: The Results

.4
.1.4
.1.1.4 :

) (1.4 30

94 3 40 3 .

) (0.05

) (LSD = 5.89

) (
).(r = 0.937
y = 0.0092x3 - 0.7161x2 + 15.326x - 26.823
R2 = 0.8785

110
100
14; 94

90

70
60
50
40
30

) (

80

20
10
0
30

28

26

24

20

22

18

16

14

12

10

)(

) (1.4
35.
) (2.4
30 1568.34 3

52.27 .3

1-

(
55.84 .3 1- ) .(3.4
40

 : The Results

47.41 3 .
1800
y = 0.0027x4 - 0.2627x3 + 7.6542x2 - 14.373x
R2 = 0.9993

1600
1400

1000
800

600

) (

1200

400
200
0
32

30

28

26

24

20

22

16

18

14

12

10

)(

) (2.4 .
60

19; 55.84
y = -0.115x2 + 5.2398x - 3.2243
R2 = 0.9949

50
45

19; 55.84

Days 18 - 24

57

40

56

35

55

30

54

25

53

20

52

16

1-

26

24

22

20

18

14

51

10

15

) . (

30; 52.28

55

0
32

30

28

26

24

22

20

18

16

14

12

10

)(

) (3.4 .
*
41

 : The Results
.2.1.4 :

%37.12
%62.70
) %0.13 .(4.4

) (4.4
.3.1.4 :
) (1.4

) (pH=7.5
) .(pH=7.9
%2.918 ) ( %1.654
%56.683

%2.441 %1.208

%16.35 %26.96

%93.5 ) .(5.4
42

 : The Results

1.768 . 1-
0.819 .

1-

1.272
.

1-

%28.05

0.553 . 1-

%32.48

%25.286
%14.634 %42.13
) .(1.4

%5.240 %5.062

.%3.4
) (4.83
) (2.89 ).(1.4

%0.092
%8.7
) %0.084 .(5.4

) (1.4 3.2
) 1(
170 ) 1(

%94.68

)(P0.05

) pH TS VS

COD BOD TOC (

.

43

 : The Results
) .(1.4 .

pH

*7.5

7.9

TS %

*2.918

2.441

16.35

VS %

*1.654

1.208

26.96

VS/TS %

*56.68

42.52

93.50

)COD (g.L-1

*1.768

1.272

28.05

)BOD (g.L-1

*0.819

0.553

32.48

TOC %

*25.29

14.634

42.13

TN %

5.240

5.062

3.40

TP %

0.092

0.084

8.70

C/N Ratio

*4.83

2.89

)Coliforms (cell . ml-1

10 x 3.2

94.68

10 x 1.7

* .(P0.05) 0.05

100

93.50

94.68

90
80
70

50
42.13
32.48

40
28.05

26.96

30
16.35

8.70

20
10

3.40

0
Coliforms

TP

TN

TOC

BOD

COD

VS/TS

VS

TS

) .(5.4 .
44

)(%

60

 : The Results
.2.4
.1.2.4 .
) 6.4 7.4 (8.4
90

1893

166.5 3
158.5 3

)(P0.05

LSD ) (2.26
) (
) 0.967 0.982 (0.992 .
y = 4E-05x4 - 0.0059x3 + 0.2102x2 + 2.7399x
R2 = 0.9361

200

44; 189
180
160

120
100
80

60

)( 3

140

40
20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (6.4
35.

45

 : The Results
y = 4E-05x4 - 0.0066x3 + 0.2637x2 + 1.2171x
R2 = 0.9636

180

47; 166.50

160
140

100
80
60

)( 3

120

40
20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

50

55

40

45

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (7.4
35.

y = 4E-05x4 - 0.0061x3 + 0.2457x2 + 1.2414x

R2 = 0.9831

180

45; 158.50

160
140

100
80

60

)( 3

120

40
20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (8.4
35.

46

 : The Results
) (9.4 90
8597 - 6966
3
8597 3 90
95.52 .31- 7234.5 3
80.38 .31-
6966.5 3
77.41 .3) 1- .(2.4
) (2.4 .

)(3

)(

1) . 3 (

1).3 (VS

8597.0

90

95.52

113.88

7234.5

90

80.38

89.76

6966.5

90

77.41

89.22

)LSD (P0.05

103.7

1.398

1.591

10

10

1
0

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(9.4 .
47

)(

 : The Results
) 10.4 (11.4

114.31 100.07 .3 .

97.22 .3 1- ) (12.4
89.22 89.76
113.88 .3 VS 1-
90 ) .(2.4

.

)(

48

 : The Results
y = 1E-05x4 - 0.002x3 + 0.1012x2 + 0.5952x + 10.365
R2 = 0.9976

61; 114.20

120
110

90; 95.52

90
61; 114.20

Days 52 - 63

115

80

114

70

113

60

112

50
40

111

1-

48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68

110

20

30

) . (

100

10
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

45

50

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(10.4
35.

y = 9E-06x4 - 0.0018x3 + 0.0904x2 + 0.7248x

R2 = 0.9987

61; 100.07

110
100

90; 80.38

80
101

61; 100.07

70

100
Days 53 - 64

60

99

50

98

95

20

48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68

10
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(11.4
35.

49

96

30

97

40

) . 3 ( 1-

90

 : The Results
y = 7E-06x4 - 0.0014x3 + 0.0698x2 + 1.015x
R2 = 0.9985

59; 97.22

110

90
80

90; 77.41

70

99

60

98

59; 97.22

97

Days 53 - 64

50

96

40

95
94

30

93

) . 3 ( 1-

100

92

48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68

20
10
0

90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

15

20

10

)(

) .(12.4
35.
.2.2.4 .


. CH4
.%59.2 - 52.6 %55.7

CO2
%59.2

)(P0.05

%55.31 %52.6 ) .(3.4

) (3.4 .

59.203

40.742

0.055

55.314

44.655

0.031

52.607

47.310

0.083

)LSD (P0.05

2.231

1.825

0.012

50

 : The Results
.3.2.4
).(4.4

TS 78.6
80.25 81.35
%70.67 75.77 VS / TS %89.91%91.28
%93.14 .

%53.89 %58.36 %62.92

0.66 0.69
%0.72 .

/ C/N 81.40 87.63
%84.71 .
) (4.4 %0.15
%0.21
%0.17 .
) (4.4

TS%
VS%
VS/TS %
TOC%
TN%
TP%
C/N

81.35
75.77
93.14
62.92
0.72
0.17
87.63

80.25
73.25
91.28
58.36
0.69
0.21
84.71

78.60
70.67
89.91
53.89
0.66
0.15
81.40

51

 : The Results

7.3

90
) (7.9
) (7.1
) (6.7 ) .(5.4

) (5.4 90
.

pH
TS%
VS%
VS/TS
)COD (g.L-1
TOC%
TN%
TP%
C/N

7.30
4.42
3.77
85.43
4.42
49.54
1.15
0.14
43.22

7.30
4.56
4.03
88.46
5.27
57.75
1.19
0.16
48.72

7.30
4.50
3.90
86.75
4.93
53.62
1.16
0.20
46.05

7.90
1.76
1.35
76.70
1.45
20.38
1.09

7.20
1.89
1.65
87.30
2.09
24.87
1.13

6.70
1.91
1.63
85.34
2.02
24.61
1.11

0.13
18.7

0.15
22.01

0.18
22.17

%60.18 %58.55 %57.56

TS 90
) (13.4 ) (1 TS %1.76
TS %1.89 TS %1.91
%4.56 - 4.42 ) .(5.4
52

 : The Results
70
60.18

57.56

58.55

60
50

30

TS Removal %

40

20
10
0

) .(13.4 .
%64.19 VS %59.06
%58.21 ) (14.4
%87.64 %90.98
)) (VS/TS .(15.4
64.19
58.21

59.06

70
60
50

30
20
10
0

) .(14.4 .
53

VS Removal %

40

 : The Results
100
87.64

89.14

90.98

90
80

60
50
40
30

VS/TS Removal %

70

20
10
0

) .(15.4 .
- 4.42
5.27 . ) (5.4 COD
%67.19 %60.34 %59.03
) .(16.4
67.19
59.03

60.34

70
60

40
30
20

COD Removal %

50

10
0

) .(16.4 .
54

 : The Results

) (%49.54 %57.75
%53.62 .
%54.10
%56.94 %58.86 ) .(17.4
70

54.10

58.86

56.94

60

40
30
20

TOC Removal %

50

10
0

) .(17.4 .
%1.19 -1.15
43.22
48.72 . %5.22
%4.20 %4.32
) (18.4
18.70 21.82 22.17
90 ) .(5.4
%0.20 - 0.14


%10 %7.14
%6.25 ) .(19.4
55

 : The Results
6
5.22
5

TN Removal %

4.31

4.20

) .(18.4 .
11
10.00

10
9

6.25

6
5
4

TP Removal %

7.14

3
2
1
0

) .(19.4 .
0.05


) ( LSD ).(6.4
56

 : The Results
) .(6.4 .
TS

VS

VS/TS

COD

TOC

TN

TP

60.18

64.19

90.98

67.19

58.86

5.22

7.14

58.55

59.06

89.14

60.34

56.94

4.20

6.25

57.56

58.21

87.64

59.03

54.10

4.31

10.00

)LSD (P0.05

1.29

1.74

2.06

1.51

1.28

0.43

0.66

.3.4 .
.1.3.4 .
) (20.4


246.33 3

50 - 39
231 .3
55 .
35

55

260

29; 246.33
43; 231

240
220

Days 39 - 50

200

160
140
120
100

80

) (

180

60
40
20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(20.4 .
57

 : The Results
55

90

11147 3 5524

) .(7.4 )(21.4

.
) .(7.4 .

)(3

)(

1) . 3 (

1).3 (VS

35

*11147

90

*123.86

*148.11

55

5524

90

61.38

73.40

12

55

12

35

10

10

)(

11

11

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(21.4 .




.
58

 : The Results

90

123.86 .3 1- 61.38 .3

1-

145.38 .3 1- 35
55 133.55 .3 1-
) .(22.4
160
55

60; 145.38

35

35; 133.55
90; 123.86

120
100
80

90; 61.38

60

40

) . 3 ( 1-

140

m
m

20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(22.4 .

35
148.11.3 VS 1- 73.4.3VS 1-
) .(7.4


) (.

59

 : The Results

0.05

32 37 55
35 64-55

.
.2.3.4 .

)(P0.05

%66.04
%41.75

%0.062 .
.3.3.4 .
) (8.4

)(pH=8
) (pH=5.6
).(pH=7.2
) (8.4
.

%1.73 %2.86
TS %4.32 .
%59.97
%33.83 ) .(9.4
60

 : The Results

%3.76 %1.4
%2.44

%62.8
%91.17
%35.16 %90.49
) .(9.4

%69.52 COD

%39.04 ) .(9.4

%19.85 %32.99
%50.84
%35.11 %60.96
) .(9.4

%1.76-1.74 %1.86

%5.38 %6.45
C/N
C/N 11.28 18.96
27.39 ) .(7.4

%0.13 ) %7.86 .(9.4

)(P0.05

) (

35 55 .

61

 : The Results
) .(8.4 .

pH
TS %
VS %
VS/TS %
)COD (g.L-1
TOC %
TN %
TP %
C/N Ratio

7.2
4.32
3.76
87.07
4.56
50.84
1.86
0.14
27.39

) 90 (
55
35
5.6
8
2.86
1.73
2.44
1.40
85.31
80.92
2.78
1.39
32.99
19.85
1.74
1.76
0.13
0.13
18.96
11.28

)LSD (P0.05
0.51
0.27
0.12
2.10
0.48
4.43
*
..
..
1.75

* . . .

) .(9.4 .

TN

TP

TS

35

*60.96* 69.52* 91.17* 62.80* 59.97

5.38

7.86

55

35.11

6.45

7.86

33.83

VS

35.16

VS/TS

90.49

COD

39.04

TOC

.4.4 .
.1.4.4 .
) (23.4


.

49 - 40

56 - 38
237 3 314 3


.
62

 : The Results
) (24.4

15384 3 11391 3

90 ) .(10.4
350

43; 314

300

Days 38 - 56
44; 237

200

Days 40 - 49

150

)( 3

250

100
Days 65 - 90

50
0

90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(23.4
35.
16

16

12

12

10

10

)(

14

14

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(24.4 .
63

 : The Results

170.93 .3 1- 126.57 .3

1-

) (10.4
) 25.4 .(26.4

206.37 .3 1-
) (25.4 148.73 .3 1- ) .(26.4

201.73.3 VS 1-
149.37.3 VS 1- ) .(10.4
) .(10.4 .

)(3

)(

) . 3(

).3 (VS

*15384

90

*170.93

*201.73

11391

90

126.57

149.37

y = 1E-05x4 - 0.0021x3 + 0.1053x2 + 2.3902x + 12.305

R2 = 0.9972

61; 206.37

220
200

90; 170.93

160
140

210
61; 206.37

207

120

204
Days 56 - 64

100

201

80

198
195

60

) . 3(1-

180

192
50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70

40

20
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(25.4 .
64

 : The Results
y = 8E-06x4 - 0.0016x3 + 0.0737x2 + 1.9959x + 7.4486
R2 = 0.9978

61; 148.73

160

90; 126.57

120
100

150

61; 148.73

148

80

Days 56 - 64
146

60

144

142

40

) . (

140

1-

50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70

20
0

90

85

80

70

75

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(26.4 .
0.05

56 - 38
49 - 40

56 64

.
.
.2.4.4 .

) (P0.05

%72.58 %67.12

% 33- 28

.%0.18
65

 : The Results
.3.4.4 .

) (11.4

) (pH=7.9
) (pH=7.3
).(pH=7.2
) (11.4

%1.71 %1.42
%4.276 .
%60
%66.79 ) .(12.4

%3.8 %1.46
%1.14
%61.7 %91.7

%70.1 %93.59
) .(12.4


4.61 . 1- 1.28 1.42 . 1-
COD 72.23 %69.2
.

%17.83 %19.96 %51.21

66

 : The Results
%61 %65.18
) .(12.4

%1.79 - 1.78

%1.91
%6.33
%6.86 C/N

11.15 10.02
26.8 ) .(11.4

%8.25
) %12.08 .(12.4
0.05


) ( .
) .(11.4 .
) 90 (

LSD

pH

7.2

7.3

TS %

4.276

1.42

1.71

VS %

3.813

1.14

1.46

0.31

VS/TS %

89.17

80.28

85.38

2.94

)COD (g.L-1

4.61

1.28

1.42

0.12

TOC %

51.21

17.83

19.96

1.65

TN %

1.91

1.78

1.79

0.09

TP %

0.26

0.23

0.24

0.02

C/N Ratio

26.80

10.02

11.15

0.88

)(P0.05

7.9

0.36
0.28

67

 : The Results
) .(12.4 .

TN

TP

TS

VS

*65.18* 72.23* 93.59* 70.10* 66.79

6.86

*12.08

61.02

6.33

8.25

60.01

VS/TS

61.71

COD

91.70

TOC

69.20

.5.4 .
.1.5.4 .
) (27.4



.
37 55
44 318 3
42 330 3 58
.

350

42; 330

Days 37 - 55

300

44; 318

200

150

100

50

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(27.4 100
35.
68

) (

250

 : The Results


) (28.4
16936 3
15366 3 90 ) .(13.4
18

18

14

14

12

12

10

10

)(

16

16

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(28.4 100
35.

170.73 188.18 .3 1- ) .(13.4


) .(30.4
221.44 .3

1-

206.42 .3 1- ) .(29.4

225.15.3 VS 1- 204.28.3

1-

VS ) .(13.4
69

 : The Results
) .(13.4 100
35.

)(3

)(

) . 3(

).3 (VS

*16936

90

*188.18

*225.15

15366

90

170.73

204.28

59; 221.44

250

225

Days 56 - 63

90; 188.18

175

90; 170.73

150
125
100
75

) .3( 1-

59; 206.42
200

50

n
m

25
0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) .(29.4 100
35.

)(P0.05

54 - 37 55 - 38

56 63
.
70

 : The Results
.2.5.4 .

%74.3
%73.52

%25.5 - 26.4
.%0.16
.3.5.4 .
) (14.4

).(pH= 7.1 - 7.2

%4.21 %3.76
%1.33
%1.4
%66.78 %68.44 .
%1.04 %1.12

%70.22

%93.85

%72.35 %94.35
) .(15.4


4.51 . 1- 1.16 1.23 . 1-
COD 72.73 %74.28 .

%18
%18.29 %51.45
%64.45 ) %65 .(15.4
71

 : The Results

%1.78 - 1.77 %1.9

%6.93 %6.40
C/N

C/N 27.05

10.12 10.33
) .(13.4

%0.24-0.23

%10.67 %14.39
) .(15.4
0.05

.
) .(14.4 100
90.

)LSD (P0.05

pH

7.2

7.1

7.2

..

TS %

4.214

1.33

1.40

0.18

VS %

3.761

1.04

1.12

0.13

VS/TS %

89.25

78.20

80.00

8.69

)COD (g.L-1

4.51

1.16

1.23

0.15

TOC %

51.45

18.01

18.29

1.47

TN %

1.90

1.78

1.77

..

TP %

0.27

0.24

0.23

0.02

C/N Ratio

27.05

10.12

10.33

0.68

. .
72

 : The Results
) .(15.4 100 .

TS

VS

VS/TS

COD

TOC

TN

TP

68.44

72.35

94.35

74.28

65.00

6.40

10.67

66.78

70.22

93.85

72.73

64.45

6.93

14.39

.6.4 :Bioreactor
.1.6.4 :

90
) (30.4

42 3.45
37 54

.
4.0
y = 6E-07x4 - 0.0001x3 + 0.0035x2 + 0.0654x
R2 = 0.9712

42; 3.45

3.5

Days 37 - 54

3.0

2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (30.4 )(
35.
73

)(

2.5

 : The Results
) (31.4

90 179.35

%52

%26.67

%21.34

. %7.47

1.99 . 1-

90
2.35 . 1-
) .(32.4
237.27 3 VS.

0.05

54-37

)(P0.05

63-53

.
200
y = -0.0006x3 + 0.0766x2 - 0.2262x
R2 = 0.9992

180
160
140

Days 61 - 75
Production 13.87%

120
100
80

Days 31 - 60
Production 51.99%

60

)(

Days 76 - 90
Production 7.47%

40
20

Days 1 - 30
Production 26.67%

0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (31.4
35.
74

 : The Results
2.7
y = -0.0005x2 + 0.0694x
R2 = 0.9939

59; 2.35

2.4

90; 1.99

41; 1.99
1.8
2.38
59; 2.35

1.5

2.36
2.34

Days 56 - 63

1.2

2.32
2.30

0.9

2.28
2.26

0.6

2.24

65

55

0.3

1-

70

60

50

) . (

2.1

0.0
90

85

80

75

70

65

60

55

50

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

)(

) (32.4
35.
.2.6.4 :

%77.06

%22.86
%0.08 %81.74

.
.3.6.4 :
) (33.4

15

COD
%25.65
14.12.
)
6.83 26 (
75

 : The Results

6.48 10

.COD

7.04 10

COD
7.25 90 .
.

)(P0.05

) (.(16.4 .
) .(16.4 .
COD

pH

Methanogens Coliforms

*0.445

*-0.5103

*0.813

*0.9571

Production

*-0.923

*0.7826

*0.2019

COD

*-0.8936

*-0.2828

pH

*0.657

Coliforms

8.0

60

Methanogensis

Acidogensis

Hydrolysis

7.5

)( % COD

6.5

40

6.0
30
5.5
5.0

20

4.5
10
4.0
0

50
7.0

3.5
90

75

45

60

30

15

)(
pH

COD

) .(33.4 .
76

 : The Results
%70

VS

%76.72
%96.26
) .(34.4

100
90
80
70

50
40

60

30
20
10
0
TP

TOC

TN

VS/TS

COD

TS

VS

) .(34.4 .

%82.39 90 %88.5 COD

60 %78.06

) .(34.4

7.53 %9.85

) .(34.4
C/N= 6.43 27.1 ) .(17.4
) .(17.4 90
.
pH

TS

VS

VS/TS

COD

TOC

TN

TP

C/N
ratio

7.20

*4.24

*3.78

*89.10

*4.60

*51.32

*1.89

*0.27

*27.11

7.25

1.23

0.88

71.54

0.81

11.26

1.52

0.18

6.43

77

 : The Results

78