You are on page 1of 15

I <:!

1J111'14

'" '"

nU1~tJfli'~U m~£J i~ftm:nfltu 1i'.i'.ilJ1J~ £Jli5 'llJ"lJfJ~ir m1 (J'W 15 ~11 tJ'Wiftlll9lu

'II q "

Q,.I ~ ... I .::.:t.ck 0 4 ~. 0 ~ .e!a rJ' 0

1J~t111lu'VIlJ']j1'W C}j' smrm fffl1:l1'lJBlJ[l1l1n!! 111H'1'fJ11tlllJ 1l1!'W'W fll'jl!f1'jl~t1 U neuunu f)

q 'II

"'" <I 3J ~ "" "'" <V <ld13J .,.. .:1

r-l[lfl151!fl'.i 1~'I1"lJ f)lJ[I ,1ltllnlru[l nunm "1$U'Vl'Wfll1lJ'KlJlt1 \PH'W

'II "

x

.

I d

U'VI'W f11!'iHW

,

I I ""

S.D. H'Vl'W f11ft'1'Wt1JtJ'l!11'UlJlI9l5111'U

...

• dll) 3J 3J

t H'Vl'W flTYI All1JlflflU'Vl1lfi'f)'U1l1rJ t-test

F H'VI'W fh~'~1)lnfllJ'Vl1lf10'U~lrJ One-way ANOVA

Sig. H 'VI'W fh~H ffll 'IN[I 'UfJ'lfll1lJUI9l flrh~t1 ~ f) , J.iUI9lf)~H '11 ~ 'l fln'YI~ffO 11

'" '"

1'Wfl1'.i1~tJflr:.I'W ~1~tJi~!ff'WON[lfll'.i1U'IJ1~rfU[l~fll'.iHU[lN[ll}Oltlu1i.:jOtlfl!1J'W

'"

51

3 \9l0'U \9IllJ~W}1J111~O~-1~f) itJu

\91f)'W~ 1 fll'.i1!f1'n~rf.umJmtlitJ'lJO~flrilJ~lmh.:j ~lH'Wfl\?lllJ~':Ht1hrY'lff 'j~~'U

'II ~

51 •

il.:j~'W 'jlCJtl¢)'~tlnfl'jtl.:j~f)!$lo'W 01%'V'I~,jflfl'.itNH[I~U'l1ri--lli'Wflf)1~() 111!ft'tW 1'U~nn--l 6

'II 'II

\91t1'W~ 2 fll'.il!fI'jl~H~f)lJr;U~CJln'Ul~~1Jflru1iJ)lJ1JjlJ']j51lJ'lJtl4't!m1£J'W lFH1rJU

'U •

" .

irull9lU ~4'111~tl'Vl:mnu ~l--l'J1'Wli 3-4 11ltJ'jllJU[l~U~[I~1l1tJ ~lHtJn\911lJ~lUlh!'V'If1

u q

51 •

':i~~lJ"l11--l.Jf'W '.iltJi~~,jnfl'H)'l~m$ltl'U t11~'W~tlnflltl.:j Ull~U'l1ci--lYivrntllHtll'W 5 ~1'W

'II 'II

. '"

i'f1'Ufl f)11lJl11N~"1$f)lJ f)11lJ~mYI9l6 f111:u,j'.i~l1U~ fll1lJiJ11111J-lfftJff[l~ H[I~flniJ

fflJ:Ulf)l'jl~ t'hm'UCI'tJl9ll'jl--l7-12

\91B'W~ 3 fll11!f1'jl~H!m (J11!l1tJlJfltu1i'j'.ilJ1J1 CJ1il':ilJ"llCl4irfl!1cJ'W h 4!1CJ'WiftllI9lU

q u

" . "

.u·:1'K1flU'YllJ1niJ GJfl'l~'W.yj 3-4 ~lu'Wn\911lJ~1HU'.i!'V'Iff '.i~~lJGJf14~'W '.ilCJi'f1'N'Uf)'fllC1'W1C1

q ...

~$)C1'U O1G]f'V'H~11nfllf).:j U[l~Hlfri4~'WnCllff(J 1'1..1 5 ¢l1'W i~uri f)11lJl1JN~"lftllJ f)11lJ~mY\9lV

...

" .

fl111Jlh'~'I1U~ f)11lJih11' 'i)-!ff(Jff[l~ !ta~fll'j"iJ1'Y'lJlJlf1111~ tJl!ff'Wtl hm1)14 13-17 C]j'l~

l.ou 'i) ~th!fi'tJ V r-lt'l m J ltflll ~MoiJf)lJ[I h.!'.iU~l'.il~ 11 'j ~ neu rn J us 'j CJ1 (J

'" '"

58

v1l'n-l6

v

l1nrnuwg:ffH'J(;'1g:lIfNntiuw,:Jt)eh-3 111U'tJn!Pl1W'Wff rg:;v"lf'Ni'U J1r/M'N'l.lnfl'JeJ..'J

. ~

~l'Wl'W

1. 1 '¥Iff

1.1 GJ11tJ 1.2 'Hru~

<J

160 190

45.7

54.3

350

100.0

.,

2. j~so11J,h~'if'W

'JI •

• rv c!

2.1 GJ11~"l5'WYI 3

216

61.7

'JI •

I ""' d

2.2 GJ11-l"l5'WYI 4

134 350

38.3 100.0

jJlJ

3. ~i1(JillN'uflfljO,:witH~v'W

...

·

3.1 r11f1-)1 1O,OOO1J1Y1

3.2 10,000-30,000 1Jl'Y1

123

35.1

'JI

3:3 30,OOl1Jl'Vl ~'Wit1

178 49

50.9

14.0

350

100.0

82 113 29 126

23.4 32.3 8.3 36.0 100.0

..e. j QJ 31

4.2 :B'jm)ftJ'W~J/fll"1.Jl(J



~llJ

350

59
.u'tJlJnY1'1!1l 0 ~
'" 'il1'U1'U 'JtJtJfI~
.
, q QJ' Q...I
5. Hl1n.:J'Yl'VHltIlrW
"'i
5.1 "l[lJ"l$'U/tlJtJ1 209 59.7
5.2 "}j"'UlJ'Yl 141 40.3
11lJ 350 100.0 '"1 • 3J 3J~ I "'" Q "" 3J ~ "'"

€lQ !'W'1f1~ 10,000-30,000 1Jl'Vl 'H)tla~ 50.9 ~IJfl'fl1t).:jlWl"l$W11JllH 'J€l(J"~ 36.0 Hn~lJ

U'Mrl~~Yrm:nffe.l€lV''Wt''~''lflJ"}f'W/dj€l~ ~€ltJn~ 59.7

... ~

60

,

Vlel'Un 2 'l~~UflWfi'l"jll'il~£J1i'j'nJ"t).:ji{fU1t1'Ul"j-.l!~rJ'w:firu-rvn1

q u

.ij~"1'J\01t.J't1:tJfiliA 1~£J"j1lJ't1ft~1'UHIl~1'W!!~Il~~1'U 'l11U'Wft

q q

'"

~l:tJVl';m'lh!rlft j~v1'lJ';l-.l1('U "jltl'~Nt.Jftfl"jel-JYifl

'iJ

A~8'U en;rlNt.Jftfljfl-J UIl~U't1~-J~ifftellft£J

qJ

fll'lH 7

rf1m~l'J ffTtJtfll'J-JlVtl3JW1'ifff1U Ufl~'i~i1JflW1i'j'jlJU1U1i'j'j3J'Va.Jifm1l'JU h.J11l'JU

.... .

x

S.D.

1.57

clOJ

f)l'j'lJffJJJJ1f1Tj1~

1.40

.34 .37 .38 .37 .37

4 Q..i if

fill JJ G}ft) ff \PHJ

ft11JJlh~l1U~

1.58

1.55

'"

f1l1lJihl11 ,\Hi1tm~~

1.47

':i1lJ

1.52

.29

\11 fWIl n ~ 7 u ff ~ -l1 11111 tl':h lrl e)'Vhll ':i ill 1 fI ill "Ii 'j 'j JJ 'i) j un 'j' 'j' lJ 'lu f11 VI)" 1:U 'Ynyj 1

q

uf)i~eJ'w h..:.t!~tltrBrui'~tf iJflfU1i'j)JJ'i)1tl1i'j'j'lJvv1'W)~~'lJff~ iJfhm~tlryhn'lJ 1.52 U~~

u CII o:u qJ

i''lJ~~"lftJ'lJ fll1JJ~i1ff\9l6 Un~fll11l11':i~'HV~ f)V1'W'j~~'lJff-1 i'Jfi1m~unilti'lJ 1.57, 1.58 U~~

'II 'II

'"

1.55 ~lJJ~lil'lJ ril'U~1'Ufll1lJihh1il-li1mYa~ H~~m'jlj-ffllJJlfl1)"1~ ljflW"Ii':i'JJJil1tl1rnlJ

~

tld''W'j'!:il'lJlhl-Jf)~l~ iJriwi~~tlryhn1J 1.47 lW:: 1.40 ~llJrll~'lJ

'II

61

, ,

, .d r .d Q.I ~ g..r d 0

fJ 1 UHW "ifJ iu '1J (J~ l '1J u u W1 'j if Hi U f1~ 'j ~ ~ '1J fJ flJ 1i 'j 'j lJ iJ r (J 1i r 'j Jj"ll fJ '1 u nts (J 'tJ y iu 'tJ ni"l1 JJ

~ .

i 'Jwh m«

'll'ltJ q
HtlJ..:j
~W1i'J'nJ1l1fJ1i'J'nJ ... 1~~'UfJW1inlJ
'J~WlUfJW1i'j'jlJ
X S.D. .. X S.D. .,.
ll'JfJllnlJ ll'HJ1i'J'JlJ
~ ."
f111lJJ'UNWl'll'-eJ'U 1.54 34 ft..:j 1.60 .33 i,!..:j
"
.;t ... ~
f111lJ<:Ji8ffAtJ 1.51 .40 iH 1.63 .33 ff..:j
" ..
f111lJ'l.h::HUI'l 1.49 .39 ilrunms 1.61 .36 ff-.'f
'"
~
mllJi.hh11l-l~fJ~Hl~ 1.41 .3& il'runme 1.53 .36 i,!-.'f
..... ilrunau 'llllJflill..:J
fIl'jlJfflJlJ1f11'jJ~ 1.35 .39 1.45 .35
51'lJ 1.46 .3l illlJmm 1.56 .27 ff..:j
... 11 fli~ EJ'W'lf1U)Jf1tU 1j)llJ1J~ en l)lJ~ ll.lfl11lJl1J N~ GJftl1J H ft: frnlJ ~e)"ff~V tI vl 'W 'J: ~ 11 ft'..:J

q '" ...

• . y

1Jrhmamvhn1J 1.54 U"~1.51 ~llJrll~1J ri1'W~1'Wfl11lJ,).h~YlU~ fl11:lJlhh''il-lfftHH'1:

HII:fll11li1lJlJ 1f1111: 1JfJru1j11:U1J~ tl1j'j'JlJtI~h.!1 ~~1J,jl'W nn H iithm ~ml'ho1J 1.49,

oQ.i 1 QJ.d.~.d. .C\ jJ Q.,I~

i.41 At,,:;:; 1.35 ~llJCl l~1J HfI:'W1J11 'W ru 1 tf'W'\1Ul.:JlJfllli 1jl 'JlJ 1J'HJ1j ';i 'J l.I~ ru fl11lJ 11J N\?l

u q

• 3.1 •

'lft)1J fl11l.1c)fmr~V fl11lJ,j'J~l1V~ Uft:fl11lJ1J'l-'h11J-tffUft'I1:t: t)~''W'j:~1Jft'-:j 1JrhmutJ

... ...

lCl OQ.l 1 gJ d.Q.J .ct ~

rmnu 1.60, 1.63, 1.61 Url:1.53 ~llJm\?l1J ft'TU\?lTWfl11lJb11JlJlf11'J1: lJfJf.U1i';iUJ1J'J(j'jj'j'jlJ

€)~''W ';i:;:;~1J'l.h'W Oftl1 iJfhm~(J!'vhn'U 1.45 HfI:;:;trleJ'W1Jljlli 1 hHll'W11lJ"lltl1flW1i'j'j].j

... .

\l~tf'jj1'JlJ h.j'Vlfl~''U 'V'I'U-h l! m1tJl.mru11JflW1i'j 'jlJ1J~tl1j'j'j:UB~' 'W'j~~1Jff1 fltl iifhm~tJ

QI ~ q q,) ru

rvilo'U 1.56 th'W11 m~tI'W&}flt1iiflW1j'j'j:U\l~tI'jj'j'j'lW~''W1:~1JiJl'W0'''1 fio lJfhm ~(j

. ...

I Q!

!'Vl101J 1.46

62

. .

, rl f ~ CV, ~ rv.et 0

film ao 'iJ''JWl1cNJ '1J1-J JJl~ 'j '0 Ttl Hf1~ 'j~~ 'lJflfJl'Ji 'j su fJ 'j(J'Ji ,)'j1l.", nsunn ClU v 1lJ 'tJ n~ llJ

... .

>1

~'JH '11'j'jg:I'fUW'J-Ji'u

.

, QJ.d

'll"1,:j"lfUl1 3

t OJ d

'll"1..:J'll"'W114

.,.

fJ til 1) 11" lHI'HJ n n JJ

x

S.D.

x

S.D.

.dO'

fl1 'W'ffJJ lJ1 fll11~

1.58 .35

1.60 .37

1.54 .38

1.47 .38

1.41 .37

1.57 .32

..! t:.J.I '(/

vrn JJ9Hl 'ff ~HJ

s n JJ1h:~a1 IT~

1.54 .37

.,

fl11JJihh 'lll-!ihJ'ffU~

1.57 .38

1.47 .36

1.39 .39

1111

1.52 .30

1.51 .28

"I~cl.,A"" """ ,~ t

'lllfW111VI 9 mWl-!1 rl1TH"W11 nJ~'W'lll'HU1flW1)'j'jlJ'll'jU1)':i':ilJ 'WU~ft~~TW mrn

q

, 91 ,

irm1u'Wlifh~-!1ffm:ntHj1tJCJh-!1~'W~ 3 ij'flru1)1'jlJ'll~tJ1'i':i'jlJ~l'Wfl11lJ-r1JN~CJ$f}1J m m

... .

~~d'~v Uft~fl11lJlh~118f) tJ{ntJ'j~~1Jt1'~ ljfhm~m'Yhn1J 1.58, 1.60 Hft~1.54 ~llJi,h~1J

'U ...

v

1.'hU~TWfl11lJJjth' 'll-!ffUffft~ Uft~ fl1'jnffl1lJlfll'jl~ lJflW1j',j'j"lJ 'j)J V1'i'j'jlJvu1'W 'j~fl'lJlhw

q ~

" . .

i"Niu ~ 4 i'J'fltu 1) 1 s lJ 1) J (1) 'j 'jlJ~ l'Wfi11lJ-51J Nf)"l$V 1J rrnu c]fvi1~6 U ft~WJ1lJtl'j ~11 t1~

q

. "

tlr.ihn~~1Jff~ iJfht'i1~vrYhn1J 1.57, 1.54 Uft~1.57 "l1lJih~1J ~hu?llufll1lJnlh''il

... . ...

!~hJff"~ !t,,~f)11Jjd'lJlJlfllj1~ ij'flru1'i'j'jlHI~(1)'jnmfj1'W'j~~1Jtll'Wf1m~ ijfhm~vryhn1J

. ...

1.47 Uft~ 1.39 \9I1lJ~ 11011J Uft :::!rl'erYi'ill'jTlll i'W.f)1'V'111lJ"UV-!1'fltu 1)'j 'jlJ'j)~ (J1'i'j'jlJ' 'W'VI f)fl1tJ

• •

'lI t jI ..

'V'I1J11 ,;r·n'Tm1 tI'Wlifi1~-!1fff)'l:llVr.i''W"lfl~i'Wli 3 Uft:::4 i'Jfltu1'i'j'jlJ'iljV1'i'j 'jlJvul 'W1 ~\Ol1Jff 'I

~ ~ ~ ~

.

~ I Q I Q.I 0 Q.I

lJfll~\HWrYI1f)1J 1.52 Uft:::1.51 \9Ill.J"l~1J

63
VlnH 10
, d , ..,j c,..o ~ Q.I d 0
fl7m (J(J tr7'tJl'lJ(J.Jl'1J'lJlJ7~ 'JtUl1-.1 IHl:;'J:;IPJUfliJJ fj'JJJJ flJ(J1iJJ lJ6fJ f).J 1-.1 fit 5 (JU fJ iu U nmu
.. 0
vl7UV551(J l~N"_JnflJf).Jvif)d';f) U
'"
"hfl':i1 10,000 'Ul'YI 10,000-30,000 'l.Jl'Vl 30,00 I 'I.Jl'YI ~'W 'hl
fJw, li'J'nJ'il~ 1J1i'J'Jlj 'l:~1J 1":~1J ~:'fi'lJ
- S.D. l"l'(\JlinlJ - S.D. fj'(\JlinlJ - l"lUl1ll1lJ
X X X S.D.
1l1VlinlJ 1I1Vli"1'ilJ ~
1l:iVli1"'HJ
... ."
flTUJ'JUHlI'lHlU 1.59 .34 ff.:j 1.58 .33 'l.:j 1.53 .34 ff~
" "
'" .. '"
fldllJ'lJ'€H'I'lllJ 1.56 .37 ff~ 1.58 .38 'l.:j 1.60 .34 'l~
..
fl111ltJ':I ~l1 0'11 1.53 .38 {f~ 1.58 .37 ff.:j 1.51 .37 (f~
.. .. '"
"
.r::::I 00' .d ihunme tJl'Wmn~ 'lhumm
fl1TlJlJ'Wl 'iI-1f1'VffCl~ 1.47 .38 1.48 .39 1.47 .32
dw tJl'Uf1cn~ ilrunme thunme
m'Jllft1Jmt11'j1~ 1.40 .38 1.42 .37 1.37 .37
':1111 1.51 .29 tOP 1.53 .30 ff.:j 1.49 .25 ihunms
.. 'h ,rfli1v'W~~tJml'H)~i}ntJ'~\9leH~5'W~lfl';h 10,000 1J1Vl iJflW1)11lJll1U1)'j'jlJ~l'W

'U •

f111lJ11JN~'b'f)1J f111lJ~f)t1\9l6 mt~f111lJtJ'j~'I1V~ 5~hJ'J~'fl1Jff~ :ufilm~tJ!'ti1t11J 1.59,

'U 'U

SJ

1.56 U'O~1.53 \9l1lJihf11J ri1'W¢i'1'Wfl11lJihh'\l-~-ff(Jff'O~ U'O~fln:ui1lJlJlf11'J1~ :UflWfi'j'jlJ

..

~~Uf)f1'j5~]j:ntl1¢i' 10,000-30,000 1J1'Y1 lJfJtufi',j'jlJ'iJ~V'jjl"jlJ¢i'1'Wfl11lJ'i1J~~~f)1J f1111i ~f)ffmJ H-et~fl11lJtJ'j'~l1V~ mjh.,t'j!:~1J'ff~ lJfllL'H~Vrl'hi11J 1.58, 1.58 U'O~1.58 \9l1lJalf11J

'U ..

"

riTW~ 1'Wfl11lJih'h 1 \l-!-fftlff'O!: Ul:l!:fl1'JlJfflJlJlftl'Jl!: iifltufi'j 'jlJ'iJ~V1i'j'jlJf) ~''W'j'!:~1J

~ ..

t SJ.

1hwflm~ lJfhm~tJ!'vhfi1J 1.48 U'O~1.421111.Iihll1J 'Wf)fl'OlfliUi~'Ymil ,rm~fJt.J'Vi~UflfI'H)\l

SJ •

lJ';iltJ '~\9lf)!$if)'W 30,001 lJl'YI GU'W 1 11 ijfJu!:j)'j''JlJ,\)~ fJ1i'Jl]J¢i'1'Wf111]J~1JN~'b'f)1J f111lJ~f)if\9l6

Uft~f111lJ11'j'~'I1V~ f)~''W':i~fi'1Jff\l nfhL'H~(Jl'vhn1J 1.53, 1.60 Uft!:1.51 \9l1:mhf11J riTW

'U ..

SJ

~1'Wf111lJiith' \l-t-fftJ'i"ln!: unems iifflJlJlfll'Sl~ lJf1tU 'jj) ':ilJ'il~fJ1i',j'jlJ ~~, 'W'J!:f11JUl'Wflftl \l

~ ..

iJfilm~tJt'l'iln1J 1.47 U'O!: 1.37 1I1lJ~1~1J !W~!rlf)fi'Ol'JW 1 ''Wnlyt11lJ"uf)~fJW 'fi':i';ilJ 'O~(J'fi':i'j'lJ''W'VIfI~TW 'W1J11 ,rfl!~tJ'W~N'11f1f1"jf)~iJ';ilI'J1~\9lf)!$if)'W~lfYh 10,000 1J1V1 Hl:l!:

q ..

11 f)!~ 1'J'W~~lIflfl'j f)~ihltJ'¢i'\9lf)!$if)'W 10,000-30,000 1J1V1 1Jflu.t1i J 'jlJ'il~ fJfi'j'j]Jf)(j1 tJ ';i!:~1Jf1' ~

'lI q OJ 'U

64

)jrhm~tll'yhnlJ 1.51 UrI:;}.53 \9IllJill~1J ri1'Wirm~tI'W~N'tlf)fI'H)~ii'ntl1~~m~~J'w 30001

~ ,

., .

1JTV1~'W 'hl iJfJtu1i'i'j1Jll~tl1i'j'jlJ~~''W'j~~1JlhU f)rll~ iJrilm ~tll'Yhfj'1J 1.49

~1~1..:J 11

, ,

• .d • .c:t Q..I ~ t:V d e

111HUW tf1Uf1J(J-JfUU1I1WijllJ U(J:;'j:;~UfJW1i'j'j1Jv'j(J1i1'j"''VCJ-JUnrj(HJ fJIUUn~n1J

i1Uvnnt;wN'tlnfl'iCJ-J

'"

-

x

S.D. fjlJl1il1lJ

1I1[JlnlJ

~

X S.D. fjlJlUHI

~1!llinlJ

-

X

S.D. fjlllUllJ

~1[J1iHlJ

-

X

S.D. fjlJlllnlJ

1I1DlilllJ

... ~ ~

f111lJ'lftllT91U 1.55.40

1.56 .34

1.59 .36

1.64.29 1.59.38

1.57.34 1.58.36

f111lJun;l1V'1l 1.52 .36

fll1lJihf, 'hI-

1.57 .37

1.57.41

1.55.39

LiltJU<l: m1iifflJlJl-

1.40 .40 thumm 1.48 .36 th)'H1i11~ 1.55.33

1.49.38

1.40 .35 1l1umm 1.41 .36 U1UOill~ 1.44.40

rJ~ thu

mlH 1.39.39

1.49 .30 thumm 1.52 .29 '!~ 1.56.29

rJ~ 1.51.29

~1JNlI'lftl1J fl11lJ~mY\916 Ha~fl111Jtl'j~Mffll 'e1Vl'W'j~fl1J""'~ lJfil~n~m'i'hfj'1J 1.58, 1.55 ua:;;

... ..

.,

1.52 \9IllJih~1J ri'n_JllltJflJll.dhhl'il-!"fftlffa~ H~~m'jiJfflJlJlfll'j1~ liflUl'Ii'j'jlJll1tl'fi'j'jlJ

q

tl f)f! 'j tl ~lh ~ f)t11J~1~'W 'Ii 'j nll ri1'W\9l1/ft 1"lJ 1 tl lIfllli1il 'jlJ '\ll tJ1il 'j1J ~1'W fl11:JJ~ 1J N~'lf'f) 1J

• q

f111lJ~tli1)9JU tH'l~fl11lJlh~'Hff~ tlVh.,l'j~111Jft'~ ihllm~(H'Yhn1J 1.56, 1.59 ua~ 1.57

'U ...

.,

\911:JJ"1h\P11J ff1'W III 'W fl11lJihh 1 'il-tiYtlffa~ !H'I~ finll ff:JJ1J lfl1'j1~ lJfltu 1i'il1J'il l un 'j 'j:JJ



tlcihJ'j~~1J,jl'Wf)-aN iJfhm~ml'iln'lJ 1.48 u-a~1.4l ~l1lJih~1J Hn~'W1Jil tTm~tl1_J~N

'U ...

tl f1fl'jtl~ tll~ f)tl1Jtll~"'" tf11:H9I'j ns Uflill 'Iill1J'il~ u1in1Jlllu fi11lJi'1J NlI 'lftl1J fl11:JJ~tlff\9l6

~

., .

fl11lJtl)~'Hff\9l un~flJllJii'I.Jl'll-!i1Uffn~ tld1'W'j~'fl1J'ff~ ljfhm~m'Vhfl1J 1.64, 1.59. l.57

'U ~

Ha~ 1.55 \9IllJih11U ri·:n..l~l'W m'jiJ~lJlJlfll11~ iJfJW'Iil'j:JJ'\l~U'fil'jlJtl~hJ'j~fl1JlhW

. ., ,

f)aN ufhm~m'Vhfi'1J 1.44 'Wtlf)'illf)UEJ-lW1Jil irf)i~tl1,r}1Nt.lfif!ltl-l'lh~f)tlUtll;'Y'li''lJ:ij'l~

'U

65

lJflru1i'J'J1J'i}jtl1J'J'J1J~lWfl111Jf1JN~~tJ1J fl111J4tJff~U !n:l~fl111Jlh~'HU~ edhJ'j~f11Jff~

. ~ ~

. "

lJfhmfitll'vllotJ 1.57, 1.58 Hft~ 1.55 ~n1Jih~1J ri1U~l'Ufll11JlJt'h''\l-tihJtn'l~ Hft~f)l'J

lJffWJ1f1n1~ lJfjru1i'J)1J'\ljV1i'J'J1JtJQ1'U'J~~1Jlh'UflUl-:J lJfhm~tJrvho1J 1.49 Uft~ 1.39 ~llJtil~1J Hft~-W'i}lnln' 'Ufll'VU1lJ'UeNfltu1i'J'j lJ'\lj tJ1illlJ'YlO;}TW 'WtJ·-,h '11 fU1t1'U~lJ~

. . ~

f.)d1'W'J~~1Jff~ lJfhm~ml'hn1J 1.52, 1.56 Hft~1.51 ~llHl1~1J rhU,rfU1m . ..I~~11of1'JtJ~

~ ~ ~

11}~ flf.)1JtJ lGJf'W1U'J l~f)n 11~ 1n'1'Hf)1l lJfjW1i 'J'J lJ'\lj tl1i'J'J1JtJ~j1 'U'J~~lIU1'W mn.:! ;Jfht II ~ tI

, QJ

rmnu 1.49

66

fll'JH 12

. ,

I ~ r ~ .r,;v ~ Q..I L:f 0

f11 HUW "'1 UA u o oJ 1 'U 1.J 1I11WHr1 U 1m::: J::: ~I1JfI fJJ 1i 'j ') 1I11 'j o 1i r 'i:JJ 'if rN un A'i (J 1.J 11 1 u 1.J D1911:IJ

~ .

1Pl1U 'lhn rtf g{ ,1';1 tV n en r10

1 "'!.
t m,H'l1lJ"l$U/!lJ tl':)

.....
"" 'J~~1J
fl tu '.IT'j 'j lJ 'il 'J U'fi 'J 'j lJ

X S.D. fI W 1i 'J 'JlJ

""
'il'jU1i'j'jlJ
~ ""
f111lJ'HJN~C;1H)1J 1.58 .32 ff~
..
..,j "" .,.
fl11lJ9Hl ff\91 U 1.55 .36 ff.:)
'"
fl11lJlh~'KV~ 1.56 .38 ff~
"-'
.,
Q 0 1 Q lhwmn~
munnn 'il-!bWffm: 1.49 .38
"""" thuna n
ms lJfflJlJ lfll'.l 1~ 1.40 .37
"J1lJ 1.51 .28 ff~
., X S.D.

1.57 .35
1.61 .38
1.55 .37
1.49 .37
1.42 .39
1.53 .30 thunnu ihunme

iJ m~ UtJ ~ihL 'Kci-!l~-Wf1tllffUt)ti' 'iH'lJ\91'l1lJ'l1'W/ttlv.:) lJfltu'fi) 'j lJ 'il1 V1i'J)lJ~1'Wfl11lJi'1J N~"l$V1J

"'. .

flJllJ~mY\9l6 Utl~f1JllJ,.h~'HiJ~ t)ti''W'j~~1Jrr.:) iifhm~CJ!'vho1J 1.58, 1.55 Utl~ L56111lJ

.. ..

v

rll~1J riJ'W~\Wfl11lJii'ih 1 'il-lilurrtl~ Utl~fll'JiiiflJlJlfll'j1~ lJflW1i nlJ'il~ CJ1inlJtluh.t

. ..

. .

.clQ.l Q..I l L:1 A 9J Q.I~ ~fV~

l'l'V'lfl t11ffVtl V'W t) fit "lJlI"l$lJ'l1U/"lfl.! lJ'Y1 lJfltu 1i"J 'llJ'iI"J V1i -:; -:; lJ~lUfl11lJ ,)1J N~'l1t)1J fl11lJ"1H) rr\Ow

'U. •

Ufl~fl11lJllJ~'HiJ~ vtil'W'j~f11J'n'.:) iJfhm~vl'vho1J 1.57, 1.61 Utl~ 1.55 \9IllJrllf11J rl1'U~1'W

'II '"

v

fl11lJihh 1 'iI-tirvrrfl~ u fI~ fll'.liJiflJ:lJlfll'.l 1~ iiflill1i'j jlJ'iI~ V1n jlJ8 ti1 'W 'j ~~1J'lhw nms

. '"

iirhm ~ CJt'vh01J 1.49 U fI~ 1.42 \9IllJihf11J U tl~ Lrit)'W'ill'jill 11 'Will'Vi'j 1lJ 'lit) ~fJtu n 'l)lJ 'il~(J1i'j'jlJl'W'I1f1<fi'l'W 'V'l1Jil iJm1(J'W~ihmci.:)~~mJlfff.lVti''W!'lJ\9I"l$lJ'l1'Whtl8':) Utl~irfl!~f.JU

q_ . cu q

~iiH'}fci.:)~vrfl81ftU8 VU 'elm 'lJlIGJ5lJ"lfU/"J$'W1J'Yl iimu 1i'j'jll'UjCJ1i'j 'jlJtJ V 'lu J~ ~1J'rn iifhIU ~ CJ

.::u q ra -qj qJ

67

I

Vl6'WlJ 3 flTHmtJ1J&lltl1JflW1i'l'llJ<l)~tJ1i 'l'llJ"6~itfl{jtJ'W 1 'l~~~tI'Wiru1VI11

Q u

cil~l'i1Yllh)lJ1il'n l'Wu~~~~l'W u-g~ 1~1tJ'l1tJ'tlf)~l'W 'lllH'Wf)vlllJ

Q Q

Vll'll~ 13

N t'ln nUn ou rn tJ 11 film 5 (J f1 W 1i 'j J ts 11 j o s 'J J:JJ 'lJ fI {J um'1 (I U to 1U. u'n~ 1:JJ ~ -:Jl nh m«

~

'lflU

t

Sig.

x

S.D.

x

S.D.

1.54 .34 1.60 .33

1.51 .40 1.63 .33

1.49 .39 1.61 .36

1.41 .38 1.53 .36

-1.706

-2.844 *

.089

~ Q.J "

fl1llJ9fBft'I9IV

fl11JJlh~lfV?l

.005

-3.013*

.003

d '"

f1l1lJft'lJlJ lfll11~

1.35 .39 1.45 .35

-2.967*

-2.502*

.003

.013

11lJ

1.46 .31 1.56 .27

-3.292*

.001

*p < .05

'i)lfW1111~ 13 'W1J11l!mlV'W'lflVm'l~1!f)tl(j'W'Hru~ lJfltl!1j'j'jlJ1l1V'Bl),1J h!f)1'V'l),1lJ

" q

. ~

~1'Wfl11lJclfVft\9l6 fl11lJlh~'Hi1f) fl111Jihh 1 'il-!ii'vfHl~ WJ~fll),lJffJJ1Jlf11l1~ U\9Ifwh'H1'W

68

\?ll-al~ 14

N(;Jf)l'JJ mow nEl'll r11t fJ ~Ofl W 1i':i J 1I'iJ 1El1iJ'i1J'Ilf) vU mJ au ~ lJJ'l,m)VI711reJ'W 1i'i'i~ 1<f'lJ

o

<V 1 '"'
'j~~1J"151~']j"W
. d
1 QJ <::I • ....
"151~"151,!'Vl 3 "151'1 G]1'U 'V1 4
X S.D. X S.D.
1.58 .35 1.57 .32
1.60 .37 1.54 .37
1.54 .38 1.57 .38
1.47 .38 1.47 .36
1.41 .37 1.39 .39
1.52 .30 1.51 .28 it '"' <J'

'fI11lJC}j"tH"~tI

fl11lJ ils ::;'l1cJA

<::I",

OlJ lI'fflJlJ lfll 'J 1 ~

t

Sig.

.096 .924
1.5l3 .131
-.734 .464
-.103 .918
.633 .527
.352 .725 , 3.1 • :JJ •

~lfMllH 14 vnrh uflt~tI'Ul1nTir'lfffllJl0~h!)~~1Ji1'l9f'W~ 3 !H'I~i1~i''W;tl4

'"

lJfltuli'j 'jlJ'il~ tlli'J'jlJ lUilTVfi1lJU (l~J 1[J~1'U 1 ~Uti ~lUfl11lJ~1Jt1~"15fl1J fl11lJ~mf\PlV

~

"

mnnls ~l1V~ fl11lJlJth hl-lff[Jft(l~ t W~ m'j]JfflJlJlf11J1~ U\Plfwh~ til! flril'l iJ_jlJ'l1mhfiiu

"

69

~l~H 15

fli:! n1J A mmJl'n01J rhm don fJJJj'J su» 101i'i'i:JJ"lJ8·:nJ m1 nu ll1H l.Jn"n:JJ~ ':J111i'i'J1EJ 1~

o

'1 "''''JJ , ..
':ilfl Flj:.l nfl':i~NmH~H)U
..
~ln11 10,000 10,000-30,000 30,001 trm
.s
'Ulll 'UTYI '\lui'll
- S.D. - S.D. - S.D.
X X X
1.59 34 1.58 .33 1.53 .34
1.56 .37 1.58 .38 1.60 .34
1.53 .38 1.58 .37 1.51 .37
1.47 .38 1.48 .39 1.47 .32
1.40 .38 1.42 .37 1.37 .37
l.51 .29 1.53 .30 1.49 .25 .d Q.r If flJll.19!Vff~fl

fI'lll.lJJ'l::;'l'! Ufl

..

fI,)ll.1ihh 1 'iHfffliH'l::;

iiftl.ll.l1 fI1 '.i 1:::

'j11J

F

Sig,

.637 .530
.235 .791
1.155 .316
.032 .968
.293 .746
.306 .737 'UlfWll'Jl'! 15 v'I1rh ,rfU~tJ'W~H'lImlnHiJ'jl(ll~~'e)!~m.J ~lf)'h 10;000 urn jj

...

"

l1J sr » <!! 0':1 1 :lI, <!! .,g ,~ I ~

11(1 !~H9H)!~tl'W 10,000-30,000 1J1'V1 H'O~ll'Jlt'J ~\VleH~8'W 30;000 111'1'1'11'W 1J lJfj\U'D)"'Jl.t

'Ul(l'DHlJi 'Wfll'V'l'JJ:UUfl~'J1U~"'W l~u ri ~1'Wfl11lJf1Jti~"1l'tl'IJ flJl:u~~~~6 fl11lJ1I1~lfiJlI

'"

fl1111ihJ1h-!ffmHl~ Ui:l~flT;dhllJlJlf1T.i1~ U~fl~1-3n'WeHh-31~ihr(lrl1ftty111-3fff)~

70

fll'll--1 16

F/tlfll';fAmtJl1lnfI'U f'ilm i(JflfJJ1i 'j su» ~(J1i'j'jlJ'lJfJ.JiJfH~mJ ~ iu UfllP11lJl"11UV'Hniilv

~

..

fll'lJlt1

F

Sig.

~

x

-

x

S.D.

-

X

S.D.

-

X

S.D.

...4 Q,I fI

T111lJ9H1ffWiti

fI11lJUl::11 iJ~

1.58 l.55

.35 .40 .36

1.59

.34 .36 .37 .36 .36

1.64 1.59 1.57 1.55

.38

1.57 .34 .451 .717

1.58 .36 .212 .888

1.55 .39 .289 .833

1.49 .38 1.439 .231

1.39 .39 .175 .913

1.56

.29

"

.... 1 ...

1'I11lJlJ'Ul 'iHffUff"~

fllliJiYlJlJl1'l1'j"1::

1.40 1.40

.40 .35

1.57 1.48 1.41

.41 .33 .40

1.52

1.44

l1lJ

1.49

.30

1.52

.29

1.56

.29

1.51 .29 .412 .745

'lj'j f),ni1'U~'":)/f(1"1JltJ tfl1JIPl'jf)'5 H (l~ 11J~1-!l lJflf.U 1'1'5 '5lJlI~ tJ1i '5'5lJ 11.Jill'V1'51lJUtl~ 'lltJ~l'W

~ q

• 91

'~Htl ~1'Wfll1lJ11J~\Ol")j'tl1J fl11lJcJfm11PlU f111JJlh~l1V\Ol fll1JJl:hhl'i)-lf1t1t1'(l~ U~~fl1'i

lhllJJJlf11'J1~ ulPlfl\9h'1n\'!eHh'11:uiJtTmhrlru'Yll'1ffn~

u

71

~Tn-117

Hl:'1n1'JimClWn81l fhm~(Jf1fJJfi'J'nl1J1(J1iJ'jJJ'YfJvUm1E1l-J UlHUWII1'JJi'JU'1hU11r1-.'J



.
d ""' ""
nnnfJ1fW
.
'QW Q.I
U lHH 'VI VI n tll flu
..-!!
"" '1flJ 'lfWltlJ tl ~ ~'W1J'Vl
flw 1)'5" 'jlJ 'j)'j tl1i) su .. t Sig.

X S.D. X S.D.
<V "'"
fl11lJ'j U ~f)")fBlJ 1.58 .32 1.57 .35 .195 .845
. <>'
~ .,..
fl11lJ 9i' tI 'ff \9l tI 1.55 .36 1.61 .38 -1.381 .168
fl11lJlh~l1i1f) 1.56 .38 1.55 .37 .247 .805
y
0<:1 0' 0<:1
f111lJlJ'Wl 'il-t'ffU'ff{;'l~ 1.49 .38 1.49 .37 -.834 .405
d '"
nl'jlJ'fflJ)Jlfll'j1~ 1.40 .37 1.42 .39 -.499 .618
'j1lJ 1.51 .28 1.53 .30 -.580 .562 'illf1\9l1'jl~ 17 'V'I1rh ,rf1i~tJ'Wihmci~~vrm:nfltltJci1'Wl"lJIPI")fJJ")f'W(djtJ~ lmd.hmci..'l

'U ..

~~ mJ1ffUtl ci'W tl m"lJ lPI")flJ"lf'W/'lfW lJ11 ljfl W1i 'j) lJ'il ~ t!1i'j'jlJ 1'W fll'W) 111H{;'I~) ltl~ 1'W i ~n ri

'U.. ..

• y

~1'Wfll1lJflJ~f)")fBlJ f111lJ9ft)l;lIPl6 f111lJlh~l15f) f111lJljth l'il-l-fftlTI'{;'I~ ueerm nfflllJlfll) 1~

U\9l f11l1~ fttHJcil~ 'l ~lj,r tlrllr1ru'YI1~ ffD~

"

You might also like