You are on page 1of 10
REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE DIREITO PROCESSUAL ~ RBDPRO ote oe sc a reretoescn amen oa erie tee serree, eet ier nae eeceecs cence ae seceeee — SNE ieee tke eae a tesa Seeree =a eee aa Eee — Eeeerertaort cae ee sa oto tn ae. Eicon — Seroaeaeey Sue eee Sear SE ee sees ieechanaeas i BSE 8 ieee iowen Serer «= REE aes aa et ett ee eres comme —e Sate areemae eames mie gene SEE So Siren ete Soe EE Sookree Seance Fave Sreeee coe BES sae aaa Sensors {aoe ot sos sano. € probs» repateto es!opta. so sunt oma a por ae mean ou ncn ‘che stmcs de peceares nee ettxoncs a depos, ues ar osoto 2 pour aon cress © roriin ls dude Rocrigues Ferera ort Fro 00 oscercetet e comtes ess res nanos aac toot aja 4 on/mat 07529924 / una? rine en Uno | —_ A aplicagao da actio nata no redirecionamento das execucoes fiscais e€ seus reflexos no desenvolvimento e na seguran¢a juridica Andre Folloni DDoutor em Direto do Estado pela Universidade Federal do Parend (UFPR). Professor Adunto {da Pontifela Universidade Catéica do Parana (PUCPRI, em Curitba/PR, Brasil, Advogado. Pesquisador. Emait IUDLL easy ovbnoaxe wa osde seupi0 anb zinf op oysedsap ojod ‘coup wo anavosasd sORdepas BIUINBaS & WOD JEIOBIA & NK ougINGU O31p99 Op ‘| ‘oon oyesBEIEd “pLT OBMUE Q *,[e9Sy ORdNI9x9 seuapio anb zinf op oysedsap 019d, oplduiouaiu 10s e nosed feu *GO0Z/STT au JeuaWa|dwiog 197 ep oWanpe ojad epizen EaELUA}S!S BACK x'8002'60'ET WO OpeRin{ ‘euuN| e: PASUING BP eUNIEIRS 9p ‘OS/198"PEL dSAY OU BYBY 9D 9 «\G00Z'TT'S; wo ope¥inf ‘opiyjemeg uoyWeH “UIWN Op eUOYeIO1 ap ‘oBdag eu!eWIUd “9S/B8Y ds3u3 OU ByBy ap soepsoDe so sae! Waquie) WI9AUOd ‘OpNUas OLISAL 2ewor ovu sasaigaly se 2 ‘soparap oe ‘oysodsip 0 joneor 2p ozeid ou 05: (0 anb op of SeuUNL «Z 9 ef Sep elouaprudsun! y “E'vOIRMAT VOSSId “OYOVLI "UNIO 0109S ‘OVOIHDSIMd "OSL OYONOIXG “AID OSSO0Ud [""] ‘opduosaid © ossad ep opSey9 ep soue coUID ‘k9p 0109 0 eRUOD oBdNo9x9 ep CWaUIEUO!DBNIPS) fos Ou oWaUNpUA|UA 0 opueWEIDO:E WER ayO eISop ‘opiaoid gu jequaUufBas one Be “z *600z"v'OT 8p ara “ewuNy epuNBoS Jeg eUEITZ ENSIUIN “IY 'SH/OTE'PTG dS3U ‘600z'6'OE OP OFC ‘296 0534 Ou Buy MEH “UN “19Y “OS. ssad ep ogieu9 ep ‘S0pEIUO9 SOUP ODUID ap OzeIE OU 2S:42 aap SoIDS $0 eNUOD oZINDaXD ep cluaweuoysauipa1 © enb ‘epesaiias ewioy op ‘opuepuayua asiwaA “sieosy SepINp sep epepiignuososcun e Jeyno 9p opepyeuy e WoD ["] :edqsnr 9p eunqu souedns ojad sopuayoid soepi9se op soyse.i saquInBos so ‘oysodoxd e ‘as-enbyUon “oUOs08 -oJ908 op ‘oquouuouaysod ‘2 esaiduia ep ovdeyo ennaja e anue SoUe COLO op SIeUI sopwoosuen opuenb ogdnoaxs ep ojueweuo|sa1Ipas 0 e1ed ogduoseid e e10d0 0 op opauos ou opetuoWupas oWUaWeUO|aIS0d eyUN eiouapudsUnf y ‘oBdLOSa:d e sesedo as 2p euad gos ‘epeinooxo volpun! eossad ep oBdey9 ep Sope uD SoUe ODUID ap ozeid 04 s01J000 euanap aqUas08-0100S Op BoSsad e e1ed oBSNDDK ep OIUAWEUOIDaNIPA! © ‘sleosy SepiNp Sep apepriqnuosoudu e se11A9 9 op wy y “Je0sy ogdnooK0 op ogbe Wo sopanep op jeossad oBde119 ep eIep ep SoPeIUO SoUe OOUID ap oze1d OU BIRaLOSOLd oupinqin oupe10 op ebuesGO0 & Bied OBE e ond eIDeIeqeISe NUD O ‘oedepal ens nosayle anb SOOz/BTT oll JeUaWo\dW0D 191 ep JOIA we epextuE ep Say ‘0861/08E"9 wt 191 oad oppaiaqese coyjadse oiuowpe9esd Usay anb “Jeosy ogdn9exe ap Bde e 9 OUEANAIA OUpgI0 Op euesqoo e e1ed opde essq “enmuyap oedIMNSUOD Ens EP eIeP ep SopeILCD ‘soUe coulo wa anaieseid oueinqln oup9i0 op ebueiqod e esed oBde e anb “pLT OBIE OU ‘euuuarep jeuoIeeN OUEINGUL OBIpED 0 ‘JeUOIMASUED cYUEWEpUN) SSB WOO jaj98}89 @ AOD “BwWBe OpEp jax Op ose OU ‘osIND Nos !NPp0} ‘0ze10 2183 "NUD OP LT He Op SOLLIa, SOU "SOU DU!9 21 9 opipad gu anb wo sosax0d4 219 Op euexqoo exed ozesd 0 ["] ‘Seu owssaus “Jossaons op oUEINal © ‘o\dwaxa sod ‘as-efon “seinBaus! ogdnjossip ens ap no esaiduia ‘suoq 9p b19U2}S!xaU! ep BoLode eIOU9IO ep JIMed & seuade e11011090 op ovsuayaid ep oyowioseu 0 ‘eoriand epuazey ep oedejoudioqu eu ‘noe ep eu0a) © eoonu! eoljand epuaze, e ‘g66°TOZ"T st [e90ds3 09 leosy ovdno apepijiqnuosaidu! & @ eeu onoe ejad oBdeyUAUIN 1 BURUIBIO 19] 29d No Je jad seido apod ond “(| ‘zz “Ye YO) oBIUN ejad opeU ‘9p Ewa} ap as-eIe4] “eUO} Op JeIeN spod eLeUIp: eqUawo!duod 19] 10d ayusHHO9Je1U! oBduaseid ep ojUDWIETEN 0 oF JeNqU Fenssad0Iq OHONIG Oe SOLaJe BOBE ‘oRdNDax9 Op OL JouIeUESs9B9U OCU SeUL “feOSY, ORINDDX e BIE soISodNssox said ep 9 OUPALO Op JeYeN WORD “sEQUOUIO|ALLIOD 19}, ‘9p Slei08 seuoU sy “opeplssod0u esso 4 "S9NBILOD OUPOLIA UN "PA SW/ELGORE BY OU RUBY “NSN 9p UKNLOUeINS ISNA (L007 "¥M9 9z ‘GSE “A Yq “LO0z"0r'60 :e opeBinr “Cun 9z “BJO OSeD ONSIUIW “104 'SE/TE'SLE at Su) uaze} eInbeyne ep BIDI9UI © epezu9}20I29 OPIS eYUD OBU aN eDUIE ‘e0ssad ep oBSei1o e wepzons anb soue g ap opouad op oqUOp 24 e[0s cquaweuo!9auipa1 op opypad o anb Janbal EIEN ONdY ep eODL ep opdeonide v “9 [~"] (G00z/¥0/TT 9p nia ‘ssz'TpS su BY OU FaBy !go0z's0'9t 9p nra ‘8so'srr ou dsay ou BBY !S00z/90/0z 9p Nra dds3u $5007/80/T0 ap nra "288'S0z x ds3y ‘SoIUap20014) (ou o1sodsip 0 jaxeaiideu! opuas “2: ‘9p 02810 Ou 98:1ep anOp 01995 0 2 :auInBas Way! ou e}SOdxo guas anb 9 ‘eIS:9NOAUOD ep OVA opderap|suos We opuens| o|UaUIeUOIDISod asap najen as Bf [1S 0 ‘anisnjoul ‘(6002 “A0U 20 “era “600z “sou Gz :wo opefiny “oed9g exjawd “opiyleNeD UOYEH “UIN "Tox “OS/88¥"T9Z WU sau Sou Byfy) Ieosy epmNp & feAnUosaidul, s2UiO Bue OpoU Bp ‘so!99s Sop Jeossed oBdeIID e 9 esesdiUo EP logbeyo e anua soue oouID ap sJeul Sopusov9p 9s sIUOLORNU] OBDLDSANK 4 ‘feos. ogdnoaxe ep o\UaWeUOIBoupA1 ap oSeD OU “soLEpIIOS 15801 Soe Opde|a/ WO ogd}9said e edwiOLaNU! eoIpus ‘ede119 @ ajuesqo Ogu “and ap ovoWIpUaTUD o nk {uBY Op cIUaWeBINT OU “oBdag eulaULd Y 'S00z'vO'TT Fa ‘ssztys By ou Sy8¥ ‘s00z"s0'9T (a ‘eG9Sby csIy OU Fysy 'g002'90'0z fa ‘OEOSEL AS34 !S00z'RO'TO fa “IeH ‘L880 dszu uosaidult ewo) Oey B OPOUI ap ‘NID feu enieq was ‘sopennbue ogsas soine $0 ‘susq ap no soponap op ‘ogbezi}e20] @ axa) anb elouapino.d zanbyend was ‘oWIKEW O7e/6 2559 InDoK Op lelaIpnt aueWAsA:das Oe SoINe Sop EISIN nO eossad ogdewnul ep seIU09 e ‘oUe wn sod ewuEKIOS-08} JesnpUOd ogdemnis esse seul ‘0251 ‘osuadsns ‘quowen(o7 “eoyued e wJe994 essod slenb so 2190s su0q ‘sopequcoua no Joparap 0 ope7ie0| 10} oBu cyuenbu ‘ap ossa00id op ogsuadsns ap oseo wn “ouaUisojdul 194 onnisodsip 9ssou onb 3 “ouerngy lopeaidiayul 195 axap [easly OPdnoag ep 1o7 ep OF OBUE OT I~] INLD Op “21 ‘and 0 9 j29slj 025N99xq 99 197 eP ‘OY OBIE © aud oedeZIUOUL +“, oquajoduioo woBenBul), ep eu09} e osuno: sanbjenb was ‘9s-s10ue ‘oss} “o]uaWeUoIDaNIpA! O ‘ogdnoaxa ep osing ou ‘opuenb ,odwar sonbjenb apepijgissod @ epusjsp ‘jeu onde ep euoa) eu epe: yuooua *,odura sont 5 sine So ‘ovdIpuod e ON 'st 16068 ‘sone01n 99 020} wo Jey op8n92x9 9p ante 2 e109 onb Was ‘slangioyUed suag Sop no Jopanap op o2dez1Je00] ap ee) EU “OU in sod ogsnoaxa ep ogsuadsns op apepilig’ssod © ao9joqeso oyooa1d O ‘epuaze4 ep opers3 ap anSIUIW op O1e Jod opexy owIUILH o@ JoVO}U lefps Jojen ofno sielaipn{ seduesqos 9p ose9 ou epesuadsip gos oAIME ‘2180p «pS OU EYSIAAIA eaNGNd epusTeY EP eIAaid oBdeIsajIUEW y ~ GS ‘erpou 9p ef gia109p 9 ajuosoasaqu! oRduoseId ‘oroyo op ‘e9p0d “eotiand epuazey @ eprAno ap siodap ‘2m o “Jeuoiouosaxd ‘oze10 0 opuiosep san cquaWeAmnbse 0 Jeuapl0 anb oBs!99p ep 2S - sbS ‘opdno0x9 ep cwUoluindassold ered so\ne 60 SopenNbuesop Og195 ‘suaq 50 No sopanap 0 ‘odway sanbjenb e "wefas end sopenuoou - <¢8 ‘soyne sop ‘ouewienntie 0 e1eu9ps0 2:0 “slangv0yuad sudq SopeUcoUe no JonaAEP (0 opezieo| efas ond wes ‘oue (WIN) Tap WIXPL OzExd 0 OpLIODK - ZS ‘eoyand epuaze, ep repsipnf ayuewuosaxdos foe some sop eIsin euaqe 919 ‘ORINIOxO ep OsINO O osuadsng - 51S “egduosald ap azeid 0 919109 0Bu ‘soseo sassal ‘9 ‘e10yuad 1 s18201 essod sjenb 0 asqos suaq sopenuooua no Jopexap 0 opeziIe00| 430} Ogu cluenbuo ‘ogdna9x9 ep osind o wiopuadsns zINT O - OY “UY ‘opdepar aquinflas e way opliajes oyooaud o "JenIe oRdeInBYUOO ens WI ‘siPosiy SaQdN0axq op 191 P Ob OBIE 0 soaaqeis@ anb op eaiflojeuR no enjsuarxa ogdealide ap aiggdse euin Jod seu! “ja] wo oys|Aold OU oBdUOSaIC ep onndnoqu} oasew onou win es-opueIUa}sns ‘o}UeWeUO!OesIpa1 op onb e seIp 0 opiBune euat 9s Ogu “epuanboxe epiNp & Jeples op stonlssed suaq op eloudysIxoU! eANajo epeieisuco ou oqenbus ‘anb es-aywipe ‘oedeyaidieqUl op eANeWOUIe ESSON + ogduoseud ap ozeid 0 g191100 ogu ‘soseo Sassou ‘2 "eoyUAd e 118991 essod sienb $0 eiqos suaq sopeuooue no sopanep 0 opeziieoo} 40} oBu oqueNbuD ‘opdnoaxo ep osino o esepuadsns zin¢ 0, :@noi0seld onb “(OB6T/OBE"9 at! 191) sIe9S1y sagsnoaxg ap 191 ep Op OBE ou o1edwe eUeAUODUD CWYsUIpUaIU 2153 Jgynqua oupauo 0 joxesuodsai op 4181X9 cost, (0 9p oulaup o afins ‘oqueisul aisop smed e oquowos ‘anb e351A wo OpuD) “senoid sep sjusiadwoo woBensuy) ead epznpea ‘sasaiodiy seano anuop ‘eojpyn{ eossad ep awueyuoso,dos ojod oy! oye wn op eoRE:d ep ado ewun ap efas opdesNfyuOD ‘ap owIUIWY opeyse wn edejaqelse as anb eied ‘esioa1d eossad epeg “s sep 9 seossod sep epin e einas Jewio) Jesnoosd anop ‘apepinnayo sep ap 2 ednsnf ep ovduaigo ep eosng eu ‘Ol oedqquawepury @ sapisuo9 and 9 lun @ owedsa1 uk bu 9 feuuos ous soupyyo e soapaqe ceSnnsues ens & oWoD Wod ‘oa}pun| CwoWseUEpIO ou sepepuny 9 sepiooxe|as0 08s oDjpunfojwsoo!ves op segsnyoUoD se 9 sess|uiold se opuend sejuasaid ‘o1W90)28s op saQsniauco se 9 Sessiulald se opuend sauesaid ‘olupoioe: ap sese}o seummnsso op sn oe oyedsas wazip someyuaunsie sowawo|9 50 “sienss020x1 2 sontewounsie sowvownsie op apusdep eduemnBes essy [~] juawinie 9p stevoioe :,S@uuou sep 02500 jad apuaqua as anb o ‘auuoyun opdeoiide ens e WAqUIEY a © 2 ‘0po) win owoD oaeuapJ0 OB epeuO!oeja: 12189 oped eoIpU .¢ 004puinf owsoueuap.0 op 095: yuioo 9p 9 2 ep “ouisoiy ‘no So0si20p sep epenbope oedewuoWepuny op {ep apnun wa ‘apepriqlasouBloa ap -epepniqeinojea ap 9 ape 9p ‘apepiiqiosousioa op sewioyqoxd opesneo Wo) oBdipsunfe WAqUIE)| bu ‘o|UaWeUOIDauIpa1 Op eYoUaUIOR e Bled SOU sis 9p OWIKeW jexodUIa) osde} LUN woo ‘sonsodsip ap ovdeziuouuey epipusyaid @ assannoy enb epule ‘auapaoaid ‘way! ou opeqUaljes auLs0jU09 ‘enbiod oss} “sleosiy Segdnoaxg ep 197 EP ‘Ov OBIE op eaffo}eue oedeo1ide ep ojuatenInsap wn Je01j198 janissod 9 ‘asIjeue Wa OSeD ON ‘epeiedns afoy ‘aquaisixe ‘0gqu9 eIsi9A0.QUOD e JONJOSOL e EpeUNsEp ‘Boland epusze ejad seplNpE soso1 Seiad epenyow jerouaprudsunf ogdnasuos ewin ap ‘asayodiy eu ‘eeu onge & ‘aseyes, ‘ogdnoaxe ep Jopanap 0 JesjUODUa Wa eIOUIap ejad epezt|euad eo11qnd epuazed @ 19S 9p opepiiqissod @ ‘opua ‘asnoyseyy “oeduosaid ep oddnuou op esneo @ sepsetes sapod ‘opesquodue 12s wo eloueniojesal Jod 'sopanap op apepiliqissod Janbjenb Jeujuja ap oRpUOD O Ona} ‘NID OP “| OSIOUI “yLT OBIUe OU 'SOOZ/BTT ot JeyUatUa|dwWo9 19) ejad epeztteas oederay!e eUoUd & anb as-eoyUaA ‘wissoANO, “ope3noaxe op suaq ap BIOURISIXOU ep oyAWIOa4UO9 © WOD OBDNIAXe EU OYIE!ID ap CIUBUIOSEU JeMUENe WOD OBDEIA1 Janbjenb ‘oqueyod ‘einey oeN "elouspenap no oBdyosaid wa enejasseoe oBu "et owisiuedaw oe S2qUai8U! SONROW Jod ‘oBd=}!9 BU BOA e anb as-eIpUaUa ‘oUEINA) ‘oYauIG 08 IIAIQ O5S800/4 BP OBIPOD Op “GTZ OBIUE op a sJeosLy saddnoaxq 9p 197 2p ‘Op OBIue op eugipisans ozdeayjde sod ‘oxy “ajanuoD nas qos assanisa ov anb exowsp ejad epeziieuad asso} eo1jqnd epuazey e nb Jeyno BABSIA C\UOWIPUD|LO 2889 »,'8OISNT ap JeUNgH| JOUedNg Op “BOT su BINNS ep oedeoIIde e WO>D ‘NID OP “| ostour “p21 ome op oedepai eBque eu epeoiide e12 eEU ONDE ep LUO Y Jeuojseu OJUSWIA|OAUaSAP OP 2 edIPUIN[ eSuesngas ep aquelp ejeu o9e ejad soyuauNge sop elsugpas0ldu! Wy “steosy seodnoexe sep apepiiqnuosoidt @ Jeno] 9pod oBu 4311 &P Op OBIE op ogdecIide e and ey!UBIS OSs} “eJodu Osce| 0p [e101 woBeIu09 eu sleosiy Sagdn2=Kg 9p 197 & soBlaqeISa and OBsUadsNS ap OVE tun 9p ozesd op oebesod0ou) en ‘ogwva “eUOReH “easy oBdNOxa ep OBDUTXO e exed owinew o7eid wn opniuupe euas anb as-eoytin ‘oBbezuOULHeY eSS9 10d {66F eneseG :ojneg OBS “p99 OW 180 *T0g “unl/-uel “Eu ouy 208} wo 2981) O88NGax9 op Bde EP o1UOLEUOE tee: eystaay :oMned 08g “(e002/ETT 91) SSI 9 (zO0z/PTE 919 966T/S8 9 ‘ofue “erougpeudsun! 2 euuinap :openaweD feuD}seN oueInaUL 081009 ‘SVUIRL 21 “PLE © SOT 2 G6 & EB "19 €9'TS B OP ‘SUE Sor SOU ‘pLOz op odsew ap gt “eanung "Ayrajouog “ANoag YB oUNdO}IRIC “uO “opdnsjsuos wo eso e| “sojasue snas sezejspes eied eperadsa apepiienb e woo se we apepatoos ep eduel4u0a 9 BiouR!oya op SepEIOP ‘52 eonesowap opepiuunisay e 151301 19p0q o}ad Jepog op ovddo eyswoy “senu0d 2 $038 ‘reroce ‘L002 lwo fend eped “(op “Ue) sieasij Saghnoax 9p 197 eU O (FLT “Ve) IeUOIDeN OURINGUL o1p99 ou orsinoid op oBdeBnfuod ead eUAEUI eU eoyJoodse eUIciOsIp BU ‘ofo}} “sa ap o8zel ens napiad ‘apepljeuy esse Woo ‘eeu onze ep ogdeatide e ‘Nopanap op ogde!0 e SIeUL Oe 2 oBSeyo e eUApIO anb oysedsep © uss jeuoiouaseid ozeid op sondnusaqu! Soo!eWu sop Wn anb seysuoD e opueSsed iL OB|PO0 OP “1 OsIou! “yLT OBIE op Sa0disodsIp se Nooy!pow anb ‘g002/8ET gu Jewowe\dusog 197 ep 408A we epextua ep smed e “ws0g “oBdnjos ‘ew Jod enewieja 2 erouenbay e199 wo eW0D0 ogdemMIS eSS9 “GOOZ/ETT aU 97 ep o1UaAPE Op SalUE oILOBIA ‘eonewiEISIS eBNUE WiOD ‘oTe4 aq -opesUCDUS 19S OLU ied 1sap SeINpUCD 9p BUBLOD9 “sopaxap op oRdeID BU eIOWOP ep eIoUELI099p we sozinferd assoujos ealgnd epuszey eB anb JeyK9 eU9S BuO ep JOS op oLzes y “stenpsuodse1 sosjaain So e1ed jeosy eaqnoaxa ovbe ep ojuaWeUoIoa,!pel 0 Bied ozeid © wiaBeiu09 ap sul eved e1eU onde ep euo9) ep oBSeaIIde OBU ejad as NjOUOD sieuy segdesapisuog “epin ep no sueq sop ‘unas Jenn janissodu! 9 ‘oyd0u! oy!auIp wn ap apiB9 e & gos ‘soIe snas ap eoneid jesSa00U B WEAUODUA Ov anb soepepID Sop apepillalasoUz09 nojeo & Bee ‘edueYUODSAP esned ‘ezayeO e euU|9 anb WO epIpaL eu ‘ojUauiIsjonuasap oF slanpuIosadul! sivioos soodmnsuI o|UeNbUD oUPIOIPNE Jepod Op 2 o's1IG op oUps19 0 eIeqe ‘etoUgNbasuOD JOd ‘edueINBesu! eSs3 levoroipsunf ejay e 12 q0 ap wertop ebuenBosul e198 ossi ud ‘sonjno 2 waigo sun ‘euaiqoid owseul o exe ‘sien soseo wa sieunqu, no sazinr Jod esianp eusueur ap opeyaidinqut 9 01 no eifa1 ewsow Ewin opuenb ‘21D, ‘IqWeD opseNp| EUNYe aUuO}UOD “B19 se pepmiarsinaid 9 oBdeztgerse ap jaded nas “19] ep “opuesn 9 eduesnBasul 3110) opuesoB ‘seo OUISOL o Bed S19] SEIN ap eIoURS! ‘soseo eyed ogdnjos ens & [2% ‘sowowiesinf ap ergugsne y ‘aszenly & essed elouepni edueunBosur ‘owuevod “eH Ybues, 2124U09 ay] anb o ‘soy 1d sowuoWa}9 uesngos ‘y10¢ 198/'ni cet 828 U'Ze OW ‘squazOH OP8 '044a9y = fss220%4 aNG ap eyaySEXIeIsK2y Wo}pUN eDIEAIS 5 9 oquouaonuosop ou soxoyos snos 9 ste08y soginooxo sep cIUOW {UNAY) S2310991 SeUON 2p ob0!2085¥ BP ZOOR'EzO HAN & auO}L09 ‘x= 2189p eaYEIBONIIG ODD “eT0z 290/190 ‘ya “u "Tz oue ‘aiuozLOH O19 ‘alsa — fensse0014 ‘sesuds 2 soud :emauaprudsunf ap oebemuLoun “BIRUEC “SUOAVIA “esou. “tog ‘enexes :oIned OFS ‘po “E “OUEIMaNA OWN ew :0Ined 08s “ovIN Ip ou ozduosard 2 eougpeoag ‘ap 21UIa s ‘S00z ‘SouBUIEW :0INed OBS ‘Pe “9z,“OHEINAUI CNEND ap Os: aad ‘owozuol 019g ‘oLuaay ~ fenssedoKg oa op exoyse%E eisiiou “50 2 01131 op fer1pnf opdeuD “ep sandupoy oMOPrer “YOIND IGNIY “3002 steunauy sop wisi ‘sosseq suspen, "p1009 “(e002/SET 91) SSI (ZOO/FTT 919 966T/SB 31) ‘Bue ‘ersu9pmudsun{ 9 euunnop :opequewo> jeuO!DeN OUEANEN Of1009 “=p: “etog ‘enews fenos 9s0r ap sed 2 seansadsied 9 eanuo seg ou oupinain "5002 ‘aw cone i soesBew omen “OLONI “ D000'r betwee TOG “unl Ze "ara “Ao “Wed ee ‘SO ‘9p opersa op ednisnr op roun ‘ous00y oIned “ey "S20 “T-GB6LEL ot UI "FEO NO Tr ‘97a “NO “wed eF “zUN ‘SolUeS aupuy oR 18u “Sq “G-99PETR ot UiBY "gUEreY Op OPeISy OP eaNENF ap YeuNgU “ISvLIA 0102" T'E0 :Uo open Teun ‘a1be19 way “UW T9W ‘94295 tl OveUIpLOeMg OS:nIDy “es9pE4 eUNqUL oWaIANS “ISVE "6002. seu ve ‘870 'g00z"TT'Oz Wo opeSInt ‘ewn, epunitog “uwefuea ueWwoH “UN “184 ‘SU/TLS'Z90"F dS3y OU Buy “ednsNr ap feunqu. soVEdNS “ISVEa "6002 195 BT ‘9fg “BWLN, epunitog ‘SuIMeWY CYOqUINH “LIN "198 'S4/LO6°OOT'T day ou BYBY “ebnsnY ap feunquL sovadng “SVE ‘OuoqUINH “UW “8Y "SUL «z JS-LLE"OST'T day OU BuBy “et "600% i9® =F “97d ‘6002'€0'Gz Wa Opefint “ovdos, ‘ound “epnaty 9siUAd ERSIUIN 18H ’S3/006 POT'T ou ds3u “ednsnt 8p feuNaU JoUBdNS “USVI “epnuy asiuag EASING "eu ‘9S/208"rEL dsau OU Bey “edsnr 9p euNguy JoUadhs ~ '6002"T'Sz swe opeIny‘opIyjeNIeD UOMINHEH “UN “08, “opdag exiauud eed open ‘os/eBPTOL dsa¥a OU Fay “e>nsnr 9p yeunqu JoUadNS “SVU ‘YOO 398 90 ‘GAT “d ‘ra “yo0e'80'EO “ewiny «2 ‘SHOW OnSeD ONSIUIN “ey ‘Aa/TTS'EL dsau “edNSAT ap jeUNqU JoUadns “SYS “0102 “unter ‘ara “eum az “eHaW onseo “UW ‘ee ‘OPPOBYTOEOOE wt dezu OU BoxBy “ednSNr OP FeUNqU JoUBdNS “sya “POE “*94 vz ‘970 “TFOR'Z0'ST "eULNL ez "sonbiew yeaciwea osnew “UN 8M S/ETZ"TTZ"T WU By OU BBY "ednsny ap jeunauovadns “usw “2002 798 62 7a “nz, joy "2uuny

You might also like