Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adviser:
Louernie de Sales-Papa
Assistant Professor, Department of Environmental Engineering, University of the Philippines Diliman
Abstract: Climate change has greatly altered the environment and ecosystem like Artex Compound which has
remained under floodwater throughout the year. This paper addresses public health concerns in the consumption of
kangkong grown in the area and proposes propagation and market strategies. Based on the TDS (total dissolved
solids) calculated which is at 3000 to 4500 ppm, the floodwater at Artex was classified as brackish. Also, considering
the local activities, the floodwater was categorized under class SC of DAO 34. Water analysis has shown an increase
in parameters from December to March greatly due to an increase in ambient temperature which affects the rate of
chemical and biological activities. Water quality at different points within the compound also reflects the activities
done in the area and the characteristics of effluents discharged from sources located near these points. The
propagation experiments showed that the floodwater is suitable for kangkong propagation. In addition to this,
kangkong grown in this area turned out to be safe for consumption and do not impose adverse effect to human health
based on the metal toxicity analysis performed.
1
healthy under controlled conditions. The 2. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
bacteriological properties of the floodwater on the
other hand guide the community on proper way of In the past few years, there have been a lot of
cooking to ensure no bacteria are consumed. studies concerning about toxic metal contamination
This paper also helps the community gain of soil, aqueous waste streams and groundwater.
extra income by propagating kangkong in the One of the most commonly used method for dealing
recommended area. The income can be used as with heavy metal pollution in the biosphere is the
additional fund for the livelihood and other use of plants. The process is called
community activities. phytoremediation, where plants extract, sequester
and/or detoxify pollutants from the medium by
1.5 Scope and Limitations absorbing the metals into their system.
To simulate the situation in Artex, sample of Ipomoea aquatic, locally known as Kangkong
floodwater was taken to UP Diliman. Kangkong is an abundant green leafy vegetable in the
were grown under controlled conditions. Floodwater Philippines which grows in stagnant streams,
per set-up is only up to 20 liters and stagnant freshwater swamps, muddy fields, and pools. Other
condition was assumed. Propagation of Kangkong names for kangkong are aquatic morning glory,
reached 21 days. swamp cabbage, water spinach, potato vine, and
The AAS testing was done at InChem water convolvulus.
Laboratory. The metals are cadmium (Cd), A study on the heavy metal uptake of
chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), lead (Pb), and nickel kangkong was made by Serrano under the Institute
(Ni). of Chemistry at University of the Philippines
Financial analysis in the propagation of (2002). Results showed the behavior of metal
kangkong is from the initial set-up to one-year accumulation in the different plant parts – Cd: stems
propagation. Analysis is on average expected < leaves < roots; Pb: roots < stems < leaves; Cu:
output, not considering any unexpected leaves < stems < roots; Zn: roots < stems < leaves.
circumstances that will affect the propagation in the Moreover, the study showed that heavy metal
future. uptake of kangkong increases with increasing length
of treatment.
1.6 Conceptual Framework Another study on kangkong is made by
Marcussen et al. in Hanoi, Vietnam (2007). The
Site ocular inspection Artex officials & study aims to assess the concentrations of 38
residents elements in soil and kangkong cultivated under
Interview with officials
Brgy. Panghulo, different degrees of wastewater exposure. Results
Malabon officials
Field sampling at Artex showed that the uptake of elements in kangkong
depend greatly on the organic carbon content in the
Kangkong (Artex)
soil and not on the soil pH and the total element
In-situ sampling Floodwater collection collection concentration in the soil.
Moreover, Gothberg et al. (2004) studied the
- Color - pH - Heavy metals effect of nutrient levels on the uptake of heavy
- DO
- Turbidity
- BOD5
metals, especially mercury, cadmium, and lead, in
- Temperature
- Conductivity - TSS kangkong. It was established that metals accumulate
- TDS in plant tissues through absorption in the root
- Coliform
- Oil & grease system. The result of the study indicated that the
- Heavy metals lower the nutrient strength in the medium, the higher
Kangkong
the metal concentrations that accumulated in the
propagation Laboratory test different plant parts and vice versa.
The method employed in this experiment for
the heavy metal analysis is taken from the work of
Daily test Initial & final test
Pungor (1995) employing Flame Atomic Absorption
Spectroscopy Method.
- pH - pH - Kangkong number of
- Color - Color leaves
- Turbidity - Turbidity - Kangkong length of
- Temperature - Temperature stem
- Conductivity - Conductivity 3. METHODOLOGY
- Heavy metals
2
from the Standard Methods for the Examination of Table 1 Laboratory results for sample point 1
Water and Wastewater. Sample Point 1 (Inlet)
Parameter
In-situ testing was also done using 11 Dec 11 Jan 01 Mar
Time Collected 10:55 am 9:15am 9:56 am
conductivity meter and Hach colorimeter.
Floodwater depth, m 0.94 0.98 0.86
To prepare the kangkong for AAS, leaves were Temperature, °C 29.0 27.7 28.0
separated from the stems and roots then dried for Temperature (ambient), °C 31.5 29.5 33.0
Temperature rise, °C 0 -1.3 0.3
two hours. After drying, four grams each of ground Conductivity, µS 3.3 5.3 7.4
kangkong leaves and kangkong stems (roots Turbidity, NTU 1 3 19
included) were brought to char. Two milliliters Color, PCU 47 22 105
pH 7.00 6.61 8.16
(2mL) each of distilled water and concentrated nitric DO, mg/L 6.9 4.8 4.5
acid were added to the char and evaporated. After BOD5, mg/L - 15.6 12.0
cooling of the sample, 20mL of concentrated nitric TSS, mg/L 4.5 13 4.5
TDS, mg/L - 3220 4454
acid was again added to redissolve the kangkong Oil & grease, mg/L - - 52.6
residue. The solution was cooled to room Total Coliform, MPN/100mL 170x10 80x103 1600x102
temperature before filtering and then transferred to a Fecal Coliform, MPN/100mL - 80x103 220x102
After the analysis of data and results, strategies 11 Dec 11 Jan 01 Mar
Time Collected 11:07 am 9:46am 10:16 am
on how to propagate kangkong inside the compound Floodwater depth, m 1.05 0.90 0.93
was formulated along with its potential for Temperature, °C 27.4 27.9 27.2
Temperature (ambient), °C 28.1 28.5 33.0
marketability.
Temperature rise, °C 0 0.5 -0.7
Conductivity, µS 3.1 5.0 7.3
Turbidity, NTU 4 3 14
Color, PCU 60 35 177
pH 6.50 7.63 7.70
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION DO, mg/L 7.4 2.4 4.4
BOD5, mg/L - 29.4 22.8
TSS, mg/L 6 28 31
4.1 Wastewater Characterization TDS, mg/L - 3106 4414
There were three sampling dates at least Oil & grease, mg/L - - 44.8
one month apart. Within this period of sampling, Total Coliform, MPN/100mL - 1600x10 3 >1600x102
Fecal Coliform, MPN/100mL - 1600x10 3 >1600x102
seasonal changes have occurred, from rainy season
during the 1st sampling on December 11 to summer
on the last sampling on March 1. This change in The effects of hot climate are very evident in
weather conditions, aside from other factors, greatly the results. First, the water depth has decreased by 1
affected the results of the analysis. Some parameters m. This evaporation of the floodwater may cause
gave very different values for the three sampling pollutants to be more concentrated which is apparent
periods. There were also three points where samples in the increase of turbidity, TSS, TDS, conductivity
were taken- from the inlet, dumpsite, and residential and color during the sampling in March. This may
area. The in-situ and laboratory results are shown in also be due to the proliferation of algae during the
Tables 1 to 3. summer period as suggested by the green color of
filtered suspended solids.
For all the samples tested, the DO
concentration was observed to be lower during
summer, when the temperature of water is high
3
compared to the rainy season. At lower 4.3 Heavy Metal Analysis
temperatures, more oxygen is dissolved in water. pH The sample of kangkong plant from Artex has
also increased possibly due to the increase in Cr (1.154 mg/L on leaves, 1.382 mg/L on stems and
bathing frequency during summer period. roots), Cu (0.439 mg/L on leaves, 0.502 mg/L on
BOD5 and coliform were found to be highest stems and leaves), and Pb (7.018 mg/L on leaves).
at point 3, which is the residential area. A possible The high concentration of Pb in the leaves is
explanation to this is that some houses do not have because of the lead-laden dust in the environment
septic tanks and their drainage leads directly to the from air-borne gasoline emissions (Bassuk). Artex is
floodwater. a residential compound, even though the floodwater
The results also showed that the influent has has no heavy metals, the dust, sediments, smoke
the highest levels of oil & grease. Since a lot of from the vehicles stick to the leaves and stems of the
houses are situated near the flooded factory, effluent kangkong (see Figure 2).
from these residences is washed into the water
during storms.
Floodwater at the case study has a TDS value Table 6 Maximum estimated safe and adequate dietary intake of
of 3,000 to 4,500 ppm which falls on the category of an average adult for metal
brackish water. Maximum Estimated Safe
Several activities are observed at the site Metal
and Adequate Dietary
which are boating and fishing. Kangkong plants and Intake (ESADDI)
[mg/cap/day]
banana tree are even observed at some locations
Chromium 0.2a
inside the compound. Based on DAO 34, water Copper 2.2b
which serves its purpose for recreational (i.e. Lead 0.25c
boating) and fishing activities class II must be (a) The US National Research Council (Cabrera-Vique, 2004)
(b) International Programme on Chemical Safety (Copper)
classified under class C or SC. Thus, floodwater of (c) (Mount Isa Mines, 2007)
Level of Level of
Actual Actual
Concern Concern
5
5. CONCLUSION and eliminate the metal by normal biological
processes. In this case, a better recommendation is
With the current situation of Artex, the to limit the intake of kangkong to acceptable
residents have learned to cope with the environment. equivalent concentrations.
To make use of the resources naturally occurring at The metal readings in the kangkong leaves
the site, strategies to propagate kangkong was were due to the environment and not to adsorption
presented. Based on the TDS calculated at 3000 to from the floodwater. A noodle factory is located
4500 ppm, the floodwater was classified as brackish near the compound and further studies can be made
water and was categorized under class SC of DAO to determine if the air emissions of the factory have
34. significant effect in the metal adherence of the
During summer, the high temperature causes kangkong.
an increase in the rates of evaporation and chemical Lastly, if the strategies regarding kangkong
and biological activities. An increase in the values propagation was followed and implemented, the
of TDS, conductivity, turbidity and color was savings from the selling of kangkong can be used as
observed as pollutants were concentrated in the capital for other livelihood programs.
water. The DO levels measured in March were
lower as compared to the results in December. The
pH level was also observed to be higher during
summer, which can be explained by the increase in REFERENCES
human activities particularly bathing frequency.
Another apparent change is the greenish color of 1. Bassuk, N. (n.d.). Cornel University Website.
suspended solids which suggests proliferation of Retrieved March 17, 2010, from Lead in urban-
algae during summer. grown vegetables:
Oil and grease was found to be highest at the http://counties.cce.cornell.edu/schenectady/M
inlet, which could have come from residential and aster%20Gardener%20Website/projectdocs/fa
commercial establishments near the area whose ctsheets/vegetables/Lead%20in%20Urban%20
effluents were washed into the water and entered the grown%20veggies.pdf
Artex Compound. Fecal coliform counts and BOD5
2. Beuchat, L. R., Jaquette, C. B., & Mahon, B. E.
were highest at the residential site where some
(1996). Efficacy of Chlorine and Heat
houses have drains and sanitary pipes leading
directly to the floodwater. Treatment in Killing Salmonella stanley.
The propagation experiment suggests that the APPLIED AND ENVIRONMENTAL
floodwater is suitable for kangkong propagation. In MICROBIOLOGY .
addition to this, kangkong grown at Artex turned out 3. Cabrera-Vique, C. (2004). Chromium presence
to be safe for consumption based on the metal in foods and beverages: a review. FoodInfo
toxicity analysis. To reduce the metal concentration Online Features .
on kangkong leave and stem, washing with vinegar 4. Center for Watershed Protection, EPA, USDA,
solution (1%) or dilute dishwashing liquid (0.5%) USGS. (n.d.). Removing Pollutants from
should be done. On the other hand, salmonella and Stormwater. Retrieved March 18, 2010, from
E. coli can be eliminated thorough washing and Stormwater Authority:
cooking of kangkong at 60°C for at least 5 minutes. http://www.stormwaterauthority.org/pollutan
ts/default.aspx
5. Chromium and its compounds. (n.d.). Retrieved
6. RECOMMENDATION March 16, 2010, from
http://www.environment-
To fully characterize the floodwater, water
agency.gov.uk/business/topics/pollution/138.a
analysis should be done monthly or quarterly within
spx
a period of at least one year to determine the yearly
average values of these parameters. 6. Copper. (n.d.). Retrieved March 11, 2010, from
Since kangkong thrives in the floodwater, the International Programme on Chemical Safety:
conditions in these waters could be appropriate for http://www.inchem.org/documents/ehc/ehc/e
other aquatic plant species or for hydroponic hc200.htm
purposes. Aside from kangkong, some fishes can 7. Desalination. (n.d.). Retrieved March 24, 2010,
also survive in the floodwater. Since some residents from
eat these fishes, it is a good study to undertake http://www.tcn.zaq.ne.jp/membrane/english/
which will benefit the community. DesalE.htm
If the metal concentrations of the sample 8. Gothberg, A., Greger, M., Holm, K., &
exceed the level of concern, biological half-life of Bengtsson, B. (2004). Influence of Nutrient
the metal accumulation can be computed to Levels on Uptake and Effects of Mercury,
determine the time when the body can metabolize
6
Cadmium, and Lead in Water Spinach. Journal
of Environmental Qualitty , 1247-1255.
9. Guidance Document for Chromium in Shellfish.
(n.d.). Retrieved March 11, 2010, from United
States Food and Drug Administration:
http://www.pzpays.org/ref/03/02843
10. Interpreting Results from Additional Water
Tests. (2006, August 25). Retrieved March 18,
2010, from Alken Murray Corp.:
http://www.alken-murray.com/TESTS01.htm
11. Irwin, R. J. (1997, July 1). Environmental
Contaminants Encyclopedia: Oil & Grease
Entry. Retrieved March 18, 2010, from
http://www.nature.nps.gov/hazardssafety/toxi
c/oil&grea.pdf
12. Marcussen, H., Joergensen, K., Holm, P.,
Brocca, D., Simmons, R., & Dalsgaard, A.
(2007). Element Contents and Food Safety of
Water Spinach (Ipomoea aquatica Forssk.)
Cultivated with Wastewater in Hanoi, Vietnam.
Environ Monit Assess , 77-91.
13. Metcalf & Eddy Inc. (2003). Wastewater
Engineering: Treatment and Reuse. 4th ed.
New York: McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
14. Mount Isa Mines. (2007, November). Whole of
Emissions Study Phase 1 – Emissions to Land
Study of Lead in the Leichhardt River and
Surrounding Locations. Retrieved March 11,
2010, from
http://www.xstrata.com/assets/pdf/xcu_whole
_of_emissions_study_phase_1_20071128.pdf
15. New Hamphire Volunteer River Assessment
Program. (2008). Interpreting VRAP Water
Quality Monitoring Parameters. Retrieved
March 19, 2010, from NHDES:
http://des.nh.gov/organization/commissioner/
pip/publications/wd/documents/vrap_paramet
ers.pdf
16. Pungor, E. (1995). A Practical Guide to
Instrumental Analysis. USA: CRC Press, Inc.
17. Serrano, S. (2002). Heavy metal uptake of
Ipomoea aquatica forsk (Kangkong). Socio-
economic Development through Science and
Technology, (p. 20). Manila, Philippines.
18. The Indicators. (2008). Retrieved March 19,
2010, from World Monitoring Day:
http://www.worldwatermonitoringday.org/Do
cs/2008_Indicator_Fact_Sheet.pdf
19. Water Quality Parameters. (n.d.). Retrieved
March 19, 2010, from Earth Force:
http://www.eeweek.org/assets/files/Water%2
0Quality%20Testing/Water%20Quality%20Para
meters.pdf