Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No. 95-2086
JOSEPH ARGENCOURT,
Petitioner, Appellant,
v.
Respondent, Appellee.
____________________
____________________
Before
____________________
____________________
In
his second
trip to
this
district
court erred
in denying his
Motion to
was
convicted of
conspiring
with
on direct appeal.
Vacate, Set
2255.
Argencourt
his co-defendant
Rodney
The
Suffice
it
facts
to
say
are
set
that
undercover investigation
forth
the
FBI,
in
our
in
2255.
prior
the course
of insurance fraud in
We now
opinion.
of
an
Rhode Island
cocaine.
to
quantities of
be the supplier of
the cocaine.
to appear to consummate
the deal
-22
its case
1302.
Petitioner's Burden
___________________
Id.
__
at
-33
The
arguments
properly before
their
merits.1
Those arguments
heavy
burden of
proof
demonstrate
the law
court
are evaluated
imposes.
fail on
against the
Argencourt
must
an objective standard of
counsel's
this
deficient performance
undermine confidence
Strickland v.
__________
the relevant
the
so
outcome of
v. United States,
______________
determining
in
was
987 F.2d
whether trial
objective
48,
51 (1st
prejudicial as
the
trial.
that
to
See
___
Cir. 1993).
counsel's performance
benchmark, "[j]udicial
In
fell below
scrutiny
of
effort [should]
be made to eliminate
of hindsight."
____________________
1.
Many of
were not
heard
raised in the
here.
district court
Among others,
and so
he has waived
to this court
will not
be
of conviction).
the examination
and decided
against
Another of
of Special
him on
1304.
his arguments
Agent Brotan
his
-- was
direct appeal,
Argencourt.
--
on
See Argencourt,
___ __________
is unclear
whether Argencourt
issue is
Thus, we do
also
argues that
he
developed in
his
perfunctory
manner,
unaccompanied
by
some
effort
at
_____ ______
494 U.S.
1082 (1990).
The
sentence was,
in any
event,
-44
indulge
strong presumption
that counsel's
that is,
under
the
the defendant
professional assistance;
circumstances, the
conduct falls
challenged
presumption that,
action 'might
be
considered sound
trial strategy.'"
Id. (quoting
___
Michel v.
______
Louisiana, 350 U.S. 91, 101 (1955)); Lema, 987 F.2d at 51.
_________
____
The
a high
hurdle.
"An
error by
counsel,
aside
no effect on
The
requisite
postulating
effect
Rather,
showing
that
on the
of
counsel's
outcome
Argencourt must
probability
the
the judgment."
that, but
Strickland, 466
__________
prejudice
"errors
of the
for counsel's
requires
had
some
proceeding."
affirmatively
U.S. at
more
691.
than
conceivable
Id.
___
prove "a
at
693.
reasonable
unprofessional errors,
different.
reasonable
undermine
probability
confidence
is
in
the
probability
outcome."
sufficient
Id.
___
neither objectively
at
to
694.
ineffective
Conspiracy Indictment
_____________________
Argencourt
dismiss
argues
the conspiracy
failed to charge
counsel
indictment
should
on the
-55
have
moved
to
grounds that
it
distribute.
The
an
it
is not.
The
statute that
distribution makes it
or
dispense,
distribute, or
or
__
with
intent
to
distinct,
essential
and
distribute,
manufacture,
be
criminalizes possession
unlawful to "manufacture,
possess
Indeed,
21 U.S.C.
element
of
the
crime
of
See United
___ ______
offense of
illegal drug
essential
elements: the
distribution
cert.
_____
denied, 507
______
U.S.
. . . contains
[defendant] must
1991) ("[T]he
(1)
(3) a controlled
953 (1993).
three
knowingly or
substance."),
To the
extent
that
that
wrong.
(1994)
Tapes
_____
115 S. Ct.
an overt act
846).
he is clearly
382, 386
is not required
concerning
tape to the
See
___
his challenge
to the
replaying of
Argencourt,
__________
996 F.2d
at 1305
n.6.
a particular
its deliberations.
Variants
of this
-66
on direct appeal
but
argues
now,
fare no
conversation between
FBI
agent, and
tape
asserted
being
than a
listeners had
counsel
inaudible.
inaudible,
problem.
He
The
however,
The
stated
that he
any problem in
of a
Andreoni, an
contends that
of the tape
asserted problem of
appears
trial
defective earphone
explicitly
a tape
jury of
on
the
He focuses
an undercover informant.
on
better.
to
be
judge alone
(which
was
was
able
of
more
the
replaced);
to hear
the
in the face
of a
could
not hear.
Moreover,
provided with a
they
attack under
See Lema,
___ ____
not
just
redacted versions,
certainly, trial
tapes
be
played
strategic choice
be played
counsel's decision
in their
entirety
to try to limit
-77
to
the jury.
not to demand
was,
on
But
that the
its face,
See
___
Lema,
____
show
any prejudice.
He
Further, defendant
has had
access to
has failed to
the unredacted
It
exculpatory material
or otherwise
undermined
the
trial.
confidence in
outcome of
the
See
___
Argencourt
evidentiary
argues
hearing
in
that
the
he
district
was
entitled
court
to
to
an
determine
should have
his
be granted.
that counsel
motion
failing
be
erred in
call to
consummated.
had
argues
him
He
been stopped.
the Phone
Connection" (a
Connection's phone
service
have made a
call to him
from the
Phone
asserted
at trial.
"discovered"
motion.
after
He
the
The government
asserts
that
district court
this
evidence
was
his
2255
denied
-88
about the
counsel
before
evidence
trial,
before it.
In
and
that
the jury
even
had
such
Even if the
evidence truly
short.
"newly discovered,"
Even should
it would still
not have
fall far
been made
to
Phone
Connection
transaction,
The
no
on
the
scheduled
resulting prejudice
date
could
of
the
drug
be established.
illegal
suggestion
that
phone
company
records
(which
Argencourt's
Argencourt
To
the extent
that the
phone call
testimony at
trial was
was in the
vicinity of
the parties
would be completed,
evidence that
his
seen
undercuts the
utility of
Furthermore,
if
car was
the
in the
this "newly
phone
call
had
independent
area at
the
time
discovered evidence."
testimony
was
somewhat
attempting
acquitted),
to
distribute
it
had
drugs
little
(of
which
apparent
Argencourt was
bearing
on
the
-99
case,
which
was based
conversations between
would
have
been
Connection's
prejudice from
primarily
conspiracy charge.
on
the earlier
unaffected
telephones.
by
Thus,
any failure by
the
status
Argencourt
trial counsel
That
recorded
FBI agents,
of
has
the Phone
shown
to obtain
no
the
Affirmed.
________
-1010