11
 


 
 
www.ninars.com
1




***


     # 2010 ( *)( ' %
 

 


./ Skeptics Society .D  BC
A ..  >#(' ; H ./.GH F
( IH# J.B  LG F( .H# K(.H H   .
***

(1  &%
# "!  1  0   .
# +, -
 (L(O  (HR NOP I LG
 
.L '  .L% I (L
 (O (
.  
T %
 A* I(O (D Y  I A  FHU# F #H  ( Y H H#
V
W P  GP .CH
V_ aD   * V
#LG%Z CH  
..# T`B\_(  ALZ(L  >#\
[ THZ
"

) Homo habilis 3,4 G H((

"

) G  Homo erectus (K` H
"

9) 3%78 G  Z( . T JW T`B V_ mC(O (P

; B NOP R  `P mO(#H H P
*) Homo Sapiens I G  (TD#  O a
KD;H.
*

<
(27  !" GFG  E<B%
CD " @AB 1?8  
" =%
P aD o# ` .pR  q[(
 \' (P* .%\( TL* F o[H  [H \.D F
% \'B  qHZ T' sG  oB P r .mD  ># q\  F >#
/ .  (#v qHZ m G  >#) u/ .  * s%( .( ) .G
   * F
/ .( I OR*  %' s[.  q 
(O
  qHG  sH
 TZ OR* R %
(L  q{  F\ m* TD'%Z (zUZ '(
(P R # 
P
 (L   F\ TD 
 \' (P(BZ W
'(H YVG YV* 
(L (O 
* W
FHU#
 . (U F 
A  RZ L '
 m(|RG
F 'B 
WH T    .W  
I
F YR  |
   A I *(BH (~ P P.  .
(|RGH H(P  P . .
R A pHG (|RG
F .  F I TRO | (;Z qZ(|RGH  
O(% F p%G
 
  V
.# zPH 
D  B' TLD 
 G \'B.
*

((O  zHU#
 )zLZ  \_( T`B G  %Z (zU I*

*
B9# 
#
CD @ B%  0 1 !7% "<! 9" - 9 (  
3
Z R T`B .T ) F T  T .  F
.Z Y B'\ T
|G P BH(
.R _(F` P 
( .(B JW V_  \P |(RGH(  [(
 Z( ) B (OG

punctuated LM9 
I* P(#
H P ( G V
H . HZ  | oOH) LG (G
 #
pL`Z G*
H|
T`B Z ' ` _(B (% .zHZ  H .'` P .equilibrium
 /_) LG a(* (Z (L;Z  H #
( / G* H|H JW mO H) .**\ H|H

TO * . Y A  . (G T`RZ H ( \[( .( |(
  ' OG
(L H|H
.z|G (P'\
(P'\
 ..# Iz Z ) (B IzZ
F (P\ PR .. `P F R H T`RZ 


   [(' H F(' \H '(H  B' T
|*  . pL`  G V
.# .. ~BRH
.(_ Z  `(O( B P T`RZ **\ \ ( Hz  O Y(' H|(
 RG
F T`R
  L  L P B
ALv (Z( O*Y( )
 P ** T B'\ T|G  qW
.R
*

  Q (4 9
=9 P7A,
%  Z I;
[ mL aD A  q 
..#\ 
P OGH  .  aH|Z B;
H JW;./V
 L H(P
  | I (|RH I  L I R |( P I L(p
 BOH  I |   L|  L% I \  |  | TGGZ H| 
 
..## \_(  (Z z /V_ F R %Z .;) O
 W  C(B; L% ( .
 T'B ' F .%  % (L Y V_ 
A
(|RG '. .% (LZ A
..#
\' (P K  FOH  |    T`BOH  ( R  B   
..#\R
 H#\_( P .  H aD ( % .R
; P /_ (L   R u au;Z  (L
Z
P (`D .R (Z *( P #( .W '`  '  P(#
F %Z B (B* (L
  TZ ' .
 # .L%
*

. I#Z  %(L  W aC* (U o  YOZ

*
S
(5U, QV QA 
= 9T, @T=
 O  o #L% (L TH# Y` .P. O  F PR #L%LGH ) (B;

\_% IzB  .(D T; P q  F TH#{ O  .#% (O  L%(R  13\ 
F 
m
` K% P. qO  R
2613  F\ 
TD T |
|H W ( ID
G  H|
s#C 16
[ 
WY  U  F' GH .
    ..O  B' F(R ` pR;
 (R
;)F H T#BZ HO Y  H #L% | PR
335 (L q .NOP  (# %  A
 (Z  . O (  . O (HH I \ P TuP T`B R
 O %%Z . #

  *G' #O'. .# HP pL` H _ P #.O#H Y 

 H ; V zP(# T`R I
`V_ 
T`' T P. Y ;% * % (ZP mH  zu#\ >#L T'.
m# z #TuP
[( .#P 
..# JW;% Z Y P  ' T`RZ.#L%

*
Q1T1 !1 Z  (6 E 9 A" X Y7T " @G!A
   # P HH`
z  (zUZ (L ( T aD . .
OH  L
*#| ZP F K
u (L TO Z  (O *.# TG(v H . ; VO#H V_ \
( ; V\ OP;V
[   TLD L%O T`Z F;H N\)(  RZ v  uuL F ` L . WZK
 F(O (_
P (`L 
.  zR/ F  .zHzP   H  (( . Z
HH *O

` IH  L  O
O(% #
*#
.O# JWz W ` IzP H IH*L  NOP J  O Y
 F  #L%V_ 
# H H(P * O   ..R  F; VH
    u# .OG#
 mL[Z  ()  I Z%
   * O ()  Y` IHW
 `.(B
*
(7

"B  1 ?G" \ E
(P T # (U F Z(Z . Z(Z C(P F L_ D (Z  (L
 
  OR
 H .I#L 
(U L[
z
   a%GZ m U L( .. 
H zZ._L 
.
.zR/ aD Z   (P 
#H \.   zP(# I# (U  \P  (GBZ(Z qZ
 .aD .O#(B>  H Y mRZ z#CL_Y  mG
  (U .I# % PGZ(v P I#
:D.
 F Z(ZO  .#L% (Z  O OP  .#L% L_V D I P\ |(.L _ D
zZ/V% D.  z.RZ H(L  H#* zP T_ F  O(%.H# O(%'. L _ (U %%   (L|
(|RG 'B [. #Z  oB
 |
T
( |
(|RG ( #Z 
 / . 
 I I .| 
 W  TLO T |G
\'B  A  (zU  
B;
T`P q  P T
 .
*


[ (|RG
F \' ./ .

*
!1 7% (8  ?@
, #?7 =
 !  3? .+D 

# ? - +. _`# " CV
\   
(U  q Iz#* P%| T;O T\ \'B H(P ' YVG  (L OG O
* F IzP #L% T I#W .O

[ _. _% .O#

(zUZ z (zUH I#  .s#uW  .
*(H  (LB*Y
 _ A%
 |' F AZG ..O  F L ( H  O(% .O  z.I#
.O  pR`Z F (U  zRZ O(% H# '.
 D
  .I#;.  T[
BH. T
) z# / B
H|H' .H# .O  >#H# (B  F z( NOBH   (L(O (FHU#
\_% ` T[
D(L T* )R HU T
(O  J.OH# P (#  F # A '.
YVG  a
I Z ((L P .zRR`Z mD  I aD; O puP 
I JW\_%  TH# I
D W
 .qW; OB (O  JW\_% I IzB.
*
(9  
 E @T1 Ed1  0 @T= c

%  F T`R

. (P ) .
 
 (# . HZ

V  G U'V
H Y
( (L P( L|  \ ' `P .# Y uO (P ) . BZ  (H VG .zGB (L
% (H* T`R 
H P AZ.[(

| % W A#Z (L(B* 
[ *L
 PC .J % F q  ># q%  HzH  W
zU'V
H{ .  q* #
 PG G
V_ V  20 s \_( .OH K#
(H * 1350 .o Z ) I|R
 (zUZ '| I
. (L D OZ
O T  oBHzH .O#H
H#  G
    # q PB 
. W  R  D

   ># P `OZ  # q  W  R .# I  qZ T[

z  .` zH#G(% .(z

 P *(BH

 TLD.

*
(10 
 "79 EG= ?! U, 
"@=%
 O [   
 .(R W O U T (G; P(H* D% (' Tv FF NOP L% 
\ HU OH H .# H \ F T`RZ 
 H 
D% >B; Z oH\ ( );G
(R( G
.  P .O#v R  .\  O

U mGR  H %Z  
z
_( O   H) .#L% (RZ oH T*(Z  R H D% Z( %Z sDZ ' . oH
('Y W_Z ( Y
|( HZ R  F\.
*
7 !1 0 (11
%C#
g <D

IU#R  \** . ' qHZ H H

F AHG# \_DV _ T`P /[. .(O \*
V
U
qHZ z * OZ .G
F  zu# >#L' H\.z`P P s#C
Y
[
.  ) (L  #v  %; H` .z 
P L #  LD#H\   . `(P
(B G' F |H W # (%B ; %` (P GR *  . `P r% _  P
 (H\_ DV   zL Z W  r;   D(G
 _) \ (
.Z z[ P ODV#   G
o_.DV
D F .H#Z  OOR`. ('Y  .
 \ HH ' T`P   
r# '
#H|H  F  L
(L #L% (L .Z ; %` (%B.

][