Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Whichever way the pendulum of crude oil prices swings in coming months, India will be better off taking much needed measures to plug in holes and to tie up existing loopholes that lead to fuel wastage and to further improve the aggregate fuel efficiency of vehicle population in the economy. It may be prudent to be prepared for the worst case scenarios that project crude oil price of USD100 a barrel (2) and to ward off nightmarish events of 2-day long queues at petrol pumps in the near future. As our oil companies continue to bear the brunt of oil subsidies (3) and with the oil import bill getting out of hand (4), such a scenario may precipitate much sooner than we might ever bargain for.
At present, for every incremental unit of GDP growth, we consume three-times more fuel than Britain, France or Italy and twice more than the United States. (5) China has made significant gains in lowering its energy intensity in past two decades. As a study suggests, much of this reduction comes from real change in energy intensity in chemical, mining and manufacturing sectors and little from structural changes which would imply that the country has moved out of such sectors. (6) Our GDP growth also comes at higher carbon intensity, amongst the highest in the world, as Figure 1 suggests. What is particularly noticeable is that even though China has higher carbon intensity than India till the year 2000 and has been one of the biggest polluters, it has made significant improvement over past 3 decades in its carbon intensity even as it has grown at phenomenal rates in the same period. TEN Systems 1
TEN Systems
and incentives to minimize wastage of fuel as well as road space to floating empty seats or empty load in vehicles. This paper proposes following policy initiatives that focus on fuel use in the transportation sector : One, every vehicle should have a legitimate and readable license number plate and should be issued a tamper-proof tag that stores key vehicle related information. Vehicles must carry this tag for identification and should present it for purchase of fuel as well as for inspection. Two, similar to the way government requires households to disclose their electricity consumption through household electricity meters and similarly, for water or telecom services, vehicle owners should be stipulated to disclose road usage through working, accurate odometers. Three, based on parameters such as vehicle footprint, its weight and emission level, every vehicle should be assigned a Vehicle Index that reflects their cost to the wear and tear of road infrastructure, to traffic flow and to the environment. Four, government should create a new category of registration of privately owned vehicles as shared use vehicles (SUVs). These are operated by licensed fleet operators for high occupancy usage based on prescribed terms and conditions. Five, public transport vehicles bus, taxi as well as shared use vehicles should have higher consumption level, for which no fuel surcharge is applicable than general category of privately owned vehicles. These vehicles should be provided further incentives in form of reserved and concessional parking in public places.
TEN Systems
TEN Systems
reasons. Similarly, fuels like petrol, ATF, LPG for industrial use were priced above the cost of production to discourage their inessential use. 5) The prices of petroleum products were reviewed and revised from time to time to see that oil pool accounts were balanced.
TEN Systems
Accordingly, in the first phase, effective 1st April 1998, the APM was dismantled for the upstream and refining sector and a partial deregulation took place for the marketing sector. Subsequently, effective 1st April 2002, the Government announced complete dismantling of APM. (7) Since, the government has gone back and forth on this issue and a Post-APM fuel pricing mechanism hangs in balance as of date. So far, Fuel pricing policy in India has been lopsidedly supply-minded. Various committees to date have focused on issues like facilitating investment in oil sector in India, phasing of deregulation, subsidies and tariff structure that are the key words in the deliberation so far. The approach so far reeks of either lack of awareness or oversight of key demand-side issues such as: A. Assess how much fuel tax should the government charge and for what purpose such as for road construction and upkeep; develop energy system based on alternative energy sources that are sustainable, cover economic losses in natural disasters caused by the effect of fossil fuel emissions on climate change. B. Explore how fuel pricing as well as transaction records could be an effective instrument to crackdown on fuel adulteration and spurious usage, and to manage fuel demand to meet objectives of fuel efficiency and energy security.
TEN Systems
In the FuelSaver scenario, further to the policy measures proposed in the earlier section, petrol pumps record odometer data, Vehicle Index and fuel quantity purchased (making it mandatory to fill-up tank once every month or every two months and provide incentive/discounts for fill-up tank every time a vehicle comes to refuel) and upload this data to a National Fuel Information Center every day. This data is collated to generate accurate and reliable measure of fuel efficiency for every vehicle. This data is analysed for causes and the extent of fuel efficiency variation across vehicle models, fuel, traffic and road conditions and driving quality for vehicle population in the country. TEN Systems 7
5. Key Benefits
Key benefits of the FuelSaver transport fuel pricing methodology are: Check fuel adulteration and spurious use: By real-time monitoring of supply and offtake of fuel through the supply chain, it is possible to check fuel adulteration. Making it mandatory for vehicle identity tag to be presented for purchase of fuel will check spurious use of fuel by unauthorised vehicles or for illegal purpose. Eliminate unwanted diesel subsidy: Government gives diesel subsidy for goods distribution. It is inadvertently availed of by private vehicles cars and SUVs - in absence of alternative method to pay the full price. This will now be done away with. This has also been demanded by key parties supporting the present government (8) but can now be effected. Allow increase in fuel price: Higher fuel prices in tandem with rising crude oil prices is required to keep the oil companies in business, to allow government to raise fuel tax revenue as well as to manage demand. Coupled with incentives for greater fuel efficiency and vehicle occupancy and focus on fuel expense per passenger (or load) kilometer, oil companies and government can mitigate resistance to any increase in fuel prices. Increase in fuel tax revenue will particularly be necessary if the forecast about decline in oil supplies after the peak oil point are correct as it is increasingly becoming plausible. Improve fuel efficiency: By diagnosing why a vehicle may be losing fuel to its rated fuel efficiency based on the fuel efficiency database for vehicle population in the country, it will be possible to prescribe remedial steps for the vehicle owner/driver; for choice or quality of fuel; or for agencies responsible for traffic and road conditions. The government will, for instance, get better feedback about the quantum of loss due to poor road infrastructure in an area. Public Transport buses, taxis as well as Shared Use Vehicles are also more likely to switch to more energy efficient and environment friendly fuels such as CNG or to hybrid as mobility service providers will have better economies in purchasing petrol-to-CNG conversion kits, original CNG or Hybrid/Plug-in-Hybrid vehicles, as well as economies in refueling CNG, Hybrid/Plug-in Hybrid vehicles. World over - in San Francisco, London, and Vancouver, more and more taxis are now Hybrid Electric Vehicles. New York City, the city that many consider the taxi cab capital of the world, is getting ready for a hybrid revolution. (9) Improve vehicle occupancy: Incentives for higher fuel efficiency such as Shared Use Vehicles category registration for private vehicles as well as parallel measures to improve load factor in public transport services will go a long way to manage fuel demand in the country.
TEN Systems
Protect environment: Vehicular emissions and other transport sector related pollution will significantly reduce in this scenario. This is due to the rigorous check on fuel adulteration; measures to improve fuel efficiency, as well as focus on using appropriate vehicles and fuels such as Hybrid/Plug-in-Hybrid, CNG, electric-solar or even human power- cycling and walking. Improve affordability: For the large majority of Indians, fuel prices will not impact their affordability for commuting or for price of goods, in this scenario. Progressive taxation benefits: a. Government can implement differential fuel taxation based on Vehicle Index which accurately reflects their cost to the road infrastructure, to traffic flow and to the environment. Vehicle Index factor vehicle characteristics
for fuel tax calculation e.g. SUVs, big cars pay more taxes on fuel consumption ; motor-cycles and small cars and space efficient vehicles such as buses and trucks pay less b. It can also levy a fuel surcharge if fuel consumption is above a
TEN Systems
TEN Systems
10
GRID
Environment Cess
The lifecycle environment cost of emission and other wastes created in its consumption and in production such as toxic spills, mining waste, acid rain, smog - till they are naturally absorbed must be covered. Scientific findings on man-polluted climate changes, to which vehicular emission and automobiledependent, sedentary lifestyles are a significant contributor, portend dire economic consequences in near future, with large-scale disruption in climateextreme temperatures, flash floods, water shortages etc. The economic loss due to overuse of cheaply priced oil must stop and fringe treatment of alternative energy sources must stop as historical evidence of development of solar energy suggests.(11) This will help channelise resources and attention to sustainable energy development. Environment Cess is used to compensate for environmentled disasters as well as for environment conservation programs.
TEN Systems
11
Oxygen Valley The new mantra for Energy and Environment Policy
"The good news is that a host of energy efficiency, renewable energy, and other clean technologies are available to reduce heat-trapping-gas emissions substantially without impeding economic growth. These technologies often produce net savings to consumers, when compared to continued reliance on inefficient, polluting technologies. As a statement released in February by over 2,000 US economists put it, "Sound economic analysis shows that there are policy options that would slow climate change without harming American living standards, and these measures may in fact improve US productivity in the longer run." Source:http://go.ucsusa.org/publications/nucleus.cfm?publicationID=215 Concerned Scientists", 1997 ,"Union of
The difficult and humiliating truth is that Indian leadership in government, industry or media, with honorable exceptions, is poorly informed and foolhardy in reiterating that reducing emissions come in the way of economic growth or that energy efficiency or alternative energy technologies are far away in the horizon. On the other hand, the prevailing leadership has summarily failed to test the hypothesis over the last decade put forward by eminent experts around the world even as these measures are already taking centre stage with Oxygen Valley likely to outdo what Silicon Valley achieved in terms of fueling innovation entrepreneurship and economic boom. This requires primarily a reassessment of the yardsticks that we set for economic development. So far, we have failed to make the necessary investments for "course correction" even if it opens up opportunities of much accelerated and well-rounded growth opportunities, particularly for India, which has key advantages in this regard such as: 1. India does not have sunk costs in energy-heavy infrastructure (though it may soon fall into the trap if government policies fail to take notice). 2. It has a rich heritage that emphasises on holistic living - that has been finding popular followership in recent times as the example of Swami Ramdev suggests (even as government policies continue to mindlessly favor the western "cola and car" culture and fails to learn from its brigther side - such as its religious support for research and innovation with a rich network of government, industry and academic institutions. This is a vision of India that nurtures a variety of lifestyle choices that appeal to the cross-section of Indian population and to international tourists and are yet sustainable in their demand on fuel or electric power or in their environmental costs. In my view, it presents unprecedented opportunities for Indian media for the domestic as well as international markets to showcase the economic, social, cultural and political dimensions of these choices, to project an "Indian Dream" and to create a market for Indian lifestyle products. Is this a recipe for over 20% GDP growth over next 15 years for India? Can India leverage a proactive commitment to emission reduction for international trade and geo-political negotiations, beginning NOW?
TEN
Systems.
Send
your
feedback
or
comments
to
TEN Systems
12
References
(1) Govt. says oil price rise could boost inflation Reuters, January, 2006 (2) Oil prices surge to new records April 2005, BBC News
Crude oil prices hit record levels with leading investment bank Goldman Sachs warning the cost of a barrel could eventually top $100.
(3) Oil firms brace for crude shock February 2006, The Telegraph
The third quarter of the current financial year was bad for national oil marketing companies. But it seems the fourth quarter will be worse with the average price of the Indian basket of crude imports shooting past $60.5 per barrel in January. The January price is over $5 higher than that in December. The January surge has brought us down to our knees and unless the government takes drastic steps to redress the situation, the oil marketing companies will turn sick, According to a senior Indian Oil official. Indian Oil, Bharat Petroleum, Hindustan Petroleum and IBP have suffered a combined loss of Rs. 2,898 crore during the April-December period this fiscal and these losses are mounting further. The same companies had clocked a profit of Rs 5,223 crore during the corresponding period of the previous fiscal. Upstream oil companies ONGC and OIL and gas firm GAIL have already forked out Rs 9,751 crore as subsidy.
(4) Net oil import bill to go up 21% January 2006, Financial Express
The government has revised the net oil import bill for 2005-06 to $33.2 billion (Rs 1,48,269 crore), up 21% against its original estimate of $27.4 billion (Rs 1,192,94 crore). This is almost 50% higher than the actual net oil import bill of $22.9 billion (Rs 1,03,462 crore) last fiscal.
(5) There is life after fossil fuels - Budget 2006 must help to rearrange Indias energy basket - February 2006, The Indian Express (6) Why Had the Energy Intensity Fallen in Chinas Industrial Sector in the 1990s? - The Relative Importance of Structural Change and Intensity Change, ZhongXiangZhang, Faculty of Economics and Faculty of Law, University of Groningen, The Netherlands
" Based on the data sets of value added and end-use energy consumption for the 29 industrial subsectors and using the proposed decomposition method of giving no residual, we have examined this disagreement by investigating the relative importance of structural change and real intensity change to the change in energy consumption in China's industrial sector in the 1990s. Our results show that 93.2% of the cumulative energy savings in the industrial sector for the period 1990-96 were attributed to real intensity change, with about three quarters of such savings from the four chief energy using sub-sectors (i.e., chemicals, ferrous metals, nonmetal mineral products and machinery)."
(7) Ministry Of Petroleum & Natural Gas - Pricing of Petroleum Products (Sixth Report), August, 2005
TEN Systems
13
(9) Taxicabs Start to Turn Green - Cities around the world are looking to hybrids and natural gas-powered vehicles to cut costs for their cabs Dec. 2005, Business Week (10) "Motor Fuel Taxation and Economic Development: A Regional Approach", Professor Richard England, UNH, January 2006
It covers both the economic and environmental advantages to raising the gas tax. It touches upon the benefits of rewarding conservative drivers with a rebate, stimulating greater interest in public transportation and boosting skilled employment.
TEN Systems
14