2003

____________________________________________________________________
:

20523-3100

:Development Experience Clearinghouse
) (

).(PN-ACM-007

.
(703) 351-4039 :
)Experience Clearinghouse (DEC

Development

docorder@dec.cdie.org

 :

1998


.

.

.

.
:

. (1) :
) (2
) (3
.

Michael Miklaucic

(202) 712-1982 :
(202) 216-3231 :
mmiklaucic@usaid.gov



20523-3100 Washington DC

http://inside.usaid.gov/G/DG
. http://www.usaid.gov/democracy/
:

Gail Lecce



1979
.
) (
.
.
)(IFES



.
100
:
.
Sandra Coliver
)
1999 (2001
) (1998 1996
.
19

.
.

 Keith E. Henderson

" "
.
1993 1998 /
50 .

.2001

Louis Aucoin

.
William E. Davis
DPK Consulting
.
Inter-American
Development Bank

.

.
Guiseppe Di Federico

) (1981 )
(1992 ) .(1999
)(
)( .
)( Ecole Nationale de la Magistrature
)( Institut des Hautes Etudes sur la Justice
.
Stephen Golub

Boalt Hall .

 Ford Foundation
.
- Mira Gur-Arie

Federal Judicial Center
.
Linn Hammergen

.
.
Erik Jensen
Transnational Business Law
Program
.
Margaret Popkin
Due Process of Law

Foundation 1999

. ) 1985 (1993
.
Edwin Rekosh

1997 Ford Foundation
.

) 1992 .(1995

.
Russell Wheeler



.
Jennifer Widner
" " (W.W.
) Norton, 2000 .
_____________________________

)
(
.
-

Richard E. Messick Amb.
James Michel Tom Carothers John Blackton
.

) Paul A. Magnuson(
) Peter Messitte(
) Vicki Miles-LaGrange( Bohdan A.
Futey Marvin Garbis
)( Nan Shuker
Louise Williams Karen Hanchett
.

: John Lobsinger
John Blackton
)( Jamal Benomar
Doug Cassel
Peter Russell
" " )(2001 Joseph N. Onek
Joseph Jones
Carl Alexandre
Amy Young
.



Alexandra Braginski Gerry Donnelly
Patricia Liefert David Black Margaret Sarles
Neil Levine Don Muncy .Jan Stromsen
:


.

.






.

.

.



.

.

.
.
.


Sandy Coliver


11 ............................................................................
14 .......................................................................
:
14 .....................................................
(
14 ..............................................
(
15 .............................................................................
(
16 .......................................................................
(
17 .......................
:
17 ..............................................
(
20 ...............................
(
36 ..........................................
(
42 ....................................................................
(
46 ..................................
(
49 ............................................
(
50 ......................................................................
(
52 ....................................
:
52 ......
(

(
63 .....................................................................................
82 ....................................................
(
93 ...................................................
(
109 .......................
(
143 .......................
(
161 ...........................................
:
161 .....................................
(
170 ..............
(
178 ......................
(
( 189 ........................................................
202 ...................................
"":
"" : 214 ...........................................

10




.

.
26

.



.
""
.

.


.




.


. .

.
""
.


.

.

11




.



.



.

.

.
(1) :
) (2
.

.
.


.
""


.




.
.
""

.

12

 .


.
""

.
.
.




"" .

13

 ::
(

:

.




.


.
" "






.



.


"



" .

.

.







.


.


.
(

.
:

14

.


.

.

.


.






.



.


.

26

.




.



.





.

15


.
.
(

.

.

)

(
.
.


.




.



.


.

16

:
(

(
(

(
(
""





. ""



.
""


.
""

.






.


""

.
""


.





.
""


. ""

.
(

17



.
)



(


.


.




.





.


.




.



.

.

.

:


.

.



.




.









.

18




) .


(





.



.






.





.





.

.

.



.





.





.




.


)
(





.

19


.





.
(

. :




.

.



.

.

.

.
.
(1

20





.

.



.





.



.



1958


.

.




.

.

.




.

.


.
-

.

) ( .




.

.



.


.


%20 )
(

.



.

21



)
(




.





.
-

.


)
(
1
.


.

.




.

.





.



.



.



.






.



.

1 Margaret
Popkin
.

22



.



) (




.

)
( .

.

1995




.

:



1997



.




.







.



.



.
%32 %21
.







.

23

2
.



.




.




.


Louis Aucoin




.


.

.

.


1946


.





.




.



3
.

1883

.



.

2
" " " "

" " .

.

3 Margaret Popkin
Edwin
Rekosh
.

24





(1) : (2)
) (3 .



.



.

.


.





.




.




)
(
) .

.


(.



.






.
Margaret Popkin

.




.
Giuseppe Di Federico





.


" "


.
.


.
-

25


:



.






... .



:

(.
) (2 :






.

.


:

)(
) (


) (
.

4
.

) (1 :




:

) .

4 Giuseppe Di
Federico

.

26


.


.


.





.
) (3 :









5
.

5

.

1998


.



.

.



.

.

.







.




1994

27

.



.









.

.



.



.
) (4 :






.
6 Margaret Popkin

.

(2

)
(
.




.







) (

.
-

.

:





.

28

 .
)
(.


.

.






.
:



.






.


.






.

.


)
(.







.





7
.


.

:




.

.

.

7 Giuseppe Di
Federico
.

29









.




8




9
.



.






.

.





8 11
17
1999 "".
9 ""

.

.




.
-

:




.



.









.
Latimer House
Guidelines


.

30



)
(

.


.





.
(3

.


.

:
.





) .
" "

( .

.

.


) (


.


" "



.

. )
(

10
" ".


.






.

.

10 " Linn Hammergren

:
The Judicial Career in Latin

America: An Overview of the Theory and

) "Experience (1999
.

31








11


.

(1) :

) (2

) (3
"
".







.


.




11
Margaret Popkin 11 . 15
6

2000

E/CN.4/2000/61 1 61
.63

.

:








.




.


.
)

(

.
(4

:12

12 William Davis
Eric Jensen
.

32

 .



.


:


.



.


.


.
.





.

.


.



.

13 1939


.







.




.




.


.



.







.
13 Mira Gur-Arie
Russel Wheeler
.

33



.








" ".









.


.





.
-

:14

14 William Davis
Eric Jensen

.

.




.





.



.




.




.








.

34

 .



.


""





)



(

.



%1

%2
%8 .
%1.73 2000

%6



.%1.5

%1
.

:



.






.

.



.




.






.






.


.

35





.

.




.





.


.



.





.


.
-

.

.



.


.


.



.



.





.
(

.


.

36


.


:

)(
.
.1
-

.
.





.



.
)
(



.
.



.

.







.




.
.




.




.





.
-

37






.


.



.


:





.




.






.


.
-

.



.15



.16

.


.
-

.



.





.
-

15 Margaret Popkin

.
16 Jennifer Widner

.

38





.




.
-

:17

.



.

.








.




17 Edwin Rekosh

.

.






.




.


.




.

.

)
(



.



.


.

39

 .


.

.
.

.

.



.

.




.

.

)

(


.






.

.2

.3

.


.




.

.

.


.



.

.



.

40



.

" " .


.


.


.
.4

.




.
:




.

.

.




.



.




.18
)
(





.19

.


)
(
18 Eric Jensen

.
19 Vinod Thomas
) The Quality of Growth
(2000

http://www.worldbank.org/html/extdr/quality

41




.


.



.
.5

.

.
-1

.

.

:



.

)



(.



.

42



1998

1061

.

.



.






.

.



.20


.


20 William Davis
.

.


.



.


.

.

""


.



.


.









.

.

43



) (1
(2)
.
-2

.
.



.



.





.



.




.

.
) (1 (2)

.
-3

.

.
)
(
.





.

)
(
.

.

.


.

.

44

 .






.




.





.



.

) .





(.


:

.

.

.

.
)


(.


.

.
-4

.






.



.

45



.


.


.21







.


.



.

" "
.





.

21 Margaret Popkin

Stephen Golub
.

-5

.



.



.
(

.



: .

.


.





.
-1

46











.



.



.



.




.



.


1994




.

.

)
(
)
( .
:








.

.







.

.
-2

:22

22 William Davis
.

47


.


.

.





.




.


.
-

.





.
-

.
-

.



.



:

.




.


.



.
-

.
-3

48



.


:




.



.

-

.




.

.







.


.

.
-4

.






.
(

.



.23


23 Linn Hammergren

-
Mira Gur-Arie Russell Wheeler

Giuseppe Di Federico
.

49






.


.




.

.



.










.
(

.


.







.



.

.


.


.

.
:
.1

:




.

50

)( .

.2

.6
" ..." .








"
..."



.




.

.3




.
.4





.



.

.7






.

.5




) :(

51

 :
:
(

Jennifer

Widner


:


.

New York Times
Robert
Kaplan "
"Atlantic Monthly "
"


.



" "
" "
.




.






.

.

1996



.

.



%6
%8 .




%14

.%45





.






.

52



.




.




.
" "

.









.24
.1

.
24




.

" " .


.



.
" "


.





.






.





.

.

53


.

.

.
1962


.




.





.


.


.
(

"" .




.

)
( .



)

...( .


)
(

.




.



.




.


.

54


.
(

.

.

.







.



.
.
.2

.
" "


.


.




.



.


.


.
(

.

"
".




.

55


.




.




.



.





.


1998 1999

.
(

.


.

.


)
( .



" "
.
.





.

) (

.



.



.

56


.
"
" .




.





.



.




.






.

.


.



.

.


%1 .




.


)
(


.


.


.



.




.

57




.




.



.


.




.
(

.







)


(

.

.



.


.
.


.
" :



".


.
(

.

.



)

( .



.

58

 .



.






.







.
(

.


.





.

.

.




) (.



.




)
( .




.





.



.



.

59

.


" ".




.




.



.

.




.




.


.

.






.





""

.
(

.



.

.




.

48

60







.



.





.





.
(

.






.

.






.
.3

.





.



.





.





.

61




.







.


.


"
" .


.


.




.

62

Rekosh
.1

25

Edwin

.





.

.



25


:

.
" )("

Peter H. Solomon, Jr.
Todd S. Foglesong "
: "
) :Boulder Westview
(2000 " ".

Philip Webb
Natalya Scimeca
.

.


.




.

.







.






.
.2

.

.



-
.

63




.


.




.

.




.

.


) (
) (


.
.3

.





) .

(4 .



.
-

.


" ) ".
.(6 .








.
-

Ewa Letowska

"




.

".
) (

64



.
Jan Hrubala
"





) ". (
-

.


) .(7 .







.





.

) (


.

"
"



.




.



" "

) .
4-3 Gazeta Wyborcza (2000

Lech Walesa

) . (


1994




1996
) . (





.

65


1991


.

1991 1999



1994
) . (








.
-

Safulko
:




.



) . (

" " )
(
) . (





.

""



.



.

" Serhei Safulko " "

".

.4
-

.









.

66


.
) (













) . (

.
1995





) (
.






) . (



.

.








) . (



.



.


) . (






) .
(
-

67

 1997

) .

,Mark K. Dietrich

"

) :

(2000 8-7
(.
1998
1998
.2000

.







) . (


.

: 100

%75

.






.

.


.
47

) .
(

.


.


.



.




.
.5

68

 .



.




.






) . (




"
) ". (





) . (
-

. 1997
3600
.



4000 120) .

(
.





25
30 .
-

.






%75 ) . (




] .
Richard E. Mesick

:
) (1998

[.


.
-

69





.

.
"

) ". (8 .








.




) . (

.



.

)
(
1997 .


) . (

.6

)
( .

.
.


1989 .1992



.





) . (

1999

) . (



.





.

) . (

70





) . (




" "





" "

) .
(


)
(

.



.
) (






.


.2000

.



.

.
-

2000

"] [


) ".
( Jan
" Hrubala ] [

".


) (


) . (
Monica
Macovei




.


) . (

71

 Ewa Letowska



.

) .
(




)
( .



) . (

.


) ( .




.

2000


.

.




.

.
) .
(
.

.





.

.



) .
(

72


2000



1997

1998 .
) (


. 2000


. 1999
21

) . (

.
) (
1999

.



)

(
.




.

.

.7

:

.






.


) . (



) .
(






) . (
.8
-

73





2000 %27 1999

) . (







) . (
Jan Hrubala
"


...

) ". (


%36

%60
%38

%20
] . L.
Bojarski and J. Swaton
) :
(1999
" "[ .





.

.







.
) (39-37

1999
Vitaliy Boyko
:


""




... .





.

.
) Holos Ukrainy
24 (1999

.
) (

74



) . (


.

1997


.





) . (


.

) . (




.

.


.
)

(
) (.
) (

.
1997
) .
(



.


.

.






.
.9

.







.
) (

75






) . (



.

.
4000 120
.


.


) . (

.






.



.

.

.





.





.



.

Ecole de Magistrature



.

1996
.


2000

Soros

76


.

15 30
40

50.



500 .
.10

.








.






.

.








) .
11 .(20



.

178
179 1997

179
178 :
) (1

.
) (2

.
) (3


) .
2
1997
(.1997

77






1993




.
1994

) . (

.
1992
" ".
" "
"][



] ".
)(Zakon Ukrainy, ProStatus Sudddiv
11 12
Verkhovna Rada Decree -2863
15 12 1992
10 Holos Ukrainy 1992.
3 2 1993
[.

.

.




.

.



.

.

.

.11
:

)
(
.

.




.

.
) (

78






.


) . (
Jan Hrubala


) . (
Ewa Letowska





) .
(
.12
-

.

.


.

)
.

(
1997





) . (
Iustitia



.
Iustitia 1998
"
) ". (

.
-

.




.



) . (

79



.

) (

) . (





.






) . (





.


.





.


) . Bojorski
(and Swaton
.13

:
-

"
"

.

.
-

.


.


.
-

80







.





.

.
-

.



.
-

.



.



.
-

.






.

81

: Louis Aucoin
.1

"
40

.

".




.




.
.


.
Onseil

Superieur de la Magistrature



26
.
26

""

.
. 64

65

.


27.



.


28
.







.
27



.
1945


.


Delmas-Marty report

.
28
Delmas-Marty commission




.

82

 .



.







.



Jacques Chirac 1997

Elizabeth Guigou
29
.Marylise Lebranchu






.



.30

29 Marylise Lebranchu
Elizabeth Guigou
18 .2000
30
Conseil d' Etat

.2

1883
)
(
.

.


.

" "Sitting Judges
" "Standing Judge
.

.


1883
.


.1993
1946


.

14

)
(

) ...
(

83


)
(

.

1958

64

" ") .31
( .



.


1946

.65


.
)
(
.

1993



.

.
1993


tribunaux de grande
instance
.

.


.

1958



.




. 1993
31
1814 .58
1946 .84

64 1993
:

.

.

) (.

84

.


.



1994

.32
1993




1993


.

Statut de la Magistrature




.
65

.


.
32
5 1994 )
100/94 1 .(4

1993

.33

34

.
Antoine Garapon

cohabitation
.35



.



.

.




33

.



.
34 "
"


.
35 " "cohabitation


.
.1986

85



.


.

1993
.

1997



2000
.
.






) (

23
.









.

.

24

2000




.






.


.





.
.3

. 64

" ".




.
.

86


.






.


.








) .

(.


.

.



.



.

)
" ("detachment
.

.






.



.


.



.




.




.

.

.




.

87






.



.



)
( .baccalaureat



.Ecole Nationale de la Magistrature



... .

.



.


) .
(.

.



35

) .

(.





) .
(.


.


Ecole Nationale
De l'Administration
.

)
(.
"
"detachement judiciaire

.

.


.




.




.

88



.



.



.






.

44


.



.



) (
.
.4

.



.

.





.


.




.


.





.








.

.

.

89







.






.




.





.
-

.




:
:


.

.

.








.





.



.



.


.





.



.

90









.
:



.



.



.



.





.



.
:

.




.


.






.





.




.
:




.


.

91




.


.








.



.

92

.
36
) (

Giuseppe Di Federico
.1

)
(





.

36

.

.

:
www.irsig.bo.cnr.it

.


)
(
Consiglio
.Superiore della Magistratura



)
(.

.
" "
%92
.


)
(
37.
15

38
.
37


Consiglio di Stato


.
38


.

) :(

93

 :
(

"
"magistrate








39
.

.

)
(


.

) (
)(


.


.
39
" "magistrate
.
.

.
.2

1948

)

(
)
(
.



15 .



.

33
.

) 1959 11 (.



.



.



.
1959 1968

94


1968

.

)
(


)
.(1
.3

"
" .

40
.




.





.
""
.


40 G. Di Federico "
"
The Judicial Review
The Law Journal of Scottish

Universities 1976 .55-40

.


)
%20

(.

23 27

.

) .
200
(.
:




)
(
"" .



.








.
.4

95






.






.



.


.




.




. )
(

.


.
.5

)
(
.
:


.


) 40 35(
)
72(.




)

(.


) (.

) %1.18
(


.
)
"
"(


.


41
.

41

96


%55



.


)

( .



)(


""
.

1963 1973


)

( .






.





)
( .
)
( .

.




"
"


.







""
.

.




42.






28



%1 .
42

.

97



)

(
) .2500

(43.




.


) (.

)




(.
.6

43 6882


102 .
9109
) 10 (

.112




.

40 45
.






)
( .


.





.




.



40 45

.





.

98



.






.


.




ANMI .

.



) (

.
.7

.


.


)
( .

.

:
) (
.
12
1976


.
1996


27 ) 10 17
( .
.

)
(




.

)
Partito Social

.(Democratico

)
(136





)
248 .(2000

99

 )
918
( .


)
(.






)

( .



.


.




.

)
(
.


44
.
44 2000

Pierluigi Onorato

Marcello Dell'Utri

- .
)

(




.


45
.






.


)

.


.
45
Truman
Robert
Jackson

Harlan Stone



.

100

 (



.







.



"
".


) (






. :












.

" "


.




.46
.8

46



.
Oscar Luigi Scalfaro

Brunetto Bucciarelli Ducci

1946 1948
.


. 1973
" "

25 .


:
1993

.


.


.

101


1984







.




.





.
.9

6



.

) . 1998
130
(.


) :(

)(

.



.

:



.



.





.




.
" "




.
.10

.


.

102

 .
.

) :(
) (
.


.

.
)
(
130
)
(
)


( .





.

.




ANMI
.

.








.


.



:
.1


)
( .
)
(1


.
.2




.
.3

103


.
.4




.



.

.

.


.

48
.

)

(
.



.


.

:
.1





.



.

.



.
.11

47
.


47 )( C. Neal
) Tate and Torbjorn Vallinder (eds.
Global Expansion of
Judicial Power 1995

48

Lawrence M. Friedman
Total Justice
Russel Sage Foundation 1985
Kate Malleson
: The New Judiciary:
The Effects of Expansion and Activism
Dartmouth Publishing Co.
1999

104

 )
( .49

)
(

.

" "
.

)

(1
50
.
.2



.
.3






49 G. Di Federico
" The Italian Judicial
"Profession and its Bureaucratic Setting
The Judicial Review
The Law Journal of
1976 Scottish Universities 55-40
50
) 1997 "Truche
" (Commission

.
1985

.

.




.







.
.4


" "

)

(.


) 51
(



51

.

J.M.Shaman, S. Lubet, J.J.Alfini
Judicial Conduct and

Ethics 1995
.Michie Law Publisher, Charlottesville, VA

Ethical

Principles
for
Judges
www.cjc.ccm.gc.ca

105






.
.5


52
.
.6





.

.




.53


) (



.


.



.

. ""



.

.

.

52




) :(
) (


) (

.

53

Giuseppe Di Federico
"
: Prosecutorial
Independence and the Democratic
Requirement of Accountability in Italy:
Analysis of a Deviant Case in a
Comparative Perspective
1998 -371
.387

106







.

.







.









54.

54 -


.


Julia Fonda
: Public Prosecutors
and Discretion: A Comparative Study
1995

55.






)
(
56
.

55 .
(Commission de

) reflection sur la justice
1997
.

..." :


][
".
56
1993
) 2 .(1993



.

107

 :1 :

**

***

****

33

12

21

17

)
(

10

Tribunal
Supremo

Tribunal
Supremo

3 :
1

8 :
8

7 :

)(

20

12

* Consiglio Superiore della Magistratura

)(
.
** Conseil Superieur de la Magistrature

. .
*** Consejo General del Poder Judicial
**** .Conselho Superior da Magistradura
Conselho Superior do
Ministerio Publico

108

57
:
:
Popkin

Margaret

.58
57

.

) Victor Abramovich(
) Eduardo Rodreguez(
Juan Enrique Vargas
) Mauricio Duce(
) Fernando Cruz Castro
( Eduardo Jorge
Francisco
Prats
Alvarez Valdez Felix Olivares
Victor Jose

) Castellanos (
Francisco Diaz Rodreguez
Carlos Rafael Urquilla
)( Yolanda Perez
) Eleazar Lopez(
) Jesus Martinez(
) Jorge Molina Mendoza(
) Jorge Bogarin( .

.2000
58 .1983
1982
.
Augusto Pinochet


.

.



.



.
-

.


.




.
.

.
36 1996
.
1992 12
.
21 1989 .
Alfredo

Stroessner 35
.1989

109


59
" 1998 ".




.
) "
"(





.



"
".


1975


"

".

"



Victor Jose
59
Castellanos
2000
5 . ILANUD
.

".






.

"





.








.



".

.



.

110




.


1973
Selvador Allande

%10
60.




.

.



Augusto Pinochet


.




.
Eduardo Frei




.
60 Juan Enrique Vargas
Mauricio Duce

20002 .

61
.
-

.


.

.

.





.


1989





.

"


61

Vargas and Duce7 .

111


62"...


.


1999





.

""
"
" "
63".
2001
.





.


62 Francisco Diaz
Carlos
Rodriguez
Rafael Uriguilla
2000.
.2
63
Param Coomarasawamy

31 1999 :
6 E/CN.4/2000/61/Add.1
2000 .142

.


.




.

.
.


.
Jorge Bogarin




.



.



64
.


" .

.



64 Jorge Bogarin

.2000

112


65
".





.




.



.




.



.


.





65 Eduardo Jorge Prats
Fransisco Alvarez

Valdez Felix Olivares

2000.6 .

.



.




.







.

.
.2

.



.
-

113



.


.




] . 2

3


[.


.



.


.





.


.

.

66
.




67
.1991

) (1999
.


) (.



.



.
:



.

. Jorge
Bogarin
.

66 INECIP
Asociacionismo e Independencia Judicial
)en Centroamerica (Guatemala, 2001
.54-53
67
1983
.1989

.1999

114


.







.



.







.


.



.

.
-

.


.







.

.


.
Linn Hammergren
"

68
".


" "
.




.


Farabundo
68 " Linn Hammergren
:
The Judicial Career in Latin

America: An Overview of Theory and

) "Experience LCSPR (1999

.

115

-Marti National Liberation Front

.




.







) (
.
1994

.
.





.
) 1994
(

.




.




.

.
Varagas
Duce

21







.



.

75.



1997



1994



.



.

116

 .
1997 )
(
69.





.



.
"





".

.




.

Carlos Menem



.
" "
69




.

70
.

:

.

) (2001





.




1999
71.



26
13 .

. 1999



1996

70 Victor Abramovich

20002 .
71
7 63-61

117

72

.

73.



.

.



.





.



.

72 Gabriela
Independencia y Judith Vazquez Smerilli
Carrera Judicial en Guatemala, Ideas y
documentos para la democratizacion del
Sistema de Justicis (Guatemala: Instituto
de Estudios Comparados en Ciencias
) Penales, 2000 .46-43
73
1999


1999

:
:

.






)
( .






.




.




.





.

118



.




.




.
.


.






.


.


.
1994




.
.

.



.


Vargas
Duce



.


.





74
.


1999





.




75
.
74 Vargas Duce8 .
75 Yolanda Perez
Fundacion
Myrna

Mac/Programa de Investigacion y Analisis.

"Informe sobre el Grado de Cumplimiento
de las Recomendaciones del Relator

119




.

2000

2001
454

.

.







.



.






.

.


.
sobre Independencia de Jueces y
") Abogados, (2001
.

.


.

" ".

" .




76".
41
.


.


200

77. 2000
%50
78
.





.

76 V. Abramovich8 .
77 Linn Hammergren
The
Judicial Career in Latin America10 .
78 Eduardo Rodriguez
Veltze
2000

120






.


.
.



" "
.


. Fransisco
Diaz
79
.


.

)
( .

500 .




.
3000

.

79

Diaz Urquilla7-6 .

.

.





.




.


80
.





81
.




.



.
"
80 Jesus Martinez

20006 .
Asociacionismo e
81 INECIP
Independencia Judicial en Centroamerica
34 .

121



82
".




. 2000



83.


. 1999
%50
84.
2001

.
.





82 Jorge Molina Mendoza

20003 .
83 Fernando Cruz
Castro
2000
84 Fransisco
"Resumen sobre Javier Dall'Anese Ruiz
la
Independencia
Judicial
" Centroamericana,
Libro Blanco Patricia Frances Baima
sobre la Independencia del Poder Judicial
y la Eficiacia de la Administracion de
) ,Justicia en Centroamerica
(2000 27 .

.


.


85.




86
60
65

70
75.




.
.


)
(

.

85 208
86 1998


" ".
Prats Alvarez Olivares
3 .

122







87.

.


.



.


.





.





.





87 Dall'Anese
Ruiz, "Resumen sobre la Independencia
in Libro
"Judicial Centroamericana,
Blanco26 .

.




.
.3

.


.


.


.





.
.


.

123

 .





.

.
-

.


.
)(

) (
) (
.



.



.
-

.


88.


.


.



) (


.



.



.

Eduardo Rodriguez





88
19
35 1986

Coomaraswamy 99

124


.




.






.




89.



.
-

.



.

89 Prants Alvarez
Olivares16 .

.



.

.



.



.

) (2000-1999




2000 77 12
108
90
.





.

90

Abramovich7 .

125


91
.






.


.


.



%95



.




.
.



.




.
91
13 Abramovich .2000

V.

.


92
.

93.


) (


.


.




.
-

.

.

22



92
93

Vargas Duce11 .
Hammergren31 .

126


.
Fernando Cruz

.







.

" "

.

.



.
.4

.

.




.

.




.


)(procurador de la administracion
.




.




.




.


)
(

. Vargas
Duce





94
.

94

Vargas Duce27 .

127








.


.




.





.


)
(


.

)
(.


)

(

.








.
.5

.



.

" Jesus Martinez






.


95
".

95

Jesus Martinez-16 .

17

128

.

.




.


.








.





.


.






.

.



... .


.

96
.





.

.



)
( .

.
:



.
-

96
Centro de Estudios de Justicia de las
Americas
)(CEJA
"Crisis
en
la
capacitacion
"?judicial
Sistemas
Judiciales, Ano, No. 1

129


) (


.


"
",

97
.




.
-

.


.





.


)

(
)
Alberto Fujimori
97

Coomaraswamy

153

( .

98
.
2000
Fujimori
.

99
.


.


.





.

.



.



98
48 2000 166.11
Walter Humberto

) Vasquez Vejarano( 13 2000
Corte Interamericana de Derechos
Humanos, Serie C: Resoluciones y
Sentencias, no. 71, Caso del Tribunal
Constitucional, sentencia de 31 de enero
de 2001.
99 Consejo Transitorio del
1 Poder Judicial .2001

130

 .


.


.







.
.6

.



.

.
-

%50
.


100.
100
2000 645.500.000
%1.31 .

Patricio Aylwin

45
1990 75
101.1997
.

%6


.

%6
101.628.701
.2000
%6


.1999

%2
. 1999
%4 .

Public Ministry
%2
.


.
%3
.
Public
147.700.000
) Ministry
(.
101
%0.59 1990
%0.83 .1997

131



. Vargas
Duce





.


.





.








.
%50
%1.47
.

" " %3

"" ""




.

21 .

.

.

.


%30



.





.

) (

.

.

.




.

132

 .




.

.
-

1996
%275 %400


.



) .

(.
%75
.


15 20.


.




.

.
1995




102
.
.7

.




.

.




.




.


. "

102 10.000
2.500
1.500 .

133






103
".





.

""


.


.




104
.








.
)
(
.

103
104

Diaz Urquilla15 .
Vargas Duce22 .

.





.


.




.

.





.



.


105.



.

105

23 .

134




Xaman
.
Candido Noriega
.


106
.





.
Sidney Blanco



107
.
.8

106 Yolando Perez
Eleazar Lopez
2000.
17
107 Blanco
.
Due Process of
Law Foundation Fundacion Esquel,
Implementando el Nuevo Proceso Penal
en Ecuador: Cambios y Retos79 .
) (2001

.

.








.


.




)

(

.
-

.




. 1990

135

 ) (FINJUS


.

FINJUS 1990
1994

.
1994


.






.

1997


.


.


" "


108.

108
Rodolfo Pizo Escalante
Cesar
Luis Salas
Edmundo
Barrientos
Orellana .Eduardo Gauggel

.
FINJUS





.



FINJUS



.




.


.


.


.



109
.

Fundacion Myrna Mack/Programa de 109

Investigacion y Analisis, "Informe sobre el
grado
de
cumplimiento
de
las
recomendacions
del
relator
sobre
"independencia de jueces y abogados,

136



.




.

Poder
Ciudadano




.






.



.

)
(.




.



.





.

:









.


.
.1 .
32 11
.




.

.
-

137





.

)



(




.



.

.

.

.



.


.






.
-

.

.






.




.

.

desacato


.

El Libro Negro de la Justicia


.


.

138


110
.
desacato


.

.




.




.

" "
.

",
.
-

.





.

.
-

.



2000 "
110

Vargas Duce29 .

139

 :2 :
*

140

19:
4 8
4)
2 2
( 4

1
1

5:
4

5:
4 1

)(

7:





6:
3 1
1

Public Ministry
5:

8:
1 1
1
2 1

1 .

:3

141

2001
45 .
.2002

)(

)

(

26

13

142

:
:
: Mira Gur-
Russell
Arie
111
Wheeler
.1

Alexander Hamilton

"
"
" " "
] [
) . The
:Federalist (78
" "


.


.

Madison

James

111

.
John Cooke
Paul Magnuson Peter Messitte
Peter MacCabe
Fern Smith Sylvan Sobel
.

"

) ". :The Federalist
37 .(39 ""





.



.


900
800
28000
112. 53

.






.

112

.



.



" ".

143







.



.

.



.
.2
-

) 113

65 70 .(114







.



) :1996 Posner
.(31-21

115

:
113

) (1776
"


".
Blackstone

" " "
) ".
.(9-8 :1988 Wheeler

) (1787 "
"
"
" "

".

" "

.
" "


.
114 65
80
) (


28 U.S.C.
371
115
2000 141300
149900
173600.

%10 . 1999

31908 ) .(2000

144




.




)
.(1999




%3
: 900

) .Rhode Island

) :1995 Rottman
(.
4 .(6

800


14 8 ) 28
).(U.S.C. 152(a)(1) & 631(a





15

.

) :1999
25 (2

116
.




.






117
.





.


.
-

.
1789 1939
116 Rottman
4 .8
8
7.8 .


.
117
)
(718 :1999 Hensler

145



.




)

(
.






.


.
1939






] .

26

118
).[(28 U.S.C. 331
118 13

12
.


.

1940

.


.
:
.






.





.
) Fish
23-122 :1973 :1975 Baar
( "



" ) .(738 :1939 Shafroth



.

.

146



.




.





1995


119
.
.


.






.

.


.
.


.

119 28 U.S.C.
1915 and 2254

.





.
1967



.




.








.
.3

1989

)
(
(5 U.S.C.
%15

147

) . 501-505





.

)
(
.

) (28 U.S.C. 455


) "
28 ",
) U.S.C. 455(a)(4) & (d)(4
((.



.





.







.
.4

.



.
.




.








.
.
"


]
[


" )
( 120.
120

.
900 1700 )

148





.




)
(
)

( .
%90



) %73 (Carter
) %56 ) (Clinton
:1999 Slotnik
Goldman
.(280

. 1950


" " .


.




.

( .


" "
.

.




.


.
Carp Rowland
57

Woodrow Wilson
William Clinton

""


121
.





.



121





"" %48 %39
) Carp
(1998 Stidham

149



.

.
Chief
:1996) Justice William Rehnquist
(16 "



) 122".


(.

1789
3000

.

.

Theodore Roosevelt
Oliver Wendell Holmes
"
...
Holmes

" ) .(307 :1993 White
Richard

Nixon Clinton


" "
)
(1974
122

.

) .(1997





.

) :1999 Klerman
.(456 %36
253
2000
123


.

.


124



) U.S. Sentencing Commission
Sisk Heise Morris

.(93-1487 27-1423 :1998

123 1 2000
" "
.
52) 158 .(%32

.
124
"
"

) (81 :1996

150





"


" ) Klerman
.(456 :1999
.






) "
"( .
" "

"" ""
.



) 4
:1995) Rottman ((.
.





.


.

.

.

.




.
Chief
Justice Rose Bird
Penny White )
(
David Lanphier
)


( )
.(52-49 :1999
125


. Pinello







) .(131-130 :1995 Pinello


.

125
http://www.ajs.org/cji/fire.html
.

151

 *
:4
:

***

**

14

**

**

13

17

12

) (

) (

15

10

)
(

) (

15

.
* ) 1995 Rottman
5.(7
**


.
***
.

) Aspin
(306 :1994 Hall

645



.

152





.

)
.(332 :1999 Burbank
Aspin Hall




) .
%60

%5
).(13-312







Eisenstein
)
(2000



.
1997

722.720
)
(13 :2000 Eisenstein
.

) Cheek
) .(23 :2000 Champagne


2000


[The
4 TelegramFort Worth Star
126
.[2000



Aspin Hall


18 645

) .(306


.




17 35 )
Nicholson :1994 Nicholson
.(297


.

126
" %83


"
9 Houston Chronicle 2000

153



15


" "
) .
.(2000

.




:
.
.

" "



) (
.


" :
" )
( .

1804



) .(114 :1992 Rehnquist




)
( .

127


.





U.S. Virgin Islands

) :2001-2000
.(5.23



.


.

.


.


"


127 1997

" "


Thomas Delay
"

" )
.(16 :1997

154

 " ]) .[28 U.S.C. 372(c)(1

800 1999

"
" 128
.




) McBryde
.(1999

%90
)

.(1 :1999




)
.(1975 Battisti
) (

1980 1991

) Barr
.(80-177 :1993 Willging
.

128 406
826
30 1999
300

420
) .416
) (.
(81-80 :1999

.





.



Optimal
Utilization of Judicial Resources
) .(2000
.






)

(
.

)
(
.



)
( .


.

155


1990





)
( ) .(28 U.S.C. 476


.





30

"
"

"
"
30
)
.

(.
.5

.




. Stephen

Breyer )" (1998

,
".


1996 %84
" "

) Lou Harris
.(1996 & Assoc.



" "


) Toruella
.(975 :1996 Mihm





.




.





.

156




.



Gullop 1998
) %78
(
) 8 Gallup
.(1999




.





.

Annual Report of the Director

Judicial business of
) .United States Courts


(.1940
)
(2000
Optimal Utilization of Judicial
Resources

Report on the Commission on
Separation of Powers and Judicial
(1997) Independence

)" (1996
What is Judicial

?) "Independence
(1996
80 73

American Judicature

Society 1999
Larry T. Aspin
" (1994) William K. Hall
Retention

77 "Elections and Judicial Behavior
306
(1975) Carl Baar
:
Separate but Subservient: Court
Budgeting in the American States
) (Lexington Books
Jeffrey N. Barr
" (1993) Thomas E. Willging


1980
Decentralized
Self-Regulation,
Accountability,
and
Judicial
Independence under the Federal
Judicial Conduct and Disability Act
142 U. Pa. L. Rev. 25 "of 1980

157

James Eisenstein
( " 2000)
Financing Pennsylvania's

84 "Supreme Court Candidates

Judicature 10 (2000)

( "1975) Frank Battisti

An
Independent Judiciary or an
25 Case W. "Evanescent Dream?
L. Rev. 711

1978

.

Gordon Bermant
( "1995) Russell Wheeler
:
Federal Judges and the
Judicial
Branch:
Their
"Independence and Accountability
46 Mercer L. Rev. 835

Peter Graham Fish

The (1973)
Politics
of
Federal
Judicial

)
Administration
(Princeton
"Fort Worth Star-Telegram

"State Sued Over Judicial Elections
at 1 2000 4
Sheldon Goldman
(1999) Eliot Slotnick
"
82 "Clinton's Secon Term Judiciary
Judicature 264
Deborah Hensler
" (1999)
Do We Need
an Empirical Research Agenda on
72 S. Cal. "Judicial Independence?
L. Rev. 707
(1999) Daniel Klerman

"
Nonpromotion
and
Judicial
72 U.S. Cal. L. "Independence
Rev.455

158

(1998) Stephen G. Breyer

"
:
Bulwarks of the

Republic: Judicial Independence
and Accountability in the American
" System of Justice
61
61 Law & Comtemporary 3
Problems 3
Stephen B. Burbank
The
( " 1999)
Architecture
of
Judicial
72 S.Cal.L.Rev.315 "Independence
Kyle Cheek
( "2000) Anthony Champagne

84 Judicature 20 "1998 1980
Robert Carp
( 1998) Robert Stidham
Judicial Process in
) America
(

 " Legal Times

Growing

"Concerns over Judicial Elections
27 at 18 2000
Lou Harris & Assoc.
) (1996


http://www.abanet.org/media/augus
t96/graphs.html
)" (2000

Call to Action, Statement
of the National Summit on
"Improving Judicial Selection
) www.ncsc.dni.us
(9/10/01
" New York Times

A Spirited Campaign for Ohio
"Court Puts Judges on New Terrain
2 at A11 2000
Marlene Nicholson
Norman Nicholson
)" (1994
Funding Judicial Campains
77 Judicature 294 "in Illinois
(1995) Daniel R. Pinello

: The
Impact of Judicial Selection
Method on State-Supreme-Court
Policy:
Innovation,
Reaction,
) Atrophy Greenwood
(Press

Richart A. Posner
) (1996 :
The Federal Courts: Challenge and
) "Reform Harvard
(University Press
William H. Rehnquist
) (1999
15 2000
http://supremecourtus.gov/publicinf
o/speeches/sp_05-15-00.html
William H. Rehnquist
) (1996
) (
:
9 1996
William H. Rehnquist
) (1992 :

Grand
) (
Inquests:
The
Historic
Impeachments of Justice Samuel
Chase and President Andrew
)Johnson (William Morrow and Co.

) (1999 " Clay Robison

No Easy Way to Change Judicial
"Selection Houston
9 Chronicle .2000
Daid B. Rottman
Carol Flango R.
(1995) Shedien Lockley
) 1993
(

159

 " Will Shafroth

New

Machinery
for
Effective
"Administration of Federal Court
25 American
(1939) Bar Association Journal 738
Gregory C. Sisk
Michael Heise
" (1998) Andrew Morriss
:
Charting the

Influence on the Judicial Mind: An
Empirical
Study
of
Judicial
73 N.Y.U.L.Rev. 1377 "Reasoning
Juan Torruella
"
(1996) Michael Mihm
"foreword
40 St. Louis U. L. Rev. 969
The Book of States
.2001-2000
The Gallup Organization
) 8 (1999
Public Trust in Federal
Governemnt Remains High

http://www.gallup.com/poll/releases
/pr990108.asp

)" (1997
Judicial

"Misconduct and Discipline

15 1997
(1988) Russell Wheeler
:
Judicial Administration: its Relation
) "to Judicial Independence
(
(1993) Edward White
Justice Oliver
) Wendell Holmes (

520 Clinton v. Jones

(1997) U.S. 681

McBryde v. Committee
to Review Circuit Council Diability
(1999) 83 F. Supp.2d 135 Orders
U.S.
(1974) 418 U.S 683 v. Nixon

48 F.Supp 2d 52 Williams v. U.S.
)(1999

)(2000
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
" 1
Covered Employment and Wages

http://stats.bis.gov/nes.release/ann
pay.nws.htm 8
2000

160

 :
:
(

:
:
Linn Hammergren
.1

.





,


.




129







129

.

.
)
(





.




.



.


.


.




:


.



.

161


.


.



.








.
.


.



.




.



.


.

.2

:


.



.



.

)
(



.

)
(
)


(

.







.

162



.


.



.




"
" .




) (



.





.



.


.

130.




.
131
.

:
132.

)
( .


.
.3

130


.
Malleson
.
131
""
.

.
132 Konner



.

.

163


.



.
:






.

.



.




.




.


.



.

.




.


.



133.

134
.
.4

.

:

.
133
) Klitgaard = + (.

Weberian command bureaucracy
" "
) ( .
134



.

164






.
-

.


.


.


.





.
135

.
""



.


135
)
(

.

)

( .

.



.

:
)

(

.


)
(
.



.




.


.




.

.

165

.




.






.


136.


.





.
136

.
)
( )

(

.

.





.




.



137
.



.



)


( .



.

137


.

166



.
.5

.


.



.
-

.
)

(






.


) (

138.




.


.
-

.


.


.


.



)
(
.


138

" "prevaricato



.

167


.








.
-

139.







) (

.



139


)" "(
.

.


.
)


(



.




.



.



.
-

.





.

168


.




.


.
-

.


.
)
(

.


.




.





""


.

.6

.




.


.




.

)

(
""
.

Robert Klitgaard
Controlling

Corruption :
1990
kate Malleson
:
The New Judiciary: The Effects of
Expansion and Activism
: 1999

169

:
:
Davis

.1

140

William

.



.
Alexander
Hamilton Federalist
Papers




.


)(
)(

)(

)(


140 DPK
Consulting 1993


.
William E. Davis Robert W.
Page Jr.
.

.
.
.2

.

:

)(
)(
.




.



.



.

.




.

170


.


.







.





.

.



.

.

.





.



.

.
.3

.


.




)(
) (
) (


.






.




.

.

171






)
(
.






.






.


.

.

.

.



.



.


.

.
:

.

.

.4

172

.
-

.





.

.



.

.





.


.

.


.
-

.



.


.



.


.

173



.




.
.5

.


.
-

.

.


.


.




.


.
""
.

.
-

.


.


.




.


.


.




.

.



.

174



.

.


.



.





.

.


.

.



.




:

)
(

)
(
)
(


:

.


.
-

.




.

175

Warren Burger




.



.

.





.

.

.


.



.


.


%50
.

.6

.


.
%6



%2.5 .

176




.





.


.




.

.
.

.


.


.

.


.





.
.7

177

:141
: Stephen Golub

.
Justice

William Rehnquist
.142




. .143

.1

.






.
.2

141
USAID
Individual Project Fellowship

Program Open
Society Institute
Ford
and Asia Foundations
Asian Development Bank
USAID
International Human Rights Law
.Group
142
Samuel F. Harahan Waleed H.
Malik :
Partnerships for Reform: Civil
Society and the Administration of Justice
) : (2000.1 .
143 :
Helping Countries Combat

Corruption: The Role of the World Bank
) : (1997 -44
.45
.

Chief Justice William
Rehnquist

.

1994
Blair Hansen

Weighing in on the
Scales of Justice

"
144".
144 Blair Hansen
:

178

147
.

Blair Hansen

.
Harahan Malik
.145

"

)

( .

148".





.





.

.


) (

.




" "

146.

Weighing in on the
Scales of Justice: Strategic Approaches
for Donor-supported Rule of Law
Programs 7
) :
(1994.51 .
145 Harahan Malik .
146 " John Blackton "
.2000

.






.


147 " Hector Soliman
" 2000
148 5 .

179



.


.




.

.



.
.3

.






.






.


.

.
.
-

:
:

Center for
Social Justice

Gujarat
.

.

.



.
) dalits

""( .

:


.


"
.
"

.

180


149
.

150
".

.

.

.





.



.

.

.

dalit
)(
.Gujarat

.









.
"
149 Robert S. Moog
:
Whose
Interests
are
Supreme:
Organizational Politics in the Civil Courts
of India
) 54 Ann Arbor :
.(1997

.

.




.




.

150 John Blackton
4 .

181



.
-

:
:

.

.



Khmer Rouge



.

Human Rights Task Force




.






.





.

.

)

(

.





.



Marcos

.








.



.

182


.



.



)
(.




.




.
Law Group






)

(



.





.

151
%40

.

.



.




.


.
-

:
:

.

Philippine
Center for Investigative Journalism

.


.


151 7 The Economist
2000 .107

183

 .



.






.



.


.







.



.





.


alternative law groups

.



.









.




.



.

.

.






)


(

184

 .


.



.

"
" .
Makati Business Club
1991


.



.





.

152.




.
152 Mahar
Mangahas
Monitoring the State of the
Judiciary and the Legal Profession
Social Weather

Stations
Cordillera Studies Center
) : (1996

.



.




.
-

: :

.
Ain O Salish Kendra

Madaripur Legal Aid Association

1992
.

.







.


.

185

 .
1996



.

" "




.
Rozan AGHS
AGHS Legal Aid Cell

.


.


.

.



.


.

.





""

.






.

186

.



.










.
.4

:








.

.



.

:

.



-

.



.

187



.


.



.


.





.



.





.

.

188

:

:
: Eric Jensen153

.1

.
"


" .


.

:
1-1

2-1

3-1

153

.
Tom Heller
Stanford Law School

.

.


.





.






.

.




.


.



.
.
" Sir Isaiah Berlin

154".
154 Isaiah Berlin
: The Crooked
Timber of Humanity: Chapters in the
) History of Ideas (1991 :Knopf

189



.
.
.2

155.

" ".

155
:
.
.
.
.

.

.
.




.

.


.

.
.

.

.


.
.

.


.

.



.


.

:



-

:
.


:



.

190

 156
) (

.

.

.4

.5

.



.

.





:



157

.
:
.1

.2 )
(
.3
) (
156 " "
.

.
157


.

.6

.7


.8

.9

.10

" " 158



.


158

Mark K. Dietrich
:
Legal and Judicial
Reform in Central Europe and the Former
Soviet Union: Voices from Five Countries
) (2000 :6 .

191

 .


.



.1999


)
(



"" .


.




.
.


.




.

.
:
.

.

)

( .






.


AC Nielsen
.




159
.
-

""
"
".




) (
.




.




159
.

192

 .

)

( .




.


" "
.
:



"" :

%1

%2
%8 .

.



.
:
.

) (1 )(2

.


.

.




160



.


161.


.



162.



160
.


.



.1939
161


.
162

: .


.

193


.









.

.


163.







.




.


"".
:
"" .

163




.

:



.
: .





.


164.
.


" "


.


.


:

)( .
.1995
:


164

.


. " :
" " ".

194

 " "

165
.
166
%1 %4 .
.



.


.



.

(1) : )(2

) (3

) (4

.


.
14
1992

165

.


.
166 %6
%3 %3
.

.

) (

.
.
.


.

167.


.

.


.




.



.
-

167 Vinod
Tomas" :
" Quality of Growth
) : (2000

www.worldbank.org/html/extpb/qualitygrowth.htm

195

 ""
"" .


.



168
.



.






.

"" "" .

.

168
" Erik Jensen

:

Meaningful Participation or
Deliberative Deception: Realities and
Dilemmas in Legitimating Legal and
Judicial
Reform
Projects
Through
",Consultative Processes
) 4 :
(1999

169
.
.3

.




.



.


169
1997
"
"
"
".
(1) :
""
) (2

.
)(1999
Veronica S. MacBeth :
Symposium: Judicial

62 Alb.L.Rev.1379 Outreach Initiatives
) .(1999
:
"

196

.4

.








.
.



.


.



.



.
:
)
( "
"

170
.
170



.

.

)(
.
)(
) (



)

(
.
)
(
" " .


Rick Messick
Albert Hirschman
)
( " "
171
.
-

.


.
171 " Richard Messick
:
Judicial
Reform
and
Economic
"Development: A Survey of Issues
World Bank Research
Observer 14 .(1999) 1

197




.



. 1992

1997


172.




Mancur Olson
" "


" 173".
172
Global

Development Finance
World Bank Debtor Reporting

) System (1998 :
Theodore Moran

174
" "
.



.



.



.


)
(
.




175
.

FDI
and Development: The New Policy
Agenda for Developing Countries and
) Economies in Transition
:Institute for International Economics
.(1998




1997


.
173 Mancur Olson
:

Power and Prosperity: Outgrowing

Communist and Capitalist Dictatorships
) .(2000 :Basic Books


:
.
174 Amanda
Perry ]
Jensen 23 :Perry [.2000
175

.

198

.
""
.


.




176.



.










.




.
176

.
Dietrich supra 18 .
.

6
7 ) 35

(
.

177
14
forum

deaerah ) Fordas
(.
Fordas
1000 .




.

Fordas




.

.





.
177
Private Enterprise Policy
) Reform Program (PEPR

Policy Reform for

)increased SME Growth Program (PRISM
1999
.

199



.






.


.



.




.



.


.
.5

.
" :"
"" " " .

.
.

.


- -
.
:
... 178

.






.
.



.




.
178
" John Ferejohn
:
Independent
Judges,
Dependent
Judiciary:
Explaining
Judicial
72 So.Cal. L. Rev. 353 "Independence
) :(1999

".

.

200


.
)


(.
.



.

.

179.

.

)
(
.







.


.
:

.

.




.








Machiavelli Weber
Durkheim .Marx



.

.

179




.


.

201

 "" : :
"
".
.
.a

.

(1

10 10 1948
217 ).(3

(1)14 16 1966
2200) GAOR 21 (21 ) (16 52
171 UNTS 999 (1966) 6316/ 23 .1976

(2

)(1999

1998 .98/02/30 POL :

)(2000

.2000
)(1985

26 6 1985 32/40

202

 29 1985 146/40 13 UN GAOR 1985

53 .(1985) 53/40/
)(1989

26 6 1985
32/40 29 1985 146/40 13 1985
1988
ECOSOC 60/1989 24 .1989
)(1990

27 7 .1990
)(1990

27 7 .1990
)(1994
"
: "

E/CN.a/Sub.2/1994/24 .1994
:
17
.1999

(3

.d1994
.

(4

203



27 1981
CAB/LEG/67/3 (1982) 58 I.L.M. 21 21 .1986

1948 XXX

OEA/Ser.L.V./II.82 6 .(1992) 17

22 1969
1144 36 123 U.N.T.S.
OEA/Ser.L.V./II.82 6
(1992) 25 18 .1978

4 1950
.5

(5

" "

LAWASIA 18 17 1982
.LAWASIA

204

LAWASIA 13 15 1993

" "

LAWASIA 19 1995
.
) (

"
" 19 15 .1998

20 1993 .
) 12(94
) 12(94 13
1993 518 .

8 10 1998
.

" "
" " 14 16 1999
" " .

205



4 6 1998
.
a .
:
(1)14 (1)8 (2)27 (1)6
(1)7 26 .
http://www.amnesty.org/ailib/intcam/fairtrial/fairtria.htm b
http://www.lchr.org/pubs/fairtrial.htm c
d / Mr. Dato Param Cumaraswany

206



26 6 1985 32/40 29
1985 146/40 13 1985
_________________________________

16






.

.

207


.1
.
.2

.
.3
.
.4

.
.5

.
.6
.
.7
.

.8


.
.9
.

.10

.

208

.11
.
.12 ,
.
.13
; .
.14 .

.15

.
.16

.

.17
.
.
.18
.
.19
.
.20

.
2000 1997

209

210

.
.
"".
:1


.

. .
:2



.
:3
.
:4

.
:5
.
.
:6
.

211

 :7

.
.
:8

.
.
.
:9


.
:10

.
:11

.

.

.
:12


.

212

 :13

.
.
.
:14

.
:15

.

) 17 (1999

213

 "" :
(1

http://un.org/
http://unsystem.org
http://un.org/rights/dpi1837e.htm :
http://www.undp.org/
http://www.unhchr.ch/hchr_un.htm
http://www.unhchr.ch/hchr_un.htm
http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu2/7/b/mijl.htm

http://www.ahrchk.net/
http://www.ahrchk.net//solidarity/199704/v74_20.htm
/ Justice P.N. Bhagwati

http://www.coe.int/
http://cm.coe.int/ta/rec/1994/94r12.htm )
(
http://www.echr.coe.int/

http://www.europa.eu.int/
http://www.eumap.org/
: / .

214


http://www.oau-oua.org/

http://www.oas.org/
http://www.cidh.oas.org/defaultE.htm .
http://www.corteidh.or.cr/ .

http://www.usaid.gov/
(2

http://www.amnesty.org/
http://www.amnesty.org/ailib/intcam/fairtrial/fairtria.htm
98/02/30 POL : .1998

http://www.hrw.org/

http://www.ibanet.org/
http://www.ibanet.org/humri/index.asp

http://www.icclr.law.ubc.ca/

http://www.icclr.law.ubc.ca/html/publications.htm
: .
) (
http://www.icj.org/

215


http://www.fidh.org/

http://www.ihf-hr.org/

http://www.ili.org/
http://www.ili.org/Publist.html .

http://www.iawj.org/

http://www.lchr.org/

http://www.lchr.org/pubs/fairtrial.htm

http://www.lchr.org/feature/judicialreform/feature.htm
) (
(3

http://www.worldbank.org/
http://www.worldbank.org/publicsector/legal

http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/legal/judicialindependence.htm

http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/legal/protection.htm

http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/legal/annotated.doc

216

http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/legal/related.htm#World%20Bank

http://www1.worldbank/publicsector/legal/premnotes.htm
PREMnotes

http://www.worldbank.org/wbi/

http://afdb.org/
http://www.adb.org/
http://www.coebank.org/
http://www.ebrd.com/
http://www.eib.org/
http://www.iadb.org/
http://www.iadb.org/idbamerica/archive/xjudicie.htm

http://www.iadb.org/regions/re2/consultative_group/groups/transparency_worksh
op_2.htm . Dr. Jorge Eduardo
Tenorio
(4

http://www.asiafoundation.com/

http://www.abanet.org/
http://www.abanet.org/govaffairs/judiciary/report.html

http://www.abanet.org/ceeli/

217


http://www.brennancenter.org/

http://www.ajs.org/cji/index.html

http://www.iris.umd.edu/news/conferences/tinker/judreform.html

218



PN-ACB-895

PN-ACM-001

PN-ACC-887

:
PN-ACH-305
:
PN-ACH-300

PN-ACD-395
:
PN-ACC-390

PN-ACE-070

PN-ACF-631

PN-ACE-630
:
PN-ACF-632

PN-ACE-500

219