583687

MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9 -10-8 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
Iterations:
60
CD
[ ]

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
113.0115227
113.0148437
112.9981424
113.0194165
0.002241245
0.00224131
0.002240979
0.002241401

Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 66
MODELO.SLDPRT
[10^9 -3-10-6 ANALISIS Y SIMULACIN
Analysis interval: 21
Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

Value

Averaged Value

Minimum Value

Maximum Value

0.164251714
0.164195758
0.164006072
0.164251714
MODELO.SLDPRT [10^9
-10-9
ANALISIS
Y SIMULACIN

Goal Name
Unit
SG X - Component of Force 1[N]
CD
[ ]

0.003619287

0.003618054

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 16 of 18

Iterations: 64
Analysis interval: 21

Iterations: 65

0.003613874

0.003619287

Value
Averaged Value
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
8399.899568
8400.038131
8398.856106
8400.321466
0.001665868
0.001665896
0.001665661
0.001665952

31.12.2013

Anlisis y discusin de resultados:

Con los resultados anteriores se ubic en la tabla los puntos de acuerdo a la rugosidad y
Reynolds resultando el grfico que se puede observar en la siguiente pgina (Ver archivo
Grfico.docx si se revisa el CD)

Ah se puede ver que para rugosidades muy altas como

lo que arroja
e programa con lo que dice la grfica difieren en 0.0008 en la zona turbulenta
y en ms de 0.002 en las zona laminar pero esto no sucede con una rugosidad
ms pequea como la de
y se va haciendo mas aproximados a lo que
dice la grfica mientras se baja la rugosidad.

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 17 of 18

31.12.2013

Conclusiones:
De acuerdo a los resultados se puede decir:
Se ha logrado hacer el clculo con resultados que como el caso de altas
rugosidades no coinciden con mucha exactitud con lo que dice la tabla.
Esto se pude deber a que las ecuaciones para esta zona son aproximadas
y basadas en hecho empricos y que como dice la teora la transicin se
puede adelantar (y por tanto la zona turbulenta) si es que la rugosidad
es alta.
Ya que es claro el salto de los datos que se realiza en un Re=10 6 y que
justamente corresponde a la parte de transicin entonces para esta zona
se necesitara un modelo ms exacto y tener cuidado con el valor del
coeficiente ya que como se ve para la rugosidad de
hay un
salto con una pendiente muy inclinada entre
.

Bibliografa:

Mecnica de Fluidos. Frank M. White.6ta Edicin. Pg. 474-475

Experimentacin en Flujos externos. ISBN 978-84-481-6603-8.

Boundary Layer Theory Dr. HERMANN SCHLICHTING-7ma edicin -pag. 653-654ISBN. 0-07-055334-3

Vsquez Arribasplata Gilmer-Ing. Mecnica Page 18 of 18

31.12.2013