Professional Documents
Culture Documents
-.
•• •• • •• ··~qJll.4 ~J' U' ;r ".!~.:Ia...::IlJ A! « C' 1 G .!J 9.:1 J --.!.r " ... .. J !S•.«," CI I d !',.....II '-' I· d.!. t r II 9 ~J ~. ......!:I,."I I .. U I ~ .. .... •• d .. ~ •. = .. .~ .. II .• .u« ?t 9 '~
...•
t
• /~II"
'", ,,.,
~..)
,
~, alA"
~,.
•\ ~~'.;-;-'--
u!"J.
'f AY :~
j.."\ · J. \ JoI~\
~,)IS'':J1 ~I
~t ~ 'Aq_·
:v-S'U -
r tAO
- 4 yAW' - ~--Ll'
fl~' ~ ,~,
:~")L....I)I
u! r-W' ~_;~
UfS
Aaiu·lil
~
~J.ij
(JoY lA_Jj
'_y~
wP ~L.~
--------------------------
....
''\'tv
UP ~L.~
~~ ~ --------_
~t.:ll
J_,b- :
J;')I\ ~~611
~LUa;#J~'~
d
•• ••
f""~l£:.UcId •
f -; •
.,.11
o~W\_~JJLflr:J'
r f ~ , A'\·
~ )/1 ..:,..j l5
~__,11S
J 'Y'
"? lSi
.r: ~L-S ~~
J~I
---
4tt,j'4M4
...
oL...\~ ~( -------------------------------
-,
?U
In •.-'
;$'.JJ 'b. ::s:J~ 4.i}.ll4 1~,..,;uL..~1 ~ .J-.o.t# J.s:- 0,).\ o~ ~I ;_rA.l1 ".1I uL..G...u1 ~ '1J .)k 'iG ~I ~WJ
O~ ~
~.!.)l5"'1\
~I
w-:
..1... :.;
~WI
.)6·.,j
J
W~
~..L-.
)\J,~
,~~
~\&~
~')U
~
.-
'i ~\
J•...>-\
..
\&-,;L...::,.. ~
"*
. \Afi~
~r ~
~';J.:I
r.P
j;.
,.
0~
~~J
01 LSI (Future-oriented)
~IJ "::r
J:h,~~
~y
~)I
if ~WI
J')\k;1
,~lll
ibL";;· ..
l~
)tk'il
~4:, ..~1
~ '~)y..~'il
cr ~..r.J1o.l6·~ ~ J~ t._}_dl r~lA.::.!1 o: ~WI ,. .)~I J~I ~l5" jJ~ ~'-' ~ ~:~ il_rl)'1 ·Jo'.rJ1 ~~~J 0.)\11 _y.;,M!; ~I :i....~ Jo',;~ '11 ~~,; .~
c:
~I
~,;~
0\..j ~
,~
JuilG
~
~I
~ ~_,1.6l1Creativity
:~\ •·..jiG .)I))\J ~
~I
~~Li.i
~
~,;~'i\
r..l.AJ u=J1;j!~jII.lj1
iWI ill'il
,~WI
0~'i\
";)1 c:i..ulo_,i
..LV
,~L.;)lG ~L.-:~
~
ii,;,;J1 ..:,;~
yL-",: .. I
.~.r-1' ;~y.
~ ,t~? ·ili'"'
d
cr"
A.j_)l4A
Jlk~
~Lc;, ~b
t,{
\ ~~
Comprehensive
0_,5JIJ
A41:.~\
~~.rP)\
~,
J~
r:.r- ~~
wl.J)'1
J..l.:::i
~I
c velopment
!J1,;~'i1Jlb: .. r:f ~WI J~4o.....l ~j,; t-I...lA; J.1,:...; tlJ...J1 oJ.. ..:.. .... _? AI
~ ~.ljl
.r:_,J.r-JI
u,:.J'-J
u=J1 ,~LWI
e
(pi ~
'
-'i ~I_,II
~_y.-J
~.rJ ~fP.S'
'~J
rJ.Ai 81 '~r}1 ~I
~
~~.)T ~
d4o-W1 ~I,;,;JI
~» 0~
w~ ,~~JI 04J,) 0J~ ~~~ - ~JI i.u .:/ ~ wI) t.. ~J'-' ,:-.J
~~?
r:f ~_,k W\; ~
~~J
J~\.~
-liJ .i~..w\
~Wy.J 4j~lrJ
------------------...----------
.-----------------------
...
ulw.\·( -~
~>-6:- \~J
~
.~I
A,A...,l; )~;'jlJ ~~ ~
~L..~\ ~
\,~
~\5:; ~
'JI.."')'\ if
~
s.\_}
§'
Jl ~
J~ ..}_y
~~~r
,a.~V
J; ..
.•.t
u.. _ ~~·\j~t\ .. .»
--
lJ':i·......~Lw.\JS ---------------------------
y)y. cr:
0t~G
t!WI
~ ~_,1.1 "':f:.
. .u_,
~.
·'.-----1
,~I
J_,_lJJ ~ltpAJl~~
.
'~4~!G
IJ"'~I r,1_"..J \.ilr' ~UWI
;,1.,4:..
'\ ~ \
4.::i~
ifl;.... ..;~
'~,;)\A \....I""":'J ~
:!~l...i)'\ ~ ~
~)ai ~
-I.,:
~IS'
~ ~
o;JoWl
~~
t;_?:.i ~
G~
r-lt... ~ w...... j ~, ~ ~ J ,~}:l\ IJ~ IJ~ ~ »P- ~ 4JA l:;_ ..uJ ~~ ·L.~U '-ii ~I y Jsj~
UP
~l.~
J.a..fo ~
---------------------------
"
,,
••••••••••••• :.: ••• : ••••• , .: ••••••••• ' '....
,',',
,'
','
',
"
, ,.
..'
',
"
' ..r-:J.ij
~
--.'
...... I , t.=.·--..
16
i, l
,0
••
..
.)'\ J
I-
..
W~W)'\J
A4+*.liHJ ~ jl'l
~)J
,-",)..L.
~..w
#
..................... ~I}I
_)_~I - ~
ot
........ ~~ ~J~..li
W\ .. .
~
'0
v·
Vi
U
J~\'\
•.•...
~tJ')U\
~_)Ir='")lIJ r..l4:l1
vv
.......
,','
~t...~
---
~Jl:i"&a.A
~ \.wlJS -------------
_._..
._
~L.
t.>_; ,~\~\
~-:li
tS_;kl>. ~
~\.;.,.J
~\
,~\)
~
,
..
\.
11
"~~
S
d tt_;k}
~)\
,:ikL. - ~
4P \}~\- ~\ J':~
:. U.J.4NUZ4 .ItI
~
_;b l.5
AklJ\
i.? L.
_J
~'-;,:¥'
J
~k.. L5"~'j\
~
"'~
~\
J\ 'l1_,..J\ ~,~
~
r-W\ ~-_;
../
\jx...., .. ~\ ,~~Q:~
J"'-
C"~
l..~\
01..;lA
J
U
,Aj;~
_\ ~ )~
~
~ ,.~ ...~~,
~p\ ~_rJ\
~
w\_)~\
":_r"
J}I .'(~,~~~
y
L~~
~J
(.51)\ ,.)
j')\.->.
Y ~)~
Jl Jy_,.u ~)
,J~ JIy
p
~
\J~
J:~.'~-~ ~~.A:>v
..b-
..::.ol_,.k;- ~
...... ~ '--~\
J-..: ~J
L>__,k~
J_rJ\
ili.}J\ ~J
,It-' .••••••••
..
..
I.~.tl
\oJ
..>\
~~ ,
. ..
u-'
...".J
_____________________________
.d.J'Ji;"". ~L..,\JS --
~y
~\
~..y;;:l\ ~41\
:J_fl
~;;JI
~J
.....
45'..M
$0
"-
~J
,~~I
;1.~ ~~
~J
~1)2.!1 ~~
440:4>
0\ 0U~)
#..:"
,0U\'~ ~
c_S~
~\
.!J~ 04
6-
Y_r.aU 0:-:)jj.JI ~
4.i)..til ,y- ~
d)6- ~
l:.,ilj «~..ul
r~..l:-i ~
C.f ~
_,AJ ~\
$.",.
~
o.u.u,
($\
~
;;~I)
y ~~I
«(~W\
~~.J
0\1 ~I
~~J
~l_j\ll
Ji)
A.<t.::kll ~
l>ft-\I ~1..b-\l1 04
~
')\is:. ~~~
·j;Q1J
J4:!J
J~
oh J
cr"
j-4.J\
y ~~
,_
,-:.?:-)
'1G LS-;:kB
0_';LW
Ji
({~»)
\~
o" ~'lS"
l....tJ
~~ I
;;JJ4
~
~l.
cr: ~
w.s::; ·~f
«(I.$"-!:kH r-LJI)
;,;.rJ\ ~
o~
~yW\
~I)
~
I_.Q
~}G
J.
o.u.L.!l1
(.$""'\_)~
J>- rlW\
C~:~
r-LJI ~
4JI . dWI ~
~I_,.Iill ($)2;.11fl'
u
r-LJ4 t.,.,b:-
~I ,..u:.\_;.ll .)~
r;ill'
~~~kjl
~L.
.i:ll_, ~~I
Jl
~
._:.,l$'"}1 ~
\g.~4~
;;.J ~
if ~J
·dJ\.Q.JI r-WI
jl.~.':S--1_, ,~WI
~
,~I
Jd ~
.kl:,.j ,~
o~~1 ~ ,~I}
._:.,\~ I_r.I
· is..l4.i ~
fo.J
~
s:-~
L. I
.r.)))
,~\s;.
.~I
~h
~I~-,
L• ...-
obI
jA.J4 il..;:J\l1~
~R!1J ~)I
~
.1:.JI 0~
~
.!J.l_) ~
w.JJ
~l
~I
if ~y
..:,..1)_,a~1 0\
J_,A;
«(~I--4-lI))r-WI
~~)
d ~I
J'L.I
'~y
Jl
1-4J) .~
J.W~ i..rlll
j.:i ~\
t.~1
'u--W1
jU
~\)
J.j
'u--WI
: ~J\j
l._jb
LA..&'
#r
Jl ;"'\s;. ~\
~j
~ .. Qj '...S_r:c:
'1 f.. ..';; r)
~k:i
«~~
&-
'i»
p ~4 J) \II
~}::Jl ".j\.LJ\ ~
~
JJ \II
..
A.l.....)\
So
p)
~Wl_,
\,k;.J1
~G ,~'ll) JJ'lIl7')\ dW\ tyjl ~ JIb W" ~ ~W)'l JI-:..... j _r\ 01) ~W\ t_,;3\) ·y~1_, 4 Ik.;.J1 ..u:.1_.,Aj.)~I_, ,~I
J4-J1
-. #--
-----------------------
(..W'~
\~
--
~)
yA
,4:.&-
y)J...u1
~~
o.1~~)
JA.-J1.r.P ~
JJ,,(2~
'iJ C4..b-JJWI.;
~;!;kll ~~I j;:J~)
.~\
Jl
Jy)IJ
OJY
r:r ~
'J~Jr;!
~j11
~
\.:l.\; ))
I:-
· oGl...!.;
#-
~J
J:i
r\
~
,.
UL..I ~
~~I
JI 'O)"~ J~ ~ ..:f)
l;.j~
_}:AJ 1 t_Y
L4~1
if
I~ J ~ \l
~
~..Lijl
~
~\}..a>JI
~.J ~ ~j:I..l)) ~
\.......1-
0Gl.A>
.o~~
Jl
~
~I
I~\l) ~
~\
\.a~)
~
'u-W1
~ ~_j'-.5j_.:~J
41 4~_;
o.4..b:JI J_;JI
,~
J_,i\ 'i) ,~
~~
~
~\~
~~
JY"c..
~\jS. ~
~I?
if
<.S...Loo
~¥
u~
~,.
r:r
~
#
~}.:JI
\.:.j~)
..::."L,ag:1\
J-:..J ~
~)
~.r-P)
.
J~G J~)~yy4J1
01
:~tll
~
0J_.,aJ1
ly,a:.Y ~
lSjjl
I-
~")l4.J1
..::."G~I
~
\~~ •.a~
~J.=.:J\ ~)
.."
._j)_)J1 ~
.Jl ~
.u ~I)\ ~
\.:...ts" ~l.:~
~
~
~
~)I ~\
'11 ~1.AiI1eo: .J
p.; JI )J..,.J J ~\>.- '11 J"J IP ~I.,.k::.~/I ~) '1 ~I ../ ~I ~~ r.rL r-' l. ~I c: l..4iWJ '(,$.J.Ja ~
...... ~WI
~~
Jl ~ _,--;;
:J~
0\.-.k..!. ~~I
r:r
8 .. A .~
~...Loo
interolisciplinary
~
~4bS:.1
u-WI
·JrJI ~Jt:i
U~
~)lj
~I
"I...ooJ...lj)
uLa6:!\ u'i)1:-..
o\Aki\...
jSJ ~G
C~I ~_,l~_,....
#-
~}:jl ~J
0~
.r ~
r
0) uaJ I ~~I
~\kLJI t-J'u
.)2;
0':)\$:.1
Jl ~~
.~~\~\
~I 0~
.
;jJJ.i utiW
,~')U.JI
Ji ~~I
oJ~
-~ )\
\
,,~
~ ~I
0-!~I)
~l.J..J\ ~ _,$'
4J
\.f"
U~
Mts"
~J ...
~\
ultl4!.ll
I..S"')
·
,~I
l-
c~1
~\:>{J"'!
..
4JG)1
..
~\.,a>
f
c! Oiz-o...:A
..
Aj~J.!.k'C
...t~
1.
L. '-4 ~.J.J
"1"
.LQ·.~)I
w~
·I_~~
'LflRI
L. o}~)
4.:;;"Q!G ~4G
,~ ~ } ,~
4.. ..
,~..uJ\
~_ra11 0J~I
4J1j~1
~I
,~I~ ~~I
1_$.lJ1~4
IJ~li ,t;llli
~li
4; ~
e:: ~J cr-Wl ~
~."J.I0G
~
,~~
#
J~'YI
~..1h J"L...G
..
~I jAJl ~A);.) ~~ 'jAJl ~.r) ,o..b-) dl.,_j"J\ J.WI 4Jb! c~ s. - L.I 0yV 01 )JJU'j ¥\ ..,;"':'" '11 ultl.Aill 01 I~ d'- ~ J ·J!'" ';.JI_; y~ 'YI
,-A~J
• I
\,
Lu' ~\,.,.
~..)a ~
-----------~--------------
." . • ,""U.,. ..
.. ..
,~ '--
..4
'. "" ..
4-,..
. "--'W
,
._)
~'i
..
., ~
:1i.
.. ~,. ..
.l
,/
~._)
"
.~I
.
JIo
.-
.
~~
~~
.~
~.7"
t\A~~
\A~
0\~
~~\
(...$jj\:1~\
~.
~\\
l;~r
.:
~
:.
-~ E
.:
'_'~-!
~4~.~
~ ~ ~
..
'~
.. . ~ ~.;
~';.y.l'
~ '_
4J
_, J \.) ~~ ,~..>-;
.~
~; ;
~~)
$!
Gy-J..,. L.y~
~
. j-:?-
(.S,;, 4-;!
i_,' '
Ls'. ...
. '
~.,.."....-..J'I!
,.,
,-
A','
,., -s 1
" ~, , ... : !
,"I ~ ..
~~p"
,.
.1
h_)
J '.~ .~.
i-';:';;-!
~j
1
.,~'
cWI A:>:-y ~~
~
~.J~~J\
L;
JLa\ )~
. ~y
, ,
~. "III;
..
-t
T·
.,.. ~i!
.. ..
't
'.t
:
~.~,;~4
__.I
'.
~;..JW
. .
~
,,
;'~J.:.~
...... _••,f
L._'
[--.:.~ .. -~~~ ;l ~
.I
..:...1) t..p._
i}s- ~ .a...-J..i
i~_~;......~,t;o.,-
••
.f ""
~.-
... ... ~
I
,,"
........
",
~.
,~ ..,.
,;~
:.,""'.'
,'. ~
~;."~.'" '~..
',.
'\,
.
~
....
...
__ ,J .:'
1,...':;
.•4'_~';'~;
/'
r • ~'-~
.
-
L.t
~, ~. .....¥ ..J'.., \
e .... :,1
,.r
~'9 .....
....
,
~""""'j •
.,r
%,,:
~~,
"~
...;.,s._;_~
1.
iJ..J
"~' 'C-' .
: jL....... .f
i.,_~~.~~
, ~l
.<","
""I.,
,
lAS
.'
r-·_~i
-"
~!
-i.
.
t
1
":t.
~.
~-, ...
.~.._Jl.~
\ I
I'
-·I~ ~W ..
.. ...
\~\-::. 0ltW
c
V 1•.,J.. i /~
,.
.~
i. ~ ... ,
.....
)~l
~..
;1
t.l
~~I
~l:.AJ\»
~)
~~J
({~I ~")\.A&. ~
:f ~'})
~\
t.
~~~\~)\j
J- ~\J
. ~\
_l;y
~L.
y- ~
~\>.-
JI ~\
J~I
~
~)
..a)
....... _rJ1
J-.: L. Jl ~y)
foJi
J\ ~\
'-'~\
;_~ .. ;f
"iJts_)
'~G!J
~
to
C__r- ~
;:\)
:.r-: ~
DC.
J\
)1 J~i~1
",~~~,
'"
:',
I L~
ti
"
Bunge
lJt, ~~
Li~
~
~J
0? I)
~I
• t,
;; ~ ~
J I..u. I) ,~
i~ \La.f Yo ,__j ~) ~k
4-it~ ~
La
.,L')
J-.:
~
~ '4~
)1
~I.J
,~6:-
~~-,"""y
4JJ .!+.J\ ~
e ~\.~-:i
,JIJ.A\J
--
4,1,ji14L1
....
~\.w.' ~ .e ----------------------------
·4J1.,i2c.~ 4_.p\>
~;k.;..
• \ .-:,,; ~
J~)
~IJ~
t~
~.,
4J Lo..;G~~G
L" ..
~
.. ~.
~\j)J
\
4-i1}~~ ~
J
~I
~J
t:-fJ
(,f'*' .
4i ~\.
-'
: .. tl 0J~ ~L:.H.J.
. UA'-'
..
\Ak;.4
~t.lt
\II
Jl
0~I
4.
~ ~
e
Jl 0~G
0~
~L.a>1
.re_,.. 01_,
~Ij
if <-Q...~I
~
~Wi
Jl ~\
~~
,.
_)pl
~
J~)
~\.j
.~I
J'l \_)2.; ~
~I
~\
~_r-ll
0\) ,~
0~ ~
~_,LJJ
y~
0"')
,,$.
jSL.yU ~\I)
·~I ~GI)I ~
~W~
~La,...J
)5:.i1_, ~~I)
0J~ ~I
,.
wL.l4':4N J~I
~I
~
o~L.
l~
:t:~
y) u~~)1_,
~
~)
Ala::. _. ~~~
~~
~I
~
lJl_, ~~
I-
,~.)W\ ~ ~\
')J-l>-
'j\
~Q
;;iJ ·~
L•
~~
is' ~_,J_J:(--4~\
4JJ~ ~\ ..:;~\
y}1 ~ '11
~
I-
..IS-G
~_,k:;J .~)#I
Jl
1-43) ,~14~
~_r-ll
~>...: )~ .. ~
t.J
_;::kL.I ~
~
'rl ~
~
L~\ \f\ ~
_,J~w4 ':/\
LJl.c
~
~..yl lk;.; ~
d ~)
,_)~I
~I
GJJ,k""I ~
lPl..l,:¥"J
~)J:!~'jl
_r- ~~
_i) 4J..t.1
!J_,L
#
JI (;}~.,bJ1~)
~ _;M ~
~~I
J.aJ
' (~L...i~1
J..l..aJIJ~I)
r-J
~~~ ~i~ ~
~\..:... ~ ~)
~
)1 ~
#.-
_rJI
jA.JI
~
~\.y
~
,.
¥~I
rA
($..ul r-WI ~
Js;
'LS~
.yl.,)~y~:Jl
J\yJI lSfi 01 ..;\.:,.if ~I
~)J:!--4~IISI)1
~} ~..I.; ';JI ~
~
$ ..
.!)~
op ~;';j
~
~\
~l;JI )1 ,~I
~I)I
"
d J~I.J
....,c.~) ;
_1,JA."
~
d J")\>JI
t ..I.•.a~ 0\
~
P
\..:.:1 ,~I
Jwl.J
#.
~I
•
c)L..:,'j ~I
4.iL::. ~
~~
#-
(bP
~~
)1
..
-,~I
Cl~ 0~b
J\S' I~I_,
r-WI ~J
. ~~
'~J
r.1~,02U
~I~ ~ ~ if J ·L.W
Js(.5..u
AS"'_,,-JIoh
if
lp-L...,
46L ~
p.,,4J ~
r..u ~
~I
_)Lp ~~
J'L..
~
~
L.f!"")~--4'11
~~
~)
~--4\II ~
w-
~tA)1
Jw
Js~
1Jl41;
~~J
if)
~\.a>
~_,JJ:!~~I J~
L. y:.) - \..J~ ~I
(4-::k
A~!Q>
J.r-!
01 ~
~_,Jy-~)fl
~I
,~L..J
rJs:.) '""".,a.jJ ~~
y~i
!J~J ,~Qi.bA
~II.S.JJ
'~.:2;
4-i)' fl_.i=1I
'0 ~
(JM\...~ ~_;.b
ulc- -------------------------
____________________________
.. •
,t,i' ...
~\-..., .. __ (
"...,J-
Js~I
~\
I_,S:>.
y~)
1.2
.-:;1
~I
~I ~
~~I
r-~
~_,J~~)l1
iA ~I
~l.:c.IJ
G.>WI
,~)~IJ
~
~I~I
~
~)
- ~\ .~I
~
L!'")I
..L.:.~
'-.>JJI ~\
Js.r
0~ ~
~ ~)I
U"'*)I \ ~I......k
If ).1i I i~1 ~\ ~
~-;-iL ,.
01
~W\ Lei
A..... .;; ~~
'''-! ~);
._r-JI _,. ~
~\ \ ~~WI
r.?)y..~ \'1
Wb ~~
b~ ~I
~~G
~\_,JI
1I~')l.; ~I
I-
:ir..ul
~.r..J
(:_,k;
Jl
~'Y
:i_r..ul ~
l
<II_?~)
~
_;+AJI~
·r-WI ~
c.
,~'pi~\
~
;jLij ~
~~.)
,~»- ~laL
~
~I
0~ ~
01
Jl
~i
~\
4-- ...,...;~ L.
.~~ 'Y Ji
~)1
~I...~ 0~
I-4JJ
~\ i~
,
~4
jl;
\;);
~.J
~
.~W\
;;~
JI jy) .!Jj ~
~
~':.~'" 01 ~
~>if
~ ~
j)"')1 ~ ~J
~
o~1
t: ..kl!..i J')b:.
--41.J
j.!~1
·d'JAs.'J
~I jj_.,...i:ll
._j \, ...,4,!
~J
fl''''
~j:-)11 l644U ~
j;
.~I.J
~
:drJl ~ ~
L.iL'al1 ~~I
.r""-'I
c~t
il..b.o;,.\ ~J~ .
Js- ~I
~I}I
~
if ~I
~
"
\.,k;JG
~fr)
Jai) ~)fi~1
~
Jl J?)
I~
'i\) ,~f'"
.)_r.-- r-WI ~)
~
~ 'r-:
bL.
ifl~1
~I
'r-:
o;c:. \ ~ :>~
oli4>--';J ~\kJ
~I ~I
oli~ts::..1_, d",.ll
.!J~:l ~I
~w ~~ ~ L-t
~41\lJ .
~_)
\j
It
~.,J
,~I
~..,J.I
Jl ~~~ ~~ )_,ld\
~I ~I
~J)aJ1 ~~
0~
IJA ~
,~..b."..
JJ? LS~l.o'1:i'i\
.... 0:5"'
~I}I
~l.....
l\)~
~I
~G
~W
;.;W '~J
d \6·~::j ~
01 ~
#
WJI
¥~I
0~
~l..;~
0i lS_?-i
~w
~
($1 L
~I ·~~ ~~I
'1\
~_)W\
6JS ~l..__':; J.t_;J:a ~
\,
J}.Q"
0.J~.J':'Ml
~~
L'';'~
-------------------------
--
al'.'i;~
~l....t;s ---------------------------~I) o~
~~ 1--4J · «~\_:;ji
~:lYJ
_'.:"i)
J~~
'~y..
~\
;~l;
d'JJ
~.rtl
t~J
O~
~_rJ.1
~
1..$
~
4j __
.. :H ~
J'
I' iJ.iW\
.~
~..
~L"
«, .. ~\~ q
~I ull11
..T.
,.
.~ v·.. ~L
U.4"
\.4:\
c: ~~I
~
~\
~
~bJI ~~ ~JJ)
J:i t~,jAJl
~"YvJG,~_rJ.I
~
0)~ jlJl
e:: ~I .~.:I_p.--J
dL.
~
i.bJ
~
.!Jh ~~
.l:!.,ajJ
~
I..?'
L.J
't~)G
-,.
~
~..,j
~_rJ.1
J~I
~)
~I
JJ."" ~
.r- .. 4; r='~
JA,JI
~J~
utS:..) ~IJ
~~
d ~_) ~
I~
..
0_).t;
~ JAJI
J'Y_l-:...'11
~\
.~..bJ\
lS..v.J A...'!":hlubJS.\
r''';;;
4J
__.kl ~
u-W1
;_)zJ1 J~
f;
~ _;J.I ..kWI
)1 Jlkl ~
#-
lS~J
6:.c.1 ~I}I
,_,J.:3 ~I
Jl
.?1; JA:..:.l1
" .r ..~) .0l.....i'Y~
~I)I
j,j__,-JJ ~L..)l1
~ -
~t- ~J
~
~I)I
~
iUG
-.
)1 oJ.>_,JI 0-41 0~ ~J
~b- jS"
;t~.
t.l) ·
Ofl'"
~
b J.1>-)
.~W\
,
Jl
o)2.ill
J-
.~\4-;>'1\• ..
~J
u~\ ..
~~
A,;_rJ.1ul...\>-J 0'"
~ ru_t\
'-...I".
.+~ ~
..
~\\
· ~_r.:lG JA,JI
~
J)I..I.,'W.l'l : ~L..i
~~
if
~
u-W\
d" ~\
~I
J.l~J
~~
I-y
c..?- I~
f'~ ~\
1..1.;~ ~\
J~
..1.;~ ~
01 LA : ~
0~~\
I-J ~I
~J
t~.r
~
A...~
itk:;\'\ f~
_;s1 J::..:; ~i
,_}
0_r.. ~I
J'J_ri.ll ~
~GA-:.":~\ <.S~
0G .LS_?-i 4L.a.i Jl \.i~_,id 4--L..1 ~~~ ~pl 0fo cs": kAj cfJJ .~)dl JG J'J_;JI J"L..i Js- ~i Exper- 0..r->- J\ ~ft .4..$) .oJjlt) 0J..b:- 0'" ~ LS~\... JS"' ~ J\ ~k: ..J !lG~~1 c.5_,;._. ~ ~J~\ ~W~ Jl..a;}'\ ~f:"'" ~'J r-WI J~ ~ ience
Jy)1 ~ :4..l.o;~1 41.,ai1i
fJ_riJ1
t~
o..u.
. ~I
II~
~ ~I_,
~~~ ~.J'"
~ti
..
\~;w;
~.lj
J.
,Y\t. ~I
Jt:'J} ~~
dJ
o~~
~)
~~I~I
lSr.,
~~~J
~»
.u.;~\
,y
uP ~\...~ ~~
-------------------------
----------------------------------~ ~ ~
~\..w.\.(~
--
letA 'u:-~
I~\ '->
U•
_. • -
_"
~\ ..J~j\ J
~.
.l~~
~~...w J -~
~
...
_j r'--... ~l~~>-\~
I
\'4}.';A
~_;...S'
't_)~ ~I
, ~,I
\',
1-6;. ,~~
\
.J ~
,~.J.i
~..J
t~
a.J •..L~~2HJ ..
...
LJ~!
\\
'
I(
.f ui
-t ~LY
I
j>-I)I
~
~L-_;... j;o:-b Lp}t I...S?-- A.i_r ~1 ..bl':.JI ~\ ~~ ) ~G~ ~1 ~.J.j o~..bv ~~)_r..,. ~) ~\ .... WJI ~l _ _;-JJ ~I. I~J . W5JJ JJ.JJ\ ~~
~
I
- ~.!..,.lA. ~I ~l ·0':1\
,y\>..
~
;;_,.\..b
~\.,a";'
~
i.$p.J
J\ ~~
;;jJ~~
;;".,.Jb:-
We
~
if~~
_ \..
I:-
\'\ _l.,W, ~
Q.,4JQ,..A
Jl:J~l.glA.iJ
. \_
~r
~_)).)
,.,..
t~
<.$..J.J
~'\
t.5~
·1
.'}\
t?Jf
~J
~\ L\!..I
$)
....
t \ __ \
~...4A~
;~.
~.~
.. •
.~~
~_)l:H
~
.J~4
W~
~\;)
\1,~J\
~~)
'~J\.:H
J..d.1 (.\:,;'11 ~
b}:JG
~k:~\
~I
J\k\
tl '-~ ~
~\ ~
~~~
o~~
.b:-YJ
JjW
~IJ
~~r
jJL..J
~>us:- ~
~!'oa)
~.)\
JW'}'_-,
":"'\..1> .. ;;11
4.:Qq ... \J ~\ J
~J\~.~
':1~ LJ)W\
~IJ
~JL;.I
_k l;:,.;.U
~G
~
4l-J1 >~I
d ~:k:1\
~\.i ~
~l5:..~ ,~_;;, ~
I~J .;;~~
y_,L.k'J
~WI
W}
: ~ ...r :~, \
~\
<f
~
~\>-
.1,WG ~b:.
¥~\
+ \.......
J)
~
:JY-J
·t5.J ~\ ~~ .>..
')\
J~' J-
~) \~.4~,._..
~U.:.HJ
{•
~,;W
bpi ~
-+-
Q~~'J
4.
Q~
I C' --,--
~\
~ I
..r~,.~
\4~J
'~rLI~J• I,o~Uill ~\
$
U--
~'t
~
a"~J\\
LA
~plJ~J e:::
'1J ·dJl:>
.~li)
JU)f\
_;s1 ~W\
~I
~
~.JijJ
J. d~;,;:J\
t~.~
r\...\ ~__,.-..J\
~..bJ1
Jl ~
d 0L;")U
A.~~hl\
Jl a.w. ;~
~ \A
------------------------------------------------------~~~~~~
__
4".... ,i1HfA
~~\
~ .(
-----------~----------
.. --------------
if ~~ -4 ~
~)lSJ1
~L_':J\
.J"
~~_;.:AJ\
;,;,.Q~
\~:..~b,."'\ ~\
.. -'
~i~\
~ ..)
~W\
~
0J~
w.:l...LS:
fj~'
.&
J~L·.l.J My:::-.
~-Ys:.ll ~~
6\J~
~.
IC·
'-' ~
;_~~"H4
,0U~\'\
....
l ~~~ ,~\.)
:~l..w\
~)\
I
£.S
•
W~~)
JI
,«(~!:aJl
...
Y'J 'iAV i\,;. J OJJ.il\ U'S'J .~_rill ~I ... 1 "U .... , JI 'H ~ l ..~ .... \ ? t~J..:s, .. 4.A1.~ err" ::;:),~o J_r-J ~
~)IJ\
r~
~~J
(.$..lA
~l
~~
4:.u ~
_,L ~\J
~W\
Jl ~ ';A5J1 a_>.j\
.J~~
~I.JV
4J~J...~~
~I
~WI
")r r\}J
~
j
~;..
d } }\,~I"..J_,J\
~
j';~C-\
~
~~\
!.
0\5)
0~1
. I r' I '
..b-~
.~':i
J..
~\"""I
\ \
U~
• \ .'
~;
• \J~ 44
r)
U~ _iJ~
••.•
..
1 t_ \ \
. ~.. ~~
cr=«
~~ ~~ Jl_jl L5 . _!
L..b-\ ~ \.M.JOW" ~
.J
J~":~)
~L.a.ij\ ~
~
LPL. b.
M)
.I,j\ ~l..1Ji ~
j;.
t_SjJ\
,_r.:>'11
,~\.j
~)
t
·rL.jjj'j\
e_rP
o~\.i\ ~?
.j ... .;.. r '1
)
JI ,..:...Iyill ~\_(JI
~>.JI
L.J\ ~
~J
"
l
A~l;ktA
~\}) ~~\
U-.
6\.) J
~.rJI ~~
J~
~I~
~.r
1~c__J44:J
if
Wj.U ~,a!\
~ tt
~
·1 -
L._~J
- - (l
4..)
-~
_r ~J
.~_,J~I
~_,~
A. ~\
1\
..:..._r: .... ~ \
c._)I.:;..JI if
45'rll
0\ ~
~
~£\
;;J~ \~
...li) ~\
...... C"'\)I
~
0_,sJI
~~
01_, ,~l.::z4.l1
~ _,-JI
~;;:~I ~W\
;)~
.~L..I
~I_,i
0') 'u~
.!J_~'1
~.
4..;~\
w~_?--
J\
j
~.ILr-1
_~~)
'c~5:
4J'u~)
~
o~~
~
~Iy
4J
L.JI ~
~
~,,\..o Ih
0 ..5J\j
'o~_".b. 4.S~.r
..... ~ ,0L.YIJ J~\
o~\ll .:,,\S".r
o~~ ..:..~,..."
JL.. W
~\ ~J
JIS',~ ·oUz.JJ1
~L~b-\ ~J
LSI.";
.;;...lJbW~ J' ~
~L.l.>-yU ~~y
y-
~ l~iJ
Lc.:;.a:!
0l.S:J.\) 0\..0)\ 0\
\. ~-~~
~_,...,;..y
~ 0"") .:~'
--4~I)1)
~
~I
J.
~I
«JL..:'_~I)
~
~_;S'':J
~\ ~JISJ\
li:"..,o
~~_ft'i.I1
d JJ;.~J
uLS::.; :J'~'Y
~
~>-
)1 ~~I
I~
~~
~?
0Li .~I
~J
._:.,~ydl)1 ~~\.,Q,-Ll
~
J)_rJ.\_, ~I
J~~j
~I
~
~
~ ~
J\_, .~
j,y..;a", ~
l4Z·",.
~
y
.yL>JI jkWI .k....) ,~.)WI
~I
I~
~~
4i\J ~
~I_,.... '~j
~
u=U1
~I
~J)
I~I ~\;
~i d A::.?_r') ~ w-4~
I~)
d
I-
..
U;.y
~I
._:.,'~I \
~Js:.;'1)
~1
..:..1~1_r4j1) ~~..JI
11)\ ~ olS'l. ~)
J~
if
~~-:tl
J.
,~I
Jl
.liUI
,.
,A.A:i..u1 t.}....JI
~I
._:.,lj.F.Il
d~
~I)
~..L:>-
~\j_,JI ~I)~j'1~
1oJ"l...>- '1\ ~
~~
~I
~~I
J~I
~I
~
~'-'
.~I
Jj~ d
wl~ ~
~la .. ~ a
~)~I
r).JI
~I
~L....WI J.:s.
,~
~.J,}_I WI
· ~\..b-
~I...\>'YI) ,~I_;
_,...~ ~ ~I
#
J).!I
Ih
r-L t.l
l. ~
.uJ)')
J)yiU _)~1
4~\
A.:~_r-AJ\
o)~.!1
~.; ,j; ~
~"J41\
0\5.11)
~I
e.) .~
04
o~
~
~t¥1
<.S..iJI
~I
~G
.!I1..\:..o1~~
,.b;~
~~
Jl.Yl
r-L
~I)
Jy~\
~\.I.'11 Jy . .I;';!\ -4 ~
~
~~J ,~O;;lk ..
~\_, _r.iW'1
'W~I
~\_j'Yl
~WI
J-WI ~ ~ 4~~l:$.
.~
~
"
!llS:t~)
if
~
~I!ll
J~
If'
,0~y~
if
~WJI 1-4~
)\ ~L4JI
o..\..~1 JfLWI
uL:J
Jil
~L.
~I
t:'1_,J1 ~
Jyo-:.;
:l~
,J:>- ~\ ~I)
oJ;c.
J_,k ..~j) ,j=4od ~ j-<J) !l~ ~ 01 'r el::.ll J_;JI Jl J.~) ~ :':J~ ~I · ((kj..uhl
~
$
tl..,all
t.lkA.;1_, ~I
J.i~'1 -~ r.. )
~ if)
i.!-'-! ~ I~\
.AS\..... ~
J1; d ~J
~_,k uJ"';~)
~I_,i ,- .:.~ \~
~ L~ l1JJI ~I
~j_))
J)J\ 1LLJ\
dlbJl
L..,j
JJ) .~LJ~
rl ifJ
~
.~1
," "-18
~J
\l ~y.!\.u i--4-b.uP_;J~ ~
o-4~
o-4~
~L,i ~
ts'"'
~~I
JI ~~1
~
~
JI) ~~ J~
_uj .
~ ')\5J \ ,,~~ I
.~
J.:1 ~ H C'?_.j
~~pAJl
I_,.-J
LQ~W\
~#).w
J1lb-
u_# ~)
(.SJ...:::N
_}-'11 ~
~
~l;l~'
~\)~ :~~~,
f~\
if ~f
w.,s
~l.~
~_;:. ~
~•
__
1,',1,..... ~~, ~(
...
-------
~ ..J=.8....J~1 flplJ
u~~1
~J
~_,..;J\ fipG
~~~I C~
~)~\
~~..ul
J'
- ~J litil
~~
0~~
~I
~
J-WI
pb .~~
~~
.)J~G
c.?1
~~J\
~..y ;;-:JIfl_,.lJ1
~
.r.f LJ.!..l;~
~~..u
ul ..;.~\
:i!~~)
~J
~
,o~fil
u~)ai J\dIJ
~WG
W
.:u...:J.1~I
;~\ f~
.o..b-b ~Ij
4!..... ~
P
~
~I
~I_,AJI 01
Jl
J_;;. ?I
~~
L.S"I~b
r~1
~~
r-' ~J
~Lo.:t ~'1
~I
~
J)l.!1
L. ~~
.).).fl
JA.ou
~ ~
JJ':11 4,64;l\J
J-~\
_f1~
Jl wLl>\ ~
~_)~\
~\.kl'
~I I~
#.
\~Ak:.! ~I
"
u\y~1
~~I
01 ........
·fl_,lJI
• ..u. ..:....J~
~ 0i
y~\
01 (_r.} ~
if J ·O~;l) ~ ~ ~ ~I
s
iyKjl ,_) ~
~I_,; ~~
J 0L.i'Y1
"-! ~\,;JI
j5J
_)~
d~
~
~I
o..u.J
'~.A.w
J-~I
~J
~...l..a.l~ ~\.WI
~~A:!I
.1>1 ~
~ld.1 ~~I
~~ f'1); ~
~WI ~Ij
'"
~
?\11
e
Jl ,.J\;,..
~WI __,a1_,1;
~
~
J ~.L.J.,J\ ;"".1..,..,
.!.lllS"'
41
,!j~ ':}\ ~~
f'1_,1;
Js01
b
~
~~~I
~IJ.?- ~G ~~I
~:ki
Jl
~I
\_,.A.. c.
~
~I
if ~~
J5' ~\}
y~
Jlli-l
~
J
lSI ,~l_j\11
JI ~)~I
cr ~;
~ yill
~f ~ ~ I--4-lJ ·uP\>.
J~ ~)
U'"~
l:i?
o_FL...-:i1 _;A'\_,WI
if ~ w.J I
4 ,j.&-
IJ 0_r--J I ~
..:,....1 ~~ .. 1
cr I~
~li)1
c: t!\i)1
k. ~.r' if l.a
- J\jJ J. oJ_;>-'
($l.!1 JI~I
. ~\
~ I~I r f,ea--!
.~
i~l)
JliJ
~
.~~kl\
d ~1_,A.l1 ('1..wIJ
0':1 ,~li)1
;;.)~I i~
>-~~\
o~~
~
~li.r.J:-
4...;~l\
b- ~y
C!~ ,lil~10l5"
.4._1 d _)dl
if
t?' ~_)dl
,;~ ..
~\.:J\
o~~
~J
~
~H
L"
Z:>- ($..iJ1 ~I
·~I
4i.A~ J6,... 4J
J_;WI" ~lbJl
0\5"' ~~I
JI ~..y;dl ~\!~I
01
r
)",1 01
~
~-' cr"
..
if ~)I
'l~
l:.;ts"')
~
,~I
Js-J ~
r"u
'0J,s"
..:,..\!:a\
<.Sl.!\ j~1
~ ~
JI o..wl
cy"t..,;
0.)J..,b.,...
~jJl ,~I
J~ L..S'
,I: ,,';il
#.
J ·A •_....
~ \j~ J
fifo.
d ~\i')\&;.J
~1_,1; ~J
~~I
~~_r.Aj1~
~ I-
15'" ..\AJ · >- If. .!.ih if J '''-! J-.v ,. i\~1 I~ ?- ~l:J1 0_;J1 ,-0.,<2'::'I~J qs)a.o.ll ~~J ~':i ~~I
P 1..I.t~ ~ ~\ uP
~G
~L.jl
---------------------------
.---------------
,;
~.j
...
.... ,k,"
\Q
1 ':
0\
w
6\J~
.....
Becquerel
fu,.}(~_'
I" L; • '¥~
-.
.....
r"J..,?,-~.e4! ~
:
\.
...;-.".': \ :.h.
~~
t;
tI
_. '-
+~". ~
~
l' .
•. ~'II}". ,';
... '"
,...".
f
,'~ . /.
~~
c_. ,
i. \. ~,""
A\~ Ii • ; ..
~-.J ......./ Jw:J-r
l(
-'
I .: •.~
~I)jn,;YIl11~li
J:.
j
J
Ii
)))
.+--" t \
.lJ~ ...
,t
_ft- .;i
~k ,:.'! "
,. '::J
\ eJ _.t· It1
_.& ~
. ~.is-
Jlk&'\
~
($..r? 0~
. .;
4f
l"
·:~LJ
,
'I" ~
?
'
'JI
~.r
(J~'::J
W::o- ..:,:..~~I
U~~
o_).;)L..a.ll,~I ,
0~ _,/';":1\ r?
c!p ~\.. ~
o.4..b.JI Wj~
J_)yJ
j~L.)
~ft
.
(_"aA~J
..
, .d ...
...
.....
-------
~L.~
~~
~,
___
l.1,L;J'J.6
...
~~\.<
~
.:_,.;~ J d"
ifJ .;;~I
~\
~~
.:_,.;Ij L? ;;..i-::~I
~ ~
~.r-ll
..:...I-b- I ~~ ~
~")\5J\
~6.Ji .
~\}
~\ U::Jlj 01
4_-0
.,~i
~
~b
~~~\
~
'4~1
..
Jl w 4";1 W)'
,~~\ ~~
~
~\.45'1).)\ ~
:.J..; ~
~\}
0
• .~\~ • \ ~"t'
.s_?-\
~
.-
fGk
~
\!
.J.-il} 0\
I.
0\
4J
~\~
I__,~
~I
J~ lk>J\ ~J
~ ~ O~
#-
.ow4~
CL;
~ ~
\;!~
1
;~~
J..
~)
::._..~ ,.!
:;~I
A ..
••
6.:1~\
c: d4L. ~J
~I__JJ ~~
~~pAJl
l~t\'
U )JJ".a:~),lar'~:,
~~
... •
,o~
j...aAJ\ J_,AJ\
J\ r\.:>J\ WS"
't ~ •
..,4
W\ .Ij
~IJ
~.#
~
d -4~1
:f
~.k4'''J
..:...~I
~
~~
~~
~Jf.J
~..wl ~\
~~l.Wl
..li) .OJ'?-\"
~ ~
JI ~I
Heisenberg [__fi~)))
\..
Bohr)j'!
J., .
J4;J glie
• ~
~J
-~ ,
t\
~....u}
\ ~h
- ~)li
·\.1J1
~~J
~f~!
\ \-.t
~-
~\.A
'
., -u~
A!Q+.....LQ
..
!. ,\ ~ t
1 ~~
t\
if
)4' I)£G
u_JJ
.•.
~W\
_)J::'
if
(~4~§"
.. ~~, '\
L).L.)
,0J_?J}i\ ;;.;l~\ ~-
u\..;a~
,
·\('11 ~UJ1
~~~fJ
.. \
·_t
f\
~1I!:iad
r-'~
'-"\.-'.A~~
..
l:'\:.
..;:'
~.
.~,\
.... ~I
~ J~
'J~
\~
..:;_;lS ..u) , n
4_...,\)..I..l ~~~~
.
o-Ub ~J6rt~J
..
..
f.
~ ~.lll ~LJ ~
~~
f
~
\ j \
~\ iL>.-)1\
~ ;~~
~
.:JJ.:>t
.. t \
~
i
·~_,J~l
~~
~Iy)
i ..
):._·;ac, J'
~
I' ~L..a'" 1,
~
J\
o.ri1--.) ~~~
'-'~")\.~J ~
• ~,
0>
J~
~ ~\~
J~\
... ,s
r-e»
'-
'-.>~\
\~ .u\.J \ .~.~.l""\
1"_
it·
£\.A~\
\...,
,)1
Jl ~~
~
~I
;;J )\ j-y_) ~
~;\
4J
,_)~
l_;~~
0L.~1
?Ji~
~ ~
rJ.i) ·udWJ\
.,_1t,
~J
Yp::: ~ ~~~)I
t\
~~ ~~
? ~~L.
~_F
~
0'\ ~\f J~ ~
..
,1~"1 II ~ '"
:i))J:.J..r.'"
~!4J\
d__,~
~
1 .... (\
~l<z.;.
~
..
t\
• d' :_p.~\ ·
-.
t:...~'
~!..v
J~
'" ,
r•\
- 'A i A)
i: t /\ O~l
..
Jl
t L.
I .., l!
-,
L.
(.,)
i('· ~\
U
J~~ . ~J
.t...AJ10'
_t"1
~~
t..
..
c~ J!4" '~~ -. ~J
_
?J~~
~j
c.
c:: .?
~l
•
jJ 01
~
UAJ
t
J (\
..J~I)
-:
\.+
" ),
J'\ '-;..~
~~~A
i:
~-u1
#.\ .
1 ~\ •
"
'lA.;j;-'~\
·1
I·
~lr
s;,'
l.
J~
t\
~
~
01 t$:J ~
.~_r...
t...
A,
0i..ill1 ~I
0\
JltJ
·~~
'}\ 4J ~
~\.i.
~
~
~
':d J~~~
wL.J~ ~..
~
':1\ j:::
4J~ l;;...
· ~;
~ It")\y
.Y'
,d_.,4\ ~
J 1 0}.!.~I
J.;y
4--~
O.J;:J
~L.~
Jy; ~~
______________________
---
a_,l.'l!wloA
u\.w,\jS --
,\l.a11 J;",il
:i'; ~~~\:I
i.~I1..."1
~lU.l1 .JJlJJ
~
a;f
Jl l::-~L...I
Jl_NI uflJlj)fl
~\A..
4WJ
~
~I
..Lp.J\
._:.,'l'6,..
L~,lii) )1
,~~I
j:.~
~\;
~~ 0lS" J\ I~
.Jl
Js-
~~\
~~I
~~
..:..;
~_';:.JJ
_'\ ~ ~\ ..
)_,k-;J\
J!.
~?
L.P¥
(.5jJ\
~t/ . l>~
~~_r-A.U ~..\>J b~
• ..
~lk~ ~J
•••
J~
.~)
~~
'~\~.
W.
\~
• LS'
i~
~
d _r-JI
.A V
~~
~~
J.:
J.;- ~W\ ~
$.
~bJ\
.. ..\ t, t
~~
..
w..Ji
_,I •
J-._)
~.
'~·o
UI)~1_,
~Lil\
~
r-LJI \.lAo ~
~_j-
i~
0i ~1rt'J
s-~pil\ ~
~.)
~) ll>f
Jl
lS-YA.j\
~\
..
o)~
y:.s1 d ~~)
WW\ ~jjl
~})
Js-
...Lea..:: ~
lo..i G
\j I~~
Jl ;_"W\.,
~
~\,;.JI
~JJJ
::..=.
jl
\~
~):a; ~I
I-
c:-_jj)
~
.~
(!ly
if ~Y.
~\.~.H
~l::; ~
~_,J~
).1.J1
~..ba~
.:i.-;!klJ ~~
0ylA5' ~~
($~..w.
t.::kl\ ~~
~iJ
~!:kj\ i"wl
J~ J .ftLWI
\_,..J~J dCrWI ~I»
~I
t:1.,apl\ if ~I_f';
c:~
if ;'!,,a'
J5""' ~
Ji ~~Y'
~ ~
O»~
01.A1~')I1 ~I) J
~
._:.,~4 441,k~ ~
:iii)..
o.::.-L...l5:JG J;lA.!')I1 ~\jI ).1.J1 lS--4.c. ~.JS" ~W~\ ~G .UJ.,WI J~ W-- J~ L. 19J ~ )1 ')I).M ~'j
~lS" ~
,_)~)1\
,.
if .r.V ~\
,.
rY
~
. o\...j ')II
~\
~.M
Js-
~i
if ~)W\
§ .r-:
Jl w. ~~
"
, 4):;;J ~
0):>r:..li!1 ~I
.. JI 4..:k~) ')1\
~
\_,..->-\)
t'IJ
A~ ..·JI
~.JJI .i I» 4d~:» u
~~ftAJ\4-:ki}J1 i_,A; ~\
L-il5" ~I
~ ~I
..... ~ ~I
J. ,ll:.~\
j\.:f\ yl~
6-
i_;1:.-.;
~I
~ j 'l'1
l-
0~)2J1 01_,
J)~
~\
~\..cil_, oy ~;,
~ ~
Js~li.r.
0"';
01_,.l.c-:.~b J>b
--4~) ~
,J" ~
,}:.ill
J. ~~I
~1zJ\ ~ ~I
d ~~
~:,~.JI~)aJ1
t wi
UJS
~L..ji ~~ ~
--------------------------
~!
,.
---
ll'li;~
~Lw\jS
-------------------------------
l.l"L.i
Ji 4::"..;JI
~~\
~l\.\
~~ 1f'1 ~
~l>i
L.J# ~~)
~.~ 0i ~
.~~I
4.k~\
i}.JI'
!J~\
JL. 0~
~
.)\,..:e\'\ ~I
..w
.:)Jl.';.7S'"\'\
J'!_,Jill
J.iJ1 ~ \ ~
~ ~
r-W I
... 18
Y.WlI.J
~)
~J
~WI
c:f :~ J)
~I~)
~~I
~WI ~\
j*
~
.j~'
&
~WI
~_rll
~i
t ;.. lwVQ
~I
~\
l:-j
.~I_,.4J1
~J
.I"q
~..bv ~
~y4J\
·1 ~~
y~\ o~~
~~J
~W\
:\
,~\1~\-,
~~+'OIJ
.. \..
... t, rJ 4~
.. \ · ~')~ ty'y
\c('
~yL4..JtJ
l\
~.1U
l' '\
,~
~J~j
Ji J.:tj\S
o~ ~
~\,)' ~.lIG
~L...W\ ~
r~
~
')~
\-g;,.
0\
0y'
.!l}.::. .1iJ
,LgJ ($~I
C~)-A:1I
.f' ~1.s:J.1
01 ~
,J_)WI
~I
u~
l>?
.bl!..i
J~ \~ ~
~
w~l ~
~~
~_"'I
&-
c.?t..j
Jl
0t5"'
~-.)2l\ ~~
if 0:!~1
L "'"~)
.!l1.11 -=...~
J5'
~I
~
..w ·u-W1
JlJ ,~
~WI ~~~I
~
..kl!..:J1 C~
JI..y ~.!;.k
«J'1~
'ii» (.S""_)..u.1
r-I.~I
JlJ ,oJ,~
.,;.J4)2J'-'
~l.a> Jll:~.kA ~
4.!.. ~1
Ji
~
:i.,<2~1
~\.J.,-,
~~
~
<\JL.I_)-~~~
l.._.,t> \~
'-0.)1 ~)
4~
• \~'MRj
~~
d ~ ~")\.S:J\
~I
(.$~~11
~ ~
r-WI c...r-"')
l-
<3»
u.r.f..l.Y ~)
($'_)dl
-=...I~I\ 0\ ~
01 ~ f-...b:-J
JbJ\ ~_.,.aJ\
.~}.".....;
F d ~\
-!)fl ~~I
o_)_,:j\
if ~\
A!.~w:. ~\
i.}JI ~
~
~.r"'_r
~I Jd;.
t
i-L4
IJ f~
J~J \1\
~.rJ1
'i t...y ~~
Werner Heisenberg,
Philosophical
Problems
______
~---------------------I~ ..
lJ'.t;i"t.
O~,~--
.'.~I ~"J
-,j~JU!l UUJJ.!
J» ~~~...Jl J\J~
"
~~\
0i
1 ~b:-
tll ..... ~..,..ll.r-l-) ~_rJ.I ~.!:kLr t.~ L.l...:.1 ~'S' ~G 'tyP_,l.I - ~UJ\ ~ ~')WI .:f
4o-iJ'
",.
4j~
~L.,)'\
t.>~\
r-lWl_, ~I»
.-
~\:S" ,_}
r.~y.
iJ.-fo
0'"
..u=.L.. te JJLJI~I
uA ~I l-tJ
..
J!
,,-pI
,.
O~)
~~I 0\ ~)
,.
\~ yl.) {(~...bJ1
ylkJl ~)
~I li-,:!~I
j:.\;~-; ...
,:r J ,4j1~~~I
~~~
~I
I~
,.
.
I
t_f ~
~4~1
~~.r.-W ~~I
,.)UG
0~IJ
4 ;;.JI
..
"h
0.r.f-
..w . b~~1
_#I
..:,..4-41 01 ~
,ill
&.
"
WyW
J.Aj ......
,.
J~I
-':!..b:-
~..uJ\
JS" ~_,.I!J
J_rU\' ~J
b..,:l!J ";;11!J~al!J
~~I
J-
~I
,,4-11 if
J~'-' ,pi~G ~4..rt5::JG ~'11) tS.)\lG ..!,.I wi ~\... .~..b:- _)"!."lij Jl ~~ oJ...
\...1.
~.1'" ~1('1:I('f
L
\,,4,.,,; \j~I';,
.y>_.J1
1<'" ~ ...
';~
:.i;,JiU Jl.lll
'V 0_,ill ~~
~I)
#-
,.
0\....j
Li
f.)~\
~\5l1 0.)\11
~l>-
dUJI ~~I
\'1
r ...i:i
~\
JWI
LI.J') 01
- uA
~I~
,~,b4:1.1 4=i~
tlJ
tl
~\J.)
~
)1
,.
...:....;\.s' J.A.l
l..5"ij
!l_,:.:.11 ~~_,i\
<.SI ~_rJ.1
u~1
~>Jh
.:.J'" ~I
~~
Jl
j OJ~
~I
i~4
ul'llSJjI
~Ull
~~j::AJ1 ~W.I
\:>.-}~I
..;.. \I)..\.. ~
c: '-:li;\
·~
wl;).1
~,,,
~J
Li;l1
_fD1_,W1 4..-..G.)
J~
t.i
w!!
~J~\
$
{,!J o-.UU~
_r:A!,J
w\s" .lA.h : J~
toj \'1 ~
-
,,1J..,p\
~I; wi
'l_,bQ.)I
r:.r t\:;'~~J j\.. J\l')II j _,._J!ill ~_)a; Js- ~.J~I o)~1 ~: ..:JI ~)a:J1
-
Jt~£'1
cY ~I
#.
~:u.:1' ~~
~
~\
~\...Qi
v~)'G
..
J\S"' u=ll
~~Q:I\
~llil
~~
'1' ~
t..;J.A.l\
4...~..liH YW\
cY ~I
0'"
~__w
u.J~4 4=11 A
0\5"" ~I
41 A4B
Ji JL.!.:S1 ~
u.,s
U.Ml.~
--------------------------
JL>.b ~
~,
--
lJJ~i).~..
c.::t~'fi ----------------------------0\J
~I
L~I
~.r.>- ~\j
.~
- ~\J \... 01
~I
~~ ,.
~~I
":"~r
;U~~)
~J
is"
~I
wl
'~j
~
" )1
La.r
.~I
L... y. ••
ul_.# ~
4::--~
..
_:'~~4 4J
4i.l.1' J; ~! ~ ~
8 «4)~~19 )1
~_,..;.,)) ~I~
y."JI ;~I
L~I
~
r-l~ r..J
~ ~
~
l·
A '\
0_,.~
U..
~.iJ1
\
•
~ ?Jf.J.. J\iJ
~J.J.j)'\ .. -
:....J'J 0. iJ d J..J"
.....,-;7
J'.
..
\ - ""..
JbJll~J ~I ~ \:,~
0\11 ~~\11
A_..~I
~
~I_,.i ~
o»~
~\j
0\",)1
~I
,.
rJ+Al ~:,..:14
jAJl
- i~1 ,~}Sl
o.la. ,~
J!4,u)
W~ a~~1
~~
.l:... ~L-;~I
",:-GJ
.,;,-;iG·~G
~..w ~
~G
\",l.,j
Ji
..
~_)&i
t_y',4!
<.S..ul~I
~..\..Qj
i~~
~L.I ~~_)2;)
Cr" ~).
o.u. u\$"")
·u"~kll
r-W' t:_~ ~
~)
~u...
o»~~
fi ~I
r-lWI
~)
·~~k!\
~\) ~~I
rjJl ~ r..li:ll
lS.,.I"p
~
~W.I
~
j~1
~I
~~
J.:..
~ ~I
..
. ~j~1
~)
,.
" ,~j\11
o.1A
oj_,. ($.L.p ~
Jjl ,~\5:J.1
Jk4 ~,
~
j:k4\11 jk4)
J~
~)~
,.
4.iIS"J
~i
~'_,l2J\
JJ~ ~
~~.JA
Jll~)"
j
\~
\1) ~
."..\#' ~
~1a!l
y~'
JJ:J
4J.,;$"J
~\5'" ~I
\.;J ~b~J)\
J..s-)
.:i;Ala~L\ ~~_,J\
~Iy. ~ ~~
;~L!J.l
~JW\ ~'.lH
'~J
~I
0jWI
· ~!:.b"
,.
."..!_,l;J1 r~\ ~
;.i.:lWI
Jl wt5:J.1
J:,~
t:
~ \i_),
~./'
~G
1l+,aiJ
~G
. ,~):-')II-
-~I
\j_.?.)
4t~\...al14.f.ll
Jl":-i
Tychism
•
J1k1-
~WG
~~I
.J)~I
Jl
a..L4;
Hans Reichenbach; the philosophical Significance in Readings in the phil. of Science; H. Feigel.
New york Appleleton'
~v
LuS (_WI\.a~
t.kJ1a ~
--------------------------
------
---
4,1,ii6M
... •
-:.a\..wa,.( -r_,-
~L·.:q .. ~~
cr"
~\_l:.q ~ ~ J>-I
~
~ ~
·_C
r:
,~.
~
C'
.ts:J.\ ~'
UI
,~Qi.
~'ACH u- if
~ ~\.l1
I
::::l,_tl ~\......i),1
"
$.
A~.~ •.,;.
0~ C..,-ll
l$.l11 .r+e: ~J
o~
~~J
..
· o--4~\
'II
o.l:..b:-oJY ~ ~J)J.I
~L,a.:il\ J~
41_,A....
4bJ ~\_,...;:,)l1.r.P )1
r-:.li JS'
)'y if)I
0G
'~J
4......
d' ~
,a:J ~
WG
0J~
J4o;wMfl 0\$"
~
,~
o~_;
..
)\.1,\ ~
;.r ~":J if}I ws-- lJl JI.i - if Ji\~ ~J O~\J ')\ ~L~ ~l>'i\ /~ ~W- d ~ bl/il .!.lli 0J-4J
;ijY\J \
0'" (,$ /1
&.
L~
~ Iy.#.
Js~
)~I
s;.1_,..p I ~
~
t.p\>. ~
lir·,a.- ~
;,!"",,I
(.S_;>-\ ~Li.
~!~I)
d~\
.J~~)
J:,l!.J\
(~)\
t~r)
~I
..::.;1.l11 ~
')f~i
~I
U').J.J ~~
~_,.w C'__,...J\
Jl ~
i__,1;
J...!.i) cwyw')l\
Jl
o)~'Y1
I-
r,.ts.,
~J~~_!:j)l\~
~~.
A __
~\
ir--ll
~
ul-.J\ l5~\
~L;J\
.Ls.~ J\j. \~ ~ .~
0\
J\
"
.?jJ~_;.!~)
~
J!.- ~
~I
~
i_,lJ1 ~l:.....:
~\J.)'YI ~)~ ~\
~I
ii~\_;')1\
..:.,_A1)
if
~
tl
A..~
r!\:;;
s.1$'.AJ\ ~)~J
J")\>
U"L. Y
~..b:-
~~\
~} ~ ;"""I)~
~
V j_f.l) · O~~
)I.kl
d tp:.~
r ~.r'
d 4l-t>:J
~~
iwS.l11~~
0~
~..r-:!_,_J\ ~I
~~
\.a ~ ~~... 1
~I£" ~ ~)~
(,$_;_,jadl~~l
rJf ,a .. LI)'.4
~~
~
? ..lAJ . 4j~1
')1\
~UJI ~
0~
~
u=dl
uh~1 ~
;""'G-=>
Jl
J....?j ·
~..u\
J,l!..;j1
~ I)) \
Jl>-)
~\
,~_rJ. \
J:, l!.J \ ~ li
_,s:.
J..yo ~
".Y
t_,..p_,11)
.1WIJ
;.
.t,_,..p}~ .1~)
01,.4: ... Jii ,~~
~ ~\
06:- ~ ~
~
J>-..li ~ PI~ op
w.JJ._f& ,~\ ~
J~
01 ~
~)
if)
.~ll.'jl ~_,;~)
,~I ~I
J!.
,~~)lI.r";:'"
~)JJ
._:,")b:..1 ~I
if)
~
e ,4-)1
0\5"
:lftl
~
J~G ,~
LJ"J ':l~\
\.:..t. ~I
~\
Jl
~L:JI
(iW1
Jl ~pl
LJ"
~I (.51 ~~\
C:!\k ~
'-: ~ ~
~1
J#
---------------------------
~w~ ~
uk-
~A
--
~ .. .1,i'lnMA
ulw\·< ----------------------------~
...b:- ..}) ~
,t'':.A
~)\i.:j
4...~;":; ...:...~
~b:-
~J
)p
·J
'-lJ
Jl)2i .d ~J..iJ1
~1..iJ1 ~
~I
~
~
U'j,)
y~
~
~I · J~~ J:,\.~.)
~~I ~_:,~\
~
;.;_rJ.1 ~
~." ~)~~
~~
~) ~_rJ.144"
uUJ\)\ 0J~
#
t.~)I)1
4.i1 (.S.~
:~WI uPI_,>J4 ~~
'--'
~6;. p.o.:.!)
Ie.
.t._,..;:,)\
Js_u
b.~;11~\jJI
.
.• ...lJ•
~
~ \
..
:~J'
01
,~,;;> t~}ol
J~ d J:,L:;..JI I~
._;,l-:~ L>..iJ1 ,~\..u\
~J
· ~).I
~4,J1
~}14
f.~I)
!JG~)I1
~'-!~\
j~4
~\k
.kl!..i
J~
J"
to- ..illl>~\
t.~)\
,L).)W
<:::s:u
«~j~)
uP6:-
6.; ~
\~'N.ij
- ...::,..1.lJ1 4.i~)
.._:..\.,Ak
)1 .,:_, \I.?- ~
J-': J \-k..~;!
d~ I ~\
.J~
.J I : \!J1j
.~ .....
4,~! ~_:,l!.j
#.
L._:- ~~
...w:.
~J
'11~.)WI
;ijW,1 ~
~
<.>L
u\..._r-j~
~J
assimilation
\.:..aI ~WI
Jl s:-lS).A.lI
(4J)'_';:'J
i_r-j~1
· ~ _)JJ ~\.) ~
.)\~Y ~\f ~~
'+l' ~~I
rJ::>J
~}l1
~
JAW! J1 J~
f..
...
IljjUffiOib,hUI1
~ ~p~I
'~J-:'!.~
~
~\.,t'':''
.,:_,tkk;¢.\ ~
JlSJl
\I) ~~
~~J
~ ~I
4S")~ w- ~\-b-}1\
~
d )1
~
~ ~
r.1
\~~
li~
J ~ ~ 1--4~
JAW I J:4,:.",:!
~)..;:jJ ~~\
~ ~
JAW \ 0~
J_,.bJ JI ~
JJ~J
~
WW\ u1kk;¢\
d o.!>~\
~.J~
~\.....bJ1
~
~
c: ~I
~
~~
J:.
oyil ~
0_,,:;l.JI U" ~J
yL,,!::.. Ij ~ .)
s:.
' "-0~
~4 01
~ ifJ
~
4~:-lJ
r:-~ ~~
JI
~
by..r I.kk;.,...
~)IJ
~
.~~I
,~U:k~1
~Y~.Lo.S:'
4~1
~
di1:Q: .. '".! ~I
o~)_,.1I u4-41
~
.J"""l:&. ~
~')L.J
~I),)\
4;;:11~J~
0\ ~I~I
d JAW I
~
~H ~
·o~~1
0~
~~J ~
• u~1 JI
~s.1)1
u~1
f')W
.u\.lak:>.....
.J;;:'iU
-----------------------------
~:tl!i; ....
~l...'JS--
'. ;.a:!
~
~
s.L..J&. J
:i,J.rJ I •.:.AiJJ ~
~~I
,~WI ~
r-'"-" ~
#.
·~~ ~I
~
'11 ~l4!l1
;.ill!_, ;.;_roll ~
}IJ
r-'\&. ~~
Y
~J.riJ1
iblS' ~I
~L.,~..LI~~
~G
ftL.,
~f
»--4
J~ ':JJ
':JI ~) Y-J'?':JI_,
if ~
JGJ ~
~
:ik;.c.1 ~l~
AUL.G.)J'A~o!'''J J\.....ajl
0J§' J'L.~
~Ji
~J
;,p.
Js- o~t
,lfJ ~
0)1.i
~
($...La
J'_;JI
J10J~
~
lau
-J
~I
01_,,~I
0J~
~YJ
~IS'
~\:;.JI
~J
e:'1)1 ~~
. ~ _,..ill lil
~_,;li
J'L.y
I~
y_,L.i ~i
4Ji J.
,~IJ
J~'J4
u~1
~J
~W JI.J~
..lA.IJ
4j;-11 ~~
-L4'; ;.)~j
~j'l\
~!'!;
~L.,G..u1 J\,6_j
L#~J ~\
J,
($\
'lG
$.
4jJWI
..
~ljJl
~:!......
1J\.....) r'J.,;...::· .. 1
4W ~
dl,_j'J\
4J
.1.~:iJ
~
4J\_j'J1j-.I
~W'JI ~~\
~
~I
~I
..:J\&.~_,ll
~ ~
c:~-'
~
rl
(0L.i'J1 \.-:_.", ~I
L. JD ~l..;~\
0..L. lp _r.U ~\
Js-
i-,~
J'~\ ~b:.
.. ~G.)G
~W.\
i~\I\
~~~I.J ..
~f)\ ~)L!.'ll
J~
,. ·JW)'I
~ ~4
tabula
..:..t.:J ~
~J
s.~
.r.J ~\., ~~
~\.oQ!! ~
\~ u\S'
~ ~J
- ,~1j:.I1 01.J
6-"
.JAJ J,l.!..:J1 \~
i, ~~~\ J
t L...>.".
l>.lJ\ ~\
~lll
~
~)lJ c_..r-lG
~\?I
I..L.
·r).J1 ~~~\
~1 ~.1A.i
~l:SIJ
~
i> ~I
~rll
._;)~ ~'J
~i
I_r.I if~_,J.\
••
l
\..~
~I
~W, ,-,,'
~
~\j:.-yJ lb~.,
1'-\·' U· -
o}~.o~
u\
~fi ~
!#~
~\J
&
4.il jS\i J~
. 0\
t~."..
zww ux •
u;.
'J.J'!4,. ~
J. .~~ ~
~)_}
J~
~I
JA_, ~~\
~_rJ.1 .J~
4JJ
~L.)I
tll.S? 4J...w
u,s ~la.J.i ~
~
--------------------------
r.
--
~~
~-; ]JI
4:",:14
'::
;;.J~
~
~}j
.! ..
4AS- <.Jb
I. ... \ ... , I:c.
I ." •
':r Lf o...l>-Ij
~
c...~ ':_ .. i
,'l L...J 1
~
".
\..1.. "lI1_;....~\
4i__,.l1)z:iJ ~I )
JI .vl~ ~I
.J'6 jA ~~I
~Ip
__,..l..
:4):< ~ "lI~
if ..I.>G
e.
;,1.1::..IJ ~
~~
~I_;
J,L!.J
~}j
LA!S'J Y ~~~,
;;.)~)
4$.J... ~
.J'6 ~I
,.
01 J.,AJI ~
..
h.Qi
A~
'r-WI
wl_j~1 ~..\>I
4J
J1
~I
($JJI ~li\ if
. ~I !£\lG
J__,1
~
tJY 0G · JJWI
~I
~
~
o.u. J_,.k:oJ
J# t..~
01 ,~I
~}j ~I
La~
($JJI_, ~I
~}j
J!--
~}j
4';, ..~
,;>II-$:_Oo/.J'"
~
l.S"u1 ~~
,ii..b- ~
w\-b:J1
\J.A j
JiJ ~I
"
. y':>\iJ Y1
~ ,!jb
JIy.":J oIjl ~
wt$'
I...b:-
~..b-
rWl
~\~
tJ.J~
,!j~
J·
i'-:aNI
I~
~
..wJ
,~\
..
.w ·~laJj"J
~
J~ ~ .~I
,-
o.u. ~ cr
.~
JJI ~
~
,.
LA> . 4-;!4-A~
Lr'Y- '1
iJ 8 4"
J~ _y&
~)\;
~\J
·~\
,. ~}:.l 0WI ~
Jy_'"
~
I.'j
J)I ~ 1oS.lJ1auL p
r
tannery
.s_r.i\;
tJ!J 'J.
~ \.. ~Ij
I -.
- 1:.-.' .. ~i · ~~ ..
- 0J~ ~I
J_,.w
0~'1
A ~
~I
~
J-JJ
'al LJ, 1 J "'d '. U 1",- P 1_" .. :.i;4 .. l.;l! ~WI 0'11p
tb:"J.r.?- ~
.t.M..
'r-LJI
iiJ~
, j ~ u~ J ~":JJ .~
b.JI_,::l1}
jY ~~
01 ."""1.'1 rWl
tJY-J
.o~
~~
~~
",;i
t6:.I..1:.I..1 ~\.i")\.J1
~I ~t>::ll 4JJ>-J ·
A:?
.J'~J
.~I
t.i
.0~I
L ~~
~
~~J
,$ ~~'-' ~~~I
~:'I'';i
'>-JJ
'~lf.;':i\"
Jl
.14_
J~
·~~
;.;~ ~
4..p.-J ~b
~I
)2.JI ~tp...J
iL!.;
Lf'
LS.lJ\ r-LJI
J~ ~
i
~
~I
~'>'-JJ ''''-il~ ~
u ,'1
I!I'_'"
U1)
J',"
jJL..'j
--------------------------
~'(2!f
~~.:II
~w...J\)$ ~
t:-):; ~
if)
.J:.,4s)~1_;_,k;J\ \..1.".
",:",Ut.~G
o_;yW) ~\
~)\1 4......ly,) .. \ ~
J..A.l
If\ ~1
~
'~I
_;_,1d ~
Jl
if ,-;,.~ r-LJI
(:::)\:; 0~ ~..ii
~)I
d) .~)
)y-I
~
1)\ ~~~
~
~'i\ ~4
~
~j'~~\
~\
~i
,.
Jl
'irPJ ~~Jall)
if
~
jA.JI _;1_r...1 ~)
I~
J\.~ ~~_.... t\
Jl
'r! ss:_rJ
0L;}'\
~l
cr"
~.
w!)L...I.~
~_r.d\-, ..... ~I
'u.;MttJ..1
i ..~ t,
.c_\\ ~
~)
~i
~~~
,,'''\.z._C:--\
'-:
~\; '1\
o~
~)I
0~ ·Oj~1 ~l.e
d\......\
I.i~
Js-
i.$~\":2:')I\)
L?-""}~I)
~I-;;~ \'\
~~ ~
wI.:, a} ~
~b:-)
d ~.)\'oa,:;'JI
~
.~\)yW
~}:.l\ ~~\
~J
~)
~
is" ~6A
Ji_, .~Ll.1
'::iJI _Jib
JJ~
r-Wi t_;..;... 01
)\ ~\y ~~
~
~~':JG ~~\)
~..lJ' ~lil!.5\'~ ~
_)J-14j
r
\
~J
-
\~ L._,:
~\ ~
F
Jl4J~
,I.
I-
,64'. _---' ~ ,~
:--W'
•
0\
~,.
'-ii'.J
I~>' o,L..-v
__, •
fl.
~\
lu,Q4"i '-.5 ..
J\
J~
o_;~~
L.~ U ~\
¥
~1
I
Ji ~
~...._ 1.\'.
j~
~i Ih if pi) ·4.l
...... :
f_
A_l:;z:ll \.HI}
i
~~.~~
l(I/J
J_'
l
_;_,k;
... \
I ~y
~
./
~u.' ~'.)~
• t (,
It ulJ;llijJ ~ ·
II .r:J....~~l
.1
_,l~I
~_;Y.)
j:o>-_;_;l\ ~
~L,.. ~ r-WI .W
.r»: ~ ~
~_,jd ~j;:t\
U~\J~ ;.)~ ..
b..l:>-)l ~\;
.~~;k!G ~\)
~I_,.QJI
if ,_Q.:.5JI_, ~
~_J'-:; c-:_,l
~k:ll ~~)
j,j~I
..:r-:~lo'r;i'JG u.....)U.HJ
~
u)l~
d ~WI
. .~\ ,
---------------------------
(.US LWU~
r~
__
r~
r-LJI
J")\:;.JI
'11 ,I~~
JIy. '1
r-WI f:jJ'u
t~ ~ r'-
Jl
I.)J§"
jJJ ,~t.;.. ..
~
~I)~IJ ,~I)..ul ~
I~b
w~
cJ
J.ro
r.J.AJ
r-LJI
#
:u_,.ll J~J
!lla ~i ric.>
r-WI
Jl
_d.
tL.WI ~}dl
J.:j
tl,..J'"
LS_j .~\-1J\ ~
J.A
,-P.,4-;
J__,..... 4.lJ1
c.>...La
Js- ~WJI
~
j1;
~}j ~ ~U!ij~1~
JIJ ~ (.S~I
,
~..l+.!L. t:t}:ll ~ ~
jAJ ~~ij!hJl~
~_)dIJ
" ,
Jeo
~J
~yWG ~G
..
u--W1 ~IJ
tL.L!. ~IJ.')
•
oJ wi rl ~~~
~I_;.U JI
I.)~
JAM-... Jl ~I
~ ~I
bJ~~
6!}.:ll Ih ~
t.j!J ~I
~I
"
~bJ'
,:.f' yfl
~ ~~I
<:..r.i~
~
t4' l-J ~
#
b~
~f
!-o;"~J
r'
.;1.-4
t.jl ~
/;
..:.i)1 ~I~
<.l
C3_)1J
yl-!-:, ..\
_)_,.bJ
0'" ~I..ul
, r-LJI J~ ~ r.J.AJ j) 01 " '"r'lu,.., ~ J'~iJ WI ~~~)I .bl J~ • ~ .!.H)~ 'lG ;';..,.J.I i~~j I.)~ IJ.S::.J ._)~G u~ tala. ~L.. ..:,..ls\oP! ~I J~i tY ~ J.S"" ~ ,)} § JG ~WI «~»~~ ~WI ~ j 0'" ~\:::J~ .')J.? I~ J ·~lc;')lJ1 ~~~ '11 ~ cr i~'-' ~~I ~ wi ~I !lG.)'11
W \5:11 ~
•~ uO,_.
t
Jl
~I
J1 ~I.....II"
.;.,l;L~tS''1 ~l;:j
~
~J."
~;; .. ..1~
~ b.JI ~ ~ lS:. ~ I
~ ~,
.').J.&. ~
• 1
.II"
M,tj ~~ ~
0\S"
:.H
~
(')
.....
~~).lJ
~J ..... 4MJijJI ~
!l~~G 4-i1_,JI~~'il
~
..
~)
~lli)ia;_,J
~"""'J
("_,wI
~j
~L...WI
if tY\.W t..J;-J1
~b-.:l :iJ_,\-..
~I-, ..... ~
I.)~I
~~~~~r: ..~
~.') ~I
~_,.. 6 A,!
Js-
b_)~ LG.!I
C WI) ~I
~I
wG
•
iJ>.
• ~!;.'Z.: .. O_)Y?l
" wWI I~ ~ ~I
,;,; ..liJ ~).:l
History
of ~I
~G
~_)~ iJ'4~ b
"?.liJ
Science, Department of the international Union of the History and phil of Science.
,r ~
(.,WI\.~ ~
------------------------
-----------------------------
~J'Ji;ua.A ~\..w.l~
--
~
r
.,:_,~ ~~ JS' ~y
~WI c.~1 ,~
,.
C)~I _,>:...J~I ~
AI- I_II
~
~\..!...,
U :i,;.~~';I~
~Jl:l
~
cr
~I)
L 1:11
.L
o}I..u1 ",.iA ~
'.)/1)
~I
JJ"I ~J1WJ
~\...:2j
i~ ~J4
~I>.~
J'
~I
~I
JJ:J ~y
~).:d ~ lS.llG
'~Ao
...\J..;11 ~I
~I}
C:!UI JJ..u1
" U""la.~1 A
~;il ~_r:-\
c:r
~I
~IJ;.
Jl ~.J;!
r' \ if ~J~IS"
4_·f"J ,~}:jl
J' ~I
0~
J!.a
l;~
"::"'~~y" ~
..::,..~Jl\
~b:-
oJyJl ~
.)\.;"')'Ij
,~~I
cipt'WI
~_,J.I ~
~\ ~~-J
~
#.
(jJJ~J ~I
J:J4:J,1
4.bt,41
~FI ~)
~_,Jy.!-4 \'G
~
J.)L41 _r-1WG,~_,J#G
~')\..JG
,~I
~JD)
..:..1.A.vl.;J~I
~I
if ~I ....
r-WI
'~G
JI
. ..
~
r-LJI ~
~I ~
l~~
~ l:-: ;.~U
)1 ;kl.JG
~\
~lA!JG
·
~
~)
~WI
JJ..u1 ~j11
~~~
~ ~_"'I
c..J_,..JJJ ~~
Jti L.
~.rU ~I ~
fi-b.-)
G. HULton
~I d~~1
J?~ .~
~):d\
'4 ~J
"V,
ik. ~y
~ ..1.4...:11
r-LJI 6)l:l
~I
Jl o-4~1
(jJ~4 )'} :~
~6.J\ ~J
j_,1d\ ~
~
41)j if ~1)a.J1
LM ~Ju
,ylt
:;~I
'O~~
~..l=o-
~..bJ\ I~ ,.~
~~ ~
~UI
,.,&- L.Qo~4
,L-WI ~I
~j ~
str--J
JS" Ji LW )~
:;'~.~-JI_:j
4_..W\
\jJ>- 0J~~
Li ~~
,~~
Jl5:;\'1 J# ~~I ~
f:}Ju
~
:;JY
d ~\ 'bJu ~
0.J!"'A
~WI oh ~)
~I
d
#.
,~..wl
~I
~J'u
,-" ._.I
0\ ')U\i 09_yb
'..5"" .
c..Jw,G .~I
u" ·
et
..kL~
~ ~,£
JsJ';'
~l4!l\
4J~1 ~Je:l'
- ..kH r~l-H
~
ib),1
01
~W\ .. ·
.. ..
~t u'Jl
~
UiJ
~I
~
~...J\:j
e~ u\.i ~~ ,~_,wl :r ~ d
W,!.. ,~£
JG)
~W\'1
~\J~ J~~_j\
o_j~~ ~-'
~\-,~ 0\ ;~W\
~~l:ulJ
~W\
ullwji/\ JJlLJ\
. j\ ~J'4'
.>J
~L...\'G
,~~\
,J
~)~_,.....
~>.J\ Aj~
~Iy ~
~jll
J')l>_
I~
I-
u.l!. W.?
4.ly...:..e
i~1J.;,
} if~\'\ ~ ~I
.ra:J~ i~~1
..:..~
..lSiJ
bJ\;
II~
.i. ...
:i.....ly-4 .!.1l~J ~\
Li
ifl--:;:-),I
~fll
~
.~
;,Id
UA<'~
~b~I
:;i~~'
!~J'i Iy. ~
>o~)G
i~ ~Jftl5'" ~ .14.11 ~I
~}:J
If.i~
~
-4..l?J
~_,1JJ ~)a.J1
~U.IJ
.r-: ~I ~~
~I
~\J
..
JJ...u\
_,..Jjll uL...G~ c
!Jb JIy\'
..kWG
,.
oI,jl \ ,\Ao
~J
p •
"
r-LJI b)\;
;......G~ ~
I-
~~
a!~)\
r-lWI
,4-6-
Jl5J\ }~
--------------------------
u.,s C.)M\..~ ~
,f-
__
l,J,i1wW .. •
~L...'.c ----------------------------..Jt-
rilll ~\
J~
~
f:j)\j
6_)J~ IlAJ
~ ~
.Jw'1 ~
.~
~
~J
:i.i.J4.ll d'
j!1_-: ..
_;;!_,1d
~
~J
'11 ~\..
~:< ,.11
4J~
J\.,b C::'YJ
~> ~J
~};dl
~
~
:iA'''~J
JI r-LJI
.r:»: ~~ ~ .WlI ~\ i411 ..l>-i~1 ~}j LG) ~i f:jjv L~~ 01 Jl ~_;ll ,J.>- ~))J.\ ~L.~..u\ A..l;.,a> wJ~G
-G};
~;A)
~I
~I
~~\;fIJ 4JL-y J ~\
~~
'4)I$') ~
($J...
~\.::~
Js~I
~liJ
Jl C~
~
'r
0i
1
~. ~
r.,w~ ~\j~J
..
~}:JI
~\s)1
~
J-!..i ~)
Jl ~\
~L.t:J1"
~I
.~I
&.
t:
~
~\AjJ
JJ~J ,~I
t.~.r
WI
J.:.~j\.. J5'J ~I
~.iS"J
~..a ~.:tk~ .. ,
~r11
~6.J1
~I
t•.;:k LG~
U~4
r-LJI ~
[.\;;;!J .~I
uL-YJ
..u.t.~\
~I
J~
«(ul';!.~))) •..Aj.;,_,A-. :
oJ_,:JI ~
.~IJ
,4....P~
~I
~r1IJ
lfW
'''_jlp-..
,:i,..~
~.rJ1
$-
t~.r ~
LG.lJ i~1
Js~\.:...J
o,~
Q~\k lA!~~
.~I
~_)~I
~.r-11
y.,Q:e.
~r--1J
~I)\
p,,,,.;:J1 ~t5:..1_, ~\
~r--1J ~~'il_,
oJ.<
~A-:l1
~I
~I..b-)I
:f' i_,wI ~
t.J
,.
4,..~
~:,.
;;,.,s::t
.b:-~'l .~~
~u... ~ o_r>- WI ~~
)tk~\ ,~\
U:! ~illl
~)jj.u ~L.I
J ;;~..l$;.
:i:~
t_"';")!
I.h. ~J
~~
e:\.:....
;J'l.ill
,~pl
::iil:;h\
~_rJ.\
wlJ.>-)
Js,.
J~
.~\.All
~I
li~~
,~I
~li..r.
'~)~J
-JS"" '-:" ...- /)I_rJ ,;.!lA... .s~ 0 ~ dk ·a JS' 0':1 I..l:_i..; ~ I c.l,.;a;J .>4 J5"' J$ ~tsJI opl ~ . Ji ~ L. J:a!4i Js-) ·,.>.;.- Js- >~ o" tAI\.# u=11) ;i4:,..ll ubU .... ':I1JI .bJ,r!JI '40~.~ W. lj~ ~I ~._;'oJ :... :} ~} Jr-i :} ~~ Jl~ u ui UJjJ I~f Jl ~ J.' Ji l)jlr Jl ~)J ~'''iJ ·lfJ iJ"\.....),1 j!..J ~I ~I~IJ..~ ':IG .bJ.rJI t.~ ~4-:J1 t.i y. _rl A L" ,;
4;:4!:..ai u\......I)) u~
tJI ..... ~I
L"
.,.j
L"
.J~
\f; ... J
:~
u\_!- ....... ~
..J'a'"
;4: .. 1\
j,J.f~HJ
~\~L..lJII:."')'\
o.h.
~J~\
4;A ..·U
,«.ul~
r~ J.;-
koyre
~J!.§'JJ.;". s:JI
l,5",!:kll rlWl
Ji.a
TouLmin
_
,0
UJS ~L..jJ ~
---
____
., ~
--f
1,1.i;;.u ~~\.~
.. • '...I"'"
_-
r-IWI '.$) uW__,:l1 w-- ~L.I \kW\ W ~~ ~'-' ~_,k1,-, ~")UJ\ r-t- ~y .. " .. .)..li! ~'-' L.5' ,'+)~ r-lWI JU (,) ~ (51 J; 13jJ,;'1 WI ~ h 4J')\>. cr 4lt J~ L. ~.llJ J. (e:!~_,u ~~~) ~ J.w ~ ,4JL ~I ~t;I W . ~ r-lt- l:J .)~ ~I alA (,)1~\ ~ll.y »s .w ~~...J~ ~1j}1 . ~I ~I.b- '11 . .. ~\ ,~I~')IJ lS'!":hll _;u.~ ~}A..J \.:...I_r.:. .. ;i r):-3J W.J> r-IWI ~ tSft~
(.5
0.1- ~
~
WJI
~~
t.J J.\i
0\ ~
_;~'11
~
~ ~
,.,.
01 W ~
''=;0 .. ~
LJI I.-A;';'!J
~\ ~\
J.
_;."w
~>c:.r
.o.>~1 ~I
!.,
,j;
rj.;-J~ ~I
~I~
~
. ~4
f,
I,)"J..li ~J J-4
\:J~ ~J
~I)'11 lS~
~::hl\
~I
~\:S' ~ ~fi
~I 0Jp dL._,;.~
uGp' ~::!»
t ••
u _r.!J ..u ~I
~}j j ~I
~)\j
'-'JWI ~
Jl
o~1
0i Jl Dudley
("t)J'> ~ ~
shapere ftl.!.
J,:,b
~
~J
~I_;
~
.;;././>
4.c:.
~
.M.t ~ ~I ~ ~
~I
If J\A:j'11 0i ~
0Jr-"WI
~..rs1
u~)2.i ..)
..w.i ~L...-:.\
~
vv
(J~I
~~.>
Jl_,k....) ~~.)
U--1.u ~
~li")W\ Lf ~..b:- ~
.J..t',.t: ~
..I...! ~J
~~
~lf..J1 cJ
\.l ,~\A..
~\kl '-+f~IJ
\,.p~ ~
.kJ~
<\iIJ ~
o~
Jl
ul~1
y. (Sri
~!"'"
ubl..l.-: ...\_'
Vy:J1
~\._..\'1
~~WI
0jWI
w--
'1r-'~ _;s1
~J
~I
,+-,.v;
ds- ~
~I
ts.)L:lI ~
.~~'J
.Jj
~
~~
~I..l>1 ".
~}::JI
•'-fi'"
J",Jd1 LJ\ Jl
~
I.-;-
~~I
i~..b:-
~I
•
c:-"';"..w)
£
e; ~i
($r'11 J')..ul
01 J_,AJI ~)
o~1
· .~\rl \~
~li
h-*",
rJ' ~IJ
J. '''':!%lJ
alA ~~
O~J
Js- b~
~~I
~J
~~JG
uP
l\
u~1
~~J ~I
J)JJ
4!G_t..21 ~.~
UML.~ ~ ~
----------------------------
__
.1 ,lei;'M. 4!a\.w\.(
.,
.,:_,~
'11 ~
. 0G
Jl t_J
([J\.!.~S"'~
~\I.
. "'-i~
Js- ~~ ,~,
r.1A:.lG ~\
~\s:.
01 jp.. ':>UI_,
4';
• 4JI~
~.:S"")'I
..lo! ~
._j\
t~
~I
~I
\J.)~I
~h .r.PJ c..>.,JIJ
~I
.J
~L;JJ ~)~ 1,._1) ;U-,J ~ LLr .)~~ ~I bJ~Jl ~):.1 J )\1\ .r.. 4:11.J'" 1.lAJ - .)'>~ ii..lt!? ~\iW,1 r-i r..u:ll ,y
H
t_ii.ka~LI ~~I
rW ;_.~.)t~.r ,.
:iL')U 0\ ~
~ ~\
")\..Aj
IoU ·~\
r-W'
~I
£_Y- L"::l
~
«rS'I?1
H .• 0\ ~;')I .li
uAk:J1 ~I
l!..!-
cr
"'~I
~:k
~.p_J1 J..16-:·-;
u..u~
~~
"'!;~
0yWI ~A~
.J"'\...J ~I ....
J> ~I
r-LJI L~.)
~\J
,.
~I
t:)~ .j_?U
($1 ,~
<->_;>"iII.l";I..u1 ~
.. ••
L.s-
~,;.
~~I
.J~~
"
J_,AU ~I
:ii .• it
Jl
($rl
l)s- l ~\
)~I
~)\j
J,W\
r.J\:; )~ 'c.S_r'
tJ?1
Js-J ~\
JI ~;J.I
..
f ..
o/,,\.\;) \kL!.;
,~
JJ.)JIJ
" )I_,kl
}S~i ~I
~
,_
,
~}~_,....
~'''ll.
'4J
r
~
~I
..:J~I
(f ~~J
\;..l...
u-::lJ ~I
..bW~
~j ~
Wl
1.1..
JS"
~I
,~.
~p
44.....li if I~f:,~I
~l,a41\ !..s_,;:-
.~~
\JJ') ~
..
:~.;'}I
L)-ll.1 &
.l";'
o~
~~~I ;..;.J;
~...dl" ..liJ
L~ ~ _
lfJl~
0'J
..
..!.1J~
$-
)* -
,-;-u.->-
.~I
~i
'J}
~I
o.:JWA;
J.~ ~
~.,a; ..
J-W
'+~
o.ha
~I
WI JI ~~
..
JrY
\...:.!
'r-W'
($P-
Js-
0'J~1
J.
i.)..b.,..
uA
,~)..:.\'1 ~I
"'i~
J'+ ~
-. #
t;~JY ~
I-
...:..~..
J"t2"4i
~I
.,:_,L..,...
I~
~I
J_,-Y 0i - ~u
,~
~\.,!". .j;1\
JS"
W ~~J
~I
~I
~~
J:.:la;
J":>6:-
If
r'
· ")\.4": ... ~I A
:Li •.~ ~~
~!.r-_4:l1 ~
~L.pJ4 li.)J..r-
J- J-,~
~.4la:tl ~p:J1
ji - wu
rv
UJS
UMl....jl
J:u1s ~
-------------------------
------------------------------
l",i;~ .,.•
~J.ij
~~~ '.,J~<--
~~
~ u
4...41:1\ ~....~-q ~ ~~
~.1. ....1
~\.J)
'4~~:1 ---.~,
".\...t)l\.-' ~
~('z.t\
o\.;.,.~
. o~~
c!l}1 ~
~I
r-W~ ~J
I.::.l 1 ) l:;ll
J:....:. ~
1..La.~ ~jf.1
.r«}:;J\ )_,la;:j i
~ l.
01 I.S_T..
~\)
0).!l
~
~\
'.r.y.
~
.)
J.j_"~·:U
J}.s"
.ft""
)~I Ih iJ\&.\ ~\
~
if)
·~
~I.J._,;J\
1)1 ~J'-'
fiY.
,:,
J~\
\.Sf\_j
~l_,J
Jy.J
v):> · ,",."
)b:-I ..k.i) ,
(I.~I
'",0"
i~ .!l))\
fiy. J)IS'
J_,. -¥I
it.. ~ ~ft.~1
J1 ~.J
~
JJIPJ ~ ~~
\jly
JIAt
....;\..;£)'1 ~)
~J\j
u
r) ~)\
!.~
!-oili) <\.,4,)
ic. LJ\)
.J •..J.
.J
J
~~q ..
.J ....
J~~
J
J\
F·
S'jJ~
~
.J~\. •
l. ~6:~\.;.JI
~~}
P \ .) r 6J 0\5"' 0'-' ,~
~
<,Ai-:.,;.j
~I ~\
.l::i ~
t
~ ~~)'I
~AII
~k;~1
~
..!JJ~ ~
WJI
~J
~I
~K...\)
W-J\
~!~
uPJ.ril1
'ifl~1
~J
J~
.~j
J:!> d'
if
~_,.-P
_r.S1 ~
} u,Jr
.!) ~ ._;,.~\
J\i
~W\ ~~
li.1""
J.)~
~
e.
'1 oJ.. J~
1
~
'11 u~
if )J.i
U·~--IL!l..._ J"
..; :~ 0\ ~
~
U: '..
lllIil \
'i't! IJ~
Juti
~I
~~~
~l
Ul .l!)}
0~
.!.U..u
,~L.a;JII-o~j 0J':) ~J
~I
01 ~k: ~l.a
y 0\ _;!y. £ju .~
Lf' ~\
J.;..,~
t..i J-i
~
,t6>Jj ~)..dl
~W~I .... j ~I I
.~J.>dl~~
~I_,.AJI a~ 0J~ ~I ~I
~
\;;lk .. ti.. l~
0Y'.,Q!
Jl J~)I
fo.. ~
en- j~»
:..r->
~4l\
~J
L ....
J~l.
~
~J
~\!la- s-__"';:'
l.a~ \.;yaforce
«~)~~ 01
.} ..:...~
0~'::J
~\j
.~
~.iW\
~ "~J
~
\J.~j
,a->-i...uJ
4~
~
..:_,L;)'
t4lj
U:-il} 01 ·~l.1
~J
~\j
ul}~1
4-i~
,a.ii)..J1 if ~1_;i\'1
d ~_) ' ~ d
~ ~
t_J? ~ _r.y. ~
"L.r·-.
~
I..
lij;
~
J~
~I
·tlJ J
JI ~I
~
WJI ;,;r1G
~
~·YJ .1J?'~ ~J
J5::;
\6"._Qi
..:..l.__,1J.1~
0\5"' I~b .~~I
~\
s.
~» ,y ~I.-;w
.t:......1_,>~ ~L.~ ~~ ~
_ro-'"w .. 1 ~
0h. ~)
~
r"'~ ~r.r
_rpJ
ul.aWI
Ih ~
~G
.~I
Jl
~..llJ
l;.il~w...
___________________________
--
~
~illl
Jl Jj
.. . cr ~P
#-
l".j1 •.." t
u~\ .e
,..."..
~):i
~>:.r lS~IJ
~\
,.
~.;~ iJJ,?
Jl
s:.WJ\ oy~
,.
Jl
01 ~
'i ~ ~)I
~UI
~.J
r~
~IJ ...:..~_);JI
~_,..;.,)\;
·tJ\; ~
~l;jJ
~Ua;)
~_,5J' ~_,J
~)2.i
~rl\
c.?' ~~\
~~
0\ J.y! ~f..J
4j
I-
·44)-.11yL£1
cJ
~~UI~)I
4P~1
,--P
~ ~)I
~
l~~,"~!
F1}
#-
41J~
~)
rtl_, ·41,;)
\~A)~ ~I
Jl:>- ~)
..,J. Ail ~
~
,.
~)a:J\ ;.i",.J.1 ~)
~~
')\.,:1~ ~~
~Q
0\5""~)2J1 ~j
~I
I-
:.r .!..>-WI
ifJ
~J
d L.'l:.:..
~ ::Jr.J
~.",":!
4.i1~I
jAJ ,~
~\.P~
-. ~\
d I_,Qi_rl1 c: ~G
;!S' ~r.)~i
rilll
;~~ ..
~J_,4j1 } ..:...~,)dl if
'f.~
UJ ,Jaj
\;j
f"~
lSlJ
~
d ~\
0~1
L c~;j
~ aJ. ~
~~I
~
,.A
t~ ~~ \ ~~
J\y--)l\ ,y
J\,k; t,.} ~
~I
1k;:~
~ilil
_A
r~'il
..
- Js-Ij~
~
Jb-
g.
($~
lk>Jl ~ ~ _rIA'"
'i ~}
~J
~.r.=J10fo
o.U) .jA..J1 if
r'- U"I_,>JI
~
JJJJ
o:
i~
Jy4J1 ~
,~_)zJ1 ~ _rJ.1
~.J
,..
WI_, ,~I
t9 !"'~ ...:..I~~I
JiJI ~
J~)
4-lJ1
~~I
-.
~
~.iJ;_,.l ~
I~
0'-' ~I
Js:- ~
~
ill 1 J")6:. .r
'~j
uWI JI
~.J)i
JIy~~ )} ~ 01 Jl Wb Qy.
iJL.,.J1
~J
·~ ..-JI..:,..~'-' l ..:,..I}~;,.U
,~\.... tJ\_..aj
J'r -:...~_roJJ .4
J
wldl "':"4~
~_);!jl 0~
,. 01 \~;;k:..a ~
~~)a.:J1
.).M.i ~)
~i ~
Ih ~J
iL.\r1
Jl ;~
it;L:..:S"I
J~
o~~1
.~}.~a:ll ~l:.:J1 ~
r..I.A::.I1
Jl
~
ji'il
""
~
Js~
lS'"~';'
01 JI
~l.1 ~I>IJ
.\wS
0h
~I
Li+!J .~
01
<51 ,~L..
V"L._,J.yl '-1.a.~L.~
:l... b f
oJ} ~~
rLJl ~
JdldlJ
t.1_,...J1
·\~J
J-l50~ .rAj
~I ,.!Jj~ ~
Jl ~ ..a.;j JLtA,:...IJ ~W ;Jb.- .j ~I 0i if JJj if <l,jl \II ~s-~ u-:lJ 4J} r-LJI d rill1 0~ \~G IJi ~ OJ~\j '->fo 0iJ .l.!'i '~y ~t5" 4 OJ.:~ ~p ..r.~ c: '-> J..P LJ"L..,; JA.-~J·~ ~I ~1:i r-W ~G ~ \.....
~ ~ ~
Karl Popper; The Rationality of Scientific Revolutions; in Scientific Revolu- • tions. ian Hacking. ed., Oxford University Press. 1981.
r~
(jII\-.~ ~~
--------------------------
_________
_____.
nj
~I
;JJ6'" ~ ~~
rl,_..·"":!
"'t..l;u
'1) ,~ ~_;l\
~~I )~I
t.~
O_r-'""!
,.
.. .
,..".
J. ~~I
j,~
o.)W,/11
~
~~r-ill
~
~)
o~~
.~.)
#
~j) ~
~ ~.)~
" ~ 01 Jl ~I
J"J~
'r-L4:J4 ~ raJI 0.1. ~-j''?J ~ JjA! 0J§' d\.."_; !5)- ~ ~)I J~I _". _,-4 L.J ~I 01 J_,At_,.)'>4 4...14-:.. "6'r b};; r-WI ' - 1.1. 1.5- ~J .~~ 0.04; 01 ~ lS.lJ1 ol....i'1 1 Js- ~ i, \_;~~..u 01 .. t.l r..Ld\ ~I- ~I " 1.1. d'-J 'i..l4:U )l:- Y'J ~L.. Jl d~4 ~p c.>1 t_y ,. C _t, _9..,. 0\ lS·..•• ~~ ;. ~... W\ ~\, _;yw.. . W~ -'-'li .4,. •• 47 · ~ _. ~ i." .... ~ r\,,1
..
.~L ·'1 il
.J ~
~I
- o~-l-.
-.
. \.-..".1
Js~
.)\.i:J1 ~
l»_}:;i
t, .r I.l...J
.fly.
J}S'
~
" W\j
: v;;-.~~
-
t1,
_r. ~)~_,
p\
.~\
~\.4<=' _, •
J'
l,.,o.,i_t ~..
~~)lL
~\
1..l.oL! .)~
w\ .. ~ 4 •
\.S~\1:a=i)1'
~6:J\
~
~I
~I
~
U;\
,.
y ,~.)\.,Q:i\
CJJ ~
.
_)P- L...~J
_,I ,-:,t,Q,,;J1 ~
,.
~:.,li:i '1l_, «u>._,Jy-~ ~I» ... ~;:14o.)\&. ~ A <,S.:ul 0;t..uG ~) y.~ -'11 .)6:- JWa; ~J~ ~I:i.1ii:.lJ ~»~ ~~I )1 4:A.:kL."....u I ,:f bJ-l>.,. J ~ G~ ~I c.>\ ~A ~ J .)~\.... r:r t..li.ill ~..lAJ1 ..:.,.~_)dl ~~ if ~~I ~I - ~ A.i
)'1 ·J~I
~
C'"L.:.II
rJs.
i"w ~ t.l ~iP W')\) ~I cA-i_rl1 oj)IJ i..LU ~yU ~I ~}y-~)l1 ":"'\:4JI Jf·~G
tSG
~
~J
.~.A...t:&.l1 ~
~
\A~
LrJ
HI ,fi....
,~'1J
.~I
,..L4; ~
U.JJ~
t.l
0~J
.~ ~..\>-I
~~I
d'
i~..b,-
~>
:!'".a-.:t\ ~.!;;),\....:.:...ul
J:,\';-:>
'1
:..r->-
~.!....JI ~I
~
·\.-.Ir
l+l
L. \~I
J--.;-:.':! u-W\
)~I
~4)aJ4 ..
'11 'J.~
JI~
..J~'1\
'-.S.:u\ )a>Jij
~I
0L.)l1
..
- 4-lli lfj\'
~\
.),.,...:11 ~
~.)~I ~
1-4J dt,.;:-l\
&
~~)i.:JI~..w
~I
J~J»
-k_11 ,c!tir
.r-WI
~i£jl LS.,lj1~\.r-i ~ l>.~J.rs1~. JI.h ~ U;\; ,~~.,aIG ~J ~\} if \.r:.-.j ~)~I ~~~I )\.-..)jI) )l.!.;j\ rL.i ~W\ ~ U ..J.iI_, ~)_,-: ,~~ ~~.) ~i ~ ~_,..,p_,AJ1 ~i_, c~1 J5'" d
~
~J
\i~1
~.r!4
,~lll
y\i
~l!i_' c!\;J
.r ~ _,...j
r
l/!~ )~I
~~
~Ual.1
-
~4-i ~
I-
~I
&
~~..J\.i_'
~I
J..::.~ \.....it.,
,~L..
-------------------------
UP (jML.~ ~
t.
---- .. ~
~I
_.'JI
~-U
d ~) .~~
$-
fo wi
\-~()
La_."..,.
,::.,:.j.~Jt; Lr
~~\j
U~)
~
~lA>-» J fi ~
r-W' 01 JJJJI
Js~ ~
,~\,6> "Y~
~,Y-'I2A
I_;>-Ij \;w ~ f
~L.s.J
r-WI
t:i:ju
,..
0lt
'<..T'\>. ~
4-:-11
~£
~
JbJG
L.I tional L. )~
4.._.-:l)
~\k:;. ~4 4~)
So
tk_,.:;. ~
ttl ~
L.WG
4...?f 0~ if J\:.l.i 0~
;.k~J ~~
o: 4J
~
,.
pi
b!+~
~£J
'.r-:"':;;;~
.rs1
~
Js-J .lp.l.?1
~I
~I
J_,4.J1 0L:.
t!:}j ~
~ I~
L. I.l.)
~
t.)~
~u
~I_,; ~~
~
~\.......) ~
~.r"'!G
j
«¥.r==oy»
~)
J.l-A!
~_;k Lr ~I
«r-WI
&
01 ~
~ c.S.r-J .~};.I, ~
~)-U
y- ~I
Y_,L~ O.:llQ::j1
..
J\;,.- ~
J:'~
~
~~
~b .~ ~)WI
J'L.y Jli L.
\.Sjjl
~~~
O..\..~
~~
>~~~J
~..lj
d t:JJ.P
~')W\
~
- y~ )\5:i\
~
.?,j;
~.)'.ll\
L.
01 ~
Jl
~\j
t:J~J
~I__,i .~~
p- I~
~J)'I
Wl- ~ ~)Ij
b)
~I_r-i
J~J ......"L.w
,.
-~ lAJ..:": .J _rl
(.S.J.:s-)
I'
01 y _y,a:..ll ~I
:..
..
JI \""I_;
,-~.a!)
~>~ ~! .
· "Y 01~~I
~
~~
~
: Jlj-II
($1
I.l.
Js-
4. JJy.l1 ~"Y
~
~)..\..
j J'.J~ W' ~I
6;.,..,:a1l;;~
~
\j~l...:i
#.
~I
01
4J1
c: J:')~
.·liL.;~1
:~u
.
,.
JJ~
~
~~I
.::kll if "_r:0'" ~
~
~
Y ~~J
~I
~~yiJl
~I.wl d~\... ~
0i LS~
.... j),).1
·~I) ~I ~WI
,~ -tb
LS4
r..w j~1
r~ l. ~
~\
w~ \~
·~
~jS"'
~
-~
blAJ
u~p'
,
Jwt, uW
J _
') u~\j
jA)
~l1?,"" IS"Y ~
lSI 01 ))J
~~J
I~.r.--~~
t..U-
J..:...j
wi 'J4:.-l1
(.SI ~
~
O~fiJ J
6...lA l!.ll
~~
AkL
\.A.).r:-J ,;;~t.W1
Y'
JA:_.. ~
" 0\ ~
~
4J
~I
6~\)
l:.i~~1
~
L•
J~
.,._
if
~f"A.i
WI) 'u~~1
~ ~
4L.,:a.i
~I~';:p
UbJ~4
Ub..!,,';; 01 ~
~_rJ1 8J .~4
..... ~-'J
Js-
~.r:-
4bL ~ ...R+H ~\
4j\ ~
JJ4
fl~\
~J
J\
~~\_r!J~ ~
_________
J~ LS'/".:1
~IJ
~~
4..ili ii~J~
~.
#
lJ!J'l,HA
~~\~
--
.r.P
#-
wy~IJ
bJ~.r.P
t.l ~
L>~\
##.
o~1
~}il\
~KJ
•
Jl ~~J
f')
J~\
J~4
\i-.!~
dW\ 0\
...;}i ~I
$.
J} ~
..
~)1.Wj ~1.5:..1
JS' ~
(f 4I!;..b-
\~
'A~
4-y
4.~ ~
_rll ~
t.~IJ
~tJ~1
0 J§
-fL. y
JI_, ~I
~I .~I
~
~):JI
~~
~
4J ~ ~ ~_);;JI 4~
~
4.;;..j
y ~I ~I~
~
.sJ-.)
y-WI I~
t_lyl ~\5'J
wli
,.
16 ia~ ~)
4.i}.All ~I
~
~
t..S~1 ~JWI
4.j_rJ.1 ._:.,~
4-i'" JL..:>-\ Jb
..
:t.....;~
~JW
J~'
v\,j~ ~JI_j ~
JJb
01 ~I JJ~ ~\
._:.,l!.iUI
\~.a~
J ..tJUI
JJI
~
01 J~
..
~\1a4H 0J\.A.j
.oJJl,:..
~I .....
.r.P) 4$'r
.r.!=- \~.~
~
..
-~ ~I
dlf-
Jl
~I
\,$"':':;
~I
\..Lt.) ..... ~I
~I
;Jlj~IJ
4'A~~J
~4_,.a1_, ~.:·;'4)1
~~
Aj\;: ~J ~.J~
it::.iJ
~I_,i
: r-1W1 ~~
L-:.H ~,
o~U.1
If :l._!-li ~\~
\,j..l.A;
_;
,lfl:4,!
~I
wY"J 4:i_rJ.1
•
if ,~\ J
~I ~ ..J ';!I
,4 ,; .;~ )
0.1\ ~
,.lA:lJ d~
#
,. JI )~
Js-
Jy
J-WI
"
t.\~1
~
~
._j. P_j
~I ~
\,j.J..4.i ~
J) \II
~~~)· ~ (_;:::>:-:'yW y
.J
~.r
~)
,.
Js- ~)
~WI }::=JI
~
.J'i) ·~I.J
} )~I
)_#
O)y
~)I_r..:· ..G ~I
"IJ\II
_;s1
o_J-W1
rl:1J ~ J.&vl~
0__,ill ~~)\j
c:
~I
~
s.
~I
~.JW
JJ \1\
".
o~ ~
~
~
ojJl
nA,"\,"\ - 'V~t)
4';".1.;)
whewell
J~)
«~.fll»
~
tAL.......I r-LJI
~.JU'
d~
~~
,!}t:A.J · , '\
"t r~
~I
C:!.JU ~
._;y_t;!AIIJ ~,.,A.II
rij2j»)
,'\,
r r~
.r.:!
t1))~ ,_;-!.)y
«~b
~
J) .~I
Dr)
~I
~
~I ~k:ll
,j G·l.p7 «~WI
~~I if
~I
0G
~.J
J.
bO•. r·4i'1 ~I
£'Y-
.~_)a.J\
--------------------------
).#)
~~I
~~
,"~I
rSG:l1J":>\>-
4j.a-; .. ~
L1JS ~\.t~
tJ-a"'):' ~
£~
--
~8
~~
J}_.ll
~ ~\ i..w JI
~\
~ Jk.U ~ .. _c 0\
A •
') C~~}}
41 .!.\laJ
~j~
,.
u\;I.,:·oS''l'
~
:i;; 1\
.' .
,Ide
i .1..._
r-W\ JP
&.
0\
LS;~
~G
-4~1
~..rJ.I ~
~~I)
;~~j ~
~
o~~
c.S_r--\
~\';-Ll
0\ C~~
e
(..5~)
.~J.ilj
.!.\1_;~"l'1 ~ J
J).i
~
o.)ltj j.,a4!
"-1l5'
~I 0\ ~
~
~G .r: .ai) . ~\ ~ J~ ;1 ~\
~
t'~ ~
~
J_,.... ~1 ~jlJ
0-"
t;_,w
I~\ 0~
~
d
~
rJ ;;M~ ~I
#
Jl
~r
l..::5""\ ~\
JS' ~
\~... ~
rf'!"
J'
~J.>..
6-
.;.';.SI
J~
~
if ~
01 ~J
~L...I ;;_.,$.; 0~
u~\i
4.....j..ll1 oh ~J
0~
~)WI
~
J__,.k:J1
~I_; ~)
~)
r) \r.- ~~ uly
~I
~..bJ\
~\
~I
~ ~I
tyjlJ J~
t91J
ii~J
iL.l
~
Jl
oJl;.'11 ~\
,.
bj'u)
tL..l;
J~ J ~
~
~..b..:j
0\
~_)JI
'L! ~)
0'11 ~
o~
.J~4
0~~
~.rl\) ;~~\
« ~~
I [_)J
))J
I,$i
I~
»)
I (_J) Il)
c:: J.
o~..b,-
~ Ai
l.; .;_,~ I
I
J
(4~\
~~\
«(;!4::k:H 4i~\})
~
o~1
-4~\
18":~4!
~.1.
J
lS_f..)
~jJ~J ~..bJ1
r-WI ~
4iWy ~J
[))\
0i )')\..!:.~
:i::~v,j
.0\1\ ~
~..bJ\
~
j,:':!-WI
.}~
_;s1
~I
~~J
~j
01:-<
~': ~~I
wJ
tr"~J\
~j_;.ll
$.
~~I ~I
~\... J#
"-:!GJ ~~
if ~I~\
~.,4)1
~
41 L ~ih; L.
~ ~
j~~
~~b..6,
J..-~J
~)~
r
~\
~jG
~
J!, .. Pj
...::_.j
~§'
'L! JJ~
')_,.6;:1.l
'
~")\!JI ~I)I
.p;) ~)
· j_j_rJ1
.IJ\
~I 01)\
~
~
j~~
Js- oJ~ ~jlr= .... :i;:¥,l>J wJ ~ ~Ij ~ ,__,1J1 t}jG L.-:!l ~I ,. ~ c?\ 4.;1:J!\ ~I)I ~ coupure Jl.,a4;)'1 )\ t ~'11 I~ ~..iS"
~
ol,.;p j_,k,.J
~\~).r-""~ '1~
,~b.
r'~)~) ',\Y ~
~.T-
~I
j.4.J1
0~
(O_;yW
~
~I
t'}j 0~ yWI
---
l ,lhiiua.4
~
~~t·t~
--
I)~
6}::ll ~
P1
~I~J'6 ~
~
J.WI wi
«~~\
Ih
wi
4. J'_4!
~L..I
~J64
... J':>W-~ ~J
.t~.!Qc.
t:)J
J~
~.J
L..... 0~~1
~
0~J
~!~~!I» i.J@4 ..
)_,...:.JUI
>~J «~k4J1 ~li.,,$1l» ~..,..11 ~w~ ~J 'JJW.~ ~ r-WI ·~·=--W\ ~4>.-YJ u\)~\ c_}J 0w)'\ .!l_,L, ~ )~ (.$jJ\ ~J) ~
~~\
6.
..
:~41;k,:
..
cr
~JJ1\
o~
y~\
I-
o~
£
~)..1~
,_,.wI
i_)~
r-'
~
,:l!4, ..U u~
.y ~
fl,,·AsJ
,~lAll if ~~I
. ~W\
#-
t.rP
~
~_;L.J
O.:l~\
r-WI
c_}
L-
~j~
L...J
A.Dh3A1
.6·"\ ~I
Jl ~_)~111~
,;J~
~J
ifL..~1
Jl~:.. - ~\!:.!G
•
,Lt;~r-1-J 4:1L..J
1w4J.o,r.l
u~
~~
.
~~I ~_)~~
$-
J11.l. ~G
~l,.P~.J
Cy :.r
<,
o_,i ~\
i_)_rll .}I
6-
·~~
~
JiJ
~t...;:,1~
4JJ~J '->rl
..
~J~
:.r
~ _,..i;
r-WI ~ ..liJ
:.
~J
~'
II ~J
~~
Jj-JI ~
o~1 ~I~
~y
..Li!
~\':;I
~\
c;..":"
Js- JY
_,J~I
i\~1
r..i ~G
..b-
ol}~
r) ¥w":")'
~LJ.I
~!~J
1 u~\
Js- ~
~I
..
~J\:ll Lf4 ~}
Jl
C\:j'Y1
J~ d A; .. 1.11..;:..ti\ ~.M.S"\l1
11 ~:la:IG J\.~ .. S\'I
~\ ~ ~~~\
r:.r
')l;ai ,~I
~~J
U"'\:JI :4.~
'-'J> ~ )~
\..;..t.J ~~
~WJ
~_,J#I_, 1.A_).,lj1~
~
~I
),.;.W ~':l..l......:
~ ~I
~
c.?
~
~
o~1
-.
_)~I
t.\~1
il~1
~
· 4-i1j~1
~G)I ~J
.:: 'Y_w ~I
y~"MI
l.IIJ..ulJ ,~:~
~I
uP.A
,.
bti\,\
r:.r- ~~"k;)
WJI
•
4._:4.::k-'1,) ~\...:~\
·~ \::;\1G A.:ii).t:l1_,
,->~I ~\,6.l.. ~I
#
~ ~I
~I
$
(51~G
0~ ~I
~
,.
~G..ul
j~)'1
o}...Q.-lI oj\:.- ij ~I
i~
~J
01_r.:.;......, ,~W\
t.l ~ jS"'
a... WI ~~\
0~
~ _,J~IJ
r-WI 0~J
'J'WI ~
Lf
jA
- cr
,I.r.f'.l11j
J. '(,$_,.Ajl
W I~
0},J1 J$.\"';
r~J
j,WJ
e::
J_,il
--------------------------
u,s
(JM\...~ ~
ii
--
lj')i,1a6I.4
~\.w\.,)S ---------------------------if
;;J;;~I u~1
,-Qe\';";.!
J,;.wl ~
if
J.tt. ~ J:l-:U
~~
r-WI ~ ~
~WJI .)~
01 ~ ~I
e:tpl
if)
~l!..J' ~tk) ~I
'Jil
4:;:2 Ai Al.-t1 ~I
~WG
F
~
C::'
" )1 "
.rs- Y ~UI
(.1).1 ~
W~)
~!4il
wbJl
~~I ~W ~)
;;_,.i!G ~WI
cr" J,;}I
r-LJI
~)
J~
01
. ~r-J'-'
o1..L4.I I
,_}
~ ~\.:i
4s-f"J ~I
r
,_}
u~1
uP~1
~ d ~I Jl ~ if
~o~ . o_)L-
~\6-:~1
~ 0rl bfJ
~
,.
,,-,,,l:.ll ~J..lj
.A_"IJI w~_,.wl
~I
c.S.j!-..A
r~
: .)}ll
i~ ~~ ~ L.., ,~I
,. .r-: \lG
~)\j
_b~1
IoU ~
~
~I) \;\~
~y)
~ ~
~I
~I~I
0J_ .'_' ~
",:.,t.:i
wL.;\l1 ~
P. )fl ~~
~
d~ J) .aI,j'\~ ~l.J
.o~
~~I
},kl J-If
I.SI ~ ~
~I
~
r. r,ll
i~ 01)
..
...:..1)2i JI i~1
·~I
4...:f-~
~~y
I):
j;:J1_,A.l1o~
w~ ~)
jl,ai '4JI~
.~I~
~
~Ir.
#-
tY-.:kdl t.l
if
bu\II If'
($1 )-
~J~ '~J~
;;~ ~)\.; ~
· (4.-6.;J.;;iJ
.J ~I)
~~\)
r-W' }_.l ~I
~
Jl
J.;~ ~
r-LJ1)"wU;I;
r-P
~
..
~!.....
I ~j_.r. b if
~~
J1 ~JI ~
_yt»
J.
_~ J Lf '~J .>-y o~
..J)
GJ
j)~
.AiJ ~_)\jJ
r-WI ~
4..A . ..li) C9\.;
gy or scientosophy
L"
.1>1)
~I
JS"" d ~~I
~_rdG ~I
,tl~\l1
~
\61!:.~ ~J
~.r':" ~G.)
uL.~..u1 o.1A ,~I
,_}
~
~}.J:""r)
J)t;:;
~~I
J..o; ..
~\.:...)
.~I_r:-\l1
r-WI
,~\
~~~l.Q::;'-'
,u\-._,LJ.I ~)
~J
~WJI ~~)
Lt
\")<2':"';
Jl Jy}J
.~
r\
~
J"l!..J1
(,]"'"!!)..l;
~_,l~J
L..L..I ~
r-WI ;';~J
-'z"~_)~~
if JJI_,
~
J- ~
1.1A~I
r-WI
:\..)WI
r
I
L
~I
if"J)1 BernaL
y)'1 ~
_r.-:_-!.J
~I
0WI Ih
~ fi
~
:.>
~iJ
e)Y)
.~I
J)... J-:,AJI
«~).:.ll t1 ~I»
yl;S"')
n" i")
. ~ ..
«~
~.r
~\4-:~)l1
~~'yl
._\
~)I.!\)
~
4~1
#-
,\"
01 f\ll
~
I-
e:i\JJ
w~
~ if ~)\.,.. I~ /1 ~ ~I
.r-W1 rf
~..;» ~
;";~I
u\,j~
t?
if J)I \lJ ,~
~'''.J
J~ J
aP ~'u~
J\ll
dLi.i\l1 ~-'
~)_,.. ~~
'V ~_,AJI b
i0
-------------------------
------------------------------
lJl)i'tli.A
L ;::c.
~
~\ ...,d_>S --
~I
~~
.fl__,.dI~.La
~ ..}
rl
O~~
)J~
a...~ '. -:S' ~.J~ LS .Jhll ~ ~y ~~J :4.i ... ')\j r)\i4 ~I
~
r~ u:~1
\,bj)u'i»
0h.
yt:5"'_ ,
bJU
on the Decline of
:~~~
,,'V
C 44
'V~or~\:i~'1Jl4..6-.J,..:.~-,.....-i
ilY \#.1
Science in England
t..i
~I
.J~I
c:fl)
(('Ar,
~ 1.,:. JS'
~IJ .)~
}IJ ~IJ
~)#I_, ~I
~\
L;-
J ..a4!
J..l.f.ll
Jl
J~)I
J5"'
L ••
~IJJ_r';/I
4-i1 ~
~
.4~~J ~
t..i
~yiI\
(_)_,:-J.\
J>~
-.
~..;t..J) ~)
u)l..a1J
~:ji-; •
r~
d ~I
(_)jJ\ ,~\
~ I~\j
JJ ~I JlS"" ~ J . ,
4\ i'
Ih
r~
J..l:.l
LG..tl ~1~'11r..i
J~J
J")\b\ ~
~WI ~jl\
~~.,JI
~_,.p.- ~;ll
Cl? '1
J,\~S
~
uL..G~)J..L.a.l
~J..:.t ~_)~
~j1.\
IlA
Ih
Lll5'"J. a.WI
.\5'..r1~~ l::.iL...;\
.y
L!)~
,(.S~)'1 ~t ..... ~\
i.,Sfl'1l
~W\ ~ it; ~I
~jJI
d ~l;
);)Lajl_,)
LG~ JJIJ
:_,:... . IA
LJ""'"'""i»)
«U~ y~
~~
Hessen
-.!lUJ
·~1 t;_r.i
Jl;..r. y\5
o~
)~J
.<,4\,..,
i~
uL:J'1\ ah
~') ,j..,JJ
~b:-
ej~
o)~~
~\
.~b:-
<.i
ll_.",\1\ ~ _,.J\
\~l)~J 6JS
(.}M~
..
j!L..J i~
--------------------------
cJ.a_)a ~
i\
-o..l;o-) ~
lJ'Ji,~
~.;
~l...w\.F ---------------------------
u>'1J.::,.
;i;~
~l)1 ~) ~
~~
~y
t_ k
J5'
j;lQ;;,..1 ~
t:l1
.....
~)
l'G ~~\
_,.ly.....iJ
~)
~_'_PIJ
,~~_rP ~
~
~1.A.:l1
if)~
y.
~J
,o)yWJ ~
~
,~\
~6:-
~I_,i
~
~ ~
~I
.kWG ~I
wl~ LI).) i~
~~~.))
01 l.u ~ )1 ,~.r)
~
'c:...... ~
4_,1 ~~
C;:J LS_r'j1
4ts:.J 4l. j
)_,k; .)1> ~
~}:.I1 ~
I-
rl
:fJ .LI)..ul
~J
~ _rJl
if~\
o)J~
~\
..
r-\12 ....
\.. 0\..
» \.. ~ ~I ~
~\~':-\J
}-~
o~1 0\
Jl
J-'.fl.J · \.;J:.~
J~
_,.lY-~\J
t\~'jl
~~\rtAa\
J.-~
~.!.lLlS'
of\1; ~
#.-.
;0'_;:.W.I
~JWG
~lQ.,..
ipi~J
~I
,",>WI
.1&,:" ~
'_;l~-:5"1 4~
~)
~ u'a4:tl
~:4k;t\ j..lyJl ~)
J$J ~ J\.~-;<)''j\
k_, ~
,,~\
;jt.,....
~
el
u=J1
0)~
._r\.._,J ~~
~)I
I-
dl i)~,),1 ~
j~1 ~
~)
~
~)I
Jvi!~).};J')'\
,_;b-J ~ l4!bli~1_,
~l.!..;J1 J)~ L\)~ s.Lr=-\
~
j> jb- ~) ~I
~I
Jl
Jw
~li,.
~J~~
~G..'I
~J
(.5ftJ .~p-4~1~
il.-:a.~ tl~\,1 ~
~\;..J ~
~)
~.r-11
~~Y'
~I
Jldl J!.- ~
~
r.#lS~
~J
~_)J..4lj ~_)\:J\
elJ ~\ .....
JI.~-5'~1
- ~I ut)I_,
~JrlG
~W\ ~
j6.J\J
~p
w}.!.L, .~\
~ ~ ~I
c.~
~
w\;~
~\...J
~
,_r.S\ ;~~
J-1y..U J~ lSi
.,:_,L,IJ.)
~L..oJI
~\
y~'1
;..1.;~
~
;yJI
4-)1jil}Jl 1.lJI
t,S..b.:J;
~i VJ 1 ~JJI ~lLWl
~\1 .... ~
y~4
jiJl
t.1..l!':J\i)..a i
~
w~
($.1
.a-:IG t J~
~1.....1J1 ~
'. :... 2; .1
0~ ~\
~? 0\6L,
..#
tv
UJS (jM\..t~ ~
----------------------------
~ ~) c: ,~..,J.I
_rJ1
~;
)~),I
&
~Jl)i;fHA
c.:aL...a\...;S --
\4-- r ~ ~..,s:..;J1
~
~Jf~
4 :~
tl:.. _}_ij
~)..ul
• ..l.A y~1
£~ 1-4J_, .• _),lih\
•
,.J.>b
cr
~U ~WI )}
~I
01_,,t~
6-
J ," _,.,4U
.)L~,:c. 0'1 \'\
~
.(1--4')1\..,...p._
r ~I
~:J_' )~
o_,i ~
~
\6':-.:.t,)
~I · ~I
;p ~1
c:f
tUG
~\
~I
t\~'11 ~
~)
..
~I
~
;,).rJ.1 jtfo.
.kJ_p
-L!JU ..;A>s._rP
01 ~\...
#
_>A_'
.~I
~Wl
L.J ~
~I
~
)_,.6::.!I_, if\·-:~),I
\... ~IJI..b-1
uAk: .. Y'\...J
">.)6:.
.J"""
~t.-:~~
~6:.
o'1 ~I
...;I~i jl_,.... ~
if ~ ~_;.Lfl.~
Lw u;=l\ u)'_rJ!_,
4jk'J _'~J ~~\
Ai ~\ ~
)_"ki
~I
J.k:...
L&
.J
r-W'
t.J
~I C :.> (~I
4-.JI
jbJl_,
~WI ~ jl~ 1-4lJ ~~I ~\J.-.lI ~ .. .;fJ ul.ill J>b if L...L...I C:ft.\' ~.iI\jbJl b if')1.>- ~ ~J 'l..?-'"_)WI b.h ~ l..Si ,o)_,laJ ~ u~k,:. :.r Ji ,~I ..kL~dI ~}:ll J\.:-JI J>-b jb- Y' flM,;;\1 1.1. '--: ~J ,,*,- c._,...JJa .~I ~I ~-" )\kl ~
jl>Jl ~ ~
~
~WI
J..\~:.v.,! ~
l..lf~ ~
4j)'
tJ4 ~)\
if.')l:,:...
~b
lii.t,
\.J44 • .)~
l:.A
l#
.~I
}kl
~
4j~
.!l~
r-WI ~
~J
fi \l ~:.. ~ .J
_;A:.JI
4.f:")6:.J
41_,AJ
tJ4J
~I
~_,..,;::,)I j\~1
...
~'ll
..
~w
~
~
A":'~• ~
~~I
~.,!~:, .. .!
Y • L.~'J\
J\~.~W\
~Q.~S ~
~I
~~
~\.,:",:-I
_I-
Lf ~UI
~
~\~'ll
~
~bJl ~bJl ~
~I
r_r.j~
1.1.
~y.!
Yr
r"'w r
J")\>
if
)_,1J) ,~)~
c;.ill ~WI
if)
~J
~
,~~
4w.;
J. <..p_,Aj1
,.ul~ ~I
r-W'
u-:l
LL.,_WI JUs; ~
~
=r-: ~
A_- .. bJl
~.rr
~L l.l\ if ~k. ..
J5' ~
!l)-4 ~I ~::~~
J"ac,
~
J~
if lp ~J
cJ r-W' cJ
jt).)WI
4jJW~
_ri ~~ ~~ ~ .!.I~J
,r.i'u i_r.:j~
~
if ~I
.)1)')11~
l..l..1 ~J
$
. · ifl~ <.SI
~G
15,,4j
-~l....)/I u"%.!.ll
\II ~I
~L.,:~\l1
~
t.~\l1
)_,.b; ~
4j~
~6:-
~~I
~ d b_;.#)
.v~_'
(~.JI
phiLogeny if _,JI)}dD
lS"o:;lall
rW'
~ ~~ ~_;la ~
-------------------------
fA
--
4''''\*6'4
~ t ,~..
.. .
---------------------------
. c._} ~I
J)dl
~J
~~
~I ~).:ll ;a~
~I_,.JI ~
~\J
~
L;:..
e:'1_,J1 ~W\
~I~
A.:Q:oo-
" <w.J1
~~J
~\.:.:-
;~~:
~Ij.!l
.. ~\.yyP_y
U~_"';'.Y if ~y
rl d'
t
'iJ
j_..lj.!l
)U:........ ~
~) ,~Q"! .....
~
~\\j ....
J
UJ~
-..
4
~
)1 ~I
~
&
~
~
f..S
:.4' ~~\.,a:i\J\ . ..
I.
w;;'J\
~j.M
y~1
~~
if
Js~I
01
~
~_r..J .~
~WI
rl Jl ~; ..~
~
~ -y.s-
~J
~
'~
L$lll
~L ")\!..
4;.. ~~ IJ_,...i~
J,WI ~
~J
Iy-..o
~
0~
Js-
Wb
j.o..ooJ ~ La ~
~I)I ~
~
4:-i IS:.
J Q A::..
4A
.J.AJ I
J'L...I ~
'"
~'i_,A-.) \~A;:I!>Li..
_r- 01 ~
~
_fl#J
Wb
J......-u ~
L.) ,~I
u~~1
~__,..11~
~.:-.JI
~JJJ
JyJ!~\ 0\ .4PuJ.iH
.1A~
- 'r-LJ1 tJ} J ,~ ~\ JI
0fo
~l ~
,.
~\ ·~ rJ,1
~.r~l..t
p
~
J~
~I
. ~~ 'il
~ 'i
t.WI ~I_,A.II ,
4.:s:J
,.i
~\.J.JIJ u....')WI ~
~!_,
~!..
~ ..J.111
_)_,.J.dl U>.~
if
(.$~
J41\ ~I
b.
=:-1
~L....;~I
~I
"~I
U:-! ~)\
~J'~
ut;")\.JIJ ,~I
.Jy1d t.WI
~I
~I
~I_,..ijl
LoG"
~
u~ o~J
0~
.!.U£
~I
~_;:.!l'
~_)J
o\i")W!_, ~~.....wlu~~1
j~
,~!_,
_r-t~I
>-\~\
4
~)#G ~I
(;...b~ .d;4~
J~J
u~ts::..1 ~J
,uLa_,w1
~
~
rU:u
~")\.JI --4~)
~_,J#G
i-L4:l1 ($"':"-)
U\)~\J 4.:4.::k:HJ
U~J.,...a
>-W\.-'
Y
uG~1
,__j
~~~\
JjW\
oh
t:ll ."...~UI
~ ~~
J.&~..li
O.l:~
~\
Wb
~- OJ
d 4l- ~')'
}kl ~
.... ~~
uP~J
~ Ak_,J.1
~\
~b~ ~
- I~~
)1 - J,kll
,,#-
04
\...:2:1I ~
~f..J .~I
t~Y"
i~
01li>.
j:b'li ~I
~ ~
y~1
s.
~lb ~
6F ~LA~
------------------------
------------------------------
aJ1Jiit#.t
~\.w.\.;S --
~j)u1
~
~W.I
~~J
~ .. WI a;_.,..11 ~
jfL....
,~
J&-
bAt ~li
;,;..._).
.r.P
o~..I,;.:-
J.b.:ll
4.i~
~_,.ll ~Ift
~G
~l;..
.i~~
c:--. ~ ~p JW~
U"'l> o~l ~~
~J..b- J>b
Jl
,i,;1 .,:_,~I
,.
_J!!;uJ
~W ieW, ~\_,iJ'J
~\_;A- oJ)'\
.-4J
.~I
~b:-
~~
Jl
~
J-
~WI
# ~~
~\
~
~4;-l)
~IJ
J.6.11
·~'-'
~\>.)
~}.i ~t&. ~
,411 ~i
~
,~I
~~ ~~
J }.J.\ ~
if lA_;.!yW
~G l.S' ,o~~
- -4!~)
t.!JJ.)
•
./.0 .. iii iJ ~
__,.:J (ii--4~1
0~1
•
~
alA ~I
t~
·J\-J\
,-0
J1.;- ~ ;,..::k! '.J '? o~..b.,.. r_,1;. c_) o~.J.:J:.1 ,--A il_,ll ~ J. ..:! .. ~ ~
Y'J
Js-
..)\4lS' IlA ~I
r\J:2.::j'Y1 ~JI ~
r-LJI ~.;}J
~I
'YJ ,.~~I
J.JWI J!-A,.,.;!
~I
~}j .} ~G ,-oil_,..
~ •. ..; ~I ~
r-W\ ~ _rJ
~
v-:l
~I
~~I
j) ~
yo)
u-W1 ~\
I~ J..b--4~
~};.ll
o~1 ~~
Js-
.!. -;.!)
~1
I.S';;' .~}:JI
~~
d ~..b- J5'
• ~1 d"~ A.J..ts:::j1 - t
t.\~1
~1 l...Sj;aia!
-~ ~w.1J ~G)l1
~)l1
jt4:J1 01
~
1..5-"1
~A
~~.~i~1
~ ;~~
"\
~~
.~LAi8\ '..b-J if
.Jd;. ~J y~\
~\.,
~J.,l.o
o~
y6-..,.?i ~~
~J
~ri~A.aj
LyM
~.:,i,All
,4,..,1A,:: ... ~
Ja.. ~.r- ~
~~
~JJ.,4!J
~):.ll
,.} W-JI
~ 0f
~_,A.!
u=d' ~~,
'u~
,.} ~
~..w) O,:)~jJ
_,...J 01 ~~I
rill\
--------------------------
uP ~~~ ~
o.
__
l,',j'dMd ~·
ut..w.'~( --------------------------'.r
u~i ~I
~
~
o~
til
~
~G
0\ ~J
~
l-~'
JJYJ
L. ~
It-
.~1jJJ
\lA 0\
..
~Jl_
~1- r).J1 ~
,...,.
~} ~
~J_)~J
.;_,.4.b J\ ~~
~l.. ~
J\ t.;»\
4..< '+4
I-
l,6.;1~ )1 W dj_rJ.1
JS' ~G
~
~j>
·r_,.LJI ~
~J
~ ~ ~
~G\
,_.
...... 4i
")\...lS'"
~
Ifll.;,.. ~
l,a.~:.J
~y
;;..lt~1
~~I
~ ~\
~l5' 0~
.r
~
"}\,..~
\-~h 'il~\,1
l..boo_'" ~
J\ A.5'" ~I 0\' ~
~~L.,., 0~
...:...i)\ ~
1.,i""4
,. f!.
~4
~J
'~?J~
~~I
~':-:;J
~!~
i~J
)1 ~
&-
.0\...)1
~
if ;;.)~ o_? ~~
~f ~\ 'y_r;.il
~
JI ~::;-:-~
~
tLJ1 cr"
.4A-:j
Js- ~
J,l.!..:J1
..
4,j\;
~rtl1,~4 1!~4 ~
d'
b_r:j
.~l:JI
~.J.i)
aLienated ~I .....
4.""';:'.Y
~:::j
~)2.i
~W ~
" ,lfJ
y_p..... ~
~j'l
~I
J..1yJ1 )1 ..:J~~)l1
~)G
Ih
J~\' L?JJ .~
1)....J1 ~,:JI
~
I; .s ~ ~i
$> . I. -
.J \l ~~, rl
rili
J__,.aJ1
~ ~I
Jl ~
J_}d
~J
uf:·~ 01
~l>JI
0),)
~L.;a411 )1 .J~)lG
~1_,AJ\ o..k
d' W~
i}"J1 .J#
bJ:.,_A ~
~
.r-W1 i~
Jl \'JI - ~_'>\.)I
~.lJI ~L..\,I
'4-i~
j....a.AJ1
4S'.r- ~
~L..)l1
iW1 LlyW\
W~)I)
Jl ~
~\;;.Jl ~I
J~
~jjl
-* ~I
.~\
~ j~
~l
..
v\'.J.to.,t) r-WI
.;..~I
J# j,)~ Jl.ft~
1.Sy.:.- if
fl ~:::611
~
'il.:4>~1
JyWII.1P:. ~J
~\
• ~
rill t.Wl
J
---f\
6~~~
J.
'..S".
- .. kH r~1_"
~
..k~'-' ,~~
'-='J
:~:.:"'" .)~I ~~
J~
J-""
l~t
d r-Wl
t$'1 ~J
~ .t , \~
#
Yj ~
~~ ~
,u
t~\ if
~\ ~
~
4S'? tt ~)1
&
J&-
IlA ·~).JJ
. ~Lt~~
hlll ~... ~J 4~
~
~»~ ~J
~'J.>~\
~.)L. if ~
o.rJS'
:t .
~Ir
c: ~\.~)
..
l4>.)l.-:~G 'loS.,),,1I ~I
~WI
.;..UWl ~
-,
.~
o\
i...lii ~
WP
tf' ~I ~)~G
~_)s ~
-------------------------
------------------------------
tot
,~kl\
#.
r-WI ~
A.j
_rJ.I J~
~WI
J1d1
Jl
(.$~J
y:. ~.; ~\
,_:.,W:.JI ~
j-~~ ~~ ~
-"
~\~, :.r
U,'::' 'r"
_)2J\ ~
4J\~ ~~\
~~
.JA)
. O.,:)~ \
W~
L.
~I
y't'J ,~\
J~I
J
\~J
~k-JI
j::-! ~
~w
~
W ~J
\£)
'4-14-S1)
~}:jl
~
..:..I..l>-s,u~~) \ ~
~~ ~I
pi ~ ~ ~ ~
J)d
LS""\.... ':Jl ;.)yW\ ~
~,)\l.\ ~1y.J\
~
~
.b;.u 0\ ~
·~\
Lx:,,. \1._r.
.
J=...= ~
6 ;'"
wI l:.li I~I ~)
. ~_)dJ
YJ ; ..l:>-IJ 0...1.:>- J \.-Jb}~ ~ I..S'~ k 11 ~ \ _)_,ld ~ J) I) ~~I ~WI r ~4J1 ~ ~la;j\ J.r~ r-i _;>- ':}\ t:::
~\
~I
#
JIy'l'
4.i~
r-WI ..ill ~I
4-.J1 LJWI
~
~\
J_"b;:i5'_r-J ~L...:)I\
JyWI
y....,JI~~b.J\
Jy .)~
~
Jl'1yPJ
\~~1.Y ~~':}I
~\
Jl ~6.J\
1..La. \' _r.;~
~ y. ~ ~
~
~~W\
yl_p.&J:;..-;"j
1S..u1 }).l:s11 ~I
A:;U
#: \ \
JJL,.
Jl
..
\.;_)U2;1~I
~
~~I ~l
Ji,("2J
~. ..
~\? dJ ~.rol\ if
._\, ~'J
o~
l . ...
~)U
lA-4w·..;~1
..
'f
I'"
4!~f
.. '" 1r" :. t \ ~~
\~'!"'W
cs""
, c:
l.
~,
1t -
-\
t Loa
,~~
A ~\
\..
.lJ1~ ~)\
#.
tJ JwJ ,~~\
~I
~
if .)~
;;~\J
_r.51
,)~IJ
rL.:1b1 ..t.::.
Jl ~)~ ~
~\ ~~\
).,,1u ,;.
4..-W\
~\}i .JJYJ
~I
I-
J* Jl
I o..La. ~
Jl 4b-J 4>-_;1
~.)YJ
~P~
'L,Ja:JI
~\
u\Iill; .... ·
u~~
· (5_?-)r\ ~I
~\I~
_)_,1d
~
~WI
~G
~\
«~)#I»
L_)WI 0Wk-:~ ~l
#J
r-LJl ~Iy
I ~k:l1_,
~U1
L>.;l \11
..,_"k:J 1
.,nJd\ ~~
l,b:. ._:., ~
~ I , <i.Ji ~ ~
LOi?-J ~
j~
.)lb;..J1 .J\~
J
~ if)
r_~1
;f
.4 ......\-11
..:..~I
oh
..
4.il ~ ~_) ~\
t9'u r ~
.
Y 4l>
Jl
rWI
iSl ~J'u 0~
'Li)
;J;.....,...
~1}iJ
~I
ypl
&.
~J\;
~")\j
~?
~t:J1~~I
o:
~L~J.~.p)1
Jl
l..
'=:~j tt.~
J_,AJI -I>\4;,)
~, · 1\~~I, uW U\,:j
0\.jL;,1
L .-~
.:?JJ ..i~ ~~I e~\ .)~\)~ ~.;:,l:!A~ ~I )'1 ~IJ Js- J!Y- J}5"- LA Al u=JI 0(lj 1;j1~1("-'JJ j.'" WJ ".. 'ill'i
~:J§'
~
J'l..y
(!}_y y.L.
>-
~)U ~.JI
0lJ ~I
Ajrll ~)..La
J~
J~I
if (..~ ~~
~
~
y~llf
<.>..ul J~~
~_,;:....-b.-
J!
y)\
u-:l J5' ..!.1J~ ~ ~J ,;j"a'~ ~I_; r~ ~y. ~J ,;;p YJ~ ~Ir ~J 41.1..'.
->-J'
~
(as cJMl..~ ~_J.b ~
0~
---------------------------
---
~Jl.1ii~
u\.w\_;S -----------------------------------
c_.)_,.-:JIIh
~\)
t..?
WJI
I-
o)~I) ,~
LP~J
')il c_~~1
,.
),1,\ J>b
e
L.Sj':4.
~I
.b~
Js-
~)__,k.,. v~
.;--4~
J>,.bl;_j)
-
r:/'
1I_r:.s;-,)
;.,..)
e.
r-:'J...ill .J\~I)
~\J
~W ~
.oJ~-J
_y" \~
--4~ _r\
J.J ~
J
--
<:.2l_,..~
...
I ja:i -I"
YlJj ~\.>-
o_r.4-J• ~'~ ..
~\ J~\~ ~
ij uili
,.
liU.•Ji
ij)lIjl
ui cJJ j .~l
JW j
L.UJ
J~
~
~
~\ 0
lS""lw '.II ~\
iJ:j'')~)
LS\ ,~~~
~Is- ~
·~\
is~I
~..\>JI \.i~
d ~W\
!..s..
· ~WI) 4i1.A'Jl
~\
iJ__'~
r..5J_r.1I J_yd\
~\
~r.?)\~..... .;.~JJ.1
~)81
J_,.-~~
~~j
~~lt.~ ~ L.k
~
~~
~Ib4~J
,..,.
~
~
ilr Lll ~
J>l5~
e:--~ 0i
..
~}j
4..~+.:I
}
~
J . 4!l.Jlll
~
JJL4!H ~
- 1.\\ r--:i.i)\.J1
~L.\ .'
,~\)
\
'-'
«:
j~ ~,
~I
~Lb r)
~r ~J\)
.
0\ AJ ~-
Lf ~J>J\ ..
;;W .il\
cJ::-!
~
L-~~l
~ L,J.iJ\
~ .. t,
L-
ic. ~~~ .... Jt ~J 44 .. liB ~~~q...bl:J ~.. aJJ~ LJ U .JJ" tS1.HJ ,~l;~\ -J" \ .. t s: _.\ •_ ,i .. ::> if AL;.4..Y ;_)y ~+M4: u~ ..:l...:.._ ....... ~JULJUJ ~t,~ :~ . \_\\ ~ C ~\\ _)~ · ~IJ,)t
~
~j.M
.r.i-) 4-iGI ~
J·
~\
u~J.j
>-l-lJ\ J~
:~J.:>-
LS ,~)1
~I ~~
~p}
~~ ~
~.rl\ ~p ~ Jj.i ~~
J.AA
Aj~
[_~
J)LJ ~\
~
\~t;
wbl..lot':...\ ~
~
')UJIJ 4..LJ1 ~I
I.J~
~
~
t..i
~
)1 ~\)I
U"L.___,.;
~)j)
A4-_1. ~
LS"<J
~\
r
Iti~
uJ..P
j.Ai 01) ~
t•
· ~I
.. L I /I \. ~ J \ \,;IJ.
~._,.wl ~~~\
U'" •
.."..; .:..; to"
if \i)\kjl 'L.S~\
)
_r--:" ~;~)
~;,
I !
~~
i \ ~:. toz_,4 ~
\ ,~ ~./
\
.
;i 1
w:; t
,"" ::..
;. (;~_~;:r.rt;-J ';
~~
;~
\"""./.-
~~ "~"'~
...
,I
fi \I\ U·
I".
.. U
[I - JI \ s;J
l'J QJ \-I~
· ~L.i)l\
:; l~ ~\
UL.. ~l I)
;;.. l.;I) I
t\-"r \I)
t-- \~..~ \
.
,
~I
;;~
--------------------------
__
~~,J;JI ~ ..LL.
.C.\.,A
UA
:; ...
11
~4J ,
.~
~,.
·tsk6:- r ~~I 4..~; II ~~y.l1 ~ ~._Uj} - Y.1WW 81 J}JI ~ t? ~~\~ ~~_;J ~uJJl
· WJI
"U,iiuLA ...
".
~L...\ ~ .c __
01 if ~.)J.; J~I ~J
~J
A.i..,-11 JP J~
$,"
\.;,;\.S:il
;4';,.J.j
'~VA
~
,r.-":;'"
'"~,
~~\
..
\~.
~-
~W\
..
~l..-:.'
\
,.)
,
II
l:J~I - ~
.,12'\ ... «(i. t:..'\
~ :.~
~ ..l:;-:LI ~I
J.. -
....Aj ~)...
~"')2; ..
.Jw,\
,.
f'J
,'-.>,.,_rll)($'"~I
r-WI rJ64A
Js-
t_...... )1
l.f'L.y
J.> ..l:';!G ~WI ~I .?..il~ J.~) .«~I ,. i)~4'" ~ J'~ ~\ ~4h;. 4 ~;ll
JJb-) ·t~)1 loa (f ut:;-: ...l\ J~
J c.?1 J-sneed
t~.lP ,.. :.tl...
..l.:-:..... --
LS..w~1
l.f'L..y
oJ§' ~ _,l:2;
~~I wly;
~~\j
~ ts- I..K.J
.r.S1 ~~
~_"v
t.l ~))(.$..iJ\
.~~I
~J ,:f
~
.4;:;:1\ ~,h'4aL
d"
~
0J~
~A.~I
V'L..y ~
~\&.~y
,~I
~\
~.f'" JI
,.
~I
/.Sf.. ~
~4J.;.JI (5oa
Js-
y~)l1_, jJJji
J!.&
~I
~
~L...;~\ i}JI ~
r..lAJJ ~_,.:.; ~
a.t~1
~J_,k.:.I1~.rll
J.p
J.i ;) f
u~~)
~J
~bJl Lia'~J
.,:..,\iJ\.J1 --4~J
d tA.r.'-J
~~
~I
F.J
:r
~I
~\i)1
,~L..j~1
.;)"WI ~\"a~
if ~;d$JG ,~I
d \6-:J;>-".>l-
u=J1 c:~)1
~~
liJ\.b.iG .4.....ly1.11
~>~~_,....; ~ ~~I ~
u\i~1
~;'V")
If ~
L;"~\
~ «c..>_,: ..... ~
~~I
·t~_,....u
~t!.II ~I..d.\
o" i..b-J
JJjJ ~\J
Ah
J'M:ll ~WI
Ull.,!
~~I g
f.~~J ·MUdl
)I J
u~~1
~I ~
JI ~\_,.AJIJ
u~ ~)I
Lf
~I
WI) ~
..
Ur...r+'~
,~y Ji ~
'-.>'~
'-.>'.)\... _,..\... ~
Y.
Jl j4":.1i ,.::.;~~_,...
..
)1 r\...~1
..
~~ _,=:-
~)
~J
.db- ~ ~I
·~ ~I
~
J~'J ~~ Js.,:..,~_,:-1\ ~~
.).1...;..
~~\
_"i ~
~_?JI ~
~\
;';__,..l
JsWI
~_)&;
__.r+'~
:4;: ; : U
~
~I.cll
L.j';)l. ,
jj')WI u~~
~I)\
WJI
u~~1
r.i JI.A::;\'\
0~J
·~G
6.JS ~Lt~
--------------------------
J.a~ ~
--
A.J!)ii'-'A.A
~L...\_>S ----------------------------
~::)~_,::......a Jl
~~ ~~~
~~
,y Jli:;'il ~ ~I
t_~y
~~..J'-' Jl-i'il
.~\
•
0_,s:; I~J b~~1 0'" ~?
~\.iWI ~JY
~
,~y. 0~ \.L.,..,J W"J ~~I ~ rJl J_,At w- ,!JIJ.)'11_,.u..u,J jSJ\ JW «~» t_yPJ ,-;5)1 Jl
~,b!y
.I if ~J'11 uL..l...>-'J'
JI ~I_; 0\
.. ~ ...
4.&-~
~b ~J
;j4>."
#
,~
01 0~
~
.."
..
~~
0.f>t)1 0t5' 0\ ~J
~t>c.Sy- .- . .)
t-
b!l_; uWS""
~
-. JI
_JIb
l-... ~I
~I}
bl...;c.\
jSJ\
,~£
...,.
,lA_rP6:.
I-
..r.f--
~L:..
fl
Jl ~ if _r.JI
~l>J\ ~Ij
,...
~
~I
o.:u. ~t~y.
v-k Wl
4J
w ')' I ~
if ~
~
~ ~I
0~
,-"...."u
~~J
0_;:.-::ll
o.:u. J~
~~I
rl ~I
l5_):a.JI..,.(.4j1
:i.... J
.u~ya:ll
U..~ J d
:; .:',1_•• :i J ....1.) .
~\_II .1C.'J~1!
".J 1;.:"
0'" ~
WI 01J_,.A;
.;,..LiH _;J'M-J ~ ~: C ='1
JllS~J
~)I
.. •
jj~
Jl
~J-AJ' r-
~I
.~~\
..
Ji ~w ~\;.-, j
4,,5
tSJ.Ji:H ..
~I}
4J
01 lSI
,~I.:;.JI ~\}
.J ')\...L:.. ~
WI JJ_y
op.e.ll ~~I
~I -
4_,.-!JI - I
·0~\..:.J
3_r=. oJ
~J~
0
d'
J4'!.....~
y
l·
'Y~
~
JJ\>. J~
if ~
~i - J~I
~
WI 01 <.i'~ ·~W
·_rl
'''~J
Jl ~ J o"
,..b--) 1
dl.lll ~I
if ~I~\
00
JLiI.J ,~
..
Js- ~\
,.
.j ~I
dl5JIJ
~ ifJ
-------------------------
----------------------------
~,',i1.._"'4
...
ul...'·~---..
~
e:: d.l>.\..cll
if ~
~..l.J\ ;.;~I
~JS')
. .J
:i..
J.;:tI 4.iL.j!i~)
~I
~:"M~I_, ~\ l+1J.:>.) ~
ililll
~I
iL.l
Jl ~I
l~\ '~U·
~J
.. ..
\~0);.;;
;,;_rJ1~)~
J~
~I_,
~r~1
~\rl
.r~
j..W\ ~\
~I;
J\.!.':s'G 0)\
Jl
J
b::.~1 .
.r
~
Jli:i'1\ JJ\>
\ ..we.,.' ...
1i.>.J::4A
~
....A..-:J J.
.. •
.. .
· f.. U~
.. ..,£.~
"1-
~ ..
'\
• . _.
~. ~l' h
.. • J
¥u _;s1 ~I
~~
~~
JI ~\j
~\
~);.JI ~
.1l!.,jJ
O_;A-:'_
..;..I_,iv ~
J4:'~ 4-i\' ~~
4\~ Jl../YI
j-iJ1
o~
.r:J~I ~WI ~) ~I J~\ ~ J.)~I 0\j~ ~Iy ~ <.Sy ...,. Js- U".a4j ~G '~..rJ1 ~'11 )".1.,,, .. ~y u-=JG ..,..JG ~I
lS.1,. ~
.__k\.Q..:j c
li~
~~ ~
I..~
JyW
rL
~
AL\.t;. G\
.. •
J\
"
,;W':J\
loS.).,.
Js- ~~
4.il.-;..'1\ .
~G~ L'~Y
fl_,l;Jl
(".$ ••
I..i5:...J,~~
J>-..u ~I
v
tS?-~1 ~).JI ~~
w.JI
\~J
j?-I..u u~I~\
'1YJ
;,)u
Jl
4-:
.:l\':"~'1IJ
4J~~4
O».r4!
124! \..t
;.ill I LI_)) ~
J~
~~""~ltlJ ~\ u
Ji 'J}ll j.lJl Ji
Jl
~
_.\ .. ":> ~ \
~
~I ~b
8>
.r-!~
~)
J~8y-.i? ~\£
o~~ op
(.))§'
u~y I~
~
:l'p
~\ ~
~
.yl ~
o~1
p-:;;";
0\
\;.)y ~
~I
.:l_;A-:t, ~I
O)J&J.P
r\:.r-LJI
J~
;;J~
4."I:-:-:."";!
(.)1 I.SJ.-J · ~j
J.
..
JlJ ,~~
<.? L.J
~..lA.I1
tf W
JL,a; 0--4~
• .:ll_.,k~
r
$.
~.,..ll
..
~WI~)
~.)~
.;..1.i~1 If;\s'"J ~~
Js- 4
1.1i
J}..... Jl
UJ.S
U-"L.~
-------------------------
J.I~ ~
0\
---_
4\0"' • ..
.. to......
.......
-"'WM~'< ----------------------------'...J-
.. '\
J\
4; ... 0:\\
:~~yU\ c!li}1
):w
0\ '-.$"\ ~I
J\.~:S"'~
J~)
fl~
J~
A
~
.~I
d .:l\Q::c\'1_;;?
U"L.},\~)
u\jt~:S"')U ~~\,I
Jl ~~ ~ J
i_;.JIJ . ..l>-I_,~I)
~~
d' ..l>-IJ ~
.!5~ ,~\
~
iJ>-) - ~
·~\j
rtd u46:. ~
\f";:'~
~~I
~i -
;;J~I
~) ~ lS"Y ~
)1 ~
J! ~
r )1 ,~\j
~
~
J? r1 L)"l::i
u\~;;i ~:ki
oJ?
~ ;_,.) ~.oa.;! Jl
.1I).b1 ~
~ ~
~
0\ o\.il!. ~
~J.l.!J1J*)
jWI
.iJjd\
J- j,l.:.,j
Jl ~\
.!5~
~J
t>.:lL!.) c:~_,..oJ .j
L$"""\J ~
ul}~\,1
..l!&-
J5'
:~~L!._)}'I
C~W\ - "
1J~ ~
·~
J_rJ.\
WJI
:0\,::""
.J ~.)W.J)l1 r.~~I)
~~
)1 ,~-WI
~WI
~
~
~Loacl
,.
~~..,..-JI
~WI
~
';J..L;, ..:~l,l2..
j>- Lr ~
~.1A.l1I.5""GJ..l1 ~I
Jl_~U
o~~
~.rU o~~
0\j~\
..
~j,),1 ~~
.~j')'l
·~
.!5l>:; ~) W.
Js- r::..Ai
Jy.) ~
l.P l.;;.)
~tj
c.:,~
....
W )I
~..Lill
~-
lA ~
~
~I ,~Wi) /,1#1
.~WI
~ _,_.,... )1 o_;Al,W1 JY o
·~I.J
._j ~\
~
.rJ:-
~I
J1 ~I d o~~
~>J1 ~l!.J
JI J5'J1
J~I - "\
J~
------------------------------
~JtJi1W1 .. u\..w.\jS --
"-:-Al...
oJ~
L.
j!l._) 'f)
\.-:;!
lli..i
J\~a~ b~i
~~',Ca"
\ky) ~_} ~
~,.\a.JI:~ bl>. ~
~>J
w~ii.uWI,
.1..a4'i
_'~J\
ir
r-WI 1..Sy-.... 01
L~_;~
~
..
I;';
LJ...... j\-1I
~~l'\.i
,~_)a.J\
J~
o_JY
If W ~JY
~.)\.:..J\fl C~WI~
IJA ~ ...>oJ .~WI
JU,I
~ ~~
Wl
\64,.9J
~>J ,~
~I
0)§' ,-",ley ~I
P
~
tPL!.)),1
C,)_,..;JI,r-iU C::)
~J_,J:d1
'~If
~~I)
J>-b
c.Sft
c.S.)W\ )1 lS""~1 ~
ss:_rJ1
)1 ),-,.6:11
~1' ~I
~)
)1
#-
uP;4; ~
jP
Js-
~~\':"J)l1
~~W!J
'-.S""'~I ~I
(,5~1
0)§' ~J
r6:;!
..boo)
..l.:Jj; !S"'~I
r--Wti
~\
.~\..Aj
~ .!l.r~~1oS.)})I
~1..d.1
wl~)
~~
r.~_,..JG .~
~\.A:;)I~ ~.~
_JU,)l1 ~
~G
~I
tS)2.J1 .)~~Ilf)"u
~L:...
)J..a ..
,~I
~~\
,.
Y') · illl) ~G
~
~ ~li
,.
~I" ~ . ...j cJ
~I
lSI
(,$..u ~_r.4i\
_r-l-)
4..K.!l1
~ti:.
~
~ _) ~
J\: 4-:... 1 w~
~~_rlG
c::._)_,....JI
J\ ~~
Js-
J\A:j)1\ J\ ,~,
..
_r.;.; ~)
.J.~ J.J
_JU,1 ~ ~
A;.;'~) ~
J--li if
~;_,-.j if
J~I ~
'r.\
~~
~
J!
~I
ipJ ~~
J~
~\;.J\
~j) j\kj
dJ
~j
.1.11 ~
LS ~_) J\ ~~_J;a.:J\
~ ~I
_r-W\ ~~J
,:i;;!~\
~>
4J ..::~!~I ..
~.)l:dl
~J
..:..L.I_rl\'1 ~~
Js-)
~I
~.)U.J),I ~,)WI
Js-
I..boG ~
~L.WI ~
~.))l1
~G
J1 c.S.)\.:..)
J;;~ w.J1
~ ;~
~
~
4.Sft I~
aJ.rJ.I" · tS..u.1 i~
do.",,! _,...:;
i\.:j Jl
I~I ~
,..
\,$',4;;
tiAi
JS'J
'_?-\
\fL..;;1oS)"~
u=J1y~..ul
J~.)I)
u.l4i
;J~
J~
r1 ..\.)4; JI d~J_;»)
~
«~lJ»
J>~
~~4.tJJUIJl
.:'..J ~
~~I uP.rU
if
J~1j ,o~..l>.- ~~
..!.J ~
tY lk..~.:1\ 4-iJ1
W!,.. l..l..,j ..r-:!)
U'" \ill
1,';.P- w\- • :~ 1 0~
,.,_-------------------------
uP
(.)M\.-.~
Jt)a ~
oA
--
~,S,i;t~
...
Cal...\·< ---------------------------~
J~
~~I)
r+11'1 ~I
~
~fil'J
~~J
~~
'~J
J.:."":! ~#I
.o_;_)))
oyiJi \l
~£
s-~\
~
41.,~411
u-"~I ~I
c:~
41)\-)
~l:.Lo":1I ~I Lr
,y ~')\j LPi)1
Lr
~I
.~UI
i.S.lL!._)'1 \
~J
~ . ...>~
L4~
J~ Jt o~w. ~.r.~ .p_r L.. I~I ~I ~ C~.,.-JI)I 15U2.J1 ~WI }kl J ',.-8; Jll')1 ~I ~\ ..:..~_)u .)~I Jl J~ \') ~Sl_; ol:- ~ LS""~I ~lj
.kWI
~ ~
JL, ~I
r}u L. I~I ~
·U-. ~I
L"
~~
l'
J_,A.!
~J
.l,jl5')
Jj--4 ~I
~I
';$'~
~_)"1..J)
'~j.i!J1 ~~
.:;.,)~
I..?
J)I J_f>WI
~'j
JJ~ ~
J5"'
~WI
L~) ,.~~\
.:;.,~~'jl
• J6:-.l\ _,.-l'1
~y.
'j}>- J--Y ~I
.r.? ·4,j\~
, ~I
J
if~1
Js;
~~
w~..w
('£.)YJ .~
. s- 1-*a4~i. v\
j .,./
o_)y ~J..bJ ~I .16.,j ;,..) t~ l:A .:.;-eJ 'if~ J~ ~'jJ .. ,~L:l\ ~\~\ )1\. ,~¢~ld.\ tLJJ\ ~L t:..\\ )\.~.-:i\ J\".J4_..,'1' ~lA
A" __
M • ~
....
,y- ~I
$.
~'QlJ
,y!_raJI_,
fit~
j:!~J
,~\
~\
~\
-~ ,'ac.\
d\';}1
c: JI lS'"\l2.J1~WI
J\;.:..)\ ~
cr ~I
~ ,JAJ ·~I
~~I
~I
Jl
~1.tJ.l ~I
Jl ~~
b-_,...k
~
~Jr~
J;-)
.)~ JI~
'L>?I
.,P
..
~L-
y\::.S'
.:;.,)I~
Js-~
.;W 1.b,Q"
W Jj§'
~lJ)U1
uL..y L.6C.L,.:, ~
.r:j ..;~ 1 'uP}-J J.L..,.) --4";" I .. r--"I jJ) .~....wl ~_r11 _)~ ~!:.tl
~WI JI L>~\:.._) <:_.)_,..jl l'1 ~t.~
dk ..
a~)
i.S~1
_)tk'J'l JI ~U2.:J1
~
~
WJ '.l~
J-\A.i
t_"';'_", ~)lIy\l
..
d~"a..
IlA
~ ·~I
~L-) ~I
~_,J.I J~I
rl
~J
~.)w.J
~I <:_~WI ~
Jl,aJ~1 JI ~_)I_r.;;... ~1
OJ;}s.
.,:.,'kk:l:.1
it> J';'
>~lS.lll
r.1.A.:l1r'" 6 A,..
c.S~L!.)\II
i~1
c~ __,.....J19 .p ."... "",l..._,J ~~ '-»~ ~ _rs1 ' .. ,ail I.-4JJ · «41..,-11 _,-j d lA.JJ')J ~~
.~\ oJ.fJl) lS~W.J~I [_.)_,_JI
i.e,""
i~Jii.I'J I~"
iJJ
r~
0)§' ~IJ!
.,:.,'j~
~I
r--G
#-
._r.!:v-J
L:-"U J::ki :~
lS.)l:-,) '1\
C~_,.._JI ~)
~ )1\ ~
'~J\ ... II
i~\,1
~lk'l\
~'lJ
(LQ=t?\ J~
o~
~)__u ~
-------------------------------
~I
J~
,)~J
..
,-p~_; ~I C')_,..jl
. «jW~1
~) ;.3~ .>~
~l;
J-» li_?~)
~ ~
iJ)§' ~y..J
4.L.~1
$>
~W\
~~
J")\>.
16
L ~ .~
cr" 1.S'""L..1
~..b-J
.>~I
,Q",,! ~
,->..ul ~I
il~1
,~WI o_;~ ~~
.«(~
ojuw ~_#
t- ~ 0yj!
~I ~ ~
,~\t
J 1 ~r
Ifo
~
~ Lf...D1 ~JI
,.iJL, · ~)..L:JIJl
$
~I
t?1
~~_)a.:JG
~
~li.ll
li-- iJ~
~
if ~
~ ~ :~ ._;Y\:>JI Ifi ~
.>~
·«~I)\ J}ll
~J
,.
I~J
.~_,.".J:-)
Jl ~\
~~
6-
~~
ib~1
j..P) <.5111
.~1.1I
;_;jJl
1.5> ~W.I
6.
Jt ~
~I
~\
~\S"' o_;y. ~
Jl
~j'1l
_;*
~L..\
~I ~JJ~
o.')frY
~
..
o..La.»
'->~G ,~I
if) 1 J--e~
(.~) ~~
....
Js- ~
~
..... ~ y_,LI ~
~
if
#
~WI
~\"'!,;
~ J-kll (,$~:ll
o~1
~~
J~
~lS""
I .J.i.~ o~~
~jyUl
~ ~
oh ~J
.Jyc:;.J
~~
4j~
;,:,~~
I~J
61> ~~
· "J\_; 01 J-:.'~ ~ ~
J.'~ "-'\.-J ~~)\.,. ~~ cr-> 0J§' 0\ tby. t..S_)~ ,
~
Js..£,
'->~
~;,.~
,v
LP~
t;",.:Y'
'ri ~ ~
~
- ~.)l;,) .,rl
~;.)
b.-,)~
($.'lL:.)
~_)rJ ~~
Js~J
J_,A.;
Ih
.. !JI':' JT C~~I
£;; 01 ~ )~ J')\>. ~
"jjJ-D
..:,..1!.k~1
._;~ ~I
~I':'
_
II-
4S'\_;.)\ ~
.!.1J.:, o_;>-I
uu4J.l)J~
0).r--1,-;,',o.;' 'U-.:6""J
r~}-f
~l:1IJ
J~ ~
..uL..
iJ)§" U"\...~
t:-
£\
~
L_o.:,.J
~I
J-,,_,s-L.
!l ~ ~ _;
J_,.6J\
ij~\
op (.51 ~.)J.Jd~
J_,AJI
Jl
~Ij>.i ...:,,\5"'.r ~
~G)\
V ~;':"'" 0~ tifT
~_r.i~1 ~~
wi LSi)
* Kuhn, t.s., A Function for theory experiment in Scientific Revolutions, Oxfrod Univ. Press. 1981 p. 20 - 22. ** Hilary Putnam; the Corroboration of theories.
----------------------------
uP UMl.~ ~_;.b ~
\.
--
1t . At.. ilULA
w~,
t_skb:-
.c ------------------------------
l~i:Q-.j_rs1 }
\~AA",!
0~
.~~
..\iJ J_,.bJ1 if
J4J\'
~
.),..U::.
')ftJ ~L..
~
~J
~..>I.5J1_~ c.S.fJb
ft .. .;;
i_r-j~1
J:,J~
.:l..lY .:ly."J
t~ • .:.~
~i.J ~'1
e:?'J ~
J_,.bJI
if
J4-i'1
if ~;
~~4
.)~J
u\JJ .•a:~1I ,
~ J'~
Jl
~_r.:J1 u\:kJ.1
J';:
..b:--y- '1
~i ~"~4:!\ ~i £~ if~.:l ·
,,) ~~
~~
u~
'~pl
t>_r.. c.SjJ\ ~~
~JJ
P
..
~J
,~
o)y ~
J d~
~.ai
#-
r..lY
u,..J" J Iy.::-;
I~I
W4 r:~
~jS'
~\
.~I
0i ~)
#.
J~
..::..'1\J.!
~..u A....:..u
j')\>J\ J~
~~\
0i J~J 'l>~i
.~\~L..
c_} wi JY~\
\l.a.
_p1
0i ~ ~
.~~.t..
("S..l.J-*1 ~WI
6~U;,
'. ".~t>i)
&_rAj1
J:.. Jb
ol!..;
~
J"';'
if 0} ~~
.)ft)
~~j:AJ1
if
L,,-
J~ ~~
~tA..
d).l.e ~
if
_pi ~
fila ~I
c
u-AJI ~ J~ d ~)j
~4J · , '\ ·
JI.i) .Ipl
+ -
c! ~
J')~
'A"\·
d uJ~.)
ol.:.~
)l5J1 ..::..)L... ~
'V 0_;JI ~
ih ~ ..>-G 1 ~
.iJ
L....U:.\...
Jl
t....>~4
4---J...u
l.
:,;!
~.fr ~
~t5:J\ ~
~i ~J~
#.
'11
· «(W) ~\J
Q')\jl
Y" 4. ~I
I..":.Ilk,kall ~~
£\.)
d
(,)~)
~I)
t~
~
,.
d' ~~ ~} ~ ,
A;.,ai
W:.;..... ..::..~K.I
~~_r-AJI ~I)I
(')1 ~
~
1_,tS:.i1
(,)~
,~~.r-AJI
d _1,1}'11
Jl
WW,I ~ )LS:t'11
o~
0i.r.P
,~,.b~ \6.!"~
,-,~~I
~J
.j,j.rJ.1 .;;~~_~
(.51 ~)'ut.;.
~I
} ~~.. \ ~
if~
,.
~\J;>-I ~
J<.4J 4.4~
U~J
)~I
o~rrJ~~
~W\
ot.;:: '1\
0~
"::"~_)=.;J
)LS:ti ~i ii , Disjunctive
alternative
.)Wl ~
JW~J W
'-.>.lI1
~u.t\
o4J
~}::JI
LL.t- YJ
. a....:,lpyl~
~l.:.l.1
~WI
L :!~O.:l\.a":A yl~ ~ ..
~L.:l\
~}:ll
)#1
cJ rWI
~GJ
l>.ll!._) (:~~
4\~ L.S'
~
_t"
~\.j
pi Js- J..: ~ <.>..ul ~l:J1 ~I .r.f- ~ ~.pb_) \'1 ~~__,..JI ~L. lip
if
0i
~J
4 ~~
~.H4.A )~I
\..i..A
Js~
~~J
,~\:..JI ~}:ll
~ ~
it.. ~
~
J}j
~
~Y-
~I.0)§'
~\l1
,~
I}kl JI ~.)L!.)6:-';_,...;
..
I..».?
..i
~
U-- J , •.)\.,4.0.1.\ .
J'~\ <51;yl.:dl
J_,Aj1 i~\..
1-4.!) .~~I
L..jl::.11 ~W.I
~~_,.....; ~fty.
YJ ., ~) ~\l1
~Ull
til>-
LS.)\.!._)
\II (,.l_,.-;.ll ~
\II ~,;
-
..
~
if
~YlJI 1.5"~.)
0~
l>.)l!._)
J_';: ~~
J~
!\ta) ·~!.s0
... y
Jl ' cr
~I ~.J..JI o_).fll
:U_rJ.I
..
J.
i~L,;':~L
_,.....JI ~J>.I
A~)
Jr
~
;J"J,) ? \II
Jl
L.
..
- J1LS.)W,) )1 _rl
,~~ ~(~~I4...J~ Ajb ~)I
~)
,t~1
if ~ r ~I
_).,w
-. 01 Jl wJ§' J'\..Y
C,;_,...; ,y v\_).b ~
O"j'JI,slli
J\i\...
~
~}:ll )10\,,)1 ~
IJ' •
(.$~
.'.J\
'w.1J! ~J1
~
t~
,
~ J)_)~Y.
Jl.)_r
1..>_,..,;,tG ~
J..l!. J~
..
Y"
~I
.r_;J1l.m ~}Ai
J)s:t
_r'-I ~}
~~I
-,.
\..~ ~~
.J~:~.fly.
.~
,-;-,4\1.1 ~I ..
~6:- \II ~
JI J'__,Ajl 1..>1
-
~pJI
u\fl>-
j:.
~ ..:.r
)1 J',;AJI
w.J>.1
J:- ~ ~ ,J'J
Jt.w 0~
IJ_,J~
..
.. \'4
~j
#-
0i
Duheme ~))~
~l.JS. 0i
~WJI
~I
LSf,. l.:!! ·~ ~
~--4
cJ
~
\j~1
~4~1
~
j!~
~
o~ t>llG· , ~
~I ~I .... .;}~
·J~G
~ J" - I
J-~I
~/\l1 ~
.!l_,L
"
Jl
,->_.rl
"
r-W I _)_,.kJ d ~
~J""
- '-:"
#
.~~L!.) E~_,_.;."I~,
..
.r' ~
o".l...l! 0)§'
~I ii.,_.:jl
a..:.4411
~,Qj
01 1.1t.
~
_.
l.pl!.)\lI.
~JJ.)J
I.! ~
~\
,r'>U ~lA..
I.i?
v I_#U
\Ai_,...
.r
Js-
.s:~ \ rW I ~ ~
J~I
_r.y.
o: Y
..
J~I
t.?_,...
J~ IS'
)k\ J>b)
Jl
I -':'" ~
L.I '«(.$~~_)
,.
and philosophy;
Bulgarian
Academy
of SC.- Sofia.
~
) \ e.
**
~ ~L.~
--------------------------
~..fo ~
,y
--
lJ'.,i;"L.
~\.w.'~-----------------------------.
--
4.]\'.) LS~..r.P
J:-:.j
J}j ~
~G..LII
t~_y
~\ill
4.]6- LSI ~J
JJ,.,o
i_"i.)
,J)I
~
.. iJ'A~
:i4~J .)J~"v.;:
~)I
·~\..:;. ~
,.
· (~ '-':LSl) ~J~
L.w
oh ~
LSI
~
L ...
~\..
._j))~Y.
'~4_r-iJ1 u4)aJ1
~;'~.aj
..,.
:4:.-:J~
yWI ~
~I
~\il\
~Y
~)
o_':::-'
. &..\'\
h..
6-
~4~1
u-I ~)
(,)r·~lG ~\
J'L..I
J;
,J
~.itdl 01 ~\j
L;';:~!J
JWI ~ ,~~I
~~)\J
tSy··· ~I
- ,;'!.,;,4)1 )1
~I
-->-
ob\'I o_,:·..•
if
-.
:i-":. ..l, ~
~"l J.jl ~
~..w
..
'd4_p4JI
~I
LSJ,:.d
.,.
o~
..li ~ JI
~
cY
4)~
~~
..
J'L.."l1
,.,!...)b..J1
~-!~
4 ': ~
~I ~I)I
~~\i
~
if WW\
,!jla
~)aill
~")\5"')
iJ~
r-.i ,~~
JWI
,.
la....Y
Js-
.~4~1 ~ ~
~\... iJf4A
LS~
,J~\...
~:j
yo) (~(')
~ \..;.;~
~.:-: ..,jJ
~jJ
JsO.)~
ul}-
I~I 1...;. ~
t>.)~ ~
~~
0i jA ~ ,~
~
j ,.
~''':!J
~\&. ~~
~b
u~
c..S---!. ~
~~~\
j~1
~~\ ~
~I 01 ~
4+M4\;J\ ~~\
~
~
::!
4j\ rl ,o}1\
I-
t.l ~~y)
~ ~~
...:,.t;~~
~\
~\ ~~
J\!. ..J ~J
l.W 4lL-\
ul)~
1.1.. ,~~\
L.
Jl
Jl.A:;\'1 ~
~I
i..w
if .J ~
01 ~
r-' H ~~I
~141\
~
~
4' V"hf.JS
~... tl .i,
Js- J.:...!..'i
~)6i .. ~
:i;:.WI
·~J..i.S'
I. ..
.d=- \~ ..a~J
c!l"J
.v- •. !.11
YJ4.:>."l1 d)jj
04
($.,:&4)
~i
LSy· ..•
Jl
J\.A:j"l1 0~ I--4JJ
,r ~~~~~~
-----------------------------------------------------
~~I
I.._.
~ ~.\J';-:.N \'\ .
~I
,_
)a.J1 ~
_.--,.
l.~
(51
JVi
O\~\ ~. _j
J\ ~ ~~
.~_;;!~
~UG ~~G
'..S .,4';,.,./ .. ~
A .:
~!
..
l.i1J ~G
J
G•
l. ,. t ~ tP'MW\. \ ~..
4-.'; ~ JI b;~'. ~
~)d; Jl
.t..J.:.-)
~ if)
~\S"
,~
~~)
;;~~
0~
...A;
JI
t!b
~L~I J~
YJ'b ~~)
J~~I
J~ ~~
,.
J\
01 ~~
L...~
J)_,A.l1 o.Lt.)
~}All
..!.U~
Jt:... 'r-WI
~\.A4oo;' ~
J~~I.J'b
..:..~)2.ill
0L.y4;
L...;.:!
~
if ~)I
0~)
~~.-: ';.:ll
ts.)~ ~
~ y:.;.". ~LOJ
~)a.JI ~
t.p~
:'ft')
J~ ~~
0\...i.!..s:i ~J
l:.A.) 'yl~1
,y-
\II l.~:!!
ylJ--P
.)J..l.>
u.)..b#.
i~..b:J1
1.1t. if ~)I JI
Js- ~~\
4;:...:.l1
«.. .1';J
cr" ~)\
u\.;.11 J
c.j
b-_,....k
~
JI UJjS' 1.1)!J UI if
,.
411 ~~
~JI;;)
~J_r-. J>w-!
~
Jly':l ~\
':J\ ~\
~.L
~\
~
:Jli
4.~tAj
~
(.))~
~\
c:f
r.
~_,A
~\
(..$""'lJ
{(.!lI~)1 J)dl
~\""'l.
l)
)1 ~\
,.
;;_"\.e-ll ~
G)y.H J ':J ~~
01·bl_;bl ~_?,.,,:'"-QoJ
...:..~I
~ ,.
'1 ~I
~~':; ~ ~
1\
cJ ~)
~)
J..:=Lr \~ .."A
l...,I4.A ._:_,~I
.)J:~::.:J .~
U< ~i a . IM
U~ ifJ j
J2.~1
I"j J LW 4-i~
J)~ ~J.Y J~i
L..,.)
4J ~\
~I
~
~_;ll
d' ~:,
Ji ~
..li t.~~1
d' <.iW1 if
~lS' .~I
i~1
cJ ~
.J ~
~I ~'J
'41~1
~\.,iJ l.,k~ ~
rA_~t~)\~~~~
**
H.M. Collins
of Extraordinary
---------------------------
uP
(jML.~
tJ.i~ ~
'\ i
__ ~
4,1,8, __ ~~\t( w
.. .
....,..
s:
,J ~_;'\
LS ~\ ~':1 ~~\
o: JJ.i ~
-l$"_)_,:j\
~~
~I)I \J..,. ~I
#0
#0
if ~)\
~L~ Y\/J
Jlkl ~
~J
A
,~
.d ')1\ ~~G
~I
~J_;JI
y~
Lt.
0)§'
••••• ~
J~G
~\
;,_~\
~
J~I
oJ?' ;_"~I
~ ~~ ~:~'i
~I
o)_,:J\
!>-
J~ u\
OJ? I ~
P ~;, ~I
~~
~..u
'~_"""'P"'J ~
c.
~J_r1\ Jt.(;')1\
~j$'J 0~.u
s-I-LJI 0"'~)
01 J__,A; ~
~)
:~~~
~ ~J_rJ_,s'
J~ W ~~ ~
~
«(~I)
.G\.,ap\
~
«~J_,:JI» ~_,.4j1 w~
if
wI - ~lS
oJ.fl1 0':1 ~~ ~I~ ~ :: ..
~
~W_JI JK;I
0~
~
0~
,~
'1 IJ..,. 0\
. ~\
r1 -~
~ J~I
}.b\ ~ ~~
d ~I
" 01
(J)~
'~Y-
J.
ut5"
Jl ~> d JUaN I L 4~
~I)
~J
~
t \la,:~..1
,~I
~I..u~ ~4J1
e:: b~
6J__rJ.1 J.J~J Y. ~
'll~
&.
JWI ~
..:..}~I~I
-
J} L>..i1I) ,WJI ~
t.>~
oj.fll (,$1-?I
(,$..ul ~WI
o.!l~
.r.?
~!.t.l4.,..J
~I
J1
Jli:.i':11 ~
Jfi)
·~WI
~
J~
a.~
~..uJ
r:.
W,:, ~I
. ,!j~.!I)/1J~
..::.;tJ) ~
J:.
~L(lIJ
.~~H ~1a~ ~
~~
~y'1J
~)
-.
\~.;a~
LQ~
•
LiJ
(o~\J
~) ~'l y
i~
J5' t.~I
~\A.:lG
Jl.,.zj~1
..u
...I.:~I
~~
.1.r.\A.. lt~
IJ..,.
L$.J:!) ~
W ~~
~
~.,Uj\
• 0_r- l;._\J
~y)1 ~\~I
0~ ~~I
J.s=- J~)
j5JI )1.1
d I~~
\!.i.$" ~.l>~
J5' ~J
tJl
~ '::J _u\
\0
UJS.
~LA.jj
J.*~ ~
-------------------------
------------------------------
...,.
oh
~..r. ~'1~
c_s'bJ
r-lJ · ~\.J.lG
~? J~
~£
)li ~I
~
l!'. ,:"\..i. ~
J)JI
)J.l1
~WI
4JJ~
~~)
U::-il_,;
J~
w)
4
~~
Jl
d'.r
.o~~
~I~J
vl.,..,1 ~
~~)
ftL
Ih ~....»
·.yl :;}.~)l1
#-
r-~ J fit.. Jl ~G
t>..ul ~WI 0~
~yJ..r-!l.t.. ...,..,\.....I ~
~.J~)I
~
~tj
Of"...A.:,J ~.JJ.j
d
~
l:'
o~)
LQ!~.~j
~I_,..il lit) ~~
Al~)l1 ~~I -~I ~I
l-
Jl
~I}I
ts.r. _,t ~
~~
~
J'_ri.I1
~J
~
.J.:J:-~"J ~I
::>'J ·
411 jJJJI ~
.~
~Ir
J-
0':'y.-.r" :i ~l::.shl;..k. .
0~ ~l::jjL...::,... 0\.:;J
41.)~
:f ~
.k_# ~J 4.::.6l\ ~
· «~I}I_, ~I_,
d J_;)) J~
l:;W U
.aL!l1 ,,~ ~'1
~\P\Jz.i'1\
"
cJ
W
~
LS~l
w..p"
~
~WI 4J~ ~\
l,.,I.;:o!
#.
Js- ~
u=JG
~
YJ - WAc:.
#
01})l1 :;.l~\
l~ .12::-, ~:kll
~
0.)y.-)I ~I
JL.;I ...,..,\.....I
#-
Js..
II:. ,. - ,'\J'\J,
J
c(
~
r \ ~ :\ ~ \ Q .. II )T :J
~
l~~
I~
--.11 \~
Ie. \ ~
J.;;.;.\
~
.. $~
Jl
0\
#.
'1)4'J
~~ftAJl WI ~
!Jla
~
_ftW L. J~
(j ~
0J~_;-'!'1 ~.u.l.!.ll
JaJ
~)I
c:.r ~
~) ~
.1..:J~u;.
\"w ~I_,
c::
Js- }y rl :fJ ,~
~\ ~) ~ ~
~:J~) C~W
.r"\;.; ~I
~_rj y'l
e::.,ai wi ~
r-L- ~
!3_,L
~I)~)_;;
0i 1.1..~ ~
w ,pI _r-l~)
.")\!.. ~I
~w.J1 ..:.>~
~.rJ1~
~ \W\ \' ~ ~i .fl
~> 01 ~
~
U~A'>' if
.l_r:w.A 01
o...\"bl!J
t.. }kl
l~ ~~ ..., ~
01 ¥ · ~..i1..d.1 4J,;)~ ~
~\
•
~.J.:J:I
J.~~ \Aj~
o~~
....
~\ ~
~ ~
.0,
_)~
!t, ~:.~t~.\\
'-ii'J - -
c~
t,_.l_J\
A'i ~~J ~I
~_,:-11 ~
'~r-ll
o~
4-!:kll WJI P d
--------------------------
u.P
(jM~
~~
\\
--
lJltii, 4
tl
ul.....\-.F ------------------------------
if ~I
01 J~ 0i
;;J~
~
I~_.?~L
;;~ j
40 WI ~~)2.J1
·o~
<.S..l.a
cJs- if' ~
J t_j I
~
6-
~I ~I
r' if J
~I_, r-WI if
~~
o~..bvJ ~IJ ~~
\.;::..i ~
:.r ~
~I
}kl
~.",:!L.
WI ~~W.j)'1 C~WI )1
d cs~I
<,Sljl~?I
~L,a;
~
~-.4
~ _rJ1 ~"YuJ1~
~~I
j.-W_,
01»
~ ~
~J
o_r.>J1~~
J~
~~
~L...l5J\ J")\>.
if I_r..i
J-; Lo:;J
01 IJ.. ~
#.
01
Ll
J4;.i
·* ~~6J\~1
~li1.\
~>
01 ~
~
;py
~'Y
~I
t5'
- 4k.:,,,) lS_?--I
~~_)2j1
~")W)
~~
J")l,;.
~L. \'1
7.J~
Ih
t: <Ji~ \'
~-~~_;,.J\
if
J.
o_r.>J1~ if
l5.r~
~~_)t.J1
P) ~..wl
~l5J4
t::~')i
;;-4~1
if ~~
wJ§
\"~~J
~\
ill \ ~~
,-;=.4C 6\.i\ ~
lJ~ .fl~\J
<:~WI ~ <.Sj\_j ~I A:.:";'_).l ;;,!)..I.~dl ~~.:>I)I ~~I 44\:Jo!:.I ~':>\.;..J C ~W\ d y\_,-,4! ~ ')il I~I J..ii yt:S:l1 ~~ ~ £t ~I · «~~I -. j::.! 0~ ~ .r:Yo J_,.QJ 1 ..:r E'I; ~ .~ IJ'i ~ \ 'i\ ~~ 4:11 6....>.-_,ill A..4 \j .:r.P ..
~1_,.J11») ~.:>I.;..J 'YI
~J
~I ·~
~I_,::jl
WJI
~l,. .. -:~I
~L;,~I ~~
r-LJI ~tp
yti:.J ,~_J\
~ ,.
I ".
r uP c::-)\ ~
~;~
** Albert
Einestein: the Problem of Space, Ether, and the field in Physics. includthe publishers of Science; Washington
Square
-----------------------.--------
4~lJititft.
~~\JS --
~
~
LoL..::1!I1 ~I
~J.M
~~I
lS~1 01 0J~
6-
Jl
~,}I
~I
c:-_r..)
br-"~
0U~
(.$J~
LIJ~ LS'I,~I ~I ~I
~4.P thematic
~}J
analysis
is_,s::..tl1 0.Jo4',~ll ~
~~I
~Ir
~J
if 4..b-f if
Jizi
.J 0~
~I
;,;_rtl J_#
~
J~\
JI
~
~I
~.J
,;;_,A.l1 iJdQ~
·~.i~~1 JI
$
o,:,lU ~~)
~
~~I
oPJ
.) ~
~\J
($~~_),}I ~~~\
~j~1
~\""')'I
01J .~Lo
Jll>~L::.) ~~~
~ti~
o;,~
if
b
Jc-;·j
~\
(tll ......
~
4\....aJ'i\
J-l4..
~
~_)jJl :~~
4'_r>)1' J.\.A...
J~
• ~i;"
o..u. ~
tl.A.>~
;)~J
\
QI__, tionsim
1 -\ \ 4.J ~ l.. -~
..
...
\~~)}
, ~, \
~\Lt, \ -..
)
_fo
-'.....
-A.J J.J~
-
'-"
~
J~~~,\
\..:_..../
r~....j
~
...I~
,_At:.
0\
I-
8\ · ~..wl
1.lAo~
01
Jl ~
~
'i <0\ ~
$-
· ~..w\
o~
oJ"':).s. .} ~
~J
.J~I ~ ~
i--'~ 4.~ J~'il ~~
t}.Ju ~
QJ~ ~
-;S'y.'wa ~L..\
~
J*
,~WI
c:.v:- J.-!.s'i
iSJJI
ul~1
0~ 1.1bu,.h-
JI--41 i~
r ~ ~~ J~
'1\ ~. •
• -J
~
j
.;:~
..q
~.1ij1 C~~I
,j:{
I~\ \II
ts=- JS"' ~
C~
,,)}I
r'i
tl ~~~ ~
.J J~~ ,~I
.~'J\
c;_,.....JI
f·..A~ ~
y.;'"
aj
d U,a.t;ll
151_,.J1 ~J
01~ 01~_,H ~
,. 01 ~I_, ~l.
~) ~\...
0~
'i
J!'
,,;::1\ IlA
rJ
_ ~)\
.~..\.AJI
~ iif
~...::;;- ,~
~ ,.
r · 1 ~)\ uP
i*i::
---------------------------
u.,s
~l.~
~~
,\A
- __ l ,t"'+HA
...
U~\·<~
-------------------------------
~~I
~~I
~
~\.j
Wb.-- ~
_'.-J •
)1 LAW
Oj~
~..wl ~~w.j
01 · -4~\
($ ~~) ~ \
~
')11
C~~I
d .u.~ rJ'
~JA
U..• ...1
!.Sf.. \ .. ;;
;J".~
\.)J~
../
4,k~
4 -...; ,S"
[_,)y-J\
~ ~~
_.I
.:.;:-r.o11 _
--.J •
ct
Uk iL. ,J\ ~ .. -
L_j '1\
o.l.:>- \ ._
\.
u.. J.... ·
7 \\
~ .w
..b-~
LS'~w.) C~_,-j ~
!.S~l!.)
C'::,)r:!
,. ~ I.
~\ · ~ I~?-" ~
0\ 0)~
\~
t ~
~\
Ai."2Q~~1 · JU;:......J
jJJ6-
i..?'
r:"U
~lb~1
c.SG ~
~4!b;l •. JI JL.i":l1
Cl,....I,j\
~..wl
JWI JLiI
~~~_) \II C~UI
c.S~\.:;.J ~I
c_,)_,...J1 \.eA!~ ~\
u..~1
WI ~
~l;.
~t.....I,j\
L,r.:-!
1St If
I ~\
JL:u":l1_, J~t41
~U:JI
(,$..iJ1 .J"b
-4~1
~4p4J\ ~)j
J'_)Jy_
Jt
ll.~ ~
) ~I '~
.d~
~I)
· ~£
I~
,. uk-.J 'il)
J. ~f y.:.:.ll r..>~l!..J\II
\l~
~
$
c_;W
~Jl ~
~j-4
~ 0)§'
)1
'__,k-) ~
,.
·~~)
~ \... :~~I
01 J~
~J
..::;4p)
.~I
~I
0\ 0J~ '~J
#c
JI~ e;?'r
~J ~__,.-iJ ~~
~..wl
JI_~~I
~I
J~\
,y- ...::.lk,;."J1
c.S.lJ\
tlWI
~~I
j.A1J1 ~
~~
0i tjj--ll
.~Jj
L:f-.:
~
~I
d 4,ji
~~
~
~
~jJ.J_
r-'
C~W\ ~
(.Sf..
~~.)
J-Ir
1.l".JJy_ c.S.ll1 ~\
01 J~ ~~ Js~WI
(.$f-
l....~J
. j.A1JI
oGe
LA~
JI ~
~~I
".
":I JAkU
WI Jy_~\
s.~
~\jJ
LS~l!.)JI
C~__,.-J\ ) ,o~~\
~I
01
~
..:_,I_,~'.JI
J:. ~
~I
L:f-.:'iJ
~.Y'~
\Ftu ur·tU
J:.. ~
~.)J.:>..:.,. l ~~
UAIS' ~_rU
~u w ~~
"~l' .i\
J
.....~
·1
..,;i
(.S~)
.~..L4J1
~
4~J
J...a;
,.t\
~
(.$~
:J~'
i
tiW
<: ....
._:-i}1 ~
~I
.!.\bJ
V\.!r\
I.
...
t,
ruwAl
U\R::-:.~
·t·
~~)
, ... • t
· 44;:$
(.~~')
.t,
~·1_.11
t.:..\'
~t;
~\.S"
~
~~l5''':14
J"\..._';
~J.hJ ~I
4Ji '1\
;.bWI
~.rU
---------------------------------------------------------l~ .. ..
~~I
,-Q!j k
A, "A'i.U
~.U.,""'\·< -_ t· '..;-
:!3 i~~1
~I
..
~
'~
I_,lill
d
jA)
.!J~ \1 _,A1_,l;J1.;..I~ ~
~~I ~pl ~ ~Ip
o-4~1
~o~~1 ~)2.JtJ
~J
w ~ :4W\
~6- (~~I
~I
I~)
~\
~'!>
if ~
~..wl
~~I
,)1 _I
,.
.;~~\
~)2J\ ~ '1\:.- ~
~\>..
((Jil_rll)) ~
lSl)1 y~
So
~..u)
~\.Q;,..
,(.;..~y)
...j
~I
.;..\_r-A:lI
d~
j5"' ~
J\ y\AJ\
~
tU (~I_,:JG
~\.r-'M.i; ~
-y.s- ~
l-
~
1"~
J.,A-lG .~
~~)'J)
J. ~~
:/ ~ rLll -
:J~
~.lJ\ ~li>J\
~
~!J.,j\
o~U2Jt; .~
~J
l......L I~\
,_;>-I
i"'« 4A
~
~~ :.>- if ~\~J>.-.J:!~ ~~
'-.i.~)
.. ~ ~~\
0~
Jl tYlP
~.uJ
y~'J
0~
J\.ii
jj
oJ !.. ..A;
~'J
4!~
--4~1
Jl
~..wl
.w~ ..
Jy.v JL~.rJI if
I#-
(._)oM ~
~Ull
~
J~ ~ _r.:\;dtJ
u\ utJI
I-
J~')I\
.~\_,.l\
-.
I-
i4J1 ~~I
~
r:r
~J
~~..J~ ~
...l:>,.
J,;,.? ~
~\
oh
J>- ~ ~
Jl
~
"\';A;!
~.IJI
(JJ~
~pli
u-'L._i
.:r
~..wl ~
~I_,..pl~I
t5.lj1
. ~. ·:.H.,
~'.l> ~~
.J
~W=-1 0.r--Ih
r~1
_r.;-,:
&.
~Jr"""'~'j
~
Ii ir.i.. '
J; ~ ..:..~\>" \II ~
?i wi J.J;J ~
01".,.....
0J')
~ )~
·dL.. J J_,1- ~ ~\
Jlj.J1
-------------------------
Y.
-yy
..
~\
4..a~
~~}I
JI t~:kJI ~
~I JJ~ r..lA:l1
.J~
#-
~~
.vi
l:.li )J ~
,J~I
IJA
Jl
~.rJ1
01
..
~_;::.t~
(Sf-J
$.
":"'.J j~
'i
,~ti:-J
AJ,)J>..
t._,....,..,.. ~
yb.~
\..lydl ~~
aG ~~
.J~
(f
d~
J) WJ
'4. ..4;
IJJ§' )~
r...lA::.ll V~
~
rilll
~I 01) ~.1.LlJJ·~l...J
·o,))a..e
~\
u 'l'l~ ~
·~G
IS~
j)a::.lG
~)__,.w
,.
JJ ~\.;~~I
if
~WI
0.4.:: . ..j
<s.~:.6J1 ~W\
.0L..;j\j
IJJ~
.~ 0\
J~
d ~~
lS..u1 ~~~\
tj rillI
~
'Y iilll
Js:-
~I
~kLU\J . d'J.>.l
~I_~~G
aJbJl
~1)1 if
Ja.Aj ~I
~GJI
j;..w ~
r~
01 ~I .~I
I~J ,~
..
oJ.. ~,..i
wlJ
i.?")~1
.r.f-
r..1.A.:J1_,
0G
if
d;J..:,:..),1 (.$'~I
0~1 ~~
~r.Q"J y~
y.~\ ~
~I
1SJ.l1 ~I
cr" ~~II!.D~
A.a
)II 0A'Y
r..l.A:.lG
0l.J~
.:.
'J_,.6::J1
.~,..:l~
o\j:;- if r..lA:d1rJ~
~;;'J ·~G
.~Ld\
~I
~_,.JI AS'r
J_,w ~~ ~
~b ~I
lS..;:kll
~J
~.'lL:..J)/1 C~l-:JI ~ ~I
JY\> ~
..;...W~I
d ~G
01
~ ~
~..ul
~y
Jl
~) 'jl
~
..;...w~~ ~
,)~)I
s- ~\ ~llj421
Jai.flJ ·~
rs-.Y-
tS.lJ1~_r.t\:JI
oJ~
r I~~ c)J~ "..,4&.1- \.. rJ4;· rWl 01l:J,..a; .,,6;.. ,',....J i~"" J~ \11 Jl ;;~ Jl ~\:.~':l <4j':J JA.--I Jl k4i."':! ~I _,...II
.. "4.
0i
~G
.!J~
01 yWI
J.
y~
rJ.j ~I·~~
if .hit$"'
~
.. J\l~I
Js- 'J*
JyJ !ill
:.r
i..Li.:J1 i.J ~ 4 ~
JA=.iG
..b\5"' ~~ J ·~ ~
~.r
~)
J\~i
\~J
, ($
JWI ~
~~
':11 Cj\,b.ll
:l:,..!~)\ 14l1 ~
· ~WI
Jl
WI
i..l.i:.l G · J_.,....!J G
~J..d\
~
~J
J~)\
cJ
t_,i;
iii ~I
4;:LJl
~
($yijj
~\S'
~
Js-
~WIt..i
~I
If o)~~4J)I U./' Y.
ti
.)~
j,J4J1 ~WI
·J>: ~I JL.SJ\
V\ LaS ~lAjj
~ ~ -------------------------
Lr-'~~ ~~
-~
Jl
-----------------------------
.41J,il~ . .. .
4S'_rJ1 ~
~
I.
~J
I-
~_)~I
wi,J-.=
r..1i"':!~I
~
J.a. ,I~
~
~I
~)
#-
..l:J-\ ~!;;H
r~1
1~
6r
~I
~WI
..lil ~~I
01 J_,.A; ~
~
~!4J1 r~1
~L... \/1 u~1
~
\.AJ~~
~ \.;.j~
~l...::~G
~6:-
:i~::; ~\
01 .AA.! ;U_rJl ~
~~I
~?
~? ~L.ai :,~
C\.::; ~
~~I
.r-1W1
~I
f":';.J
\'W
')I...~
~
~L;I
t...}
Jl
L.~G
J...:ai ~I J1
~
Jl..r!"~ J. t W ~
~
)\
~\j
I~I i~\.~~\
~ ~J
.~WI ~~
4:LJI ~')UI
o.)y!dl ~I_,
~
i ••
Ipti
~I
~
J,l.!..:J\ ~.,,,~ ~~
~\ · rJ..Q:J\ _)~
}kl
:f o_)~
~I,JI 6~\
~I
d ~\; .1l!J J. ~
~
~~
.. .. ..
.kl.!.; ~I-- ~
Jl ~
'Y
. .:l?~..w ......)~'YI
,~I
~I
~I
~
.)J...:,.
~
L.-,g4~
6_)~4
r-WI r..l.A.1
Jl~
~\
wI l.k ~
if
l •.
~I_,jI)1 4i~;jjll
:i...j~\
(.$Y:--J '-f;1~
JSL...)
~r-U d rwW)
~Iy
45'_;>
,til ......I ~
6~1
if
c.S_,::-11
Js-
i..wJ
(~~G
~tll 0~
~~I
J..LpG J>-i
~i I...oA
~.~
\1
LI li--f
~I
)i U"'~)fl
~)f
~ ~J
.rPW1
W
~ W ,U"\~;:NI ~\'
~
~4)2.:.U ~}~I
•. .i1A:J\j . ~1
Ji) ,?bJl)
~\ll
~
~I
if
\.)J§'
s-GI ~.)
wJ~
Ji-w"1
IJ\Q!;'"
jJ~)
ya-L..
d' ~~ ~\ .o~ ~
~I_; _)__,k:l4
,.
JL
~
~li A_;r~'
~I
j~
~\.)_,:J\ <f ~~
.... ~\
l.~
~)/
~\ ~
,;_.~ ~\
~~\
J~
iJ~4" 0~ ~j5'
~J
~I
o~
u)l~
'-.>.)l!,_)
d ~~ W.
~I C~~I
o.:l~ ~
~l;J1
r_,wl _)~
..
0~
~I
~~'4~J <..S""'~\
·~~ ~.".1\
~
~~I
~ J~ ~
,~A ~
(J'1 ~~ .~~
~J
~
~)Jo;; ...1 ~~
~11-4.!
i_)_,!.\1_,
I.h. ...:..W
J>-I~ .!Jb
,4#
~J
.:..r- t) ~~lJ\
OJ? I J\j
r:/J .~I
,.
Jlb:J ~I
1
A,j"W," .. IJ""\>.
(.$r
"
__________________________
y~
,----
.,
--------------------
".".. ........
r. ..... ,.,_,
••- •.
'~.c3C._~:'""""'~_,.~
o)yJ'i 0\
LyA
'~)r
~!< .....
.. J~ 1
_)2.;
w
~
,0)~
4.'"jL. 01i
r-LJI ~
~\
~..u)
.4j)~1
C))
4J ~L~
~
~~
~ A':\
~ -_:\\\
;.~')
0)_?"-lY ~J
'J~4J1 ~I?I
00.!1..\>~
Jl..aJ)l1~
(J).!I
).rM-,,)l1 ~
.~U.~I~hl\
iY.r" J..v.
~J~ ~
~)I
r1 t.).,41\
if
(;JJ~
(_,.hi. --4~Il.l1
, at;.;f
L ~ .;"-)
4)1
I.S..DI ~L:JI
~_)
J~ ..r.f- ~\ \~
ij>."~
A:'~.!
)II .....
r-:..liJ~ ~l..all
..r.fI~J
~
,4a!\ .!JJ..li':i ~
0~ rj\
~
UJ 6'~ lS.iJ1 ~I
~.:
w:.JI ~I ~ I.AJ__,.b;) ~
~~ ll..... 11 ~J.L)' ~I
_rll ~
0J)~
'j \~ ~)
o 'Y6:...0
..
u~fll
~
r' ~~I
~
l.S'" ~)
)1 J-~~
V~I
rl
#
tL.\.;. ~~
-4-\..J1
oJ_; ul_;_,:lJ
0).w
~~I
.k_r. 4..p\:i.J\ ~\
1.)\1 4.>1 ~ J:.)_r.
~
V ':1~
~IJ~
0~':l
~I;~I
rl..l,..j'Y ~l>J\
•
<l
~~)
~
\'1 t....\:f
J
~I
~~I
~i ~\ Y~~
01
·~\
..... O)~
oJ_,:J1 0~
c.
c?l ~
~\:...)
Jk.:.e <l
~I_P.I ~~I
~)all ~};ll ~
~I uA ul;_,!ll ol.
(,$.J_., ~
J!.-J
'1)
..
..... ~_;kll ~I
~i~)1
i..l4:.l1
~I
uIJ~IJ
~J
o)_,;JI
.I....
_}b~
'..-J~.·vO
./-
cr" lSy.y.- ~
w
r-WI ~
~\
_r.dU
~
0i c.1
$.
.~.~\
4>
t;.i
W ,~, ....
~
C.}W\)
JI~I
':1) ,~L..':ll
J~"lI1
..
~ -~ u----~ l ~ ..
~I
\.>
,j
JI"'U\, . 4 •• W\ J
J
j::l ~
JJ..,.il1 ':t
'r--W1 cJ
4.>_)_rJ1
~J..ci
d' 0)§'
J~ :.r.:::.
.!.U.iJ .~~I
d~
A.-.} cY
J ~ ~ 0.,-.:.LI)
r-WI :i_;~\
."
~~I
0~
rl if)
:J):J/)
~L •.;?!""':1\
.J)~
~I r-WI
0l.J':t1 ~I»
0l ~
.~~\
=r» d o l.J"1I
j)~
..
J_,;.;
~ ~
Ll'L..::.:.:-1
~};JI
~)' ~
..\6~
obi
~I
0\
Jl _)'~-:..-l\
~\
c__,...1 ~
J_'~\
~t:..
------------------------------
"4
... t ~
t,I;1"4
~\.w.\.)S --
Jl
Jl:. d
AA!b-
c.S.)~
0i ~L. cr"
'~J
L.~
~J
,.;1'; ti)i-J
.!.lIJ.,) If ~L...;)'I 1
r-WI )~)
LS".lj!
i~
j)
(1) ·~I~ ~)
• "':11 ~
~}.i
~1J_,A.l1 ~
~
~I.)\l :~
~
~6:--~ ~~I
r"c
rUu Y' ~
i~
~I ~I
~\""''il
..
.!.U..: ~~
:t~_,.ll
0.1.
r-WI
~};;
#
io.~b:.
JS"' ~
J~
r-W' ~
~h ,~
L..) '0"')1 ~
.lbJ" ~IJ
.-4J
,,4.;_J"J
_r#WI
L.~
. ~ '->;J \
tyy
•
..
o.;A\J:2Jl!
6-
,t·lt..
~tj~,-!
I t:A'
.)\.J
t~\•
~\:I:-
tie"
~J \i:!k,
,o~u
... ,..
....
..
,.
(,$~
~~
~I
Ii-
(..5""G.) ~
\J.c.
-41£ ~
.)} _)\:;..i\
Ji LI;...u1
...l;&.
.. ~ ~L..I
l.u
~I
.."\.S.)~J Jl )~I
~I
.:f \.oj..b- ~
~Jfi'Jl._J1 01
~) 1)11
~
Js- ~I
~I
0f
Jl )\,;.~ ll Jl J~ ,4._-!!k
~I 6.~ ~~
J"WI ~
0~ ..... ~lA.. ~
i~.AiJ
ffi'iJ ~l:;
~I
.._.,..;
&
~..iJ1~I
)~I.r-fU
J~,:r
J ~.l;u
ifl.:"':"''il
,.
c.S~1
}~':JI ~~
~~J
rJ ,\;!4l: .. J. ~I~I
Jl ~J
JJ»
j,_.l;
0r..:'~J ~
_,s:J1 ~
r Uai J:.a
,~)I
-s:yL.
,~~6:- JUa.iJ ~
ii}!ll u~1
l.;- • ..>-
,)~'il
j)~
(J~
~~1
.,1 I.l.
#
~.J
<.Sri .,:...~
o)..fll ~ 0""--'
~I
~_,s::J1 J")\::>I
~~
i~
.4••
,a. JJ~
y~
J~IJ
~IJ
I>
~~.)I)I
lS.J,.. ~
J)_,A.II
Jl
~I
b
~J\j
».,t:I~J
y\;:S'"' .JJ~
• .1.. ..:.1-:_1,.J~I
»,a
[)J~
~..,..Ual ~L."IJJ ;
~G.)
\..pf
J"'! ~lS' ~J
------------------------
~L.~
~~
Yf
-_._--
_..-,_
...
~~ i ,;r
\l.)S
~G
0~;l1
dJ ~WI
~
'J ~
~~Jl
J>b
,t.~
JJj; ~
<.S_;>.r1.
~I
LJ'l ~G;,
~(.I~
o~..b:- ~
~
1f!1
IIIII"~'-~.~~
r'J2... LIJ~
(.$i ,~~I
JL.a;)'1
r~
rf ~..LiJ1 0~1
· ~ _,.J.I if\~
Jl)a.J.I
\'1 J~\,I
i~ JI
t ~':J\
~
~j,
~ 01" ,~I
\4: ¥)
,J_,l:.:.!1
~
y _,L~
J!:.j
WI oy~ yt:5J1
0\ <.SI cI~..b:-~
oJ§'
..l~
ifJ:; \..~
J.y ¥~
)# L\J~ (.$;;~
~1
.,aj
~~~
0~
I-Q:»
\.. ~
~~I ~I?
~
~
l;L?) ~W
._,..J\;,.:J.I J~~
JI C~~I
~ _rl Jl
'r-W
r.~~
cr"
J_"..:ll
r~J .l~1
)\1.)'1
~1~)l1 .bWI
~JIr;,.. ~ 1
)'1 } y.N
'lS~1
J "'Y~ ~I
Js- ~I?I L.1).l ~ 01 J1 b ~_,>I La) liJJJliJl ulf... ~ 1)\ ~ J- Jl ~Jj r' iii/II' U' v:» U j' ! f1~I' '4.:ij;-)' rl ifJ ,t~ J~ ~)' ~JJY 01..\>.-)t W-I ~~) ,t.WI ~ ~) . Jl ~y-I L. .0),;JI 0"..\.. Js- 1-4~ J~ l...:i ~)' ::'1 ryLJ ~I IlA ~ ~I
.
I~ ~
lS..u.
~I
G·
~~\ ~
0_?-j) ,M }.;) ~\ ~
0.l.1..j
~I
~,.
~I
r..,wl LS':4':~J
,w_)\jt; ~'l\ ~A
~
,~I
lolA
~
~_j}\J ,~ ~
~lilb ~~J
£\) ~\)~
0yil' lS~
~\_)~J
;l:> ~\.;S,1Jl ~\
4J\ ~~,
..:J~~
'-!jJ\
1
~
11
-._I
\;..,.._j\
.y:;..;
!
&.
~\y
0~
I ·~
,II
r.5))')
4>.J ~
{
~
• II Y_rtJ1
I....
\.;.;1
e-r_c dl
0~
I~ .J! ._,.._r_U
11
..
~--.W\ ~I
y jJI
j;
Jt::- ~
$
;S-}~;ll) .:l~:~:J\
Jl oy-JJI ~
~
~..r
if
'J~
~
~l_;
_Li.j\ y LiJ ~.
\1\
r:
b·
~ II
Ie ~l&;. J
«~of v ....
p
·ifl~
01 0)~
.._.:aaaa
.........
jIf
..
!Ii
-----------------------------
--
I~I '~G..JI
t_,..p_,.. O__,,-Ua.l\
\~\ ~
#-
4..~!Ja! ~)
~_;a.!\ ....
-.
~
~p "Y &"
..
r-W'
rji ~
~.rJJ 0t5'"
~ f ~ ~I ~I
$
s:.~..;J
0-","')
Jl
cr
0 _,s8 oy-..ul ~
~~J:i~~
..... W,JI
4i_rJ.\ )1.;;
~
c.l
c:.\...l.i\lG ~I
~
J::k'J ~I ~ 0~ ~)I
~
J~ d y_,-Jl
r-WI if ~J ~ .... i_,wI ~
~ r~J <.JL.}\;-
tS..\.i1 ~lS ~I
if <J
~I ~
~
~I_,i
Jl LwlJ
~'-'
~
dl~ ~L:.;
~~ ~
J_,AJIIh
Jj ... 'li~1
~...\.eI~
y~ LSjJl ~
J_,AJIIlA
~
J...u ~I o_r.J.l\
~ ·
~~
~~
~ ifJ
<.SJJ. ~
~_,l~~1
~I
JL..1
~YJ
y _;JI
\..l.t..b.-
~1 '
J ~\
<!:S: ..
..\6 ':..: ~
if.)
Jl
I~\ )'I....;;.S'""\
~J
_;s1J d} ~ J" ~1
4!:~ ,4.~W'
;i~t~'
~~J
~'f' J'
t....1..ui ~
~I
~
~I
¥L..=.,.\
W,\/G
,\.i~
~
&'" ~~
\j~J
L..QiJ ~l.~~'J W
~_rJ\
til
14-.)
.~I
~ ~ \.i~
'~f
\.. \ ~ P 4>
I~J v.li~1
~__,k
--------------------------
~L.~
&~ ~
V,
· '~V'1.ft1_r.j
-~ r'
- 1'''
-:r.-y..:; ~
(~\)#)
0\4;';'" ,~.)__,:
....AI_
,
Y
t - ~ _Y-~
I A..':.'''_;J ~.JL.
(.$G ~ ~)
y.--4 ':JI - ~
&
Jy. -
· ,o..VAft~Y
~y..;:;
- ~I
A4 ,,1,;
Jt
~}y--: ...\,I !
"
0~~\,1
,.
d)o.U,r-t
..:..!_,\i...!,:' - t
· , f\A' - VY
t.
6. Collins, H.M." and pinch J.T. The Social Constructions traordinary Science, Routledge & Kegan, London, 1984.
of Ex
8. Feyerabend;
1978. 9. Heisenberg, Science.Fawcett.New
Werner, philosophical
problems
of Nuclear
York 1959.
presented
to Cultures
by
12. Lektorsky.
--.....-_...,----------
-..-
...
•• \ '-,.l~1
l~
---
ill
vols. Mouton/ Unesco, 1978~ 14. piaget 1. Structuralism; presse Univ. de France 1956.
esco ..
of Scientific Revolutions.
in
ot" Theories.
18. Readings in the phil. of Science, H. Feigl ed, New York, Ap - pleton Century Crofts, 1953.
s.
J 972, 1 - 1974, 2, 3, - ] 986. 22. whitehead, A, N, Science and the Modern world, Cam
bridge 1945.
"
--------------------------
UJS
L)M~~
~~
VA