Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jeremy Olson
I. Introduction..............................................................................................................................2
II. The Struggle of Orders...........................................................................................................4
III. Expansion............................................................................................................................10
A. The loss of “Civic Virtue”
b. The Roman soldier’s relationship with his state and his general
IV. Ambitious Politicians...........................................................................................................13
A. Tiberius Gracchus
B. Gaius Gracchus
C. Marius and Sulla
D. Gaius Julius Caesar
V. Conclusion............................................................................................................................32
I. Introduction
The definition of a “republic” according to the Oxford American Diction-
ary is “a state in which supreme power is held by the people and their elec-
7 Christopher Heaton, Kings of Rome, 2003, UNRV History, June 21, 2005
<http://www.unrv.com/empire/kings-of-rome.php>.
8 Titus Livius, 1.48.
9 Titus Livius, 1.57.
10 Titus Livius, 2.1.
23 Gelzer, 3.
In 147 BC, a Roman army led by Scipio Aemilianus utterly destroyed the city
of Carthage.1 This marked the end of the Carthaginian empire and the begin-
ning of a new stage in Roman history. The Carthaginian empire had been the
last significant threat to the Romans. Carthage had been a significant danger
to the Roman’s and as long as it stood as a threat to Rome, the Romans were
united against it. They could not afford to fight among themselves, lest they
be destroyed.
When Carthage fell, so did the bond between the rich and poor class of
Roman people.2 Without the imposing threat of Carthage, there was no unit-
ing factor to keep the Romans “civic virtue” alive. Before Carthage, the Ro-
man government relied heavily on civic virtue: the willingness of the indi-
vidual to subordinate himself to the good of Rome.3 This is clear through the
laws that were established in the early republic, such as that of the tribune-
ship. The tribunes could use their veto power over any piece of legislation in
the name of the people of Rome. The Senate established this law trusting
that the tribune’s would use the tribuneship for the good of Rome and not for
their own personal benefit. Carthage helped fuel the civic virtue that was
already dwindling during the confusion of the struggle between the plebeians
and the patricians. When Carthage fell, the civic virtue that was keeping the
Romans united was essentially nullified. This loss of civic virtue led politi-
cians, to fight primarily for their own interests, rather than for the good of
Rome.4 This general corruption in Roman politics elevated the struggle of the
orders to an unprecedented level. It also led to many unfair laws and dam-
aging rivalry’s between Roman politicians which caused significant problems
in the effectiveness of the Roman Republic as a government.
1 Christopher Heaton, Third Punic War, 2003, UNRV History, June 7, 2005
<http://www.unrv.com/empire/third-punic-war.php>.
2 J. Rufus Fears, “Famous Romans Part 1, lecture 7: Tiberius and Gaius Grac-
chus,” University of Oklahoma, Norman, 2001.
3 Fears, “Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus”.
4 Fears, Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus.
Not only did the fall of Carthage and conquests in the east bring im-
mense wealth into Rome, but an unprecedented number of slaves as well.5
Because the price of slaves decreased so significantly, equestrians pur-
chased thousands of these conquered foes and used them to manage huge
plantations. This became a significant issue for many years because the bulk
of Roman citizens made a living off of farming. Because the small farmer
could not compete with the giant estates nor with any other job because of
cheap slave labor, the majority of working class Roman citizens were forced
onto the streets of Rome. This became an immense problem because the
backbone of the Roman army was the small farmer, and only land-owning
citizens were allowed to join the army. This became an even greater dilemma
in 107 BC when the Cimbri and Teutonic tribes began migrating in the north,
destroying everything in their way.6 The already dwindling Roman army had
no recruiting base, and the forces fighting in the North were suffering numer-
ous defeats against the Gauls. This led to the adoption of Gaius Marius’ le-
gion reforms which, in themselves, became a major factor in the decline of
the Roman Republic.
In 107 BC, Gaius Marius was a rising star in the Roman political world.7
As consul, he proposed one of the most crucial reforms in the decline of the
Roman Republic. Along with numerous reforms to the legion and the way it
fought, Marius offered the entire head count of Rome, rich and poor, land
owning and non-landowning, the opportunity to serve under him in the
army.8 This gave disenfranchised Roman farmers the chance of some kind of
A. Tiberius Gracchus
Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus were essentially the initiators of the trend
of going to any measure to carry through an agenda with the backing of the
general people of Rome. This caused the senate and the higher class Roman
citizens to fight back with equal energy, resulting in political turmoil such as
Rome had not seen before. This went on to such an extent that laws were
compromised, holes in the government were found, open corruption began,
and violence ran rampant.
The Roman historian Plutarch praised Tiberius highly for His virtue, say-
ing in his narrative The Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans, “Notwith-
standing, amidst the greatest misfortunes, and in the most unsuccessful en-
terprises, not only the discretion and valor of Tiberius, but also, which was
still more to be admired, the great respect and honor which he showed for
his general, were most eminently remarkable.”1 Though the Gracchi brothers
1 Plutarch, 673.
2 Homer, The Iliad of Homer, ed. Britannica Great Books, 24 vols. (Chicago,
Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc., 1952) 47.
3 "Optimates" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimates>.
4 "Populares" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populares >.
5 Plutarch, 674.
B. Gaius Gracchus
12 Plutarch, 680.
13 "Scipio Aemilianus Africanus" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by
Jimmy Wales and Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 <
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scipio_Aemilianus_Africanus >.
14 "Gaius Gracchus" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales
and Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Grac-
chus >.
15 Christopher Heaton, Gaius Gracchus, 2003, UNRV History, August 16,
2005
< http://www.unrv.com/empire/gaius-gracchus.php >.
16 Suzanne Cross, Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus, 2001, Julius Caesar: The
Last Dictator, Agust 16, 2005 <
http://heraklia.fws1.com/contemporaries/gracchi/ >.
17 Heaton, Gaius Gracchus.
18 Heaton, Gaius Gracchus.
The stakes raised with Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus escalated to an un-
precedented level with the infamous rivalry of Gaius Marius and Lucius
Cornelius Sulla. The years of Marius and Sulla were marked with political tur-
moil, confusion, and bloodshed. If the Roman people were convinced that the
Roman Republic was becoming ineffective as a government, this became
even more evident with Marius and Sulla.
Just as Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus, Marius spent his early career
serving under Scippio Aemilianus in Hispania.22 Because Marius did not have
any political position at birth,23 he had to rise through the ranks of the army
before he could have any political influence. Marius proved himself to be an
excellent soldier and quickly rose through the ranks of the military.24 In 123
BC, Marius became a novus homo or new man, the title given to a plebeian
22 Plutarch, 333.
23 Plutarch, 333.
24 Christopher Heaton, Rise of Marius, 2003, UNRV History, June 15, 2005
<http://www.unrv.com/empire/rise-of-marius.php>.
In 107 BC, the Roman people were utterly frustrated with their govern-
ment because of Jugurtha, the king of Numidia. Jugurtha was a brilliant gen-
eral and led the Numidian armies against the surrounding nations, including
allies of Rome. The Roman allies appealed to Rome for help, and envoys
were sent to stop Jugurtha’s attacks. The envoys were sent home empty
25 "Novus Homo" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novus_homo >.
26 Heaton, Rise of Marius.
27 Plutarch, 333.
28 Heaton, Rise of Marius
29 Plutarch, 334.
30 Plutarch, 334.
31 Heaton, Rise of Marius.
35 Plutarch, 369.
36 Christopher Heaton, Cimbri and Teutons, 2003, UNRV History, June 18,
2005
< http://www.unrv.com/empire/cimbri-teutons.php >.
37 "Marius" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and Larry
Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marius >.
38 Heaton, Cimbri and Teutons.
39 Christopher Heaton, Political Turmoil, 2003, UNRV History, June 18, 2005
< http://www.unrv.com/empire/political-turmoil.php >.
40 Plutarch, 345.
41 Plutarch, 345-346.
42 Christopher Heaton, Fall of Marius, 2003, UNRV History, June 18, 2005
< http://www.unrv.com/empire/fall-of-marius.php >.
43 Plutarch, 373.
51 Plutarch, 386.
52 Plutarch, 506-507.
53 "Julius Caesar" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_caesar >.
54 Christopher Heaton, Gaius Julius Caesar, 2003, UNRV History, June 18,
2005
< http://www.unrv.com/fall-republic/gaius-julius-caesar.php >.
55 "Julius Caesar" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_caesar >.
56 Heaton, Gaius Julius Caesar.
57 Plutarch, 581.
58 Plutarch, 578.
59 Plutarch, 578.
60 Plutarch, 579.
61 Plutarch, 579.
62 "Julius Caesar" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_caesar >.
63 Plutarch, 582.
64 "Julius Caesar" Wikipedia, Site created and designed by Jimmy Wales and
Larry Sanger, 15 January 2001 < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_caesar >.
65 Plutarch, 586.
75 Plutarch, 600.
76 Christopher Heaton, Caesar the King, 2003, UNRV History, August 22,
2005
< http://www.unrv.com/fall-republic/caesar-the-king.php >.
77 Christopher Heaton, Ides of March, 2003, UNRV History, August 22, 2005
< http://www.unrv.com/fall-republic/ides-of-march.php >.
78 Plutarch, 603.
Soon after the stage of growth, ambitious politicians exposed and used
the gaping holes in the Roman Republic for their advantage, and the Repub-
lic’s demise. The Gracchi brothers found the power of the people. They used
the general population’s thirst for equal rights with the governing classes to
gain tremendous power. And they used the tribuneship to use this power in
practicality. Gaius Marius and Lucius Sulla contributed to the political power
machine by exposing the tremendous power of a loyal army at the back of a
politician, exposing the ineffectiveness of the Roman Republic to the public.
Caesar combined all these powers and circumstances along with his lineage
and brilliance to completely upturn the Roman Republic, causing its collapse
in 44 BC when he was proclaimed dictator for life. What started as a Republic
with tremendous hidden holes, was weakened with the growth of Rome, and
finally completely destroyed by ambitious politicians who manipulated the
holes to gain personal power. These three major factors, though ineffective
by themselves, built on each other to cause the fall of the Roman Republic.