نتائج وتوقعات - ليون تروتسكي

- -

:

# $#% $(%' . 1965
" :-"#$%" http://www.al-mounadhil-a.info
$ $&
:

" 0 5 231# 4#01@# 1? >1
1 1 1(<#1 41# 1:19 1
@ C> . :EF 09 :2D> 1 L K1< >1 1I1$ >1 21 ' C#%F11$
@( $ @ C( >:# 0 M5 .??N O
I >:

I#:.1 <( 0@) O##( : (O#I L :U5 >: LE
0 S V#(01: 1
? O O[Z X# WY 9: :
U5 : W L
IFS C( 01: ? O1 O12D1
L O#0 0 2D 253 C?] 00 \.XY
1:.211$ $011 911 011@ O## O11 >11?11 211 11% 11c11 #11 #' 113119
$ f O# < ( :? #S 05: c[ . ( #Z3 ]?1010
311 11: C11$ (11% E11 311 0 ]?11 11 0110311 C? XM11 O##$ 11 11? 11I 11 011
.g$ 9 90@# ( : #(F$ (% (i0:31 19 901@#
(
IFS : 0$ 0:3$ 3 (1 1:?1 #(F1 k1# 1$Sj1 1
#1%
?(# @ K90@# F 0 : $ (% c:N .Ic?M1 K1% #F1
$ D 0 :0 5' 0@ O## .
I
> 0: ? O$ f Oc ?

I3 m# #(% O%
[ O j 0 XM O 23 XM1E [ 101 1 31 31 @( >1
I1F1
F# > O m#.
I
?
I#: O (M 01I 39
L1 315f 01# %1 1#:
I31 1:
IF1S 1#(%(
I#15
E 419 O? q9 2F1 >1 p
Ii1
I11($ 1[#(r >1 19@ 1#( 1
#Z3 U0 O:
#U5p (# ? K< .2F 2 ? $ :
Ii[ 0."D
) $+, ( " 12
0."
1850
: 1849-1848(.$$

# 0 ) >?F'
41# :>#01# t#F1Y" 1$@ >1 (O1" >11 1# O1 C F1
: O1 D: > 1879p1 O#:1I# . i15F1 CF1f O1 1#p >1 V1 1: 1D$
1m1
0 [ " >1 "F1" O#1 "41#'?#1:f 1888 .1897 21(9 1r 0 O1" 1 "41#'?#1
09 >?F
U 5 $) O## (O##($
( k m5:: 0$ #F O1 ]1
i1
'-#90@ # >Fj 09 "f 5< >$ ."#1 >1 21:1: 21D 1898
Ci: \ > OY' I' > #9 0: OU L #$@( C? >1 1:5
" ."4#'?#< > p0 O<F O#5
>S 0 (# 5 C 0 .p >1 O1 1S5?05F1
?F1111S@ 11I 011 115# .(#11 >11 115 >11 11S5 i11
i11 >?F11 11'11 '11>-
90@> > "(# V I$F "\-0#" ># m$ 2 >: 019 .>11 O11S5
: 1902( : > O#5#M 05 k# O :< m:0 O# O##F> q031 S#1
"?F" )( O#15# K1 1r# F1 t#11 1 .1 >1j1 [1>
"p11 11$ '11>-9011@> ">11M11 >11 011: 2#F110115 11: 1903M11 01 V11#'11
O# >r(c S .]#S5
U >?F S ]#S5

I5: 23S O1: cF1 1S9 M1r c1<15.O#
$ > : " : 19040# #" > ( 0$ # q V[: .# ( > # : 1905
0$'0 [ #f ? 0D9 ' # I(#%Y05 <" #D > $" (1% >1
> q##~.
> ( : g: >?F 2 0$ 1907[ 0 ? ? V#S5 I (# < C# O X0V9
0 # # k( V .# ZcY > X O<F O I #" O: VU[
05$ > "D " D$9" . iS : O# 1907 C 19140# # # I0
5## > > # k#0 < " 0" ) ? (#5 V9 >S3 .>#Fp >?F F
0$'0 #$f I5 F 2: k# # S#3 c(# 03 (## > .#
0 " S# ." V# >I 0$ ' #[ 00 O#: "j
: "0 1915 K(# #IM 0 O:j.
E :$ V " #E #f[[" > I V5# U5 5 0$ O#5# O# @
Ocr @ .I5# O E< F ' 0 : 1917
: 05: #'0 (.

U >?F p (: >S 1917: V >?F .1917: V(r .
I50 q##F F#DcY > XM
K35
U 9 O#: . S j K$ r 1#9 c 0 X S " qF
# "]F# V g #@ KI '" # '
" #S Oj r .#
j S O#: : O# 1917" E 1923< t#f" 9<5 X cY : f .#
i: > ? K >#F> < 5@ p XM0cY . XMS O" :K ( S
" "]F# qF #:#L" ( Y # C# j Frf ##:#
c I I.##F

> : 9 1923 >?F $ ?5F O#F
#I90@ # ###F
9S(9@#
> p 0 C#53 (%[ > 2#L .>##F 0$ O# V#: 4 4##5 4##5 YO
#
#S O : cY .1925 XMS " :Kf ["" 0I$<" "00 O#F
%#" " ?"" 2# "##Sj Y . 4: >?F C 1926 4##4##5
FE O# 0 "$ 0" 0$ 4#5: C# i #f #F $@ #:#
O >?Fp > : Y 1927 ? O >S "\-" :0 -# #5#3 k#> 5
V#$ > X0" O: O# U' 0 > # "0 m%> I $j #:#Y
V#< X[ : #5#3 1927-1925> "\-" K" :>?F 0 ?5"" [
0 "DSj Y.
0$ >?F p O?F # " "?#(5 1933 4# > 0 > V0j
#U5 00: 0
" $" " :K~ [ " "##>" Sj Y . 0 : O 1929 O Y ($

- 1
"" ,- .-) ( $ "
1 ( 0) 1917 -)4
) .- ,) - ) .1945)(0$
%Y 0 #:# 5

mM V' ?> V5 q( .< #F5: ###F 1932
K( V:9 # V # S#5: .O# q#0 5 V: -5# 1928 Yf
: -5 0$ O# > 1933 Op 0$ ( I5 q< #F5 ###F O q$5 > ID:.#
Y0 >?F 0$ F C# qi ( V5< :0 I#5 " #E#f
@ ."$ O >?F: F S E< 1935 #39 5 k#" K[ M$" . 0$
4##5 4##5# ( #S 00: (1936 q >) I qr? 5 O# WZi #
?F#S3 ?(" > .] O# q O#$ :#?F
qZ 09 .I
I" > >?F ?" j #i 00: '# O##
t##
4F C (@ # #Z gU5 >##F< Dp'
: > .>##F 1937Y0 >?F ? ]#F 2[ k# " i" IF#S >?f
0 . g >?F VS 0 > >f XM C# 'I I V#0
? ?( I O >?F
I I V#> 5F> q O:" #E #f "$" K(
'> # ."$ 099 E(5 #$[ # 2 I<D0: > $9 O
r0
' . K V5f # -> # Z L > $' >##F>
0: 2# ( O #(
>?F: .
ID V5f( #( > - : > 1938 # V "U5
@ "F 09 ###F .X L ] i9 O 00$( >?F(c: 0 :
I XM
> U5( # FF .> : O 1940 F #5# 3: q >?F .VFS 0$]
0 #39 09 # " F" > : 1940 q 20# > Vp5 > >?F? 5# .]#F
:] LI O # # .O#

>?@.<$ 0

[ O O###FU$ > M Of cr 0 0I%i
V[ >?F 0
O$ F .VI C] ' 05[ 0 09 O#5# :M 0 3$ V>?F
OE? U: O>?F 0 p ? X 55p Dc ViM p# >?F #f>
?S" Vf" 5$ M V#%f #L " #[#" ?Sf ?: : V#Y
" #[##" " ?S" . V: V I V# .2(F V 2? O> : #Z'c
E# 0 ' OM> IA M r .
U:f
] i % O 2$ 2 #Z'c <0
' U : > #F ~ . # VV9r V
UU5 .
D C O>
' " C 4#5: #[##" O# VFS ?S" O#".
S ' ? Ki5 .
% # V
" qE # \ "2?M 05: > .X: O O$ (: 05: -O$ MYM :
F
" 0#9 : q#N > O 2 2 0Z 0Z (3 k#LF <0# 2# 0 :
~ < VI # \ ' O 0< %(Z$F!" 05: 0I V0 'I% M 0 V#
0 Vj" :#3 O q<."W #$
5% MF >?F 0 (#> 0 5$# .VcY C#@ VFS5 3r 2 05:
2c Wr > 35 > 2 pI # V0 >S . 9 V 0$5 (9 O: C
O 2$ 2 0 O 2 ##Z'c [ 0 .D> 05: pI 'I% % X
? f # 05: ' X ( M V: 2 3 V5r " :
f qE # \Y >S ".2
"-i" "< 5" > ?: ]#F 9 1937 >:
O 2<5 ' O
2S?p : O O:
#%> 2(F(
" < #> >
r
: 2 KF 0 ?$ .I ' C(% >5 M L 2$ # Oi( M V
O > >$[: 5 f# 0 > #$ > 4#'?# 4> M L V US q
V 0 .V#( [ <i? 0S
V5 O #"V
c < : %F 05: V M ?
F q V#50# > #> I> 5F
V M 2f E# OM :X0$
"? I O? O >N > N ]F ' p:p 0Z .>:# M L
LF p X0Z> > M 0 q9 : ' C#%F O > C#%
O % K$ : iYf <0 F p9 V9 #3 > ? 2 . # <#
I% # f O 2 I% 45: I C 39."0
# O 2I g > OE# 'pI M 49 E V$5" VS > 0I$
?#S" Vc: :p # I V #p##" O0" . O O? IN ' >?F
5 (#% c: > % #( ' E Oj \> > < C( . V WY~ $I

#I' > X$ .F$ V $ ( 09 @ 0F U i
0:3 09 > S 00: '# ' $ II' : 09 I(: > q #
LF 09p V#YELF 2 #M$.
#~ O V (F5 0 2: C5 ( ' > 039 I . C]
iY >S
~ # Ip0> C#%F E 0# > < ILF : V:S( > #
" 0#$3#>
" V#U5' >:09 V0 :L mr> > D :F q# f
#Yf . XM0 j 2LF k0 C> i V > ID5 .2(F I? O V5 <2$
i V[ 0 :5 O OS$ i 0 .qi C# qi > 0$ 9 :
0 ##Z p0 > D :F<$ : D? q0 I I(#3?
#$#(% > ' #: 'c >(5 f #S % O:f .?MN 0 ' > %
LF [> $0 f 0: % 9 XL qY 0 .# #5 [0#Y i XMI
'p LF < C# 2D> I C#%F p<5 2<F V[( I .Ir V5? 0 O
- 2 ) ,) ( ,DEFB? B ( ?> ,- ) ; ( 1:: $" :
"J
"
-K" "

" . " ( " )F OP ,) ;N> ) ) -K ." 4 - 1" ;QP )0
F )- )( - ,P ) W$ "V; "U 1-.
,- T) .1)(0$
5 0#$ X 0$ >: L Y 4:i V : #% .C M 03
S >f # 05: #r.>?F
09 :
D? O>< OI?
>?F 3$M > Ci
V V FcF #YfM V:Y
$ #5 0 .( 0 ' 0i W? O 4F5 f( # # .i
9 L 09 # 0 :5L M> . S >?FM ($ 0 LF 9cr> 03
f> ~ > OFf Sr O 2(9 3:M > mF.S
0 .E%Y :
D? OI0 c$ >?F 3$M ? 2(9 ]M OI<S c O0$
O > Op
q9? O?S %Y 09 V# ( O O###F 0 $ (
U5 f ?]? .3 " ?Sf" > M < 9 [ ' #:> ##F
3: c I > r
$ .#5? V #F
: : >?F E 20 LF L #
0 LcY #: ~0 4:i : V'I% Kr 2: 2 > >0 U >:V9p
i95 V0 #Y g95 VFS >S .#Y< C >(%? (%' #:%#F S @59
%#F 9 : $#(% 2$F XM >? 9% : %#F ' #:$ I?> I$ir I%
) ]M0$ (F5 2$S r >( 0 . < pM f p# 09M L S I' O: >:
': (#> 0 > < C( 3 . $9p #r " : $ @ 01 <
C
$ @ @E( .1 " . % >?F M C9p . M5c O# : O#FY
( (#> q$5M M C9( #<0 ($ ' ( V0
D V (K NV< V
f Vi" VS Y"
E 5 I< C ( (0 [ %Y O 2(9 C%F
>?F E(5
0 (3#M ( > 20 3$M" : ' # #I i" c C#%F : MYE
0 ?S #F :Y >?F
I? O #: 0 .(#3 q C]N
S #
>?F? O(# N O#?F' q$9 Vj(5 .K#Z
: 2(F VLF ?: p
0 LF f V 2$ O 25 .V(F 2 " V9 qE # \ "2 # q2
0 O$9 V: .2$ 5IS : VM ? 5 [ 3$ DcM f .Y\ 3:
(0 LF O5L M>0 ] < K (3 : V#3S V[ .:0 SV
' c.
( > VD O# E# >$ #:
FF ' j
> 0# > [ O .# 2[ V0 ?S > #F I 2(9 q W
>?F F
I5M(# '-#90@ # .#5#F ?$ V >:f 2# : ?S'0 >9cYf
?S . # f O' O## O##:#Y OM i5 F > # 3#0 #5#F
'cZ 'I% OM <F O >S5: OM OfZ 9 O 5 0:L
E
OM E ?E ' >9cYf'j C(@
I >?F C< X> I5: ($
]M . q V O # mDM .3$ 0<# I#S #: < 4r C< 2 2'cY
C<
I$< O: V 43$ [ # V$F ?S >#F'0 .2$
#F#Z O0 ?S #F#D ?(# 09 > ' pS9 00:(
I5 Sr K > 0 O :5% . p >?F < K O 0 K#F
0#( I< :[ 0 .D @ 09 XM?S > 435 cY : C
: 1848 09: >?F 2IF > I#M cY [ #f : .1906-1905 M5]
O#> cY C p M5 > : O#$
$0 :(: I f .
5$ E# :0 55M M 0 #5#F )
I#r# ( 2
0I
< [ 0$5 D E IM ?> % I . 2(9 O#
IE >?F0D9" V
@ $#[ i > ) "
$ E V I 4#(L@ #( 09E VS 2$" V "mD E" V 2
: 2$ "t #i c > #:# 2
$ E VM(> < 0M :0 [ "(#
"3r E0: V cS O# " Z3" "(% "%Yf . 0 g XM'I > 2#
#Yf ? ' V V I0 > Dc O %
I> O# II >?F' ?( IM
' .VFS5
? 55 3 > I
>?F? > O C9
U >?F> > IS # m#: ($ 2 C#( > : I5
$ p %
0$0 : I5Yf > #: 0 . U ?: 2 ? 55 : >?F
- 3P ,Y$ ( ) 1 ") 0 1 ";Z) .9-6)(0$
'c ' > >:M V$#(%

$ 2 $ X
F V F 4r : i > 5
5( 0 #:
@ X0:( Sr > I5# #p ?.
M 0 : 05: V >?F VM f M5 : O#F U5 0(
0
$#5 q
U$ : %#F ( > q(@ I'c I #U$(0 ' r.I
> N<: P@: #M :@ > $2 $EI,$+ ? G F:@ @@ ."1
$ : :T $S .@$ R $ $2 > VW S >E% (? % ( C@
$
: %1 >$2
$ 1$ $ : Y$S
C 0 . #F
0$ : > ] O# " # Z<" c #
M ': @c
U$ 05: #
' O##f .O## (F5 2
# 0 (: : I[ ' 0 .# ': CD I<V
j I O m$5 #5 >:%9L[ 2# # [0 Y\ 5$: I
] m# rF5 O: #[ S #F.U$
O
F9 Y 09') O## (]#S5 K< V ( #9 [ > . O# O#5#
(0 V: ( (# ' # C#%F' 0'c% XMI I (% $ #5 >
0# > : C#%F :cS O# O r i5 [ # .VI 2 O#5#
$5 09 0M '59 E ' # C#%F %r[ ( qS 2$ ' I
' 2. g > # .# ZcY O#5# 2 09 0:O 43
C#%F > 5 ' #
2? :#[ O? 4# 0 I$ ( : (%
(1917-1903) Op
2 >?FM L? M(>
" ( C$% C V
# >I5 0##U > 0
]:
#
a 2
a
$: ]% YT
( ` (+] <
S I: A
@ ". c<: $ R2b E% e<. $b(
2.
. d
.
.
%
I 5 ? .#3 #F IS #9 'S # F 3: :
'39 i ( > [ #> 0 > ? O< O CS C#VDi:
OZ 'F .#(%
? OM5 > $(@ # SrYE 0 ]M . (: >?F #
C#%F 1 [ ' W # 0 Z $C I I#: 2#F$ .$E [
' < 0 #@ #59 q [ > Z .
09E >?F' [ V
23 @0F m
? O 3[ O #% ( O? ' ]M 05: I0 @#5 ? I 0
' S
$ 23Sf O XM' .S XM> [ 0 : D 0#$30> @.>5
O KDf < K0> OcY C O?
U5 05: Vf >?F #
0 .0$$ V#F 5 29$ L V: : >?F #> > MYE
( > ' S'.#
q #F 0#0 L $ #0 #@ I$ >f qjY 2? 0 :

#F0> 2$ X($0 I .#0 0 (: <" > p(# ">:# ' #(0
k# >I5 .# q XM?S p O ?S # .>F I q0 > q#F
IE : 4#$ # #F #$ .#$
0 t$ >?F XM?S %: $ 00 . (: ' #0 >@ : # .g#?M
g " O: O# U' 0 > # 2(9 "0 (0 .: O$ I #( O#
# M ' #Z >:0#5#F 05: V qp$[ > #5$ 0 >?FI# 2f
E? ID( #% 0 . j >?F 0 [ ' O 0 (0 : 0#$3@ >5 <
S p$ I> > 0 .0M 05: p$ U5 ( #$ >S VD O: C < VS

j K$ S 0 > (0
VS0 #: C#53 >F#D > CF' .>##F? 3 O
($ 2 V 3 [ > 0 0 ' S9 p# 0 . g U5 [ (: #
#:% ? >S IFS5 IFS 05: >I50 @ .#5 : 3(: 23Sf O 2
$
0$ ( O# "'" O# 23Sf [> @ 09 [# .@( O: O# O$
$ V#r" O: 3
O# "2' >##F #:# 0 #$ m$( #f >S #F O #[? O ? OVi
.5:' ?S > 0j O# W US q ? ? 2 >?F.V:
cY O$ r 5 O$> O# C 2D5$ Yf 5#$ C# q> 2D'0
0 Y ' >##F 0 EI
C >$ # ?: V U
.>?F [
3 2U 2Y0 ###F .0 f' ? O #5#F@ " > "S9% [ : . 2
#5#F ? C 4#@L @[ >5
6
2 KF O: q5:? : IDS I O: IDSM> : 0#$3@ .>5 0 2 O 00$$#:# O

V$ : O#F XM'j OM iS 20 O# >$9" >?F
" " 2$ ."mD]M
C# q$fp ? .#:# F " :I : O# # 2$< 05: m' 0 > #V % 0
'cF [#(r$ [ > 0 > C0 >?F ? g m#' 0 > #."0
0( O# 3 O#
VZ 0 @ < CM <( .V ?N 5
"' 0 > # "0> 2$U # 0 \ #? O 2? " >:p "4D qF# 2:
0 .>$9 0 23S[> O[ 0 2(9 D9 ' O >##F'0 # @) . O V'
: # >:0 ' >##F O# $< #
V0> ( k0
435 O# m% #' .(# : O#?5 O# F 0 V#I 2
'
rF I5S3 ?E V V( @ ( ' 45: O 0 V K$> .' ?(9 O XM I#: q#5( :% O?
.#5#F[ #
p$ <5 C%i I > MY : IFS f I V 2#F M#S5 XMI > % 0.
?
U$ q: O#' > " C#0D" %L < >: q O: VU'0 > #
O: 0 50" m "# IS 0 .>?F I5: rL >##F > c#3SI
#$[ 05: # # q V> % # : (0 #(5 f [ :
I> c9 .I
c] 3 [ : #5#3 1949-1948 XM[ >
O# I KF F M X0I 39
C$ .I@ > 2#9" qI '" : # . CF 3 O Y\ 23 O: [ .#$
M5] O##Z [ < \ # # ? c .#5# q 20 O XM'S>
@ C 0$@ O##5 C] 0Mr 20 ? I5 > I I5 O .>$ C#%F 0
C0[: 0 . [ 0 D 0I: m q@ I I( qZ Ip IDc (
i ' ->:MI >#F .
~
U$ > ' 5 ' E X0#? f m% ( .#U: #9
2[ 5M E 0#
f >?F3$ ># ?S 0 ' V O: .E%r ( >?FMY\ #U$ m#? : # O?2
M .V E(50( ' 09 S # (F5 $ 0 (0 ' 3: >S .5 U5 05: mj
# #$ > O IS9 S 2 .Z # # (F5 $2#<
>?F S9 5# S # 2 '0% 0 > 3S #F#D I 2Zp# O#5
@ 59?F 435f O# V[ > 0 i 435[> I5
[ > p O . 5 q(#r pI
D> q3 V
$
F >(F5f( O .O# 0 Vi>
' >##F 0# < : $ O I( k# V: #?F q##FE
IE ""O##5
]f( O# 0(: O: 0p M5 [O# O c# " [0 O# 5" 0 SY ( .O> Y
'
>##F? O #?F p<$ $ ## #f O: "$ (0 0 .##p<:
(: >?F O: ##F 2?F 0 .V?F
C9 C <F 0# #F 0# ? 3S > I5 Z " 0i" .?O
O: :]0 0 SrYE F [ >F#D .M ' >5$ 09 >?FO: 2Z
9% ? > 5 # ($ V @9 99% q Z > 0$ 2 I9% >
K$0
.
39 U5M ( W(@
## #0 >F (% $ > #:53< C k0M
##
M XMI r($ #I" : ? [ O C5$ ' ? ]5 (" . C]

? O 0 O'S ' cY #: O0$ O" O#Yf C5$" 0 .KFMSU5 I$# I
? ?F: p 9@ ##Z cS [ O I# #:(# .#:53 09< M
?Y 2 >
U: XM'S :[ 0 .#5#3 23 >F [ O 4 > 50O#
' ( 0 q
($ >?F [ O 50 4 9 m% XM[ O <5
#9.I
C] K< ' 5 2<$ g$ 2$S? < .5 p q M V %r
IS >FM ($ (% $ #:53> "(> ">rc >F#D .#' < K F5
(% > $ E q 0#(5 c #F#DcY # O: O 0p < 2# <I5 2#
09M 2 0 % q c .
$> C#%F > c< O ~ : " "O##L?p#
> " #:" i $ f F 0 cp5 i5 F > M VY
7
$ '# #:# > cY # 9 43 'S (# : # 1905 .1917]
' <c ( 0#($ f9 cS "f" 0$0 ? OM (%
ZF0I%i > <$ (05?
#D < O (% $ 0#$ O [0 '< > K9 O
#?S >#F%#F : S5
#U5 0 .2$ " 3 > "C (%
" OM ?"
Fj> 05 <" q#: > $" ) (q##F #[S (c S .]#S5 < q##F#
%5 5 # Z> @ I#: qZ(9@ ( # : 0I 0 (% $O
>#F
V k#(r> .I q C#pI
D> I >5$ 4%9 >
I 3
I p<:
O:
K$
> S O0$ 2M ' ?0< >S
5 " K O ' ##F#D" .M KM
cY X 9 O 5#: .Op (F5 0 S( >? 0$S #: O:
#$0#$ #r 0 O 9c%
@ O W 0@.
' O 09LE 0#$ % >r q IS #9 >F ' #(#
:5 #$\ .I [ 0 D
$ 43$? O 2> ' #(# ?>
? : >?F O 0 ' I# I# mf: : :
f #:53 0 > '
>##F > Z O5r 'cF M
I$ V# #5#FLc ## Z

I#: S 0<
IFS (5 ' # .O##F#D O" EF : %#F M " q
C : %#F 2(9@# D%? (% $> [ 3 2< C$ :XM
#3 49 EF# >
?[ O # 0#: C#<
# #> IYLF I
].
: :
E D (% $> > K$0 > >F#D[ ' #: K< V 2U K$M 0 XM
?S 0 #?S >?F >#FU5 VIS >##Fp ( >S 0 ViM(# '-#
90@ # : #5#FF . IS "90@ # "#$ IS >F#DM 0 C# V?X
<<.V
($ >?F O X#Z O##F[ O# (# > >#Fi '
O
$ # ' .#
? O O V9 V3Y' O#5#[ c > V5 #3]F
MI (0 > U5> .m#(% 3 : >?F VF CD [ 4
#: 45$ V
"0" ( #S :~ . M 0#I : # O?

#U$ K# p:' K#
4%LF> .
$ 0: (# O'%$ > I~ 090 qr% ( O: :
.$
F 05: E $5 I 0 < .C
Vi # Z I#9 O2# 0
XMi > # : M <cY #: O# O##$> q:( f
5 . O: 4r >?F] M O?
V ' > O
fF V'
$%0 0 .
U:f i F S S q# -1917 0I 00: O#(9
E I 0:
< $ 05: 0D9 > f # $ ]S0 %>
I V<$< 0 ' #: > I5 0 # M5.
0 Oj (# f V E
F f> O##?> 5 ' 0#($ :
? O:
I0
I% 9 >M . q0 > 0 > 0I m% [ > .#?O
4#? @( $# XM0
> 5#: KM 03 ?f 0#$ 5$ >?F f> ) O#5# (F5(c Sf @(f ($
< f U? 09 (Totalitarian) # : q XM?f KD #S5 ' q E I# .
(# (F5 >?F> 9@ #: #< I#: K ? .]M #M K< .k#(r M
>?F O X#Z$ O##F : C# 490@# ( )? #0 > %#
I # > # >#F' 0( E" I
" . $(@
$ XMf qF# U ( V : 0#$3 >#F0 (k
]M
: : > I C 2 > K$90@ #(.#
# >?F : 3 4U5 (> E > Z V 5$$ XMI($
VU :? # #(% Oi I9S'39 ' >: > @#Z I[>
.>#F (: "0 ( " 90 43M S #Z% > ' i >5$ U
O#$ @ > ?

? 05$ ]M .) >?F O#5# ( O: (#N V
2$FM X5$ #($$ U (% Oi $S ' >: #? @ : (F
?
? V0 . (# E IE 0 "( " ?
? 9@ I$ @ > # >#F 09 Mr?' >S .:5S > > [ ( cY
8
f O I 0 ' # $ @ Mr? [ > [ @(N #$# I< V r ? 29@>.
> @ 0 ( k U5 > >##F 0I: O Oi90@ # #$ #
#($$ 95 : 29f? O
I5 : #$ 9? .' MI 9c: IS 0 E
?
0F #: O X VFS" V#: %#F "# # ?
E U ?
"0>"
> ?: V] .' K<: O0 #5#FM IS E V@ #S5' K<: i > #?S
0 .>:# q:p0 : O #5#F Mc IL E (% $> K?F O X#S O
#M '59 >S? . > #M 03 >?F
cY : 2 cY O#5# C : : Fr: V cY O#
I : O$
' cY 5 q W] 5F > "p : O# "
$ 1917 .1923 ( c FC V
K(c S
qF# O#5# IFS(f > V: $ .O#
]c? $ 0 gf >?F ?2
O? : # p$ . ] : 2(9 1917 % O#5# XM , 09 0M
% <0F ? > c .O# r 0: O >?F E VFS V? E%Y K > O#5# V##M
p ( >? >S@
$ >? # >E# .
I$ir p# 05: >?F O# 5# #:
I O O# '3 I OY ]MU5 < #Dp> I 09 0:[ O
c S: : >: 05: >(%$ :
ID
I[ (: ?S XM$ 2? 0 >SI
> 0
O#E3 ' .# < 5 U5 (% $E I < #: F I
] C# 0 : D 2$
.>#F? (@ O XMI Y 2#M :p
I# 35 O: ($$%.I
O#5#M ': X05: >f L $ #r5
IS ' #0 O##F#D
U (% O $ 0[ ? .#$9 0$ < # I5# # F? 0: O <:
? I5 2 V V#( WcS I5 2 O# ( #Z3 :< DF (% $ IFS
'(@ ?F I5 2 X[> V#:' >:? I5 2 O0 ) OY : (p<$ i5
' I$(# > < C0:
[ .' < q# C p XM? p 2 I5# # p
cZc > 5# S 9 I5# # > : IY ( > 5(c I .# qXM
(%<@@ ? 5: O #0Y 5: O #$ # Y 0#5: O <:
Y (M q p ?> 9 F " "I[ . > >S? c I35
p $ ?3 #S $%
II5: #($ V#: K XM$% . W > VFS(0 $
V 5F >? O#0 [ 4
I%$ : K .OYEp ? "@ $##" (r
#F ' %(i5 I9 :?" O# [ "$.
.W9 I5: 2? O O k($ ? %Yf >
0( 5 >?F 5 XM?S #5#5#
r
2Yp (r5 XM%Yf > >?F 00 #F< k# I 0: c FV
0 F O#5# I > p 0 Ij(5 9 > 23U5 O .>5#F0 2IF (r5
# ) (Oligarchy 0 XM S0 3$ O: E%rM ' ? O .V O O? I
N K(F O#5# I5 2(9 09 >?F 2#M O# 9c$ #Yfp (% c#0 #$9 ?Y 2 K(F
%> p O#5# #9 I ?: :) V % #5#F r O
( .(#0 #$
O'(i > p 2 0< $ [
F O# 90@ # 2Y
#U5 I5 0#SF 390
# p 05 #90
I Y ? M 5 m03 I# ? .
I#: 95>

U$f# ## #i9 2 .5: # 05 90: O#$ OM c3# $
> I C< 5 p #5#5#> ? %00 pS : O## p 2? 2$ 0m
.
' O 0" O# p##90@ # O#5# 05: "p O#-p(9@ #00 > C(%( .#5#F

? Op O#5# (F5 (r5 #? >S IFS5 IFS 2 2 (%5 > $ ' .# V#: (
p O (% [ $( > $#% 2$Y #3S I MS5
.5#$ q0: > Cp 2? >5#5# > I ##Z< 5 [ p (% m $U
r p
> .X#Z C %r 90@ # #$
90@ > # 2Yp.

O M 9 ' I5 V# ]N 0 [ .V$ qF@ 09
? O] " 0 "#r
< O: #($ O# . #5#F C O: #($ 4r # .0 q[
f 09 # ?I (% $ #> C 2? q$% 0: 0 2# I50 U5 # #I
9
'39 < V 5$

#%E .I( q9 # I : : U90@ # #$ :%#F :
p
.> 2Yp q i0: > I99 (9 .I FU5 ($ @ >S
9@ #0 #cY V S : O.Op
09? 2 0 O# >?F O 2M N . 0 M 3 V#3
$ > C9 " "#?F[ 2 >:[ f I qM p ( >S p V<X
90@ # #$f I q > 9S (% $ 0$ (Y 09 O?
$% $ > #9
2'>? . qcY #?F ( O Op( 20[ .#5#F 0#
q? >?F " 5 ' > "#i C O# U .V#(%$ > 09
$ M i . >?F O : 2#( > 2 C#53 > CF' M >##F N : Vi V
$ ' >##F'39 > . ($ < C#p %Y c C#53 Vm%
O WL pS >: :] W5M :?# #S#Z3 > S % 09
.# 3 09 O# $ 0$ >?F Vp V MY C#53<" O: C#$
F#".
0 CM " g$ > O##D3Yfj ' ">##F 0 ' V ( O# O# #>?F
# V < O .I5# S XM< O: $ % > O#0 "#" 0$ >?F
0 IF cS O#$ .3Y 5 O? S O# 5 @" > O# '."#
V I5 > ($ >?F K< V C C#53 f $ #

I .
I3
M I5 S C > :53L #'cI # %i OF > F
K$$> $ L #: > >:" W#%r O W#%r :f O W#%r > 2Sfq9
# ."VFS 09 O#< C% V 0 % :53 L # 2:53 'cI .#gSr
$ C5
I( : C#53 O >
> F < #$> 20 05:
2
#F'39 C# O '< L 0 .cY O O0: Op
$ $0 O VSL "(i $" 5 O($ ?F$
# > KM$ ':
.#5#F cY >?F [c5# 3 0#M 0# CS
I5: CM 3 M q
0 > X 2 0
$ :0 #5#F? >
3 . O #Y q: C#< >?F
p :E
F<# V M#S5M < C0< # %59L cS O# # "< " O# V
> S : O# 1929.1932
259L 2 > F : 00 C#53< > C#' >##F ? V5
( g$ V
(9 >5 V'39 :F ?F$c ?> r 35 O #$[ #?> ? O O
#%
'? 9% >?fM 0$] 0 #39(9 O? ' . [ 2M #?S Vi5 <(#
. < >?Fi 0 E I# Z # ($ V #9 39 [ c: #i
#9 O O#[ < I5 9 q K$ ' >##F'39 : ?F$ ~
( q[ #$> V#: . ? K> 5 K(F O#% V$ : C 0 Fr K(F
(9@ #0 C#US $ . SY O# # S' > II>?F
C5F cY r 05: O# 0I: 'j > : 0#
. ?L
"f" >5#F O # I U5N #r $ ] W p ###F Y
(9@ # : ###F00 4r 5:
#5( @ ]F ?
>##F[ i 9
' .#> 2# O? #Yf F (9@ # O: m[(5( # 0>
0$ ? .I#: q(ZE q #E >?F i>
I C%F'S (
> 25$ .I5
0< 09 O 00$ > $3 r3 M 0 > cY # O O0: Op?O O
j 0 >?F V$ 2 ( M 3 C0?S >9cYf E LF .# $
V 2 CM V V@ V ?$5 > I 9 0 .V O#5# O: :" ?S V0#$
( "#r M V#: m(%5 .i
? X p X3: 2[ p
0 %r XM0 23# D 9 $ Y " q" \M 23# ( 5 XM k#(
? 2 K$ Vr fM ? O#Y O $ @ >Si : c #F .##> 5 V#S#Yf
05: 'I% " > Z90@>" % >5#F O X V(r Kf
S #F 9 ##Y O #> 50? V: 49
]#F U V(90 $ O .
$

? O V:p< #f ? :59 IS: > p q i? O: 4 > IFS Oi> $ C2
10
%9 O:% ( 0I%i 0 5 > $ 2 C K$E 2? V# > VO K$
$ 2 O
f F
> I3[ 0.D
O #Y F \ m#[ VD 0 0 . 0D9 >?F ## : #:39
0D9 #?S ?F:" > $' "#D3Yj [ Fj Y # K09 #0# O
# [5> 0(%Y
U: ~ r V V:[ K9f 2#0 Vr : 9 #($ 2O 2
@ $ I .V 2 V%r
V<$F 2(9 O .0$ O E< 05: 0
(#I0 0( #F E 0#$ V #> I XM(#I0 I# k(## 00 ' k#r EI
'
"I##" V [ M O##F( #
V#3r% DM( .# O:
?
? 05:< ' ?
E 0?( I > V@( V$ V
9 C# O V(.V:
' f 3$ .i 2? ?$ >?F CDS (O #%
"f LF"
~ [ IcU #F E Ip .# M5] O#< K0 cY 2 ?
>5#F XMS
O: O#:< 2# q$ ]M(I ( cY (# > q(: > #5#F'
>##F> (0 #9Yf.
>?F > 2 09 VFS' mr V F #:# : $ 0#$3 C .>#F]
Z > : C9' O? ' >: : I#%9 0 >?F 2 05:: I M(
# L < XMI 0 ' .#: O ( <0 ] : \$ ' 09 OY O O
XM?f : .I#> g$f# #F <0 > < > @ F X3
E< >Sr Z q
f ( % @ #F O @ F V
0< <S5 :?0 2 0 :?0: 2
# ( .5 " "#?F V CM 0$( .C 9 C O" I#S3 qS@ "#DI5 > %F
' I? # >##F
0$ V#:' I V E qF9 09 I 5$ > ?I
: q:# ([$.
>Scr Y O# >F M p
$
I >:#% Ii$( g$.#?F
@( $ @ 2 m3 #Z Y I 05$ 5? @ 2IE V$ V( @ 2 ' p
'5#F0 #?F . C] ]5
O XM K#:'f > #<FM 'I ( .
40( ]M r . L ] g$ I5 2? m
c E V r >?F
Y (0 $
> O: ?Sf X?S YMS5 I # >?F ##F? MS5 Op I5 2 I5 Sr
I
c$S ] ? X 2 .I: :p5r #$ #5#F> 3 0$ >?F2? :V
c >0 >Y > MS' : M5 >##F O?
1953 0 0#$ >?F V(%> @I
> O#p :p'I 'S M> O: 0I$ >5#F : O#I #Fr #
c .>##F : O ?$]p U 0 >YM ?$ O#3 ISr9 5
> >5#F O#< 0 0 Y #F r # %> I $ i #:# #$ '
]#%$ g$ [ 0 D$ #f ?. 2
[ O V 9" : Y % #?"! #?F$ F # 0
5: p ? C 2(# ( O5$ .#5#F #:#> q$> " O
'
0"
>#F 0$ C %> j I# 00# % : I? 2 W .C%
($ ? p >?F > 0 5#: .V F# 4#M '($ 4#
\
0< I5# # >?F # O: rF5 #?F 0?3 O I I< @ O 00
@ #F> >:> 00 V5< 3: . O O? I Oj 0 $
>?F Vi
IS Z#Z M $> V5
$ >:##Z > % > V#:5F
(.
: 0#$3 E : p >?F $.
1964
< F0
11
@
0? 4r q'< # 0L#U5 ##F 2Y [ 5 # :O1 1IS9
#i9 #> C @ #i9[ .# 09 XMcY #i >1 1'1 #90@1#
M5 I#: qf0 @ : M5 .## $ 1904 5M Mr XMcr ? 2< O#:O##1
#S5(? .#S q I U5 #S5 ?1 15 1 .
h 1I<#?1 1#$#(%
?
( mYU # Dc ( #( . q I U5(O1
1 #S
9 11# 11 C 11%( 11 [11 11 11($ 11I[11 >1111 I 119@ 11#%11
? $ cS.O#
2# > ]#S5 > 3 #%F : X #r ] f 01# M1
" X0$[S" M 0 c .% # #M mYi95 V1#(%9 015:M1 1
K111$90@ 111#( 111 111' < 111f0111 c 111 >$111 41119 ]#S11150111
90@" 11# "#311" "11#11 >11 11 " "11f( >115( 11#0119 11 %F11 11U
90@% # > .> ? 2 205 '
IFS \ % 90@ #( 1
0<
k# XM :YMYE . ri # 1 1 "9@1: 15# "1# >1q19
: VFS O1 2#19 1# (# 1 O1L'1 % 11 #F1 I .#i15 21 f O#E1C 1%
( "[ ">: #M : 9 O#~ V(% ? ]M c1Y
I [1

05: I 9@ # # I0I$ E
( g$( I<5.
9@ 11#( 11#Z311 r O11 11 i11 > 01111> <11 O11 #i11
>(@ >F ?N -$(@ I 3 > [ O: 4r 2? #3 ]#S5OM
11($ p11 "11[ "011D ( .11 011 011:9 110 11#:? p11 11I#90@ 11#( 11 m1
:F ]#S5 0S5 @9%
I
I3 >(%( > I[ O O[.
: O ?$] O?
(c5j S 9% [ ? > 590@ #( >1 #1'
M5 .I(0 9 f # (% > $[ . r # 1[1 01 1I319
(c V# S 1 1: 1f O#1c 31cS O#1 :%1 O1?
1 OM1(# 1 1 [1 1
\Y 0
p$ O .
I5: 5 :
I> C %90@> 1
[.
119
#11# m11$ 11# [11 0 11#Y$9 411j
i115
11 11IM11 ?11 >11 ]11 O#11 O11L<11O#
O##f O0DF 2Y #$ .# ?L
1%r >1 V1S9 i1$ ]1 1: O#115
1IIf1 1 011: @( 1S#5: 1#O1 >1
> : [ > (0 [ 1r 1#
' 0$ 25?
I# (%0# 1 1#9 1: <1 #0I%i1 XM11(%
35 #Yf
> (# .< (3(# > ?
N O I E 3 O IFS( 901@>
KF? 0< I5(< IFS : V#%ri 1 O1 O?1 m1#[1 1 >1 W1 1I51 1
[11 #11 1111 211 211(# 11f .11# 011 (311 11(% 11$ #11 11%r
( 1901@> ( 1 [1 011 X@ 1#51 #i1 %#F1 ##F11 1# >1 I111
? 0#$ # 0 .
(# > N [ i ( O1 1 m1#% 1
? < #? > 0#$ 0( #F # 0 I O: $ cS O#90@M .#: 2#F
(# ( O0 90@ #( .1(15
h h 1:
#1%
p> O# 23S 0f 0 K% O 39f L #90@ # 1:
< E c #:[ M $F KF C 0#E( O[ > .1# Z M1
? M 03 O V
0M 1904 >: O# K$ 1906 M 49.V
cY 49 V?F0 >: [ 0@ D : : FY ' O 4j 0 >1 C1015: E1%r
115< X011 O#311 O#: 211Y 11L11-#90@ .11# 11 c11<115 O#11 O11 m11%5[11
1
(: 4j cr O qF# I5# k# m$j1 101 '1 .1 21E
> q9 VFS ( O% f0 4$1 1:90@ 1#( 1 #101: 1: O1 1I#
12
I : #: 2#F V 3(# O IFS0 ( 901@> 1I O1 .1#1
OU M ( 2p( 2 # cY O#.5 f
V O 0 0 cr O#(cS
K(F Y 4j c<5@ O# O#(35$ > p I I IU0$1 ?41#
> IY 05$ . q$0 19171 p1 (01 019 >S1 1U5 1p< C1 2i11$ O#01
[ O#S[ O# q:% ( 0$ 5 O3 0 #5: %%Y >Y1# :01 ? 1 1(%1$
L #
<F5 <F C c C0> < V C9c$ > #(% .# <5 ? >?#S5 09
> i] O# i5?> M j V 2(: m#90@ #( .
> 09 XM $(%<00 O1I< > 1 ' W1 01 1 (1 C1 >155? >11 \O1Y
5 00: Y S p ( O1 >S1 #31 W 1 M1I p1 0 >11: 1 ) 41917 (1
MI ' ?:L >S @( C?( ? >1? O 0#$1 21#->:1 L11 >r 1[ 1 #1M1
VcY O q 5L c (% %F1 $ O1? ##F1< K1 ?1 01 [1 #1
2(9 (3? (# .2@ Op $9 < 5:% C1(@ 01#$M1 ?1 M1 K1
: 1906M V@%Y q #F#Dp : M5 1904 < V#: 20$ M 2#011 1:
U5 qF# #F K( 2090@> ( M V0 ]#S5 1 K1 ]1p1
M m? (% $.#$ #
' U5 #Yf < M . 2#0@ : C 5(@ 5 U5
# 2? #F 5
E(5 %r i$0 > I# E? XM M5 .: : Fr
M11I m11 ?1111 C11(@ 0#$511 " 11< >11 11 17 >11 "11 c11 >1111 >1 1915 11 115$
"i5 O 2c ?
" . MI I #< 0 1: "" 0 2?1 1 1II1 ]#S15
" > ."# > rM % 9c$ cY #(% 5F 01$ 1$1 019 1905

% 2 > ]#S5? #9 9@ # O V( >I0 ( #31 W[1 #1[ O1 1
#i 2(9? (# >S V3 ?S M cY 5F 00$ F O1 2?
1
C @" O:Z" > < !V
> $ 49 O: 5[0 O ]#S5[ O 0 ' L 1 1I 5>?F1 C19 1 .]#S15
>?FM1 < 01 " >11U" 1 1#Y >#F1 O1: 1#($ V15S$1U5 O1 5$1 .>#F1
0$ >?F :X5$ 1917 c# (% : $? K1<
1 ?1 1IM1S5 1#r
p L>-90@> p >:#>
2Y01 1? O1
1(1 1r M1 V1 V15#:
>?F> q9M 0 X V < K
#F?F#F> # 1<#
I#:c0$ c O 0 ' . ? 0 >?F >$ E 09 mM'j OM1(1 1 [1
#f S O#:E 9 ' c1Y >?F 1905 O#1$ >1S .1906 ]1 q19? O1>?F1
) E O # (F( O
IS[ #: I # 1$ E 1I5? ' V1 >1I5I 11
9@ -# 2j I (# F <# M VZ3 V1< >1(%
> ( 0 VFS C <# # .>$ > >?F] 31
?1 O#1 O1:?1? 1#: 1
L#-90@# ( .I# #
W9 V( %r rF#F 3 #$#(% 1( >1(% 1(#
> #%90@ #.##F
> ]
I O# >?F [ 0(1 O#1c ]1cS O#15$ 1( 1#Z31 >101
# $0 01 01$ 1( 015$31 O#1(# 1( 1 #1 V1?1
< #cS #F : q 00 >D O% 5 >#F Ip ##F #%1' >1
?$ (@ YEcS O#101: .
1I 019 >?F1 i1 (# 1 m1%5 I$01 >1[1 1I1
c ?
O C#%F 2 jM 2$ ' 2? I f 1I?1 019 IF1S5 I#i1 q1Ym1%
[-i . > V c (# ?
I#: # #3 m$[ : pf( 219f
< # #: > U O UU : 2 I#: ?$ %F1 ##F1 O#1 :1I01
- 4) 0Q
( - >D 1917 4 _Q " 1
`K 1Q 1: 1" 1 1Q "ab_ 0V 3000
W4 , Y -( ) .)(0$ ( 5 ) (1938-1854 ) -)4 b ) 1 Z)Q" 1 _" ) Z( - P .1883 J
D) )( i
) 1 1 . Z i4 . 1 1-) ,)- 1 .1899 - , 1915 Pk 4 N , K Wj)

)Y l 0: , 0Q ) ) >4 4 : , )) .)(0$
13
I #:
r XM< #cS #< Sr .I#U5
I >?F #F[1 #11
11 >11 O11 11II 311 XM11011 11< 11 m11(% 211I 11 .
11$ 011911: O11:C11 m11
O##F11[11 >11 O# #11 E 11# >11 V1111 c#11 (# 11 11: #11? 211(9
11 11I#: >F11
(# f I#: K # 2ZF I$ (%
#F1 # ( :F1 1I$9 1?>1? O1
0 0:F [ 9 (# > .XE
$ XM$9 #f1 # 01#$
1 #F1
23 I#' 2 I#5 >?F : Kr5#1 41#? #?ScS1 0#1 O1 E1 >1
I1 r 1
#$< F > #F#E( : (F .1917
0$ q$9 > (1 1: 1: F1Y M15 11 C19 g1 >?F1 51
[ #I ' f <
V 2#<F' > Ic< > V5# ? K90 >#F@ #( .
O V0 0L !t% ?N !#F 5 O: m " OS$ #f[ O1: 1(: 09 "# >1 VF1SM1
?
0 : >:[ 2(9 O #( ?S XM 2? #f[ V15: 1(: : q31 1K1
3 4 > \ 4 : .1914
0 ( >?F [ #: LcY I5: C : O1 .Op1 1 019 q(1 XM1(1
S $9 O >?F .:M I % r V q##F .#$ S9 Mr V O1 1<(1 >1
0 I(# > #:#E? .#> ? >?F] 0 ( DM cY 2 51 010: 431 C1#
M#c0 O V 101 .1U1#Y 01$ 1r V10Y >51 q1I 11I N1 >15 ' V1
$ V1?# C#) Ki1Z01 1 Ki1Z O1? 1 0 ]11# (1 [( q1 #1 C1#1
C# (# > f $#(% V ? Z 2 O#~ .>$#(%? O O OF $ '
[ ' E( O 0'j fM O#M[
I 3 .C#
C1
<F15 2?1 2
OMc O#S9 K11$ 1f :5 ]F1 15 C1#[1 019@ 1
9 O# $#(% #: L9 C O# U5\ > #F 01 f 01 31: qF1# #F1 #11 1
~ > 2# K# >:> I<I5 #$#F > #r I.##
0 q c? O# : 1906 : 1915 I#: 01 .201$ >1f21
c 5U V 9 F f0 0# > O: q$9 XM11?S 01$ 1 .V1 >1$ >1
Y0 > S? 2# >: 4:<
? M 0 # f q9 1L V 11 1 "
@( 2#9 "O#0DS (F5 .
O] > (: Wr?S > V: #f 0(O1 #
55MM1 .N1 1 M1 (M1 01I1$ 1: m1#M1 ?11 1D IF1 V1 5F1
4#i VL3 CD9i O %(5F< 5.#
? 12$ 1919

14
j$
$2d
[ > E 09 # <0: C# 90@-O## M5 .O##: L 21@ OE1(5 1# #F1
[11 #11 >1111 ' O11 011 11<S5311 11<# O#11
D1111% >11 119 O#11 ?
11m11%
< . q5# 0 C @ S #F[ 05$ .@ I#: q S[ ( q #
W $2? [ > r" #U % #$#(%< C( ."V
0 q : #F mM ' ( . O I 010 V1 O##F1:
(1%
I E1 ?S1 "?L1" ? >1 15[1 >1 1 15 %1 21# 1I(#01 .>YO1 21
( V#E 50 1793-1789 0 1848 E%Y > C O1? c1 .1 1#r>1
I#: t#$(# #MZ I 2 2 2#.>: L
[ # 0 C % p# #3L< Xr M V1#1% >:1 L1015: >r
M S 9\ 500 #r.
15
-1A
+ $` :$
5 O#% # >: L O#% > >: L(0 f #Yf : 1
< O# C Ir~ # 55?f V5: Xp# C %% >f # >: L0 1V1#D
Yk+.#(F5.
O11 0115: 4119(11f XM11I 11#$#(%(0 11#D? O11 XM11 O11? ' 11# q11#5 011 :11I# ]1111# 11#: L
0:9 : # 39 [ 0.#D
5$ #F % 9 L 0 1#$-1#: L O1? .1#r<1$ 319L 1(%
% ( 05: W O? 64DM % F .5#$ p% 4D(% M 0 X%
#F121$
mY 4D #:[ 3YS O1 F9?F1 1$ OM1 >1L1 1 (1 15 1
O: g#ScI :V W %] (% 1#M1I 1<5 gD1S C#%F1 ]11(% E15(1N1 .

#F O# 2$(% <5 ( 05: W O? IFS% p : 5#$ C#%F1 Oj1p 01?F1
#5 O##S p m( 0 .>: k# : XM: % #f .>: L
O: 5 ]M] O1
1 V " 11Z >1 "7 15r31 0 11 %1f 1#
? ' W( 0 % 39L M (( VU -#$#(%) #rZ C >1?1 1Dc 219 (1[$(
O #: m#$? O >(% $ @ I#: >Si[ 0.#D
O11 K$311 011 2?11M11 11 11% >11 >:11 Lp11$ 211 11 XMr#11 #11' $E11 11#
p5: 0 >S? .W #Y j 0 M
# .23 #: L #( 1: 1#51 319 >1Y
O#$ q D qE # WZ q I%->: L >rr >.
0115:0%11 M11
#11U5 >:11 L?c11Y >11 11#:?11#U5 V115 <11 11Y 0 q11($11#D
9c$ 39L 05:f % CS 05: #(FYf > #$> ( O: kM L0%.
0 #> 0:9 : q 39 0 #D19c: >1 q1Y C1 q:%11#U5 1#5( 1
: [ :S( .Y ' : I5 0 1 #1 1<#1 C1 I: XM11#U5 [1
019
I "#$ M( > 8"# C I: ? < > % 9c$ 39L 1
( O9% O #M ?N I p$ q# V3 .' 39L > 1% 1%
C5# :$ m#L f
.
%0 ? I5MY 5 WZ q K# V 39L.
?M> #1 f >f #101:f 19% q1 O1M1I .1I 21 1S F1S ' X.C1
E m(%5 ' 0#M : 0 > \ Y [5 ? > . O Ii$ C I: 2( 01: XM1
0 : 39 I O?
0% #U5 0 $, WZi : I# 9 M q
.V : #
0 :03 0( 2D > M FF
? O
OM1 ( 1: 01$ 1# 1?c1 O1
#r0 #$0# WZ V # #.0F
MI <# WZiM V0 f # q$0 ?1 2 F19(1# gD1 O1L1
I q1 1: t#1$F1 1(% ? 1 >11@ >1 q1 ? ]M1 q19:E O1% 1M1 1 >1 1#%
f .2? O1?
1 OM1 >1 1 21 01 .1f qi10" 1: 115 i1" p1 2(1 O1 V1
6 W " 1 "1iN) Estate 1$ N , ;Z W
4) 1 n 4
$ ." j 1iN "1jj " 1iN"
1-Z ,
) B
B $ )( ( , : W
4 ) .1789)(0$
- 7) " 1(o" 1 , (
4 ;Z >E) ;) .)(0$
" - 8 ) P
"1 $ "" F $ P ;VFK) ) ( ) j )-) - W )Y o_ "D-
"") .)(0$
16
V#$ ( : V f >
V OF q9?> 1 M1I q19$ 1I# 01: 1 ?F1 1%
9 L .?M0( q0 ( F9 C l$: O cDL q ]M 29$ p(>1% O#1 c1
% 4D 0
F9 : q( O #5 b q ]M1
% 1 ]1 1fL 1#(01#D
> .I#: 0$
? >? O? O0 O( O IS# : >1? 1Yf O1 O?1c#1L 1: 31>1
O I5 $<. N$ ( >n% ?
+MI .m 5# q 4F15 1f319L % 1q1
>11 $F11 q119 V11 11 11% XM11 11f %11011 #? 11# q11:#Z O11 11011 211 11%
% .I3 4D #j 9 [ # M C 2? g951~ 1 1# .1# ZV1
' g95.5
?# % > 4D %> q ?
9 m%@> q? O c?1 01S 1
g$ 39c$ #: L0 .? OM ? O 2? 0 1 31 KF1? 1
Y 3) V cF 3(9@ (#31 31 C1 W1 #1% 41D01 #?31 C1 O1
% 4D #$ .i % 41D%#F1 >1 q101 " 2?1 "W1M1 ' 1 O#1 V15: 15 #K$1

#U50 1: %Z1
#1U50 1< O1 21$ I@1 >1$ 1#($ .I31 O1: >1$ >1q19
VF11S %11 q110 111 F11 11U5 311 11% 411D 11#$ hhn hhE $hh .hh11I% q11
$ N .I%F I:iY 1~ 19c$ >1$S O#10 1% 41D q11%Y >1 #F1 $01 F1
] .
I$ > I #: #F#D0 > q.#
q110 11 2ZF11<11: 3119L >11? 11#5 I311 I$i11r 11# ?F11$011.
<: 39L %#F cY q 2ZF0 ~ # : I? 21# @.41D
> ($ XM #: L q % 3 <#50 0 ( > V#: q 1 .1# Z (1
011r %11 O#110 1111S 11#: L 11: 11#$F11 <11 # 11$M11 >11 ?$511 C1111
( (:f #L 1 219c(15 1$S L1# >1 1 #11 1#? >1 V1#: %>1 41D
cY # Z .%M ' ] .V# O O? IN O1 V( 1Z?(1# $1 F1
(F5 5# V% q1Y 4D0 >1 11Z %1 q10 >1 1 #1 >1 q1Y >1%01r 41D
)I3 #(.
# 0?> ' $#%F mY% 2( .4D Mr XM S' #: ]1 1SD@ 2?1
# 0:F %0 O I 0 ' ? 09 q39 < 2 C#M O1 151# .1#:
' ? O C5% 4D O
m K S m 9 " CD" . %0 1W1 C#%F1
C#< 0:F #$39L f 1# >11#5 01 319 F1 1: .C1 11 1
0 019 # q?I1 31(1# 19@ O1 #(F1 1#: ]M1 19$ 1f(1 >:1 L? 1I5q1
XM I3 #$r . O V >$#(% qE # I%# WZf > f[ ( ]
WZiM1 c1Y 21
#1U5?F1$ 0 1 $F1001 1 1 C11% p1 1: >1(%1
39 0 .>D K]N C0 1I 4$1 I#i1 >1?15 -1#: L319L
O1 >1$#(% 1 0 1 IS1 1 %1 2$F1 I<(1 V11% 1(% 1#$ V1m1
.I3? I@ > O m#< ( > #M L< X 0 0 IFS' ?( IS$i C %(0>D
I#U5M $ 0 #D(#5 .>: L
?M0 #> : U 39L # WZi :0 qY 0:>D
>
U$f# O #U5 0 > (01 <1 1: 1D1 319 [ 11% . 01 O1q19
O#11$Y O11 11 11I11 qM11 11: C F110 11011I 3119 211#<$ 1153119L >11 >11$#(%(.011
q311E0110 11: O1111 \ 11#311 C :511(11# 11 11: C5%311 2?11<011 3119L
0( .>$#(% E #> 50.
9 ) (1943-1859 ? i4 _

) . Wo E) ? k ( 1$ 1? 14 0)E.
` k : ) ))(0$
17
O 9c%M 55? 49 C#1$ #1 O1 >11$ <1I ? >1 1I 1I
#1$%
10
: 4p<0 2I< >$#(%@.>5
1?S >1 ?S1319L 019 c[1 >1 21 >1 11E1( # 1 V1#: V11$ 3119L
f[ % > #9Z .f 9c$ C(0 Yf Mr @ C9c$ C0 C @ K(F 39L-
>$#(%M : Z%U 39L 5(>% < r 1# M1rE1 # XM1(01 2?11
4#5: :0 2(9 Mr? 2 539L ( . 319L >1 Z 1: 1319L >1
%0 .?> ? O O( 0#9 :# > 0 W $ c I9S %1 #1 1 15
3 C?# ( 5? K0 # O#3 \ .XY?
1 O? O1#F1 319c 1$
0MI >Y ( 0?( > #F #M L< X VF1S 1 1% f1 319L m1r
1 1 1
1$1$
? >#(%I< C# q 0 ( q(39' . @ >5M @(% $ O39L >$#(%
39L >-( >:i ] W K#<F L ? #>
Dc% X W 0 c CM1
% . ~ :53 #U #> 4#F?> > 9 2i
:0 ODM .
(F# :4#c0#
" ( # ):53 :5$ ?F WS51 1#% 1 :51 019 (#F1501 1<#E1#
( 0 #? #> g$f# 0:F i$ ?Y # f ? 1 q1( C11
11# 2?11 11c11r . ?
11 311#?05F11 q11? 11 XM11 #F1111 >11< 11I
f ? # #$> q : #( m#(% > 09 # : q5 I[ (@ O 015
[."I$# S
) :4#c05 . $ # (% -1906.(84
M 0 S F5 #:53 4#i #? 1I# O1?
1 1 1%1
#:53 W1 1I#1(:L 1#1(:L ?F1$M1I .>1Dp 2?1 1#5 K(F11# q1
$ C W # 31 #1f1 C1 21 >:531 31r1:< 1 1 1:f
.Sr?M W O: I O% "i KD : $S< O% LS 1Z #1 I
< C# : O% O 3 2 # #(D'" .[ q? > ( "m1Y" 1# 1I:%41D
m0 0 ]M I" > >f" C#53 (% 0Y 5pY0 .' ] > ?
1
S K$ 09 ##Z > 2U 3 CL > f .#
0 05: < C( $ >5 Fj > ##FZ ( q?
1: m1%V1
(< F 0 f # 0 . 9 \ : 0$@ # ' p> 0S > 1 19c: 010
? I5 > : 0#
Y( M#S5 #c 2 .U5 C9Z ? F > $( 0 1fM1
511L $11 [ 211$ 11M11 11 V11 11: S11 11I :F11L<F11 #i119 >11) >(F115c11
.(C ? q 09 00? # 2 @ O :F ?F$ ( 0 % .Y ? 21(9
( [ >
1? O11$ ]?1 010 1Z .1 < t#11 q131 ?
1m1%
( 09( > V O: q 00 # m# '$ > 0 #%#F 0W1 #1 .1#Y
? 2(9 F[ U$? O?: I
1848? O] #M ? V #.
5#? 2ZF( 0 01$ 01 1I\ %1i1 #(D 1#?f ?F1$ q:%1 C11I
5F # (
r
9 5 .2 I# .1I1 ?
11S ( 1f 1#1
.V 5pY?M ( Ci KD> 0 XMI I( f .#
?M11 >11 11S 1880 O#11 18900311 ? 11
11$ #119 - ?F11: 11U5 IS11@11#
( # - # ' .I
( ? # %> ?F$

>:( f 2 KF #(# # #]M
0S XM?N I ( > IU C1 #5:?
101( .m1% E1 (1 ?
1 m1%?F1$
> : i9 09 # [ .#
? OE > 0 C9 ?$.#
- 10 4 1 DK , 1 ,
1 OP)FK - W4 W " "-ND ,$ 1
.;E YZ 1 j -P NDu . P P ,)
Z -( 0Y4
W , ._ 1 Y

.1 , k .1 P $ O)Fv ) .O)Fv .(.
18
? q9 p? O: 'c< C O1 q 9 01Z 1U5@ 1#1 41

< .C 9 qU: # ?F1$1@ 1 O1 Ii1 21(1 qS:i1?1 < .V1 01
p I> ( # 2 I5M ( 11# 1# 21 I1#M1 (O1 O#1c $i1 1
qcF C#%F > F( 01$ ?1 019 O1: q1S9( 1# 1 f 15 1#- >:1 L
< # L 0 #Y? O #i ?F$M ? q XM0 > f# 2.
@ M C 9 O# g95 1 1L1 319L [ >1 1# O#1? 1M1
? 090 @9" I0$ '<" . 0$i ( "$#9 Lc #?(#"
1 >1 O1 O?121
i1195 11: 211 11?$ f 11I 11 2?1111 O11 (11011 K$311 O11 2#F11 #F11S ]F11
? #Y @ m(? .# r O 0# XMi95 # C1< I$1 >1 1<C1#
0 ?> O(r > 2?
m% .<S5
?M11N11 119 ?
11 m11%L 11 ?F11$ 11#M11 Ii11S C#%F11 ( O11
11 1111%

11 >:11 L 0$(F11?11#9 11# [11 11 11 11(# 11: 211 KF11 O## O11 q11$ 11?$[11 11r
.0#c: O:] 0 [ q5 M $ @ S 2<M 0 mr?
(< m1% V11 V15#
O# O .f m #F # ? r ? IM K 0#M F< XM % ?E OIV?1
> 11$ O# (## E1
I1:[ 1 "<( 1#[ "1#"#($1" [1 1#$ 1:
(0 #F :L .KD<$
% >: L 2$ 09 V< m F[ .# 9 q XM[
11 ))4 b $ Wj

)( > 0 ;N ) ( .n ) N ,- "j 4 1-E" : u) 4 , ) (
B 0Y)( Z ; 0Y-y( (!)1D Z > `` ,)o i - 1YZ ( 0Y
P E (Y "V
j ") ."1N )( 1" ) (120..(.
19
-2 $
#0 O C5~ k0 ? 2 O I $i C5$ #Yf O >S .Op0I: I
% f > C1f O11 [ 1: O11 01: ?1 01 ' 01p[1# 328.000 O1: O1 %3
< 0: ? ( .0> I 1.301.000 VFS < O %4.1 01: ?F1 . <>1
: 1812 0: ? 0 1.653.000 09 $ O %4.4< .> 435 1: C

? 3.482.000 O: 0p O O %7.8< .#Y M L31 1:) 1#Yf (1897 01: ?1 01
12
( 16.289.000 < O %13 ?F.
(: 50? # -#:39 1< qF# 01 11 ' O1 15 0119L E1 f19
M ' Xc: >%$ O:% 0 q5 0 :0 > # Ir 01 I(1
f I5 0#$ 2( O: 0$0I .>$
O]N XMf9 ( 2? O# 0: #0 >
0I:" 2(9 #Lc" IS> c1Y CF 01$ .1#Yf01 >?F1r# 1 01: ?F1
> 0 : O# 1885: 1887 %33.8 (F5 4$ O: 0p (F1 01: ?1 #1?21
) (%15.25 c $ (F 0: ? (%12.7) 4 5S M V1 #:531
#Z3 < 5?F CF 0 ) ? # m@5p (#: .
' 0 # ' [0 O: 4r0 0$ 0 ? KF I? 1I$#(@ >1 O 1#: L :i11I
p# < .#:53 (0 # 5 01? q1 K1$ 319 f 1I q1 p1 1
? 2$ ?F: :c9 4r > I 4D0 #$ :F q#1 1: 2?1 q1 p1 1
?F: p <( i.KD
05: f> # OF O#S > 50 > O1 I I#01:f
1I$
1
O11: ]11'11
I11:Ep 11#: . F11 ?11 11( >11 1150 11 #11
11 110? 11: O11 01111#($
# " #? p:(
F9 W ? O 2? 3 I Y 1i1:E >1 #1 11
011Y .11 311 11: 1701 11D: 16.000 O#11 O11 V11 q11 I5?F1111 O11 (%44) 11D: 7000 ]115
O#5@F O## XM1$ 21D q1 O?F1i1> 0 1$ 1F1 21$ .31 11 9000
D:Yf? O I5 D: 1500? 5I( O # (%" .?M01 #1E1 IE1 01
q?
# m% ?: :01 1#< >1 1 1 1 1 %1 q1 K1$
'
# o?E' .> S I<0 q Z > S (0 0: F > > O?F 1
0
# % C F [ 2 XMf0 . O qS# O1 q11 01 >1 q141
p.:
F11 3119L gSr511311 40 11( 11U 11(: 1111 11
[11
#F11 >:11
.2$ 4#3 #3 > 4#3 #9Z F1S <1 1 1 @1 O1 1K(F1 .1
XM$
2 23S5 :511S# O1:p 1:
1< >1 C101 ? >1 q1# 1I5 411#: 1S#
p (F5 .:0 05: :53 # >1 CF1 4315[1> O11
1 1: C1? O11 >1
0 1(: 1I@ >1? O11 1 1 .01#$ 011 #11# O1: 01p ' 1 21 " : 431
# O$ > O##:53 O1: 21 ' 1 0 # c1 O#1c 1$ Z1 :531 19 >1 1#p5
'
1 1I
5#
IZp > #: q9 .VFS XM> (% I> I#: q93 Cf #
F
E ? O 2f? > 3 0## C."#
@( $ p0: 0 ?F 0$ #S
I# 0:9 mY I#:
#F1 .21$ >:1 L1
@( #$# F ] : > 0 .i1 WZi1 1<#5319L M1 V1(01 10q1
:53 #?(# :0:
k#< 0 > 0 q9?> ?> 5%.
12 OPK4 Fy , "" . 4) E - 1897 - ( Y ()
Y (
l
17122000 %13.25 ,Z) .>" : )( 1"
)N 1906 Z Z -) (90 1E..(.
20
q O#cf O $ O##> 35$ VM ? > 2 ? 0 OMY "$1#
"# O#$ # O#
0 % >
IFS Y XM$# # .# #@( O##
I> (%> q?1 1#( 2?1 [ 11# 1 1 1 [1 S #F1 .1U$ XM11#
0 0: # > 0 -# IE # :.135
F113119L 1150 #F11#D 11[0 >11 11I 2$F1111 11r >11E11> O11M11 .411 q11
c .I (F5 #3 # Wr00 W M 3 C O0 2$< k#
O? O< C#S # O5 .I# 019< q1i1 < C1#?F1 O1: 1 :531?(1# . 1
?F > 50 : [0 > 29f g1$ 1I 50f 1#319L ##F1 1(@ >11$ E1O
> p# D O:(% . XM 1(%
1 >1?1( O1 c1Y [1 S #F1 1U$ >11(%
j K$0
> .5
U5 C0 ' >:53(# S3 p$ 2 KF #f 90@ #( >1S .i
0: XM#Yf :( #Z3 > 0 O O## q#Z \.XY
(( \0 Y >#F?( #M V($(# C1 K15 ' 1 #1< 1I 11 1
> 2 .VU$ > >(5 >?F M 09 K(F 01: 1 (# 1S:i1 1
9 IE# :FS : ( (#.#
N11 11 1159 11 >11 #11
11 #11 O11: m11[(511U 1 011 . q11 #11 11 11 11
3119L 11I 11# IF115# 411 ' 11 >11 11M11 ' 11 V11' 119 >11 1150( D1111
cS S F M 0 9% .2$ 0
?
% m% ?( 2#(# 0 .#
>S0 f ?
1 m1%c1S >1 1 O1 01 01(1 >1 .
1$ 1 (01
? 0 D Y V# 1 (3Y 1#(5 f M15 .1#1 ?
1 15[ 1#1
">" "" 3 > F 05 O# $F 0 21?
1
S < < O r (?L O?
. F O# p## 0 #Y 19
Fj 4#F@ #5 O# f #(5 f I O#1 1$# q101 O##1 f .K1 ?
1m1%
N XcS O#
I # q@E i KD 1$S1 31 O#1c >1E O1 V1#1
:
$ <# ( 1#15 1: <F1 1%Y ]?F11? .100
F1f( O1 1XM1
3 5 # 4( O5 #39L .
F9( O #Y0 > 2 11r 1:01D 2?1
' ( 1 >1 1# 1 >1 S 1>#F1
> 0p f@ # > # .I
%i11 2?11 >11011 (c11Y 11# 511 11$ 11#Yf >11 011$ O##11 O##:5311 11S311
11#Yf XM11( 11 q11? 11 311# 11 011# c11$ 11I 211
11 11Ip11 (311 O11$11
( 2Y #' >1 q1 ? 1IS%: >1S .V1 1I q1 1: #F101 (1 >1I1
3 405I " > "X M 1 3# X09 1: 1798 19" :C01
0DS $En $ " ( f ( 3 # >11 L 1:?
1f m1% O1 1
? Y I3 I Oi # .# 19 0
1 1? O1 #101# >1 1IcY O1 2F1
f > .# VM 1 0S5F1 F19 V1$ O1 1 10 1 #11 1$ 1
: #? 2 < >:5< V1 M1 ( 01 1# 1#$#(%[F1 Y19 1 1# 21$1U5
>
? > O] 09 O#: : ]M . qS #Yf O(( #:53 q1: >1#1
1893 O#: 1899 i < ?[1 S 1 f .>1?M1 N1 1 M1 21[ >1 21(9
# 0#$ 0M 9 KF V >1 ##F11 F1 < 1?# 1 1 M1 21 1(%1$
.#
0$ C f > M1 ( 011#9 >1 41r ($ 1319L E1< 11
#F1 V1
#F#D@ c F : V O 2 #5'39 %#> % 1 >1 1I#
c Xf .#?i V5 01: 1 p >1 %#1 m1@ >1 1II V$hd 101 M1 1: V1($
0#$3.>#F
([ q( f " O # SD%0 > Third estate "# .% 09F1 q1$ L<1
11: 511 4115$ OM11 I1111(% 11Yf 311
11 K$11M11 q11 11% >11 11.VcZ11
( 13 , "( _
D )` 1 1 ,j ) 1: )( ( 1789 ) i "(" 1 OP ( 1
N; k P OPk )Ej )) .1..(.
21
0: U?
? - # > #(% cY % #: 2 IF1S 19 1U@1: 1% 1#
?11 011 >1111 011 I:11: ? 115Ic(115 . 011 qZ11( 11M11 311 211 f 11p11
.>#F?M 0 ?
(9@> m% (%\ > # 0 015:311: : 1789q15
( : I 0#E UE f.
> 0 # ?
2 > m% WZi( M V101 1I5: 215 .1# Z K#1?1I
? 2(9 I FU 39L 5 ? .# M ?
]1 m% q1V31
# #U(# \ 9@ # .r # 090 ( @ O D 3 > >1 1O1
0 q #p : t# 39L.
09 2F OZ 0:F ?
m%( 0: O101 10 1 p1<1
#:5 VcY E p# O0 Op < > #:5
O?E O .21(9 O1019
I M > [ O #f# :? 21 F1 (1# .c1Y 1 5F1 O1 1$((1
1893 O# #:53 1902 #9 F
#> 5# 2 09 q >11S 1: O#1
1854: 900.000 ( 1892 0 .W 2 (# E< IFS 09< > q$#S # ' I31S
O:?
m% @( 1 1#9 #101$p$ " O1: 1 "K$1 IS31 >1(5 1S 101#
I$0 #r 0 I .
22
1905 -1848 -1789 -3

~ ' 0#$ .VFS > 5Z I( V#[ [ # S #F O1? ' U$ 21[1 f1
? [ [ .# 0
: C (.K
: 4r 1848[# : O: .1789 05: [1 O#( #1F15 [1 S #F11U$
? E S I : I O .0 q [ 2(9 I 1I O1Y 01 1 01$ f.
] S3# FM1 2?1 V C1#1 1 1f
h@. $h
Wr. hhhh 0115: $ 011 gS115?
1111%9L 11( 11 hh 411#5: hh@1a 211Y XM11 11fDF11 m11@ >11
>S . f 1 101 1793 -1789 O#10S51 21 1#@ 1#5 I%Z1 >1 11U5
cY I
0 3 0 .#$ > 1[ 1#
1 >101 >1 01$1~ >1 1I<$ 15IS1
#11 '11'N11 11# 11#$S119 11I 11 % 11~ 11U011 211Y 11f( 1111 @(11#
"p 0 > c< ."O#I 3 0 >Y 4#5$M1 101 f( O1 1 1#( 11I
K$ O0 C0 >F#D Ii1#(# -1 1 10 1I 1r< 1: 1 1: I1 011I#
# IF ?
. XM (% 3> ' $ < #Z f0 ##Z .c
? O m#[ 05:? q$ 09 fpS IFS ci 01f 015: 1
F151: 1f
Ii$ FcY #DI 3 ]M r M1#S5 1I# 1 2i11I q1 >1 >1 1fM1#S5 .1 1
<: $ O #r $ I? W #%5.>5
m% I5# W > ' 00: % ? OM m% W M : I .1848
> ( 1( O1 1#%1~ S >F1< 1(@ 0115 1
1 %#1 01$ C1i195 I$11
~ : :#9 I I i15 O1 21 m1#1U F1j 01 #1 010 F1( KF1 1#?01 O1
> #$ .i q( D < ID3 C# ($0D9 IFS ? f q ($<1#
i5 % I$ > W%Y I#:3 ?I3 .#?# 90@ # g$(1 Ii1$ 1f%1
.## # 0 - K$( 1#Z31 >101 cS1 1$ K1r5 -( 1 O# V15: 1
q# > I0(Y5 'j 5 ? Z( > MY II >$ .#c1Y
[11 11 O11
11 i1195 11#(% q1111 0i115 11$ [11 M11 11 5$ 11f[11
O U( Y m% .>#F
1M1 Y 1 1' 01$ ?1 019 1I9@ q1 1 1S>1
.ISY f? 2 >1 i15 O1 2101 K#1E I 415:[ 1 .#31 015: q31S1S
O #$( O( [ O< :#> q0Y 1 1 C1 q1SF1
:( K% q 1f0@ 01 1I 1#( 1 1fM1 1F1 m1'1r <C1#
#9 %5> 90@.#
q[ S #FE U$ 0# .#9 1[ O1 1 ]1 01i1 ( 101> O1 21
%#F 'S 35 #($0# O V5:@L >.
0 0 .
@2 : C# XS O#M(# .O## 0( :[ < #1:
119 11U:11~ M11 >11 C531111 0119< C11 >11 V11 Y11?511 C11011 : ! hh.
@2t#11 O11
(# #$ 59 >$ #S3 F C #r M5 # $# .2@ O 2 (# 1#$
$ 09? qcY O q9 i5 0 0# 0 .# $#U5 5$ 05 I 1IUS 5i15i1
0# > qcY ($ : O Op .0
' 50 O: C 0 # $#(# # i F: 0r IDc:# (9 k p1I .Ic1 O11 [ 21 >1C1
'j .I5: (# 09MY : : I > 1 >1( 1[1 . (#1 1I 1
23
m1: I311S O11: >11$ 011#( 1[11 11 11I#: 11N1 011 O11$@ 411 11#(5(11%
09L K%Y : 4%$ mSr I(9: "j ."> $#
M : S(# # 1I# O1?
1 01#[1 S #F11U$ >1 1 1Y q1$S
90@ 11#( 11 11 ]111E11 q11M111I $11 L11 119 >11 K$111c11Y q11$ 11 111
90@ # # $#L # # ##(F": (les sans culottes )14"O#0$ 1793
# O O? # $#? #S #F ? 4r : I5< O I ( 1#( 1: 1K$1
F I# (# qS > V# qY O( ? > # 1# F15 1Ir#31
:f $#$
> m # I# 0E # $# ##F< " % 5M MZ ? O##? - O##L > O## F[1 315#1# 1 1#
O O###F$ OM 0 4#$ O:?p < C1( 1 1E #1 1% O1 1% >11
(" I$#?" cY 01I:1# [1> 1
1$5 901@ O##( 1 >1 O#(01 1Yf 1U5
O#$
I# 0F? O
I5] I5 :
D # $#( %> 03 q p
M.
0$ q% 00$ q # $#0# > .K$01 @ q1 1(# 1O1:
?1
Z I(F: >S .f 1840 0$ 4#9 43 #9 : ?" 1<( "21 21(91 1 [ 1848 1#
: "0:15"O " > 2$-" 1 1: C%# 1 X1$ "1%9
1 1:%9 O1 1(%
00 > K? ."# #" : 0 5 0: 00 K%Y ##(F#<$ 15 ]M 1 1
> @($ ( I5 rF5 O# 0 V#~ [ g1$ > 11 O#5# 1 1Sj C1#
#> #Y 1 1
#1$ j V11Sj 1I 01 1" E1(5E1 " ::1 01 1 XM1
(M ?# c : \ #9 %Y c I > ."F
> : 1848 q( 09(p<: O: q K$ O:
1 >I .#91
1 O1 O?1#S31
U5 >: LM $ @ I 1?
1 #S31 .1 151$ 1 1 1f .]M11 I01
2Y011 1111U5
011i11 i11 %#11 m11# #11 I ##F1111< 11
11119 C11 %F11
.f q >$M 0I >:? . q #?F1 ]11# q1r< 1( 1S #F101S K(F1
#Y I
1 >1I .I K(F SDr1#9 >1 21S <1 g1 #1U5 KF1
01? 1I5 q1: i1M1
U5 ?> C5< # O0.
0< q( S > #F <S I? .#U$ I#: >1:< C11?L O1?
1 f
> Fj' 0$ > : I#:? 20 : ? .># mY ? 2( <E
S9 F >? # O: >Sr m# IFS0 I:( ? I5 q #F f.
: O1 1?$ ( ]1 1f
1 1#" C531[1" 1 01 21(1 01 .1I51 1: 1I#:
U #:> j I 2%#F?L O?
. m#[ I% 0 O1: 1$ . (01
Fj 90@ I # 0 O 25 0 V %Y 0I .I3
> : I 1848 @( C#%F 1f p1$ O1:( 1 ' 1(@ 1I5:
1
? 0$F C0( f KF I%Z %? I5> [ O r( 1##F1
O# 05:f .
??N O ( #Z3 > 0 ' cS ] .
0 q1
M : $ W #? 0Z O? .]M I q(19c$ %
( O # %?p : I5 O1:31 >1 " V1 :5311" ? 1 1Ip1 j1 1:01
? I5 >r m%1 ( 1 %1?(1# ? >1 19S 1I#F1\
31 I #<1 1If01
? ZF I $ ZF q1 I$1 > FF( 1#Z31 >1@
1 .1I O1 O?1%#F1
:0 :F$.S

IR 0 [ O( ##F .F?cY O0($F
I 9 O Op>$90
S(< O# #Y C# cZL V09 V[0 cS > 03 5#$ 3 O #5 19%
[ 11?11? O11011
I
#11U5?11 O11[$(
Ip11$ O11: O#011 K311: 11# ##F11[ 11#?11
I
14 0{
) 1 ,D ,)( ,- 1
1 1 ,j )) .1).(0$
15) n (1856 -1797) , )- 4 Y )- . "VYN.u 0 a NK) P O)N. ) )u (
} - ) .1831)(0$
24
(# 3 O

I9\ > O0 19
1 21? O#1( 1# V1 1?S :%1 O1?
1 150cS O#1
?
I #9 0D9? . cS > U> K1: 1I# C1 1S gD O1: 1#:%9L
I1
2i :0 O Ii5
I#: 2?5
I9 <.2#
@
R
d
a S 5# .#(%( C XM S I#?( -( (#-1#
0Z I ## c@ O: r( (# > # U ? 0 .IS$ O: 4@ q1IF1S
> i95 ' 2 q XM@ I$ 5(.q
1$ 0 $ S#$ 0 q S
#U5(r .$ q 09 #%
Z 9c$ #:%9L 0?

I5? 09 O% % ?> M C0 F 1(% 1$1 19c$
#:5311<0110 11 11011 #11# .1111 O#11 g9115(# 11( 11 O11 1111@L
@ >5f> m1: 09 01 1 ( V1# F1 01$
1 O1 1 01 01 1Y K1$ 1: 1: 15#I
O@11? O11M11 O11 O11?
11 g9115 m11$? 11(% F11 k11# >11 O11 11$ K11$M11 011 . 11#
L? 0 > >Y[ ( 0I# Ic >#F? > V5] O# O1 W1 1p$4$1
0 2$ M ( ' 0I V ( [ :( > ? 0$ 2 I3 If 1:1I
q .#$
2[ F5 1Y 2?1 C M1I 1# C 1%? 21 O1 >1I519c$ >1 1#: L1
[.
0 q51$: $%: : $ % : 1848 : ' # .Ki5 q
1$1 1 01$
@(> 1S
I(1 1IS 1 f 2101 i15 M1YE O#1 W(1r$1 \ .1YO1
I$0 f
0 t #9 (# q 01 Ih+ $h
S
d ha 1$S01# >1 q:%1
? I I: <#S ( > # < # j > :f0 ' .] > c%
( F Y ? 2 C1$ 1#
1I1 Op 1: O1: 1 #F1 V1# [1 >1

I "" .
(# 1# 1U5 ' >1 ]11(r ##F1' 1# 1 F1 c1% .41r
1
$ > U 2 O1: 1 01 "F1 1$ OM1 $ "
I1" 11$ OM1 15# ."
I01E1
c% :0 $ @ 0F
II O m%i> .50> g$f1# 1 c1%
ZF
I% ##F0$ : " 9S<$5 >? "#$ $ O
I(%
0 .F M
? c 0# O? ?0 [ #r :(# .11 1 qi1 XM119c$ 1#: L
1: C1# K 015 O#(#<F1 15## c1% 1p1 cF1 O1c1% ) 19S<(1#$
> 05: 26
? 05: $
I50 [ 21#%#1 15## 1: 015: q1 F151I
115##S m11 F11 0115: q11? 11: 11# ]1111I 011 0119 211 11I# 11Y\ q(11 0115:011
O ?F$$ WZ1 q K$1 015: q1? 1 F15 O1?
1 1I 1S#Y O#1$19 ]15
0 ]F ##?
. 23]
0 qi( (# 039 O: #c ?
'c# 3 2? V#:> q11$ W1
1
(L@ M " %5#".
$h2 1: O1 K11I9 k1# :<1 1# 1#$?
1
1I1 1: O1 K1
#1U5>:1
?# O## ? .I q5 9 #:? O3 >(%(# 0I >#F0
?O
09(
.0$? O(#19 1 1:c1 1 ? >1 q1S
1'c%1 XM1I 1I 1#rri1
KF90@# ( 0I > [ U $S > O 00$f#.
?> < (# 'j I : O## (
I F I5 K% O #O1: 21 ' i5
F i ? O? .9j #:
?: 2 E C VS$ K MI 4 0" :#3 q5: 5##?
O0
C11 011 ."411f XM1111 11IU011 q11 011 @ O11: 11F11 11#rF11 11 c11
(F 09.
25
' 0$ Y 09 16 < V[ O#< f # 11[ O1? ' V1 O1 0:31
< 0 I :' > (# > K? .>(% 24 >1 O1[1> )1: ((1 1848
>:
" < f O f Y\ 0 > <5 .Ii$ ] O# O ( Y p I#
' $> O'F i95 > $> > I5 # Zf [1 019M1r @ C 1i15 O1
2cL @ >5 O
. 0] qpI< #Y <# p
Y 2? %a.
" 5S11 11 ]1111~ c11Y 11# 11 1849-1848 2311 11511L 11[ O11? ' V11 >11 <511
' M5 q5:(0 I$#(@ O:L # .3' ?f O1 i1 <51 1 V1# q1Yi1
: W?5: O1
I(1 35: 2 X1 >1 q1#Yj1 1 i15 1r 1 q1 '(1$ >1
1 11 C1
?L O?
: ? 2 >#F W%Y %? #?# <F51 1I 1f 1I.WZi1
W%Y(# ? #?# F> 9 Mi5 I I$9 O 9c% >(% OM KF1 C19>1
0 ? m# #S3 [.
(% $: # ' 1906 > V : : 5## .1848 OF 1: 2# ]11#9 1 <1
05 > $ ) : (q##F 0#$ #
1 .1I? O1 XM1<1U5 1 1 1 ? >1 1I5m 1 q19
Zc# $ : 015: %F'01 1 . c1 q11U5 XM1 1IY<1 # IF1S %1W#1%r
Z m#F15 Ii1[1? . 1< q1 q##F1 >1 1I(r5<1 #jF1 1 <1 #01 >1 ]1
Fj 9@ # I# 3 0 #(@ # MS5 L #[.
p# [ # (3 2 #i19 1<$ 05: #F1 .1f q1" #1##1
@ -">5 K%? KFf[ O# 1789 > 1848 C#1 1#% 15## >1S .O#1
11: 184811 K11%11 "11 ">5@11 11#: #F1111(% ? 11"[ "11S K11% 11$11
( E [ S 0:' I5
? #( O : U ? (F f 1
" " 0( O KF? O? #( S O1<1 (#1 .1 j1
(#> L?p# M 0#" :#% #%L $
: O## ### [0 F F1
> g?
.m%> 1L 11 ]1 1(% 01 1 15? 1 %1 019
E> O ."17q #$ > ' ] 0$ ?> O<5 > #$ i1 1: 1S
11:<11 #[ 0119 11 q11:cF11 11:( 011 .1111 ?
11 ( m11% 11 C119 1111$
<0
OcF
( c O I?.I
>
# mN (% ### < 05:fp ( 0 . (## 0 01
#%r 09$ g$0 O:M :01 ?
1 .m1%?
I511 1$S i1
> ###p1$ #1 O1:(# 1 01 . 1: F1# #1 [1: 21 1: 1848OM1
1 >15$ #1 #F11$ 1Y 2?1 .(#1# 1$ OM1 M1
1: O#1#rV1
r > O ###r# .V 1 O: >1
I$9 V1?
101 m1% 19 [1

" (Thiers) "##( > F F < 0 V #F$.
>11 ]11(11# M11 011 X 411(#->119011@> 11: O11 11:< 2?11011 115$ "011
0" 0#F S##S# > $ L V95 #9 [ 1 1# m 1:" :< C1V1
?11 11:( 110$11L 011 O11:11 O#11 0115: X ."]M11 q119 11 11<#5M11I 11#%5 11 >11
#F (% 0< K$M F#S (#> O1" V1i1" " 4#i1 O1 #1i1 21
2 O K$cF" C5 180L O .i ? < : C( 0$1L #1 1'.
)( 16 B ) (1864-1825) ?} "u K" 0: .
T Pk >4uY( 1 O} o W
$ ( ) 1 1K) .1)(0$
17 " :l~ u "1N - 1901 1 Z ) 220..(.
"- 18 1 -"1 1-Z 1
NK - ) 49..(.
26
' O 0cr O <#M ?c >I r M 19 31$ 901@015: O## O1(#1
F 5 O
IY O
U: ?
.m%
MI K(F I C #F[ : : m(# 0 . K% ###0 #M V09( 1
> : >1 V1 ' 1848 K1% #1 #F1 1: K$1(#Y 1 .1 #31[1 1: 419XM1
.#i
27
-4
1$$
[ O#1S c1Y 1#: L 1 O1 21c1 ? qF1# .
1001 1 1
.I1 #F10 1 >1 31 1#(% 1I 1 1I# 1 1:031

#$0> ? >F5fp : L $$ gDLS . 3
#U5'cF % 4D(% 3 : I O1: 1#($ ) 1
>1?
1 (m11% O1: ) 11f >1 111U5 (1>( . 11<1I M1#S5 11IL I@111I
 1( #1
#1U519c$ 1#: L 1I#S 1:L 1I#U5m1
00 . ?N I ? [ # ? ? U5 KF0f > .I#: %#F
211p11 $F11 V11 011 >11# 11c#11L 11:rF11 %F11 0 110r 11 11(%211[ >11
.I311@( $F11 11$L11#-9011@#
IS11p11 (# 11 11%#11 m11# 11(%11$
.##F
(# 59 4:i 5 IMI .# ? 5$ % # 1% (#>1 1
< X m# : .I q#9 ?
01 1(%( 2?1 01$ ' 1$ 1: 1F1 M1
9 VZ L :9c$ > 3 >1(% 1: C1 >1$1#Y 01: 1: O1$ 21M1#
0# (% $( I0$ i5.
O 2 231$ 1? 41r 01 >1
1319 21(9
I101 01 >1 V1#1: >1S . 1871
$ : 039 O: ( #Z3 0 15# W OI1$ >1 p1 #1?(1#
% >11 11#'11 011 F11
11 ?
11 :F11 11011 . 311 11#9 ? 11(#011$ 11
: %% ( 0 >5 : X p O
:
: "39L" .I I 1U5XM1
' qE #F .
[ # m1r 151U >1' 01I1 %F1 11$ >11 31 [1
I#: MI 0I ' 2(9 O###F 5F( O#(# O## $ 2 >
I: ##F?
.
> $ 1 < V31#r[1 [1 i1 1: 184801 >1 1849 "(1#" 1#?fK1
" : 1(% 1$f 1 1#p1 >1 1Sr% 1 >:1 L O1: >#F1 1(% >1 1$?1
0 F 4r( 1f O1: 1# 1 OM1(1? 1[ .O01 0#F11? ]M1 LF1 . 1%
@( # $0$ 9[ S#1 W1r #F # C11% 1 1 @( 1%1
11#5 $11011$ [ 11S# .119' ? O11 11 11(% 11$ ?11 F11' ? 11I5 (311 @(11$#
# ' 0$ : >F %F 2D3 4r ##F (% % r #3Sf[ 1#0
:I5#:53 ?( 0#$ ? O0 m .I O 0 ' ( 3 > O# 2$2$
' ? O V# E ."Y\ O#
M 01 E C% 1" 01: 01 #F1 1#" 1 VI1 1 01( >1 1#f15
0 .[0 X< ? 0 r #9 ?
> >:1? 1[" .#1 0#F11? ]M1 LF1".
# :
? O #( O k# : >F?
1 i1 ?1 1#9 @1#: 1#
%# m# (# .##F
#F > 2(9 2# ? > \ : .Y qF1# I 21# 1315 ?21# O1
9c$ .#: L 3 2 4$ #1(# >1 1# #1 >1 4$1 V1 11#$ 21
31111 O11? ' V11 E115 >11 F11 11#: 11 #11' 011$
F11( 11?
11 ? >11S 11%
28
MI f ? >? 2( O# ? F1D # >1Sr 101:9 21 #(F11 1#r 01:9 1 1
~.
c11Y 11'11 >11 >:5311 #11 F1111% :5311 " 11$ @ 11I#? 11# "11# :5311
# >1 # $ 11 qF1# 1## @ 1S 9 1 >1 :531 q1'1 01 >1S .5 #1
O#c r < O %16.6 0: ?F O#:S39$ > :53 1' (F15 01
N
9 2 O#c 6 r .%22.2 XMf9 ' 0#S > # I#( 1Z< 015: 1M1
0: ? # 0: 4$ ? ' 0 .?> 0 $ f O#:53 #$S #1#?f
0? K< 2 c 3 C 2?(# > ' 0 <: q
1 CDi 1900(C1#
( # 25 I#9 5# 2< q3 C > #$ ' CDi V# 2.5 O: I#9 0p .192
'] > 0: (# 1 #:531[ 1I 1I 1I >#F1 1I01 1: 01$ 1% #:531
.#' ' I 1: 0$M1 1% 1: (119 O#1 . L1 O#1$ 01 >1 19 O#1 @( V1##F1
> 2Y0 O1 1U 21U: 21 1#: 1Sr #1# @ C 1@ >15>1 019 1#Z XM1$21
#($ O: >#F9c$ 319L 1 01 019 1I 1#Z1##Z O1
1( .11 19 L1 >1'1
0 $
r 9 O L > #' 0 M V($(# #E# 1# 1:
0 ? E# : >1 #F >1
1$01 1I 2(F1 ]1 1
1U: C#%F1 1 V1(#>1 1
' 0.
# >1 >?F1 V1 O1: 1#Yf(# 1 1#?f01: 1 1 ( 19c:1 19 O#1 (#1
( I O ##F F O# % > I OY# .:
" O#(5 ( 5 >S .I5#0 % 5: 0 11Yf 2?11 K15 ' 1
F C % @ L # > Yf O Y\ 35: 5 XM5$ >S .0 f -?-
q (% > 5# # # q(# .' Y\ 0 0< V#? [ 1<1
> ?
5# .( (# F O > #i5 [ Y\ 0 q V# .# ' V1# ]1 M1
F #f CS M (0 0 > 3 >(%0 M5 k0 0#$( qF# > S '< VY #F
L M 3".
# I(F O:
$ # 0 : 0# #:
" O V >: K<$ ? (# #> > 5(F 5 0 1($ 1M1 O1: 2(F1
> VFS< (% $0 > # % . #> f[ 1 O#1 1Sr(01 ?(1# >1

$> (0 E g95 VIS ~ M ($ % 39L % .">#F
%F :cD9 >?F
" # M g95IS ~ 3 53Y X ($ ' OM V <?" 1
< "0$ "V## .20"S
5> O##F 9 XMY 2? %f f0(F
I 2#19c$ 2F1 1#: L
%(5F O V3 < 0r .C O>F 0 0 #F >F1 1 1I#'j1
"#F -
I@ - : -r".
?M ($ >?F F : # gSr539 O% > ? : I5 0#$3>#F
#9 #f # # .9j M
" 0 3 O 3 2 #?: : $E m @1+
h
h
h h: :h?1(#1
MI .#:53 K(F? KF(# #:53 Z ## #MI K(F i 3 #1
O #?
m% 2 .<> Fh?+1$ $h$ $%h C#%F1 1cS1 01
0:F I# ?$#%F '
I5 ($ #9".
' :0 5L "LF" >
F?
X0#" 2(9
*****
19
20
.>" : )( 1" -1906 ) 99..(. - " : ( )" ) 1$) 1 )
)N 1906E 4) 5 ..(.
29
5 : OS 0( .>#F (9 >1 1 15 >1$ 21 >1 531 >1 C11 O#1$
: : MYE5I 5 ( 9c$( O# . Ci0 S - 5I -[ %i 5$1V1
I#%r.
090 < C# i[ $ j5 0 5>
.
> 0 I #:1 >1 >1
I<D<5 # ]M 2 (# > > K$0 > >F#D XM[ #[ C0 V
XM(# c ?
.
0119 O11%11 5F11S %#11 (# 11 O11 ##F11@11 [11 ( ?11 11 %#11 11#
: ]M 55 (# >1 11 Ic1? O1
1 V15: 1r' 01$ #F1 1' 01$ <1
p O# O V: I0 .F
09 O% 5FS # #: Lp #< (5 39 > O1: ]M O#Z
(# Ic?
%i m%5 K(F I$ V m# 0 .:53 ($
# #F11011 11$ :
hh 1
' hhE11 211 11 O11f11 11 2i1195 K:311>11
% I K# .5#$
>S I [ : O q (Les sans culotes) O#0$ 2Y@ [1 ( 1>1
II r > #f%# O#E
1? O1 XM101< 1 1: 1 01\ q11
: M Xc VM
O I 0$ :F qS0%0F I [ ( . 1[ (F15
> 0 O$> III i 0 C9%#1 1 (# 1 1# 1
: 29 .0 21$(# 1 ' 101Z XM1%#F1 <1 " 1: "1 g1$ 21E 1f1#:
.O##$9 ?L 1% M1 jF1 : 21 q1S?0 1(# 1 1<#0%10F1 I [1
(
O V 2 ( > IU #r #$ # L3 Y
XM0F 2DF% 5#: 2DF 5? :#?# 2(1% O1 21$11#9 21 f >: ?1#: 1
0 j % [ #9 > 2#<$ M ?
5#: U5 %F1 1: ##F1 1I 21#V1 >1
[ ( : 2$ ?# O
I 2if <X
5#: 2 < K# S5 5FS %> ?
1I#" >#F111 ">$9 1 1#: >15 O1: 1:
1871 O: :" :
Ic?
f
I 0r 5"
30
-51$ : $<>
IR
> 3 [1
1 215 %F1 101 1(% q1($ >101 1# >1i15 ?1
Y : 0 (#0F5 . O#D19 :F M1 ' >15$319 [ O#1[11S O# 1# 1#: L
(# O:' > ?
. XMS ?
? O M .KN ( q1$(#1# 1
N #9 :0 I ( #Z3 (1 >1 O01 [ O#1ScS1 O#1
I? .
1' ?1
0 jF > : < <
$ <>
1?tW .$ ",<

11 [ >1111% 011@> O11 >11 K$11? 11 ( 11#: 11#>11 1111 [O11: O#1
(# > ? @ -#
IS3 > O#5#?F \ Y.
11#( 11 #11(# 211? 11# I M11 M 11I$#Y011 11# 11I 11 .11# 11
(# >I[ 1 .'1? 1# O1[
I1$#(@ K(F1 O#1S 1#: L #%1
I:1###F1
#cS K(F O#
I:5 >: L
I$ >% 0
I#D #( #Z31 >101 i1
K(F I#c I$ >%0 I 0# - ##F # XMS #: L[c 01 1# W19
( # ' #' > S #.
? >S 2#r? @ # 0 [ O: O#(# >? IS qI MIM1 .
N g90@-O##' O##:' > ? < 2$ 21[ 2#?1 XM1? 11 c#F1?1
[ #Y 1[ 1 .' 1 (# >1 1? O1 1?1 #:1 21 1F1 V1
( 05: W #D0? XM $0 $d
$E:1$ $ hvR+h . 1?L @( 1$#F1
? " XM1I 1(# 1cS "O#1 " 1(# 1cS O#1L "#F15<# " 1?1
41 11(% C11 11$( 11#Z31" ? 11( O11jF11 % 11: %#F11# O1 :11? 11 11IO11
: IcY(0 05$?
O:? #: ]M >5$ K< V ? %#F (%.$
"j @ ">5 ?
i O?
(9$# (9$#0
2 .[ O] (9$#V1# #9
: WZ11Y O1 (Les sans culotes) O#01$ 01 "j1" 1 101 1# 1 M15
O@11 $11? 011 >11
11 .11(9$#?M11 115#( 11 "j11" [ 211 $hh O@11 V11?11 O1111(9$#
<# O#0 W?( #M M M V#: m%
" "C5F :
Y ?0 .(9$#
05:?
O:? #: >15$? 1[ 1I#: %#F1 1 1(% 1$1 #9 .1I? >1~1
(# ? ' I C#%F' 0:9 C [M<5 . [ 1:%9 (1# O1<1 #? 1>1
r 4 01$ W1 #1#
U5 1$#@ 41[1 -# 101 1: - 1? .
1
11# ]1

#U5[0:F O# 0 .0Z %F #$ C0 $< > #L< X1[1 . @(1$#
9c: 5 #: L #r> > K$ m#[ ( : 2(# O1 K:31 m1r
? KF #$?0 I5 S i010: 01D >1 1f O1 1 1: 11 1 .219f
j :9c$ O#(# cS.O#
>1111 1793-1789 1848 q11 %F11' O11?
11 m11% 115$ 11 O11 110$( 11
q11 XM11 11(% >11 >1111 cS) O#11 +@ hh >11 11I#
11M11 11 11 \ 211(9 (11Y
F11
90@ #[ ?
2(9 .VcL #i 0cS 211 >115 ##F1
11 >11 ?11" 11I 011" >1111% [11 11 (11 < 1111f "11U5" 11Y [11 11#$
3# #$ E2.$1
[11
11 #11 119N F11 11 O11111 11U5 110-( 11 ?N V11 111 2112
90@ 11#f 11# O11 >11011 V11 F11 @M11 .11 C11#< <11I "115" I011( >11311-
(#9@# [ ">" " "O# 1M1 K 11 1 'j1 O1 21(1 01#9 1:1#f
#3111 WF111 3111cS 111#[ 3111 111cS O#111 "hhh 111(%111 #3111[111 111I #3111
(#.
31
1$ : $<> @ m$
. hIR $ERh h@1+h h .>E?
1(# >15$ ' 1F1
90@ #?
M> CK: 2 i: : KD m(% F# M K< t#> >U5
K$11 F1111Z i11 KD? #F115pL 211 KF11 11# i11'11: ? 21111#Z [) 11c#11L 11:
f( > 0 IcS > 9c$ p :.#:(# 1 < O1 21$ XM11##Z 1%'c1% 1
O 0p L I0 > 2p.>:
> ?# XMI 3 OcS > O# f O ($3[ U :U ?
1
(# )90@ # C# > (#$f [ cS O#S > 3 O##F : UU ?
# ?F$ M c O O#<0 ?

I .VM >5$ Fj f[ 1##0$51 >1
# (# 0$ : 0#EcS O O#? #$ 9@> ?
(#.
? O O # 2 pcS (# ?I M 2? .2#F< 11#r
21
0 gM ' . < #r( O# cS Op : O# O:# 0 >#@".
11~ #11 1111~ ( 11#$ 011 .1150 411 i11911% >11 >:5311011 f 11# p11
9c$ > #:%9L .4 k# (@ mr
4 C#%F : 1: M1YE 1I 1I1Z 2?1 1#:%9L
50 > qp : > > 9 qY 1: I%1 q%F1 41 q1[1
:0 9c: : ? # .V# 05:0 q% ' C9($ # 4 1 319L
C9cS > (: #fp E .# q# XMfp > #:%9L #F( # O1 q$
4[$( c 0# ' .# r 0 ( [0> cS 1 O# O# 1 >1%1
i KDf U ?F$< #F I F V5 2$ O# %1 1I5I0 I1 F1 %1 1#
> ?5 <.t#
( <( : C1# O: >r 1I$9[( 1# .11 1r%#1 O1: i1I
: ##FcS .O#> CMI O: 5 %F (# 01< OcS1 01 O1'1 1U5
0@ # .#$0( O 2? 49 2$cS1 S51 ]10 O1 1 >:1 >1
I$01
: c U5 ?
( .? 5# O 2p 1: %#F11 cS19 01 O#1X
0r cS O#
I#i >rp m% > \ 0$ Y F f 15# 1f (F15 ]M1p1
( O K% (# 09 2 0:F cS : O# #5
I#: : CF [> >
.4 X59 i1? O1 15S9 1 "? 11$ cS qF1# ."O#1 EF1 15 1M1
? O1 21$ >#F119 ( #D01 " X01 ' ."X01 15 @F1( 1($ O1? ' V1 21[ m1#M1
$ : . 2 : 2? # 29f(.
>11 C119 O11 11SM11 115 11S 11 ? 1 011fp11 ( 11 11 11S5 C11 O#11
cS O#11 11 ?11 cS11 0119E11
I311 O11: 11($ cF11 119 #11# 11 p 11# 115 115 11IU
c'.O#
21 W N "u " " O 1-Z)) "Wo(( ( } Z P "- 4 ,4 .
"u " " W )D- ;V)4 1b$ ,- 1) ? V Y )DK )j - ,n }
b ,
-N , , Y Z) - j )4 1bDu .-

)
1 -P )N" "u " )" ( o K"( P
) $( O
" OPQ- :
; N ) 1 1- a- ) P N , 1Nu -K " nu " Bv 1Z V4
N;
N . V- O ( 0" - ):y Z "1 j ( 1-)> P) " Z
"1 ? E4-1 , , 1- ,o
1)> :1 ;Z 1K .)D
" 1 1-Z "Wo 1Y$ , Y 1Y$ ,)F _ )
B ,- 4 N ( , ,jF .1 () K
_
1 OP 1-Z "_" ) )4 ,b .(,- W } Z V _ 1-Z)4-1b
.1-$u
1 j , Z. - VK YU
0E - - $j , ) .0.
.(.
32
$n -6 > 1$$

' C#%F11(# 11 11: >F11?
11' : 11: 11 11S: #($11 11 11:11 .>5@11
(# > ?
IS[ 2[ IS 0D@ >5$ >1 V1i15 01
?
m%( .#:%9L Ic?
01( 01I: 010 01I: C1[1 #F1 1# <L?1I5
M11I 0311 O11 C#%F11 11: 11U 11I 11($ O11: >:11 .11f?#11 11 XM11r 11411#U5
c(% 0I$( 0D@ ? I] L M 01#E 1U1E 1f V1:p 1
1 21 5(#1#
O: g$#F > #.K$
11#: K1 411#U5 >#F11 XM1111:
#11U5119c$ >110 11< 11: C11 11@ .11#11
%i? #$ qE #Zi K%( 2Y0
> C#9c$ f0
? I I> % O< t#1 O1L C1# OM1 q1r%01
I01 K$1 F1
] 0 ?F$> q[ # O < .X0
D< K
] > f f O1 1[1 21(9
5FY U r O## jF
I$ O#< X
I#(Y
#U5 ##@ : .#5 ' #i015: >I5
M .0 90@ # #$ V # i #ip #: #i9(.%
> 0 :0# 2 1 1 1# m1$(# 1 1 >1 01p1 h21aTh <>h
. @1+ 1 K11 ]1
31S5 D1[ 1 >1 q1 01(# 1 1 M1r# 1f 21cSO#1
>(%? ## c
9S O# g95@f > ?
# qi@ #$ O: r
# I9@.#(@ # (3 : #
C11 11# 011#( -11S 11 11#F11 $( 11# 0115: 11cS O#11[O#11S
0:F (# :c ?
Oi ' O: K#Zf1 1# XM1#F1 1 #1X
11 >11# >11: 11: 211 11 11?$ 11 11 O11 11#E0I%i (@
I .1 1#( 01jcS (1 O#12Y01
.0:3? O M#S5 9 > (# p >9c# #: 0#E( #cS I O O#$ >19cO1 1
I O
Ii$Y.
11 < 011(# 1111(< IF11S 11: 211311 >11(% 1111 11: ]M11 >i11 011 311
C1# O#1 ]1cS O1
1 O#11 01 3131 XM1 O11% m#1M15 .#(F1
11Uf Ic11' 11? K11
11 211(# 11 11: 011$i1195 11 O#11 11 11ID#5 O#11
(# p #:( 01: m1r 15#( .1#S <1 O#1cS O#1 K:311 (# 11
0:9 IN ##F 0: p >1(%?#1 1 1(:1 1Y 31 >1(%(1 >11
cS O#M ?( O# .V#: 0$ 0 #DcS O#( 0# II0$.>D
F > 0 cS O#?
I ##F
9S$ > 1:% O1? '
I51 1#$
' j :% O[ O#S :( #Z3 > 0.
?M ? # q(# q9 (3f O q1019 I .q1:p:p M1 01
2 > 0
O#F11 #F11 O##11f(# 1111 O#11 11# 011$ O#11 1111 11S (# 1111
]S A%W .
0 11#DcS O#11@(
I11$#( 11#Z311 11U
I 11#S #i11p11$ O11:
I'(11 '11

$ O###Fr > mr > K:3 V
#:0 #F[ > I<I5(# .
33
I0@-O##' O##: > rY ? ' #cD#9cY I Lc
[ 110@ 11#i115 O11 211M11 11$ @ 11ID%: '11: 11:(# 11 11U5 011$
11M11#S5
( 11190111@> 111r 1110@-111# O111: 111#: L3111 M111 0#111 V >111r m111%p111
' M11I 011I 11? 4F115
( 11 2115 >11 11S11 $ ]M11 11S 11( 11 #F11(11# 119
? O #$f # .I M F # < "#D0(" V @ : #iM < 0#$311
O 2 ?f O9 V # >$9( V O % [ #:0 %.
MI :K(F
N
#F< 5 0 39f 0f V' ( r #D0cY #: >1
? I#?
> 0( f . < ( > ?
M O 1 01f C1# 1K1%
>1111$ C11? 11#S 2D11 11L11 . XM11 K11%i11 >11 [11 L11 # >1111S 11
(#.
? O11 11 2115 %F11 011 11? 11 11 ( 11#11
#F11 #< 115 11 11 011f11
0 0S 39f : X5$ 2 0#$3( >D0 : 0#$ 2$(E O? c . Of1
O<F? (# O IFS XM0 K% MYE5 #i> : > 2:1# . M1 ' K1%
g9115 1111$ 11 C11 119c$ M11 #11 011 11I >11 11 011f 11M11 V11 211$11
90@-# .#: L? O 23 5 m#M1 c1Y K1% [11 >1 O1$@ 411#(%
S#5$ ' ] > 03# O## V U50 09 Mr? 2@ $ c 3.C
0<# ' O$ >
IFS . : K? 2$S q?
qZ I? O >I I# F 0 E 23 M f 0 0 :1 >1 21:1# <1 1$ 21#?5 OM1
.
q? %# q (# N ##F 19 M1#S5 [1> :1 >1 21:1# j1 1
? (F5 .Sr 0 D $F :L :(# : # 1 1 21$S(# 1#>1
' $F K$ " W##" M V1($90@ 1#( 1? (F15 11? O1 XM1I c1
3( C(% C p : > 2$# .5 @ m 0# V?F? #$ 31 31C
Z
#U5 : I# 2$ >.
@( O? $ : MI ?S5 :2 ? #$( #< 09 I0 901 1
: [ 2$> : > # N 0 9 M 1 L O1? ' 1V1 1 1I#: K1Z
( 119011@> ( 11: >115'11S ? 11#S 11 11$9011@-O##' O##:11 #F11
(F115 c
cM11I 11 11:< (F115 W11 21111
?11?11? O11 V115 1
11I 11(# .11 1
(# 2(F1 (F5[1 01$( . 2#F1901@#-' #:11$ C1 1 11 1 V1#:
% :c ?
. I O: I #Y I U5 1[
U: 1 O1 c1
?
> f .p 2if (% $' ?
: % 1 $F1# V1# VS$1O1
.2#F
CF11 ' .11Y\ c[11 M11YE5(# 11' ( 115 11 #i119 211 11(f 11% O11 V11( >I011 [>11
$ > ? $#%F O K% : L$ O: O#@$ C % < 2$[ ( .
? O MY ? : IFS 0:F O: O#@$ # 2$MI
I 03 00? 2 XM10:F1
N M >5$ 25 :F %F ? >$ 2 K(# .?M1 #1 01$ OM1 >1 1
$
IcZ : t# O >@#$0<# 0
IFS 9 $d ? 1: O#1 21
1$
$ > \ .0
05: MYE? : :0:F I O: O#@$N 2$ I > 0I$ q9F VFS0 N .O# i >

2$S] 0( qSF Of.
( c O## <E @ $ c 3 .C O( >I0 $#%F 2$
2($ 49L [ V$#%F$M ]15 1 01#1 V1? 1 1: 1#$@1$
$' 3 3 C 2Y0 ?(@ I5 # L #: ?.#
34
E51' < K1 1SE1 1 O1f1 1: V1

? 11(#311 011$ 1111? I S 11 11IS( O#11<5 11I$#Z311 [F11# . m11%
0# ? >
U5L $> N1 " "1#$ <1
#1U5L1 21(9 O10( 11.
? O XM m%> m% L.#
11 C11# j F11 ' 11 011 ]11011 O11? ' V11@-O##' O##:11 11 >11? 1111
' `
h+ M1 (.1
' $%
O: 0f O0:( > q9 E1 VFS
$ S O0I$
[ 2M 0I$p ' ? O .V# < [> (# > ?
# '
1I
' 9 ? O #90I 0S O# 2 0f 0 319f V1 bhd ]bh]hS
A : .TR% 0M X05: 490 (# > M1 L< 1: 419 X1 O#1 19c$1 1: #1
p (# f.#
MI # K(F ]5 O: k0 5$?$, 2 O? ? (# >1 1[1 ( 1
O11: 11# 11
d) hha O11: 11(# 11cS .(O#11 11(% ' 1 $ C#%F11
C % S90@> ?0 I' q%r0 < I0@> . 1 XM1>1I 1%5
$ $ 0@-# #: L#I M5(0.
(# < : IDc#?
c 21S V1 1 .1I51? k1# 01 >1 I1M1
cS %F I#:0 ] >
#U51Y 2?1 41? c1 I 1Y 11I 1#
< .#$#? O < C# m% #0# f O C9M < 01p1 1
21 KF1 V1# VF1S
'S MI F C90 (# .i
05:( ? [ F > 3L # XM?S > O#1 W #S31?
1 m1% O#1
[ L # 1 K1
91S31: 1#: L1 1:%9 010 1# O1(# 11 U '[ .W #D5 O1 #1 1# 11 <21$
[ D? O E " m@ > O? q9" \ XY \.XY
[ 5$ M > XM0@ #<
IFS 9 0[ O1 1I"K1?" 1U
XMI .S 5j(c 1( 1# >1 m(F11 ( 1# ' 1Ic1 2?1 >1 #131 01
[ (#0<5 .
r @ Y .0
I : #
IS9 1 ?01( 1 1: O1
1I
E V CD9 : "?L" >r : " "#$9 ##F11#Y 1#Y 1: 1
" "#F .I
'
? : O m] ( >F1#5#S% 1# 19" :%#1 0I1F 0191
L< 0r 2#"V.
'j 0@ O##? ' O##( ? ? 1 >1 1#$ KF1 #11?5
1I ?1 1#9
> # > ( #r( .i
I" : 1[ (F1
1 ."01$ 121
M # qF# #i9 C(% #i : 00# S3 [1 L1 #? O1 O1i1 L1 1
$9 I #r.##
35
-70 F@< @1
09 #F q1'1 # 1#
1: 1 M1 " g1$ C15
1 O1 "O##F1 21 #F11
M @ K.
: 0 ?$ > : X(< '1 #$" 1#1 (F1i1 <C1
( 2 " % M jF" : 2 (F 1 #:1 >1?1
O% >5M 4$i C? KFS 'Z )05( 2$L O EF >: L( f [ 2M F O #5( W(@1
%#F # L1 ?( 1# V(11 1:<)C1#( 1 319L 15Z 21I .M1 1% 11 (F1
M # #FS5p # [ 2 >:0 >(% (# F M m0 O#1 #
( # K$F" .%F ? " :cD9 5
$ #$ 2$ 2[ # p S #F#I
> "\(>" 0$ #$ #:Y > F C] N < Fj F ' 0] V
> m: 0 V0S
F( V#?#Z% F S 9c$ $ .# XM C> <
W1
WF # >5F1 1: 1#$S #1 h: Nh $hE@ h
h+ $%h
h@ C $hEY
> 9 F W.C
" 0115: W11(11 O< 11<11#$ L 11#S O11: 11 11I K11$ #9 >11 1111# 3119L (311
0 5 OU 00 W C#%F E O 0 U i 09".
C5 5 ? 5Sj 5F $ V > > ? ( %(rM
03 V# C F m# (FL .#<0 5 > U :M W(r
? O1 O1 21
? O 2.#i
O$ ?
5 0$ 23 ] F1 O11% >15M1 4$i1 C1? KF11S 'Z1
]05[ 2$L1 >1 EF1 >:1 L
( f.
O V K$3 ? V1#5$ 1 41M1 01( .C1% ?1 01 1 >1 0 1f 1 1#5

[0% O 0$0: :53 9@ O # 2$( > 0 [ # #:% O XM
1'
011$ %#F1111 C?(11 +hh $ V1hh 11: hh11 ]hh 3119L
hh<: $hh$. ]hh$hh hh?1(hh
.$hh < C
hh V1hh$ ."hh >:01 ?11 11 O 11@11 (F11 c11 #" 119 11011:
".
115 311 ?#11 411# C11119c$ #11 11($ >11 ?11 '1111 # 0115: II
0119 .I "%#F11 V(1111 11 C?(11# 11 C11# 11: 3119L" 211 >11 >115$ #11 11
<5 Z3 % > p : :53 11# O# 1 1 1 X1E K$11
# # . %#F #5 : # XM C?( j O1 2# 19@ 2#Z121$
( 1 1 011$1 01 11#(ZF1 ?11 O1 (
I511 %90 215 01 211: t#1 1>11 t#1$ >@1#
F O : #$F 001: O1 %90 159 0 . ?F1 ? ' O1>1 O1 15$5 ?1 21#r5 O#1#%5
$1 1#: V11# 31L1 11\ 1: 11I 1#?#01 ? 1#$ 11I #:51101 119 >1S 01 011
> .
$ XM U5? $c> :0 I#(F# " ->1 .">?F
I 2$
" 2L " ">: L( f" %#1 %#F1 21 KF 1 .i1 21[ >1XM1
[ 2 XMU '
U O >$#(% CIE C
< if $ E f5[ $ D1? OM
" : t#$ "qF SF $ > F O .#$?M O 2% ? E1 V
11
" V1111 - .">?F11 C#%F11L11 # 11: 11IUF1111r# . O11 K$11F11 O11#$
3 c < :? .O#' @([ $ ?0 (#.
36
11($ ?11 11'0'3119 [ 11: 11# i11(11# 011 L11 #? >11 O11? 11#+hh L11
$> > .VY 2$ p $" > #(>" > F : qF# F F1 O1 9 1
> \L .Y '> 05: W 5? (3? $# :@
h+ $%h 015:?1
> C@$.
XM11< 11 11I? 11 .K11: 11: 11 $11# ' C#%F11 11 11% f #11 >:5311 M11
%
C%f (0#$ f 09 V01 h2. hIh .' >1 ]1 1% 319L m1r1 1
V#:$ ? O M $ 5( O1: k11$ >1( 1: >15 21$ E1N1 21
15 C53111 O1M11 1$ .>11 C111% 1#5p 011 211[ 1#M1 11$ .i1? 1 O11>11
11% >11? O1111% O11 #11 C11<11#$ $ 110" >11 11# K11">:5311 11 11: (>115
?1 \ V1 <11#$ $1 1# 1@ O1 O?11 <11#$ " #:5311" 11 ?>11 1I
110 K1111% >:5311 O11( >I011 V11
1 11: 11( O11 ]11<11#$ $ 11#' 011 11 11:
3 C# C #
0$ g#Sr] : >1 21$1# 1 k1# C1#< 21$01$ <
1
L 41r >1<'1 ? >11S f1 XM1I . 1%?1 019 01
1$1U5 #1f L1>.
i 5 i ' V [ % ?0 (#.
m(F[ I k @ C 1 :>F1S 1" 1 231 >:1 015: >1(%(# 1 1F1
M mr0 #( O# # K$F" . "0 > "#M < >5$' ] Oi
L> >: r m# ?1 1($ 1 >F1S5c m(F11 # 11#("
#1U5
K$F" > S1 p1 '1> -901@> O1 . 1 ?1 E1
F1 #1
I$0 O#<5Z3 S (# I$0$ S t# 2$' >@# 01Im1%
' -#90@5 # 1$t c20 (%90) @$< >
I$0 .#
M11 2#F11 11
11: >11 V11# #11( 011 11 11#Z@ 2#F11 11 $11# >1111% i11
.#? O O 5? V# >$#(% "( # K$F" 0 mF1 1#:
g$( O## Z $
#U539L m I> ?.
?11( O1 15jF11 .>1 ?11 1($ VF11SM1# 11 1# . 1111" V11: 01$
(Fc #f" > "#(1# ">:#1 1(:1 ( cY01 18481 1[1 '1' 1$(@ .#
U 1: O#1 0$
IS >? K9 1 1 f 1%r
1$ 1 >1 .1D9?O1
4#? K %YTE
c C?(#
C# : 0$ %#F '319 $1#
L
#F #9 : 0$ C?( ( # K$1F1
1 01$ 011 1?f @ >11I
"(11# ">:#11 ' 115c 11 XM11f#11 >11 11 1159M1111 c
1111 11 11: 184811# 11I
(0 @ $ : 1848 9 V5# M I O# #F O##O1 O#31$
! E%r
?M O
V m# ? ' E >5 Of N 2I V [
(# O (Fc #f .# ? 1 ($ 1 \ O1: 01: ' E1 O1 V1
> O##F5 c> p O i 0F M %Yf > ?( > I(0 > .#
' O 0 : 2? # < ? #3 m$ #$# V3r 5 m(F
.X0
15 91011$ O## 21M11 01 ( W#F1011
D 1p11 L1 1 K$11 1 K111:
011
>%M V($<1#$ $ 1#L 21#(9 1#1 (# .1 C1# OM1 O#@1 1: O#(F10#$1
5'39 > I$ O #[? K$ ( k
V (0 5 M #Yf .2#F
? 55 " $@1($ OY\ "O#(F O# 0 1: O1:[ 11 ' . >1 ]1 p1L1 1%
#5 05: >:<1 # >11 (F1c #1f1 1# .# XM11#$ <1 \ >1 01
? 0 I5p Y ? O m#$01 1I51Yf >1 q19 V1< 21? .1I5 h01 O1XM1
#$ K%> > F 9% #$ 5#$Y F1 : 1# .1 1% ?1I5 21? 21
$ C% ?#$ 2 Yf.
' ] > % ( #5 X0[> 05: >\ K#p5 0 r >
#(%1I 1
>09 05:LF :? 2 cI #p .
1? O119c$ 1#(%i15 E1> O1 01 c1: 1I5
37
U5 >? g$ 5 > m S 05: #5 O [ K1# >101
O@ U5 > j IM >Z #.
pL M 19 O1: 5 O#i1 < O1 V11 V1 11 C1#?F1 . 5#5[1M1
5 m S # I$ 1I5
1 C015[1 c1Y 1#:1L 1#
'< X
O# 5#$ 9c:
'0 [ 0 2(9 @ O 1 ?1 #1 1f t#1 1>@1#
> t#$?5 > (<F V.
O1 >:1 01 c1 ]M1 L %i1 2?1 15 2i1S ]1< 1i15 >1# 2i1S<1I
>:M ( VMfp ' .# [ 5#5 XM 55? #$ c 5#r > mM 5 1#(
i15
K$ 5 U5 I5# C< ##F Oi101 01I . XM1I 5F1 1#$ 1 p01
# j ] : I#: O?f m#' # #" % 0 "# > #:1 q19
O O$ [> .O$
' %5 I? > O #$ >1 2?11 (F1c 1#r1 ' #1% p1$ 2?1
00 I5Yf 05:( % 5#$0 X 00: 01#$ 21( O1: 01$01 XM1I # F1
#$ #Z #: O 0 I(# 0$ : %[ V#F .#: L
0(5 O #$ SM : .>: XM ' #$< MYE 1$ >1f1# O1? k1#
< p(# ? O#Fr C5%3 2 D : DFY < MYE > #F < C>1
: @(> ' .49 05: >:(#1 1 31 >1(%1$ @ V1#: >Si1
[ 0 K<F : X 2(9 O 2$(% %#F . 23i (# 01 1( 11
'S 2(90 O 2@ O %# C?( C# : .:53
L ] 3 @( $ >: 1: 01$ >#Fp 0101: (# 1 ?1
(# S ? 0: (# (# k#? O1 I5 1: K1Z 1[1 ( 1i1.
' M ' E >5$ Of #(" : K< V K$F" ? > (% $ ?1
" #(ZF" O$ O' O## .O#: O $(@ K< V ? t#1(# 1[1
>:9 t# O i [ K1< ]M1 ?1 1S %11 1#(O1 1#
>11 K$1111U5 F11 C11 ? 11(# 11 I#F11 ?F11$ 11[11 ' S5
i115 11?F11$ 11
0: .ID : K #F(# $(@ >$] O#$ XMYE'(:.
2M S 5# : :53p :%# : 50.4
*****
25 S c (F # m I#: (Fp 0 (F0#$.
qF11# -1'11 EF11 #F11 C11 KF11 11 EF11 >1111 ( 11.]M11 '11 # L11
$> > 1% 1( 015: W1 15? C11% 19 L1 F1 V1# 151 C?(1 [ 1 115
11 C#Z311 0115$ . 11 11S11 C?(11# 11: 11S11 C#Z311 p 0115: 011 1111#5
4:iS 0D'39 '> (3F [> K$ V[ :S <# C1F1
( : >5L (.
0 m(Ff c11 # M15 M15 21@ O1
#F1 21$ >:1 L 1
#F1
2L1 >1 >11? C531 1S01Z . 1C
> 2$1U 1S . 019 q$F1 M15 V1$9 1
?( [ [ 0D fM >5$ 2 XM C Fj 1 # O1 01p1 <.C1
O 2 C# :530# 1 C1#< 1: 1#? 1531 11 O1 0p#11#9
ID@1
0 > O# S ?1$ 1: 1# 1$% 1 31 C 101 1$ 1$ OM1
I# f C# 2DL ?(# 0 C#?F 1 F1 C1 K$11 ' ]1
0 ? F M VZL ?( #? ]M F .K$
( ?
? '# " O: #" K1D5L?p1# 22M1 019 (1 1: 1696 j1 21(9
" " 0 9 N >i1 :1 1#$ $ 1#p1 1 C1#< IF1S .2F1 2?1 V1 >i1M1
0- 22 ,) (
i
) . " 1ib)" .4 4 ) - "- W 1 1Y$
) ))0$
u (.
38
L E
i XM$# L 0: # O#D O#c D O .r C#%F 5 O< 0#F
" #" qF# >I $F V# >1
I 1f 1 '319 < >:1 1 1U 11: W1 V1#
<: D O#D c D DFY r ($ O $ I U5L # >
I .: C F
0 >111 111111 111: C111" 111111 "V111# V$N 111$111 111#$ -111#cI111 #:0111
"'S "#F
i0 0: I5 O# O#Sc \' .r
? O F V1#1% 190 p1#
0 2 V% S > ] 1#$< O#1 319 O1 1#[? C1 ]1 >1.21#9 M15 1
:
O O? I O f 1#$ " 1 1#" "'S "#F1 1I
1 >1 1: V1#1 01 >1
9 ? > @( I$# : 39L >
I1S .' ? @ O1 1 XM1:1
> " "I#' > 0" I 0 "$#(% q5< : > #:#? O:? I#
? > O: >D Sr I #F O: % 39L.
0 %
#F O >: L IL M : 0$ I O1Y 1<1 O1 21$< C1
0 > 5M #I$ #> C#%F 2ZF 0DL < : >:% .C L ]
N ( 39 ## : KL L> %r0 2? S#5$ S.
0" 3 "?#5L> 1f> M1 ' ( 15 1I 1U5 #F1 C15319L EO1 1#
m#(%'39 '> O% > # I [ .: O
? O#r % p# ?#5 .m
0 q? X01 1: ]1 >1 1 #1'319 15( .<< 1: V1 1 1: O#1#:O#105I
$ O? O:L .
I#: M ' O 4$i<< V < K I5 C#5 > VS
' ( .V : Y 0 2 ?#5 2Y 2$ 5[ 4:i[ 1 1 1 21$ 1
11 11 431111 V11#: 11
#11U53119c #311 '11> 2#Z1111 11#5 >1111 q11 >11
435 0$ O #Yf .: C
C] ' < K OU ?#5 O I 01DL1 #'319 . 1S 1#>1 21$
C?( I O
#U5L 1I O1Y 1 1I5: q31f1 '319 >1I 1
[ i :59 ' O # 0M $ V# ?#5 F V' .# 0r> I09?>1 O
O: (: V XMS 0D %9 (.#
115 m11511 11 11 11r 11 115%i11 119%LF11 11 11#5 C115 O11 011p
' #[E1 1[ 1 1#5 m(F1? m1# 1#L1 <1 >:1 1D M15 E1> 51
' > # q9 R $%@ : # % 0#$3@ KF >5 1: 0#$31 >1$1
0#$.i
< S 0D O?
#5 X0 m# #' 0 .#< q 0DL ?( : # 2?1>1
: #? 2> cY O#[ : O .1: C
11 M1S51# C 1 .V1# f 1
' #:j 0$F M#S5
? 09 O 0 .0$
-2 2115 O1111 (F11 C 11%L > 11 >115 1111 c (F1111 # C 11%
C -$$dC
.? O1 >1 1$M1 i1 < V19p 1$ g915 >1(%1r
<F15 C1< 1
>:? 2 VU'39 ? q F ?#5 #' ] 15 O1 L1 .#?M1E 01#1
?#5] '> (M U5 9 .V I U5?L 0$
XM >1 I#(% q19 1'
O11011 211: 21111: 11 11 . O11 115 11S 11( O11 O#?11 11%Y 11Ec11
39L NY # [0$ Y 00 ? O 00 2?
#U5 2$ 010 1U
91
' ? O(# 0DS < > # .I5: 5 M # # > 50 <$39 < .V1? C
i 3 31 1 .15 31 1 31 #1 01 .1Y 1# 1(%01 ' >F1 11#
(%Yf KF >F < XE CM .i i m#L # 1 O#1 01
1(% $ >11 11< C119 >11 11I
11? 311 1I 11#: >11 >:1 m11#L11#
? : O K k# C#%F : KZ 3 m XML.#
0 0r #f> I09' # #$> 1I 1: qS1 0#$311U5 (#1
>11 XM1111 11#: L q115# XM11 11(% >11 2?11 115 C11 >11 11 ' #11<cY 011 I11' >11
39
'11# C11(# 1111$ I$011 11L11 #c 011 ' V1111 O11 # >11 (311011 (011#$
# 0 (%.$
O11 2IF11 ( O#1111%r <(11 1111 %Y >11 11j 0115: ?#115 011 V11" q11([ 11 11
2DL 00 ' (( j1 2 KF $ 11 g#1Sr 21$1 O1 21$< i1
E 0 U p SY (% > %< ' : C."V #
11($ ?#115 11@ V11E11 011 '11011Z" # O11 k11($ m11#$11 11:
51111% 3119L
K# $ ]![ > #i? 2c 2 OL S L ?>1
."23>: L
$ 05: : ?#5 C %$ ( ]#? k'1-O##901@ O##1 "1" 1
> c #i ' # F5 L-O##90@ O## S 11 cm1# 1
]
#[> ' ( #i: Fr f ' 5 % Y0 ' #
1?F1
I
p ?
. W%Y ?#5' qF# #[ cF :59Ip5 W1%Y V1#: q1(F15 V1#
cF( ' < K O: K#Z 5 V50" 5 09 V# 1S01 1: "##F1 >1 #121
11U5'3119 >11 O#11 ?#115M11 ' @ 211 O11: 11 >11 V11# 211 115 0119 ##F1111: V11U
#D3 .M 5
F M < K ( VZ p m1 >1? >1(%1 m(F1[1> c1# ?1 1Y:
< K ? [ 20$ ( >(F5# K< 2 ? 20: 43 ?F1 [ V1# $F11:X V1
O k($ 4$0 # F< MI m(F[> c# >S0 f 5#:
> % M <I5 rM ? OE VS#53 V# K1< 21 Ci1 q1M1

L] S $> O#1 C1(# 1cSO#1 K1< 21
i1<1 #' 1#@## 101
<05 OM > (# ##S% O#F3 I O 1 1I O11Y .1 150<1
Z ($ @U5 m$ # ##S 39L ?2 qF# : %#F EFc@L.
#(# 0$ : #0 M > V($L ?( .# ( 1 >1 01$ O1 Ii1 21
%#F 9 : ##F I39L . 2(9 ? O O O#E%#F ##F 0$ 1 31 2D1L1 >1
( O# 0 .I0M 2$M 0 > I< .C O1 O? IN1 1f (# O1
1 1f1
$ 2U # O 2DL #9 O# [ ' .# 9 I #: L? > O I> >
C#%F ]1 2D1L1 >1 1I#: %#F1( .1(# 1 O1 >1 1I 1U5( 101
2DL > ? C ID 2DYf (#0 ? O(# 1 >101 <p1 1#>1 >1
M11 K11#' ? O11 11I 11 11\ C11 qM11 11I 11#?#( 11I< O11 11 . M11 11U 11r
(# #F 49 39 < #Dp C # % #Dp .: O iM1 1#
(# p (F5 0 p0: 0 L #> ? .IM >5$ C531 > 2$( 1#
q$ 2Yf ] c #:( O[ 2M ?0 2: V ] ]M > 2$ 50c
( O] M ? V > 2$ .4 ? 1YN1 01 >#F1M1 V1($(#01
1$ 1 1
p @#Z L ?( : #L #Z3 0 %#F1 1: :531p 1: %#F1 1: 150.41
0: ~ # ? > ( 05: q# O( O0 2?101: O1 (F1 ?F1 1
(F5> ? I(# > #< 0 I#
1 #:1? O1j 1I K1$ #1#01
M V($(# > #.
> : m(%5 VFS 0 ( m 05: .5 0: ? 0 > O1 W1 %15 2? #
< 0: ?F > ( 0 > C #( %r
0 0 f # C#%F1 K1$
> # ( 039L ##FM V($0 >1 # 15 .XM1 31F1j #:531<1
?(# > 0 W0 4 %(? ? 09 000 : S 5 #S ?[ 1#01: 1# ?1I
W p 0E m(1 09 I#1 01#$ 01: 1 ?1 >1 I O#1 01: 1 ?1 01 1 019 01 X1p
0$ #$#(% ?F > : 2? 4 >11: 1#% 01: O1?
1 1848 1$ 01# #1 - O#(1#O#
KF
I5 53 1< O1 %15 O1: 01p -O#F1 01: ?F1 #1 V1 O1 219 (F11$ 01#O#
(# > O# # .? O0 M 1 V1($'j1 1 O1 1#[? 4$101 M1 V1($(#1
> #:53.#
- 23 }" : 1 "o
_ )
)N 1906 ) 23-22..(.
40
< K 21#9 1 C# O i 1 m(F1 2?1 0101< O1 (F15 ?F1 K1< >1 ?1 >1
S 1(% 1U >1 1$c#1L 1:? ' 1I >1I
1[ O1: 1: .11 ]1 01 g1$f19
( #> ( O# 0$ (% #(F5 > $(0 > 0 q9 . 0: ?F $ >
: # ) 20.500.000 ( 1895M 2 '
9< t#1' O#S1 fr1 Z1 ' OM1 21: >1
011( O11M11 011$ 11 115
I#11 11 ) c11: 12.500.0011$ E11 >11 Op 11: :5311<11
0r ( (## 0: $ $ p .10.750.000 O##: 0$ f( O 8.000.000(O1 #9
(# O#: O i O:53 O #p5 D$ .O#$ \ .XY 0: $ E>1 O
p ( :? .c: 5.750.000 X0 ?F1 1$ >1p?1 1: 1< O1 %36 01: ?F1 >1
( .0? XMf9 # : C 0 .18950 q5F L0 :#Yf ##Z cD' ]1
> < X ? (F 0 :? (F ) 4 0: ? : 2? 4 O1 %42 1882<1(
> < X (F(# 1 1: #:531 (F1(# 1p 1#:1#Y >1< X11 1# 1
2: 2? 5 >:5 1: V1#: q .1895? O1 119 1895( O#1 (# 1f 1# 2?11
L # > #%( M5 0.0#$ O
< 0 ?#0: ( k# >:5 ? 7.000.000 V .3r O# O D 2$ r 21: >1 >1
\ >
I5 %41 2$ Y 5$ :53 XMI m#i? 1 >1 W1 %21 21$p .1:3.000.000 O#1 O1
$ r ? 2 >1
I51 1.800.000 01 qS1 (# 1 .%60 (3131 [ 11
0115: 4#i11 11(# 11p11# 11 5$ 11 11#: L(" O#<511 F11 11 11I# 11%"O#F11
O#SZ3 <5 \ XY OM
F ? > W c O# 0#(:
I .c$
[% 2 #? f C#53 m$ #39L ?F: >S . 0: 1901 fr1 OM1
$ > p : 0#1f 2.300.000 >1 31r01: 1 O#1 >1 O#1$ :531<1
12.500.000 25 3r?M ? 0 9S ? 0: 4 > (0 f 1#1# .#F1#D
#Z% ?F
#U$ 0 ' ? > W O L #? >1 1I >1 1? O1f >:15.1
50<M [ 5$ # 0 O .41 1(1 M1 %1L#D31 1fK$1

> K#:f ?F 50 4 ( # 2# :] . XM1I 1#' 1Ir.1
>S 1896 # 0: 1$ OM >1p 8.000.000 1:1 01: 1$ OM1 >18.000.000 :531
.i? O 5F9?F m:
< 0$ OM > p9S : 0: $ OM > 1# :53
># > r0 f :
14 O# .1: 40M1 1IU "?1I "O#$1#
11( OM1 2?1
Y > .4
j 5M 5L 1 :531 11 C?(1 101 1(#1: 2?1 1
(# Y 2? #:53 0I 09 W # m% $b (# O1 1 21 %F1 ##F1O1 1
2 : $EI?
.]M
-3( ?N 5 $ m(F[c k1 :#? 1(# .1 #F1 >10#$31
k#@ C (Fc #: C # (FM >S .# -1#:319 01
5#$ (@ Ci K3 I5#:0 'c# : %F9 C< ##F 1p1 19 01$ 01 .C11
> M %5 [ ' k? (# c$ . O:$ 2M # >:'0$ ( > #F1
% 1111Y m11%5 m1111 V(#11$ >11 11 M11#S5 01: I#F11 O11$ 211 #:11#F11
(% F1j 0 1 1 ) t#<101 1#(%? F1#5? (1#19c$ 0 1#1
\.XY
> $ fU M :#0$ (# [ '1 1$(@ >1S? ' .# ?1 F1
211$ 0119 #i13119L '11> 011#S O11 11I 11U 11# 211$' .>:11' ? >11S i11 ?11 p11
>(%M : XM : (@ mY 09 #5> (% #fU 0:f 01 319L M1 V1($
> > #: 3 IL O .#i1 i1 ?1 XM1 1(% I31 h#:1
Oi ? NE: 09 ' r I' cY O ' # Oi i5 1 q1 t#1
? O C#%F k#'c# : %F$ > ##F .#5:
O V(c > q9 ?5 i1(# 1: 1M1 .2?1 "(c? "O#1#OM1
%r
Op1
101
E1 OM1 cr1 c1Y O1 (1 1U5 1(1 p1$ O1:<1# 1
41
S $ OM >@ :

I$ g#
0$ OM Sf O? ' S: # 0 ? OI
j .V# '-O##0@($ O## c %F " @1a V. ]?+b
.
11# 011: O11 5$11 ) 24O## 011L V11I #F11? 11 'j11 11( OM11 11f (K11: 11: 11
? O: #i(# c I[$ 5$ # : K<# .#9cY(# " :(1$ "1
0 I$#(@ Of # 0< K Z%#Z 1:1# ' 1#: 1 1 .]15 115
0 O0#$ 5 2[ O:M C " $#(%(" W( #Z 00 2 j'0$ # 9019 .
(0 I U5 XM0 #$9 X1% 1 1 ]15? >1 qF1# 1I51 C19 1 O1( #1>19cYf
.2i
S K< V #5 #FS5'#9 2(9 # U5 '> ? Y O1 V? O11 1
#FS 2 > #U5 > K< ' . > WrM i1 O#1 L< X11 >: 1L1 # O#1
#FS5L1N1 .# XM11#Yf 1S 1 1# '319 O101 Cf >1 1# m1[(5 O#1'< X11
' #i5 ( > I #FS5 05: #(%(# . O1 O1? I 1 11 1 010: O#1#F1S5
05: #(%(# O# #FS< C >(%? O .I5# 23S C
0i5 0cZL i O $D[ # Oi1 >91S51 #i1 >1q19
N VFS 3 1S O1 21(1 1 1S #F1 >1 p1S1 1$
IF1S WZ1<1#
< O qE #fp ( 0S ' XMI Fi $D % ? 2 .2 C1M1 V1

2$$ ( M #' S [ 2$ (% ( " >1 1 1#LF1 "#
1M1
11$ V11 M11 c11Y O11 211$ < 11 O11? ' V1111S WF11 Vh $1?+
Vhh hh21+ 11: C11 11U5
>
q' #0I 00 $#(@ mY O01 < C1 O1 >1I
01?1 ' 010 rF1
O: % .#9cYf ' ' #0I mY #F1S1 #1 c m(F11 # 101I 1
mY # # #FS5 m(F'.#
- 24 ) ( P ( - P jB (

- W " "1$Y Y ;i) } Y Y
P a N - 1$ i $ Wj W >i) .;4)(0$
42
-8<
: $2 $C
> 5# 0 23S m F % 39L > (0 # m1Y 019 101(% 1# #:1
[ ' .#? OM > V9 C#%FM < 03 #
0 2 C19 ?1 1 ?
1 1(# 10 #1 21 1319 >5@1 1319
> 5 M5 ( : 5M1 jF1 1 >1 1I#: q51 431F1 1@5 Ih<15 >1 O# 15 p<1
.S#5:> ] :> 59
" " : :
(% O #$> 9 1 C531p1<$" . O1 K1< ' i1
p<$ C9 O $ (# %F .( qF# ##F . O k($'1 V1
? >S
F(# ?
0(F ' # #19 $i % . 1U5 319L ' V$531
: ? . 2 C#%F(# V 9 2$F I 21? ##F1
Yp1m1@ 01($ I01 1
' < #:3.
> (0 m(# ] Lc 0 > ( F1 1 1 01f 11S
1 1I#:I$1
V ( 25 r L <.#$#
9 O O#[> : > 2:# (i : 0:3? 2Y0 I #(F1? O11
> M i1 ?1 p1[ 21 >1 1 1#:
#1U5 M1#S5 XM11 O#" O1 >1 #11 01 "O# .1I?O1
$3 #f> >
#U50 > ] 3 C> I I :0 XM O#5
? O' < !#:?# O 2IF #(F0 9 >Z mL .V#(% k1 1: >12?1
0 O (# O[ : 239 .? >? O? O0 O1 #$ K1$ k1
K< >:53 ? E#I
#U5L .>: L
S m(%5?0 : O 3 : C ? q XM3 g$ 0 .g$
3 0#S g$ #1#? 1I5 ($1 O1 m1#5 1# 15# 1#31 01 01#S g1$ O1
5 # #? I5 ($ : m# 0#$3 .>#F1? O1 K:31?(1 >11 >1 V? 11#$
cY I#U5 .? : ? (# qF#? C53p<$.
< K (0 2L> > L ] S O :53> 0 09 29 ? O O1? .K:31
:53' > #S f (0$ I# O (% W 1r %11 O# >1
U51
( .:i 0 ~ U5 >#F<0 00 1?1 1 L '319 >1M1r (#01$ 1# 1
[ >S . XM L C#%F< W ' I#: K 9 : 0$ L @ #5? : O > #5
$
V O1 [ i I1# >1 01$[ 1: 1< 119c$ 1#(% 21Y( KF1 01? O1 01$1: i1
< #r I> IY(# ."#$
%# (# ##F(: C1 >F1?: W1Y >1 #F1 1I'319 . 1I? O1$1 1 >1
I(# ?
N( #F #F' .# O1 V % 1 1@S 01$
?N V (# > I$0 K#0[ >Y ( 1c1 %F1 ##F1 31I1
> mYU 90@ #@1# 21$ 11$ >1 #1 O%#F1<1 KF1 >#F1? >1 O1<1
39L i ? #S > 2DL Y #' . XM D5-#: L'39 1#
0 (# ( D :F 2(9'I O U5 1: >#F1 19@ .1#
pM O# 23S " 0f" " 0I5 "39f ' >< 05: (# ?
.
43
< K V<$U5 (# 05:

? Vc 2 #ip #:> #3 I#: 49
#S # O K$> .> $ 2 XM1 #i1 #i19 11Y 1: (# 1 Ci1K31
I5#:0I I#F >f'39 %#F :%9 C ? O V# MS5
#U5'39 '> .'
%> I# MS5 XM #Fp #: :M M#S501$ 1:1 1 #:1 q131
(# :M 2$ ' S C0 ? O#5 S 0: [.
#iA #3 #i9p9c: > : I' ' #: #i9 : C(% 3W :
#i9? ? #f .' ] > #i9 2f ' 0 #3% pN >:1: V1
0 29f #3 #Fp #:> I<I5(# . ? YN 4191U5 (1# #i19 O1
f ?# :( VS9 m#$ O< % p >:#iMI .V K(F 21 #i1p1#:
? f.
0 #i1f C1 >1 1IL1#-[1 01#E $1 1
#E1 21f XM1
($ IDc@ Of > < >5$ "F > [ f" ) " Cf"( .?M N
Cf F S 3 C#f> W #f >1 11: 2?1 1 1 ]1>1
? IcS > N . M XM3 ? O U5 < 00k#
?11 119c: - #11( 11 :i11p11 @ 11#< 011 cS?#11 O#11 " "11 XM11311 )
f M 0$( . M cS cY C0 0: : S:L > qf 1
11 ]11 V11 M11 g11$cS O#11F11# 0119 O?11 F11 O11 $11f 11 2?11 11:
F #i (# ' ] < 2#> C0I5 M 2M 5#: 2IF C9 21
f #:?# S #Z3 c .S#5: U5 < 010 31 M1I
? 2 (0 N $ > X0 9 cS.O#
K(FM 2 :0f> #:?# S #Z3 c ?> 0Z 2?
Y11 q11311 >?11 C11#f
I#11 11 cS11 ' OM11
11I11$ p11#:[F11#
39 " F" .?M OU5 < 00 1: #1 2h$hdC 31 ?1# #Z31 f
q> 0 f> $ <1 [1 1: 2?1?1# S 01$ 1 .1I$1
: 2$N U5 <? 00 09? E%Y ]M K(# f# V #cS 0 O##1
0 I #F[.
K
F1 ]1 C11$ 1 E<#1 V1
1 2#Z11$ 1 9 1 .1# 1Z 21$
E ? O< K ? Sc 39L ? O? ' O
m(F 2? X00>>1S? c .
:> Kf 2Z$ 5#: K< ' # 2$ Oi]
( 2( 0#9 :1# 2(F1 O1 1$ 1I 1U5-1#: L'319 . q1 1F1 >1[1
fj
2#Z$ ( $ #? O# :'%# > C%9#Z O1
f 11I O11 (11 ? 11: 11p011
11 011$ cL 11 11#
I 1111$ O11 11I11U5
.#: L
OIS @( $ 2Y0(# >
#U5p01( O1 : W 11$ C1% O#1 (1[$ ?O1
[11 ?11# 211(9 O11 $110 11 11#$ . 011$ W11 ~11 11L11 L11> ? O1111#: C11
2'> f
2$ E .M 2$<#p 1: #1#Z31 F1S V15? #F1
< ?# > ? >S IFS5 IFS > O?S 3 XMI F?1# ' 2Y01
O% C(# '.#
: 2 O? c M#S5 0I$ 11: C1 31
F1 g1 #?1' 01 1#? 1I
#Z3 I O q#S K%?# $ C%9#Z I OY . XM1 #F11r O1 1I
U5'39 O? ' ' >Sr $ @-#$ 11 j1 21(9 21>1 1$1 p1
[ .##
******
? O 0 C#%F (% $ I# MS5' > # #1'319 >1 0101#
I 0%3 $ 2(9 ## 2#9 0%3 $ 2#9> I@ > I$i 4r( 0. .>5 $

$1 @h $hE $E1$ $hW h h h. h@1+$2? h: h $h h$h@1 h:< >h<
"h
44
$E+} (
$ .M ' ] .V# I OY # ]5 1 >1 ]1 [1
' > #Z ? O 55%# 2 (% $ #' .#
> : 1904 K$ > >?F $9 V95 % ' > >: #?L #9 (?
> :> #
" [ > O? ' # j ' #9 U >.
f U '39 > (
0 i5 i5?> MI Z".
' [ ? # E 0#p (# > 0 D 3 <#5 M 01
09E> (# f # ?

.%F :cD9 >?F
" <#?# XMI IE# : 1 K1<# .1I j1 %#1 1 (# 1 >1 ##F1 1
11# Z ( 1# >11 11 11 #911?11 #11r 211% 0hh: 11k$hh Chh "0hh.
]%+h 19 O1: 11I#115 1f> C#%F11 ' .< C1? 211 O11: C5%31 2?11 p1S 1 O1 11211
% .X? O:%9 C#%F OM < C 2<$F% 0# YE(0 f[ 0 2iSM 01#
09 O?1 O1 1 1$#@ >1 (31 K11% f ' 1I1 q1 21 01# >1 1I(01 f[019 1
O I5 2 23] ? O 1 59 151 1< 15 1< 2Y015 1# $hM1 ?O1
< > #F \."Y
0 K ?S90@>- >: Lf> XM > %f O V# $ q[ C015
> # > Z ' . 0$ # qS(# 9 O: # I$9
D90@#-' #:1
' 0 .0 < [ F m$ # # I .#f O#5 M5 c1
> [ U S
I 2111111111 2D'0111111111 #111111111 111111111 111111111: V111111111( V111111111 .$ h hhhhhhh #3111111111
01111111119 $ h hhhhhhh% (111111111< hhhhhhhhh
45
-9 $.
> : # 1905(:> 5

" 0[ O9 43 1: 1: 184819 431 O1'31 #1%i1 >1
1$V1
119 4311 O11? 411#(11 119 O#11 11#$( 11119 11#$ 11#:%9L119 4311 V11# qS11
( 5 O:I I<5%#F # 0$ O # .I
" [ 0%3 (" O: k 0($ "D 00 C<# 1 1 1#Z 1< 1q01 ]M1
( \ ? I: 5 k#1S 31 " 1#1>" C11 $ .1I 1? O1 101 ' V1
( O: k 0 O D 0%3 > O? ' ($ I5 I#%r19" >1 1: 1U "19%' ]M1
( 0 O 0%3 > @ ($ I> ' ? O I#%r i> g95 >(%M ' ? O VF'
%3.
" # C# W(0 E g$( Ii$ I # .0 W 4#F'\ k0 CU5 # D # :F
M11 k11# 11 011 011: 11c #Z11 ? >11 K(F11 V115 q119 O11 11$9 11# 11 VF11Sf11
39L $N ]M I< 2 #'39 >#F C#
i > #$ O F 09 #$ 9 C1#
f ##F' mY #: <
\ > C#U .01 ( 1@ 1: 1I$ 1

$ C# S K:3 I C#< I# E i #$ #F $0 #Y0 #C#< II
i95 09 q:% 2 j'S ?0I I5 M #S3 ]M ? 1: 1I 0#$31 01 .>1$q?F1
( <9 2? C #$ .I ( 1%F1 1[$> ' O1 g1$ .ID901K(F1
? 0#
I: m "03 C "9(@ O#3 2[ ' V 9? . I31 O1 K1I5cV1
O: : [ I0Y > V S I@ S> 1I5pY O I C0r .1?M1 < 01 ( 1
q$ 09 #$1 ? 01$ 1I 1 31901: 1: 01 1 <1# 1#$21(9 1 01I: O1: 1
( .
M 1: >Sif01 >110 @ 1$ 1# 1S 19\ 15 .$1 1 #11# >#F1
11(% C#11 11$ XM11 11(%F11 11 V11$
1111~ 211(9 O11115 >11 Ci11 119 I011 11 (11
< I$0D #S3 # #$> ~ C# IU ."#:

( (# %# 0$ # I : #?
2[ 1f f N1 1# 19
-#:%9L( > #$ 1S : $] . O $(@ k($ 0 > M q19 2D1>1
< : K[ # (c I$i : # 0 .0? 4 XM1 O1: 2D12?1 IF1S
'
[ MYE5 . S ? # I O# 2 [ Z [ . 5 MYEM [ ? # 15
' 5 X($0 09 #$ $9 > ] (.0
3 [ > # j L3 > [ > .# O1 #1 K$31 31
>
U > @$ ( # $> I#: %#F # ? p ''0 [
#F11# 11 .11 < K11#? c11 1111Ip5# ? c11 11(F11 I 11:M11 N11 011
?F$ 0 ( #Z # # m0$ > :Xp . O [ ' #C#%F
( II O# # Z0 5 #? .F5 0? >11# [1> p121[ >1 41
XMU #: O: S5< E1 1I#? 1[1 >11 .#1 < K1 ?1 419(#>1 1
F5\ #M O( >I0< ' V p K 5# q3r # I0 0 #(#[.
O# #-#:%9L( O# #[ j i '0 [ >1 .1#15
0( OM
IM Z % E1 1#?S 01 11? 1Y\ >r [c 11( L 1 1$
f Y : $ 9 4? #5: 0 I O##$f.
46
05: q5:? ) O ( > #f? > #$E< # : 1 019 XM1
1
(#$ # ( .O# O #: < 20 0 40 51(Y O1:''31 1 >1
S O#?> O# I 5## 2Y0 > Fj #0 C1 1#Y K19 1? .11S
1
? KM > E # 031 >101 I(1 XM1''31 01 . i1 E1[ 1%Y O1[1 2?1
39 > 0 $ 0 [c < . O? 2 ? #] 2 C#%F?1# -V(11#:%9L
< ? 40f 5# # [ O0 %I
[ 05: # qp 0#$ 2( O: 0$ > I$ q$ 09 35EO1 #F# : #
cY 0 .# pj > >?F p '>-90@> (> > "S" > I OM
$ O" : C#%F ?: M5 OI 1< 1 >11# 01 q1: XM1 1cS 1#0 >1 121
11 11$@ .F115 11 K11r511 #@ K3115 11# K11D11
< 11@ .11$cS11 0311
S#1111 #11YL 11I 11
IcS O#11" I11 1111" ' 11: < 11# ri11011$
i c 30.000 K> 2'c: 05'> [ 1r 1 19 #F1#>1
q #( ' D 015: 231 O1 m1%5 #1 Y1
#E1f 231 CF1 1'j1 cSO#1
O#$90" M5[ O#: O1 1$ >1 >?F1 1 C1 XL1> (1> " "#51 1 K1< V1'
0$ U5 : # I : #09 # U5 : #1%9 I O1 >91 1
[ r < 2( .?F ($ >?F > V '0 [ # m#3
N #i(" # p 0 Y ? 5$ # OM O >I .#5 X0? 0 I#
XM 0 F5 #01 1 101r #i19 1#[1 O131 1II 21U >101 O1:
[ 0 # 25[ # ."F5 M j(59 V5 m#.>?F
0# #[ > qF# 1 O1f1 m1%51[ 01# >1 01 .11 1 1
( 09 C# > q$5(5 O: 2 O1 010$ i11#%r 01$ >1j1 1: #F101#Y
r .#? I q$0: O1 1D15 q1cF1
1 O?1?1 ( O1 1 1I@ m1
4#F W #F0 .# ? 0#E U f> F I31 1# ?1: 1
#SI I$0< :E# C#%F 2 ' O( . [ ?(# S5
Z <5 09 #> > O#E( 31 21 >11U 1[ 1[0 ##F1
1$?F1$ k1#
C11#< m11'11r k11# m11(% 110r 11: ?F11$< >11S .C11#11 S-#F11(11: #11 187011
F# O 2 2 %# : #j # m#0 # XMi f #>1
I Oj 2> M > < IYf q5 ? # 1 [ k1 S31 S#$i1 >1?1I
f0$F Z f ( 5 I#Y > ?
. 09 23 Cf > VFS -# #>S .#
I q1? 11?#
1 >1$ 01$ I1# 1 1 O1 21 %#1 21 1 1 #> 1:
39f >1< 1I1Yf q115 ? 11 1 1I $F1 1 1#%Zp 1ID0m1# 1#Y
'3 > r.
>11(011 #11 "11#9" K11% 011 ' 110 K11% ]hhS1
hh "hh C#%F11( 11
>:0 I .I# ? F % # 1#p 1: F15 O1: O11 .1#9 31
< # # 3# 0I%i #F0 #Y( > I<I5 .>9 O5 #[N # 3< C>
> O# C0 O# Y XM? ] I C9 > IS#F V O1? ' X1E
1$
< O#<M1I .# ' K(F1 C#%F1( 1 1r 1#9 1' 1I5$ 01 .1
O i< O#5 > O#5 # 39f M \ q V# $ .#
pI $#5> I q#5 #$'$ % >1 ' 1#1$ >1 21# 1#Yf 101 M1
11I5 X1111 "( "11 m11 11M11> >#F11M11 V(F11(# 11(% 11# 11 11<#[ 1111#
#F'$ [ 00I 3( (0 0 M> F 01 1%r .$11
E (F5 # -# # : #? N $ 0 I ' k# 05: 49 .? O1
@ 5 O#< O#( < 0 O V U> 0 1I#(#91 1 1: 1I# ]1?1
f # K: O
D #r O# XM [ . M r O (# M M1 1S
:( > 3 K ( @ O D 31 1r E 1I 1K1
.
F
" < ?
# "# U5' 0 f .# XM31 ' F1#$C#%F1
@( $ >Z5 O# #(%0 ' 2 jL0% .F
47

F FM > D9 0$ (-#Sp1# 1: 01$ #F 1 >1 1M1
S :5 #< Dp #S : F5 : 1 O1F1S#FS 'F1S#F) 1#5 $1(
'
0$ : i : U?
> m%cF < 0 # ?> K$ @ #$f .#
-# # 019 1# M1I #19 1 q1I 1U5 M1 <1 C531 V1#: 1UM1 [ 21?
1
S ? f .V# q31S" F1 1: #11 f 1#N (Concert of powers) ."151I
. I OY 1 31 1 (# Z p1D0$ 1#? >1 15( 1 #1Y1
% I5 >3M K1$ >1 1 #F1$1 . 1%Y
91S1 1 >1 1%5f .1#
3: >1 r1? 21 019
1 1I 1 2D1 #1 #1(015 1 O1 21UXM1
2D # .2@ O >5$ # '0 [ f .#
0 O:p L> > F 1 1 -#1 # 1# V1 qY01? 1S #F1 1K1
?
S > N # V :0(# r 09j #3$ .>
: 05: 1906< 3 O# F # t" Mr? K'> 01>" 19 E >1 V11
%Y
9S "1 Ci1 2i1 2D1 21$ q131 C1#fp1 '1 #0 1# 1(%1$
C5 U5 L ."IDI@( > $M ( : 0 . 11 1 '1
' 0 11( 1111 11I I (11 >11(11 O11 11I I 11IM11 '11 .?11 O11 O11 11
V11
( m%59c$ 0 # 9 m%5 O.#(0
c 0 > # L <# (9@ > # ##Ff <# ? 11 g1
C0 O U5 ?#
0 VE : # .F ? O##1%#F1 OM1 01 1: F1
##F 09 0I$ 05:
Ic?
r C#0 #c 31 1M1I . K(F115
c O# f #E O #c # ( 2? ?$5 : 1: F 2?11
## ' >I5' ?
'1 .# 1% YE1 1 2Y01[1 01 1#1
0 ] cY O '0 > # cY O D # cL <# 0 > .#
O WZf0 r # cL 09 C05[ > 2(F1 >1 K1 01(01
f #
9S <#31 O1 .>1(%1 O1: OI?1 O1 01(01 f 1 1# ?1 f >1
@ m[ ' 0] V# i95 C# > #(%(0 f qZ 09 # O $S
0 > f 5.[0
115
ri11 11'11-#90@ >11 11# O11 11#@11 11 11 m11% V(11 j1
(# 11 11 11Y011 >1111 ?11 011? 11# -11#:%9L( .11 11 11'c11
>#F11 %1111L 11$ 0119 (11:11 >11 #F11#D11# (# 11f 11# M115 ##F1111$
> .> F ?
? O##
#1% O1: 01#01 (# 1 >11(< q1c1Y
0 @ : $ Cfp ( > 3 0 #%#1 0 ? .F1#5 p1 L1>
M11 X11511 11[ >11 S #F11f 411 C11 V11 11I11 ( 11 11U >11( F11C119
? .11#% >11 11#115 k11# 11 p ( 11 11: ]11f 11(119 M115 11# 011:
(# Yj qE F # O$ 1: 2 m1@ >1 #F1'31S .>#F1 15# q9Z1XM1
#$ : $ O > Op # C#%F (% $(% #> ] 19 05F1(Y 1>1 1I
i5 '39 23 t# 0' #f #pS9 $i %.
E #[ : #(# f I #E #f 1L( .# 1
#1%?
1>1 m1%
: # #$f 1 1# 1 XM1[1 1 f 1#i1 L([1 >:1[1 >1>1:
(% $f #p .I
11S#fp11 '11 # q11 (11 11#5 >:11[11 0115: 11(% 11$ m11r 1[ 1111%
> > 9c$ ' .#:? #: O] >
#U5S (# ] 9 I0 $p#
C @ Z@ 0 : Ufp ' #f 1# r 1p1 '1>-901@> 1f> (1
XMfp (F5 '5: < #c $ #
#U5 XM<1 # 1 .I@(i1]M1 1<#5
( q '-#90@ # IS 1U5 >1< 0F1< 1(# 1( 1(: ##F11 1
11<S 311 O#11 >115$11$ 11#$( .11 ?11 11YN11 C 11% 11 11: >11%11:0
' #p (# > (3 09 O#$ q9 i (# (1 'c1 ? .
1j01
E #( [ #1 V
1%1 O# >1 p 1#5 1U #i19 Ci1(1 O#1(#1
48
#$ > # p# .M#S5 i5 O 2Y m'9 < > C# F5F # 09 #
9Sq1
E #( L >1 (1 .#1 [1 >11 1 01: 215 [ 1#[ 1 1(#1
# Z[ I# #( > ?
" IFS?
11
] <# \> U > 5( >I V 0: U5 I5 1#$1#$
I O#F1 #31 >1[1 #11I
#3[ '1 >1 # .11 [ 21 %F1? 1# ##F1 >1 1I 11 \1U >1 >1
[ ( > # S3 C1# >1 >1(%1
1$ .>1 (# 1 #11
[ i1 1ID 1#$1 1I 21 1 C1# >1 1I91 f #11
11111111110 >1111111111?1111111111 XM11111111111 11111111 #1111111111111111111125

> 5 < 5 5%%Y?5$ #?# "I > V(# - #1 1 11
> ."# 09 : C9 XM :# .F .5# . .>?F?# .
$1 1 [1 1: 2?1 1Zp1 1 1901 O1 O#Sj1 41 1>1
0 I $9 ##F' 51 ?01Z 1#?# %31 1$D IF1S1S$ 1#: L
(.I
(0 O K9r 5 #1 1I:<1 :< X1 1: 101 >5@1
i1 1 01 O1
c I (r# < ($ Y\ X'# $ O: V#E VFS?1 01: O11 " 1U5S"01
(#9@ #$ '% > . mrM1 '<1 0DF1 i1 O1: 11
> m[(5 #($ #i9 O: 2(F0 @ .>5M '< jF' 1 O1: 01#$ 011Z M1 ?415
" EF[ "#($ 05: C XM" EF 2 EF0 @.">5
? p
IFS mr
0 9 : XMf .1 1~' 15 (F15
(0 C
#F #i95 . #(% #: Lp > IFS> 5I1: 1 1905
@ 09 g$ I#:c0$ cY I 5F $ .35 V1$ 1 211 1 1I2?1 qS1
\> >%Y5 O:cL 1U5 >: .? >1 1I5 q19 VF1S q1: >1 1S >:101( >:1 L
E "< 09 "C#0$ K# 05#( 0$ : 0U ?
[ O k .#? 1[ Oq0%1
" U5 @ "#($ M5 3#U fj 101 ]M1 #1[ O1 k1 1# >1 C19
" "#($> ' % N ]M 9 "[ 0%3 "#($ @ 1r# ##F1M1 21
M ? O(: X 1< V1 %1 41 O1?
1 1 X >?F15#1 ?1 @1#5-
$ [.
90@# @#5 (## < O

??N O "" @( $ < 2F f @( ' < 2 : K< V 1f M15IF1S
: O K91 O11U5 >1 %1[1" . O##5@1)26O##51f (O# 1 O##01?q1
O##:53 O
F9L< #F5? K< # 5$ 3 p<: 0(#9@ O: #0 O:O@1
(% ($ #i #: L0" 23 5L $#(% m$ # #3$1
[ 49M :0 "$ C? # O## C(#9@ #c(5 0$ 2#(1 >101 O1:
0" .( O# ? 2 # i 49$ [ M " XMr@#5 ( ? 1<1"
I
4#i M @-O##5' O##:
OM
> .
< K O rM '-O##0@F# O## p [ $ KF? V5p
[ 0# > ( 0i qF#<: Yf V5 29 : #3 m#(% 2D[ KF1
? I5p # .i ?1 1Yp1 '1>-901@> V1<I5 [1 1@ >1 i1
p$ O:
, <? 1$ %?2
"'#1 1$" .M1 51L f E1 01 O#1$ M1Yj
'(: ? O .00
fp (@ qF# @(? 0 $ 49p 3 C
<F5 # S 1#: L1I#: 01$ >1
09 ] g95 .0$ # p 0( 09 q1E1 #15 <1# .M1 19 ' 1V1#
] .M ( 00 K ?> O1: C11:L >1 F1: 1: 5 21 2191 01 1# [ 1$1
p V%%Y? #?# qS : 2 #r[ :Y #5 f >: L O# 9c$
#(% '< > I# #F%.
- 25) ( " 1 Z" (" )}( 17) ) 1915.(.
- 26) V j ( - " 17)" - 1905P "( - )Ey ) 4 -) .1 P
Wj ,-E
K P ,) - 0Y- . 4 ) 1)E 1 1 Fk .1$
D
1 - ) .1906)(0$
50
# " >Sj" < XM i< c .> "[ >1 "#($1: #1 1915 <K1#
Sj ( @F (# 5$ 0@ #> > < K " ."I$53 15 1
1$ >1(# 1?O1
O> "5$ 0@"# 2> p ># i Xc1: qF1# 1I .]M1 21 >1<1 #
# @( $ I( #:531< 1#Z31 [1S cS1 O1? c1 ?1 15: 019
($
I #.XM
> O F' 5$ " 1$9 5019 "##F101 1? 019 1 1: 01 [1
XMI . 5 < [ #Yf 53S#Z > @ cY 5F $#Yf :9c$
O#1 11: V1#: q1 :1905 21 q1 XM11#Z G$h90@) 1#( (1 h#$ ]11
jF >F#DM <@ K W%Y :
? V(# ? .1#?# q19 210@ 1#( >1 1#1
11: M115 1905 11 11p11 >11 1111I 011 C11# q1111 5 F11011 11 #3110@11#
( OM ' $#%F : LM jF %(r > c1U . 15< 1: K1#M1 jF1 1
> :
1

%a<? :W $ T ?1 @R (h@. ha
h
h01 . ?h
i O[1 @ 1: 1#5f (F15 219f 1[ 1 i1 O11 @ O#1( .1#5f 1[1#
( .m# 5 > t#$ '$ > ? L I O US '$ 1S 1#9 1U
>11 O#11$ 211Y( 011 .$F11 '$11 X11011$ O#11 11f( 1111U5
011? >115 V115011$ O#11
(# f( .
># m( 0( #Z3 < Z3 ($ > I .1905' ] >1 f1#
XMI #: L 09 (% q3[1# c1Y 5F1 1$1#Yf . >1 #1 #1 21$1(% %1
F1 11 [ 11 1 V11$S#1 >11 I(011 >11 1$011 '319 .' ]11 >1 i11 L<0119 #F115
0: qS:i '39 09 .
$?0 I5 > q9 VFS ] "'c" > M q
> V C.m F ? L< #F5' #: <0 I M > V($
#U5 :53 #>1
111($111 111$ ( 111 . 111111 0111 111 " >111 " :>111 111 "111 O111
F1119 111L<#F1115
? 11($ K11% 11#11 ' O11 11#: #i119 211011 ". M11 11 @ O11 211 V11 L<#F115
? #? $E ($ K% ' O #: #i9 20 W I5 $d # 0j > M %9 49
11 O11L< #F115'11 #
11 .11I#( 211 ' 115?11 5S:11 0119011: "0@ "11# 11$#(@ 11
L<.#F5
?M 0 I ( #:53< 5# :FMY L< #F5 O: r 1I$9[ .11
5$ (F5 0@ > #0 N01 qF1# 1I M1 315$1 1( c1 .' cS1 ? 155
1$
\F11 11 ' 11$ 11#(11# 11: cS O#11[11 311Y 211I .2F11 11'511 p11
>11(%p >11 011S11 cSc11Y O#11 5F11 11$11#Yf 0119 O11 11#
11 [ 211M11 '11
$ C# 5L U5< .#r
? O11: O11 11 " O110@ "11#011 >11 11M11 0311 11 115$ 11? 0115: " O11:[11
"#($
@11 $11 :011 11#$ 011: 1111S #F11#E 11 C1111 211I M11 11 C11 211V11
11 ? O11: 11($ ' V115'11 VF11S @ 11#11S 11 11I# ?11 01190$F11 q(11 j 11
#S3U5 3# . : ?$N q XM 09 O: q3> 0: O$ 1 @1#
> M (.0
c?11 2 I[ 110 m11@ >11 #F11 11#Y'$11 0119211S q11I
11 #11[ >11 k11 11# 1
M # .C M ' >5$ fp > ( 2? q ( # >1 11U ?
1[ O1 k11 1#
m@ ]F[ ? >5$ V5 ? [ > I5: qS? ?F$> C01(% 11
C%9 @ > @ m'$ O qS: 09 # (%[ 0# > (.0
( 111I[ O111 k111 111I9p 111:p:p 111I( 111#3111 0111 111# .>Y M111 ' >1115$ ""O##5111
)f (O#?IS q ? %F[ 1i1 ' 1# C19( 1c(15 .O#S11
>5$ 9 ? : WZi[ Y 09 ' ] O I0#$F .:F
? #(#9@Z # $ ' M ' >5$ I #r O:?
01 1 . 1< 21
0 c0$ #Yf 09($5
OM q 01 0$ 1$ M1 '1 O1: .C19' #F1
51
> I<I5(9@ #> >1 F >1 1I I1 2(F1 0:F1'1-O##901@O##
: ($(# ? 2.
p K$(% 0 > #0 0r I: I%r .I(i? OM ' >5$ 90@#
[ 2$ F K(#1 . ' 1#:5$ 1#1 qF1# 1 ?21[ O1
XM >5$' >1 ]1 ]1 WrF1 >1 m1#$1 1(% 011 # 0:F1 1(%1: 1$
I%Z[.

111 111U5(#111I 111 @ 111# 111 qi111?111 ( 111#Z3111 cSO#111
011011Z
I Ii11[ 11 #311115: < 110$11 M11 " 11 11I11%" 11c11 ?
11
p 0S >? I< < # #(# 05: O# U . < @ $1
[3" 2 f>" V # V ( .M : m(%5< t#[ : m(%5 %9 \1Y
M < t#M V#: 49 ? 1 .1I ( 1#<1 t#1 21# 1I 1 1(%[015: W1 1
C5 XM ' (% MU KF O 25 2c ?
i g$ I0 > ] .1
? > #:@ 55> ? %F ##F> I5: qS5 '?1 . 1]1?S
> F (% . # p >1 01S1 <1 >1 #01 1 .? O1(# 1>1
35$[ 0#M C#%F'S OM CS > O1 1#[? 2i1S >1
q : .1905
(011 E11 011 11(: " XM11 "1111 O11 XM11 11%5 .#F11#D 11 11: K11 V1111$
'-O##90@ O## " M i5 @@ >5 ?
? #[ O k 01 ."#1 X1
09(: V#5$ "i5 @ .">5? O (: q " " ' W >5$ 01I 1$ 01
1I
I11 DF11 11 11$S ]11 11 >115$ 11: K11 V1111$ F11 "11# i115 "##F11
XEM i5 M ?# 'i# 0#$ 0 O 1 $h Th $bh% chS kh
( ]#? . + @1+ $d T $b% 1$ $C -@. a
EF< qF# " EF? "9j XM1($ 1#$ 01 ' >1 O1 1#r 1
i >
EF h$ h EF1 1c#1 (# 1 1: #1? .
1 01$ 1(%
#$ #F#E@ #5 [> : > 2:1# 31 f 1L 1I#? O1 >1 1N 1(%1I
' ': m >
f#31 1 1 '1 01 f 1# 211 XM1 K1$

> 2$?> M V'#-0@# # . [ > #i9?
1' \1Y ' 1II
? 20 ) #$I #F#E ' 0( 0 i II ?
.>: L 1#$ 0$ (%
#F11#E 311 f >11 011S5$ 211 11[11 ( >11 1111U 11#
11? O11(#0$F11 11
c#c :?

p5 (# O# O %F0 ?
?> OY MI .2$
: #$[ #i19 >1I1Y 01: 1: 01$ O1$ 21 ?F1$ ##F1@ 1#50.1#
XM$ 09 2 m#$% [ I 2<$> 019' 01I31 [1 j1 1 1p1Y .?O1
I? OU : K (# @1 I .V?F1 21(9 1I#: K1 21>1 1
Of .
: V5 q(# cY Ir q$ V5 V# ? : I.OY
52

نتائج وتوقعات - ليون تروتسكي

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

نتائج وتوقعات - ليون تروتسكي

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

- -

" :-"#$%" http://www.al-mounadhil-a.info

c I I.##F

%Y 0 #:# 5

- 3P ,Y$ ( ) 1 ") 0 1 ";Z) .9-6)(0$

'c ' > >:M V$#(%

2 KF O: q5:? : IDS I O: IDSM> : 0#$3@ .>5 0 2 O 00$$#:# O

'39 < V 5$

9 ) (1943-1859 ? i4 _

? q9 p? O: 'c< C O1 q 9 01Z 1U5@ 1#1 41

11 ))4 b $ Wj

1905 -1848 -1789 -3

(# 3 O

Z 9c$ #:%9L 0?

# ?F$ M c O O#<0 ?

$n -6 > 1$$

E5< I 2 < 31 f >1' < K1 1SE1 1 O1f1 1: V1

S $ OM >@ :

- 24 ) ( P ( - P jB (

< K V<$U5 (# 05:

09E> (# f # ?

> : # 1905(:> 5

-10$b% " I <>25

You might also like

نتائج وتوقعات - ليون تروتسكي

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

نتائج وتوقعات - ليون تروتسكي

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

-  -

  " : -"#$%" http://www.al-mounadhil-a.info

c I  I.##F

  %Y 0 #:# 5

- 3P  ,Y$ ( ) 1  ")  0 1 ";Z) .9-6)(0$

' c '  > >:M   V$#(%

2 KF O: q5 :? : IDS I O: IDSM> : 0#$3@ .>5 0 2 O 00$$#:# O

'39 < V 5$

9  ) (1943-1859 ? i4 _  

?   q9 p?  O: 'c< C  O1 q 9 01Z  1U5 @ 1# 1 41

11 ))4 b  $ Wj

1905 -1848 -1789 -3

(# 3 O

Z 9c$ #:%9L 0?

 # ?F$ M c O O#<0   ?

$n -6 > 1 $$

 E5< I  2 < 31 f >1' < K1 1SE1 1  O1f1 1 : V1

S $  OM >@ :

- 24 ) ( P  ( - P jB (  

 < K  V<$U5 (# 05:

09E> (# f # ?

> : # 1905(:>   5

-10 $b%  " I <>25

You might also like

- -

" :-"#$%" http://www.al-mounadhil-a.info

c I I.##F

%Y 0 #:# 5

- 3P ,Y$ ( ) 1 ") 0 1 ";Z) .9-6)(0$

'c ' > >:M V$#(%

2 KF O: q5:? : IDS I O: IDSM> : 0#$3@ .>5 0 2 O 00$$#:# O

'39 < V 5$

9 ) (1943-1859 ? i4 _

? q9 p? O: 'c< C O1 q 9 01Z 1U5@ 1#1 41

11 ))4 b $ Wj

(# 3 O

Z 9c$ #:%9L 0?

# ?F$ M c O O#<0 ?

$n -6 > 1$$

E5< I 2 < 31 f >1' < K1 1SE1 1 O1f1 1: V1

S $ OM >@ :

- 24 ) ( P ( - P jB (

< K V<$U5 (# 05:

09E> (# f # ?

> : # 1905(:> 5

-10$b% " I <>25