You are on page 1of 69
IN THE MATTER OF: HEARING BY THE GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATI ON A PROPOSED 210-MILE PIPELINE SUBJECT: PALMETTO PIPELINE HEARING DATE: APRIL 21, 2015 ~CD~ ~ Condensed & Index ~ ~ Exhibits ~ Page 2 Page 3 : soopmy rca osactraie 3 ane! Gta Caedatiose Ct © Settee me saan runaroemassinns ‘ (Orr peoeiabeniinioepeupe ean : BOLO Caneel ema. 5 Ginsu tapanebme? Cn sonra oma mana ak 2 aC BOLDEN. Be Oty up. —— =e M4 Bo te Sa iy po, sssscrnoen = ROWE: a ee Taek 2 esate ies re ae 21 Depenato Tapa. Peet 32 sesh Duta niu ee 22 ete taiman pane Aryan 34 Pinan ei, Pint Pole eed 21 feeemiearal aie ceeue a Page 2 Page & 2 APPEARANCES: 2 mien bate gh 2 2 Dept fronts a we 3 axel. Se Lily GDOT apes 3 ead am Suea Crain denao ele, 44 Heke Tayor-Teprn cunt {gions 3 cts Gre Pom at {Alsotve:Aepacnae fm Ranke Monga |S Smacru~ oP Tas scot é sees at ey at dei ty do : INDEX ppt te a ey ° PAE mtd. Weve i elt Tay 5 exananation Steen ted dos cd Spee om Commer Cereof Rater (Gop Dione Senet ‘Hosoda tack ness) EXHIBITS (alles by Mt Detect "pf Tilley woo tlw aps tnbem fabri) ei along ite ae Tas bate fm pases (Sms nfcrrs orea S Sexes hte in arhedGOOT ray comme reps tec ‘set a a oy pling ‘stot arn chong wea S528 ‘atte peo Mayet oa ‘Ss pd be ee an 0 1 (Pages 1 to 4) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 5 Fase? 2 Hiden Tr Ses ar atone th OOOT 2 mse tte of Oo | 5) gts twa wert mato 5 Asem alow be ate pod: npn | Seeman © heapnon te cri of ae | : MRTAVLOR Tha ou Aadtkenide | 5 enneaeandscety. Web te 6 tan Maer Na tomy ibe ese § tampa Mie et espe 3 Dayna emp sn i tere 3 pennant hppa pet 5 pens train amma vey : COW: Sp. 5h ib GOT and ese wate Ry MS TOVLOT eae away myn | 1 nde Teeter ato mt | 3 seen Olay Lnmetrlisbaing?” | LL Semen emt omen Yanai 1 lsypae Weelwetndybeaeectoy | 12 ewemateratieromd bebe wich 15sec ecto 22, eae Oi 12rd noe Waymreoe He GnietouamanwOCGs 225azpmme | 14 Sey, onc we yr ren er il Ss pipdnccompmietergtansaucpepey | 18 winapi ox ee 1G — mecsingeptyoyecie eam ere | 38 thst patsy, Osi you 28 umes ppt has. 1s Sharliie Aan, Wehse roi | 25 fmmdtitcndeeton stefan onte | 33. bsp am ou py em 20 seo poi, ter are 25 ate atom lel eager 2 fog nie ema psd 21 Smpterasis. Yorn Enea 22 teenporn cnparymctés | 22 Gomme cmon oe el 25 thorns Toyama ge tetdonner | 23. stmt ma Ard de nda he 2 Tom tay ah acento 25 mtg ve cams Ags Page 6 Page & ene al ety ont Gea DOT. ‘Rete tye tp oe 2 5 eit ah em i Prion Dison Ge Demet {ative nom ai sh 2 Nimultemmer itn te Cnept Stollen wlth fest nce GODT {vette alison piaine — | &——gerejapeiet Bat wel er 2 snaps pops pi MPa 3 Meat te site ye ei prey ts ito pie © Tiaeawsgnin sera cmc he 3 prvi mat te earl ry eins + ht tes rw ld eto 25 Comin fates weuions Se | 10 ult Aad eo wo mye Lt tere of teat den et 11 torte pte nating ter den 1 Comicon ft ae siete Ges | 12 aye neem be 1 BamayrenosedMicseganyeeme | 13 feu wee sue pie Limonene Be ramuaiepesat ro ppt 15 Gente ie meneceanoconky 35 Stespcaie tection (Sita aoe dg beg 36 Gremonenewotpojet Tari | TGs ase pee 31 Smo heen meme Toumnieinetontnter herent | 20 aflncrthmesgenap siete iar pain popes 33k oe ne ta abe ‘eer aeons 2 ne et Frieagain e f peee B ere (molten bury ih fodmogets | 22 wptyneactnametie ois ape 3 etamsumeeCimasan ory 190, | 23 ier fwyarome. Antwerp o8 Bt Gamal caste mesma! | 24 tamaketecomman = npr ropa 2 (Pages $ to 8) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 9 Page 11 reat on ts oposd rem Aln Fer we rt id Nop nt | ‘Shlcieconeen themsphce ta he thea eninge ym ev fou Surette am ray oot and ter eye ple 1g penn re eoeot 1 Samat cnng tt ie 5 Sameer ey ogee Pzommecend econ. ‘Ne mes igang Srpse, Asjou nw Hinde Ma tattered pron wb gest ‘pce nara ind tpn Therein tietecurteparro ny ropa Weve ed Graaf oe | Ictmmonepewmstttine dsherrin” | 9 Somanlwetumpar pect Weeant Pilnpen tote peingsetutcaeme | 20 patie mqusttax estes Mo Hepa ean wil etme, 21 Thea pvt epi tr inten teConmasrie icing mts | 32 toes prea, wee ‘Slaca espe When on cone op 12 pone ote got done Pesesteyarnanesncetomyrete- | 14 het lei te wea eaeyowcae arpa ocrwil | 15 sana bel gs sth may Fu wt ‘ister et eo 2 ertrght etn tut ming S beh me inciodel vbw Mewesiowede | 27 Saale exp we ate Grnieyorens Wedursedyarenre | 18 setfebat fenton ween uae gocm peiinifynwshin As | 2 Shenemegay. And wet pops! lst oc esther popehee 22 tmwewebnted eth bern em Tone Wea oegtohnemimedetre | 71 Bal ep cnet ese Feeipe tape mimctornre | 22 pant nth sso. Aad a te wesongstatmy conserve cay Tie | 23 tudntety apn geo fil poaes, Sanath epee sto a 26 und dt un cout rey eves int enue Tere te 55 fee al bate re er eet Page 10 Page 12 2 magictreCemiaDoTio gow pti | 1 25yem.Sowvtetinrn disease 2 Sm Pes enenertatoaysbanegis | 2 vg toment he cure meds ao 3 Fede ote ae 3 attested teats Gg So 4 Sime taney. eel the Gas Fade Wat we peng $ Sviemcet er gratin lato he ae ple tat wot 50,001 & ——_Taaont pin wl eed & pata 16500 ade sca ote 5 Mranetytetoacte rd Rewres, | 3 Anteaters bn oo 3 tte ag DOT Bele ete Fo © Shire ngs dy ha we 3 eget opp or es, 5 Sigs ont pnb 10 Mean yorbne wing ey 12 ead vba bt woe 5 ‘MiCHOLDENststc meso | Lm unger ote ac 22 adorei fs Panettnpeet | 12 canis ctr oma is al ny 3 Seiten epic smeie | 12 Soe ple asin ie Sindee pe, Arai H¢tStkeemarengacy, erro, 1s Remutviletarteeceywntowsts | 15 tklsnat Thee emma shes 15 aleommcrsppconeapioientewitin | 16 Felonies sip psiton it Soke Toi rn er hey 0 17 pj Howe Fle Ppsepet e $1 Riysegnatentnettm mts br 2 ilnewrmenns mtg yes 39° Payee lg np ni 29 Titre arpa nl Go spwwcrgussmey apltsonmatenenecm, | 20 dbomenc ae dy sure oe 2 Sous! wend eprmtne PL equate qs smth we he 22 fomPulucinisconeupasgretisemes 22 eelop-eceungs yo bk 2 MRTORE Masswotebmpsmenet | 23 Sot Barwa ia pation 2 Trapt cling sheng | 20 pins We are amps 2 datjorvinarcmmgowtouetopen | 25 ol pnto te ste Gps edt 3 (Pages 9 to 12) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 13 Page 15 1 rey hein stata io Se 2 enc a ie, Wet neuen 2 rosie aan Be. New | 2 Sa tpt Rape {Tamar Gs engin ietnland | $s resi 4% tctfthentieytesescesettiant | £ les pte Shae Sov acne nein fat © Sma ee pr yams Se + Guam sie spteroed pastes | opujat lt bet a 85s! {—Gomp Cureton St | 9 team dons td 18 Gna tre acs ord] Wetpneson spo. Wee 11 GepettysnsinNrAaputneainSewewe | 32 rte nr Sizmane 1 folencwetoiertampatmests | 32 Gag Taal don miin Et putairara, sowoanqeealadwiacis | 14 ealngt eta oma Sie 15 pets thea whe peenecstaen | 1S Gogoi gmermen: Weantopue shat te fetstientantton hts piepwlapat | 16 2eftneempesan pte ptt 17 fatiairaemsaevkar ie mo naerot | 17 st ere wks pee 1s pwetinecuny tesco Gain 18 phe tenon best Gbit 22 Cohag ight end Chan 23, freageetisove $00 stn ht 20 Gautis Weveopetednee sey, And | 20 tates te prec Hot 21 weloklwdiostmagiocreiestony | 21 etcamigin ex pi, al of he 22 theleset heen! tt ee 22 cai jets fr hf Gon 25 pope, ope ttiensh or | 23 Aung thence ue 2e Ractive wien Weaiagae, | 2 pura gticnnd oma hte 25 Gofheopwocinay 50 100Dbanse | 23 apc Me Page 2 Page 16 5 perdysntinpetexinsty SO paca | 1 jutbgrng he cso whan, 2 Griwamiywtteloiguet rte og | 2 stamping to ther efneroteg b 3 tun tadlat Gemgeacrbcanesone tte | 3 arco hte eed {Beer gna parl esol 4g ylonnen skier ors 5 Gmpinttantoi vile nation Gemsie | 5 FxmplesefatinSeren Can, oral, & jana Atprtcemponne a we © inst il ea fa at + Tie Gawinseotnprpstiotesbow | 7 sured a cols be Gem 2 Syren pent fee $—Rowrboe pony npc Aaloatoneiucrtowartoa goto | 9 Per denieAapata rend ah 2 8 18 Sand enceparyweSeamsh ea Toe | 12 lees sh of ereminageapeny oat | 12 70. et pty, fr Bat eaten ef uy cl ‘Sladal ialo e ling ayn ese of Geo ein ts psi sous ilo, ihe Foci ee ple desey ‘ee frit ps Henney {tamer om Sos ote ee ‘teneybecliiy,forsompatones. Indes tectonen Now ete ‘2 eur ht gem om sara the Fats pr ect pret. We ov War Ball. Se iter ono te at of Gop ‘Satan spect 0 Sheet oeasting rane. Tet Intenso eh es hin trate xing. And uty design dbs ene oo ‘Slnotie weiner, Wee espe afecetng pa He ome Anh pat wether ‘prota ete cna Ie) 4 (pages 13 to 16) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 2 Page 19 2 Titer ging an cnet a 2 Need tin ote MF nd al 2 pre poe nese pe toieposss | 2 atelepicml for Kinga Spi Yor 5 eters cr isin Gongs 5) Kateri i ein © Sop an pconmatso ih eye cy te ve 5 Kndiwmts er wrtirgepey ich 5 Rheamatqgencs pnd tater § nds seni ake sis ppt paperanian Som 5 a Andwewe bent ame Panipat ne an te mi 8 ee mecm a Myron a 5 brome yur moyte yur 5) Spina oo ast Pp ed 25 Gomes Eat notewersgealfyooio | 20 Sacked heb nee jot had ee St SkEvEkathepmecdoorgm insist | 32 Se tetas atom i Sue 12 weiopopingdn Tiweriiocalol | 32 Cane Reece fort ery 33 lfmat te ah ec 35 Spain Bain on bein 3 teerjhetwoieag tna eyes, | hm Taye arpa end te 15 Andweregnogiote wali ayhanods | 25 yuewaa Theyre npr h 26 te Onna reba we 16 Hanes teeisn eran wsesty Le owas enews pease pots | 18 epg oi nce 22 tdllealiinaton Aadwecoeensiclarn | 12 hewamo ean sed espe 2) Ghyercapmaicion de savoroaapa | 20 ‘chow. mee 21 tees ers wits od 2B Nak MORE ei age 22 harm ispeelaeaem opracintesame | 22 pogrotpgelne we aki bee ed 2) Smpausphartsapenateconal nts | 22 hperlan parbyores n oae, 24 tacafGrurtrtsyer Welsk | 26 meeaningiern eta ee 25 fandiowekng with, Tank yo 55 fete Fa Teor, Rnd Mar Page 18 Page 20 2 Mk BOLDIN: cay. Thewy=temsy | 1 Rela pine opine al Tey 2 tmgengsog thse pig th 2 Somat oe 8400 mdse 5 peng psa 2 curt id ne The ord a &—Gitepe en 4G ath tata ae pene ent 5S hee lem ie ce 1 5 Nameasidem Thee arate & —piagaeup font mageommceyornme, | § these ora. Tis 3 Tenge doe ttm 5 Mar 5 Felosneeomae The sting yore a CRS Rie leapt emp. ose o of 2 orgs wher espe on at > onto wtcnanebentmeycur | fwemeet ae edand oho | ‘Geyer. moe domi ich saad ‘high tonsa rere nd at often. Kase Menno pb hel festoaingoapay. Temes woomke | 8 ae stress » ‘Sophos tsa scaaer ey Z lamer whew opi eet da, | 12 Gorga chime ret neh wel a dart Gnrpaciaos | 26 ‘een way bens dom paps s rela 1% (CROWD: Ann, a MeMORNS Taepapredvinsae es] 20 totems Gop tng me % Specmistaicateste Nomtinfow | 20 Sidteemesmetertisidersmaytca | 22 Eovpieshovarion, ba tetewosinn | 22 hrm Sener | 23 ‘Avie fod Nh Again SoC, | 26 ‘meinGorg (dapring KinurMrgn ie | 20 Page 22 mot ihn dia : densi oeinewitine 2 ‘erg lM Chin is ‘ fein ba a eta (pp 1 5 oy te of Grea ‘ horde oe ne 7 ‘coe Tne meh gree a NEL OLDEN: Chay. Aud tapmsiaeyour | 20 sommes Anta nee hon say Eom | 22 Prusrtunwomsannitercteneg | 2 ‘beable tty tw pp Tope = Beonpepentartoaetnreont | 36 rodeo cigpngce ming | 27 ‘con. 2 BOLDIN tetra x pepe nd ops gen B Page 23 amy Bat mle ee To is "CROWD: Gnece. Meveon MMC HOLEN To sete Nl rN ibeteon Ses ‘erst ik ee ie fey Ata Gaye pit ‘regi Oi oie mle S511 sey fs ne sn Tow tte Coc neces 2-2. Te Ft act oni go ‘hong repr erin reser tino or pray eon Sern pen oe athe ‘sf mg ren (oat) "hep pod Ts in eta ta ce Sst pe tte pnd teins pete etry tee ‘enon ey. Nes ay tar Page 24 Pie plied msec oer any ‘ihe comeing pert) ery me CROWD” Anes (hein BOLDER ml ear eae ‘MR SANDERS i Bh Snes ‘mi com a guna Sern Cum MY fi teen feng a my ieee ine a cmt he mig of Wal in fone) ‘Seedy ber wae tg eet "Mr oslo Irepeyomnen Ithaka we hg aco jh ef Svor= sy ip ang he Fie dagen cto. losing tel we cee tidied al eno hen a oct 6 (Pages 21 to 24) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 25 eng, Fras my aloe Clee ih ta sans Ample ‘tite cada ule ingt soe ‘rnp Ty ming at py ih ore 1023 coro Sp Sleelear ay orto Sr Fi pas teens {pl hr ft cu en op Briar Thaw tiglfewee te Tov ne bch sory SStcandewsndencniepoontin. Wen ‘workun! appe= ver ol Th sine Wikisantcnmconusenbe "plant hag reo ex rie ‘rye emai ey tie ‘cons mei tog ng ‘pine bro ae ty a nd {te ind Ti poe hab nd ‘Tye ha ‘MR BOLDEN: Hews Marien, MR YEILING Tryon ert ys tr Yin Ye Yin ‘VELLAN, Tot onl Cel Page 26 (6, tan sty po ees ‘ene ron S0je. A fs mayan ‘CROWD: Token NOL YELLIN: Hayy be exis de apis ee etme keto gt oe, Plater. DOT, 308 tte adn ge Kee Mena ‘Minny power nd porte 2 "epi. Yoo a inf he aero vera ye oh te try aes Tae ee ep es ‘Sete teva 3k ate (ety at ie a Gran sone Chcen ae rpc ese ite, bend eso! Tepe cnet ow pecned tena se yo ‘ego spf ins ely ‘sie jake Gai They a at si wuld tet nay, Jute Gel, Wes amar fini Cie Page 27 (CROWD: es. pin. 1, YELLIN" DOT ys. Pat runt, DOT shaken becae Kie opin a me steer otf Kier Nog tiie pope ti howe ed ‘Sed Gap erp yh Kise Mpa. alr ‘salteushg yo pete. Teli wee, va Ipsec bre ee (CROWD. Yas he thy ye a a ar Fes. Kinks Mr me rou po cu ap ‘aes bgp hae say oie ba alban, Arig han A care ‘Saat Cp es epi) titipson ony ng es, ae ‘Seed re Crise Neary, ae ‘ia he zl and: Evie eaten pens Anl Min sr the coro (cp Mi MORGAN Mr Balen, od sere fp Sobss ae ey va we treat eto A snk ys ‘Sty tts dein ile cavenee Andere af fon ‘een ory Eg igi ran fo oles. pat este ti, An whe Bay Ene lo El Chap bl et tom frac an tole yt oho stato ge pinto cone ey? Serena heart a pee a ic Pts reer feo awn aye Ae py 0 ‘oan nem sion hn Koad (alent. Tats oe Cok Ot 7 (Pages 25 to 28) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 29 pp, Bt ng Cpr ao Fete mre ty. An Nene ‘eet ree Yen 2 wh youn tt ee Sortie And stoped pein ‘gi tae ‘pres hee ae a i eine a ite ee es ‘Enron ome a hy ee na. atom No PER fg te PRE gh ame op yr anh bes Nespus pen Su at Ga ch Tea oat ear pi ‘Thi a ne uy emt cninanaly ned ‘Sr ober ee nd ote oting OL ROBINSON: My ne ban ea a tary wth Get (an ra. Wet sopra aitan mee ree pe tte tne pe an (erie We pranandorer20400 9 "owt Gag, Now tet Hae ‘Rr i tera et Sent wept br 30000 es. THis ‘a ee ied Mk py or pee pring go eng ches we ‘ese ind In wen se ar re nee eg oor rote wt The pps Bt reese Ft Seman eile ‘Sane ng ey et oon po ‘en pss inp. Tso ‘to alin eines an Po San Ie Thiet ges dh i ‘tn hn a were sat bogie ‘eesti yen Ovrom af Page 30 tig ony, A etn we hae (rae pnigie Now ner eale ting gt. Wir nnd om Kier aro rete Noa sti om Smee own fin ge ‘oer ow py {Gem comison Oh, Now wha a Fepeaedou sb opie of est. wets das. ching Tot "eu ehopahs scan yd thy ot ti ak ested ing se Cea Cony Ty atin. Som pat 2, hey wan tpt ii ine Beinn nti igh ae 00 MIR MORGAN 290 ome Det tee? GR HOLDEN: Wy aia i fe They weprposg apo fat Sn ta eevee whe Been eekoderaong few Far nuh ft eth wee, ou mcrae te (Suing Ones piri yo ae spar opty te ont bees oe et Tio, ath ft ph ic wee ig twat Yared ‘Ndi emote on meting aot ‘xa. Ph went eet itr se oil en ‘opie Now ey on tt ‘coh fant Ply re ‘ke hgns 920 ye dom male 8 (Pages 29 to 32) McKee Court Reporting, Tne. 912-238-8808 Page 33 1 Anda ingress we 2 edt wits a8 2 utnde fet Semetarequremeniss | 2 levy ene mt ppn te 5 eioure soiees boc o 2 Gibson sop a Siow, tetra eddies Ths |< syrbemsny oie tn tty $Me wetting 5 banat neha earner & —Spurvndiclerin Beene © taps tt bena 05 gr 7 ict iets Tes | 3 tec Acer rs, ei Fntloytapemansenantetieenste fae | 9 fiom. Anleoes many adam 3 apes age Hea tye 3 Gphemeceonboy i piergateytrde 20 thre Heth cn i oa 29 Sete Retr 31 thoes Chere wgeatay | 12 has pe wt en yond 22s Soltakyoutoryor te. pi 12 jntenapb eka dee 14 eaigtsetene Yovacee. Fein | 1¢ tase a pl sn a 13 wine 15 Suey ne op) te MSCUNMNGHAM: MymaresNaky | 16 Swe ra psoas Kine Mn £7 Gaming Hein Sea Ge ABow | 17 Thyra esol oy 12 juve pues Tsp ae Tawa 25 leptin tgny Urpratisee 20 tuseighrod se ied Alte 21 did DOT he Depa Tepe Tete 22 Campeanu eta teniswowarmnctine | 33 NE DANACHATAVIS. Wha pany 23 Gamma inAay eso taray edie | 33 wegehmprleo gual tata cee 2t— ailainmadiser Antonis sasiet | 23 fu Cylon ences 25 inp purging ereoren | 25 ghana sii age 3 Page 36 {teas Tinta be ped Te 2 acest 2 min fits pod wit 2 Kinks Mier mtbenttmenin | 2 aso po! wi as Soa 3 Goes Hirt eomenn Hit 2 Ginetta ng Tem 4 nen: Wed nedi We uth {bento wenn pater, Adobe + falwoiiping tore hepa 5 pte ee wih you, teh : NL BOLDEN Now oe To § Ile etre Svea Tele 5 tment a Tey Die 7 ing tsk ch engin : 8 Warn resp 20000 are S.DANACUATANI: Hy ae sti ae Seah Rt ee ‘se 4h ee ane Pl, wh seis, [hesme wos Tey ene tek Owen sigan tcp tl evens ee ios nd sree then en te, Suma Ty ining i200, Wa ‘been woe Wit sn ode ‘ete? Tek op) HOLDERS Up Vera Das aa 2a bbe wil ee MR DAVIS: NY ee Ty Dai sein Egham Cony ashe aly i ‘hows ba fer po ee seg Yuko cr i Wee nt ped ‘Strebing st gobo ney a ‘epipins ak esc eying Ane me wy we shui bie ‘nse weve uy of pe kg (ors Ur lone donates bakers. Wetare pied fat [pon pots orrgs Tae aor prltcampny. oy been 9 (Pages 33 to 36) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-2808 Page 37 Page 33 senior notre 2 end apac Kn Me tn (Gee pe ora Me 3 Gham Cont xe The tet ‘oot a pal a en wil {Sop rota oping pn ott pple fd 5 Seta rate prety rcs ‘Sai: nt nt ‘een str tet 2) ‘yo oun ee en dr ppp bebe el oe Frey Ter en ae 2 Stone atin” fstiyineteanetatinenecesioé | 22 abuts acne sn Uechone ener deqwesetenine | 22 cia Thane wht ates Soma Weve ny fo se 1h Ghee): Kicks Mpa even ent ‘evi, en aed Be tn ulema teeige Que toc se Ty at ep 35 hegre of mono es ‘Wart penn est bee 36 Kine Mogan ie fly, od low ego aie 3 Gree true rede they my pow igen ee? 33 sine, Ni Set emetRaet (Coa. 19 Rane Meg rearsheof rt "at acLDEN: toythttu peat) | 32ers Mae erect 2. Gente ne aay sae Sa tnnOARD Royttaeasiuoann | 22 pcmracdrcld fans fe edn Hm ye 33 ue png, Cal ee, US at testo Rend Te eed Bipot lad ink ate ovens sb Rd pe nd eo 2 pert pee poles, Vise Page 38 Page 40 ple Sane cae oe taaniongsts ibe sega BO Ba (i, Te any epi th Inna sbo nt be ae ithe en 218 IS, yo nb eesti fg we 0 5 pinand as say ttc ah Cline le {Sebi mae snd aly gg lee Danis US paint dea na nc Thee mene eo ‘rotation, ed Kae Mang i ho ‘heDOT ns tive ye a er iene pce era oad ig set ein ey ev ig Feperuiies soni tmhedithopres, | 23 emia pope eine et ig (din Weg Ose 1 tome pes vee. ng fpr jn hs ea Te 32 Meany mane pts 29 Gd pone, tnt see hn poy 13 atdoyeanet. Thy ei fom Gr cans eo porn i ‘ BOUDER Fok ae apa {te ely eg ood 2 Hey Man soe (capa Let expla eno te ae ‘Ms HUARD Fou PEACH, eto his ti ned ith 1 RUSRARD ymmel Fee tabs Now [Eero tr eo 00 of 15 eto pcre ale pop at Ctboymovcntig rts Seve anke | 22‘ and ctatgen fom Kine icy of ing be et ore 32 Mimgmpipn tbr nnn. {tyne Tn sp 8 eae 23 pene tepid be itn teal on. Let moe vel > 2 Gomgacet are on knw Tepe Me Kacteensomy Reira neigeue | 25 clyonepteeafe mc ae ee Tt 10 (Pages 37 to 40) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page Page 2 piping tanya fomaisatisig | 2am 2 ate esp Gp 2 MS AROSDORTF AR Nac, 3 See ne TheDeptiesoncamemate | 3 SDOR-ERasindatleFonk Ansa {ppt jess yet. Api 20 4 Gyn nis Armas Wel yale 5 Bo Eupns a eit wne 3 hae se tet sop © fern er Tsao mann © Yasue wih me FomneoT ne + Rowrberetand heute pl 3p og Coy a 8 einige pls 1 ingting y erepo tt Tse 5 epson vee eee rhe 5 eprops es pig eh Solan 25 aera damage crowe poner 20 thf nn Sm Se a mig aot at 11 Senpratcn tnd 2 yee er Be Son 32 tgeemdateneap ther poy, Th 22a ln oe il 22 fumirbee l.Ove he ni 23 hang rset the 15 eels Rinker Mant rh a 1H tne lcorbiche twig walwehine | 18 Gein and thee i at 35 Somat foray orcapeuatin ie 1S Gene cong yl nee at 26 Gamage! BP arcane pls eananotintot ] 16 Whe ey weigh ne se san 1) Gavalinte le Tew wemow ner 3250- | 27 Thema andthe 1% Slate ae Gate Migostichaou | 1b ips Rane Mm. erp ee is 13 Gamulwamay adorn Medet | 12 Getelimtey at mang runny co Thee 29 wateubentii oat yor seciedwin | 29 Uatenyaesasingar thee ee 2. Givin Presi veyed | 21 rotten 22 Wit Han dato cones 22 tive Soon hen mses. Tas 25 ew tty eps re 31 ipfengtonctnon. An they 2¢ perm nyo yam Tote 26 aca Kinde Morgen. Lato beots 25 tube Doy Water Hn de 25m Thewsnie Riker ro Page 42 Page 4 1 romeo hares mermigthy | 1 Me Mia Me Kade Lt peut ie 2 egmermeatrte cin Andere | 2 aack Someypsi, fo fay 5 Sapposto mot em oseont pss nao | 3 peou ural er ene am ig {is Owrwmounot a filedeeaeay to |< cay memin f= epee Sef pete te Sateen, aan yoy we & Gave forcast, The |i Met aay ace eal Ui. + Chin Siwergorennan afte’ | 7 Now ging tat acnee tribe © etymaingourineonicrormoment | thts Pm algae urge. Ta om 2 tnd died or pay papstin 3 Cais rec esha #0 en. Pa e 20 Gauiteonncamiserr wits, | 29 thswewelog manos Ace 3 Kine Merges pti by rng cur 22 epi wil ta engage. Ad {2 epacabeniommes irwiieandour | 12 that bg. Bu wo ete 13, fphawpmper, alowtiemny illite | 13 meen ee er ls em DOT er nea 14 Rev onenpcleme halons: | 34 taucreoamaer cag bene Pe 15 nthesume nate cond ish stacin | 25 lamalonaesingmonoy Renee 16 hadtotiweindctol pee smaurng | 18 Ope 21 Geico ton Tees " ‘CROND: Oya 3% famines peed Sep | 19 inten Naw Le 20 Teplie cow. pp 22 Mn i EFDA ve B ‘3 BOLDIN: Hor Mer 2 Bye Lown dees PA CROWD: thst pe 22 ndTowy te wriprac ove he 2 MRBOLDIN: Heed preke. ay. | 23 pes gog in Tmtayou vane Lees al, And Cin Amar. Di ‘ath? Cyn Newbee Aon sie a ne er D2 mand ei Bri 9-09 11 (Pages 41 to 44) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 4 1 dae eked et aap re 2 ned tispipeine Rds go et 2 enced meet erp i 2 elma aa aby 3) eee ee een cy 3 herp arcmin We sd 1 Titre ese ei 4% tanatet a Tym (pn 5) keenest bce la 5 HOLDEN Hy Chaar nsx nd 3 aR tenart eset 7 7 CHANDLER. Run Cn Shier Tk ra 8 catan estan wa wh Cn Gr, : 1M BOLUEN: ein Bop anies 3 epee sf Clot on to me 2o sean ape 22d whe = "crow, Res 2 Ghent eng 13 Somymiewp Wie ea? Eat 25 tates wn np li 24 Mt: Nex wile Li Vi 3 Bacteakupbor soy lan spree & HS MARKEST=V Tyas Me Make iy | 25 co oon ed nig ad SF smb tnbMiwauen Menecegranrac | 16 wtp wt pater” Ano me 1 Rainy Oe Rerieper 17 Gate guodiat ato of 18 Womthmersen ailing $8 ove mening ie ee 13) jotet nto mye ly 23 Sinha ometar Me ee ofthe 2) eecelilieweh td ae vnn 2° cemented Bi ye 21 hms tr Sn ts 2 min on? 22 hho aa eee al ite 2 (GOW Cutamer 3 pmlm Sotmgary ei aay a (HOND Hn tener. 2 weno cheng he DOT. a GLCIANDLER: Custer An ie Page 46 Page a8 1 tmgsingto epost ay Gong DOT seme | 1 male itr i hain te ing 2 thew ht, Pe ope i Pino 2 Mca hy ptt of oun 5 Des Pee day Ke Megs. 3 Mrapteate ttre Get Doo {——apcin Bra yusnt iow ducking; | 4 mpi, Gs to etna Moparts sn pane. |S cesta ees hs iin f teukttorGage Aadttuin mot |S ple! Gna? + Content i Tce 5 "CROWD: (moe enn. 8 soe capi 8 CHANDLER Late te, ide , NR BOLDIN: Newieauetten ett | 3 Moxp in pe pele roe a 38 dwveRjn Ch. ha. Lae. 28 resin an SIVINIZY Lae Lave inten | 1 ‘ckown, Catan 22 hap Gere PALINIZV Oneotbe | 12 MR CHANDLER: The cay ty 3 Ger rnd sa ard 13 Gane Mt Garp conse. Neto Eh Aepranf ten rine teh 34 nota. Teno ny, Ant $5 hemeopey whee tebe, | 15 Somber a rt epee 36 There oly wag 26 nye ning teresa. Tak £7 wpe iy war. An heya Sehr Baie onmc 19 pneu a wld ena iene tetime Wasnt dane singel 25 Seige. ‘tes i ck te abd 21 edwin wry usd hee ‘piney tin Aatachaste 22 casting The iy yig © ‘tar my ht i pe wos 25 salads jutton gras bse ‘ena i wtp Sereda Cymer ics Yon ir Fe Spit ee yar pc id 12 (Pages 45 to 48) MeKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page ot stn tv rbd hse yer 1 Regmnet toutes cle Pisine pst aris Gere 2a acter Irhing Kev Mp and scm NO 3h tect Ps os Pini preaehoworenictrceyboty, | $ Remote. le pei athe FERC ings Simone nari a as Pevinccomplsatacdets dept | € adnate of he Coen + Ge Baer doe a edly . 4 let hn isi pis 4S tadeeritnes Cnt th tie 2 Waynes eat ety ot eet 10 ahowiagitnay et dame eke 11 Ginger Tannin senay mt | 11 teenanten gem sam. Woe a we 12 aylottnetote Aaddeseoe wot | 22 dws? th mene oar ah H1 stampa. Dats Kine ern 21S xl dg oad Sh Gaftivrtoeparagy,exply amt | 13 omen, Misco wale pe 1 foneGurgeDopumengperon tat | 35 hcentatbnd ated So 2 le as mcblptnt deny er SS Sola ier mon ela ope 1) glnn rape nite 2) neta opt he 2 ovenimeeand sen Thankyou vey | 38 sip visto cas ries Cami. 15 eens opt 2 TMC BOLDEN: Uprowit Ak Nkdsind | 20 DOTS Se pei Kad Me. Thk you 21 exiles By. 2 ania 2 MS NICKS Taryn Hiram | 22 ‘MC BOLDEN: up ows et By. 22 Nichelle Sin Rertoger Thake | 23 Metwieky ET EROUER, 24 yu (Gund), Leyes DOTIaBigs | aw Zieoe 25 Hewgisoesagtnd pingcppemntyor | 25 MR DOLE Cay Page 50 Page 52 1 epubscm gaa tec The 1 EDGY: Mie Egy EDGY. Welt 2 Sense gang m her oul 2 amantavaan pla bat = ete 2 tenemos a pte vould | 3 fw igh ig Tet 4 Guten ve ur Sale Rier {Gremio pe ins a Snot te ean, 5 Reames enteanelk Semis mesa woe Wevebensait | 6 tad Bus aprpey omen ben 3 Hroeatnt ny ew ies pase | 7 Sex gene me th gwen Fopblicbomtand ew nt n> 2 eaten ars mine Baise 4) Rett erie be aan 9 ety ai a pope, eat 20 Gin Aus open Tieton isk 10 ‘Poerhaten 2D nor op 31 hat-susisy etme anos | 21 en soi The = ga 3 ok 12 Secor ning or 12 eases acesafmy peer. ow te 1) Gnioeeey ay nthe Sebie | 19 plewatn mein and eave 4 Reno bea en Eee Aad thon al ot he 32 Themeanurgndniocrnters sto | 15 th nin deine a 36 dace ivigonr pgelns ATV ay 15 bene Way ani cane or ey 55 Saenallsestins, Aad jatar | 2 ey py eas wt kan 32 Usrpuonssirstsate ton ott | 1 Soy hl meme a he i ey {5 WahiScecweowitalcrappeloe, | Lo bvevapilanueite ags p. 20 tune ATwriercneng oe doris | 20 satan. Ream apes Anh the 21 pecan popond tt erdeyot | 22 Lander once rope. og 22 Fatmmldtecquaserw70)icempar | 22 llturpee My open hin. Wel 21 taodunpingtirbasintthesmerdat | 23‘ gogo ran at reper ote y 24 dy hadsuca gnc Smit yes | 24 ater Tate. Wel La 22 Tamthomowthofouraron Salah 25 ‘euler ty 13 (Pages 49 to 52) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 53 Page 5 2 dacs they uisale fier tesesotmy | 2 Me arrouae me ziTTROUER | 3 gene etsy any sate, (want | 3 Katy tae jst hy «ete Mee np att walt 4 sai tit am ops pet and ot 5 Sse ica j= wat ee oatiftece |S asic Comms My a te pai {—Thatsny‘amiye betta owing anit | Tre Ger Dee | 2 neces omes inthe ue | 2 Tanti oyoara mech andotke 20 elint ry wat ethon ay 10 tetera at Kr rn 11 Untmapyepucomgotonr eracmske | 1 tanga sets pein wepeaenyn | 22 eager, Saaz 12h Lak you ona 3 lctewnegentpcabecin-me | Ne thom toe 15 fae Thaw if dewykifwaasattt | 18 keen si of 12 inbeinahare Wet Gnbes hing! shd | 36 Gan lt fa se Ont 17 Tputeinsapeeciag seamen 87 gate at omen os ss Le comme ee wb we! poe 30S Ane puch re 13 Naima. troetie gettin neg | 25 andes oppaion te ppin cpne 20d ny tomy eit Babe | 20 ‘Mk HOLDEN Up at ie et 21 ope pag oct ose 2 srnbechdete ctr 22 Tein). Now tee re Thtenot 2 TMS BEVIL Hy amet ie Bo, 22 fle Anidhetsaltor=thmkor This | 23 BENULL Cm fem pegs Gomh 24 teas bce lanTinten ining | 24 Superba ee tf ng 25 Gettmoer Boldin wend etabe | 25 epee ai Web Page 58 Page 56 2 po 1k wend ik rae aka Gis oa as in fy 2 emis Tepe ays wane | 2 Sache Sabres tod arr Soe 41 attem yew ty Raves Bont | € et ig ower nerd hey 5 ettey encom ean jb be 5 tog eat ropety. Then nes © pneametgetim pemiscortatcwrind | 6 SSaees SoitysMy yous rhe 5 BGuetierlolind: Andlaaceate | 7 despa ay emp oy Steet cnt kwh es nmr iy fs. Hse 5 yous fre Detnand> | 9 gesan al roped dares hab 25° anfesnme mnie. Lovtmean | 20 ep ? a,d eetopatal 31 Sule an an ice BS yopey tet ie 32 pee pagerywtoingdgtoceant | 12 BRTdo hme Sa you iow. deseo ea 35 ph Thguepingtewektoneerdocimge | 13 ecrnsanl te Deeet of Tnsperon 2¢— oaprwentey weimipsigtocamtan | 14 ori athe gr bene pair 35 Theyargnegiosy me, oreata 12 Wout een tongs on Scotadieelve Welly oreo | 16 sey DOT tot nl wee Gea tin ecumogs Teacandcaciedee | 27 moe eal nes sock ov oe Btoccinge Ty vonteetepe frsmar | 3 pepe mention tay ieet ‘scarier plne They wept 19 Soap i ha woe ape thy haat ets po frit one) 29 loads me at nc ot (cei 21 Dearptcoficls Sohow sane ig "ik BOLDEN: Upset Kay 22 Sing tating ton bs ofa 1S ZTTROUBR Ze 23 ea ofthe epee wang ine MR BOLDEN: Reasegiegean, Nec | 2¢ ——fvartow you hanes eon shai 25 pon). Nowa nse. 14 (Pages 53 to 56) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 57 Page 53 Laan. eset ie yoy ca 1h op ridged 2h os ta yw 2 Beyeamastogase Wem ep ine 3 you tht ines 3 plea een sis inn am 1 RtnatemssoccicmatEttam — | € — Oiveraymatepetione whe eo 5 Simmer Band th hr eneralng |S sling sr bing wie, & hte hts. Tan ye. é (CROWD: tae he + moa > S.COLLIER: Newer eyes : Me OLDEN: Canali 8 sas a fd sig ae 2 teva ar ha es st ae, 5 dia ud on te eerie. And se Wat 30 titectans of eri oy LS iu MS TAYLOR: tse omen 22 etm operany een ay =| 2 TN OLDEN. ke 32 gies tha ery Garg cal a NS TAYLOR: Remain 35 into hat of ry inp, rr aX OLDEN: ase thing 14 jatar cera hy eran 1» MS TAYLOR Wo vesting hs? | 1S erm, ate uno peg he is Na MOLDEN: Wecmtdic Else | 16 let ght ow wee pov mee 27 DR Tamer eer oe Oi tint 27 jet appl came mw ol 18 mot 14 Gena tp Boing er poet epi & VME TAYLOR: Locke ony Gain | 18 When p= bing Se rc FL tons Ge cron hay. ARererwl | 21 sentence oe ne ow 22 bel koee 22 ppermen len pet Yes ond 2 WS COLLIER: Clin Cot 2) Seats sag bys 2¢ CLAUDIA, COLLIER Anttaon | 24 eng ay er 25 thowinglin igs Me Mae. er | 25 dey Thy ne) Page 58 Pege 60 2 ing a en Geng stone 0 1 MR RUDE: Up an Dae, Neat 2 Sndsowscteanetsto moe rps! | 3 wii Stes 3 page yeu nna, Win emer 3 CER pe spe a Sarena eis bei 4 itm ary tern en 5 Semtamcactindotremminton Gompns | 5 Ratofd arene reer Ite © fenton hte see dnoizen nd | ftonathrepesetie cans ei Wi + Restmvlee to arson areate | 8 CROW: Cat ao hy tte pm wae : MIC RYLEN tn store 19 ety onder cowdcienein Tens | 10 SssimbieCout his sn sopra Sade ve 1 semi 2 (CHOWD: Aol be "CROWD: Laie = NS.COLLIER: Not Gain a MICRYLER ad sb 40 xu (CRONE: oy. Abt Eh ag Or Re none ent » Ns COUR Teh a ete 15 Satna eal Geese 35 retest redone te Glenionnen Anthea) rt Hse em ep 2 Sayama tera rn MSCOLLIER Srcva tealsamier | 38 meitsetwe nr esp meting 22 whrelmditengetvn ry eto yeni vege eee Beamish Gensler fates col On eO8 22 ttn ore ate eden ‘tee Teh ‘Nona nt np ee see [snd oi ig oid Mag ys eon a ‘leo Andante gaya owt 15 (Pages 57 to 60) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 age 6 Page 68 ceca a gta erie wie {pal tar ve we epost nig. And ‘ren tt a oe ncn peti al et ep epi | Seto cjot integra is (rao. | Pips. Noten re tape 5 "MC HOLDER: a pes pandas ‘eliotn pita ee ‘Byte, el hm or me ‘tea ui het pop a a STEPS Tn vy beg | (Cama ec agree ok tee Ie il Sten STERN. he | lg ctjeieinonedepsic haces sh | > ind Mylo ae sire Seyret Aten | 20 Stamm wih Oke ‘eeplsandeoumen nen Lemcaethees | 12 wen. The= then cone eh Svceepinbaren eden atistit | 22 even col we hres, Fubcocaaoy warned tang | 3¢ eater tena eto my mos Tapioe eee DOT cammisnar | 15 he Tm ptt rin, a Pit denctfesiona# hop). Oaer | 16 ewig eaten cf ik ‘Reentovadd oe epting ty 17 epoca yi oped eng with Tminkanlyerargry ected emit | 18 toaiegulecangeman emt wa mt ins Wz Tht lev for dain | 19 darter ste. And cin ul Tale wcldicre ft eindecame | 20 tenn agg haem bm ingyen ty sapsto eevee | 22 vd ngayon ecm of te Bc natn ld Be 22 taresaring And earn on. ‘eotmdaeasne orogens Tess | 23 topenewe goeg tte met, ad he puters tl yt ath Dy 2 Dama Pepa stipe Teavatbee Sens Tséomepoe | 25 pene Tyre mos (Shon Page 1 bean fore sitingand epic We : 2 tinkitaseseidene ort cae 2 4 tvs aphcioe rain cnet eto {paceager tool ety mas 5 gh pre oni nd Sona 5 aah Hb pee Page 64 MR HOLDEN: Up it Bra. Ne eps Ae ing nie Wie ‘Net BOLDEN fer do ‘tof ol the in Ses IN RYANT Weca elt) Sing usc een goin bb NGL BOLDIN: Youemat ot Ween 5 Str re oe ta Sts 2 dottteaae me rm etek le 22 wiecrtetppiversewaidotoeihal | 10 Spyfup woul 22 anlgranye cremate n “CROWD, Bow Bon Bos 12 Gein Na pes wit sow e | 1 MIC BOLDEN: Le etme 1 Galutgrtobeping mo adem wt | 13 someting ff ed tie 3 Sietaph ieee ping tbeeparig | 14 enol ome ands pind yal 3 Mecexpning vl fees | 18cm po hy tae fr Dor 1 16 comets ueopueetaed 6 so thn ie et uy pe 37 Gioia anterr ti pete ba 2) Reve edgy omens 13 hep Anon tee 6 GROWD. Sobek 20mg he Therein Septic 20 [CROWD Two nt 31 feed Reng um weg atl a Sou OLDEN, Wet tan 2h, ato pote ween alent 2 COND: These mt 2) agen eu sn sn a 2 eR BOLDEN Hebe et et 2 te one in are 2 tame 25 in atematrecorey being | 25 (CHOND Sohn wi 16 (Pages 61 to 64) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 HENDERSON: ey ender HENDERSON, Spee the tomer Commi iy Eon en (CROWD: A (hei). snc ate beste (pana tay ne ‘tans ow yp re ya woes rom. Can a ming, Cet buldmyngenit Bat dp Aletta Pau 2t pete (Coe BOLDIN: igh nw er ele NS KELLER: Tis Ordotiwes st fe Kee Im to Kings hs Maer evn Smartest! cic me he ions. Tey star Io in y= ty tral, "Thea ry dare oie jo te Finca pln Ere pion er ‘On ant 290 2013, cen Hohe ‘pone! its mes cep Mayon, ‘cr cui ech ene ‘ching nde ope seal king Shae commiy Ul et ‘or se Ge Langa ofa wo ertede thik, Teskar ski muri 2 pti ne erties ‘Shien Te le were aod eg nh et fo anlar twee ng Le Cony were Inoue cpr ea ap ‘They ered fom be es ares nol a ema ay le ‘uted ca asd ey eo twelve be nrg fit pra a cf al, Page 6 ‘ec at ni pete bles Tract ci yp of le ‘Spastic Wh ‘Smuirnaced ae hio e ‘eon winme mepeoe Fisae Powe at eh ‘hepa TM LOVE: Mya an Love Timbo veri py er | ‘gc veg ety ah tas en orm es op tty sk “yoyo hye ee tn ‘maine bo ow gg ie Poin Thy seh you bow ney ple they gg ptt fees she tenes meme dee Fesctrini donee Te Poe lean rb origi ‘Taya ving i tes ith [objeto tepton a hak oe yar tine (Gaping). One ater ig, ty EMD het ayy tts ing ig! eth nt pepe a foetal ono soe in NL BOLDEN: Upson se tis NS MILBURN ey, yous tks acannon ee thro Aten ep ‘CROWD face (cup MS HMLL Tb h ia, misnomer obo sn mas bbe heap of ‘oti set wet gen mh on Oe 17 (Pages 65 to 68) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 312-238-8808 rege © Page 71 2g win kinteMerm enol | 1 fen inet thei ft meg 2 tating te cag for ane 2 Sonya weal haem DOT? 3 emandeanday lr ef tine Te 3 Andean mee ide emda 4 elder co oa aie Newt bara ona, 5 Soir yee tn you au Me MMR. Chen, 2 Sopigenac amreueof WO tse Hacienda nmiencnte | St Singur it es 33 etbennn cing ty epeang see 13 dt ei icyn ete Xt Nance te 14 Toorop mh (ne. = kin Yon Ye oe | 38 A poe one » SIC NILMINE: Yeu Inowtmataiew | 37 WANT Ri ee Woe 25 beetogwan eBoy go fn 0 MR ROLDEN Pew eer te ae, 2 feowsonaeSsattmeyatendin? | 22 DARRELL Tan ORME Ane 23 Teamcectweniawarntienile Now, | 23. sae Tatgn Gp Aju wa 2 newte DOT mare saat He Ghritear Nestbowtigi anand 25 eeumemetirtagtambot pets | 25 Severn pect Aida By ae 18 (Pages 69 to 72) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8608 {teresa seve aed vy hy eed ‘wat inheaer Sath Ct Get rn Sat Can Cpl hs Jenna Peo Shion vor web. Tt ly hepa {CROWD They wee hes Yostee Welw igi nae ye 20 twin sagt sean uino | 10 andes pete DOT 32 wibrematonfotpbunmeniy, Due | LL leit eae ins ona 32 Samtdone Now evn wedistev | 12 Wefeoring tok. se perinse 35 het mpfr bloga tne nd teal 13 bie Kaerbce nh Sand Em Ae seynartorenpe Wes ypseounge | ie RS in"8 fel ee emig bak 15 sedoone sity onetingssei 1S Send Hedi ern atime 26 Giloulscuigwesonlngrspmdcongs [26 Crmaiepce oad ier Co 0 31 feo Kin gan weve tay 82 37 alga cme oh oer se 12 Dorksmasapayyceriorm ee | 18 canetnagh te game pee 13 eommgyonnmtloyen iaanl fines | 32 soup say a eho dat 20 tom te DOT an oven of se 2 Mes ayant 2 mampedeyaremmmeratiawemy — | 2. {CROWD Ra £2 ucmiwiayon Wevantoharfomsen | 22 OL ARAL Thee oy od 23 Wemumobertiemyan Teluyoureavene | 23 (Cpa) emt pele tie ant my Bt Manage 2 exepacge eifynokesterewae 3 "CROWD: Ne 35 pond Theis herein 21 (Pages 81 to 84) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 65 cong now. Lina he opstinie Page 67 sence mtr Mane Ty 2 Sateting red ant ae lag 2 Sine Te Sse aS 5 Caan velattoa ou whee shel ogee | 2 Gra a natn Coy. are {Glu tre Amierge peeegt | 4 bncenjsomaan tee fcc Satan or2tinc in yd et 2 atm ep te § Sat dotnet me Sot © eng Ad Totti pd 3 etna ote? Hsed > enon) as nee ne 1 fedeinan spine nd ke veo 2 Regen wean eda dee ey 5) Mngt you sets sv 5 terpke at tattle pst 22° Gawciygimgonr sown leew | 18 bmpn did perl Kander n.d Enlaces estenaomet tgs | 11 Me Risen iin 22 Satrapton An ay iy ose 12) dnt state pean ag. 33 eine itey jargon eenecceese | 13 Seng shun gh Ean py ck 3 Resewirandwatrand wider Aadactcly | 14 Sueded pre ett 15 Gacemeinedute ston tanteyole” | 33. Seingintarn. pg pinay 16 BShecewot yrs oot thes 26 Sepergtaute wong fan 27 fering They pay youtre ter | 39 ictal Ba ora 28 tect onplt west ey | 38 ing yntenaing Sette re 19 Gutta eee at 32 jpeg pees rae 20 Getinmandapunathepoperyoome. twee | 30 may Aad lecow agp mae 21 reathetenesbagme wn tect | 23 afore Yn, ro 22 Adaya ne med jt 22 ener pom con Tm 25 Ginteesnyose ny ngnanit Andtiy — | 25 Gch dda a dan 25 allsimeatotsneyng rtd yon | 34 fltagmdpay ange 25 pool yaad eid 25 out a i ake Page 06 Page 88 3 mp ofdig i tal ey tt Sheen eit Sa 5 anim ay. aigeewih Eda 5 Geol orto maa compar nd {het tain rad ee {ech humdrtj Fw pit 5 Sonam Newt ate pcetoheone | 5 eWenjsen erect te a0 & —Gyenedthansemiataseomnenryos | 6 aed erin sl hms pe 7 Srlg, yeu ey gig ad oe {este tantra mae te 8 Singer yon you btm a a put Ne ee acs ihn eres (CROWD: He re ite MARKER: Ta 10 psn (erie Tu BOLDIN: Kut ater. And atin heat pr ety A Werewinolewenae Yoreoae an ietome psy enmensepee. Ty set CROWD: Weneettmets MRRYUR TORY. CENDER | freee Aad raring tke ee epy ‘ret Site pore ge ut aig SSopay, Leon oom monte. hy sdb te at ul Ta yu rent TMS TAYLOR: Taken sos ir our conmet nih Pe 3s dg {ono np oe oon ‘tess bleh a Waar te NS TAYLOR ery. Yao. P Publ comment cans on (longa 77pm) 22 (Pages 85 to 88) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 65 Jeekrinscars Le Wes PE aR Ne, ey ape noe mest 0 fm eA, 25a Cy Ce, ‘Bo Catron eo Or th Seeing cae nen ete ‘organ atte ie (elt Gute 241 23 (Pages 89 to 90} McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 1 x add $4:7,19 72:6 49:20,22 ARNG2 | additions:s 24 aside 32:1 3424 Gbitigggosi7 | 312136122 | agricutture 1:5 | application 6:14 | 35:13 Ables2:1¢2817 | additional 12:19 | ahead 42:24 | 6:19,2174 | asked 8:13 Miag3sa3 | 13221417 | ain'es8:18682 | 8159113 | 1221 I3:4 7810 15371719 Jairo611 72:24 | 11:6 26: 26:8 3425 absolutely 27:17 | 2620 airborne 67:3 | 27:16.46:4 696 72:2 882 Se12,14 address723.—[airplaness:s | 48:3.49:17 | asking S2:14 abstractor7.25| 91916: [airport28:21 | $1:2,8,14 844 | 53:8 80:5 accepted 428 | 88:23 AI28:1 applied 10:9 | 8718, 05 addressed 37.9 | Alaska 41:12 — | apply 6:7 38:5 | asphalt 66:9 access 17:5,7 | 382 ‘leon 42:25 | appointed 56:16 | Assembly 73 ‘3012 32.12,12 | adequate2621 | Allen2:5 11:1 | appraised 46:23 | 56:17 568 35115 63:18 | Alley2:21 appreciate 8:6 | assets 36-23 accessing 16:22 | adequately | allow2:21 7:3, | 18:13 22:10 | associated 17:18, eeidene2021 | 19224012 | 24:16 37:17 18 tecidents 203 | 632 61:8 75:17 assume 52:18 ‘Sos10 adjacency 23:21 | allowed 16-25 34:10 accommodation djacent 16:13 | allowing4:10 | approvalolat | Atlanta 7:18 Tr 16:1646:15,15 | alluded 55:24 | 86:1 '33:20,20,23 account23:21 [Administration | 61:1781:9 | approvess22 | 49:2067:20 accounted 33:10 | 40:6 Altamaha 68:15 | 63:2481:14 | 80:5 88:21 aeeoumts 63.16. [admitted 38:20 | alternative | approved 81:8 | Atlantic 75:17 aecurates9.9 [adopted 44:8 | 62:25 approximately | attached 2:15 advocate 60:14 | Amen 19:20, 1261325 | attempe78:7 acknowledged | fect 15:5 57:6 | 21:1724:5, 4:1 attempting 16:2 ‘1 atfidavie30;s | 6597115 | Aprit-94ia | 78:2 acknowledging | affiliation47:10 | 78:16 897,15 attended 70:23 333 afront27:19 | America 40:4 | aquifer 63:14 | attention 12:20 acquires:15 afternoon 3:23 ‘Archer62:6 | attorney 52,6 Wl 33,13,17 282 area 433,311 | 26:1 31 acres31-69,13 | @geney 613,13, 15944322 | 71:17,18,20 164422 74:21 7921 [answer 71:20 | 4419,19456 | 87.22 S2gioi2is | 8029011 Janswers925 | 63:13 764 | ATVsso:I6 Sed sq6 {agents 17:16 | anticipate 13:24 | 80:18 ‘audience 8:18 actz7e9sos [ago33I8 41 | 14:74 154 | areas 1331417 | 60:5 aeting 4:6 60:1483:20. | 15:10.15 3217516 | Augustad:4 action 39:1 agree 67:16 82:3 | anticipation | Arkansas 66:7 | 15:11 14:6,10 $9.12 85:21 27:20 ‘Arnsdorff42:24 | 18:15 21:24,24 activist 763 [agreed 90:14 | anybody 28:16 | 43:23,444:18 | 23:13 46:12 ies 60.24 | ngreement 36:2247:20 | arrogant 7:23. | authorities ity24-22 | 29:10,11 48:6 68:5 71:2 | Article 90:2 23.23, 35:19 agribusiness | apologize 18:6 | artillery 33:8 | authority 26:3 acute 66:17 674 | 1820 appalling 61:17. | Ashley 47-6 26:12 Page 2 available 39-17 38:22 80:1 avoid 58:7 aware 22:4 ‘awesome 22:20 45:20 B bases: back2:13 4425, 45:24 48:20, 51:13 5438 6835 8144.56 84:12,13,14 857 87:13 backwater 81:22 823.6 bad 45:23 63:11 66:3 Dalance 35:25 36:1 balances 45:8 balers 46:21 bank 31:23 Barker 80:21 846,8,8,22 8611 barrels 12:6 13:25 14:9,11 1413153 36:8 50:21 729,12 74:4 barrier 79:1 based 6:25 11:23 12:7 39:23 51:16 6021.22.22 73:28 74:12 bases 13:5 Dasteally 44:2 m3 basis 75:15 78:23 90:14 Battlefield 169 beaches S1:6,8 bear 74:4,13 beautiful 41:20 beginning 16-1 40:23 71:1 begins 35:8 begrudge 48:15 begun 16:20 behalf 25:25 bbchest 11:18 believe 14:23 24:16 25:17 36:25 43:13 ‘ost 87:20 bell 32:24 belonged 69:15 Belton 13:9 19:11 benefit 15:7 21:13,15,23 26:23342 47:1648:22 49:10 50:89 51:17 58:24 149,11 7721 81:12 83:17 85:22 benefits 21:19 21:21 48:5,10 best 18:7 20:17 ‘31:12 46:23 5:16 61:14 Detter 311,12 17514 88:7 BEVEL 5:1 Bevill 55:1.22,22, big24:16 25:11 44:3 56:6,21 igger 40:25 Dill 36:6 56:19 (602 63:58 73:25 7620 billion 74:1 84:10 87:12 billionaire 38:13 Dilly 187,14 bit3:8,9 347,17 4718 48:1 56:12 68:24 ns Diteh 80:16 Dlame35:8 leeds 66:21 blessed 18:19 19:72822 Bloomingdale 57.25 blue 43:19,20 80:23,24 Dowrd 4:20.21 38:8 56:16 90:3 boat 14:21 34:20 Bobby 28:12 Bolden2:3 3:2,7 312,14 16,19 319 10:11 18:1,9,12.22:9 2231024 23:5 2311246 25:22 28:1,2 3088.24 33:13 34:636:12 37:20 40:14 4221.23 45:9 45:1246:9 4735 49:20 51:22,95 5422 '34:24'55:20 5738,12,14,16 57:20 60:1 6335 64:1,68 64:1221,23 65:1,19 67:11 ‘68:11 69:22 08 11:4 15,1820 PATIO 7521 772 78:17 79:7,9 80:20 84:6 86:13 bond 34:22 35:13 36:4 Boo 64:11,1111 6:11 TSA 4 Tad ‘booing 54:20 book 28:55 ‘books 38:21 bottom 57:3 739) bowel 66:20 Bowman 79:9 80:20,22,22 81:24 82:6 831 84:3 box 1:17 715,22 86:19 88:23 BPAL:16 branch 43:23, break 1:14 43:6 51:10 Brigham 24:9 24:10 Brighton23:6 Dring31:23 369 45:24 52:3 363 7A bringing 15:3 brings 21:18 British broke 54:16 broken 50:20 Drought 43:17 65:11 67:18 Brunswick 77:7 7128 Bryan 13:19 40:18 57:5 Bryant 63:6 6413.37 build 31:6,14 59:9 65:16 73:6 78:6 19:10,16 22:5 87:24'98:3| bulldozers 24:24 bunch 65:7 81:21 bbuncher 32:21 burden 27:4 46:6, Burke 24:15 burns 66:12,12 66:23 7620 Dusiness 26:6 39:21 $3:15 62:16 67:15,22 77:25 87:19) Dbusinesses 11:12 26:2.48:17 52:16 60:22 Doay 33:10 57:2 buying 59:18.19 59:3 eo 506 CENDER McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 3 ‘catastrophes | Cheapo 28:13 | 57:759:18,25 | 61-7 63:13 40:21 Cheapo’s29:1 | ot:i66219 | 7414 ceateh 51:4 cheatings7:13 | 63:4,2565:9 | coastline 75:2 | ceategorize 8:25 [ehecked 54:17 | 65:1867:10 | 75:11 | feause89:12 chemical 66:23 | 68:4,16 69:21. | coasts 51-18 caustic 66:7 | child 39:25 70:772:14 | Coca-Cola | 5724 Cedar 1:7989:8 [ehildrenc7.7 | 73:13.7519 | 87:23, | COLLLER | Cender8619 | 77:1679:6 | 76:13,23 Ti:1_ | eode5:14,19.19 5724 87:2 indy 42:24 | 78.9,16,23, 6:17 23:16 California 20:22 | cent 3:11 circumstances | 79:6 80:16,19 | eoimeidence 62:2 20:24 Center 1:7 60.9 | 90:14 s114841s | 623 eall$:21:10:17, | 89:7 cited 40:7 84.23 86:12 | Collier 5:21 18243321 |eemtral 13:8 | cites 19:21 87:6,15 88:13 | 57:8,23,23 called 28:25 | certainly 14:16 | citizen 17:20 | larity 64:12 | 58:13,15.19 38:18 3924 | 330389482 | 69:25 lass 39:1 65:9 | 59:7 | sai7aso4 | 758 citizens 21:13,14 | elassies7:4 | Colonial 25:25 calling33:14 | certificate2:11 | 22:627:19 | | Claudette $5:21 | 28:25 46:18 805) 325525615 | 3e4s7s | Claudia s7:823 | 47:89,11 Camdengs.24 | 7481591 | 58:1 59:10 | elean35:8 41-15 | Columbia 40:2 capacity 1214 | 1094917 | 66:25, 51:11 54:12,14 | column 71:23 148,12 55167422 Jeity 1:79:18 — Jeleamed 1:16 | come 9:13 10:16 capital 39:12 | certification 46:1718 | cleaning 7:10 | 10:22 23:4 capitalism 36:25 | 61:16 lear 47:10 28:17 34:16 card 75:19 | Certified 89:19. elaim 58:21 7224 52:13,16 54:3 eards39:19 30:4 3:16 elearly 25:12 | 54:3,5,9 58:9 ceare'75:25 84:24 | certify 896,11 |elaimed sit | 28:6 58:17 64:14 ceareful61:10 | Chairman22:4 |elaims59:17_— | elients 77:15, | 76:17 85:15 carefully 39:16 | ehance37:12 | clapping 18:22 | lose 15:12 88:16 7622 88:16 W9:18209 | 43:18 comes 14:20.21 carl39:23 | Chaneery39:3. | 21:2522:5,8 | etosely 11:20 | 36:10 48:5 Carolina 4:3 — | Chandler 46:10 | 22:13.17,22 | eloser3:13 84 | 58:3 83:6 iano | 475,7723.25 | 2452521 | Club Tos comfortable t9i22i24 | 48812 26:25.27:1,19 | CO-CSR1:12_ | 35:10 73477433 |change24:22 | 27:2530:11 | co-located 16:7. | coming3:16 carries 5438 3475815 | 33123615 | 16:7,11,15 10:25 15:21 carrying 50:21 | charge90:12_ | 35:1536:11 | eodocation 43:15 47.21 ease 11:12 19:12 | eharged 38.22 | 37:3.1938:11 | 1619 62:25 68:14 19:17,18 34:24 | charges20:20 | 38:1640:13 | eoast40:2,24 | 79:15 84:12,14 5821829 | Charlie69.23 | 42204414 | 4sssoio | gsi 90:10,11,13,14 | "70:8,10,11 45:8,1746:8 | $13.13 60:10 | comment 4:10 90:14) Charlorte 13:4 | 4741349219 | orteri6 — | 4:247:15,22 eases2612 | Chatham 13:19 | 49:245121 | 74:280:9 :25 47:20 catastrophe sor1667:14 | $3:2254:21 |eoastalgi:20 | 69:8 71:2 868 413 87:3 893 55:19 3625 | 42:17 60.1521 | 88:25, McKee Court Reporting, Ine. 912-234-8808 Fage mL 83:10,11 2433 90:7 1522 53:34 comments 4:13. | companies :15. | condemned 5:24 | contaminated | 74:13, } 42161925 7:8 | 88:3 conduct 7725. | 66:13 Council 90:3 7.1114,17,22 | company 5:22 | confidential | contemplates | Councilman 118,19 15:2 | 29:10 4956, 33:23 18:18 20:19 confiscated contest 20:20 | counsel 24 19:2 21293625 | 58:20 ceontinue?:17 | 89:11 90:11 17101813 | 37-1738:1825 | confusion 66:22 | 31:1932:1 | Counselor 28:3, 22:111618 | #4e447:13 "| congress 41:22 | 35:20 ‘counties 4:4 34174613 | 48:166822 | Congressman | continuing 13:2024:15, 64:17 725 74:19 82:18,19 | 33:22,25 13211721 | 57:58:19 86:6,17 88:15 | 87:2488:11 | connect12:23 |continuously | 81:22 83:17 commercial | company’s 35:3. | eonnected 41:19 | 29:23 countless 69:3 11:21 60:23 Jeomparable | eonnection | contract 90:9,10 | country 19:4 commission 2:1 20:21 ‘contractual 589 6:1030:7 83:1 | Comparest:9 | consequences | 12:11 77:15 | county 16:5 commissioner | compelled 58:2 | 25:432:25 | contrary 61:6 | 24:11 30:16 6239:12, | compensated | conservation | control 15:1 36:15 40:18 is2427.21 | 176419 3:1 4:19 42:10 43:7 382255 compensation | consider 4:16 | convenience | 52:16 65:24 Seaselas | 41:i1,1 8645:7583 | 325611575] 67:14 79:11,13 6587614 | 6x8 considerably | 9:20:13 | 79:21 80:24 874 competition 20:11 11:5 25:18 8416 873.4 commissioners | 14:1736:7 | eonsideration | 26:16 28:7 58:5 70:14 6321 4918 55:6 le 44:7 718 considered 4:15 | 74:22 ‘court 1:16 2:20 commissions | complete25:2 | 7:108:1,3 9:11 | convenient34:3 | 9:4,8,16 26:13 42:10 component 14:5 | 26:14 38:15 | convinced 82:20 | 39:3 6:14 commit 72:2 1486 consistent 39:21 | Conway 66:16 | 89:19 90:1,3.4 commitments | components | constitutes9:9 | COO 38:19 90:5,7.8,8,10 12111216 | 1s constitution | cooking38:21 | 90:12,17 committed | conceded 32:19 | 21:4 coordinated | courtesy 82 1719314 [eoneern 63:12 | eonstitutional | 58:10 courthouses commodity 15:6 | 87:7 424 copies: 78:1 156 concerned 32:3. | constraints 86:4 | eore21:3 47:17 | eover 90:12 common8:2 | concerns 4:13 | eonstruction | corner 88:5__| covered 66:22 2325256 | 16333725 5:17 6:12 | corporate 17:20 | crabbing 75:16 Ssi7eois | su sorsex | I3asisi7 | 59.21 crabs 75:13 61:12 56:13 | 45:2258:16 | corporation | ereate 14:17 communities | coneludest:12 | consultation — | 74:12 46:19 rT concluded 88:25 | 16:6 correct 87:22 | ereating 59:24 community feonelusion | consumers | corridor 31:8 | erentures 75:14 1418669 | 27:23 48:13, 42:15 Croek20.22 commuter 83:7 | condemnating | contacted 16:24 | cost 14:23 15:20 | creeks 74:18 McKee Reporting, 238-2008, Page 5 critically 61:10 ‘ross 50:4 51:1 crossing 32:7,10 50:20 52:21 692, crossings 32:5 S4:17,18.18 erowd2:10 3:11 3:15,18 5:9 192021:17 22:20,23 23:4 24:5 26-4 27:1 27:12 28:18 30:20,23 35:21 492:22'4417 45:11 47.22.24 487.711 51:24 58:12,14 58:18 59:6 608,12 64:11 164:19,20,22.25 65:9 68:9,16 70:15 13,7 TuILAS 73:14 7318.23 788 78:16 81:23 825,25 84:2 84:21 86:10,20 86:23 88:19) RR: Crude66:12 CSR 49:5,19 €SR27H1 1:12 Cumberland 516) (Canningham 30,24 33:16,17 ceurrent 12:2 currently 6:8 11:24 12:34 1318 159) 24:13 42:6 ‘customary 90:13 ‘customer 11:18 12:12 48:18 ‘customers 11:10 1118 128,15) 13:13 47.22.23 472425 4811 48:16.182022 cut 4:24 52:25 $3:5,5,15,20 53:21 69:14 85:16 ceutting 32:21 8615, Cynthia 42225 coer) DP damage 18:21 24:23 25:16 54:13 74:15 75:27:10 damages 41:10 41:16 569 damaging 38:6 Danachatavis 349,10 35:22 dang 86:8 danger 20:14 dangerous 19:15, 6633 dangers 66:4 Darrell 70:9 7:15.21 date 1:9 6:18 10:7 90:17 David 57.22 60: Davis 34:7 36:12 —___D_| dealers 80:3 1101113 34:12 3658, 50:13,20,21,24 517614 T9,1 74:4 16.7.7 84:20 86:6 89:15 days 6:18 43:16 31:12 66:19 79:22 87:12 dead 53:4 deadline 7:24 85,7 deal 9:17 22:4 44:6 68:8 dealing 70:20 ‘dealt 35:1,3 80:3, Debbie 2:20 deceased 44:21 decide 9:13 deciding 9:12 38:5 decision 6:20,23 36:24 61:3,10 61:20 decisions 60:15 dock 85:20 decline 24:20 ‘declined 25:20 ‘declining 62:12 deed 33:34 deep 32:16 41:3 412125 defended 81:15 defending 81:18, defer 35:19 deficient 61:5 definitely 50:8 ‘definition 57:4 Delaware 39:3 delay 18:5 delicate 75:10 deliver 49:14 delivered 14:14 delivery 13:13) 13:24 14:19 demands 19:17 democracy 34:15 59:25 democratic TRS deny 46:3 49:16 '51:2061:16 69:20 84:4 department 1:2 3:21,22.4:2 5:7 64,18 10:7.23 18:23 3:18.21 40:6 48:3 49:15 55:78 56:13 63:24 dependent 49:6 depending 39:1 deposition 90:8 90:9,12 depth 325,13 depths 25:8 descrip 6h9 descriptions TTL desecrated 85:9 design 12:1,9 1617 designated 14:2 designed 13:12 desirability 19:12 details 49:7 developed 48:9 devices 40:9 die 53:15 diesel 1:13.24 42, ference 25:11 28:6 different 8:13, 24:24 49:9 Aigital 66:1 directions 51:2 directly 31:22 44:11 76:16 disaster 41:12 41:22,25 31:15 2718 333.4 So: liselosures 33:6 ‘discount 90:13, discover 51:10 79 discovered 43:15 45:2 discuss 4:9 82:22 disruptive 19:14 distributed 15:13 59.26 distributors S72 disturb 25:5, disturbing 37.6 divide 32:10 Division 6:4 dizzy 66:21 DNR 74:25 ‘document 12:21 ‘documented McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8308 Page 6 40:22 documents 2:18, 12:20 dog 62:21 doing 35:20, $514 63:22 64:17 68:1 70:22 71:19 86:1 dollar 35:13) 74:1 dollars 15:13 39:15 83:16 84:11 Dolphins 41:5 domain 5:1621 6:11 21:1,6,12 2444.22:1 23:14,17 244 378,13,18 ae7 a7:12 48:19 S2:11,15 (68:22 74:23 95:7 16:11 79178723 doors 80:24.25, 80:25 aot 6:1,13,23, 10:1,8 26:7 27:23 35:21 385,844:13 | 45:25 46:1 49:24 51:20 56:16 61:15 65:25 69:19 7033.24.95 1123,13,17 71:19 74:20. 82:18,20 84:10 DOT's68:18. dots 42:14 double 43:3 62:2 ‘drafted 2721 ‘dramatially| 49:8 draw 12:20 drawer 76:15 drawn 61:13 draws 61: dried 80:9, aitl633 drilling 62:1,6 driven 11:19) 21:8 drivers 67.23 ‘drives 83:7 driving 50:16 drop 13:11 86:18 drove 3s:4,5 54:15 872 Ary 66:19 dubious 39:5 due 35:24 50:15, 50:15 51:2 dumping 50:25, Dunn 90:7 dying 4:5 62:24 dynamic 45:21 E E2716 EDGY 52:1 EY 79:2 ‘earlier 19:1 ‘early 15:25 cenrn 48:17 ‘earth 30:6 61:24 16:7 ‘easement 16:23 TTL S318, ‘easements 17:3, S2:11 easier 61:4 easily 81:15 eastern 45:5 75:5,6 easy 26:3,5 Bhenezer 56:2 71:33, ‘ecological 74:15 ecology 39:4 75:10 ceconomie 61:11 83:16 economy 60:15 (60:17.21 61:1 83:24) Eadie 57:11,12 S714,16 Bagy 49:21 51:22 52:1,1 educated 87: effeet 63:23 effectiveness 1423 Effingham 43:7 S725 79:11 Fo:13.21 80:23 efforts 17:21 ‘either 19:6 21:23 23:19 50:10 128:13 29:1 lected 38:9 Bel electri 66:1 electri 25:7 25:12 electricity 30:1 59:14,16 elements 60:19 eloquent 72:25 Emily 5:13,16 eminent 5:16.21 6:11 29:1 6,12 2144221 28:14,17 24:4 37:8,12,18, 3a7 4712 48:19 52:15 (68:22 74:23 75:6 16:11 1687.23 88:12 ‘emit 66:2 ‘employ 21:12 ‘employee 90:5 ‘employees 15:16 ‘employment 59:4 Enbridge 67:1 encourage 12:18, 1222 17:10,17 endangered 7:20 endless 65:20 ends 43:11 energy 6:9 1333 14:22 48:12,14 584 50.24 62:25 74:6 enforce $2:5 ‘engineer 2:3 3:14,20 engineering 81:19 English 28:8 enjoy $9:2,7 60:25 Enmark 28:10 28:25 29:16 Enron 38:18,19 84:13 87:13,15 ensure 9:22 29:22 censured 39:13 entire 9:18 13:1 lass 1S: entitled 77:21 entrance 8:8 enveloped 66:6 environment 10:5 20:7 36:19 40:20 42:8,12.509) 53:12 60:16,17 63:13 75:25 ‘environmental 63 45:6 52:5 53:17 676 (68:23 87:7 environmenta. 52:4 75:24 6:12 environments 473, EPD6:3 44:20 68:5 ‘equip 82:10 ‘equipment 40:10 46:22 ‘equivalent 50:22 ‘erosion 25:9 especially 85:10 Esq 90:7 ‘essentially 31:20 ‘established ‘58:10 60:13 estate 87:22 estimates 12:7 sthanol 1:14.24 42 ethical 61:18. ethics 5:17 Eva 79:9 80:20 80:22 evacuated 66:14 evaluation 61:11 evening 18:11 49:28 T0113. ‘eventually 89°18, McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 7 Everette 28:13 everybody 35:9 35:9 49:4 70:1 Bo:12 871 evidence 55:12 evil 30:9 33:24 341 exactly 38:16 S814 PXAMINATL. 29 ‘example 16:5 20:19 36:8 66:4 71:12 examples 16:5 37:13 exclusive 90:10 Excuse3:8 30:21 exercise 6:11 exhaustion 66:21 Bxhibit2-18 ‘exhibits 2:20.22 exist 42:6 existed 2622 ‘existing 16:13 16:16,19 19:24 49:9 78:4 exit39:15 Exley 90:7" expand 11:17 expect 6:22 expecting 70:13, experience 2921 59:4 Trin a4 12 experienced 673, ‘experiences 59:9 exploded 20:23 exploding 39:4 75:2 explore38:16 explosion 30:10 419) export 62:7 exporting 62:14 625 exposed 77:17 THB exposure 66:17 ons ‘express 10:25, 18:22 ‘expressed 4:13, 164 extend 4:3 extended 4:22 extension 6.24 72136 extraordinary 26.9 ‘extremely 24:25 Exxon till 4933 eye30.9 eyes 66512 fact 26:10 31:15 35:24 62.9 facts 41:25, 35:10 68:23 82:19 83:4 fail 70:5,5 failed 42:4 71:13 714 falling 40:79,9 40:10,11 fails 28:5 failure 0:12 fair 22:4 32:7 78:13, faith 36:23 86:8 aM 83:11,21,22 Families 55:25 66:14 amity 18:15 24:11 53:3,20 56:1 63:9 79:12,20 family's 1821 46:22 53:8 famous 78:24 far 28:16 29:14 35:17 45:7,21 36:3 63:21 fur 24:14 25:1 25:16,19 46:20 farming 24:12 25:49) faster 62:8 63:2 faule35:3 faulty 50:16 favor 71:24723, February 4:1 62, federal6:69 21:5 306 35:18 38:24 feel 45:20 7026 414 F008 37:66 Feet 25:10,11 325,667,716 32:17,19 85:6 859,15 16 fellow 32:21 elt33:9 FERC6:9 29:11 29:17,17.19 49:5 Ferner 57:17 Fernon 70:9 Festival 61:25 167 field 25:15 48:23, 499) flelds 24:18 fifth 52:7 60:21 fighting 78:25 figures 55:10 82:19 83:49 File 90:19 filing 29:17,18 481495 17:20 final 6:20 37:10 finally 82:1 financial 90:13 find 43:10 58.2 finish 67-18, fire S14 firefighting 40:10 fires 66:2 firms 12:11 firmly 12:10 first 4:7,11 5:23 621 8:13.20 1621324 48:4,15 553 70:23 84:23 fish 36:19 51:5 754 fisheries 51:9 fishing 60:23, 75:15 fits 12:17 five 10:18 15:12, 414S2121 52:13 53:2,2 69:2 70:22 fix51:10 flammable 74:6 floats $13, flood 70:3 floods 36:10 Florida 4:5 12-4 1310452 B57 flow 67:20 flowing 58:25 fy 56:6 oeus 60:14 fold 43:12 folks 19:3 26:2 36:24:10 ‘4413 55:24 62:12.67.25 78:1 follow 23:8 28:3, 3417 2:13,13 39:20 following 5:19 90:3 fond 58:5 food 59:8 77:18 foot 32:13, force $8.23 Fore2:5 10:23 11:2 18:12, 194,11,25 21:20 47:19 48:24 foregoing 89.9 forest 24:18 forestry 20:11 forests 74:7 forever 32:22 forgot 63:15 forgotten 44:18 form 7:24 703 formal 70:21 format 53 8:12 9:25 former 84:17 forms 7:19. 88.22.24 formulas 15:14 Fort 31:8,18,21 32:1 33:2 forth 51:13 Forward 13:21, 17:25 38:24 fossil 627,15.21 62.28 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 8 found 16:6 26:20,22 67:2 85:3 founder 65:24 four 28:22,22,23 49:6 52:32 66:10,18 80:24 80.25.25 81:1 four-tine 33:19 fracking 74:6 fraction 60:6 frame6:25 Frank 3:3 freedom 19:5 frequently 12:21 freshwater 50:5 Fresno 20:24 30:10 Friday 20:22 friends 849,10 front 18:6 60:5, fuel29:13,14,15 29:16 50:22,22 513,49,13 62:21 79:22,24 80:1,3,4,,10 80:11 fuels 62:7,15,24 full27-18 80.2 full-time 15:16 fully 25:1 70:13 Fulton 65:20 omnt3 fumes 66:6 fand 1:11 fundamentally 387 funding 5 further 16:2 61:19 74:25 89:11 furthers 31:21 future 12:3 29:4 29:5,631:5 32.9 56:04 gallon 83:8 gallons 21:22 "79:22 83:10. game 78:13) gas 11:14,15 13:3 15:1 28:24 29:3,20 29:24 30:14,15 3018 42:6 50:12 54:12 364573 62:11 65:12. 4358 83:11 83:21 84:17,17 gasoline 11:13 11:24 28:17 3063 741 75:3 gasped 66:23 gatekeeper 26:11 GOT 23 4:14 415 527.9 8:5 78:22 7933 gen52:7 ‘general 72, '56:12,16 71:17 71:19,20 generate $914 67:19 generation 52:7 generations 18:16 31:6 69:12,16 Genieve 66:10 ‘gentleman 22:25 ‘gentleman's 81:10 gentlemen 18:12 Ba Georgia 1:2,8,18 3:20 44 516,14 5:18 6:1,45,12 6:17.24 10:18 11:8 12328 13:8,9,18 142 143.45.7.16 ¥4:19 15:1215 1511822 16.7 1631117320 17:24 18:15,23 21:13,14,1925 216 23:13,14 24:15,16 24:10 26:13,15,2224 27:7,193123,7 33:17 34:3 383,14 40:24 4124314 44:9 46:1,6,12 4833,13,18,24 49:2,11,15 52:9 55:7 8,16 35:23 57:18,19 57:21 58:15 5813.17.25, 59:1,10 60:21 6186525 7223 73:47 74:9,12,20,25, 75:59 77.624 78:14 79:1123, 79:25 80:69 80:12 81:17 873 89:18 903 Georgia's 38:11 '42:10,17 6015, 75:10 Georgian 44:8 ‘50:12 getting 313 2933.24 30:1,2 30:3 38:17 a sifted 60:4 sive 5:23 6:17 8:16 9:19 1022113 26:8 52:14 54:6 64:4 (68:24 72:20 421833 87:19 88:10 stiven 6:20 59:11 61:3 89:10 90:13 ives 68:21 giving 30:8 49:25 glad 76:21 slobal 62:5 03:17 53 8:18 10:19 1424 22:13 28:23 29:4,131:12 37:6 42:24 46:16,18 47:1 52:23 62:19 65:10 67:9 70120 81:6 85:23 86:2 885,11 God 40:12 78:11 spoes 12:13 31:22 4433 56:9, going 4:4,12,28 8:21,239:21 0:11 12:2 13:16 14:17 152317115 182,237 22:14 3.2.89 27:10 34:5,20 43:89 447,11 44:23,24 45:19 45:2446:1,14 49:10 50:2 52:9,19 53:21 54:12,13,1415 34:24'56:5 58:18 62:13,14 63:23 64:16 65:10 67:19,20 61.22 68:57 10:2. 11:62 72:10 73:10 76:25 80:13,14 85:4,10 86:2,5 867,16 19 87:21 88:6 ‘good 3:23,3,13 3:16 18s 19:5 23:22 28:2 36:1,2,16 50:7 52:2 55:17 65:12 0:11 73:12 15:88 16:24 82:16 84:9 85:25 87:24 Google 20:24 government 21:7 36:24 3743812 3916 42:2.4,7 54:6 59:22 68:21 ‘government's 41:10 ‘governments 15:15 21:5,12 Grainy 73:20 75:21.23,23, rant 55:5 granted 22:1 granting 17:1 a grants 5:14 56:1 ‘great 22:12,25 34:15 48:13 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 9 os: 759 | haltissi2isi20 | 712,16 102 hhuge25:3 74:11 greater25:7 | 152021 1024179 | mimburnor12 | huh 71:25 reatest75:18 [hamburgers | 45:2849:25 | 68:11,13,15,17 | hundred S3:1.7 greed azo | 887 58:1 722822 | Mineaville31:7. | 53:13 66:15 38:17 hana sons | 8817.25 7023 733 88:4 grocery 3715 [handed 76:18 |hearingsd4t1 | hime 46-2 hundreds 39:7 ground 58.25 |handle35:26 | 70:20 72:1 ‘9:15 4021 wo2e2s | 3665604 | a2 66:8 97:24 groundwater | 6720 heart 73:1,9 Hunter 90:7 S119 happen27:16,17 | Reartbeat3:16 | Hitehens 7621. | hurrieane 29:25 | group29:1 47:8 |27:1846.20" | heaved 66:19 hold3:124:12 | hurviemes | grow 35:20,28 | 50:10,15 52-19 | heavy 25:1 2324295 | 29:24 807 e515 goose | 46: 6m husband 44:20 growing3521 | 63:1 70:487:3 | held 48.9 72713 |holdings:1t_ | 44:21 ae pened 14 | 8k 2i8 77 | a7s4924 | ———___ uarantee 14:25 | 66:25 Helen2:452,6 |notde2as | ———_T 822 happens 32:23 | 10:16 homest:t 6302 guarantees | °342535:722 | neus5:2 Homeowners | idea27:17 38:15, 1428 36:10 Helmiy 78:18 | 74:9 39:12 63:1 guess 48:46 [happy 82-7 | 79:7,88,10,10 |homes {1:11 | 6633 621269: | hard 17:15 28 |help 31:18,25 | honest 36:5 | Klentfied 31:10 nisms | 326579 ele28 | a2 no's 26:13,15 surs71 | Harolazt6 | svt hhomored2i:4 | 26:20,25 guesseasi9 | 25248721 [elped3i:ta [hoops 38:12 | image66.24 quy3822_ | 90.7 36196723 |opess:13.__| immensely 2:1 gulf40:2 41:5 | Hartsville 13:3 | helps 22:6 63:23 76:21 immunity 78:11 “41:17,18 74:2 | harvest52:23 | Henderson 64:2 | 78:12, impaet 13:16 / 80:8 hay 46:21 65:3,5,5,10 Horizon 41:3,22 | 25:3 31:20 / Gulfstream | Harardows40:s | Henry2522, | 41:25 323387 87:25 Inead 51:2, 40:1542:21 | horizontal 69:4 | impacted 67:7 uméd:1¢— [health7’3 | hereunto 86:14. | hospitality | impacting 1638, uy 86:1 hhear3:34,7.10 |heyste8 68:13 | 18:20, impacts 16:18 fuys284 2915 [S11 108) |HI3I:1 34:9 — | hosting lo2s | 16:18 32:2 Be | aaasazi20 | 372349:22 | mosis 70.24 ‘| implicated | eoars2n | 65:23 hour 83:20 a819 216 78:1221 $2:22 | hiding29:10 | house 39:19 | implications HLE-L-M-L-Y 82:23 high 30:18 31:10 | 45:1250:23 | 49:11 79:11 heard 19:1,10 83:8 houses 69:7, ‘important 9:6 BENDER. | 19.24.2617 | highly 61:21 [Houston 73:25 | 23:13 56:18 65:6 sissos | 733 Houtons5:12_ | 61:10 HOBBAR. | 69:117224 | highway21:7 | fubbard36-13 | imposed 6:6 37224017 | 73:8 S39 211 | 3720,21,22,22 | improperly Halts hearing2.6 | wini:7g3i:s | 3723401616] 39:10 Haldon 45:9 3:22 4:25 616 | 37:23.2472:9 | 40:1764:5 |_| improvements McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 10 28:7 egrity 79:18 5422553 | King’ss6:1 inches25:5 | Intense66:17 | Jacksonvinead | Katrina 79:20 | Kingsland 65:23 | Incidenees 20:25 | intent 7:2 Tmoria3 | 79:23 KM 747 incidents 69:13 | intentions20:17 | ta:15 911 |keep23:8374 | KM's40:1 including 1:19 | interaction @asras | Reeper34 10 | knew 70:25 i92s4i8 | 23:23 jail38:23 “45:17 49:23 | knocked 35:5 493 interest 5:16 [Tames 78:18 | 51:16 68:15 | know 3:23 4:20 incomessns | 112i tet |" 907.20 Keller 65:2,3,19 | 1:6 17:7 193 increase 72:10 | 70:1890:6 | jgniee 5425 | 652123 2:19,19,21,21 indefinitely | interested 89:13 |"'s5.99,29 | kept 76:12 271616293 35:19 interesting — | gay':23,24__ | ld S315 295,17 308 Indicating?20 | 47:18 syra2.25 459 | Kil63:3 32:18 36:1718 individual 1620 | International |Jaynsi7 [kilingst:s | 40:42445:22 176 1344 Tenniferzait |kilowatts9:13 | 45:23 464 individuals 59:3 | interpretation |“Garitia [kin649 80:12 | 49:7.853:9,15 39:9 Henny 642.65 | kind 22:18 28:3 | 55:15 56:12 industrial 2:19 Simmy6siss | 30188525 | 6421 69:3 industries 75:16 jobriiassa |kinder2:5 112 | 706,172 industry 41:24 6 116 18:17,25 | 7:10.18 7225 4226 48:12 jovss89 soar | 1925201719) 7721'78:22 agi18 542 frig. | 218252417 | 79:19 80:1415 62:25 12872025 | 258273,4,7 | 80:18 8620 inevitable74:15 ]invasive38:6 | gad 27:1529:16,19 | 87:10 info712 investment | yohm 33:22 303.342." | known 28:24 information — | 15:18,2339:18 | "so.20 8468 | 35:1,1637:25 | KV30:19,19 B:i4 10:13 | tavestments | Jon 76:20 38191921 | Kyler 57:22 73,1419 | 392,13 Joness7.i7as | 392,89,13,6 | 60:13913 27117021 | investors39:10. | "'33-19,21 39:19,2024 | 8625 ma involved 6:18 — | joy 75:11 gor721 421_ | infrastructure |1"25:1138:310 [eeuceog3 | 43:13,18242s |—_ 117 1538 30:863:21 jumping 38.12 | 441463413 | LTSA TI 16:13,15,16.19 | involving 50:12 | ustineation | 48849313. | L-O-V-E67:14 3922 18 sizassio | L-¥79:12 inherently 20-16 | 48: jestity2420 | 58256119 | labor 8:16.21 initiaing’S:21 | irreplaceable "46:7 @rir6o1 | 38:23 8720 input4:10 73 justfying2s.as | 73257421 | ek 51-1617 inspect 40-11 | terigation 25:6 * | rao 7612 | $620 instat24:17 | Island 51:7 k=] 7771322, Jladies 811 38:13 issue 03 26:14 [KELLER | T84sii7,16 | 7221 TH installingS9:5 | 70:18 16522 81:21 828,17 [lake 66:11,16 39:23 issued 6:22 37:8 | Kanters4:7 | $3419.25 | Lakehead 26:18 ingurance28:23 |issues 10:4 | Karen 73:19 | 8413 87:10,11 | land 17:16 19:14 intangible36:3 | 362252: | 75.21.23 | Kinder's38-25 | 2019.16 24:18 integral 6i:l | 65:11 66:20 | Kathy$i:23 | king 9.24gas | 25:20 30:13 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 11 313,4,5,10.11 31:14,15 33:2 335,837 46:21.472 54:6 58:20 58:1 74:10 75:4 79:12,15 79:19,19 84:16 85:9.24 Lander 52:21 landowner 17:6 34:13 landowners 5:23 16:1,4,20 175222 36:22.372,11 52:17 53:9 7424 754 ands 22:3,7 69:11 12 large 56:4 largest 20:1 laughter 39:13 48:13 6222 71:8 80:16 Laura 45:14 46:9,10,11 Taw 512,19 6:10 6:2423:14,16 24:1 87:7 Fawnmower 35:5 laws 6:6 56:17 lawyer 18:12 28:4 73:2 87:17 ead 42°14,16 leadstainted TENT leaders 48 leadership 38:17 teak 25:15 34:21 “41:14 5081011 50:19 51:11 leaks 40:21 earn 58:6,8 learned 44:15 lease 42:8 leased 7:23 leasing 59:13 leave 7:14.21 $413 leaves 14:12, ed 47:19) eft 28:13 30:14 79:13 82:8 88:1 legal 5:3,8 8:1 19:2.97:22 787 legislators 58:4 59:12 end 87:5, lessen 59:21 let's 38:16,24 42:24 43:24 58:15,15 59:10 letter 27:21,25 level 48:23 49:9 levels 25:8 lever 35:5, Lewis 33:22, 34:1 abilities 52:18 liability 56:8 able 78:12 Liberty 84:16 lied 7823 life24:12 36:15 60:25 81:19) snd Ligonis 2:20 iked 44:12 Limer 39.23, limit 9:21 Tine 13:22 14:8 168,14 18:4 25:12,13 28:19 30:13,14,15,17 30:18 43:21 46.17.18 54:16 36:4 57:35 62:19 63:2 (65:12 84:17,17 85:5,67 lines 13:22 25:6 28:11 12 30:18 43192021 46:14.15 564 36: Hiquefied 74:5 liquid 30:17 Lisa 75:22 77:2 TS ist 29:12 23 39:16 toning 55:18 76:15,22 Literally 81:4 Uitigated 29:18 Utigating 41:13 litigation 90:14 litle 38,9,13 8:12 18:17 19:1347,17 42:1 43:6 48:7 44:10,19 47:18 48:1 50:4 36:11 62:19 68:24 72:8 771983:89 84:16 live 18:14 1934 19:7 24:10 33:17 36:15 63:8 67-14 72:22 80:23 lived 18:15 33:20 66:15 livelihood 51:15 52:24 53:8 3427 livelihoods 33:10 ives 66:11 ing 53:24 673 LLC S611 Toaded 32:8 oad 50:23 local 11:15, 15:15 16:6 205 41:7 58:19 67:22 logs 32:9 ong720:15 35:19 3834114 44:10,13 51:10 55:24'58:24 (65:13 66:10 longe-term 12:11 146 longer 18:17 20:10 35:23 59:2 82:16 longest $2:13 Took 11:17 12:19 12:22 13:17,21 171,20 3304 35:25 36:7 50:19 S41 55:12 56:14 85:4 87:9 looked 11:20 13:16 45:1 85:8,11 Fooking 36.21.23, looks 13:15 5719 85:10 Lord 73:16 lose $3:7 74:10 losses 41:10 lost 87:14 ot 9:16 17:12 24:25 30:1 48:2 50:6 524 5258 53.3, 56:20 68:1 66:2 72:5 75:24 763 78:20 lots 31:25 68:23 81:1 83:24 loud 87:7 Louder 3:15 0:12 Louisiana 40:3 Love 65:20 (67:13,13 68:10 na lows39 lower 59:2 Inekily 52:25 Icky 43:5 lungs 66:12 lying 87:12 small 7:17.23 main 63:12 Maine 43:3 maintain 40:8 40:10 ‘maintains 39:20 ‘maintenance 5:18 39:18,23 major 13:33 Mckee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8608 Page 12 14:18 682, 692 making 14:15 21:92:17 34:14 43:16,19 43:28 61:91, 883,10) man 44:34 manager 24:13 mandated 41:23, ‘manner 89:13 map 43:17,17 82:13 84:19 maps 12:19 40:8 THD March 66:5 Markesteyn 45:14 15,16 ‘market 29:2,7 36:11 37:1 market's 29:23 markets 62:11 marsh 41:6 Marshall 66:25 marshes 50:6 $13 741417 7512 marshland 7710 Material 40:5 math 7238 matter 32:23, 50:14,14 79:2 1944.6 Mayflower 66:6 MeKee 1:16 90:5,7.8,10,12 90:17 ‘MeMurry 18:24 2721555 57.95 65:8 76:14 81:13 el MeMurry's 38:3 mean 16:17 37:14 71:25 85 ‘means 16:12,15 16:18 19:23, 37:10 39:12. measures 21:11 Medicaid 59:8, meet 12:227:24 meeting d:17 5:4 1o:1 11:16 0:13.25 71:1 71:18 22.777 meetings 48,14 7:7 811 69:8. 70:21,25 81:25 ‘members 8:17 8:17 38:7 ‘memories 44:10 memory 4:15 ‘men 67:23, mentioned 32:22 484 Mexico 41:18 Michael 49:21 31:22 Michigan 66:25, ‘microphone 5:12 8:199:3,8 ‘middle 8:19 71:3 82:8 ‘migraines 66221 mike 2:3 3:4,14 321619. 8:21 10:10,16 45:15 52:1 86:13) miles 13:17 20:2 33:8,8 50:3,24 69:3 83:78 rilitary 13:5 31:21 sillion 15:11,12 15:1934:11 39:15 rllions 83:16 Milmine 69:23 70:8,10,10,12 0:17 71:12,16 Milzathem 24:13 Mimi72:16,16 BAT ‘mind 37:4 38:20 45 ‘mindful 7:24 178. smine73:11 10:18 13, 22:13,18 23:1 23:1,227220 64:4,16,20,22 64:24 minutes! 81:10 mirror 66:24 ‘mispronounce 186 mission 32:1 mistake 24:16 25:3.32:23,24 mistakes 58:7 mitigates 31:20 mitigation 31:23, six 76:8,10,11 MLP35:17 Mobil's 49:3 money 31:25 34:23 35:8,23, 42:13 3:16.19 48:17 33:6 83:18 87:20 ‘monitor 40:12 4233 ‘months 66:18 ‘Morgan 2:5 11:2,6 18:18 18:25 19:25 20:17,20 21:8 21:2524:17 25:22 26:8 27:4,58,15 282,20 29:16 30:4.21 34:2 35:11 16 37:25 38:19 39.2.8 39:10,13,16,19 39:20.24 40-7 40:15,22 42:21 43:13,1824 44:1 465,13, 48.9 49:3,13, 51:20 55:10 58:25 61:19 67:18 69:1 7325 74:21 15:49 16:12 117 13,22 78:4 81:16,21 829,17 83:19 83:25 87:10 Morgan's 29:20 42:11 4633 sL7 834 Morning 86:5 882 Morris 18:78 18:11,14 19:21 21:18 23:8 30.9 88:1 Morris'34:17 smother 66:10 motives 61:22 mountain 85:10 ‘mouth 50:25 move 23:4 38:24 67:23 moved 43:11 moving 68:1 ‘multiplying 8315) x NDT N-O-R-T-O-N 15 same 3:13,19 18:6,14 23:11 25:24 31:1, 33:16 34:9 Seid 3723 40:17 45:16 55:22 579 63:6 67:13, (68:14 69:24 Jos1l 7220 15:23 775 a7 ‘names 9:17 "Nancy 30:24 33:16 43:2 national 29:20 (62:21 82:13,16 natural 6:5 10:7 30:14 74:5 77:20 nature 60:22,22 near 12:14 33:2 62:4 72:23 nearly 67:2 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 13 necessary 344 | 33:20 number 26:7 org6s25 81:16 neighbors 66:15 |"27:338:1 organization necessity 1 6:1 | Neil2335 §3:19,22.25 Bis 313, 157592 [neither24:1 | mumerows.i2.14 | 7687711 | 60:11 Tos,14 11: | mervous6s:22 | 5033 ‘okay 3:12 5:11 | organized 85:2 1916219 |never292 302 [rurture75:13 |" 18:1204 | outeome89:13 asis26i7 | airari2 |---| 22:10 2927 | outdoor 6028 graers9 | eoe7i2s |__| 30:7423' | outlinea>7.22 poesiii2a2 | 721 eni2 — fotelock862424 | 46.1051:25 | outrage s2:1,14 45:7 49:18 new 3:16 32:11 88:21 57:21 68:10 | outside 12:22 55:6 61:14 32:11 38:25 | O.C.G.AS:14 | old 44:25 45:5 | overhead 25:12 6207422 | stzssou1 | 90:69 78 coverrie61:9 81:9,11,12 65:25 78:5 ‘oath 30:6 Olympic 23:21 | overriding, wti2i — |Newsss:s8n2 | objeet6t:468:5 [onstines1:23, | 19:16,19 need 93,18 —|newspaper | objective6139 | 43:15 oversight 42:1 13:23 15:24 20:23 40:1 obligation 49:16 | once 17:2 32:10 | overview 8:16 19:17,19 26:19 | Nicks 7:6 49:00 | 6217.18 7425 | "35.2 113 2862938 492223 | Observer 0:1 "| ones 43:19 66:1. | owned 21:7 Shas 34— Noctiso2s:s fobtnins.2562 |""gsx521 | "31147919 37:4,13,1415 | 23:12 obtaining 79:24 | open 69:7 owner 32:11 Jor aeas, | noisese.7 66.21 |oceursi:t —— aperatel3:21. | 52:667:15,15 47:11,3,16,20 | "78:25 oceurs357.14 |"7a9 1819 | 85:20, 4721567 |nonprofita1:3 | 36:50:24 | 2924825 | owners20:13 51:17 33:18, |" 60110 Ocean 75:17 | operated 11:8} 24:19 69:15 $4116 56:0 | nortn L311 14:6 ffee5:3.77217 "3.201723 | ownership 3146136 B24403 | 718 70:3 | operations? | 74:19, erasea20 | To258069 |Omeias:13 | "299 owns 44:1 7833 r42280:10 | 80.11 olficials 16:6 | operations, | 85:5 northern 13:8 $6:15,21,22 24:15, = needed 12:10,15 | "14:5 wid operator 925. | P8714 32233412 |Northwood | offthoret:3 "30: PAAT-T-O-N yoaraits | 66:3 ait pinion 38:4 ‘Needlessly 56:25 | Norton 75:22 | Ogeechee 44:16 | opportunity meeds 9:9 12:2,3 | 77:2,4,5,6 78:9 | 45:17 9:24 49:25 1313278 |Notaryé9:5 [Oxlethorpe | 59:11 zo223211 noted 7712 | 63:10 apposes62. | 46:12 Ysi2ses — froteseaia — fohoet5.23:12 | "sh 22 pa 1:10, 31 56:1428 61:11 | notice 5:24.6:19 | 441757217 | | opposeass:e | 88:29 89:7 sivas [621 261202716) "eragi2. [ROUT 6:14 notieed3422 | 2825412118 | opposition 7:21. | package 8424 negutve2os |"a7adas2s | 417,819.21 |"Noaia0 | PAGE28 negotiate 22:4 42:2,3,6,7,16 55:19 85:1 pages 89:9 372 88:11 4795012 | orders 60:5. | paint 0:18 neighborhood | 25:25 54:10,11 62:10 | Ordinary 81:1 | Palmetto 1:6 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-9808 Page 14 3:23.24 67,12 8:13°10:12,19 10:22 12:17 1425199 37:25 40:18 42:15 46:2 55:11 66:4 Palmetto's 6:21 panels 59:13 paper 76:18 86:17 paralleling 62:4 parallels 61:25 paraphrasing 33:25 pardon 83:19 parent 47.9 Parkers 28:12 29:2 parkway 78:25 part 14:4,6,24 156,17 21:22 23:2428:25, 3421 particular 11:12 13:14,17 70:18 particularly 27 parties 89:6,12 90:13 party 90:10,13 path 22:2 pathetic 2:5 Patton 68:12 (69:22,2425 pay 15:10.27:14 3518 37:1 52:17 53:11 54:49,18,20 65:16 73:7 74:10 85:17,18 a73 paying 59:1,14 S95 yyments 28:23 sach 37:21 40:14,16,17 pending 6:3 39:2 people 8:21 9:6 9:20 22:15,16 34:11 3621 40:12,19 41:7 41:12 43:7 449 52:43, 53:21 56:25, 61:7,12 63:19 63:20 649,14 64:16 65:7 66:8 67-21 6815.6 71:9 735.6 7525 76:15,23 78:2 78:13 79:14 80:5,17 87:8 87:10,11,14 people's 10:20 percent 14:1,8 16111224 1743130 46:13 46:14 67:2 86:11 percentage Sell perfectly 36:5 period 4:24 75:18 permanently 2319 permission 16:21,25.25, 546 permit 62 51:20 (69:20 86:6 persisted 66:18 person 9:7.9,10 9:22 183.4 649,15 70:25 88:6 personal 38:14 4219 perspective 15:25 76:6 petition 5:8 26:17 petitioner 26:19) petrochemical 66:7 petrochemicals ors, petroleum 19:23 26:21 39:16 41:24 59:21 pets 77:17 pharmacy 37:15 Phinizy 46:11 46:1 PHMSA 40:4 phonetie2:10 23:21 24:3,13 30:7 piek 70:5 pileture 40:25 50:18 pictures 28:10 281114 piece 40:25 52:8 52:25 53:13 76:18 88:16 pieces 52:22 pine 7477 pipe 13:18 25:14 43:7 50:21 pipeline 1:36 3:23.24.04 4:2 47,10 5:1822 6781277 8:13 10:6 11-7 12:5,9,13,17 1224 13:5 14:19 15221 16:14 17222 18:1820 199 19:18,19.22 20:1,2,9,10,23 2131618 23:2 22:5 24:17,23 24:23 25:10,14 25:19 26:6,18 26:23 27:9,10 2711523 31:12 31:2232:10 33:25 34:1,2 34:18,19 36:19 375,10:38:1 39.24.25 40:5 40:89,18.22 40:23,24 41:1 4114'42:11,14 42:18,20 444 44:23:24 45:24 463,19.28 47111 48:59 48:22 49:4,5;6 503,13,19 54:19 55:4,11 55:19 58:2,17 58:24 59:17 615,615 6221 624,17 83 63:25 65:17 66:4,4,6 67.9 67:21 683, 69:14 73:6,10 41 15:18, 80:25 81:2 8454.23 85:12 87: pipelines 5:18 19:13,24 20:15 20:18 35:1,2 3948.22 40:11,12423 42:14 43:18 473 48:95, 49:22 50:16 58:8 69:18, 74:16 753 74 79225, 808,11 85:13 pitfalls 58:7 place 35:15 39:10 placed 36:23 73:25 places 40:5 45:4 plan 87:6 planning 4:21 31:12 plans 13:24 40:1 plant 65:15 plantation 12:23 494 Plantations: 24:14 platform 41:8 platforms 41:1 4118 42:16 playing 48:23, 499 pleasant29:21 please 3:15 7:24 822 9:14,17 10:2 23:1 46:1 46:2,3 63:6 6435 65:17 67:9 72:20 Ti BBS pleasure29:19 pled 20:20 plenty 36:21 3713, plume 66:7 Plus 32:16,18 point 16:23 26:7 27:261:13 pointed 76:18 pointing 35:9 points 13:11 26:7 27223 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 15 | 36:16 65:12 | president 1-2 | 16221722 | 1125 protect22:3 poles 25:14 412 23:1037:12 | projects 1:17 | 31:15 33:2 | policy 62:22 | pressed 63 | 38:9,104718 | 12:981:20 | 304245318 political 24:2 | pretty 67-16 | 70:1971:13,21 | promised 41-24 | 56:11 61:2 42:19 previous4:13 | 78:15 58:9 O17 75:1 | politicians 82:3 | 7:6 producer 62:10. | promoted 33:9 | 79:14 | 82:7,10 previously 4:9 | produet11:9,10 | proof27:4 46:6. | protected 31:6,9 pollution 75:17. | price 37:2.3 1:11 126,16 | §2:11 S4:1 69:16 portion 23:20 | 83:11 15:2,49,21 | properS:24 | protecting31:4 ports 62:5 priced 49:1 23:23 40:10 | proteetion 6+ poses 61:6 prices 14:24 properties 42:9 | 53:17 74:20 position 61:21 | 15:1 83:11,21 51:19.66:13 | proteetions positive 15:5 | 83:22 property 15 | 35:15 51:14 208 pride 75:11 5:16.24 16:22 | protester 47:14 possess 23:23 | primarily31:4 | produets3:24 | 17:5,7 18:21 | proud 58:6 Possibly 32:20) 87:15, 11231225 | 20:12,13 2419] 75:24 post31:19 | printeds0:10 | 13:7 1420 | 26:1027:5 | prowaty 26:1 poster 39:25 | prior 5:20 15:6 19:23 32:11 3813 | 81:18 61:24 priority 31:10 | 26:2174:6 | 39:5 40:19 | proves2:8 potential 20:13. | prison 38:24 | professional :2 | $2:13.42:89 | proven81:9,11 potentially 6:8 | private 21:2 732 43:11 46:15,16 | 81:11,13 3741386 | 26:1037-17 | profit21:8.9,10 | 52:6,79,10,12 | provideo:24 73, pound 32:14 | 38:1339:5, 375,17 | 52:21,22.23 | tt 178 pounds32:8 | 429134713 | 4204323 | $335412,146 | 486,10 5822 power i6:sl4 | 5215342 | 61-0214 55:25 56:5,9 | $9:16 73:11 251142699 | o1:kest821 | 97:1988:3,3 | Se116s13 | 90:7,10 26:11 30:18 | 68:2269:11,15 | 88:10 67:15 68:18,21 | provided 7:18, 52:10564 | 74:1975:7 | profts42:744:2| 69157423, | 721977312 59:21,22 7610) soize7sie | ssuusse2s | 75:778:3 | provider 13:3 88:10 programs 58:23 | 80:1385:20 | provides5:20 powerful 37:18 prohibited 90:9 | 87:1988:9 | providing 17:14 Dractices 25:9 project7:7 8:12 | proposals 62:6 | 55:11 precedent 37:16 8:16 10:14 | proposes8:3 | provision 7:1 precious 69:10 | probably7:19 | 11:1,41922 | proposed 1:3 | 24:1 predecessor | 78:2479:18 | 12:017,17 42,96:7,19 | provisions 90:6 29:20 problem 2618 | 13:9.15'141,7 | 111,19 19:9 | publie3:2225 prematurely | 79:24 141625 15:7 | 19:18.2220:8 | 4:8,11,11,17 379) problems20:¢ | 15:10,16,18.19 | 21:15,18 50:21 | 4:23 5256.15 PREPARED | 20:1839:25 | 15:20.22' 1610) Sia6x17 | 6192173347 rs 67:4 68:2 Traits 26.21 | 69:14 T1156 present 8:14 | 70:198618 | 25-2031:16,18 | proposing 11:13 | 8:11 9:2,11 10:1231:5 | proceedings | 31:2048:9, 12413623 | 10:13,13 14 presented 4:16 | 5:21 81:16,18 17512325 15:23,24 23:22 preserve 75:1 | process 15:25 | projections | proposition 19:6 | 24:2,425:17 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 16 26:16,19,23 27:7.24 28:7 45:25 46:5 47:16,16 48:20 49:17 50:1,7,8 51:16,17 52:2 55:5 $6:14,21 56:22 584 6LS79,1114 62:16,18 68:20 69:89,18 7811 81811 81:12,25,25,25 82:2,11,20 83:3 88:8,17 88:23 89:5 publicly 7:11 2182738 suit purpose 9:25 15243117 79:16 Pursuant 90:2 pursue 47:12 push 83:24 ut 30:12,13,16 30:16,17 33:6 33:19°35:15 4124321 46:28 482 Sh3,13,17 S417 S6:10.22 63:17 67:22 76:14 85:4 86:17 88:4 puts 40:19 80:24 putting 54:19 9 ‘qualified 73:16 ‘quality 60:25 612 (quarter 39:14 39:15, ‘question 21:1 47177 ‘questions 9:24 105 12:21 3516778 ‘quiek 26.7 quickly $12 quit 86:15 quite 36:16 46:19 52:8, 8 quote39:10 48:8, R R12 995,19 REN-A G24 radiation 66:2 railroad 16:14 raked 47:2 rally 33:23 76:6 range 33:89 rashes 66:22 rate49:4 90:13 rates 27:14 496 reach 51:6 reaching 17:4 read 20:23) 27:15 28:5 57:1663:14 84:22 86:4,6.7 87:17 readily 80:1 readiness 31:21 reading 57:9 ready Reagan 13:4 real 52:2 57:9 87.21 really 8:6 13:1 23:15 2635 30:12 45:19) 49:10 $5:18. 79:18 83:21 85:22 87:11 reams §2:11 reason 36:20 39:20 43:12,14 60:16,17 82:14 82:17 86:2 817 reasonable 6:18, reasoning 82:21 82:23 83:5,6 reasons 20:5.5 25:9 39:6 50:7 50:15 reassert 23:18 reeall 7:16 received 4:14,19 recipient 77:22 recognize 23:14 recognizes 26:15, recommend 2 reconstruction ST record3:6 9:11 20:3 25:23 27:25 28:15 618 recorded 39:7 recourse 22:3 reereational 60:23,24 reduce 51:18 reek 75:3 referral 90:11 referred 39:19 refine 16:2 refined 11:23, 1225 13:7 14:20 15:6 refineries 80:8 refrain22:17 refute 20:4 regarding 9:1 regardless 20:16 region 13:24 L 60:20 Register 45:10 45:10,11 registered 71:23, T2 regular 23:18 regularly 25:4 regulate 373 regulations 6:6 617 7141.23 425.903 regulatory 69 3036 rehash 45:22 reign 48:21 reintroduce ‘61:23 rolated 10:3,4,5 30:22 62:16 relationship 90:5 relevant 10:13, reliability 18:22 remained 69:8 remaining 14:12 remark $1:10 remarking 58:5, remarks 19:8 ‘remember 10:2 288 4415 65:14 71:22 7920 Rena 68:12 69:22,24 render 6:20 repairs 784 repeatedly 42:4 replant 85:18 report 39:18 672 reported 26:12 reporter 1:12 211,21 9:48 158 9:16 89:19 90:1,41 Reporter's2:12 reporters 86:14 reporting 1:16 90:3,5,7.8.810 90:11,12,17 represent 3:22 3411 439 356 representative 2:5 1012.21 76:20 representatives 8:14 10:9 18:25 38:10, 44:14 76:19,20 86:21 represented 261 78:14 republican 84:9 request 11:10 16:21 37:8 69:19 requested 12:8 require 58:16,22, required 26:17 33:5 requirement 8:1 33:2 34:23,23, requirements 66,10 research 55:9 resembled 66:23 reserved 27:6 reside9:18 resident 37:24 40:18 70:12, residential 46:24,24 residents 59:1 66:19 McKee Court Reporting, Inc 912-238-8808 Page 17 10:7 69:9 75:18 77:20 respect 22:25 382 respectful9:7 respectfully 46:1 49:14 response 60:5 responsibilities 6819 responsibility 385 53:12 54:10 69:20 responsible 35:10,12 56:10 eos responsive 60:5 rest 9:6 59:20 restore31:17 restored 41:7 restoring 74:13, result 26:23, 74:16 retained 2:20 reveal 20:25 Revenue 55:7 reverts 85:17, reviewed 10:6 Revolutionary 169 Richmond 1:7.8 31:837:23,24 72989:78 ridden 81:17 ide 87:2 right 3:75:15 13:19 4:17 18:8 19:5 20:10 22:1 23:17,19 269 27:56 30:13, 37113825, 42.25 43:8,23, 44:22 5225 53:21,22,23 55:13 59:16 62:24,25 65:19 72:17 73:24 74107741 84:21 85:1 86:10 87:16 888 rights 21:3, 36:24 97:18) T4i28 rigs 41:21 42:4 Rincon 79:11 risk 32:19 40:20 63:17 risks $118 risky 20:16 iver 34:10,12 45:17 4923, 50:4,420,23 50:25 511,16 68:15 rivers 51:14,18 63:13 69:36 TANT T5112 THLAS road 21:14 28:28 32:7 33:28 43:10 47:15 roads 56:20 Roberts 28:1 Robinson 31:1,2 rode 28:9 47:14 8538 roll 80:17 room34:13 roughly 60:20 round 83:9 route 6:20 16:7 16:12 routed 16:9 routine 39:22 routing 16:2 Roy 36:13 37:20 37:22,23 6:5 RPRI1289:5, 9:19 rubber 76:14 ruining 51:8 rule 38:6,7, 55:17 65:2 Rales 90:2 run d0:1 46:21 rung 32:24 running 17:8 25:18 30:15 8522 runs 65:13 rupture 50:12 50:20 ruptured 66:6 Russ 63:5 64:1 Russell 18:24 Ruthie 77:3 781719 Ryan 46:10 47:5 417 82:16 SD-ORFF 83 STEPH... 638 sacred 74:25 saeriffcing 42:8 2:11 safer 69:5, safety 21:11 23:25 36:18. 39:24 40:59 41:23 61:17 Salzbargers 36:2.63:10 Sanders 23:6 24:9,9,10 sa 72:24 Satilla 49:23 5012,4,4,25 S116 isfied 60:7 ‘Savannah 1:18 131 M1118 24:23 28:10) 33:17 34:10,12 36:9 61:25 5 63:9 0:12 74:3 76:4 80:1 86:5, 87:2 88:1 save 59:24 83:13 83:14,23 saved 83:12,18 savings 87:15 saw7:19 saying 26:18 33:28 35:10 53:24 55:4 57:2 76:16 813 says 4:20 28:5,9 66:10 67:5 7624 seary 49:11 seene 46:19 schedule 15:24 scheduled 4:17 4:23 19:10. schools 79:24 Schwear 18:10 18:10 25:7,12 23:12 scientist 67:6 Sereven 16:5 ‘24:11,15 57:5 seaboard 75:5,6 seal 89:15, Sean 45:10,13 search 20:24 783 seat 48:20 second 423 7:12 716 84-15, 88:17 Secondly 7:14 seerecy 76:10 secrets 76:12 section $:13,19 23:16 90:6 sections 5:20 sector 61:8 security 82:14 R216 089:20 56:6 B11 704,13 71: 73:28 85:9,23 88:16 seek 62:22 seen 8:9 33:11 44:13 78:1 $0362 46:23, 88:6,7 semis 72:12 senators 70:16 send 70:5 82:1 sending 86:7 sense 5:2 30:22 $5:17 61:12 sensitive 7533 sent 82:14 separate 172 serious 20:4,21 35:16 82:15 servants 78:11 serve 48:16 served 29:23 614 serviee 12:13 24:22 383 Sea services 5:8 25:7 90:8,10 serving 48:18 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 18 492, set 34:24 35:13 37:16 89:14 settle 79:17 settled 56:2 seven 18:16 severe 25:3 75:2 shareholders 21:10 shed 50:2 sheet 8:20 35:25 36:1 sheets 8:8 shift 48:23 49:10 shifting 35:7 ship 12116 shippers27:14 29:12,13 7716 7:19) shipping 74:7 shirt 63:11 shocked 77:9 short 20:15 23:9 78:19 shouldered 38:4 shoulders 79:14 show 26:19 0:17 showed 76:6 showing 40:8 shown 46: shows: shrimp 75:13 ‘shrimping 75:15 shut 79:25 80:7 sic 7:13 24:6 sickening 66:8 Slerra 76:4 sign 838.20, 715 64:14, 685,7,7 70:2 1638 signed 8:17.18 42:23 64:10 significant 20:18 25:16. 48:10 513,18 617 significantly 1821 signing 12:15 silent 69:9. ‘Simons 77:6 simple 25:2 sins Ht65:14 situation 50:9 50:18 sx 48,14 726 Skidaway 28:24 skidder 32:15, 32221 skidders 32:17 skilled S821 593733 skin 66:22, slick 66:16 small 66:8 smart 26:24 65:24,25 smelled 66:9 ‘Smoke 63:2 smothered 41:20 smothering 42:16 society 19:4,7 sock 84:15 soft-spoken 43:5, s0i123:20 25:59 solar 59:5.13,23, solution 49:12 somebody 30:3 3544.5 76:17 someone's 62:16 81:6) Sonad 30:16 sored3:5 sorry 63:14 6418 65:2 38:20 sort 37:16 sorts 50:17 sound 51:8 sounds 65:6 source 14:21 South 4:3 12:3 13:9 193 21:24 73:4 43 southeast 13:5 ‘southeastern’ 1B ‘southern 13:8 14:4 29:20 sovereign 78:10 space77:24 Spalding 19:2 sparked 66:17 speak 5:97:11 8:99:22 183 19:6 37:12 38:25 50:1 60:3 68:25 70:2 76:1 88:16 speaker 3:5 522 3:2 speakers 2:10 45:21 61:17 76:28 speaking97,10 specific 10:5 11:18 13:12 specifically 5:13, 1323 speech 19:5 22:35 speeches 72:25 sspell9:15 spelled 21:3 6 spellings 2:10 spells 66:21 ‘spending 39:23 spill 20:21 34:24 34:28 35:7,14 36:4 50:24 52:19 S4:11,11 54:12 67:1 spills 63:3 67:7 (68:2 74:15,16 TH spoke 10:17 28:21 33:23 4222 poken 68:24 87.9 spread 51:7 spreading 5I:4 Springfield 35:23, St776 stacked 85:20 staff31:2 stakeholders 164 stamp 59:8 76:14 stad 23:3 28:18 55:17 69:19 70:2 86:21,21 standards 27:22 61:18 standing 34:13 start 1:10 55:3 6:15 78:14 84:20 started 16:10 66:1 starting 37:16 starts 25:10 starve 39:21 state 23 3:14,20 5:18 6:109514 9:15,17 12:25 13:18 14:16,18 15:14,1822 16:1 179,20 17.21.24.18:16 21:5,20 23:17 23:20,24 24:1 2773817 39.6 41:24 B13 4414 48:14 543.8 55:15 58:4 63:19 67:2 9759) 76:19 78:10 19:23 83:15,17 83:23 86:20 87:18 88:5,10 89:1 statement 2:12 30:5 states 12:3 13:1 13:6 20:3 42:7 50:13 58:6,11 279 B34 75:68 station 28:11,12 28:24) stations 11:15 1s statistics 50:11 statutes 6:25 stealing 87:13 stealth 71:8 step 4:7 Stephens 60:2 685,78 steps 4:6 20:16 Stewart 31:9,18 31-21 32:1 332 stock 29:7 44:2 Stocks 65:24 stop 42:19 59:18, McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 Page 19 59:19,19 62:20, 63:3 771 store 37:15 straight 10:19 strategy 39:21 streamed 66:5 streams 20:15 Street 1:7 39:18 59:8 stress 22:12 stroteh 87:1 strip 56:7 strongarm 68:20 strongly 24:16 24:20 struck 56:17 stuff68:1 80:18 subdivision 24:2 46:25 66:14 subject 1:6 6:16 submit 7:10.23 8:4.27:25 28:14 30:11 494 submitted 3:24 7:9 8:7 84:19 submitting 7.25 Subra67s ‘successfully 13:20 17.23 successor 38:23, sudden 71:20 suddenly 82:15, sue 78:10 suffered 66:20 sufficiently 46:5 suggest 58:8 7836 suie39:1,3.9 ‘summed 23:15 ‘supplied 19:22 ‘supplies 13:7 ‘supply 14:2,14 15:48 26:21 29:22 80:4,6 support 7.21 8:14.24 13:12 52:5 60:19 62.28 87:20 suppose 42:3, supposed 36:17 715 81:24 sure 12:12 24:21 35:14 36:5, 57:1 68:19 surface 24:22 survey 16:21,24 1625 surveying 85:24 survivors 41:8 suspect 61:21 sustain 60:15 744 Sustainable 60:10 sustaining 39:11 Suzette 1-12 895,19 swamps 51:5 69:14 swath 85:11 Sweeny 18:9 swell 54:25 sworn 305 Sylvania 24:10 symptoms 66:17 oT system 12:18,24 13:7 1420, 15811 162 1722 systems 17:23 T Tae TERR. 65:22 TONY 8625 TURNER 722 table 86:18 tables 20:14 fag 62:19.21 63:2 85:13, tainted 77:18 fake9:9 113 26:10 27:5 32:14 35:24 38:13 462 48:20 s1:10,11 52:13 53:2,11| 54:6 55:9,15 55:19 74:23 oss 80:14,14 0:17 81:24 82:19 85:15,15 86:15,16,19) 87:18 889 taken 20:9,16 52:10 56:5 takes 21:2 52:17 tall 11:4 17:17 17:17 264 43:24 64:15 765 talking32:22 36:18 38:11 55:11 71:21 talks 30.9 Tallapoosa 223 tanks 80:2 ‘Tanya 33:13 3469 tax 15!14 35:18 35:18 36:6 55:8,15 taxes 15:10375 59:1 65:17 77411 taxpayers 57:6 74:13, ‘Taylor 2:4 5:2,5 $:6,10 18:12, 22291 57:11,13 57:15,19 88:14 88:20 ‘teams 58:10) ‘technieal 25:2 1127.89.13 28:16 29:1421 30123113) 33:1,1435:2 35:17 48:23 548 636 721 BS 79:4 82.21.23 86:1 87:61 telling 79:3 temporarily 219 ten 10:18 11:20 52:12 64:13 8110 term20:15 terminate 13:10 terms 63:18, Terri 65:2,3,19 65:23, terrible 77:14 territory 23:24 test 27:24 40:9 testimony 89:10 ‘Texas 38:12 403 58:10 thank 5:5 17.25 18:13 22:8 25:21,23 28:15 5x12 3415 36:11 40:13 44:12 458,15 46:7 47:4 49:18,22,23 31:20 53:23 37:6 59:25 3:7.25 64:3 168:3,10 69:20, 70:672:14,19 73:12 75:19 TTA 789,15, 7916 80:18,22 88:12,14 thanks 10:23, 55:18 68:13 88:24 thereof 24:2 thiek 66:11 thievery 78:7 thing 21:1 3341 34:18 36:7,17 32:7 53:16 54:11 56:22 67:17 68:46 ost 71:22 12:6 85:4 things 5:23 7:25 3 24:20 34:21 44:18. 50:17 52:3 56:14 63:16 76:11 83:18 think 17:13 23:7 23:9,13 24:19 29:6 35:12 37-7.7 45:4 53:25 S415 622.323 63:10,16,19 71:13 761: 77:1421 80:10 82:3 86:7 thinks 52-4 81:21 third 7:16 3525 36:31:16 thought 48:2 169) McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-6808 Page 20 thoughts 11:1 61:23 thousand 44:25 37:2 83:10 thousands 41:6 41:7 42:16 87:14,25 88:4 threat 61:7 threatening 5:22 754,10 three 5:23 62 7.102815 32223338 62.9 66:18 67:1 s3:18,25 throat 3:5 tidbit 44:19 tidbits 44:8 tides 51:3,12 tiered 49:5 ‘Tilfany 2:21 timber 24:14 25:20 31:5, 52:24,25 53:14 53:16,25 time 412 6:25 8:199:9,21 1o.1,14,21 178 22:14 23:22 2412 25:8 28:14,21 33:12,22 34:16 4819519 57:9 62:6 (64:13,15 65:1, 684 82:13, R415 857 86:4 89:10 times 30:1 tiny 75:13 fp 452.3, title 0:5 77.25 783 today 5:10,12 7151323, 19:8 25:25 26:15 28:4.9 28:17 29:4.16 30:18 33:25 352043315, 414.492 62:17 16:1623 78:13,21 878 today's 10:2 told 67:19 69:4 7912 86:23, tolerance 32:18 tonight 7:12 8:109:6,17,21 1025 11:16 122217:16 36:17 47:20, 604.612, (68:14,17 69-11 726,24 16:59 76.17.19 88:15 88:16 tonight's 4:16 504 8:12 ‘Tony 84:7 86:19 ar top 62:10 tornado 85:11 tourism 60:23 63:15,15 touting 43:20 town 914 toys 7:17 ‘tractor 4:15 ‘tractors 24:23 traffic 727.13 transeript 1:15 2:13 89:10 transeripts 7:6 translates 14:9 transparency 48:21 49:13,14 transport 19,9 11:13 12:5 15:2,941:1 50:22 51:13 transportation 1:22:6 3:21 5271024 11:7 15:1 18:23 ails 40:7 48:4 49:15 3529 $6:13,19 63:24 transports 12:24 travel 51:49 traveling 72:11 ‘treasured 69:12 ‘trees 44:24 45:5 S15 85:16,17 85:18) tremendous 7asl4 ‘Trespass33:21 ‘trouble 29:3.24 20:25 30:2,2 40:2 62:3 ‘Troy 34:7 36:14 truck 14:20 32:8 32:15,20 34119 35:4 67:23 723,12 trucks 24:24 5016.23 72:10 trues9'9 ‘trust 31:3 39.24 42:3 56:14.20 78.22 82:18 try 79:14 frying 12:1 46:22 48:16 a3 turbines 59:5 turn 3:5,8,9,15 35:11 42:18 59:3 ‘Turner $717 72:1521,21,22 twice 29:19 42:23 83:13,14 two d:11 5:25 9:29 22:13,18 Bidd.2 26:7 5:16.24 33:8 43:17 36:4 (60:19 62:4,20 64:4,2022,24 69:13 76:11,19 33.22 ‘two-pronged 299) ‘tworyear 77:24 typically 25:4 28:23 a 083923 40:6 Uberous 44:6 terior 61:21, ultimately 11:11 14 unbelievable 25:15, underground 25:13 vunderstand25:1 44:5 71:16 understated 39:1 undertaking 63:17,22 ‘undone 32:25 uneducated 78:2 ‘unemployment 593 unfortunate 63:20 unfortunately 86:14 United 13:1,5 20:3 42:7 50:13 62:79 ‘untrained 78:2 updated 40:8, ‘upstream 50:24 usage 11:23 use 11:25 14:7 20:1221:13 243,446.23, 59.211 74:10 83:4 87:12 ‘uses 79:21 83:10 ‘usual 90:12 asualy $820, utility 23 3:14 3:2027:7 vtiize 37:17 —s Valdes 41:12 valuable 74:18 value 79:19 valves 50:17 ‘Vancouver 39235 variety 18:19 60.28 various 19:23, so:15 vary 25:8 vehicles 28:22 28:22, venture 47:13 39:23 62:16 verbiage 39:14 vibration 33:6 vibrations 23:4 33-711 vice 11:2 vicinity 67:3 Vietovia 36-12 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. ‘912-238-8808 viewpoint45:6 | 7811522795 | 8:21,23 11-12 | wider 85:14,14 Vineey 45:14 | 82:18,19,2223 | tig i2ta | 8: violations 39:7 | 84:1 87:6 88:4 | 13:2,6,1422 | wilatifes0:20 virgining 62:8 | wanted33:18 | 15:125 1712 | 429,12 visible25:13 | 7625 17:15,19 22:14 | williams 77:3, | 2525 voice 78:21 87:5 | wanting 77:19 | 23:931:323 yard 81:44,5.6 vvolumes9:7 | wants27:5 3222335 yards 66:15 volunteering | 3813412 | 34:5 36:17 yeah 27:12 | 763 31623 871 | 4224525 | wis 4417 WAS.AS vomited 66:19 | 8711 64:16,17 77.21 | wish TiAl 82:5 vores0:15,16 |warte9 2322 | si:218412 | 29:56 year 29:18 31:24 votes 83:1 Washington | 86:15,16,19 | WITNESS 38:20 59:12 Vulnerable 7:8 | 13:2 we'ved'8 118 | 89:14 83:7,10,1213 | wasnt 217 |°11:2013:20 | witmessed 60:18 | 83:15,23, 3822 82:12 | 16:19,23 19:10 | woods 32:7,15 | years 11920 watch 38:6 31:1634:22,28 | "32:20 12117334 | 6515 71:5 | 36:2137:13" | word 28:8 84:22 | 18:17 20:19 watchings6:23 | 50:69:11 | words 2:14 | 21:6 25:17 water20:14 | 78:1280:13 | 28:759:15 | 2623117 ‘Wade 24:13 41:22,25 46:17 | wearing 63:12 | work 8:5 25:14. | 32:23 33:18 wagging 2:21 | 46:1850:2 |websitet2:19 | 3i2ssz8 | 3823399 waitaiets 7247] 67.2376 — |weedsosis | 3415478 | 41:4.611.21 7219 waters 41:3,20 [weekssitia | 599 44921,25 waite7217,18 |"4217 5119 |weekssi:12 worked 79:20 | 53:16,7$6:18 73:18,18,19.21 | waterways workers 15:17 | 60:13629 73:21,24 19:15 67:24 | weights 24:25 28:1 734,11 67:1 TIL WatMart368 | wayess.2s | Welv11289:5 | working 7:15 |years'31:24 36:10 way 12:8 13:2 1725 31:16 | Yeller 24:6 wall39:18, 14151723 |weleomess:17 | 66:38 2524 Walnut 20:22 | 18:1,1 20:10 | wellsdi:19 | works 67:6 | Yellin 248.8, want: 10:18 | 21:10,15 22:6 | Wendy'ss8:5 | world 20:1 25.23.0428 178 220112 } 32483745" | went85:11 $9.206210 | 26527213 30ai1t23 | agv7as.4o_ | "86:23 worse 6610 | 29:48721 3017323" | sa23'60.19 [wostS81t— worh31.24 | 9027. 344,16 36:9 71:12 85:12,23 | wet 32:16. Wow 45:18, ‘Yellin's 2:18 aizpas21 | 63 Yretlands 31:17 | writing0:s | yesterday 41:4 45:21 46.1617 | Waynesbore |""50:5,653:19 | writen 418 7:8 | Yield 6478.13 4794s” |“steseigg0 | 5325542 |"714i725 | oad oo 50:17 523.13 | Waynesvie | 693,710 748 | wrong 312,14 |——5——— saassi0 | rasant7 | 78a 8711622 889 542018 |ways7:10322 | whatmot506 | #89 casts 6423 | "3:24 WHERFOF |wrrssis | 5128552 7047223 well 1510469 | “89:14 WRESSIS |) giterouer 51:24 7520761 |we'rea:iz 512 |widess? | ___X_—__| $423.23 582 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-6808 Page 22 o — 12:18 26:7 442 443) 1.434:11 10443,3 45:3 ‘64:15 83:12 10.890:2 100 86:11 100-mile 75:11 4441 12 15:11 87:12 1200 15:17 14a 13th4:1 14387 1244.22 143.72:10 1553:6 6415 e414 15.14.3790:9 150 13:25 150,000 12:5 153 15th4:19,24 5:1 84 160,000 13:25 168 74:4 165,000 12:6 1675021 17008 79:13 1825:5 60:13 1823 18:16 18th 622, 19909 44:25 1998 26:13 19th623 184.20 2 225111 32: 201410 32:23 41:11,19 48:21 | 42s:10 32:56 | 84,00020:2 songs — | gaia 67:19 83:8,13 | 40,00032:14 83:23 841 | 60:20 20,000 36:8 83:7 | 42-inch 85:5 859 480 53:14 200,00031:6 | | 201041:5 —_s_ 2011 40:4 5:00 1:103:1 2013.66: 88:21 89:6 2015 1:9 89:7,15 | S014:1,8 50:24 20th 41:4 85:15 211:989:7 | $0,000 14:9 210-MILE 1:3 | $00 15:19 30:18 2225:5 66:13 | 52,00072:9 ma122316 — |5201:7 898 22-3-825:13,14 | 5821220, 2303022021 | 587,00053:5, 238-8908 1:19 | 2438223, a asa 2ekineh 85:5 asiaii gs:i6 | 60118 1724 2soo rath | 1817 672 Foo 36.9, | year 17:20 Have | misiesas |rares For tt sos aainees eas |R2EIL | nn gon "s 38804617 Lago st.an 30,000 31:9,13 | 78 71:25 85:6 0a 219.13. 7 tts Bots Sov.or8s7 Sonatas tag ias 31324 1:8 8821 Sata 118 | —y sion a2 38566 3300 86:24,24 | ort 32:16,19 86:13 | 86161112 46:14 40149959 |g 92:11 3 932:6,3,7,13 9-11-2890:6 96:18 16:24 174 84:20 9092 1:17 Ws 4:1 912 1:19 199-063 90:17 McKee Court Reporting, Inc. 912-238-8808 | HunterMaclean Ee ec at! arroaners Dentipinies ter nc Semi GA 42008 jetnhntamncm “April 21, 2015 EXHIB! | ‘Commissioner Russell MeMunty, PE, Georgia Department of Transporation ‘One Georgia Center {600 West Peachtree NW ‘Ailanta, Georgia 30308 RE: Exercise of Georgia Department of Transporttion’s Eminent Domain Power for Construction and Operation of Petroleum Pipelines Dear Commissioner MeMurry: ‘This law firm represents Colonial Oil Industries, Inc. (“Colonial”) with respect to the application ‘of Palmetto Products Pipe Line, LLC (‘Kinder Morgan”) to the Georgia Department of ‘Transportation (*GDOT"), roquesting & Cestficate of Public Convenience and Necessity for its proposed Palmetto Pipeline Project (“Pipeline”) ‘This lor is writen to express the deep concerns that Colonial has wih respect to Kinder Morgen’s application to use GDOT's eminent domsin power, as well as the alleged “convenience™ end “necessity” ofthe Pipeline. GDOT and Kinder Morgan have specific and very different responsibilities inthis process. The Georgia Assembly granted GDOT the power to act as “patekeeper” to those secking CDOT's cminent domain power. In this “gatekeeper” role, GDOT is tasked with analyzing whether an applicant, such as Kinder Morgan, has established thatthe proposed use of eminent domain convenient” and “necessary” to the Georgia public. Kinder Morgan, on the other hand, bears the Durden of proving it will only take property for a public use. ‘We submit chat, afer reviewing the facts and circumstances of this application and applying the relevant lav, Kinder Morgan cannot satisfy its burden of establishing the threshold requirements to obiain access to GDOT’s eminent domain power. We respectflly request that GDOT. exercise its role as “gatekeeper” and deny Kinder Morgan's application for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity HI HunterMaclean Mo! ATTORNEYS ‘Comnissioner Russell MeMurry, PE. Apail 21,2015 Page 2 1. Legal Standards for Granting Eminent Domain Power to Pipeline Companies ‘The Georgia Assembly granted GDOT the power to exercise eminent domain in certain specific circumstances. The Georgia Assembly recognized that eminent domain is an extreme measote roquiting limitation. In O.C.G.A. § 22-1-2(8), the Georgia Assembly wamed that no ‘condemning authority “shall use eminent domain unless itis for publie use. Public use is a _mater of law to be determined by the court and the condemnor bears the burden of proof.” Pursuant to O.C.G.A. § 22-1-3, fiftis the province of the General Assembly to determine when the right of eminent domain may be exercised.” Georgie lawmakers outlined very specific requirements pipeline companies must satisfy before GDOT may delegate’ eminent domain power through issuance of Cerificate of Public Convenience and Necessity. O.CG.A. § 22-3-83() sets forth some of those requirements as follows: (1) A requirement thatthe application for such eerifcate shall include a description of the proposed project including its general route; Q) a description of the public convenience and necessity which support the proposed pipeline routes @) the width of the proposed pipeline corsidor up to a maximum width of one-third miles and @) a showing that use of the power of eminent domain may be necessary to construction of the pipeline, and a showing that the public necessity for the petroleum pipeline jastifies the use of the power of eminent domain, (Emphasis added). A pipeline company must satisfy each ofthese requirements. Additionally, « pipeline company mast give reasonable public notice of the application for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity, s¢ must provide the public withthe proposed onto, and it most provide for # hearing on the application and the filing and hearing of any ‘objections to such application. O.C.G.A. § 22-3-8(6)@)43)). GDOT is suthorized to implement additional reasonable requirements of the pipeline company to eid in GDOT’s decision. O.CG.A. § 22-3-83(65). O.CG.A. § 22-3-83 makes GDOT the guardian of its eminent domain power. GDOT is given the authority to grantor deny Certificates of Public Convenience and Necessity and, in so doing, aa Commissioner Russell MoMory, PE, Apeil 21, 2015 Page 3 {is given the authority to share or withhold its power of eminent domain. GDOT must zealously prvleet its power agains Usove sock lo use i fae punjses ores than the public's best interest ‘Based on the foregoing statutes, it is clear that GDOT has the authority to delegate its eminent domain power to pipeline companies such as Kinder Morgan; however, what is equally clear is that the sbility to delegate the eminent domain power has been ertrusted to GDOT and the decision ~ whether to allow a private company to utilize the power of eminent domaia, right ‘otherwise reserved for the State of Georgia, orto deny such a delegation of power isa decision ‘that must be based on all of the facts presented by the applicant for such an extreme measure. II, What do “Public Convenience” and “Public Necessity” Mean in the Context of a Pipeline Company's Application for Use of GDOT’s Eminent Domain Power? O.CG.A. § 22-3-83(b) requires that pipeline companies demonstrate the “public convenience” and “public necessity” of a proposed pipeline before GDOT may issue a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity. But how does GDOT determine whether public convenience and necessity have been shown? What factors should be considered? Georgia courts have not addressed these specific issues; however, a 1998 Illinois case dealing with a nesly identical set ‘of facts and iroumstances is instructive. In Lakehead Pipeline Co. x. Mlinois Commerce Com’n, 296 IlLApp.3d 942 (1998), Lakehead Pipeline Company (“Lakchosd”) wanted to construct an ofl pipeline and to be awarded the state's power of eminent domain, Lakehead intended to construct a pipeline through several rural inois counties to deliver erude oil to refineries inthe Midwest. Similar to Kinder Morgan's ‘application currently before GDOT, the Mlinois Commerce Commission also required an application for a Cettifcate of Public Convenience and Necessity. The Mlinois Commerce Commission denied Lakehead’ application, because Lakehoad could not show a public need for the additional crude oil to be transported via the proposed pipeline. In finding an absence of public need, the Hlinois Commerce Commission found that an adequate supply of petrolemn products already existed in the affected area, and thatthe proposed pipeline would not esult in ‘any positive effect om the market in the arc affected. (On appeal, the Mlinois Court of Appeals agreed with the Illinois Commerce Commission's denial ‘of Lakehead’s application, holding that there was no regional need for the pipeline, but instead only a desire by a private company to deliver more crude oil tp cefineies in the Midwest. Lakehead Pipeline Co, . Iinois Commerce Com'n, 296 Il. App.34 942 (1998). ‘This Minois case is strikingly similar to the circumstances surounding Kinder Morgan's application for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity. Like Lakehead in Iino, Kinder Morgan has not and cannot seisfy its burden of proof end demonstrate that Georgia has a seam tomicie hsicinane AR raceme smn cto Commissioner Russell MeMurry, PE April 21, 2015 Page + public need for additional supply of petroleum products. Kinder Morgan has not and cannot ‘stablish there willbe any nct postive effect on the Georgia market. We have heard whut could [happen and what might happen, but we have no proof of what will happen. m. m san Diselosed and Not Disclosed about i sd Pipeline? Kinder Morgan, as the party seeking condemnation power, bears the burden of proving that its proposed pipeline is for a public use. Faced with this burden, however, Kinder Morgan has disclosed surprisingly litle information to establish any public use or benefit to the public as & result of its proposed pipeline. Instead, Kinder Morgan has relied on simplistic and speculative statements that a public use and benefit will result from its proposed pipeline. What could ‘happen and wit might happen isnot sufficient. We submit that when a private company seeks tuse of GDOT's eminent domain power to take private property trom Georgie citizens for a venture that will undoubtedly generate financial gain for the private company, GDOT must require more than unsubstantiafed statements fom the private company that the public will benefit. In one of the more glaring statements from its February 13, 2015 application submitted to ‘GDOT, Kinder Morgan stated the Pipeline “will promote competition within the markets," which could serve to decrease prices.” (February 13, 2015 application at p. 3). This statement is, at ‘best, speculation because Kinder Morgan refuses to provide any of the necessary information to ‘assess whether the proposed pipeline would promote competition or decrease prices. At worst, the statement is misleading because the Pipeline, by Kinder Morgan's own admission, could deliver more petroleum into Savannah (25,000 barrels per day) than the entre market curently consumes (approximately 20,000 bartels per day), In other words, the Kinder Morgan Pipeline has the potential to replace al existing competition, an issue not considered and an outcome not addressed in its application. ‘To assess whether the proposed pipeline wonld promote sompettion or decrease prices, Kinder ‘Morgan must disclose specific information about its plans, including but not limited to its pricing structure for petroleum products that will be transported through the pipeline. Information that ‘must be disclosed to conduct this analysis includes the following: ‘+ How many shippers ave contested for space on the Pipeline ? © Who are these shippers and do these shippers currently do business in the Aestination markets? meng unin, 206 Sin Se An uc OMice Ba 98S Smaah GA SHAL20018 Commissiones Russell MeMutry, PE. April 21, 2015 Page 5 + At what volume has exch shipper committed in each destination market? ‘© Whats the rate structure fr all shippers on the Pipeline? ‘+ How much will t costa shipper to transport product from Belton, South Carolina to North Augusta, Belton to Savannah, and Belton to Jacksonville? ‘+ How do these transportation cates compare to the cost of existing transportation ‘options into each destination market? [None ofthis information has been disclosed tothe public. ‘Without this information, neither the public, nor GDOT, can assess whether Kinder Morgan's ‘assertion that the Pipeline “could serve to decrease prices” has any merit whatsoever. We respectfully request that GDOT require that Kinder Morgan disclose this information before ‘deciding on Kinder Morgan's application so the necessary analysis can be conducted, including ‘he involvement of independent experts as GDOT may deem necessary. Unlike the clear negative impact of condemnation facing many Georgia citizens who have clearly articulated their grievances on record for GDOT, Kinder Morgan's porported claim of pablie benefit remains ently uncertain. But one thing is certain ~ the impact on Georgia citizens must be discussed, analyzed, and fully vetted before Kinder Morgan is given the power ‘of eminent domain that will allow the taking of private propeity of Georgia citizens. There can ‘be no discussion or analysis until there is fall disclosure by Kinder Morgan. Anything less then. full disclosure of all aspects of the Pipeline is an affront to Georgia citizens. GDOT must not allow Kinder Morgan to shir its esponsibility to the Georgia public. Don't Georgians deserve full disclosure before GDOT decides whether Kinder Morgan is entitled to use eminent domain? In addition to the nondinclooure of etitical information needed by GDOT, there are also tunsetling gaps in the information concerning who will use the Pipeline. Please consider the following: ‘Kinder Morgan has stated that it has received commitments from certain shippers (“Committed Shippers”) to purchase up to 90% of the Pipeline’s capacity. If the number of Committed Shippers is small, but those Committed Shippers control 90% of the total volume of product the pipeline will generate, then that small group of Committed Shippers has the ability to comer the Imarket in Southeast Georgia. In effect, those Committed Shippers will have such a high percentage of the total amount of petroleum product in the region that the Commited Shippers veang temteee nonsienintme LR) nomena sm ctsnsen ‘Commissioner Russell MeMurry, PE. Apsil 21,2015 Page 6 can price all competition out of the market, The end result of ths scenario is not better pricing land more eompettion for the Georgla consumer. Insta, i will eealc an oligopoly whereby a few firms will control the fuel market in the region and have the ability to raise the price of petroleum products in Southeast Georgia. ‘Why does Kinder Morgan's Pipeline reward “higher volume” shippers? The two existing pipelines serving Georpis are “one size fits all” pipelines where the cost to transport petroleum is the same for big and small buyers, ensuring a level playing Geld in our State. Kinder Morgan's ‘proposed Pipeline, which will spli off from one of the existing Georgia “one-rate” pipelines, will slant the playing field in favor of large shippers through it use of a “tiered rate” system. Kinder Morgan, in. futile attempt to justify is tired rate system, has publicly stated that it will charge atleast $0.01 per barel ($.0002 per gallon) more to Committed Shippers than it will charge to “similarly situated” shippers who have not committed to purchase volume at this time ("Uncommitted Shippers"). We have no idea whether Uncommitted Shippers, which are by Cefinition shipping smaller volumes, could possibly compete against large Committed Shippers ‘with steep pricing discounts in higher volume tiers. Ifa pricing discount is given for volume ‘purchasing, will an Uncommitted Shipper ever be similarly situated to a Committed Shipper? ‘Don’t we need to know the cost of product transportation, the impact ofa tiered pricing system, ‘and how sach a system will benefit the public before Kinder Morgan is awarded the right to take private property as ematter of public necessity and convenience? {nits February 13, 2015 application fo GDOT, Kinder Morgan stated the “southeast region of the United States" has “critical need” for additional petroleum products. (February 13, 2015 application at p. 2), Fist, Georgia's “need” for petroleum prodacs is the only “need” GDOT is to consider in assessing a private company's application to exercise GDOT's eminent domain ‘power to take private property from Georgia citizens. The relative “need” of markets other than Georgia is not a factor in deciding whether to grant eminent domain power to Kinder Morgan. ‘Seoondly, Kinder Morgan does not ack up the statement that a “eritical need” is present in the Southeast region of the United States. In reality, there is not a “critical need” for additional petroleum products in Georgia, because gasoline prices in Georgia, net of taxes, ae some of the Towest in the country and, accarding to the most recently avauable dsta released by the United States Energy Information Administration, Georgia’s demand for gasoline, diesel and ethanol have declined by 18% since their peak in 2005, Interestingly, gasoline prices in Florida, net of ‘taxes, are some ofthe highest in the Southeast. Kinder Mongan’s application also contains material factual misstatements that lead the reader to ‘question whether it has conducted even an elementary analysis as to whether the Georgia public ‘would benefit from the Pipeline, For example, Kinder Morgan stated “[cjumrenty, marine ‘transport is the only source of supply [of petroleum products] to Savannah and Jacksonville markets.” In reality, Savannah is primarily supplied petroleum products by trucks driven from ce, tai ensaniee Rl tot raises Commissioner Russel] MeMurry, P-E. Apa 21, 2015 Page 7 existing pipelines in Macon and Augusta. Unlike Jacksonville, marine transport actually makes ‘up only a small percentage of the total petroleum product supplled to Savannah. Kinder Morgan's unsubstantiated claim that its Pipeline will generate up to 28 new jobs (not all of which are in Georgia) is misleading, because it ignores the fact that each gallon delivered {rom its proposed Pipeline will offset a gallon already being delivered to market. As the Pipeline displaces gallons on existing supply chains it will also displace the associated jobs. Considering Kinder Morgan's spplicstion demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of Georgia's ‘existing supply chains, it follows that it osnnet have properly evaluated the net impact to Georgia jobs, Kinder Morgan predicts thatthe Pipeline will temsport 167,000 barrels of petroleum per day, ‘with an ungusrantged maximum of only 25,000 of those bacrels being delivered direcly into Georgia. What preven's shippers’ use of Kinder Morgan's Pipeline to transport all 167,000 barrels of petroleum across Georgia, every day, solely to fed another state's fuel markets that ‘command higher premiums? Why should fifty-eight percent (58) of the Pipeline be located in Georgia, when Kinder Morgen cannot guarantee the first drop ofthis petroleum product will stay in Georgia? By their owm admission, tht decision Ties in the hands of their shippers, who remain unknown, but who will surely be motivated to move every possible barrel to the highest price market: Jacksonville, Florida, Kinder Morgan has made a number of promises and ‘unsubstantiated statements in support of its Pipeline; however, the obvious, though unstated, result is that Georgia will bear a high cost for the Pipeline, but will reap litle bene. IV. Critical Implications to State Interests are Unconsidered. Georgia's two petroleum ocean temminals are critical to ensuring the security of Georgia's petzoloum supply and therefore implicate vitel State economic and security interests. By Kinder Morgan's own admissions, the contemplated Richmond Fill terminal will have the capacity to displace all existing competition in the Coastal market, including these two ocean terminals. Since Kinder Morgan will not disclose any information required to evaluate the competitive Impact on existing supply chins, Qeoryin must onder the very seal possibility that the existing ‘ocean petroleum terminals will be forced out of the petroleum market at the hands of an oligopoly established by the Pipeline and its tered pricing structure. Georgia's two ovean terminals have a petroleum storage capacity in excess of 1.5 million bares, ‘which is enough to supply the entire state for nesely 4 days. Pipeline terminals, on the other hand, typically have only a fiaction of the same storage capability. When Hurticanes Katrina ‘and Rita damaged the United States Gulf Coast refining complex, Colonial’s oceen terminal ‘sopported product dolveries as far inland as Atlanta and Northem Georgia. ‘Kinder Morgan's application alleges thet it will help ensure continuous supply; in fact, by eliminating ovean vagy ttn srttnintnn AG) motets tna ‘Commissioner Russell MeMurry, PE. Apiil 21, 2015 Page 8 ‘terminal competition, it will eave Georgia wholly dependent upon the Gulf Coast, eliminating existing supply optionality and significantly increasing exposure to the risk of “inclement ‘weatber" on the Gulf Coast. (Ocean terminal inffastracture changes are long-term in nature. Onee a terminal has bees replaced or modified, there is no “light switch” that can be turned on in the event a natural disaster

You might also like