1

2016 - 1437


6 .........................................................................
: 7................................

9 .................................................................... :
11 .....................................................................
:
: 17 .........................
: 22 .....................................
:

: 32 .............................................
: 51 .............................................
: 67 .................................

: :
: 74 ..........
: 87 .....................
: 95 ...
:
: 111 ....
: 119 .......................
: 135 ..
:

: 145 ..........................
: 192 .........................
: 219 ..............................
235 .....................................................
5


-
2014/5/14
:



2010

. " " .

.

.
.

. ""
. " "

.(1920-1864
.

1804) . .

-
-

.
.

.
.
.

-
.
. .

.
.

2015/04/24




.
-
- .


.

10

11




:
. )1


" " ""
)2

. )3



- - :

(Richard Daft, Leadership, China, South-Western Cengage Learning, )1

5th ed., 2011, p. 28

( )2 :
2010 .24

( )3
1996 1 .14

12

" " )4
.

!.



)5

.)6

" "
.

)7 " : " )8

.
( )4 .
) )5 .28
Richard Daft, Leadership, p 28.

))6

) )7
2008 .7

))8

Joanne Ciulla, Ethics, the Heart of Leadership, Westport, CT :

Greenwood, 1998, P 28-130.

13



.)9




.

.
)
.
)

.
:
)
.
.
)

))9

M. Hitt, C. Miller, A. Colella, Organizational Behavior, New Jersey:

John Wiley and Sons, 2009, P 48.

14

 .
.
)



.

15

16

 :
:
)
" "

"" .


.
:
. . - .

17

 1-1 :
"
" :
: " "
"" ""

.

:


.
:


.

.
:



"" .

18

 2-1 :


" "


. )10


:
:
1-2-1

:
-1
.
-2
.
-3
.
( )10 : .2013

19

 -4 .


Validity .Reliability
2-2-1


:
-1

-2

)
.

-3

20

 3-1


:
-1 .
-2
-3 .
-4 .
-5
.
-6
.

:



.

.

21

22

 :
:



)11
.
"

" )12 "

"
" )13
"
" .)14

( )11 :

: 2008 1
SPSS

: 2009 1

2013 1.


( )12 .64
( )13 .74
.16
( )14

23




.

:
1-2




.


) .


)
.)15

( )15 2011 1
.73
24

 2-2
:
1-2-2 :

.
" "Mixed Methodology
" . )16 "Hybrid Methodology
2-2-2 :
.)17

.)18
)19

Quantitative ) )20 Qualitative
.

( )16 :
: 2004 1.
Mixed Methodology, 1999. Tashakkori & Teddlie 2004

( )17 :
.

( )18 .74
( )19
2003 .217
)20 .218
25

 3-2-2 :
.
""
.
:)21
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
)

.
)

.)22
4-2-2 :

: .

( )21 :
- .

()22

.226
26


)23
:
)1 ) .
)2 .
)3 .
)4 .
3-2





. 38

)24
:
.1
).

.2

).
( )23 .247
( )24 .286
27

 .3

).

.4
).

1 ) 5 ) .

)
)
.
)

.


.


.
.

28

 4-2


:
.
. )25
) :
1

30

15

0.6

15

0.6

15

0.531

8.7

0.5

15

0.400

6.6

0.250

10

0.375

5.6

0.200

9.04

0.316

.
( )25 :
)2012 329
353
)2012 .424 417

29

 5-2


.



.



- -
.
:


:
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5

30







.

)
.

.

31

32

 :
:
""

" " .


.
.
:


. . :

33

 1-3


.
.)26

.

.

.


.



.
. )27

2002 1 .23
( )26

( )27 :
12004
:

..
34


:
.

.
.
.

.
.
.
" "
.
.



.




35


. )28
2-3

1-2-3
"
"

. - -
"
" .
2-2-3


.

" "
:
-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4 .
1
( )28
2008 .144

36

 .

.)29
3-3

:
.1 ).
.2
).
.3
).

: " " . )30

" :
" .)31

()29

2010
:
: .

( )30 . 96
( )31 - 2
2008 .8
37

 " : " . )32

" : " . )33
"
"

.)34

" :
" . )35
" :
" . )36
" :
( )32

1997 .128
()33

- : 1
2001 .35

)34 .53
)35 : 1999 131
: 2008 .139
)36 :
2012 1 .23
38



" . )37
" :
.)38
"
" : " .)39
4-3
"" Bass " : " .)40
" :
" .)41
"" Golembiewsky" : " .)42
)37 .238
()38

2010 1

.18

( )39 2002 1 .40

( Bass,1960: 90 )40 2002 .90

1997
( )41

260 : 2008 .139

39

 "" Tead " : " .)43

"" Litterer " : " . )44

"" Hyman " : " .)45
"" Landsberg" : " .)46
" " Burns " :

" .)47
" " Yuke ":

" . )48

( Golembiewsky, 1961: 34 )42 2002 .90

( Tead,1963: 19 )43 2002 .89
( Litterer, 1973: 168 )44 2002 .90
( )45 - .6
( )46 .25
( )47 12008 .15
( )48 .15
40

5-3 :
1-5-3
:



. " "
Raven, French
" :
. )49 "
"" Yukl

( )49 .149
41

: )50
-1

-2

-3

-4

-5

-6

.
-7

-8

.
-9

-10
.
( )50 .149
42

 -11

.
2-5-3


.

.
Robert Kats

: )51
-1 :


: )
)
.


.

( )51 142
43


.
-2 :

.


""
.
:
- .

. . . -3 :
""
. ""
.

.

""
.
44

 6-3


:
1-6-3
Trait Theory

.

. )52


:)53

- Consistent Pattern of

.Traits

. .
( )52 .312
( )53 . -
2006 .43-42

45

 . .
)54 10 - - :
.

"" ""
.

- " :
.. ..
)55
"
2-6-3
Situational Theory


.

.

) .
( )54 .
( )55
2009 1.
46




.

: )56
. -

.
3-6-3
Interactional Theory


. ""
.

.


:
.

( )56 . - .95-93
47


. )57
4-6-3



Effective

Efficient

.)58 Management by obgective

" " Transformational Leadership
" " )59 Burnz



.
: 2010 1
( )57
.48
) )58 : . -

E., Integrating Leadership Styles and Ethical

(59) Aronson,

Perspectives, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 2001, 18(4),

p. 244-256.

48


" "
.
7-3
Transformational Leadership


" " Visionary Leadership

.
Burns,

Pase, Nanos, Bennis

.)60

Burns

).
61

( )60 .74
Terry L. Price, Understanding Ethical Failures in

()61

Leadership, Cambridge University Press, New York, 2006,

p. 124
49


.)62

""

.

.

) )62 2012 1
.41
50

51

" ".

- . :

52

 1-4
1-1-4
" : " . )63
" :
" :
"
" " :
" .)64 )
)
: )65
.1 .
.2 .
.3 : .
Ethics Ethos
" " . )66
:)67
.1 " : Values
".
()63

1996 5

.1137

( )64 1989 1 .252

( )65 1992 2 .34
( )66 . - .334
()67

2012 3 -18

20
53

 .2 " :Customs
".
.3 " :Traditions
".
.4 " : Morals ".
2-1-4

:
3-1-4

"

:

" ).

68

":

: :

:
) )68

1985 .25
54

.)69 "

: )70
" ". " ."
" "

)71

" )


" .)72

) )69 2008 2 .27

()70

12006 .18

) )71 1 2005 .12

) )72 21
55

 "
" . )73
"
" . )74
"
" . )75
: )76
" ".
"
".
" ".
".

2012 1.8
) )73
) )74 .8

) )75 .8
) )76 .12
56

 " ".
4-1-4


:



.)77

.
:
" : " . )78
-

" : " . )79

" -
" . )80

) )77 .29

)Rue, L. & Byars, L.Management, Irwin, Homewood, 1989 P. 93 )78

)Hitt, et al, P. 49 )79

) )80 .30
57

 Ethical "
" Longman Ethics
:)81
" ". " ". " ". " - ".

) )81 6

58

 2-4


.

.
: .)82
:
{: } . )83 { : } .)84 {: } . )85.)86
- "- " " " . )87 " " . )88
- -
.
- -
2012 4 19
( )82

( )83 .4

( )84 .200
( )85 .1
( )86 .
( )87
( )88 .

59

 " : " -
- ": " .
.)89

- -

" : :
:
" .)90


364 -) :

"


" . )91

( )89 )258/1
2010 1 .25
) )90 : 2006

.40

) )91 :
2011 5 .188
60

) :
92

.
.
.
.
.
.

:
. - - . . . . . .-

.
.
.
.

) )92
1996 1 .52-32
61

.
.
.
.

:
. . . . .
:
. )93
3-4


" " : )94

( )93 :
2010/6/6-5 .
()94

2013 3

.21-20
62

 " ".
" ".
" " .

: .
: )95
-

" " . )96

" " . )97
.
.
" " . )98
.)99
" "
.
.

()95
()96
()97

.37
.
.

( )98
( )99 .

63

 )100
- -

" " . )101


.)102
4-4


" " Code of Ethics

.
. )103


.

( )100 .74
( )101

) )102 :
2012 5.101

2011 1
( )103

63

64


.



" "
" " 1776)
" "
- 1962)
.

)
Multinational Corporations
.

" " Ethical Profits
" " Absolute Profits
" "
. )104

-
Abdullah Al- Beraidi, Developing Morality in Business
Students: Insights From Arab-Islamic Culture and Business
Experience, in: Charles Wankel and Agata (ed s), Stachwicz()104

Stanusch, Effectively Integrating Ethical Dimension, Information

Age Publishing Inc., Charlotte, North Carolina, 2011, p.39.
65

 "
" .)105

. .

( )105 2006 1 .54

66

67

 :
:



.

" ".
:
) . :
.
.
.

68

 1-5 .
""
.



.)106

" "

. )107




.

()106

:
2006 .
( )107

2009/12/11.

69

 " "
.

:
-1

.
-2
.
-3
.
-4

.
-5
.
2-5


.



.
70




:
.1
.
.2
.
.3
.
.4

.
.5
.
3-5

.

.

71

 " " " "

social media .)108


" "
.
:
-1
Business Ethics

.
-2 )
.
-3
.
-4
.
-5
.
-6

.

( )108 : : 2011 .
72

 -7 Benchmarking
.

. :
)

.

73

 :
:

74

:


)
.



.


:
. - .

75

 1-6


)109
.



.
1-1-6
182-113)

" "
.

"

( )109 :
12000 4
2010 1996 6
. 1998 4
.
76

 " .
.)110
2-1-6
329-259)
" "
""


.)111
3-1-6

450-364 ) .

. )112

" : - -
...

( )110 -

2010 1 51

( )111 : 1
1991 : .
( )112 - .53
77

 " .)113

. )114
4-1-6

505-450)
" " "
" .


:)115
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .

( )113

1 1983 .137

( )114 :

( )115 :

78

 5-1-6
808-732 )
" :


" .)116
2-6



":

" .)117

- -

( )116 1
2004.

( )117
.231
79

)118 .

:
" : "





.

" " "

"

{: } )119 { :

} )120 { : } )121 {:
} )122

- -
( )118

2005 1 .234

( )119 .4
( )120 .159
( )121 .45
( )122 .128
80

 " )123 - " -

"

" . )124 ""

: . )125

" " )126
- -
" :

"

.
" " "
)127

"

.


{ :
} )128 .

( )123 .
( )124 .
( )125 .
( )126
( )127

( )128 .90
81

{: } . )129
"


"
" :
" )130

.

- -
..." :





" .)131
" "

. :

. --
( )129 .26
( )130 .
( )131 .115
82

 :
:
. )132
" : "
"
"



.
:
. . . . . :
)
. )133
"
"
( )132 . .
2010.
2011 1
( )133

.337

83


.
":

:
)


" .
" :
"

.)134



. )135

()134

. ...
( )135 -
- ..
84

 :


.

.



.

85

86

)
.


)136
.

.

)137
.
:
. - .

( )136 .
( )137 : . -

Joanne Ciulla, Ethics, the heart of leadership

Terry L. Price,Understanding Ethical Failures in Leadership

87

 1-7



.
Leadership Archein
"" :

.
Interdependence
Relation ""
.)138

" " .
"


" .)139

: )140

( )138 : - :

( )139 .35
( )140 .37-33
88

 .1
.
.2 .
.3
.

""
.
2-7
" "
.
:
Brown )141 " :
".
Resick : )142"
: ".

)141( Brown, et al, 2005, in; Lenny Akker, et al,Ethical Leadership and Trust,

International Journal of Leadership Studies, Vol.5, Iss.2, 2009.

()142

Resick, et al, 2006,

.1019
89

 Fox " :)143

".


.
" " "
" )144 " " "
" )145 " "

)146 " " "
" Servant Leader
)147 "" ""

( )143 .1020
( )144 . - .336
)145( James M. Burns, J., Leadership, NY: Harper and Row, 1987.

Ronald A. Heifetz, Leadership without easy answer, Cambridge,

()146

Harvard University Press, 1994.

Robert K. Greenleaf, Servant leadership: A Journey into the

()147

Nature of Legitimate Power and Greatness, Paulist Press,

New Jersey, 2002.

90


.)148
" : " " "

:
" " " " " "
.
: )149

. . ""

.

"" ""
.
" "


- -

()148

()149

. - .338
.336-333
91

 - ":
".

"would you wish others to behave in the same :
. way if the action affected you?" .
" " "
"
: 1500

. )150

)151

:
.
:


)152

Richard Daft, Leadership, P 342.

Christian J. Resick, C., Keating, M., and Dickson, M.

()150

)151( Martin,G.,

(2009), Ethical leadership across cultures: a comparative analysis of

German and US perspectives, Business Ethics: A European Review
Volume 18, 2009.
Manuel Mendonca, Preparing for Ethical Leadership, Canadian

()152

Journal of Administrative Sciences, Vol. 18, #4 , 2001, p. 266-276.

92

"" "" )153 :

.
:
)154
:



).
Cyril & Girindra
172
.
. )155
R.N.Kanungo and M.Mendonca, Ethical Leadership and

()153

Governance in Organizations: A Preamble, Canadian Journal of

Administrative Sciences, Vol. 18, #4, 2001, p. 241-243.
, Ruiz-Amaya,C. and Knrr, H. (2011),

)154( Ruiz-Palomino,P.

Employee Organizational Citizenship Behavior: The Direct and

Indirect Impact of Ethical Leadership, Canadian Journal of
Administrative Sciences, 2001, p. 28: 244258, Published online in
Wiley
Online
Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com).
DOI:
10.1002/CJAS.221.

Cyril & Girindra, 2009,

()155

.1015
93

Resick

14000 61 475

)GLOBE
:
) .
. )156

Resick, et al, 2006,

()156

1015
94

95

:



.



.
.

.
:
.
.
.
. - .

96

 1-8
:
:
)157
)158 .
:


.




.
.

Collier ()157

;et al., 2000; Mendonca, ;2001; Price, 2006

Kanungo et al., 2001; Aronson, 2001; Knights, 2005; Broussine,
;et al. 2005; Rickards and Clark, 2006; Puffer et al., 2008
;Sendjaya et al., 2008; Martin et al, 2009; ; Millar et al. ;2010
Ruiz-Palomino et al., 2011.
( Journal of Ethics in Leadership, )
The Journal of Values based Leadership, The International
()158

Journal of Ethical Leadership, Journal of Authentic Leadership in

Education.

97


.
2-8



:
1-2-8
:
( )2 .

98

*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

)(1959
)(1963
)(1974
)(1986
)(1990
)(1991
)(1991
)(1993
)(1994
)(1996
)(2004

*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*

*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*

*
*
*
*

19

17

17

14

*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*

*
*
*
*
*

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

( 842)
( 1058)
()1965
()1975
)(1988

()1990
()1994
()1994
)(1996
)(1997
()2000
()2006
()2008
)(2008
()2010

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*

*
*

12
13
14
15

*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*
*

*
*

*
*

14

14

14

12

12

12

99

 1-1-2-8

:
)159
{ : } )160
" " .)161 )162
: .


" "
.

:
.
)163 - -
:

( )159
))majles.alukah.net/t2392/
( )160 .4
()161

) : -

( )162 : .37

) )163 1965 1 .145-37

100


.
)164
:

.
)165 " "
)166
: .
:
.
)167 ":
" )168
:
.

( )164 .1988 . .467

( )165 : 1990

: 57
( )166 1994 1 .103
( )167
1994 66-64
( )168 .
101

 )169
:
.
)170 :
.
)171
"


" -
- : :
.

)172

) : .

)173

:


.
( )169

1996 1 .140

( )170 1975 82
: :
1998 4.206

( )171
.1997 . .226-177
( )172 .447-44
( )173
) 2006 .44 31
102

 )174

. )175
:
/ .
)176

" " { :
}



:

.

2-1-2-8

.
:
/ .

( )174 - 2
2008 .131-126
( )175 .250-241
( )176
.243-238
103

 1959 )177 Mann

1400
:
.
)178 Holic and Claycomb
1963 :
.
)179

Stogdill

1948 124 -1904
1947 163 -1948
1970 :
.

2-2-8
:

( )3 .

( )177 . - .37
()178

Holic and Claycomb, Search for leadersip, Journal of

Cooperative Extension, No.2834, 1963.

( )179 . - .36
104

*
*

)(1955
)(2002
)(2004
)(2007
)(2009

*
*
*

*
*

)(2008
()2010

*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*

*
*

15

13

11

*
*
*

*
8

)(2008

()2006

()2004

()2002

)(2001

( :
)

()1994

)(1996

1
2
3
4
5

)(1984

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

)(1977

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*

*
4

105


.)180
.
- - :
.
1-2-2-8

.)181 )182
)183 )184 )185

)186
)187 . )188
( )180 : -
- - -
.1977 .-

) 2008 .
) )181 .412
) )182 .109
) )183 .69
) )184 .319
) )185 .111
) )186 .110

) )187 ....68
( )188 2010 1
.44
106

 2-2-2-8

)189
)

).
190

191

3-8



:
1-3-8
-1
.
-2

.
) )189 .318

Peter G. Northouse,Leadership; Theory & Practice, London,

))190

Sage Publications, 3rd ed.,2004, P.40.

)191) Martin, G., Christian J. Resick, C., Keating, M., and Dickson, M.,
Ethical leadership across cultures: a comparative analysis of German
and US perspectives, Business Ethics: A European Review Vol. 18,
Number 2, 2009.

107

 -3
.
-4

.
-5
.
-6
- -
.
-7


.
-8
.
-9

.
-10

.

108

 2-3-8
-1
.
-2

.
-3



.
-4
- -
.
-5

.
-6

.
-7




109


.
-8

.
-9
)
""
).
-10
.

.
.

110

111

:
-

.
""


" " )192



.

:
. - .

( )192
- Governance
2009/11/1-10/31 -.

112

 1-9
""


. )193
"" Model
: )194
. "" " ".
" :
".
" "




"
" .
( )193 : : (
1998 3.
( )194
-16

2009/5/18 .22
113

 .

.
)195 " "
:

.

""
.
2-9
)196

:
-1
.
-2

.
-3
.

( )195
( )196 .23
.22

114

 -4

.
-5
.
-6
.
-7
.
-8
.

:
.1 :
1-1
2-1
3-1
4-1

.
.
.
.

115

 .2 :
1-2
2-2
3-2
4-2

.
.
.
.

.3 :
1-3
2-3
3-3
4-3

.
.
.
.

.4
1-4
2-4
3-4
4-4

.
.
.
).

1 ) 5 ) .
:

116

 ( )1

117


""

.
.
:
.

118

119

 :
:
" "




.
)
.
:
. . - .

120

 1-10




.)197


.
- - " " )198
""
.
" :
" )199
" "
65 .


" "
( )197 :
.

( )198 .
()199

.2012 ..

121

 " " " "

" " .


.
2-10

"" .
: )200
Good Leadership
" " " " Influential Leadership " " Effective Leadership


.

.

Jane Collier & Rfael Esteban, Systemic leadership: ethical

and effective, The Leadership & Organization Development
Journal, Vol. 21 Iss.: 4, 2000, P. 207-215.
()200

122


" " " " " " .

Normative Approach
Positive Approach

" "Systemic Leadership: Ethical and effective

.
. )201
" : "
" "Ethics and Effectivness
" " :

""
)Good
- - :
.

:
"" ""

( )201 .
123


"" Ohio Studies
.)202
"" Michigan Studies
- -

: )203
.
. . Rational Emotinal Spiritual
.
)204 :
- .

Joanne Ciulla, Ethics, the heart of leadership.

)203( Fakir Mohan Sahoo & Jitendra Mohanty, The Critical Factors of
Effective Leadership in Organizations: An Ideographic Investigation Using
Lens Model, The XIMB Journal of Management , Mar 2010, Vol. 7 Issue
1, p17-54.
()202

Jack W. Wiley, The impact of effective leadership on employee

engagement, Employment Relations Today, Volume 37, Issue 2, pages
4752, summer 2010, P 47.
()204

124


.
.
.

3-10

1-3-10

:

2-3-10
1-2-3-10

:

-1

125


.
:
-2
. . . .
-3

.
: ) 10

. )205
-4

. )206
-5
.
-6 .

( )205 : .

( )206 :
- .

126

 -7
.
-8
.
-9 .
-10
.
-11
.
-12
.
2-2-3-10
Validity ) Reliability
)207
.

-
( )207 :
- -

.
127

 1-2-2-3-10 :
:
- :

.
)%80 .


)36
.
- :
)

)40


:

128

 ( )4

**0.76

**0.83

13

**0.81

17

**0.86

27

**0.90

**0.74

10

**0.86

14

**0.89

18

**0.90

28

**0.86

**0.80

11

**0.61

15

**0.87

19

**0.86

29

**0.89

**0.82

12

**0.81

16

**0.89

20

**0.85

30

**0.90

**0.86

21

**0.88

31

**0.88

**0.69

22

**0.86

32

**0.73

**0.64

23

**0.83

33

**0.81

**0.78

24

**0.81

34

**0.85

25

**0.83

35

**0.82

26

**0.88

36

**0.86

* 0.05

** 0.01

)4
)0.86 0.64
)0.86-0.61
)0.89 -0.81 )0.90 -0.73
)0.01

.

129

 ( )5

**0.88

**0.88

**0.91

20

**0.92

* 0.05

** 0.01

)5
)0.01 -0.88
)0.92
.
2-2-2-3-10
" " ) (Cronbach, Alpha
:
( )6 " "

0.89

0.78

0.88

20

0.98

36

0.98

130

 )6
)0.98 -0.78
)0.98
.

.
)111
: )7

131

..

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6 .

-7 .

-8 .

-9 .

-10 .

-11 .

-12 .

. -13 .

. -14 .

-15 .

-16 .

-17 .

-18 .

-19 .

-20 .

-21 .

-22 .

132

-23 .

-24 .

-25 .

-26 .

-27 .

-28 .

-29 .

-30 .

- 31 .

-32

.
-33
-34 .
.
-35

-36

133




.
- -
:

.

134

135



:


.
)
.
""
"
"
.
" " "
"
.


:
. . .136

 1-11

:
-1
" "



.




.
- -


.
-2



.
137



.

.



: .)208


" ".
-3



{: } )209

(208) Abdullah

Al- Beraidi, Developing Morality in Business Students:

Insights From Arab-Islamic Culture and Business Experience, in: Charles
Wankel and Agata (eds), Stachwicz-Stanusch, Effectively Integrating
Ethical Dimention, Information Age Publishing Inc., Charlotte, North
Carolina, 2011, p.43.

( )209 .4
138

 - -
.
- " -
" )210
-
- ": " )211
" " )212
- " - " )213

.
2-11
-1

( )210 .
( )211 .
( )212 .
( )213 .
139

 -2




.




. )214

:
.

.

.

( )214 :
2010 2 - :
2011 .
140

-3

"" ) " " ).




.

:

.
.

141

3-11

-1

)215
" " :
.

.
.
. )216

()215

2011 .30
( )216
.12
142

-2

:


.


.

"
" .




.
-3


" "

.
:

143

 .
" " )217


.



.

.



.
( )217 :
: .2004 ..

144

145

)

.SPSS


.
.
:
.ANOVA
:
: .
: .
: .

146

 1-12

1-1-12
-1

( )8

35

10.1

250

72.0

2.3

54

15.6

347

100

( )2

% 72
% 15.6 % 10.1 % 2.3
.

147

 -2 :
( )9

66

19.0

262

75.5

19

5.5

347

100

( )3

% 75.5 % 19
% 5.5 .

148

 -3 :

( )10

51

14.7

181

52.2

115

33.1

347

100

( )4

:

% 52.2 % 33.1 .% 14.7

149

 -4 :

( )11

25

14

4.0

35-26

164

47.3

45-36

127

36.6

45

42

12.1

347

100

( )5

% 47.3
%36.6 )35-26 % 12.1 )45-36
25.
45 %4

150

 -5 :
( )12

24

6.9

233

67.1

75

21.6

15

4.3

347

100

( )6

67.1
% 21.6 6.9 % 4.3
.

151

 -6 :
( )13

160

46.1

2.3

2.3

1.4

49

14.1

44

12.7

73

21.0

347

100

( )7

% 46.1 % 21
% 14.1 % 12.7
).

152

 -7 :
( )14

79

22.8

6 10

102

29.4

11 15

65

18.7

15

101

29.1

347

100

( )8

% 29.4
% 29.1 )10-6 ) 15 % 22.8
5 %18.7 )15-11.

153

 2-12
.1 :


:
( )15

3.44

0.96

3.06

0.95

3.18

1.14

3.03

1.11

3.19

.93

:
-1 )1.79-1
.
-2 ) 2.59-1.80
.
-3 )3.39-2.60
.

154

 -4 )4.19-3.40
.
-5 )5-4.20
.
= 3.19
0.93 .

3.44

3.18
= 3.06
3.03 .

.2 :

155

 :
( )16 .

4.04

3.37

3.34

3.41

0.88

0.96

1.52

0.84

3.61

2.99

3.22

3.03

0.83

0.97

0.60

0.84

3.89

3.06

3.16

3.35

1.30

1.11

1.04

0.98

3.74

2.94

3.25

1.1

1.1

1.32

0.99

3.82

3.09

3.24

3.22

0.94

0.92

0.91

0.80

156

 :
-1

.
-2

.
-3

.
-4
.
-5
.

157

 :
( )17

3.38

3.47

3.39

0.97

0.92

0.95

3.22

3.038

2.91

0.97

0.92

1.22

3.21

3.19

2.98

1.24

1.22

1.17

3.15

3.02

2.86

1.11

1.1

1.22

3.24

3.18

3.04

0.90

1.24

158

 :
-1
.

:
-2
.
:
-3
.
:
-4
.
:
-5 :
.

159

 :
( )18

3.91

3.45

3.23

0.8

0.93

0.98

3.40

3.10

2.89

0.72

0.98

0.9

3.71

3.17

2.98

1.03

1.1

1.21

3.57

3.06

2.76

1.02

1.1

1.15

3.65

3.20

2.97

0.79

0.91

0.91

:
160

 -1
.
-2
.
-3
.
-4
.
-5
.

161

 :
( )19
45-36

45

35-26 25

3.5

3.26

3.48

3.5

0.97

0.91

0.96

0.94

3.23

3.24

3.46

3.55

1.04

0.93

0.93

0.88

3.57

3.47

3.94

3.85

1.09

1.06

1.15

1.19

3.24

3.15

3.16

3.36

1.22

1.06

1.12

1.07

3.69

3.51

3.59

3.76

1.02

0.87

0.93

0.93

162

 :
-1
45 25
)45-36 .)35-26
-2
45 )45-36
)35-26 25.
-3
45 -36
)45 )35-26 25.
-4
45 )45-36
)35-26 25.
-5 45
)45-36 )35-26
25.

163

 :
( )20

3.27

3.37

3.62

3.63

1.05

0.95

0.88

1.09

3.03

3.00

3.16

3.26

1.18

0.91

0.95

1.03

3.13

3.12

3.25

3.85

1.29

1.13

1.10

1.19

2.82

2.97

3.14

3.17

1.31

1.10

1.01

1.24

3.06

3.13

3.29

3.32

1.13

0.91

0.88

1.09

164

 :
-1

.
-2

.
-3

.
-4

.

-5
.

165

 :
( )21

3.49

3.17

3.53

2.94

3.42

3.35

3.47

0.95

1.16

0.83

1.07

1.01

0.96

0.96

3.09

2.80

3.11

2.93

3.11

0.48

0.96

0.93

1.02

3.10

3.15
1.22

3.04

3.59

0.94

0.81

0.93

3.23

3.34

3.06

3.30

3.13

1.13

1.09

1.12

1.27

1.17

1.08

3.06

3.13

2.51

2.28

3.14

3.04

3.00

1.15

1.34

1.05

1.36

1.02

1.03

1.13

3.20

3.31

3.14

2.87

3.23

3.10

3.18

0.94

1.00

0.60

1.04

0.94

0.90

0.97

166

 :
-1

.
-2

.
-3

.
-4

.
-5
.

167

 :
( )22

5-1

10-6

15-11 15

3.35

3.30

3.54

3.61

0.94

0.90

0.98

1.00

3.01

2.90

3.14

3.21

0.91

1.04

0.86

0.92

3.05

3.00

3.28

3.41

1.05

1.18

1.06

1.18

3.07

2.86

3.11

3.14

1.03

1.12

1.15

1.14

3.13

3.01

3.28

3.36

0.88

0.94

0.91

0.96

168

 :
-1
15 )15-11
)5-1 .)10-6
-2
15 )15-11
)5-1 .)10-6
-3
15 -11
)15 )5-1 .)10-6
-4
15 -11
)15 )5-1 .)10-6
-5 15
)15-11 )5-1 -6
.)10

-3 :
:

169


ANOVA
. :
: :

( :)23

4.734
3 14.201
0.889
341 303.003
344 317.204
3.533
3 10.598
0.876
337 295.327
340 305.925
7.043
3 21.130
1.249
340 424.515
343 445.645
6.173
3 18.519
1.193
332 396.193
335 414.712
5.008
3 15.023
0.834
330 275.143
333 290.166

0.001
5.327

4.031

5.641

5.173

6.006

0.008

0.001

0.002

0.001

170

 ()24

0.68

0.07
0.025

0.62
0.057
0.08

0.58

0.36
0.22

0.57
0.008
0.21-

0.80

0.07
0.09

0.054
0.025
0.15

0.79

0.049
0.03

0.73
0.06
0.24

0.72

0.057
0.14

0.60
0.12
0.024

:
-1

.
-2

.
-3
.

171

 -4
.
-5
.
: :

0.92

0.46

316.28

342

0.92

317.2

344

2.12

1.06

303.81

338

0.9

305.92

340

0.5

0.25

445.15

341

1.31

445.64

343

1.52

0.76

413.2

333

1.24

414.71

335

0.6

0.3

289.57

331

0.87

290.17

333

0.5

1.18

0.19

0.61

0.34

0.61

0.31

0.83

0.54

0.71

172

 : :
( :)26

17.54

8.77

299.66

342

0.88

317.2

344

9.17

4.59

296.75

338

0.88

305.92

340

20.06

10.03

425.58

341

1.25

445.64

343

22.76

11.38

391.95

333

1.18

414.71

335

15.88

7.94

274.28

331

0.83

290.17

333

10.01

5.22

8.04

9.67

9.58

*0.000

*0.01

*0.000

*0.000

*0.000

173

 ( )27

*0.70

*0.50
0.20

*0.51

0.33
0.18

*0.74

*0.58
0.15

*0.81

*0.51
0.29

*0.68

*0.45
0.22

174

 :
-1

.
-2
.
-3

.
-4

.
-5

.

175

 : :
( :)28

21.15

7.05

296.06

341

0.87

317.2

344

13.59

4.53

292.34

337

0.87

305.92

340

27.95

9.32

417.7

340

1.23

445.64

343

19.51

6.5

395.21

332

1.19

414.71

335

19.48

6.49

270.69

330

0.82

290.17

333

8.12

0.000

0.000

5.22

0.000

7.58

0.000

5.46

0.000

7.92

176

 ()29

35-25 25
25
35-25
45-36

45
25
35-25
45-36

45
25
35-25
45-36

45
25
35-25
45-36

45
25
35-25
45-36

45

45-36

45
0.55*0.78*0.57-

0.23

0.023
0.21

0.31

0.17
0.14

0.31
*0.62*0.48-

0.60

0.38
0.22

0.27
*0.87*0.65-

0.39

0.18
0.20

0.35*0.74*0.54

0.37

0.18
0.37

0.37
0.19
*0.75-

177

 :
-1
)35-25 )45 )35-25
)45-35 )45 -35
.)45
-2
)35-25 )45 )35-25
)45-35 )45 .)45-35
-3
)35-25 )45 )35-25
)45-35 )45 .)45-35
-4
)35-25 )45 )35-25
)45-35 )45 .)45-35
-5
)45-35 )45 . )45-35

178

 : :
()30

4.99

1.67

307.21

341

0.9

317.2

344

6.16

2.05

299.77

337

0.89

305.92

340

7.95

2.65

437.69

340

1.29

445.64

343

4.85

1.61

402.86

332

1.21

414.71

335

263

1.08

282.91

330

0.86

290.17

333

1.85

2.31

2.06

1.33

1.26

0.095

0.08

0.11

0.098

0.084

179

 : :
()31

2.51

0.42

314.7

338

0.93

317.2

344

3.75

0.62

302.18

334

0.9

305.92

340

1.2

0.2

444.45

337

1.32

445.64

343

5.01

0.84

409.7

329

1.25

414.71

335

0.99

0.17

289.17

327

0.88

290.17

333

0.45

0.69

0.15

0.67

0.19

0.85

0.66

0.99

0.67

0.98

180

 : :
()32

6.32

2.11

310.88

341

0.91

317.2

344

5.28

1.76

300.65

337

0.89

305.92

340

.958

2.98

434.7

340

1.28

445.64

343

4.59

1.53

410.13

332

1.24

414.71

335

6.64

2.21

283.53

330

0.86

290.17

333

2.31

0.08

0.12

1.97

4.060

2.33

0.3

1.24

60.05

2.57

181

.
:
( )33

1.6

3.7

11.1

21.7

0.11

0.49

*0.039

00.00

17

2.7

12.5

*0.002

0.62

*0.02

*
%

8.3

8.3

6.4

16

11.5

1.4

0.12

0.12

0.24

0.004

*0.033

0.092

0.54

*
%

1.4

12

17

11

3.9

14

0.58

0.78

*0.024

0.001

*0.049

0.46

*0.08

*
%

7.8

8.2

17

15

1.2

5.3

0.15

0.27

0.13

*0.006

0.8

03

0.002
%

6.4

4.2

6.5

20

14

1.1

12.2

57

0.24

0.44

0.085

0.000

*0.01

0.72

*0.032

0.00

182

 :
-1
:
.
-2 :
.
-3
:
.
-4 :
.
-5
: .
% 57

% 57

.

183

 3-12

: =
3.19 0.93
- -

3,44
3.18
= 3.06
3.03
.
: :
-1 :








.

184

 -2 :







.
-3 :







.
-4 :
45
25 )45-36 )35-26

45 )45-36 )35-26
25
45 -36
185

)45 )35-26 25
45
)45-36 )35-26
25 45
)45-36 )35-26
25.
-5 :









.

-6 :







186





.
-7 :
15
)15-11 )5-1 -6
)10
15 )15-11
)5-1 )10-6
15
)15-11 )5-1 )10-6

15 )15-11 )5-1
)10-6

15 )15-11 )5-1
.)10-6

187

 :
:
) :
-1










.
-2
.
-3







188





.
-4

)35-25 )45
)35-25 )45-35 )45
)45-35
)35-25 )45
)35-25 )45-35 )45
)45-35
)35-25 )45
)35-25 )45-35 )45
)45-35
)35-25 )45 )35-25
)45-35 )45 -35
)45
)45-35 )45 .)45-35
-5
.
-6
.

189

 -7
.
:
:

:

:
:

:

:
= % 57

190

:

.

:
)
.
-

.
.
%57
)%43
.

191

192

)

.
:
:

.
:
.

: )218
-1 .
-2
.
-3
.
-4 .

( )218 :
-
.
193

 -5
.
:
-

).

).

194

 1-13


36 .


. :
-1 " "
-2
-3
-4
-5
-6
-7 :
-8
-9 :

:
:
"

.

195



:
-1 .
-2 .
-3 :
.
-4

.
-5 .
-6 .
-7 :
.


.


: :
-1 .
-2 " ."Just to be fair
-3 ) .
-4 .
-5 .
196

 -6 .
-7


) .



.



:
-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4 .
-5
.

).
:
-6
.
-7
.
197



" .. "

:
-1
.

-2
.
.
-3
-4 .
-5

.
-6

.
-7
.

198

 :
""
:

-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4
) .

.
-5
.
-6
.

. :

-1
.
-2 .
-3 .
-4 :.
-5
.

"
199

 " )219" :

" . )220
-6
)

.
-7
.
.

.
:

:
-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4

.

( )219 .
( )220 .
200

 -5

.
-6 )
) :
.KPIs
-7


: )
.
2-13 :

:
) 40

.
:
-1 " "
-2
-3
-4
-5 )
-6
201

 -7
-8
-9
-10 :
-11 :

:
: :
""

.
" "



- - .

:
. . - .

202




.





.

)
{
} -

" ".
" " :
-

.
.
.
.

" " :

- .
.203

 )

.


:

" " )221
:
.

" " )222
.


.

- -
.


.
( )221 .
( )222 : .
204


- -
.

.

.


:

.

.

.


- -
.

.
.

205






- -
.

" "



" ".

- -
. .

.
.



.

.
206




.
.
" "

.)223



- - .

)224
" : "

! .

.
" "

( )223

.2011 . .44
( )224 .
207





.



.

.

.



.



.

.
208

 )
.


.
.


- - .
:
.



.

.


.

)
.


209

 .

{ : } .)225


.



.




.


.

.
.

) )225 .61
210

.
.

.


.

.

.



.


.
.
.

211

- -
.

.


.


.



.




!.


.

212


.

.


.

" "

:
- - Automation


.
""



" ! ! It is not what you know !, it is
"!who you know

!.

213


.

.

.


.

.




.


.

- - - -
.
.

214


.



.

.

.



)
.

- :

).

).

- :

).

215

) .

:
-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
.
-4

:
.
-1

-2 .
-3 .
.
-4
:
.
-1
-2 .
-3 ).
:

-1 .
.
-2
-3 .
-4 .

216

 :
-1 .
-2 .
.
-3
-4 .
:
.
-1
-2 .
-3 .
-4 .
:
.
-1
-2 .
-3 .
-4 .


.

217




:
.
:
.

.

.

218

219

:

" "

.
:
. . . . . - .

220

 1-14

:

-1
.
-2
.
-3

.
-4

.
-5
.

-6
.
-7
.
-8

.
221

 -9
.
-10

.
-11
.
-12
.
-13

.
-14
.
-15
.
-16
.
-17
.

-18
.

-19

.
222

 -20
.
2-14

:
-1
.
-2 .
-3
.
-4
.

-5
.
-6 " "
" "
.
-7

.

223

 -8
.
-9
.
-10
.
3-14

:
-1
.
-2


.
-3
.

-4

.
-5
.

224

 4-14
- -
:
-1

.
-2
.
-3
.
-4 " "


.
-5
.

5-14

:
-1 )
.
-2
).

225

 -3
.
-4
.
-5
.
6-14


:
-1

-2

-3

-4

-5

-6

226

-7

-8

-9

-10
.
-11
.
-12
.
-13
.
-14 )Verification
.
-15
.

227

228

 ..................................................

" - "

.

)
20 )
100

.
:

-1
).

-2

).

-3
).
).
-4


1 ) 5 ).

.

229

 : :
-

:) ......................

:
/

:
45
45-36
25 : 35-26

:
:
15
15 -11
10 6
5 -1 :
:
................................................................................................
................................................................................................
................................................................................................
....................................................... ........................................

230


: 36

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .
-5 .
-6 .
-7 .
-8 .

-9 .

-10
.

-11

-12 .

-13 .

. -14 .

-15

-16

231

.17 .

.18 .

.19 .

.20 .

.21 .

.22 .

.23 .

.24 .
.25 .

.26 .

. 27 (
).

.28 .
.29 .
.30 .
.31 .

( )

-1

-2

-3

-4

-5

....................... : ................... : ............ :

232



..


.
: ( ) :


.

-

:
: .
: / .
: .
25 : 45 45 36 35 26 .
: .
:
.
15 11 10 6 5 1 : . 15
:
: 1 : 5 -

233

-1 .
-2 .
-3 .
-4 .
-5 .
-6 .
-7 .
-8 .
-9 .
-10 .
-11 .
-12 .
-13 .
. -14 .
-15 .
-16 .
-17 .
-18 .
-19 .
-20 .
-21 .
-22 .
-23 .
-24 .
-25 .
-26 .
-27 ( ).
-28 .
-29 .
-30 .
-31 .
-32 .
-33 .
-34 .
-35 .
-36 .

234

235


: 1
2009.
1 2005. ) : --

1 1983.

1996 6. 2012 3. 2000 1.-

2011.

1985 .

: 2011 .
- - ..
-

1994 1.
236

 2010.
.2013 3-

1
2010.

. -

2006.

. .2010.
: .2004 ..
-

4
2010.

- 2010 1.
-

1997 .

: 2010.
: 2008 1.
SPSS
237

2003.

)
2008.
-

1


2013.

: 2011 5.
: 2010/6/6-5 .
- .22008.
- : 12001.
-

: 2011 .

)2012 .

- 2002 1 .40

238

: 2010 1.

2006.

1996 1.
. 1998 4.-

2004 1.

2004 1. ) 2006 .
..1977.
- Governance
2009/11/1-10/31 -.

2009/5/18-16.

239

2009/12/11.

2008 2. : : ( 1998 3.
)2012 .
1991 1. 12008. 2012 4.
: 2004 1.
.2011 . .44
) .
-

1996 5.

2006 .
240

 .111-

2011 1.

2010 2.
1997.
-

1975 82
: :
1998 4.206

. ...
1996 1.
: 2012 5.
.1997 .
-

2012.

- 1965 1.

241

 .1988 .. : 2012 1.
-

1989 1.

2008 1.
1992 2. : .2012 ..
-

1
2012.

:
1990 : 57

12006.
2011 1.
2002 1.
- : 1999 .

242

.1994
.2005 1 .2008
.2006 : -

-Abdullah Al- Beraidi, Developing Morality in Business Students:

Insights From Arab-Islamic Culture and Business Experience, in:
Charles Wankel and Agata (eds), Stachwicz-Stanusch, Effectively
Integrating Ethical Dimention, Information Age Publishing Inc.,
Charlotte, North Carolina, 2011, p.43.
- Aronson, E.,

Integrating Leadership Styles and Ethical Perspectives,

Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 2001.

- Brown, et al, 2005, in; Lenny Akker, et al,Ethical Leadership and Trust,
International Journal of Leadership Studies, Vol.5, Iss.2, 2009.

Fakir Mohan Sahoo & Jitendra Mohanty, The Critical

Factors of Effective Leadership in Organizations: An

Ideographic Investigation Using Lens Model, The XIMB
Journal of Management , Mar 2010, Vol. 7 Issue 1.

243

Holic and Claycomb, Search for leadersip, Journal of

Cooperative Extension, No.2834, 1963.

Jack W. Wiley, The impact of effective leadership on

employee engagement, Employment Relations Today,

Volume 37, Issue 2, pages 4752, summer 2010.
-

James M. Burns, J., Leadership, NY: Harper and Row, 1987.

-Jane Collier & Rfael Esteban, Systemic leadership: ethical and

effective, The Leadership & Organization Development Journal, Vol. 21
Iss.: 4, 2000.
- Joanne

Ciulla, Ethics, the Heart of Leadership, Westport, CT:

Greenwood, 1998, P 28-130.

-M. Hitt, C. Miller, A. Colella, Organizational Behavior, New Jersey:
John Wiley and Sons, 2009, P 48.
-Manuel Mendonca, Preparing for Ethical Leadership, Canadian
Journal of Administrative Sciences, Vol. 18, #4 , 2001, p. 266-276.
-Martin, G., Christian J. Resick, C., Keating, M., and Dickson, M.,
Ethical leadership across cultures: a comparative analysis of
German and US perspectives, Business Ethics: A European Review
Vol. 18, Number 2, 2009.
-Martin,G., Christian J. Resick, C., Keating, M., and Dickson, M. (2009),
Ethical leadership across cultures: a comparative analysis of

244

German and US perspectives, Business Ethics: A European Review

Volume 18, 2009.

Peter G. Northouse, Leadership; Theory & Practice, London,

Sage Publications, 3rd ed.,2004, P.40.

-R.N. Kanungo and M. Mendonca, Ethical Leadership and
Governance in Organizations: A Preamble, Canadian Journal of
Administrative Sciences, Vol. 18, #4, 2001, p. 241-243.
- Richard

Daft, Leadership, China, South-Western Cengage Learning, 5th

ed., 2011,

Robert K. Greenleaf, Servant leadership: A Journey into the

Nature of Legitimate Power and Greatness, Paulist Press, New

Jersey, 2002.
-Ronald A. Heifetz, Leadership without easy answer, Cambridge,
Harvard University Press, 1994.

Rue, L. & Byars, L., Management, Irwin, Homewood, 1989.

-Ruiz-Palomino,P. , Ruiz-Amaya,C. and Knrr, H. (2011), Employee

Organizational Citizenship Behavior: The Direct and Indirect Impact
of Ethical Leadership, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,
2001, p. 28: 244258, Published online in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/CJAS.221.

245

in

Failures

Ethical

Understanding

Price,

L.

- Terry

Leadership, Cambridge University Press, New York, 2006.

:
AAK500@gmail.com : : 94530 11614

246