American Council for
Southern Asian Ar.
rN
2
Features
Let Us Preserve Our Heritage -- by Falk Reitz
Two Recent Documents of North Indian Jain Painting
~~ by John E. Cort
CAA Panels of Interest
Calls for Papers
Position Announcements
Museum Listings
Contemporary Art
Fall/Winter 2006 * No. 66Let Us Preserve Our Heritage
Landmark Protection in Kerala: Work Conducted by the
European Foundation for indian Heritage Monuments
by Falk Reitz
Freie Universitaet Berlin
1, History of the project before the
founding of the European Foun-
dation for Indian Heritage Monu-
‘ments (EFIHM) in 2005
With regard to the protection of historical
‘churches in Kerala, like in Ramapuram,
ithas to be mentioned that Dr. Joseph Va~
huthanapally, a Catholic priest belonging
1 the Syro-Malabar Church and having
obtained a Ph.D. in Christian Archaeol
ogy from Rome, started a very important
project within the Syro-Malabar Church
(one of the many Christian denominations
in Kerala), He received administrative
and financial support from the Archbishop
“Mar Joseph Powathil of the Changanass-
ery archdioceses in Kerala to open a study,
teaching and documentation centre in
the complex ofthe Archbishop's House
in Changanassery. This centre, innau-
grated in 1996, is called the Centre for
Indian Christian Archaeological Research
(CICAR).
‘After obtaining my Ph.D. from the Freie
Universitaet Berlin in Indian Art His
tory in February 1998, I was awarded a
scholarship from the Indian Council for
Cultural Relations New Delhi (ICCR) to
study the historical Christian monuments
in Kerala, Goa and Tamil Nadu under the
‘mentorship of Dr. Vazhuthanapally. Dur-
ing my fieldwork, I enjoyed the hospitality
‘and resources provided by the Archbish-
‘p's House in Changanassery. I had access
tall the library facilities and I had the
opportunity to teach laymen and theology
students, In addition, we went on an
‘extended Kerala excursion under the guid
ance of Dr. Vazhuthanapally. During that
time, we prepared video documentation
of historical church buildings in Kerala
‘which now fall under different administra
tive units, including the Syro-Orthodox.
CChorch in Kerala
A first publication in summer 1998 in
the Indian Express (August 8, 1998)
with the title “In Defence of Christian
“Monuments,” was intended to increase the
awareness of the danger of a modern trend
with regard tothe heritage buildings ofthe
Christian community in Kerala. A number
of vicars and church couneil members of
different denominations wanted to express
their new financial opportunities and
their desire to update or modernize their
churches through the demolition of the old
buildings. One of the churches featured
inthe Indian Express anicle, St. George
in Angamali, ha to share this fate: it was
pulled dovn and replaced by an unaes-
thetic conerete structure which has limited
Visual appeal.
ACSAA 66 + FEATURES
2. Our relation to the Archaeologi-
cal Survey of India and INTACH,
Kerala chapter
‘Since the initial days of the project in Ker-
ala I tried to get in touch with the local
authorities of the Archaealagical Survey
of India. They have offices in Thiruvana
sthapuram and Thrissur. With regard 10
the protection of historical churches under
local heritage laws I got the following
response from the then Superintending
Archaeologist (dated 15.12.1998):
“Sir, with reference to your letter dated
8.12.98 regarding advice on the erec
tion of Notice Boards at all the important
churches, itis informed tha the Specific
"Notice as quoted in your letter ean be
displayed only in the protected monu-
‘ments of the State or Central Government.
If you are very particular to protect them
as monument(s], you may transfer them to
the list of Central or State Department of
Archaeology as they deem fit
nnLet Us Preserve Our Heritage
by Falk Reitz
This statement is modeled after regula
tions that were created after India's
independence in 1947. The monuments
‘of religious minorities, like those ofthe
Thomas Christians in Kerala, were put
under the property management oftheir
religious authorities (ie, the respec-
tive Bishops and Archbishops). Local
and central governments did not get any
authority to intervene with any sugges-
tions regarding their property. Ths legal
situation creates significant problems for
the safety ofthe architectural heritage in
Kerala
When local activist realized that neither
the church authorities nor the local state
administration can hinder the destruc-
tive process in Kerala, they started public
actions for heritage protection. They or-
ganized themselves in the Kerala chapter
of INTACH (Indian National Trust for Art
and Cultural Heritage). Within the Kerala
chapter there are again five sub-chaprers
forthe different regions (see hitp:/www.
intach.org/eh_south Kerala htm). The for-
mer Mayor of Kochi, te largest tadition-
al business centre of Kerala and so-called
“Pearl of the Arabian Sea, isthe Head
(Convener) of the whole Kerala chapter
‘of INTACH. Mr. KJ. Sohan is also the
‘Convener ofthe Kochi sub-chapter and
is very active with regard to the heritage
‘monuments in the old Kochi harbour and
ancient Fort area.
Before the volunteers forthe 2005 cam-
paign of EFIHM started their measuring
‘and documentation work atthe different
historical places in Kochi, Kottayam, and
Ramapuram, we visited Mr. Sohan on
the Sth of April 2005 and have taken his
advice. He welcomed us happily and told
us that he honours our esteem to come
from Europe to help with volunteer work
ina field which is very well developed in
‘our home places - landmark protection of
architectural heritage
3. The members of the 2005 cam-
paign of EFIHM and our work
At the end of 2004 I started contacting
fiends with landmark protection experi-
ence from my home region in Thuringia
(central Germany). They got their
experience through professional work
inhistorical monasteries, churches and
castes in Thuringia After working for
‘yeas in this region with a high density of
heritage buildings they were very excited
‘o.come with their knowledge toa region
deep down in the south of India and do the
same there what they usually do at home:
survey and measure historical monuments.
Since 1991, EFIHM member Gerd Flach
has run his own survey office for land and
building surveying (please see htp/'ver-
-messungsbucro-fach de/referenzen/ref10.
‘hum). Gerd also brought his own LEICA
‘measuring equipment from Germany to
Kerala His brother-in-law, Thomas Fuchs,
is working as technical advisor inthe
castle complex of ‘Friedenstein’ in
Gotha. Both have worked in the project
“Reconstruction of Pars of the Medieval
‘Monastery in Georgenthal” for which they
received the Landmark Protection Trophy
of the State Government of Thuring
‘Thomas’ partner, Simone Jeron, also
joined our team as photographer
We started our work at Kochi on the Sth
cof April measuring the historical syna-
gogue. The next day, we proceeded to
take photos and measurements ofthe
Jeeva Matha Church Mattancherry (17th
century) and the Cutchi Hanafi Mosque
(established 1825) in Kochi. On the 8th of
April we had a meeting withthe vicar of
the Ramapuram churches to discuss our
work on those monuments scheduled for
April 9th, We spent the rest ofthe day in
Kottayam measuring St. Mary's Syrian
‘Orthodox Church (so-called Cheriyapalli,
established 1579) and the Jama Masjid
im Stadttell Thazhathangadi (so-called
Muslim Pall, establiched 1611)
Below: Thomas Fuchs, Simone Jeron, and
Gerd Flach at work in Ramapuram. Photo
Courtesy of Falk Reitz
12 ACSAA 66 + FALL/WINTER 2006‘On April 9th we measured the Ra
mapuram Church Hill. One highlight of
‘our visit was the opening of the reasure
store of St. Augustine's Church. The vicar
Rev. Fr. Mathew Narivelil found our
‘work to be of great importance and liked
the way that we worked as volunteers
for the congregation, He honoured us by
showing us a number of precious objects
‘golden monstrances, historical palm
leaf manuscripts and the famous golden
chalice which the Spanish Queen Isa-
bella presented tothe Rev. Mar Thomas
arayamskal (1736-1799) whois bred
{in Ramapuram.
After this very kind treatment in Ra-
‘mapuram we were honoured inthe eve~
ning hours of the same day through are-
ception inthe Bishop's House at Pals. The
Bishop Mar Joseph Kallarangatt was very
‘much interested in our opinion as to how
landmark protection could be improved in
his dioceses and invited us to come again
to proceed with our work at other places
within the Pala Dioceses.
(On the 10th of Apri, we photographed
and studied the large Hindu temple
‘complex in Kottayam The 11th of April
was reserved forthe analysis of catuhsala
houses (the traditional four winged Kerala
hhouses with an open courtyard) in the
Kuttanad region of Kerala, while on the
12th we studied the Thathampally Church
(18th century) in Alappuzha before we re-
‘tumed to Kochi. In the evening ofthe 12th
cof April we departed from the Kochi Insr~
national Airport to Germany. The data and
‘Photo material collected during these eight
‘working days in Kerala gave us work for
weeks and even months in Genmany. And
itis not over yet: we still have to present
all the drawings and photos on our web
site (www.efitm. de).
At the Eighteenth Intemational Confer-
‘ence ofthe European Associaton of South
Asian Archaeologists held at The British
‘Museu in London (July 4th-Bth 2005), 1
delivered a lecture on our 2005 campaign
in Kerala and presented a poster with
{general information on EFIHM.,
‘We are thankful to the Freie Universitaet
Berlin that we can keep our archives and
office on the university premises. nad
ition, we obtained office space in Kerala
itself. Through the efforts of Dr. Va-
~huthanapally it was possible to purchase
‘plot of land in the Thalapulam Pan-
chayath, Melampura, Kottayam District
for ane of cur offices in Kerala We weld
like to open another office in Kochi within
the next few years
4. Our plans for 2007
We are going to translate the “Denkmalp-
flegerichtlinien der Deutschen Bischof-
skonforens” (Guidelines ofthe German
Bishop's Conference — see htp:/www.
«dbk delimperia/md/content/stchwoerter/