Professional Documents
Culture Documents
18 March 2011
The newest estimate that the CPI for March will be about 2.2% seems to have
been well received by Vietnamese investors, who stepped in to fill the selling
orders foreign investors flooded the market with. Liquidity improved
significantly with 53.5 million shares traded, valued at 1,307bn, up 48.6% in
volume and 60% in value. Market breadth improved with 194 winners and
only 49 laggards as many small and medium cap stocks closed at ceiling
price. Bottom fishing strengthened to drive the market upward and close near
the intraday high at 461.08 points, up 0.55 points (0.12%). Without being
affected by large cap stocks, HNX continued its third consecutive increasing
session, up 3.1% to close at 95.12 points.
Foreign investors suddenly offloaded many blue chips on HSX, with a net sell
value of VND215bn, the largest sell in a day since September 2009, resulting
in a net selling of VND224 billion on the bourse month to date. But they
remained net buyers of VND34.93 billion on the Hanoi Stock Exchange today.
Vietinbank (CTG) and Vinaconex (VCG) were their largest net buy stocks,
accumulating VND83bn in CTG and VND26bn in VCG.
Domestic prop desks were net buyers of 86bn, in which 55bn was in short-
term bond and 22bn in the fund certificate VFMVF1.
Although the index just gained minimal points at the end of the trading
session, stronger buying force is the most positive factor as we saw
unmatched bids for 20 million shares on each trading floor. We expect the
market to test the resistant level at 470 points next week.
Economic Update
By Hoai Doan, Economist, hoai.doan@vcsc.com.vn
In the foreign exchange market, the VND was mixed today in the interbank
market and the grey market. The VND gained 28bps and traded at
VND20,935/USD at mid-day in the interbank market. While we saw the VND
weaken 18bps on Friday cf. Thursday and traded at VND21,455/USD at mid-
day in the grey market. Most banks are willing to sell dollars for importers but
refuse to sell dollars to individuals at the official upper ceiling rate.
In the money market, the O/N rate traded at 16% pa, up by 250 basis point cf. Thursday.
We expect the monetary condition remain tight due inflation concerns and foreign exchange
risks. March CPI is expected to come at 2.2% MoM, according to a government report at the
th
12 National Assembly, marking the highest level since June 2008. As such, the March
figure could reach 13.9% YoY and 6.15% YTD.
Looking forward, we could expect MoM April CPI to be significantly lower cf. March thanks
(1) to the fact that most of the effect of the lifting of price controls will mainly be felt in March,
and (2) to relatively stable foreign exchange during April from tight monetary conditions.
Key notes:
- SJS posted VND 1,047bn revenue and VND 641bn profit before tax (PBT) for 2010,
missing its PBT goal of VND 1,000bn as set by management at the beginning of the
year.
- The company hardly sold any products (houses, land lots) in 2010, and its revenue
mainly came from unearned revenue in 2009 from the sale of 26ha in South An
Khanh. This explained why SJS missed its revenue and profit goal for the year.
- The reason SJS did not sell its land in South An Khanh was due to the change in
the development plan of the area. When Ha Tay merged into Ha Noi in 2009, many
projects in the West, such as the South An Khanh project, are required to change to
comply with the new development plan in 2010. SJS has changed its development
plan for the South An Khanh project, and the company expects to get approval from
Ha Noi authority in 1 or 2 months. Once this is done, it can start selling land in
South An Khanh again.
- The company sets its revenue and net profit goal for 2011 respectively at VND
3,000bn and VND 650bn. We think this is feasible, and SJS may even outperform
this target, which we will explain later.
- In 2010, SJS initiated 3 projects, acquiring land in (1) Hòa Hải – Đà Nẵng, investing
VND 1,010bn, (2) Phố Nối – Hưng Yên: VND 220bn, and (3) Trường Lưu – HCM:
VND 168bn.
- The company has sold the first project in Đà Nẵng in Q1-2011, gaining c. VND
100bn. Although it did not make a good profit, we think the sale is a good move as
the property market in Da Nang is cooling down, and the trend of developing luxury
seaside villas has lost its steam. It seems that they got out just in time!
- The second project – Phố Nối, Hưng Yên is about 26km from Ha Noi. This 100ha
land is to be developed into residential area, with townhouse and villas are the main
products. The company plans to start selling 10ha (out of 40ha total area)
commercial land in early Q2. We estimate a gross profit margin around 30%.
- Văn La – Văn Khê, the second largest project of SJS, is expected to start
contributing profit this year.
- We estimate the company could achieve VND 1,100bn profit before tax and VND
825bn net profit, beating its profit goal by c.27% as below
Analyst opinion
Although SJS’s result in 2010 was disappointing, we think the company will perform better in
2011 as the South An Khanh, the largest project in its portfolio, is approved for further
development and sale. In essence, the stock’s price has lost 38% from its average price in
2010, making it one of the top losers in the real estate sector so far.
At the current price VND 50,000 per share, SJS is trading at 7.6x earnings FY2011
(management forecast) or 6.0x (VCSC forecast). Our target NAV per share, which is
contributed 75% by the value of South An Khanh – calculated on a DCF basis for a horizon
of 10 years – comes at VND 56,000, implying 12% upside from the current price. The
reason we use a DCF valuation over 10 year for South An Khanh is because the company
does not have any intention of selling its land here in a short period of time, and therefore
the cost of capital over the years should be incorporated. Considering the NAV per share as
an intrinsic value, the reasonable PE 2011, and an optimistic prospect for the year, we think
SJS is a good trading opportunity thanks to its high beta and the fact that it has been
unloved over the past year. For longer term holding, we are concerned over the price bubble
of the property market in Ha Noi, and corporate governance issue of the company.
Highlight News :
Vietinbank Licensed to List 168.5M New Shares on HOSE
Vietnam Commercial Joint Stock Bank for Industry & Trade (CTG) or Vietinbank, has received
approval from the Hochiminh Stock Exchange (HOSE) to list an additional 168.58 million shares on
the bourse.
The additional listing will help the bank raise its total listed volume on the bourse to 332 million shares.
The shares were offered to IFC Capitalization (Equity) Fund, L.P (Equity Funds) and International
Finance Corporation (IFC) recently.
After the acquisition, IFC holds over 55.28 million shares, equal to 3.28% stake, while IFC
Capitalization Fund owns 113.29 million shares equal to 6.72% stake. It helped Vietinbank scale up its
registered capital to VND16.858 trillion.The lender had a surplus of VND1.854 trillion ($88.7 million)
from the sale.
In 2010, it netted a profit of VND48.41 billion ($2.3 million) on revenues of VND1.7 trillion compared to
VND8.13 billion and VND1.334 trillion in 2009, respectively. The full-year earnings per share was
VND3,765.
Vietnam Food Firm SAF Plans to Give Bonus Shares at 1-for-2 Ratio
Safoco Foodstuff JSC (SAF), listed on the Hanoi Stock Exchange (HNX), plans to give 1.52 million
bonus shares to shareholders at a 1-for-2 ratio this year.
The firm will seek shareholders’ approval for the plan, the firm said on its website.
SAF targets a net profit of VND13.5 billion ($640,000) compared to VND18.12 billion in 2010, and a
dividend payout equivalent to VND2,000/share.
VN-index Market value, units: VND bn HNX-index Market value, units: VND bn
FOREIGN NET ACTIVITY LAST 10 DAYS HOSE FOREIGN NET ACTIVITY LAST 10 DAYS HNX
Contacts
Head office Hanoi branch
67 Ham Nghi, District 1, HCMC 18 Ngo Quyen St, Hoan Kiem District, Hanoi
+84 8 3914 3588 +84 4 6262 6999
Research
Manager, Hoang Thi Hoa, ext 146 Senior Analyst, Vu Thanh Tu, ext 105
Senior Economist, Doan Thi Thu Hoai, ext 139 Senior Analyst, Ngo Phung Hiep, ext 130
Senior Analyst, Truong Vinh An, ext 143 Analyst, Hoang Huong Giang, ext 142
Senior Analyst, Dinh Thi Nhu Hoa, ext 140 Analyst, Nguyen Thi Ngoc Lan, ext 147
Senior Analyst, Pham Cam Tu, ext 120
Disclaimer
Copyright 2010 Viet Capital Securities Company. All rights reserved. This report has been prepared on the basis of
information believed to be reliable at the time of publication. VCSC makes no representation or warranty regarding
the completeness and accuracy of such information. Opinions, estimates and projection expressed in this report
represent the current views of the author at the date of publication only. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions
of VCSC and are subject to change without notice. This report is provided, for information purposes only, to
institutional investor and retail clients of VCSC, and does not constitute an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any
securities discussed herein in any jurisdiction. Investors must make their investment decisions based upon
independent advice subject to their particular financial situation and investment objectives. This report may not be
copied, reproduced, published or redistributed by any person for any purpose without the written permission of an
authorized representative of VCSC. Please cite sources when quoting.