Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
info@braheen.com
fb.braheen.com
t.braheen.com
y.braheen.com
..
(
) .
.
.
()
.
()
()
.
- -
- -
( .)Kenneth Miller
.
()
()
.
() .
() Chance Randomness
.Speciation
() .
() .
--
()
( ) " :
.
. .
".
. -
()
-
.
-
)( .
-
Pettazzoni, Raffaele (1946) The Pagan Origins of the ThreeHeaded Representation of
the Christian Trinity. Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, Vol. 9, (edit.),
p.136.
:
Gregory, Timothy E. (1986) The Survival of Paganism in Christian Greece: A Critical
Essay. The American Journal of Philology, Vol. 107, No. 2, (Summer), p 235236
.
:
Neusner, Jacob (1963) Jewish Use of Pagan Symbols after 70 C.E., The Journal of
Religion, Vol. 43, No.4, (Oct.), p. 278, 288, 289, 293. University of Chicago Press.
:
Watham, Arthur E. (1910) The Bible in the New Light, Biblical World Journal, Vol. 36,
No. 1, p 49.
The Only Way Out
() " " .
)(6
Denton, M. (1985) Evolution: A Theory in Crisis. Adler & Adler.
( ) " ".
--
( ) (
) ( )
( ) .
()
. :
:
()
:
()
.
.
()
)Inherit the Wind .
: (
( )
. .
.
.
()
--
.
.
.
. ()
- -
.
.
.
:
""
.
( )speciation
( )
. (
)Edward O. Wiley :
" - : -
()
. .
()
( )
.
Wiley, E. O. (1992) The Evolutionary Species Concept Reconsidered. In:
Ereshefsky, M. (edit.) The Units of Evolution: Essays on the Nature of Species; MIT
Press, p. 79.
)(12
--
.
:
: .
.
": .
. " )( .
-
( )
" : .
.
- -
()
".
.
. .
. :
.
)(13
- -
. .
- -
(- )great divisions
-
( Georges Cuvier )
( 1871-1792 Roderick Murchison)
()
( Louis Agassiz
)
( ) )( .
" :
" "
" ()
()
.
.
( )Intelligent Design
. . .
:
( ) ( )Illustrious
"".
Murchison, R. (1854) Siluria: The History Of The Oldest Known Rocks, London, p.
469.
( ) . :
)(17
- -
)( .
.
)
(
( ) : :
.
.
( )
":
" () .
.
.
. .
.
()
()
.
(.) /
- -
( ) ( )
.
.
.
- 31 -
( )Of Pandas and People
. (
)
-
. "" -
-
.
Percival Davis Dean Kenyon
4991
. ( )ID
.
.
NY Times
- 41 -
( )4
( )2
( )1 ABCs
()1
( )NOVA
- .-
- BBC -Horizon NOVA
BBC ( ) .
.
-Peer-reviewed
-
-
: -
-
- Robert J. Marks II -
.)1( The Evolutionary Informatics Lab
)(1
James Glanz, "Biologists Face a New Theory of Life's Origin," New York Times
(Sunday, 8 April 2001), 1. Kenneth Chang, "In Explaining Life's Complexity,
Darwinists and Doubters Clash," New York Times (Monday, 22 August 2005), 1.
()2
2001-8-41 ( )
2001-44-28 ( ) .
See, for instance, the episode titled "From Whence We Came" (airdate January
16, 2005) of ABC's Boston Legal.
( )1 2001/1/9 - ABC
)(3
- 2001/9/21
.
See respectively: www.biologicinstitute.org and www.EvoInfo.org (last accessed
September 26, 2007).
)(5
- 41 -
( )
IDEA
( ) ( .)1
Kitzmiller v. Dover
-
( )
.
- -" :
" ( .)7
" :DNA
" ( .)8
- -
()9
()1
ideacenter.org/clubs/locations.php .2007-8-40
Richard Dawkins, The Blind Watchmaker: Why the Evidence of Evolution Reveals
a Universe Without Design, New York: Norton, 1987, 1.
)(8
Francis Crick, What Mad Pursuit, New York: Basic Books, 1988, 138.
)(9
See, for instance: David J. Depew and Bruce H. Weber, Darwinism Evolving:
Systems Dynamics and the Genealogy of Natural Selection Cambridge, Mass.: MIT
Press, 1995; Stuart Kauffman, Investigations, New York: Oxford University Press,
2000; and Franklin Harold, The Way of the Cell: Molecules, Organisms and the
Order of Life, New York: Oxford University Press, 2001; Lynn Helena Caporale,
Darwin in the Genome: Molecular Strategies in Biological Evolution, New York:
McGraw-Hill, 2003; Gerd B. Muller and Stuart A. Newman, eds., Origination of
OrganismaI Form: Beyond the Gene in Developmental and Evolutionary Biology,
Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2003.
)(7
- 41 -
- -
- (
).
( )40
( ) 2000- -
. William
Dembski
( : )
4998 - .
( )The Foundation for Thought and Ethics
( ) .
( )
(
)
( ) .
( ) .
( )
.
)(10
- 47 -
Dean Kenyon
Percival Davis
.)44( -
-)Simply Biology ( - )(
.)42( - -
) (
.)41( -
: ( : Taxton ) 44(
.)The Mystery of Life's Origin: Reassessing Current Theories
: .
Angus Menuge, Who's Afraid of ID' in William A. Dembski and Michael Ruse,
eds., Debating Design: From Darwin to DNA (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2004), 36-37.
(12)
Claude A. Villee, Eldra Pearl Solomon, and P. William Davis, Biology ,2nd ed.
(Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1989). Davis and Solomon also published a
textbook on anaromy and physiology: Understanding Human Anatomy and
Physiology (NewYork :McGraw-Hill, 1978).
(13)
Dean H. Kenyon and Gary Steinman, Biochemical Predestination, New York:
McGraw-Hill, 1969. Dean H. Kenyon, Prefigured Ordering and Protoselection in the
Origin of Life, in The Origin of Life and Evolutionary Biochemistry, (Festschrift
commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of the publication of Proislehozhdenie
Zhizni and the eightieth birthday of Alexander 1. Oparin), eds. K. Dose, S. W. Fox, G.
A. Deborin, and T. E. Pavlovskaya (New York: Plenum Press, 1974),207-220. Dean H.
Kenyon, "A Comparison of Proteinoid and Aldocyanoin Microsystems as Models for
the Primordial Protocell," in Molecular Evolution and Protobiology (Festschrift
commemorating the twenty-fifth anniversary of the pioneering thermal hetero-polycondensation of amino acids and as a dedication to Sidney W Fox on the occasion
of his seventieth birthday), eds. K. Marsuno, K. Dose, K. Harada, and D. L. Rohlfing
(New York: Plenum Press, 1984), 163-188.
- 48 -
- - -
- .
( )
( )
RNA
.
.
( .)41
.
()41
. ( )
.
( )41 :
) (www.dissentfromdarwin.org 700
" :
".
For entry into this literature, see William A. Dembski and Michael Ruse, eds.,
Debating Design: From Darwin to DNA (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2004), especially parts I and IV.
)(15
- 49 -
.
.
-
.-
(the Wind
.)Inherit
.
Jon A. Buell
- 20 -
- 24 -
. ( :
) ( ) (
) . ()
()
" :
.. !".
()
.
:
.1 - - -
-
.
.2
.
. .
- 22 -
.
- - -
. (
:)Jerry Coyne
" :
()1
. ".
() ()
- 23 -
()
IQ
( )
()
Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar
.
()
( )
()
.
.
- -
( )" :
.. - -
" ().
.
Emergentists .)( Harold Morowitz
().
()
- - .
-
..
- -
Francisco Ayala
" :
.
( )
" ." :
" ().
.
David Hull
" : ()
" (.)
- -
:
.. :
.
.
. .
. .
(
)SETI
()
.
.
SETI
( .)
()
()Panspermia
. .
( .)
() : .
" . .
() " :
- -
" :
Raymond G. De Vries
. " (.)
- -
:
.
() .Homo Sapiens:
Hominidae
.)Pan
.-
Class
( ) .
- -
.
( Homo Neanderthalensis
) Homo Erectus
( Homo Habilis ) .
- -
.
- -
() .
( Rudolfensis ) .
( ) ()
- - .
( )Australopitbecines
Anamensis
- -
Afarensis
- . - - Africanus . .-
.
.
.
- -
%89
.
.
DNA
- .-
DNA %
DNA
.% .
DNA
% -
- %
() . DNA DNA %
DNA
DNA % .
. .
().
Charles Sibley
Jon Ahlquist
()DNA-DNA
- -
DNA
() ().
DNA DNA
. - -
. .%.
.
Homo Troglodytes
. " :
.
" () .
.
DNA
DNA
DNA
( )G C T A
!
DNA
%.
- -
% DNA
DNA
-
DNA
) - -
.
()14
:
.1
.
6
.2
.3
.4
.5
- -
.
.
.7
-
.8
Pilot
.9
.-Whale
.
- -
.
11
.
.
.
.
.
- .
. -
-
.
- -
.
.
- -
- -
- -
:
. -
.
-
()Nature
Michael Hopkin ( )" :
" " :
. .
.)( "-
-
- -
.
.
- -
-
.
.
Isaac Asimov
" :
"( .)
.
" :
- -
" .
" :
" (.)
- -
.
.
.
-
!
-
:
- -
- -
!
- -
- ( .)
-
-
Irene Pepperberg
)" :
" (.)
.
- -
Roger Lewin
- " :
".
" : -
- .
" ().
" ().
() . :
.
.
- -
- -
(
) .
.
() .
.
.
- .-
- -
- -DNA
-
:
.
Barbara King
William And Mary
() .
() .
(.)
. .
" :
( )
- -
- -
. .
" (.)
- -
. -
( ) . -
- .
" :
:
. .
( )" (.)
- -
.
.
.
.
.
. -
-
.
. -
- .
" :
" ( .)
(
) : "
"
- -
.
.
- -
- -
.
.
.
:
.-
.
Michael
Ruse E. O. Wilson :
.
Nature
--
. " :
- -
. (
) .
-
.
"
().
- -
().
- -
().
Macbeth
" ().
- -
- -
.
.
. -
- .)( -
- .
Jeffrey Schloss
" :
() .
- -
.
.
" ().
- -
- - .
.
.
E. O. Wilson
" :
"( .)
" :
" (.)
( .)
-
.
( )
.
- -
( .) .
( ) .
:
(
) () .
.
- -
-
" :-
" () .
- -
- -
.
Human
Humus
()
.
- .
-
- - - -
-
- -
-
.
.
.
- -
)
- -Australopithecines
) %
) -
.-
)
.
( )
- -
) -
-
- ( )
)
-
- -
) " "
" : .
".
) " :
" .
- -
:
) sidis.net/WJSJourLinks.htm( :()
. //
(2)
" :
..
."
(3)
Mortimer Adler, The Difference of Man and the Difference It Makes New
York: Fordham University Press, 1993.
(5)
David Hull, Darwin and His Critics: The Reception of Darwins Theory of
Evolution by the Scientific Community, (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1973),26.
(7)
See respectively:
http://genomebiology.com/researchnews/default.asp?arx_id=gb- -
spotlight-20031215-01 and
http://www.nature.ca/genome/03/a/03a_11a_e.cfm (both websites last
accessed August 18, 2004).
(12)
Jonathan Marks, "98% Alike? (What Our Similarity to Apes Tells Us About
Our Understanding of Genetics)," The Chronicle of Higher Education (May
12, 2000): B7. Also See :Jonathan Marks, What It Means to Be 98%
Chimpanzee: Apes, People, and Their Genes(Berkeley, Calif.: University of
California Press, 2002).
(14)
Taken and abridged from Geoffrey Simmons, What Darwin Didn't Know
(Eugene, Oregon: Harvest House, 2004), 274-278.
(15)
) ( ) (
.
. - -
.-- www.alexfoundation.org :) (
. Irene Pepperberg's
. -- .) (
(20)
Roger Lewin, "Is Your Brain Really Necessary?" Science, 210 (12
December 1980), 1232.
(21)
Stanley L. Jaki, Brain, Mind and Computers (South Bend, Ind.: Gateway
Editions, 19(9), 115-116.
(22)
(23)
) (
( )
) ) ( (
. . ..
.) (
.//
(27)
(29)
Charles Darwin, Letter to W Graham, 1881. In F. Darwin, ed., The Life and
Letters of Charles Darwin (New York: D. Appleton & Co., 1905), 1:285.
Available
online
at
http://pages.britishlibrary.net/charles.darwin/texts/letters/letters1_08.ht
ml (last accessed 4 August 2004). For a full-scale philosophical treatment of
Darwin's worry and the skepticism it forces on human knowing, see: Victor
Reppert, C. S. Lewis's Dangerous Idea: In Defense of the Argument from
Reason (Downers Grove, Ill.: Inter Varsity, 2003).
(30)
J. B. S. Haldane ()
." ":
( )
.
(35)
Ibid 165.
(38)
- -
:Abiogenesis
.
:Allele .
. .
) :Allopatric Speciation
(
. .Sympatric Speciation
:
.
.
.
Analogy
( ) :
.
( )Homology
. : .
:Apparent Design
.
.
.
.
.
- -
:Argument-From-Ignorance
Objection
.
() :Argument From Personal Credulity
.
:Argument From Personal Incredulity
.
Hypothesis
:Artifact
.
) :Autogeny
) . .
:Autotroph
. " ."HETEROTROPH
:Biomacromolecules
.
Watchmaker
:Blind
- ( ) .
.
- -
Effect
:Bottleneck
.
Burgess Shale
-Burges :
( )
.
:Cambrian Explosion
.
Mutagenesis
:Cassette
DNA
.
: Catalyst
.
:Chaperones
.
:
. .PREBIOTIC EVOLUTION
Biota/Fauna
:Chengjiang
( )
.
- -
:Chirality
.
:Chromosome
DNA
. .
.
:Cilia .
:Coacervates
.
:
.
:Coevolution
.
:Colloid
.
:Common Descent
Universal
.Common Ancestry
.
: Complexity .
( ) (
) .
Kolmogorov
- -
.
.
Specified Information
:Complex
. .SPECIFIED COMPLEXITY
:Fallacy Of Composition
.
:Computational Complexity .COMPLEXITY
Evolution
:Convergent
.
:Creation .
. .
.
:
SCIENTIFIC CREATIONISM
.CREATIONISM
. ) :
) .
) .
) .
- -
) . .
) ( ).
) :Creationism ) .
.
: .
. : .DESIGNER
:C
.
PATHWAY
:DARWINIAN
.
: (
) .
.
:Deep Divergence Hypothesis
.
Complexity
:Descriptive .
:
() : .
() : ) :
) . ) .
) .
- -
. .
.
:
. .
.
:Design Inference
.
.
:Direct Darwinian Pathway
.
. .
() :Disparity .
.
:Diversity .
St. Bernard
.
: .
:DNA
.
.
:Dominance
() .Heterozygote
- -
:Domain
.
:Ediacaran Fauna
( )Vendian
. -
.
:Embryo .
:Embryology
.
Emergence
.
:Entropy
.
.
.
:Epistemic . " ."ONTOLOGICAL
:Eukaryote
() .
:Evolution
.
. :
() .
- -
Informatics
:Evolutionary
.
:Evolvability .
:Exon
DNA
Mrna
. .
:Fixation
.
:Protein Folding
- L - ( )
.
:Founder Effect
.
() .
: .
) :Functional Information
.
) .
.
:Gamete ( )
. .ZYGOTE
: . .DNA
DNA .
:Gene Flow .
- -
:Gene Pool
.
Drift
:Genetic
Information
:Genetic
. .
:Genome .
:Genotype .
Fallacy
:God-Of-The-Gaps
() .
.
.
:Gradualism
. .SALTATIONISM
:Hemophilia
.
.
:Heterozygous
.
- -
:Homeobox Gene
.
.
:Homeotic Gene
. :Antennapedia
.
:Heterotroph .
.AUTOTROPH
( ) :Homochirality
( )
.
:Homology .
(
) .
. " "
.
:Homoplasy
.
:Hox .Homeotic Genes
Hox.
:Hydropathic Signature
.
- -
:
.
:Hypercycles
.
:Hypothesis ) : ) )
.
:Improbability .
Darwinian Pathway
:Indirect
.
. .
:Inference To The Best Explanation
-
.
.
:Information : .
() .
.
.
.
. SEMANTIC INFORMATION
SYNTACTIC INFORMATION SHANNON INFORMATION
- -
SPECIFIED COMPLEXITY
COMPLEX
.SPECIFIED INFORMATION
:Intelligence ()
( ) .
.
Design
:Intelligent
.
- -
.
APPARENT DESIGN
.OPTIMAL DESIGN
.
.
.
:Intron
.Mrna .
Complexity
:Irreducible
.
:Isomorphism .
.
( ).
- -
Analogy
DNA
:Junk DNA .
. .PSEUDOGENE
:Kolmogorov Complexity .COMPLEXITY
) :Law (
) ) .
- -
( ).
:Linkage
.
:Lipids .
:Macroevolution
.
.
Mechanism
:Material
(:
) .
. -
.
.
: Materialism
.
. ()
- -
.
.
METHODOLOGICAL MATERIALISM
.SCIENTIFIC MATERIALISM
:Melanism
.
:Metabolism
.
.Metaphysical Materialism .
:Methodological Materialism
.
.
.
. .
:Microevolution .
.
() :Mimetic Butterflies
.
:Minimal Complexity -
.
() :Monomer
.
:Mononucleotide .
- -
:Monophyletic
.
:Morphogenesis (
).
:Mrna RNA
.
.
: Mutation
() . ( ) .
:Natural Selection
.
.
.
:Neo-Darwinism (
)Modern Synthesis
.
( )
.
( ) .
:Notochord
( Chordates ).
- -
:Nucleic Acid
( ).
: ( )
( ) .
: Nucleus
.
: (
).
:Ontogeny
.
:Ontological .EPISTEMIC
: - .
.
Design
:Optimal .
.
.
.
) :Order - -
) .
( - - ) ) .
.
- -
Inertia
:Phylogenetic
.
.
:Phylogeny
.
:Phylum .
.Division
.
() :Polymer
.Monomers
() :Polymerization ()
().
- -
:Polymorphic .
( ) :Polymorphism
.
:Polynucleotide ( ).
:Polypeptide
.
.
:Polyploidy .SECONDARY SPECIATION
:Prebiotic .
Evolution
:Prebiotic
CHEMICAL
.EVOLUTION
:Prebiotic Soup ( )
.
) :Primary Speciation
(
. .
()
Structure
:Primary
. .
Complexity
:Probabilistic
.
:Probabilistic Resources (
)Replicational Resources (
- -
Specificationial
.) Resources
.
:Prokaryote
.
: ()
( ) .
:
.
:Proteinoids
.
:Proteasomes
.
:Pseudogene
.
.
. .
:Punctuated Equilibrium
"
" . .STASIS
Niles Eldredge
Stephen
.Jay Gould
:Racemic
.
- -
Variation
:Random
.
.
:Recessive Gene -
.
:Reducing Atmosphere
- . .
:Rejection Region
.
. ( )
.
:Replicational Resources .
:Residue .
.
:
. .
:Saltationism
.
. .GRADUALISM
:Scientific Creationism .
:Scientific Materialism
.
- -
:Scopes Trial
.
.
.
.
:Secondary Speciation .
.Hybridization
.
:Secondary Structure
Beta Strands
Alpha Helices
. .
Pressure
:Selection
- .
:Selective Advantage
.
Theories
:Self-Organizational
(
) .
:Semantic Information .
Shannon
Information
Warren Weaver
:Shannon
Claude
( )
.
- -
.
- .
:Sibling Species - -
() (.)Genealogy
:Speciation .
:Species .Genus
" :
" .
.
:Specification - -
. .
:Specificational Resources .
:Specified Complexity ) :
( ) )
( ) .
.
:Spontaneous Generation
. .
()
Selection
:Stabilizing
.
:Stasis .
.PUNCTUATED EQUILIBRIUM
- -
) :Sympatric Speciation
. .
()
Information
:Syntactic
(
) .
. . " " "".
:Taxon .
:Taxonomy .
.
.
:Teleological .
:Teleology .
:Tertiary Structure
.
.
:Theory .
.
.
:
.
- -
:Transcription .
.TRANSLATION
Form
:Transitional
.
.
:Translation .
.
:Trna .
.
Of Selection
:Unit
.
:Unit Of Variation
.
:Universal Probability Bound
()
. ( - )
( - ).
:Vertebrates
Chordates
( )Chordata
.
.
- -
()
Structures
:Vestigial
.
- ( ) .
:Zygote ( )
.
- -
! 6 ....................................................................
13 .................................................................................
14 ...............................................................................
22 ......................................................................
25 ...............................................................
27 ............................................................
33 ..................................................................
%98 32 ....................................................................
36 ................................................................
39 ................................................................
42 .......................................................................
46 .............................................................
51 ...........................................................
53 ......................................................................
- 415 -
63 ...............................................................................................
66 ..........................................................................................
73 .............................................................................................
74 .....................................................................
78 ............................................................................................
84 .......................................................................
88 ............................................................................... Evo-Devo
98 ..................................................................................
131 ...................................................................
135 ..............................................................
112 ..........................................................................
114 .................................................................................
116 .........................................................................................
119 ......................................................................
123 ........................................................................................
125 ...................................................
- 416 -
129 ............................................................................................
131 ...............................................
136 .........................................................................................
142 ...........................................................................
145 ....................................................................
149 ......................................................................
153 ............................
154 ................
158 ..............................................................................
162 .........................................................................................
167 .....................................................................................
171 ....................................................................
174 ..........................................................................................
( 176 ..................... )Homology
183 .......................................................................
182 ...........................................................................
- 417 -
: 187 ....................................................
() 193 ..........................................................................
196 ..............................................
199 .........................................................................................
238 .........................................................................................
213 ............................................................................
213 ...........................................................................................
215 ................................................................
221 ................................................
226 .................................................................................
227 .........................................................................................
232 ............................................................................................
Contact
234 ..........................................................
236 ................................................................................
239 ....................................................
243 ............................................................................................
- 418 -
( ) 244 ................................................
247 .............................................
249 ..................................................................
251 ..........................................................................................
254 ..........................................................
261 .......................................................................................
264 ..................................................................
( )! 266 ....................................
271 ....................................................
277 .........................................................................................
286 ........................................................
.. 287 ..........................................................
292 ..................................
294 .....................................................................
- 333 .................................................................
333 .............................................
335 ....................................................
319 ..............................................................
- 419 -
323 .....................................................................
326 ...............................................................
: 329 .........................................................
338 ...................................................................
343 ......................................................................
347 .....................................................................
349 ..........................................................
358 ....................................................................
:
374 .........................................
375 .........................................................
378 ...........................................................
381 ...........................................
384 .....................................
389 ..............................................................
- 423 -
- 421 -