You are on page 1of 8

Saulan 1

John Vincent Saulan


California State University Northridge Professor Florian
English 114B
20 March 2014
An Ambitious Vision of a Utopian Nazi Germany
Sir Thomas More, a sixteenth century English author, introduced a magnificent and
blissful fictitious paradise nation in his novel, Utopia. He brilliantly described a flawless society,
called Utopia, where every citizen had equal rights, spoke a common native language and were
educated. The majority of the population dressed in similar clothing that symbolized equal status
throughout their region. Every Utopian was required to be a farmer since agriculture was their
greatest asset and resource, while also being trained in another specific skill. There was still a
distinct social class, a meager number of Utopians that were excluded from labor and were able
to pursue higher education due to their professions.
The nation of Utopia was absolutely peaceful with its public affairs where political and
social disputes were rare. Everyone must follow a common law throughout their region, and
those who have gone against it will be enslaved. Each citizen must not leave their specified
district or city, have complete tolerance over other religions, and spare any enemies from
conquered nations. Surely slavery is not a characteristic of an ideal utopian society but within the
context explained by More, it was more of a social service for the beneficial growth of the
country. The slaves were not treated inhumanely and there were even immigrant indentured
servants who voluntarily joined the slave labor force as a gain of having better life opportunities.
Thomas Mores philosophies depicted in his novel were certainly radical for his era as it
goes against contemporary beliefs, societies, and government systems. His proposal of a
Saulan 2

balanced and equal society where everyone sought to be educated, have an efficient labor force,
and create equal status among all social classes can be drawn from modern ideologies such as
socialism. There was no clear economic gains by the Utopians from their labor in agriculture or
other occupations but instead worked for the well-being of their country. This utopian socialism
is a perfect example and a foreshadowing of Nazi Germany.
Adolf Hitler, the leader of the Nazi regime, had the fantasy of creating a thousand year
global rule for German and Aryan peoples. Germany, a heavily ravaged country from the First
World War was a dystopia. But during the reign of Hitler, he transformed the country into a
prosperous nation by creating jobs for every citizen and educating all of its children. Although it
was certain that Hitler was surely thriving to a utopian society, Nazi Germany and its Axis allies
faced the troubles of the Second World War that proved a great obstacle for his vision of a
German utopia.
During the early 1930s, Germany was a dysfunctional nation which greatly suffered
from the wreckage of World War I and the global economic depression. Famine, poverty, and
unemployment struck the region by the masses. Adolf Hitler and his National Socialist German
Workers Party, better known as the Nazi Party, took advantage of this dystopian society by
seizing the power of the government in a militaristic fashion. Hitler was appointed chancellor of
Germany, and strictly imposed Nazi ideals and control. He prioritized on improving the economy
of the country by giving the citizens lower taxes and higher wages, and creating Germany as the
nation with the highest standard of living. The excerpt from the website, Institute for Historical
Review, clearly states the example in an interview of Hitler in 1934: In my opinion, the
Americans are right in not wanting to make everyone the same but rather in upholding the
principle of the ladder. However, every single person must be granted the opportunity to climb
Saulan 3

up the ladder. (1). His greatest objective though was to institute a worldwide order for Germans
and Aryans, people of Germanic ethnic descent that contain strong Caucasian features, and
exterminate those who are not up to status. It surely was a progression to a racist and socialistic
utopia.
There is a clear correlation between the society that Thomas More created in his novel
and the ideologies of Adolf Hitler. Certainly the imposition of Hitler was vainly immoral, but the
idea of a coercive equal nation for a certain population was definitely present. The society
described in Utopia contains features that can be interpreted as early operations of social control.
Every Utopian household contained thirty members who have elected officials and
administrators ruled over them. Under this hierarchical-like rule, it was used to contain any
disputes and disapprovals against the government and prevent it to spread throughout the region.
This restriction of government criticism surely rests on the totalitarian approach of the
Nazis. Censorship was a prominent action enacted by the Nazi party, especially during the
inception of their rule in the 1930s. Any ideologies that posed as threats to the reign of the Nazis
were censored from all forms of media. They carried and implemented strong images of
propaganda throughout mainstream Germany. Such actions included a mass burning of books
from intellectuals whose views were indifferent of the Nazis; and an excerpt from the United
States Holocaust Memorial Museum website cites this example, more than 25,000 books were
burned. Some were works of Jewish writers, including Albert Einstein and Sigmund Freud. Most
of the books were by non-Jewish writers, including such famous Americans as Jack London,
Ernest Hemingway, and Sinclair Lewis (1).
Adolf Hitler and his trusted high-ranking officials used numerous propaganda campaigns
to gain influence and power over German citizens. In order for the nation to progress into an
Saulan 4

absolute utopian society, education became one of their main priorities. The Nazi-controlled
German government surely provided schooling for all of its youth, but also enforced their own
socialistic racist ideologies for supremacy. As they censored and banned books written by
individuals who they thought were degenerates and threats to their culture, wrote their own
textbooks that included worshiping Hitler as a supreme being, absolute loyalty to the Nazi
regime, anti-Semitism, homophobia, and that the Aryans were only the righteous beings.
National holidays that celebrated the glory of the Nazis and their leader were also created
throughout the nation to further impose their influence.
As Germany continued to prosper and regained its economic power, the desire of Hitler
to expand his regime throughout Europe and eventually the world grew drastically. He greatly
ambitioned to create a Nazi centralized global capital megacity called Welthauptstadt Germania,
meaning World Capital Germania. He longed for magnificent infrastructures of Nazi symbolism
and the largest capital buildings and monuments that would have put the empires of ancient
Rome to shame.
The ambitious fantasy of Adolf Hitler for a thousand year German global reign saw a
bright gleam of reality during the beginnings of Nazi occupied Germany. Hitler sought absolute
power by demonstrating dramatic, theatrical speeches and elegant parades of Nazism throughout
Germany. But he also desired for absolute global exposure of his power and enacted on this
through the 1936 Summer Olympics. With the help of brilliant and creative German architects,
they created the Olympic Stadium in Berlin where the sporting events were held. The Nazis took
full advantage to showcase their dominance with a well-choreographed opening ceremony with
international competitors hailing Hitler. The modern practice of the Olympic torch relay, which
is still used today, was first enacted in the Berlin games to symbolize Nazi and Aryan supremacy
Saulan 5

to correlate their athletic dominance with the ancient Greeks, who were the originators of the
Olympics. The expert from an article on History.com titled, The Olympics Torch Relays
Surprising Origins, by Christopher Klein proves this example: torch relay would be coopted
by the Nazis as a powerful propaganda tool to bind not only the ancient and modern Olympics,
but ancient Greece and the Third Reich as well. (Klein, 1).
With the success of global exposure of Nazism through the Olympics, Hitler aspired for
the games to be played under Nazi control for the next event and years after that. According to
the blogspot, Secret Weapons of the III Reich, it mentions a grandeur newer stadium for Hitlers
plans of permanently hosting the Olympics in Germany: A much larger stadium capable of
holding 400,000 spectators was planned alongside the Nazi parade grounds in Nuremberg but
only the foundations were dug before the project was abandoned due to the outbreak of war (1).
If this colossal stadium was completed, it would still stand as the biggest coliseum in history.
The grandeur of centralizing sporting events and other means of entertainment under Nazi
control is certainly a quality of a perfect society.
Furthermore, the plans for Hitlers new world capital, Germania, were under construction
through the early years of Nazi rule. He planned on completely rebuilding Berlin, the capital of
his nation, with the grandest monuments and capital halls symbolizing his socialistic dominance.
Hitler gained influences from other European structures and implemented those in his city but
with greater emphasis. As the Lost Worlds television series on YouTube.com titled, Hitlers
Supercity, descriptively states the ambitious plans of Hitler for Germania; such as creating the
worlds largest domed building structure based on the Pantheon in Greece that have would
become a massive forum hall for himself and his people. He also gained interest in planning to
create his own arch of triumph based on the Arc de Triomphe in France but in a grander scale.
Saulan 6

Although Hitler envisioned a Germanic unified metropolis, there were numerous flaws
and obstacles that he overlooked that led to the downfall of his dreams on developing an absolute
utopian society. First and foremost, Hitler requested for the highest quality of materials, such as
expensive granite, to create his fanciful world capital city of Germania. Once Germany was
succumbed to the Second World War, its focus on spending was rapidly switched to military
efforts. Architectural projects, especially the monumental infrastructures and stadiums for
Germania were completely abandoned. These structures only saw their foundations cultivated
but nothing else as they became Germanys least concern. Berlin, the landsite for the new capital
city could not sustain the mass renovations as it stands on a marshland.
Hitler was still persistent on pursuing his concept of implementing his ideals by first
conquering Europe and then the world. But his militaristic method to his aspirations led to his
defeat. It surely was an unavoidable fact that he supported the needs of a ravaged German nation
when he became their leader during the rise of the Nazi party. For slightly more than a decade,
Hitler gave German citizens, specifically the ethnic Aryan race an absolute utopian society.
They thrived under his rule and were blindly loyal to his actions of progressing into the most
superior nation. These citizens coherently undertook the same Nazi ideals and beliefs, and
discounted any ideologies posed as threat to theirs, all of which Hitler propagandized.
The main concept of the novel, Utopia by Sir Thomas More, was to introduce this
unbreakable and magnificent society where its citizens lived away from corruption and
implement his example into his own society of sixteenth century Europe. The perspective of
Adolf Hitler and his followers truly correlates to Mores novel as the Nazis believed that they
were the outmost righteous civilization in the world during their time. But the Nazis totalitarian
socialistic approach to their goals and their absolute belief in ethnic supremacy ironically became
Saulan 7

their demise. They underestimated the intelligence and diligence of the allied powers with
Britain, the United States, and the Soviet Union attacking Germany on all fronts. Quite
surprisingly, the Nazis faced treason among their own officers who attempted on ending the war
and preserving true German integrity by killing Adolf Hitler.
It can be concluded that it is quite impossible to create an absolute perfect utopian society
as it has never been done in history. Surely, the visions of Hitler had the blueprints of a direct
utopia with some similarities to the fictional world created by Sir Thomas More. Hundreds of
millions of people perished during the Second World War from a dream of one man with desires
of global power for himself and his nation. There would be too many consequences and damages
made to create such a society. As long as humans have the ability to reason, to question authority
and have differences in ideologies, will be undeniably unreachable for societies to progress in
total equilibrium.

KEY LABELING:
TOPIC SENTENCES
THESIS
COUNTER ARGUEMENTS





Saulan 8

Works Cited
"Lost Worlds Episode VI: Hitler's Supercity." YouTube. YouTube, 27 June 2012. Web. 18 Mar.
2014. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6H5kxyhuek>.
"The Secret Weapons and Facts of the III Reich: Welthauptstadt Germania ("World Capital
Germania")." The Secret Weapons and Facts of the III Reich: Welthauptstadt Germania
("World Capital Germania"). N.p., n.d. Web. 07 Mar. 2014.
<http://secretweaponsoftheiiireich.blogspot.com/2011/08/welthauptstadt-germania-
world-capital.html>.
Klein, Christopher. "The Olympic Torch Relays Surprising Origins." History.com. A&E
Television Networks, 17 May 2012. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.
<http://www.history.com/news/the-olympic-torch-relays-surprising-origins>.
Longerich, Peter. "The Nazi Racial State." BBC News. BBC, 17 Feb. 2011. Web. 05 Mar. 2014.
<http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/genocide/racial_state_01.shtml>.
More, Thomas, and Dominic Baker-Smith. Utopia. London: Penguin, 2012. Print.
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. "Nazi Propaganda and Censorship." United States
Holocaust Memorial Museum. United States Holocaust Memorial Council, n.d. Web. 06
Mar. 2014. <http://www.ushmm.org/outreach/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007677>.
Weber, Mark. "INSTITUTE FOR HISTORICAL REVIEW." How Hitler Tackled
Unemployment. Institute For Historical Review, Feb. 2012. Web. 05 Mar. 2014
<http://www.ihr.org/other/economyhitler2011.html>.

You might also like