You are on page 1of 2

Wrong operation situation of the Directional Phase Over-current: The standard setting for the angle is 45.

With such a setting, it exists a ris of non detection or!and un"anted tripping: detection of a fault on the opposite side of a transfor#er $d or D%. This ris of "rong operation can occur on & net"or configurations:

Protection of 2 transformers in Parallel


The + phase currents on the ,, side, are in the ration &-,-, The characteristic angle is set for the Directional protection at 45. The highest current is in the expected .one /operating .one for the fault% inco#er, non tripping .one for the safe inco#er0. One of the 1lo"2 currents is on the li#its of the .one. With the data given /cf dra"ing0, it is %et in the tripping .one. The ris is to trip the )oth inco#ers. (ore generall%, the ris exists if the i#pedance of fault% )ranch /3t 4 3f0 is higher than the i#pedance of the safe )ranch /3t 43f 43cc0. 5olution: With a +-phase directional protection, the highest current is al"a%s #easured6 using an 17D(T2 ti#e dela%, the ris of spurious tripping is avoided. 8lse, use a +-phase directional protection and trip "hether at least & phases detect the fault in the .one. 9: & out of + logic used.

2-phase fault

This exa#ple is a t%pical configuration on 'tilit% (ain su)station in '*.

Protection of 2 Incomers
This fault is ;uite si#ilar fro# the previous one. Onl% the values change. The + currents seen )% the directional protection are in the ratio &-,-,. One of the 1lo"2 currents is in the "rong .one, "hether the i#pedance of the fault% )ranch /3t 4 3l0 is higher than the short-circuit i#pedance, "hich is often the case. <onse;uence : spurious tripping of one or )oth inco#ers. 5olution : 5et up the threshold of the directional higher than the &-phase short-circuit current at the secondar% side. 8lse, set up the angle at +=. 8lse #ore, use a +-phase directional protection and trip if &phases at least are detecting the fault in the .one.

2-phase fault

You might also like