Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No.
DATE
REMARKS
CHKD
APPD
REVISION
LAKSHYA
PACKAGE :
TITLE :
765kV SWITCHYARD - SHORTCIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION
-EQUIPMENT
SCALE
SIGN
DATE
DSND
VTN
03/03/06
DRWN
CHKD
SSV
06/03/06
APPD
AKS
07/03/06
DRG.No.
CODE
REV.
01
2 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
DESIGN CALCULATION
SHEET
3 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
4 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
SYSTEM PARAMETERS
1.1.1
System Voltage
132
kV
1.1.2
Frequency
50
Hz
1.1.3
Fault level
Isc
31.5
kA
1.1.4
Duration of fault
Tfd
2.0.0
ENVIRONMENTAL DETAILS
2.1.5
gn
9.81
m/s2
3.0.0
OTHER DETAILS
3.1.1
3.1.3
2.50
3.1.4
Width of Girder
Wg
3.1.5
as
3.1.6
ls
3.1.7
li
m 0 for Equipment
(Assumed )
(Assumed)
(47 discs)
vtn:
m 0 for Equipment
3.1.8
Z0
40
kg
392.4
30
kg
294
3.1.9
100000
N/m
3.1.10
Material Constant
Cth
0.27E-18
m4/A2s
4.0.0
CONDUCTOR DATA
4.1.1
Type of conductor
ACSR
Code name
COWSLIP
a)
As
0.001013
b)
Aa
#REF!
c)
Overall Diameter
d)
e)
sq.m
ds
41.41
mm
m's
2.791
kg/m
6.73E+10
N/m2
(Typical Data)
5 of 89
TITLE
6.5.0
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
Lc
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
L -(2li + Wg)
4.00
SHEET
m
1
------->(7.4a)
6 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
8.0.0
8.0.1
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
. Temperature rise due to Short Circuit and the subsequent reduction in tension to this effect is neglected.
. The equations apply for span length upto approximately 60m
8.0.2
b)
Tensile force (Ff) after Short Circuit caused by drop (Drop force)
c)
CALCULATION
8.1.0
8.1.1
0.75 (I"K3)2 Lc
2a
8.1.2
(Pg-39)
L
59.54
N/m
F'
(Pg-39)
n * m's * gn
8.1.3
59.54 / (1*2.791*9.81)
2.1744
arctan( r )
arctan(2.1744)
1.1397
radians
65.30
degrees
n * m's * gn * L2
8.1.4
(Pg-39)
(Pg-39)
8 Fst
8.1.5
0.14
0.8 *bc
gn
(Pg-39)
7 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
2 * (0.8*0.140 / 9.81)
0.67
secs
SHEET
8 of 89
TITLE
8.1.6
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
T
d1
1+r2 1-2
64
8.1.7
DATE
2/21/2016
(Pg-41)
2
90o
0.67/((1+2.1744)^0.25*(1-/64*(65.30/90))
0.47
secs
5.00E+07
N/m2
392.4 /( 1*0.001013)
sfin
Fst / n As
3.87E+05
Actual Young's modulus
Es
(Pg-41)
N/m2
E 0.3+0.7 sin
Fst *90o
n As dfin
nAs
8.1.8
6.73E+10*(0.3+0.7*sin(392.4*90/(1*0.001013*5.00E+7))
2.08E+10
SL
8.1.9
(Pg-41)
n Es As
2.55E-06
( n gn m's L )2
1/N
24 (Fst)3
8.1.10
N/m2
(Pg-41)
3.2468
Tfc
sec
0.4T
0.268
sec
Tk1
Tk1/Tres
Minimum(1,0.268)
0.268
0.27/0.47
0.5686
(Assumed)
sec
(Pg-41)
Swing out Angle
dk
9 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
2d1
Hence dk
2* 65.30
130.61
SHEET
degrees
10 of 89
TITLE
8.1.11
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
=
Hence
8.1.12
SHEET
1 - r sin dk
(Pg-43)
for 0 < dk < 90o
1-r
1-2.174
d = -1.1744
(Pg-43)
dm
8.1.13
DATE
2/21/2016
1.25 arccosd
10 + arc cosd
180o
d < -0.985
180.00
180.00
0.4716 / 4
0.1179
3(
degrees
secs
(Pg-43)
1+r2 - 1)
8.1.14
3 ((1+2.1744) - 1)
4.1800
d2 c 3 + w ( 2+d) d
+ (1+2d) d - d (2+d) = 0
(Pg-43)
17.473 + 21.932+7.494-20.065 = 0
Solving the above
8.1.15
0.6691
Ft
for n=1
for n>2
(Pg-43)
Ft
8.2
8.2.1
392.4 (1+4.1800*0.6691)
1490
1.49 KN
1.2 Fst 1 + 8d dm
Tensile force (Ff) after Short Circuit caused by drop (Drop force)
Drop force Ff
(Pg-45)
11 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
180o
Ff
2446
2.45 KN
SHEET
12 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
8.3
8.3.1
8.3.2
DATE
2/21/2016
N (Ft - Fst)
2.80E-03
SHEET
(Pg-45)
Thermal Expansion
Cth
Eth
0.27E-18
Cth
m4/A2s
I"K3 Tres/4
(Pg-45)
for Tk1>Tres/4
nAs
Cth
I"K3 Tk1
for Tk1<Tres/4
nAs
8.3.3
0.27E-18*(31500/(1*0.001013))*0.47/4
3.08E-05
1+3
8
8.3.4
(Eela+Eth)
(Pg-45)
(1+3/8*(4/0.14)*(2.80E-03+3.08E-05))
1.37
1.05
0.97+0.1r
1.15
(Pg-45)
CF
=
=
8.3.5
L
bc
1.15
#REF!
1.15
bh
bh
b h=
CF CD bc
CF CD bc sin dm
CF CD bc sin d1
for dm > d1
CF CD bc sin dm
for dm < d1
slack
=
1.15*1.37*0.1396*
0.22
#NAME?
13 of 89
TITLE
8.3.6
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
a - 2bh
2.5- 2*0.22
2.06
(Pg-47)
#REF!
14 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
RESULTS
9.0.0
CONDUCTOR SELECTED
a)
Conductor Type
ACSR-COWSLIP
b)
No.of runs
1 run
c)
2.06
d)
Tensile force Ft
1.49 KN
e)
Drop force Ff
2.45 KN
g)
2.45 KN
Short Circuit Force of 0.00 KN (0.25T) shall be considered for Tower and Associated Foundation Design.
SHEET
15 of 89
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
16+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
DESIGN CALCULATION
SHEET
17+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
18+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
SYSTEM PARAMETERS
1.1.1
System Voltage
132
kV
1.1.2
Frequency
50
Hz
1.1.3
Fault level
Isc
32
kA
1.1.4
Duration of fault
Tfd
2.0.0
ENVIRONMENTAL DETAILS
2.1.5
gn
9.81
m/s2
3.0.0
OTHER DETAILS
3.1.1
3.1.3
2.50
3.1.4
Width of Girder
Wg
#NAME?
(Assumed )
3.1.5
as
3.1.6
ls
#NAME?
(Assumed)
3.1.7
li
47*0.145+0.2
3.1.8
Z0
30.00
kg
294.3
(Assumed)
0
3.1.9
100000
N/m
3.1.10
Material Constant
Cth
0.27E-18
m4/A2s
4.0.0
CONDUCTOR DATA
4.1.1
Type of conductor
ACSR
Code name
COWSLIP
c)
As
#REF!
d)
Aa
#REF!
e)
Overall Diameter
f)
g)
sq.m
ds
#REF!
mm
m's
#REF!
kg/m
#REF!
N/m2
(Typical Data)
19+18 of 89+18
TITLE
6.5.0
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
Lc
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
=
=
=
DATE
2/21/2016
SHEET
L -(2li + Wg)
#NAME?
#NAME?
1
m
------->(7.4a)
20+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
8.0.0
8.0.1
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
. Temperature rise due to Short Circuit and the subsequent reduction in tension to this effect is neglected.
. The equations apply for span length upto approximately 60m
8.0.2
b)
Tensile force (Ff) after Short Circuit caused by drop (Drop force)
c)
CALCULATION
8.1.0
8.1.1
0.75 (I"K3)2 Lc
2a
=
=
8.1.2
(Pg-39)
L
#NAME?
#NAME?
N/m
F'
(Pg-39)
n * m's * gn
=
8.1.3
#NAME?
#REF!
arctan( r )
8.1.4
(Pg-39)
#REF!
#REF!
radians
#REF!
degrees
n * m's * gn * L2
(Pg-39)
8 Fst
=
8.1.5
#REF!
#REF!
0.8 *bc
gn
(Pg-39)
21+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
=
=
#REF!
#REF!
secs
SHEET
22+18 of 89+18
TITLE
8.1.6
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
T
d1
1+r2 1-2
64
8.1.7
DATE
2/21/2016
(Pg-41)
2
90o
#REF!
#REF!
secs
5.00E+07
N/m2
#REF!
sfin
Fst / n As
#REF!
Actual Young's modulus
Es
(Pg-41)
N/m2
E 0.3+0.7 sin
Fst *90o
n As dfin
nAs
8.1.8
#REF!
#REF!
SL
8.1.9
N/m2
#REF!
#REF!
( n gn m's L )2
1/N
24 (Fst)3
=
=
8.1.10
(Pg-41)
n Es As
(Pg-41)
#REF!
#REF!
Tfc
sec
0.4T
#REF!
sec
Tk1
Tk1/Tres
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
(Assumed)
sec
(Pg-41)
Swing out Angle
dk
23+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
2d1
Hence dk
#REF!
#REF!
SHEET
degrees
24+18 of 89+18
TITLE
8.1.11
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
=
Hence
8.1.12
SHEET
1 - r sin dk
(Pg-43)
for 0 < dk < 90o
1-r
#REF!
d = #REF!
(Pg-43)
dm
8.1.13
DATE
2/21/2016
1.25 arccosd
10 + arc cosd
180o
d < -0.985
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
3(
degrees
secs
(Pg-43)
1+r2 - 1)
#REF!
#REF!
d2 c 3 + w ( 2+d) d
+ (1+2d) d - d (2+d) = 0
(Pg-43)
#REF!
Solving the above
8.1.15
0.6198
Ft
for n=1
for n>2
(Pg-43)
Ft
8.2
8.2.1
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
1.2 Fst 1 + 8d dm
Tensile force (Ff) after Short Circuit caused by drop (Drop force)
Drop force Ff
(Pg-45)
25+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
180o
Ff
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
SHEET
26+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
8.3
8.3.1
8.3.2
DATE
2/21/2016
N (Ft - Fst)
#REF!
#REF!
SHEET
(Pg-45)
Thermal Expansion
Cth
Eth
0.27E-18
Cth
m4/A2s
I"K3 Tres/4
(Pg-45)
for Tk1>Tres/4
nAs
Cth
I"K3 Tk1
for Tk1<Tres/4
nAs
8.3.3
#REF!
#REF!
1+3
8.3.4
(Eela+Eth)
(Pg-45)
#REF!
#REF!
1.05
0.97+0.1r
1.15
(Pg-45)
CF
=
=
8.3.5
L
bc
#REF!
#REF!
bh
bh
b h=
CF CD bc
CF CD bc sin dm
CF CD bc sin d1
for dm > d1
CF CD bc sin dm
for dm < d1
slack
=
#REF!
#REF!
27+18 of 89+18
TITLE
8.3.6
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
a - 2bh
#REF!
#REF!
(Pg-47)
28+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
8.4
Pinch force shall be ignored if the sub-conductors of the bundle said to clash effectively. For effective Clashing following conditions shall be satisfied
as/ds < 2.0 and ls > 50as
(Pg-47)
#REF!
ls/as
#NAME?
n1
#REF!
8.4.1
Factors n1,
8.4.1.1
Factor d1
(as-ds) m's
mo
sin 180o
(Pg-49)
(n-1)
as
2n
n
=
I"k3
50
#REF!
sin(180/1)
(4.10-7/2*(31500/1) *(1-1)/0
0.00
1.02+0.98e-3(R/X)
1.81
-2f
ln k-1.02
0.98
Factor d2
8.4.1.2
( As per pg 47 of IEC:909)
Assuming X/R = 14
-2 *50/3*ln((1.81-1.02)/0.98)
22.44
0.045
arctan(2fd)
arctan (2*50*0.045)
1.50
(Pg-109)
Factor (g)
n2
n1
= fTpi d2
(Pg-109)
(Pg-109)
8.4.1.3
n2
n3
0.0000
Factor d3
ds/as
sin(180/n)
(as/ds-1)
tan-1(as/ds-1)
(Pg-111)
29+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
#REF!
#REF!
0.0000
SHEET
30+18 of 89+18
TITLE
8.4.2
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
(n-1) mo I"k3
ls
d2
as
(Pg-49)
n3
#NAME?
0.00
est
(as-ds)
epi
The Parameter
(Pg-49)
(Pg-49)
#NAME?
0.375nFd ls3N
#REF!
#NAME?
(Epi/(1+Est))
#NAME?
sin 180
n
j
j
=
0
sin 180
#REF!
(as-ds)3
8.4.4
SHEET
8.4.3
DATE
2/21/2016
#NAME?
(Pg-49)
31+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
32+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
8.4.5
8.4.5.1
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
ya
asw
1/2*(as-d*(as-ds))
SHEET
(Pg-53)
as 2ya/as
((1-2yaas)/(2yaas))
sin 180o
arctan((1-2yaas)/(2yaas))
(Pg-53)
n
fh
h3 +dst h - dpi fh =
Solving for
asd3/asw
(Pg-53)
0 < h< 1
(Pg-53)
d
h
n4
#NAME?
8.4.5.2
h (as-ds)
(Pg-51)
as-d(as-ds)
=
ne
8.4.5.3
#NAME?
#NAME?
2 n
as-ds
d4
#NAME?
1/2
(Pg-51)
Fst(1+de/Est *
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
d2))
(Pg-51)
33+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
34+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
RESULTS
9.0.0
CONDUCTOR SELECTED
a)
Conductor Type
ACSR-COWSLIP
b)
No.of runs
1 run
e)
#REF!
f)
Tensile force Ft
#REF!
#REF!
g)
Drop force Ff
#REF!
#REF!
h)
#NAME?
I)
#REF!
###
#NAME?
#REF!
35+18 of 89+18
TITLE
DOCUMENT NO
: LAKSHYA
DATE
2/21/2016
PREPARED
CHECKED
VTN
SSV
SHEET
Quad Moose-60m
Page 36
Quad Moose-60m
Page 37
Quad Moose-60m
Page 38
Quad Moose-60m
Page 39
Quad Moose-60m
Page 40
Quad Moose-60m
Page 41
Twin Moose-60m
Page 42
Twin Moose-60m
Page 43
Twin Moose-60m
Page 44
Twin Moose-60m
Page 45
Twin Moose-60m
Page 46
Twin Moose-60m
Page 47
Twin Moose-137m
Page 48
Twin Moose-137m
Page 49
Twin Moose-137m
Page 50
Twin Moose-137m
Page 51
Twin Moose-137m
139.7
Page 52
Twin Moose-137m
Page 53
Twin Moose-150m
Page 54
Twin Moose-150m
Page 55
Twin Moose-150m
Page 56
Twin Moose-150m
Page 57
Twin Moose-150m
152.6
Page 58
Twin Moose-150m
Page 59
Twin Moose-153m
Page 60
Twin Moose-153m
Page 61
Twin Moose-153m
Page 62
Twin Moose-153m
Page 63
Twin Moose-153m
155.8
Page 64
Twin Moose-153m
Page 65
Twin Moose-130.2
Page 66
Twin Moose-130.2
Page 67
Twin Moose-130.2
Page 68
Twin Moose-130.2
Page 69
Twin Moose-130.2
130.2
Page 70
Twin Moose-130.2
Page 71
Twin Moose-124.4m
Page 72
Twin Moose-124.4m
Page 73
Twin Moose-124.4m
Page 74
Twin Moose-124.4m
Page 75
Twin Moose-124.4m
124.4
Page 76
Twin Moose-124.4m
Page 77
Twin Moose-133.7m
Page 78
Twin Moose-133.7m
Page 79
Twin Moose-133.7m
Page 80
Twin Moose-133.7m
Page 81
Twin Moose-133.7m
133.7
Page 82
Twin Moose-133.7m
Page 83
CUBIC EQUATION
+d st d - d pifn = 0
A0
1
1
Coeff
A1
0
(Eqn 62,Pg-56-IEC:865-Part-I)
A2
2.10E-031
2.10E-031
A3
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
SOLUTION
REF
Schaum Series-Mathematics
=(3 A2-A12)/9
6.99E-032
=(9 A1A2-27A3-2A13)/54
#DIV/0!
=3(R+(Q3+R2))
#DIV/0!
=3(R-(Q3+R2))
#DIV/0!
=Q3+R2
#DIV/0!
D<0
D=0
D>0
Result
#DIV/0!
Theta
#DIV/0!
Root1
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
Root2
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
Root3
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
CHECK
(-) abg
(+) d d +d d +dd
(-) d+d+d
Calculated
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
Actual
#DIV/0!
2.10E-031
0
Error (%)
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
0.00000%
Error (%)
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
0.00000%
CUBIC EQUATION
+d st d - d pifn = 0
A0
1
1
Coeff
A1
0
(Eqn 62,Pg-56-IEC:865-Part-I)
A2
#NAME?
#NAME?
A3
#NAME?
#NAME?
SOLUTION
REF
Schaum Series-Mathematics
=(3 A2-A12)/9
#NAME?
=(9 A1A2-27A3-2A13)/54
#NAME?
=3(R+(Q3+R2))
#NAME?
=3(R-(Q3+R2))
#NAME?
=Q3+R2
#NAME?
D<0
D=0
D>0
Result
#NAME?
Theta
#NAME?
Root1
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
Root2
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
Root3
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
Actual
#NAME?
#NAME?
0
Error (%)
#NAME?
#NAME?
0.00000%
CHECK
(-) ddd
(+) dd+dd+dd
(-) d+d+d
Calculated
#NAME?
#NAME?
#NAME?
Error (%)
#NAME?
#NAME?
0.00000%
CUBIC EQUATION
d2 c 3 + d ( 2+d) d
A0
+ (1+2d) d - d (2+d) = 0
A1
A2
(Eqn 33,Pg-43-IEC:865-Part-I)
A3
Coeff
SOLUTION
REF
Schaum Series-Mathematics
=(3 A2-A12)/9
-0.032102
=(9 A1A2-27A3-2A13)/54
0.590669
=3(R+(Q3+R2))
1.057113
=3(R-(Q3+R2))
0.030368
=Q3+R2
0.348857
D<0
D=0
D>0
Result
0.669078
Theta
Root1
-0.060062
0.669078
0.669078
Root2
-0.597573
-0.962143
-0.96214+0.88919i
-0.96214+0.88919i
Root3
-0.597573
-0.962143
-0.96214-0.88919i
-0.96214-0.88919i
CHECK
Calculated
(-) ddd
(+) dd+dd+dd
(-) d+d+d
Actual
Error (%)
-1.14839
-1.148388
0.428878969699712+9.992007220.428876
-0.00008%
#VALUE!
1.255202
-0.00048%
1.255208
CUBIC EQUATION
+d st d
A0
1
1
Coeff
- d pi = 0
A1
2.10E-031
2.10E-031
(Eqn 51,Pg-54-IEC:865-Part-I)
A2
0
0
A3
0
0
SOLUTION
REF
Schaum Series-Mathematics
=(3 A2-A12)/9
-4.9E-063
=(9 A1A2-27A3-2A13)/54
-3.4E-094
=3(R+(Q3+R2))
#VALUE!
=3(R-(Q3+R2))
#VALUE!
=Q3+R2
D<0
D=0
D>0
Result
#VALUE!
Theta
Root1
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
Root2
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
Root3
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
CHECK
(-) ddd
(+) dd+dd+dd
(-) d+d+d
Calculated
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
#VALUE!
Actual
0
0
2.10E-031
Error (%)
#VALUE!
0.00000%
#VALUE!