Law OFFICES: ROBERTS, STEVENS & PRENDERGAST, P.L.C. Jay P. ROBERTS 321 EasT Fount Stacer TeLEDMoNe Canren J. STEVENS P.O, Bx 956 (319) 234-4600 HEATHER A. PRENDERGAST? WATERLOO, IOWA 50704-0956 Fax "aso veenseD nemo E-mail: lavlirm@rsplaw.biz (19) 234.7678 ' January 12, 2011 RECEIvep Iudicial Nominating Committee JAN 2 Black Hawk County Courthouse teed 316 Bast Fifth Street STATE Waterloo, Iowa 50703 COURT ADMINISTRATOR RE: Craig Ament Dear Members of the Judicial Nominating Committee: Thave had the pleasure of knowing Craig Ament professionally for the past 20 years. Asa young lawyer he was a mentor of mine. He spent countless hours giving me his insights with respect to criminal law, family law and juvenile law. Over the years I have relied on his sound judgment and expertise in various areas of the law. Most of us who know Craig, appreciate his unique sense of humor and his dogged and zealous representation of his client's interests, His attention to detail is unsurpassed. Craig has a municipal wealth of experience in civil, criminal, and administrative matters as well as general practice. He is an excellent draftsman and is a highly effective communicate think Craig would make an excellent Appellate judge and [urge you to support his nomination. “ Very Ffily Ypfirs, Cater Stevens tevens(@rsplay Roberts, Stevens & Prendergast, P.L.C. CSijacPEDDICQRD, WHARTON, SPENCER, Hook, BARRON & WEGMAN, L.L-P’ Sake ARTTORNEYS & COUNSELORS AT LAW rd = senate ne sara sini Seon ws SOS tne om ae ae Steven Duriek@Peddicora-Law.com January 20, 2011 Justice David S. Wiggins Jean Dickson ‘Margaret Redenbaugh david wiggins@iowacourts.gov IZD@bettylawfiem.com denbaugh@bvuedu Steven Pace Coleen Denete Beth Walker sip@shultleworthtaw.com cdenefe@yahoo.con beth@walklaw.com Mary Beth Lawler Amy Skogerson Madalin Williams mmlawler01@mehsi.com amy@raccoonriverlaw.com mw 2471@gmail.com Joseph Fitzgibbons David Cochran Guy Cook fitz@fitzei wfirm.com David.Cochran@loras.edu goook @arefesidney,com Steven Brody H, Daniel Holm, Jr. ‘Timothy Mikkelsen ve brndy@pioneer.com bkh@aballkirkholm.com Amikk@aolzcom, David K. Boyd State Court Adm RE: Joseph Barron's Application for Position of Suprome Court Justice Dear All: Lam writing this letter with great privilege and honor on behalf of Joseph Barron, in support of his application for one of the vacant seats on the Supreme Court of lowa. | am a partner with Peddicord ‘Wharton and have had the opportunity to work very closely with him over the course of my 15 plus years in the practice of law. During my 15 years of practice, I have been involved in many complicated eases from products liability type cases, to breach of contract cases, to insuitance coverage disputes, all of which involved intricate legal issues that involved eavefil and detaited analysis. In virtually every single one of those eases thatIowa Supreme Court Commissioner Jaanuary 20, 2011 Page 2 have ended up on my desk, | have requested Joseph Barton of our law firm to assist me in wading through, analyzing, and advocating those tricky and intricate legal issues. While I would be tremendously saddened to lose him asa law partner, I believe his legal mind is second to none ancl 1 ‘would be remiss if | did not support him in his pursuit of this position, as [believe the Supreme Court of Towa ~ as well as the State of lowa ~ would benefit greatly from his tremendous legal acumen, Additionally, I must tell you that I find Mr. Barron’s character and integrity to be unmatched, In my humble opinion, I believe those traits are perhaps even more important and significant in terms of qualification for the Supreme Court of fowa than even top level legal acumen. I would be more than happy to share with any of you specific examples of where I have personally witnessed Joseph Barron's legal acumen and character integrity in the many cases | have brought him into over my legal career. Please know that { am absolutely available to discuss with any of you his qualifications and field any questions you may have regarding him, that ‘Thank you for each of your service in fulfilling this important process. Tam grateful for your you invest in this process to see that only the highest caliber of individuals ~ both personally and professionally — are scated on the Supreme Court of lowa. Very truly yours, PEDDICORD, WHARTON, SPENC HOOK, BARRON, & WEGMAN, LLP By: sTDIcar<4 PEDDICORD, WHARTON, SPENCER, HOOK, BARRON & WEGMAN, L.L. Sone gacky ARTE ATTORNEYS & COUNSELORS AT LAW ‘EON G1 2200 ieee (800 LAKE DRIVE, SUITE 125 oan Jost nanox \WEST DES MOINES, [OWA 0266 sat ons ae RECEIVED ~~ ae JAN 13 2011 ‘STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR January 12, 2011 David K. Boyd State Court Administrator 1411 East Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 Dear Mr. Boyd: I write to you on behalf of my law partner, Joe Barron, in support of his application for nomination to the lowa Supreme Court. Joe has been an upstanding attorney and appellate advocate for the past 22 years. | have personally practiced with Joe Barron for the past six years, and am tremendously proud to call him my law partner, I can state without hesitation that Joe Barron is uniquely qualified to serve as a justice on the lowa Supreme Court. Our law firm is comprised solely of litigation attorneys, and Joe Barron manages, in exclusive form, our appellate advocacy. Joe is a highly skilled attorney with excellent communication abilities, and a unique understanding of lowa law. Joe routinely briefs our attorneys on the fine points of lowa law and interpretation of the same by lowa appellate courts. Joe routinely argues before the lowa Court of Appeals and the lowa Supreme Court, and is highly respected by his peers. Joe is a man of high integrity and unquestionable character. He is a genuine man who will serve the interests of the State of lowa and its citizens with honor and dignity, Without question, an elevation of Joe Barron to the bench would be a tremendous loss to the Peddicord Wharton law firm, Our loss, however, would be replaced by a significant gain to the citizens of the State of lowa. | endorse Joe Barron's application for nomination to the lowa Supreme Court without hesitation, and request the Commission give full consideration to Joe's application, credentials, ‘experience and personal integrity.David K. Boyd Page 2 January 12, 2011 If | can provide further information, please feel free to contact me at your convenience. Indy: pa thao aia IWibamCLAYTON COUNTY ATTORNEY Alan Heavens 120 Main Street Natalia Blaskovich Clayton County Attorney PO Box 116 Ass't County Attorney aheavens@claytoncountyia.gov lkacler, 1A 52043 nblaskovich@claytoncountyia gov Ph, 563-245-3808 / FAX 563-245-3809 Jamuary 23,2011 RECEIVED TO: State Judicial Nominating Commission JAN 24 20H Dear Commissioners, STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR Please accept this unsolicited letter in support of John W. Bernau for the Jowa Supreme Court, I have known John for approximately two years now and consider him to have been an irreplaceable mentor throughout these early stages of my career | met John as a law student when I was clerking for a firm in Dyersville. He took time to set up at meeting, with me at which he listened to and answered almost two hours of my questions, always with an insightful answer and a smile, Since then John has been a “first call” for me when an important issue atises. Last April I decided to run for County Attorney immediately out of law school and was fortunate to be elected, Both before and after the election I sat in on neighboring Delaware County court fo observe John in action, He searched for the just result in each case and without exception he consistently treated everyone with respect, whether the person was a judge, defense attorney, defendant, or courthouse employee. 1 am proud to call John Bernau a friend and mentor and I sincerely hope that he is able to fulfill his dream of becoming an lowa Supreme Court Justice. His criminal law background in both prosecution and defense would be an asset to the Court and his personal kindness and integrity will be appreciated not just by his potential colleagues but by every citizen in Towa who meets him. I encourage you to submit his name to Governor Branstad. If you have any questions please don’t hesitate to contact me. Thank you. Sincerely, ae Alan Heavens Clayton County AttomeyISEA, Fducation Assocation 777 Thied Sereet zp, Schools es ain nes 50309-1301 tel 515.471.8000 fox518471.2017 wrnyuisen.org An ationesttne Aisin edscaton Students Parents A Teachers Great Education, t RECEIVED ‘5 An lowa Basic, Jan 1.9 2011 STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR January 14, 2011 ‘The Honorable David 8. Wiggins Justice, Towa Supreme Coiurt Judicial Branch Building 1111 B, Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 Re: Richard Blane If Supreme Court Vacaney Dear Justice Wiggins: By way of introduction, my name is Jim Smith and I am the General Counsel for the Iowa State Education Association, The Towa State Education Association is a professional association with a membership of approximately 34,000 public school employees. For the fourteen years prior to joining the Iowa State Education Association, I worked in the Polk County Attomey’s office (the last six years as the Polk County Attorney). It has recently come to my attention that the abovenamed Richard Blane II has submitted his name to you, and the other members of the Iowa State Judicial Nominating Commission, indicating his desire to be nominated for consideration of his appointment to fill one of the current vacant positions on the Iowa Supreme Court. The purpose of this letter is to urge you fo nominate Judge Blane to fill one of those vacancies. Thave known Judge Blane both personally and professionally since our days working together in the Polk County Attorney’s Office. I have also followed his career through his days in the United States Attomey’s Office, the private practice of law, and his sixteen years as a Judge on the Polk County District Court Bench. Over the years, I have had ample opportunity to observe him in a number of these different settings involving many different people and situations. These interactions with people of varying backgrounds have benefited him greatly in his current role as a District Court Judge. Whether in the courtroom or in the community, Judge Blane always speaks and acts with the appropriate amount of dignity and respect. Ne‘The Honorable David S. Wiggins January 14,2011 Page 2 During my time as General Counsel for the Jowa State Education Association, as well as my fourteen in the Polk County Attomey’s Office, I have had occasion, on an almost daily basis, to observe the Judicial system, and its participants, in action, I have been very fortunate to be in a position to wateh, and learn from, some of the State’s best Judges and attorneys, both at the District Court and Supreme Court levels. I feel that experience puts me in a unique position to assess the qualifications needed for a member of the Iowa Supreme Court. In my opinion, Judge Rick Blane meets all of those requirements, Judge Blane has a great respect for, and knowledge of, the law, He has an almost uncanny ability to analyze a given situation, identify the issues involved, assess the options available, and make appropriate decisions. He is also able to explain his decisions, both orally and in writing, in a manner understandable to the members of the Bar and lay people alike. I have always found Judge Blane to be prepared, articulate, courteous, and respectful to all who appear before him. Perhaps most important, is his overriding sense of fairness. Judge Blane’s awareness of, and appreciation for, our judicial system and its important role in our society is obvious. Each day he welcomes the challenge of making our court system the best that it could possibly be. During all of that time, Judge Blane has also been very active on numerous Judicial commissions and committees whose role was to enhance and improve the practice of law and the role of the Judiciary. Somehow, he was also able to find time to teach a very popular trial advocacy class at the Drake University School of Law. In addition, he has continued to seek out, and attend, numerous meetings and conferences to better assist him in his service to the people of the State of Iowa, Judge Blane’s professional skills, demeanor, and integrity (both personal and professional) are above reproach. He works as hard as any judge that I know. He possesses all of the professional qualities, temperament, good judgment, and common sense that one looks for in a member of the Supreme Court. I have, in the past, had occasion to represent numerous clients before the Supreme Court. Should it be necessary for me to represent the interests of other clients before the Supreme Court in the future, it would be an honor to have Judge Biane as one of the presiding Justices. 1 realize that the task before you in nominating individuals to fill the current vacancies on our State Supreme Court is not an easy one. However, your decision to nominate Judge Rick Blane for consideration of a position on the Court would be one of which you would certainly be proud. His judicial ethics, command of the law and rules of evidence, and respect for, and commitment to,‘The Honorable David S. Wiggins January 14, 2011 Page 3 our judicial system would make him a fine addition to the already high caliber Towa Supreme Court. ‘After reviewing this leter, if you or any of the other Commissioners, have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you in advanee for your cooperation and assistance in this matter, Sincerely, Gude ow mes A, Smith. General Counsel JAS/tb Copy to: David K. Boyd, Secretary, Iowa State Judicial Nominating Commission Members of the Iowa State Judicial Nominating CommissionWIEDENFELD & McLAUGHLIN, L.L.P. Artorners at Law Mare J. Wieoensreto 8400 HIGKIMAN ROAD (915) 278-9900 encil: njw@8400a.c0m DES MOINES, 1A 50325-4320 Fax (515) 278-9977 Joser# P. McLAuGHIIN email: jpm@8400lav.com Lawes W. Russet, RECEIVED email: james(Q8400lcw.com January 24, 2011 JAN 2 4 2011 Judicial Nominating Commission STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR Chairperson: Honorable David Wiggins 1111 East Court Ave. Des Moines, IA 50319 RE: Judge Richard Blane Dear Justice Wiggins and other Commission Members: It has been my privilege to have practiced before Judge Blane for years. He is an excellent jurist. I enthusiastically recommend that you include Judge Rick Blane one of your nominees, Judge Blane is a very capable disixiet court judge. He is known for his thoughtful, well reasoned rulings. In fact, [ am not aware of him ever making a mistake, other than the times he has ruled against my clients. Seriously, Judge Blane is regarded as one of our finest trial judges, He has the experience and skill you are looking for: Although we would hate to lose someone of his caliber from the district court bench, he would be an excellent addition to the Iowa Supreme Court, Please include Judge Blane in the group that you submit to the governor. Sincerely, Akad tiatapie Mark J. Wiedenfeld MJWillmRECEIVED JAN 1 8 201 Dear Mr. Boyd, STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR 1am writing in support of Rob Blink for appointment to the Iowa Supreme Court. Ihave known Rob for 4 years and he has been a pillar of support for me during that time, Rob's support and advice for me has been of a non-legal nature however. 1 cannot comment on his legal ability and know you have others who will. I can and would like to comment on his moral character, which should be equally as important as his legal ability. Ina time when I needed advice, Rob, although he had never met me, gave me hours of thoughtful listening and wise counsel. He was always willing to listen and gave me a perspective that was well-thought out and, as time has shown me, right. During our meetings, Rob proved to be calm, caring, and logical, I cannot thank him enough, He deserves your consideration for this calling. Sincerely, Douglas L., Schulte, M.D.THE LAW SCHOOL LEGAL CLINIC NEAL AND GEA SMITH LAW CENTER Drake UNIVERSITY January 10, 2011 Mr, David K. Boyd State Court Administrator 1111 East Court Avenue Des Moines IA 50319 Re: Robert J. Dear Mik Ayan A, Judge Rob Blink has informed me that he is submitting his name for consideration for appointment to the Iowa Supreme Court, and he has asked if T would write to members of the Commission in support of his candidacy, Tam glad to oblige Judge Blink, I have known him for nearly more than 30 years as a graduate of Drake Law School, as a prominent prosecutor in town, as a colleague on the Drake Law Faculty teaching in the Legal Clinic and for two decades now an Adjunct Professor of Law co-teaching ‘Trial Advocacy with Judge Blane, and of course as a District Court Judge in Polk County. Judge Blink is an enthusiastic and tireless participant in the legal profession in al of its facets and would bring a variety of experiences and perspectives to the Court, Very early on he was seen as a highly capable lawyer warranting major trial assignments not long after graduating from law school, and the personal experience and insight into the criminal justice system that he offers as a former prosecutor and longtime trial judge would be of assistance to the Court and the State of Iowa in dealing with cases on the Coutt’s docket, a significant portion of which deal with Criminal Law and Procedure. He has been active in the profession in a variety of ways in addition to practice and service on the District Court, as his law- related professional activities attest, He is a person of practical inclination and experience with his feet on the ground who recognizes that cases involve real people and many interested participants. At the same time, he has long had a scholarly inclination and thought reflectively about the law. Based upon his performance in Law School and my observation and discussions with him at different times over the ‘years, I have no doubt about his intellectual ability and habits of study regarding cases and issues that are brought before the Supreme Court, do not practice in District Court of have occasion to speak with lawyers or parties or others who miay appear before him, but I know from speaking with students who have had him in Trial Advocacy that he teats them with respect, is highly knowledgeable, is effective in his teaching, and is fair in his comments and assessments, They have remarked, as have I, that Judge Blink has a shatp sense of humor, and that he is helpful in sharing his own experiences and lessons with them, I believe that the Judge is well-regarded in the fogal community outside the Law School and enjoys an camed, solid reputation as a good and fair judge. Lam happy to share this assessment with you and recommend him for consideration for nomination to the Iowa Supreme Court. If you have questions that I may answer and would like to speak personally, please feel free to contact me at (515) 271-1805 (direct dial). Sincerely, wid Vi David $, Walker Page Crean 2400 Usivesscy Avene T-515.271 3851 Distinguished Professor of Law Des Moines wa F sisazicion suauiasos ‘rnwdeakedeHITFIELD REDDY PLC. Defoe Sona “Teepe 515-288-6041 Facsimile S15-246-1474 ATTORNIS AND COUNSELORS ATLAW. ruannusccon Coy oy beg Oat Tamar oes Pe ane i a See, Raho Nepieeaee | CoN Thane Ler ete a Tc ete ee ee re ee oe ee ee em Fane tes es esc Rae NE eet ee ea See RT, nace ee er Be Ay SS te Petia Sage” ess muh Reve tcote— Saarer inal er Teta eee A Sy Tet Rhee ee ee cen ee eer ee aia January 13, 2011 ‘hansong@whitfieldiaw com David K, Boyd State Court Administrator RECEIVED 1111 E, Court Ave. JAN 1 4 2011 Des Moines, lowa 50319 Re: Judge Robert Blink STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR Dear Davi It is my pleasure to write to you on behalf of the candidacy of Judge Robext Blink for the openings on the Towa Supreme Court. Asa three time applicant for openings on the Towa Court of Appeals myself, [ had the pleasure to meet you and th you about your vision of what qualities an appeal judge should possess. Broad experience of many areas of law, good analytic and writing skills, judicial temperament and personality come to mind as qualities we discussed, Ihave known Judge Blink for nearly 25 years. We first met when we were new associates together with Whitfield & Eddy. He came to private practice with 10 years legal experience as assistant attorney general and assistant Polk County Attorney; I came with 12 years experience in military, business and banking, We worked together as associates and partners in the firm before he went on the district court bench in 1995, Judge Blink’s entire professional career has groomed him for this opportunity. His experience as assistant attorney general, assistant Polk County Attorney, attorney in private practice, and 15. years on the bench for Polk County, has situated him in an unequal position of being ready for the next challenge in his career — justice on the Iowa Supreme Court. I say challenge because Judge Blink will not assume the seat swith the attitutle of it being his reward, He ‘will work to utilize his legal expertise and experience (o perform the duties required of a justice. I know fiom my personal association with him of his analytic and writing capabilities, as you yourself will see from his samples, He may share with you he writes exira curricular as well, “Aka wilson TON Toereon, Sut 10, ik saan Von SHAT - 310.385 I5PE DISH Ankeny Ble, Ste 100, Amery, oa 50028» 515:968.3633 5737 Weed Aves, Site 43, West Des Mones, loa 80266 + 1S-SS8.0111WHITFIELD & EDDYp.c Page 2 with some of his work being published. Judicial temperament and personality are by definition subjective qualities to evaluate, But that does not mean you cannot do so. 1 know from my personal association with him as a partner, and continuing during the last 15 years as he has been a Polk County District Judge, he carries himself with dignity and respect for the office, for the attorneys in front of him and for the parties to the action, Judge Blink has a wonderful sense of humor when the occasion is appropriate to exhibit it Without hesitation or qualification I urge you and the other fourteen members of the commission vote to nominate Judge Robert Blink for the openings on the Supreme Court Sincerely, Mark V. Hanson MYH/ac Ene,EKSTROM &BURKEYLAWFIRM RECEIVED ATTORNEYS AT LAW JAN 13 2011 ‘Association of Sole Practitioners — Nota Partnership Eating aasos STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR 515-249-6395 / FAK 515-249-6146 Susan L. Ekstrom ‘Max Burkey burkey@qwestoffice.ne January 12, 2011 David K. Boyd State Court Administrator 4411 East Court Ave. Des Moines, IA 50319 Dear Mr. Boyd: 1 am writing to recommend Judge Robert Blink for one of the vacancies on the lowa Supreme Court, | am sure with all the politics surrounding these important offices you want to be certain of your candidate or choice of candidates for the governor to ‘choose from and you couldn't pick a better candidate then Judge Blink. | have been practicing for over 30 years and have appeared in front of a lot of Judges, so | feel that | have a good working knowledge of their skills and attributes. When Judge Blink has heard my cases, | find him to be attentive, well informed on legal issues, congenial with litigants and lawyers alike. In short, he would make an excellent candidate for the Supreme Court. Thank you in advance for your attention and for serving on the committee. Sincerely, Susan L. Ekstrom Ce: Judge Blink SLE/shWIEDENFELD & McLAUGHLIN, L.L.P. ‘Artorwers at Law (Mag J. Wiepenreto 8400 HICKMAN ROAD. (515) 278-9900 email: mjw@8400Ia.com DES MOINES, 1A 50325-4320 Fax (515) 278-9977 Josertt P, McLAUGHUN ‘email: jpm@8400!avs.com James W. Russett ‘email: james@8d00Iew.com RECEIV ED January 24, 2011 jaw 24 201 Judicial Nominating Commission STATE, Chairperson: Honorable David Wiggins 1111 East Court Ave. Des Moines, [A 50319 RE: Judge Robert Blink Dear Justice Wiggins and other Commission Members: Ithas been my privilege to have practiced before Judge Blink for years. He is an excellent jurist. [enthusiastically recommend that you include Judge Robert Blink as one of your nominees Judge Blink is a very capable district court judge. He is known for his thoughtful, well reasoned rulings. In fact, I am not aware of him ever making a mistake, other than the times he has ruled against my clients. Seriously, Judge Blink is regarded as one of our finest trial judges, He has the experience and skill you are looking for. Although we would hate to lose someone of his caliber from the district court bench, he would be an excellent addition to the lowa Supreme Court. Please include Judge Blink in the group that you submit to the governor. Es Mark J/Wiedenfeld Since: MJWAlm, COURT ADMINISTRATOR:PETERSEN, EDDY & JUDGE 326 Fith Avenue South inten, lowa 52752-4511 ‘Robot J. Potarson (ot counsel) Pn. (559)244-8200 George C. Edy st. (1994-1898) Fax (589) 244-8002 ‘Michaol M. Judge January 10, 2011 RECEIVED Mr. David K. Boya JAN 1 8 2011 Tilt east coure Avenue STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR Des Moines, Iowa 50319 Dear Mr. Boyd: Z am writing to recommend the candidacy of James Bruhn for appointment as Justice of Towa Supreme Court. 1 have known Jim since we played Little League Baseball together. He is one of the most experienced and knowledgeable attorneys in our State He has always shown a broad understanding of the law and has tremendous trial experience. Jim has given much of his time to civic and charitable causes in our community. ‘He has served on the Clinton Community School Board and been President of the Board. Jim’s integrity is clear and above reproach. He is respected by his peers and throughout the community. dim is always there to provide advice and help whenever asked. He respects the law, which is no small thing. Perhaps the best asset he has in regard to the position of Justice of the Iowa Supreme Court, is his abundance of good common sense. I could go on, but the purpose of my letter to you is simple, James Bruhn should be appointed to the Court. He will do a great job, and bring his hard work and intellect to this henorable Court. Thank you for your consider- ation. Very truly yours, PETERSEN, EDDY & JUDGE SsTimothy W. Hartsock 2185 11" Street Clinton, 1A 52732 563.212,2042 tim,hartsock@corevens.com January 12, 2012 RECEIVED David K. Boyd State Court Administrator JAN 18 20tt 1111 East Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50139 STATE COURT ADMINISTRATON Re: Letter of Support James D, Bruhn, Candidate for lowa Supreme Court Justice Dear David K. Boyd, | would like to take the time to tell you alittle about James D. Bruhn, whom I call Jim, I met Jim in 1998, We were introduiced at a charity golf outing anid have been friends ever since. Over the years, have grown to respect Jim for his unending commitment to our community, our schools and the justice system. The utmost respect | have fof him’ camé in 2006. H Iwill tell you about that later. f 7 {can tell you his professionalism is as good as I've seen. He has the respect of his peers and the community because he holds his professionalism and profession in high regard. He believes part of being a professional and earning respect requires a great deal of citizenship and concern for others. His demeanor is one of his great assets and his actions certainly prove that. He is respectful, considerate and a compassionate person. tn 2004, my wife and | returned from Ukraine with an adopted son, Jake. Jess, our biological son, now hada brother. While in Ukraine, we met Jake’s sister, Veka, She was living with her grandmother and doing well, even though she was living in very poor conditions. In November 2006, her grandmother called our attorney in Ukraine and asked that we adopt Veka. She could no longer provide for her and was afraid her life would be left to live, running the streets and without any education past 8 grade. A few days after we received the call we were in Jim’s office, discussing our excitement and the legal remedies to finish this adoption as quick as legally possible. Jim’s excitement for us and his understanding of how bad this girl needed to get to the United States was immediate. We gave him a picture of Veka and asked him to work for her, every day. His efforts helped us finish her adoption in February, 2008. She is now a freshman at Clinton High School. His work and commitment to her was the greatest gift he provided our family, just ask my daughter. We would have paid anything for what he did to help us, yet we have never recelved a bilJim has the courage of integrity. His ability to choose ethics over convenience and truth over popularity defines him as a person and a professional. 1am proud to be writing this letter on his behalf and | encourage you to give him a fair look and a honest assessment for this most prestigious position. He would be a great ambassador of the Court, Respectfully Submitted, het w. WEE Timothy W. Hartsock 218511" Street Clinton, 1A 52732 563.212.2082ye FARWELL & BRUHN Richard W. Farwel,P.C. ‘Attomeys at Law (Admitted lowa & Missouri Bars) 343 5" Avenue South James D. Bruhn Clinton, Towa 52732-4510 jbruhng@ferwellbrvacom (Aaited Tow. & Hino Bars) Christopher L Farwell ‘Telephone (563) 242-6162 farwell@farwellbruhn.com FAX (563) 242-6165 (Aatited Towa & Minnesote Bars) January 13,2011 " RECEIV Secretary of the Commission JAN 19 200 State Judicial Nominating Commission feeae David K. Boyd s San Ca ance TATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR i111 B. Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 Dear Honorable Commissioners: ‘The purpose of this letter is to recommend James D, Bruhn as an Iowa Supreme Court Justice. After practicing law with Jim at Farwell & Bruhn for approximately fifteen (15) years, I have a unique knowledge and insight as to his character and abilities ~ all of which I can say highly recommend him to a position as an owa Supreme Court Justice. He has the intellectual and analytical skills to become an “excellent Justice, with the ability to carefully and objectively analyze the facts and the law, augmented by common sense and practical knowledge. As a general practitioner for thirty years, he has been exposed to multiple areas of the law, including family law, juvenile law, ctiminal law, real estate, probate, and personal injury. He is respected in the general community and by his peers alike. Not only have his clients sought his advice, but other attorneys have done so as well. He possesses the necessary judicial temperament for the fair treatment of litigants. He will carefully listen to the parties and evaluate their positions in an equitable manner under the applicable law. In broad outline, without further elaborating, James D. Bruhn would be an outstanding choice as an Iowa Supreme Court Justice. Very truly yours, curr 7"v RECEIVED JAN 1 3 201 MAYER, LONERGAN AND ROLFES ArTonners ano COUNSELLORS AT LAH STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR Alani maven ceie-sooe January 11, 2011 THe sassese State Court Administrator David K, Boyd, Secretary 1111 Bast Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 In re: Supreme Court vacancy - James D. Bruhn, Applicant. Dear Secretary T am writing this letter to support James D. Bruhn in his application for appointment for a Supreme Court Justice vacancy. I am a practicing Attorney in Clinton, Iowa, and have engaged in the practice of law in Clinton, Towa, since 1976, for a period of 34 years, and Jim Bruhn commenced practicing law in Clinton in 1980, and has been a broad spectrum general practitioner for 30 years. As an Attorney, Mr. Bruhn has been practicing in both Federal and State Courts and he is an experienced litigator. In his general practice, I regard Jim as a problem solver as well as an advocate, which is a rare combination by today’s standards in our community of lawyers. Jim also represents the City of Clinton as Attorney for their Civil Service Commission and he therefore has experience in the administrative law area. Jim is a good technician, and he has great attention to detail. Mr. Bruhn is an excellent student of the law and when I have had difficulty in construing and applying the law, I have turned to Jim for assistance and sought his opinions regarding interpretation of the law. I have frequently opposed Jim Bruhn in the handling of cases in our community and if we have not resolved the problem prior to Trial, we have tried our cases in a civil and professional manner... Mr. James Bruhn has an excellent understanding of the rules of ethics and he exhibits professional decorum in his practice of law. In ny opinion it is important for small town general practicing Attorneys to have representation in our appointed Supreme Court Justices. I believe Mr. James Bruhn is an excellent candidate for the position of Supreme Court Justice, and my only reservation.in making-this recommendation is that I would miss his: participation-in-the practice of law in oux local Bar Association,Respectfully, Mayer, Lonergan & Rolfes 7 By? Thomas D. y TDL/tIb xc: Justice Wiggins CommissionersSS FARWELL & BRUHN ward W, Farwell, P.C. Attomeys at Law (Admitted fowa & Missouri Bars) 343 5" Avenue South James D, Brun Clinton, Towa 52732-4510 sbruinifarwelibruha.com (Admits Towa & Minos Bars) ‘Christopher L, Farwell ‘Telephone (563) 242-6162 il@fanwellbouhn.com FAX (563) 242-6165 (Admitted lowa & Minnesota Bars) January 10,2011 RECEIVED JAN 12 2011 Scoretary of the Commission ‘STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR: State Judicial Nominating Commission David K. Boyd State Court Administrator 111 E, Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 Dear Honorable Commissioners: The undersigned is the partner of Jim Bruhn, who has filed an application for appointment to the Iowa Supreme Court, We have practiced law together for 30 years in Clinton, Jowa.. While I cannot perceive practicing law without Jim, it has always been his long term goal to sit a a Justice on the lowa Supreme Court. Jim is an exceptional lawyer with excellent skills in all areas of the law, By its nature, the practice of law in a small city is the epitome of a general practice with coverage of all areas, Jim has excellent demeanor and the ability to calmly present his legal arguments as well as listening to the legal arguments of his opponent, Moreover, he has the intellectual capacity to make sound decisions on appellate level. He has the capacity and energy to handle a large volume of work and is able to shift gears from ‘one case to another with seemingly, very little effort His character is beyond reproach and he is unquestionably one of the best litigators in our area of the State, He has the respect of his peers, not just in Clinton, lowa but in various other jurisdictions in Towa and Illinois. Jim amazes me with his ability to handle a, workload. that I have seen few lawyers able to perform. ‘The last thing I want is for Jim and 1 to no longer practice law, together. However, he strongly desires the opportunity to be a member of the lowa Supreme Court and [understand his desire:‘Thank you for this opportunity to extol the virtues of my partner, ‘There is no question you will find no better candidate for Iowa Supreme Court nomination, Very truly yours, FARWELL & BRUHN Lee a, Richard W. FarwellRECEIVED JAN 1.2 2011 CLINTON COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION Clinton County Courthouse COURT ADMINISTRATOR P.O. Box 2957 Clinton 1A 52733-2957 January 10, 2014 Dear David K. Boyd, The Clinton County Bar Association is pleased to endorse the application of James D. Bruhn of Clinton for appointment to the lowa Supreme Court. Mr. Bruhn has been a member of our association since 1980 and has served as its president, He has demonstrated competence, integrity and leadership both as an attorney and as a community leader by serving on the school board of the Clinton Community Schools. It is the opinion of the Clinton County Bar Association that Mr. Bruhn possesses the requisite experience and qualities necessary for a Supreme Court Justice and recommends him to you for that position. Sincerely, R PW Robin L. Strausser President Clinton County Bar AssociationJames J. McGraw RECEIVED 3 Heather Lane JAN 1 0 2011 Clinton, Towa 52732 STATE COURT ADMINISTRATC January 6, 2011 eae Justice David S. Wiggins 1111 Bast Court Avenue ‘Des Moines, lowa 50319 ‘The Honorable Justice David S. Wiggins: Tam writing this letter in support of Mr. James Bruhn, On a personal note I have known Jim since 1980, As a young man, he played on a softball team my company sponsored and supported. After college and law school, he joined a Clinton law firm and soon after became my personal and corporate lawyer. During this period I observed a competitive team player that gave 110% effort at whatever he tried, Recently Mr. Bruhn ran for a school board position and was elected and served two terms dedication. Currently I am president of the Clinton Community School Board and having served with Jim in prior years, it is comforting to be able to discuss current ‘matters with him, He remains very knowledgeable. My real experience with Jim came following a tragie accident that left my son, age 19, in coma for nearly six months, He was very professional and at the same time compassionate in his advice and handling of the situation. After coming out of the comas, it was apparent my son was to need long-term care and rehab, Again, Jim was able to give advice and guidance. A long-term settlement was achieved that will allow my son to live a comfortable disabled life. Thave had many contacts with Jim, whether in business, at Rotary or on a personal level on the golf course or as a “Hawkeye Fan”. He has acted and played as a truly mature, caring and knowledgeable individual. I could not think of anyone I know who could represent the state of Iowa in a more honorable, judicious manner any better than James D. Bruhn, et James J. McGraw ‘ cc, Jean Dickson, Steven Pace, Beth Walker, Amy Skogerson, Joseph Fitzgibbons, Guy Cook, Margaret Redenbaugh, Coleen Denefe, Mary Beth Lawler, Madaliry/ Williams, David Cochran, Steven Brody, H, Daniel Holm, Jr., Timothy Mikkelsen, David K, Boyd 5 weMarilyn K. Huff Clinton County Clerk of District Court P.O. Box 2957 RECEIVED Clinton, lowa $2733 - 2957 (563) 243-6213 Ext. 4230 JAN 06 2ott STATE COURT Aoy January 4, 2011 MINISTRATOR David K, Boyd State Court Administrator 1111 East Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 Dear Mr. Boyd: It gives me great pleasure to write a letter on behalf of James Bruhn, a candidate for nominee as a justice on the Supreme Court . Thave known Jim for about thirty-one years, ever since he graduated and began his career as a lawyer for a law firm in Clinton, Lam currently the Clerk of Court for Clinton and Jackson County. When Jim started his career, I was the civil deputy in the Clinton office. In that capacity, I worked closely with Jim. I am just starting my 39" year in the Clerk’s office, the last 26 years I have been the Clerk of Court, Because of Jim’s law practice, in every aspect of the clerk’s office, I feel with Jim’s experience, he is a great candidate for one of the vacated positions. Jim is a people person, gets along well with everyone. He is courteous and respectful to all he comes in contact with. He is very well thought of in the court system. His reputation in the community is above reproach. I believe Jim is a top notch candidate for one of the vacancies on the Supreme Court. Iask you to give him your utmost consideration. Respectfully, Wes. bigp Kip Marilyn K. Huff Clerk of Court for Clinton and Jackson CountyRECEIVED / JAN 05 2011 HOuteran, SHAW, MURPHY & Srournen AE GOURT ADMINISTRATOR Remesatinterene) Gunton town sce January 3, 2011 Mr, David K, Boyd State Court Administrator 1111 East Court Avenue Des Moines, [A 50319 Re: State Judicial Nominating Commission Dear Mr. Boyd: ‘The purpose of this letter is to recommend to you Mr. James D, Bruhn from Clinton, to be placed on the list of potential candidates for the Towa Supreme Court, have known Jim since he has started to practice law in Clinton in 1980, He has ‘an excellent reputation in his law practice and specializes in civil litigation. Jim has also worked in the areas of dissolution, corporations, real estate and probate, Inall of my dealings with Jim over the last 30 years T found him to be an excellent practitioner, achieving good results for his client while treating the other litigants and their counselor with respect and consideration. It is my opinion that Jim would make an excellent lowa Supreme Court Justice and would highly recommend the commission send his name to the Governor. Very truly yours, By VY, A {DREW CHAMBERS, P.C. JDC: ADCLINTON COUNTY ATTORNEY’S OFFICE Se 2.0. BOX 2957 RECEIVED (612 NORTH SECOND STREET — 2° FLOOR comonsenngge saw 03 2 Facsimile: (63) 249-0011 STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR E-Mail: movolf@elintoncountyattorney.net Web Site: swww.clntoncounty-ia.goy MINTY. ATTORNE PARALEGAL MIKE WOLE (Cell Ph, 563-269-1782) SSTRAUSSER ‘TERESA DECKER ZABETH A. SRP (CHERYL NEWPORT SECRETARIES LISA ABBOTT BARB MUSSMANAWEBER MICHELLE ANDRESEN December 15, 2010 Secretary of the Commission State Judicial Nominating Commission David K, Boyd State Court Administrator 1111 B, Court Avenue Des Moines, 1A 50319 RE: James Bruhn Dear Honorable Commissioners: Attorney James Bruhn serves the citizens of Clinton County, fowa, with the highest degree of professionalism, He brings a great deal of energy to his work and is in good standing James Bruhn is fair and straightforward in his approach to cases, He is liked by the community ‘and well respected, Please give him serious consideration in your nomination process. Sincerely, CLINTON, COUNTY ATTORNEY’S OFFICE Mike Wolf County Attorney MW/ma