U.S. patent 7805860: Footwear having independently articuable toe portions. Granted to Fliri on 2010-10-05 (filed 2006-09-26) and assigned to Vibram S.p.A.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vibram S.P.A. et. al. v. Fut Glove, LLC (Florida). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
Original Title
Footwear having independently articuable toe portions (US patent 7805860)
U.S. patent 7805860: Footwear having independently articuable toe portions. Granted to Fliri on 2010-10-05 (filed 2006-09-26) and assigned to Vibram S.p.A.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vibram S.P.A. et. al. v. Fut Glove, LLC (Florida). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
U.S. patent 7805860: Footwear having independently articuable toe portions. Granted to Fliri on 2010-10-05 (filed 2006-09-26) and assigned to Vibram S.p.A.. Currently involved in at least 1 patent litigation: Vibram S.P.A. et. al. v. Fut Glove, LLC (Florida). See http://news.priorsmart.com for more info.
‘US007805860B2
2) United States Patent (10 Patent No: US 7,805,860 B2
Fliri (45) Date of Patent: Oct. 5, 2010
(34) FOOTWEAR HAVING INDEPENDENTLY Sa7g19 A 61994 Fig
ARTICUABLE TOE PORTIONS, 538979 A M1995 Lydon
05) verte, Ment S41409 A 81906 His I
sic ert Flr, Meran (IT) S647 145 A (997 Russell etal.
(73) Assignee: Vibram S.p.A. (IT) 5.774.898 A * 7/1998 Malpee .. 229
5913592 A+ 61999 Moore 3681
(4) Notice: Subst oany sls thetermofthis ——goigs75.A* 12000 yeh 229
patent iserended or adjusted under 38 eangay G00 Bae
C 154(b) by 909 days. 6.118941 A 92000, Ellis, IT
aatenetine 6.40599 BI* 102002 Che sens
6708348 BI 32004 Romy
(22) ied: Sep. 26,2006
6) Prior Publication Data
US 2007/0144039 Al Jun. 28, 2007. (Continued)
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
Related US. Applicaton Data
(60) Provisional application No. 60/720,750, filed on Sep. ones 7767-0006 2005
26, 2008, provisional application No, 60830.92,
fe on J 15, 2006
(S)) Incl, (Continued)
ANB 726 (2006.01) OTHER PUBLICATIONS
(2) US.CL 95,3688; 509 2289,
7409 Amacto Form PCTISA206 Communion ling othe es
Oonredt concen ere 369 oTlhepalltertionl ech PCTUS2O0605 70 dade
‘36/113, 88, 93, 94; 2/239, 499 Ysaref 2006.
See application le fo compte search history. Primary Esoniner-Mori Patron
(86) References Cited (4) Attorney Agen, or Firm—Cantor Colburn LLP
US. PATENT DOCUMENTS eo) ABSTRACT
Lm A+ 21990 Finklseia ex
BO1S66 A 12 Levey
A “Aided Langeafeldeta an 12894 A footwear is provided ncng a sole ad an upper where
A+ Tye Aatins 364 thesolean the uper dln inva oe portions contig
A 1aost Stacie ted receive ein, and allow independ arcs of
AS M1987 Petrey 2259 corresponding individual toes of a foot inserted in the foot-
Ay SBT Hey coc 3643 yearn whee te soe inl an exesion prion whi
tag el line tens upwardly around at east a portion the To.
A+ 111. Sipala 368
A 41909 Hlerpeneder 15 Claims, 11 Drawing SheetsUS 7,805,860 B2
Page?
US. PATENT DOCUMENTS oso4eir AL 8200 Grewedtl
Sipcuroa al Tap Bu nw
670.028 BI 04 Bs Soolson Als Sab tana oe
Crees BI 130! Awe
Sastaer BI 46 eget seu FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
7ae)s0) BI Tm sy ve .
THI B2* BOG Gretel nanan 3689 EE esse
7 iioves oe
oiensest At 123901 Beh ee
Jimi Al '9ap0s Gn oilers Mars
2008091728 AL $2008 Alley
2008009172 AL 52005 Alley * cited by examinerUS. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 1 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2
Aig. 1US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 2 of 11US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 3 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2
AG. 3US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 4 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2
Aig. 4US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 6 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2
FIG.6
48US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 7 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2
100
AG. 7US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet $ of 11 US 7,805,860 B2US. Patent Oct. 5, 2010 Sheet 11 of 11 US 7,805,860 B2US 7,805,860 B2
1
FOOTWEAR HAVING INDEPENDENTLY
ARTICUABLE TOE PORTIONS
(CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED
APPLICATION s
This epplicaionis related o and claims the benefit of US.
Provisional Patent Application Ser, No, 60°720.750 filed on
126 Sep. 2005 and U'S, Provisional Patent Application Sex
No. 60890,922 led on 15 Jul. 2006, the conten of sid. 10
applications are herein incorporated by reference in their
entirety
TECHNICAL FIELD OF INVENTION
‘The invention concems footwear and, more particultly,
feotwear having provisions for allowing independent move-
‘ment ofa wearer's tes while providing comfort, protection,
‘and enhanced haptic response
BACKGROUND OF INVENTION
As is widely accepted, toe movement is essential t0 the
efficent overall movement of the body. See, eg wow
posetech.com; “Kick OM Your Shoes and Run Awhile, »
Christopher McDougall, NY Times, 23 Jun. 2005; et. Toe
‘ction and the overall haptic response ofthe foot upoa the
round play an important role in walking jogging, running,
et, and a providing and mitaining a person's bodily bal-
ance. Herein, “haptic response” is used t meana tctilesense
cof response relating particularly fo the sense of touch asso
ated with te foot and lower logs with espoct othe ground!
sree
Conventional shoes generally include a sole portion and an
‘upper formed above the sole and attachod to a periphery
thereof. The soe is shaped to undetle the bottom of a Weat-
rs foot from te hee! area through te arch, ball ofthe foot,
‘upto and even beyond the tips ofthe toes, The upper extends
cover the sole to delimit a eavity which receives the foot.
portion ofthe upper extend over the toe aren of the sole to
forma toe cap at the font portion of the shoe, When the shoe
is wom, the toes extend into the toe cap and lie therein aj
cent one another. In this way, the foot rests upon a thick sole
the bottom of which is generally fat for providing even con-
‘et withthe ground. That is, when the shoe sat rest, the sale
is disposed fush agains the grou.
‘When the conventional shoe is worn, the entire font toe
ap portion aets2sa single unt. The movement of the toe cap
portion is generally limited toa pivoting action about the ball.
‘ofthe fot. Thats despite the various movements f the five
toes dispose therein, the toe cap portion moves asa single
‘unit in only one dizection st a time.
In this way, the coaveational shoe can limit the natural
‘movements ofthe toes and thus effet the overall operation
ana performance ofthe foot. Additonal the toe cap potion
limits, if aot restrits, the wearer's ability to spread hisher
toes Within the toe cap portion. This ean lead to significant
iscomfort of the wearer. This discomfort is compounded
‘when the toes are eroded into the toe cap portion.
‘Moreover the thick sole of a conventional shoe isolates the
‘tural contouring and curvature ofthe fot from the ground,
thus minimizing the foots haptic sensations with respect to
the ground, Thiscan cause a general dsessocation between a
person ad the ground resulting te development of eaproper
foot andlor toeaetion while walking, running te and ean be
‘generally disadvantageous with respect tothe person's bal-
ance, agility, and overall foot health
x“
8
s
2
Attemptshave been made to provide footwear having indi-
vidual portions which encapsulate each te separately, Se,
for example, U.S. Pat. Nos. 3967390, 4,651,354, and
'STTA808. However, none ofthese have been successful in
enabling fee and independent toe articulation while atthe
sume time providing enhanced comfort and inereasedbapt
response along wth a significant degre a foot and toe pro
tection
Further attempts have been made to contour the sale of
shoeto correspond to curvatures the foo. See, forexample,
US. Pat, Nos. 4989349, 5317 819, 5,544,429, 6,115,941,
and 6,708,424. However, all of these teachings require an
futsole and a mid-sole, the combined thickness of which
separates the foot ofthe wearer from the ground, thus reic=
ing haptic response. Additionally, dhese atempis are gener-
ally directed toward shoe sole Whicl has a generally planar
bottom surface for fhshly engaging the ground. As men-
tioned above, tis configuration further deprades the haptic
response provided by the shoe, Moreover these references
disclose a shoe having a conventional toe cap portion for
containing al five tes ina restrictive single compartment
‘Therefore, independent articulation of toes isnot permitted,
thorefore farther degrading the wearer's haptic response and
resuling in increased foot discomfort.
Thos there isa need for footwear which is shaped to the
natural contour of the feet and which allows independent
intrinsic movement of the feet, and particularly the toes, in
order to enhance performance of the foot, increase haptic
response, andto bring increased comfort tothe wearerand yet
‘which il provides coverage and protectionto the toes and to
the remainder ofthe foo.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
‘The above discussed and oer problems and deficiencies
ofthe proe art are avercome or alleviated by the invention
‘which provides a novel and nonobvious footwear dove,
A footweuris provided including asoleandan upper where
the sole and the upper dcimit individual toe potions config
‘ured to receive, retain, and allow independent arculation of
corresponding individual toes of a foot inserted in the foot
‘wear and where the sole includes an extension portion which
extends upwardly around at least a portion the fot
‘The inveation further provides footwear including asole,
‘an upper attached to the sole, anda convexity formed on the
sole proximate tothe upper, wherethe convexity isconfigured
tw engage a fore-fot portion of afoot inserted ato the Foot-
‘The invention additionally provides a footwear inching
sole an upper, and a securentent arangement configured to
securethe fotweae tothe foot ofa wearer, where the soleand
the upper delimit individual toe portions configured to
receive, ean, and allow independent articulation of eoere-
sponding individual tes ofa foot inserted inthe footweae,
‘whore the sole ineludes contouring and curvature which it
imately coresponds tothe shape ofthe foot, and where the
sole and upper are disposed to provide an enlaces haptic
response tothe wearer.
‘The above-discussed and oer features and advantages of
the apparatus and method willbe appreciated and understood
‘by those skilled inthe avt from the following drawings and
datsled description,
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
Referring now tothe drawings wherein tke elements are
‘numbered alike inthe several gues:US 7,805,860 B2
3
FIG.1 shows a perspective view of a footwear according
‘he invention;
IG. 2 shows aside elevation view thereof;
IG. 3 shows atop plan view thereof:
FIG. 4 shows a perspective view thereof with te portions
in an articulated position:
FIG. § shows a bottom view ofthe footwear of FIG.
FIG. 6shows asie elevation view ofa fotwearin another
embodiment aecoeing to the invention;
FIG.7 shows a perspective view thereof and
FIG. 8 shows atop plan view theeeo.
FIG. 9 shows aside elevation view of footwearin another
‘embodiment according the invention
FIG. 10 shows a perspective view thereof;
FIG. 11 shows a side elevation view of a footwear in
another embodinent ofthe invention:
FIG. 12 shows a perspective view thereof;
FIG. 13 shows atop plan view of a sole ofthe footwear of
FIGS. 9-12; and
FIG. 14 shows a bottom plan view thereof with contour
lines showing the contouring and curvature ofthe bottom of
the sole
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED
EMBODIMENT
FIG. 1 shows a prspostve view ofa fooowear 10 in one
‘embodiment ofthe invention, The footwear 10 is generally
‘composed ofa sole 12 and an upper 14 attached tothe sole 12
around a periphory of the sole 12. The footwear 10 further
‘comprises an insole 16 dispose atop and attached to the sale
12. The insole 16 also attached to the upper 14 ata periph-
ery of the insole 16
‘As best show in FIG. 3, the footwear 10 includes several
regions which generally corespond to various parts of the
foot, A rearfoot portion 18 is disposed toward a rer of the
footwear 10 ands generally configured for fitting wound and
supporting the el ofa wearer A midfoot portion 0 extends
forward fom the rear portion 18 and eoresponds generally
‘with the arch area ofthe foo. fre-foct portion 22 extends
Forward ofthe mid-faot portion 20nd generally corresponds
to the area ofthe bal ofthe foot, thats, the area proximate to
the joining ofthe metatarsals and proximal phalanges. fat
portion 24is the forward most egion ofthe footwear 0 and
stenerally aligns with, supports, and protect the toes ofthe
foot.
“The tion portion 24 ofthe focteur 10 includes invidual
toe portions 26 formed by a unique and intricate shaping of
the sole 12, upper 14, and insole 16, The sole 12 includes
splits 28 in te font portion 24 which delimit respective toe
portions 26. See, particularly, FIG. 5. The upper 14 includes
toe regions 30 which extend from atop 32 ofthe upper 14