:

( .)11:2


( .)4:02
.
.
: . 22 (
)1:11
. :
.

.
. %90

.
:

22 .



.
.
. .



.
.
.
. .

.

. (
) .

241



.



. .
.
. .

:
)1

.
. .
.
.
. .
:
[ .]...

.1
.
. ( )1129

. : .
:

.
[ .]...
.2
.
:
[ ]... :
. ( .)12:10
. ( )1402
.
1
2

1214/4/1 .4
: .2-9 1

244

 .1433
1222


.
1

.
( )1222

. :


.
... .

[ ]... .2
.
1224
3
. .4
:


[ ]...
.5



.6

.

.

: (
)1:13
1
2
3
4
5
6

Allgre, p. 11-52 Le cas Galile, p. 1071-1074

.1221/11/21
.)2
32.31
.13-12
.10-42

241

( )29:22 ( .1)20:23
. :

: .
.2
.


.
.
.
. .
.

.
.
.
.
.
.

.
.
)2

. .
.
.
.
.
. .

.
.
.

:
)
.
.
1
2

Mamonide: Le livre de la connaissance, p. 97-98

.22-29

249

 .

: ( .)23:21
.
. .
:
.
: .
.
.1
:

0000
. .
.

.2

.
.3
: :
.4
.
.

:
. [ ]...

.
. .5

.
.6

)

.

1
2
3
4
5
6

Glass, p. 17
Glass, p. 21
.
Goodman: Jewish circumcision, p. 22-27
.13-12
.214

242

 .
:

.

( ) 0-3:13 .

.
.
[ .]...

.1
:
.
.
: :
[ .]... .
[ .]... :
. . .
.2

:
.

. %91-41
.3


.
.
100
.
%10.3 %23.9
.4 ( )%29.3
91 .
.
1
2
3
4

.13-12 .94
.94
.1
: 12.11

210


.1
)
.


.
:
)1 .
)2 .
)3


.2
:
.
.

. .
.

( ) (
)
.

.
.3
)


. . .
.4
.
.
. .
. :
.

. .
1
2
3
4

: 10 12.91
: .13
: .01-13
Tangwa, p. 190

211

 .

.
.

.
.

.
.


.

:

. .
)1
.
.
)

.
.
.

.
. :

[ .]...
.
.1
.


.
.2
1
2

Hosken: The Hosken Report, p. 32

Nous protgeons nos petites filles

212

 .1
.
:
[ ]
. .
. .
.

.

.2

.
. .


.
. .
.
.3
. .

.
:
.
. (
)
(
)
.4

.

.5
.
1
2
3
4
5

Sanderson, p. 17 Benote Groult Thiam, p.

IV Schnll: Einleitung, p. 14-15
Dorkenoo, p. 52
Bodily integrity for both, p. 7-8,
22-23
13
Female genital mutilation, an overview

213


.
. :
:
.

.
.1
:2


)1 ( ).
)1
( ).
)2
)2

.
.
)3
)3
.

.
)0
)0 .
.
:

[ .]...

.3
)

.
. :

. .
.

.4
)
.
.
%11
1
2
3
4

.92
.14
.14-11 21 .2
01-00 .31

210

 . .
.


.
.
.

.
.
.
.

. :

.
.
.
.1 .


.
)2
)
.
mutilation .
. .
.
.

.

. .

.
Le Petit Robert :mutiler
.
:mutilation .
Webster's :mutiler
.
1

Toubia: Evolutionary cultural ethics, p. 4-5

211

 .
.1
.

.

.


.
)

.
.2
:
.3
.
.4
.5
.
.

1224 .
.

.

. .
.

. ( )

. .
1
2
3
4
5

Zwang: Les mutilations sexuelles fminines, p. 24; Zwang: Functional and erotic
consequences, p. 71
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 52-54
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 34
Scott, p. 9
Taylor (et al.): The prepuce

214

 .
.1

( ) 41 .2

.
.
. .
.3
. .

. .
.
.
. .
.
. :

. .
.4
)

.
.5



.6


.

.

.
1
2
3
4
5
6

Ritter, p. 11-2/11-4
Cold; Taylor: The prepuce, p. 34
Ritter, p. 9-1/9-10-3
: .10
1 .
1 .

211

 .
. [.]...


.1

:1244
.2 .
.
.3 1213
1210 140 .
. .
.

.4
. :
.

.
.

:

( )
.
.5

.
)9
)

. .

.
. .
.
.
1
2
3
4
5

13 .
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an american health fallacy, p. 170
: .
El-Saadawi: The hidden face of Eve, p. 35
: .41-40

219


.

.
. :
.
)


.
.
.

. .
.
. .

.
)
.
. .


.

.
.
.

.
.
.1
)

.
.
.
.2 : .
. . .
1
2

Llewellyn, p. 473-474
Ritter, p. 28-1

212


.
.
.1
)

.
.
. .
.
.
. ( )
( )
.2

.
.
.
.
.

.
.
. . .

. .

:
)1
:
.
.


.
.
.
.
1
2

Boyd, p. 136
Boyd, p. 135-137

290

 .
.
.
. .

.
.
.1
. .

.
.
)2
)

.
. :
. .2

.

.


.3 .
: .
.
. .4 :
.
11 :
.5
.

. .
.6
.
1
2
3
4
5
6

Ritter, p. 3-1
: .12
21 .
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 66-67
Goldman: The psychological impact, p. 98
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 7

291

 :1222
.1
!! !
!
!

.
.
.
:
.2
.
:
[ .]... .
.3
. :
.
.4
)

.
. .
. .
.
.
.
. . .

.
.
.
.
9 12
. .
. .

.
.
.
1
2
3
4

American Academy of Pediatrics, Task Force on Circumcision: Circumcision Policy

).Statement (RE9850
Fleiss: An analysis, p. 392-393
Weiss;Weiss
: .21

292

 .
.
.
. .
.1
. . :
( ) ( )
( ) .
. .
. .
. .
.
. .2
.
. .
.
. .
.
.
. .3
. .

.
.4

. .
.

. .
%10
. .
.5

.
. .
.
.
1
2
3
4
5

Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 10-13

Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 13-16
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 16-17
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 18-19
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 20-24

293

 %0 .
%24
. %10
.
.
.1
)

:
.
. .
.
2

.3 . 1214

.4
. . .

.
. .
.5
. .
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.6
1
2
3
4
5
6

Goodman: Jewish circumcision, p. 22-23

Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 8
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 33
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 135-138
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 188-189
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 191-192

290

 1229
. %13 %39
%03 .
%13
.

.1
)


.
:

.
.
.

.2

. .
.3
.
.
.4
.
.
.

.

.
.
.
. .
.5
1
2
3
4
5

Fletcher, p. 267-268
21 .
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 127
Goodman: Jewish circumcision, p. 25
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 125

291

)

.1

.
.
%20 .
.

. .
.

.
[ ] ...
. :
.2

() .
.
.
. .3
)9
)
.
.
1220 %0 30
. %10 : %20 .

.
.4
.
.
.
.
1
2
3
4

Dirie, p. 64-77
.120
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 140-141
Van Howe: Anaesthesia, p. 67, 86-88

294


%11 .
.1
)
.

.
( ) .
.
.
( )1224
.

. .

.
.2
.
. .:

[ .].. .
.
.3


. .
.
.
.
. .
.
. .4

.
.
)

. 1904

1
2
3
4

: : 92 19-11 : .11
Hoffman, p. 217
Barth (editor): Berit Mila, p. 202
Romberg: Bris Milah, p. 61-63

291

 .
.1
:
.
.
.


.2

.
.

. .
. .

.3



. .
.
.4
.
.:
[ ]...

.5


.
.
.6
)
.
.

1
2
3
4
5
6

Romberg: Circumcision, p. 99-100

Boyd, p. 116
Conant and Katz Sperlich: Nurses, p. 187
Van Howe: Anaesthesia, p. 88-90
: .14
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 36

299

 .
. .
.
.
. %10 %10
. .
.
.

.
10 .
. .
.
.
.1

.

.
.
.

.
.
.
.2

. .
.3

.
.
.
1
2
3

Van Howe: Anaesthesia, p. 73-85

Boyd, p. 115
Kenyatta, p. 104, 106

292


)1

)

.

: .
.
:
.
.1

.
.
.

.
.2


.3
)
.
.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.4

.
.5
.
1
2
3
4
5

;It's a boy, film by Victor Schonfeld, 1995, Broadcast Channel 4 TV, 21 Sept 1995
Price: Male non-therapeutic circumcision, p. 432
Romberg: Bris Milah, p. 94-95
Romberg: Bris Milah, p. 57-58
Female genital mutilation: report, p. 9
Kilanowski, p. 166

220

 :
. .
:
.1


: . .

. .
: .
.
:

. .2

.
. .3
.
: .
.

. .
.
)
( )
.
.
. .4
.

.
.5

. .
1
2
3
4
5

Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 22-23, 59

Tangwa, p. 187
Bulletin (du Comit inter-africain), no 14, juillet 1993, p. 11-12
Hosken: The Hosken Report, p. 326, 327
Gallo: La circoncisione femminile in Somalia, p. 158
Favazza, p. IX-X

221


)2

.

.1
.

.2
. .
. .
.
.
. . .3
. :
.
.4
.5
:
[]
[
]
.
.
.

[ ]
.6


. .7
.:

.
.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Barth (editor): Berit Mila, p. 164

Le Talmud de Jrusalem, tome VII, p. 9
.92-91
: 2 .00
.)1
: 1 .21-21

.)0

222

 .

.
. .1
.
.
.
.2
:



.





.3
.
.
. .

.

)

.



.4 .
.
.
. :5
. 100.000
2 .
.
1
2
3
4
5

Albucasis, p. 401
Albucasis, p. 9
Albucasis, p. 167-169
.
. 41-40 100 : 102-101

223

 .1 .

.
: .
311-221 .2
[ ].
:1292
.
111.000 .3
134.094 (
) 2.4

.
.
.
.

.
.
.
.

.
.
.
. .
1213
. 1233 1211
10.902 .
1900 1202 1210
. 1219 %1 .
%1 %10 .5
1224
.

%100 .
1
2
3
4
5

Wiswell: Routine neonatal circumcision; Warner; Strashin: Benefits and risks of

circumcision
Wiswell.: Routine neonatal circumcision
American Academy of Pediatrics, report of the Task force on circumcision, Pediatrics,
1989
Wiswell (et al.): Risks from circumcision
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 198

220

.
.
.
:
.%100
. .
.1
222 . 1 100
.

.
.2
.3

%20

1.4
1220
2.9
()%10
41.4
%10
11.3
%2
4
1.4
%1
.
.

.
.


.
.


. 10.000
.5

. .
.

.
.
1
2
3
4
5

Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 106

Denniston; Milos (editors): Sexual mutilations, preface, p. V-VI
Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 106
Bodily integrity for both, p. 42
NOCIRC Newsletter, Fall/Winter 1995

221

 .
.


.

%2 %12
%10 %10 %1
. .
.1
.
.

.2

)

.
.3 .
.

%2 .
. .
300 .
.
.
.
.
. .
.

.
.
.
. .
1

2
3

Denniston; Milos (editors): Sexual mutilations, preface, p. V-VI. See also

.;Crowley; Kesner, p. 318-319
Bodily integrity for both
Crowley; Kesner, p. 320

Romberg: Circumcision, p. 199-231; :
Ritter, p. 5-2/5-6; Warren: NORM UK, p. 93; Zwang: Functional and erotic
consequences, p. 73-74; Cold; Taylor: The prepuce, p. 41

224



.
. %10 .

.

.
.

.
.

. . .
.1

.
. .

.

. .

.


. .

.

.
1 %10 .

.Plastibell
. .
.
1

Romberg: Circumcision, p. 171

221

.

. .
.
. .
.
.

.
.
.



. .
. .
.

.
.

.


.
.

.
. .
.
.

.

. %9 %31
.

.
.

.
.

229



.

.
.
. .
Plastibell
Gomco Plastibell .
Plastibell
. .
.


. .
.%9
.
. .
.
.

.
.
.
. Plastibell
. .
.
. 1294

.
.

.
.


.
. .
.

. .

222


. .
20 1221 1243
.
.

.
.
.
.
.
. 10
.
.
.

. .
:

. .
1212
.1

.

.
.2

)

. .
. .
. (-100
)421 .
.
.
.

.
1
2

.10
Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 106

300

 .
.1
.
.
900
.1240 %0.12 100.000
.
.
.2
.
.
.
22 12 132

. .3

. .
.
.


.4

.
.
.
.
. .5

)9

.
.

[ .]... [ ]
1
2
3
4
5

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 158-160; Romberg:

Circumcision, p. 225; Zoossmann-Diskin; Blustein: p. 344
Glass, p. 20- 21
Zoossmann-Diskin; Blustein, p. 344
Goodman: Jewish circumcision, p. 23
Cold; Taylor: The prepuce, p. 42

301

 . [
] .1
.

( )1320
.
.
.2

)

.
:
[ ]...
. .


.


!!
!.3
:
.
.

.


.4
.

.5

30 1214
:
.
1
2
3
4
5

: 10 .019
. Nefzaoui, p. 302 :
.110
: .9-1 .11
: .11
Sanderson, p. 21

302

 .
:
. 1 .

.

.
%90.1
.2 %93
.
.3

.
.

.

)

.
.4
. .

.

.
.
.
.

. .
.



1
2
3
4

Cook, p. 54
El-Dareer, p. 28
Koso-Thomas: The circumcision, p. 29

: : 21-19
: 19-10 31-24 : 19-10
40-19 Sanderson, p. 40; Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 57-60; Zwang:
Functional and erotic consequences, p. 67-68; Female genital mutilation, an overview,
p. 25-36; Kalthegener; Ruby: Zara Yacoub, p. 85

303

 .
.

.

.
.


.

. .

. .
.

.
. .
.

.
.
. .
.
.
.

.
.

.
. 20 % 21 .

. .
.


.

.

300

 .

.

.
.
.

.


.
.

.


.

. .
.
.
.
1224/10/14 .
:


.
( 0)
( 3)
10 .

.
.

.
10 %30
.
.
. .1
1

Lightfoot- Klein: Prisoners, p. 56

301

 1 .%4
.
.1
.2

)

:
. .
. .
.
.
: . . .
( ) .
.
- -
.
)0
.

.
.
.
. .
.

. .
.3

.
.

1
2
3

Thiam, p. 102-103
Dirie, p. 76-77
Odent, p. 121-124

304

 .

.
.

)1
)

.
.

.
.
.1

. .2
:

. .

. .

.

. :
.
. :
: ( )9:0
:
( .)22:1
.3

. .
. .

. .4
: [ ]
.5
1
2
3
4
5

Philon: De specialibus legibus, I-II, p. 17

Philon: Questiones et solutiones in Genesim, III-VI, p. 107
21 .
Barth (editor): Berit Mila, p. 124-125
2 .021-019

301

.1

.
.
.2 (
)1422 ( ) : .
.
.3

.
. .
.

.4
)

.

.
( )
. .
.
.
: .
. %90
10 20.000
. .5

.
( ) .
.

.
.
. .
.

1
2
3
4
5

Thomas d'Aquin, vol. 4, p. 524 et 525

1 .
: 3 .103
Sorrells, p. 336
;Fleiss: Where is my foreskin?, p. 41; Cold; Taylor: The prepuce, p.1 and 37-38
Laumann, p. 1052-1057

309




.

.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.
() .

.
.

.

. .

.1
:

. .
.
.
.
.2


.
)

.

.

.
.
1

Ritter, p. 12-4, 15-1; Romberg: Circumcision, p. 173; Warren: Norm UK, p. 89; Zwang:
Functional and erotic consequences, p. 71; O'Hara; O'Hara, p. 79-84; Hammond: A
preliminary poll, p. 87
Ritter, p. 15-1

302

 . .

.

. .
.
.
. .
.
. .1
31 31
.
.2
. .3
1220 313
.
%41
. %00
. (
)
. %10
4
%3 .

.
.5 .
. .
.
.

.
.%10
. .6

. 14
. %10
1
2
3
4
5
6

Hammond: A preliminary poll, p. 85, 88; Ritter, p. 17-1

Romberg: Circumcision, p. 171
Ritter, p. 27-1
Hammond: A preliminary poll, p. 86, 88
Money; Davison, p. 291
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 39-40; Boyd, p. 111-112; Romberg:
Circumcision, p. 172-173

310

 %20 . %30 %41

. . %49
%10
. .
.1

. .


.
.

.

. .

.2
. : [ ]
.
.
.3 20
.


.
.
.
.

.4
.

.

.5
.
.
.

.

. .
1
2
3
4
5

;Zoossmann-Diskin; Blustein: p. 344 Hecht: The cutting edge, p. 14-15

.41
: .12
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 115-116
Vatsyayana: Kamasutra, p. 37

311

 .
.
.1
.
.
. %10 %11 1290
.
. .
.
.
.
.2
.

. .3

.
.
.
. 132
. :
. . . . .
22
.
. .
.
. . .4

. .
:
1
2
3
4

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 116-118; Ritter, p. 30-1

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 118-121
Zwang: Functional and erotic consequences, p. 74
O'Hara; O' Hara, p. 79-84

312

 .

.
.
.
.
.
.

.1

.
.


.2
.
. .
.
.
.3
.
.
. .
.
.4

( ) .

.5

)2
)

.

: .
.6 :
1
2
3
4
5
6

Message from lbisque@atlantic.net, 16. June 1999, sent to intact-l@cirp.org

.)1
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 59-60
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 174-175
Kenyatta, p. 127
)2 ).

313

 .
[ .]... () :
. () .
. [ .]...

[ ] [ ]
.
. : .1
.2 :

.3 : :
! .
. .4
()
.
.5

. :
.6
.
)

. :
[ ]...

.
. .

. .
.
.



.

.
1
2
3
4
5
6

: 1 .22-21
: 1 .00
: .42
: .11
1 . . .11
: 1 .232

310

 .

.1
:
%10
.


.2
:
.
.
.
.

.
.
.

.3
.

.
.
.
. .
.
.
.

.
.
. .4
1211 20 %21

.
.


5
. .
1
2
3
4
5

: .30-22
.43
.49 .12-11
Zwang: Functional and erotic consequences, p. 70-71
Zwang: Les mutilations sexuelles fminines, p. 25

311

 1224
.

.
.
.

)

.
.
. :


.

.1
:

: :
. :
.2
.
1220/11/3 12 - - :
: .
( 11) .
.
.

:

10 .
!

.


.
.

. 1220
.
.
1232 . .3
1
2
3

1 .
.34 : 31 :
.31-30
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 186-187

314

 1213
.1
1212
3000 .

:
. . .
. . . . 30 .

.
.
.

.2
3
1213
.
1214
4
. 1211

.
.5
. 1213
Playgirl : .6

.7
11 %20 .8 Cosmopolitan
1214


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 177-178

Rathmann: Female circumcision, p. 115-120
Wollman: Female Circumcision
Burt: Surgery of Love
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 188-190; Hodges: A short
history, p. 32
Kellison: Circumcision for women
Kellison: 100$ Surgery
Walden: Letter to the Editor

311

 . %10 .1
1290
2000 3000 .
.

. 1211
.2

. .
.
.3
Toronto Globe and Mail 10 1229
12

. . 1100 2100
. : 21 31

. .

.

.4

)

.

.5
131

. %20 .
6
.
%20
.
.
.7
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Isenberg; Elting: A guide to sexual surgery Wallerstein: Circumcision: an

American health fallacy, p. 183-184
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 183-185
www.circlist.org/canatomyfemale.html
www.circlist.org/canatomyfemale.html
Kamara
;Assaad: Female circumcision in Egypt, p. 24 Giorgis, p. 31-33
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 80-81

319

 2311

2004 %10

%23.3

.
.1
:
.
.

. .
. .2
.3
.
.
. .

.4
. .5
.
.
.
.

.
.6

.
.
.

.
.7
.

.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

El-Dareer, p. 48
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 83-87
Couchard, p. 147-148
Kamara
Couchard, p. 145
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 91-93
.Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 23, 87-90 Gallo; Viviani: Il ruolo
dell'olfatto

312

 .
.
.
. .
: .
.1


:


[ .]...
.
.


.
.
.2
)
.
.
.
.
().3
( )1320 .
: .
:
.

.4
.5
1291
.
.

.
.6
1
2
3
4
5
6

Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 8, 78, 119-121

Female genital mutilation: an overview, p. 35
.11
.141
Sanderson, p. 52
Rapport du sminaire rgional sur les pratiques traditionnelles, Addis Abeba, 1987, p.
101

320

 300
. 244

.1

.
.
.

.2

. .
.3

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.4

. 10
.5

.
.
.
.

.
.6
)9
.
.
.
1
2
3
4
5
6

.23
Koso-Thomas: The circumcision, p. 8-9, 11
Ombolo, p. 101-102
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 58-59
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 60, 98
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 104-105, 125

321

)
.


. .
. .
.1
20
.

.
.2
)
. :
1210

.
.

.3
:

[ ]...
. .
.
.


.
.

.4
:
42
.
.
1
2
3
4

Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 142

20 .
: .199
.10-42

322


.1
.
1211 .
.
. 20 .21219

.
.
.
.3
:
.:
() !
.

.4
)0
)

.
. .
:
: .
.
: .

.
.


.
)
.
.
1
2
3
4

.12 43 1422-21 El-Masry, p. 56-59

El-Masry, p. 31
.11-14
: 09 49.10

323


.1
2 1211
1241 11 1 1
.
.2


.
.
%32
%100 .

.
. :
. . .
.
. .
.

3


.
.


.4

.
.5
.

.

.

.


()

.6
1
2
3
4
5
6

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 33

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 195-196
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 175-177
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 144
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 39
Laumann, p. 1052-1057; O'Hara; O'Hara, p. 79-84 ;Cold; Taylor: The prepuce, p. 1

320

 .
. .
.
.

.
.

.
.

.1
.2
.3
.
.

. .4
)
.
.

. 1211
. .5

.6

.
:
.
.
.7 .

. :

.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Favazza, p. 219
Bigelow, p. 52-53
Boyd, p. 90
Boyd, p. 141
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 190
Abd-el-Salam: Female sexuality, p. 75
3 21 .1

321

 !
!!
!
.1
)5

.
.
.
)

. .
0100 %90
%20
.
.
. .
.
.

.2

.
.3
.
1229

.
. .
. .4
:
-1
.
-2
.
-3 .5
1
2
3
4
5

.13
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 144-148
O'Hara; O'Hara, p. 82
Immerman; Mackey: A proposed relationship, p. 369-373
Immerman; Mackey: A proposed relationship, p. 371-372

324



.1

.2
.
.
)
.
. :
.
.

!
.

.3
. :
.%10
.


. .


:
.
% 10 %19
%3
.4

.
.5
1
2
3
4
5

Immerman; Mackey: A proposed relationship, p. 374; see also Immerman; Mackey: A

biocultural analysis, p. 265-275
Aldeeb Abu-Sahlieh: To mutilate, p. 593
.11-14
.43
: 19-11 : .12 30
14-11.20-23

321


. .

.1 10 .
.
.
.
.2
.
.
. %20
.3
.
.4
.5

. :
[ ] [ ]...

]...[ .

. .

. .
.6

.

. .
.7
.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Koso-Thomas: Aperu, p. 120

Koso-Thomas: The circumcision, p. 11
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 95-96, 101
Rapport du sminaire rgional sur les pratiques traditionnelles, Addis Abeba, 1987, p.
108; Female genital mutilation: an overview, p. 8
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 7
.42-49
Ombolo, p. 153

329

:

. [ .]...
.
.1

.

.
.

.
.
.

:
)1
.
.
.
. .
. .2

.
. :
.
. .
.
.3
.4
)2
. .

.
1
2
3
4

Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 104

) 1 )
)1 ).
Erodoto: Le storie, vol. 1, p. 179-180
Philon: De specialibus legibus, I-II, p. 15

322

 : : .
]...[ :
.1 :
.2

.3
:

() [ .]...
[ .]...
()
.4
.5

.

.6
.

.

.
.
.
.
.
.7



.8

. :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

: .31
1 .
.)1
: .90
)2 ).
: .22
1 . .43
13 .

330


.

.
.1
.

.

. .
.

.2

.3
.

.
.4
)9


.5

. .

. .

. .
.

.
. .
1
2
3
4
5

.14-11
Koso-Thomas: The circumcision, p. 7, 10
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 9
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 60
DeMeo: The geography, p. 3

331


.1

. 1212 1200
. .
.
.
.2

.
1219:
. .
. .
.
.
.
.3
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.4
.

.
.
.5
.
. .
.
.
.


.
1
2
3
4
5

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 68; Romberg: Circumcision,

p. 2-3
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 59-60
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 23
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 67-68
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 75

332

 .
20 % 30 .

. 1
. .

.2

.
.
.
. .
.
.

.
. .

. .
.
.

:


.
. .
. .

.
. .


.
)1
)
.
:
1
2

Ritter, p. 7-1/8-2
Ritter, p. 3-1

333

 . ( .)1-1:23
( .)02:20 ( .)111:1 .

. :
.
: .1
( )1210 .



.2
: .3
: [ ]
.4
:
[] .

.

( )112:4
( .)22:2

5
.

( )4:1
.6
.
1-1:23
( )121 :2
.
.
:
1
2
3
4
5
6

: 12 .104-101
10 .112
.11-49
1 .112
: 11 .323-322
.9

330

 :
.
: .
.
.
.
.
:
...
.1
:
.

.
.
.

.

. .2



.3
:
. ( ) : : [ ] .
[ ].4
.1
2
3
4

1 .230-222
.03-02
.Serhane, p. 153-155
.3329

331

 . .


.
.1 .
. .
.
.
:

-
- -

.2

:
:
... !! .

.
.3
:

. ( )
.4
)
.
.

.5
1
2
3
4
5

1 .231-232 .92-12
.11
.119
112 .02-01
Dingwall: Male infibulation, p. 33

334


.1


.

.
.


.2
:


.3

.

.4 :
... . ( )
(
) .5
.
. :
!!
( ) -
[ .]...
]...[ .
:
... .

.6
1
2
3
4
5
6

Dingwall: Male infibulation, p. 49

.40 : : .13-12
13 .
13 .
.42 01 .12
.40

331

 )2
)
.
:
. .
. : .
.
. . ( .)10-4:39
( )4-1:21
.
(

) . .
.
onanism .
. :
.

.1 .
.
.

.
.

. .
: :
( )10:39 .
:

( .)1-0:11
. :
.
.

.
. .2

.
.
1
2

mutilation, p. 61 Erlich: La
.Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 23, 87-90 Gallo; Viviani: Il ruolo
dell'olfatto

339

 .
.
.
. .1

:
.

( 1 .)10-2 :4
( )mols
mollities
. .
1410 .

.2
1111 Onania
.
1119 .
Onanism .


. .
. .

.3

. 1120
.
1101-1103
.4
( .)1121
1119 .
1140 .
1192
.5
. 1191
1
2
3
4
5

Rosner, p. 104-105
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 41-48
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 49-64
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 65-72
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 72-89

332

 .


1
.
.2

.
. 1912


.3

.

. 1912

. 1911

.4

1201-1931
.
.

.
.
.
.
. 1992
.
31 .

.
.5
.
. 1911
1
2
3
4
5

Stengers; Van Neck, p. 70-72

Stengers; Van Neck, p. 105
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 12-13
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 32-37
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 58-59

300

 .
.
1911


1
.
1211
.
1222 1220
. 1202
. 1211
.
.
. 1244
.
. .
. . 1214

.
:
.2
)
.

.


.

.
.
.3

. .
.
1913 19
.

1
2
3

Stengers; Van Neck, p. 135-151

Stengers; Van Neck, p. 180-188
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 49-64

301

 . 1191 .1
1940 .
1941 1232 20
. 1221

. 1222
.
. 1202
. 1211
.2

.3
.1910
.4
.5 1921
.6 1220
.7
.
( .)1913
( )1990
1901 .8
.

.
. 1911
.
.
1921 .

.
.
.9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

Lorenzoni, p. 15-16
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 19-28
Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 59
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 124-128; Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health
fallacy, p. 32-37
Dingwall: Male infibulation, p. 51-52
Favazza, p. 190; Dingwall: Male infibulation, p. 54-56
Erlich: Les mutilations sexuelles, p. 73
Hodges: A short history, p. 19
Hodges: A short history, p. 23

302

 1210
. 1232
.
.
.1
1921
. 1234
.
.2
.31229 1231
:
.
.
.
. .
. .
.4
.
1202
. 1214 :
.
.
. -
.5
1201
. .1214
1244 .
1211
.

.
. .6


1
2
3
4
5
6

Hodges: A short history, p. 25

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 122-124; Romberg:
Circumcision, p. 97-98
Editor: Routine circumcision at birth?, p. 201
Sorrells, p. 332
Spock: Letter to Editor
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 125-126

303

 .
.1
.
. hysterectomie
. ( 309
.) :

.
. .
.


.2
.1922

. 1940
.

.3
1919 .1944
( )1913
.1941 1919 3011
.
.
. .

.4
1941
. .5

.
.1944
.
.
1
2
3
4
5

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 13-14, 170-172

Platon: Time, p. 467-468
Stengers; Van Neck, p. 124-128; Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health
fallacy, p. 32-37
Favazza, p. 195
Kaziz; Fleming

300

 .
.
1921
.
.

.1

. 1201

.2
.
. 1213 .
Shield Blue .1211
.


.
.
.
.
.
.
.3
:
.
.

.
. .

:
.
.
. .

1
2
3

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 122-124; 170-172; Romberg:

Circumcision, p. 98-99
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 125, 172-175
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 174-175

301

 . .
.
.
.
)1
)

.1

.
.

.
.2
)
.
1910 .
.
1201
.
1221 %10 .3

1910 1220
.4
1210
.5
1920 1220
.
.
1920 1221 .


.

. %40
1
2
3
4
5

Philon: De specialibus legibus, I-II, p. 15

Philon: Questiones et solutiones in Genesim, III-VI, p. 109-111
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 174-175
Hodges: A short history, p. 23-24
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 2, 30-40

304

 .
.1


.21230

.

.
.
.
.
24 20.000 .
1249
. .
. 1210
%22.022
11 . 4 .
.
.
.
11 %0.3
. .
( )

.

. 11
. .3
)
.
1920
:
. .
.

. .
.
. .
1
2
3

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 37-39

Hodges: A short history, p. 25
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 127-134; Ritter, p. 34-1

301


.



.
. .1


.

.
.2

. (
) . .
.
. .
.
.3

.

.
.4
.
)2
)

.

. .
:
.
1299
40
.5
:
1
2
3
4
5

Soubhy, p. 128-129
Lightfoot-Klein: Prisoners, p. 39-39
Koso-Thomas: The circumcision, p. 9, 11-12
Favazza, p. 152
.10 Fink: Circumcision: a parent's decision for life

309

 .

.1

.
)
.
.2
1911
.
.

.3
.
.1911
. .4
1990 .5
.

() .

. .
1290
.6

. .
.
.
1201

.7
12 1201
.
.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Schoen: The status of circumcision of

: .29
newborns
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 37
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 12-13
Hodges: A short history, p. 21; Hirshfeld: The Jewish circumcision
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 37
Middle East International, 22 November 1985, p. 15
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 37

302

 .1
%10 .
.
.2
1213
.
.
.
.3

. 11 30
.%11 .

.
.
.
.
.4
1911 1221
.
.

.5

.

. .
.6
)9
)
.

.

1
2
3
4
5
6

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 20-21

Hodges: A short history, p. 27
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 20-21, 85
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 81-87
Van Howe: Does circumcision influence, p. 58
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 87

310

 . .
.1


. .
:
. .
.
112-221 . 3000 . 1000-110
.
.
1232 1220 1400 .
40.000 1230 .
.
400.
.
.
.2
:

: ( .3)30:30
:
.
() . 1400 :
!!.4
.
:
:
( ) . .
1
2
3
4

9 . 0
: 1213 0340 .24-21
01-01.11-10
.03
.00

311

 .
.
.

.1
. :


.

!
!
- -
!.2
)

1232
.
. .
.3
1202
.
.4
1201

.5 1211
32000
.
.6

. .
.
.71232
.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

.41
21 .
Hodges: A short history, p. 26
Hodges: A short history, p. 27
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 37
Hodges: A short history, p. 29
Fleiss.: An analysis, p. 396-397

312



.
. .


. .
.

.
.1
.

.
.2


. . 1211
20.000 1.400 221
.3


. .
. %1
.
.%31
.
. .
1210-1200 ()
.
.4
1213
%1 %12 .
. %12 .%2
% 10 .
.
.5
1
2
3
4
5

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 96

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 88-91
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 105-108
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 91-92
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 110-112

313

 20 %21
.1%22.2
.%22.2
1
100.000
.
.
.2
1212

0.1 .
.
. 1213-12 12 .
33
.3
1222
.4. 1221
11
.5
.

.
. .
.6

1211
.
.

.
.7
.
14 :1224
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Schoen: The relationship between circumcision and cancer of the penis

Fleiss: An analysis, p. 385
Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 100-101
Wiswell: Circumcision circumspection
Wiswell: Circumcision - an update
Fleiss: An analysis, p. 386-387
Barth (editor): Berit Mila, p. 196

310


.

.

.
.
200.000 .

. .



.
.1


.
.
1211 221
300 100 .
.
.2
1 100.000


. 100.000
.

.3
)0
)
1220
.
.
.
.
:
.
1
2
3

Bodily integrity for both, p. 27

Wallerstein: Circumcision: an American health fallacy, p. 109
Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 106

311


1221/9/23 .

.
NOCIRC Noharmm
. 1221/2/1
:
.

.

.
.
.
.
.
. .
1221/9/30 : .

.
.

.

.
.


.
)

.
:
. 1292
Science .
.
.
.1 ( )

.2
1
2

Marx: Circumcision may protect against the AIDS virus

Simonsen (et al.): Human immunodeficiency

314

 :
.
.
.
:
( .)93:14 :
( .)30:31

.
.1
1221/2/1 : :
. :
. :

.
.1220/2/1
1221/2/2 :
. :



.

.
:
:

.


.

. . -
- .

.

.2 :

() .3
1
2
3

.19-11
: .10
.22

311

)


.
.11294
.2 .

.3

.
.
.
. .4
.

.

.
.
.

.

.
.51222
10 .

.
.
.

.6

.
.
1
2
3
4
5
6

Fink: A possible explanation for heterosexual male infrection with AIDS

United Press International, release date: october 29, 1986
Hodges: A short history, p. 35
Van Howe: Neonatal circumcision, p. 99-100
Kreiss; Hopkins
Fleiss: An analysis, p. 393-396

319

 .
. .
100000 :1221
24.1

19.0

02.2

20.9

20.2

14

9.2

4.1

0.0

3.1

2.1

2.2

1.4

0.2

0.2

0.2

.

. 19.1
1.1 400.000
. 20
.1220
.1
%1 %41
.2


.
:
. .
1
2

Fleiss: An analysis, p. 393-394

Ritter, p. 33-2

312


.

.

. .
.
.
.1
23109 2.4 .
.
.
.
.2
.

.
.3

:

.
)1
phimosis
( ) paraphimosis .
.
)
:
:


.
.
1
2
3

Ritter, p. 35-1; Van Howe: Does circumcision influence, p. 59

Van Howe: Neonatal circumcision, p. 100-120
Ritter, p. 33-2

340


.1
.

.
. :
.2
.
:
.
:
. :

: [ .]...

[ .]...
.

.
.
: ( .
) .

.

( ) .

.3

.4
)

.
.
phimosis
. .

1
2
3
4

Albucasis, p. 395
Mestiri: Abulcassis, p. 135, note 2
.10-41
33 : .92-91

341

 .
. .
.
.
.1

.

. ( )1200
.
.
1990


.
.
.

.
.

.
.2

. 1991
.
22
.
.
.
. 1920

.
.
.3

.
.
.
1
2
3

Hodges: The history of phimosis, p. 37-40

Hodges: The history of phimosis, p. 40-44
Hodges: The history of phimosis, p. 44-46

342

 ( )1212
.
. 1232
.
.

.
.1
.

.
.
.2
.
1232

. .
.3
1202
.4 100 200

. %0
%20 .
.

. .

.5
.
.
.
1213

. .6
1
2
3
4
5
6

Hodges: A short history, p. 27

Hodges: The history of phimosis, p. 46-51
Hodges: A short history, p. 27
Gairdner: The fate of the foreskin
Hodges: A short history, p. 28
Hodges: A short history, p. 28

343

 1249 1249
4 11 1
.

.
%9 1-4 %4 11-9
%3 13-12 . .
.
. .
.

%20 .

.
.
.
.
. .

.

. .

.
. clobetasol propionate
( .)%99

.
.2 %13
.
1224 %1.1 .3

phimosis .
.4 phimosis operation
: :

. .
1
2
3
4

ster: Further fate of the foreskin

Hodges: The history of phimosis, p. 51-54
Donnell, p. 63-64
Pang; Kim; Kim: Male circumcision in South Korea, p. 74-75

340

 .
.
( ) .
.
.

.


. .
.
.1

.
. .
.2
)2
3

.
.
)

:4
1292
32 .
000.000

.5

.6
. %34
( )
.
. .
1
2
3
4
5
6

Warren: Norm UK, p. 91

Rickwood, p. 49
Urinary tract infection
.32-31
Wiswell: Declining frequency of circumcision
Wiswell: Routine neonatal circumcision

341

 . %11-10
. .1
.2

.
.
)

. 1244
1292 %9410 .
1241 .
%1.0
%0.10 .
.

. .
.3

.
21.000
.
.
.
.
. .

.4
:1221

.
.
.
.5
:
.
1
2
3
4
5

Wiswell: Routine neonatal circumcision

: .11
Hodges: A short history, p. 33
Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 105-106
Fleiss: An analysis, p. 397

344

 %0.2 .%39
. .
.
.1
. .
%100 .
. .
.2
%1.1 . %22
.3
. .4
100

. .

.5
)9

.
.
.
)
:
:
.

.
. [
]

.
1
2
3
4
5

Warren: NORM UK, p. 97

Goldman: Circumcision the hidden trauma, p. 30-31
Prescott: Genital Pain, p. 14
Ritter, p. 32-1
Rickwood, p. 49

341


.
[ ] .
.
.1
.

.
:
[ ]...
.
: [ ]
]...[

.
.
. :

.2
)

.
.3

.

.4

.
.5

.

. .
.6

:
1
2
3
4
5
6

Albucasis, p. 393-395
.11-14
Warren: Norm UK, p. 91-92
Lander: The human prepuce, p. 83
Romberg: Circumcision, p. 341-342
Rickwood: Medical indications for circumcision, p. 48

349

 : .
.
.
. .1

:
.
.

.

:

.
.2

.

.
.
)1

.3 ( 30-323.)
.
. .
( 1 .)09 11:1
149
.
( 1:1 :
.)41-40 140-141
( 1:2 :
.)04 .
. :
1
2
3

AAP: Care of the uncircumcised penis, 1984; Ritter, p. 36-2

Crowley; Kesner, p. 320-321
21 21 .29 Ginzberg, vol. V,
p. 273

342

 .
. .
. . .
( 1 .)20-11:1

. .
.1


.


. ( .2)100
( 3)10
.decoris causa

.

. .4

.5

. ( )24
.
.
.
24 .

() . .
.
.
.6

.1201-1230
1
2
3
4
5
6

The Talmud of the Land of Israel, vol. 11, Shabbat, p. 459; Babylonian Talmud, vol.
XIII.C: Tractate Yebamot, chap. 7-9, p. 49
.Martial: Epigrammes, 7:35:1-4 Brandes; McAninch, p. 109
Celsus: De medicina, book VII, 25, p. 421-425
Brandes; McAninch, p. 110
Josephus: Jewish antiquities, VII, 241, p. 123
.;Schultheiss, p. 288-290 Bigelow, p. 61-68

310

 .
.

. .1

.
. 1292 2
. 1221 3
.

.
.
.

1000 .4 20
1220 .
.5
.6
)2
7 8
.

.

.

.

.
.
.
. :
:
.
.1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

Schultheiss, p. 290; Brandes; McAninch, p. 111

Brothers United for Future Foreskin - BUFF
Uncircumcising information and resources center - UNCIRC
Burrington
Griffiths, p. 297, 301
Bigelow, p. 121-130; Schultheiss
Bigelow Warren: Foreskin restoration
Foreskin restoration

311

 . .
. .

.
. 40 .
. .
.
:


.
. . .
.
. .
.

:

.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.1
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
.
1

http://www.eskimo.com/~gburlin/restore/restdis.html

312

 .
. .

. .
. .
.
.
. .
.
. .
.1

.
.

.2

.
3
.

.4
)9

: .
.

1220
.
:
. :
: . :
: : . : .

. .
. :
: .
. :
1
2
3
4

Boyd, p. 144
Boyd, p. 123
Penile enlargement
Goldman: Letter to the author

313

 :
. .
. . :
. .
.

.
.
.

:1
: .
.
.

.2

.
.
:
.
.
: . . .
.
: 12 . .
.
.
: .
.
.
.

.
: . .
1
2

.Bigelow, p.113-117 Warren: Foreskin restoration Griffiths

Lander: The man behind restoration
Boyd, p. 112

310

 .
.
.
.
)0

.

.1
. .
.

.
.
)5
200
. %93 .
:

.2
313

.3
:


.
.4
1
2
3
4

Erlich: Les mutilations sexuelles, p. 92. See also Mohl (et al.): Prepuce restortion
seekers; Brandes; McAninch, p. 112
Griffiths, p. 300
. Hammond: A preliminary poll, p. 87 Ritter, p. 20-
1/20-3
Griffiths, p. 302

311

 :

.
.
.


.
.
.

.
.
.


:
.
.
2 13 .
.
.

.
.1

.
.2



.3


. .

1
2
3

Third regional conference on traditional practices, Addis Ababa, 1994, p. 162

Dirie, p. 208-221
.1229/10/14

314

 .1
.

2000

. . .
.
.
. .
.
.

.

.
.
.
1 2000
.
.
.
.
. . [.]...
()

.
. .
.

.
.
.
. .
.
. :
(

) . .
.

.
.
1

Iaria: Several accounts, p. 29

311

 .
. .


. . .
.
[ ]
.
.



.

.

.
. : .

.
.1
.

. .

.


.2
.

.
%40

.
1
2

Denniston: Circumcision: an iatrogenic epidemic, p. 104

Erlich: La mutilation, p. 108-110

319


.

.

. .

.
.
.
.

.
1224

.

1224 :
.
[ .]...

.

[.]...
.
1221 :


.
.
:1222

.

.
.
.
.
.

.1
.
1

Boyle: Ending the forced genital cutting of children, p. 6-7

312