.

. 
+,  ( '&%  ! "#         
6  5% #  234 /-  0' & .'&- ; : 78
 %3-.
? > 8   '&%?  #A 7  0   @,? 7 0
8  B:A C 0-  A &A& 20 E/ C6D &-,  7; H F
 K-D 2-,; ? &   /L "'&% - : - 0-- O
%A4" :0 0;  &  O R,%L S-'&% 0Q & 2 -
% 20 D.7
  7 2O ,   '&% W  734  LO 2L
  5X , 0:8 5 20 ,Q  (O 2?% &3   20 F"&
 A-8   7 2O , ; % ( / : 7 Z/ 34 &0:X'
&O  K8; H/-' & K-%& - @/  34 20-
"  K+, 34 S-  A' ( & CQ'/A 6- ; 
'&% \ "# %".
L ; & E/  X 20 &  20 8,/  ] ,XD
" 20 _ K Z:0 7 L  A( & `X 7 7, .7--
 : _E &A4 '&%? 2 &a 0-  L 8,/X _ ( 
 20 7"-% (& 234 5 6 K:, , 7 B/-LD 7
c 7 H "L .e: ? 6 ! Sd:  "#
]  K? 72 20 _- :A  'L  2 -;  E- - -g
D' 20 -, `X   -,? ?%  (  O , -A E! 20 
7 3 'QA ( -> "#
 ( O  & D 20; H'- @0
  ! 7 O&L -? K &; ?  &- ]h  -  -:L 3
 :&Q & ,E/,+A 6# & , "0   8  20.5 -
&Q  -! '&% ': 7 \ - -W  20 -  -, 0'
& K  K? 7`X K- ] 7,  -L ,  S Q a0,
 7 ,-   20 K 5  :- 5 K&  0 - --
_ & -  K 0 20 ,0 -d 20;   7 iD 5 -  ,
&,  H  - &( 20 ;3L- DD -, ]    8/
.
 7 7 , -    ,:/- & 2!  &Q '&%? 20
k0 ,XD - "  ? 7?%&-? 20Oj ,  ?   Q- 7
  Aj.
7-0OjD  /  7 -, H(  ::  ' h  QL 7-  & 7
- " A , 5 34 (  _ 0 &(  7   5&, 5  -

    .

 7:&,; H_  5  e:, 5 5X 7 "&, ( 7 R/# /A"- 

.-,:
&  7 , 5' (  @,3a #D  ,% 34   "(
  7L?   7@: 20Oj ?  L !   78.7?%
 7 O  7 2LhL& E/ -&-;  .a ' h   7/D
'&%? ' 20 - " 34 56 , e 20 3q
W     ; & E/' , D :L 8  7.F
:&, 20 ,0 . ; F . 0 - "A  7- D 7\ CQA 5
  0  #   Kda &( '   C  7--K@0 K
20&A L 5 X- E j  D  @, A F( ? 7,jc A, j
&( @ ? r ( : -,34.
 7 , 5 s   .&-&,  F" 7! 7 234  K C/0 /_ -  @,
? 7  "A 3j . Q  (& (O -   A0? FL 20
"& 8L /L 8 \. /
?  - e  _&%, 7- &  W, A ; H&Xh 20 D-
! D\ '  /  0;j /, 3?4   Ah 7&  7 7, 5 -
,   K 7 5 '&  ; H&Xh K:&A' (  -jD &2
   A  0  C  K@0 7-- - 5 L 5 A0 ]-L 
- 7 `X  2j" , K K ( 5 \ .D 20 D
#  " 7 234'"L  20 Q 234  -(   6
"   7,Q- Z:( " 5  7A;,, 7,  X ./-
O& .&&- !  - `X D , A ; 7: &  -& t3 % .
' - ? ?Q  20 5 - ( D i#`X 34L S:/L  W,%A
# \   /   5X     - s/'&Q:  7Q- "
& F`X  # A; H -/  K_  5?%&- ; ? : iA
 a 20' "] 0  Max van Bercham "5;  F; 20 HL4
 s/   20 7: %A 1891  "; 20`X " L
!" &  Gayet.Alpefl ," 7 20 "2 1893.
# - ;  F ! 7/ @ 20 2Q:LQ- ! 5 L; H/
(  : # A- jE 20"  ( :34 #j"
 A    , A OAE O: 56'& h  K8-;H
 :- A  &-_ 5 0 20" 7 234'  5+; H/ '&%?
;WL "    :  0  &  \6'   A  K@0 20? d- 5K %L
jk 3!  ! 7 Q :0 "# -/.,
5 A0  F"
? KW 20" 7 s,/&E/" '&%? \ K@0 ,OL ( 7--
- 5 L  7/, 5 A0 A  7 7;   &0\ 5 LF; 2A
hL K, "L!&E K i,ELQ &.W,
: ('& $% "!
:

 -  03j!   & W, 7 8,/&-  :Q & W,& 
&  !&A 7 W, ' AA& E/? :0 2QW% 7 "A:&A 7?%&- 
- 7j  @ dELhL ? . C&, - , L  20 
,XD' ,+A" 2" ."2
; H&"L ,+ &  ,E  j A  7 -  + 20
' & A X 20- " ? ! ; 4 20&   @ 7
 7?%&-( /A4 8  7D '_- 2-   A WL '&8 ?.
01 .1" /$ '+ ,- :
SO,?%&-   ,:L 5  D j 7  5 -'!&- -2A
 - H;  7 &: 20 5  A    7 .dQ 5 AA ' ,
# & 5 A 20 ,  :&"L  F; 5 A&A "
 - 20? - 5 L.5 A0 K %L
' L ",E  !   20 7?%&-:&A Q
 : ;WL j 7 ; "?
& W,"L.
  !/ ( 4 (  , ! ? j 7  7 !-  Q:, ' K
 20& L ! (-  -; 0 Q:, K H  5  K; ,  7,
E, :&, (& .\-   ? K 0 (-(   K 0 0&L jc.?4
]  K C/0 F ? Q; & i,W 2A ( 3 20 5  7-:- /
? 0 -A   7'|&0 (  Sd:/6-, 0& W,&\ %L 2 (
  !  3 K % 5 7 @, Kd: & 2   a20 #D
&0 ( 7- L.&& W,
& ( E ,+/-" ,"  "2 ; 7?%&- .0( @,
 /"# & ,   7  ,6  L - ,E ; 7,A  ,  % 
 .-
  i, - ; '|&0 (  &\ E/E, ' 5   , 7  -6'&0%
,XD& 20 &L 2!  ,E  20 jD & 2 &X %
-- ,@/ ,  : 20 -d? A ; "&W-Q .-,:
K"/L,E  X}  : e 20  eD , ,:, j Cd"W
 7  L 5  ;Xc F & &? K8-L 2  AD 7 R@&, F
; HD , 20 A ::/ A , 20  7,D   0"\ ( i@&L  7
D ,,; '&&   H&  7 S,64  7!  A 3 20 ,a
 ;  H 7 ]L H-  A ?  7 A  AD -+A
 / 20 CQ,4) ,&, / (-D  :,  C! ( K- 5H-
 7 F   5+&W  ; _ X3X! 7 # CA 8 6 7
/A &-L( /Q (  7 , % 2X   20 CQ&0\: .
EW K-&L .H-
.245 " "!
:

 -?%&- ( & C- 7 7j 7--6:, 5 7  0Q &,L 2

! 5 - "0" @ 3 20  &  ,,!  +A 7 FL 5Sd:/
& W,& ( (Q&L 2 : ,0   -  "# L.W,
LE E 5 -   7/-  K (  -3a4  :2,
.  ,5%6" 9 , , :,'7
,+A .  ?L"  ?%&- AA4 -- ,  7--( ?
.7,jc
 0 )" 20 (/"$7& "- 34 -" ;, C( : h ; (  
? K34   2%$-" -"  F  :0,  ::/ 6   
  ( K 7 :A  d :,a.%/
  34 k0  7  E    65  20 ,! 7 )684( K@0
'  7" 20 0   / @.-W
) C (K,, W&,  -
 ::/ ;  5'&%? ? 2/ 20 7  C - 20 K@0 5 L -
&( A  Z- L 20 ,- &:L 2 ] &8 -
 A 70 2 O ) -D`!-O( /L 5 A j  20
 D @ : -W" (-& E/) "S- 7 (K,,  D
  7& :0 20 W   %,E    (& A - 7
"  20    65 k0  F :&  :0"  /L 70
.
] ( K8 0 L; 4  7 Q-   20 %L  L "&W
( - - 7 7, ? -h - 20 ,QD   ? 7 Kd3
   -8 7 " K8" ; ( ?O    20 Q >j a? 7 2
 7 E,E  ) 69688 -( " "+ 7 2/,; (  -  7
 ,   20 L: 92)  F, 7709 -( " 7 R#" ; 
( -L -    20 ,-   787)  F-706-(  7
 7?%&-\ 7  /"#  K8; H-D & L 2 .5 L,+A
? :  K8; H'&0\  |aW  7 7?%&-( % 5-L  eQ
 6 7  RQ   d- 20 7--! ' ?  &(  , 5
L BA  Ah% 2W, ; /L/ '&? RQ& d8  ' ,  A :
 # #  :O (  7 ,E'&&!  2"0 |aW & Q? ,:
 OD &0 ) 20 (Creswell K,,& "- 34 -" AA
 -! .  7- %L 20 0j&!" 5  Q:  7 Z:A &7,Xh
 e& 7" Xh"!! "2
) .O&, 5 (K,, /,  ,  7a 7&- 7LjD:,  20 C F
 .O,4 2A; , (  - -  &",   7L 7&-0 A
 AjD ?.
 ::/ ;  5 7 , 5 2AO,L  20 H K@0 ., Q? 0jO
( 6  : :0 7--( jc F  -+ 5;  H# K L
" 20  @A; ?  0 7  -34 ) 126 744/( \&00 "W
4

D    7 ,E, 7 ? F-&W - H%L 20  7 , /-0 7

 K 7 . @,
 i?&, 5?%&-  7'& % Q L% "L W, 6 ;"L 20 7--
ZOWL d-  (& 34 & 0 -  &QW 34"&- :&-
 20 ,;  3X , S/&L  i?&A.
Q 7 3 ?   " -
"
?& :?  E,:- :A OOj 20
a 7    H   % iQD  7:  s8  )9( 
 !/( - 300  K-/ ":  ? , (  K  ]d --,:
Q/ (   L-O&0 j QA - 2A /La 7 ? & ZOW.
 0 K/L s/   !` - - j 5  7?%&-  ,;7,
 -L  ; H , (  &?# +, ( :L  2! 20 2
 i ?  ? K .- 2AO 20 XhL ? jD; H &:
? & 2   , %L !   -0  7 . (A
 F L.
"
@/&L :
5  7? Q , A 20 " s -a jc"W
" 7-a\  7, & -  7" 2&j 'A j 7 7d X3X F
 , 20 7d"O ;   LQ- & W,  20 (Wiet/,) 7
& "! :" \ ( ;  QW +3 B  0 20 F ' A '
 7dA  K:, ' AD 7/  K:, -  20 K-  i?&, 5;
%&-  ;  K /   5E,  O  7--A &, 
 5 A 20 K- 7/-!.5
 "
@@
 %& KQ&&0 :  ,:  7 h ,  7,20 2-
 iQ 7 2A8:  ]W  )11( 3j 03j  Q&-".2-a
:, E,:- 20& " "ZOW X3Xj ?    , Q
 "&  ) 5!L (K,,;  20 BE D  7&  7-
Q 20 34\   H 7 R#h0 "7/" - BEA4 /&, 7
" X3Xj ? 7/  7."..
 : ; H/-'  & ,  7 K@0 K( ?   0 7?%&- 
& "- 2 " K 2"0 34 7 s/# Q ? -,"&W
 # d S,E-L 5L 0jE K F0&  RQ&  -&- & ":
 7 @ j.
,c FL F - \,! & h 2  ) /L  (K,, ? WQ
j  0 ?# 5 ( ,| CA ,+ :0#D &-  %22 K0
 A OAE %22 %55L / ,  Z:0 %1 . #D -L
?  ,  7 5d3- A    -- ) 20 (Briggs /E,& "-
D 5:L 7 ",-/-  7?%&- L 5  .'03&j  5  -0 :- :,
" | F;/, 7, K@0 L 20 ,- &,  A 7 7,
20 L  5 A? ( -, -  Z:  7OAE " ? 
\ '  & 2:"&, 5 5 A ' ( ,L  7 5  K@0 K  55 "A
5

"&j  '3&j . 20/,4 &%- /, - ! Gayet ,; Q 20 .-
/, O:" H0'," 3 20 Dieulafoy 0 - ,E /," HHavell "K0
20  ","," 20 Rivoira K' - c 0W  -L .&: `."7,j
.?$C : A7'
7%B
, 3 & " :  7-- D 
20 R-A&   7?%&-
"? ? 7/L ?&   . ]d 2QD /0 &"- ?    (  ]d
&( ? '&3     ;WL ! 3Q.
' ! 20 ? :  20 OO:, LD  7A-8 K,/L 0#,
( ! .? L X ?  "L ( ,| F 7?%&-(  /; 0A  ,
( &  e/ "# 20 , 34 ? .
 ( F 7 56 , & %L 5 W, 38  . ]d?&  ---
 .&" 7/- ?Q.
:0 " 20 2:- 7& "5:( ; H   ]d R&0 -" A--
- B- (   0 ." !  "QA
 3 &0" 20 " (    C 20 A8  7--;WL  "QA
!  -     20 88& " _- 20j _-" '; 7
2 ? a?  ; 7 (  7--?&- . D5X 7/-
&  5  . \ 20 5
 / X . KQ&L 2 0D  S%& 2 e 5 7?%&-  7
  F-&_E! K   ?4 .D.
 : _  L 7; H ] :-4 3q  Z:0 7-- -AA  @,
ZOWL !-( '?& a 7   ]d /- 20 #j.,
j!   7 ; H/ " ( RQ, ' ,3a4 ? . - '  --L 
"%Ak 7/L |  20 !-:   D @    20  7%A 7--
k0 3  Sd:& %L ,( ; '?&  &0 ?Q  7 7E! A 20
#
  7; H'/ '& d8   ]d &  h j L - 
-- ( , C ! 7 ,  B- ZOWL 7  :O OOWL ]&:, 5 S%
  ]d.,
? ! a?  20 d" , &X  .a: +A ; 20 ZL, '" -
2 ?+ Z   & 2 "\ 20 A ; H? ::/ %&- )L/
(Terrasse ? K,/L Q ? a  ' L  L O a  e
 Oh  %L 5:L  7 j   ( S%.
.(4G- I  E( FG H7$D%:
-&L; HW 0&! 2 & 20   >,&  ; 7?%&-, : &% .
(  7&: 7&d'j 7 -   7 7 ?4 /Li:D
7 - AX    (# 5,   5.
? %&- ) :- (Ceatani/2A&,D(  20 , 7 FL 7 H
0 7?%&-   2-) 5 (2A&, L%   / 7 5
 K; , 7,   20W   7-0 % K @/ 20O -_A? A
6

  : 5 ,  C K#h&--  7D 7 ; ":-, 

. PhobiaContingent Clooustro
; :, 5  j K? 7--! 5( "& %,  !-    20
20.,-
  :-L :0 A8 : ) (K,, 2, -/ (#  %, 5 5
  AD 7-- H , e/, ( !& :, "  "
 "7-? & BW jD  s, 7 H" 20  7:O  " KQ&,
 O  L/ -  7X E6    -0  (# 
 7 5_E +A(  7 ( Kj dA?  :;  :0 ,
iQ :0 ,  -    0 C  7--.
 :\ %L , (  !  (# 2   5 A 2jD
% ? KO F  7 /0  s,/ H&  4 20 '
iQ- 7 -,  i%&,    (# 5,   5 S"&,; & .
@&:  -& 2 !L C!L A %  ! K 34  20  2
D  %,E .
 ) i "A (K,, /"# e .O, j  7&   7; C:A
# 0 &0 ( ; '&3W _- !  (#  ? ? 5 20
 ( 7" i, s,  O? B/"- (  &  20"  5  @,
 (#   ? 5 ;  +/D(  20 H - :,
 7% "EA  (#   ( 5 2, &( (  H K-0
0 (#   C6 5 20 7--? 5X " 0 K- " - Kj0 , 7
? ."7 H:X
? ) (L& (2A 20  @, ,+A 1915   )  -0 ( (K,,"
34 3Q ! ! ;W&, 5 '  0  (#   57 , 5 A
g  20 .!  7-- K? ,- F 5 -  K  -; -/ H
'  E 7!L
(#   20 5 7 , 5 ,-     K  E
 7--A -&, 0 20  A ; E-.
, !   dEL Sd:/?&  ? 7  3& 2W,4- - 6
 7  @?, - 2?3jD ? .d `' ? ? . 20 7- &CQ
 (& (-D  - 7 Sd:/ \ ,_ . ,
7-0- 3Q ( \0 K? 7--   ,(  ,-0 A  5
3#   20 - ! .   -  :: ,-  , ,X
L  W, L , & ( .-L W,  7 (# 2   5 D
 ! L; -d? A  L  - +- +"&/ :  A  5,:( ?
   7    F-j \  20  - ,  ,-- 
 20 F 87.
K8- S/,; HE-  5) j 7 (K,,\0 ' L  L &O  HL -
)&c 7 (2A & Q ( 20& " 20 %A ) "Q&W- 1958 5!L(

   (7,: 2  20 C%A  !-  20 7 , 5 K#D K ,A

 . K
F;  L! K@0 .%A  !- 2034 ( ",  7 ",; 20
 Q ,   20) 44 665 /( Q, 2  F !-   73Q
! 20 Kd:& 7 ;W !- -&!3 A  -& 2 :4  -+,
 20 COW-   !!.
 : ) 7 -! (K,,    Sd:/ S,O E - K  Q-
& ? W,! ( - ,  7? , &  .Q  \? !L
 7Q- r .L . !-,   7-- 20  A KQD
 &"- &8  7 i,O ):, (K,,  20 7-- ,-- r
_  !, . 3# 0 54)  (& - 674/( 5 : - (  FK
Q  :D K  ;  F "O  -#'.Q ,
 K S - i@, A K  00 -A  !-  C 7 0L 7X -
 7L  5  (- -  ,- - AX-  7? D  - ?5
3 A !!.
  3 
;   :#3  - ; 
:5J FG LB MK!1
C:A7
 7 L 5; HO_- & W, 0% - A  -L  -/j  6  ?
 &,6& ( ZOWL !- # 20 34 ? ?&] ( : d- 7
34 -a  A , 5 ( " , - &( h 5 A Q CA!D
-a%, 5 5 A  !- '   &A  !-D(  7"& &- 2
'a , A\ Q 2% - .:,0
  %A  Q&j ( ZOWL !- ZOWL 7 ]&:
 -  ,-- ;   ! 7  O j! 0  % 20
  3Q r  ?%    i: 7 i: KW-/- ( - ;WL 2@,
;! 7  5X KW? r -!  /L ],":  7 7,! - 5;0 7, hK
 "Q  7EA   K,/& 2 /A : / 7  \  -
&! /A - (Q?D K+L CA?  7\3   . KO&-;F
# ! & 20 ZOW -   7/QD Z% - ; /L  3r .
3Q.
   FL 7;   7"   ZOWL 20 , !- D(
!  7/Q3+ D .  7L\ .  '&%? 2& 2E ( 
 ? 7--/&A ; & 20 -,? d- 7 ZOWO?D - D\ .5
?   7) 7 K ( PoolLane /) (Diez/EL K- C,3+ 
"@ ; O&L  (  Q S, Q FL .!,"  ( ZOWL
 !D  ; %, 20W Cd" :6.
_ FL 7 ,?D 2&&  0 3+ " O/- %  Z & r 2
 20 ,- 20 K- - &: A/  K? 2 -34 &k0 2 ZOWL
 -  7/Q3+ C, 20 C, ) 7( ) (EL( 67 7--

 K8 7" 7:6 5 , 7--   5 , A S0- 5  Z/-

, 20 5 :a  7,.234
 ::/ ; H/-  -    e:, 5 %&L , 7 L    77?%&-
" !&  .  0 L
7-0-   3+ a/ 7 L 5@" K  7D O   
7 - 2LOW  03W!  - ? " &(    SQ&L
L   7O  k h0   :O 7 d- &&   Z/L  
@0   a ? ! K 0 SL A RQ- 0 R&0 ! 5X
-8 "W " 7  h0 3r  20 . CAD & 2 07 - "W
OW  d@0   Z/-  F!4 --  20 )24 26 644 -
648( F; K L K % / 2d  2 -  ;W&,  | C?L 7  -6
3#4 & ( ,;.
 -L 3Q & W,&L 2 ' -
 : 7) C L( )0 hOj (EL   -
' h F% 3r   -A&  7 - ]  ].
, 
 7 7 , - ; H/-' D & 20 F % ZOWL # !- :0C
?%&-     20 7 s/# ?;  -, &.ZOW
.1?$C 
7%B(:
$
&", - 7 S,0 `X +A  -?&] +A 7 OOWL   ]d ,5
20&, F ( ` & 2 ) 7 K (Spiers /) (Dickie/2 , 1897
 %A & 7 - .D .S%
:0! R-  -D  20 K#D    7( t0 F-
  5+!E  d&"  + t;WL  !  .7--
?  ;j  7 H;  7?%&-` ) K8 (Diehl/K ,)&!/2 0
(Strzygowski)0  (Van-Berchem /5/AEL0) %A 1921  20
(Watsinger&   7 S% ,hL 0; HE-.5
' E, ; H` , h  .D
  %A 7") 2A : (Dussaud/H
? 20 5  - 2A (&!) 5,:;  ? ;WL  -0 ; -
&"+ t FL .
56 )QL ? (K,,  '  KOA  5 & % Q LW,
   ?   ,?   \ 20 H'  A &0
   7 F-&j +A +A 7 H   ]d 20 /-D , - 7--
;,) C (K,,A ? "   ( !-; HQ   L K,/L 20 5 L ]d
( !.
j :A 20 2" , / 20 :A  ZOWL .D h?& 20 X38
r/ %, ' :  7D  s 7D  L  :-   -,? ,F
& ) "A (K,,?k " (Sqvvaget/!0) 2A. @,
 K; &  0; # ': ?& ZOWL .D  7  ]d ,
; ) K8 ?%& .00',( ( /, X  ? a ? .?&]
+A 7 OOWL   ]d ! K :,  (  a?  A ZOWL; -
9

#  ZOWL 7 :  %0 ]d Z:-  - 7 .O&:  7 .O&: 2:0

?, a OOWL 0 Z: Ah r KW, (&   (:0(  7- ZOW
: -  7 5   ) 70',(  h( @" j ? ?&O !E 7
,E & 2\" (  -D  ? 7 7A d%A& ; E  .O&:-
?;  -d - L 20? .E! D E! 22 7  7 -h 5d:.-
? i% K . 0 - ; H 20 W&  !" d:  " 
%A Z:- K  2:0D 20 -!  ZOWL  ; \&0; %&-.
?  &% jc /-  a?  . )';0 (Lambert /
 -+A 7 S&% (Q?D   ]d +A &-, 2# & /!DE )'(
# 5 , &E! ZOW  0  +, s/ a?  7+  2Q.&-
  (') 7   F 8, ZOWL !- -A?&]  ZOWL 7 K
+A 3    0, : ; %&- ?  ( &-;  ZO%;
  8-& ,
, 5 0 ,  7.7?%&-
.2?$C 
5D"':
B
 ? (!0)  A - h +A & ZOW!-  7 S&%  ]d? ,
' 2&: +A  7 -  , A 2 - ; A
 #j ,+A
:L 0 0 :L - /- ? &,'&: .-
c S/&L ) (!0 L  ,k ] O Z:0  &0 -A3 i% L  AD  @,
 7'&"W 34  K.Hd% S-
C/0; " 2A; '   L L-L 20 -: ,- k0 34 7 , 5 -
W&,    A :   W&,  -&!3  A  - % W&, 20
6 j  C  0 "&W ? 8- , - /-EW /D - A
&L 0  O:-,D &- " .(L-
& ) (!0 @,  .D K  - ]    '!&- 
, 20  - 20- D ' - 3Q  -&3 K (  OW&2
 :, "W / 5 20 Oj 23Q   ?3 ' , .-
H;   :0 ,+&L 2 ( E CAk0 "r  -  ,-   :/
E-  K# 2   5; F  R# 20 S% QD   :/:  -
.03W
' &  : F 7 A2 20 - / ; !  c "L 20 ) (!0& 2&-
(  % /& "r O:  Ah Q 2 ,d:.,
 K? 7 _A ; H, O:  A(  7?%&-:a +A (  @,
-  ,4A D &- ) L& ZOWCruci Form /2Q
(Plan  ;, - , ? K@ L 20 ,0 . (  0 Q 7 |aj
& ?: K-&/, 7 S&% Ah 2, A Z:-; (  K 2Q]d  2:,64
./-
0 !, -   7& K, ' 7OOW !, ' s -   #&  K
 Z? 20 CQ- 34 D  ,4A   .-! 20 ,'/

10

3\D  ,:L  7/Q; 3W  R&"L  K CQ!- Z: 20  7 ]d;
.
.3(
KK!1+:
 r  &%? h% "&W K#D 2!D&"- & ZOW !- 20
# 34 S - , ) 2AO, 7 (K,, K#D  2
& ZOW .Dj ; %&-  20  @,  7 s/# ZOW& A
 !-? , ; H ? !-?& 7  LOOWL: '&: 20
Q: " .-,:
56 ):, 5 (K,, 0 : 2OOWL 5 / 20 &,+A   , !.
  ZOW& 0: " ' ! K! E! & .! ZOWL 7 %  0?
0 "&\ :20
.1/ .-
.2  !` -.7  A
.3 i: /O-.%W
.4 i: -d: ( : 6 7 -.
.5 - ,/ A. 6 %W
 ::/ ; H #Q SOL -W ; (  -  ,--
; ' 20 F)  (& &# (K,,;  , A W&, .-
;  S/,   7'&0\ &:L ' 2 (  X L S/&, 2W, : 
C "3) 2A 7 (Saladin / ZOWL !-&?  7 S 7,Q-
 20;  ) L(.
? ( L !, ' Ah (E,) F  5+A 7 7+A 7- 8\  7
& +A 7 ! 34 +A  ".
: @J( $  $ "

:
 "Ac ,  5 L 5 7?%&- >,WL 20 K/#  6 ZOW& 3-
234 ( F 7 56 F- D OOWL  ZLL  d:
A, &   7, 2  /# -  Ak0 5X 7 A XhL j! (:Lidr
? .\ 20 + 7-0 K& ( XL 2& ZOW--.
k0 .O W  20  7 s/# "&"  -- , 0jE
3 AD /&A " # 7 ' Z,
&   E-L 2" 7 234  ,
  5rA  0 5 /&L "r - / 20& ZOW--.
.1:D%
 ?%&- A - 234( #  O? /&- ( QA LW,
 "D? "2245) 20&-859 /( 20& "j  " D? 2 7 K?A
, "  K? X? X3X / L0.
:0 20& O ! "  (  K /  -D %
    ?h%A K ! ,  A" &0 C%W -/ H ? , 
     ( / ?" (,"?  D? 2 A   ( A 
-  7 /  7.C%W
11

; H ,) F   (K,,   Z&, "?"    %, -  -

]   ? - D? 2 7 , 5 F e:  0 ,D? #j  & 2
 A , 5 &+   " RL%j :  ?  5 20 F
608      20 5, W 7X38? K L(  ,-- h
  %!  "?"  j  D? ( 2 A ; .# -D
 20  ,- A   ?.O
E_  - H )  (K,, ? % K# - BA 7 Z:D? 2 5
"?" &( '  , e?L 20 .:, 20 &,+A  %     % -A 7 ]&:,
)  ",  ( Becker/  (#   5 ;W&, 8- - 2
; K0 F"W  H 7 ;  . C 7 - "WOW  ( -" Q
 7"  7? ( D - 20"W %L F  C ) ( " 7\R
 7 -OW - ( A -  7  ;W&, 20"O   - (- 5,:;
20 K8-&, A :-  "W ".
) K:&A 7 (K,, ,D? 2( L 7&, 7&W, - 7 K 7?-
5,? BA 7 3;L &, &:O&- A - -  7 
E,:- :A
' , ?   6.
; H ::/& W,\    7?- E,:- &0\ & "? K  
 7 E,E  K- A  e 7 ... Q ]d? K  ,F 2&? 7
  H(   7  7 2 A  s &(   5;  O:
 7 KA".
? ) (:&A 7 (K,,; H'&0\  %,( K#D  - 2 , h F
 K;  K  7 K:A ? - &) "% 20 (K, 7 ,, :  & ?%
jc ) ? (!0& ) e/ (K,,&0 ] 0 &- k0 /Q
& ? 20 ,0 X) A CA (K,;  -( :  3-
 :: 20 A 7 ]&: D - 34, L j(    7:.
3- ( ! .7:
(:, %A ( 7 AL 8  W,  - 20 ;WL - H%L  ,-
' Ah 7a 7
A   "7L0" 7 && 7 !& 7? K  @,  -
20h F  : ? K 7)  20 C%j 7 ;W&, 8629 -(.
.2 :
 7 7 , L W, j !     - ,-
 ) 91 708 -( &j ?%&-  OjQ  -!    d:&A ( /-
- 20;  ? ?&]  7  K./-
' &@   F - 20    7F-
 : ;  ZW?
320 K#
 7 ,:-; C"" - L % 7 5   7,%
.3
K 3(  d  7,%
 e, (   7
 :%& K"6 ) K8 (K,, K; H&?@ 6 .0(  L  7:H
 e- 7 7j - Z: : 20  s - K- -0 : r 20"W

12

j !  &&>  7" F - A  7  5- E ;  0/-

 ;  Hk0 Z:  K, F  O? K#D&." / 2
20 - K'/  :0 X--) K"6 (K,,, L W,j R!L -
 ? /- -8 03j 20 " 7 -8 &0 Q  7 Z:
A -, K S0 H 56 ' %L Kd(  7 L 5 5 ! 5 - K
 0jE 0\4 F( ? , & W, FL 2& 2 ;L ' 2:
  ? Q   ""  7 7,%Q.
&/, 5  @, ) D (K,, '   A %, ( 7 Q K
Q   ( 7--  7 5 "# - Z: %, (  20 7/-%
7 5& 7 5 ? D S K% ?  ? 0jEWQ ?K
,L - ! -  F 7.
 ::/ _' ) (K,,\O h 20 &: /- -  7 ]d
e .!@ eQ&0 7?%&- &";.H
 ? /-?
 3L 20  d ,- 20 F ' A
:0 ) (E, /- -  
 7--D ? Kd&j ;  C/0 a K % ", 5 20?& 7 H:L
 .]d
Q? (!0) :&A-  Z:) 5W@L& (2A)&   (K,, ; H,
O ' S/&L'& ' A    7 /Q  @, " t/-  ,
? K34 20_   5! 7 -# ?a 20 ( &A #j(
&h h /- \ 7 . - q  QQj.
.3$4:
 7 L 5Q:- & 20 W - &  X/ F? ? K  7;WL
 7 ," 2  a 7W! 2? K  7 a 7 5 / 5X 2A-;WL
"W  7.-
Q:-0     2-/,/3Q !&, 7 5 20 -A 2
 7XD  S/- ZOWL 20 KjL 30 -]   (  K % #
 .]d
.4:
5TU
 ?%&-  7 5  K:A 7 >  20 , 7 s/ K#}- 7
: OL D( ( D "A;    /-  -
D ;  , (  &  ?:( Q  6 6.3
? ) K:A 7 (K,, 7?- E,:-  7 }-   W 7 -2
 53)  Q 672 -(  !- .  7 h# . 20 . -
 (   7 "WD  7 ," 2 ? 5L& ( E; H, jh&-
' 2%  ;L  A # . s .L  F) (K,,   Q,, LW,
/&L  7    7L F-  -D 2;  !E  (   S%-
2&  W.
 ::/ -  7" :;   7    7 F- ; ;WL
 - 2X}-  ;   K  -; -  ?  i&  2
13

) 291 903 -( -  A ,?    3 &0" C# "

) 245859 /( "L ? |; 20 A34 FL& 2 .  :/Q  2
,  7  F (   7 "W 7 ," 2  3  -
  /  F  .D  .,! 7 H
 7?%&- & ,3 :, ]"A 20" !/ - 7 ?@" F
Q ( &: }-  7 -D 20; '& : /,# "W  &
& W,&Q- 2OL 2 ?D   g ?# -(.
.5@' VB:
W&,  s8-  & K,/ ,    &-?  .(  K L 7-8? ? :
 ?  5?%&-  ? :A ;   Sa 7':&A 7 5 ? 20 .d%
 - 7OAE ::/&  0, 2 - L ," 7 -  OAE7,L  L
"@ K  20 7%&  88-   Sa 20 ,':&A.
,( .6$4:
& - k 34 20  0&W : )?D( K- 20d- i: ,
  ( A- ? L  0# @  &  ' S, 5 0 F  7
-- 7,:(.
? X : - ( 34  20Q '  -:  -& 2& 
%  2 234A - 20 ) 0( 5X A0 20 (,) , 20
:   K " :  d QQ"-  %&-- # 2,
%& A - 20 - :,0 ]AD? ?& - D @,A ?D
 - O a:&-- O&0   FL 8D :& 2%&A - 20
  ]dQ:  20 a: E  AO,; ' ! 0 -
  A a:& 2    &0 ? -j ) 7: /  %( :
  , (%(   O  34  D #W& 220 -d? A
 Q%.
(  7 56; H Sd:/_ & %L 2(  S- 34  L", 20
&W A  7 "&W:k0 , 5 D  e 7?%&-; 7,  C-
34; .S
:0 E-! & 2&    ! a? .&, 5 2    20  d K? +A )169
785 -(  )!  (George Marcais /  ,( ?& a? 7 2
, 20 A %A 7-, a: - : 2A8 ! a? .  !
 s  OQ  - : 0 ? a\L s/ -W 20+A 5 : &:
  _0 ::/. -L F
 0\4 F( : E-! L a?  20 :   ?3 ' "r ?a
, _    '"L  i:? 3Q ,E R-, - - \4
 A O :&", 2-  20 ]-% a C6? &%.
?  - jc : A j  K8 :"-  : 2X38"Q ( 5
j Lh0   8h  O: 7 Q- L 34  W, 0 / 7'5 L

14

 "/  #j K% &    " ; H/-' L 7
&    H;  7--AD & S, 5 2   .5 ? 7
Q, "A D ( - Kj - )( & 2 20 d A&Q/ 34
 2 Kj .a L 20 7-! -( 'OA (  K  -d? ,?&5 /
  0  , !   5 - :0 70!  ?%&- s/ 5 "A
 7@ 20 -,? 8  : !.
O D  :3 A&E/ '&%? & 2 K  a& -
@/   34 20- " & :O &(  20 
: &Q.,
 : ?%&- ( 8/,  ; - c 7 ?(  7 `X 5D -,:
 7% _ # -8 ( ",  "# "@/OQ 7 j
-  ,-/- " 7.234
56 L  K8- 34 " 7# ? 234  &L &  7
 7--D - K? "a ,  jc C' 2_, A& ,  ( &
" "#"   Q, 5  7 7?%&-  ::/  %- ,Q? 7 -A
'     -& iW ,+  :0"  2& 2 A  . "Ac
sj
c : D  A j &E/ '&%? L 2 ! # -  7 ,
20&  78  K0 7-- F  ,  e,L j " 7/L
34 7 5  S/ - @ 5 ?:/ 5& W, 5 L,:" &7 L   2
3q j  "A  7-- CQL &3.

15