English 360 iFixit Progress Report Rubric - Peer Review

Criteria

Developing

Proficient

Advanced

Sections
organization is
absent, illogical, or
inconsistent;
Form &
Headings may be
Organization
absent or do not
describe content
effectively

Sections
organization isn't
always clear or
consistent;
Headings may not
describe content
effectively

Sections are
usually organized
logically and
consistently;
Headings describe
content adequately

Sections are
organized logically
and consistently;
Headings describe
content concisely,
specifically, and
accurately

The report fails to

describe the
group's completed
tasks, current
work, and future
work; the group
Content &
seems in danger of
Persuasiveness not finishing the
project on time.

Descriptions of the
group's completed
tasks, current
work, and future
work may be
vague; evidence of
the group's ability
to complete the
project on time
isn't quite
convincing.

Some specific
details describe
the group's
completed tasks,
current work, and
future work
adequately;
evidence of
group's ability to
complete the
project on time is
convincing.

Specific details
describe the group's
completed tasks,
current work, and
future work directly
and aptly; evidence
of group's ability to
complete the
project on time is
convincing.

Appearance

Language

Absent or Below
Basic

White space, fonts,

and design are not
used to increase
the readerfriendliness of the
report.

White space,
White space,
fonts, and design fonts, and design
may be distracting are effective.
or ineffective.

White space, fonts,

and design are
effective and
attractive

Spelling, syntax,
diction, or
punctuation errors
impede readability.

Spelling, syntax,
diction, or
punctuation errors
impede readability
or otherwise
distract from
meaning.

Outstanding control
of language,
including effective
diction and
sentence variety.

Spelling, syntax,
diction, or
punctuation errors
are few and do not
distract from
meaning.

Notes

Progress report is missing team members names.

Form: Layout is inconsistent. Some headings are above the content, some headings are to

the left of the content.

Content & persuasiveness: current work and remaining work is a little vague, should include

more detail as to when they think they will finish, why they are working and 3 different guides.

Work is very brief. Schedule is mentioned, but not specific. You should go more in detail about

how long it to you to accomplish what you have, how long you think it will take you to complete

what you haven't yet.

Appearance: Delete the prompt for the progress report that is pasted at the end of your report

draft.

Language: Nothing is wrong, but nothing really stands out either. Up to you how you want it to

sound. Sounds monotoned to us. Some sentences are run ons, shorten up what you can. Short

and to the point.