Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://www.boardersforchrist.com/2011/03/pray-for-japan/
more often and stop rushing to the aid of others, I will argue here that the U.S. should not only
continue aiding other countries but that it should do more than it already is to help others.
This tag hoped to unite the world in helping a country through a string of disasters.
http://www.pixteller.com/livingclay
In May 1999, a storm struck India reportedly killing 278 people and affecting 40,000.
On the same day, a fifteen-year old sophomore shot and wounded six classmates at Heritage
High School in suburban Atlanta. The two events competed for news time. Since this was just a
month after the Columbine High School tragedy, the events at Heritage High School were
extensively covered by the U.S. television network news, while the Indian storm was not covered.
About one year earlier, a storm of similar size struck India (killing 250 and affecting 40,000
people). At that time, there was less breaking news around, and the storm was covered by the
television network news. Two days later, the U.S. Ambassador in India, Richard F. Celeste,
declared this storm a disaster, and its victims consequently received U.S. relief. He did not issue
a disaster declaration for the May 1999 storm and its victims received no U.S. government
relief. (Eisensee and Stromberg, 2007)
The anecdote above, provided by Eisensee and Stromberg, perfectly illustrates this
picture of how media coverage and international attention at the time that a crisis occurs affects
how much aid, if any at all, that the U.S. will choose to send. We see similar statistics in the
affected people between both events; however, in one case, the event is overshadowed by a more
relevant and domestic issue and, in the other, we see that it becomes a world headline because of
how much worse the event seemed because it was declared a disaster. While Eisensee and
Stromberg assert that [t]here is no reason to believe that the severity of natural disasters in
foreign countries is related to the availability of other news, they also claim that U.S. policy
makers are less likely to declare disasters when other newsworthy stories are in abundance.
However, because more severe disasters are more likely to be in the news and, therefore, more
likely to receive relief, they allow that the question of whether or not media coverage actually
correlates directly to relief aid is a difficult one to answer through empirical data. Additionally,
they share that a policy maker could equally alert the press of disasters that they would
personally prefer to provide relief to and, by doing so, strengthen the correlation without making
it any easier to determine the cause. The question is a tricky one to unravel and answer; however,
regardless of why the U.S. chooses to send aid to those that it helps, Eisensee and Stromberg
refute Natsioss claim that the U.S. has fallen off as a leading nation in relief efforts by following
where the majority of resources have come from. Providing roughly one-third of the total
resources for relief, the U.S. leads all other countries by a large margin and is also almost always
the first to respond to the scene of a disaster because of its dedication of government funds
toward international disaster relief programs. (Eisensee, 2007)
of the help that they provided during the Revolution (Stewart, 2013). When Hurricanes Katrina
and Rita struck the U.S. Gulf Coast in 2005, many countries like Australia, Canada, and France
came together to provide aid and relief for the friend that had so often and quickly responded
during others in their times of need, donating approximately $7.5 million, a variety of emergency
medicines and supplies, and hundreds of emergency personnel (Liu, 2011). It is most easily seen
when countries face desperate times, which is simply that humanity is never more powerfully
brought together than when tragedies like tsunamis, floods, hurricanes, and earthquakes strike
and affect the lives of many.
Stand Together
Standing united, the world is not a heavy enough
weight to crush Mans spirit.
http://theamicableguns.deviantart.com/art/United-westand-Divided-we-fall-361104648
Given all the information before, I would like to propose that the United States, already
doing significant work in aiding others, should strive to do even more. Though many would say
that it would be an unnecessary exercise, it should be worth noting that, even with the combined
efforts of all the relief agencies, many disasters go unaided. (Eisensee, 2007) We can never help
others enough to the point where all disasters will be provided for but the least that we can do is
try. As noted earlier, there is an incidental relationship between media attention and disaster
relief. If we as a world would unite in our efforts to relieve other countries of disasters when they
came up and passed resources along freely to work towards the goal of united progress, rather
than competing with one another for the best statistics, the world could be a much better place.
As more and more crises arise, its no longer enough to offer emotional support (though I would
say that it does go a long way), we must unite in our efforts and push even harder to aid each
other when disasters strike quickly. Theres enough pain and suffering that occurs when the
disaster strikes, theres no need for us to prolong the hurt by taking unnecessary amounts of time
trying to mobilize relief efforts. In summary, though the United States does more than its fair
share to try and aid others when disasters happen, I argue that we must do more as its citizens to
set an example and make an effort to unite as humans.
Works Cited
Cheyfitz, E. (n.d.). Tarzan of the Apes : US Foreign Policy in the Twentieth Century. Am Lit Hist
American Literary History, 339-360.
Eisensee, T., & Stromberg, D. (2007). News Droughts, News Floods, and U.S. Disaster Relief.
The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 693-728.
Liu, A. (2011). Resilience and opportunity: Lessons from the U.S. Gulf Coast after Katrina and
Rita. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
Natsios, A. (1997). U.S. foreign policy and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse humanitarian
relief in complex emergencies. Westport, Conn.: Praeger.
Stewart, L. (2013). The history of us. New York: Simon & Schuster.